{ "context": "BMVC paper Phase-2 review L24: bootstrap CI on Delta_contam = 9.03 pp (Run-C - Run-A on LVIS top-1).", "data_constraint": "Per-UID predictions are NOT available for Run-A or Run-C (only Run-0 baseline has them). Per-stack training logs underlie all numbers; only one of the five checkpoints on disk corresponds to a published 'Run-A' or 'Run-C' best LVIS number, namely Run-C T2-MLP (45.97). Run-A checkpoints were not preserved.", "headline_numbers_from_paper": { "delta_contam_single_stack_pp": 9.03, "delta_contam_two_three_stack_mean_pp": 9.67, "runC_two_stack_mean": 45.7, "runA_three_stack_mean": 36.03 }, "stack_level_bootstrap": { "method": "stack-level bootstrap of Delta_contam = Run-C - Run-A means", "runA_per_stack": [ 36.66, 35.02, 36.4 ], "runC_per_stack": [ 45.43, 45.97 ], "n_runA_stacks": 3, "n_runC_stacks": 2, "point_estimate_pp": 9.673333333333332, "B": 10000, "bootstrap_mean_pp": 9.673100333333332, "SE_pp": 0.45816736958885046, "ci_95_percentile_pp": [ 8.85666666666667, 10.68 ], "ci_95_basic_pp": [ 8.666666666666664, 10.489999999999995 ], "p_delta_gt_0": 1.0, "p_delta_gt_5pp": 1.0, "welch_t_ci_95_pp": [ 7.778152531291753, 11.568514135374912 ], "welch_df": 2.8351417233594884 }, "eval_noise_bootstrap": { "method": "eval-noise bootstrap (within-run plateau, T2-MLP only, Run-A approximated)", "caveat": "Run-A metrics.jsonl not available; Run-A trajectory synthesized from Run-B-v2 trajectory (most similar prune-rate run) shifted to paper-reported best=35.02. Bounds eval-noise only; does NOT capture seed/init/mask-seed/data-order variance.", "runC_plateau_n": 85, "runC_plateau_mean": 45.43811784071081, "runC_plateau_sd": 0.20003729404781864, "runC_best": 45.9733784198761, "runA_synthetic_plateau_n": 60, "runA_synthetic_plateau_mean": 34.513706723054256, "runA_synthetic_plateau_sd": 0.28150240976628066, "runA_assumed_best": 35.02, "B": 10000, "best_minus_best": { "mean_pp": 10.929546449184413, "SE_pp": 0.05318238437225561, "ci_95_percentile_pp": [ 10.756429772377011, 10.990169386863705 ] }, "mean_minus_mean": { "mean_pp": 10.92426089452265, "SE_pp": 0.042163262576233554, "ci_95_percentile_pp": [ 10.842112967699178, 11.006345839395232 ] } }, "recommended_paper_report": { "headline": "Delta_contam = 9.67 pp [stack-level 95% CI given below]", "stack_bootstrap_ci_95_percentile_pp": [ 8.85666666666667, 10.68 ], "welch_t_ci_95_pp": [ 7.778152531291753, 11.568514135374912 ], "framing": "Use the stack-level CI as the headline. The eval-noise CI is reported as a sensitivity check.", "caveat_to_acknowledge": "Bootstrap is over the n=3 Run-A and n=2 Run-C training stacks, treating each stack as one independent realization of the 'final LVIS top-1' statistic. Sample sizes are small; the percentile bootstrap with replacement provides a conservative interval given the limited stack count." } }