EVALUATION_PROTOCOL.md

# Evaluation Protocol

This file defines how the public Xperience-10M sample episode is turned
into benchmark-style tasks, how the baselines are evaluated, and what the
reported metrics are allowed to mean.

## Protocol At A Glance

| Item | Current protocol |
| --- | --- |
| Source scope | 1 public Xperience-10M sample episode |
| Frames | 5,821 |
| Sliding windows | 1,161 windows, 20 frames each, stride 5 frames |
| Current feature vector | 8,546 dimensions |
| Split | chronological 70/30 train/test by time |
| Baselines | minimal interpretable heads plus compact neural MLP heads |
| Audio | AAC stream extracted from the sample MP4 and included in the current baseline vector |
| Raw data | not redistributed |

## Data Unit

The basic unit is a 20-frame aligned window built from one synchronized
public episode. Feature blocks are documented in
`results/episode_task_suite/feature_manifest.json`; the committed window
table is `results/episode_task_suite/windows.csv`.

## Split Policy

The current suite uses `single_episode_chronological`: The split preserves time order so future episode segments are not mixed randomly into the train set. It is still one episode; cross-episode generalization is evaluated in the multi-episode stage.

This makes some classification metrics intentionally harsh: later test
segments can contain action or subtask labels not present in the train
segment. Those cases are recorded in the task metrics as `unseen_test_classes`.

## Feature And Head Policy

- Input contract: 8,546-dimensional current feature vector.
- Source manifest: `results/episode_task_suite/feature_manifest.json`.
- Normalization: Scalers are fit on train windows only for the baseline heads.
- Audio status: Audio is represented in the current feature vector.

Minimal heads are used first because they make task contracts easy to inspect.
Neural MLP heads reuse the same windows, splits, and feature tensors; they
are not foundation models.

## Unified 20-Task Contracts

Tasks 1-12 are the original public-sample task contracts. Tasks 13-20
are additional sample-supported contracts attached to the same 20-frame
window, feature, chronological split, leakage-control, and minimal/neural
baseline setup. Historical `tier2_task_suite` paths are retained only as
stable artifact locations for tasks 13-20.

| # | Task | Artifact id | Origin | Family | Unit | Input -> target | Primary metric | Minimal | Neural |
| ---: | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ---: | ---: |
| 1 | Action Recognition | `timeline_action` | original | supervised classification | single window | current 20-frame all-feature window -> current action label | macro_f1 (higher better) | 0.0500 | 0.0148 |
| 2 | Procedure Step Recognition | `timeline_subtask` | original | supervised classification | single window | current 20-frame all-feature window -> current subtask label | macro_f1 (higher better) | 0.0506 | 0.0281 |
| 3 | Action Boundary Detection | `transition_detection` | original | temporal diagnostic | single window | current 20-frame all-feature window -> action boundary versus steady | macro_f1 (higher better) | 0.6118 | 0.5862 |
| 4 | Next-Action Prediction | `next_action` | original | short-horizon prediction | single window | current 20-frame all-feature window at time t -> action label at t + 20 frames | macro_f1 (higher better) | 0.0593 | 0.0419 |
| 5 | Hand Trajectory Forecasting | `hand_trajectory_forecast` | original | trajectory regression | single window | current all-feature window -> future left/right hand 3D joints for 10 frames | mpjpe (lower better) | 0.8647 | 0.1079 |
| 6 | Contact State Prediction | `contact_prediction` | original | binary classification | single window | non-contact and non-caption feature blocks -> any body contact | macro_f1 (higher better) | 1.0000 | 1.0000 |
| 7 | Object Relevance Prediction | `object_relevance` | original | multi-label classification | single window | non-caption feature blocks -> current relevant object set | micro_f1 (higher better) | 0.1803 | 0.1679 |
| 8 | Language Grounding | `caption_grounding` | original | retrieval | caption query | caption object/interaction query plus candidate sensor windows -> matching time window | mrr (higher better) | 0.0160 | 0.0168 |
| 9 | Cross-Modal Retrieval | `cross_modal_retrieval` | original | retrieval | sensor query | motion, IMU, and camera query features -> matching depth/video window | top5_accuracy (higher better) | 0.3678 | 0.1983 |
| 10 | Cross-Modal Reconstruction | `modality_reconstruction` | original | cross-modal regression | single window | motion, IMU, and camera features -> depth/video feature vector | r2 (higher better) | -0.0153 | -0.0102 |
| 11 | Temporal Order Verification | `temporal_order` | original | pairwise diagnostic | adjacent window pair | two adjacent windows -> correct versus reversed order | f1 (higher better) | 0.5400 | 0.8520 |
| 12 | Multimodal Synchronization Detection | `misalignment_detection` | original | pairwise diagnostic | paired modality window | motion side plus visual/depth side -> aligned versus shifted by 8 windows | f1 (higher better) | 0.5052 | 0.7153 |
| 13 | Long-Horizon Next-Action Forecasting | `long_horizon_next_action` | additional | classification | single aligned window | Current 20-frame non-caption multimodal window. -> Action label five seconds later. | macro_f1 (higher better) | 0.0750 | 0.0655 |
| 14 | Long-Horizon Next-Subtask Forecasting | `next_subtask_forecast` | additional | classification | single aligned window | Current 20-frame non-caption multimodal window. -> Procedure subtask label five seconds later. | macro_f1 (higher better) | 0.0455 | 0.0507 |
| 15 | Interaction Text Prediction | `interaction_text_prediction` | additional | classification | single aligned window | Current 20-frame sensor window with caption-text features removed. -> Raw annotation interaction phrase for the same window. | macro_f1 (higher better) | 0.0444 | 0.0381 |
| 16 | Action-Object Relation Prediction | `action_object_relation` | additional | classification | single aligned window | Current 20-frame sensor window with caption-text features removed. -> Joint action plus active object-set relation. | macro_f1 (higher better) | 0.0000 | 0.0000 |
| 17 | Future Object-Set Forecasting | `object_set_forecast` | additional | multi_label | single aligned window | Current 20-frame sensor window with caption-text features removed. -> Object set active five seconds later. | micro_f1 (higher better) | 0.1694 | 0.1972 |
| 18 | IMU-to-Hand Pose Reconstruction | `imu_to_hand_pose` | additional | regression | single aligned window | Current IMU acceleration/gyroscope feature block only. -> Current left/right hand joint feature blocks. | mae (lower better) | 0.0420 | 0.0426 |
| 19 | Camera-View Synchronization Retrieval | `camera_view_sync_retrieval` | additional | retrieval | held-out query window | Fisheye camera-1 feature query projected into fisheye camera-3 feature space. -> The synchronized held-out camera-3 window. | mrr (higher better) | 0.4943 | 0.2409 |
| 20 | Time-to-Next-Transition Regression | `time_to_transition` | additional | regression | single aligned window | Current 20-frame non-caption multimodal window. -> Frames until the next action-label boundary, capped at 200 frames. | mae (lower better) | 10.5374 | 10.5545 |

## Leakage Controls

- Use chronological train/test splits instead of random window shuffling.
- Fit scalers and learned projections on train windows only.
- Keep future labels, future mocap, contact labels, object labels, and caption labels on the target side unless a task explicitly treats language as the query.
- For cross-modal tasks, split query-side and candidate-side feature blocks before training and ranking.
- Report unseen test classes when the chronological split exposes labels absent from the train segment.

## Current Limitations

- Cross-episode generalization for Qwen3-Omni has a first verified diagnostic pilot, but strong model quality is not yet shown.
- Feature-vector reconstruction is separate from pixel depth, mesh, NeRF, or Gaussian reconstruction.
- The final verified Qwen3-Omni diagnostic result meets the strict-JSON target, but action/subtask held-out quality remains weak and needs error analysis before larger model-quality claims.
- Full audio-visual representation learning still needs multi-episode training; the current report includes single-episode audio/no-audio ablations.

## Scale-Up Gate

The next Qwen3-Omni quality pilot requires all of the following before
claiming improved held-out model quality:

- selected prepared Xperience-10M episodes
- held-out episode split with no train/test episode leakage
- validation samples during training
- manifest, training metadata, progress logs, metrics, predictions, and run report
- held-out evaluation on test episodes rather than train windows

Current status: verified diagnostic result; strict-JSON quality target met, action/subtask quality still weak. Read
`docs/data/omni_finetune_verified_result.json` before interpreting any
Qwen3-Omni metric.

## Machine-Readable Copy

The JSON mirror is `docs/data/evaluation_protocol.json`.