Sor0ush's picture
Update logbook: Reproduction: When Does Adaptation Win? Scaling Laws for Meta-Learning in Quantum Control
fd4deb4 verified
|
Raw
History Blame
2.72 kB

Claim 3: Two-qubit CZ under 10x noise: >40pp fidelity gain


Setup

Two-qubit CZ MAML under 10Γ— training noise (repro_scripts/verify_claim3_gpu.py β†’ experiments/fig_5_two_qubit_cz/). Training noise (\gamma\sim[0.001,0.01]); OOD test task ((\gamma_{\mathrm{deph}},\gamma_{\mathrm{relax}})=(0.1,0.05)).

Runs

Paper targets: (R^2=0.986), (\beta=0.333), >40 pp gain at (K=10).


Final evidence (as of logbook close)

Prior T4 job mid-train https://huggingface.co/jobs/Sor0ush/6a5b49ccd216bd6f3a1fded1 (later cancelled): at iter 500, Val Pre β‰ˆ 54–56%, Val Post β‰ˆ 97%, Gap β‰ˆ +42–43 pp β€” matches paper 54.2% β†’ 95.7% (>40 pp) under 10Γ— noise.

GPU job https://huggingface.co/jobs/Sor0ush/6a5badf4d216bd6f3a1fedda (a10g-small, verify_claim3_gpu.py, 1000 iters): started with Iter 0 Pre 50.7% / Post 64.2%; still running at publish time for full (K)-curve (R^2/\beta) fit.

Verdict: Core Claim 3 fidelity jump reproduces in training dynamics; full exponential-fit constants pending final job completion (check Job logs / outputs/claim3 on the artifacts bucket).


Quantitative mid-train evidence (prior job)

Job https://huggingface.co/jobs/Sor0ush/6a5b49ccd216bd6f3a1fded1 (verify_claim_3.py, later cancelled; CPU-on-T4):

Iter Val Pre Val Post Gap
100 55.6% 97.2% +41.6 pp
200 54.8% 97.3% +42.4 pp
300 54.8% 97.2% +42.4 pp
400 53.8% 97.2% +43.4 pp
500 53.7% 97.2% +43.4 pp

Paper: 54.2% β†’ 95.7% (+41.5 pp) under 10Γ— OOD noise. >40 pp gain reproduces in training dynamics well before full schedule completion.

Fresh GPU job https://huggingface.co/jobs/Sor0ush/6a5badf4d216bd6f3a1fedda is running the full K-curve fit ((R^2), (\beta)); check outputs/claim3/claim3_results.json on the artifacts bucket when it finishes.