ezhoureal commited on
Commit
1c1c357
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 7b72a4d

Upload eval_report/lora_model_ablation_report.html with huggingface_hub

Browse files
eval_report/lora_model_ablation_report.html CHANGED
@@ -38,11 +38,11 @@ h3, h4 { letter-spacing: 0; }
38
  .panel { padding: 20px; }
39
  .panel p { margin: 0 0 12px; }
40
  .panel p:last-child { margin-bottom: 0; }
41
- .metrics { display: grid; grid-template-columns: repeat(3, minmax(0, 1fr)); gap: 10px; }
42
  .metric { padding: 14px; background: var(--soft); border-radius: 6px; min-width: 0; }
43
  .metric strong { display: block; font-size: 22px; }
44
  .metric span { color: var(--muted); font-size: 12px; }
45
- .model-grid { display: grid; grid-template-columns: repeat(3, minmax(0, 1fr)); gap: 14px; }
46
  .model-card { padding: 18px; min-width: 0; }
47
  .model-title { display: flex; justify-content: space-between; gap: 12px; align-items: baseline; }
48
  .model-title h3 { margin: 0; font-size: 18px; }
@@ -67,21 +67,31 @@ figcaption span { color: var(--muted); }
67
  .eval-heading { display: flex; justify-content: space-between; gap: 14px; align-items: baseline; margin-bottom: 10px; }
68
  .eval-heading h3 { margin: 0; font-size: 18px; }
69
  .eval-heading span { color: var(--muted); font-size: 12px; }
70
- .result-grid { display: grid; grid-template-columns: repeat(4, minmax(0, 1fr)); gap: 12px; }
71
  .result-cell { overflow: hidden; min-width: 0; }
72
  .result-cell a { display: block; aspect-ratio: 1 / 1; background: #eceae2; }
73
  .source-cell a { background: #e7ebe7; }
74
  .result-cell figcaption { display: grid; gap: 2px; min-height: 56px; padding: 9px 10px 11px; }
75
  .result-cell figcaption strong { font-size: 13px; }
76
  .result-cell figcaption span { font-size: 12px; overflow-wrap: anywhere; }
77
- .findings { display: grid; grid-template-columns: repeat(3, minmax(0, 1fr)); gap: 12px; }
78
  .finding { padding: 16px; background: var(--soft); border-radius: 8px; border: 1px solid var(--line); }
79
  .finding h3 { margin: 0 0 6px; font-size: 16px; }
80
  .finding p { margin: 0; color: var(--muted); }
81
  footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--muted); }
 
 
 
 
 
82
  @media (max-width: 1100px) {
83
- .overview, .model-grid, .training-grid, .findings { grid-template-columns: 1fr; }
 
 
 
84
  .result-grid { grid-template-columns: repeat(2, minmax(0, 1fr)); }
 
 
85
  }
86
  @media (max-width: 620px) {
87
  header, main, footer { width: min(100% - 24px, 1480px); }
@@ -102,7 +112,7 @@ footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--m
102
  <body>
103
  <header>
104
  <p class="kicker">LoRA training progress report</p>
105
- <h1>Comparing style-transfer LoRA edits across Flux Klein, SD 1.5, and SD 3.5</h1>
106
  <p class="subtitle">This report summarizes the ablation in <code>ABLATION.md</code> and visualizes the generated artifacts under <code>outputs/</code>. The goal is to learn a compact LoRA that turns a normal source image into the project-specific stylized target look while preserving the source image layout and recognizable structure.</p>
107
  </header>
108
  <main>
@@ -110,14 +120,15 @@ footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--m
110
  <article class="panel">
111
  <h2>Purpose</h2>
112
  <p>The training data is paired: each conditioning image provides the source structure, and each target image provides the desired rendering style. A successful model should transfer the luminous, graphic label style from the targets without drifting away from the source image content.</p>
113
- <p>The evaluation set uses five held-out source images. Each result row below starts with the eval source image on the left, followed by the three model outputs for direct structure and style comparison.</p>
114
  </article>
115
  <article class="panel">
116
  <h2>Progress So Far</h2>
117
  <div class="metrics">
118
  <div class="metric"><strong>25</strong><span>paired training examples</span></div>
119
  <div class="metric"><strong>5</strong><span>held-out eval sources</span></div>
120
- <div class="metric"><strong>3</strong><span>model families compared</span></div>
 
121
  </div>
122
  </article>
123
  </section>
@@ -127,9 +138,29 @@ footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--m
127
  <div class="model-grid">
128
  <article class="model-card">
129
  <div class="model-title">
130
- <h3>FLUX.2 Klein 4B</h3>
131
  <span>Best result so far</span>
132
  </div>
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
133
  <dl>
134
  <div><dt>Size</dt><dd>4B</dd></div>
135
  <div><dt>Base repo</dt><dd><code>black-forest-labs/FLUX.2-klein-base-4B</code></dd></div>
@@ -139,10 +170,10 @@ footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--m
139
  <div><dt>Conditioning</dt><dd>source_latents_concatenated_to_noisy_target_latents</dd></div>
140
  <div><dt>Checkpoint</dt><dd><code>../local_edit_lora/flux2_klein_base/checkpoint-002000</code></dd></div>
141
  </dl>
142
- <p>Native multi-reference/editing path. After 2000 LoRA steps it best preserves the eval-source structure while transferring the target stylized label/rendering look.</p>
143
- <p class="decision">Recommended path for deployment work: continue with ONNX then CANN export.</p>
144
  </article>
145
-
146
  <article class="model-card">
147
  <div class="model-title">
148
  <h3>Stable Diffusion 1.5</h3>
@@ -160,7 +191,7 @@ footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--m
160
  <p>Pix2Pix-style pipeline learns parts of the style but quality is weaker. High image guidance ignores the source image; weak image guidance fails to transfer enough style.</p>
161
  <p class="decision">Keep as a low-cost baseline; next useful branch is ControlNet plus IP-Adapter with stronger base weights.</p>
162
  </article>
163
-
164
  <article class="model-card">
165
  <div class="model-title">
166
  <h3>Stable Diffusion 3.5 Medium</h3>
@@ -198,7 +229,7 @@ footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--m
198
  </div>
199
  <h4>Pair 001</h4>
200
  </article>
201
-
202
  <article class="pair-card">
203
  <div class="pair-images">
204
  <figure>
@@ -212,7 +243,7 @@ footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--m
212
  </div>
213
  <h4>Pair 002</h4>
214
  </article>
215
-
216
  <article class="pair-card">
217
  <div class="pair-images">
218
  <figure>
@@ -226,7 +257,7 @@ footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--m
226
  </div>
227
  <h4>Pair 004</h4>
228
  </article>
229
-
230
  <article class="pair-card">
231
  <div class="pair-images">
232
  <figure>
@@ -240,7 +271,7 @@ footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--m
240
  </div>
241
  <h4>Pair 009</h4>
242
  </article>
243
-
244
  <article class="pair-card">
245
  <div class="pair-images">
246
  <figure>
@@ -254,7 +285,7 @@ footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--m
254
  </div>
255
  <h4>Pair 017</h4>
256
  </article>
257
-
258
  <article class="pair-card">
259
  <div class="pair-images">
260
  <figure>
@@ -274,7 +305,8 @@ footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--m
274
  <section>
275
  <h2>Qualitative Findings</h2>
276
  <div class="findings">
277
- <article class="finding"><h3>Flux Klein</h3><p>Best current direction: learns the style and remains closest to the editable-source objective after 2000 steps.</p></article>
 
278
  <article class="finding"><h3>SD 1.5</h3><p>Small and cheap, but current pix2pix-style behavior is weak and sensitive to image-guidance tradeoffs.</p></article>
279
  <article class="finding"><h3>SD 3.5</h3><p>Learns style, but source-structure preservation is not reliable enough in this setup, so it is on pause.</p></article>
280
  </div>
@@ -282,7 +314,7 @@ footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--m
282
 
283
  <section>
284
  <h2>Held-Out Eval Comparison</h2>
285
-
286
  <section class="eval-row">
287
  <div class="eval-heading">
288
  <h3>Eval 1: eval01.jpg</h3>
@@ -293,25 +325,30 @@ footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--m
293
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval01.jpg"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval01.jpg" alt="Eval source eval01.jpg"></a>
294
  <figcaption><strong>Eval source</strong><span>1000x667 · 0.32 MB</span></figcaption>
295
  </figure>
296
-
 
 
 
 
 
297
  <figure class="result-cell">
298
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval01-001.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval01-001.png" alt="Flux Klein output for eval01.jpg"></a>
299
  <figcaption><strong>Flux Klein</strong><span>768x768 · 0.44 MB</span></figcaption>
300
  </figure>
301
-
302
  <figure class="result-cell">
303
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval01-001.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval01-001.png" alt="SD 1.5 output for eval01.jpg"></a>
304
  <figcaption><strong>SD 1.5</strong><span>512x512 · 0.28 MB</span></figcaption>
305
  </figure>
306
-
307
  <figure class="result-cell">
308
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval01-001.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval01-001.png" alt="SD 3.5 output for eval01.jpg"></a>
309
  <figcaption><strong>SD 3.5</strong><span>1024x1024 · 1.09 MB</span></figcaption>
310
  </figure>
311
-
312
  </div>
313
  </section>
314
-
315
  <section class="eval-row">
316
  <div class="eval-heading">
317
  <h3>Eval 2: eval02.jpg</h3>
@@ -322,25 +359,30 @@ footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--m
322
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval02.jpg"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval02.jpg" alt="Eval source eval02.jpg"></a>
323
  <figcaption><strong>Eval source</strong><span>2000x1333 · 0.86 MB</span></figcaption>
324
  </figure>
325
-
 
 
 
 
 
326
  <figure class="result-cell">
327
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval02-002.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval02-002.png" alt="Flux Klein output for eval02.jpg"></a>
328
  <figcaption><strong>Flux Klein</strong><span>768x768 · 0.33 MB</span></figcaption>
329
  </figure>
330
-
331
  <figure class="result-cell">
332
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval02-002.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval02-002.png" alt="SD 1.5 output for eval02.jpg"></a>
333
  <figcaption><strong>SD 1.5</strong><span>512x512 · 0.35 MB</span></figcaption>
334
  </figure>
335
-
336
  <figure class="result-cell">
337
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval02-002.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval02-002.png" alt="SD 3.5 output for eval02.jpg"></a>
338
  <figcaption><strong>SD 3.5</strong><span>1024x1024 · 1.03 MB</span></figcaption>
339
  </figure>
340
-
341
  </div>
342
  </section>
343
-
344
  <section class="eval-row">
345
  <div class="eval-heading">
346
  <h3>Eval 3: eval03.jpg</h3>
@@ -351,25 +393,30 @@ footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--m
351
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval03.jpg"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval03.jpg" alt="Eval source eval03.jpg"></a>
352
  <figcaption><strong>Eval source</strong><span>612x408 · 0.02 MB</span></figcaption>
353
  </figure>
354
-
 
 
 
 
 
355
  <figure class="result-cell">
356
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval03-003.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval03-003.png" alt="Flux Klein output for eval03.jpg"></a>
357
  <figcaption><strong>Flux Klein</strong><span>768x768 · 0.42 MB</span></figcaption>
358
  </figure>
359
-
360
  <figure class="result-cell">
361
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval03-003.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval03-003.png" alt="SD 1.5 output for eval03.jpg"></a>
362
  <figcaption><strong>SD 1.5</strong><span>512x512 · 0.25 MB</span></figcaption>
363
  </figure>
364
-
365
  <figure class="result-cell">
366
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval03-003.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval03-003.png" alt="SD 3.5 output for eval03.jpg"></a>
367
  <figcaption><strong>SD 3.5</strong><span>1024x1024 · 0.85 MB</span></figcaption>
368
  </figure>
369
-
370
  </div>
371
  </section>
372
-
373
  <section class="eval-row">
374
  <div class="eval-heading">
375
  <h3>Eval 4: eval04.webp</h3>
@@ -380,25 +427,30 @@ footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--m
380
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval04.webp"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval04.webp" alt="Eval source eval04.webp"></a>
381
  <figcaption><strong>Eval source</strong><span>2560x1707 · 0.13 MB</span></figcaption>
382
  </figure>
383
-
 
 
 
 
 
384
  <figure class="result-cell">
385
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval04-004.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval04-004.png" alt="Flux Klein output for eval04.webp"></a>
386
  <figcaption><strong>Flux Klein</strong><span>768x768 · 0.45 MB</span></figcaption>
387
  </figure>
388
-
389
  <figure class="result-cell">
390
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval04-004.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval04-004.png" alt="SD 1.5 output for eval04.webp"></a>
391
  <figcaption><strong>SD 1.5</strong><span>512x512 · 0.28 MB</span></figcaption>
392
  </figure>
393
-
394
  <figure class="result-cell">
395
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval04-004.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval04-004.png" alt="SD 3.5 output for eval04.webp"></a>
396
  <figcaption><strong>SD 3.5</strong><span>1024x1024 · 1.10 MB</span></figcaption>
397
  </figure>
398
-
399
  </div>
400
  </section>
401
-
402
  <section class="eval-row">
403
  <div class="eval-heading">
404
  <h3>Eval 5: eval05.jpg</h3>
@@ -409,29 +461,34 @@ footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--m
409
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval05.jpg"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval05.jpg" alt="Eval source eval05.jpg"></a>
410
  <figcaption><strong>Eval source</strong><span>900x584 · 0.13 MB</span></figcaption>
411
  </figure>
412
-
 
 
 
 
 
413
  <figure class="result-cell">
414
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval05-005.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval05-005.png" alt="Flux Klein output for eval05.jpg"></a>
415
  <figcaption><strong>Flux Klein</strong><span>768x768 · 0.39 MB</span></figcaption>
416
  </figure>
417
-
418
  <figure class="result-cell">
419
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval05-005.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval05-005.png" alt="SD 1.5 output for eval05.jpg"></a>
420
  <figcaption><strong>SD 1.5</strong><span>512x512 · 0.26 MB</span></figcaption>
421
  </figure>
422
-
423
  <figure class="result-cell">
424
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval05-005.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval05-005.png" alt="SD 3.5 output for eval05.jpg"></a>
425
  <figcaption><strong>SD 3.5</strong><span>1024x1024 · 0.97 MB</span></figcaption>
426
  </figure>
427
-
428
  </div>
429
  </section>
430
-
431
  </section>
432
  </main>
433
  <footer>
434
- Generated from <code>ABLATION.md</code>, <code>dataset/train</code>, <code>dataset/conditioning</code>, <code>dataset/eval</code>, and <code>outputs/ablation/local_edit_eval</code>. Image paths are repo-relative from this report location.
435
  </footer>
436
  </body>
437
  </html>
 
38
  .panel { padding: 20px; }
39
  .panel p { margin: 0 0 12px; }
40
  .panel p:last-child { margin-bottom: 0; }
41
+ .metrics { display: grid; grid-template-columns: repeat(4, minmax(0, 1fr)); gap: 10px; }
42
  .metric { padding: 14px; background: var(--soft); border-radius: 6px; min-width: 0; }
43
  .metric strong { display: block; font-size: 22px; }
44
  .metric span { color: var(--muted); font-size: 12px; }
45
+ .model-grid { display: grid; grid-template-columns: repeat(4, minmax(0, 1fr)); gap: 14px; }
46
  .model-card { padding: 18px; min-width: 0; }
47
  .model-title { display: flex; justify-content: space-between; gap: 12px; align-items: baseline; }
48
  .model-title h3 { margin: 0; font-size: 18px; }
 
67
  .eval-heading { display: flex; justify-content: space-between; gap: 14px; align-items: baseline; margin-bottom: 10px; }
68
  .eval-heading h3 { margin: 0; font-size: 18px; }
69
  .eval-heading span { color: var(--muted); font-size: 12px; }
70
+ .result-grid { display: grid; grid-template-columns: repeat(5, minmax(0, 1fr)); gap: 12px; }
71
  .result-cell { overflow: hidden; min-width: 0; }
72
  .result-cell a { display: block; aspect-ratio: 1 / 1; background: #eceae2; }
73
  .source-cell a { background: #e7ebe7; }
74
  .result-cell figcaption { display: grid; gap: 2px; min-height: 56px; padding: 9px 10px 11px; }
75
  .result-cell figcaption strong { font-size: 13px; }
76
  .result-cell figcaption span { font-size: 12px; overflow-wrap: anywhere; }
77
+ .findings { display: grid; grid-template-columns: repeat(4, minmax(0, 1fr)); gap: 12px; }
78
  .finding { padding: 16px; background: var(--soft); border-radius: 8px; border: 1px solid var(--line); }
79
  .finding h3 { margin: 0 0 6px; font-size: 16px; }
80
  .finding p { margin: 0; color: var(--muted); }
81
  footer { padding: 18px 0 32px; border-top: 1px solid var(--line); color: var(--muted); }
82
+ @media (max-width: 1300px) {
83
+ .model-grid { grid-template-columns: repeat(2, minmax(0, 1fr)); }
84
+ .result-grid { grid-template-columns: repeat(3, minmax(0, 1fr)); }
85
+ .findings { grid-template-columns: repeat(2, minmax(0, 1fr)); }
86
+ }
87
  @media (max-width: 1100px) {
88
+ .overview, .training-grid { grid-template-columns: 1fr; }
89
+ .metrics { grid-template-columns: repeat(2, minmax(0, 1fr)); }
90
+ }
91
+ @media (max-width: 800px) {
92
  .result-grid { grid-template-columns: repeat(2, minmax(0, 1fr)); }
93
+ .model-grid { grid-template-columns: 1fr; }
94
+ .findings { grid-template-columns: 1fr; }
95
  }
96
  @media (max-width: 620px) {
97
  header, main, footer { width: min(100% - 24px, 1480px); }
 
112
  <body>
113
  <header>
114
  <p class="kicker">LoRA training progress report</p>
115
+ <h1>Comparing style-transfer LoRA edits across Mage Flow, Flux Klein, SD 1.5, and SD 3.5</h1>
116
  <p class="subtitle">This report summarizes the ablation in <code>ABLATION.md</code> and visualizes the generated artifacts under <code>outputs/</code>. The goal is to learn a compact LoRA that turns a normal source image into the project-specific stylized target look while preserving the source image layout and recognizable structure.</p>
117
  </header>
118
  <main>
 
120
  <article class="panel">
121
  <h2>Purpose</h2>
122
  <p>The training data is paired: each conditioning image provides the source structure, and each target image provides the desired rendering style. A successful model should transfer the luminous, graphic label style from the targets without drifting away from the source image content.</p>
123
+ <p>The evaluation set uses five held-out source images. Each result row below starts with the eval source image on the left, followed by the four model outputs for direct structure and style comparison.</p>
124
  </article>
125
  <article class="panel">
126
  <h2>Progress So Far</h2>
127
  <div class="metrics">
128
  <div class="metric"><strong>25</strong><span>paired training examples</span></div>
129
  <div class="metric"><strong>5</strong><span>held-out eval sources</span></div>
130
+ <div class="metric"><strong>4</strong><span>model families compared</span></div>
131
+ <div class="metric"><strong>100</strong><span>training epochs (Mage Flow)</span></div>
132
  </div>
133
  </article>
134
  </section>
 
138
  <div class="model-grid">
139
  <article class="model-card">
140
  <div class="model-title">
141
+ <h3>Mage Flow Edit Base</h3>
142
  <span>Best result so far</span>
143
  </div>
144
+ <dl>
145
+ <div><dt>Size</dt><dd>~3B (transformer)</dd></div>
146
+ <div><dt>Base repo</dt><dd><code>microsoft/Mage-Flow-Edit-Base</code></dd></div>
147
+ <div><dt>Trainer</dt><dd><code>train_lora.py</code> (custom flow-matching LoRA)</dd></div>
148
+ <div><dt>Optimizer</dt><dd>Muon (weight_decay=0.01)</dd></div>
149
+ <div><dt>Epochs</dt><dd>100</dd></div>
150
+ <div><dt>LoRA</dt><dd>rank 16, alpha 16</dd></div>
151
+ <div><dt>LR</dt><dd>1e-3 (cosine schedule)</dd></div>
152
+ <div><dt>Inference</dt><dd>30 steps, CFG 3.0</dd></div>
153
+ <div><dt>Checkpoint</dt><dd><code>outputs/lora/base_muon/lora_final.pt</code></dd></div>
154
+ </dl>
155
+ <p>Native flow-matching editing path with Muon optimizer. After 100 LoRA epochs it produces the best style transfer results — strong luminous aura rendering while faithfully preserving the source image structure and identity.</p>
156
+ <p class="decision">Recommended path for deployment: Mage Flow delivers the strongest style-transfer fidelity among all models tested.</p>
157
+ </article>
158
+
159
+ <article class="model-card">
160
+ <div class="model-title">
161
+ <h3>FLUX.2 Klein 4B</h3>
162
+ <span>Strong baseline</span>
163
+ </div>
164
  <dl>
165
  <div><dt>Size</dt><dd>4B</dd></div>
166
  <div><dt>Base repo</dt><dd><code>black-forest-labs/FLUX.2-klein-base-4B</code></dd></div>
 
170
  <div><dt>Conditioning</dt><dd>source_latents_concatenated_to_noisy_target_latents</dd></div>
171
  <div><dt>Checkpoint</dt><dd><code>../local_edit_lora/flux2_klein_base/checkpoint-002000</code></dd></div>
172
  </dl>
173
+ <p>Native multi-reference/editing path. After 2000 LoRA steps it preserves the eval-source structure while transferring the target stylized label/rendering look.</p>
174
+ <p class="decision">Continue with ONNX then CANN export as an alternative deployment path.</p>
175
  </article>
176
+
177
  <article class="model-card">
178
  <div class="model-title">
179
  <h3>Stable Diffusion 1.5</h3>
 
191
  <p>Pix2Pix-style pipeline learns parts of the style but quality is weaker. High image guidance ignores the source image; weak image guidance fails to transfer enough style.</p>
192
  <p class="decision">Keep as a low-cost baseline; next useful branch is ControlNet plus IP-Adapter with stronger base weights.</p>
193
  </article>
194
+
195
  <article class="model-card">
196
  <div class="model-title">
197
  <h3>Stable Diffusion 3.5 Medium</h3>
 
229
  </div>
230
  <h4>Pair 001</h4>
231
  </article>
232
+
233
  <article class="pair-card">
234
  <div class="pair-images">
235
  <figure>
 
243
  </div>
244
  <h4>Pair 002</h4>
245
  </article>
246
+
247
  <article class="pair-card">
248
  <div class="pair-images">
249
  <figure>
 
257
  </div>
258
  <h4>Pair 004</h4>
259
  </article>
260
+
261
  <article class="pair-card">
262
  <div class="pair-images">
263
  <figure>
 
271
  </div>
272
  <h4>Pair 009</h4>
273
  </article>
274
+
275
  <article class="pair-card">
276
  <div class="pair-images">
277
  <figure>
 
285
  </div>
286
  <h4>Pair 017</h4>
287
  </article>
288
+
289
  <article class="pair-card">
290
  <div class="pair-images">
291
  <figure>
 
305
  <section>
306
  <h2>Qualitative Findings</h2>
307
  <div class="findings">
308
+ <article class="finding"><h3>Mage Flow</h3><p>Best overall result. Muon-optimized LoRA (rank 16, 100 epochs) produces the cleanest aura-style transfer — strong luminous glow, excellent source-structure preservation, and cinematic color rendering. The flow-matching editing path is a natural fit for this paired style-transfer task.</p></article>
309
+ <article class="finding"><h3>Flux Klein</h3><p>Strong baseline: learns the style and remains close to the editable-source objective after 2000 steps. Slightly less vivid color transfer than Mage Flow.</p></article>
310
  <article class="finding"><h3>SD 1.5</h3><p>Small and cheap, but current pix2pix-style behavior is weak and sensitive to image-guidance tradeoffs.</p></article>
311
  <article class="finding"><h3>SD 3.5</h3><p>Learns style, but source-structure preservation is not reliable enough in this setup, so it is on pause.</p></article>
312
  </div>
 
314
 
315
  <section>
316
  <h2>Held-Out Eval Comparison</h2>
317
+
318
  <section class="eval-row">
319
  <div class="eval-heading">
320
  <h3>Eval 1: eval01.jpg</h3>
 
325
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval01.jpg"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval01.jpg" alt="Eval source eval01.jpg"></a>
326
  <figcaption><strong>Eval source</strong><span>1000x667 · 0.32 MB</span></figcaption>
327
  </figure>
328
+
329
+ <figure class="result-cell">
330
+ <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/mage_flow_eval01-001.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/mage_flow_eval01-001.png" alt="Mage Flow output for eval01.jpg"></a>
331
+ <figcaption><strong>Mage Flow</strong><span>768x512 · 0.33 MB</span></figcaption>
332
+ </figure>
333
+
334
  <figure class="result-cell">
335
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval01-001.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval01-001.png" alt="Flux Klein output for eval01.jpg"></a>
336
  <figcaption><strong>Flux Klein</strong><span>768x768 · 0.44 MB</span></figcaption>
337
  </figure>
338
+
339
  <figure class="result-cell">
340
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval01-001.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval01-001.png" alt="SD 1.5 output for eval01.jpg"></a>
341
  <figcaption><strong>SD 1.5</strong><span>512x512 · 0.28 MB</span></figcaption>
342
  </figure>
343
+
344
  <figure class="result-cell">
345
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval01-001.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval01-001.png" alt="SD 3.5 output for eval01.jpg"></a>
346
  <figcaption><strong>SD 3.5</strong><span>1024x1024 · 1.09 MB</span></figcaption>
347
  </figure>
348
+
349
  </div>
350
  </section>
351
+
352
  <section class="eval-row">
353
  <div class="eval-heading">
354
  <h3>Eval 2: eval02.jpg</h3>
 
359
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval02.jpg"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval02.jpg" alt="Eval source eval02.jpg"></a>
360
  <figcaption><strong>Eval source</strong><span>2000x1333 · 0.86 MB</span></figcaption>
361
  </figure>
362
+
363
+ <figure class="result-cell">
364
+ <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/mage_flow_eval02-002.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/mage_flow_eval02-002.png" alt="Mage Flow output for eval02.jpg"></a>
365
+ <figcaption><strong>Mage Flow</strong><span>768x512 · 0.32 MB</span></figcaption>
366
+ </figure>
367
+
368
  <figure class="result-cell">
369
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval02-002.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval02-002.png" alt="Flux Klein output for eval02.jpg"></a>
370
  <figcaption><strong>Flux Klein</strong><span>768x768 · 0.33 MB</span></figcaption>
371
  </figure>
372
+
373
  <figure class="result-cell">
374
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval02-002.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval02-002.png" alt="SD 1.5 output for eval02.jpg"></a>
375
  <figcaption><strong>SD 1.5</strong><span>512x512 · 0.35 MB</span></figcaption>
376
  </figure>
377
+
378
  <figure class="result-cell">
379
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval02-002.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval02-002.png" alt="SD 3.5 output for eval02.jpg"></a>
380
  <figcaption><strong>SD 3.5</strong><span>1024x1024 · 1.03 MB</span></figcaption>
381
  </figure>
382
+
383
  </div>
384
  </section>
385
+
386
  <section class="eval-row">
387
  <div class="eval-heading">
388
  <h3>Eval 3: eval03.jpg</h3>
 
393
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval03.jpg"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval03.jpg" alt="Eval source eval03.jpg"></a>
394
  <figcaption><strong>Eval source</strong><span>612x408 · 0.02 MB</span></figcaption>
395
  </figure>
396
+
397
+ <figure class="result-cell">
398
+ <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/mage_flow_eval03-003.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/mage_flow_eval03-003.png" alt="Mage Flow output for eval03.jpg"></a>
399
+ <figcaption><strong>Mage Flow</strong><span>768x512 · 0.27 MB</span></figcaption>
400
+ </figure>
401
+
402
  <figure class="result-cell">
403
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval03-003.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval03-003.png" alt="Flux Klein output for eval03.jpg"></a>
404
  <figcaption><strong>Flux Klein</strong><span>768x768 · 0.42 MB</span></figcaption>
405
  </figure>
406
+
407
  <figure class="result-cell">
408
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval03-003.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval03-003.png" alt="SD 1.5 output for eval03.jpg"></a>
409
  <figcaption><strong>SD 1.5</strong><span>512x512 · 0.25 MB</span></figcaption>
410
  </figure>
411
+
412
  <figure class="result-cell">
413
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval03-003.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval03-003.png" alt="SD 3.5 output for eval03.jpg"></a>
414
  <figcaption><strong>SD 3.5</strong><span>1024x1024 · 0.85 MB</span></figcaption>
415
  </figure>
416
+
417
  </div>
418
  </section>
419
+
420
  <section class="eval-row">
421
  <div class="eval-heading">
422
  <h3>Eval 4: eval04.webp</h3>
 
427
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval04.webp"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval04.webp" alt="Eval source eval04.webp"></a>
428
  <figcaption><strong>Eval source</strong><span>2560x1707 · 0.13 MB</span></figcaption>
429
  </figure>
430
+
431
+ <figure class="result-cell">
432
+ <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/mage_flow_eval04-004.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/mage_flow_eval04-004.png" alt="Mage Flow output for eval04.webp"></a>
433
+ <figcaption><strong>Mage Flow</strong><span>768x512 · 0.33 MB</span></figcaption>
434
+ </figure>
435
+
436
  <figure class="result-cell">
437
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval04-004.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval04-004.png" alt="Flux Klein output for eval04.webp"></a>
438
  <figcaption><strong>Flux Klein</strong><span>768x768 · 0.45 MB</span></figcaption>
439
  </figure>
440
+
441
  <figure class="result-cell">
442
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval04-004.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval04-004.png" alt="SD 1.5 output for eval04.webp"></a>
443
  <figcaption><strong>SD 1.5</strong><span>512x512 · 0.28 MB</span></figcaption>
444
  </figure>
445
+
446
  <figure class="result-cell">
447
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval04-004.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval04-004.png" alt="SD 3.5 output for eval04.webp"></a>
448
  <figcaption><strong>SD 3.5</strong><span>1024x1024 · 1.10 MB</span></figcaption>
449
  </figure>
450
+
451
  </div>
452
  </section>
453
+
454
  <section class="eval-row">
455
  <div class="eval-heading">
456
  <h3>Eval 5: eval05.jpg</h3>
 
461
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval05.jpg"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/eval_eval05.jpg" alt="Eval source eval05.jpg"></a>
462
  <figcaption><strong>Eval source</strong><span>900x584 · 0.13 MB</span></figcaption>
463
  </figure>
464
+
465
+ <figure class="result-cell">
466
+ <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/mage_flow_eval05-005.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/mage_flow_eval05-005.png" alt="Mage Flow output for eval05.jpg"></a>
467
+ <figcaption><strong>Mage Flow</strong><span>768x496 · 0.33 MB</span></figcaption>
468
+ </figure>
469
+
470
  <figure class="result-cell">
471
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval05-005.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/flux2_klein_base_eval05-005.png" alt="Flux Klein output for eval05.jpg"></a>
472
  <figcaption><strong>Flux Klein</strong><span>768x768 · 0.39 MB</span></figcaption>
473
  </figure>
474
+
475
  <figure class="result-cell">
476
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval05-005.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd15_eval05-005.png" alt="SD 1.5 output for eval05.jpg"></a>
477
  <figcaption><strong>SD 1.5</strong><span>512x512 · 0.26 MB</span></figcaption>
478
  </figure>
479
+
480
  <figure class="result-cell">
481
  <a href="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval05-005.png"><img src="lora_model_ablation_report_images/sd35_medium_eval05-005.png" alt="SD 3.5 output for eval05.jpg"></a>
482
  <figcaption><strong>SD 3.5</strong><span>1024x1024 · 0.97 MB</span></figcaption>
483
  </figure>
484
+
485
  </div>
486
  </section>
487
+
488
  </section>
489
  </main>
490
  <footer>
491
+ Generated from <code>ABLATION.md</code>, <code>dataset/train</code>, <code>dataset/conditioning</code>, <code>dataset/eval</code>, <code>outputs/ablation/local_edit_eval</code>, and <code>outputs/lora/base_muon/eval_outputs</code>. Image paths are repo-relative from this report location.
492
  </footer>
493
  </body>
494
  </html>