{ "paper": { "title": "Bregman meets L\u00e9vy: Stochastic mirror descent with heavy-tailed noise in continuous and discrete time", "source": "arXiv:2606.03769v1", "orid": "69IOkVkTQX", "geometry": "X=[-1,1], h(x)=x^2/2, mirror(y)=clip(eta*y,-1,1)", "noise": "centered symmetric Pareto / compound-Poisson jumps with alpha=p+0.12; Brownian tame component where stated" }, "claim_1": { "rows": [ { "p": 1.25, "seeds": 8, "horizons": [ 256, 512, 1024, 2048, 4096 ], "gap_at_max_T": 0.0027975895691645996, "gap_se": 7.535740222972052e-05, "measured_slope": -0.37776974920457357, "slope_se": 0.019167750380046526, "theory_slope": -0.2, "paper_R0_bound_at_max_T": 0.12211924043813976, "gap_over_paper_bound": 0.022908671550260218, "bound_pass": true }, { "p": 1.5, "seeds": 8, "horizons": [ 256, 512, 1024, 2048, 4096 ], "gap_at_max_T": 0.00035007881854882776, "gap_se": 1.9804117526887215e-05, "measured_slope": -0.6439671830292583, "slope_se": 0.025713989326114472, "theory_slope": -0.3333333333333333, "paper_R0_bound_at_max_T": 0.035355711961319064, "gap_over_paper_bound": 0.009901619826856596, "bound_pass": true }, { "p": 1.75, "seeds": 8, "horizons": [ 256, 512, 1024, 2048, 4096 ], "gap_at_max_T": 7.857721818242748e-05, "gap_se": 7.915933425194222e-06, "measured_slope": -0.8160305880222549, "slope_se": 0.04288091043475578, "theory_slope": -0.42857142857142855, "paper_R0_bound_at_max_T": 0.015032066676439535, "gap_over_paper_bound": 0.005227306389319391, "bound_pass": true }, { "p": 2.0, "seeds": 8, "horizons": [ 256, 512, 1024, 2048, 4096 ], "gap_at_max_T": 2.6736924457419256e-05, "gap_se": 4.088291516479964e-06, "measured_slope": -0.9303635689782251, "slope_se": 0.0686837330855816, "theory_slope": -0.5, "paper_R0_bound_at_max_T": 0.008144422535135941, "gap_over_paper_bound": 0.003282850851864967, "bound_pass": true } ], "baseline": [ 0.0003378313353985914, 0.0 ], "destructive": [ 1.3496873426608316, 0.0 ] }, "claim_2": { "rows": [ { "treatment": "tame", "p": 1.5, "eta": 0.004, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 0.00014929900449299393, "mse_se": 3.7622850557952236e-05, "slope": 1.0368699653429303, "slope_se": 0.11660538616094784, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.00025, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.5971960179719757, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "tame", "p": 1.5, "eta": 0.008, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 0.0002666660062656201, "mse_se": 4.039227466934179e-05, "slope": 1.0368699653429303, "slope_se": 0.11660538616094784, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.0005, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.5333320125312402, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "tame", "p": 1.5, "eta": 0.016, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 0.0005072655632009312, "mse_se": 4.787226606085312e-05, "slope": 1.0368699653429303, "slope_se": 0.11660538616094784, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.001, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.5072655632009312, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "tame", "p": 1.5, "eta": 0.032, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 0.0010150335607430642, "mse_se": 9.4003822213678e-05, "slope": 1.0368699653429303, "slope_se": 0.11660538616094784, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.002, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.5075167803715321, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "tame", "p": 1.5, "eta": 0.064, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 0.0020234008070470298, "mse_se": 0.00016287197719308278, "slope": 1.0368699653429303, "slope_se": 0.11660538616094784, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.004, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.5058502017617574, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "heavy", "p": 1.25, "eta": 0.004, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 0.00017476583663295398, "mse_se": 6.767571663681561e-05, "slope": 0.8030460481197103, "slope_se": 0.1800764623141729, "theory_exponent": 0.25, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.05810778124857912, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.0030076150367077978, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "heavy", "p": 1.25, "eta": 0.008, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 0.0002619893025607717, "mse_se": 0.00012062527045458774, "slope": 0.8030460481197103, "slope_se": 0.1800764623141729, "theory_exponent": 0.25, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.06910218689783199, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.0037913315673804146, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "heavy", "p": 1.25, "eta": 0.016, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 0.000473011218946514, "mse_se": 0.00026194727931930245, "slope": 0.8030460481197103, "slope_se": 0.1800764623141729, "theory_exponent": 0.25, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.08217681232114961, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.005756018097878645, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "heavy", "p": 1.25, "eta": 0.032, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 0.0008820029655063091, "mse_se": 0.0005310178887407616, "slope": 0.8030460481197103, "slope_se": 0.1800764623141729, "theory_exponent": 0.25, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.09772524990055437, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.009025333436382503, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "heavy", "p": 1.25, "eta": 0.064, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 0.0016401994437966144, "mse_se": 0.0010597170138130425, "slope": 0.8030460481197103, "slope_se": 0.1800764623141729, "theory_exponent": 0.25, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.11621556249715824, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.014113423439625149, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "heavy", "p": 1.5, "eta": 0.004, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 2.6636070530708478e-05, "mse_se": 8.299501598672298e-06, "slope": 0.9612324664087314, "slope_se": 0.12858925872082533, "theory_exponent": 0.5, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.005464415796770956, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.00487445895798199, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "heavy", "p": 1.5, "eta": 0.008, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 4.7251903797643956e-05, "mse_se": 1.6747638001254604e-05, "slope": 0.9612324664087314, "slope_se": 0.12858925872082533, "theory_exponent": 0.5, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.007727850930239268, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.006114494731354885, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "heavy", "p": 1.5, "eta": 0.016, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 9.371465785293939e-05, "mse_se": 3.7850566947734126e-05, "slope": 0.9612324664087314, "slope_se": 0.12858925872082533, "theory_exponent": 0.5, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.010928831593541912, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.008574993314776435, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "heavy", "p": 1.5, "eta": 0.032, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 0.00018598671949029006, "mse_se": 8.086916626820479e-05, "slope": 0.9612324664087314, "slope_se": 0.12858925872082533, "theory_exponent": 0.5, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.015455701860478536, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.012033534366101675, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "heavy", "p": 1.5, "eta": 0.064, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 0.0003608037705263764, "mse_se": 0.00016584022244962081, "slope": 0.9612324664087314, "slope_se": 0.12858925872082533, "theory_exponent": 0.5, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.021857663187083824, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.016506969086227997, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "heavy", "p": 1.75, "eta": 0.004, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 7.469037938573843e-06, "mse_se": 1.7734414066451914e-06, "slope": 1.0758020845653231, "slope_se": 0.09429872740415576, "theory_exponent": 0.75, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.0005016321095481787, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.014889473373826137, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "heavy", "p": 1.75, "eta": 0.008, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 1.5371063148690825e-05, "mse_se": 3.4654114915303694e-06, "slope": 1.0758020845653231, "slope_se": 0.09429872740415576, "theory_exponent": 0.75, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.0008436412853904444, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.018219903903324227, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "heavy", "p": 1.75, "eta": 0.016, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 3.337590187591608e-05, "mse_se": 8.286589651469961e-06, "slope": 1.0758020845653231, "slope_se": 0.09429872740415576, "theory_exponent": 0.75, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.001418829865289721, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.02352354055438551, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "heavy", "p": 1.75, "eta": 0.032, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 7.028415940920038e-05, "mse_se": 1.9269793422117813e-05, "slope": 1.0758020845653231, "slope_se": 0.09429872740415576, "theory_exponent": 0.75, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.002386177895154074, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.02945470224660772, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "heavy", "p": 1.75, "eta": 0.064, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 0.0001409088008229936, "mse_se": 4.140548424767764e-05, "slope": 1.0758020845653231, "slope_se": 0.09429872740415576, "theory_exponent": 0.75, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.00401305687638543, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.03511258503515418, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "bounded-control", "p": 1.25, "eta": 0.004, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 3.386847057887935e-06, "mse_se": 4.387272295379809e-07, "slope": 1.170718408582711, "slope_se": 0.06361377815110031, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.05810778124857912, "mse_over_radius_bound": 5.828560280764036e-05, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "bounded-control", "p": 1.25, "eta": 0.008, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 8.46900815286997e-06, "mse_se": 7.335720018321259e-07, "slope": 1.170718408582711, "slope_se": 0.06361377815110031, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.06910218689783199, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.00012255774430686907, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "bounded-control", "p": 1.25, "eta": 0.016, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 1.9548381224532743e-05, "mse_se": 8.105673779282874e-07, "slope": 1.170718408582711, "slope_se": 0.06361377815110031, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.08217681232114961, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.00023788196052357255, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "bounded-control", "p": 1.25, "eta": 0.032, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 4.153629462439247e-05, "mse_se": 2.262732013317742e-06, "slope": 1.170718408582711, "slope_se": 0.06361377815110031, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.09772524990055437, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.00042503134723789385, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "bounded-control", "p": 1.25, "eta": 0.064, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 8.413195210145845e-05, "mse_se": 5.537671168253215e-06, "slope": 1.170718408582711, "slope_se": 0.06361377815110031, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.11621556249715824, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.0007239301716025827, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "bounded-control", "p": 1.5, "eta": 0.004, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 2.5460791273237015e-06, "mse_se": 2.9724486048579667e-07, "slope": 1.1923593010844815, "slope_se": 0.06454791953287653, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.005464415796770956, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.00046593802924518223, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "bounded-control", "p": 1.5, "eta": 0.008, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 6.6046367547084715e-06, "mse_se": 5.255760969689046e-07, "slope": 1.1923593010844815, "slope_se": 0.06454791953287653, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.007727850930239268, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.0008546537471193146, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "bounded-control", "p": 1.5, "eta": 0.016, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 1.5572976904900848e-05, "mse_se": 6.129022967410445e-07, "slope": 1.1923593010844815, "slope_se": 0.06454791953287653, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.010928831593541912, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.0014249443567328152, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "bounded-control", "p": 1.5, "eta": 0.032, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 3.348206405434443e-05, "mse_se": 1.9955619825243574e-06, "slope": 1.1923593010844815, "slope_se": 0.06454791953287653, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.015455701860478536, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.00216632439966772, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "bounded-control", "p": 1.5, "eta": 0.064, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 6.813730613131983e-05, "mse_se": 4.83994917962275e-06, "slope": 1.1923593010844815, "slope_se": 0.06454791953287653, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.021857663187083824, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.00311731888025357, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "bounded-control", "p": 1.75, "eta": 0.004, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 2.0092585150399113e-06, "mse_se": 2.4566595467664723e-07, "slope": 1.2057123500508078, "slope_se": 0.06579312961374312, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.0005016321095481787, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.0040054423885457725, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "bounded-control", "p": 1.75, "eta": 0.008, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 5.313153634821394e-06, "mse_se": 4.39608935263333e-07, "slope": 1.2057123500508078, "slope_se": 0.06579312961374312, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.0008436412853904444, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.006297882437513025, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "bounded-control", "p": 1.75, "eta": 0.016, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 1.2637064884574077e-05, "mse_se": 5.302540525572664e-07, "slope": 1.2057123500508078, "slope_se": 0.06579312961374312, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.001418829865289721, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.008906680916244756, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "bounded-control", "p": 1.75, "eta": 0.032, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 2.7332033053486355e-05, "mse_se": 1.661470436378566e-06, "slope": 1.2057123500508078, "slope_se": 0.06579312961374312, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.002386177895154074, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.011454314914656245, "bound_pass": true }, { "treatment": "bounded-control", "p": 1.75, "eta": 0.064, "seeds": 8, "stationary_mse": 5.567109721144275e-05, "mse_se": 3.976220630479608e-06, "slope": 1.2057123500508078, "slope_se": 0.06579312961374312, "theory_exponent": 1.0, "paper_radius2_bound": 0.00401305687638543, "mse_over_radius_bound": 0.013872491451351132, "bound_pass": true } ], "baseline": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "claim_3": { "rows": [ { "p": 1.5, "delta": 0.5, "seeds": 8, "mean_hit_time": 1.1750000000000003, "hit_se": 0.025000000000000022, "censored": 0, "paper_bound": 15.288238079999976, "mean_over_bound": 0.07685646925770546, "measured_delta_slope": -4.8372629435235535, "theory_bound_slope": -6.0 }, { "p": 1.5, "delta": 0.35, "seeds": 8, "mean_hit_time": 7.925000000000001, "hit_se": 0.2561737691489901, "censored": 0, "paper_bound": 129.9478795399874, "mean_over_bound": 0.06098598936784751, "measured_delta_slope": -4.8372629435235535, "theory_bound_slope": -6.0 }, { "p": 1.5, "delta": 0.25, "seeds": 8, "mean_hit_time": 39.025000000000006, "hit_se": 0.3730903758761792, "censored": 0, "paper_bound": 978.4472371199985, "mean_over_bound": 0.03988462384018558, "measured_delta_slope": -4.8372629435235535, "theory_bound_slope": -6.0 }, { "p": 1.5, "delta": 0.18, "seeds": 8, "mean_hit_time": 186.22500000000002, "hit_se": 0.7610495572375224, "censored": 0, "paper_bound": 7023.319615912199, "mean_over_bound": 0.026515239257812538, "measured_delta_slope": -4.8372629435235535, "theory_bound_slope": -6.0 }, { "p": 1.5, "delta": 0.13, "seeds": 8, "mean_hit_time": 814.6, "hit_se": 3.50957872929827, "censored": 0, "paper_bound": 49489.98810601364, "mean_over_bound": 0.016459894842872597, "measured_delta_slope": -4.8372629435235535, "theory_bound_slope": -6.0 }, { "p": 1.75, "delta": 0.5, "seeds": 8, "mean_hit_time": 0.2, "hit_se": 0.0, "censored": 0, "paper_bound": 3.2139349063010916, "mean_over_bound": 0.062229013913097396, "measured_delta_slope": -3.632913212690609, "theory_bound_slope": -4.666666666666667 }, { "p": 1.75, "delta": 0.35, "seeds": 8, "mean_hit_time": 1.0, "hit_se": 0.03779644730092273, "censored": 0, "paper_bound": 16.979030550633492, "mean_over_bound": 0.05889617767150373, "measured_delta_slope": -3.632913212690609, "theory_bound_slope": -4.666666666666667 }, { "p": 1.75, "delta": 0.25, "seeds": 8, "mean_hit_time": 3.4250000000000003, "hit_se": 0.11611263005006327, "censored": 0, "paper_bound": 81.62885841951473, "mean_over_bound": 0.04195820040013199, "measured_delta_slope": -3.632913212690609, "theory_bound_slope": -4.666666666666667 }, { "p": 1.75, "delta": 0.18, "seeds": 8, "mean_hit_time": 10.325000000000001, "hit_se": 0.42583950699093875, "censored": 0, "paper_bound": 378.1163058596349, "mean_over_bound": 0.027306412973982848, "measured_delta_slope": -3.632913212690609, "theory_bound_slope": -4.666666666666667 }, { "p": 1.75, "delta": 0.13, "seeds": 8, "mean_hit_time": 27.550000000000004, "hit_se": 0.3849860850917675, "censored": 0, "paper_bound": 1726.4796060424853, "mean_over_bound": 0.015957327212889217, "measured_delta_slope": -3.632913212690609, "theory_bound_slope": -4.666666666666667 } ], "baseline": [ 40.6, 39.0, 38.6, 37.6, 39.400000000000006, 39.6, 39.800000000000004, 37.6 ], "destructive_censored": 8 }, "claim_4": { "rows": [ { "p": 1.25, "T": 512, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.06273554919866123, "sda_se": 0.00037013150912261884, "lmf_gap": 0.005718644000595717, "lmf_se": 0.00025930587776265405, "sda_slope": -0.2676957755301662, "sda_slope_se": 0.018201976853914177, "lmf_slope": -0.366548481131481, "lmf_slope_se": 0.034754686990722046, "theory_slope": -0.2, "sda_paper_bound": 0.6810555664229504, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.09211516987984072, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.18505837196131789, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.030901838917025953, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 1.25, "T": 1024, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.05248535029442655, "sda_se": 0.0003664977483775579, "lmf_gap": 0.004463997687288207, "lmf_se": 0.00021439783309429945, "sda_slope": -0.2676957755301662, "sda_slope_se": 0.018201976853914177, "lmf_slope": -0.366548481131481, "lmf_slope_se": 0.034754686990722046, "theory_slope": -0.2, "sda_paper_bound": 0.5927630353030516, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.08854356153904448, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.16110266995358896, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.027709023621856867, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 1.25, "T": 2048, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.044140012874287315, "sda_se": 0.0005941957843441603, "lmf_gap": 0.003599440584931757, "lmf_se": 0.00010533454774557434, "sda_slope": -0.2676957755301662, "sda_slope_se": 0.018201976853914177, "lmf_slope": -0.366548481131481, "lmf_slope_se": 0.034754686990722046, "theory_slope": -0.2, "sda_paper_bound": 0.5159650584429876, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.08554845362491661, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.14024802007660644, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.02566482281151396, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 1.25, "T": 4096, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.0370380464912295, "sda_se": 0.001467599889439019, "lmf_gap": 0.002781289717521668, "lmf_se": 8.713466275181362e-05, "sda_slope": -0.2676957755301662, "sda_slope_se": 0.018201976853914177, "lmf_slope": -0.366548481131481, "lmf_slope_se": 0.034754686990722046, "theory_slope": -0.2, "sda_paper_bound": 0.44914110434805815, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.08246416578814655, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.12209299287885586, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.02278009287790449, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 1.25, "T": 8192, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.029784548576652997, "sda_se": 0.0013475960805069023, "lmf_gap": 0.002062079719786912, "lmf_se": 0.00015556582567764153, "sda_slope": -0.2676957755301662, "sda_slope_se": 0.018201976853914177, "lmf_slope": -0.366548481131481, "lmf_slope_se": 0.034754686990722046, "theory_slope": -0.2, "sda_paper_bound": 0.3909837574293442, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.07617848059080932, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.10628812372519765, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.019400847879470624, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 1.5, "T": 512, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.020299189970658348, "sda_se": 0.0001350993052377635, "lmf_gap": 0.0012196309094500268, "lmf_se": 0.00010124192639684171, "sda_slope": -0.5860486846836914, "sda_slope_se": 0.01571147844420545, "lmf_slope": -0.6461334464274452, "lmf_slope_se": 0.047829592773955466, "theory_slope": -0.3333333333333333, "sda_paper_bound": 0.2885552660332561, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.07034766770923827, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.07060000000000001, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.017275225346317657, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 1.5, "T": 1024, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.013804600306821398, "sda_se": 0.00014340029094809246, "lmf_gap": 0.0007893202151434956, "lmf_se": 4.815502192397839e-05, "sda_slope": -0.5860486846836914, "sda_slope_se": 0.01571147844420545, "lmf_slope": -0.6461334464274452, "lmf_slope_se": 0.047829592773955466, "theory_slope": -0.3333333333333333, "sda_paper_bound": 0.2289232123349109, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.060302317820988355, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.05603525713447745, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.014086135328142211, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 1.5, "T": 2048, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.009311845934982011, "sda_se": 0.00014303413305610552, "lmf_gap": 0.0005268383778813218, "lmf_se": 2.615453238909645e-05, "sda_slope": -0.5860486846836914, "sda_slope_se": 0.01571147844420545, "lmf_slope": -0.6461334464274452, "lmf_slope_se": 0.047829592773955466, "theory_slope": -0.3333333333333333, "sda_paper_bound": 0.18164484699460537, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.05126402476618872, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.04447521306128902, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.011845662822465014, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 1.5, "T": 4096, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.0062041119932328935, "sda_se": 0.00022987555612491003, "lmf_gap": 0.00033187104436155487, "lmf_se": 1.6491064682524838e-05, "sda_slope": -0.5860486846836914, "sda_slope_se": 0.01571147844420545, "lmf_slope": -0.6461334464274452, "lmf_slope_se": 0.047829592773955466, "theory_slope": -0.3333333333333333, "sda_paper_bound": 0.14414579707912803, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.04304053339707977, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.035300000000000005, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.009401446015908069, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 1.5, "T": 8192, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.00399279074445409, "sda_se": 0.0001268877262009361, "lmf_gap": 0.00020107692314433383, "lmf_se": 1.7484666345610177e-05, "sda_slope": -0.5860486846836914, "sda_slope_se": 0.01571147844420545, "lmf_slope": -0.6461334464274452, "lmf_slope_se": 0.047829592773955466, "theory_slope": -0.3333333333333333, "sda_paper_bound": 0.11439568819870544, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.03490333252350043, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.028017628567238724, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.007176800229961466, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 1.75, "T": 512, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.007561183833494433, "sda_se": 6.82066036829144e-05, "lmf_gap": 0.0003855622117886156, "lmf_se": 5.161907756358701e-05, "sda_slope": -0.8167287045566036, "sda_slope_se": 0.014409603100413768, "lmf_slope": -0.853328489837801, "lmf_slope_se": 0.07336203210294678, "theory_slope": -0.42857142857142855, "sda_paper_bound": 0.1579294649488694, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.047876967328056304, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.03640708556210963, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.010590306964584012, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 1.75, "T": 1024, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.004402023411794142, "sda_se": 6.526116958336639e-05, "lmf_gap": 0.00021470374620362524, "lmf_se": 2.042049541653712e-05, "sda_slope": -0.8167287045566036, "sda_slope_se": 0.014409603100413768, "lmf_slope": -0.853328489837801, "lmf_slope_se": 0.07336203210294678, "theory_slope": -0.42857142857142855, "sda_paper_bound": 0.11725571281659952, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.037542080518323036, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.02705036061470758, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.007937186097507641, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 1.75, "T": 2048, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.002507430185174823, "sda_se": 4.524585108297467e-05, "lmf_gap": 0.00012530583710447163, "lmf_se": 1.064206793552962e-05, "sda_slope": -0.8167287045566036, "sda_slope_se": 0.014409603100413768, "lmf_slope": -0.853328489837801, "lmf_slope_se": 0.07336203210294678, "theory_slope": -0.42857142857142855, "sda_paper_bound": 0.08707794546525582, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.02879523824060927, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.020098340696275252, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.006234635933288467, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 1.75, "T": 4096, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.0014176658045538316, "sda_se": 4.055653734780267e-05, "lmf_gap": 6.829678301285914e-05, "lmf_se": 5.958577468930608e-06, "sda_slope": -0.8167287045566036, "sda_slope_se": 0.014409603100413768, "lmf_slope": -0.853328489837801, "lmf_slope_se": 0.07336203210294678, "theory_slope": -0.42857142857142855, "sda_paper_bound": 0.06467730766466505, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.021919060266145565, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.014933009747896872, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.004573544393652987, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 1.75, "T": 8192, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.0007881026054856755, "sda_se": 2.0255505859212637e-05, "lmf_gap": 3.5226367570175975e-05, "lmf_se": 4.260407316694122e-06, "sda_slope": -0.8167287045566036, "sda_slope_se": 0.014409603100413768, "lmf_slope": -0.853328489837801, "lmf_slope_se": 0.07336203210294678, "theory_slope": -0.42857142857142855, "sda_paper_bound": 0.048044376327768146, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.01640363900467945, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.011095183602500565, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.0031749242583274484, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 2.0, "T": 512, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.0030867723109672075, "sda_se": 0.00011794200437935845, "lmf_gap": 0.00016251347907582744, "lmf_se": 3.2047746472274625e-05, "sda_slope": -0.9309027617644667, "sda_slope_se": 0.024641881808545537, "lmf_slope": -1.0230989279420224, "lmf_slope_se": 0.11455613134941793, "theory_slope": -0.5, "sda_paper_bound": 0.10110788271683502, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.030529492142685754, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.0225967757041181, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.007191887957989092, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 2.0, "T": 1024, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.0015847846314102551, "sda_se": 6.398889735758811e-05, "lmf_gap": 7.966563315752725e-05, "lmf_se": 1.1643850041373132e-05, "sda_slope": -0.9309027617644667, "sda_slope_se": 0.024641881808545537, "lmf_slope": -1.0230989279420224, "lmf_slope_se": 0.11455613134941793, "theory_slope": -0.5, "sda_paper_bound": 0.07142125852272728, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.02218925659096239, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.015978333333333334, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.004985853749297627, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 2.0, "T": 2048, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.0008161060532538181, "sda_se": 2.1256955109896918e-05, "lmf_gap": 4.2051562210437934e-05, "lmf_se": 5.891467102667199e-06, "sda_slope": -0.9309027617644667, "sda_slope_se": 0.024641881808545537, "lmf_slope": -1.0230989279420224, "lmf_slope_se": 0.11455613134941793, "theory_slope": -0.5, "sda_paper_bound": 0.05046605073341751, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.01617138732659757, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.01129838785205905, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.0037219081838099884, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 2.0, "T": 4096, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.0004341538580646733, "sda_se": 1.0594666112589563e-05, "lmf_gap": 2.0493742766596674e-05, "lmf_se": 3.085560054155993e-06, "sda_slope": -0.9309027617644667, "sda_slope_se": 0.024641881808545537, "lmf_slope": -1.0230989279420224, "lmf_slope_se": 0.11455613134941793, "theory_slope": -0.5, "sda_paper_bound": 0.03566668394886364, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.012172532178408631, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.007989166666666667, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.002565191542705331, "lmf_bound_pass": true }, { "p": 2.0, "T": 8192, "seeds": 8, "sda_gap": 0.00023416948415784977, "sda_se": 1.054267847585875e-05, "lmf_gap": 9.181136220669485e-06, "lmf_se": 1.726781423025942e-06, "sda_slope": -0.9309027617644667, "sda_slope_se": 0.024641881808545537, "lmf_slope": -1.0230989279420224, "lmf_slope_se": 0.11455613134941793, "theory_slope": -0.5, "sda_paper_bound": 0.025211052710458755, "sda_gap_over_bound": 0.00928836597373441, "sda_bound_pass": true, "lmf_paper_bound": 0.005649193926029525, "lmf_gap_over_bound": 0.0016252117277061415, "lmf_bound_pass": true } ], "baseline": [ 0.003939990777114324, 0.0 ], "destructive": [ 1.3468851594615545, 0.0 ] }, "claim_5": { "rows": [ { "p": 1.5, "eps": 0.08, "seeds": 20, "eta_mean": 0.19509221155311723, "sigma_p": 0.07014805770653947, "iterations_to_mean_mse_eps": 40.0, "iteration_se": 0.0, "log_corrected_ratio": 0.1013568898531113, "max_mean_mse": 0.0011930736004510086, "measured_eps_slope": -0.9660220671769074, "theory_power_slope": -2.0 }, { "p": 1.5, "eps": 0.05, "seeds": 20, "eta_mean": 0.07620789513793644, "sigma_p": 0.07014805770653947, "iterations_to_mean_mse_eps": 44.0, "iteration_se": 0.21275139927797618, "log_corrected_ratio": 0.03671890207648675, "max_mean_mse": 0.0008852798018670184, "measured_eps_slope": -0.9660220671769074, "theory_power_slope": -2.0 }, { "p": 1.5, "eps": 0.03, "seeds": 20, "eta_mean": 0.02743484224965711, "sigma_p": 0.07014805770653947, "iterations_to_mean_mse_eps": 76.0, "iteration_se": 1.0647460779577054, "log_corrected_ratio": 0.01950630846628178, "max_mean_mse": 0.00033664730177849133, "measured_eps_slope": -0.9660220671769074, "theory_power_slope": -2.0 }, { "p": 1.5, "eps": 0.02, "seeds": 20, "eta_mean": 0.012193263222069827, "sigma_p": 0.07014805770653947, "iterations_to_mean_mse_eps": 152.0, "iteration_se": 1.7605322161808135, "log_corrected_ratio": 0.015541830893028151, "max_mean_mse": 0.00024188293800586833, "measured_eps_slope": -0.9660220671769074, "theory_power_slope": -2.0 }, { "p": 1.75, "eps": 0.08, "seeds": 20, "eta_mean": 0.1714285714285714, "sigma_p": 0.033699430083239904, "iterations_to_mean_mse_eps": 40.0, "iteration_se": 0.0, "log_corrected_ratio": 0.5459169989332092, "max_mean_mse": 0.0005737974650562938, "measured_eps_slope": -0.1504183539919776, "theory_power_slope": -1.3333333333333333 }, { "p": 1.75, "eps": 0.05, "seeds": 20, "eta_mean": 0.1714285714285714, "sigma_p": 0.033699430083239904, "iterations_to_mean_mse_eps": 40.0, "iteration_se": 0.0, "log_corrected_ratio": 0.24595198517321656, "max_mean_mse": 0.0005737974650562938, "measured_eps_slope": -0.1504183539919776, "theory_power_slope": -1.3333333333333333 }, { "p": 1.75, "eps": 0.03, "seeds": 20, "eta_mean": 0.1284565312197629, "sigma_p": 0.033699430083239904, "iterations_to_mean_mse_eps": 42.0, "iteration_se": 0.13377121081198773, "log_corrected_ratio": 0.1116511710955674, "max_mean_mse": 0.000516434333314606, "measured_eps_slope": -0.1504183539919776, "theory_power_slope": -1.3333333333333333 }, { "p": 1.75, "eps": 0.02, "seeds": 20, "eta_mean": 0.07481141082758229, "sigma_p": 0.033699430083239904, "iterations_to_mean_mse_eps": 50.0, "iteration_se": 0.20390916450326857, "log_corrected_ratio": 0.06938654534568188, "max_mean_mse": 0.00021137691982808332, "measured_eps_slope": -0.1504183539919776, "theory_power_slope": -1.3333333333333333 } ], "destructive": [ { "p": 1.5, "eps": 0.05, "seeds": 20, "control_final_mse": 2.8899999999999997, "control_final_mse_se": 1.0188105198175e-16, "control_reached": 0 }, { "p": 1.5, "eps": 0.02, "seeds": 20, "control_final_mse": 2.8899999999999997, "control_final_mse_se": 1.0188105198175e-16, "control_reached": 0 }, { "p": 1.75, "eps": 0.05, "seeds": 20, "control_final_mse": 2.8899999999999997, "control_final_mse_se": 1.0188105198175e-16, "control_reached": 0 }, { "p": 1.75, "eps": 0.02, "seeds": 20, "control_final_mse": 2.8899999999999997, "control_final_mse_se": 1.0188105198175e-16, "control_reached": 0 } ], "baseline": [ 2.7733391199176196e-30, 0.0 ] }, "claim_6": { "rows": [ { "function": "Huber(a=1.0)", "seeds": 12, "trials": 12, "margin_mean": 0.10717406311828749, "margin_se": 0.03336110366071947, "pass_rate": 1.0, "destructive_margin_mean": -0.2528259368818276, "destructive_margin_se": 0.03336110366067248, "destructive_pass_rate": 0.0, "max_jump_note": "unbounded Pareto large jumps, alpha=1.45" }, { "function": "Huber(a=1.5)", "seeds": 12, "trials": 12, "margin_mean": 0.17434671657397904, "margin_se": 0.020135557496682843, "pass_rate": 1.0, "destructive_margin_mean": -0.18565328342610443, "destructive_margin_se": 0.020135557496646556, "destructive_pass_rate": 0.0, "max_jump_note": "unbounded Pareto large jumps, alpha=1.45" }, { "function": "Huber(a=2.0)", "seeds": 12, "trials": 12, "margin_mean": 0.20395777275784496, "margin_se": 0.010385763662758767, "pass_rate": 1.0, "destructive_margin_mean": -0.1560422272422015, "destructive_margin_se": 0.010385763662717389, "destructive_pass_rate": 0.0, "max_jump_note": "unbounded Pareto large jumps, alpha=1.45" } ], "quadratic_baseline": [ 0.0031226959787806342, 0.0017117577613460437 ] } }