{ "Deepseek-R1-0528": { "comprehension_score": 7.481132075471698, "structure_score": 7.339622641509434, "prose_style_score": 7.59433962264151, "creativity_score": 8.018867924528301, "depth_score": 7.688679245283019, "helpfulness_score": 7.367924528301887, "overall_score": 7.5 }, "Deepseek-V3-0324": { "comprehension_score": 6.39622641509434, "structure_score": 6.386792452830188, "prose_style_score": 6.9245283018867925, "creativity_score": 7.367924528301887, "depth_score": 6.311320754716981, "helpfulness_score": 6.216981132075472, "overall_score": 6.367924528301887 }, "GLM-5": { "comprehension_score": 7.4245283018867925, "structure_score": 7.518867924528302, "prose_style_score": 7.320754716981132, "creativity_score": 7.433962264150943, "depth_score": 7.254716981132075, "helpfulness_score": 7.443396226415095, "overall_score": 7.330188679245283 }, "Gemini-2.5-Flash": { "comprehension_score": 6.4245283018867925, "structure_score": 6.490566037735849, "prose_style_score": 5.773584905660377, "creativity_score": 5.990566037735849, "depth_score": 6.018867924528302, "helpfulness_score": 6.339622641509434, "overall_score": 6.09433962264151 }, "Gemini-3.1-Flash": { "comprehension_score": 7.415094339622642, "structure_score": 7.471698113207547, "prose_style_score": 7.632075471698113, "creativity_score": 7.669811320754717, "depth_score": 7.2924528301886795, "helpfulness_score": 7.433962264150943, "overall_score": 7.40566037735849 }, "Gemini-3.1-Pro": { "comprehension_score": 7.830188679245283, "structure_score": 7.764150943396227, "prose_style_score": 7.811320754716981, "creativity_score": 8.037735849056604, "depth_score": 7.688679245283019, "helpfulness_score": 7.962264150943396, "overall_score": 7.745283018867925 }, "MiniMax-M2.5": { "comprehension_score": 6.1415094339622645, "structure_score": 6.39622641509434, "prose_style_score": 5.377358490566038, "creativity_score": 6.066037735849057, "depth_score": 5.688679245283019, "helpfulness_score": 6.10377358490566, "overall_score": 5.849056603773585 }, "Mistral-3.1-24B-2503": { "comprehension_score": 4.1415094339622645, "structure_score": 4.386792452830188, "prose_style_score": 3.30188679245283, "creativity_score": 3.650943396226415, "depth_score": 3.518867924528302, "helpfulness_score": 3.8679245283018866, "overall_score": 3.7264150943396226 }, "Mistral-3.2-24B-2506": { "comprehension_score": 5.169811320754717, "structure_score": 5.311320754716981, "prose_style_score": 4.89622641509434, "creativity_score": 5.688679245283019, "depth_score": 4.745283018867925, "helpfulness_score": 4.981132075471698, "overall_score": 4.89622641509434 }, "Phi-4-14B": { "comprehension_score": 4.245283018867925, "structure_score": 4.40566037735849, "prose_style_score": 3.5754716981132075, "creativity_score": 4.0754716981132075, "depth_score": 3.707547169811321, "helpfulness_score": 4.009433962264151, "overall_score": 3.858490566037736 }, "Qwen3.5-Plus": { "comprehension_score": 7.632075471698113, "structure_score": 7.745283018867925, "prose_style_score": 7.754716981132075, "creativity_score": 7.716981132075472, "depth_score": 7.622641509433962, "helpfulness_score": 7.632075471698113, "overall_score": 7.556603773584905 }, "Qwen3-235B": { "comprehension_score": 5.773584905660377, "structure_score": 6.113207547169812, "prose_style_score": 5.433962264150943, "creativity_score": 5.745283018867925, "depth_score": 5.226415094339623, "helpfulness_score": 5.679245283018868, "overall_score": 5.566037735849057 }, "Qwen3-235B-Thinking": { "comprehension_score": 6.179245283018868, "structure_score": 6.1415094339622645, "prose_style_score": 7.490566037735849, "creativity_score": 8.056603773584905, "depth_score": 6.69811320754717, "helpfulness_score": 6.084905660377358, "overall_score": 6.39622641509434 }, "Qwen3-30B-A3B": { "comprehension_score": 4.7075471698113205, "structure_score": 5.10377358490566, "prose_style_score": 4.179245283018868, "creativity_score": 4.547169811320755, "depth_score": 4.245283018867925, "helpfulness_score": 4.471698113207547, "overall_score": 4.330188679245283 }, "Qwen3-30B-A3B-Thinking": { "comprehension_score": 5.867924528301887, "structure_score": 6.009433962264151, "prose_style_score": 6.584905660377358, "creativity_score": 7.122641509433962, "depth_score": 6.009433962264151, "helpfulness_score": 5.811320754716981, "overall_score": 5.943396226415095 }, "Qwen3-32B": { "comprehension_score": 5.037735849056604, "structure_score": 5.30188679245283, "prose_style_score": 4.518867924528302, "creativity_score": 5.018867924528302, "depth_score": 4.5754716981132075, "helpfulness_score": 4.754716981132075, "overall_score": 4.688679245283019 }, "Qwen3-32B-Thinking": { "comprehension_score": 6.377358490566038, "structure_score": 6.273584905660377, "prose_style_score": 7.3584905660377355, "creativity_score": 7.886792452830188, "depth_score": 6.60377358490566, "helpfulness_score": 6.2924528301886795, "overall_score": 6.5 }, "Qwen3-8B": { "comprehension_score": 4.613207547169812, "structure_score": 4.811320754716981, "prose_style_score": 4.216981132075472, "creativity_score": 4.528301886792453, "depth_score": 4.169811320754717, "helpfulness_score": 4.433962264150943, "overall_score": 4.311320754716981 }, "gemma3-27b": { "comprehension_score": 4.90566037735849, "structure_score": 5.113207547169812, "prose_style_score": 4.047169811320755, "creativity_score": 4.7075471698113205, "depth_score": 4.30188679245283, "helpfulness_score": 4.632075471698113, "overall_score": 4.367924528301887 }, "gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14": { "comprehension_score": 4.69811320754717, "structure_score": 4.613207547169812, "prose_style_score": 4.179245283018868, "creativity_score": 4.4245283018867925, "depth_score": 4.160377358490566, "helpfulness_score": 4.235849056603773, "overall_score": 4.216981132075472 }, "gpt-4o-2024-11-20": { "comprehension_score": 5.2075471698113205, "structure_score": 5.216981132075472, "prose_style_score": 4.877358490566038, "creativity_score": 5.377358490566038, "depth_score": 4.764150943396227, "helpfulness_score": 4.8584905660377355, "overall_score": 4.877358490566038 }, "gpt-4o-mini-2024-07-18": { "comprehension_score": 4.2924528301886795, "structure_score": 4.5, "prose_style_score": 3.8773584905660377, "creativity_score": 4.122641509433962, "depth_score": 3.952830188679245, "helpfulness_score": 4.0754716981132075, "overall_score": 4.047169811320755 }, "gpt-5.4": { "comprehension_score": 8.0, "structure_score": 7.971698113207547, "prose_style_score": 8.377358490566039, "creativity_score": 7.830188679245283, "depth_score": 8.216981132075471, "helpfulness_score": 8.11320754716981, "overall_score": 7.943396226415095 }, "o3-2025-04-16": { "comprehension_score": 7.886792452830188, "structure_score": 7.933962264150943, "prose_style_score": 8.273584905660377, "creativity_score": 8.160377358490566, "depth_score": 7.764150943396227, "helpfulness_score": 7.90566037735849, "overall_score": 7.8584905660377355 }, "o4-mini-2025-04-16": { "comprehension_score": 5.433962264150943, "structure_score": 5.537735849056604, "prose_style_score": 4.971698113207547, "creativity_score": 5.5, "depth_score": 4.8584905660377355, "helpfulness_score": 5.150943396226415, "overall_score": 5.056603773584905 }, "step-3.5-flash": { "comprehension_score": 7.5754716981132075, "structure_score": 7.59433962264151, "prose_style_score": 7.481132075471698, "creativity_score": 8.339622641509434, "depth_score": 7.877358490566038, "helpfulness_score": 7.490566037735849, "overall_score": 7.547169811320755 }, "gpt-4.1-2025-04-14": { "comprehension_score": 5.0, "structure_score": 5.0, "prose_style_score": 5.0, "creativity_score": 5.0, "depth_score": 5.0, "helpfulness_score": 5.0, "overall_score": 5.0 } }