[ { "id": "T1_00001", "filename": "P06_108_67_af1dd90706354a80_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 1.5s and 2.4s, the purple item experiences two sudden flips without external force) Physical behavior (at 1.3s, items inside the drawer move on their own without being touched; at 4.1s, the drawer closes automatically without external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00002", "filename": "P06_108_69_9aea7b74224b9dff_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (1.5s the item held in the right hand shrinks and disappears without transition; 2.6s the black item in the hand suddenly disappears; 3.9s the item in the right hand changes its attributes illogically and transforms into another item).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00003", "filename": "P06_108_113_3b78e10b9b10525b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (1.5s, the color of the item on the lower right changes sequentially, from white to black without transition).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00004", "filename": "P06_113_107_de929860172c9323_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is inconsistent (the liquid in the bottle suddenly disappears at 2.9s, and the water poured into the cup in the middle of the video disappears out of thin air at 6.4s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00005", "filename": "P07_101_29_b70a45de04eebba8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00007", "filename": "P07_101_29_b70a45de04eebba8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00008", "filename": "P07_101_65_f4d671a4c7536f0a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual impression is off (the video is overly smooth and lacks natural dynamism).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00009", "filename": "P07_102_57_e7c5d0edce639e19_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: Time continuity (7s, scene jump without transition)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00010", "filename": "P07_102_57_e7c5d0edce639e19_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (the cabinet door in the lower left corner of the video closes automatically without external force at 2.1s, and the cabinet door in the lower right corner opens automatically without external force at 7.3s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00011", "filename": "P07_107_57_61112229c2201302_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 6.7s and 7.6s, the bottle cap disappears from the video twice without any logical frame interval).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00012", "filename": "P07_110_11_d0d35a5d17011ae3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.7s, the left-hand object undergoes a sudden property change, the banana transforms into an orange without transition) and physical effects (at 1s, the banana moves to the left without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00013", "filename": "P07_110_11_d0d35a5d17011ae3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Continuous timing (1.1s: unannounced video freeze; 1.6s: the peel of the object in the hand disappears for no apparent reason; 4.02ss: the peel of the fruit below the hand in the video suddenly lengthens).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00014", "filename": "P07_110_29_8c99a271f9d4cd2e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (finger piercing through cardboard box in the lower right corner of the video at 2.2s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00015", "filename": "P07_110_39_00b9f80d347cca55_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00016", "filename": "P07_113_46_1a4e0a62d11a6cfd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is too continuous (the water ripples in the tank are too regular throughout the video, lacking natural and random physical characteristics).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00017", "filename": "P07_113_46_1a4e0a62d11a6cfd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00018", "filename": "P07_113_79_2d512fe1c8ba1152_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical action (the lower cabinet opens outwards without external force at 2.1s) and continuous timing (the towel on the cabinet handle suddenly falls off at 2.9s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00020", "filename": "P07_113_79_2d512fe1c8ba1152_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Continuous time (the flame suddenly increases at 1.3s) Physical effects (the lower cabinet moves backward without external force at 3s; the right cabinet opens on its own without external force at 4s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00021", "filename": "P07_113_109_4a89712eb436edc6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (1s, flames suddenly appear out of nowhere at the front of the item in hand).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00022", "filename": "P07_113_109_4a89712eb436edc6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Continuous time (a black object suddenly appears on the left hand at 0.7s; an object on the cutting board suddenly turns into a ball of light and burns at 1.6s); Causal relationship (the object burns from 1.6s to 8s without any change in its shape).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00023", "filename": "P07_113_109_4a89712eb436edc6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time sequence (a black object suddenly appears on the left hand at 0.4s, flames suddenly appear on the object at 1.7s, and a black object on the cutting board appears out of thin air at 5.3s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00024", "filename": "P07_113_113_c315992575f2e66f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (the garlic clove is suddenly cut open at 3.4 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00025", "filename": "P07_113_113_c315992575f2e66f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Surface anomaly: Causality (the object in the right hand shows no change in shape after being cut throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00026", "filename": "P07_114_31_d87f3f495021ab1d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.7s, the broccoli in the pot suddenly changes from one to two; at 3.7s, the broccoli in the pot suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00027", "filename": "P09_103_5_d9beda35ce08488b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Cause and effect (the knife penetrated the plastic wrap at 5.1s without leaving any gaps in the plastic wrap).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00028", "filename": "P09_103_5_d9beda35ce08488b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The video is continuous in time (the object on the right side of the video suddenly appears at 0.2s, disappears into thin air at 2.3s, and the transparent plastic film in the middle of the video suddenly turns black at 7.5s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00029", "filename": "P09_103_11_3d5dcf160404add7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The time frame is continuous (3.8s video, oil stains appear out of nowhere in the pot).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00030", "filename": "P09_103_20_21083d8008a843ca_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00031", "filename": "e377893c31a30a8126598e0dc9c5e83f81773c7d0a523a742ff6b07cf688a147_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the oil stream in the video is a vertical, rigid line, lacking the natural curves, variations in thickness, and surface tension of liquid; it resembles a solid column of light rather than flowing oil. The splashing ripples inside the bottle are strangely shaped, lacking the lightness of splashing liquid and the delicate texture of water ripples. The glass bottle's transparency and refraction are incorrect; the bottle lacks the transparency and refraction that glass should have. The light and shadow of the liquid inside the bottle are distorted, and the glass reflections on the handle and bottle are harsh and lack gradation).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00032", "filename": "e784931b287ff99b242f9e661d771cfa44ee9bc3137a7d60d5fe8a2ede83ed76_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall visuals are abnormal (in the entire video, the match is burning in the middle of the paper, and the ignition point should be in the middle, but the fire starts from both sides of the paper, while the middle of the paper is not affected at all).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00033", "filename": "e784931b287ff99b242f9e661d771cfa44ee9bc3137a7d60d5fe8a2ede83ed76_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall visuals are unusual (in the entire video, after the match lights the paper, it should burn from the center outwards, but the left side is burning at the same time as the center. The paper will generate heat as it burns, but the person's fingers do not react at all, and there is no soot left on the fingers after the paper has burned out).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00034", "filename": "e2109806cdc00d948c69fd828be6cd6efb6af5429736e11e9ce23538a76e53c0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is off (the main object in the video presents a contradictory texture of semi-transparent gel and frosted grain, resembling both melted ice and rough crystalline grains. There is no natural melting and dripping transition at the edges of the object, and it is completely disconnected from the surrounding liquid and semi-liquid base texture. The shape of the object's shadow does not match the outline of the main object, the edges of the shadow are blurred and disproportionate, there is no transition of light and shadow under real light source, and the direction of light and shadow also contradicts the overall ambient light).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00035", "filename": "e614989934b58cf76ef82efb9a05e6068acb8824b9d69111741f47ff5a6503b5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (in the entire video, white reflective dots appear suspended in the air in front of the camera as the camera moves, the strings of lights wrapped around the railings are extremely uneven in size and spacing in some areas, and there are even cases of overlapping bulbs, twisted lines and broken lights, the halo effect of the lights is unnatural, some areas have too strong a halo and some areas have no halo, there is a lack of a unified light source logic, the reflections on the ground railings are harsh and misaligned, and there is no softness and consistency in the light reflection in a real scene).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00036", "filename": "ea1ac4b622d7b43fb228fbad1f4861c3b98d746379ab3bbd778f9259ba72b2cc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the yellow brick ground on the right side of the video appears to extend as the camera moves, and an unidentified black shadow suddenly appears in the lower right corner of the smoke at 4.5 seconds). The overall visual impression is abnormal (the water column from the fountain and the white water vapor and smoke completely merge into a columnar cloud in the entire video, without a clear water flow trajectory or the sense of dispersion and diffusion that water vapor should have. It looks more like a semi-solid white mass that appears to be generated out of thin air. The sunlight appears as a blurry and diffused light cluster, without the directionality of real sunlight beams or the light spots and shadows formed by passing through tree branches).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00037", "filename": "ea1ac4b622d7b43fb228fbad1f4861c3b98d746379ab3bbd778f9259ba72b2cc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is off (the boundary between the water column and the water vapor in the entire video is blurred to the point of disappearing; what should be a transparent water column and water vapor boundary is blurred to the point of disappearing; what should be a transparent or semi-transparent water flow is completely replaced by an opaque white mist; and there are no water flow textures or bubbles inside the clumps, nor the lightness of the water vapor; the light and dark gradients on the lit and shadowed sides of the water mist clumps are not natural; the transition between the edges and the sunlight is blurry and harsh; there is no light and shadow effect of real water mist being illuminated by sunlight, with the edges bright and the interior gradually darkening; instead, it looks like a composite effect of white blocks and strong light superimposed).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00038", "filename": "eae18c34613bb4ead8b1b36d3b7bc59d81f5c82af540d1465c07edb5c8418f82_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall visual impression is abnormal (in the entire video, the containers exhibit asymmetrical deformation without any apparent force during the explosion, such as one side suddenly expanding while the other side contracts strangely, violating the laws of material deformation under stress; during the explosion, the two containers rise, tumble, and break apart in perfect sync with each other, without any difference in force. In reality, the shockwave reaction force of an explosion would cause a significant difference in the trajectory and speed of objects, rather than mechanical synchronization; after the explosion, some red fragments disappear as they fall; the diffusion speed and shape of the pink smoke do not conform to the physical characteristics of gas diffusion; the smoke cloud is suspended in a solid cloud shape without a natural dissipation and dilution process; and the interaction between the smoke and the flames is abnormal; the two objects return to their original shapes after the explosion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00039", "filename": "eae18c34613bb4ead8b1b36d3b7bc59d81f5c82af540d1465c07edb5c8418f82_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video footage is unusual: The overall visual impression is off. (The shockwave from the explosion should have spread outwards evenly throughout the video, but the debris is flying in a chaotic and disorderly direction. There are even instances of debris flying back towards the center of the explosion, defying physical physics. The size and shape of the debris, such as long strips of wood or irregular pieces of aluminum foil, do not match the impact force of the explosion. Some debris is too large and too intact. The initial flames are bright white or yellow, but then suddenly turn into pure red smoke. In reality, the color transition between the flames and smoke in an explosion is gradual, and there would be no abrupt change from flames to red smoke. Furthermore, the texture of the red smoke is like a pigment cloud, lacking the layering and dissipation pattern of real smoke. Also, although wood fragments were produced during the explosion, the original wood planks at the explosion site remained intact.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00040", "filename": "eb4fc1ea734796fd276c1ab5311a2b912a45b044cb7430c398370bbd4187e7dc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is off (isolated small red pixels appear randomly throughout the video, such as in the upper left corner and on the right edge of the fluid, completely detached from the overall cyan-green fluid texture. They lack any visual logic; they are neither light and shadow, nor fluid impurities, nor design elements. The fluid on the right abruptly transitions from a smooth gradient to a rough, granular, foam-like texture, with a harsh transition lacking the gradation logic of a physical fluid. The fluid edges, which should be softly blended, instead feature harsh white and light blue lines, resembling outlines rather than natural fusion. The fluid lacks natural light and shadow gradations, with harsh highlights and shadows, lacking the transparency and light and shadow layers of a real liquid. The overall effect is like a stack of flat color blocks).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00041", "filename": "f0f92e4f8200e6abc9f2d71d2d42e9ea8d2acd0a4dadc063fba8ea5880b2210a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (in the entire video, the edges of some flames are blurred and the outlines are stiff, lacking the dynamic swaying feeling of real flames; the warm light of the flames does not form a natural gradient reflection on the inner wall of the lamp; the brightness of some flames is out of sync with the surrounding ambient light; the bright areas are overexposed and the dark areas lack gradation; there is a lack of realistic light and shadow projection; the light source direction and brightness of all flames are highly uniform, there is no difference in light and shadow between lamps of different distances and sizes, and the image lacks a sense of depth).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00042", "filename": "f1a705e41ef02233566600293f1b1df1ed03592a00b0a74dde9278e1d16a7783_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (in the entire video, the edges of the cleaning head's cloth cover are blurry and the shape is irregular, lacking the regular structure of a real cleaning head; the steam emitted has blurry edges and a strange shape, without the diffusion of real steam; the foam stains on the wall are distributed in irregular dots and rings, and the texture of the foam is like a pixelated patchwork, lacking the fluidity and layering of real foam; steam should disperse and melt the foam, but in the picture, the steam and foam overlap without affecting each other, and the foam is even denser in the steam area).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00043", "filename": "f02fec8a907cde0d01f9b8caf319d1027d6562b2a85afae4a91e8ab65b1f32fd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is off (the edges of the clouds in the entire video are abruptly fragmented, as if they were cut and randomly pieced together, without natural transitions or blending. Some cloud blocks are isolated and suspended, lacking the continuity of atmospheric flow. The size and density distribution of the cloud blocks is extremely unnatural, with some cloud clusters being excessively dense while others are abnormally sparse, lacking gradual layers. The perspective and occlusion relationships of the clouds in the foreground, middle ground, and background are not reasonable, and the sense of space is completely distorted. The light source of the sunset (the sun) should be at the horizon at the bottom of the screen, but the direction of the lit and shadow sides of some cloud blocks is chaotic, with some cloud blocks being bright at the top and dark at the bottom, while others are the opposite).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00044", "filename": "f2bd8e3ae36c50cf397f9353f3c52fcda5b032efbe2a92f3a9888d4d9059447f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall impression is off (in the entire video, the foam produced by melting butter should be thin, fragile, and small bubbles that diffuse as it melts, but in the picture, the foam is thick, solidified, and disc-shaped with regular edges. It does not move or deform with the butter, like fixed plastic foam, which does not conform to the fluidity and fragility of liquid foam. The butter block always maintains its sharp edges and solid shape, does not deform or shrink with the high temperature, and does not merge with the surrounding foam. It seems to be suspended on the foam, with no natural transition between the two in physical contact).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00045", "filename": "f2bd8e3ae36c50cf397f9353f3c52fcda5b032efbe2a92f3a9888d4d9059447f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall impression is off (the distribution of whey foam from melting butter in the entire video is extremely unnatural. It either forms an eerie arc around the butter or spreads out irregularly over a large area. In contrast, the foam from real melting butter gradually spreads evenly from the edges of the butter, rather than in this fragmented, blocky distribution. The size of the butter blocks hardly changes, and there is no dynamic melting process such as the butter blocks shrinking, the foam breaking, and the oil spreading. The yellow color of the butter blocks is too bright and the saturation is distorted. It lacks the creamy feel and translucent texture of real butter, and the surface does not have the shine of melting butter. It looks more like plastic or wax blocks).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00046", "filename": "f3bfe95682baca3770ca1b683bd092c07f97a3bcbd64d9f13c9ab201128277fb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: The overall visual impression is off (at 0.8s, a person suddenly appears out of nowhere on the bridge, with a blurry, disproportionate, and strangely sized body; the puddles on the bridge surface at the bottom of the frame are completely disconnected from the pedestrian bridge behind, without any connecting structure, violating the physical logic of bridge load-bearing and passage, as if they are two independent suspended road surfaces; the cables lack reasonable stress support points, which does not conform to the mechanical design of a cable-stayed bridge; the arch structure also has problems with disproportionate and stiff lines, lacking the curvature and support of a realistic bridge; the extended perspective lines of the bridge are not convergent or parallel, showing divergent and distorted problems, resulting in a chaotic sense of space, as if the bridge is deformed; the perspective of the puddles is also inconsistent with the perspective of the bridge surface, further undermining the rationality of the space).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00047", "filename": "f3bfe95682baca3770ca1b683bd092c07f97a3bcbd64d9f13c9ab201128277fb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: The overall visual impression is off (the figure on the right side of the video is blurry and lacks detail, with no normal human proportions or limb details; the reflection of the sun in the foreground puddle does not match the actual position and brightness of the sun; the reflection lines of the bridge structure are broken and disproportionate, not following the physical laws of mirror reflection; the shadows of the figures and the bridge structure are inconsistent with the direction of the sun's light source, appearing stiff and unnatural; the cables lack reasonable support points, which does not conform to the mechanical design of a cable-stayed bridge; the arch structure also has disproportionate and stiff lines, lacking the curvature and support of a real bridge; the extended perspective lines of the bridge are not convergent or parallel, exhibiting divergent and distorted features, resulting in a chaotic sense of space, as if the bridge is deformed; the perspective of the puddle is also inconsistent with the perspective of the bridge surface, further undermining the rationality of the space).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00049", "filename": "f05d47ab3f4d96eafe3e5c7788a02bd1a143c3247d61ee74324d98180c23a0bb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Overall, the visual impression is off (the object's surface appears smooth and reflective like plastic resin throughout the video, yet it also has irregular textures resembling ice crystals, creating a disjointed material feel. It doesn't resemble the translucent, melting feel of real ice, nor the natural crystalline structure of natural crystals. When illuminated by strong light later, the object shows no light refraction or translucent texture inside; the surface is merely stiff and white, completely contradicting the optical principles of transparent objects. The perspective lines at the corners are not parallel, the ground's extension is distorted, and there is no sense of depth in the real three-dimensional space, resembling a flat, box-like space. During the transition from dark to light, the details of the object, the ground, and the walls lack natural light and shadow transitions). Temporal Continuity (the object refracts light when illuminated, but at 5.7 seconds, it suddenly emits light spontaneously without refraction, even without external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00050", "filename": "f5b4799213511dbf80faed6e87045fa4468c9170904dbd1aa8421d039effbb11_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is off (the entire video is too smooth when the ship approaches the water, the water is too calm, there are no ripples or waves after the ship moves, and the contrast between the ship's speed and the changes in the clouds is obviously abnormal. The lake surface is too smooth without obvious ripples, the clouds look like they are pasted on, and there is no natural light and shadow blending with the warm-toned city lights and water below. The edges are harsh and lack the sense of atmospheric perspective. The reflections of the ship and city lights are too uniform and without ripples. The water surface is like a mirror but has unnatural blur and noise, which violates the laws of light and shadow refraction on a real water surface. The high sky is filled with cool-toned noctilucent clouds, and the ground is filled with warm yellow city lights. There is no natural transition in color temperature and brightness between the two).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00051", "filename": "P02_101_79_117b97072302e410_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.9 seconds, the jam on the knife tip suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00052", "filename": "P02_101_79_117b97072302e410_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 6.2s, the bread slice in the character's hand and the bread slice in the bowl suddenly merge into one).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00053", "filename": "P02_101_82_8edf24284732e4f3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00054", "filename": "P02_101_82_8edf24284732e4f3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (at 0.3 seconds, a fruit knife suddenly appears on the table to the right of the bowl).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00055", "filename": "P02_102_77_c73b0d8a649c1bc4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time sequence (At 0.1s, the black liquid in the bottle suddenly increases and fills the bottle. At 0.5s, the middle part of the bottle cap suddenly disappears the instant it is opened. At 3.3s, the bottle cap disappears into thin air the instant it is closed.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00056", "filename": "P02_102_100_a26e6525a6171ba3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Physical Behavior (From 0-0.7s, the bottle opening is downwards, but the liquid inside is suspended, violating the fundamental laws of gravity and fluid statics. In the real world, when liquid is poured out of a bottle, it flows downwards under the influence of gravity, forming a continuous liquid column.) Temporal Continuity (Judging from the bottle's tilt angle and opening size, the volume ratio of the poured liquid to the remaining liquid in the bottle is highly inconsistent. In reality, the outflow speed and flow rate of liquid are directly related to the bottle opening size and tilt angle, but the way the liquid is presented here is more like a static texture or special effect, rather than real fluid movement.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00057", "filename": "P02_102_100_a26e6525a6171ba3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 3.8s, the black bottle cap that fell onto the table suddenly turned transparent. At 3.3s, the transparent tube connecting the bottle cap and the bottle opening disappeared into thin air.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00058", "filename": "P02_104_111_ff2113d2018334c8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (at 4.9 seconds, the slices of meat being stir-fried in the pan suddenly flip over).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00059", "filename": "P02_104_149_8b768193f6d97ae2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00060", "filename": "P02_104_149_8b768193f6d97ae2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00061", "filename": "P02_104_165_d1b8d60ec7a8d76f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time sequence (dumplings appear out of thin air in the plate at 1.6s and 3.7s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00062", "filename": "P02_104_165_d1b8d60ec7a8d76f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00063", "filename": "P02_104_165_d1b8d60ec7a8d76f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 2s, the dumplings in the strainer suddenly turn into strips of dough.) Physical behavior (at 2.6s, some of the strips of dough fall from the strainer into the plate; the strainer's holes are insufficient for the strips of dough to pass through, violating the impermeability of solids.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00064", "filename": "P02_105_68_6dd450c698ad8b36_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (at 4.6s, there are no obvious signs of movement on the character's wrist, but the pot in the character's hand suddenly flips over.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00065", "filename": "P02_105_85_a184128bbf06f580_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 3.6s, the number of black stripes in the character's hand suddenly increases.) Physical behavior (at 3.4s, water from the faucet passes through the character's palm, violating the principle of impermeability of solids.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00066", "filename": "P02_105_85_a184128bbf06f580_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 1.6s, a towel suddenly appears in the character's hand. At 4.5s, the towel disappears into thin air.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00067", "filename": "P02_105_89_88acb57f7e56cbfb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 1.4s, the fork and fruit knife on the character's left hand suddenly merge into one fruit knife. At 2.6s, a silver strip suddenly appears inside the bowl in the sink.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00068", "filename": "P02_105_89_88acb57f7e56cbfb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 5.5s, the fork in the sink pierces the plate, violating the impermeability of solids.) Time continuity (at 2.8s, the fruit knife in the character's hand suddenly turns into a fork.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00069", "filename": "P02_105_89_88acb57f7e56cbfb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Time Continuity (At 1.5s, the fruit knife and fork in the character's left hand suddenly merge into one fork. At 2.6s, a fork appears out of thin air in the character's right hand. At 4.3s, the forks in the character's left and right hands merge into one fruit knife the instant they touch. At 4.8s, the scissors in the tool slot suddenly turn into a fork the instant the character's right hand touches them.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00070", "filename": "P02_105_178_a199dc8af81930a6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.2s, the snacks in the character's hand suddenly merge into one bag.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00071", "filename": "P02_105_178_a199dc8af81930a6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 4s, the number of snacks in the character's hand suddenly increases. At 5.9s, a bag of snacks appears out of thin air in the character's left hand.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00072", "filename": "P02_107_31_c6e03c2415bf383d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 1.5s, the cabinet door under the desktop closes automatically without any force, violating Newton's First Law.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00073", "filename": "P02_108_116_5286ed55d078040a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: (At 0.8s, more than half of the bottom of the cup is suspended in the air without falling. Under normal circumstances, the cup should fall directly due to gravity.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00074", "filename": "P02_108_180_1edef8bcc465376f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00075", "filename": "P02_108_180_1edef8bcc465376f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (at 4.6 seconds, a finger is inserted into the dough, but there is no obvious fingerprint on the surface of the dough).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00076", "filename": "P02_108_223_e37f22b02735c782_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (At 6.2s, the water in the sink directly penetrates the frying pan, violating the principle of impermeability of solids. From 5.2s to 8s, the two hands are on either side of the frying pan, with one hand lifting the pan using only two fingers. In this state, a stable grip cannot be formed, making it impossible to lift the pan from the sink or hold it stably.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00077", "filename": "P02_108_351_4611aba364e6bb0e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 3.3s, the cup on the machine's lid suddenly flattens and merges with the lid.) Physical behavior (at 5.1s, the character's arm has left the machine, but the machine remains suspended in mid-air, violating the law of gravity; normally, the machine should fall due to gravity.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00078", "filename": "P02_108_447_6b7ebbc070e4e336_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 3.7s, the blue towel on the character's right hand suddenly turns yellow. At 4.1s, the blue towel pressed down by the character's left hand suddenly disappears. At 5s, the steel pipe being wiped by the character's left hand suddenly disappears. At 2.3s, the blue towel on the character's right hand suddenly splits in two.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00079", "filename": "P02_109_149_21af70ea6cb45625_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time frame is continuous (the entire video shows shredded meat being stir-fried in a pan, with obvious oil fumes being produced, but the color and shape of the stir-fried meat do not change at all throughout the entire process).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00080", "filename": "P02_109_149_21af70ea6cb45625_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: The video appears blurry and distorted throughout (the meat shreds in the pot are visible throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00081", "filename": "P03_109_244_7d988ea8da9cab00_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the scissors bend and deform without external force between 1s and 1.6s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00082", "filename": "P03_109_244_7d988ea8da9cab00_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.9s, the blade of the scissors disappears into thin air without any external force; at 4.6s, the character's hand clips through the scissor handle, violating the principle of impermeability of solids).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00083", "filename": "P03_109_244_7d988ea8da9cab00_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (at 2.2s, the movement of pushing and pulling the drawer did not follow the normal trajectory, and displacement occurred, violating the law of inertia) and continuous time (at 3.3s, the drawer handle disappeared and turned into scissors; at 4.1s, a hand suddenly appeared out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00084", "filename": "P03_109_291_6b76ce53b04d2263_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00085", "filename": "P03_109_291_6b76ce53b04d2263_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00086", "filename": "P03_109_292_dc435ca3dce51838_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00087", "filename": "P03_109_318_24bf90fdcacc85f9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.7s there is only a small clump of butter on the knife, but when scraping the bread, more and more butter is scraped).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00088", "filename": "P03_109_321_bd3f45ea44ea64fe_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (at 5.2s, the butter on the blade was originally scraped off, but then it returned to the initial amount).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00089", "filename": "P03_109_342_fc9925db0f44f975_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.8s, only a small half of the cheese strip is cut off, and without any obstruction or addition, the cheese strip suddenly turns into a sheet).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00090", "filename": "P03_109_372_f9a0547118282ba2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: The timing is continuous (between 2.2s and 3.2s, the hand is facing upwards when releasing the knife, whereas normally the palm should be downwards, violating normal motion inertia).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00091", "filename": "P03_109_372_f9a0547118282ba2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 3.4s to 4.4s, when cutting the bread, the finger penetrates the bread, violating the physical law that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00092", "filename": "P03_111_16_49c3417aaaf75e67_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: During the continuous flow of water from the tap (0.9s-5s), the sediment at the bottom of the box increases out of nowhere.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00093", "filename": "P03_111_16_49c3417aaaf75e67_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The screen is abnormal: between 1.8s and 2.1s, the finger passes directly through the faucet, and the faucet sprays water out of thin air without any external force, which violates the physical law that solids are impermeable.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00094", "filename": "P03_112_96_e070a22994164ebb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the visuals: The time sequence is continuous (from 0.8s to 1.5s, the character did not touch the kettle button, yet the kettle's red light illuminated, and at 1.3s, steam suddenly appeared from the kettle).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00095", "filename": "P03_112_96_e070a22994164ebb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00096", "filename": "P03_112_112_78e5231e10c0e671_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: from 5.4s to 7.8s, when the character is tearing the packaging bag, his two thumbs are overlapping, which violates the normal hand movement logic of tearing packaging bags in reality, and the posture is unnatural.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00097", "filename": "P03_112_112_78e5231e10c0e671_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00098", "filename": "P03_112_150_f35dc439e8ff6b81_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: From 0.8s to 5s, the sweeping motion of the person is too stiff, unnatural and unrealistic; from 2.4s to 4.5s, the dirt on the floor does not decrease but increases during the sweeping process.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00099", "filename": "P03_112_150_f35dc439e8ff6b81_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: at 3.4s, a piece of white trash appears out of thin air on the ground, resembling the corner of a white plastic bag; between 3.5s and 5.2s, the character sweeps the same piece of trash twice, but the trash is not moved, which violates the realistic logic that sweeping should remove trash, and the action effect does not conform to normal physical logic.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00100", "filename": "P03_112_150_f35dc439e8ff6b81_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: from 3.03 to 8 seconds, the character's sweeping movements are stiff and unnatural, and the garbage on the ground is not removed but instead seems to increase, which violates the basic functional logic of sweeping to clean and remove dirt and the laws of reality.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00101", "filename": "P03_112_160_7dded1abfb4e3720_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (during the 0s-3s period, when the character is brushing rice, the amount of rice falling to the ground increases out of nowhere.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00102", "filename": "P03_112_160_7dded1abfb4e3720_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00103", "filename": "P03_112_160_7dded1abfb4e3720_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00104", "filename": "P03_113_48_ecc89f1395c7b22d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is as follows: From 0.22 to 3.1 seconds, the action of the character stirring the liquid with a spoon appears too smooth and unnatural. From 3.12 to 4.3 seconds, the water in the spoon disappears into thin air, violating the laws governing the retention of liquid in a container and contradicting the logic of real-world physics.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00105", "filename": "P03_113_48_ecc89f1395c7b22d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: between 1.4s and 2.4s, the water outlet of the faucet suddenly shortens; between 5.5s and 6.2s, when the character turns off the faucet, the shape of the faucet changes from straight to curved, which is an abrupt change.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00106", "filename": "P03_117_218_16502d99e2351f4f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00107", "filename": "P03_117_218_16502d99e2351f4f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00108", "filename": "P03_117_220_11e08d81d136fb0e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is as follows: from 0.5s to 4.9s, the action of the character applying butter is too smooth and continuous, lacking the natural pauses and jolts that should be present in real-life movements, which does not conform to the laws of human movement in reality.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00109", "filename": "P03_117_236_20c0ee7a59e22c6c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: from 1.7s to 3.1s, the butter strips gradually increase in size out of thin air, which does not conform to the law of conservation of energy.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00110", "filename": "P03_117_236_20c0ee7a59e22c6c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Between 3.1s and 6s, after the character cuts the butter with a knife, bread appears out of thin air underneath the butter.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00111", "filename": "9eb36c5f235fe5ec139050303e4b9380b7bc1760b8b7c635da687a2d49d50256_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous (there is no real heat convection between the flames and the firewood, no sparks flying, no dynamic changes as the firewood is burned, the edges of the flames are too smooth and the outline is fixed, lacking the dynamic, irregular jumping and swaying feeling of a real flame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00112", "filename": "9eb36c5f235fe5ec139050303e4b9380b7bc1760b8b7c635da687a2d49d50256_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (at 0.6s, while the firewood is burning, the camera suddenly changes direction, and at the same time, the flames suddenly grow larger out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00113", "filename": "9ed856378e3c9066c5e5aff1c99b9b7608b14a6e116bba64ae8d0ed4a9b00353_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Physical Behavior (The raindrops in the video are semi-transparent lines, lacking the shape changes of real raindrops under gravity; the circular light spots in the background do not show the occlusion, refraction, and brightness changes that occur when raindrops pass through them in a real scene.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00114", "filename": "9ed856378e3c9066c5e5aff1c99b9b7608b14a6e116bba64ae8d0ed4a9b00353_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the raindrops falling from the eaves in the image appear as large \"teardrop shapes.\" In reality, falling water droplets would become flattened spheres or flying saucers due to air resistance, and would not maintain this teardrop shape with a pointed top and a rounded bottom.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00115", "filename": "9ed856378e3c9066c5e5aff1c99b9b7608b14a6e116bba64ae8d0ed4a9b00353_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the background is blurred in the video, but the rainy scene is dark, and there is a swaying of light and shadow in the background).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00116", "filename": "9ee37626316595035b6439ecf631e308acd2b5931b9c96df273b49b70e070dff_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (the flocculent material in the image is in the water, and when it moves up and down without any external force, it lacks the characteristic flocculent flow and stretching sensation that flocculent material should have).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00117", "filename": "9ee37626316595035b6439ecf631e308acd2b5931b9c96df273b49b70e070dff_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (during the transformation of the object from a compact to a loose form, no physical causes such as liquid flow or buoyancy changes that could drive the shape change were observed. Its unfolding process is more like layer overlay or image replacement than the natural fluffing of real matter in a liquid.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00118", "filename": "9ee37626316595035b6439ecf631e308acd2b5931b9c96df273b49b70e070dff_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00119", "filename": "9ee37626316595035b6439ecf631e308acd2b5931b9c96df273b49b70e070dff_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00120", "filename": "9f8f6bb0a73b559ab312e6988ebcac4ae2116bca9c025222be22db1edd531923_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the candle flame flickers, but the light and shadow projected onto the wall remain completely still without any change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00121", "filename": "9f8f6bb0a73b559ab312e6988ebcac4ae2116bca9c025222be22db1edd531923_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the candle flame remains vertical, but the shadow projected onto the wall at 4.3s shifts downwards, and the shadow does not match the light source).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00122", "filename": "9f8f6bb0a73b559ab312e6988ebcac4ae2116bca9c025222be22db1edd531923_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00123", "filename": "9f2688b090695b906ead22e584cd777f52769f3d8d72f17ab121e3cac7c152a1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.2s, the crusher crushes the glass diamond. According to the laws of physics, the material should be crushed into fragments and scattered. However, in the video, there are plastic-shaped objects and the rebound is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00124", "filename": "9f2688b090695b906ead22e584cd777f52769f3d8d72f17ab121e3cac7c152a1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (at 2.7s, the hydraulic press had not yet touched the bottom diamond in the video, but the diamond began to rotate on its own).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00125", "filename": "9f2688b090695b906ead22e584cd777f52769f3d8d72f17ab121e3cac7c152a1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2s, the hydraulic press is crushing diamonds, and there are only two diamonds in the footage, but the amount of debris produced is far greater than what should be expected after crushing two diamonds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00126", "filename": "9f2688b090695b906ead22e584cd777f52769f3d8d72f17ab121e3cac7c152a1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Physical behavior (at 2.2s, there is a noticeable pause in the process of the hydraulic press crushing the diamond, and it instantly turns into a large number of fine sand-like fragments).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00127", "filename": "9f3474ac9f58a72aa0e871e39761c1dcda72e401354f3cdf78d3e8ab3f068a52_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: The timing is continuous (the entire edge of the coffee cup in the image flickers, and the side of the coffee cup facing away from the sun also shows flickering light).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00128", "filename": "9fb1a7e7c193441794ce9c89a531b4afa0ae1d6834f9963e6d95c722cb5025ef_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00129", "filename": "9fb1a7e7c193441794ce9c89a531b4afa0ae1d6834f9963e6d95c722cb5025ef_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows a continuous flow of water on the whetstone, which suddenly appears to increase without any external force being added.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00130", "filename": "9fb1a7e7c193441794ce9c89a531b4afa0ae1d6834f9963e6d95c722cb5025ef_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the water on the whetstone appears to shake and flicker without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00131", "filename": "9fb1a7e7c193441794ce9c89a531b4afa0ae1d6834f9963e6d95c722cb5025ef_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is discontinuous (the person pours water onto the whetstone, but the water doesn't flow down the edge of the stone, violating the laws of liquid flow caused by gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00132", "filename": "9fca2219e22d70eb78a39278ab3a9b62baa7d7aee54b3d1a95dc3ff2ac92148b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (There are three eggs in the pan in the image. The egg on the right shows bubbles forming on its surface as it is being fried, but the two eggs on the left are completely still. The same phenomenon should occur under the same heating conditions.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00133", "filename": "9fca2219e22d70eb78a39278ab3a9b62baa7d7aee54b3d1a95dc3ff2ac92148b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the scene shows three eggs frying in a pan, but without any external force, an excessive amount of milk appears out of thin air in the pan).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00134", "filename": "9fca2219e22d70eb78a39278ab3a9b62baa7d7aee54b3d1a95dc3ff2ac92148b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the eggs in the pot are half-cooked, with solidified cooked egg white at the bottom. The eggs should not be sliding in the pot, which does not match the physical state of solidification after heating).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00135", "filename": "9fca2219e22d70eb78a39278ab3a9b62baa7d7aee54b3d1a95dc3ff2ac92148b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00136", "filename": "9fce6fe9124387aa211b26c64eff95ae3a72e1f618cea5436f48d811a709f567_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.6s, the gold coins on the table in the picture are deformed and twisted before automatically returning to their original shape; from the beginning to the end, the number of gold coins falling on the table gradually increases out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00137", "filename": "9fce6fe9124387aa211b26c64eff95ae3a72e1f618cea5436f48d811a709f567_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual effect is abnormal (the gold coin pattern and its edges appear blurry without any reasonable physical cause during the falling process).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00138", "filename": "9fce6fe9124387aa211b26c64eff95ae3a72e1f618cea5436f48d811a709f567_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (at 3.5 seconds, a coin falls onto the table; multiple coins are in the same environment, but only one coin glows, while the others do not have corresponding visual effects, resulting in inconsistent visual presentation).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00139", "filename": "9ff879e8c5a085e0c4f4418994e98e5b4a02132039d8df7ff3f1391125973f46_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the projected image flickers frequently without any apparent cause, indicating a visual anomaly).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00140", "filename": "9ff879e8c5a085e0c4f4418994e98e5b4a02132039d8df7ff3f1391125973f46_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior (the projector is completely stationary in the image, but the projected image continues to move to the left; the displacement of the projection source and the projected image do not match, violating the physical logic of projection imaging).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00141", "filename": "P35_103_235_4183a2599a052d53_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The time sequence is continuous (at 4.7s, the drainboard on the person's hand twists and deforms; at 0.5s, the water flowing into the trough suddenly disappears, with no obvious trace of it flowing into the drain plug).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00142", "filename": "P35_103_236_4260abb27a75bf01_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00143", "filename": "P35_104_64_4c52c9241014390e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 0.9s, a white plastic sleeve suddenly appears on the chopsticks in the person's hand; at 2.1s, a white plastic ring appears out of thin air on the person's index finger.) Physical behavior (drips of water from a faucet fall onto a bowl throughout the video, but no splashes are produced; normally, water dripping onto an object would create splashes.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00144", "filename": "P35_104_64_4c52c9241014390e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 6.6s, the fruit knife in the person's hand twists and deforms). Physical behavior (drips of water from a faucet fall onto a bowl without creating any splashes; normally, dripping water should create splashes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00145", "filename": "P35_104_64_4c52c9241014390e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.1s, the fruit knife in the character's left hand suddenly turns into a white plastic ring; at 3.9s, the fruit knife in the character's right hand suddenly turns into a screw-shaped tool.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00146", "filename": "P35_104_102_65d74300562d0ed0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is discontinuous (the person in the video is lighting the gas stove in front, but the water in the pot on the gas stove behind is boiling).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00147", "filename": "P35_104_206_5af2275caf0a2ed1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomalies in the footage: The timing is inconsistent (at 3.8s, the water in the plate in the character's hand disappears into thin air. At 0.8s, the plate in the sink suddenly flies into the character's hand. At 2.7s, water flows out of the faucet automatically, but there is no shot of the character turning on the faucet.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00148", "filename": "P35_104_206_5af2275caf0a2ed1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (In the entire video, water dripping from a faucet falls onto a plate without creating any splashes. Normally, water dripping onto an object would create splashes.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00149", "filename": "P35_104_206_5af2275caf0a2ed1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time sequence (At 0.3s, a bowl suddenly appears in the character's hand. At 1.9s, the bowl disappears out of thin air. At 4.4s, the plate in the character's hand suddenly flips 180 degrees.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00150", "filename": "P35_104_210_a2557b689381c587_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (In the entire video, water dripping from a faucet falls onto a plate without creating any splashes. Normally, water dripping onto an object would create splashes.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00151", "filename": "P35_104_210_a2557b689381c587_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (At 4.8s, the plate in the character's hand suddenly changes from front to back. At 4.7s, the white brush in the character's right hand disappears into thin air. At 2.3s, the moment the character takes the brush from the sink, part of the plate in the sink suddenly disappears.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00152", "filename": "P35_104_234_04d0749af19e5abe_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 1.9s, the cat on the ground changes from black to white the instant it jumps up. At 2.8s, the cat suddenly rotates 180 degrees.) Physical behavior (at 2.8s, the cat jumps onto the chair, but the chair shows no obvious signs of moving; normally, the chair should sway from side to side or fall over).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00153", "filename": "P35_104_234_04d0749af19e5abe_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.6s, the kitten on the ground suddenly appears on the character's hands.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00154", "filename": "P35_104_234_04d0749af19e5abe_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (1.8s: the moment the black kitten crawls under the table, it has already emerged from the other side of the table). Physical behavior (between 5.7s and 8s: the character's movement does not properly hold the white kitten, yet the kitten is attached to the character's hand; normally, the kitten should fall directly).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00155", "filename": "P35_104_240_eca5746da9df4c37_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00156", "filename": "P35_104_240_eca5746da9df4c37_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00157", "filename": "P35_104_280_2f352341a1d4a63b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.1s, a graphic label with text suddenly appears on the lid in the character's hand. At 4.7s, the label disappears into thin air the instant the character tears it off.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00158", "filename": "P35_104_280_2f352341a1d4a63b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 3.7s, the pink box on the table disappears into thin air. At 3.3s, a white label suddenly appears on the lid in the character's hand.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00159", "filename": "P35_104_291_2e1f637b1cbb42ed_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 0.9s, a large number of yellow granular foods suddenly appeared in the pot.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00160", "filename": "P35_104_291_2e1f637b1cbb42ed_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00161", "filename": "P35_104_367_a903c6d0aa7a2cd8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly: The timing is continuous (at 3.5 seconds, the trash can on the ground suddenly turns into a pile of crumpled paper).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00162", "filename": "P35_104_367_a903c6d0aa7a2cd8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 0.8s, the character's finger penetrates the bottle, violating the impermeability of solids. At 1.7s, the water bottle on the table suddenly flies onto the character's hand.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00163", "filename": "P35_104_367_a903c6d0aa7a2cd8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.3s, a blue cap suddenly appears at the mouth of the bottle on the table.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00164", "filename": "P35_104_438_06f464b144636a9d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.1 seconds, a red basket suddenly appears in the cupboard.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00165", "filename": "P35_104_438_06f464b144636a9d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 6.2s, the basin in the character's hand passes through the edge of the cabinet, violating the principle of impermeability of solids.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00166", "filename": "P35_104_450_abc7c1770ce456a7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the water in the pot on the gas stove is boiling throughout the entire video, but there are no obvious flame marks on the gas stove).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00167", "filename": "P35_104_450_abc7c1770ce456a7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the pot on the gas stove is boiling with obvious bubbles, but the food inside remains still throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00168", "filename": "P35_104_499_3bd6c02b819a29ae_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00169", "filename": "P35_104_614_ea1898564b04ed98_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00170", "filename": "P35_104_614_ea1898564b04ed98_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (at 5.5 seconds, the food inside the box twists and deforms).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00171", "filename": "P12_104_7_fd7e871924edc085_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Timing continuity (0.2s-3.1s: water jet and spoon clip through each other); Physical behavior (2.1s: water jet hits spoon without splashing)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00172", "filename": "P12_104_7_fd7e871924edc085_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time sequence (0.1s: left hand spoon flies out of thin air without any force. 1s-2s: right hand spoon and sponge appear out of thin air. 1.2s-3.8s: water clips through the hand, spoon, and sponge).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00173", "filename": "P12_104_52_ba1373ec2cfb4e57_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time frame is continuous (dyes disappear out of thin air in areas not wiped by the sponge between 1.4s and 1.9s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00174", "filename": "P12_104_52_ba1373ec2cfb4e57_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (At 1.1s-3.6s in the video, foam appeared on the sink while wiping without any dish soap; at 6s in the video, the water was turned on even though the hand did not touch the faucet.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00175", "filename": "P12_104_98_dd5c467a08dfb56f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (a knife is present in the water tank at the beginning of the video, but disappears at 2.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00176", "filename": "P12_104_98_dd5c467a08dfb56f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 3.3s, the handle of the cutlery in the hand turns into the blade; between 2.3s and 5.9s in the video, the knife and spoon in the sink are connected at the end; at 6.4s, the cutlery is placed in the sink and the blade turns into a brown spoon handle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00177", "filename": "P12_104_153_f284eabe65aa408c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 7.4s, the brush tip changes from a square shape to an arc shape, indicating abnormal deformation.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00178", "filename": "P12_104_173_ca467de1ba8daa62_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.2s, the brush and the cutlery in the hand connect to become a fork; at 2.1s, the right fork splits in two to become a fork and a spoon; at 3s, the left-hand brush becomes two forks; at 4.5s, the right-hand fork becomes a spoon.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00179", "filename": "P12_104_173_ca467de1ba8daa62_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is continuous (from 0s to 1s, the lower left corner of the black pot and the brush are clipped through and abnormally deformed; at 3.8s, the fork changes from four forks to five forks).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00180", "filename": "P12_104_174_4aebe81e4ade5154_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (0.6s-5s, the spoon body and handle are centered and connected, the handle is connected horizontally to the spoon body, not vertically).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00182", "filename": "P12_104_176_7e9a5a039e578ea5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (4.1s-4.6s, the front of the plate changes to the back).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00183", "filename": "P12_104_194_0c078fb0f0d988e2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at the beginning of the video, there are cherry tomatoes, a transparent bowl, and a pot lid with a black handle on the left; at 3.9 seconds, the cherry tomatoes turn into slices, the transparent bowl turns into an iron plate, and the black handle turns into a cylindrical handle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00184", "filename": "P12_105_63_79586fe2db8f125d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00185", "filename": "P12_105_63_79586fe2db8f125d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The abnormal footage occurs continuously (from 0.2s to 6.1s, two different bags merge into one bag in the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00186", "filename": "P22_101_122_d884d0ffe919cc1b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (1.6s-2.2s, the snack bag in the hand combines with another bag below to become a bag of cookies).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00187", "filename": "P22_102_137_71deadc21e397e91_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The abnormal footage was continuous (at 0.7s, the right hand and the towel were clearly clipped through each other, with the towel passing through the right hand).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00188", "filename": "P22_103_181_80344a1f4df9a36b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (0.1s-0.7s: the green object under the cutting board suddenly disappears without external force; 1.7s-2s: the cutting board deforms).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00189", "filename": "P22_103_319_23a1c139863044be_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0s-0.2s) A watch appears out of thin air on the left wrist.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00190", "filename": "P22_103_319_23a1c139863044be_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (0s-0.4s, a towel suddenly appears in the right hand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00191", "filename": "P22_104_76_4ad85ac03498c2c2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (1.6s-2s). An item in the hand suddenly multiplies and falls into the bowl.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00192", "filename": "P22_106_85_32ace7ee674e2b1b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (0.4s-1.6s water passes through the hand and detergent is clearly visible through the mold; 3.7s the hand does not squeeze the detergent, and a large amount of detergent flows out).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00193", "filename": "P22_106_85_32ace7ee674e2b1b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal; the physical behavior (the water from the faucet on the left side of the video is flowing, but the water level in the bowl is not increasing, and there is no splashing) is also abnormal", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00194", "filename": "P22_106_85_32ace7ee674e2b1b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (5.1s-5.7s: the liquid in the bottle on the right is green, then turns transparent after being poured out. 5.3s-5.6s: the faucet on the left flows water automatically without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00195", "filename": "P22_106_166_f7ecfdf62a6b2492_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (no splashing of water when rinsing items).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00196", "filename": "P22_106_166_f7ecfdf62a6b2492_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (between 5.8s and 6.6s, the foam that was washed away by the water reappears on the green object).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00197", "filename": "P22_107_8_e390bd8bf8575808_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The sequence of events is continuous (3.3s-3.7s: the plastic bottle splits in two without external force; 3.7s: the center of the bottle becomes the opening).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00198", "filename": "P22_107_94_bb9c655f9b2bdf65_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00199", "filename": "P22_107_105_c86052ef9669424a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00200", "filename": "P22_107_105_c86052ef9669424a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time sequence (2.2s) A perfectly intact bag develops a large tear without any external force.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00201", "filename": "e6384cbd3f392fa7f2ca0b2d14167439bf05b4b707ac799eddc138b65feb4796_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (between 2.1s and 4.3s, the polish of the marble wall is far from mirror-like; the light from the sky only causes extremely subtle changes in the overall brightness of the wall, completely failing to reflect the color of the sky, let alone change in sync with the hue of the sky).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00202", "filename": "e6384cbd3f392fa7f2ca0b2d14167439bf05b4b707ac799eddc138b65feb4796_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall perception is abnormal (in reality, real clouds are large and far from the ground, so even if they are not moving slowly, they appear to the naked eye as a slow, continuous drifting mass; in the video, the clouds move like fog).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00203", "filename": "e6956f519f9ccf4b204dfabbc10bede5cbb889a0f9f1cce9a681e41a61690af5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (0.4s-2.3s). The knife is clearly stained with red paint, but when it is slashed across the white area, no red trace is left.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00204", "filename": "e6956f519f9ccf4b204dfabbc10bede5cbb889a0f9f1cce9a681e41a61690af5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: The time sequence is continuous (when you cut open the pink paint with a knife, the paint at the edge actually increases. In reality, when you cut open paint with a knife, the paint at the cut area will only reveal the underlying paint, and it will never increase the amount of paint as you cut).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00205", "filename": "e6956f519f9ccf4b204dfabbc10bede5cbb889a0f9f1cce9a681e41a61690af5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (2.1s-2.6s). The knife is initially without paint. After slicing to the left, pink paint is spread and the knife is then covered with paint. However, when it is slicing to the right, a large area of pure white paint is suddenly sliced out. In reality, the mixture of pink and white should present a gradient of light pink.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00209", "filename": "e235739e9ba0cc7d12a01eb0fd891e531ed6b6eb3cc0b647089d4bccc1fba2bf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (1.7s) When the toy car is driving on the orange ramp with a person on it, the car falls directly to the ground; in reality, the toy car would tip over.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00210", "filename": "e235739e9ba0cc7d12a01eb0fd891e531ed6b6eb3cc0b647089d4bccc1fba2bf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time is continuous (4.4s-5s). The toy car falls from a height and overturns, but it can immediately straighten itself. In reality, after falling from a height and overturning, the impact force of the landing will prevent it from straightening itself quickly.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00211", "filename": "e235739e9ba0cc7d12a01eb0fd891e531ed6b6eb3cc0b647089d4bccc1fba2bf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (2.6s). The toy figure is driving a car to the top of a hill and suddenly falls down, but it can still maintain the balance of the car and continue to move forward normally. In reality, the car would definitely lose its balance, would not be able to maintain stability, and would not be able to continue to move forward normally.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00212", "filename": "e288037a3f371cb6b4cd1e475c9ba74e756be915c737460f10a9fe9cc0ceb9e4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal because the time sequence is continuous (the four ice blocks in the video appear to be melting and flowing water, but their volume does not shrink throughout the process. In reality, when ice melts, its volume will gradually decrease as it melts, and the melted water will flow down the surface of the ice blocks to the ground, forming obvious watermarks).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00213", "filename": "e288037a3f371cb6b4cd1e475c9ba74e756be915c737460f10a9fe9cc0ceb9e4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (1.9s). During the melting of four small ice cubes, their volume suddenly increases and their shape completely changes.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00214", "filename": "e288037a3f371cb6b4cd1e475c9ba74e756be915c737460f10a9fe9cc0ceb9e4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (1.8s shows excessively large water droplets forming when water is splashed on ice; in reality, large water droplets would not form on the surface of ice due to its low temperature).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00215", "filename": "e377893c31a30a8126598e0dc9c5e83f81773c7d0a523a742ff6b07cf688a147_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time is continuous (0.5s). A thin stream of pale yellow liquid is continuously poured into a glass bottle, producing a large number of bubbles inside the bottle, but the water level in the bottle does not rise at all. In reality, when air mixes inside the bottle and produces a small number of bubbles, the water level will rise slowly and synchronously with the liquid being poured in.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00216", "filename": "e377893c31a30a8126598e0dc9c5e83f81773c7d0a523a742ff6b07cf688a147_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: The time is continuous (0.6s). A pale yellow liquid is poured into a cup, and bubbles are generated in a spiral column shape. When the liquid falls and merges with the surface of the liquid in the cup, the shape of the falling liquid is still left in the liquid in the cup. In reality, when liquid is poured into a cup and comes into contact with the surface of the liquid, it will merge with the liquid in the cup instantly due to the fluidity of the liquid. It is impossible for the falling liquid shape to remain continuously. In addition, the bubbles generated by the pouring will randomly disperse.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00217", "filename": "e784931b287ff99b242f9e661d771cfa44ee9bc3137a7d60d5fe8a2ede83ed76_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (1.1s of a match burning paper, no debris is burned, and after the flame is moved, no trace of burning is left on the burned area).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00218", "filename": "e784931b287ff99b242f9e661d771cfa44ee9bc3137a7d60d5fe8a2ede83ed76_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: The overall visuals are abnormal (2s-3.7s, when the flame is still below the bottom of the cotton paper, black marks from burning have already appeared on the top of the cotton paper).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00219", "filename": "e937821e5d26a447a9c2e2db13187722c4fc69acc7b0d0717b3d274c2e728f4b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (0.6s-0.9s: when the two hanging rope poles are crossing to make bubbles, the right pole initially crosses at the top position, but after reaching the middle position, it appears below the left pole without any reasonable movement, indicating that the poles, which are not penetrating, are crossing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00220", "filename": "e937821e5d26a447a9c2e2db13187722c4fc69acc7b0d0717b3d274c2e728f4b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00221", "filename": "e937821e5d26a447a9c2e2db13187722c4fc69acc7b0d0717b3d274c2e728f4b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The duration is continuous (4s). The bubble drips a lot of water throughout, and when it is pulled apart and bursts, it is not a light, small water stain that appears when the bubble bursts, but rather a puddle of water that appears to be splashed out.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00222", "filename": "e937821e5d26a447a9c2e2db13187722c4fc69acc7b0d0717b3d274c2e728f4b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is as follows: (3.2s) When the bubble grows larger, the upper and lower boundaries are blurred, and the bubble is not connected to the guide line, but directly exceeds the line's range. (5.7s) The bubble bursts, first swirling and tightening in the middle, then bursting into many small bubbles like a water clump. In reality, when a real bubble breaks under external force, it will instantly disperse on the surface of the water film, either breaking directly into water stains or scattering out a few small bubbles. It will not exhibit the state of swirling and tightening in the middle and then bursting into a water clump.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00223", "filename": "e2109806cdc00d948c69fd828be6cd6efb6af5429736e11e9ce23538a76e53c0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00224", "filename": "e2109806cdc00d948c69fd828be6cd6efb6af5429736e11e9ce23538a76e53c0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a transparent object suddenly expands, then melts and spreads out like a milky liquid, and the liquid on the right side suddenly increases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00225", "filename": "e2109806cdc00d948c69fd828be6cd6efb6af5429736e11e9ce23538a76e53c0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a transparent object is actually small in size, but under light, the shadow it casts is very large and long).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00226", "filename": "e614989934b58cf76ef82efb9a05e6068acb8824b9d69111741f47ff5a6503b5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the colored lights of the house in the upper left corner of the video (2.9s-3.8s) are lit normally, but the size of the light strips fluctuates. In reality, the size of the colored lights does not change.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00227", "filename": "e614989934b58cf76ef82efb9a05e6068acb8824b9d69111741f47ff5a6503b5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00228", "filename": "e614989934b58cf76ef82efb9a05e6068acb8824b9d69111741f47ff5a6503b5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (white dots appear out of nowhere in the video scene, and the white dots move with the video frame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00229", "filename": "e614989934b58cf76ef82efb9a05e6068acb8824b9d69111741f47ff5a6503b5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: A white dot appears out of nowhere and then disappears in the video scene between 4.9s and 5.1s.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00230", "filename": "ea1ac4b622d7b43fb228fbad1f4861c3b98d746379ab3bbd778f9259ba72b2cc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (when water vapor rises from the ground, very little rises from the ground, but once it rises into the air, it suddenly gathers into a large mass and continues to increase; the production and diffusion of water vapor do not decrease).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00231", "filename": "c40e8befdfd2e7ca665af7ac493c94aed7536dedcdf8db8dc0052d795db9a65f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The video is continuous in time (at 0.8s, there is no transition in the video footage and an explosion occurs; the blue plastic film in the entire video footage flickers; at 3.2s, a second explosion occurs on the water surface, followed by violent fluctuations in the water surface).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00232", "filename": "c40e8befdfd2e7ca665af7ac493c94aed7536dedcdf8db8dc0052d795db9a65f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.9s, the video footage is smooth and an explosive ball of light suddenly appears on the water surface; at 2.6s, a second explosion occurs suddenly; at 3.8s, after the explosion and the subsequent wave, water splashes outwards).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00233", "filename": "c41b0f2331b5a3c2bf4c350fa83b2e686b221629468b89ca3d603cf47b2ccc6f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (ripples emerge from bottom to top at 0.8s, water flows to the left and forward at 6.2s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00234", "filename": "c91fc4e35c0a985bda71faaeae60b68574ff82bc4b4ed6a2196f1bd127e56f59_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the liquid metal flows too smoothly throughout the video, lacking a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00237", "filename": "c223bdcf69c33fab2c3820aed62d3de351a7bad631ed5a041122c8849187c11d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is too continuous (the sparks from the fireworks at 2s are too regular, and the blue flames in the screen jump too regularly throughout the entire segment).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00238", "filename": "c676c92e2fe93dc780b8423a524d83c43e9c45dc3a32986d6632a44b4edb1768_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 0.4s, the iron ball rolls across two steps instantaneously, and the grass in the entire video footage flickers). Physical behavior (at 6s, the iron ball rolls back and bounces when it lands on the iron plate).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00240", "filename": "c1409e3d3afd748ee11709f8aebd3507f843702e33f04ae9085f6db5f853fbbf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Continuous timing (1.9s: video feed abruptly switches to the next frame without transition; 3s: video feed abruptly switches to the next frame without transition; 5.7s: video feed abruptly switches to the next frame without transition; 6s: the lighter in the character's hand suddenly deforms and shortens).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00241", "filename": "c04833bf8e0277804b08d50f2aac66206be7849c92e25163474f23eaab084ff8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the grass and smoke from the explosion appear to flicker and jump throughout the video); Causality (the grass remains intact after the explosion in the video segment).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00242", "filename": "c19324b839d4218bd506b32b4cf5c709e3976251023b5c2b02a4022ab8235164_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the bubbles in the entire video frame move towards the center, shrink, and then disappear).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00243", "filename": "c19324b839d4218bd506b32b4cf5c709e3976251023b5c2b02a4022ab8235164_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the bubbles in the video move too regularly); Causality (the bubbles generated in the video do not appear on the water surface).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00245", "filename": "c35620ea420245ef4390a11e123d3e9da4672d6e4fa5099bfa47bdbf283f7f50_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is too continuous (the black smoke emitted by the train in the entire video gradually turns white; the movement of the white smoke in the video is too regular).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00246", "filename": "c82095a7157fe54e7696655eca762ec251c39afc2f193061d986a25373ec0e73_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the entire segment shows an ice block standing upright and increasing in size without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00247", "filename": "c132876ba4499ad147db9829061616bab065e9ff3746d8b188da8ad4bb91bebe_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (ice blocks flicker throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00248", "filename": "c132876ba4499ad147db9829061616bab065e9ff3746d8b188da8ad4bb91bebe_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the ice block on the left suddenly becomes transparent at 2.6s, and the ice block melts faster at 5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00249", "filename": "c0661699f8cfb2069723c9874eb0e209c436ccf08ab255d9a210231f49989fe4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The video feed suddenly zooms in at 2.3 seconds.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00250", "filename": "c2632296db4073089e3016e44da06c8897e7edd0aed2e9813ab20f95f6a9f7b3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (the green grass under the bridge in the lower left corner of the video is blurred throughout the entire video); Causal relationship (an explosion occurs on the lake surface throughout the video, but no ripples appear on the water).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00251", "filename": "f5d35538ae4d5794d88e2b430c7af48fe819437f4df05939da7137f60d15a03e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00252", "filename": "f5d35538ae4d5794d88e2b430c7af48fe819437f4df05939da7137f60d15a03e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 0.2s, the green rubber band clipped through the finger, violating the principle of impermeability of solids.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00253", "filename": "f5d35538ae4d5794d88e2b430c7af48fe819437f4df05939da7137f60d15a03e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 4.4s, the character's thumb penetrated the rubber band, violating the principle of impermeability of solids.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00254", "filename": "f5d35538ae4d5794d88e2b430c7af48fe819437f4df05939da7137f60d15a03e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.4s, the character's left arm suddenly disappears, leaving only the hand. At 4.2s, the character's left hand reappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00255", "filename": "f5e23eeb2e27b67b191abc53f82a93860df30485bbe1339bcef11484fdcc04c9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00256", "filename": "f5e23eeb2e27b67b191abc53f82a93860df30485bbe1339bcef11484fdcc04c9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, without any disturbance to the bowl on the table, the green object and liquid inside the bowl rotate.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00257", "filename": "f5e23eeb2e27b67b191abc53f82a93860df30485bbe1339bcef11484fdcc04c9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, without any disturbance to the bowl on the table, the green object and liquid inside the bowl rotate.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00258", "filename": "f5e23eeb2e27b67b191abc53f82a93860df30485bbe1339bcef11484fdcc04c9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.8 seconds, a clump of green substance suddenly appears in the upper area of the cup.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00259", "filename": "f006eee3bddc08c032695d765ddb76492d596a0613889b190e92e3169ad3505e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The timing is continuous (from 3.26 to 5 seconds, the launched rocket remains stationary in the air. Under normal circumstances, the rocket's thrust is greater than gravity, and the rocket should continue to ascend).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00260", "filename": "f006eee3bddc08c032695d765ddb76492d596a0613889b190e92e3169ad3505e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (The missile launches normally, but a violent explosion and flames occur on the left side of the launch pad. In a real missile launch, the launch pad is subjected to high temperature and pressure and generates a large amount of steam, but it will not explode during the missile's normal takeoff. Such a scenario of a successful launch followed by a platform explosion is impossible in reality.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00261", "filename": "f6a80bb6e041202a84097d88372296e13ba911eeb3312f0bc7501b8dd1789a72_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00262", "filename": "f6a80bb6e041202a84097d88372296e13ba911eeb3312f0bc7501b8dd1789a72_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time frame is continuous (0-1.8s, the ice cube on the table is gradually increasing in size). Overall visual anomaly (the shape of the raised ice peak in the middle is too regular, more like a model that has been forcibly pasted on than a naturally melting ice cube. When real ice melts, the raised part will gradually collapse and flatten due to gravity, and will not maintain such a sharp shape.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00263", "filename": "f6a80bb6e041202a84097d88372296e13ba911eeb3312f0bc7501b8dd1789a72_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00264", "filename": "f6a80bb6e041202a84097d88372296e13ba911eeb3312f0bc7501b8dd1789a72_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The video is continuous in time (0-4.8s, the ice cube on the table is gradually increasing in size).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00265", "filename": "f6dc6b3c39d863ffefbc17f86e22893dbefd3f26f7b2c2b3a13935c06359376d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the ice cubes in the glass rotate and jump inside the glass without any external force, violating Newton's First Law.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00266", "filename": "f6dc6b3c39d863ffefbc17f86e22893dbefd3f26f7b2c2b3a13935c06359376d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 2 seconds, water appears to flow out of thin air on the right side of the cup). Physical behavior (throughout the video, the ice cubes in the cup tumble inside without any external force, violating Newton's First Law).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00267", "filename": "f6dc6b3c39d863ffefbc17f86e22893dbefd3f26f7b2c2b3a13935c06359376d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (at 1.7 seconds, a large amount of water suddenly appears at the bottom of the cup and gradually submerges the ice).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00268", "filename": "f6dc6b3c39d863ffefbc17f86e22893dbefd3f26f7b2c2b3a13935c06359376d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 1.3s, the water poured into the glass penetrated the glass wall, violating the principle of impermeability of solids. At 5s, the ice cubes in the glass suddenly shrank.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00269", "filename": "f7e8a50af139df04beb51b1a55b167664607a83cacd5b1a6ef203087f38f2234_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00270", "filename": "f7e8a50af139df04beb51b1a55b167664607a83cacd5b1a6ef203087f38f2234_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (Throughout the video, the smoke lines are too regular, like deliberately drawn curves, rather than naturally spreading and distorting. It lacks the random, soft dynamism of real smoke moving with the air.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00271", "filename": "f7e8a50af139df04beb51b1a55b167664607a83cacd5b1a6ef203087f38f2234_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual effect is abnormal (the smoke lines are too regular, like deliberately drawn curves, rather than naturally spreading and twisting. It lacks the random, soft dynamism of real smoke moving with the air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00272", "filename": "f7e8a50af139df04beb51b1a55b167664607a83cacd5b1a6ef203087f38f2234_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual presentation is abnormal (the edges of the smoke have abrupt, sharp turns, lacking the soft, continuous flow of realistic smoke. The blue reflective areas are also too concentrated, blending unnaturally with the overall hazy texture).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00273", "filename": "f8cdee4e4274e1dcc570aa0d752fe9fb5bf190da5d392ac82823a3403009f596_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the movements of the characters in the entire video are too smooth, unlike realistic footage, lacking the jarring and jerky feel expected in real life.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00275", "filename": "f8cdee4e4274e1dcc570aa0d752fe9fb5bf190da5d392ac82823a3403009f596_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 3.2s, the character's hand holding the torch is completely twisted and deformed, clipping through the torch's position; the shape and connection of the fingers completely violate human anatomy.) Temporal continuity (at 1.2s, 3.2s, and 4.6s, a clear ring of fire appears out of thin air on the character's wrist.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00277", "filename": "f8df579ad7329b140f2ad3e4c9759d0523f53f29db00d3df55005c61df5f58a8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video is continuous in time (the food in the pan does not show any obvious changes after being fried in oil, whereas normally food will change in color and shape after being fried in oil).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00278", "filename": "f8df579ad7329b140f2ad3e4c9759d0523f53f29db00d3df55005c61df5f58a8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (4-5.9s, the food in the pot gradually disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00279", "filename": "f8df579ad7329b140f2ad3e4c9759d0523f53f29db00d3df55005c61df5f58a8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video is continuous in time (the food in the pan does not show any obvious changes after being fried in oil, whereas normally food will change in color and shape after being fried in oil).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00280", "filename": "f8df579ad7329b140f2ad3e4c9759d0523f53f29db00d3df55005c61df5f58a8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (from the beginning to the end of the video, the food in the pot gradually disappears; at 6 seconds, after the food disappears, a square food pattern is left on the bottom of the pot.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00282", "filename": "21a1c21ee41c4e1806479a4eb54045bafbe67a65c60a6a1a505da30ff8701d60_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00283", "filename": "21a1c21ee41c4e1806479a4eb54045bafbe67a65c60a6a1a505da30ff8701d60_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (4.9s-8s: the flames suddenly turn into white streaks and keep twisting and moving closer to the camera).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00284", "filename": "21e0f67731c0c861cab2719256b2bef07727f9793749b2210b83f98bf1732c13_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (1.8s-5.3s: all items fall down without any apparent cause or effect, and the overall screen flickers).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00285", "filename": "21e0f67731c0c861cab2719256b2bef07727f9793749b2210b83f98bf1732c13_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the number of pink squares at the bottom of the screen suddenly decreases and new squares keep appearing and moving on their own throughout the process).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00286", "filename": "21ea1f1f75a5540c0faf461c1d339d7c985310d1ef0297660b2151484e083de9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00287", "filename": "23b3a0ee3784cc7fdbcf6a908118f887992dcf6900b809c187f9f9b2f619877b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00288", "filename": "23c6fdb9b9519f61c071f99f8d687323c730d48480ac60e77319daf01d15fa79_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00289", "filename": "23f7529a2ff5ff3c8b15d5e79f86b55abac38399915d81dad5d7d59e93b67fd2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the food in the pot flickers throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00290", "filename": "24b35a5cf2c28aadf4c6840cd066440de1a540424805b13e8853116691b7f613_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the iron block below suddenly disappears at 3.4s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00291", "filename": "24b35a5cf2c28aadf4c6840cd066440de1a540424805b13e8853116691b7f613_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the iron block suddenly disappears at 3.7s, and then suddenly appears at 4.7s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00295", "filename": "27a6ca871696c781a64c8a73e3e140c38a7dffd0b137dd82bacb8f8cf44c0623_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Cause and effect (2.7s-8s: without any fried food, the oil in the pot inexplicably forms a regular frying pattern, without any prior cause or effect).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00296", "filename": "27d4fe782033afe8cc8e4ededefef77d7044b0994a00ee5d22f51fd0f636548a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00297", "filename": "27fe065de2f8b4e9c8f81cf838e4ddd542e3b8da86333b86ff66f5e8a4a8e747_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00298", "filename": "28b185e9205732a49f0e27a0a157a1c0cb1b351a6a65e87a7a9c3604123d10da_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the hand's movements are very small throughout the entire scene, while the gem's rotation is very large, which is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00299", "filename": "29d2d4cda10fe79d993df40ac4c9029dd1e3f8e11b8758abadaf6c65c4dcd558_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the object in the image is hollow and very thin, so there should be very little residue after it is crushed. However, the amount of residue after the object is crushed is excessive between 1.4s and 5s, which is inconsistent with the above).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00301", "filename": "e7a90ab893a60d79142294c14cacccae999c722e989c954d999883c07f2940a5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Continuous time (the intensity and position of the light in the image remain unchanged throughout, but the hue of the light gradually turns yellow for no apparent reason, without any environmental factors to support this color change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00302", "filename": "e7a90ab893a60d79142294c14cacccae999c722e989c954d999883c07f2940a5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the clouds in the scene move too smoothly and evenly, without the natural pauses and staggered changes that occur when clouds move in reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00303", "filename": "e7a799b9866c290c13b7788b460fca703a6d97189ffc215a74d75a0e70f609d1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without camera changes, external forces, or external interference, the candy in the lower left corner of the screen moves to the left on its own at 2.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00304", "filename": "e7a799b9866c290c13b7788b460fca703a6d97189ffc215a74d75a0e70f609d1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 1.8 seconds, the amount of liquid produced by the melting of an object in the middle of the video increases out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00305", "filename": "e7a799b9866c290c13b7788b460fca703a6d97189ffc215a74d75a0e70f609d1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00306", "filename": "e7b03a570e87b3923cb10ddfefe61db345c32125d8af71bf8ae640ecb950dd5b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, a large amount of liquid is poured into a container, but the water level inside the container does not rise).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00307", "filename": "e7b03a570e87b3923cb10ddfefe61db345c32125d8af71bf8ae640ecb950dd5b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timeline is discontinuous (in reality, when liquid is poured and forms a water column, it will produce natural ripples, swaying, or tiny splashes due to gravity and air resistance. It won't be as completely smooth and flat as in the video, without any dynamic texture).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00308", "filename": "e7b03a570e87b3923cb10ddfefe61db345c32125d8af71bf8ae640ecb950dd5b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the amount of liquid in the cup increases out of nowhere at 4.7 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00312", "filename": "e7f84b8407c74e64220b50eafcf671889b9ed66ed4f12377de8c2b33895630f3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without changing camera angles, the character's thumb suddenly shortens at 0.4 seconds, and the fingernail also turns white instantly).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00313", "filename": "e7f84b8407c74e64220b50eafcf671889b9ed66ed4f12377de8c2b33895630f3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the surface texture of the hands and rings in the image is too smooth, lacking any realistic texture details; at the same time, the characters' movements are too fluid, lacking the natural pauses and jolts of real-life limb movements).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00314", "filename": "e7f84b8407c74e64220b50eafcf671889b9ed66ed4f12377de8c2b33895630f3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, a portion of the top of the ring on the thumb suddenly disappears at 1.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00315", "filename": "e08a67ae7b5452668a10e6b770a61edcdcb92c0e6e28c4b3daf0797eccc37184_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, a white object suddenly appears in the upper left corner of the frame at 3.6 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00316", "filename": "e08a67ae7b5452668a10e6b770a61edcdcb92c0e6e28c4b3daf0797eccc37184_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The flames in the image burn too smoothly, lacking the natural, rhythmic flickering of real flames. Their shape is also too regular, and their swaying is too predictable.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00317", "filename": "e08a67ae7b5452668a10e6b770a61edcdcb92c0e6e28c4b3daf0797eccc37184_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00318", "filename": "e08a67ae7b5452668a10e6b770a61edcdcb92c0e6e28c4b3daf0797eccc37184_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00319", "filename": "e8e0e10b0d79f6a16fdf1584f7d8f7e3862525f8bdd434476193482393e664b5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is not continuous (the lake surface in the scene appears unnaturally flat and smooth, and there are no natural ripples or waves on the water surface, lacking the dynamic texture that lake water should have in reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00320", "filename": "e8e0e10b0d79f6a16fdf1584f7d8f7e3862525f8bdd434476193482393e664b5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (Under the premise of no external interference or camera change, a large ripple suddenly appears on the right side of the water surface at 1.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00321", "filename": "e8e0e10b0d79f6a16fdf1584f7d8f7e3862525f8bdd434476193482393e664b5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the lake surface in the image appears unnaturally smooth and flat, without any natural ripples or waves. It lacks the necessary dynamic texture).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00322", "filename": "e8e813dc3f89d172c5196a713758eeecd7737c2f31af6b1e10a4229e56a71b1b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the texture of the clouds and sunlight in the image is too smooth, completely lacking the natural pauses and variations in depth that should exist in reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00323", "filename": "e8e813dc3f89d172c5196a713758eeecd7737c2f31af6b1e10a4229e56a71b1b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera transition, an object on the left side of the road appears out of nowhere at 1.2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00324", "filename": "e8e813dc3f89d172c5196a713758eeecd7737c2f31af6b1e10a4229e56a71b1b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement or external interference, a red light suddenly appears at 1.3 seconds in the lower left corner of the screen).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00325", "filename": "e8e813dc3f89d172c5196a713758eeecd7737c2f31af6b1e10a4229e56a71b1b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (Under conditions of no external force or interference, the fog in the image instantly moves to the left side of the screen at 1.2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00326", "filename": "e9ef4ca2a19bb297edf8a3cf1eade935066fb5f141a26769f5bba294331870df_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is unusual: the time sequence is continuous (the balloon, after being scorched by flames, does not explode, but instead exhibits unusual resilience, without any damage or deformation).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00327", "filename": "e9ef4ca2a19bb297edf8a3cf1eade935066fb5f141a26769f5bba294331870df_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the white object in the upper left corner of the screen disappears out of thin air at 3.6 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00328", "filename": "e49ff33a013d048933f2000772211bbdb3f628151eb90af46dd31464284eccc9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the surface texture of the road in the image is too smooth, lacking the texture undulations and natural cadence that should exist in reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00329", "filename": "e49ff33a013d048933f2000772211bbdb3f628151eb90af46dd31464284eccc9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, an object appears out of thin air under the tire at 4.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00330", "filename": "e49ff33a013d048933f2000772211bbdb3f628151eb90af46dd31464284eccc9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00331", "filename": "da7979ed8be3d8469ef576cdec590b2e3420052c1e6f2d51255014887135bd93_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (0.2s-4.6s, the hand in the lower left corner is abnormally twisted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00332", "filename": "da7979ed8be3d8469ef576cdec590b2e3420052c1e6f2d51255014887135bd93_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The brazier shakes automatically without any external force for a continuous period of time (0.5s-2.4s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00333", "filename": "da69203e561e5e62d95da11a84a9129583e120bee7e2dee161c75e176cf3e404_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (0.9s-1.7s, the deer-shaped lamp, used as a decoration, changes its head position from bowed to raised).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00334", "filename": "da69203e561e5e62d95da11a84a9129583e120bee7e2dee161c75e176cf3e404_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00335", "filename": "da69203e561e5e62d95da11a84a9129583e120bee7e2dee161c75e176cf3e404_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00336", "filename": "da69203e561e5e62d95da11a84a9129583e120bee7e2dee161c75e176cf3e404_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: A continuous white light spot appears out of nowhere in the lower right corner of the video (3.8s-4.9s) and flies around without any external force.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00337", "filename": "da597961fc01282b8df3d40a815f2b0d08cb23cd016d1ed8bb0967b4880b5cbb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows a continuous sequence of events: (0s-0.6s) a single match suddenly multiplies into two; (0.7s) a match in the distance spontaneously combusts without any external force.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00338", "filename": "da597961fc01282b8df3d40a815f2b0d08cb23cd016d1ed8bb0967b4880b5cbb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The sequence of events (2.9s-4.1s) abruptly switches from a single burning match to a row of burning matches. The animation is missing; there is no clear sequence of one match lighting a row of matches.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00339", "filename": "daf232ff326b010f5cc6045a7da50ddc461fcd169151a03ee338f9250c5f2962_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the movement and transformation of the clouds in the image are too smooth, lacking the realistic feeling of drifting with the wind).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00340", "filename": "daf232ff326b010f5cc6045a7da50ddc461fcd169151a03ee338f9250c5f2962_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (when the clouds in the image are moving, they are more like liquids than gases. The clouds should slowly drift in all directions, rather than flowing like glue with a sticky feel.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00341", "filename": "daf232ff326b010f5cc6045a7da50ddc461fcd169151a03ee338f9250c5f2962_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the clouds in the image move too smoothly and evenly, lacking a sense of dispersion, unlike a realistic scene).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00342", "filename": "daf232ff326b010f5cc6045a7da50ddc461fcd169151a03ee338f9250c5f2962_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00343", "filename": "db25a5c8bd07b8ac7bcbaa1528ad94651be517871823e46837f5d4e60259e736_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: During the continuous time (2.1s-2.7s), the fish's shape is abnormally distorted while swimming, and the fish's size increases.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00344", "filename": "db25a5c8bd07b8ac7bcbaa1528ad94651be517871823e46837f5d4e60259e736_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The gray-green water suddenly turns into a clear sky blue without any external force, with a continuous duration of 0s-1.7s.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00345", "filename": "db25a5c8bd07b8ac7bcbaa1528ad94651be517871823e46837f5d4e60259e736_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00346", "filename": "db25a5c8bd07b8ac7bcbaa1528ad94651be517871823e46837f5d4e60259e736_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the bubbles that suddenly appear between 2.6s and 5.5s don't resemble bubbles; they look like a smooth plastic film twisting, which doesn't fit the shape of a bubble).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00347", "filename": "db2345fe607a7083567172c6560945563b1eebdfd60dad5ee802fe11b555c977_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0.1s, a bunch of silver objects suddenly appear out of thin air on the right hand.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00348", "filename": "db2345fe607a7083567172c6560945563b1eebdfd60dad5ee802fe11b555c977_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0.3s, a bunch of silver objects appear out of thin air on the right hand.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00349", "filename": "db2345fe607a7083567172c6560945563b1eebdfd60dad5ee802fe11b555c977_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time sequence (0.4s: black spherical object suddenly turns brown. 5.6s: hard spherical object suddenly becomes soft and elastic like dough).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00355", "filename": "dba9b205ce48942afe572eed7b10a754ac3a1532e3922ec5dabcfa35773d005a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0s) shows a straight shovel bending and twisting abnormally without external force.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00356", "filename": "dba9b205ce48942afe572eed7b10a754ac3a1532e3922ec5dabcfa35773d005a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0.6s, one shovel transforms into two shovels, then merges back into one shovel).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00357", "filename": "dba9b205ce48942afe572eed7b10a754ac3a1532e3922ec5dabcfa35773d005a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00358", "filename": "dba9b205ce48942afe572eed7b10a754ac3a1532e3922ec5dabcfa35773d005a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00361", "filename": "e2f813cbc7a6420905ccac6be8a065cf7f3940cb3e6d433fb461f8975af84df3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (the overall image exhibits dynamic flickering defects).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00362", "filename": "e3c590f62833a8400ed15d3c2a2c54adf1ec4b50e2c40bf6d5fa07ee08044eea_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Temporal continuity (the entire screen flickers), overall visual inconsistencies (the large amount of smoke from a burning green tree is inconsistent with the small amount of smoke in the scene).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00363", "filename": "e4a9dfc382de8d4df466753b701cd8a763cfe1616b9a49c7bb65b7de78afc8bf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity issue (overall screen flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00364", "filename": "e4da568251a7d238daff09d237d0c5c105f45fb415110cc7a6b7b3e82c58b799_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (the overall image exhibits dynamic flickering defects).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00365", "filename": "e4da568251a7d238daff09d237d0c5c105f45fb415110cc7a6b7b3e82c58b799_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (violates the natural laws of snow melting), overall intuition anomaly (ice melts too quickly, inconsistent with the actual slow melting).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00366", "filename": "e05be368a1e41488e8de76186badb207538260332af7c173b5ba2dd1b8c51fa3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the cup on the table is shaking on its own without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00367", "filename": "e05be368a1e41488e8de76186badb207538260332af7c173b5ba2dd1b8c51fa3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (the overall image exhibits dynamic flickering defects).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00368", "filename": "e5bdcaac3ee2654a30b222c6e84744b1668e6b57bd792aedffa7e5e998d37342_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the bubbles next to the object change while the white object in the center does not).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00372", "filename": "e5e056825cde73dbb7241ae009499d350b203535ea9af10d5f3feadd2cf23431_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (dynamic flickering defects in the electronic components of the image).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00373", "filename": "e5e023832489278311107706c0cd6ffd27ea47c7da336d412eaa719e103bf7fa_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (obvious water movement that doesn't match the stillness of the leaves), temporal continuity (dynamic flickering on the water surface).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00374", "filename": "e6eabfde37815b9aca5b042119d88801f5d19b8e6023c1ab0f38783b0b5f098d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00375", "filename": "e6eabfde37815b9aca5b042119d88801f5d19b8e6023c1ab0f38783b0b5f098d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (the wooden panel in the image shows dynamic flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00376", "filename": "e07fb99c0c73bdcd74f569a276832c977910a318c139f3f57a63dd4ca1290a41_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity issue (flickering on the right side of the screen).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00377", "filename": "e07fb99c0c73bdcd74f569a276832c977910a318c139f3f57a63dd4ca1290a41_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00378", "filename": "e7a799b9866c290c13b7788b460fca703a6d97189ffc215a74d75a0e70f609d1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the screen flickers overall, and the solid suddenly melts at 2.2 seconds), overall visual anomalies (the melting is very rapid and smooth after 2.2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00379", "filename": "e7a799b9866c290c13b7788b460fca703a6d97189ffc215a74d75a0e70f609d1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the melting is too smooth and even, lacking the proper sense of chaos).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00380", "filename": "e7b03a570e87b3923cb10ddfefe61db345c32125d8af71bf8ae640ecb950dd5b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the liquid level in the cup in the hand does not decrease, while the liquid level in the cup on the table increases).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00382", "filename": "3f921fea93ab2e2ede379fbd8cad14f0dd93b70ace446650df80eb3736ff80f4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 0.3s, the pillar in the upper left corner of the video disappears out of thin air, and at 4.4s, smoke appears out of thin air at the bottom of the yellow car in the middle of the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00383", "filename": "3fb0a1849865ba13f413f35aab93ff48df086d5901662499d100cf16db870992_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.6s, the bubble in the middle of the video appears out of nowhere; at 3s, the bubble on the left side of the video is distorted; at 3.3s, the bubble in the middle of the video is distorted and then merges; at 4.2s, the bubble in the middle of the video splits and a small bubble on the right side appears out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00384", "filename": "3fc4ceff5cea04ebd72494f53ab4820f0ee981a1a1c21c191d9b529df0cf124a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.4s, the small ball on the right side of the video splits into two, and at 1.1s, the small ball on the right side merges and disappears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00385", "filename": "3fe6eaa56fb6ae84954ef28f8b0cc11e7a5754a4c24e1497fd26cf7ea014c9dd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00386", "filename": "3fe6eaa56fb6ae84954ef28f8b0cc11e7a5754a4c24e1497fd26cf7ea014c9dd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00387", "filename": "3fe7ad2221e0737b3b027cfc2f679ce0760136355f1039976bca90b6a97b497e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Physical behavior (at 5.2s, the beam pattern projected onto the ground in full brightness is uniformly radial, rather than forming a straight, clearly defined beam. This requires the luminaire to have a special optical lens or frosted cover to achieve the violation of the straight-line propagation of light).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00388", "filename": "4a18e992d4a73f57f863c98f84e39a36459050beabfb623b645ba7d21e27eb09_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (in the 4.5s video, the cloud-based building and the building below are not connected; the cloud-based building is unsupported and suspended, violating the law of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00389", "filename": "4a18e992d4a73f57f863c98f84e39a36459050beabfb623b645ba7d21e27eb09_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous flickering (the entire cloud layer appears to be flashing).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00390", "filename": "4aa255f15879611add3a39caf2f018a72e098824721a2cc14aac37a7c4318d19_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the sphere falls throughout the video without rebounding, its potential energy seemingly disappearing into thin air, violating the principle of conservation of energy).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00392", "filename": "4ae96481656e3d49f0fb58f7b875d45ebb8af7158b8298f04f9cfb6e6d13e964_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the lights and fire in the video do not illuminate surrounding objects, which does not conform to light scattering); Causality (in the video, high-temperature flames are continuously roasting meat, but the surface of the meat does not show any change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00393", "filename": "4b0817062094ac51fe75b4296c67cf0a155af92db1d8f02b6362cee2f2c43d67_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00394", "filename": "4b0817062094ac51fe75b4296c67cf0a155af92db1d8f02b6362cee2f2c43d67_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the water mist appears to flicker throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00395", "filename": "4b0817062094ac51fe75b4296c67cf0a155af92db1d8f02b6362cee2f2c43d67_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Physical behavior (between 2.3s and 7.1s, the clouds on the left side of the video move rapidly to the right and then disappear when there is no wind).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00396", "filename": "4bc52744c02a78c9741a844a05b653778a871f964e511b0f60eae06f29852360_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video is continuous in time (at 3.1 seconds, the transparent slime in the middle of the video appears distorted and sunken).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00397", "filename": "4bc52744c02a78c9741a844a05b653778a871f964e511b0f60eae06f29852360_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous timing (the video flickers or wriggles throughout the entire clip).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00398", "filename": "4d48d0f68ed3d6a0737ed8c1fbf82a2b2cc0242c7c8a325f726dbd27335d45f1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the cloud and building images in the video are flickering).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00399", "filename": "4d48d0f68ed3d6a0737ed8c1fbf82a2b2cc0242c7c8a325f726dbd27335d45f1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (a black dot appears out of nowhere in the clouds on the left side of the video at 1.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00400", "filename": "4d96c5e8712d6f3b399e35619ea57ef6606704fe001eca66e08a1783209bf1e7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (a black oil drum appears out of nowhere at the explosion site at 0.4s)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00401", "filename": "d2d80d897320388d23819460adbd98bf1125d80692445922ab38b85b137b21b7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 3.1 seconds into the video, the wooden bridge moves on its own without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00402", "filename": "d2d80d897320388d23819460adbd98bf1125d80692445922ab38b85b137b21b7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 3.7s, the ball in the video rolls backwards on the slope, getting higher and higher, with its potential energy increasing out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00403", "filename": "d2d80d897320388d23819460adbd98bf1125d80692445922ab38b85b137b21b7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00404", "filename": "d2d80d897320388d23819460adbd98bf1125d80692445922ab38b85b137b21b7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (at 2.8s in the video, the ball suddenly stops on the inclined slope and rolls back, violating the law of gravity; at 5.7s in the video, the iron ball does not follow its inertial trajectory and suddenly rolls away from the side track, violating inertial motion).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00405", "filename": "d2d9084dee705b19855e66d684109586828bee014891b12a28ec31e2b8db6888_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.6s in the video, the person in the frame was originally walking forward, but suddenly walked towards the camera without changing the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00406", "filename": "d2d9084dee705b19855e66d684109586828bee014891b12a28ec31e2b8db6888_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 3.3s to the end of the video, the vehicle is positioned on the right side of the frame, but the headlights are shining directly in front of the camera).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00407", "filename": "d2d9084dee705b19855e66d684109586828bee014891b12a28ec31e2b8db6888_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00408", "filename": "d2f963ba992af317954b9efd1de1e2e284759d0a1804111924d969340e802012_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the entire video, when the thermometer is inserted into the water, due to the difference in refractive index between water and air, there should be a clear visual effect of it breaking at the water surface, but this visual effect does not occur in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00409", "filename": "d2f963ba992af317954b9efd1de1e2e284759d0a1804111924d969340e802012_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Continuous timing (the thermometer was placed in the water at 1.6s but the reading did not change). Abnormal video feed: Physical behavior (at 5.4s in the video, the thermometer dial kept flashing different numbers, which were too far from the boiling point of the water).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00410", "filename": "d2f963ba992af317954b9efd1de1e2e284759d0a1804111924d969340e802012_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00414", "filename": "d3e9f33dc9274851ef6f3ae838f18a11a3188d517602c49d5f31470cc30c360c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.5s, the diamond in the video suddenly becomes longer without any change in the camera angle; at 1.9s, the diamond suddenly turns green).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00415", "filename": "d3e9f33dc9274851ef6f3ae838f18a11a3188d517602c49d5f31470cc30c360c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.9s in the video, a light green line suddenly appears in the frame; throughout the video, the diamond shape keeps changing).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00416", "filename": "d3ff0f34f40292ae2e0aa8cb00f67febcadf7e16b303f9ecb41cc2ab9b942820_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 0.3s to 4.6s in the video, the front part of the popsicle stick is melting, but the bottom does not change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00417", "filename": "d3ff0f34f40292ae2e0aa8cb00f67febcadf7e16b303f9ecb41cc2ab9b942820_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (the popsicle keeps melting throughout the video, but its volume does not change); Overall visual anomalies (the melted liquid from the popsicle is too smooth and lacks the randomness of natural liquid flow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00418", "filename": "d3ff0f34f40292ae2e0aa8cb00f67febcadf7e16b303f9ecb41cc2ab9b942820_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the ice cream in the scene is colorful, but the water that flows out after melting is transparent).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00419", "filename": "d3ff0f34f40292ae2e0aa8cb00f67febcadf7e16b303f9ecb41cc2ab9b942820_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the popsicle is constantly melting throughout the video, but its volume remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00420", "filename": "d4a39268edf1440e50545d0cf6f5d3faa0275daffad386cae907c55f45036081_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (Throughout the video, the match in the frame is constantly shaking, but the flame on the match remains unchanged and stable).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00421", "filename": "d4a39268edf1440e50545d0cf6f5d3faa0275daffad386cae907c55f45036081_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.1s in the video, a candle wick appears out of nowhere in the flame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00422", "filename": "d4a39268edf1440e50545d0cf6f5d3faa0275daffad386cae907c55f45036081_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.1 seconds into the video, a candle wick appears out of nowhere in the flame; the flame continues to burn throughout the entire video, but the candle itself does not change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00423", "filename": "d4a39268edf1440e50545d0cf6f5d3faa0275daffad386cae907c55f45036081_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.8s in the video, a candle wick appears out of nowhere in the flame, and at 4.4s, the candle flame suddenly gets bigger).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00424", "filename": "d4e19c146c71c4851da4e2f535e56fe67677df799b8c1d065df77173aabd3ed7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the entire video clip is constantly shaking and exhibits flickering artifacts).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00425", "filename": "d4e19c146c71c4851da4e2f535e56fe67677df799b8c1d065df77173aabd3ed7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00426", "filename": "d4e19c146c71c4851da4e2f535e56fe67677df799b8c1d065df77173aabd3ed7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 2.1 seconds into the video, without any change in camera angle, waves suddenly appear out of nowhere in the foreground).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00427", "filename": "d4e19c146c71c4851da4e2f535e56fe67677df799b8c1d065df77173aabd3ed7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00428", "filename": "d5ca337cef8e108a26cd2de46f1e8f6bdd34c0b36291152f956c28d3268487ee_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (at 1.5s in the video, the person changes the direction of stirring with the spoon, and the direction of water rotation in the frame changes instantly).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00429", "filename": "d5ca337cef8e108a26cd2de46f1e8f6bdd34c0b36291152f956c28d3268487ee_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00430", "filename": "d5d13db9d8eb59293163f3af0469690291aeec7c124fb32e5ca63e05fb44fe82_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, there is no splashing of water in the river, the ripples on the water surface are repetitive and mechanical, and the water surface on the right side of the screen is still with no water ripples, which does not conform to the laws of liquid movement).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00431", "filename": "85aeece7277217e0edc595b0778c95a55cdb666f421fac7f4f1f4f6fa12242db_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.2s, the blocks in the upper left suddenly transform into marbles; at 3.7s, multiple green marbles appear out of thin air from the white object. Due to the law of conservation of mass, matter cannot be created out of thin air.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00432", "filename": "85f0744b02870e9d24aa0be0bc76492f0b860ed7f8412e1d8a50c6a39a77c5f3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00433", "filename": "86a487c5a07151bada4ef4ddb5263d3e484466b048f20d9ef4e8da16162ee4fa_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00434", "filename": "87a7ce41535bf5dc68946a26da6fc7338570ee2f0ca3fc5844fbe71401afe608_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: (At 1.8 seconds, the foot hadn't even stepped on the watermelon yet, and it automatically exploded into multiple pieces. In reality, a watermelon is a whole unit without external force; the foot didn't step on it, so there was no force, and the watermelon shouldn't have exploded.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00435", "filename": "87ea24f8c18b0da3d7cfffc67810454b1d8efa618efee2e7c9d630ea683c6f5b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00436", "filename": "87f7ae7a19ad98d816cb5a67c9c85b14512ea9287e0321f2e6599ddf786a9c42_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (The scene depicts lake water evaporating and producing a large amount of water vapor, which remains stationary in mid-air, contrary to reality. In reality, water vapor, due to evaporation, is less dense than air and should therefore rise.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00437", "filename": "088bf1dc14b98261de43b317b993299abb68fc086fb31aa9b63b6e4b0d2565e4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00438", "filename": "88fa607adfe47fd693e89ad6050d1e2d1d9b2e916c17b02bcb33323a3e4e69eb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the entire video shows a cardboard burning in flames, but the cardboard remains stationary with no signs of burning, which is unrealistic. In reality, burning cardboard would gradually diminish, and due to the law of conservation of mass, the unchanging burning cardboard contradicts the laws of physics.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00439", "filename": "089a19f801a147022fe8c241caaa74d7bb621d847d632d91618b9d7e50fede04_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At the beginning of the video, there is only one green ball. From 3.8s to 6s, after the first green ball rolls to the ground, a second green ball appears out of nowhere and rolls to the ground. Due to the law of conservation of mass, the second ball cannot appear out of nowhere.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00440", "filename": "89a7c8d63704d8ab0f3d7fe16cf6e00487c5fea19b63fcf36f389eeb96d1e220_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (0s-1.2s, the yellow ball rolls automatically without external force.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00441", "filename": "89aa2997c32353f2bf709cc16325e6ff723681b808af7ccacfa013c1d6487814_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00442", "filename": "89b031f85b0ba4625015cc0cd75431e2f09ac0554f7edb4f37681ac168c898a4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00443", "filename": "89dbc5bdc0451c20ed0620ca8e6d86c5d2cf51f736ad2c799f530af0c868678d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: (From 3.4s to 6.6s, the ice in the bowl disappears into thin air without any external force. In reality, the ice melts slowly into water, and the water remains in the bowl, rather than disappearing directly from the bowl without any external force.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00444", "filename": "89e8fee66b8e5a969a37457f49c8ac0b51c3501dfd3a4d57d4419b15d3a8dbf8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00445", "filename": "90d47c33f06fc7c47f05e10c07b26ae2496ff15282112d820d7d6f02f80627a4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual impression is off (the entire video is too smooth, resembling an anime style, unlike realistic footage).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00446", "filename": "90dc0025d2223cd05c159aff8fab1a75499915fea3b4892459bb22702b33beaa_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00447", "filename": "90e0efa3905ba75e8f51423b094bcb7050a2ff73726588b71a98485f9cbc163b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00448", "filename": "90f9c9387e0289211e9fcb5b1897f4e071df182368476705c4e1ed9deb42057d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical behavior (the liquid in the cup overflows at 7.9s and remains on the cup wall instead of falling naturally).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00449", "filename": "90f4878f75bd0b1dbd02623e353224dce63de42d1138f27a0e4dad8158dab126_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00450", "filename": "91c3c500704262a8c0d895709b16081ab37931c15272ec59b98b42d3658220cd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (bubbles appear out of thin air below the lens between 0.4s and 5.4s without any external force, which is unrealistic. According to the law of conservation of mass, matter cannot be created out of thin air, so bubbles should not appear on their own).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00451", "filename": "92f0c956974d402472e09f20d12fb67946c3c5a9e1fddd906d1fc66069205698_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00453", "filename": "94a18dd9f507249a2fd17f244b7b6ca7da5501f7d2c683cc1e489406ccc9b1fd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The movement of the pedestrian on the right side is noticeably jerky and choppy from 0.7s to 5.3s.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00455", "filename": "95b890a29e63db07c1f4ec4f77fe127918f332ba3f891662f1bff840e4ebf06b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Continuous time (the black ground at the bottom of the entire video flickers rapidly with light without any external force, constantly alternating between light and dark).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00456", "filename": "96bb27947a7e8f09dbe431617db92018e97a0f2f4de4affa994a39aded595a5b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00457", "filename": "96d91664d71d7eec106ae9066c8743aebfd05d9e306277096af6dc5dafc65f26_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: (From 6.4s to 7.1s, when the straw is stirring the water in the glass, the water in the glass remains still. Water is a liquid, and it will deform under force, not remain still.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00458", "filename": "97b75b911fd053ee74804cff00956fa26d0ce43dcdf737d7ad65cfcf311e5008_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (the clock in the video runs normally, but the ice melts rapidly in about 5 seconds. Without external force, the ice should melt slowly, not rapidly.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00459", "filename": "97dae0b769c7c6b7c23f3c6e1512557fede7d5faab3da754ce9845fade6e97c1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the overall image is too smooth, unlike a realistic image).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00461", "filename": "2eac771d6adffa71fd95bf0882324283643136dc459c3cefcb9ae294a24cb528_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (within 0-5.1 seconds, the internal environment of the bubble undergoes random motion without external force, violating Newton's First Law). Overall visual anomalies (the internal motion of the object is too smooth, unlike realistic visuals, lacking the abruptness expected in reality).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00462", "filename": "2eac771d6adffa71fd95bf0882324283643136dc459c3cefcb9ae294a24cb528_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (a white light appears continuously in the lower left corner inside the bubble throughout the video, and the bubble's movement is too smooth, unlike realistic footage, lacking the jerky, realistic feel.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00463", "filename": "2eac771d6adffa71fd95bf0882324283643136dc459c3cefcb9ae294a24cb528_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (deformation occurred on the left side of the bubble at 4.8s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00464", "filename": "2eac771d6adffa71fd95bf0882324283643136dc459c3cefcb9ae294a24cb528_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 7.3s, a double image appears in the lower right corner, giving the impression of two layers of bubbles.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00465", "filename": "2eeae6d1d5dad217beb9f9b2a9b78bed432ae1a6611aaa3c39380c0439a157f6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Continuity of time (Throughout the video, the wind turbine blades are rotating, but the clouds remain unchanged; normally, clouds should move irregularly. Distant blades in the video appear and disappear suddenly.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00466", "filename": "2eeae6d1d5dad217beb9f9b2a9b78bed432ae1a6611aaa3c39380c0439a157f6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is unpredictable (the generator in the distance flickers throughout the video; the wind turbine blades are noticeably twisted during rotation and then suddenly straighten).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00467", "filename": "2eeae6d1d5dad217beb9f9b2a9b78bed432ae1a6611aaa3c39380c0439a157f6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (in the entire video, the first two wind turbines from the left show no signs of blade rotation, but the blades of the wind turbines next to them are rotating).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00468", "filename": "2f2e68ce1ec015db8d30ce7137da874ef0035892bd221c4ff9bf36ee48009ed7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual appearance is abnormal (the movement of the water does not resemble real water flow, but rather the movement of gas, and it lacks the random splashing and natural branching of water droplets that would occur during water flow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00469", "filename": "2f2e68ce1ec015db8d30ce7137da874ef0035892bd221c4ff9bf36ee48009ed7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the water movement in the entire video is too smooth, lacking the fluidity of flowing water and instead appearing as random splashes of water droplets, unlike realistic footage.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00470", "filename": "2f2e68ce1ec015db8d30ce7137da874ef0035892bd221c4ff9bf36ee48009ed7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00471", "filename": "2f41ef673676b1196c893f5a87d0ed0b426e295bad5afc926ff7475aa6235acd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the entire video, even without the camera moving, the leaves on both sides flicker, violating the principle that light travels in straight lines.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00472", "filename": "2f41ef673676b1196c893f5a87d0ed0b426e295bad5afc926ff7475aa6235acd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is distorted: the timing is inconsistent (in the entire video, the trees on the left sway noticeably from side to side, and the raindrops also shift slightly, indicating wind, but the trees on the right remain stationary throughout, creating a strong sense of artificiality and unlike real footage.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00473", "filename": "2f41ef673676b1196c893f5a87d0ed0b426e295bad5afc926ff7475aa6235acd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00477", "filename": "03acbc583c88d2505b6f2f5f29f16064136b6847a894d49d313cbe6476ee5879_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (0-5s, the light bulb slightly wobbles left and right without any external force, violating Newton's First Law). Time continuity (stripes flash on the white box throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00478", "filename": "03acbc583c88d2505b6f2f5f29f16064136b6847a894d49d313cbe6476ee5879_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.7 seconds, the character's hand hadn't even touched the wire, but the wire automatically flew onto the hand.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00483", "filename": "03b11462245004b77be0bad95301e2579b5e1d6ccc378f425a1e01a0034297da_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, flames are present on the blue-green clothing, yet there are no obvious signs of burning on the clothing. The burning clothing remains unchanged from beginning to end, and the fire intensity does not alter.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00484", "filename": "03b11462245004b77be0bad95301e2579b5e1d6ccc378f425a1e01a0034297da_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Physical behavior (Within 0-5.9 seconds, the footage shows burning clothes, but the flames on the clothes gradually decrease without any external interference, and there are no obvious signs of the fire spreading on the burning clothes. Under normal circumstances, the fire should become more and more intense, and the burn marks on the clothes should be obvious.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00485", "filename": "03b11462245004b77be0bad95301e2579b5e1d6ccc378f425a1e01a0034297da_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is discontinuous (the sleeves of the blue-green clothing in the entire video are deformed, gradually shrinking). Overall visual anomalies (the gray clothing in the upper right corner is not burning, yet smoke is continuously billowing from it; normally, smoke should emanate from a fire source).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00486", "filename": "03c1a502d0478e0373e2a23828e27d3bd66bb4933c72af555b0d3df85bdd9ad5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: (Throughout the video, the rice stalks sway from side to side in the wind. Normally, rice stalks should sway with the wind, which does not conform to the normal movement trajectory of rice stalks. Moreover, the overall swaying of the rice stalks is stiff and does not look like a real scene.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00487", "filename": "03c1a502d0478e0373e2a23828e27d3bd66bb4933c72af555b0d3df85bdd9ad5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual presentation is abnormal (the rice ears in the video are too brightly colored and their shapes are too perfect, making it look more like a cartoon than a realistic scene).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00488", "filename": "03c1a502d0478e0373e2a23828e27d3bd66bb4933c72af555b0d3df85bdd9ad5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00489", "filename": "03c1a502d0478e0373e2a23828e27d3bd66bb4933c72af555b0d3df85bdd9ad5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: The shot depicts a zoom-in to zoom-out process, but at 3.1 seconds, when the camera is moving towards the distance, the image is still blurry. In real life, the image should immediately become sharp, making the zoom process appear unrealistic.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00490", "filename": "03fded8c4137cc0d28fb9d4059ca5af9cd376d4fe2e3a5d7ca5597894ccc930d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00491", "filename": "bd8b3ecab5942c69a9c0485ea2b4c80437b72348a981f423a83019ac040acd28_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00492", "filename": "bd8b3ecab5942c69a9c0485ea2b4c80437b72348a981f423a83019ac040acd28_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (in reality, when an object seeps into a liquid, there is a concentration gradient, color gradation, and blurred boundaries, but in the video, from 3.8s to 5s, the boundary between the sphere and the liquid is clear, with no signs of diffusion, dissolution, or mixing, and it looks more like it is stuck to the surface of the liquid rather than seeping in).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00493", "filename": "bd29e02133e09a20b9b5f3d0792958cfb45cbf1d8e085694768b41523f3cff46_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (the water in the cup shakes without any external force throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00494", "filename": "bd29e02133e09a20b9b5f3d0792958cfb45cbf1d8e085694768b41523f3cff46_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (from 1.8s to 4.8s, ripples appear out of nowhere on the surface of the water in the cup, spreading from the center outwards without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00496", "filename": "bd42aafca4a555c1e2fec7b11f788477128417513294d24e7b31f07ea1e9c180_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the upper right corner of the lollipop melts on its own without any heating throughout the video) Physical behavior (sugar liquid continuously melts from the upper right corner of the candy throughout the video, but the sugar liquid does not flow down under the influence of gravity)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00497", "filename": "bd42aafca4a555c1e2fec7b11f788477128417513294d24e7b31f07ea1e9c180_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (in reality, the bubbles produced by melting lollipops are translucent and easily broken sugar bubbles, while the bubbles in the video are bright and opaque, with a hard and granular texture).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00498", "filename": "bd42aafca4a555c1e2fec7b11f788477128417513294d24e7b31f07ea1e9c180_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (in reality, when a lollipop melts, the entire candy softens and flows downwards, but in the video, only localized green foam-like protrusions appear, without any naturally flowing candy).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00503", "filename": "bd109f3279e11edd3e699845dbf53a4eb335f30c4be8d18159575958fc0f7df2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.1s, a hand appears out of nowhere at the handle of the pot lid).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00504", "filename": "bd657e8aedcf269ad6a383bb3871ce74ce20b468d51a99aaab597bdf6f84c31a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the tip of the middle finger disappears out of thin air at 2.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00505", "filename": "bd657e8aedcf269ad6a383bb3871ce74ce20b468d51a99aaab597bdf6f84c31a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the beads on the bracelet seem to increase out of thin air and flow downwards throughout the entire sequence).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00506", "filename": "bd657e8aedcf269ad6a383bb3871ce74ce20b468d51a99aaab597bdf6f84c31a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00507", "filename": "bd657e8aedcf269ad6a383bb3871ce74ce20b468d51a99aaab597bdf6f84c31a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.9 seconds, the circular bracelet suddenly becomes a single strand while the round beads become cylindrical).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00508", "filename": "bdad394ebf52ef78fb8697d4c9862b7a58d0aed37c8068c0df430fc47ed3ed13_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the stone suddenly turns into a squirrel's head at 0.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00509", "filename": "bdad394ebf52ef78fb8697d4c9862b7a58d0aed37c8068c0df430fc47ed3ed13_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the hedgehog's quills twist and deform between 0s and 0.3s) Causality (the lake in the scene suddenly ripples without any external force between 2.7s and 5.6s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00510", "filename": "bdad394ebf52ef78fb8697d4c9862b7a58d0aed37c8068c0df430fc47ed3ed13_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the fur on the animal's back disappears out of thin air at 0.6s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00511", "filename": "bdb499bf071cf2dc4058066721043ef820cb1ca911c6ed36037eadf4e25f6352_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the flame is in a closed environment without wind, but it fluctuates violently between 1.3s and 3.8s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00512", "filename": "bdb499bf071cf2dc4058066721043ef820cb1ca911c6ed36037eadf4e25f6352_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is that the time is continuous (the flame sways slightly from side to side throughout the entire sequence, but the reflection on the edge of the cup does not follow the sway).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00513", "filename": "bdb499bf071cf2dc4058066721043ef820cb1ca911c6ed36037eadf4e25f6352_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the brightness of the reflective areas on the left and right sides of the candle holder is too bright, exceeding the brightness of the light source; the brightness of the reflective areas should be dimmer than the light source).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00514", "filename": "bddf321be0843c4ee7fc76c672b4423ea07db7e91b43101d6f9431979273d079_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the size and clarity of the reflection are exactly the same as the real scene, without the natural attenuation of the near-large and far-small edges caused by slight ripples in the distance from the lake surface, like a directly copied and pasted color block, rather than a real light reflection).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00515", "filename": "bddf321be0843c4ee7fc76c672b4423ea07db7e91b43101d6f9431979273d079_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the white, bluish-gray reflection of the snow-capped mountain blends sharply with the blue of the lake water, creating a sharp, unbridgeable line. In reality, water reflection and scattering would allow the reflection and the lake water to blend naturally, without such an absolute boundary).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00516", "filename": "bddf321be0843c4ee7fc76c672b4423ea07db7e91b43101d6f9431979273d079_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (in reality, even when the water is calm, there will be subtle ripples and reflections on the surface of a lake, but in the video, the lake surface looks like a flat blue plastic board, without any texture or changes in light and shadow, completely losing the fluidity and texture of water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00517", "filename": "bded6d1c50d39a87da6c73628c4f52308793c36ed68b7aa54b577f22dadc7ddd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the light spots through the gaps in the leaves are too uniform in size and shape. In reality, the density and spacing of the leaves would naturally cause the size and brightness of the light spots to vary. At the same time, the dark areas of the leaves are completely black and lack depth, and there is a lack of transparency as sunlight penetrates through them).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00518", "filename": "bded6d1c50d39a87da6c73628c4f52308793c36ed68b7aa54b577f22dadc7ddd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the boundary between the bright areas (sunlight-drenched areas) and the dark areas (shadow areas) of the grass is too sharp, without the gradual transition brought by the undulation of the grass in reality, as if it is divided by color blocks and lacks the natural blending of light and shadow).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00519", "filename": "bded6d1c50d39a87da6c73628c4f52308793c36ed68b7aa54b577f22dadc7ddd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00520", "filename": "be23faf80750bf5f3a2812fbb4d33fd7506678858efb2d291a9195b8ad3fce92_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the blue waterproof tarpaulin (made of plastic) was not ignited, but the flame was close to the edge of the tarpaulin. In reality, plastic will melt and burn quickly when exposed to an open flame, producing black smoke. In the video, the tarpaulin is intact).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00521", "filename": "3515b575c0e3502e86936d287051aab9ba375fb01441b3575a30345ded501515_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (between 0.9s and 1s in the video, the person is not holding the object in their hand, and the object is still suspended in the air, which violates the principle of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00522", "filename": "3515b575c0e3502e86936d287051aab9ba375fb01441b3575a30345ded501515_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 0.3s in the video, a black object in the frame suddenly transforms into a white film and a long iron rod without the camera changing direction) Physical behavior (at 2.8s, the long iron rod in the person's hand directly penetrates the black object, violating the principle that solids are impermeable)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00523", "filename": "3515b575c0e3502e86936d287051aab9ba375fb01441b3575a30345ded501515_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (in the video from 1.6s to 3.1s, the metal cube directly penetrates the black object, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00524", "filename": "3515b575c0e3502e86936d287051aab9ba375fb01441b3575a30345ded501515_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (a screwdriver is used to turn a black colloid in the image, but the notch made is too regular and does not match the screwdriver head).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00525", "filename": "3576f0390fbbb9960c32374c4a0c77e5f3faced45110cd0e4b3ffb6faa109de7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (from 0.7s to 4.6s in the video, the crystal does not soften, crack, or deform under flame, which violates the principle of thermal expansion and thermal deformation of solid materials).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00526", "filename": "3576f0390fbbb9960c32374c4a0c77e5f3faced45110cd0e4b3ffb6faa109de7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (the crystals in the video melt too quickly and begin to solidify while still being heated by a high-temperature spray gun, which is inconsistent with the characteristics of crystals).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00527", "filename": "3576f0390fbbb9960c32374c4a0c77e5f3faced45110cd0e4b3ffb6faa109de7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (During the video from 1.6s to 7.7s, the crystal on the left melts into liquid without coming into contact with the flame)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00528", "filename": "3607c7e5fb6fa8a41b30e2e2907710cb1535f34d7da59bae8eebbf46fda66965_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the surface of the lake is too calm and smooth throughout the video, without any ripples, lacking a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00529", "filename": "3607c7e5fb6fa8a41b30e2e2907710cb1535f34d7da59bae8eebbf46fda66965_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (in the entire video, while there are only a few ripples on the right side of the lake in the same space, the left side of the lake remains completely still, the surface is too calm and smooth, and lacks a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00530", "filename": "3607c7e5fb6fa8a41b30e2e2907710cb1535f34d7da59bae8eebbf46fda66965_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (throughout the video, the water flow on the lake and the sea remains still without any change, too smooth, lacking the chaotic feeling of natural flow on the lake surface).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00531", "filename": "3607c7e5fb6fa8a41b30e2e2907710cb1535f34d7da59bae8eebbf46fda66965_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual inconsistency (Throughout the video, the water flow on the lake and sea remains completely still, without any change; it's too smooth and lacks the natural flow and movement of a lake).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00536", "filename": "3761a9c419398c394f379d4017ea76901f7af2ed6e067ae091217ab1b5b2ced7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (within 0.5 seconds of the video, without any change in camera angle, a surfer suddenly appears on the sea surface).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00538", "filename": "3761a9c419398c394f379d4017ea76901f7af2ed6e067ae091217ab1b5b2ced7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (at 4.6s in the video, two people on the right side of the sea suddenly change from swimming to surfing without the camera changing position).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00539", "filename": "3761a9c419398c394f379d4017ea76901f7af2ed6e067ae091217ab1b5b2ced7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (normal ocean waves are continuous and coherent, but the waves in the image appear \"broken,\" with obvious blank areas between the two wave crests, lacking a sense of continuous layering of the sea surface).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00540", "filename": "03813efcf2ad1dc620b51329f5b4a447799485231bd83c8b81c518ef22b4f0b9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00541", "filename": "03813efcf2ad1dc620b51329f5b4a447799485231bd83c8b81c518ef22b4f0b9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormality in the footage: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the sunlight is constantly moving and changing, indicating that time is passing, but the potted plant in the footage remains stationary without any shaking).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00542", "filename": "03813efcf2ad1dc620b51329f5b4a447799485231bd83c8b81c518ef22b4f0b9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the shape of the branches and leaves of the plants in the picture does not correspond to the outline of the shadows on the ground, and the shape of some shadows does not have a clear projection source, which violates the logic of light and shadow projection).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00549", "filename": "4130e3ece89a1baf20bf57dc89994bc52ee985e9b1bb00500434886112960963_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.1s in the video, the pants on the right leg of the person disappear out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00551", "filename": "8c671d87fcb236166daaba0f4aac695e86b1f86ec5459f6e0576606b9effefde_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (light spots appear on the sea surface that do not match the ambient light of the sunset scene. These light spots have no reasonable basis for light source reflection and are not a natural reflection effect of the sea surface. Core image elements such as the boundary between the beach and the sea and the outline of distant islands do not maintain a stable visual form in the dynamic connection of the image. The edge lines do not have a continuous dynamic continuity, presenting a stiff splicing feeling.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00552", "filename": "8c671d87fcb236166daaba0f4aac695e86b1f86ec5459f6e0576606b9effefde_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time is not continuous (the rise and fall of the sea and the undulation of the waves do not follow the natural fluid motion laws. The shape, height and position of the waves lack a smooth and gradual transition. There are jumps without physical basis. The overall movement appears choppy and mechanical, rather than the continuous dynamics that real seawater should have).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00553", "filename": "8c8622dc4198717ea188a0be1d87d472a51b98b9a9fcdaf06e7c8588f0d4222f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (1.1s-4.4s, the character presses the yellow button, the middle part of the yellow light strip turns blue, but the timing is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00554", "filename": "8c8622dc4198717ea188a0be1d87d472a51b98b9a9fcdaf06e7c8588f0d4222f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Continuous time (without operation triggering the light strip or controller command association, there is an instantaneous change in brightness and color, without the gradual transition process of a real light source, and the cause-and-effect sequence of brightness and color changes is completely disconnected from the hand pressing action)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00555", "filename": "8c8622dc4198717ea188a0be1d87d472a51b98b9a9fcdaf06e7c8588f0d4222f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1s, the character did not press the switch, and the light strip automatically emitted light and changed color; at 5.9s, with the same light brightness, the size of the light spot on the ground became smaller).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00557", "filename": "8ce7f0248f48a3ab61f46ce49e61f05a047d098761f728603e9a90e37f0d07b9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the small bubble on the left suddenly disappears at 1.6s, the large bubble continuously shrinks in size from 1.8s to 5s without being damaged, and the irregularly moving bubble becomes round and stops at 3.7s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00558", "filename": "8ce7f0248f48a3ab61f46ce49e61f05a047d098761f728603e9a90e37f0d07b9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the small bubble on the left side of the video gradually gets bigger throughout the entire video, and between 2.7s and 5.6s, the irregularly moving bubble in the air gradually turns into a small pool of water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00559", "filename": "8ce7f0248f48a3ab61f46ce49e61f05a047d098761f728603e9a90e37f0d07b9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (0.7s-3.2s: the bubble suddenly changes from an irregular shape to a round shape; 4.3s-7.4s: the bubble bursts and turns into liquid).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00567", "filename": "8d5801a15e62d1242ccc8685e5f2b2423dc6bdba83bfa71d1b1df28b77f94e05_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00568", "filename": "8d5801a15e62d1242ccc8685e5f2b2423dc6bdba83bfa71d1b1df28b77f94e05_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (from 2.7s to 5.8s, a large amount of smoke suddenly appears out of nowhere from the metal box in the center of the screen; there is wind blowing the smoke throughout the segment, but the burning debris is not blown into the air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00569", "filename": "8d5801a15e62d1242ccc8685e5f2b2423dc6bdba83bfa71d1b1df28b77f94e05_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00570", "filename": "8d5801a15e62d1242ccc8685e5f2b2423dc6bdba83bfa71d1b1df28b77f94e05_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is unusual: the time sequence is continuous (in reality, when garbage burns, it continuously consumes and collapses, deforming and turning combustible materials into ash, and the flame volume keeps shrinking; but in the video, the flame actually gets bigger between 0.7s and 8s, and there is almost no obvious loss of combustible material in the core combustion zone).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00571", "filename": "8daa6f222e0af0e5528596833d4b2581ecd112607942bd4b2f2025e55cb92748_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00572", "filename": "8daa6f222e0af0e5528596833d4b2581ecd112607942bd4b2f2025e55cb92748_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the wind blows objects on the ship throughout the segment, while the ship itself remains stationary without swaying); Time continuity (the number of clouds in the sky increases out of nowhere between 0.2s and 5.8s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00573", "filename": "8daa6f222e0af0e5528596833d4b2581ecd112607942bd4b2f2025e55cb92748_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00574", "filename": "8dbcc6fb88bec69d003e79cdc77dc9cb7d420aa64151950c67582b9cd4094549_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The screen is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1s, the timer suddenly changes from 8 seconds to 6 seconds and the number to the right of the 6 is jumping irregularly; at 0.1s, the coin suddenly turns into a ball).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00575", "filename": "8dbcc6fb88bec69d003e79cdc77dc9cb7d420aa64151950c67582b9cd4094549_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the timer jumps erratically; at 2.3s, the 8 in the timer changes to 6, and at 5.1s, the 6 changes to 1). Physical behavior (the coin's rotation speed does not decrease as the duration of rotation increases throughout the segment).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00576", "filename": "8dbcc6fb88bec69d003e79cdc77dc9cb7d420aa64151950c67582b9cd4094549_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 1.5s, the coin suddenly turns into a spinning top and spins in mid-air; from 1.2s to 5s, the timer numbers change irregularly and appear distorted).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00577", "filename": "8dbcc6fb88bec69d003e79cdc77dc9cb7d420aa64151950c67582b9cd4094549_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.2s, the coin suddenly turns into a steel ball and spins in mid-air on the mirror; the timer jumps are not regular but jump without transition, with 8 seconds suddenly becoming 10 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00578", "filename": "8e2d766544f173c699787d1877881e5bd5115deed2ac49f8433b047877a6d1e2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 0.1s, the basketball has already flown towards the backboard, but the shadow is delayed and does not immediately follow; the shadow only moves at 0.4s; at 4.1s, the basketball penetrates the fence, violating the principle that solids are impermeable). Time continuity (at 0.7s, the basketball suddenly shrinks as it approaches the backboard; at 1.6s, the basketball suddenly twists and deforms; at 4.4s, the basketball disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00579", "filename": "8e2d766544f173c699787d1877881e5bd5115deed2ac49f8433b047877a6d1e2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 0.2s, the basketball flies from right to left and bounces forward after hitting the ground; in reality, due to inertia, it should bounce to the left; at 1.3s, the impact force between the basketball and the ground is insufficient for the basketball to bounce onto the backboard; at 3.7s, the basketball penetrates the rim, violating the principle that solids are impermeable). Time continuity (at 2.4s, the basketball appears to teleport).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00580", "filename": "8e2d766544f173c699787d1877881e5bd5115deed2ac49f8433b047877a6d1e2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 1.7s, the impact force between the basketball and the ground is insufficient to make the basketball bounce onto the backboard; at 2.5s, the basketball penetrates the rim, violating the principle that solids are impermeable; between 2.5s and 3.1s, the shadow of the basketball does not match the trajectory of the basketball).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00581", "filename": "54d2d1975d266a9da9432af7ae8a81708a9b3faac7e75220375b46402fc73348_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the clouds in the image do not exhibit any dynamic movement or stretching with the airflow; they remain static throughout).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00582", "filename": "055c1477161ef647fd42c5a70da6d6f9e69a0314107da89a4feddb2ca9267830_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the smoke billowing from the chimney in the image does not exhibit the diffusion and dispersion pattern that natural smoke should have; it remains in a concentrated state without any dispersing effect).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00583", "filename": "056b84357411f94d92532133a3b07d8a885e46d85ec455d2ec3c9b7daedb41cc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00584", "filename": "56a0f2963f70c949e3ced1a1755e8ad65f7b5a4c2e4bb4f30a8b303c6b738571_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (Under the premise of no external interference, the car suddenly levitates in the air at 5.7s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00586", "filename": "56dde3db70d6f10c8899efde3bb231da9f9328afecc9d5b01c7d35eaa04d1ab8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the ripples, light and shadow on the water surface do not change at all when the camera moves, and remain in a fixed state, completely out of sync with the dynamic perspective of the camera).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00587", "filename": "57afa1e67071c41adc9dca4f762d41dee0a8b09b3eb906ba8a64979c774bde3d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (Under the condition of no external force interference, at 3.2s, the chicken leg suddenly dents)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00588", "filename": "57d7fd5406b87e3c9ac775afbc035f9171f0a376815d2ebebbd689981664298c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera transition, a rope suddenly appears out of nowhere on the left side of the window at 3.2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00589", "filename": "57dffd2b72c28013c2abdbf44f6222cddf101439a0a96a398b0a9e9ef64f8774_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (Under the condition of no external force or interference, at 4.7 seconds, the ball in the character's hand rotates on its own).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00590", "filename": "57e540581b04a66e7a9db5e4188599d23dc724a2e9d59506930f51e3a8d40ac1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without changing camera angles, at 6.1 seconds, the clouds at the top of the screen disappear out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00591", "filename": "58f2522c892b5f6aef44e1d9fcd482943ca4bae2d9e251309919f3caadf3a3b0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00592", "filename": "59b1243dae22faa4ab9ca633c18839c3905a8eef717b74bd20ffa7b5df750ec7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00593", "filename": "59e94a5a37f6342492e9e04033d6178fa46f84e2dadb24dd4d0f15d4cae6d901_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the crystals in the image suddenly turn yellow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00594", "filename": "59fb0763f22e2390650017d65c6a39d79aeee9799abaa1541d41d7207a0f1375_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (Under the premise of no external force or object changing the lens, at 1.21, the rubber band instantly moved from the index finger to the middle finger)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00595", "filename": "59fd4d72916676819755f099e0b712e9e8d904efe100591762ea89edb10cc0af_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00596", "filename": "61bda3afbf9eeae5aa47c00c3e73a8700e6692f984b93012bb44245686420ea2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00597", "filename": "61ea7174f87e9338254bc73673acbdba416745182c4a7a208420c9caf73988c8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00598", "filename": "62b7511b94ed7d42f614df329988e2de28e35c9258d052750efc10d25578b72b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 1.1 seconds, a piece of the cup in the frame flies out to the right out of nowhere, even though the cup itself is not broken).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00600", "filename": "64aa70b3c4a57fd3b784900f8e5b49f0969508037b7c661f4740b6c033c7504f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time sequence is continuous (the wax dripping from the burning candle appears as regular teardrop and petal shapes, with rigid edges and no natural melting or deformation process).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00601", "filename": "64f00f210f3332f13acc5ff989619e8afd559f4d8ee429accc35be42bfaa0b5b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (Under the premise of no camera change, no external force or interference, the white object suddenly dents at 3.1s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00602", "filename": "65b5395df576889ba103ee96b99fc436cfa679f49f37a13b653ddde073aa94f1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera transition, at 2.3s, a black dot appears out of nowhere in the upper left corner of the toy tank in the frame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00603", "filename": "65b471917e4e9ac6883ecbe9b1eb489dcc153a7a1e403a67ef43c0edcdceddcf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (Under the condition of no external interference, at 3.2s, the fur on the cat's back suddenly dents).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00604", "filename": "65e8ee1d1aaf8e72996116a167a3a21d622f95ed5ac883641eb31581e3328cff_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (Under the premise of no external force interference, at 1.4s, the vertical pole in the lower left corner of the screen suddenly bends)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00605", "filename": "65e467721f7efeea3d16b5ee520c1a43edf453b586617679bcd24c7a7194eb90_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (under the premise of no external force or interference, the black gelatinous substance in the image suddenly twists to the left at 2s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00606", "filename": "66b966676eadef26e2e34c0fa18cad72eea07d81e61368d20da9410bc68ce33d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the boiling bubbles in the image gradually gather from the outside of the pot towards the inside, without the natural dispersal and rising of boiling water, and their size does not change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00607", "filename": "66decd8a9313d3ac42157ee5316244ee970ba30fbdedac29787c95d0b737682e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00608", "filename": "067dcb5ca0592448fb99d6ce27fa251dd2fd1634a30197e0ef52b737e144c7c1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without camera changes or external interference, at 2.2s, the weeds on the lake surface suddenly twist).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00609", "filename": "67b63e24231362ac93c11e36f99cd1703c4fc5f5c3d6187b5032c056d1017218_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the white gas in the image does not dissipate due to air resistance, but instead moves rapidly out of the image from the right side in a strip-like shape).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00610", "filename": "67da22b25d8ab461d693dae68b5ac1094af1fbebb49b155275e1956d93b92d8d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (Without any camera movement, at 6.2s, the bubble in the upper left corner of the screen disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00611", "filename": "P27_104_255_93554b15de52d053_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (at 0.8s, the person's hand has not yet touched the faucet switch, but the faucet is automatically dispensing water) (at 5.3s, a large amount of water is flowing out of the rag, but the rag is not under the faucet, and the faucet's water outlet position is misaligned with the rag)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00612", "filename": "P27_104_264_17d5179dd11864df_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (from 4s to 4.5s, after the rag is thrown, its flight trajectory is too straight and its speed is unnaturally fast, which does not conform to the parabolic trajectory of a real throw). Time continuity (at 4.5s, there is no water in the sink, but the rag creates a lot of water splashes after being thrown in).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00613", "filename": "P27_104_264_17d5179dd11864df_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00615", "filename": "P27_104_327_7e9e2c24d04d6f71_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.2s, the horizontal cookie suddenly becomes vertical) (at 1.5s, the cookie at the bottom of the packaging bag suddenly changes from a flat position to a vertical position, with no transition process in between).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00616", "filename": "P27_104_327_7e9e2c24d04d6f71_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is inconsistent (the completely sealed packaging bag opens automatically at 3.1s, but the process of opening the packaging bag is missing). (From 3.8s onwards, the person's fingers do not pick up the cookie, but the cookie automatically adheres to the surface of the fingers).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00617", "filename": "P27_104_327_7e9e2c24d04d6f71_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00618", "filename": "P27_104_341_e1b2ac08f492cc31_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 2.8s there are no items on the table and the person's hands are empty, but when the hand is lifted off the table, a black object appears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00619", "filename": "P27_104_341_e1b2ac08f492cc31_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.5s, a black lid suddenly appears out of thin air in the person's hand; initially, the person's hand is empty).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00620", "filename": "P27_105_137_e1c5d7cd66bf3e68_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 1.4s, the person's finger did not touch the top of the paper, but the top of the paper automatically folded upwards).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00621", "filename": "P27_105_166_30520b4daf415752_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The timing is continuous (at 3.2 seconds, the person's hand has already been withdrawn and the bread has been placed steadily, but the bread suddenly slides into the refrigerator on its own).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00622", "filename": "P27_105_166_30520b4daf415752_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (7.6s - end) The person's hand was still at the refrigerator opening and was retracting it. The hand did not touch the refrigerator door, but the refrigerator door closed automatically without any force applied, which does not conform to the law of interaction of forces.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00623", "filename": "P27_105_252_46bd01be7aea9884_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.9s, the lower half of the paper disappears out of thin air, and the paper becomes shorter).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00624", "filename": "P27_105_252_46bd01be7aea9884_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00625", "filename": "P27_105_261_c00c8e4c3eb2e9ff_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The timing is continuous (at 4.2s, the person's fingers have not yet been able to pinch the foil, but the foil automatically retracts).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00626", "filename": "P27_105_261_c00c8e4c3eb2e9ff_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00627", "filename": "P28_101_40_9c6cc02b62d8070d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The timing is continuous (a banana that has been peeled at 2.3 seconds is placed in the frame, and suddenly the banana peel becomes whole again).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00628", "filename": "P28_101_40_9c6cc02b62d8070d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (a banana that was eaten at 2.7 seconds, only the banana peel was left in the trash can, and a banana suddenly appeared out of nowhere in the middle of the banana peel).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00629", "filename": "P28_101_42_f4752545319fa43c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (after making a cut at 1s, the cut garlic suddenly turns into two pieces out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00630", "filename": "P28_101_42_f4752545319fa43c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 4.7 seconds, the garlic sticking to the knife disappears into thin air without being wiped by hand).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00631", "filename": "P28_101_55_0052e13ebb68822b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the scissors in the entire video go straight through the plastic bag and cut through the opening, but the bag remains intact).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00632", "filename": "P28_101_55_0052e13ebb68822b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00633", "filename": "P28_101_55_0052e13ebb68822b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.5s, the scissors that were originally in the left hand suddenly pass through the packaging bag and suddenly appear in the right hand holding the packaging bag).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00634", "filename": "P28_101_68_bc18ec4cb24fbd62_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time sequence (at 2.3s, the intact packaging bag is automatically opened when a hand is put into it) (at 3.8s, a hand takes out a white sphere larger than the packaging bag from the deflated packaging bag)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00635", "filename": "P28_101_68_bc18ec4cb24fbd62_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.6 seconds, a white sphere is taken out of the packaging bag, but the packaging bag is still intact and not open).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00636", "filename": "P28_101_71_2ca39f2ce03a381c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (at 6.9 seconds, a corner suddenly appears on the left side of the packaging bag).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00637", "filename": "P28_103_110_63826acbd81990eb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the potato chunk that was cut off at 1.9s disappears into thin air) (at 3.2s, only one cut was made, but the cut potato turned into two pieces).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00638", "filename": "P28_103_110_63826acbd81990eb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.2s, the potato chunk in the hand suddenly becomes a whole potato) (at 5.4s, the potato that has already been cut appears out of thin air on the cutting board).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00639", "filename": "P28_103_121_eb31a2ca76fc3847_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the number of diced onions on the cutting board suddenly increases at 2.2 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00640", "filename": "P28_103_121_eb31a2ca76fc3847_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the diced onions on the cutting board disappear into thin air at 2.7 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00641", "filename": "405b1ae2a3cb79203a0e61d66593a104f76d2c335f2f99514d887e99c2ede9d9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00642", "filename": "405b1ae2a3cb79203a0e61d66593a104f76d2c335f2f99514d887e99c2ede9d9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time sequence is not continuous (the smoke produced by the burning stick does not conform to the laws of natural physics. Normally, the smoke from a burning stick should be thin, straight, and naturally drifting upwards in wisps. However, the smoke in the image is thick and ribbon-like, without any dynamic changes in natural drifting. It only shows a static state of vertical upward movement, which contradicts the fluid diffusion characteristics of smoke in reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00643", "filename": "405cbc110c7375d2d54473a14c54ea6e0991d465559ab3103c5194ce92a277b9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (real sunlight is blocked or penetrated by clouds, but the sun and clouds in the image appear to be layered and superimposed, lacking realistic light and shadow interaction.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00644", "filename": "405cbc110c7375d2d54473a14c54ea6e0991d465559ab3103c5194ce92a277b9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (Sunlight shines on moving clouds. As the clouds move and dissipate, the sunlight should pass through them.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00645", "filename": "405cbc110c7375d2d54473a14c54ea6e0991d465559ab3103c5194ce92a277b9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00646", "filename": "405cbc110c7375d2d54473a14c54ea6e0991d465559ab3103c5194ce92a277b9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timeline is too smooth (the movement of clouds is too fluid, unlike real clouds, lacking the feeling of clouds drifting freely in the wind).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00647", "filename": "416d3bddb1bb5691982e3f81bf396404c45366073bcc5ad1f3648b1ed8e35655_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0.4s-4.4s) - An ice cube appears out of nowhere in the center of the red liquid in the cup.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00648", "filename": "416d3bddb1bb5691982e3f81bf396404c45366073bcc5ad1f3648b1ed8e35655_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: A continuous sequence of events (0.7s-1.9s) shows bubbles forming and exploding out of thin air on the surface of red liquid.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00649", "filename": "416d3bddb1bb5691982e3f81bf396404c45366073bcc5ad1f3648b1ed8e35655_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00650", "filename": "416d3bddb1bb5691982e3f81bf396404c45366073bcc5ad1f3648b1ed8e35655_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00651", "filename": "420e0da9121f52b19dbb8c36f90731d79b5a6bb543ccd079563770faa2973cc5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00652", "filename": "420e0da9121f52b19dbb8c36f90731d79b5a6bb543ccd079563770faa2973cc5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (1.8s-4.6s, white smoke turns into white liquid without external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00653", "filename": "420e0da9121f52b19dbb8c36f90731d79b5a6bb543ccd079563770faa2973cc5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the smoke in the video suddenly disappears completely, instead of dissipating slowly).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00654", "filename": "428b207557905b67828527a67b60c713a2fc61e07d3da4e56f854ff93629430a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00655", "filename": "428b207557905b67828527a67b60c713a2fc61e07d3da4e56f854ff93629430a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (5s, white liquid suddenly turns blue).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00656", "filename": "428b207557905b67828527a67b60c713a2fc61e07d3da4e56f854ff93629430a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00657", "filename": "435dda98f245f62beecbfc8f364af736632c11800bc68edfd65f27c678486bed_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (4.9s, a ghostly shark toy appears out of nowhere behind the wheel.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00658", "filename": "435dda98f245f62beecbfc8f364af736632c11800bc68edfd65f27c678486bed_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The ground suddenly appears to be abnormally distorted from 1.4s to 4.2s.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00659", "filename": "435dda98f245f62beecbfc8f364af736632c11800bc68edfd65f27c678486bed_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (the toy shark in the video suddenly turns around without any external force and then starts swimming on the ground.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00660", "filename": "0438ca53923b320022518f57ed8967af593442714da558d3a840431e06b8e37c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the mango in the video appears as a flickering, wriggling element).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00661", "filename": "0438ca53923b320022518f57ed8967af593442714da558d3a840431e06b8e37c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (When the mango is squeezed forcefully by a finger, the surface of the mango does not dent, and instead springs back to its original shape like rubber after being squeezed.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00662", "filename": "0438ca53923b320022518f57ed8967af593442714da558d3a840431e06b8e37c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00669", "filename": "448b93d96c9b71a09456347ca8c124f751557968201c4af834a0928136f90ccc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The light on the surface of the metal sheet flickers continuously for 4.5 seconds.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00670", "filename": "448b93d96c9b71a09456347ca8c124f751557968201c4af834a0928136f90ccc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00671", "filename": "ad09f218d8bbc4ea2541852cc512ad5c9a1980bfc082a1af06966449cb7d73f4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 2.5s, the ice block changes abruptly from a cylindrical shape with a rounded transition to a sharp-edged, clearly defined cuboid shape without any external cutting force; the abrupt change is very unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00672", "filename": "ad09f218d8bbc4ea2541852cc512ad5c9a1980bfc082a1af06966449cb7d73f4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (during the period from 3.6s to the end, the lower half of the rotating ice block gradually thickens, and its overall volume increases instead of shrinking).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00673", "filename": "ad09f218d8bbc4ea2541852cc512ad5c9a1980bfc082a1af06966449cb7d73f4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Abnormal physical behavior (the rectangular ice block shakes erratically throughout the video without being subjected to external force or melting).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00674", "filename": "ad47ddd51e028c75a61b30299c587a30b7d8f8fe8070e0809aa2d8ac20adce02_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (0.6s: calm water surface, without any object falling in or external interference, suddenly develops ripples spreading outwards).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00675", "filename": "ad47ddd51e028c75a61b30299c587a30b7d8f8fe8070e0809aa2d8ac20adce02_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (1.4 seconds after the water droplet falls into the water, the transparent gel-like substance that was originally on the water surface disappears immediately. There is no process of dissolving and sinking or spreading with the water ripples).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00676", "filename": "ad49d048142ed1937cdf64bfa8fbb01566c87bcba44b68d82ef9317c14c3db91_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (at 0.9s, after the strawberry fell into the glass that was originally full of liquid, the overflowing liquid did not flow out of the glass, but instead flowed back into the glass).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00677", "filename": "ad49d048142ed1937cdf64bfa8fbb01566c87bcba44b68d82ef9317c14c3db91_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (1.4s, a strawberry falls into the liquid without splashing any droplets, but immediately produces a large amount of concentrated foam on the surface of the liquid).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00678", "filename": "ad901a941db57025c64a415618dc2084884e67a372c6c938006b7bdf2640eda7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (the wood in the image is not completely burned, but the burning process only shows flames without smoke).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00679", "filename": "ad901a941db57025c64a415618dc2084884e67a372c6c938006b7bdf2640eda7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the flames are disconnected from the surface of the firewood, appearing to float above it, and the flames are shaped like tongue-like ribbons, which looks very unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00680", "filename": "ad901a941db57025c64a415618dc2084884e67a372c6c938006b7bdf2640eda7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity error (1.4s: the black area of charcoal on the right side of the screen suddenly brightens without a gradual transition).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00681", "filename": "ad6750f18cc81d5a3f3291b5e1b24cdd20adcbe513a371c4f51a5bddd1229cf4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (Throughout the video, the clouds above are constantly moving, and the trees below appear to be swaying in the wind, but the red plants in the foreground remain completely still, without any movement in the wind, which is inconsistent with the overall windy environment).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00682", "filename": "ad6750f18cc81d5a3f3291b5e1b24cdd20adcbe513a371c4f51a5bddd1229cf4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 5.3s, a large area of clouds obscuring the mountaintop suddenly disappears without any gradual dissipation process).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00683", "filename": "ad6750f18cc81d5a3f3291b5e1b24cdd20adcbe513a371c4f51a5bddd1229cf4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the clouds in the upper right corner of the video do not have a clear, atmospheric boundary with the green trees below, and the color and texture of the clouds seem to dye the green trees below white).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00684", "filename": "adb0ff37015a1d833cf4cfed8b136569eeb38bf5c451d5b0239af7ced0a139f0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (the ice block in the image, which is stationary in the water, frequently exhibits the phenomenon of floating up and down and rotating on its own).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00685", "filename": "adb0ff37015a1d833cf4cfed8b136569eeb38bf5c451d5b0239af7ced0a139f0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (the ice is continuously melting throughout the video, but the water level in the blue basin is decreasing instead of increasing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00686", "filename": "adb0ff37015a1d833cf4cfed8b136569eeb38bf5c451d5b0239af7ced0a139f0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00687", "filename": "adb0ff37015a1d833cf4cfed8b136569eeb38bf5c451d5b0239af7ced0a139f0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (the ice cubes placed in the basin in 1.3 seconds instantly merge with the ice cubes already in the basin).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00693", "filename": "adb9da3394e4462c53bb344455057eb7b2ca3e97308ffa0d4400bf2b925ccf0e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: there is an anomaly in the continuity of time (after the explosion at 4.7 seconds, the building did not show any structural damage, wall collapse, or debris flying; its appearance was almost identical to that before the explosion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00694", "filename": "adb9da3394e4462c53bb344455057eb7b2ca3e97308ffa0d4400bf2b925ccf0e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (at 3.7s, after the building explodes, it does not scatter debris in all directions, but instead collapses vertically from top to bottom, making it look more like it is being demolished than the effect of an explosion).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00695", "filename": "adc75f86f98c987fac0e8dd06f93de3583fa187ed91f6362639cde658a4d0521_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00696", "filename": "adc75f86f98c987fac0e8dd06f93de3583fa187ed91f6362639cde658a4d0521_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (3.5s, at this time the smoke in the picture suddenly becomes thicker, the food in the pot does not suddenly burn, and there is no sign of a sudden increase in oil temperature)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00697", "filename": "adc75f86f98c987fac0e8dd06f93de3583fa187ed91f6362639cde658a4d0521_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00698", "filename": "adc75f86f98c987fac0e8dd06f93de3583fa187ed91f6362639cde658a4d0521_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Abnormal physical behavior (at 6.5s, when the camera pans to the area where kimchi is being fried, a large amount of thick smoke is produced in the pan, even more than when the meat was being fried earlier).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00699", "filename": "adca059a4e8a43bb3aaf352a8cbbd03e6f8d6149178ee615c37daf549132bd39_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 1.7s, a large amount of white foamy substance suddenly appears on the surface of the ice cream, then returns to normal).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00700", "filename": "adca059a4e8a43bb3aaf352a8cbbd03e6f8d6149178ee615c37daf549132bd39_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Abnormal physical behavior (the ice cream did not shrink naturally in volume before and after melting throughout the video, and instead of producing the viscous liquid that real ice cream should have when melting, it generated a lot of foam).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00701", "filename": "6ef8dae2ea3f0e8a59976880012059366620a64f26f0fbfbc048ee0e48e42835_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The duration is continuous (the grass that appears in the screen from 0.6s to 3.6s is constantly flashing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00702", "filename": "6ef8dae2ea3f0e8a59976880012059366620a64f26f0fbfbc048ee0e48e42835_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (A distinct blue beam of light appears on the top of the rock in the image, but the surrounding environment and lighting indicate that it is midday. The Tyndall effect is unlikely to occur at midday, violating the laws of light scattering and the fact that light travels in straight lines.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00703", "filename": "6ef8dae2ea3f0e8a59976880012059366620a64f26f0fbfbc048ee0e48e42835_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (a fixed beam of light in the image moves synchronously with the camera, and this is not a lens issue; light propagation cannot be constant, violating the laws of light scattering and the fact that light travels in straight lines).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00704", "filename": "6f1fa2103113d9ee7e573a80366eea26effaaf5d8669ef020c9b98e25d660f11_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00705", "filename": "6f1fa2103113d9ee7e573a80366eea26effaaf5d8669ef020c9b98e25d660f11_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00706", "filename": "6f1fa2103113d9ee7e573a80366eea26effaaf5d8669ef020c9b98e25d660f11_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (the ice block in the video suddenly grows larger at 3.6 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00707", "filename": "6f27ec24220afb2c322ae75194a6ae4bb83f5a71fa1cda117fcb09b177c3af7b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00708", "filename": "6f27ec24220afb2c322ae75194a6ae4bb83f5a71fa1cda117fcb09b177c3af7b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the duration is 0.1 seconds (the image suddenly changes from yellow to bright blue, and the ray in the water also becomes plastic-like and lifeless at the same moment).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00709", "filename": "6f27ec24220afb2c322ae75194a6ae4bb83f5a71fa1cda117fcb09b177c3af7b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00710", "filename": "6f99e46e737009e58ef01c51108ba97e27625509e2d7ba247e86f6851ae342f1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the ripples on the water surface in the image are not generated by wind, but rather appear to be boiling, violating the laws of liquid flow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00711", "filename": "6f99e46e737009e58ef01c51108ba97e27625509e2d7ba247e86f6851ae342f1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the sun is also setting while people are moving in the scene, but the speed at which the sun sets is too fast, violating the laws of physics).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00712", "filename": "6f99e46e737009e58ef01c51108ba97e27625509e2d7ba247e86f6851ae342f1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (the brightness and color of the sun in the image lack natural gradation or transition, resembling a static orange background texture, violating the laws of light radiation and atmospheric scattering.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00713", "filename": "6f99e46e737009e58ef01c51108ba97e27625509e2d7ba247e86f6851ae342f1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00718", "filename": "6f97832596795382eb9396160bb261624a6f26bdefe8fb42db113a61aade85e0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: Physical Behavior: The reflection inside the crystal ball is not aligned with the actual scene. Normally, a crystal ball, acting as a convex lens, projects objects directly in front of it vertically. However, in this image, the reflection shows the sky and sun, completely contradicting the actual beach and wave scene it is facing.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00719", "filename": "6f97832596795382eb9396160bb261624a6f26bdefe8fb42db113a61aade85e0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the water crashing onto the shore is sped up, but the setting sun and the movement of clouds are not).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00720", "filename": "6f97832596795382eb9396160bb261624a6f26bdefe8fb42db113a61aade85e0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00721", "filename": "6f97832596795382eb9396160bb261624a6f26bdefe8fb42db113a61aade85e0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00722", "filename": "6ffb5c9502ccf266f5c27d13f67af530deb56ac579bf23a061a01e6bfe33960c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00723", "filename": "6ffb5c9502ccf266f5c27d13f67af530deb56ac579bf23a061a01e6bfe33960c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (high-frequency flickering and jumping will appear on the lake surface in the picture).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00724", "filename": "6ffb5c9502ccf266f5c27d13f67af530deb56ac579bf23a061a01e6bfe33960c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00725", "filename": "6ffb5c9502ccf266f5c27d13f67af530deb56ac579bf23a061a01e6bfe33960c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00726", "filename": "007d7b5a2d12b979c37f7de38080a8eb9c4f953827a360c1e1c7ebbdbce40244_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the footage records a sunrise, but the overall image darkens after 4.1 seconds, violating the laws of physics)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00727", "filename": "007d7b5a2d12b979c37f7de38080a8eb9c4f953827a360c1e1c7ebbdbce40244_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00728", "filename": "007d7b5a2d12b979c37f7de38080a8eb9c4f953827a360c1e1c7ebbdbce40244_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior (the clouds near the sun and lens appear reddish-brown, but the central part is grayish-brown, violating the laws of light scattering and reflection).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00729", "filename": "07bb1e3cf7cc7d33244bf2c11fb14bfe268e4601edb6152cf5ac5ba4ae7af8e9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00730", "filename": "07bb1e3cf7cc7d33244bf2c11fb14bfe268e4601edb6152cf5ac5ba4ae7af8e9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall impression (the flickering of the fire in the image is unnatural; the flames are too bright and smooth, resembling more luminous plastic than real flames.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00731", "filename": "88fa607adfe47fd693e89ad6050d1e2d1d9b2e916c17b02bcb33323a3e4e69eb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The overall visual effect is abnormal (the flames in the entire video move too smoothly and unnaturally, unlike real footage, lacking the flickering and unsteady feeling of real flames).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00732", "filename": "88fa607adfe47fd693e89ad6050d1e2d1d9b2e916c17b02bcb33323a3e4e69eb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.5s, the flames burning fiercely in the furnace suddenly shrink without any interference.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00733", "filename": "88fa607adfe47fd693e89ad6050d1e2d1d9b2e916c17b02bcb33323a3e4e69eb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the color and shape of the burning wood block remain unchanged. Normally, when wood blocks burn, their surface carbonizes, and their shape deforms as they burn.) Overall visual anomalies (The flames in the video move too smoothly, unlike realistic footage, lacking the flickering, unpredictable feel of real flames.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00734", "filename": "88fa607adfe47fd693e89ad6050d1e2d1d9b2e916c17b02bcb33323a3e4e69eb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00735", "filename": "089a19f801a147022fe8c241caaa74d7bb621d847d632d91618b9d7e50fede04_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 1.3s, the ball penetrates the cup wall, violating the impermeability of solids.) Temporal continuity (at 2.1s, the white ball on the track and the yellow ball in the cup suddenly disappear. At 2.5s, the white ball on the track suddenly turns yellow. At 3.3s, the two white balls that flew off the track suddenly merge into one yellow ball.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00736", "filename": "089a19f801a147022fe8c241caaa74d7bb621d847d632d91618b9d7e50fede04_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1 second, the ball falling from above the track merges with the ball already in the track.) Physical behavior (2.21-5.9 seconds, the ball rotates along the funnel track without any external force; normally, the ball should roll out of the funnel track and continue rolling along the track below.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00737", "filename": "089a19f801a147022fe8c241caaa74d7bb621d847d632d91618b9d7e50fede04_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (At 0.7s, the green ball in the funnel track suddenly turns white. At 2.3s, the white ball on the track suddenly turns green. At 2.5s, the two balls on the track merge into one. At 4.1s, the green ball on the track suddenly disappears.) Physical behavior (At 1.3s, the white and green balls in the track pass through each other, violating the impermeability of solids.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00738", "filename": "089a19f801a147022fe8c241caaa74d7bb621d847d632d91618b9d7e50fede04_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.1s, the green ball in the funnel track suddenly disappears. At 3.9s, the white ball in the track suddenly turns green. At 5s, the green ball falling from the funnel track suddenly turns white.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00739", "filename": "89a7c8d63704d8ab0f3d7fe16cf6e00487c5fea19b63fcf36f389eeb96d1e220_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 1.9s, the character's wrist deforms. At 3.1s, the yellow bowling ball on the lane suddenly turns black.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00740", "filename": "89a7c8d63704d8ab0f3d7fe16cf6e00487c5fea19b63fcf36f389eeb96d1e220_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 2.3s, the four bowling balls on the lane suddenly merge into one. At 3.3s, the black bowling ball in the character's hand suddenly disappears, and at the same time, a black and yellow bowling ball suddenly appears on the lane.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00741", "filename": "89a7c8d63704d8ab0f3d7fe16cf6e00487c5fea19b63fcf36f389eeb96d1e220_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time sequence (At 1.6s, the yellow bowling ball in the character's hand suddenly turns black. At 2.8s, the four bowling balls on the lane suddenly disappear. At 2.5s, the yellow bowling ball on the lane suddenly disappears.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00742", "filename": "89a7c8d63704d8ab0f3d7fe16cf6e00487c5fea19b63fcf36f389eeb96d1e220_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 6.6s, the bowling ball has not yet hit the pins, but the pins have already been knocked away, violating Newton's First Law.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00743", "filename": "89aa2997c32353f2bf709cc16325e6ff723681b808af7ccacfa013c1d6487814_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the doll to the left of the character keeps shaking without any force applied, violating Newton's First Law.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00744", "filename": "89aa2997c32353f2bf709cc16325e6ff723681b808af7ccacfa013c1d6487814_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.1 seconds, the cap of the water bottle held by the character suddenly disappears.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00746", "filename": "89b031f85b0ba4625015cc0cd75431e2f09ac0554f7edb4f37681ac168c898a4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (a rotating green vortex appears in the center of the video, which is not a physical effect of real fireworks. Normal fireworks explosions involve sparks spreading evenly in all directions. The fireworks explosion in the video lacks the layering and spark trajectory of normal fireworks explosions; it looks more like a malfunctioning visual effect than a real fireworks display.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00747", "filename": "89b031f85b0ba4625015cc0cd75431e2f09ac0554f7edb4f37681ac168c898a4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous timeline (at 0.5s, an explosion suddenly occurs on the ground below the fireworks. At 5s, the fireworks and the smoke from the explosion suddenly disappear.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00748", "filename": "89b031f85b0ba4625015cc0cd75431e2f09ac0554f7edb4f37681ac168c898a4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00749", "filename": "89b031f85b0ba4625015cc0cd75431e2f09ac0554f7edb4f37681ac168c898a4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00753", "filename": "89dbc5bdc0451c20ed0620ca8e6d86c5d2cf51f736ad2c799f530af0c868678d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (at 0.8 seconds, the ice in the bowl suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00754", "filename": "89e8fee66b8e5a969a37457f49c8ac0b51c3501dfd3a4d57d4419b15d3a8dbf8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the entire video shows flames burning on grass, but there is no obvious sign of the flames spreading. Normally, when flames burn on grass, the fire should grow larger and spread rapidly across the grass.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00755", "filename": "89e8fee66b8e5a969a37457f49c8ac0b51c3501dfd3a4d57d4419b15d3a8dbf8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the entire video shows flames burning on grass, but there is no obvious sign of the flames spreading. Normally, when flames burn on grass, the fire should grow larger and spread rapidly across the grass.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00756", "filename": "89e8fee66b8e5a969a37457f49c8ac0b51c3501dfd3a4d57d4419b15d3a8dbf8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the entire video shows flames burning on grass, but there is no obvious sign of the flames spreading. Normally, when flames burn on grass, the fire should grow larger and spread rapidly across the grass.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00757", "filename": "90d47c33f06fc7c47f05e10c07b26ae2496ff15282112d820d7d6f02f80627a4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00758", "filename": "90d47c33f06fc7c47f05e10c07b26ae2496ff15282112d820d7d6f02f80627a4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual effect is abnormal (the trajectory of the falling snow outside the window in the entire video is too smooth and regular, unlike real footage, lacking the irregular and wind-blown feel of snow falling in reality.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00759", "filename": "90d47c33f06fc7c47f05e10c07b26ae2496ff15282112d820d7d6f02f80627a4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00760", "filename": "90dc0025d2223cd05c159aff8fab1a75499915fea3b4892459bb22702b33beaa_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4s, the left edge of the green disk becomes distorted).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00761", "filename": "a7a261e82dd674eee87ecf421bcd63c7bea73b42e024ed88002dbdec18756203_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the drill bit is working on the wooden board, but the debris thrown out as the drill bit rotates has the texture of liquid).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00762", "filename": "a7a261e82dd674eee87ecf421bcd63c7bea73b42e024ed88002dbdec18756203_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.1 seconds, one piece of debris suddenly splits into two). The physical behavior is also abnormal (the debris is generated by the drill bit and then propelled by the drill bit, but in the video, the speed of the debris is greater than the speed of the drill bit).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00763", "filename": "a7a261e82dd674eee87ecf421bcd63c7bea73b42e024ed88002dbdec18756203_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (0.6s-1.6s the drill bit has not yet touched the wooden board, but the wooden board produces a lot of debris).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00764", "filename": "a7b5cf04a8c7dbe20e622b1086aa5037dc08dbb9286cc1f7acb0ad8aad9d0dc2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (stiff and unfluid arm and finger movements, lacking the agility and fluidity of real-world human hands).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00765", "filename": "a7b5cf04a8c7dbe20e622b1086aa5037dc08dbb9286cc1f7acb0ad8aad9d0dc2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (2.3s: palm suddenly changes from left to right; 2.6s: part of the rubber band on the hand disappears out of thin air; 2.3s: two fingers merge into one).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00766", "filename": "a7b5cf04a8c7dbe20e622b1086aa5037dc08dbb9286cc1f7acb0ad8aad9d0dc2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (2.1s-3s, finger passes through rubber band, causing clipping problem)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00767", "filename": "a7cc9fff1f9bc695013b30f1e5dc8119fb9933c305f38906ee03d337e188900c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Cause and Effect (The area inside the box shows a visual effect of particles jumping and flickering, while the edge of the box shows water splashing out from inside the box; the two are inconsistent)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00768", "filename": "a7cc9fff1f9bc695013b30f1e5dc8119fb9933c305f38906ee03d337e188900c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00769", "filename": "a7cc9fff1f9bc695013b30f1e5dc8119fb9933c305f38906ee03d337e188900c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00770", "filename": "a7cc9fff1f9bc695013b30f1e5dc8119fb9933c305f38906ee03d337e188900c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the right and top borders of the same frame appear opaque, while the left border appears semi-transparent).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00771", "filename": "a8c072fd498b978602b0a0fcbd5523a57167732bcc69f1e691e21fbc97e42e4f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Physical behavior (when the person's hand is not in contact with the magnetic balls, the magnetic balls should attract each other, gather together, and tend to stabilize, but some balls are moving randomly on their own).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00772", "filename": "a8c072fd498b978602b0a0fcbd5523a57167732bcc69f1e691e21fbc97e42e4f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 3.5s, a small ball hangs in the air on the right side of the screen, unaffected by gravity). Time continuity (from 3.6s to 3.9s, a small ball accelerates and rolls towards the hand before disappearing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00773", "filename": "a8c072fd498b978602b0a0fcbd5523a57167732bcc69f1e691e21fbc97e42e4f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (2s, the small ball between the two index fingers disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00774", "filename": "a8cffe72c3091f5aba63b4f3eb3c535bdec8be1188474a864330c64da9338c6a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (when steam condenses into water droplets on the lid, the droplets should gradually grow larger and then flow down the lid; the sudden appearance and disappearance of the water droplets in the image is inconsistent with reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00775", "filename": "a8cffe72c3091f5aba63b4f3eb3c535bdec8be1188474a864330c64da9338c6a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (when water droplets collide, they should attract each other and quickly merge together, but in the video, the water droplets merge too slowly when they meet. The water in the pot is boiling violently, generating a large amount of steam, which increases the pressure inside the pot and should cause the lid to be lifted, allowing steam to escape. However, in the video, the lid does not move at all during the violent boiling.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00776", "filename": "a8cffe72c3091f5aba63b4f3eb3c535bdec8be1188474a864330c64da9338c6a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the large amount of water appearing on the top of the pot lid from 3.5s to 8s is unreasonable; in reality, the process of steam encountering the pot lid and forming water is slow and does not immediately form a large amount of water). Time continuity: (The water in the pot continues to boil, and a large amount of water vapor appears from 2.4s to 4.6s, but then disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00777", "filename": "a8dcbf689ba92562ce810f96831b25211b55f2beccdf289919df4e071a04bab7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the video shows the flames burning continuously and steadily, but the brightness of the surrounding walls illuminated by the firelight fluctuates significantly, with excessive brightness changes. The video shows that there is no wind in the environment where the flames are burning, and the flames are dancing too randomly and erratically, lacking the natural upward swaying motion of flames carried by the heat).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00778", "filename": "a8dcbf689ba92562ce810f96831b25211b55f2beccdf289919df4e071a04bab7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the flames are generated from the burning area of the burning material and then naturally spread upwards with the heat, but in the video, the flames and the burning material lack connection, giving the visual effect that the flames are in a layer above the burning material)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00779", "filename": "a8dcbf689ba92562ce810f96831b25211b55f2beccdf289919df4e071a04bab7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Causality (The appearance and texture of the burning material in the video is cardboard, but after the flames move away in the right area of the 5.6s video, the appearance and texture of wood are revealed).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00780", "filename": "a9ac81e3759063866319e740571ee968411075e481bb2b4109a16e241f444ac8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: The overall movement is abnormal (there is no obvious take-off when the kayak jumps over the rock between 1.5s and 1.6s, but it quickly passes through the rock, and the speed of movement during the process of passing through the rock is very fast, which is inconsistent with the previous and subsequent movements and violates the principle of inertia).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00781", "filename": "a9ac81e3759063866319e740571ee968411075e481bb2b4109a16e241f444ac8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 3.8s, when the wave hits the kayak, there is no collision effect; instead, the wave appears to disappear as it passes through the kayak).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00782", "filename": "a9ac81e3759063866319e740571ee968411075e481bb2b4109a16e241f444ac8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (no collision effect occurs when the wave hits the paddle stick at 2.2s; instead, the wave appears to disappear as it passes through the paddle stick).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00783", "filename": "a9ac81e3759063866319e740571ee968411075e481bb2b4109a16e241f444ac8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (1.8s-3.5s: Waves hit the rocks and create splashes that cover the rocks, but the rocks disappear after the splashes subside).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00789", "filename": "a9f5b3778a34decd37de77b3bda0f015be1b2da4f57e92470605b78fdcbf03d6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (When two metal objects approach each other, the surfaces of the objects on the adjacent sides are very dark due to light blocking, but at 4.6s, strong reflections appear on both surfaces)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00790", "filename": "a9f5b3778a34decd37de77b3bda0f015be1b2da4f57e92470605b78fdcbf03d6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: The sequence of events is continuous (1.7s: two solid metals fuse together. 2.9s: end; the surface of the metal body twists and deforms on its own).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00791", "filename": "5d66ab2fd0b8507d83dbf24b28bc7f0a8bd4f0f3558c8a4e0a44330be7cbc511_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the flames burn unnaturally; between 1.5s and 2.3s, the flames sway from left to right and appear viscous).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00792", "filename": "5d66ab2fd0b8507d83dbf24b28bc7f0a8bd4f0f3558c8a4e0a44330be7cbc511_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (a flame is burning in the dark; given that flames emit light and heat, there is no light around the flame itself in the scene).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00794", "filename": "5d790b4257420da8dfa17ed077df26f88a48b8e4c3d0e0b33f0a634c0e8d80ac_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.9s, the oil droplets splashed in the air disappear into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00795", "filename": "5d790b4257420da8dfa17ed077df26f88a48b8e4c3d0e0b33f0a634c0e8d80ac_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (some of the falling water droplets disappear into thin air at 0.7s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00796", "filename": "5d790b4257420da8dfa17ed077df26f88a48b8e4c3d0e0b33f0a634c0e8d80ac_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The time sequence is continuous (from 1.5s to 2.7s, the oil pool rises in a circular pattern out of thin air; at 2.9s, the popcorn pops out of thin air without contacting the oil).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00797", "filename": "5d790b4257420da8dfa17ed077df26f88a48b8e4c3d0e0b33f0a634c0e8d80ac_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00798", "filename": "5d8853e9dc79afad21045263bcf195e3675a360b51c8d5ab50bc190f882c5089_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Cause and Effect (The waterfall in the image falls rapidly, but the river is calm, and the waterfall does not have the expected impact on the river).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00799", "filename": "5d8853e9dc79afad21045263bcf195e3675a360b51c8d5ab50bc190f882c5089_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a large amount of white smoke appears out of nowhere in the screen between 1.6s and 4.9s)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00800", "filename": "5d8853e9dc79afad21045263bcf195e3675a360b51c8d5ab50bc190f882c5089_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the waterfall suddenly explodes in mid-air at 3:01).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00801", "filename": "5d8853e9dc79afad21045263bcf195e3675a360b51c8d5ab50bc190f882c5089_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (According to the law of conservation of energy, the height of the waterfall rebound at 4.7s cannot be higher than the height of the fall).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00802", "filename": "5d11733ac24ec19181a5cfe074a8dfde9c7128e250a8c93dd6b9ac98633d470e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the cup filled with water uses the principle of convex mirror imaging, but at 5s, two doll images appear in the cup).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00803", "filename": "5d11733ac24ec19181a5cfe074a8dfde9c7128e250a8c93dd6b9ac98633d470e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Physical behavior (the cup full of water uses the principle of convex mirror imaging; between 2.5s and 5.8s, the doll's head does not appear as a magnified image when viewed through the cup full of water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00804", "filename": "5d11733ac24ec19181a5cfe074a8dfde9c7128e250a8c93dd6b9ac98633d470e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior (Based on the principle of light refraction, at 2.7s, half of the doll's image is seen through a glass of water and the other half through a glass of dry water, but the images appear the same).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00805", "filename": "5d11733ac24ec19181a5cfe074a8dfde9c7128e250a8c93dd6b9ac98633d470e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (between 3.5s and 6.3s, the doll enters the water through the cup without being subjected to any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00806", "filename": "5d87270375ab5ef2c4bb235e61933dda4b0909e846389782143d1ff9414d46f8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the thermometer pointer spins rapidly in the display, indicating a problem with the thermometer, but no reaction occurs in the beaker).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00807", "filename": "5d87270375ab5ef2c4bb235e61933dda4b0909e846389782143d1ff9414d46f8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (between 2.8s and 5.3s, liquid droplets in the beaker suddenly flow through the inner wall of the beaker and down the outer wall).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00808", "filename": "5d87270375ab5ef2c4bb235e61933dda4b0909e846389782143d1ff9414d46f8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00809", "filename": "5d87270375ab5ef2c4bb235e61933dda4b0909e846389782143d1ff9414d46f8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (1.2s-3.5s: the thermometer shows no change, but the ice in the cup suddenly melts rapidly; ice only melts when the temperature is above 0 degrees Celsius).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00810", "filename": "5de81eedc589ee05a26563882a35abc011e2e5b88dcfe6b8ddf3e066bd3d61ff_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Based on the principle of surface tension, large bubbles should grow larger as they merge with smaller bubbles during flight, but they appear smaller in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00811", "filename": "5de81eedc589ee05a26563882a35abc011e2e5b88dcfe6b8ddf3e066bd3d61ff_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the white line painted in the middle of the road does not conform to the road surface and appears three-dimensional).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00812", "filename": "5e38e39c35fc075bf1dc793329231e2f39352d60bacec05faf198adde59e14b9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the yellow oil block in the image moves freely without being subjected to any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00813", "filename": "5e38e39c35fc075bf1dc793329231e2f39352d60bacec05faf198adde59e14b9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (According to the law of conservation of energy, at 2.2s, the oil block suddenly began to melt from the top without being heated).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00814", "filename": "5e38e39c35fc075bf1dc793329231e2f39352d60bacec05faf198adde59e14b9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00815", "filename": "5eb3ea4cd579d4b459838b5e71b56e4fb1710bda0ee205e6bd2f888dffcc2a09_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (with the lamp stationary and not subjected to any external force, the two iron rings on the chain suspending the lamp twist out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00816", "filename": "5eb3ea4cd579d4b459838b5e71b56e4fb1710bda0ee205e6bd2f888dffcc2a09_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Based on the principle of light reflection, in the 2.3s frame, the image of the lamp is reflected, but its position is not at the same height as the lamp).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00817", "filename": "5eb3ea4cd579d4b459838b5e71b56e4fb1710bda0ee205e6bd2f888dffcc2a09_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00818", "filename": "5ecd81a89511e91b6b04c35085566b1089a76932ce46343e92bab1d923a3d794_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the paper pieces in the picture change position randomly without being subjected to any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00819", "filename": "5ecd81a89511e91b6b04c35085566b1089a76932ce46343e92bab1d923a3d794_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (According to the laws of conservation of gravity and momentum, there is no impact sensation when the beads collide with each other, and neither the falling bead nor the bead that is hit bounces away).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00820", "filename": "5ecd81a89511e91b6b04c35085566b1089a76932ce46343e92bab1d923a3d794_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 2.9s, the beads in the image slide out of thin air without being subjected to any external force, causing the image to blur).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00821", "filename": "b2ba9d0da6280b568ef7c662330defe557a07254a4f649cfe805e87ed06e5aa2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00826", "filename": "b2fa0be060db8e5c3f76e2326456841b29a4ee8f1c81a1b0bd915012bf2068a9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: causality (the liquid produced by melting ice should spread outwards, but in the video, the liquid is seen adhering to the ice surface and surging upwards) and continuity of time (at 4.3 seconds, the liquid from melting ice disappears without any apparent spread).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00827", "filename": "b2fa0be060db8e5c3f76e2326456841b29a4ee8f1c81a1b0bd915012bf2068a9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is abnormal (under normal circumstances, when an ice ring melts, its shape should change uniformly and sink, but the speed and shape of the ice ring in the video are too exaggerated, presenting a limp and twisted appearance that does not conform to the natural melting law and is inconsistent with the hardness of ice).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00828", "filename": "b3d0de871a6c412d682d6fe056d34f427402b77d4154796fc3c7a030b3f23c95_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Cause and effect (the entire video is affected by airflow, and the mountain mist and trees on the left side of the video are swaying with the wind, but the trees in the distance at the lower right of the video remain stable, and the images do not correspond to each other).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00829", "filename": "b3d0de871a6c412d682d6fe056d34f427402b77d4154796fc3c7a030b3f23c95_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Cause and effect (the entire video shows the mountain mist moving rapidly due to airflow, but the trees in the distance remain stationary, and the images do not correspond to each other).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00830", "filename": "b3d0de871a6c412d682d6fe056d34f427402b77d4154796fc3c7a030b3f23c95_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Cause and effect (the clouds and mist in the mountains are moving very fast. only some of the trees in the entire video show slight swaying).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00831", "filename": "b3e7a52d3a94b837c0ecdb26d74e587aa7b0e4079ff15a336ab58f8c0f16f382_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 1.1s, the length of the drill bit suddenly increases out of nowhere in the video without any interference).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00832", "filename": "b3e7a52d3a94b837c0ecdb26d74e587aa7b0e4079ff15a336ab58f8c0f16f382_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (during the period from 0.1s to 2.1s, the machine does not descend, but the shape of the drill bit keeps getting bigger and longer out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00833", "filename": "b3e7a52d3a94b837c0ecdb26d74e587aa7b0e4079ff15a336ab58f8c0f16f382_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the drill bit is not moving in the hole between 1.1s and 2.1s, but the hole appears to enlarge out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00834", "filename": "b3e7a52d3a94b837c0ecdb26d74e587aa7b0e4079ff15a336ab58f8c0f16f382_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Cause and effect (from 3.9s to 8s, the position of the drill bit on the wood did not change, but three regular circles were formed on the wood, and the diameter of the middle hole did not match the diameter of the drill bit).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00835", "filename": "b3ed0243e92c1574a4403bad2509ceafb1093680ef8dd0fe828741281bef2851_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the left arm of the person in the video appears as a ghost between 1.9s and 2.9s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00836", "filename": "b3ed0243e92c1574a4403bad2509ceafb1093680ef8dd0fe828741281bef2851_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.6s, the left hand fingers of the person in the video suddenly pierce through the square water glass).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00837", "filename": "b3ed0243e92c1574a4403bad2509ceafb1093680ef8dd0fe828741281bef2851_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.9s, the person in the video has not yet obtained the red straw, but the red straw suddenly moves).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00838", "filename": "b4f926353605ef07d5aa13de48faa52500f9691033fb1c312c905104a1ec2d5a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is unusual: Cause and effect (the clouds and lake surface in the sky will drift with the wind due to airflow, but the lake surface in the entire video remains calm and does not correspond to the constantly drifting clouds in the sky).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00839", "filename": "b4f926353605ef07d5aa13de48faa52500f9691033fb1c312c905104a1ec2d5a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall visual impression is off (the color changes of the clouds in the sky throughout the video are too wide and there is no color gradation).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00840", "filename": "b4f926353605ef07d5aa13de48faa52500f9691033fb1c312c905104a1ec2d5a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (clouds in the sky and mountains are affected by airflow and drift with the wind, but the clouds in the sky and the fog in the distance drift in different directions throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00841", "filename": "b4f926353605ef07d5aa13de48faa52500f9691033fb1c312c905104a1ec2d5a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (between 5.7s and 8s, the direction and shape of the ripples in the water are not consistent, the waves bounce back and forth before they spread out, and the ripple flow is too abrupt, which does not conform to the laws of liquid flow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00842", "filename": "b4fc7e685e3b6f55729d5e7da725d6bace298ba895bcc49b72a24f64783937a1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.7s, the blue object in the person's hand suddenly increases out of thin air, at 2.2s the blue object in the hand suddenly disappears out of thin air, at 2.6s the blue object that disappeared reappears out of thin air, and at 3.2s the blue object that rotated to the top suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00843", "filename": "b4fc7e685e3b6f55729d5e7da725d6bace298ba895bcc49b72a24f64783937a1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.9s, the blue object on the left side of the character's left hand suddenly passes through the character's left hand, and from 0.9s to 5.8s, the blue object in the character's hand keeps twisting and deforming).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00844", "filename": "b4fc7e685e3b6f55729d5e7da725d6bace298ba895bcc49b72a24f64783937a1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the person in the video did not interfere with the rotation of the blue object, but the blue object's circling trajectory kept changing, which does not conform to the laws of gravity and inertia).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00845", "filename": "b4fc7e685e3b6f55729d5e7da725d6bace298ba895bcc49b72a24f64783937a1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.2s, the blue object in the character's hand suddenly grows larger; at 0.3s, a white line appears out of nowhere on the blue object; at 2s, the shape of the blue object in the character's hand suddenly grows larger).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00846", "filename": "b05b99e6d2e92a3c85fa06764f04985a31d23def5d40a63025eca75c4fdd5af4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (although the ripples on the water surface in the entire video look fine, they lack natural variation and appear to be repetitive textures, lacking the random and layered dynamic feel of a real water surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00847", "filename": "b05b99e6d2e92a3c85fa06764f04985a31d23def5d40a63025eca75c4fdd5af4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (although the ripples on the water surface in the entire video are dynamically changing, the overall movement pattern appears too regular and lacks the random, multi-layered undulation details of a real water surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00848", "filename": "b05b99e6d2e92a3c85fa06764f04985a31d23def5d40a63025eca75c4fdd5af4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (although the ripples on the water surface in the entire video look fine, they lack natural variation and appear to be repetitively generated textures).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00849", "filename": "b05b99e6d2e92a3c85fa06764f04985a31d23def5d40a63025eca75c4fdd5af4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (although the ripples on the water surface in the entire video look fine, they lack natural variation and appear to be repetitive textures, lacking the random and layered dynamic feel of a real water surface).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00850", "filename": "b5daf32b643cfda53b6a1a757b9bf03d4ac744bb53b27c486ff78dc012966559_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall impression is abnormal (the flames produced by the explosion between 1.5s and 3.8s show an abnormally regular spherical expansion. In reality, the flames of a flammable gas balloon explosion will show an irregular cluster or darting shape due to air convection and gas diffusion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00851", "filename": "600e2f941c28e4b15f4e2812e5c2c668c2af44a41cc2200a8db57a9a40985a74_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (The image simultaneously displays two different cloud levels. The lower level is typically the top of low-level cumulus clouds, while the upper level is high-level stratocumulus clouds. It's impossible to clearly see both levels of clouds at the same time.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00852", "filename": "603cdad55da9e5ad6ed1b6fb96b04fb3e4c78e9973e9cf09506cac793e78b87e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (the smoke that appears in the center of the frame from 0s to 2.8s does not dissipate or move as the camera moves and time progresses).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00853", "filename": "603cdad55da9e5ad6ed1b6fb96b04fb3e4c78e9973e9cf09506cac793e78b87e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00854", "filename": "614f743cb841fa8574c047d31acf35c0131af95a8d49921f1f9f5232d5b4e5e2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00855", "filename": "614f743cb841fa8574c047d31acf35c0131af95a8d49921f1f9f5232d5b4e5e2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continues (a light spot appears in the lower left corner of the cup due to reflection of the light source. Since the light source is fixed and the cup is rotating in place, the light spot should not change position as the cup rotates).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00856", "filename": "614f743cb841fa8574c047d31acf35c0131af95a8d49921f1f9f5232d5b4e5e2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The duration is prolonged (at 2.8 seconds in the video, the smoke in the glass appears to be boiling, similar to the appearance of boiling water, without any external factors).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00857", "filename": "618e0bdaf9d3417711cace9bd2834336d7dc7032b22e120775270447d94356f0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly due to physical behavior (the low temperature of ice will be rapidly conducted to any liquid it comes into contact with; viscous liquids like the one in the video would become even thicker or even freeze due to the sudden drop in temperature, making it impossible for them to maintain the smooth liquid state shown in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00858", "filename": "618e0bdaf9d3417711cace9bd2834336d7dc7032b22e120775270447d94356f0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the duration is continuous (at 4.5 seconds, a streak of white liquid suddenly appears in the brown liquid on the ice, and the source of the white liquid was not shown in the video before).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00859", "filename": "622fb983a1fc8a170efd0eb01f9c0f5082be77286fe4448e5a5553cbd12551b4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the sphere wobbles between 0 and 2 seconds in the video, but does not roll, which does not conform to the characteristics of rigid body rotation).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00860", "filename": "622fb983a1fc8a170efd0eb01f9c0f5082be77286fe4448e5a5553cbd12551b4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continues (at 1.4s in the display, the hydraulic press did not touch the iron ball, but the iron ball began to deform).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00861", "filename": "622fb983a1fc8a170efd0eb01f9c0f5082be77286fe4448e5a5553cbd12551b4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (at 1.4s in the video, the iron ball was not flattened but entered the worktable below the hydraulic press, causing a mold break).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00862", "filename": "622fb983a1fc8a170efd0eb01f9c0f5082be77286fe4448e5a5553cbd12551b4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time duration is continuous (at 7.3 seconds in the footage, the hydraulic press is raised, but the flattened iron ball begins to shrink inward, showing a tendency to return to its original shape).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00863", "filename": "623c7addf3acb0fdb202585a5384eab61dd22eb20be6cfe00fdcf4007fcf0288_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (clear, flowing water can cause underwater pebbles to appear shallower and closer to the surface due to light refraction. However, in the video, the texture of the underwater pebbles and the ripples on the water surface are perfectly synchronized in color and clarity, and the textures on the surface and the bottom are almost aligned, without any visual misalignment caused by refraction.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00864", "filename": "623c7addf3acb0fdb202585a5384eab61dd22eb20be6cfe00fdcf4007fcf0288_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image appears unusual: the overall impression is that the saturation of colors such as gold and blue in the image is abnormally high, exceeding the true color range of a river under natural light.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00865", "filename": "623c7addf3acb0fdb202585a5384eab61dd22eb20be6cfe00fdcf4007fcf0288_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (water ripples bounce in the lower right corner of the entire frame, but this bounce does not occur when the water flow does not hit any objects).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00866", "filename": "623c7addf3acb0fdb202585a5384eab61dd22eb20be6cfe00fdcf4007fcf0288_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00870", "filename": "0656fe333c0604dd951032ebb418fd129bc9c4091e82fb145209c8b1d5085490_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical behavior (white ash continuously appears on the head of the stick at 3.9s, and reignites at 4.5s, but reignition is impossible at this temperature).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00871", "filename": "0656fe333c0604dd951032ebb418fd129bc9c4091e82fb145209c8b1d5085490_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (abnormal flame shape; a normal burning match flame should be a cone shape with the bottom close to the match head and tapering upwards, while the flame in the picture is a near-perfect circle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00872", "filename": "0656fe333c0604dd951032ebb418fd129bc9c4091e82fb145209c8b1d5085490_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00873", "filename": "656bdf6a094277ee229416d9018437adb0df9be238614f8a7c9f5ec76a3fe938_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The duration is continuous (a figure appears in the lower left corner of the screen at 1.1 seconds, and then suddenly rises in height at 2.9 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00874", "filename": "656bdf6a094277ee229416d9018437adb0df9be238614f8a7c9f5ec76a3fe938_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00875", "filename": "656bdf6a094277ee229416d9018437adb0df9be238614f8a7c9f5ec76a3fe938_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00876", "filename": "656bdf6a094277ee229416d9018437adb0df9be238614f8a7c9f5ec76a3fe938_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00877", "filename": "661bdb9ec3c0e9edd734345a3eb4c08b2ababb2c089bb18c81e3084d0de9a027_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: continuous time (bubbles appear out of nowhere in the upper right corner of the water glass in the video, and the bubbles under the ice cubes suddenly move at 4.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00878", "filename": "661bdb9ec3c0e9edd734345a3eb4c08b2ababb2c089bb18c81e3084d0de9a027_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (no heating device is visible in the video, but bubbles keep bubbling out of the water glass).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00879", "filename": "661bdb9ec3c0e9edd734345a3eb4c08b2ababb2c089bb18c81e3084d0de9a027_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continues (numerous bubbles appear and rotate beneath the ice cubes in the water glass).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00880", "filename": "671a6bd483a777857ef683d7c30ad39f4111277fe9b3a017ad6b87841c7e75ff_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the long white strip light in the picture is suspended by thin wires, but there are several wires that are clearly piercing through the branches on the right side of the picture, causing clipping).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00881", "filename": "618e0bdaf9d3417711cace9bd2834336d7dc7032b22e120775270447d94356f0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (At 2.2s, after the orange liquid with a significantly higher temperature was poured onto the ice, the ice did not show any reduction in volume or change in shape due to melting, which violates the physical law that ice will melt after absorbing heat).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00882", "filename": "671a6bd483a777857ef683d7c30ad39f4111277fe9b3a017ad6b87841c7e75ff_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00883", "filename": "687f08c08aa088611b3f362baa5ab4da8ab3aa0aca1b7af1c6274023f05f7cbe_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (the clouds in the sky at 3.4s are strange. One second they are thick, dark clouds, the next second they suddenly become thinner and the color becomes more uniform, which is not the normal way for clouds to slowly move and disperse).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00884", "filename": "787f1720704d6e68f8b321f464428e2e147ddfb08ac74811cf9480f51e729f2c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (at the beginning - 1.3s, the melting butter block, despite continuous oil release, did not shrink in volume at all; until 2.3s, it was merely covered by liquid oil, rather than melting and decreasing in volume. This violates the physical law that a solid's volume decreases when heated and melts into a liquid).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00886", "filename": "941a9c18422613eb5e1d4030cc5ccb39d9c08050160d0596cd42627c76d18e70_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (at 2.3s, the drill bit has not yet touched the left side of the metal block, but metal fragments are already flying at that location).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00887", "filename": "1605e43f0f93c91d57d3f1cd5194f62419867a3718dc00b55ed88d9b760584c2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (At 2.4s, water was poured onto the yellow solid. Although the surface of the solid showed a melting visual effect, it never melted into dents or pits or reduced in volume).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00888", "filename": "4301f6f9ced8079cefefebc6c020abdc7a173cf45b5b889b5947d3a19f9723cd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Abnormal physical behavior (at 0.5s, the white transparent liquid in the container suddenly rises and overflows the container without any external injection or melting of ice, violating the law of conservation of mass).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00889", "filename": "4958b02137633e06f034a0b79cc0ae76accd79a48bada2ab5dea20a5602c333a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 2.8s, a blue water balloon suddenly appears out of nowhere to the right of the green balloon, without any process of its generation or movement into the screen).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00891", "filename": "6352df4dad3dd0ae4ba03358bf139701e77030b5970141196857d09b36f03bc6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (At 4.6s, the vegetation on the left side of the screen suddenly changes from warm yellow to dark green. This is completely out of place with the warm yellow light of the sunset, as if the colors were changed with a single click).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00892", "filename": "7392fb10a64a751563acbf16cc95f604b04b9d5a4a6cb1df101a4ec3bf8bd3a1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Abnormal physical behavior (At 3.4s, after the object flying from the left hit the egg, the egg liquid and shell did not splash in the opposite direction of the force, that is, to the right, but instead exploded in a uniform radial pattern, which violates the principle of collision).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00893", "filename": "8165e4d6e925fd634f513d1d734afb0dba814315502d2e4e764ca3ecec50f675_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (before 4.4s, the dark brown rock surface on the lower right side of the screen has an uneven texture, but at 4.4s it suddenly becomes smooth and regular, and the color also changes to a uniform dark brown).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00894", "filename": "8819ec65021ba80b3838d27bf835e47d9dbcae295a5d0a7dcbf5b5d84501d5b3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 3s, the rising sun instantly teleports to a new position without any gradual transition during its ascent).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00895", "filename": "8867c0626f77206dd00ae0ce04d9f5d716c1a0850be0d6234e97435e45f5ca1f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The continuity of time is abnormal (at 4.4s, the central area of the haystack that was hit by the water jet did not turn into a wet, dark brown color, but instead turned into a charred black color).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00896", "filename": "9280bd8ccb93ce7e07cc10862e7addda4ebffbd48fab55c03dfd55c470d2165a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Abnormal physical behavior (at 3.9s, during the process of the high-temperature flame melting the colored plastic column, the white foam below, which serves as the base, did not show any signs of burning, melting, or carbonization).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00897", "filename": "9318bd79abf3d55412fd53909d89fc5f8039927a764c9d02f9cf8b0b1a7184bc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (Throughout the video, the red solid remains suspended in mid-air without any supporting structure or upward force to counteract gravity.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00898", "filename": "29171a29dba94edad1aacf98877d9d0df6c3af2cde745d2acb590b2328f1437b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 1.4s, the sparks in the lower part of the screen disappeared without any displacement process. Sparks from a sparkler should have a gradual process of drifting away and dimming; they cannot just disappear suddenly).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00899", "filename": "33673d82441319606c8fb001f6c276eae3ff9144586b62a47189ff53edfe7fe4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (the ice cubes never melted throughout the video, but the water in the cup increased illogically).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00900", "filename": "38062ed8866218346df3a13b821783778dea3c702ca254c894947ce7fba46dd8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 4.4s, the colored patterns on the bubble suddenly turn white without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00901", "filename": "42084a0f225b896537e84a539e69fd2936f03a374f3233643eb0d29b5c8d523a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (At the moment the fireball exploded at 3.5 seconds, there was no dynamic reaction of the ground being kicked up by the shock wave. It is impossible for the dry ground to remain completely still under such a large explosion of energy, with not a single speck of dust being stirred up).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00902", "filename": "42367d383f26e7c2dd0b124b554c2c217be9fd2fde435bf423084a730b388260_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Abnormal physical behavior (1.9s - end of video, the bubble on the left moves and twists on its own without any external force or airflow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00903", "filename": "45838e38158ffe3c6507a9389ca35cd1b9691326d88725398f7e639151cc7938_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal time continuity (At 2.4s, the clouds in the sky suddenly changed from magenta and orange to light pink and blue. There was no transition at all, which violates the natural law of gradual color change in clouds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00904", "filename": "51955dd7501d4770522c9439f26c7d15b08ba766b5d6bd252c8f5e54b95e1f43_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (at 2s, the small water droplet on the far left of the blade is stretched into a thin filament without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00905", "filename": "56118cf35e889f5ac553d7c27e9119e24842b4d88bad3ce32c9cc898451fd011_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00906", "filename": "073771a2ff1bc59c885f19d346f921a03c364a09f4dd9316ca2c58678c5d224c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (at 2.5s, the water droplet at the bottom of the screen penetrates the texture of the petals below, which violates the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00907", "filename": "77996eb81486c31b484a04a3e5e298a5599984992bdc5dc777cb7f0b1a6f66ec_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (at 3.5s, the colored page in the lower left of the circular container suddenly changed from a smooth state to a distorted and discontinuous state, as if it had been twisted by an invisible hand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00908", "filename": "80279e732e7fd30fd02a7b7d2fbd14541b5fa2387b9453fe868896dc5b1e449e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (at 4s, the sky's color tone abruptly changes from a cool, dark bluish-gray without transition to a bright, warm yellow. The city's weather also instantly jumps from overcast to sunny).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00909", "filename": "92119b340680356444ac65584c6f0b55b3a31c0d1e607f99eb553e29ff56a30f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (at 3.6s, juice was produced before the hydraulic press had fully squeezed and the grapes had been crushed) Physical behavior (at 4.9s, the grape pulp and juice penetrated the solid hydraulic container layer, violating the principle that solids are impermeable)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00910", "filename": "97123d0e71b884cd48989647b00bab8539bdbdfbc9ffc743cfd53c14d5b01159_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity anomaly (at 2.8s, the originally regularly distributed blue, purple, and yellow rainbow stripes on the crystal surface suddenly and without transition became small, fragmented patches of grayish-white and yellowish color).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00911", "filename": "835d532991a8031a0533503ca968b5a87b3bb6cb4ea6bee7d04b11b1fd693dee_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (the rain is only displayed below the streetlights, while there is light above the streetlights but no rain is displayed).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00912", "filename": "844ab69c55cf393e7312686ec57f66ffb4125daa91c43c95ae1ef96026951a53_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (the object inside the bowl is constantly wriggling and flashing throughout the entire segment).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00913", "filename": "863a3291ea37a15f08a2f3607e4457f3f9d1020bb5105935975fa5e9212aa011_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (the right side of the leaky sand table flickers and wriggles throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00914", "filename": "869e0a839a85242d380b29408d3e5d293d12ce6c6687e603da16be19d9c0ddcc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the surface of a normal hot spring usually only has slow and gentle ripples, or subtle convection patterns caused by temperature differences, but the surface of the water in the video is covered with fine and rapid shaking ripples, which is more like the violent vaporization and rolling phenomenon produced when the water is close to boiling).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00915", "filename": "921c160e9df0b97ed817e80521c42dccb850ce8224d0123b77386eb024446ebd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (strong sunlight above the clouds creates an unreasonable contrast between the intense top light and the completely black silhouette of the ground. Normally, even thick clouds would have some scattered light to reveal the basic outline of the mountains.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00916", "filename": "924d96b81485a4bd78621117fbb5ee0210e96fa02c945c73e62ea26d7e8b2c6f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous movement (the grass on the left side of the screen flickers and wriggles continuously throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00917", "filename": "941a9c18422613eb5e1d4030cc5ccb39d9c08050160d0596cd42627c76d18e70_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 0.9s, the drill bit changes from a black pointed shape to a threaded shape; throughout the entire segment, the drill bit does not rotate but is still able to process the object).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00918", "filename": "963e38a1e2cf8561e1d4201e24d300a21c20a56af23eb197fe618151ae695ab2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is unusual: the timing is continuous (the black mushroom cloud-like smoke produced by the explosion between 3.1s and 8s is huge and extremely dense, and its shape is more similar to the explosion effect of military explosives such as landmines, rather than ordinary car fuel explosions).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00919", "filename": "1197c2434367caea83bb052202a29a5d1a42c4376763379fc93f668497542f78_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00920", "filename": "1197c2434367caea83bb052202a29a5d1a42c4376763379fc93f668497542f78_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (tree trunks that are not in contact with the water surface are wriggling and flickering throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00921", "filename": "1277c81a9fc08439adfe8c6966105399a74ac0b346ae7368c32f39c98701a112_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the table and the slanted surface on the left side of the cup are constantly flickering and writhing throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00922", "filename": "1277c81a9fc08439adfe8c6966105399a74ac0b346ae7368c32f39c98701a112_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.9s, the leather-like slanted surface on the left side of the cup suddenly transforms into a book).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00924", "filename": "2175ab31176cf6d841d7e8cdde90a4fa268fa20c56136dfee9ca64dd121d5b22_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00925", "filename": "2435fc51f6224a3de844b34f4c4cee34657aa8603fc82f9fcf85c2794745e8d5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 6.9s, another colored sphere appears out of thin air inside the second glass sphere from the left, and the sand on the ground keeps wriggling and flashing throughout the segment).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00927", "filename": "2801f27cb83e2ab1cf93a75fb1124531c936830db8a55602a0dedee8bb2e2206_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4s, the clock cover of the desktop service bell is pressed to the base, while in reality, the service bell can only be pressed by pressing the button on the top).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00928", "filename": "2960dd09d1896ab911e5cb139cff74f1b26a340ea4f4d8af388b5041e770ff92_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3 seconds, the fireworks explode in the air without shooting upwards from the ground. People are recording with their mobile phones throughout the video, but the video footage displayed on the phones does not match the content of this video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00929", "filename": "2960dd09d1896ab911e5cb139cff74f1b26a340ea4f4d8af388b5041e770ff92_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.1s and 5.2s, the fireworks explode in mid-air without any upward movement from the ground).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00930", "filename": "3576f0390fbbb9960c32374c4a0c77e5f3faced45110cd0e4b3ffb6faa109de7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.2s, the blue flame of the lighter is the only ignition source, while the orange-red flame extending from the left side of the crystal indicates that the crystal itself is continuously burning and releasing flammable gas, which completely contradicts the common property that crystals are not flammable; at 3.6s, a burning flame appears above the crystal, which completely contradicts the common property that crystals are not flammable).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00932", "filename": "9c8d2b84d47f1a27c36c8cb479fd208cb554d5e4d07060551bd85c2935a77e1e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Abnormal physical behavior (2.4s-2.7s: the melted liquid portion of the ice cream spontaneously rises back and drips off without changing its volume).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00933", "filename": "9c8d2b84d47f1a27c36c8cb479fd208cb554d5e4d07060551bd85c2935a77e1e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (more and more liquid is melting, the weight of the liquid exceeds the adhesion, and the melted liquid part of the rotating ice cream remains hanging without dripping).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00934", "filename": "9c8d2b84d47f1a27c36c8cb479fd208cb554d5e4d07060551bd85c2935a77e1e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (0.3s-4.3s: the right side of the ice cream melts and drips liquid, but the volume of the ice cream remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00935", "filename": "9c8d2b84d47f1a27c36c8cb479fd208cb554d5e4d07060551bd85c2935a77e1e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (2.8s, ice cream melts over a large area at room temperature, producing a large number of droplets, violating the first law of thermodynamics).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00939", "filename": "9c102ea67d8fff8161847c2c51df08d184a091de4636c318ce6f86408adb24cd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall realism is abnormal (paper scraps only burn within a fixed area, and the burning debris sways too regularly, unlike natural burning); Time continuity is abnormal (from 2.4s to 5s, the amount of burning debris in the lower right corner of the paper exceeds its own output); Time continuity is abnormal (at 0.4s, the left side of the paper flickers).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00940", "filename": "9c102ea67d8fff8161847c2c51df08d184a091de4636c318ce6f86408adb24cd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (burning paper scraps suddenly turn into sand and the flame suddenly goes out at 1s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00941", "filename": "9c102ea67d8fff8161847c2c51df08d184a091de4636c318ce6f86408adb24cd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (from 1.6s to 5s, the burning debris spontaneously increases and overlaps upwards).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00942", "filename": "9c102ea67d8fff8161847c2c51df08d184a091de4636c318ce6f86408adb24cd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall realism is abnormal (from 2.9s to 8s, the area beneath the paper scraps, which is not burning, rapidly turns black and cracks).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00946", "filename": "9d3fe90d649312621ec9ed104a9f04953043f5fc21b9b9f4f7902f991cfa8ae6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity error (continuous flickering and jumping appears on the shore at the top of the screen).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00947", "filename": "9d3fe90d649312621ec9ed104a9f04953043f5fc21b9b9f4f7902f991cfa8ae6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Abnormal physical behavior (1.3s-5.8s) The originally smoothly flowing river suddenly forms a whirlpool, and the water flow also surges and bulges upwards at an angle.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00948", "filename": "9d3fe90d649312621ec9ed104a9f04953043f5fc21b9b9f4f7902f991cfa8ae6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00949", "filename": "9d3fe90d649312621ec9ed104a9f04953043f5fc21b9b9f4f7902f991cfa8ae6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical anomalies (the water flow in the upper right corner of the video is stationary; the water flow caused by stones obstructing the river is irregular and intermittent); Temporal continuity anomalies (snowflakes suddenly appear and disappear in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00950", "filename": "9d4ad6ca106c55686266d342ca127297b855ba23861c6af6a367cdb653d68b57_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Abnormal physical behavior (the blue object's volume and structure remain unchanged throughout the burning process, violating the law of conservation of mass); Abnormal overall realism (the blue object is placed on the surface of wood and burns, but the sides of the wood do not burn and carbonize but instead scatter and flow like quicksand).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00951", "filename": "9d4ad6ca106c55686266d342ca127297b855ba23861c6af6a367cdb653d68b57_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (0.1s: The wooden stick in the person's hand suddenly detaches from the person's hand and flies away without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00952", "filename": "9d4ad6ca106c55686266d342ca127297b855ba23861c6af6a367cdb653d68b57_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00953", "filename": "9d4ad6ca106c55686266d342ca127297b855ba23861c6af6a367cdb653d68b57_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (the blue object undergoes abnormally intense and rapid combustion within a very short time, from 3.3s to 8s, with the combustion rate significantly exceeding the normal combustion limit of the substance).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00954", "filename": "9d31ef7fa2cb50ebb01752ff05a15ee5b09d67108c6fceb56a4cc7fe92c3ee35_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (liquid is continuously added to the cup, but the volume of liquid in the cup remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00955", "filename": "9d31ef7fa2cb50ebb01752ff05a15ee5b09d67108c6fceb56a4cc7fe92c3ee35_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Abnormal physical behavior (0s-3.7s: only a small amount of liquid is added to the cup, but the liquid level in the cup rises very quickly and significantly; no matter how much liquid is poured into the cup, the water ripples produced by the liquid in the cup are all the same size).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00956", "filename": "9d31ef7fa2cb50ebb01752ff05a15ee5b09d67108c6fceb56a4cc7fe92c3ee35_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (only a small amount of liquid is added to the cup, but the liquid level rises rapidly and significantly; liquid falling in 3.4 seconds forms a spherical shape in the air).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00957", "filename": "9d31ef7fa2cb50ebb01752ff05a15ee5b09d67108c6fceb56a4cc7fe92c3ee35_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_00961", "filename": "P27_105_137_e1c5d7cd66bf3e68_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows a sequence of events: (At 1.6 seconds, the lower left corner of the paper suddenly folds up; at 2.1 seconds, both sides of the paper suddenly flip upwards; and at 4.8 seconds, the paper in the hand instantly folds into a ball.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00962", "filename": "P27_105_252_46bd01be7aea9884_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (before 5.1s in the video, the bottom part of the paper is two pieces of paper folded together; after 5.1s, it suddenly becomes a single piece of paper).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00963", "filename": "P27_105_265_18f5f81aea543589_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 6.1s in the video, the creased aluminum foil rolled up on the paper suddenly returns to its original, uncreased state.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00965", "filename": "P28_101_71_2ca39f2ce03a381c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (before 1.1 seconds, the bag opening is a zipper with the zipper in the middle and the right side of the bag opening is open; after 1.1 seconds, the zipper on the bag opening changes to a zippered plastic bag, and the bag opening is completely sealed).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00966", "filename": "P28_103_89_68d7463d48ff663e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.1s in the video, the garlic-like part in the box suddenly turns into a vegetable-like stem; between 6s and 6s, a frameless eyepiece suddenly appears in the lower left corner of the video.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00967", "filename": "P28_103_110_63826acbd81990eb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (at 2.5s and 2.9s-3.1s, the right hand and the knife exhibit a clipping phenomenon, which violates the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00968", "filename": "P28_103_167_3e0155f58922a695_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00969", "filename": "P28_104_122_cf46d20729cfd17e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (at 2:12 in the video, steam was initially escaping from the lower left corner of the pot, but suddenly disappeared).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00970", "filename": "P28_104_157_2b4e91772ff24ffd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is continuous (before 0.6s, the lid is not fully closed, the pot is already boiling, but no steam is coming out; from 0.9s to 1.3s, the lid is open and steam should be coming out of the pot, but it is coming out of the lid in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00971", "filename": "P28_105_40_3937ab210964d78f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.7s and 4.4s in the video, the white object next to the right moves on its own without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00972", "filename": "P28_108_12_251b33eb3df1c4ed_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Continuous timing (at 6.3 seconds, water suddenly starts flowing from the faucet even though the valve is not turned on. At 3.1 seconds, the dumplings that were about to be placed in the filter basin suddenly disappear).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00973", "filename": "P28_110_7_ff771de3fd9dd785_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 5s in the video, two black dots suddenly appear above the washing machine drum above the hand; at 5.2s, the two black dots turn into two black lines.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00974", "filename": "P28_111_141_a35a50549f9f19ce_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 1.7s in the video, the white towel and the cabinet handle appear to be clipping through each other; from 1.7s to 2s, the white towel should be in free fall without any external force, but in the video it appears to be in projectile motion with an initial horizontal velocity.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00975", "filename": "P28_111_149_9b1c75e5c4373002_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Continuous timing (Throughout the video, water from the tap continuously flows into the bowl, but the water level does not rise. At 4.5 seconds, water from the tap hits the person's right hand, but no splashing occurs.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00976", "filename": "P28_111_153_18a42a9a3fe5e1d0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (throughout the video, water from the faucet flows into a metal basin some distance away and comes into contact with the water inside, but no water splashes).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00977", "filename": "P28_111_156_c7b321445f9c0ba7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 5.2s to 6.8s in the video, the water from the tap hits the edge of the pot without making a splash).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00978", "filename": "P28_111_203_d618853c86d2dd86_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (at 5.7 seconds in the video, an unsealed bag containing powdery solids falls to the ground at waist level from an adult, but no powder spills out).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00979", "filename": "P28_112_72_62383abf9f0ad657_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 0.9s in the video, the garlic-shaped object on the right is suspended in mid-air on the table due to insufficient support, seemingly levitating without gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00980", "filename": "P28_112_77_7019cea5689c7299_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.1s in the video, the spoon-like object in the hand suddenly disappears, and at 2s, the two steel wool balls suddenly merge into one steel wool ball).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00981", "filename": "P28_113_39_5fa7de5f25fdbe1c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (in the video, the spoon initially touched by the right hand suddenly turns into a fork at 0.3s, and the cabinet containing cutlery closes automatically between 4.3s and 7.9s without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00982", "filename": "P28_113_133_94d6927c4fbaea03_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time frame is continuous (5.8s-7.5s, the lid of the trash can, which was opened by hand, remains stationary without any external support).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00983", "filename": "P30_101_80_776e34df3a648981_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 0.8s in the video, water from the faucet automatically gushed out without any operation; from 1s to 8s, the water from the faucet poured into the water below at a certain height without making any splashes).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00984", "filename": "P30_101_107_ac583877b61829d1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows a continuous sequence of events (at 1.6s, the yellow cylindrical lid suddenly transforms into a hemispherical lid; at 5.8s, a handle suddenly appears at the bottom of the lid; and at 6.7s, a white, strip-like object resembling melted vermicelli suddenly appears on the left hand).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_00985", "filename": "P30_101_155_1b0aa6d278a61699_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_00986", "filename": "P30_104_123_2558b753a121f4b6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows a continuous sequence of events (from 0.4s to 6s, the water from the faucet splashes onto the surface of the cup without creating any splashes; at 7.3s, the dishwashing sponge on the right hand suddenly disappears, only to reappear in the palm of the right hand at 7.7s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00987", "filename": "P30_104_136_bb9070f93f1559c4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (During the process of wiping the apple, the left thumb's behavior is extremely awkward, maintaining the same posture throughout, completely freezing the functional actions of \"pinching\" or \"pressing\". In a real wiping scenario, the thumb usually plays the role of assisting in applying force or stabilizing the object, and will produce natural undulations with the rhythm.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00988", "filename": "P30_107_86_4efe6c9bedeb2444_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 4.6s in the video, the plate in the hand is suspended in mid-air without any external support.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00989", "filename": "P30_107_96_e4fb6c0295cad84e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (at 4.7s in the video, the left thumb and the knob on the lid are clipped through each other).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_00990", "filename": "P30_107_214_221a127e894ab1ce_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows a continuity error: (At 3.5s, a single leaf in the hand splits into two leaves; at 6.1s, a leaf suddenly appears at the tip of the left middle finger.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00991", "filename": "764c8212d82f3277d1fa5c92e357d50eb8c1e59ddd6616d9ad0a370fb0b27851_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the smoke produced by the sparkler burning throughout the video follows the pattern of incense smoke slowly drifting upwards, violating the characteristics of smoke diffusion and the laws of fluid motion) Time continuity (a flash suddenly appears in the upper right corner at 3.3 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00992", "filename": "764c8212d82f3277d1fa5c92e357d50eb8c1e59ddd6616d9ad0a370fb0b27851_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the large amount of smoke produced by the burning sparkler throughout the process, which gushed out from one end, violated the natural randomness of gas diffusion; the sparkler continued to burn throughout the process, but the lower part remained unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00996", "filename": "782e6e58e25be1b76c2e560b5805954ccb633aa91e0ad4a2fa8aba4a31f46a29_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (0.4s-5s: train carriages suddenly appear behind the train and continue to increase in number; 2.1s-3.6s: the train engine remains stationary; 3.6s-5s: the train moves backward).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_00997", "filename": "782e6e58e25be1b76c2e560b5805954ccb633aa91e0ad4a2fa8aba4a31f46a29_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video content: Physical behavior (throughout the entire video, the train engine only continuously emitted thick white smoke, and the shape of the smoke did not change).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00998", "filename": "782e6e58e25be1b76c2e560b5805954ccb633aa91e0ad4a2fa8aba4a31f46a29_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time frame is continuous (from 2s to 5s, where the train engine is emitting white smoke, some of the white smoke suddenly turns into blue gas).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_00999", "filename": "783c546b0a8f2cee4db849f439b6e370a429949cb0e3f3db1cfec68f5bf3d386_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (bubbles are constantly being generated inside the ice cube throughout the video, violating the physical properties of ice) Time continuity (1s-2.5s, the small ice cube on the table gradually dissipates and is suddenly swallowed by the large ice cube).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01000", "filename": "783c546b0a8f2cee4db849f439b6e370a429949cb0e3f3db1cfec68f5bf3d386_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The time sequence is continuous (the ice cubes suddenly increase in size and change from their original form to slush, then to liquid, and finally disappear throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01001", "filename": "783c546b0a8f2cee4db849f439b6e370a429949cb0e3f3db1cfec68f5bf3d386_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0.3s-0.5s: a transparent ice cube suddenly turns into a white object).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01002", "filename": "787f1720704d6e68f8b321f464428e2e147ddfb08ac74811cf9480f51e729f2c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video content: Physical behavior (the butter is being heated throughout the video, but it remains in its initial state).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01003", "filename": "787f1720704d6e68f8b321f464428e2e147ddfb08ac74811cf9480f51e729f2c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (3.4s-4.2s: the butter moves rapidly from the left side of the pan to the right side without being subjected to external force, violating the basic laws of mechanics; 4.2s-5.1s: the butter melts rapidly until it disappears, but the volume of oil in the pan does not increase).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01004", "filename": "788b81550b1fc6db7ac40bb9375e9295fedea3bf51ce5847584d0ee17ac0d3db_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the bubbles gradually elongate and thin out on the swaying water surface without bursting, which violates the physical properties of bubbles).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01005", "filename": "788b81550b1fc6db7ac40bb9375e9295fedea3bf51ce5847584d0ee17ac0d3db_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: throughout the video, the bubbles are constantly moving without creating any ripples on the water surface; the bubbles gradually elongate and thin on the swaying water surface without bursting, which violates the physical properties of bubbles.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01006", "filename": "788b81550b1fc6db7ac40bb9375e9295fedea3bf51ce5847584d0ee17ac0d3db_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the bubbles gradually elongate and thin on the swaying water surface without breaking, violating the physical properties of bubbles).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01007", "filename": "788b81550b1fc6db7ac40bb9375e9295fedea3bf51ce5847584d0ee17ac0d3db_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time sequence (left ribbon suddenly disappears at 2s, right ribbon suddenly becomes two at 2.8s, right ribbon disappears at 6.3s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01008", "filename": "790aa1ee3590b7af4886e9408b214b99e48ea13dafce837b04909f64181a700d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the ripples caused by the turbine on the water surface are always twisted, which violates the natural propagation logic of water ripples under turbine disturbance; the boat moves forward throughout the video while the surrounding scenery remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01009", "filename": "790aa1ee3590b7af4886e9408b214b99e48ea13dafce837b04909f64181a700d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the boat moves forward throughout the video while the surrounding scenery remains unchanged; the water ripples caused by the boat's movement change from dense to sparse).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01010", "filename": "790aa1ee3590b7af4886e9408b214b99e48ea13dafce837b04909f64181a700d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01011", "filename": "790aa1ee3590b7af4886e9408b214b99e48ea13dafce837b04909f64181a700d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (1s-8s, the lower middle part of the hull disappears out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01012", "filename": "801e7319dacbc25d091c1050f3e2267324c8ec402eb0567177f553a13a1e741b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly due to physical effects (the clouds move very quickly over time throughout the video, while the color of the sky remains unchanged, which violates the correlation between atmospheric optics and cloud movement).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01013", "filename": "801e7319dacbc25d091c1050f3e2267324c8ec402eb0567177f553a13a1e741b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video exhibits anomalies due to physical behavior (the clouds and mist near the mountains rotate around them and gradually disappear throughout the video, violating the natural laws of atmospheric fluid movement and cloud dissipation) and continuous time (the sky color changes from gray to blue from 1.8s to 3.5s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01014", "filename": "801e7319dacbc25d091c1050f3e2267324c8ec402eb0567177f553a13a1e741b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (3.5s-5s: the clouds on the right suddenly split to reveal the blue sky, but the surrounding environment color did not change).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01015", "filename": "805d445525769371c4310bbc0354edb13c665b558cc5bbffeae41353310f0759_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the clouds constantly move, but the light is never obscured and remains directly overhead without any change in brightness; sunlight shines on the ground from the sky, but the ground's brightness does not change).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01016", "filename": "805d445525769371c4310bbc0354edb13c665b558cc5bbffeae41353310f0759_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual experience is off (the motion is too smooth and doesn't look realistic).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01017", "filename": "805d445525769371c4310bbc0354edb13c665b558cc5bbffeae41353310f0759_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01018", "filename": "805d445525769371c4310bbc0354edb13c665b558cc5bbffeae41353310f0759_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time interval is continuous (3.8s-6.4s, the clouds in the upper right corner of the screen suddenly turn orange-red).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01019", "filename": "806be68d232d662b30e4d95b8033d1d0d0d7c196db5a0b88a271febb56dbfbfe_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The screen display is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0s, the light around the light tube suddenly increases; from 2s to 5s, the object at the top of the screen is constantly shaking while the surrounding objects remain stationary).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01020", "filename": "806be68d232d662b30e4d95b8033d1d0d0d7c196db5a0b88a271febb56dbfbfe_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (the light brightness suddenly increases at 0.4s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01021", "filename": "b11bc716e21c8fcf8a886ab805e1ec2ccb302de35cf1d169f2fd9e3dadbe32f3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 0.1s, the book in the background collapses on its own without being subjected to external force or interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01022", "filename": "b11bc716e21c8fcf8a886ab805e1ec2ccb302de35cf1d169f2fd9e3dadbe32f3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 0.9s, the third book on the right automatically flips to the left without being affected by external force or interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01023", "filename": "b11bc716e21c8fcf8a886ab805e1ec2ccb302de35cf1d169f2fd9e3dadbe32f3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 3.2 seconds, the third book on the right flips over on its own before being touched by the book next to it).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01024", "filename": "b11bc716e21c8fcf8a886ab805e1ec2ccb302de35cf1d169f2fd9e3dadbe32f3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 1.8 seconds, the wooden board behind the book disappears out of thin air without any camera cut).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01025", "filename": "b11cd35579431784836492c532e72d0ef31fcceb0174b8b00a6c0d6ddce7a1b5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera cuts, at 1.4 seconds, the red popsicle melts, and a large puddle of pink liquid flows out from the bottom out of nowhere, spreading at an abnormally fast speed.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01026", "filename": "b11cd35579431784836492c532e72d0ef31fcceb0174b8b00a6c0d6ddce7a1b5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Cause and effect (the popsicle melts into a large pool of red liquid at 2.4 seconds, and the red liquid far exceeds the volume and mass of the popsicle itself).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01027", "filename": "b11cd35579431784836492c532e72d0ef31fcceb0174b8b00a6c0d6ddce7a1b5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the red liquid that melted from the bottom of the popsicle suddenly expands rapidly at 3.6 seconds, forming a large puddle of water that is much larger than the popsicle in just a few seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01028", "filename": "b20d61e9b0ee85dab9e5735d7c568cf08c3a21b72b07b00baf22a3b189084283_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (just as the ice cream is about to melt and release more chocolate, the screen immediately jumps back to the initial state; the entire melting process resets every 3.5 seconds, continuously looping.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01029", "filename": "b20d61e9b0ee85dab9e5735d7c568cf08c3a21b72b07b00baf22a3b189084283_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (without speeding up the video, the melting liquid from the popsicle does not drip or flow naturally, but instead flows down the surface of the popsicle in a perfectly straight and uniform line, without any irregular spread, as if it is in a fixed shape).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01030", "filename": "b20d61e9b0ee85dab9e5735d7c568cf08c3a21b72b07b00baf22a3b189084283_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01031", "filename": "b20d61e9b0ee85dab9e5735d7c568cf08c3a21b72b07b00baf22a3b189084283_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the chocolate melts too quickly without video acceleration or external interference).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01032", "filename": "b26bc26eb97157c36f84415c3c8c44095d2bc1e32b53743ed78be240d50ab709_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (during the period from 3s to 4.5s, the streetlight moved to the left on its own without being disturbed by external forces or objects).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01033", "filename": "b26bc26eb97157c36f84415c3c8c44095d2bc1e32b53743ed78be240d50ab709_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01034", "filename": "b26bc26eb97157c36f84415c3c8c44095d2bc1e32b53743ed78be240d50ab709_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (the streetlights in the footage from 1.4s to 2.7s move upwards on their own without being disturbed by external objects or forces).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01035", "filename": "b26bc26eb97157c36f84415c3c8c44095d2bc1e32b53743ed78be240d50ab709_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01036", "filename": "b28ad7ec1118dfdc23fb1de42ab5b1c705ac6e8318ac5074e539e5298395f345_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01037", "filename": "b28ad7ec1118dfdc23fb1de42ab5b1c705ac6e8318ac5074e539e5298395f345_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 2.7s, without any camera cuts or fog, stars suddenly appear in the upper left of the sky).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01038", "filename": "b28ad7ec1118dfdc23fb1de42ab5b1c705ac6e8318ac5074e539e5298395f345_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the trajectory of the Mars in the video is too consistent; the height, speed, and arc of each Mars are all like a copy and paste, lacking the random drifting feeling of real Mars).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01039", "filename": "b28ad7ec1118dfdc23fb1de42ab5b1c705ac6e8318ac5074e539e5298395f345_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 4.6s, without any camera cuts or fog, a starry sky appears out of nowhere in the upper left corner of the screen).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01040", "filename": "b44c3d20ca9b926d1d17ed3d97eeb033ab7464c7f37affc7fec91387eee59c64_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 2.4s, without external force or interference, the wooden block in the lower left corner of the screen moves to the right on its own).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01041", "filename": "b44c3d20ca9b926d1d17ed3d97eeb033ab7464c7f37affc7fec91387eee59c64_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (Under the premise of no video speed-up, normal day-night transitions require time, but the video has no gradual transition, jumping from day to night instantly).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01042", "filename": "b72e11a03fd86f1c10f2ca80a07ea71f361a67b77f8897ca4fcd6768d913f92d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera cut at 1.7s, the smoke on the left side of the screen disappears out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01043", "filename": "b72e11a03fd86f1c10f2ca80a07ea71f361a67b77f8897ca4fcd6768d913f92d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01044", "filename": "b72e11a03fd86f1c10f2ca80a07ea71f361a67b77f8897ca4fcd6768d913f92d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (The ripples on the lake surface do not spread according to the normal flow of water, but instead seem to be controlled by an invisible force, resulting in an unnatural distortion that is completely different from the texture of real water surface ripples.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01045", "filename": "b72e11a03fd86f1c10f2ca80a07ea71f361a67b77f8897ca4fcd6768d913f92d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time is continuous (the lake surface does not undulate and spread normally, but instead seems to be controlled by an invisible force, and the whole thing is unnaturally twisting and writhing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01046", "filename": "b75e10c9631abee900800a9f0167eaa1c3d60804811eb8348441438cc932f0e2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.7s, the clouds and light in the lower half of the image suddenly freeze, no longer moving with the clouds in the upper half).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01047", "filename": "b75e10c9631abee900800a9f0167eaa1c3d60804811eb8348441438cc932f0e2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without camera movement, at 2.5s, the sun in the upper left corner disappears from the right side out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01048", "filename": "b75e10c9631abee900800a9f0167eaa1c3d60804811eb8348441438cc932f0e2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time discontinuity (the clouds in the scene do not drift naturally, but twist in place, and the edges will suddenly deform or teleport, like a texture that is not properly attached and skips frames)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01049", "filename": "b75e609eab9523c5c1bcbe169316a45e6b741ae24faec7db7a45459a744383d8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 2.5s, the diamond on the right side of the screen moves downwards on its own without any force or external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01050", "filename": "b75e609eab9523c5c1bcbe169316a45e6b741ae24faec7db7a45459a744383d8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.4s, the diamond in the upper left corner, without any external force contact, suddenly rotates 180 degrees rapidly, and while still rotating, an unexpected transparent cutout effect appears.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01051", "filename": "9d889f6b73df1cdedca2c11484db42c98a8875a625c061b19542a1e4da9ef33e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (the water droplet falling at 3.8s is spherical, whereas in real life, water droplets should be shaped like lifebuoys, and spherical droplets should only appear when the droplet is suspended in the air).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01052", "filename": "9d889f6b73df1cdedca2c11484db42c98a8875a625c061b19542a1e4da9ef33e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 3.6s, the water droplets fall on the flower but do not explode); Overall realism is abnormal (at 4.9s, the water droplets falling on the flower create the effect of a single droplet falling on the water surface, and the petals change from a curved shape to an upright shape).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01053", "filename": "9d8523651d0cd0173f0585c29a237fcaf27d6e37207e6aad79d75053077514a1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (the liquid dripping into the cup in the video does not cause the liquid level to rise).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01055", "filename": "9d8523651d0cd0173f0585c29a237fcaf27d6e37207e6aad79d75053077514a1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (smoke suddenly appears above the cup at 0.4s and disappears abruptly at 7.2s); Physical behavior (liquid continuously flows into the cup from 5.3s to the end, but the liquid content in the cup does not increase).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01056", "filename": "9dc770e0dfd55c3d20580c4aa1648ff47b510efdc2f56c3c3f21e88799371902_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is continuous (the reeds on the left side of the video appear to twist as they sway in the wind).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01057", "filename": "9ddd0e35f04ca2a80ee84bbf1c7e9b0fe44a75c40918638b029a7774799e82f4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the video, the ice block moves slowly to the left and then slowly to the right under the influence of gravity alone. In reality, ice blocks can only move when subjected to force, or when the basin has a tilted surface that allows the ice to move after it begins to melt.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01058", "filename": "9ddd0e35f04ca2a80ee84bbf1c7e9b0fe44a75c40918638b029a7774799e82f4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a large amount of water appears in the basin at 2.7s, and all the ice disappears between 3.7s and 4.6s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01059", "filename": "9ddfcb0496cad80f8d6de81681ca31c90742ea83925c75489f6ce08ac7d8bc47_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video content: Physical behavior (the liquid in the pot is constantly boiling throughout the video, but no steam appears above the pot).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01060", "filename": "9ddfcb0496cad80f8d6de81681ca31c90742ea83925c75489f6ce08ac7d8bc47_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (from the beginning to 0.4s, the liquid in the pot changes from a pale yellow to a transparent liquid, and at 3.6s, the liquid in the pot only boils and water vapor begins to appear).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01061", "filename": "9ddfcb0496cad80f8d6de81681ca31c90742ea83925c75489f6ce08ac7d8bc47_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are inconsistent: the timing is unpredictable (steam only starts appearing above the pot at 3.6 seconds); the overall realism is off (the liquid in the pot is boiling from the beginning to 3.6 seconds but no steam is being produced).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01062", "filename": "9decbc62bd7bb91dc024123ae018e3a5229db450ec71ad91ee6c16dbcbf2087a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (the distribution of light from the sky is too uniform and unnatural throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01063", "filename": "9decbc62bd7bb91dc024123ae018e3a5229db450ec71ad91ee6c16dbcbf2087a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.6s, a bird suddenly appears on the left side where there was no bird before, and at 1.8s, the bird that was still in the left side of the screen suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01064", "filename": "9decbc62bd7bb91dc024123ae018e3a5229db450ec71ad91ee6c16dbcbf2087a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (the lighting in the sky during the camera's rightward movement is very regular and unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01065", "filename": "9decbc62bd7bb91dc024123ae018e3a5229db450ec71ad91ee6c16dbcbf2087a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall realism is abnormal (before 1.6s, the birds in the air are small dots without wings, etc., and after 1.6s, the bird shapes begin to appear); Time continuity (birds in the flock continuously distort and suddenly disappear).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01069", "filename": "9e5b380704acf28b17d309c262015655adb6e5e3b2c3c98ab3935daa15aa2d1f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (the smoke above the cup is tilted to the right on the left, but the right half is always vertically upward).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01070", "filename": "9e5b380704acf28b17d309c262015655adb6e5e3b2c3c98ab3935daa15aa2d1f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01072", "filename": "9e5dd44606406abe9588eaad054a14349d680d6b6e3df0db248d482f46a63c1c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the overall realism is abnormal (two cloud layers appear in the video; the lower cloud layer is too thick, uniform and smooth, and the edges of the cloud layer lack natural texture, creating a strong and unnatural sense of fragmentation compared to the upper cloud layer).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01073", "filename": "9e5dd44606406abe9588eaad054a14349d680d6b6e3df0db248d482f46a63c1c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (in the video, the clouds below light up at 0.4s, while the clouds above light up at 2.8s. In real life, the clouds above should light up first).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01074", "filename": "9e5dd44606406abe9588eaad054a14349d680d6b6e3df0db248d482f46a63c1c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the clouds above moving rapidly to the left while the clouds below remain stationary in the same space is highly illogical); Overall realism is abnormal (the clouds below are thick and flat, lacking the realism of natural clouds).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01075", "filename": "9eb3dbb41bfde84e65ae163b5e3b5e6e5fd91f6551003e5283480813e2d3a505_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the cardboard cup in the video continues to burn, but the shape and size of the cardboard do not change; the flames do not spread when the cardboard burns).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01076", "filename": "9eb3dbb41bfde84e65ae163b5e3b5e6e5fd91f6551003e5283480813e2d3a505_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the overall realism is abnormal (the flames did not spread when the cardboard was burning, but the cardboard turned charred and its shape did not change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01077", "filename": "9eb3dbb41bfde84e65ae163b5e3b5e6e5fd91f6551003e5283480813e2d3a505_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the overall realism is abnormal (the flames did not spread when the cardboard burned in the video; it only deformed but did not change size).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01078", "filename": "9eb3dbb41bfde84e65ae163b5e3b5e6e5fd91f6551003e5283480813e2d3a505_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the cardboard in the video burns but its shape does not change during the period from the start to 2.6s); Overall realism is abnormal (a large amount of ash suddenly appears in the middle of the burning cardboard at 6.2s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01079", "filename": "9eb36c5f235fe5ec139050303e4b9380b7bc1760b8b7c635da687a2d49d50256_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (the firewood is lit in the video, but no burn marks are produced during the burning process).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01080", "filename": "9eb36c5f235fe5ec139050303e4b9380b7bc1760b8b7c635da687a2d49d50256_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (at 1.7s, the flames in the video suddenly grow larger, and the firewood on the far right of the fire shows no signs of burning during the burning process).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01081", "filename": "P30_107_497_25b746c75244880a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (At 5.9s, a white object suddenly appears on the left hand, which is illogical).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01082", "filename": "P30_107_642_3e6884258e38269b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01083", "filename": "P30_107_691_8884d85c528480a3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the meat in the pot on the right keeps flashing and jumping, but meat in a hot pot will not show any light spots or jumping).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01084", "filename": "P30_107_715_7dbe8d0d68775444_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the water from the faucet is flowing into the sink throughout the entire segment, yet the surface remains perfectly still and calm, without any splashes or ripples). Physical behavior (at 7.1 seconds, the left hand is holding a tilted bowl with the thumb as the point of greatest force; when the thumb is suddenly released, the bowl does not fall into the sink).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01085", "filename": "P30_107_731_9f5c3b8089220f4e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The hand holding the sponge in the continuous 3.6s-end scene is too stiff and uncoordinated, and the pink sponge in the lower right corner of the water tank is wriggling and flashing throughout the entire segment.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01086", "filename": "P30_107_745_4135eb23726394d0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the food in the pot on the left flickers and shakes without external interference) Physical behavior (in the 6.6s-7.6s frame, the spoon, which should fall downwards due to inertia, appears to be stuck to the pot and lying flat, which does not conform to the law of gravity)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01087", "filename": "P30_107_813_538d8e8cce74b642_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01088", "filename": "P30_108_28_daedb9a67e92b52d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (clipping issue: at 0.6s, the right hand passes through the strainer, and from 0.6s to 4.3s, the outline of the strainer part wiped disappears; at 4.9s, the strainer hole disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01089", "filename": "P30_108_46_ff0737b715b37ac8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (4.1s: The pot handle is held in the hand, and as the movement changes, the pot handle with holes in the hand turns into a black wooden stick without holes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01090", "filename": "P30_108_110_28d16962eb3583b2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Timing continuity (the oil stain on the plate suddenly disappears at 0.9s without being touched by a towel, and reappears at 2.1s after being wiped).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01091", "filename": "P30_109_94_b4cbb57feef6db6e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (a white patch appears at the rim of the cup at 6.3s, and the reflection of the steel frame next to the black bracelet on the left hand is distorted at 5.7s); Physical behavior (water continues to flow into the sink without any change in the water level).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01092", "filename": "P30_109_132_9567ae7876caaad3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Continuous timing (at 6.6s, the trash can suddenly opens without any external force); Physical behavior (at 6.1s, the tissue on the trash can lid falls into the trash bag without any external force, which violates the laws of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01093", "filename": "P30_111_219_d288aee4bb34c84b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: The continuity of time is abnormal (the food in the pot and the objects on the counter are flickering in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01094", "filename": "P30_111_251_5de5056b0021782f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The walls in the video are flickering.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01095", "filename": "P30_111_283_b290c5e3f6f83143_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: causal relationship is illogical (the refrigerator door suddenly opens outwards at 0.2s without external force); time continuity is abnormal (the condiment bottles on the countertop and the food in the refrigerator are flashing in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01096", "filename": "P30_111_343_7de5c8132d98879a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a transparent glass appears out of thin air in the left hand at 0.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01097", "filename": "P30_111_460_55d6cbff38012c7d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (the food on the cutting board and the condiment bottles on the counter are flashing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01098", "filename": "P30_111_461_e8a59446c08f9002_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Causality (1.2s: yellow fruit pieces fall into the plate and disappear into thin air; 1.3s: a small fruit piece appears out of thin air on the food); Temporal continuity anomalies (the pizza is flashing in the video); Temporal continuity (at 0.1s: the video suddenly switches to the next scene without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01099", "filename": "P30_111_499_0efa292a70f6c67c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity error (the pizza in the image is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01100", "filename": "P30_111_608_001bcd37e12fccbc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the screen flickers, the trash swept into the funnel disappears at 6.2s, and a black object suddenly appears on the ground at 3.4s; the ground in the screen is flashing)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01101", "filename": "P30_111_624_ebcab3aab38c3f33_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the cutting board has an extra handle hole at 6.1s) and physical behavior anomalies (the cutting board is designed to pass directly through the water pipe at 2.6s, violating the impermeability of solids; at 6.1s, the hand does not touch the cutting board, yet the cutting board is still moving in the air without external force, violating the law of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01102", "filename": "P30_113_141_414e10217a988652_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 4.6s, the scene that was originally a sink suddenly changed to a cabinet, and there was no natural transition between the two scenes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01103", "filename": "P35_101_1_ba53c1fdaefd68b0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity issue (the entire screen flickers).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01104", "filename": "P35_101_22_2e54cbdbae5d56fd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (6.4s: a plastic strip suddenly appears before the left hand has finished cutting the packaging bag); Time continuity anomalies (between 0.4s and 1.8s, the action of the scissors cutting the bag is repeated; a purple object flashes during the process of the scissors cutting the packaging bag).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01105", "filename": "P35_103_20_fc675112a2fde06b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity error (white grid-like objects are flashing in the image).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01106", "filename": "P35_103_233_6f6ceeb2ca1083f0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity error (the entire countertop and water pipe connections in the image are flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01107", "filename": "P35_103_235_4183a2599a052d53_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity error (the towel and the plastic pipe of the water pipe connector are flashing in the image).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01108", "filename": "P35_103_236_4260abb27a75bf01_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (flickering occurs on the ground, tabletop, and surface of the red box in the image).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01109", "filename": "P35_104_97_23916bbd635f3922_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01110", "filename": "P35_104_102_65d74300562d0ed0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (the surface of the blue plastic box on the ground and table in the image is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01111", "filename": "806be68d232d662b30e4d95b8033d1d0d0d7c196db5a0b88a271febb56dbfbfe_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 3.1s to 3.6s, the object on the right side of the screen rotates automatically without being subjected to any force, violating the basic laws of mechanics).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01112", "filename": "806be68d232d662b30e4d95b8033d1d0d0d7c196db5a0b88a271febb56dbfbfe_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the button on the right-hand item suddenly disappears at 1.7s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01113", "filename": "824baa26bc86e7ce72dd9fa55a5bbb88fd63d5bf0e9c5086ea1e37bcc835c9ab_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the popsicle melts but its volume does not decrease, violating the rules of matter transformation).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01114", "filename": "824baa26bc86e7ce72dd9fa55a5bbb88fd63d5bf0e9c5086ea1e37bcc835c9ab_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the popsicle melts too quickly, and the melted liquid has the texture of flowing honey, and it continues to increase even after it has completely melted, violating the law of conservation of matter and the characteristics of changes of state).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01115", "filename": "824baa26bc86e7ce72dd9fa55a5bbb88fd63d5bf0e9c5086ea1e37bcc835c9ab_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the liquid from the melting popsicle in the entire video flows slowly like quicksand, violating the properties of phase change).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01116", "filename": "824baa26bc86e7ce72dd9fa55a5bbb88fd63d5bf0e9c5086ea1e37bcc835c9ab_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the popsicle automatically flies up and falls without any external force from 0.20ss to 6.6s, violating the law of gravity)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01117", "filename": "835d532991a8031a0533503ca968b5a87b3bb6cb4ea6bee7d04b11b1fd693dee_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall impression is off (there is no clear direction of light source, nor are there bright and dark areas, making it unrealistic).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01118", "filename": "835d532991a8031a0533503ca968b5a87b3bb6cb4ea6bee7d04b11b1fd693dee_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (in the entire video, the area illuminated by the lights shows a sudden change in the density of drizzle from dense to sparse within a short period of time, which violates the natural pattern of precipitation intensity change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01119", "filename": "835d532991a8031a0533503ca968b5a87b3bb6cb4ea6bee7d04b11b1fd693dee_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01120", "filename": "842ca2b030111a455a5c5da2aac06e59923b824427dd1e3dbea8d4236a86d169_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the bubbles in the image are too crystal clear, the colors are too saturated, and the surrounding environment is too dark, making it appear unrealistic).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01121", "filename": "842ca2b030111a455a5c5da2aac06e59923b824427dd1e3dbea8d4236a86d169_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the surface of the bubble changes abruptly from wrinkled to smooth in the 0s-1.8s video)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01122", "filename": "842ca2b030111a455a5c5da2aac06e59923b824427dd1e3dbea8d4236a86d169_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the surface of the bubble changes abruptly from wrinkled to smooth in the 0s-1.2s video, violating the mechanical and morphological change logic of the bubble film).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01123", "filename": "842ca2b030111a455a5c5da2aac06e59923b824427dd1e3dbea8d4236a86d169_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (1.7s-2.8s, the bubble abruptly changes from its irregular state to a spherical state).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01124", "filename": "844ab69c55cf393e7312686ec57f66ffb4125daa91c43c95ae1ef96026951a53_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (2.9s-5s) The bowl rotates left and right without any external force, which does not conform to the law of interaction of forces; the bowl is shaken throughout the video, but the liquid flowing out of the broken glutinous rice balls inside the bowl does not show any flow.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01125", "filename": "844ab69c55cf393e7312686ec57f66ffb4125daa91c43c95ae1ef96026951a53_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (the bowl rotates left and right without any external force throughout the video, which does not conform to the law of interaction of forces; and the liquid flowing out of the broken glutinous rice ball in the bowl remains still without flowing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01126", "filename": "844ab69c55cf393e7312686ec57f66ffb4125daa91c43c95ae1ef96026951a53_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0.9s-1.4s, all the glutinous rice balls in the bowl shrink simultaneously).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01127", "filename": "844ab69c55cf393e7312686ec57f66ffb4125daa91c43c95ae1ef96026951a53_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (0.8s, a purple glutinous rice ball suddenly falls from the top of the video screen; 2.3s-4.5s, two red glutinous rice balls fall out of thin air; 1.5s-2.3s, the white object in the plate suddenly disappears after the red object falls).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01128", "filename": "863a3291ea37a15f08a2f3607e4457f3f9d1020bb5105935975fa5e9212aa011_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the iron rod did not touch the chestnut, but the chestnut flipped in mid-air on its own, which violated the basic logic of force and motion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01129", "filename": "863a3291ea37a15f08a2f3607e4457f3f9d1020bb5105935975fa5e9212aa011_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (0s-0.7s, chestnuts flipping over on their own without being subjected to external force, violating the basic logic of force and motion) Time continuity (at 5.1s, the number of chestnuts in the plate suddenly increases)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01130", "filename": "863a3291ea37a15f08a2f3607e4457f3f9d1020bb5105935975fa5e9212aa011_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (throughout the video, chestnuts that were not touched by the shovel were all receiving heat but remained stationary).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01131", "filename": "863a3291ea37a15f08a2f3607e4457f3f9d1020bb5105935975fa5e9212aa011_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time intervals are continuous (from 5.9s to 6.1s, the chestnut in the upper left corner of the screen suddenly disappears; from 7s to 7.3s, the chestnut in the lower left corner of the screen suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01132", "filename": "864d8e74a9c374df06624de4eadb662321e8731a09885573f0c8cf891e6394a0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (0.3s-0.7 seconds) The volcano eruption site, which is currently experiencing flowing lava, remains stationary.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01133", "filename": "864d8e74a9c374df06624de4eadb662321e8731a09885573f0c8cf891e6394a0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the lava flowing from the volcanic vent in the entire video flows as fast as water, which violates the material properties of lava and the logic of natural flow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01134", "filename": "864d8e74a9c374df06624de4eadb662321e8731a09885573f0c8cf891e6394a0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01135", "filename": "864d8e74a9c374df06624de4eadb662321e8731a09885573f0c8cf891e6394a0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (the mushroom cloud that would normally appear during an explosion suddenly appears between 5.6s and 8s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01136", "filename": "869a831655f2acfba8a54c6f7c5dd93123352085a6d723439cde533de54699ba_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the aurora in the sky is only a single shade of cyan throughout the video, which violates the physical characteristics of aurora color formation) and temporal continuity (the leaves on the right side sway too regularly throughout the entire segment).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01137", "filename": "869a831655f2acfba8a54c6f7c5dd93123352085a6d723439cde533de54699ba_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: temporal continuity (the sky suddenly turns dark blue at 2.8s) and physical behavior (the aurora changes continuously throughout the video, but the plants on the right remain stationary).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01138", "filename": "869a831655f2acfba8a54c6f7c5dd93123352085a6d723439cde533de54699ba_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the aurora is constantly changing throughout the video, but the plants on the right remain stationary).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01139", "filename": "869a831655f2acfba8a54c6f7c5dd93123352085a6d723439cde533de54699ba_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the aurora in the entire video moves and changes rapidly like a ribbon being blown by the wind, which violates the natural characteristics of the dynamic changes of the aurora).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01140", "filename": "869c04540e880d31112f9a5976def470df0d71fc2db05186fd378cf285af145b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 3s, the cylinder composed of the silver spheres on the left suddenly shifted without any force acting on it).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01141", "filename": "b75e609eab9523c5c1bcbe169316a45e6b741ae24faec7db7a45459a744383d8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 2.6 seconds, the object in the lower left corner of the screen disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01142", "filename": "b76a78e0a9f8b1b36f4897ba6bc6ff13a221b4ea332cc45d219af936f09be6b8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (with the camera angle remaining unchanged, at 0.8 seconds, a hand appears out of nowhere under the car; the cactus surface is too smooth, lacking the fine lines or uneven reflections seen in reality).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01143", "filename": "b76a78e0a9f8b1b36f4897ba6bc6ff13a221b4ea332cc45d219af936f09be6b8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01144", "filename": "b76a78e0a9f8b1b36f4897ba6bc6ff13a221b4ea332cc45d219af936f09be6b8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (At 3.4 seconds, the cactus moves to the right on its own without any force or external interference).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01145", "filename": "b76a78e0a9f8b1b36f4897ba6bc6ff13a221b4ea332cc45d219af936f09be6b8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01146", "filename": "b76bcc17d3470c166d021f73e7e260aa9895c469caace67761e56cfcaec0ab71_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without moving the camera or accelerating, the lights in the footage are not as stable as real lights; instead, they appear like a paste, with the entire light cluster swaying back and forth, lacking the fixed light source feel of real lights.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01147", "filename": "b76bcc17d3470c166d021f73e7e260aa9895c469caace67761e56cfcaec0ab71_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle or speeding up the footage, the lights themselves get brighter and brighter, but the surrounding objects do not brighten accordingly).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01148", "filename": "b76bcc17d3470c166d021f73e7e260aa9895c469caace67761e56cfcaec0ab71_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the lights remain on, but the surrounding buildings and streets are not illuminated at all).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01149", "filename": "b77e3a457605fd39ea26800f8295c0909e8db39b330d1c73553a0ca3a299d2eb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time is continuous (the steam from the tea bag is going into the bowl, and without any camera movement, the tea leaves at the bottom of the tea bag disappear into thin air at 2.7 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01150", "filename": "b77e3a457605fd39ea26800f8295c0909e8db39b330d1c73553a0ca3a299d2eb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.2 seconds, after the tea bag is dropped into the cup, the liquid level rises higher than the tea bag itself).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01151", "filename": "b77e3a457605fd39ea26800f8295c0909e8db39b330d1c73553a0ca3a299d2eb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01152", "filename": "b77e3a457605fd39ea26800f8295c0909e8db39b330d1c73553a0ca3a299d2eb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: continuous time (without any camera movement, at 3.5 seconds, the boiling water in the white tea bag instantly turns yellow without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01153", "filename": "b81b42020c1b4c8dc3ca6a9a996c9ce78813ab9e115c6943868156379641a5b5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (Throughout the entire video, without any camera movement, the size of the paste-like substance in the frame fluctuates).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01154", "filename": "b81b42020c1b4c8dc3ca6a9a996c9ce78813ab9e115c6943868156379641a5b5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (between 1.2s and 3.4s, the camera does not change or accelerate; the liquid dripping from the right side of the paste spreads out immediately upon hitting the ground, forming a liquid patch much larger than the liquid itself).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01155", "filename": "b81b42020c1b4c8dc3ca6a9a996c9ce78813ab9e115c6943868156379641a5b5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the yellow liquid at the bottom of the cake does not show the natural physical process of flowing and spreading when it melts, but rather appears to jump around randomly. The shape and distribution of the liquid do not follow the motion characteristics of gravity and viscous fluids.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01156", "filename": "b81b42020c1b4c8dc3ca6a9a996c9ce78813ab9e115c6943868156379641a5b5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, at 1.6 seconds, the liquid falling from the object in the upper left corner of the frame instantly returns to the object).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01157", "filename": "b90cf9eb40fae6580a87d97c2614572d7f4ec41fae502e10faf9981d5bf863ca_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.7s, the bird in the upper right corner of the screen disappears out of thin air without the camera changing direction).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01158", "filename": "b90cf9eb40fae6580a87d97c2614572d7f4ec41fae502e10faf9981d5bf863ca_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is not continuous (the lake water lacks the weight and stability of real water, instead appearing to float gently in the air like a piece of colorful cloth being blown by the wind; the lawn resembles a green canvas with no undulations on its surface, completely lacking the layering and texture of real grass blades).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01159", "filename": "b90cf9eb40fae6580a87d97c2614572d7f4ec41fae502e10faf9981d5bf863ca_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01160", "filename": "b90cf9eb40fae6580a87d97c2614572d7f4ec41fae502e10faf9981d5bf863ca_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 2.9 seconds, the sun is completely blocked by the trees, and no light can shine directly on the lake, but the lake still has the sun's shadow on it).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01161", "filename": "b93de5d386ab1fe631e2f2e6a0b3a54b6a1b24f01ac436950bba86f17e15a20b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01162", "filename": "b93de5d386ab1fe631e2f2e6a0b3a54b6a1b24f01ac436950bba86f17e15a20b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timeline is unpredictable (the waterfall's flow is a static, looping image, lacking the sense of movement characteristic of a real waterfall).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01163", "filename": "b93de5d386ab1fe631e2f2e6a0b3a54b6a1b24f01ac436950bba86f17e15a20b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the waterfall's flow keeps repeating the same segment of the image without any natural flow changes; between 3.4s and 5.5s, the water vapor below the waterfall suddenly separates into distinct upper and lower layers, and then disappears without warning).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01164", "filename": "b93de5d386ab1fe631e2f2e6a0b3a54b6a1b24f01ac436950bba86f17e15a20b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01165", "filename": "b98ab5289ac0f7c4b1de085de61049f7abf92173557caedf6d1967275c9c7dd0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (without external force or interference, at 2.9s, the topmost colored object suddenly and rapidly rotates and twists on its own, and also illogically merges and separates from the colored layers below).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01166", "filename": "b98ab5289ac0f7c4b1de085de61049f7abf92173557caedf6d1967275c9c7dd0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, a colored object that appears like a liquid suddenly flows down and turns into a blue piece of paper).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01167", "filename": "b98ab5289ac0f7c4b1de085de61049f7abf92173557caedf6d1967275c9c7dd0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (Under the premise of no external force or interference, the fluctuation of the colored liquid is played in a loop without any change, without the natural random movement that fluids should have.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01168", "filename": "b98ab5289ac0f7c4b1de085de61049f7abf92173557caedf6d1967275c9c7dd0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing camera angles, liquid appears out of thin air in the upper left corner of the screen at 0.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01169", "filename": "b472b4589b1fc6ff384ce608715bdc54f2437663acb0fed48cbb770e21cdb461_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (Initially, the bubble surface showed a swirling flow with a purplish-blue hue. At 2.9 seconds, without any gradual transition, it jumped directly to an orange-red blocky texture. The two states were completely disconnected, lacking the continuity that fluid motion should have.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01170", "filename": "b472b4589b1fc6ff384ce608715bdc54f2437663acb0fed48cbb770e21cdb461_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 3.6s, ripples suddenly appear on the surface of the bubble, and the entire scene brightens on its own without any logical flow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01171", "filename": "63dbfdfff65a044bfde76010f50f2ed60f025ce90d72ffcfefbcfc931f291016_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (at 2s, the blue flame jumps directly into white smoke without energy decay or excessive combustion reaction, violating the law of material phase change during combustion; at 3.2s, the white smoke suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01172", "filename": "67b63e24231362ac93c11e36f99cd1703c4fc5f5c3d6187b5032c056d1017218_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (at 1.5s, the orange pattern that looks like a goldfish in the water neither swayed its body nor spread out and deformed with the water flow. Instead, it moved directly with a clear outline, which was not like a living creature swimming in water, nor like paint in water.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01175", "filename": "70a3fb395f189f81085381670514ebec6513562ba76e66f5cc52e013ec72d8bd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: The coin has stopped completely at 3s and has not been touched, yet it spontaneously begins to rotate, which does not conform to the laws of motion of objects in reality.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01176", "filename": "70c51c4d38821d07ae35b4e828b06c03a55b578d1ec4c5950c11ea68f0cf1ada_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 0.8s, the white mist on the water surface suddenly brightens without any transition, and the amount of mist on the water surface also suddenly increases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01177", "filename": "71e9e3d24d7e812b6023e02d322e8a4c915510f0af280ad126bd47b402a3f2d0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image and physical behavior are abnormal (at 1.2s, the cutting tool has not completed the cutting action, and the black material has already shown a layered effect. The material has separated on its own before the tool has even cut into it).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01178", "filename": "72f88092ebf650ad5106e16e79331583e7801eec6ab957df207d9bbca6b6c46c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall, the visual impression is off (the fireworks that exploded at 0.6 seconds looked very fake, the sparks were too neatly aligned, and they disappeared just like that, unlike real fireworks which slowly dimmed and drifted downwards).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01183", "filename": "90e0efa3905ba75e8f51423b094bcb7050a2ff73726588b71a98485f9cbc163b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Abnormal physical behavior (the lemon juice flowed out on its own without any force when the finger squeezed it at 0.5 seconds, and the juice on the oyster did not increase after it flowed onto the oyster).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01184", "filename": "90f9c9387e0289211e9fcb5b1897f4e071df182368476705c4e1ed9deb42057d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals and physical behavior are abnormal (at 1.5s, the milk level in the cup is already at the rim and appears to be full, but subsequent pouring of milk does not cause overflow or a rise in the liquid level, which violates the laws of liquid flow).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01185", "filename": "92f0c956974d402472e09f20d12fb67946c3c5a9e1fddd906d1fc66069205698_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (at 2.4s, the flow of fog undergoes an illogical jump; fog that was slowly dissipating just moments before suddenly changes shape and speed in the next frame, resulting in a disjointed time sequence and motion logic in the visuals).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01186", "filename": "096b2912c15ea8174411d7873c788b3df53faaaeeac5965488f14bbe3c0911b2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Abnormal physical behavior (at 3.1s, the hydraulic press head did not complete the pressure application action, and the pressured material had already broken, which violates the law of deformation of an object under force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01187", "filename": "0102b01bb8d99510fa5d8dfe0109580067497c67b7ff21382197978307fcb74a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 2.5s, a light purple cylinder suddenly appears on the track next to the red circular path, without any movement or placement process).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01188", "filename": "120e98d9f8ba4c27f37b551767b3e49cb3e10afea6c7f08b877224c6496b11f2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 3.2s, the grayish-white smoke on the left side of the screen suddenly and illogically turns yellowish-brown, without any color gradation or external interference transition process).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01189", "filename": "133fda5b5f13dd8da8e9f1541ea7b52457d5bc290c4931740eac14a74870f94d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: At 1.7 seconds, the white, condensed object developed structural cracks even before the hydraulic press head was fully pressurized. This violates the common sense that things only break when subjected to sufficient force.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01190", "filename": "201e0061d39bb69eadfbe19b4841053eab15d572619f04159f4627bdd2d022f2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Abnormal physical behavior (during the period from 0.7s to the end, the white lamp wall was not touched or pressed down by anything, yet it started to bend and rotate on its own, violating the common physical principle that an object not subjected to external force will remain stationary).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01191", "filename": "261d0bffa041536f94eb53981b4e0bbec439de3be6b85d49988f44e9f172feb1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Abnormal physical behavior (at 2s, the ripples generated by the water droplet at the center of the image showed an inward contraction without external force, which contradicts the normal outward propagation law of water waves).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01192", "filename": "263c50096b73bfc3a74b8baef411399ed988cea49ad467e4c2e01fafac482fc6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (at 3.9s, the purple reflective surface on the diamond suddenly jumped to the adjacent yellow facet, and without rotating with the diamond, it teleported away on its own).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01193", "filename": "328b3c9bade99c0a973aa846c21d2e30d396947c16b11df809c4fcbe880787e3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Abnormal behavior of objects (the soccer ball bounced up for the first time at 2.5 seconds, and then bounced up again at 2.9 seconds, with a height significantly exceeding the first bounce, violating the law of conservation of energy).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01194", "filename": "352ac61997187d249917cac2c15344974c610042890104cbe1a85636424d2b94_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 1.6s, the originally suspended dark brown balloon, without any external force, suddenly deformed irregularly and completely transformed into a blue halo).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01195", "filename": "0403a43eea348baedf403a1907c07639e58fd314e4f0fea2a735795624f0464c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (at 2.1s, the thumb passed through the opaque metal crystal frame without being blocked, and there was no expected change in brightness, violating the physical law that solid objects are impenetrable).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01197", "filename": "481d376ed63239b5aafbb8d335f2c04ddd880cde8cdb354b14ca109a7d1130dc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01198", "filename": "507cd81b87cd26133e6b6a6002cdf3726929abec4260e790933f5867d87eeb83_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (The warship exploded at 2.9s, but the fire and smoke from the explosion did not create outward-spreading shockwave ripples on the sea surface, nor did they impact objects on the ship's deck, violating the physical laws of explosion impact).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01199", "filename": "525c8eb9515637d25a90f2841c5d9bde0fafde2346cc56df2e27bd77b78d3db3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Temporal continuity anomaly (at 1.3s, the white golf ball in the footage suddenly turns into a small blue ball and rolls onto the water surface without any external force or shape change).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01200", "filename": "603cdad55da9e5ad6ed1b6fb96b04fb3e4c78e9973e9cf09506cac793e78b87e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01202", "filename": "03813efcf2ad1dc620b51329f5b4a447799485231bd83c8b81c518ef22b4f0b9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01206", "filename": "4301f6f9ced8079cefefebc6c020abdc7a173cf45b5b889b5947d3a19f9723cd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time frame is continuous (the rim of the cup and the mucus inside the cup are constantly flickering and wriggling throughout the entire sequence).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01207", "filename": "4301f6f9ced8079cefefebc6c020abdc7a173cf45b5b889b5947d3a19f9723cd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01208", "filename": "4421d797c72a5ed06d4999a36f4bb2ca84777d258339a1686099034fc91f0b97_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The sequence is continuous (the ice blocks are melted by the sun throughout the entire segment, but no water droplets fall as they melt).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01209", "filename": "4421d797c72a5ed06d4999a36f4bb2ca84777d258339a1686099034fc91f0b97_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (the amount of water in the ice block does not match the amount of water flowing down after melting; a large amount of water flows down when melting, and at 5.4s the ice block suddenly shrinks and a large amount of water appears around it).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01210", "filename": "4426ae07aafd12a86db2fb6427caaa670323e9f2c09b15a093dd78f59857c4af_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 6.3s, the humidifier suddenly stopped spraying when the hand touched the mist outlet without touching the switch).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01211", "filename": "4549bfa0c885a7e0175556148d0e5bdac76722370262ac106d0930573fcd7959_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01213", "filename": "4598b8a8c345aed3308ae36f5bdab710af39427d9e4e51506507569cbd54ea41_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (another ice cube is added to the glass, but at 0.4s the ice cube suddenly shrinks and falls to the bottom of the glass. At 0.6s the ice cube falls to the bottom of the glass and disappears instantly, then the glass suddenly fills with water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01215", "filename": "4768fd05d4ef2798b7fc79ffac58d4727c08a8f1b1a0aef3e20b194eb1213fb5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Causality (at 1s, the wheel did not run over the mask, but the mask moved); Time continuity (at 4.1s, a fragment appeared out of thin air on the far right side of the mask).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01216", "filename": "4958b02137633e06f034a0b79cc0ae76accd79a48bada2ab5dea20a5602c333a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the balloon appears underwater throughout the segment; it should float to the surface due to buoyancy). Time continuity (the water color in the pool changes from light blue to grayish-white between 6.4s and 8s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01217", "filename": "4958b02137633e06f034a0b79cc0ae76accd79a48bada2ab5dea20a5602c333a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 5.1s, a balloon plunges from the water surface into the water and remains underwater; throughout the segment, the balloon appears underwater but should float to the surface due to buoyancy).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01218", "filename": "5117c38588f5f1dc7fda2d516371fc85001fe4a34f8c487d4fc310d68798b8c8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01219", "filename": "5117c38588f5f1dc7fda2d516371fc85001fe4a34f8c487d4fc310d68798b8c8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (5.3s-8s) and a section of water next to the straw in the cup suddenly and slowly bulges upward.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01220", "filename": "5474f8db66dfd7827e2510b440f8d5a62450aec1e71e1c3747135f2f3a20669a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time sequence is continuous (the light and shadow reflected inside the washing machine and the water droplets flowing down the glass show that there is a layer of transparent glass separating the washing machine opening, but at 3.5 seconds, a hand is directly put into the washing machine, and the glass disappears instantly).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01221", "filename": "21941993cce06ccf039bf877cd0966500067b91849377aa03062383c710e8a9e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the smoke rises rapidly and then suddenly stops, and the orange-red water area suddenly expands and then shrinks back to its original size).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01222", "filename": "21941993cce06ccf039bf877cd0966500067b91849377aa03062383c710e8a9e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.1 seconds, the forest that was completely obscured by white fog suddenly becomes clear, without the fog gradually dissipating).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01223", "filename": "21941993cce06ccf039bf877cd0966500067b91849377aa03062383c710e8a9e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01224", "filename": "21941993cce06ccf039bf877cd0966500067b91849377aa03062383c710e8a9e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01225", "filename": "30504124a7514f4d8874f01c48fe006de053e7732dbf2f2f417fd93a31e3ecdc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the red part of the sun in the image has broken away from its original outline, shifting from the treetop to the center of the image without being obscured by tree branches, as if it were a separate layer moving.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01226", "filename": "30504124a7514f4d8874f01c48fe006de053e7732dbf2f2f417fd93a31e3ecdc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.3s, the yellow portion of the sun suddenly disappears, and the image tone jumps abruptly from yellow to orange-red without a natural transition.)", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01227", "filename": "30504124a7514f4d8874f01c48fe006de053e7732dbf2f2f417fd93a31e3ecdc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.4s, a small, isolated red spot of light suddenly appears below the sun, breaking away from the sun's halo).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01228", "filename": "30504124a7514f4d8874f01c48fe006de053e7732dbf2f2f417fd93a31e3ecdc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: The timing is continuous (at 1.4s, a small, isolated red spot of light suddenly appears below the sun, breaking away from the sun's halo).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01229", "filename": "37540883f4b60983300c564a98e142d9d7f8505bbedf6d7c05b335a77115580c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1.5s, a purple ball suddenly appears on the wall, and the purple ball on the ground hits the wall and bounces back. Due to air resistance and energy loss from the collision with the wall, it is impossible for it to return to its original position and height, let alone land without any bounce.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01230", "filename": "37540883f4b60983300c564a98e142d9d7f8505bbedf6d7c05b335a77115580c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.6s, a purple ball suddenly rushes out from the left side of the screen, overlaps with the purple ball in the middle of the screen, and forms a ball that rolls to the right).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01231", "filename": "37540883f4b60983300c564a98e142d9d7f8505bbedf6d7c05b335a77115580c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (At 4s, after the purple ball is thrown in the video, the scene suddenly cuts to the instant the ball hits the wall, the flight process in between is cut out, making it look like the ball teleported.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01232", "filename": "040565470df65ba7b00ebd198168ca051c740117e464c12219464b0a018edc41_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the visuals: Time continuity (after the colored bubble bursts at 0.5s, it does not disappear or fall down, but instead immediately returns to its original state).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01233", "filename": "040565470df65ba7b00ebd198168ca051c740117e464c12219464b0a018edc41_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.9s, the colored bubbles suddenly all turned blue without any gradient or transition, as if the colors were replaced with a single click.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01234", "filename": "040565470df65ba7b00ebd198168ca051c740117e464c12219464b0a018edc41_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.1s, the hole in the colored bubble healed itself, and the bubble suddenly grew larger).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01235", "filename": "41057413b80cef511a6ead880b42c0ba3e211fc63e25ce3c1ac9f26391316950_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the action of a character chopping vegetables keeps repeating itself; the number of sliced zucchini doesn't increase, nor does it move forward or accumulate; it just keeps looping in place.)", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01236", "filename": "41057413b80cef511a6ead880b42c0ba3e211fc63e25ce3c1ac9f26391316950_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.8 seconds, the second slice of zucchini on the right side of the knife suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01237", "filename": "41057413b80cef511a6ead880b42c0ba3e211fc63e25ce3c1ac9f26391316950_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (In the entire scene, the cucumber instantly turns into a pile of thin slices the moment the knife touches it, without any actual cutting process in between.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01238", "filename": "48169022bc0eea1da1c29e0618964db54856712aaf46fecb96661c9aa5aeaf61_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (between 3.4s and 4.9s, two colored spheres collide and explode into powder. This powder does not continue to spread outward due to inertia, but slowly gathers back together after the explosion.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01239", "filename": "48169022bc0eea1da1c29e0618964db54856712aaf46fecb96661c9aa5aeaf61_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01240", "filename": "48169022bc0eea1da1c29e0618964db54856712aaf46fecb96661c9aa5aeaf61_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (after the colored ball explodes at 3.8 seconds, the fragments and smoke do not spread outward, but instead reassemble into the original ball in a very short time).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01241", "filename": "48169022bc0eea1da1c29e0618964db54856712aaf46fecb96661c9aa5aeaf61_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a small blue ball suddenly appears on the left side of the screen at 0.1s, and the blue ball connected to the orange ball suddenly disappears at 0.5s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01242", "filename": "52769912cae9a03fd8794953c2fcb92063a78c8ea050ac057745f0fdb70b3421_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (when water droplets are placed on the foam, the foam does not get wet, collapse, or spread out with the water flow as normal; instead, it grows upward into a pointed cone shape).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01243", "filename": "52769912cae9a03fd8794953c2fcb92063a78c8ea050ac057745f0fdb70b3421_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (in the scene, water poured on the slushie causes it to melt and collapse faster, instead of growing upwards).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01244", "filename": "52769912cae9a03fd8794953c2fcb92063a78c8ea050ac057745f0fdb70b3421_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01245", "filename": "52769912cae9a03fd8794953c2fcb92063a78c8ea050ac057745f0fdb70b3421_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the white bubbles in the video, after being poured with water, not only do not break or collapse, but also seem to be pulled upwards from the point of contact, growing into sharp cones.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01246", "filename": "54133464f599f87bec37bea10219240229a236106cf04d64f9cda827a3de811f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the colored flame effect on the glasses lenses does not flicker or burn like a real flame; instead, it appears as a sticker printed on the lenses, completely still.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01247", "filename": "54133464f599f87bec37bea10219240229a236106cf04d64f9cda827a3de811f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01248", "filename": "54133464f599f87bec37bea10219240229a236106cf04d64f9cda827a3de811f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1.4s, the clear flame reflection on the lens suddenly disappears, leaving only a blurry colored spot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01249", "filename": "54133464f599f87bec37bea10219240229a236106cf04d64f9cda827a3de811f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1s, the colored flame reflection on the glasses suddenly disappears, and when the glasses are flipped, the real candle flame that should have been there indefinitely also mysteriously \"goes out\" in the lenses.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01250", "filename": "67980352c819e8ae3ccec7bac8aa2034c1a4eb3b3dead639883ece096ef33f62_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.1 seconds, the color of the sky and the shape of the clouds in the video jump directly from a purplish-pink overcast sky to a warm yellow dusk without any time transition).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01258", "filename": "72f88092ebf650ad5106e16e79331583e7801eec6ab957df207d9bbca6b6c46c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the sparks from a firework explosion are randomly scattered, with natural variations in thickness; however, the spark lines of the two large fireworks in the image are evenly arranged, lacking the chaos and randomness of real fireworks).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01259", "filename": "72f88092ebf650ad5106e16e79331583e7801eec6ab957df207d9bbca6b6c46c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01263", "filename": "73b1cfe62b01e8e4244bd5110e466a140d7d4f613fa24de38ce508169f21a6ae_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the transition between light and shadow on the fingers and gemstones is too abrupt, and the edges of the gemstones are completely disconnected from the luster of the skin on the fingers, lacking the realistic feel of objects placed on the skin).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01264", "filename": "73b1cfe62b01e8e4244bd5110e466a140d7d4f613fa24de38ce508169f21a6ae_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (when a gemstone is held by fingers, the edges naturally blend with the skin to create light and shadow, but in the image, the area where the bottom of the gemstone touches the fingers shows no real pressure marks, and the light and shadow are completely disconnected from the texture of the fingers' skin, lacking any sense of physical interaction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01265", "filename": "73b1cfe62b01e8e4244bd5110e466a140d7d4f613fa24de38ce508169f21a6ae_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (in the video, at 0.6s, the gem in the person's hand suddenly changes from a smooth curved surface to a prismatic surface without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01268", "filename": "74c1d4da47a0c8b8a9bf5628e9083329e113a185544810ecaf27b4b36916a6a4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual effect is abnormal (at 0.5 seconds into the video, the smoke in the entire frame disappears out of thin air without any change in camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01269", "filename": "74c1d4da47a0c8b8a9bf5628e9083329e113a185544810ecaf27b4b36916a6a4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Temporal continuity is abnormal (at 0.1s in the video, the button on the instrument in the person's hand suddenly changes from an arc shape to a rhombus shape without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01270", "filename": "74c1d4da47a0c8b8a9bf5628e9083329e113a185544810ecaf27b4b36916a6a4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (In the entire video, without any change in camera angle, multiple dents appeared out of thin air on the black board when the flat-headed tool scraped across it).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01275", "filename": "75ade813dc058fc4c3236ac29f4f3f741fe29eb2cd2aa2383e6c73ac2edf84d5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01276", "filename": "75ade813dc058fc4c3236ac29f4f3f741fe29eb2cd2aa2383e6c73ac2edf84d5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 1.8s in the video, the steam rising from the kettle disappears out of thin air without the camera changing direction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01277", "filename": "75ade813dc058fc4c3236ac29f4f3f741fe29eb2cd2aa2383e6c73ac2edf84d5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01278", "filename": "75ade813dc058fc4c3236ac29f4f3f741fe29eb2cd2aa2383e6c73ac2edf84d5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 7s in the video, a layer of white foam appears out of thin air in the water in the cup without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01279", "filename": "75ae49e1ba63fe6ce9d53465d6d1be1f5c75abcbc1bfb9befb2d963e68e4e9b3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the sun is clearly at the bottom of the image, but the bright parts of some thick clouds do not conform to the law of light receiving at the bottom of the clouds. The transition between light and dark is harsh and abrupt, lacking the soft gradation of real clouds when light penetrates them).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01280", "filename": "75ae49e1ba63fe6ce9d53465d6d1be1f5c75abcbc1bfb9befb2d963e68e4e9b3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the sun is clearly located on the lower right side of the screen, illuminating the cloud base with a warm yellow hue, but the edge of the cloud layer on the right side is illuminated in reverse, as if there are two light sources, violating the lighting logic of a single light source).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01281", "filename": "7b7d320f6051517cc4fca71a6ac51d15823748dfa6318db90600c85aa2001c6a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Time Continuity: The increased water flow due to melting ice spreads in all directions, then suddenly contracts back after 5.4 seconds.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01282", "filename": "7b95afb64fd31ac71611fba1de7132ce18b8a3e32301c3e24685a2468537bdc1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: 1.9s-5.9s During the pouring process, the rate at which the liquid in the bottle decreases is significantly less than the rate at which it is poured out; the two are not proportional. 7.6s After the liquid is poured, the bottle returns to its upright position, indicating that the amount of liquid in the bottle has not decreased.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01283", "filename": "7b13220fc2652ea3f569690fb37565cf2be48dfe00b8780f55d5f8b96e376da7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: At 5.3 seconds, the entire cloud layer suddenly moved in the opposite direction, and the house on the right side of the video continuously distorted and flickered throughout the entire video.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01284", "filename": "7b575514b599cfc8c42120afe255f786e51726fca827dd2000170fe91a1d29f8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01285", "filename": "7be9fb0c2a24093009bc16ea4b2e643decceee5c3529de76d144d6106116eaa0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: At 3.9s, when the finger was removed from the liquid, the surface remained calm and unchanged. At 4s, two white dots suddenly appeared in the water.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01286", "filename": "7bee47a24f7d3e4d4c637b6cf41a4e6872af9d2ab97d41b4b7c68cde95074a69_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video footage shows an anomaly: the chandelier in the entire video is continuously distorted and flickering.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01287", "filename": "7bf6354495d215047966d871a73c0f13def707da8e6f0c5465dd0385e7ed373a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: When three effervescent tablets are placed in the same glass at the same time, the two on the left can be seen sinking to the bottom of the glass, while the one on the far right disappears into thin air in 5.6 seconds.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01289", "filename": "7c07d7db8e379a74691962fdcaf4b5288a2e31f85290b0e58da9e217992a3b3f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (bubbles disappear at 1.9s, then reappear out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01290", "filename": "7c8413db7f41b79599b5ec1cf28722b2d171b5a54ae40c8142ef0fe1989a6c23_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: the fingers holding the opal rotate very little, while the opal itself rotates very much; the two movements are mismatched.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01291", "filename": "7cc166e90a996630dcfdb632e6813f5bf12f73a90da18b8f616e9c7d771a5cee_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the intersection in the lower left corner is continuously distorting and flashing, and vehicles traveling at that intersection disappear into thin air within 1.5 seconds.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01292", "filename": "7cfc5c4b2a11735ca6a3ad90e20ee697cc4bc549cd7a57e4c691138c09c83d3a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01293", "filename": "7d013d2b4f598ba1549f8083ffae89c9c73e676779dc3e1386ceb4c68f2ac147_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is distorted: the trees near the water are constantly twisting and flickering.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01294", "filename": "7d73b8846bbd84a8d43b5fef96d3471a4d7ba79580a7c3e76f3866a1df2914bc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01295", "filename": "7d6709776d93d1db8511a2239ebad72ff289261e1ee16b3c29524c704e842992_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Time Continuity: 6.4s. The wooden stick suddenly changes from a lit state to a completely new state.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01296", "filename": "7dc55acf9d236090fcf59e9492fa80cec7c5a4ea422028e04902b3b1547f3556_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Time continuity: 2.2s-5.5s. When the clouds passed over the moon, the moon did not appear to be blocked. Physical anomaly: Based on the apparent positional relationship between the moon and the sun, the moon should have been in a crescent shape at this time. Visual anomaly: The outline of the trees in the lower right corner flickers and is distorted.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01297", "filename": "7de41606fb5e79a07b54d4a3eb85fd18653a57d5dfc6555bb4b7dbe71ea877db_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: For a continuous period of 2 seconds, the black duck's movement produces ripples, but the movement thereafter does not, showing inconsistency.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01298", "filename": "7dec2725a239488dc76c4acfd290ae43e4179b5eeef6a8d27b93ccaadfb9721a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the trees are continuously distorted and warped; the explosion at 1.6 seconds lacks any coordination with surrounding objects, for example, the shockwave from the explosion should have moved the surrounding vegetation.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01299", "filename": "7e8aafd17a31aad51279eb97539bae1c36fda1eb2dfafd8085edd1f6c3606a14_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual error: There is too little smoke after the explosion, lacking a realistic explosion effect.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01300", "filename": "7e17e50a0289988e67e3b64c2f971981235648c3e6a8c63aad2d6788d16cbd16_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The water surface above the waterfall exhibits dynamic flickering artifacts and excessive noise.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01301", "filename": "7edbbe2839bb80f2f021034352d73ea61495813657852c58a1350120ffde7bb9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the trees and grass in the foreground flicker and distort throughout.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01302", "filename": "7ee4e5c5a99c51126f0048755a3d9ff68f26a74ad195e04c088f451814f5244b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01303", "filename": "7f1ce975def67cc8178244ce5a52007e822c7e8c3e41b79df720b28ea1944191_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the trees flicker and distort throughout. The lake is too calm, without any ripples, creating a sense of stagnation that is inconsistent with nature.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01305", "filename": "7faefd9fde982aaad45eb655248a7343eb96b631e78bbcc1228676535951a683_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: The smoke in the upper left corner drifts in the opposite direction to the smoke nearby.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01307", "filename": "08a640c8d4a18320595be4df17bbfac408118f7d45bd99df96a334cdf001fed5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows trees flickering and distorting, creating an unnatural visual effect.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01308", "filename": "08aaddd5db94f85999429efb9891ecef4a6654f001e653cbfa1bdb89e3a64c04_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: The two lamps were placed in the same space with no difference in environmental conditions, but the amplitude and frequency of the flames of the two lamps showed a clear difference.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01310", "filename": "8ad0e016f4e7b4dc4699a3b22f00ab2d4d5aed7635a5df0f215e3cb805736643_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01311", "filename": "5ed0ef80917e1de8c97b4e090c6612efaf20bf12a27f0cf3131372ed71fd12c5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the beach suddenly explodes without any external force in 0.3s.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01312", "filename": "5ee459265392af27485b7a19358b4b4fff8d925a2933029fc97e2dce43de42cc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (between 0.8s and 3.7s, the viscosity of the flowing water is distorted, turning from clear water to a viscous, glue-like consistency).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01313", "filename": "5ee459265392af27485b7a19358b4b4fff8d925a2933029fc97e2dce43de42cc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (between 0.5s and 1.5s, the flowing river water suddenly disappears without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01314", "filename": "5ee459265392af27485b7a19358b4b4fff8d925a2933029fc97e2dce43de42cc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01315", "filename": "5ee459265392af27485b7a19358b4b4fff8d925a2933029fc97e2dce43de42cc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the light in the flowing water flickers and wriggles as it flows in the scene.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01316", "filename": "5f82a107111e9ffb3c290e1cd43de6f0118774be0cc99f90372b77a669595c9e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the axe hadn't even struck the object by 0.2 seconds before the object exploded.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01317", "filename": "5f82a107111e9ffb3c290e1cd43de6f0118774be0cc99f90372b77a669595c9e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is unusual: the timing is continuous (between 2.9s and 3.6s, the falling axe suddenly explodes in mid-air; there are no explosives or any explosive devices in the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01318", "filename": "5f82a107111e9ffb3c290e1cd43de6f0118774be0cc99f90372b77a669595c9e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01319", "filename": "5fae34f56a2a0f550f9aac8dd1243803a7bb57b422ad9cc2b39e27c1ed7e4fb1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the clouds, which were slowly drifting for 2s-3.7s, suddenly disappear completely. Slow cloud drift indicates weak airflow, and the clouds should dissipate slowly, not suddenly disappear completely.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01320", "filename": "5fae34f56a2a0f550f9aac8dd1243803a7bb57b422ad9cc2b39e27c1ed7e4fb1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01321", "filename": "5fae34f56a2a0f550f9aac8dd1243803a7bb57b422ad9cc2b39e27c1ed7e4fb1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (from 2s to 4.8s, the sky changes from blue sky and white clouds to fiery clouds, indicating that the time has changed from morning to night, but the position of the sun has not changed and has remained in the same position).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01322", "filename": "5fae34f56a2a0f550f9aac8dd1243803a7bb57b422ad9cc2b39e27c1ed7e4fb1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 2.08 to 6.7 seconds, the blue sky and white clouds turn into fiery clouds, indicating that the sun is setting, but the sun keeps rising higher and higher, which does not conform to the sun rising in the east and setting in the west.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01323", "filename": "5fe4ba88b9ef16cf1ad6dbf3a54e63a593f051d85973f754e1af9ab377b7bf99_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (0.3s-3s). When the hydraulic press is pressing the upright wood, the wood is flattened and twisted like rubber instead of breaking. The toughness of wood defies common sense.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01324", "filename": "5fe4ba88b9ef16cf1ad6dbf3a54e63a593f051d85973f754e1af9ab377b7bf99_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (1.2s-5.1s). When the hydraulic press is pressing the wooden stick, the stick is flattened like rubber instead of exploding and breaking under force. The stick's toughness defies common sense.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01325", "filename": "5fe4ba88b9ef16cf1ad6dbf3a54e63a593f051d85973f754e1af9ab377b7bf99_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal; the time sequence is continuous (2.8s-4.9s, the broken wooden stick automatically returns to its original shape without external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01326", "filename": "06c912f28e18f565281c51ef2aba7649f184e5aee11e0bc4bda616d068e9b537_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the light reflected from the sea surface flickers and undulates).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01327", "filename": "06c912f28e18f565281c51ef2aba7649f184e5aee11e0bc4bda616d068e9b537_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the light on the sea surface is flickering and creeping).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01328", "filename": "06c912f28e18f565281c51ef2aba7649f184e5aee11e0bc4bda616d068e9b537_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01329", "filename": "06c912f28e18f565281c51ef2aba7649f184e5aee11e0bc4bda616d068e9b537_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01330", "filename": "06e82a11a7891004b69c9da17a6a68c8904b3db7141f7604146ee76abd4bc998_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (The giant tornado is rotating at high speed, indicating strong winds, while the trees around the tornado are only swaying slightly.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01331", "filename": "06e82a11a7891004b69c9da17a6a68c8904b3db7141f7604146ee76abd4bc998_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (from 0.4s to 4.5s, the tornado should appear as a spiral of gas, and the smoke should be light and drifting, not thick and sticky like glue).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01332", "filename": "06e82a11a7891004b69c9da17a6a68c8904b3db7141f7604146ee76abd4bc998_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01333", "filename": "06e6892063323397663eb81061279228e68154a09199f806105c074acc4c7d9a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (from 0.6s to 4s, a purple jelly-like object automatically contracts and expands without external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01334", "filename": "06e6892063323397663eb81061279228e68154a09199f806105c074acc4c7d9a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (1s-3.5s: As the ice melts, the water on the ground increases, but the volume of the ice block increases.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01335", "filename": "06e6892063323397663eb81061279228e68154a09199f806105c074acc4c7d9a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01336", "filename": "6a0dc5a4da39e2360717ed6c884f5cd5f421a2cf3ce5f1675716cfb915d1f132_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time sequence is continuous (from 3s to 4.6s, the water in the tank automatically rotates and creates a vortex without external force. The water surface should remain calm.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01337", "filename": "6a0dc5a4da39e2360717ed6c884f5cd5f421a2cf3ce5f1675716cfb915d1f132_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the water on the cutting board disappears into thin air in 0.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01338", "filename": "6a0dc5a4da39e2360717ed6c884f5cd5f421a2cf3ce5f1675716cfb915d1f132_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01339", "filename": "6a6e49bbe749eb20fb78016877d02762f105ce59aa0265f3a88d528109e6db2e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual error: Continuous timing (the water spray from the spray bottle should be a fine mist, not a slow, flowing stream like glue.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01340", "filename": "6a6e49bbe749eb20fb78016877d02762f105ce59aa0265f3a88d528109e6db2e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (the viscosity of the liquid in the image is distorted; clear water appears as sticky as glue. Clear water should flow smoothly and without resistance, with strong fluidity, rather than flowing slowly and stickily like glue).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01341", "filename": "6a6e49bbe749eb20fb78016877d02762f105ce59aa0265f3a88d528109e6db2e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01342", "filename": "6a8f7793e4a2d774b7fa72b1977f306535d973983a56951e097859f8cedeaa75_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Continuous time (0.8s-4.2s). When the hydraulic press is pressing a tile-like object, the object is flattened and then automatically returns to its original shape without external force.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01343", "filename": "6a8f7793e4a2d774b7fa72b1977f306535d973983a56951e097859f8cedeaa75_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The time sequence is continuous (2.5s-4.1s). When the hydraulic press is operating the hydraulic tile, the tile does not shatter or explode, but is instead flattened and stretched like rubber.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01344", "filename": "6a8f7793e4a2d774b7fa72b1977f306535d973983a56951e097859f8cedeaa75_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: During the continuous time frame (from 1.6s to 2.3s, only the upper half of the tile being hydraulically pressed exploded, sending debris flying, while the lower half remained intact).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01349", "filename": "6a2141646e2f04eeef6075a261dccf633788d25cc5d9979ed7cca04e8d0715eb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (0.8s). When lighting a match with an alcohol lamp, the flames of the alcohol lamp and the match should be connected as one flame, not separate into two flames.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01350", "filename": "6a2141646e2f04eeef6075a261dccf633788d25cc5d9979ed7cca04e8d0715eb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual error: The time sequence is continuous (the white smoke from the flame between 1.3s and 2.3s should be coming from the top of the flame, not from the bottom).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01354", "filename": "b6d8fd6c49e76f9170facab92eb106224269ee640f56c0269c177c3f3992ce99_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the liquid in the pot is constantly being poured out throughout the video, but the amount of liquid in the pot does not decrease significantly).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01355", "filename": "b6d8fd6c49e76f9170facab92eb106224269ee640f56c0269c177c3f3992ce99_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual presentation is off (the edges of the liquid being poured in the entire video are blurry, lacking the texture and sense of gravity of real liquid flow; the texture of the flames is too uniform, lacking the dynamic layers and random variations of real flames).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01356", "filename": "b6d8fd6c49e76f9170facab92eb106224269ee640f56c0269c177c3f3992ce99_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect (the light from the flames in the entire video does not create a natural gradation of light and shadow on the surrounding wood chips and the ground, the light and shadow appear flat, and the fire intensifies between 3.8s and 5s, but the light around the fire dims).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01357", "filename": "b6d8fd6c49e76f9170facab92eb106224269ee640f56c0269c177c3f3992ce99_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the intense light from the flames in the entire video does not create physically realistic variations in light and shadow or reflections on the surrounding wood chips, ground, and grass; the overall lighting and shadow appear flat and lack the three-dimensionality and atmosphere of a real scene).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01358", "filename": "b6da9968acc670423b4cda74554891a0a8010356f3f20a85914ebd7d17bd649c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the green ball rolling in the frame suddenly disappears at 1.7s, and the yellow ball suddenly twists and deforms when it falls into the haystack at 4.5s). Physical behavior (from 3.1s to 3.5s, the two balls suddenly bounce onto the track above without any upward force, which does not conform to the laws of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01359", "filename": "b6da9968acc670423b4cda74554891a0a8010356f3f20a85914ebd7d17bd649c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (2.2s-3.4s, the brown chicken-shaped object suddenly moves onto the blue track without any force applied).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01360", "filename": "b6da9968acc670423b4cda74554891a0a8010356f3f20a85914ebd7d17bd649c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.4s, the three balls on the track suddenly twist and deform, and at 4.7s, the green ball falling on the track suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01361", "filename": "b6da9968acc670423b4cda74554891a0a8010356f3f20a85914ebd7d17bd649c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time sequence (0.9s-1.3s: Brown object moves onto the track without any propulsion; at 1.1s: Green and yellow balls on the wooden track have not yet rolled onto the blue track, but yellow and green balls appear out of nowhere on the blue track; 2.6s-3s: Red ball appears out of nowhere on the blue track; 3.4s: Yellow ball on the blue track suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01362", "filename": "b6e74825217b8b3d888f3804be6f579a83f4953c55c03b1dd7b52f000ad98b12_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (from 0.9s to 5s, the speed of the screwdriver rotation is inconsistent with the speed of the screw rotation).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01363", "filename": "b6e74825217b8b3d888f3804be6f579a83f4953c55c03b1dd7b52f000ad98b12_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (between 3.4s and 5.4s, the silver object in the hand penetrates and embeds itself in the screw when it touches it).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01364", "filename": "b6e74825217b8b3d888f3804be6f579a83f4953c55c03b1dd7b52f000ad98b12_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The screen is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.1 seconds, the silver object in my hand just touched the screw and before any force was applied, the screw started to pop out).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01365", "filename": "b6e74825217b8b3d888f3804be6f579a83f4953c55c03b1dd7b52f000ad98b12_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.6s, the screwdriver tip penetrates and embeds in the screw; at 4.7s, the shape and color of the screw in the video suddenly change).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01373", "filename": "b7e3b2f08ac98af4efeeb7b9165370549c3cd225b7b0cb5df157ef6506ed8935_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (from 0.1s to 5s, the character's right hand fingers are constantly twisted and deformed, and the silver rod inside the blue object in the middle is also twisted and deformed).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01374", "filename": "b7e3b2f08ac98af4efeeb7b9165370549c3cd225b7b0cb5df157ef6506ed8935_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 1.2s to 4.2s, when the person moves the blue object, the silver stick above it suddenly becomes longer; from 4s to 4.4s, a right hand suddenly appears on the object above in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01375", "filename": "b7e3b2f08ac98af4efeeb7b9165370549c3cd225b7b0cb5df157ef6506ed8935_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01376", "filename": "b7e378cc18ddccffcec642e4534717e0b7e4ec91343f0e12775ff907eff6d0d7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous movement (the silver object on the desktop moves continuously without any force applied, and twists and deforms during the movement).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01377", "filename": "b7e378cc18ddccffcec642e4534717e0b7e4ec91343f0e12775ff907eff6d0d7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous movement (the silver object on the desktop moves continuously without any force applied, and deforms constantly during the movement).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01378", "filename": "b7e378cc18ddccffcec642e4534717e0b7e4ec91343f0e12775ff907eff6d0d7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the silver object on the desktop moves continuously without any force applied, and connecting structures are constantly generated out of thin air during the movement).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01379", "filename": "b7efa13c8cea12855ecf5292810d5b479e57de7d65e84f8206b67662db4f40f2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the Ferris wheel was not in motion throughout the video, but the wheels were rotating up and down, which does not conform to the laws of force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01380", "filename": "b7efa13c8cea12855ecf5292810d5b479e57de7d65e84f8206b67662db4f40f2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01381", "filename": "671a6bd483a777857ef683d7c30ad39f4111277fe9b3a017ad6b87841c7e75ff_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the long white strip light in the picture is suspended by thin wires, but on the tree branch on the right side of the picture, several wires are clearly passing through the branch, causing clipping).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01382", "filename": "671a6bd483a777857ef683d7c30ad39f4111277fe9b3a017ad6b87841c7e75ff_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01387", "filename": "687b3e536cc65ae5a4b3d0f38124e9af692c71135ab1eb6719455f0c36c8b1ae_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the ball undergoes exaggerated deformation without external force when it bounces up for the second time at 1.9s, and briefly suspends in the air at 2.6s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01388", "filename": "687b3e536cc65ae5a4b3d0f38124e9af692c71135ab1eb6719455f0c36c8b1ae_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continues (there is a spot of light in the center of the ball due to the reflection of the ceiling light, but the spot of light does not change position or size as the ball falls).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01389", "filename": "687b3e536cc65ae5a4b3d0f38124e9af692c71135ab1eb6719455f0c36c8b1ae_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: Time continuity (a rough ball that appears in the screen between 0s and 0.7s disappears out of thin air, and a smooth ball appears at 0.6s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01390", "filename": "687f08c08aa088611b3f362baa5ab4da8ab3aa0aca1b7af1c6274023f05f7cbe_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the transition between the rain column on the right and the clear sky on the left is too abrupt, lacking the gradual changes between clouds and rain in a realistic weather system.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01391", "filename": "687f08c08aa088611b3f362baa5ab4da8ab3aa0aca1b7af1c6274023f05f7cbe_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01392", "filename": "692c2ce9a1e0cbdae754a95cb6f409b2a410adb5476941cfa8eda153e8a664ff_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01393", "filename": "692c2ce9a1e0cbdae754a95cb6f409b2a410adb5476941cfa8eda153e8a664ff_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (In the experimental scenario of a hydraulic press, the hollowed-out nut structure would immediately deform or shatter under immense pressure, making it impossible for it to remain intact as shown in the image, let alone support the heavy hydraulic press head above.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01394", "filename": "692c2ce9a1e0cbdae754a95cb6f409b2a410adb5476941cfa8eda153e8a664ff_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time duration (in the footage, after being pressed by the hydraulic press, the nut undergoes an illogical deformation and becomes a cube at 4.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01395", "filename": "697cdb13befbe9f6b1dfbfe19938120c1008eb3db11cbfaf52469be6c3cbd60b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The smoke in the image is a very uniform light beige color, covering a large area but with a very uniform concentration, more like stage smoke effects created by dry ice than black smoke or water vapor produced by a fire.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01396", "filename": "697cdb13befbe9f6b1dfbfe19938120c1008eb3db11cbfaf52469be6c3cbd60b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01397", "filename": "697cdb13befbe9f6b1dfbfe19938120c1008eb3db11cbfaf52469be6c3cbd60b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a person in white clothes disappears from the sidewalk next to the road at 1.8s and suddenly reappears at 2.9s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01398", "filename": "697cdb13befbe9f6b1dfbfe19938120c1008eb3db11cbfaf52469be6c3cbd60b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01399", "filename": "702d8c431145505ec55a5000978b3b325ee409b8a4942841ff9d182c5549ce0e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (the water in the plastic bottle is dripping one drop at a time, but the water stains below appear to be falling continuously).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01400", "filename": "702d8c431145505ec55a5000978b3b325ee409b8a4942841ff9d182c5549ce0e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the water stain below the plastic bottle appears to grow larger as water drips from the bottle, but the bottle doesn't contain enough water to create such a large stain).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01401", "filename": "702d8c431145505ec55a5000978b3b325ee409b8a4942841ff9d182c5549ce0e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (the video was not sped up and the environment remained unchanged, but the ice in the plastic bottle melted rapidly between 2s and 6.6s, producing a large amount of water, which is inconsistent with the normal melting speed of ice).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01402", "filename": "704e8cca80ebba11580c52e8365bd8caf36d2ae4a019f6a67b4dc1b555919c23_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (the water droplets inside the plastic bottle do not move as the bottle is shaken).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01403", "filename": "704e8cca80ebba11580c52e8365bd8caf36d2ae4a019f6a67b4dc1b555919c23_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the water flow pattern in the image is abnormal; the water inside the bottle appears to be flowing in an overly uniform, stringy pattern, rather than the chaotic, turbulent state of real fluid moving at high speed inside the bottle.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01404", "filename": "704e8cca80ebba11580c52e8365bd8caf36d2ae4a019f6a67b4dc1b555919c23_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time-lapse (a large number of dense bubbles appear after water is added to a water bottle in the background of the screen, and they do not dissipate after a period of time).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01405", "filename": "704e8cca80ebba11580c52e8365bd8caf36d2ae4a019f6a67b4dc1b555919c23_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (clipping occurred when water was added to the bottle between 0-5.5s in the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01406", "filename": "711e0c836a16a4644823bcc563986fc24dbca98c4dcc4b715066978c0372fd44_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall impression (the texture of the bubbles in the image is more like plastic than bubbles).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01407", "filename": "711e0c836a16a4644823bcc563986fc24dbca98c4dcc4b715066978c0372fd44_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: duration continues (at 1.4 seconds in the video, the bubble suddenly turns into a plastic bag).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01408", "filename": "711e0c836a16a4644823bcc563986fc24dbca98c4dcc4b715066978c0372fd44_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (at 1.7 seconds in the video, the rod on the left side of the screen suddenly turns into a fishing rod, and the bubbles suddenly turn into plastic bags).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01411", "filename": "357a5bf22712a4f68c76d8173b5906d763aa4fa8d2aab8d6fdc1bd7a4ced2d4c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (a red rectangular object appears out of nowhere on the road in the video between 1.4s and 1.5s; a red rectangular object appears out of nowhere again at 1.9s; a blurry object suddenly appears in the lower left corner at 2.6s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01412", "filename": "357a5bf22712a4f68c76d8173b5906d763aa4fa8d2aab8d6fdc1bd7a4ced2d4c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (from 0.4s to 1.3s, the clouds gradually display a fixed lightning shape; at 2.3s, the clouds suddenly cascade down like a waterfall, violating the physical properties of clouds); Time continuity (at 6.2s, white light suddenly appears on the black clouds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01413", "filename": "365afbb3a534cfedda08f9e88bd8371edca7b76e1bb5a3b437fdff1cba4ace23_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (at 2.6s, the clouds on the right suddenly increase in size and move very fast, which does not conform to the principle of cloud diffusion; throughout the video, the clouds and light and shadow in the distant sky do not change at all, like a texture).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01414", "filename": "365afbb3a534cfedda08f9e88bd8371edca7b76e1bb5a3b437fdff1cba4ace23_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (the waterfall on the left turns yellow at 0.8s; at 2s, a cloud of mist suddenly appears gushing upwards in the lower right corner of the screen).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01415", "filename": "365afbb3a534cfedda08f9e88bd8371edca7b76e1bb5a3b437fdff1cba4ace23_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01416", "filename": "365afbb3a534cfedda08f9e88bd8371edca7b76e1bb5a3b437fdff1cba4ace23_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (a black unidentified object appears out of nowhere and then disappears between 5.7s and 6s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01421", "filename": "372f0c30decc11d5d87259662343d343a67e1d6b5b78c72636a0db2ec88ad367_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 0.9s to 2s, the white light cluster on the left remains stationary while the leaves are still swaying, violating the linkage logic of light and shadow projection).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01422", "filename": "372f0c30decc11d5d87259662343d343a67e1d6b5b78c72636a0db2ec88ad367_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (in the entire video, the leaves being blown by the wind are in an irregular, random motion, while the light spots formed by the transmitted light show an almost repetitive pattern of change, ignoring the random nature of the leaf movement under the influence of the wind).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01423", "filename": "372f0c30decc11d5d87259662343d343a67e1d6b5b78c72636a0db2ec88ad367_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01424", "filename": "372f0c30decc11d5d87259662343d343a67e1d6b5b78c72636a0db2ec88ad367_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01425", "filename": "378fd205195c7ca3ccb2757ab9df5c388e9dea5f0caf3a7022dcf6389928ceac_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the video is too smooth and doesn't look realistic).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01426", "filename": "378fd205195c7ca3ccb2757ab9df5c388e9dea5f0caf3a7022dcf6389928ceac_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the clouds in the sky do not change much over time, only moving from a distance to a closer distance, which does not conform to the continuous influence of atmospheric movement on clouds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01427", "filename": "378fd205195c7ca3ccb2757ab9df5c388e9dea5f0caf3a7022dcf6389928ceac_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.5s, ripples suddenly appear on the water surface at the bottom of the video without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01428", "filename": "378fd205195c7ca3ccb2757ab9df5c388e9dea5f0caf3a7022dcf6389928ceac_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01433", "filename": "393ed3e43e1a36f777a80478a78a82bba328847450d4b92a0dfbb002316e592f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 0.5s, refrigerator debris suddenly turns into water and splashes outwards; from 1.5s to 2.1s, the smashed refrigerator returns to its original state; from 2.4s to 3.8s, the refrigerator automatically swings back without any external force; at 4.4s, the video replays).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01434", "filename": "393ed3e43e1a36f777a80478a78a82bba328847450d4b92a0dfbb002316e592f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the lower left camera deforms and moves without any external force between 3.7s and 4.2s) and continuous time (the hammer shape changes at 2.3s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01435", "filename": "393ed3e43e1a36f777a80478a78a82bba328847450d4b92a0dfbb002316e592f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (the hammer penetrates the refrigerator directly at 0.3s, violating the principle of impenetrability of solids; the fragments of the smashed refrigerator in the entire video are too small)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01436", "filename": "393ed3e43e1a36f777a80478a78a82bba328847450d4b92a0dfbb002316e592f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (1.4s: the wrinkles on the refrigerator door suddenly disappear; 1.5s: fragments appear out of nowhere in the lower left corner of the refrigerator; 2.4s: a crack suddenly appears on the refrigerator; 3s: a yellow object suddenly appears above the refrigerator; 4.1s: a hammer suddenly appears at the center of the explosion; 5.1s: the amount of debris suddenly increases).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01437", "filename": "0403a43eea348baedf403a1907c07639e58fd314e4f0fea2a735795624f0464c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (the shape of the object in hand changes at 0.8s; the blue light suddenly disappears at 1.1s; a blue unidentified object suddenly appears on the right side of the object at 2.1s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01438", "filename": "0403a43eea348baedf403a1907c07639e58fd314e4f0fea2a735795624f0464c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (2.6s-3s: the refraction of light moves along the direction of the object's edges, violating the law of refraction of light).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01439", "filename": "405b1ae2a3cb79203a0e61d66593a104f76d2c335f2f99514d887e99c2ede9d9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (white smoke suddenly appears in the lower left corner at 3.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01440", "filename": "405b1ae2a3cb79203a0e61d66593a104f76d2c335f2f99514d887e99c2ede9d9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is due to physical behavior (the smoke emitted by the object from 1.7s to 5.9s is fluid-like, which does not conform to the randomness of gas diffusion and airflow interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01441", "filename": "ac9c3db11c269db53b6342b6ca0cdb0e3ecfa225e2c99f8a035bac765457140a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the small white object in the center of the video has a noticeably different texture from the surrounding radishes. It is whiter and has a gel-like surface that reflects light, making it stand out from its environment).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01442", "filename": "ac9c3db11c269db53b6342b6ca0cdb0e3ecfa225e2c99f8a035bac765457140a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01443", "filename": "ac00127a75db387743f3646f0e49ac3e2c1174e663c6447f397293ffc961c05f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Abnormal physical behavior (the ship sailing in the entire video does not produce any ripples or tracks on the water, and the smoke above the ship in the picture is stationary and does not diffuse naturally, which violates the law of free diffusion of gases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01444", "filename": "ac359a7c04efb5ea07efe17f32bc756d1adb34ccf53ef9d14cdbc6438f9282a1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (at 1.3s, the snow on the umbrella appears to have been largely shaken off. However, the amount and distribution of the remaining snow on the umbrella at this point are exactly the same as before the snow was shaken off, showing no change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01445", "filename": "ac359a7c04efb5ea07efe17f32bc756d1adb34ccf53ef9d14cdbc6438f9282a1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (at 1s, the snowballs shaken off the umbrella did not fall downwards due to gravity, but instead flew upwards in the frame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01446", "filename": "ac359a7c04efb5ea07efe17f32bc756d1adb34ccf53ef9d14cdbc6438f9282a1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (snowflakes falling from the umbrella surface at the start - 0.5s do not fall downwards due to gravity, but instead remain suspended in the air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01447", "filename": "ac519a62566d0af1a714d6b8f6c7eb265f7270075951cb6fab17ef06e647192c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (between 1.1s and 1.3s, the white wreath above the left door frame and the blue ornament next to it disappear in the next frame, and part of the decoration on the edge of the terrace also disappears simultaneously).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01448", "filename": "ac519a62566d0af1a714d6b8f6c7eb265f7270075951cb6fab17ef06e647192c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (although the snow on the right side of the outdoor area appears to be thick, there is no snow on the terrace floor or the Christmas tree, which is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01449", "filename": "ac519a62566d0af1a714d6b8f6c7eb265f7270075951cb6fab17ef06e647192c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (at 7.4s, a tree without snow suddenly appears in the frame, which is out of place with the surrounding environment covered in thick snow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01450", "filename": "acb97c8fe4b552b2f2d613c23606d8e3b1d677afafc2454d0065dde11aba8e47_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (the ice cream lying on the table does not exhibit the softness and fluidity that should be present after normal melting; it does not spread out where it touches the table, nor does it show any signs of flowing down the edges).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01451", "filename": "acb97c8fe4b552b2f2d613c23606d8e3b1d677afafc2454d0065dde11aba8e47_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (the ice cream did not flow and pile naturally along the cone and table during the melting process throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01452", "filename": "acbd488ed5e8332a91c5f0d9e07a415962b9d574dcbb7a76895053d1b28e0fbd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (the match showed no signs of being blackened or carbonized by the flame during its 4.6s burning period, and maintained its original color).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01453", "filename": "acbd488ed5e8332a91c5f0d9e07a415962b9d574dcbb7a76895053d1b28e0fbd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (the burning match on the right at 1.6s does not undergo the process of turning black; the charring process suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01454", "filename": "acbd488ed5e8332a91c5f0d9e07a415962b9d574dcbb7a76895053d1b28e0fbd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (the match on the left side that was burned by the flame at 3.9s did not show any signs of being charred or blackened, and still retained its original wood color).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01455", "filename": "acbd488ed5e8332a91c5f0d9e07a415962b9d574dcbb7a76895053d1b28e0fbd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 5s, the burning fire suddenly disappears, leaving only a pile of ashes and scattered unburnt matches on the ground).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01456", "filename": "ace338df22e1df90b14c2704585bef6b1562d411d3cc38e209c13104b747077b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical anomaly (no dust or debris was kicked up from the ground after the explosion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01457", "filename": "ace338df22e1df90b14c2704585bef6b1562d411d3cc38e209c13104b747077b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior is abnormal (the smoke and flames from the explosion in the entire video do not spread outwards, and the generated dynamic sense does not match the impact and diffusion of a real explosion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01458", "filename": "ace338df22e1df90b14c2704585bef6b1562d411d3cc38e209c13104b747077b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior is abnormal (after the explosion occurs in the entire video, no dust is stirred up on the ground due to the impact of the explosion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01459", "filename": "acff745a2791928daf6aa32dc7468bb799865a97684c8e7be7244716915fd613_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (the blue ruler is suspended in mid-air without any support throughout the video, violating the law of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01460", "filename": "acff745a2791928daf6aa32dc7468bb799865a97684c8e7be7244716915fd613_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (at 3.5s, the blue ruler is completely vertical, but the metal block on it shows no signs of sliding down due to gravity. It remains firmly attached to the ruler).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01461", "filename": "acff745a2791928daf6aa32dc7468bb799865a97684c8e7be7244716915fd613_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 4.4s, all the small cubes under the blue ruler turned into small spheres without any change in shape).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01462", "filename": "acff745a2791928daf6aa32dc7468bb799865a97684c8e7be7244716915fd613_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 1.3s, the originally translucent blue plastic ruler suddenly turns into a blue metallic ruler without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01463", "filename": "ad0d913cc20e74e38c2bf67bb01fc9fc35688da446f8abc886ede36a61019843_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity error (a large amount of white foam suddenly appeared inside the glass container at 0.7s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01464", "filename": "ad0d913cc20e74e38c2bf67bb01fc9fc35688da446f8abc886ede36a61019843_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Abnormal physical behavior (at 0.7s, the glass container suddenly boils without being heated, and generates a large amount of hot gas).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01465", "filename": "ad0d913cc20e74e38c2bf67bb01fc9fc35688da446f8abc886ede36a61019843_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: A continuity error occurs (at 1.4 seconds, a large amount of irregularly shaped white foam suddenly appears at the bottom of the glass container).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01466", "filename": "ad0d913cc20e74e38c2bf67bb01fc9fc35688da446f8abc886ede36a61019843_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Abnormal physical behavior (at 5.2s, the liquid in this glass device suddenly increased and the liquid level rose without any liquid being injected).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01467", "filename": "ad4bc350e26905bb7c7c87f115afa0233cf8c0542f6c2bfbf1686fa885c3521f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (at 4s, the fire on the left side, which had no burning material, suddenly became intense, with the flames rising sharply and becoming brighter).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01468", "filename": "ad4bc350e26905bb7c7c87f115afa0233cf8c0542f6c2bfbf1686fa885c3521f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 4.4s, the flame color suddenly changes from orange-yellow to bright red without a gradual color change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01469", "filename": "ad4bc350e26905bb7c7c87f115afa0233cf8c0542f6c2bfbf1686fa885c3521f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Abnormal physical behavior (the color of the burning haystack did not change throughout the entire video, and it did not show the charring, carbonization, or other color changes that should occur after being burned).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01470", "filename": "ad4bc350e26905bb7c7c87f115afa0233cf8c0542f6c2bfbf1686fa885c3521f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (at 4.1s, the fire suddenly exploded without warning, and the intensity of the flames instantly increased, creating two giant flames far exceeding the size of the firewood pile).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01473", "filename": "6da06a0e65219a5ef08a7d3f82c685547fb61c50f98697ad0b0be963831b5f32_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01474", "filename": "6da06a0e65219a5ef08a7d3f82c685547fb61c50f98697ad0b0be963831b5f32_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (at 2s, the mop handle is black, but at 4.8s, without any external force or environmental change, the handle suddenly turns yellow).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01475", "filename": "6da06a0e65219a5ef08a7d3f82c685547fb61c50f98697ad0b0be963831b5f32_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (Throughout the video, the steam from the steam mop flows too smoothly, unlike realistic footage, lacking the jerky, uneven feel expected in real life.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01476", "filename": "6dc7594ccecf0dbfca21a285b036be90c0224c95b76666f3599afe84cb471dce_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the movement of the flames violates the upward lifting principle driven by thermal convection, exhibiting a formless stretching and deformation of the lateral translation, and lacking the motion vector characteristics of a real flame interacting with airflow.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01477", "filename": "6dc7594ccecf0dbfca21a285b036be90c0224c95b76666f3599afe84cb471dce_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01478", "filename": "6dd3e2864bc00e9772cf6357c9155cf1f6619dd7fbd3f66b3e1cec298364727a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (The bottle is in a snowy environment throughout the video, but the water inside appears to boil without absorbing any heat.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01479", "filename": "6dd3e2864bc00e9772cf6357c9155cf1f6619dd7fbd3f66b3e1cec298364727a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (The black impurities in the bottle sink to the bottom and gather towards the bottom; normally, the black impurities should disperse naturally after sinking to the bottom.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01480", "filename": "6dd3e2864bc00e9772cf6357c9155cf1f6619dd7fbd3f66b3e1cec298364727a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 4.6s, the black impurities in the bottle move towards the center and then suddenly disappear. At 2.7s, a blue substance suddenly appears at the bottom of the bottle.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01481", "filename": "6e5a5182affe4d79745e2be735da95ed1b1ccd244160bd258d4f4ebc7ad79973_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (0.19-2.4s, after the balloon is punctured by the drill, the water in the balloon does not fall naturally, but is sucked onto the drill bit and gradually sprayed outwards, violating the law of gravity.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01482", "filename": "6e5a5182affe4d79745e2be735da95ed1b1ccd244160bd258d4f4ebc7ad79973_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: At 1.4s, the drill pierces the balloon, but the balloon does not burst; instead, water sprays outwards. Between 1.4s and 5s, after the water is ejected, the balloon's size remains unchanged.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01483", "filename": "6e33d4370c2bbd3998412439e256e3bfd68da060fb6abe7170796ab2ac113497_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: During the continuous time (0-2.7s), the burn marks on the cardboard gradually disappear. During 2.22-5s, the burn marks on the tissue gradually recover.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01484", "filename": "6e33d4370c2bbd3998412439e256e3bfd68da060fb6abe7170796ab2ac113497_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The burning of the cardboard continues without any change in its shape. Normally, after carbonization, cardboard should shrink or deform.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01485", "filename": "6e33d4370c2bbd3998412439e256e3bfd68da060fb6abe7170796ab2ac113497_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (at 0.4 seconds, the smoke from the burning cardboard suddenly disappears). Overall visual anomalies (the flames move unnaturally throughout the video, unlike real flames).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01486", "filename": "6e33d4370c2bbd3998412439e256e3bfd68da060fb6abe7170796ab2ac113497_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 3.9s, black impurities are added to a burning pile of matches. The black impurities do not have time to burn within the match pile and burn instantly.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01490", "filename": "6e1919496e6b540b62e62f18b7a6ddaa80e90d709b9ab308e607e7176e868a47_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual presentation is abnormal (the entire video shows the process of wood burning, but the surface texture of the burning wood is neat and regular, without any carbonization marks, unlike real footage. When real wood burns, it carbonizes from the surface, and the surface texture deforms and peels off).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01491", "filename": "6e1919496e6b540b62e62f18b7a6ddaa80e90d709b9ab308e607e7176e868a47_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 5.6s, the burning wood suddenly changes from orange-red to grayish-white).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01492", "filename": "6e1919496e6b540b62e62f18b7a6ddaa80e90d709b9ab308e607e7176e868a47_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01500", "filename": "6ef8dae2ea3f0e8a59976880012059366620a64f26f0fbfbc048ee0e48e42835_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (as the camera moves, the leaves of the trees appear blurry and shaky, unlike real footage, and have a strong sense of being composited.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01501", "filename": "3e6667f5d51f1f4bfd88db729959c7a82a7968fdb7aeebddd7303fe87855432c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The continuity of time is abnormal: smoke drifts into the air and gradually spreads outwards with the airflow, but the smoke in the picture keeps drifting without dissipating.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01502", "filename": "3e06798a73e429a42a5918b9e77626e8dda3ff902d73e8602a590cc633045571_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Intermittent time anomaly: Starting at 3.7 seconds, the ice in the frame suddenly and rapidly melted into a transparent liquid.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01503", "filename": "3ea3c768d8c248b289b3b2ad999dcead249e5287c7ec6ca07febff3cce42b3f7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: When clouds move, they constantly change shape due to atmospheric turbulence and temperature changes, but the clouds in the picture only move horizontally.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01504", "filename": "3ec6c96f61445e890dd2b973055ba2eab7650978a51081c1d4a559f9b8fe210e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical behavior anomalies: The clouds in the image show no signs of dissipation or change in shape during their movement. Temporal continuity anomalies: The water ripples at the bottom of the image exhibit a rapidly swaying, S-shaped motion.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01505", "filename": "3ed5839ee03c2cc03910447970a33723248cc49e7c68fd7dfb66ebd423abee18_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: In a valley, clouds and fog would flow and spread with changes in terrain, wind, and temperature, but the clouds and fog in the picture are stationary.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01506", "filename": "3edfe964f3afcacfd8de61df5a217a216e9172cdedcb1aac3ace87352ae39393_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: Clouds are formed by the condensation of water vapor in the lower atmosphere and will continuously flow and spread with changes in terrain, wind, and temperature, but the cloud sea in the picture is in a static state.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01507", "filename": "3f04bc68c0af960b3ddf771dd575ebec1d376bfa07eda733778c780e5e2f7da9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Intermittent timing issues: The entire sequence exhibits noticeable stuttering and frame drops, disjointed hand movements, and unnatural transitions between scenes.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01508", "filename": "3f9ac9e6c98d847d8f501fde56e2180373f0f68835c4b9528f684136025497ea_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical anomalies: The high temperatures generated by burning should cause the plush fibers to quickly shrink or break, but in the footage, the white plush appears as static black spots during the burning process, without deformation, and the burning area does not expand.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01510", "filename": "3f999c966080d773966438c598f117f24ae206d05b1fa864652ab7c396bf075e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Temporal continuity anomaly: The white solid form in the image gradually melts and shrinks, but the melted liquid does not exhibit the actual melting, flowing, or morphological evolution process.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01511", "filename": "3fb0a1849865ba13f413f35aab93ff48df086d5901662499d100cf16db870992_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Interrupted playback time anomaly: at 3.1 seconds, the video suddenly plays at high speed, a colored bubble splits into two, and at 5.3 seconds, the video starts playing in reverse, with discontinuous playback.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01512", "filename": "3fc4ceff5cea04ebd72494f53ab4820f0ee981a1a1c21c191d9b529df0cf124a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01513", "filename": "3fd8beebcc2f458c4129feba110cc41aac0bae1531577ab40b3216fef2b9fddd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: The water vapor sprayed into the air in the scene did not fall naturally due to gravity, but instead gradually disappeared into the air like smoke.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01514", "filename": "3fdac7ec93a848a4b82d31edffce1196e9c8712151670566c4fc590920c325b1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Temporal continuity anomaly: The smoke outline in the image remains stable and moves slowly, without any natural diffusion or dilution.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01515", "filename": "3fe7ad2221e0737b3b027cfc2f679ce0760136355f1039976bca90b6a97b497e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Intermittent anomaly: Irregular gray blocks continuously move inward from both sides of the screen. After the light went out for 7.1 seconds, it suddenly turned on again, and the gray blocks gradually disappeared.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01516", "filename": "3fe9974416306a51d653818b649b56efe5c8df3e89475e83e616e5cb49759981_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01517", "filename": "4a4b8985768502f59a9bfe59dc3a595714de7005ef5947262c9316e4be8297aa_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in causality: It is raining heavily in the scene, but the trees remain still throughout, with no signs of rain hitting the leaves/branches and causing them to sway.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01518", "filename": "4a8a6a1eb3182454c8f003072a16c3681f2d17473721c61badd7fd6de9b616e5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Intermittent anomaly: A blue explosion effect suddenly appeared on the wall at 0.4 seconds, but no trace of the explosion remained afterward.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01519", "filename": "4a226073e9416329e67d0a0d6fcdab4a69be87c0f6cc975e58ac7834d76df6d9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Intermittent anomalies: At 1.5 seconds, the water ripples changed from a chaotic net-like pattern to a regular grid pattern; at 3 seconds, they gradually became parallel lines; and at 4 seconds, the water surface gradually turned black.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01520", "filename": "4aa255f15879611add3a39caf2f018a72e098824721a2cc14aac37a7c4318d19_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: In the footage, small balls fall and bounce back up without touching the ground, and some even float directly in the air.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01521", "filename": "4acc8c618e1d253e1042ac2b80086f2c9dade53933a916a77039718b1892ad9b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Temporal continuity anomaly: In the footage, the reflections of distant trees on the water's surface appear as regular vertical stripes, without any distortion or blurring due to water ripples.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01522", "filename": "4ae96481656e3d49f0fb58f7b875d45ebb8af7158b8298f04f9cfb6e6d13e964_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Causal relationship: The food on the barbecue grill in the picture is continuously roasted at high temperature, but there is no oil or traces of being roasted by fire. Physical behavior anomaly: The wood in the picture is continuously burning but not completely burning, but only flames are visible and no smoke is visible.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01523", "filename": "4af73cff1d8509073cabdffe4711829e0bbc8405b371df87a5885ad41cf5c3dd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical anomaly: Despite the continuous scouring of the water below, the ice block in the upper left shows no signs of melting. Causal anomaly: The water in the lower left corner of the image impacts the ice block but fails to splash any water.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01524", "filename": "4b1efea0e69b090d53244c73df515f67a2309561c5d444bc31669bb0fd8fe05b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical Behavior Anomaly: 1 seconds after the green crystal melts from the heat, the droplets should fall downwards from the heated area. Continuity Anomaly: In the footage, the green crystal melts and drips, but the heated area retains its original shape.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01525", "filename": "4b9d4d496bd7c45d0e43cda3855c7f491da516ada64e60d1b9173669827febd5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical behavior anomaly: The wood in the video does not carbonize or produce ash during the burning process.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01526", "filename": "4ba99d059ccc850359293fe13e693ffea58bf283f205fc2f8779aa4f37588dc2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Intermittent anomaly: There were no snowflakes on the tree, but 2 seconds ago, snowflakes fell from the middle of a dead branch, and there was a cloud of smoke in the middle of the branch. Physical behavior anomaly: After the explosion at the base of the branch at 2 seconds, there was no dust splashing, and the branch was not affected by the explosion in any way.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01527", "filename": "4bf5f9ba65522008ed143b0d3956fafe877d68fd2ac816578dfb3a29fa15e7f1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical anomalies: In a whole corncob, the cob absorbs a large amount of heat, preventing the kernels from heating up quickly and accumulating sufficient vaporization pressure. Even with localized heating, only the kernels would scorch. However, in the footage, a whole corncob pops directly into popcorn. Timing anomalies: Starting at 3.2 seconds, popcorn appears out of nowhere in the oven where there was no corn.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01528", "filename": "4c4bf08b3420453d7cd8ef4e4e4d9902616df8ea77ccfd6c7a551b95c7668cba_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical anomaly: The tree branches in the image are burning, but not completely; only flames are visible, not smoke.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01529", "filename": "4c554e3369db38b45edbc1bdb3c4923d5aae14b0e167d9e89643a693b541aace_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01530", "filename": "4cf1b60a6112c10b50a6ad4a7d07e15fe70ad6f0c861924f780247ea4d9229d5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: During the period of 0.2s-2.6s, the character's fingers did not grip the disc or make any movements that could support it, but the disc did not fall.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01532", "filename": "68edbd5940b2b926b89f5f2259b6437d691af366ede2e7b4e07a393481edafcf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 0.5s, a water droplet falling on an object disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01533", "filename": "68f4b134eeda7650e8d2ee6d1894f10090a410ea711ca4d3c45587451cdecd10_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the yellow particles on the knife disappear out of thin air at 0.8s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01534", "filename": "69c0ac57de0328f9bdde61961c412771f431f876e782ac0ba21d919ae7ea475f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera transition, the animal on the road in the upper left corner of the screen disappears out of thin air at 3.6 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01536", "filename": "69ef43bc7e2de99f838ebea75f8473ccd6afb6ec545116f3fa131eccc948e7f6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the flame on the right side of the screen is affected by the wind and shifts to the left, while the fire on the left side does not show any swaying or shifting reaction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01537", "filename": "70a82fda594fcccf68a3eb166043f9ef6e84ee63a7557c3899a84f3cf5cfb942_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time sequence is continuous (the smoke from the explosion in the video remains gathered and does not disperse naturally with the airflow, and the smoke as a whole does not have any transition in density or gradual change in layering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01538", "filename": "70c51c4d38821d07ae35b4e828b06c03a55b578d1ec4c5950c11ea68f0cf1ada_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time sequence is too rigid and uniform (the water waves in the video are too regular and rigid, and there are no natural undulations, deformations, or dynamic changes throughout the entire sequence; they remain in a fixed state).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01539", "filename": "71b9c0b287bcf8298696326f55a40c42b88be370730e78067c0cd8e454d08772_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the hammer is subjected to pressure, but only the tip deforms while the tail remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01540", "filename": "71e9e3d24d7e812b6023e02d322e8a4c915510f0af280ad126bd47b402a3f2d0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, a wooden block suddenly appears on top of the iron block at 4.6 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01541", "filename": "71ec1cbd9351409ba4b2ff84a7fefe717eee47eb3caed51fce13df36399040eb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (without any camera movement, the clouds suddenly turn yellow at 5:25).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01543", "filename": "72f88092ebf650ad5106e16e79331583e7801eec6ab957df207d9bbca6b6c46c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time sequence is continuous (after the fireworks explosion, the debris only flies in one direction straight ahead, unlike the three-dimensional diffusion of explosives in all directions as is seen in reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01545", "filename": "74c1d4da47a0c8b8a9bf5628e9083329e113a185544810ecaf27b4b36916a6a4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (under the condition of no external interference, the black colloid momentarily stops moving at 6.7s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01546", "filename": "75b09ef13d83d2665cba3388dd4132d38b1f5e869e4c5eb5468ee083f863bff2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is unusual: the time is continuous (at 3.3s, the polar bear stirs the water with its hand, but the water surface does not produce any ripples or waves and remains flat).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01548", "filename": "78aa41426c504997d77fd4bc7d811afd2e94f97ce9fe0f3664ec2e6a98c4fe62_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the water ripples in the image are too regular and rigid, without natural random undulations, and when water droplets fall into the water, they do not splash any water or create corresponding spreading ripples).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01549", "filename": "78aae24bd7e8dce0cf67600af8fc8e645e856feb4794b394fd419a5aab27257e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Time continuity (Under the premise of no external force or interference, the kerosene lamp in the image twists abnormally, just like when the flame is lit).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01550", "filename": "78ee957030609bedb37501d463ef28eaf950b08a7d8293142c5cc81c3d51dcda_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (under the premise of no camera movement and no external force or interference, the snow in the footage suddenly becomes larger at 3.3s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01552", "filename": "79f1254b0517c894e1798f10a847e1b6b6aeb855c59db69f1263372b814e2725_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: continuous time (after the pigment is dropped into the water, there is no natural dissolution and diffusion process. Instead, it instantly forms flocculent matter and sinks directly to the bottom of the water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01553", "filename": "80bf880071151c848f5d531293710d020c77c783a0792af4f0c163bdd913785e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera transition, at 3.6s, a wooden stick appears out of thin air from the flames).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01555", "filename": "80d7f7a1c6a14ecdaf7eff979d7926dbc547941db1275714f2166346556b8407_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera transition, a smiley face pattern appears out of thin air on the toy at 0.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01556", "filename": "82d8cf2c55d012b30cd50d810c55ccd3dd1d8d3511eb7f93e7acb5db78af5641_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 1.4s, the water droplet hits the apple and disappears instantly).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01557", "filename": "82ec5e44e8cd14582a144530ecf68795305ebac990d4560e5dce1489d5ec15c7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera transition, at 6.6s, the object on the left side of the screen suddenly turns white).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01558", "filename": "82ec18a86cd766c92b400a02f405aa48686c4b414683a32b81bd32cc4664f64e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the clouds in the entire image are abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01559", "filename": "83a480a542eae27c1f521a5b9c02a22311cfd0a8602eb5584c10bd4525ae2c51_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the ground in the scene is abnormally distorted, and ice blocks are constantly melting, producing large amounts of liquid, but their volume does not decrease).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01560", "filename": "83a6822f1d4958133c07594f03c350c6e58fdddab65be90afb03bcb052a17c0f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Continuous time (irregular flickering, distortion, and twisting effects continuously appear at the boundary between blue and red colors, and there is no natural transition at the color joints).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01561", "filename": "P28_103_161_0ca77dfd242a2237_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01562", "filename": "P28_103_161_0ca77dfd242a2237_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01563", "filename": "P28_103_161_0ca77dfd242a2237_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the oil in the pot boils without being heated, and oil produces some steam when it boils, but a large amount of white steam is seen coming out of the pot in the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01564", "filename": "P28_103_167_3e0155f58922a695_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: the gas stove, which was lit at 4.6 seconds, suddenly went out and then suddenly reignited, but the person in the video did not make any action of turning off or on the stove.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01565", "filename": "P28_103_194_eacabf8d7a4e4df8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01566", "filename": "P28_103_194_eacabf8d7a4e4df8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.9s, the potato that was cut and was still half gone disappears into thin air). (between 5.3s and 6.3s, the potato was cut twice but remained intact. The potato that was cut later should have been sliced, but in the video it turned into potato cubes).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01567", "filename": "P28_103_289_0b4ca78f8f9a2c2e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (at 2.4s, the person's hand did not touch the pot on the right, but the pot moved outward automatically, which does not conform to the law of interaction of forces). Time continuity (at 2.5s, the handle held by the left hand suddenly changed from two to one).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01568", "filename": "P28_103_289_0b4ca78f8f9a2c2e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 3.3s to 6.1s, the pot that was taken out on the left floated in the air without any force, which does not conform to the law of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01569", "filename": "P28_103_289_0b4ca78f8f9a2c2e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01570", "filename": "P28_104_122_cf46d20729cfd17e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 0.7s, the fork in the right hand suddenly flips, and a glass pot lid appears out of thin air in the left hand.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01571", "filename": "P28_104_157_2b4e91772ff24ffd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The timing is continuous (at 4.5 seconds, a stream of water suddenly appears out of thin air in the center of the lid and flows into the pot, but there is not enough steam on the lid to form a stream of water).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01572", "filename": "P28_105_8_d9b7a90f4e168ced_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01573", "filename": "P28_105_40_3937ab210964d78f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.1 seconds, there was originally a bottle of cooking wine under the food tray on the lower shelf of the refrigerator door, but it suddenly turned into a bag of green melons).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01574", "filename": "P28_105_40_3937ab210964d78f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (between 0.5s and 1.7s, the refrigerator door opened automatically without any force applied, which does not conform to the law of interaction of forces).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01575", "filename": "P28_105_75_eb2d25939f8e7faf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the faucet is not turned on throughout the entire video, but the water in the sink keeps increasing out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01576", "filename": "P28_105_75_eb2d25939f8e7faf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (at 0.7s, water suddenly flows out of the faucet without it being turned on).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01577", "filename": "P28_108_12_251b33eb3df1c4ed_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (0.7s-4.3s). The water poured from the pot of food into the plate of filtered water does not flow down the sink, but disappears into thin air.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01578", "filename": "P28_108_46_1c21ae1f03839e87_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 6.5s, the potato held in the person's left hand disappears into thin air and is reduced by half) (at 7s - the end, the potato held in the hand is cut off and reduced, but there are no potatoes in the plate below, and the cut potato disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01579", "filename": "P28_108_46_1c21ae1f03839e87_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.5s, the long potato in the hand suddenly turns into a square shape) (at 5.1s, the potato in the left hand passes directly through the middle grater and moves to the right hand).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01580", "filename": "P28_110_7_ff771de3fd9dd785_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.7 seconds, a person in the video stuffs clothes into the washing machine lid, but the clothes disappear into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01581", "filename": "P28_110_7_ff771de3fd9dd785_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The display changes abruptly at 0.3 seconds, and the washing machine lid, which was originally open, flips over and reopens.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01582", "filename": "P28_111_141_a35a50549f9f19ce_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: During the continuous time frame (0.4s-1.1s, while a person is pulling out a towel, the towel on the left side of the cabinet handle remains stationary and is not pulled out).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01583", "filename": "P28_111_153_18a42a9a3fe5e1d0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the steel wool that was thrown into the pot from my hand disappeared into thin air at 2.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01584", "filename": "P28_111_155_8e4fde39c5269b67_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (water from the tap keeps flowing into the pot without being poured out, but the amount of water in the pot remains the same and does not increase).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01585", "filename": "P28_111_155_8e4fde39c5269b67_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.1s, the pot handle held by the right hand suddenly moves to the left, but it is a transition process) (at 3s, the spoon on the table suddenly turns into a steel wool ball)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01586", "filename": "P28_111_156_c7b321445f9c0ba7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at the beginning - 0.5s, the pot is not connected to the tap, but a lot of water appears out of thin air in the pot) (at 2.7s - the end, during the repeated pouring of water, the water in the pot remains unchanged, neither increasing nor decreasing)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01587", "filename": "P28_111_199_92c7d0ce81912b1e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 2.7s, the white paper strip in the person's left hand disappears out of thin air) (at 3.2s, the torn packaging bag foot is restored).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01588", "filename": "P28_111_199_92c7d0ce81912b1e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Continuous timing (the packaging bag was already torn open at 6.6s, but the video shows it being torn open again from the left). Physical behavior (the hand leaves the packaging bag at 7.8s, but the item in the hand remains suspended in the air, which does not conform to the law of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01589", "filename": "P28_111_199_92c7d0ce81912b1e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The video feed suddenly changed at 7.3 seconds. The previously opened packaging bag was suddenly restored, and the orientation of the packaging bag suddenly changed from vertical to horizontal.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01590", "filename": "P28_111_203_d618853c86d2dd86_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The timing is continuous (at 4.3s, the packaging bag is not sealed, the opening of the packaging bag is facing downwards, and it falls to the ground, but the flour inside the bag does not spill out).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01591", "filename": "bbeff6b7ffba4806ad956ad01e60b35c6e7bf8cb64cd45061a2149a5402362e8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (0s-4.9s: when the water from the water gun passes through the flame, the shape of the flame is not dispersed or shifted at all, nor does it shrink or extinguish as it should when it encounters water. The elements on both sides are completely independent and there is no real physical interaction).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01592", "filename": "bbeff6b7ffba4806ad956ad01e60b35c6e7bf8cb64cd45061a2149a5402362e8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the physical behavior (0.4s-2.2s) is incorrect; the contact between the bottom of the flame and the metal basin is not right; the fire does not burn upwards along the edge of the basin; and when the water is poured on, the water in the basin does not produce a large amount of steam due to the high temperature, which is unrealistic.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01593", "filename": "bc5e28af193ade75826ef6a06620849ab02d9b8a872be05ca74b7b198358b5a2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to physical behavior (the steam in the 0s-5s video is of a single form, consisting of large, uniform white mists, lacking the fine, rolling bubbles that appear when steam rises from the water surface. Furthermore, the integration of the steam and the sky in the distance is stiff and unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01594", "filename": "bc5e28af193ade75826ef6a06620849ab02d9b8a872be05ca74b7b198358b5a2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (in the video from 0s to 4.9s, the transition between the rocks and water flow on the right side appears somewhat abrupt; the rock edges are too sharp, lacking the smooth, moist feel of long-term erosion by water vapor, and the water flow on the rocks does not create natural watermarks or damp, dark areas).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01595", "filename": "bc5e28af193ade75826ef6a06620849ab02d9b8a872be05ca74b7b198358b5a2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the interaction between the water flow and rocks in the video from 0.6s to 7.9s is unrealistic; when the water flows onto the protruding rock on the right, it does not splash or create puddles, and the water does not leave any wet traces after passing over the rock).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01596", "filename": "bc1067fa266551361c33027f91fead77d011466e91375f965125a2694d17201c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (between 2.7s and 3.7s, the ring on the right side of the screen rotates on its own without being subjected to any force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01597", "filename": "bc1067fa266551361c33027f91fead77d011466e91375f965125a2694d17201c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01598", "filename": "bc1427b57572aab021ace65642410db64a0853125cf70772b26a852eb93a2c08_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (1.3s-4.9s) The lighting and shadow logic of the entire video is inconsistent. The shadow of the hand when wiping the glass is not the same as the direction of the light on the car body. In addition, the water marks left on the glass by the blue cloth do not disappear in time with the wiping action.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01599", "filename": "bc1427b57572aab021ace65642410db64a0853125cf70772b26a852eb93a2c08_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the physical behavior (from 1.9s to 5.1s, the movement of the hand and cloth wiping the glass is somewhat mechanical, like a horizontal movement rather than the arc of actual wiping; the water marks on the car window disappear too abruptly after the cloth leaves, without a natural flow or evaporation process)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01600", "filename": "bc1427b57572aab021ace65642410db64a0853125cf70772b26a852eb93a2c08_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (1.8s-2.2s: the hand is not gripping the rag while wiping the glass; the rag seems to be stuck to the hand, violating the law of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01601", "filename": "bc1427b57572aab021ace65642410db64a0853125cf70772b26a852eb93a2c08_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01602", "filename": "bc9399ef8f143259c2344bfdc9e4ccf7e6483f98e2ccd88dc842c7f308c0c749_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (3.9s-5s: the pink liquid in the spiral section is \"climbing\" upwards, defying the principle of gravity; the liquid on the green sphere is flowing back and forth, without any tendency to flow downwards naturally).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01603", "filename": "bc9399ef8f143259c2344bfdc9e4ccf7e6483f98e2ccd88dc842c7f308c0c749_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (0s-5.1s: when the pink liquid flows from the spiral structure above onto the green sphere, the volume of the liquid suddenly increases, which does not conform to the law of conservation of mass).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01604", "filename": "bc9399ef8f143259c2344bfdc9e4ccf7e6483f98e2ccd88dc842c7f308c0c749_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (0.1s-5s, when the pink liquid flows from the spiral structure above onto the green sphere, the volume of the liquid suddenly increases, which does not conform to the law of conservation of mass).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01605", "filename": "bc9399ef8f143259c2344bfdc9e4ccf7e6483f98e2ccd88dc842c7f308c0c749_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01606", "filename": "bce2dc099bd9a9d5e14f09489a8959810cbb487dc2c4b12813012e0fb8a4a826_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (0.5s-4.9s) The highlights on the surface of the glutinous rice balls are too hard and too white, completely lacking the warm and moist texture of glutinous rice, and the bubbles in the bowl look more like coarse foam.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01607", "filename": "bce2dc099bd9a9d5e14f09489a8959810cbb487dc2c4b12813012e0fb8a4a826_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomalies: Physical behavior (0s-5s): The highlights of the glutinous rice balls are too uniform, like plastic balls, lacking the warmth of glutinous rice; the texture of the glutinous rice flour in the bowl is incorrect, with too strong a granular texture and too regular distribution, lacking the natural fluffiness of hand-sprinkled flour; the image is overexposed, and the bright details of the glutinous rice balls and glutinous rice flour are completely lost, making them appear without depth; the size and shape of the glutinous rice balls are too uniform, which does not conform to the randomness of handmade production.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01608", "filename": "bce2dc099bd9a9d5e14f09489a8959810cbb487dc2c4b12813012e0fb8a4a826_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 2.7s to 7.9s, the liquid in the bowl still lacks fluidity and bubbles, resembling solidified colloid; the connection between the glutinous rice ball in the lower right corner and the edge of the bowl lacks the refraction and watermark effects of the glutinous rice ball immersed in water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01609", "filename": "bce42a4e8f6a486af1f4125cd170a09221604b481e4558956deb941751dcf060_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: Physical behavior (0.9s-5s) The texture of the leaves is too blurry, there is no real leaf vein detail, and the shadows of the leaves in different positions are the same, without the changes in depth caused by the angle of the light and the obstruction in front and behind, there is no layering, and the light passes through the leaves, which violates the principle that light travels in a straight line.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01610", "filename": "bce42a4e8f6a486af1f4125cd170a09221604b481e4558956deb941751dcf060_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (0.3s-5.6s) The leaves did not form a realistic semi-transparent light transmission effect, and the transition between bright and dark areas was very abrupt. In addition, the blue sky in the background was too uniform in color, lacking the natural gradation of the blue sky at high altitudes, which is slightly darker in the distance and slightly lighter near the leaves. It looked like a blue background board with light shining through the leaves, which violated the principle that light travels in straight lines.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01611", "filename": "bce42a4e8f6a486af1f4125cd170a09221604b481e4558956deb941751dcf060_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the swaying of the leaves from 1.7s to 5s is too mechanical; the amplitude and rhythm of each leaf's swaying are almost identical. In reality, leaves sway at varying speeds and rhythms depending on the force applied. Also, the brightness of the sunlight remains unchanged throughout. In reality, the light spots filtering through the leaves would create flickering light and shadow as the leaves sway, but now it looks too constant, lacking dynamic changes in light and shadow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01612", "filename": "bce42a4e8f6a486af1f4125cd170a09221604b481e4558956deb941751dcf060_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01613", "filename": "bd0bada94d636ad0cdc6ebfd5cac59696450ecdbdddd8893732e855ff00fd4b8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (during the 0.1s-3.8s melting period, the ice block's edge did not exhibit the gradual transition from solid to transparent, softening, and eventually melting; instead, it directly transformed from a solid ice block into water, lacking the dripping and slippery surface effects of melting. Furthermore, the amount of liquid in the container did not increase after the ice block melted into liquid, violating the laws governing the transformation of object forms).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01614", "filename": "bd4e2f00ea410d960064ec7d56da945a9c5622a049090e95f46516d44849f9d6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the clouds in the video from 0.1s to 5s have extremely unnatural transitions between light and dark areas; the bright and dark parts appear to be abruptly cut off, lacking the soft, gradual changes in light and shadow characteristic of real clouds. Furthermore, the clouds move too uniformly; each cloud moves at the exact same speed and direction. In reality, clouds are affected by air currents, with some drifting faster and others slower, and some areas exhibiting small-scale tumbling and deformation.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01615", "filename": "bd4e2f00ea410d960064ec7d56da945a9c5622a049090e95f46516d44849f9d6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (0.3s-5.2s) The clouds move too uniformly, without any speed difference due to varying cloud thickness; clouds in the distance and nearby drift at the same speed. Furthermore, the shadows of the clouds are too dark, lacking the translucent layers of the cloud interior, appearing like a black cloth covering the clouds, completely lacking the thick, translucent texture of real cumulus clouds.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01616", "filename": "bd4e2f00ea410d960064ec7d56da945a9c5622a049090e95f46516d44849f9d6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (a black cloud suddenly appears in the frame between 4.3s and 7.9s and rapidly grows larger).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01617", "filename": "bd7e9a8d73d541f37744b8f8b90c30bfa6402ecb954ccee2338d6c75ea36a685_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: Physical behavior (0s-5s) The light and shadow of the cup and ice cubes are too \"flat\", without the light refraction effect that a glass should have. The ice cubes also do not have the transparent texture and bright reflection that light produces when it passes through them. The whole thing looks like it is covered with a layer of fog, without the clarity of a real iced drink. The cup rotates without any external force, which violates the law of conservation of physical quantities.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01618", "filename": "bd7e9a8d73d541f37744b8f8b90c30bfa6402ecb954ccee2338d6c75ea36a685_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (The condensation on the cup wall suddenly appeared between 2.1s and 5.8s. Before that, the cup wall was dry and there was no process of water vapor slowly condensing into small water droplets. Moreover, the newly appeared water droplets were of very uniform size and distribution, as if a layer of water droplet stickers had been directly pasted on them. This does not conform to the physical process of condensation gradually forming and slowly accumulating in reality.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01619", "filename": "bd7e9a8d73d541f37744b8f8b90c30bfa6402ecb954ccee2338d6c75ea36a685_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01620", "filename": "bd7e9a8d73d541f37744b8f8b90c30bfa6402ecb954ccee2338d6c75ea36a685_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (0.7s-2.7s: The white mist appears too abruptly, without the gradual process of emerging from the cup; the volume of the ice cubes in the image does not change, yet a large amount of water appears, violating the laws of object transformation; 3s-3.4s: The background suddenly changes from a white background to a landscape background, which is too abrupt).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01621", "filename": "P04_119_253_97f03b97163b7b39_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01622", "filename": "P04_119_265_eadce31310d52518_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 3.1 seconds, the water in the cup in the hand suddenly increases out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01623", "filename": "P04_120_11_16d03b340d13217d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (at 4.1 seconds, the thermometer in the hand suddenly reverses, and the entire video feed is constantly flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01624", "filename": "P04_120_11_16d03b340d13217d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (the shape of the thermometer dial suddenly changes at 4s, and a large amount of smoke suddenly comes out of the pot at 6.7s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01625", "filename": "P04_120_145_5995cbbfee8ec66d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 2.1s, the handle next to the sink is twisted and deformed, at 4.3s the book passes through the handle of the pot, at 4.8s the person's right hand is twisted and deformed and a stirrer appears out of nowhere under the book).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01626", "filename": "P04_120_156_747894580b0bcae5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: continuous flickering (the entire video is constantly flashing and the number of white dots in the pot varies).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01627", "filename": "P04_120_156_747894580b0bcae5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to physical behavior (only a small part of the bottom of the pot touches the table between 6.8s and 8s, but the pot remains stable, which does not conform to the laws of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01628", "filename": "P04_120_222_1922ee417f3ab578_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (at 2.9s, water droplets sprayed out of the wire brush even though the hand was not squeezing it, and at 4.7s, the water droplets that splashed onto the iron plate disappeared instantly).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01629", "filename": "P04_120_222_1922ee417f3ab578_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (the wire brush suddenly deforms at 6.1s, and the tilted iron plate should be smooth with water in it between 7.1s and 8s, but the wire brush is still stuck to the iron plate).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01630", "filename": "P04_120_239_cdc8caf466c82bdc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (the transparent glass container in hand suddenly deforms at 2.4 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01631", "filename": "P04_120_340_b39d486c8d577a3e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.4s, the silver spoon in the hand and the blue spoon in the pot merged upon contact).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01632", "filename": "P04_120_355_fa50a2ce3e7467c7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the ground and walls in the lower left corner of the entire video are constantly flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01633", "filename": "P04_120_355_fa50a2ce3e7467c7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01634", "filename": "P04_120_369_ae26d5efffb4516c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: continuous flickering (the bottom left corner of the video is constantly flashing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01635", "filename": "P04_121_13_5828d614e1f4c9bb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time frame is continuous (from the beginning to 1.8 seconds, a knife is used to cut yellow food in a pot, but no knife marks appear on the food).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01636", "filename": "P04_121_13_5828d614e1f4c9bb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 5.6 seconds, the uncut parts of the food in the pot suddenly turn into neat squares).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01637", "filename": "P04_121_27_172946becd329d55_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (two knives cross each other at 2.6s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01638", "filename": "P04_121_104_7ac78d4a80d6c373_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the yellow object in the tank suddenly disappears at 4.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01639", "filename": "P04_121_104_7ac78d4a80d6c373_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01640", "filename": "P04_121_188_d8516de605d0766f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the towel suddenly splits into two pieces at 3.6 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01641", "filename": "P04_121_188_d8516de605d0766f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.3s, the small shovel in the hand suddenly deforms and the yellow towel in the left hand suddenly disappears; at 4.8s, a black rack suddenly appears out of thin air in the sink; at 6s, the front of the transparent container suddenly turns into the back and the yellow towel in the hand suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01642", "filename": "P04_121_272_ad6f7cb0a063c58a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous flickering (the entire video is constantly flashing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01643", "filename": "P04_121_272_ad6f7cb0a063c58a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01644", "filename": "P04_121_407_392d5ae6ebdd4f4c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: continuous time (the entire video is flickering, and at 4.4s, the towel attached to the glove suddenly moves to the left).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01645", "filename": "P04_121_415_ecdc655cd3eda16c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.5s, the towel in the hand suddenly splits into two pieces, and at 2.9s, the two towels suddenly merge again).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01646", "filename": "P04_121_415_ecdc655cd3eda16c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01647", "filename": "P04_121_440_8ef651412f6651ba_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video error: Time continuity (the entire video is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01648", "filename": "P04_121_440_8ef651412f6651ba_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (the blue object in the pot disappears at 3s, and a large number of white objects suddenly emerge from the pot starting at 1.1s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01649", "filename": "P04_121_470_aa020cf1caa760d9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (at 1.3 seconds, the number of items in the bowl suddenly increases).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01650", "filename": "P04_121_470_aa020cf1caa760d9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous flickering (the entire video is constantly flashing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01651", "filename": "P04_121_470_aa020cf1caa760d9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the liquid in the pot changes on its own at 0s without being stirred, and the water in the bowl suddenly disappears at 2s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01652", "filename": "P04_121_505_015fcf7a4374bf29_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous flickering (the entire video is constantly flashing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01653", "filename": "P04_121_505_015fcf7a4374bf29_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.8 seconds, the black spoon in the pot suddenly disappears and the blue spoon part turns black).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01654", "filename": "P04_121_530_d8e3f67d7025fba3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1.1s, the two scissors in the hand merge and deform, and a small knife suddenly appears in the left hand; at 1.9s, the blade in the left hand suddenly disappears; at 2.5s, the object in the left hand suddenly deforms).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01655", "filename": "P04_121_530_d8e3f67d7025fba3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 1.8s, the scissors in the left hand suddenly deformed and the knife in the right hand also deformed).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01656", "filename": "P04_121_566_652097912f4e954f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the entire video is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01657", "filename": "P06_101_39_57e9b429eb0a763b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the item cut out at 3.9s suddenly deforms)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01658", "filename": "2747cf242c95a2301ad179f0e35de5e88736a1b6ad4c1a17efcb7927ad4ad7f6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Temporal continuity (the overall image exhibits flickering and flaws); Overall visual inconsistencies (the water surface in the image is too smooth, lacking any ripples and a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01659", "filename": "2747cf242c95a2301ad179f0e35de5e88736a1b6ad4c1a17efcb7927ad4ad7f6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (after 1.8 seconds into the video, the water surface reacts strongly to the wind, producing violent ripples, but the leaves in the footage remain still and unaffected by the wind).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01660", "filename": "2747cf242c95a2301ad179f0e35de5e88736a1b6ad4c1a17efcb7927ad4ad7f6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: (Throughout the entire video, the reflection of the water surface shows many fragmented cumulus clouds, but there are no fragmented cumulus clouds in the sky, which violates the principle of light reflection.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01661", "filename": "2747cf242c95a2301ad179f0e35de5e88736a1b6ad4c1a17efcb7927ad4ad7f6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (the blue tones of the water and the blue of the sky blend abruptly without creating natural variations in light and shadow, appearing as if the colors were directly spliced together) Temporal continuity (at 2 seconds into the video, numerous ripples appear out of nowhere on the calm water surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01662", "filename": "2801f27cb83e2ab1cf93a75fb1124531c936830db8a55602a0dedee8bb2e2206_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.2s in the video, the person in the scene has not yet touched the bell, but the bell has already changed to a downward press state).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01663", "filename": "2801f27cb83e2ab1cf93a75fb1124531c936830db8a55602a0dedee8bb2e2206_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.4s, the character's finger and the bell in the frame are not on the same horizontal plane, but as the finger presses down, the bell also presses down).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01664", "filename": "2801f27cb83e2ab1cf93a75fb1124531c936830db8a55602a0dedee8bb2e2206_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01665", "filename": "2827c2b628bd8b9ddfd496aec9befb417f16cb63445160910bea284494213379_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (at 0.3s in the video, a white object in the water flies out automatically without any external interference, violating the law of conservation of energy).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01666", "filename": "2827c2b628bd8b9ddfd496aec9befb417f16cb63445160910bea284494213379_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.4s in the video, ice cubes in the water disappear out of thin air without any change in the shot).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01667", "filename": "2827c2b628bd8b9ddfd496aec9befb417f16cb63445160910bea284494213379_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01668", "filename": "2827c2b628bd8b9ddfd496aec9befb417f16cb63445160910bea284494213379_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the image remains still throughout the entire video, and there is no change even when the camera zooms in, lacking a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01669", "filename": "2850d974320243551ab9927dcd4b7a5743dae3d6c5a7d3a82458a5b1764d0c37_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the sun's rays are at the top of the image, but the distribution of light and shadow in the clouds does not conform to the logic of real lighting; the shadow transitions in some clouds are too abrupt, lacking a natural sense of transition and realistic depth).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01670", "filename": "2850d974320243551ab9927dcd4b7a5743dae3d6c5a7d3a82458a5b1764d0c37_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the color transition of natural clouds is a soft gradient, but the blue and white boundaries of the clouds in the image are harsh, lacking the subtle layers produced by the thickness and moisture changes of real clouds, and more like the effect of digital compositing or rendering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01671", "filename": "2850d974320243551ab9927dcd4b7a5743dae3d6c5a7d3a82458a5b1764d0c37_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are off: The overall impression is off (the clouds in the image are too blurry and ethereal, with repetitive textures and saturated colors, lacking the soft, undulating feel of realistic clouds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01672", "filename": "2850d974320243551ab9927dcd4b7a5743dae3d6c5a7d3a82458a5b1764d0c37_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: The overall visual impression is off. (When the sun is partially obscured by clouds, light diffuses outwards, giving the edges of the surrounding clouds a soft halo. However, the sun in this image looks more like a bright spot \"attached\" to the clouds, lacking the natural light diffusion effect.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01673", "filename": "2960dd09d1896ab911e5cb139cff74f1b26a340ea4f4d8af388b5041e770ff92_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (fireworks explode out of thin air in the sky at 0s, 0.2s, 2.6s, 2.9s, and 3.9s without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01674", "filename": "2960dd09d1896ab911e5cb139cff74f1b26a340ea4f4d8af388b5041e770ff92_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01675", "filename": "2960dd09d1896ab911e5cb139cff74f1b26a340ea4f4d8af388b5041e770ff92_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01680", "filename": "3064e1c135a4e3194aeeb145c34fc062351a71c9bb76adf48965e7dfb29ab5bd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (at 1s, the round object in the hand suddenly becomes an irregular object without any change in the camera angle; at 3.1s, the irregular object rotates on its own without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01681", "filename": "3064e1c135a4e3194aeeb145c34fc062351a71c9bb76adf48965e7dfb29ab5bd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1 seconds into the video, the color of the round table in the frame suddenly turns white without any change in the shot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01682", "filename": "3064e1c135a4e3194aeeb145c34fc062351a71c9bb76adf48965e7dfb29ab5bd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: temporal continuity (at 1.6s in the video, two circular objects suddenly merge into one without the camera changing direction).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01683", "filename": "3064e1c135a4e3194aeeb145c34fc062351a71c9bb76adf48965e7dfb29ab5bd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: temporal continuity (at 0.4s in the video, a circular object suddenly appears in the middle of the frame; at 2.6s, without any change in camera angle, a circular object appears out of nowhere in the frame).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01684", "filename": "03331d9c44dfa204dd48ce3bd19a153a98f0fe3690f4f54a2998b8ce8b9d76b0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity (flickering artifacts are present throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01685", "filename": "03331d9c44dfa204dd48ce3bd19a153a98f0fe3690f4f54a2998b8ce8b9d76b0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (realistic flames sway and flicker due to air movement, and their edges exhibit a soft, gradual transition. However, the flames in this image have overly regular outlines and sharp edges, lacking natural motion blur and shape variation).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01686", "filename": "03331d9c44dfa204dd48ce3bd19a153a98f0fe3690f4f54a2998b8ce8b9d76b0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (realistic flames sway and dance with the movement of air, and their edges fade gently, but this flame's outline is too sharp and its shape too stable, lacking natural dynamic blur).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01688", "filename": "P03_117_247_9b2e82665519fd65_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (at 3.6s, the two thumbs of the person in the video suddenly merge together after crossing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01689", "filename": "P03_119_10_2f37a565f30b0627_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the shadow reflected on the floor at 1.5s is not a human figure, and it does not match the human figure bending over to pick up a plate in the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01690", "filename": "P03_119_10_2f37a565f30b0627_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.5s, the character's hand doesn't touch the pot when picking it up, but the pot appears in their hand in the next frame.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01691", "filename": "P03_117_247_9b2e82665519fd65_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (between 2.7s and 6.8s, the red object in the image becomes longer and the tin foil suddenly disappears.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01692", "filename": "P03_119_19_03b3c12383cd3826_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 4 seconds, water suddenly starts flowing without touching the faucet; at 4.1 seconds, water begins to splash even though the bottom of the pan is not in contact with water; and a large amount of foam suddenly appears in the water even though there is no dish soap in the pan).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01693", "filename": "P03_119_148_b56cbcb28e4d89b6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.1s, the blue object in the person's hand suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01694", "filename": "P03_119_148_b56cbcb28e4d89b6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is inconsistent (at 0.1s, the glass bottle and blue cap in the person's hand suddenly twist and deform; at 0.8s, the glass bottle and blue cap become noticeably larger, with no consistency between the two).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01695", "filename": "P03_120_3_7c85cff5a25ef5bf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (between 0.6s and 1.5s, the right middle finger of the figure in the image is deformed and passes through the book).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01696", "filename": "P03_120_3_7c85cff5a25ef5bf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01697", "filename": "P03_120_93_c77a764d013797e9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.2s, the object in the character's hand is only a small part, but at 4.5s it becomes much larger when placed in the basin, showing no consistency).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01698", "filename": "P03_120_107_ff99d342fdb155c7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01699", "filename": "P03_120_127_35eafda53797f4cf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01700", "filename": "P03_120_127_35eafda53797f4cf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (between 2.3s and 5.3s, the character rubs a lemon on a rubbing tool, but the lemon is not damaged).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01701", "filename": "P03_120_127_35eafda53797f4cf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0.8s: when the lemon in the character's hand is placed on the cutting board, it becomes one with the lemon on the cutting board; 2.6s: at 2.6s: the right hand suddenly takes out a lemon out of thin air from behind the wiping tool; 3.6s: the lemon on the cutting board rolls into the left hand and disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01702", "filename": "P03_120_232_4689168e3f215e1b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the scene changes abruptly without any transition at 2.6s, and the image quality becomes unstable and the screen shakes continuously from 2.6s to 8s.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01703", "filename": "P03_120_255_0eaa96cdb05d9b43_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal due to physical reasons (the period from 3.4s to 6.2s in the image violates the principles of thermodynamics, causing the object to melt too quickly; the water in the iron pot turns yellow even though the yellow object is separated from the bowl).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01704", "filename": "P03_121_17_7438308a8df02b20_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (3.2s) - lemon zest suddenly appears out of nowhere on the side of the wiper facing the character.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01705", "filename": "P03_121_17_7438308a8df02b20_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (between 0.2s and 4.4s, the knife in the footage penetrates the metal box, and no lemon shavings fall off when the knife scrapes the tool).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01706", "filename": "P03_121_17_7438308a8df02b20_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (between 0.7s and 4.9s, the knife in the footage penetrates the metal box, but lemon shavings fall out of nowhere when the knife is scraping the tool).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01707", "filename": "P03_121_62_099215c8c89ef5f6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01708", "filename": "P03_123_4_a9334390e20faf08_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time sequence is continuous (at 2.8 seconds, the yellow liquid brought out of the spoon from the bowl suddenly disappears without dripping onto the table).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01709", "filename": "P03_123_4_a9334390e20faf08_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a glass bowl suddenly appears out of nowhere in the character's left hand at 3.6s, with no consistency).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01710", "filename": "P03_123_16_5e7211dcd3a4efdf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0s, a stirrer suddenly appears out of thin air on the character's right hand, and at 2.5s, the stirrer in the character's right hand suddenly disappears, showing no consistency).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01711", "filename": "P04_101_14_db57d5aaeed76c79_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical effect (the door in the picture has no handle, but the person in the picture is floating in the air and has opened the door).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01712", "filename": "P04_101_14_db57d5aaeed76c79_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the door's style suddenly changes at 1.1 seconds, and a handle appears on the door, showing no consistency).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01713", "filename": "P04_101_77_033e86109b24ed77_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (between 0.8s and 8s, the number of items on the electronic scale in the display is still fluctuating greatly even though there are no items on it).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01714", "filename": "P04_101_77_033e86109b24ed77_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the display: Physical effect (the numbers on the electronic scale do not change when the person in the picture is stirring the bottle on the scale).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01715", "filename": "P04_102_10_fb9d7b18bb4505d3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.1s, the brown bottle held by the character suddenly turns white, with no consistency between the beginning and end).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01716", "filename": "P04_102_52_d6737baf038535c0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not working properly: there is noticeable stuttering between 3.8s and 6.8s, and the books on the bookshelf in the video are constantly flickering.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01717", "filename": "P04_102_52_d6737baf038535c0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01718", "filename": "8ad0e016f4e7b4dc4699a3b22f00ab2d4d5aed7635a5df0f215e3cb805736643_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the flames in the video burn too smoothly, the edges are too regular, and it lacks a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01719", "filename": "8ad0e016f4e7b4dc4699a3b22f00ab2d4d5aed7635a5df0f215e3cb805736643_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the flames in the video do not exhibit the continuous upward trend characteristic of natural flames).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01720", "filename": "8ad58db88ef9ce5a3d54452fed1d397165cc0cb0a315991d271d8006e4f5b413_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (the wooden strip in the video footage from 0.5s to 3.7s moves on its own without any external force and the movement pattern is chaotic)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01721", "filename": "8ad58db88ef9ce5a3d54452fed1d397165cc0cb0a315991d271d8006e4f5b413_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (the long wooden strip on the right side of the video footage from 1.8s to 4.8s moves on its own without any external force and the movement pattern is chaotic).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01722", "filename": "8ad58db88ef9ce5a3d54452fed1d397165cc0cb0a315991d271d8006e4f5b413_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (from 0s to 3.6s, the wooden strip moves to the left without external force; from 3.6s, the wooden strip moves upward without external force).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01723", "filename": "8adab147334ce0facb367cbddf053dfa01468fed631ec23b9ffafe37396bd870_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (the keratinous object on the left side of the entire video appears to wriggle and flicker throughout).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01724", "filename": "8adab147334ce0facb367cbddf053dfa01468fed631ec23b9ffafe37396bd870_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.4s, the keratinous object on the left suddenly turns black).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01725", "filename": "8adab147334ce0facb367cbddf053dfa01468fed631ec23b9ffafe37396bd870_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01726", "filename": "8b3fe431a9dbc6d6a187b05021754cf3c0b9d268fdc99c02ee8087b88e4feedf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is continuous (the video was initially blurry at 0.1s and then suddenly became clear).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01727", "filename": "8b3fe431a9dbc6d6a187b05021754cf3c0b9d268fdc99c02ee8087b88e4feedf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the fire shield opens upwards and disappears without external force at 0s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01728", "filename": "8b3fe431a9dbc6d6a187b05021754cf3c0b9d268fdc99c02ee8087b88e4feedf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.1s, there is no gradual increase in the size of the flame in the furnace, and at 0.8s, the flame in the furnace suddenly increases in size), and the overall visual impression is abnormal (the flames in the video burn too smoothly and lack a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01729", "filename": "8b3fe431a9dbc6d6a187b05021754cf3c0b9d268fdc99c02ee8087b88e4feedf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 2.1 seconds, the smoke from the furnace suddenly disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01730", "filename": "8b7c0d0170da9bb8f5ddc4464f2324b1f9527db8ca1e96af0f1a22ae63c923a9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (the shape of the horse in the lower right corner of the entire video is distorted, and the light from the setting sun suddenly intensifies at 4.2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01731", "filename": "8b7c0d0170da9bb8f5ddc4464f2324b1f9527db8ca1e96af0f1a22ae63c923a9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the moon in the sky becomes rounder at 1.1s, the horse shape in the lower right corner of the video suddenly shrinks and distorts at 1.6s, and the horse shape in the lower right corner of the video suddenly shrinks and distorts at 3.6s). The cause and effect relationship is that the clouds move faster throughout the video while the setting sun does not change.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01732", "filename": "8b7c0d0170da9bb8f5ddc4464f2324b1f9527db8ca1e96af0f1a22ae63c923a9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is not continuous (the sun and moon move in opposite directions throughout the video; the horse shape in the lower right corner is distorted; the cars on the road and the roadside vegetation are distorted and disappear).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01733", "filename": "8b6994a4d18b0739cfd80dc474279d38768741f39d613ad7680d72daed590dc5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Continuous timing (at 0.6s, debris suddenly appears on the white clothing of the mannequin on the left); Causal relationship (the mannequin remains intact and intact even after the explosion throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01734", "filename": "8b6994a4d18b0739cfd80dc474279d38768741f39d613ad7680d72daed590dc5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomalies in the video: Causality (white smoke appears at 0.5s, but the transparent crystalline dummy does not reflect the white smoke) and temporal continuity (at 2s, the video shows a secondary explosion without transition; at 3.8s, the blue glasses on the right side of the dummy's chest turn white; at 4s, the dummy changes from crystalline to metallic material).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01735", "filename": "8b6994a4d18b0739cfd80dc474279d38768741f39d613ad7680d72daed590dc5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 2.3s, two feet appear on the legs of the crystal material dummy; at 3.1s, facial features suddenly appear on the face of the crystal dummy and the upper part of the crystal dummy turns into plastic material).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01736", "filename": "8b6994a4d18b0739cfd80dc474279d38768741f39d613ad7680d72daed590dc5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the explosion produces debris at 3.4s, creating a blurry image; at 4.8s, two dummies suddenly appear).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01737", "filename": "8ba0646589c05750bff5dfb7e34b4fc65d75367563dfce96e2a4e6dcbc40ca05_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (the rainbow in the lower left corner flickers throughout the video); the overall visual impression is abnormal (cloud movement is visible throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01738", "filename": "8ba0646589c05750bff5dfb7e34b4fc65d75367563dfce96e2a4e6dcbc40ca05_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the cloud movement in the entire video is too smooth and lacks a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01739", "filename": "8ba0646589c05750bff5dfb7e34b4fc65d75367563dfce96e2a4e6dcbc40ca05_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01740", "filename": "8ba0646589c05750bff5dfb7e34b4fc65d75367563dfce96e2a4e6dcbc40ca05_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is distorted: the timing is unnatural (at 0.2s, a waterfall-like flow of water suddenly appears on the left side of the cloud layer; at 1.5s, black speckled debris suddenly appears in the lower left corner and appears distorted). The overall visual effect is abnormal (the cloud movement in the entire video is too smooth and lacks a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01741", "filename": "8baac48847caa2f215fecfc9f0d4183f01c26d79c1149308c62cf880fc7d97ba_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (0.1s: a white ball suddenly appears on the left track; 0.1s: a blue ball suddenly appears in front of the white ball on the left track; 0.2s: the sphere in front of the white ball suddenly twists; 0.3s: a ball appears out of thin air at the green ball in the upper left corner; 0.5s: the number of balls on the track suddenly increases). Physical behavior (0s-0.2s: the blue ball in the right funnel remains suspended in the air; 0.4s: the white ball on the left moves upward).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01742", "filename": "8baac48847caa2f215fecfc9f0d4183f01c26d79c1149308c62cf880fc7d97ba_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the ball on the left moves in the opposite direction at 0.8s) Time continuity (the pink ball in the lower left corner twists and jumps at 1.8s; a white ball suddenly appears in the depression of the blue object in front of the red funnel at 2.2s; the pink ball splits into two at 2.3s; a pink ball suddenly appears on the left side of the red funnel at 3.1s; the red ball in the red funnel suddenly disappears at 3.4s; the red ball in the red funnel disappears at 5s; the white ball disappears at 5.4s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01743", "filename": "8badfcff0153aec6a8aa0f84092194456783860b6e7b4faf2e129ed9d6781202_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Causality (the yellow liquid melts throughout the video, but the volume of the objects does not change); Time continuity (the yellow liquid that flowed out at 4.7 seconds is absorbed by the corn).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01744", "filename": "8badfcff0153aec6a8aa0f84092194456783860b6e7b4faf2e129ed9d6781202_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (a small white light suddenly appears on the melting liquid at 4.7s, and the yellow liquid that flowed out at 5.7s is absorbed by the corn).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01745", "filename": "8badfcff0153aec6a8aa0f84092194456783860b6e7b4faf2e129ed9d6781202_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (butter melts between 1.20 and 5 seconds, but its volume does not change).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01746", "filename": "8badfcff0153aec6a8aa0f84092194456783860b6e7b4faf2e129ed9d6781202_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01747", "filename": "8c671d87fcb236166daaba0f4aac695e86b1f86ec5459f6e0576606b9effefde_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the clouds in the video are completely still, without any trace of movement, which is inconsistent with the natural pattern of clouds).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01750", "filename": "d793547c663c634a6211a0d1d736a2a47c3d1bd345eb5cd786a4887ffd67414e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the process of clouds drifting and dissipating in the scene is too smooth, and the movement trajectory is too fixed, lacking the feeling of clouds drifting and dissipating with the wind in reality.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01751", "filename": "d793547c663c634a6211a0d1d736a2a47c3d1bd345eb5cd786a4887ffd67414e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the scene suddenly changes from dusk to daytime blue, unlike in reality where dusk should be followed by darkness over time).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01752", "filename": "d793547c663c634a6211a0d1d736a2a47c3d1bd345eb5cd786a4887ffd67414e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the movement of clouds and the setting sun are too smooth, lacking the realistic feeling of drifting with the wind, unlike a real scene).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01753", "filename": "d926169efa86c1ff560bab34c62f0d8476dfc995c99cf889b1d417ad20d65ca7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a person is holding a snowball and rubbing it on the ground; the snowball should melt and crumble, not remain intact like a stone.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01754", "filename": "d926169efa86c1ff560bab34c62f0d8476dfc995c99cf889b1d417ad20d65ca7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The trees collapse automatically without any external force, from 0.8s to 2.9s.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01755", "filename": "d926169efa86c1ff560bab34c62f0d8476dfc995c99cf889b1d417ad20d65ca7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 6.5s, the sky changed from cloudy to sunny, the sun appeared, and the snowball placed on the fence did not melt due to the heat and remained unchanged.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01756", "filename": "d965703a27c573015b93b123261855473949e4b5c194236b3e2874e4b23eb0e7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (0s-1s) One penguin suddenly becomes two penguins.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01757", "filename": "d965703a27c573015b93b123261855473949e4b5c194236b3e2874e4b23eb0e7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (0s-0.7s, one penguin becomes two penguins).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01758", "filename": "d965703a27c573015b93b123261855473949e4b5c194236b3e2874e4b23eb0e7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01759", "filename": "d48181086e7b9ec7fcee98fa824576c1b4e07695f06d1258c29fe999f8f058bb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (flickering and blurring of light on the mountain and grassland surfaces in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01760", "filename": "d48181086e7b9ec7fcee98fa824576c1b4e07695f06d1258c29fe999f8f058bb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the mist in the mountains is stationary; due to airflow, it should drift and dissipate).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01761", "filename": "d48181086e7b9ec7fcee98fa824576c1b4e07695f06d1258c29fe999f8f058bb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not working properly: the timing is continuous (the video was shot from left to right, but there is no change in light as the sunlight shines on the clouds; the sunlight should be refracted and reflected by the clouds, so there is no realistic sense of light and shadow interaction).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01762", "filename": "d48181086e7b9ec7fcee98fa824576c1b4e07695f06d1258c29fe999f8f058bb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time frame is continuous (1.7s-3s) as the grass suddenly grows taller and turns into shrubs.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01763", "filename": "d950809243a9d260e1690b27eef4b80317cb5edfc40f55588fa69f003164db0f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (The colored liquid in the image flows upwards without any external force, violating the laws of gravity.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01764", "filename": "d950809243a9d260e1690b27eef4b80317cb5edfc40f55588fa69f003164db0f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the colored liquid in the image increases in quantity and volume without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01765", "filename": "d950809243a9d260e1690b27eef4b80317cb5edfc40f55588fa69f003164db0f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (6.8s) Multiple transparent bubbles appear out of thin air in the center of the colored liquid without any external force.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01766", "filename": "d4971375213aba0cca30eb10d45cfc6615fb3af6b780a6df77a31be50945beee_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: A continuous sequence of events (0.2s-2s) shows the black liquid suddenly turning yellow.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01768", "filename": "d4971375213aba0cca30eb10d45cfc6615fb3af6b780a6df77a31be50945beee_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (When liquid flows in a vertical plane, it should flow downwards due to gravity, instead of rotating automatically in the center of the plane.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01773", "filename": "da6740fce7ae54ac9cedf6c8cd75099c41c2de8c5ebe26031fd39ce659c20b64_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (When the water in the pot boils, large bubbles are produced. When the pot is shaken from side to side, the bubbles on the horizontal surface should dissipate, instead of sliding from side to side on the horizontal surface.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01774", "filename": "da6740fce7ae54ac9cedf6c8cd75099c41c2de8c5ebe26031fd39ce659c20b64_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (0.3s) The bubbles on the surface of the boiling water in the pot suddenly disappear. Before the water cools down, the bubbles should be boiling and jumping on the horizontal surface.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01775", "filename": "da6740fce7ae54ac9cedf6c8cd75099c41c2de8c5ebe26031fd39ce659c20b64_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01776", "filename": "da6740fce7ae54ac9cedf6c8cd75099c41c2de8c5ebe26031fd39ce659c20b64_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01777", "filename": "da7979ed8be3d8469ef576cdec590b2e3420052c1e6f2d51255014887135bd93_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the wood is being intensely burned by flames; it should show signs of carbonization and shrinkage, not remain unchanged.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01780", "filename": "41ac07c071f7512ffacba80fc14f87444476b000903adf0afac77af4b56a7851_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01781", "filename": "41ac07c071f7512ffacba80fc14f87444476b000903adf0afac77af4b56a7851_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the stone wall flickers throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01782", "filename": "41ac07c071f7512ffacba80fc14f87444476b000903adf0afac77af4b56a7851_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01783", "filename": "41c70230b27863f2091eee3c34e9909e991a1b4442c350583d9ea7fdfae57d68_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (a crack suddenly appears at 3.5s; the video starts with a piece of paper burning, but when it's about 1/3 burned, part of it suddenly turns into a cylindrical piece of paper burning).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01784", "filename": "41f1dd7cd6cf8925fd3c69826dcaa7c2bc89f7d34db8860c23ca2c56233a3112_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4s, the bubbles in the cup suddenly turn into a clump of foam).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01785", "filename": "43e49dda84b16c83ddf0e8beacc91458243ed579c3ae97ce2f7fb5c2cd92b959_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the arc of the sparks and the smoke generated after the 1.1s explosion are too perfectly symmetrical).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01786", "filename": "43fc78f8b3bbffb08b2df5ae7426e4b52aa84b0154989c4aefc4b5a2d82f3791_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01787", "filename": "44e1524baf0edaaaa7b7828637bbf355e993efb3fb7634d50d20c72cad855786_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity issue (flickering occurs throughout the entire video frame).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01788", "filename": "45a41e070bb7bef7f24dab1d6af33c06af44351e23bbbaf39be90c2cac7defb6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (flickering throughout the frame) Physical behavior (distortion and warping of characters during movement from 0s to 2.6s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01789", "filename": "45c0dae4f5ef70fc78f0d10d9bc553e09830952108b454cdaa1062e2c709afa7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the bracelet suddenly disappeared 0.5 seconds later)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01790", "filename": "df88a60ab14e681793324e8302f77b9585507c4ea79a93d1841aaf4ec55515e2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Physical behavior (liquid moving inside the bowl without external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01791", "filename": "df599587eaa53a73ac8a06d7d60eb3d1efe6fe8abbb29831e86b7601879b99ea_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01792", "filename": "e0a979f603c6b5d29e7502da841bffb8c28a2e47efae9269f6ddcc219570d8f2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the amount of toothpaste squeezed out is small while the amount of toothpaste piled up is large, the two are not proportional)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01793", "filename": "e0a979f603c6b5d29e7502da841bffb8c28a2e47efae9269f6ddcc219570d8f2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (0s-0.6s, the toothpaste hasn't entered the water yet, but toothpaste appears in the cup for no reason, without cause and effect).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01794", "filename": "e1ce3196a50352b216b8938d64122c4e96a2f3484b6f6bc047fa9ca3e42cd82f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01795", "filename": "e1ce3196a50352b216b8938d64122c4e96a2f3484b6f6bc047fa9ca3e42cd82f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (sudden change in image quality within 0.1 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01796", "filename": "e2db6cd480c9f6b6241c4f015901ddaea12ab149d342bc701aed09b840b8e0c5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity issue (flickering occurs throughout the entire video frame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01797", "filename": "e2f813cbc7a6420905ccac6be8a065cf7f3940cb3e6d433fb461f8975af84df3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity issue (flickering occurs throughout the entire video frame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01798", "filename": "00c8db34810bc6e2276bb10cdc90bede1935d1695d09b8c6f3c4d645d1af5591_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (2.5s, the liquid in the pot suddenly increases and boils instantly).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01799", "filename": "0a89e9659744927ec20a96cfdc893db14dfec74485333c96094b651a8f2a2eb6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Continuous timing (at 0.3s, a light bulb appears out of nowhere above the road; at 2.2s, a vehicle behind the left side distorts and disappears; at 5.7s, a person on the left side of the road disappears out of nowhere); Physical behavior (at 3.1s, vehicle lights are scattered, but in the video footage, the headlights are beams).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01802", "filename": "0bd7ff8c025b992eff2f9d4781c7d30552a0956e83307a19b61ea3a2fd75992b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 2 seconds, the brick falling in the middle of the video suddenly becomes larger).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01803", "filename": "0bd7ff8c025b992eff2f9d4781c7d30552a0956e83307a19b61ea3a2fd75992b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 2s, the volume of the falling brick on the right suddenly shrinks; at 2.2s, the falling brick on the right twists and merges; at 5.3s, the brick directly below appears out of thin air; at 5.3s, the brick directly above appears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01804", "filename": "0bd7ff8c025b992eff2f9d4781c7d30552a0956e83307a19b61ea3a2fd75992b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is continuous (the bricks above shrink out of thin air during the 2.5s explosion); causality is unclear (the amount of debris produced after the explosion is greater than the original volume).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01806", "filename": "0c4c9cdd4428b3d954880b9a03a3b9d9b36e0a0f8c3d7e1a0f7c4b3f0238d390_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video quality is abnormal: The overall image is abnormal (the surface of the waterfall in the video has a strong grainy texture, indicating that it is a pixelated image rather than a realistic one).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01807", "filename": "0c6a76538bfbb9d00de0fd03f196b86af22d0de974d9d8e6ea60f7584bf08222_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the 5.8s video is frozen), and the overall flow is abnormal (the flames in the video burn too smoothly, unlike real footage, lacking the jerky transitions expected in reality).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01808", "filename": "0c648c1adf3ee2f36570c92045d698474a5e53f60956907a66f9b5f3939e0bc7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01809", "filename": "0c648c1adf3ee2f36570c92045d698474a5e53f60956907a66f9b5f3939e0bc7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (the hills at the top of the video appear to flicker and wriggle throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01810", "filename": "0c6389e0e6822f8739e1698dec8afaf333495ce25d733cfc1354981478f17dae_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (a black object appears out of thin air on the right at 0.4s); Physical phenomena (the black object on the right penetrates the bottle opening at 1.5s, and the supporting pillar below and the red pipe above the black object penetrate the blue pipe at 3.7s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01811", "filename": "0c6389e0e6822f8739e1698dec8afaf333495ce25d733cfc1354981478f17dae_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 0.4s, an object on the right side of the video rises out of thin air while being supported; at 6.2s, liquid in the container on the left side of the video appears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01812", "filename": "0c2956428d4a6797a892a9ad09e73d4a594a5c5ce779d3c2474743898e2fabbf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (the white dot at the top of the video disappears out of nowhere at 1.7s, and the black dot on the left side of the video appears out of nowhere at 2.8s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01813", "filename": "0c2956428d4a6797a892a9ad09e73d4a594a5c5ce779d3c2474743898e2fabbf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the video flickers and wriggles in areas with rough ground).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01814", "filename": "0c2956428d4a6797a892a9ad09e73d4a594a5c5ce779d3c2474743898e2fabbf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01815", "filename": "0cedca3800c7a51d98f135750e265ed499bf36a5c80eb9ef1672c331f6786506_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (the trees and rocks on the riverbank appear to flicker and move).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01816", "filename": "0cedca3800c7a51d98f135750e265ed499bf36a5c80eb9ef1672c331f6786506_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (at 3.7s, the leaves on the upper part of the riverbank suddenly turn yellow).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01817", "filename": "0e2cbd152accbd8aa1ffc8d923e0260dd838a66dd56f4c12a84ff02920d13d6c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is continuous (the buildings and trees around the riverbank appear to flicker in the video).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01818", "filename": "0e7c239053e75c219ec6a08911aa4ee9f1e40babb31b0ab8b4677fa0626091e7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01819", "filename": "0e89d9663e549854155bb506c14aef69efacb1a507191f2013d94c58f973a528_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is continuous (at 1.28ss, the stone under the rear wheel of the toy car in the video twists and turns into mud).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01820", "filename": "0e89d9663e549854155bb506c14aef69efacb1a507191f2013d94c58f973a528_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3s, gravel appears out of nowhere under the wheel, and at 4.8s, red fragments appear out of nowhere next to the toy car).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01821", "filename": "0e184d67b5a24606676bb0f263620300bc911ef2b3f3acecf275188e79dc4ed4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video is continuous in time (at 4.2 seconds, a lens appears out of nowhere in the middle of the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01822", "filename": "0e352a87b99f57bea55f1a5b5597d29cabd8c381759baa5301ac18973c0e64cf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (from 0s to 3.7s, the syringe tube extends out of nowhere, and the liquid in the container is injected into the container but the liquid in the container does not change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01823", "filename": "0ea1c9ae1a134fb84d98003627672e23a6dc37e2ec0df073e74828de6ceb39d8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01824", "filename": "0ea1c9ae1a134fb84d98003627672e23a6dc37e2ec0df073e74828de6ceb39d8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The time sequence is continuous (from 1.7s to 8s, the volume of the object on the left side of the video appears to grow out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01827", "filename": "0ef5df03a90cbeecc6a1fd105d0117623fc1f5260f585d5efe04ab7e7dd81e73_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video is continuous in time (there is no smooth transition at 1s, and the overall picture is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01828", "filename": "0f45e6a30b8262c80b0ee24370b9ab67bb56c98158985ce822a928b57fb48a57_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (no change was observed on the ground at the explosion site at 0.5s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01829", "filename": "0f45e6a30b8262c80b0ee24370b9ab67bb56c98158985ce822a928b57fb48a57_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (from 2s to 2.8s, the debris from the explosion suddenly increases in size, and at 3.8s, the flying debris in the middle of the video suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01830", "filename": "0f190b3328d3a314bbb9dc7a3639c4ea1b6844644f54c7c7b210dc63520c008c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the surface of the river in the video has a grainy texture, unlike real footage).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01831", "filename": "01c9b0fcf594b1237c49efcb98842ac157275b0e6e7526ae0908a9ecba4145cf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the cloud image in the video flickers).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01832", "filename": "01c9b0fcf594b1237c49efcb98842ac157275b0e6e7526ae0908a9ecba4145cf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (clouds suddenly appear out of nowhere at 3.7 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01833", "filename": "1a3e80c0b452a7920b602331742087397787be2556c9bc98639c08a8fc9d5648_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (at 0s, a light source appears out of nowhere above the video; at 2.7s, smoke appears out of nowhere above the light).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01834", "filename": "1a5f6214acac586908adafec06b2a2b0c486d1e0f9d73a78a42311de79ba3dbc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (at 4.8s, the high-voltage power tower and trees in the video are not clearly outlined by sunlight).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01835", "filename": "1a5f6214acac586908adafec06b2a2b0c486d1e0f9d73a78a42311de79ba3dbc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Continuous timing (flickering of water mist throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01837", "filename": "1a52039cda52cdcf3fd2e52ed45a783b25cafaa1c15e9cb4c7179d4f712886ca_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01838", "filename": "1ac5cb51fd867f7b3eb61a7c8191e2cea8a8fe323c4bb69e03dfa83ec7d0f773_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (the drone in the video is moving, but the person is not operating the remote control).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01839", "filename": "1ba65c6a5886a14e5ec75b3f82693d30e3ab71b93c49a7bf95340e8d4827f488_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01840", "filename": "1ba420a4d223d5bc6634d245900a585549b1a53fefc94914a74ec1347786c3f4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (the video feed transitions smoothly to the next frame at 0.9s, and the object below the hammer disappears into thin air at 2.2s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01841", "filename": "1bbae3bf5036f73fa4a817a6b7ad20de6c9aafad706bb2d7cd15b58a49c65cba_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual presentation is off (the lava surface in the video is too smooth, lacking the realistic smoothness and texture expected in real footage)", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01842", "filename": "1bbae3bf5036f73fa4a817a6b7ad20de6c9aafad706bb2d7cd15b58a49c65cba_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (flickering on the surface of lava in the video)", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01843", "filename": "1bbae3bf5036f73fa4a817a6b7ad20de6c9aafad706bb2d7cd15b58a49c65cba_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 5.7s, part of the falling lava on the right disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01844", "filename": "1c62f8cbc14466c440dbd57575ed75b632a92c3f98f79fa3500ac5e58ea42e37_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (sparks appear out of nowhere on the object on the right at 3.8 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01845", "filename": "1c62f8cbc14466c440dbd57575ed75b632a92c3f98f79fa3500ac5e58ea42e37_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (blue flames appear out of nowhere at 0.9s, and particles appear out of nowhere in the flames at 4.9s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01846", "filename": "1cbe18216eda223b1cd786f92fddda5e6e4bfd0721d3e5dc89d441e45bea5700_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01847", "filename": "1d69a0187868f2ae793e4ef0efc4a0a83094a882d9e749eac3e2b1eb368e55f5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the black liquid that fell into the water disappears into thin air at 1.2s) Physical behavior (the black liquid diffuses in the air at 2.3s without falling into the cup, but when the black liquid falls into the cup of water, the water does not change at all)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01849", "filename": "1d60505c9b260716a8a5e2783fa857c32ab6e32b5df13e8a36d224642d29c992_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The time sequence is continuous (from 0.8s to 5s, the liquid at the top of the crayon appears out of thin air in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01850", "filename": "1d60505c9b260716a8a5e2783fa857c32ab6e32b5df13e8a36d224642d29c992_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1.9s, the crayon is melting but the crayon itself does not change; at 4.3s, the liquid on the left side of the orange crayon disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01851", "filename": "1e7aac88494208a267416cefaaae3495f303cfede3c15711ab70cb1b5d460942_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 5.5s, the material changes as the hydraulic press crushes the sandpaper).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01852", "filename": "1ea5397a7c87be41b7063115783fd086400843329071427961a406e19b5a841a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.6s, the sphere below the wheel shrinks out of thin air and the pattern suddenly changes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01853", "filename": "1ea5397a7c87be41b7063115783fd086400843329071427961a406e19b5a841a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (deformation and denting occurred 1.5s before the wheel touched the yellow ball).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01854", "filename": "1ed733af6f68cb107ba92b81bcf905896ff0b5dd205dce7bbaae1a34cf118fc5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The video is continuous in time (at 3.1 seconds, the iron ball at the top of the pillar appears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01856", "filename": "1f122703236d3a8c11ff42b285eec658e24d812e928556d47d3e7dcfc146e91f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (at 1.1s, the spoon with the original notch at the bottom becomes a semi-circle and the liquid around the spoon changes from grayish-white to pale yellow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01857", "filename": "1fe91c1b45f87ca28c325e9e168793bbe27c0e3766cf1bb856b14129e18ac457_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 6.8 seconds, the tree branch in the lower corner of the video disappears out of thin air, and the scene around the person flickers).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01859", "filename": "02c65189c5e417dbee9311831c6f51777c0d763e19a91f0f7e539a4d81e55790_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (at 2s, a light spot appears out of nowhere on the left side of the lake; at 2.1s, a light spot appears out of nowhere on the right side of the lake; at 2.9s, a light spot appears out of nowhere on the right side of the lake).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01860", "filename": "02c65189c5e417dbee9311831c6f51777c0d763e19a91f0f7e539a4d81e55790_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01861", "filename": "2a6cb41001ed9af45087e325488c47f988b0d302c465fa7c1d3acf7adfa8d2af_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is continuous (dry ice appears out of thin air above the pot at 1s, and the falling dry ice splits into two at 1.3s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01862", "filename": "2a39c67849bf1e4087bd65b4c19f663453b41c5695c947bf3004b9a951772e57_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the trees and lake surface in the video are too smooth, unlike real footage, lacking the undulations that should be present in reality).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01863", "filename": "2a56e801b4b099e0dee02e9ce6931aae04b73a9bc920c690d352f9a85fbf6afe_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (bubbles appear out of thin air in the liquid in the cup at 1.5s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01864", "filename": "2b2ab8e048d46836a37eeac7a6c0e6f6287fdfdc9948029425dcc89a78f45a7e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01865", "filename": "2b2498eeff47af2f5707f37fc7d2eb08d263fbc2036ee12c48eabf524e059be9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is off (the pixel transitions in the video are abrupt, and the colors and textures are noticeably different from the original rock face and vegetation on the left, making it seem unrealistic).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01866", "filename": "2b2498eeff47af2f5707f37fc7d2eb08d263fbc2036ee12c48eabf524e059be9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The video is continuous (the entire screen flickers)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01867", "filename": "2b2338239f73491643af1c24503436ba9f1c6ca3704227561622e043a60fae18_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the vegetation on the right side of the video flickers).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01868", "filename": "2bc9c37cbeac718704161fef28670116a81c5c4954e6d9220afc194606a93f17_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (the gemstone in the video rotates without any external force); Time continuity (the image on the surface of the hand flickers in the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01869", "filename": "2bc9c37cbeac718704161fef28670116a81c5c4954e6d9220afc194606a93f17_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01870", "filename": "2bd6a2b278c74e328e2da4f2919dba062c1d40377c73e8cafaef1e71027086a3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the machine is collecting grain in the video, but the grain trough does not change at all, and the overall picture is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01871", "filename": "2bf85a26ec613de63b9a21e3e3e3c8716e29f289009e59e580e8f58fd87d8fb5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (blue light rays continuously penetrate the white object directly above in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01872", "filename": "2bf85a26ec613de63b9a21e3e3e3c8716e29f289009e59e580e8f58fd87d8fb5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the light and shadow in the video appear to flicker and wriggle).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01873", "filename": "2bfc73f0039e6c4b93437c2c5012066d0d6f5b267738b4bfc2becd196b782239_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 3.1s, the bubbles in the water stop rising and move to the left when there is no external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01874", "filename": "2c10d3e5cc44a6ee32be682a9a0545b2c20333a8002ba4b858526344344f8be4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (at 4.2s, blue liquid appears out of thin air in the upper left corner of the video; at 2.4s, the metal plate that just appeared on the left side of the video twists; at 5s, blue liquid appears out of thin air on the left side of the barbell; at 5.8s, the metal plate on the left side of the barbell disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01875", "filename": "2c25c22c7f13faeb147c2987c66a602dcf633765495c247474c0999aaad5c71e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (the object in the video is burning continuously, but its surface shows no change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01876", "filename": "2c25c22c7f13faeb147c2987c66a602dcf633765495c247474c0999aaad5c71e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01878", "filename": "2caa9017ac9a28dd43052297b49e8c66dd3a2fbd9fbf5ae169d3d261682df93d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4s, the cylindrical magnet in the left hand merges with the lower support column of the middle object).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01879", "filename": "2caa9017ac9a28dd43052297b49e8c66dd3a2fbd9fbf5ae169d3d261682df93d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.4s, the object in the left hand disappears into thin air; from 2.6s to 3.4s, the object in the right hand changes shape from a triangle to a quadrilateral).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01880", "filename": "2dae7a57563fb6ae35a7cb4c1d7f52148cc6a691da85f42935d67180d9c8c822_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Continuous time (dominoes in the entire video deform, jump, or increase in number); Physical behavior (dominoes in the entire video move upwards or downwards without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01881", "filename": "2dbf2ac94163f3a800f9e4bbb5776a566df9262d7dcf343a9b76e25a9397f813_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time sequence (wax on the middle candle appears out of nowhere at 1s, wax at the bottom of the left candle appears out of nowhere at 5.3s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01882", "filename": "2e2a748fe18e8c6bdf755a4acf289f6b93d51f2ff4d3bbd227c66e53306148db_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the timing is continuous (at 3.9s, the pointed tip of the pink tube changes into a circular collar, and at 5.8s, the number of water splashes generated by the bursting bubbles increases out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01883", "filename": "2e54b9a2b9d648eeefe737f5a966dc00fa005c933187cb000e6ac85e53c83cb4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (1. At 10 seconds, the ice cube in the hand suddenly grows larger; 2. At 10 seconds, a white object appears out of thin air in the bowl).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01884", "filename": "2e89028c2e97b9f06b9115f4504c34087fed82589552b22a8d01f7e225cf0f63_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01885", "filename": "2f2e68ce1ec015db8d30ce7137da874ef0035892bd221c4ff9bf36ee48009ed7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01886", "filename": "2f2e68ce1ec015db8d30ce7137da874ef0035892bd221c4ff9bf36ee48009ed7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the lake surface in the video is too smooth, unlike real footage, lacking the dynamic range that should be present in reality).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01887", "filename": "2f41ef673676b1196c893f5a87d0ed0b426e295bad5afc926ff7475aa6235acd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (it is raining behind the streetlights but not in front of them, only the trees on the left and right sides are dripping with rain, and bright spots appear out of nowhere on the trees on the left and right sides in the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01889", "filename": "03acbc583c88d2505b6f2f5f29f16064136b6847a894d49d313cbe6476ee5879_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01890", "filename": "3a41e2dee4c49b66aaa4436c37441f21ddb52485c74e8c23f7372511a096feea_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video behavior: Physical behavior (at 3.9s, the rotation and direction of the object in the video suddenly change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01891", "filename": "3a1076b0080dba5758ac0a43d78f1d0042976f0f3b1c793ef9b04ea3e6f1b4f8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the entire building surface appears to flicker in the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01892", "filename": "3a686187291ccced7a895db9fdff42b4d6028658efee9ddc725b1e926fa4bb1f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the light source emitted by the object throughout the video is pink, while the surrounding area illuminated appears red).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01893", "filename": "3aeeab03424a6aad7ecd30371337463441a6cb7c414613291896631b5b5833ba_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the ripples on the lake surface in the video move too smoothly, unlike real footage, lacking the jerky, realistic movement).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01894", "filename": "3af2dcb09a625df6f7c3e8cc2c847817f2f68b52112c08ff5060d0e211c002bd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01895", "filename": "3b49df62fd61c89e4db1eaa248d4707c6af4da4d4e8f51c2e6e0b311bcebfc5d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The video shows continuous motion (the surface of the building at the bottom of the screen flickers).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01896", "filename": "3be7c792ed7354a72a3f6fd38650c7237214f96699781d982e58c31f8ef369ec_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Continuous timing (at 0.6s, a yellow sphere appears out of thin air in the transparent glass bowl on the left); Physical anomalies (at 2.4s, the right hand fingers of the person in the video pierce through the transparent glass bowl).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01898", "filename": "e5d1551d26d821165975543004cf1d771f2366b3076d319eac487d4a9e030c64_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, at 2.4 seconds, the flames on the cardboard box disappear out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01899", "filename": "e5d1551d26d821165975543004cf1d771f2366b3076d319eac487d4a9e030c64_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, firewood suddenly appears next to the cardboard box at 2.2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01900", "filename": "e5d1551d26d821165975543004cf1d771f2366b3076d319eac487d4a9e030c64_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (the cardboard box opens automatically at 1.1 seconds, provided there is no camera movement and no external force or interference).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01901", "filename": "e5e7ef49cfc6674dbc569cc0cf6d870b571e74634d501780d49bedd1ccfcb9db_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without changing camera angles, at 1.7 seconds, the reflection below the red column suddenly turns white)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01902", "filename": "e5e7ef49cfc6674dbc569cc0cf6d870b571e74634d501780d49bedd1ccfcb9db_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (the water glass and water in the image are colorless and transparent. When you look at objects behind them through them, the objects will be distorted due to refraction, but here the objects behind them are not distorted at all).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01903", "filename": "e5e7ef49cfc6674dbc569cc0cf6d870b571e74634d501780d49bedd1ccfcb9db_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (when looking at objects behind a water glass, the objects should be distorted due to refraction, but here the objects behind the glass do not change at all).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01904", "filename": "e5e7ef49cfc6674dbc569cc0cf6d870b571e74634d501780d49bedd1ccfcb9db_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Time continuity (Under the premise that the camera does not change, there is no force or external interference, the paper suddenly shrinks at 3.7s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01905", "filename": "e5e056825cde73dbb7241ae009499d350b203535ea9af10d5f3feadd2cf23431_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the video shows ice being heated, the thermometer shows around 70 degrees Celsius, but the ice in the cup shows no signs of melting).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01906", "filename": "e5e056825cde73dbb7241ae009499d350b203535ea9af10d5f3feadd2cf23431_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01907", "filename": "e5e056825cde73dbb7241ae009499d350b203535ea9af10d5f3feadd2cf23431_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 0.8 seconds, the water in the first cup on the right increases out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01908", "filename": "e5e023832489278311107706c0cd6ffd27ea47c7da336d412eaa719e103bf7fa_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is not continuous (the petioles of the dead leaves in the water are floating upright, while in reality, when dead leaves float, the petioles are either close to the leaf surface or tilted).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01909", "filename": "e5e023832489278311107706c0cd6ffd27ea47c7da336d412eaa719e103bf7fa_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the water surface ripples, but the floating maple leaves do not move at all and do not follow the water ripples).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01910", "filename": "e5e023832489278311107706c0cd6ffd27ea47c7da336d412eaa719e103bf7fa_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the visuals: Time continuity (ripples appear on the water's surface, but the tree shadows reflected in the water do not move with the ripples).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01911", "filename": "e5e023832489278311107706c0cd6ffd27ea47c7da336d412eaa719e103bf7fa_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01912", "filename": "e6c1d2be91faec605d456c62a8dd1455de01f5a69009ce4180da9614f70cf90d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 2.5 seconds, the reflection on the left side of the water disappears out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01913", "filename": "e6c1d2be91faec605d456c62a8dd1455de01f5a69009ce4180da9614f70cf90d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is not continuous (the slender tree trunks are stiff and unnatural, lacking the natural curves of real trees, and the joints between the trunks have no sense of layering, indicating that the trunks are pieced together).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01914", "filename": "e6c1d2be91faec605d456c62a8dd1455de01f5a69009ce4180da9614f70cf90d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01915", "filename": "e6c1d2be91faec605d456c62a8dd1455de01f5a69009ce4180da9614f70cf90d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01916", "filename": "e6eabfde37815b9aca5b042119d88801f5d19b8e6023c1ab0f38783b0b5f098d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera transition, at 0.7 seconds, the molten wax produced by the burning candle disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01917", "filename": "e6eabfde37815b9aca5b042119d88801f5d19b8e6023c1ab0f38783b0b5f098d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the candle is burning, but the molten wax does not drip down, and the surface of the candle remains flat, which is completely different from the appearance of normal burning).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01918", "filename": "e6eabfde37815b9aca5b042119d88801f5d19b8e6023c1ab0f38783b0b5f098d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (without camera movement and without external force or interference, the candle flame suddenly disappears at 5.5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01919", "filename": "e6ee4b54d0a3c28c94893b69fb58e862b122d8e1c48bc66b9be73e55e57bd604_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 0.4s, a large number of blue flocculent substances suddenly appear out of nowhere in the cup in the footage).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01920", "filename": "e6ee4b54d0a3c28c94893b69fb58e862b122d8e1c48bc66b9be73e55e57bd604_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the blue liquid in the cup appears out of thin air at 0.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01921", "filename": "e6ee4b54d0a3c28c94893b69fb58e862b122d8e1c48bc66b9be73e55e57bd604_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, a blue ball appears out of nowhere in the lower left corner of the screen at 1.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01922", "filename": "e6ee4b54d0a3c28c94893b69fb58e862b122d8e1c48bc66b9be73e55e57bd604_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, a stone slab appears out of thin air in 0.6 seconds, and the color in the cup instantly turns blue).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01923", "filename": "e07fb99c0c73bdcd74f569a276832c977910a318c139f3f57a63dd4ca1290a41_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is not continuous (ice is a hard crystal, and when it breaks, it should be solid fragments with sharp edges, but the broken parts here look more like blurry flocculent material, which does not conform to the physical form of ice).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01924", "filename": "e07fb99c0c73bdcd74f569a276832c977910a318c139f3f57a63dd4ca1290a41_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 2.4 seconds, the light and shadow in the entire scene suddenly changed from pale yellow to blue).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01925", "filename": "e07fb99c0c73bdcd74f569a276832c977910a318c139f3f57a63dd4ca1290a41_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01926", "filename": "e7a90ab893a60d79142294c14cacccae999c722e989c954d999883c07f2940a5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the clouds in the overall scene are moving, but the clouds in the lower left corner remain stationary).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01927", "filename": "e7a90ab893a60d79142294c14cacccae999c722e989c954d999883c07f2940a5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01928", "filename": "P25_104_117_1ec52dcc0731291b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (no water splashes or sprays when the water jet touches the hand throughout the entire process).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01929", "filename": "P25_104_127_c9d4950bd9c06187_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01930", "filename": "P25_104_127_c9d4950bd9c06187_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is continuous (the small spoon turns into a large spoon at 0.2 seconds); the overall realism is abnormal (there is a flame under the pot handle on the stove that is lit).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01931", "filename": "P25_104_241_618a2443c391da74_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.7s, the spoon in the character's right hand turns into a pot lid, and at 2.8s, the pot lid merges with the original pot lid into one).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01932", "filename": "P25_104_241_618a2443c391da74_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal; the timing is discontinuous (the spoon that was originally on the tissue disappears out of thin air at 1.1s); the overall realism is abnormal (from 3.6s to the end, the tissue is put into the sink and the water pipe keeps running, but the tissue is not deformed by the water).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01933", "filename": "P25_104_241_618a2443c391da74_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: The timing is continuous (the water tank was initially empty, but a lid suddenly appears at 2.6 seconds); Physical behavior is also problematic (the water flow automatically stops at 2.6 seconds without being turned off, which violates fluid dynamics).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01934", "filename": "P25_106_68_cad14e9fcc0c5fbf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01935", "filename": "P25_106_68_cad14e9fcc0c5fbf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the knife in the bowl disappears out of thin air at 1.6s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01936", "filename": "P25_106_70_0546033caf381f67_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The timing is continuous (tweezers appear in the water tank at 1.2s, and the egg cracks without being bumped at 1.9s; at 3.4s, a complete yolk and egg white suddenly appear in the empty shell in the hand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01937", "filename": "P25_106_70_0546033caf381f67_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01938", "filename": "P25_106_70_0546033caf381f67_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 5.3 seconds, only one egg is cracked in the video, but several eggshells suddenly appear in the bowl).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01939", "filename": "P25_106_92_65140f212a40d828_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is inconsistent (the knife in the person's hand shows obvious deformation at 3.8 seconds); the overall realism is abnormal (the knife is used to penetrate the cardboard box in the video, but there are no marks on the box).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01940", "filename": "P25_106_92_65140f212a40d828_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time frame is continuous (0.6s-7.8s, the knife cuts the cookie box but leaves no mark).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01941", "filename": "P25_106_112_f17182772fcb9436_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is continuous (the fork deforms at 0.2s); the physical behavior is inconsistent (the spoon in the horizontal water tank remains twisted, which is inconsistent with the properties of a solid).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01942", "filename": "P25_106_112_f17182772fcb9436_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01943", "filename": "P25_106_118_30be49c9432717e6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3s, a black plastic block appears in the right hand, and at 5.8s, the white plastic spoon handle and the iron spoon handle on the paper below the right hand are transformed into a rectangular iron block).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01944", "filename": "P25_106_118_30be49c9432717e6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01945", "filename": "P25_106_136_7c1c4763f510e130_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01946", "filename": "P25_106_136_7c1c4763f510e130_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.6s, the packaging automatically closes as the character tears it open, and at 6.9s, the opening of the packaging with the right hand's finger changes from large to small).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01947", "filename": "P25_106_174_b203af5d54ca231a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the tissue in the hand disappears at 1.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01948", "filename": "P25_106_174_b203af5d54ca231a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall realism is off (the person in the video is wiping their hands with a tissue, but the tissue doesn't have any wrinkles).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01949", "filename": "P25_106_174_b203af5d54ca231a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the overall realism is abnormal (the tissue in the right hand was originally wrapping the spoon, but at 0.8s the spoon reappears on the stove without being damaged); the timing is continuous (the tissue in the right hand suddenly disappears at 3.1s and the spoon in the left hand appears deformed at 4.6s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01950", "filename": "P25_106_206_ec3effca98399bdb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0s, a tissue appears out of thin air in the character's hand, but disappears suddenly at 4.7s, and at 5.4s, the handle of the spoon in the character's right hand changes from white plastic to metal).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01951", "filename": "P25_107_52_673e028382201e6d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01952", "filename": "P25_107_58_dc184ee136993137_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video exhibits several issues: The overall realism is inconsistent (in the video, a person is peeling an eggplant with a knife, but two pieces of skin fall off with each slice); the timing is discontinuous (at 0.9 seconds, the eggplant skin is being peeled, but the location where the skin falls off is not the same as the point where the knife was applied).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01953", "filename": "P25_107_58_dc184ee136993137_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the overall realism is abnormal (the video shows a knife being used to peel the eggplant multiple times at the same spot on the stem, resulting in a large amount of eggplant skin falling off, and the speed at which the eggplant skin falls off is inconsistent with the speed at which the knife is used to peel it).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_01954", "filename": "P25_107_58_dc184ee136993137_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The timing is continuous (from 1.2s to 2.3s, there are no knife marks on the eggplant, but eggplant skin appears on the peeler; at 4.4s, the color of the skin on the peeler changes; at 7s, skin reappears on the areas of the eggplant that have already been peeled).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01955", "filename": "P25_107_154_1eeab7b7b9dbec29_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01956", "filename": "P25_107_154_1eeab7b7b9dbec29_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01957", "filename": "P25_107_154_1eeab7b7b9dbec29_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 2.3s, the towel in the person's hand merges into one from two); temporal continuity (at 0.9s, the towel in the person's hand becomes two, and at 4.7s, the eggplant in the upper right corner of the pot becomes two from one); overall unrealistic feel (at the beginning of the video, most of the eggplant in the pot is still raw and hard, but after a few seconds of tossing, the eggplant becomes soft and cooked).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01958", "filename": "23c6fdb9b9519f61c071f99f8d687323c730d48480ac60e77319daf01d15fa79_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is continuous (the video switches directly without any transition at 3.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01959", "filename": "23c6fdb9b9519f61c071f99f8d687323c730d48480ac60e77319daf01d15fa79_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual inconsistency (obvious stuttering and delays throughout the video, resulting in a lack of visual continuity).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01960", "filename": "23c6fdb9b9519f61c071f99f8d687323c730d48480ac60e77319daf01d15fa79_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01961", "filename": "23f7529a2ff5ff3c8b15d5e79f86b55abac38399915d81dad5d7d59e93b67fd2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (the food in the bowl exhibits flickering artifacts throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01962", "filename": "23f7529a2ff5ff3c8b15d5e79f86b55abac38399915d81dad5d7d59e93b67fd2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 2.3s in the video, without any change in camera angle, the square spatula in the person's hand suddenly becomes a round spatula).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01963", "filename": "23f7529a2ff5ff3c8b15d5e79f86b55abac38399915d81dad5d7d59e93b67fd2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 3.4 seconds into the video, without any change in camera angle, the chicken feet above the pot suddenly turned into slices of meat).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01964", "filename": "23f7529a2ff5ff3c8b15d5e79f86b55abac38399915d81dad5d7d59e93b67fd2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01965", "filename": "24b35a5cf2c28aadf4c6840cd066440de1a540424805b13e8853116691b7f613_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (when the magnetic string starts rotating at 2.2s in the video, the volume of the bottom magnetic ring suddenly expands without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01966", "filename": "24b35a5cf2c28aadf4c6840cd066440de1a540424805b13e8853116691b7f613_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (at 0.8 seconds into the video, without any change in camera angle, the black ring in the frame suddenly enlarges).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01967", "filename": "24b1114dd3db06608435000657dba1c861392f95f682cf93c7b46163d8967ede_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (from 4.2 seconds to the end of the video, the yellow liquid poured into the cup disappears out of thin air without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01968", "filename": "24b1114dd3db06608435000657dba1c861392f95f682cf93c7b46163d8967ede_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: continuous time (throughout the video, the amount of yellow liquid in the glass increases out of nowhere without the ice cubes melting).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01969", "filename": "24b1114dd3db06608435000657dba1c861392f95f682cf93c7b46163d8967ede_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01970", "filename": "24b1114dd3db06608435000657dba1c861392f95f682cf93c7b46163d8967ede_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (from 0.2s to 1.7s in the video, without any change in the camera angle, yellow liquid appears out of nowhere in the cup, and at 3.2s, water droplets appear out of nowhere on the cup wall).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01971", "filename": "24ed5ee2e279615590057256ec65497793f7308f3ce861e6a2fecf9572cb7d28_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical anomaly (In the entire video, sunlight shines straight through the branches and leaves without any obstruction, refraction, or dappled light, violating the physical laws of light propagation).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01972", "filename": "24ed5ee2e279615590057256ec65497793f7308f3ce861e6a2fecf9572cb7d28_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (from 4.1s to the end of the video, the refraction of sunlight suddenly turns into a blue ball of light without any external interference)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01973", "filename": "24ed5ee2e279615590057256ec65497793f7308f3ce861e6a2fecf9572cb7d28_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01974", "filename": "24ed5ee2e279615590057256ec65497793f7308f3ce861e6a2fecf9572cb7d28_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: continuous timing (the video switches scenes abruptly at 5.2 seconds without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01983", "filename": "27a6ca871696c781a64c8a73e3e140c38a7dffd0b137dd82bacb8f8cf44c0623_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (there are flickering and flashing artifacts throughout the entire video, and there are flashes of light in the pot).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01984", "filename": "27a6ca871696c781a64c8a73e3e140c38a7dffd0b137dd82bacb8f8cf44c0623_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: continuous time (video 2.1s, without any change in the camera angle, the water in the pot suddenly becomes clear and the white flocculent matter disappears instantly).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01985", "filename": "27a6ca871696c781a64c8a73e3e140c38a7dffd0b137dd82bacb8f8cf44c0623_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_01986", "filename": "27d4fe782033afe8cc8e4ededefef77d7044b0994a00ee5d22f51fd0f636548a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomalies in the footage: Time continuity (at 0.6s in the video, the white light above the lamp suddenly disappears without any change in the camera angle; at 0.7s in the video, the rain in the scene vanishes into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01987", "filename": "27d4fe782033afe8cc8e4ededefef77d7044b0994a00ee5d22f51fd0f636548a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (in the entire video, the door and light on the left side of the screen rotate and move on their own without being subjected to any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01988", "filename": "P35_104_632_37874415988d2ecd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_01989", "filename": "P35_104_632_37874415988d2ecd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.1s in the video, without any change in camera angle, the yellow folded object on the table suddenly merges).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01990", "filename": "P35_104_675_db59b729555fe4c5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal; there is a lack of continuity in time (at 3.3 seconds in the video, without any change in the camera angle, a piece of paper suddenly appears in the person's hand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01991", "filename": "P35_104_675_db59b729555fe4c5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal; causality (at 3.1s in the video, the person's hand is not touching the paper, yet the paper begins to stretch automatically without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01992", "filename": "P35_104_676_e914583be3d2c137_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 5.4s in the video, without any change in camera angle, a piece of paper suddenly appears in the person's hand).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01993", "filename": "P35_104_691_ebf7a4e28908410f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.5s, the character starts tearing the plastic wrap off the item, and at 3.2s, the area of the plastic wrap suddenly increases without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01994", "filename": "P35_104_691_ebf7a4e28908410f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 1.7s in the video, the plastic film in the person's hand suddenly enlarges without the camera changing direction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01995", "filename": "P35_104_697_9e6303fae0f53a1e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01996", "filename": "P35_104_700_e98b78f09f403c44_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (flickering artifacts exist throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_01997", "filename": "P35_104_700_e98b78f09f403c44_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 2s in the video, an extra layer appears out of nowhere on the lid in the person's hand without the camera changing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_01998", "filename": "P35_104_704_f83a3adfddf4c7ec_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_01999", "filename": "P35_104_704_f83a3adfddf4c7ec_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (at 4.4s in the video, the person's finger penetrated the plastic wrap directly upon contact with it).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02000", "filename": "P35_104_709_bb397278955e0f3a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 4.2s in the video, when the person is folding plastic wrap, a layer of plastic wrap appears out of thin air under their fingers without the camera changing position).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02001", "filename": "P35_104_709_bb397278955e0f3a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (flickering artifacts exist throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02002", "filename": "P35_104_709_bb397278955e0f3a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_02003", "filename": "P35_104_712_70a13e8d527e0636_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (at 4.8s in the video, the person's finger pierces through the tissue while wiping the surface of their body with the tissue).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02004", "filename": "P35_104_712_70a13e8d527e0636_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 5 seconds into the video, the paper in the frame and the roll of toilet paper on the table merge instantly without any change in the shot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02005", "filename": "P35_104_715_479de4c388af0470_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (at 0.9s in the video, a layer of plastic wrap appears out of thin air on the packaging box of plastic wrap without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02006", "filename": "P35_104_715_479de4c388af0470_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 2.2s in the video, the square packaging box in the person's hand suddenly turns into a round packaging box without any change in the shot).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02007", "filename": "P35_104_726_213c5d9e8fdf48a0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 4.7s in the video, the wrapping paper in the person's hand disappears out of thin air without any change in the shot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02008", "filename": "P35_104_726_213c5d9e8fdf48a0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_02009", "filename": "P35_104_726_213c5d9e8fdf48a0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 2.8 seconds into the video, the torn packaging box in the footage suddenly reassembles itself without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02010", "filename": "P35_104_730_74b4144975033aa8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02011", "filename": "P35_104_730_74b4144975033aa8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (flickering artifacts exist throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02012", "filename": "P35_104_730_74b4144975033aa8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 6.8s in the video, a layer of plastic wrap appears out of thin air on the table without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02013", "filename": "P35_104_732_7416f5e378bf2dc0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (at 0.6s in the video, the flesh below the person's arm suddenly shrinks in size without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02014", "filename": "P35_104_732_7416f5e378bf2dc0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (at 1.7s in the video, the soft tissue in the person's hand suddenly becomes hard as it is thrown onto the table).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02015", "filename": "P35_104_752_cef9511f727ff5e9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 2.9s in the video, the corner of the table suddenly turns into a snake without any change in the camera angle; at 2s, the back of the chair disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02016", "filename": "P35_104_752_cef9511f727ff5e9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (starting at 2.2 seconds in the video, the snake's body keeps extending infinitely in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02017", "filename": "P35_104_762_cb4de7718b0c684f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (in the video, the blue cover bounces back after touching the ground, its potential energy increases out of thin air, and the bounce height gets higher and higher).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02018", "filename": "P22_107_110_133d9f30a74dd3ef_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Time continuity (the text on the can is blurry and distorted in the video from 4.5s to 8s, and the entire video is flickering) Causality (the milk powder bottle is tilted at 4.3s in the video, but the milk powder inside does not move, lacking dynamic feedback in a real physical scene)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02019", "filename": "P22_107_183_0cce1d56c003f43b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.6s, the bayberry in the hand suddenly disappears, and from 3.8s to 5s, the faucet is running but the water in the sink is stagnant and does not spread outwards).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02020", "filename": "P22_107_183_0cce1d56c003f43b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.6s, the bayberries in the hand suddenly turn into two, and at 4.5s, the faucet suddenly twists and deforms).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02021", "filename": "P22_108_29_d97afd20450aa322_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (at 2.7s, the pattern on the mat on the table suddenly changes; at 3.1s, the tabletop suddenly deforms; at 3.7s, the red sofa suddenly disappears into thin air; and at 4s, the positions of the sunglasses and placemat suddenly change).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02022", "filename": "P22_108_29_d97afd20450aa322_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_02023", "filename": "P22_108_102_630e653c46c84d26_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the yellow cabinet and gas stove are constantly flashing throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02024", "filename": "P22_108_102_630e653c46c84d26_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.3s, the towel suddenly merges together while being rubbed; at 3s, the left hand's fingers suddenly pass through the towel).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02025", "filename": "P22_109_160_12636db4d59215ee_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a ring appears out of thin air on the finger at 3.9 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02026", "filename": "P22_109_160_12636db4d59215ee_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the bottle cap suddenly opens out of thin air between 1s and 5.2s, without any sign of it being turned on).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02027", "filename": "P22_109_246_357348604d1be43f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is continuous (at 1.3s, the left hand fingers suddenly pass through the right hand fingers, and from 2.6s to 3.7s, the finger joints deform).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02028", "filename": "P22_109_246_357348604d1be43f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous flickering (the entire video is constantly flashing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02029", "filename": "P22_109_405_e432c3ecdb4acae4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the green sea surface where hands are being washed suddenly disappears at 1.5 seconds, and the left side of the video is constantly flickering throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02030", "filename": "P22_109_405_e432c3ecdb4acae4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the color of the sea surface in the hand suddenly changes at 0.6s, and the sponge in the hand suddenly disappears at 2.3s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02031", "filename": "P22_109_473_c8504107e5af6dde_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the shape of the yellow cloth suddenly changes at 1.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02032", "filename": "P22_109_485_767c8b9ecdf5bd33_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the right thumb passes through the towel at 6.4s, and the entire video is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02033", "filename": "P22_109_485_767c8b9ecdf5bd33_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the video shows someone wiping their hands with a cloth, but the cloth suddenly disappears at 7s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02034", "filename": "P22_109_621_e32bd585130cce20_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.1s, the yellow towel suddenly tightens even though the person's hand is not applying force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02035", "filename": "P22_109_674_936515c97d80787c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.3s, the number of black objects in the hand suddenly increases, and at 1.4s, the black objects in the right hand suddenly disappear).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02036", "filename": "P22_109_674_936515c97d80787c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_02037", "filename": "P22_109_679_934d0ee1af759960_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the shape of the black frame in the hand suddenly changes at 1.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02038", "filename": "P22_109_679_934d0ee1af759960_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the entire video is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02039", "filename": "P22_109_679_934d0ee1af759960_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (the black iron frame in hand suddenly deforms at 3 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02040", "filename": "P22_109_688_4220efa2e1144e5a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the entire video is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02041", "filename": "P22_110_52_4035aa7de5db6cf9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.9s, the pattern on the white object in the hand suddenly changes; at 3.4s, the white object in the hand suddenly changes from a whole state to a granular state without any external force; at 3.9s, the toe of the shoe suddenly separates from the heel, leaving only the toe).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02042", "filename": "P22_110_52_4035aa7de5db6cf9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1.2s, a white object suddenly appears out of thin air on the carpet, and at 4.8s, the white object fragments appear out of thin air on the carpet without any trace of falling off).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02043", "filename": "P22_110_100_e4e6b27f06a65fc0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the pattern on the plate suddenly changes at 3.6 seconds while the plate is being washed).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02044", "filename": "P22_110_209_d50e5ba963d5d932_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous flickering (the entire video is constantly flashing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02045", "filename": "P22_110_209_d50e5ba963d5d932_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_02046", "filename": "P22_111_43_504ff964ebce8762_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the screen shows firing, but the ignition switch is not turned, yet the fire starts in 1.7 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02047", "filename": "P22_111_43_504ff964ebce8762_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous timing (from 0s to 2.3s, the pot rotates on its own even when the hand is still, and the entire video is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02048", "filename": "ea1ac4b622d7b43fb228fbad1f4861c3b98d746379ab3bbd778f9259ba72b2cc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.1s, the water spray in the video suddenly turns into smoke, and at 3.6s, the water spray on the left disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02049", "filename": "ea6b1bdd9ce8ef9ea3dc3374825476fd35482a5f6712495b721a90ea0aa9b969_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Causality (the video is sped up, but the fog in the mountains is moving without decreasing or increasing).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02050", "filename": "ea6b1bdd9ce8ef9ea3dc3374825476fd35482a5f6712495b721a90ea0aa9b969_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (clouds appear out of nowhere at 4.3s, and water mist appears out of nowhere in the mountains in the middle of the video at 5.4s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02051", "filename": "ea6b1bdd9ce8ef9ea3dc3374825476fd35482a5f6712495b721a90ea0aa9b969_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (the clouds on the left hill disappear out of nowhere between 3.6s and 4.5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02052", "filename": "ea6b1bdd9ce8ef9ea3dc3374825476fd35482a5f6712495b721a90ea0aa9b969_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the water mist increases out of nowhere at 0.5s, and the water mist on the mountaintop in the background appears out of nowhere at 5.3s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02053", "filename": "eac030e84ed18a8b333c215076b4c778fefd3384d6d128cbb3d7bbf412e7b435_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the sky is covered with clouds, displaying the warm orange glow of sunset, while the river surface does not reflect a corresponding warm tone; the overall brightness is cold and dark, and the lighting is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_02054", "filename": "eac030e84ed18a8b333c215076b4c778fefd3384d6d128cbb3d7bbf412e7b435_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (black clouds suddenly appear out of nowhere in the upper left corner of the video at 3.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02055", "filename": "eac030e84ed18a8b333c215076b4c778fefd3384d6d128cbb3d7bbf412e7b435_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 2.9s, clouds suddenly appear in the upper left corner of the video, and at 4s, a bright spot suddenly appears on the right side of the video when there is no light source).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02056", "filename": "eac030e84ed18a8b333c215076b4c778fefd3384d6d128cbb3d7bbf412e7b435_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02057", "filename": "eace903553a9e749e899c04f49d22a4ccbb1d238c683e5ef2032fb5f025b42d3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.6s, the texture on the surface of the object below the central character distorts and disappears; at 2.7s, the character's figure suddenly enlarges).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02058", "filename": "eace903553a9e749e899c04f49d22a4ccbb1d238c683e5ef2032fb5f025b42d3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the object on the left side of the video is stationary in mid-air at 1.8s); Time continuity (dust kicked up by the person's feet appears out of nowhere at 3.8s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02059", "filename": "eace903553a9e749e899c04f49d22a4ccbb1d238c683e5ef2032fb5f025b42d3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (objects suddenly transform into people throughout the video, sand and dust appear out of nowhere around the person at 2.1s, and sand and dust rising from the upper right corner of the sandpit appear out of nowhere at 2.4s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02061", "filename": "eae18c34613bb4ead8b1b36d3b7bc59d81f5c82af540d1465c07edb5c8418f82_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.2s, the red dust that flew up from the explosion appears out of nowhere in the video, and from 3.6s to 5s, the foil bag that was damaged by the explosion begins to recover).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02062", "filename": "eae18c34613bb4ead8b1b36d3b7bc59d81f5c82af540d1465c07edb5c8418f82_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (red dust appears out of nowhere during the explosions on the left and right at 2.1s and 2.2s, and fragments of objects on the left and right appear out of nowhere at 2.2s and 2.4s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02063", "filename": "eb4fc1ea734796fd276c1ab5311a2b912a45b044cb7430c398370bbd4187e7dc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (the water ripples generated in the upper right corner at 1.5s did not spread, and water ripples appeared out of nowhere on the right side of the video at 4.2s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02064", "filename": "eb4fc1ea734796fd276c1ab5311a2b912a45b044cb7430c398370bbd4187e7dc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 3.1s, liquid suddenly appears above the video, and at 4.4s, some of the liquid changes color from green to a white and green mix).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02065", "filename": "eb4fc1ea734796fd276c1ab5311a2b912a45b044cb7430c398370bbd4187e7dc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02066", "filename": "eb4fc1ea734796fd276c1ab5311a2b912a45b044cb7430c398370bbd4187e7dc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (from 4.3s to 7.8s, the liquid on the right side of the video moves due to external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02067", "filename": "eb7df0efae1d550a425fb706c6805167ff56ba773ff64b8e9573b7795a38dbfc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.9s, the flame of the match in the character's hand suddenly increases in size)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02068", "filename": "eb7df0efae1d550a425fb706c6805167ff56ba773ff64b8e9573b7795a38dbfc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (flames suddenly appear out of nowhere in the wood at 0.3s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02069", "filename": "eb7df0efae1d550a425fb706c6805167ff56ba773ff64b8e9573b7795a38dbfc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Cause and effect (at 1.3s, the flame touched the wood, causing the wood to spontaneously combust).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02074", "filename": "eb604adf5ed3cbbd04a4dc37ae7e111ef6d2e5a0d7a1e44de1e6d0c2807667f2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02075", "filename": "eb604adf5ed3cbbd04a4dc37ae7e111ef6d2e5a0d7a1e44de1e6d0c2807667f2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (parts of the object in the entire video are not burning but begin to turn black).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02076", "filename": "eb604adf5ed3cbbd04a4dc37ae7e111ef6d2e5a0d7a1e44de1e6d0c2807667f2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (smoke appears out of nowhere in the upper right corner of the video at 1.2s, and flames appear out of nowhere in the lower right corner of the video at 1.5s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02077", "filename": "eb50808eb30319631752f953a81cacd8741d9046e1d311c65ae410bde521e900_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (water droplets appear out of nowhere in the lower right corner of the video at 0.4s, water droplets appear out of nowhere in the left side of the video at 0.7s, and water droplets appear out of nowhere in the middle of the video at 1.6s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02078", "filename": "41ac07c071f7512ffacba80fc14f87444476b000903adf0afac77af4b56a7851_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is off (the edges of the foreground figures in the video are too sharp and do not blend naturally with the warm lighting of the background environment; the figures' clothes are too flat and do not resemble a realistic scene, lacking the realistic folds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02079", "filename": "41c70230b27863f2091eee3c34e9909e991a1b4442c350583d9ea7fdfae57d68_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (the paper is constantly burning throughout the video and is highly flammable, so it would burn quickly, but the charred marks on the paper in the video do not show any obvious changes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02080", "filename": "41c70230b27863f2091eee3c34e9909e991a1b4442c350583d9ea7fdfae57d68_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Cause and effect (the paper is burning at the top in the video, but the charred marks spread from the upper right to the upper left of the paper)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02081", "filename": "41c70230b27863f2091eee3c34e9909e991a1b4442c350583d9ea7fdfae57d68_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (The upper right corner of the paper in the entire video burns rapidly, but the upper left corner burns very slowly, giving a noticeable splicing effect. Also, the charred marks on the upper left corner of the paper do not change significantly and do not burn through as quickly as ordinary paper.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02082", "filename": "41f1dd7cd6cf8925fd3c69826dcaa7c2bc89f7d34db8860c23ca2c56233a3112_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (the cup and ice cubes in the entire video are moving continuously without any force applied, which does not conform to the laws of motion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02083", "filename": "41f1dd7cd6cf8925fd3c69826dcaa7c2bc89f7d34db8860c23ca2c56233a3112_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (from the beginning to the end, the liquid in the cup keeps increasing out of thin air, and the liquid that exceeds the edge of the cup from 1.3s to 5.8s does not overflow the cup but remains unchanged and continues to rise).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02084", "filename": "41f1dd7cd6cf8925fd3c69826dcaa7c2bc89f7d34db8860c23ca2c56233a3112_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the air bubbles in the liquid in the cup remain stationary between 0s and 0.3s, which does not conform to the laws of liquid flow. In reality, water droplets are subject to gravity and should rise briefly after splashing from the rim of the cup before immediately falling downwards. However, in the video, the water droplets appear to be continuously moving upwards between 4.5s and 7.5s, which violates the laws of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02085", "filename": "42dbb623f038be639a5a1212d4a8dde5d0165ef5c08810e46078c3153388b76b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time is continuous (from 0s to 0.8s, the silver stick has not yet stirred the water, but the water in the cup has already started to rotate; from 0.8s to 5s, the glass tube structure in the lower pot extends into the water in the upper pot and rotates with the water, but the water in the upper pot does not flow into the lower pot, which violates the law of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02086", "filename": "42dbb623f038be639a5a1212d4a8dde5d0165ef5c08810e46078c3153388b76b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (in the entire video, water flows from the upper kettle into the lower kettle, but the water level in the lower kettle does not increase, and water from the lower kettle drips through the kettle into the flame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02087", "filename": "42dbb623f038be639a5a1212d4a8dde5d0165ef5c08810e46078c3153388b76b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (from 1.1s to 5.1s, the steam from the boiling water comes out of the kettle body but not from the spout; at 1.9s, the glass tube in the lower kettle suddenly disappears; from 2.4s to 4.2s, the water from the upper kettle flows into the lower kettle, but the water in the lower kettle does not increase; at 4.2s, the water in the upper kettle does not flow into the lower kettle, but the water in the upper kettle decreases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02088", "filename": "42fdecc7f14adbb094e923192839a79a96c8a15cd157766c4be3a8e1fd2fd019_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02089", "filename": "42fdecc7f14adbb094e923192839a79a96c8a15cd157766c4be3a8e1fd2fd019_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 0.8s to 5.8s, the character's movement is only to correct the knife, but the sturdy knife in the picture is easily bent. The character's movement and the intensity of the force are inconsistent with the degree of deformation of the knife, which violates the laws of force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02090", "filename": "42fdecc7f14adbb094e923192839a79a96c8a15cd157766c4be3a8e1fd2fd019_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the scratch on the blade below the thumb suddenly disappears at 0.5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02091", "filename": "42fdecc7f14adbb094e923192839a79a96c8a15cd157766c4be3a8e1fd2fd019_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.3s, the knife in the hand suddenly deforms and its direction suddenly reverses).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02092", "filename": "43e49dda84b16c83ddf0e8beacc91458243ed579c3ae97ce2f7fb5c2cd92b959_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual presentation is off (the explosion effects in the video blend awkwardly with the real desert background; the brightness of the flames and the surrounding lighting do not interact naturally, making it look like they were spliced on later; and the grass around the explosion should shake violently under the impact of the explosion, but the grass in the video only shakes slightly, which is inconsistent with the intensity of the explosion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02093", "filename": "43e49dda84b16c83ddf0e8beacc91458243ed579c3ae97ce2f7fb5c2cd92b959_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the explosion is extremely bright, but it does not produce any obvious changes in lighting on the foreground human figures and the ground. For example, the orange-red reflections or shadow distortions that should appear are completely absent. The light from the explosion does not blend naturally with the cool-toned twilight environment in the background. Furthermore, the grass around the explosion should shake violently under the impact of the violent explosion, but the grass around the explosion remains calm).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02094", "filename": "43e49dda84b16c83ddf0e8beacc91458243ed579c3ae97ce2f7fb5c2cd92b959_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect (under the impact of a violent explosion, the grass around the explosion should shake violently, but the grass in the video only shakes slightly, which is inconsistent with the intensity of the explosion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02095", "filename": "43f6388f0530d0e912b2a3e6bf5efec7ede47fccd87672214735b6fdec51dc21_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (at 0.9s, the small steel ball in the upper right corner of the video suddenly splits into two, and at 1.4s, the small ball on the right side of the video suddenly disappears at the edge of the object).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02096", "filename": "43f6388f0530d0e912b2a3e6bf5efec7ede47fccd87672214735b6fdec51dc21_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.9s, the silver ball above the object suddenly turns into a white ball and the structure of the object on the right side of the video suddenly deforms into a white ball; at 1.8s, the two white balls on the left side of the object suddenly merge; at 2.4s, the structure of the object at the bottom of the video suddenly deforms; at 2.9s, the white ball in the lower right corner of the object suddenly splits into two; at 4.2s, the white ball suddenly penetrates the structure of the object).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02097", "filename": "43f6388f0530d0e912b2a3e6bf5efec7ede47fccd87672214735b6fdec51dc21_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.1s, the silver ball in the lower right corner of the object suddenly splits into two; at 1.4s, a small ball suddenly appears out of nowhere below the object; at 1.4s, the silver ball on the right side of the object suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02098", "filename": "43f6388f0530d0e912b2a3e6bf5efec7ede47fccd87672214735b6fdec51dc21_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0s, a small white ball suddenly appears out of thin air in the object; at 2.1s, the structure of the object suddenly deforms; at 2.9s, one small white ball in the object suddenly becomes two; at 3.1s, the structure on the lower right of the object suddenly deforms again; at 5.8s, a small white ball suddenly disappears from the bottom of the video; at 7.5s, a mushroom-shaped light appears out of thin air on the left side of the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02099", "filename": "43fc78f8b3bbffb08b2df5ae7426e4b52aa84b0154989c4aefc4b5a2d82f3791_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (when a tool comes into contact with a fully formed bubble, the bubble will burst due to the disruption of surface tension, but in the video, the tool passes through and sticks to the bubble, while the bubble remains intact, which violates the physical property of bubble surface tension).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02100", "filename": "43fc78f8b3bbffb08b2df5ae7426e4b52aa84b0154989c4aefc4b5a2d82f3791_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall visual impression is off (the rainbow colors on the surface of soap bubbles are an optical phenomenon of thin-film interference; the colors should be a continuous gradient and change uniformly with the thickness of the thin film, but the colors of the bubbles in the video appear mottled and the boundaries of the color blocks are harsh).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02101", "filename": "43fc78f8b3bbffb08b2df5ae7426e4b52aa84b0154989c4aefc4b5a2d82f3791_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02102", "filename": "44e1524baf0edaaaa7b7828637bbf355e993efb3fb7634d50d20c72cad855786_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the hand is not pressing any keys on the right side of the piano throughout the entire video, but the strings on the right side of the piano are vibrating).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02103", "filename": "44e1524baf0edaaaa7b7828637bbf355e993efb3fb7634d50d20c72cad855786_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.1s, the right ring finger passes through the black keys of the piano).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02104", "filename": "44e1524baf0edaaaa7b7828637bbf355e993efb3fb7634d50d20c72cad855786_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (at 3.7s, the right hand fingers suddenly merged with the black piano keys, and at 2.9s, the right thumb deformed the piano keys that were not pressed).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02105", "filename": "44e1524baf0edaaaa7b7828637bbf355e993efb3fb7634d50d20c72cad855786_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is continuous (the right-side keys are not being played, yet the corresponding action and hammers are moving).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02106", "filename": "44f504299ad74e2f5c852890c93f90dc08dec86fdeed96cac4f4234e198da18f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time sequence is continuous (0s-1.9s, a silver object wrapped in tape on the right side below the hydraulic press passes through the tape).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02107", "filename": "44f504299ad74e2f5c852890c93f90dc08dec86fdeed96cac4f4234e198da18f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (during the period from 1.3s to 5.1s, the volume of the object being squeezed by the hydraulic press does not decrease but instead increases out of thin air; at 5.3s, the layered silver object is squeezed and the wrinkles suddenly disappear, and the surface becomes extremely smooth).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02108", "filename": "eb50808eb30319631752f953a81cacd8741d9046e1d311c65ae410bde521e900_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, water poured into the pot flows directly through the bottom of the pot and onto the ground, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02109", "filename": "eb50808eb30319631752f953a81cacd8741d9046e1d311c65ae410bde521e900_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (in the entire scene, the amount of water poured out is very small, but the splashes are huge, and the splashes are smooth and regular, lacking a natural sense of disorder).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02110", "filename": "eb50808eb30319631752f953a81cacd8741d9046e1d311c65ae410bde521e900_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Physical behavior (during the video from 1.3s to 2.7s, the water gushing out of the pot suddenly turns into a large amount of steam after splashing out of the pot) and continuous time (during the video from 6s to the end, without any change in the shot, a large amount of smoke appears out of thin air in the pot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02114", "filename": "ebe7dd55625751c066cd5678f0347daf924f48e65380ae7f1535e2a2350c5405_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (fog should appear as flowing, wavy shapes, with soft edges and gradual transitions. However, the fog in this image appears very straight and sharply cut, like a curtain suddenly obscuring the bridge, lacking the fluidity and depth of natural fog).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02115", "filename": "ebe7dd55625751c066cd5678f0347daf924f48e65380ae7f1535e2a2350c5405_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Temporal continuity (between 3.8s and 5.4s, a large amount of smoke suddenly appears on the bridge and then disappears without a trace).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02116", "filename": "ebe7dd55625751c066cd5678f0347daf924f48e65380ae7f1535e2a2350c5405_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (throughout the video, the fog drifts too regularly, clustering together and moving without dissipating, lacking the natural randomness of fog movement).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02117", "filename": "ebe7dd55625751c066cd5678f0347daf924f48e65380ae7f1535e2a2350c5405_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (from 0.9s to 4.4s in the video, a large amount of fog appears out of thin air on the supports above the bridge without the camera changing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02118", "filename": "ec0a1a99ae9e3a15467cd68f57497a44a5c54d42e941cc735dd0b81e2b8ea04f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Temporal continuity (Throughout the entire video, the trees in the frame remain static, without any change).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02119", "filename": "ec0a1a99ae9e3a15467cd68f57497a44a5c54d42e941cc735dd0b81e2b8ea04f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity (Throughout the entire video, there is a constant flickering artifact in the image; the trees remain stationary without any change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02120", "filename": "ec0a1a99ae9e3a15467cd68f57497a44a5c54d42e941cc735dd0b81e2b8ea04f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the stream flowing in from the left in the entire scene moves too smoothly, without creating any splashes, lacking a natural sense of disorder).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02121", "filename": "ec0d14b2dd7febecd9a05b790b816462daeab6001a1dee464bae81c9b13c8ee3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video footage is abnormal due to the following issues: Physical behavior (the clouds in the sky remain stationary throughout the entire video, without any change, which does not conform to the inertia of clouds constantly moving and dissipating) and Temporal continuity (the entire video footage exhibits flickering artifacts).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02122", "filename": "ec0d14b2dd7febecd9a05b790b816462daeab6001a1dee464bae81c9b13c8ee3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (between 1.7s and 2.1s in the video, the changes in the sky light are irregular and divergent, while the light on the water surface gradually appears in a rectangular shape, which violates the principle of light refraction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02123", "filename": "ec0d14b2dd7febecd9a05b790b816462daeab6001a1dee464bae81c9b13c8ee3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video footage is abnormal due to the following issues: Physical behavior (the clouds in the sky remain stationary throughout the entire video, without any change, which does not conform to the inertia of clouds constantly moving and dissipating) and Temporal continuity (the entire video footage exhibits flickering artifacts).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02124", "filename": "ec0d14b2dd7febecd9a05b790b816462daeab6001a1dee464bae81c9b13c8ee3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02125", "filename": "ec786cdb84cc4d3b495d990e9c54c82c1f22bb1b969e09d93379793c6817d9fb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: temporal continuity (flickering artifacts exist throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02126", "filename": "ec786cdb84cc4d3b495d990e9c54c82c1f22bb1b969e09d93379793c6817d9fb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02127", "filename": "ec786cdb84cc4d3b495d990e9c54c82c1f22bb1b969e09d93379793c6817d9fb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (in the entire image, the palm leaves in the center are connected without any gaps, too neat and compact, lacking a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02128", "filename": "ec04849beb21bc00fb8f8b1c84c1b90289b7aa6acae5234ffad0c873281d96ec_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: a lack of continuity in time (during the video, from 2.4s to 4.3s, objects thrown by the explosion disappear into thin air as they hit the ground; from 4.7s to 5s, white smoke appears out of nowhere on the ground).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02129", "filename": "ec04849beb21bc00fb8f8b1c84c1b90289b7aa6acae5234ffad0c873281d96ec_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: temporal continuity (between 1.7s and 5s in the video, the exploded objects suddenly disappear as they fall to the ground; at 1.5s in the video, a tree stump appears out of nowhere in the frame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02130", "filename": "ecb6580ba87f2b9c4d8f8e05f82a4cb61c6984365556c04eafe29f0e84207f47_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (The flame burns continuously throughout the video, but the candle remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02131", "filename": "ecb6580ba87f2b9c4d8f8e05f82a4cb61c6984365556c04eafe29f0e84207f47_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the light and shadow of the flames have a soft gradation and diffusion, while the edges of the light in the picture are harsh, and the color transitions lack the sense of depth that is real when burning).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02132", "filename": "ecb6580ba87f2b9c4d8f8e05f82a4cb61c6984365556c04eafe29f0e84207f47_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02134", "filename": "ece973a8c03fe950c0e4206b4f1d8ee5d132d44383f3586d56bb0efd2a4ddbc5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Causality (from 0s to 1.9s in the video, the paint on the canvas spreads spontaneously without any external interference; from 2.9s to 5s in the video, the paint on the canvas shrinks spontaneously).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02135", "filename": "ece973a8c03fe950c0e4206b4f1d8ee5d132d44383f3586d56bb0efd2a4ddbc5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity: (From 0.2s to the end of the video, the paint on the canvas appears to increase out of nowhere without any change in the shot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02136", "filename": "ece973a8c03fe950c0e4206b4f1d8ee5d132d44383f3586d56bb0efd2a4ddbc5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Causality (between 0s and 5s in the video, the paint on the canvas suddenly bubbles and continues to expand and shake on its own without any change in the shot).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02137", "filename": "ece973a8c03fe950c0e4206b4f1d8ee5d132d44383f3586d56bb0efd2a4ddbc5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity: (At 5.1s in the video, the scene switches abruptly without any transition)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02138", "filename": "P01_109_211_4929ec23228871a3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02139", "filename": "P01_109_211_4929ec23228871a3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_02140", "filename": "P01_109_271_ea9c0304c5b0c186_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_02141", "filename": "P01_109_271_ea9c0304c5b0c186_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the orange peel in the hand suddenly deforms at 0.1s, and the number of orange peels suddenly increases at 0.8s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02142", "filename": "P01_109_309_cbe8544a1ab04cbd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time frame is continuous (1.7s-2.7s). The amount of food on the cutting board suddenly increases, and the food pieces become smaller and inconsistent.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02143", "filename": "P01_109_309_cbe8544a1ab04cbd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the radish pieces increase out of nowhere during the entire video without being cut).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02144", "filename": "P01_109_309_cbe8544a1ab04cbd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Continuous visuals: Time sequence (at 6.1 seconds, a carrot that wasn't cut suddenly turns into pieces and the number of pieces suddenly increases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02145", "filename": "P01_109_363_c32adc66c2243dee_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.4 seconds, the egg is not yet cracked, but egg white and yolk appear out of thin air in the bowl).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02146", "filename": "P01_109_363_c32adc66c2243dee_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (1.2s-5.6s the left hand did not grasp the eggshell but the egg opened on its own and the contents flowed out; at 3.7s the two halves of the eggshell disappeared for no reason).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02147", "filename": "P01_109_367_801471c732e57b9c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the number of egg yolks in the bowl decreases at 2.2s, and suddenly increases at 3.4s; the entire video is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02148", "filename": "P01_109_425_e2ddc881aa635e8c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the person presses the egg packaging shell between 1.4s and 5s. The paper packaging should break, but in the video, the packaging shell suddenly produces a lot of fragments, which is too exaggerated).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02149", "filename": "P01_109_425_e2ddc881aa635e8c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.2s, the egg packaging in the hand suddenly deforms, and at 6.3s, the paper packaging is torn, but the packaging suddenly turns into a lot of fragments).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02150", "filename": "P01_109_437_afddb3e47a126244_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (throughout the video, the left hand was not holding the pot handle while the right hand was constantly stirring in the pot; under the influence of force, the pot should have moved, but it remained stable throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02151", "filename": "P01_109_468_43ed60f74f8ef5d9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_02152", "filename": "P01_109_472_5c0c70c245616e29_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to the physical behavior (from beginning to end, the hand was not holding the wooden spoon, yet the spoon was able to steadily scoop the food, which does not conform to the laws of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02153", "filename": "P01_109_505_21e38433c8d15586_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the entire video is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02154", "filename": "P01_109_505_21e38433c8d15586_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (at 2.4s, the video suddenly shows ghosting and the image abruptly changes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02155", "filename": "P01_109_531_bda8b5d04c85a185_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the oil is boiling from beginning to end, but no steam is coming out of the pot).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02156", "filename": "P01_109_531_bda8b5d04c85a185_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the oil in the pan is constantly boiling, but the steam only appears suddenly at 1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02157", "filename": "P01_109_685_c0cfbecd7d53578b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02158", "filename": "P01_109_685_c0cfbecd7d53578b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the number of green towels suddenly increases at 2.7s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02159", "filename": "P01_109_783_c9d7a897f1828a56_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.5s, the video suddenly shows a ghosting effect and the layout of the kitchen changes).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02160", "filename": "P01_109_894_80006ed195f217d2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The timing is continuous (the right thumb is twisted and deformed between 0.2s and 1.3s, and the water in the tank does not flow out between 0.8s and 3.8s, but the water volume in the tank does not change significantly).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02161", "filename": "P01_109_901_5c37b13558d00a8c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 0s to 4.3s, the character's hand is not holding the cardboard under the pot, but the cardboard is floating in the air and moving with the pot).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02162", "filename": "P01_109_901_5c37b13558d00a8c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.7s, the cardboard between the two pots suddenly disappears; at 2.2s, the shape of the cardboard in the pot suddenly changes; and at 3.7s, the cardboard in the hand suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02163", "filename": "P02_101_63_98318a85aa8038f2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (4.5s-8s, the knife did not tilt, but cheese appeared on the toast. The knife did not carry cheese, but a large amount of cheese suddenly appeared during the movement).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02164", "filename": "P02_101_65_fae214c805c75800_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02165", "filename": "P02_101_65_fae214c805c75800_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_02166", "filename": "P02_101_65_fae214c805c75800_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (The hand did not touch the bread during the process from the beginning to 0.2s when the bread was put into the bowl, which does not conform to the laws of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02167", "filename": "P02_101_79_117b97072302e410_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02168", "filename": "P09_103_23_e81a3c04e70e0086_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 1s, the spatula and the wok pass through the mold; at 1.9s, the spatula in the right hand undergoes a sudden change in shape, and the front end of the spatula automatically flips).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02169", "filename": "P09_103_23_e81a3c04e70e0086_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 0s, the shape of the spatula below the right hand suddenly changes and becomes distorted; at 0.4s, the spatula automatically attaches to the hand; at 3.1s, the amount of white steam generated in the pot suddenly increases).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02170", "filename": "P09_104_32_344b8f6476bc6a19_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (the bottom of the refrigerator moves backward without any external force at 3.9s)", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02171", "filename": "P09_104_32_344b8f6476bc6a19_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (the liquid in the bottle suddenly decreases at 0s; the video suddenly transitions without a smooth transition at 3.8s; the objects on the right table change abruptly at 3.9s, their shape changes from blurry to clear).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02172", "filename": "P09_104_32_344b8f6476bc6a19_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 0.1s, the shape of the item in hand suddenly changes and becomes distorted) Physical behavior (at 3.2s, the cabinet below opens outward without external force)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02173", "filename": "P09_104_58_53dd714022f0ea16_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Time Continuity (At 0.5s, the item in the hand undergoes a sudden change, transforming into an apple slice; at 0.9s, the banana undergoes a sudden change, its shape distorting; at 1.3s, the knife in the right hand suddenly disappears; at 1.4s, the banana in the left hand transforms into a cup; at 2.3s, a large number of particles appear out of thin air from the apple slice picked up in the right hand; at 2.4s, the apple slice on the table suddenly disappears; at 3.1s, the cup held in the right hand undergoes a sudden change). Causality (At 2.1s, the apple slice on the left deforms and moves without external force). Physical Behavior (At 1.8s, the cup on the right stands upright to the right without external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02174", "filename": "P09_104_58_53dd714022f0ea16_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Continuous timing (apple chunks appear out of thin air below the left hand at 0s; the number of cut apple chunks increases at 0.3s; the number of cut apple chunks suddenly increases at 0.6s; the video feed changes abruptly without transition at 1.5s; the left hand twists at 1.6s; the video feed changes abruptly at 2.9s); Physical behavior (finger clipping through the knife at 0.6s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02175", "filename": "P09_104_72_0188fde785ec4046_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Time sequence (1s: white filaments suddenly appear in the hand; 1.2s: oil stains suddenly appear in the pot; 5.2s: eggshell on the right hand suddenly produces an egg yolk; 7.9s: the volume of egg liquid in the pot suddenly increases) Cause and effect (3.4s: the egg in the left hand is opened, but the yolk does not flow out)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02176", "filename": "P09_104_72_0188fde785ec4046_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the egg in the left hand disappears at 0.1s, the yolk that flowed out suddenly becomes two at 3.1s, and the eggshell in the left hand suddenly disappears at 5s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02177", "filename": "P11_101_35_5384c79702c2f189_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Cause and effect (the packaging box stands up at 0.5s but the items inside do not fall out) Time continuity (the yellow item on the left turns white without transition at 0.6s; the logo on the box on the left suddenly disappears at 1.3s; the tissue suddenly enlarges at 1.7s; the yellow item on the table disappears at 3.6s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02178", "filename": "P11_101_35_5384c79702c2f189_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (1s: the top of the label torn off the left plate undergoes illogical deformation); Time continuity (3.1s: the label held in the right hand disappears without transition).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02179", "filename": "P11_101_35_5384c79702c2f189_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time sequence (At 0.3s, the item next to the left hand undergoes a sudden change, its shape distorts; at 2s, the yellow item suddenly reveals its inner packaging; at 2.6s, the transparent plastic wrap torn off by the right hand turns white; at 3.1s, the item below the right hand undergoes a sudden change, its shape distorts; at 4s, the label on the left hand undergoes a sudden change, and the white item suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02180", "filename": "P11_102_48_66cdb76a029d82ec_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the knife and iron bar in the entire video clip through the lens).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02181", "filename": "P11_102_48_66cdb76a029d82ec_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the knife and iron bar in the video clip through each other at 1.1s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02182", "filename": "P11_102_48_66cdb76a029d82ec_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.4s, the object in the right hand suddenly changes to a knife without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02183", "filename": "P11_102_71_9d1ac03d585b47be_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_02184", "filename": "P11_103_17_ac7324a695c491c3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (the knife in the right hand suddenly changes shape at 0.1s and the shape of the knife distorts; the knife in the left hand suddenly disappears at 0.1s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02185", "filename": "P11_103_73_04354addd6b7641c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time sequence (a white object suddenly appears in the hand at 0.1s, water suddenly appears at the bottom of the tank at 0.4s, and the water in the tank suddenly increases at 0.8s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02186", "filename": "P11_103_73_04354addd6b7641c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Mismatch (A white object suddenly appears in the hand at 0.8s; the faucet switch suddenly moves at 1.8s; the towel is being rubbed at 5.8s and then suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02187", "filename": "P11_104_90_379f6b5a060c01df_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the flesh on the left hand suddenly disappears at 0.4s; the frying bubbles from the food being fried appear blurry at 6s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02188", "filename": "P11_104_174_f9278dd3e303cd24_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (the bottle twists at 0.4s and the liquid in the bottle does not gradually disappear at 5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02189", "filename": "P11_105_19_35d387f0e4c76b3f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The timing is continuous (0.5s: after the plastic wrap is torn off, plastic wrap remains on the surface of the item; 2.9s: when the plate is picked up, a plastic film appears out of nowhere on the edge).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02190", "filename": "P11_105_19_35d387f0e4c76b3f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at the beginning, only the bottom part of the pizza has plastic wrap, but at 2.4s, the top part inexplicably appears with plastic wrap); Physical behavior (at 6.2s, the grill moves on its own without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02191", "filename": "P11_105_27_15f59ef0444be9bb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 2.1s, the yellow item disappears without a transition from the white item thrown by the left hand) Physical behavior (at 4.9s, the trash can lid opens outward without external force)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02192", "filename": "P11_105_27_15f59ef0444be9bb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.9s, the yellow object touched by the left hand's fingers undergoes a sudden change, its shape and size shrinking; at 5.1s, the white disc disappears abruptly when thrown into the trash can).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02193", "filename": "P11_105_28_878c1104b4ae1010_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time sequence (the white plastic film thrown into the trash can suddenly changes size at 0.1s) Causality (the pizza was intact at 1.4s, but cuts appeared on it at 3.4s in the video footage)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02194", "filename": "P11_105_28_878c1104b4ae1010_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (at 0s, the plastic film thrown into the trash can suddenly changes shape and shrinks; at 4.2s, the blue item is picked up but the black item is also picked up unnaturally).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02195", "filename": "P11_107_16_6914796fba36523f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (scissors were used to cut the pizza at 1.6 seconds, but no marks appeared).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02196", "filename": "P11_107_16_6914796fba36523f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (items on the pizza suddenly twist at 5.6s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02197", "filename": "P11_107_16_6914796fba36523f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time sequence (at 5.6s, a cut mark suddenly appears on the pizza below the right hand; at 5.6s, the pizza at the very tip of the scissors begins to wriggle).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02198", "filename": "f006eee3bddc08c032695d765ddb76492d596a0613889b190e92e3169ad3505e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: (Throughout the video, the rocket's base lacks clear launch pads and other key structures. Flames are ejected directly from the blurry platform, which does not conform to the engineering design of a real launch pad. A real rocket has precise proportions and sharp lines, with clear markings on the fairing, boosters, and body. The metallic texture and heat insulation layer are distinct. However, the rocket in the video is blurry and lacks a clear outline, failing to convey the precision of a real spacecraft. The launch pad also has missing and disorganized key structures, lacking core facilities such as launch pads and other key components. The smoke next to the rocket is abrupt and unreasonable, and the flames explode haphazardly in all directions without consistent vertical ejection. There is no gradual change in brightness between the high-temperature core and the edges.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02199", "filename": "f006eee3bddc08c032695d765ddb76492d596a0613889b190e92e3169ad3505e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: (The rocket launch in the entire video does not conform to fluid dynamics, the engineering structure is irregular, the rocket is incomplete, the direction of the flames and smoke is chaotic, there is no unified scene transition and rendering, the launch pad structure is missing, and there is no sense of precision and regularity of a real spacecraft and launch site.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02200", "filename": "f6dc6b3c39d863ffefbc17f86e22893dbefd3f26f7b2c2b3a13935c06359376d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: (Comparing the speed of water droplets dripping from the glass wall to the speed of the ice cubes melting throughout the video, the melting speed is too fast, and the melting liquid is significantly greater than the melting volume, making it look like the liquid suddenly increased out of thin air.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02201", "filename": "f8fb4682ea7236568d58f82cc885658092314aab54a6f742845e2644cf236826_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02202", "filename": "f9f060837fc40a535a6f72d8e7fb98dab725b9f54237ac1281c07b8e8d3dc546_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.2 seconds, a large number of clouds suddenly appear in the upper right of the clouds in the middle of the sky, and the sky begins to darken before the sun has even set).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02203", "filename": "f9f060837fc40a535a6f72d8e7fb98dab725b9f54237ac1281c07b8e8d3dc546_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to the following issues: the time sequence is not continuous (the clouds and light do not move for a long period of time, there is a noticeable shadow in the lower left corner of the spliced image, the cloud shape is too regular and homogenized, and the beam of light is exaggerated, making the video look like a flat picture and losing the sense of dynamic space).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02204", "filename": "f00010aa6c7cb943d0ad2b5ba80a52fc2f6a82a50933b96df7afa1e65d32ade9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.3 seconds, the hand is holding a closed iron ring, and at 1.7 seconds, it passes through the iron pillar, and the up-and-down twisting of the hand does not conform to the spiral pattern of the circular iron ring and the iron pillar).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02205", "filename": "f21c1f9c9aa024e2984e0397d6e50f2e68348fd6e4efebad3596149c5c08bd18_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (in the entire video, there is wind blowing the leaves above the pool, but the water surface is not rippled, the water surface is too calm and has no ripples, like a mirror).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02206", "filename": "f43d995fb1a82a9f9da5dd2f39d9c0c72eca5d3aadde6b3d2888315110400199_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal; the physical behavior is as follows: (Ocean waves are fluctuations on the water surface, and energy extends underwater, but they do not exhibit the wave crest shape shown in the video. After the waves break, underwater turbulence and backflow will occur, but there are no white foam waves. Furthermore, the bubbles brought in by the breaking waves will rise and burst quickly, unlike the large number of suspended and still bubbles shown in the video. The direction of the wave surge is inconsistent.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02207", "filename": "f58b5ff81fa67dbc2972b5ae438dbf67f1a1c10e23a0a846b521cd9f0ead1276_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the bubbles in the pot are extremely uniform in size, like suspended plastic beads, without any gradual change in size or dynamic sense of bursting. In real boiling, the bottom of the pot is the hottest, and the bubbles rise densely and gradually increase in size from bottom to top, instead of rising and gathering from the surrounding area as shown in the video, which does not conform to the logic of heat convection.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02208", "filename": "f91f07c2412e52ac0a8448a20af08ba4aa5726189af8aa1533fe395d01ce162d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Causality (At 1.8s, the high-pressure water gun sprayed liquid onto the bottom of the car door. At this time, the bottom of the car suddenly started to catch fire and a lot of smoke was emitted. Under the condition of no open flame, the liquid spraying on the car body would not cause a fire.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02209", "filename": "f94edbaf6a78e1d44cb4491ae7dba0881cc8e06a7e2445ebcdfb81b19970c6a8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 4.3s, the smoke suddenly starts to tilt to the right by the wind, while the flame does not tilt to the right at all).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02210", "filename": "f238f2746c031f8775c50a3fdc381c4de9e155d8ffb8648931d7d9f588da1c20_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02211", "filename": "f238f2746c031f8775c50a3fdc381c4de9e155d8ffb8648931d7d9f588da1c20_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (at 0.1 seconds, the toes suddenly change to heels).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02212", "filename": "f410b1e976cebf27acafc92d46b262dfd2270dd942cd3438f8b3b9a06bb7f220_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Cause and effect (no water sprays out when the water gun is pressed, but water sprays out when it is released)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02213", "filename": "f960fdf2fa14fb80702f198bc68f3da7f95ea0196f1dc070e763073ae0467b54_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.8s, the leaf the character picks up turns into a stick in his hand, a sudden change with no consistency).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02214", "filename": "f3414d32d41f4028aab9214417c3fd858b2118fb08af429f57a61cdd3faf01dd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (without external force, at 0.7 seconds, the ice cubes suddenly flip from the bottom to the top and become two, the number of ice cubes in the bowl increases significantly, and there is no consistency between the beginning and end).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02216", "filename": "f6869d0a7fb443fa67e48b38a8166c3c93507f81508305dcdb8eab70fb22b3b4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is inconsistent in several ways: The timing is discontinuous (a metal platform appears out of thin air after the fragments fall at 5.3 seconds, but this object is not present when the hydraulic press is not compressing the bottle, showing a lack of consistency). Physical behavior is also inconsistent (the bottle contains gas or liquid throughout the video; under pressure, it would first crack and release the gas or liquid before being flattened or crushed. If the bottle contained solid flammable material, it would explode from the inside under pressure, producing far fewer fragments than the bottle's volume suggests).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02217", "filename": "f9508eb7b7a29a3ab4249a6a603bceb1f8b14eff2c52cdbba6f161f2f9fd1ecf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Cause and effect (in the entire video, the surrounding soil and weeds were not affected by the explosion, with no soil flying or grass being overturned, and although the explosion was strong, the wooden house was not blown open, only one door was blown open, and the wooden house was only overturned on the ground)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02218", "filename": "5110f62c8bc7cd411d06db0830a34c8020e85c502f0645aaa313b13f6a73141f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (starting at 3 seconds in the video, without any change in camera angle, a large number of ripples suddenly appear on the lake surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02219", "filename": "5110f62c8bc7cd411d06db0830a34c8020e85c502f0645aaa313b13f6a73141f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the river water is constantly rippling in the wind throughout the video, but the leaves and grass on the bank remain still without any change, lacking a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02220", "filename": "5117c38588f5f1dc7fda2d516371fc85001fe4a34f8c487d4fc310d68798b8c8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior (the pen in the image bends excessively in the water, violating the principle of light refraction).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02221", "filename": "5117c38588f5f1dc7fda2d516371fc85001fe4a34f8c487d4fc310d68798b8c8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (from 3 seconds to the end of the video, without any change in camera angle, a layer of glass suddenly appears to protrude from the cup).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02222", "filename": "5117c38588f5f1dc7fda2d516371fc85001fe4a34f8c487d4fc310d68798b8c8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (Throughout the entire journey, the water in the cup remains constant without any external force, and the swaying arc remains consistent).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02223", "filename": "5311d8d8ae300c229a558722c7e55a33b12c3cbec0f1e07bba629a6c5b461fe8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is unusual: The overall visual impression is unusual (the fog in the image is morning fog or water vapor close to the water surface. This type of fog usually forms on still or very slow-moving water surfaces, but the water surface in the image is covered with obvious ripples and waves, which indicates that the water surface is moving).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02224", "filename": "5311d8d8ae300c229a558722c7e55a33b12c3cbec0f1e07bba629a6c5b461fe8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the trees in the upper left corner of the screen are constantly being distorted throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02225", "filename": "5311d8d8ae300c229a558722c7e55a33b12c3cbec0f1e07bba629a6c5b461fe8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (a real fog layer would lie close to the water surface, and the ripples on the water would cause slight changes in the shape of the fog layer, but the fog layer in the image is completely static and has no interaction with the undulating water surface below).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02226", "filename": "5311d8d8ae300c229a558722c7e55a33b12c3cbec0f1e07bba629a6c5b461fe8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (flickering artifacts appear in trees and mountains throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02231", "filename": "5474f8db66dfd7827e2510b440f8d5a62450aec1e71e1c3747135f2f3a20669a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 4.2s in the video, the person's arm passes directly through the washing machine partition, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02232", "filename": "5474f8db66dfd7827e2510b440f8d5a62450aec1e71e1c3747135f2f3a20669a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 0.1 seconds into the video, without any change in camera angle, the front-loading washing machine suddenly transforms into a vertical-loading washing machine).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02233", "filename": "5474f8db66dfd7827e2510b440f8d5a62450aec1e71e1c3747135f2f3a20669a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02234", "filename": "5520a0d6b2d6ef92a7bbbbff5509e6c4ceb087c8207175f0de05d509f67ce822_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.5s in the video, the pomegranate seeds scattered from the plate disappear into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02235", "filename": "5520a0d6b2d6ef92a7bbbbff5509e6c4ceb087c8207175f0de05d509f67ce822_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 3.4s in the video, pomegranate seeds suddenly appear out of thin air in the hands of the person in the scene without the camera changing).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02236", "filename": "5520a0d6b2d6ef92a7bbbbff5509e6c4ceb087c8207175f0de05d509f67ce822_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.1s in the video, when the character lifts the bowl full of pomegranates, a bowl appears out of thin air on the table).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02237", "filename": "5520a0d6b2d6ef92a7bbbbff5509e6c4ceb087c8207175f0de05d509f67ce822_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 4.4s in the video, without any change in camera angle, two pomegranates appear out of thin air in the person's hand before the person's hand has even touched the pomegranate).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02238", "filename": "5561c32c6ca36c943946a0e0cc891ff5b616d917fdcc6fd17e12a6d45bb5ca9b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (at 0s in the video, the ground in the frame explodes out of thin air, and at 4.9s, the ground remains unchanged after the explosion, without any impact).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02239", "filename": "5561c32c6ca36c943946a0e0cc891ff5b616d917fdcc6fd17e12a6d45bb5ca9b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall impression is abnormal (the dust in the image appears as a uniform, static, smoke-like mound, lacking the dynamic layering of naturally rising dust. Dust from an explosion would have a distinct granular texture and a diffusion trajectory, unlike the blurry and detail-lacking clumps in the image).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02240", "filename": "5561c32c6ca36c943946a0e0cc891ff5b616d917fdcc6fd17e12a6d45bb5ca9b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual intuition is abnormal (the dust kicked up by the explosion is sprayed out too neatly, the smoke is too evenly distributed, and it lacks a sense of random falling). The time is continuous (2s - end, the debris disappears into thin air during the falling process).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02246", "filename": "5818cdd8e8a030041597f076862e4f0afdff7e085a5d1cefa902b3308d58d326_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (flickering artifacts are present throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02247", "filename": "c0e64cc7edbf45aed7ed579560b9f666129d405ecb76a9b4320b66c7e97851d9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the waves on the right side of the screen replicate the same undulation at 1.4s and 2.5s, whereas in reality, ocean waves are irregular and would not replicate this effect).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02248", "filename": "c0e64cc7edbf45aed7ed579560b9f666129d405ecb76a9b4320b66c7e97851d9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02249", "filename": "c1ec660f7e675df7bbe358e36297c83ee532f0a3d5988367ddc6c6b5a5c11a26_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0.1s-4.8s: the window frame changes from one white frame to two white frames; simultaneously, three paintings appear out of thin air on the left wall of the table; 0.2s: the black rectangular object on the right side of the table changes to a square object).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02250", "filename": "c1ec660f7e675df7bbe358e36297c83ee532f0a3d5988367ddc6c6b5a5c11a26_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (Throughout the segment, a strong light shines from the table in front of the window onto the wall opposite the window, while the light reflected from the window's mirror is much weaker than the light source, resulting in a mismatch in the emitted light).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02251", "filename": "c1ec660f7e675df7bbe358e36297c83ee532f0a3d5988367ddc6c6b5a5c11a26_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (4s The speaker on the right side of the desk changes from a black casing to a white casing, the white radiator under the desk changes to a storage shelf; 4.2s The pattern and color of the bed sheet on the left side changes from a pastoral style to a black and white style, and the white iron shape at the foot of the bed changes from two semicircles to one semicircle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02252", "filename": "c1ec660f7e675df7bbe358e36297c83ee532f0a3d5988367ddc6c6b5a5c11a26_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.3s, the positions of the picture on the left wall and the picture reflected on the window are inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02253", "filename": "c2d30dce3be2dcdf0cc752213057fc06b94e78ca2e34ef83faf0dc876abe126f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the white paper in the video does not curl or wear down under the influence of flames).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02254", "filename": "c2d30dce3be2dcdf0cc752213057fc06b94e78ca2e34ef83faf0dc876abe126f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time is continuous (after the paper pile burns out in 3.1 seconds, there is more ash than before; in reality, it would not burn more and more, but should turn into finer ash).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02255", "filename": "c2d30dce3be2dcdf0cc752213057fc06b94e78ca2e34ef83faf0dc876abe126f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1.1s, flames suddenly appear out of thin air in the lower left corner; at 2.6s, flames disappear out of thin air in the upper right corner).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02256", "filename": "c2d30dce3be2dcdf0cc752213057fc06b94e78ca2e34ef83faf0dc876abe126f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is distorted: the timing is continuous (the entire video shows white paper burning, and although paper is a flammable material, only the middle part of the paper is burning, while the right side is not).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02257", "filename": "c2e2ac19573aa9d04d8efd63b1cb2d38131f8e61c440e723515aefb33ef74c17_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The time sequence is continuous (0.1s-2.2s: the shape of the diamond on the lower right changes; 2.4s: the diamond's position changes from right to left).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02258", "filename": "c2e2ac19573aa9d04d8efd63b1cb2d38131f8e61c440e723515aefb33ef74c17_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (in the video, the diamond's reflection in the mirror does not connect with the facets of the diamond above it; in reality, a diamond's shadow should travel in a straight line, with the facets connected).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02259", "filename": "c2e2ac19573aa9d04d8efd63b1cb2d38131f8e61c440e723515aefb33ef74c17_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02260", "filename": "c2fa7c6e9f8b263c72f5932560fbe31df6a445226970d8582605771f76b88c64_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is discontinuous (the protruding corners on the edge of the crystal ball in the video appear to bulge outwards as it rotates and then disappear; in reality, they would not bulge out during rotation and should rotate parallel and aligned).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02261", "filename": "c2fa7c6e9f8b263c72f5932560fbe31df6a445226970d8582605771f76b88c64_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (starting at 1.4s, the blending of the glitter inside the sphere is unnatural, and the color is also fluctuating between blue and purple, without any color reflection changes inside the crystal ball).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02266", "filename": "c3c2dd97d173a555f3d2fca10d5eda65b2c407eded92e27e98d1377776c31d88_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the steam is too uniform and the fog is too strong, lacking the dynamic dispersion and gradual change in concentration of real steam, making it more like a static smoke effect than steam produced by boiling water).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02267", "filename": "c3c2dd97d173a555f3d2fca10d5eda65b2c407eded92e27e98d1377776c31d88_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02268", "filename": "c3c2dd97d173a555f3d2fca10d5eda65b2c407eded92e27e98d1377776c31d88_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (there is too much steam from the water evaporation, and it appears in large clumps; in reality, there should be only a small amount of water vapor evaporating).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02269", "filename": "c3d780c8c7205bdd7843f85e6498848e194c97f3b3228faf96bd953498862429_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall impression is abnormal (in reality, the strong spray and splashing water from a waterfall would blur the lens and wet the image, and the water flow would even directly hit the lens, but the video footage is clear and clean, with no water spray or splashing marks).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02270", "filename": "c3d780c8c7205bdd7843f85e6498848e194c97f3b3228faf96bd953498862429_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (water rushes towards the person next to the video at 3 seconds, but no water splashes up in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02271", "filename": "c4fe1930efdc8b2c5fe0883d3efd6c5aa5aa040ceb0c7da1b4981ed1dc5a622f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (0s-2.3s). A black moving dot appears and disappears in the upper right corner of the lake. The waves generated by the yacht in the video are small. In reality, the waves should extend to the entire water surface.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02272", "filename": "c4fe1930efdc8b2c5fe0883d3efd6c5aa5aa040ceb0c7da1b4981ed1dc5a622f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the overall visual impression is abnormal (the wave motion on the right side of the video repeats itself from 0.3s to 4.7s, while real ocean waves do not move in such a regular way but are random).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02273", "filename": "c4fe1930efdc8b2c5fe0883d3efd6c5aa5aa040ceb0c7da1b4981ed1dc5a622f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02274", "filename": "c4fe1930efdc8b2c5fe0883d3efd6c5aa5aa040ceb0c7da1b4981ed1dc5a622f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02275", "filename": "c5dd4a1a5168876a5b105f14215bafe188c0a56c9cf25bf037221318c26b1f13_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (at 2.9s, when the egg is placed on the spoon, it pauses in mid-air without undergoing free fall). Time continuity (from 2.7s to 3.4s, when the egg falls, the inside of the pot does not reflect the orange color of the egg; in reality, the egg's color should appear on the pot wall simultaneously).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02276", "filename": "c5dd4a1a5168876a5b105f14215bafe188c0a56c9cf25bf037221318c26b1f13_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (there is a pause at 4.2 seconds when the egg is put into the pot, and the color of the egg in the water is not directly reflected).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02277", "filename": "7f1ce975def67cc8178244ce5a52007e822c7e8c3e41b79df720b28ea1944191_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall feel is off (the lake, floating objects, vegetation, etc., appear static in the video, lacking a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02278", "filename": "7f1ce975def67cc8178244ce5a52007e822c7e8c3e41b79df720b28ea1944191_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall feel is off (the lake, floating objects, vegetation, etc., appear static in the video, lacking a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02282", "filename": "7f61a2e7ed5a96cbb0ce533d81cdf183973d99f97017ebd0cd6d8135fd04d055_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: The overall impression is that while the palm trees in the image are swaying violently in the wind, the branches and leaves of the second tree remain almost still, unaffected by the wind, which appears unnatural.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02283", "filename": "7f61a2e7ed5a96cbb0ce533d81cdf183973d99f97017ebd0cd6d8135fd04d055_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: The overall impression is that while the palm trees in the image are swaying violently in the wind, the branches and leaves of the second tree remain almost still, unaffected by the wind, which appears unnatural and uncoordinated.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02284", "filename": "7f61a2e7ed5a96cbb0ce533d81cdf183973d99f97017ebd0cd6d8135fd04d055_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: The overall impression is that while the palm trees in the image are swaying violently in the wind, the branches of the second tree in the image sway very little and are hardly affected by the wind, which looks unnatural.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02285", "filename": "7faefd9fde982aaad45eb655248a7343eb96b631e78bbcc1228676535951a683_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the mist in the distant mountains on the right side of the screen appears to be flying horizontally, meaning the direction of the mist's dispersion clearly violates the natural wind direction and the laws of gravity, presenting an unnatural horizontal movement.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02286", "filename": "7faefd9fde982aaad45eb655248a7343eb96b631e78bbcc1228676535951a683_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly Comparison: Physical Anomaly (During the period from 0.6s to 7.9s, the video shows a relatively dry environment with no obvious source of moisture, yet dense fog appears, which violates the normal logic of air humidity and fog formation.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02291", "filename": "08a640c8d4a18320595be4df17bbfac408118f7d45bd99df96a334cdf001fed5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the waterfall's cascading speed appears uniform, violating the law of velocity variation caused by gravitational acceleration.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02292", "filename": "08a640c8d4a18320595be4df17bbfac408118f7d45bd99df96a334cdf001fed5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image appears abnormal: The overall impression is that the waterfall's shape and texture are highly uniform, lacking the dynamic changes and randomness of natural water flow; the surrounding water area and related vegetation appear excessively static.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02293", "filename": "08a640c8d4a18320595be4df17bbfac408118f7d45bd99df96a334cdf001fed5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the water mist from the waterfall does not show the diffusion and drifting caused by wind and temperature). Overall impression anomalies (the water surface above the waterfall is too calm, with almost no movement, even though the volume and speed of the water flowing down are too large).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02294", "filename": "08a640c8d4a18320595be4df17bbfac408118f7d45bd99df96a334cdf001fed5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02295", "filename": "08aaddd5db94f85999429efb9891ecef4a6654f001e653cbfa1bdb89e3a64c04_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall feeling is abnormal (the flame in the center of the oil lamp in the picture remains still without any flickering or shaking, unlike the way a flame in reality would sway slightly with the wind or airflow).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02296", "filename": "08aaddd5db94f85999429efb9891ecef4a6654f001e653cbfa1bdb89e3a64c04_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the entire process, without any external force, the flame in the oil lamp on the left flickered excessively. From 4.3 seconds onwards, the flame only burned on the right end without any slight flickering, violating the laws of fluid motion).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02297", "filename": "08aaddd5db94f85999429efb9891ecef4a6654f001e653cbfa1bdb89e3a64c04_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02302", "filename": "8a552979c4d51ba1c55a713ec46f6b5c2dafea787f7b1443020125f0d6761245_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (at 2.1s, the ball suddenly flew out of the blue frame without being subjected to any external force).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02303", "filename": "8a552979c4d51ba1c55a713ec46f6b5c2dafea787f7b1443020125f0d6761245_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (the ball suddenly disappears at 0.1s; at 0.4s, the two shuttlecock-shaped objects in the frame suddenly split into four; at 1.2s, the upper ring in the frame suddenly merges with the lower ring).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02304", "filename": "8a552979c4d51ba1c55a713ec46f6b5c2dafea787f7b1443020125f0d6761245_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the video, the frame supporting the ball is shaking, while the ball itself remains stationary and does not shake).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02305", "filename": "8a552979c4d51ba1c55a713ec46f6b5c2dafea787f7b1443020125f0d6761245_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 1.6s, the two separate white rings in the image suddenly merge into one without any merging trace, then suddenly break apart again at 2.6s. At 4s, the white metal plate connecting the two rings suddenly disappears, then suddenly reappears at 5s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02306", "filename": "8ad0e016f4e7b4dc4699a3b22f00ab2d4d5aed7635a5df0f215e3cb805736643_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall impression is off (the flames in the video have a clear, regular shape resembling an animal, whereas natural flames are affected by airflow, the distribution of combustibles, and the intensity of combustion, and their shape should be irregular and constantly changing, not forming such a stable and figurative form.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02307", "filename": "P03_109_357_22e8f4e5bcc70a75_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (the image flickers continuously throughout the video)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02308", "filename": "P03_111_16_49c3417aaaf75e67_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02309", "filename": "P03_112_96_e070a22994164ebb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (from 4.3s to 8s, the steam from the kettle should gradually dissipate after rising into the air, but instead, the steam increases out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02310", "filename": "P03_113_48_ecc89f1395c7b22d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 5.2 seconds, the foam in the white bowl on the left increases out of nowhere, and water is continuously added to the black pot at the bottom of the video, but the water level does not change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02311", "filename": "P03_117_218_16502d99e2351f4f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the upper right corner of the blade disappears at 1.2s, and the butter below the blade shrinks at 1.5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02312", "filename": "P03_117_220_11e08d81d136fb0e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.4s, grease appears out of nowhere on the right side of the knife and the grease on the knife body increases in size out of nowhere)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02313", "filename": "P03_117_236_20c0ee7a59e22c6c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.5s, a small piece of butter appears out of thin air on the edge of the butter on the left hand).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02314", "filename": "P03_119_19_03b3c12383cd3826_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (3.6s). The clear water that was originally flowing into the tank suddenly turns into a white liquid, and the liquid spreads in the tank from right to left.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02315", "filename": "P03_119_148_b56cbcb28e4d89b6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time-related (2.1s) The sponge in the character's hand, which was originally yellow and white, suddenly turns pure white.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02316", "filename": "P03_120_255_0eaa96cdb05d9b43_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous playback (no transition to the next frame at 0.2s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02317", "filename": "P03_122_4_c46b1028cb79c033_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02318", "filename": "P03_123_4_a9334390e20faf08_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Continuous timing (the desktop screen flickers in the video).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02319", "filename": "P03_123_16_5e7211dcd3a4efdf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_02320", "filename": "P04_101_14_db57d5aaeed76c79_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: physical behavior (at 0.5s, the finger and the cabinet door's retainer appear to merge backwards in the video); temporal continuity (at 4.5s, the kitten's shadow suddenly becomes larger).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02321", "filename": "P04_102_10_fb9d7b18bb4505d3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 0.9s, the bottle picked up on the left did not touch the black bottle, and the black bottle shook on its own).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02322", "filename": "P04_106_41_4c252a66c1b13d6d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (at 4:26, the left thumb is stretched, and the transparent glass bowl on the left side of the video flickers).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02323", "filename": "P04_107_168_b1684dcdf4aa725f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1s, the originally damaged cylindrical object on the left is restored to its original state; at 5.3s, the cylindrical object on the lower right disappears out of thin air and a white object appears out of thin air; at 7.1s, the cylindrical object in the middle of the hand appears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02324", "filename": "P04_107_357_c3b6e9ab1ed72310_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the desktop and objects in the video flicker).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02325", "filename": "P04_107_440_3ecbd3778c211fcf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Continuous time (the desktop screen in the video flickers and wriggles).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02326", "filename": "P04_107_559_82e0189225300ef7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: physical behavior (the bag above the screen continuously and slightly shakes without any external force or wind); continuous time (the indentation on the cutting board suddenly enlarges at 0.3 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02327", "filename": "P04_107_562_0f891959174435b8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.3 seconds, the sharp corner at the lower right half of the cutting board suddenly shortens).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02328", "filename": "P04_107_615_80e7b0e2cbd56d84_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the volume of the dough on the cutting board suddenly decreases at 3.4 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02329", "filename": "P04_107_927_e4f8e0de5ef239f2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (the entire screen flickers and twitches).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02330", "filename": "P04_108_44_a5949b9fbee49681_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: continuous time (at 3.4s, the video transitions to another scene without transition; at 5.2s, a hand appears to float in mid-air on the left side of the pot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02331", "filename": "P04_109_133_7b71b040189ed07e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 2.8s to 8s, the cucumber cut by the left hand changes from a square to a circle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02332", "filename": "P04_109_174_115912896c53c07e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time sequence is continuous (the cucumber shreds in the bowl twist and merge at 0.7s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02333", "filename": "P04_109_231_a5d439fb5cf0ec8e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the amount of cucumber and radish shreds being grasped in the container by the right hand decreases throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02334", "filename": "P04_109_312_b96e0912ddf0ea37_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (the broccoli was not in free fall at 4.1s due to lack of support).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02335", "filename": "P04_110_17_93a3f33512b01d99_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the broccoli cut next to the spatula is intact at 3.3s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02336", "filename": "P04_110_200_7636b51b1aaa41e3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous flickering (the video continuously flickers throughout the entire clip).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02337", "filename": "17ec12da5069e06c9e63d22bc4346e2ea821301f5e96b322c44d478495f94784_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, a third ice cube appears out of thin air on top of the two ice cubes in the glass at 2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02338", "filename": "17ee049554770ab552cd2f68d77e65d013a038a66ecf69d001f587659567def8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the land and trees in the back right corner of the screen are abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02339", "filename": "019c2446b47f1125aaedced3fb5cae96a66e8bd476f3f34642821a8025d569f1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 3.2s, fragments on the left side of the screen disappear out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02340", "filename": "19d91c1c5dbb3a456bfb36e7c2b67ba6581497667e6efa32008297207ca9f7f6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time is continuous (the flame shape is too regular, the outline is rigid and symmetrical, the height and amplitude of the flame swing are completely consistent, and there is no random jumping and shape change of natural flames).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02341", "filename": "19e41c63a6f1dc51ea302116628f80a67cbc3e6a0560c8eb5466db06d1e0eaf7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (the light source in the upper right corner of the image is constantly changing, but the brightness of the objects it illuminates remains constant; the change in light intensity is completely disconnected from the amount of light received by the objects).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02342", "filename": "20d27383bebe4b3b8f850e216675e3b2e9966f93b0d358e11b2cdc9e0eb19bdc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 1.5 seconds, a blue liquid appears out of nowhere on the right side of the screen).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02343", "filename": "21ea1f1f75a5540c0faf461c1d339d7c985310d1ef0297660b2151484e083de9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (clouds at the top of the screen are abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02344", "filename": "21f6a78d0cb7c1f0de49df4ab46ca597b301ef610fb2ed1ec1eb4ff56abaa61b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, at 0.2s, fragments appear out of thin air between the character's fingers)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02345", "filename": "22e4e454d760fb8ca7c6cfd07faf2bf2bc1817c4d2bef0416ce97d3a669ace5b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the water vapor next to the water column disappears instantly at 3.9 seconds without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02346", "filename": "23b3a0ee3784cc7fdbcf6a908118f887992dcf6900b809c187f9f9b2f619877b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02347", "filename": "24b35a5cf2c28aadf4c6840cd066440de1a540424805b13e8853116691b7f613_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the object at the bottom right of the screen disappears at 6.7 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02348", "filename": "24b1114dd3db06608435000657dba1c861392f95f682cf93c7b46163d8967ede_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without camera movement and without any external force applied, the ice cubes in the glass are transparent at 3.1 seconds, and turn yellow instantly in the next frame)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02349", "filename": "24ed5ee2e279615590057256ec65497793f7308f3ce861e6a2fecf9572cb7d28_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (leaves in the lower left corner of the screen are abnormally twisting).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02351", "filename": "27a6ca871696c781a64c8a73e3e140c38a7dffd0b137dd82bacb8f8cf44c0623_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02352", "filename": "27d4fe782033afe8cc8e4ededefef77d7044b0994a00ee5d22f51fd0f636548a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (in a scene without camera cuts or external interference, the water droplets do not fall vertically following the natural trajectory of gravity, but fall at an angle throughout).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02353", "filename": "27fe065de2f8b4e9c8f81cf838e4ddd542e3b8da86333b86ff66f5e8a4a8e747_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (Under the premise of no external force or object interference, the objects in the lower left part of the image are abnormally twisting).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02354", "filename": "28ac59ce74e8bc2df7c3e60d28d0c6fda873865f71645c1a1137edc9c6289cdd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the white dot in the upper right corner of the screen disappears out of nowhere at 1.3s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02355", "filename": "029f1a347e8434d4d60e2505278baff6546a087b4add4eeadf75c0a5645b1b03_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the trees in the back right corner of the screen are abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02356", "filename": "29d2d4cda10fe79d993df40ac4c9029dd1e3f8e11b8758abadaf6c65c4dcd558_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (objects on the hydraulic press are deformed and sunken downwards without being subjected to external force or interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02358", "filename": "31f8e9e4d321d3bc4ae2c3bcd7c84e6a67dbbe0b6682ae958fbdb146166af3e4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any external force or camera movement, there is no acceleration transition at 7.6s, and the next frame suddenly switches to rapid movement).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02359", "filename": "32d4cfe239118042e9636707ccb605ac0383ba1bbdab20aab216729aed985844_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 4s, the object in the lower right corner of the screen changes from brownish-red to a blue-white color instantly without any camera movement).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02360", "filename": "32e23a8db8455396ef4af5b893b05cac0dfce2963c01826ea346e281df09712c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (abnormally distorted background)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02361", "filename": "32e68575fc3fb19c98a12ddc17a24382dfb702f7568df67580c83c211f2448d4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02362", "filename": "32fd0c50e2fec1e13da7e9153a2d9827c0c6ee999cd3220eaf192a663054adfd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 6.5 seconds, the hole in the steel ball in the middle of the frame disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02363", "filename": "33f75948ff199bafbe29849470f3e01feaf78320a4c30bec24572c6f6122f295_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02364", "filename": "33fcdead0f26faa900ec5d3c9c206a50cfcfaa0e5d90b8a5efb71d5d0b320e72_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time is continuous (when the flames are burning in the scene, the flames do not have a natural, soft, and smooth movement, but instead appear stiff, abrupt, twisted, and swaying. There is not a wisp of smoke rising next to the flames).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02365", "filename": "36acf8262bc1bb7bb68127f2d9c853743d7feb527c01b8481f534208e70d2f8e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the hills in the background and the starry sky in the sky are abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02366", "filename": "36de8f22fafbf554bff5fd98229870f9ccae5aaf639c518be13c8a4af40326e9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02367", "filename": "ade07fce7c5dd10ed97d6200a5108c1602187c0a0ad7f8e2913d89770ea9cf69_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the entire cloud formation presents an overly perfect spiral structure; real storm clouds should have irregular turbulence) (the grass on the field remains still and does not sway under a strong storm)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02368", "filename": "af548aeb7ab0b0d214a7f5e02255ae4b48acdc31e0e333c895a36280b149bc2b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.4s, the spoon changes from digging to scooping up instantly) (at 4.4s, the edges of the pit left at the end are too neat, without natural collapse).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02369", "filename": "af928dbc80e837e69e611188ea68eb7661197e4a53ebe8544e5d41558f889b31_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02371", "filename": "b994d9f4328ed1f99431d9282c2cceb79e58d41c8b69508a94d81fb6986c0949_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02372", "filename": "b9607b38bcecb38ead4260251eb80752907d1587d44a974708ecde7c26c1f4d0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (snow piles up too quickly and too neatly on the entire window) (the video suddenly exposes and turns white at 3.9s)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02373", "filename": "b9620c1f66b8f4784eaf335b5af685e5d893d009d3ac0c86a4fe39f48a017783_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (3.5s - end: The building on the left collapses on its own without any force, which does not conform to the law of interaction forces).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02375", "filename": "bb4db348c25de1db9a421e93d5862d2e0b62862076640692d203dc5f969ff851_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (from the beginning to 2.7s, the vegetation and distant hills in the video are transparent and have a double image) (from 3.7s to the end, the sky begins to brighten, and the ground is instantly covered by thick fog)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02376", "filename": "bc5e28af193ade75826ef6a06620849ab02d9b8a872be05ca74b7b198358b5a2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (the white bird flying to the left disappears into thin air at 4.1s). Physical behavior (the entire column of steam does not rise vertically from the pool surface, but enters horizontally from the left side of the screen, which does not conform to the principle of hot air rising).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02377", "filename": "bc1067fa266551361c33027f91fead77d011466e91375f965125a2694d17201c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the entire ring stands upright on a horizontal paper without any force) and temporal continuity (the entire diamond should reflect stable highlights and moving shimmers, not continuous self-illumination).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02378", "filename": "bce2dc099bd9a9d5e14f09489a8959810cbb487dc2c4b12813012e0fb8a4a826_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (from 1.7s to 5.2s, the bubbles are too uniformly distributed and still, with no boiling or rolling, but real boiling water should have violent bubbles rising, bursting, and water rolling).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02379", "filename": "bd0bada94d636ad0cdc6ebfd5cac59696450ecdbdddd8893732e855ff00fd4b8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the ice on the water surface rapidly disappears and melts at the start - 3.9 seconds, but the water level does not rise)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02380", "filename": "bd8b3ecab5942c69a9c0485ea2b4c80437b72348a981f423a83019ac040acd28_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the entire liquid appears as a high-viscosity, stringy substance, but in a high-viscosity liquid, bubbles should rise slowly, deform, and merge, rather than move rapidly).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02381", "filename": "bd42aafca4a555c1e2fec7b11f788477128417513294d24e7b31f07ea1e9c180_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (melted candy from 0.8s to 5.1s, after the slime flows down, the candy returns to its original shape)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02382", "filename": "bd109f3279e11edd3e699845dbf53a4eb335f30c4be8d18159575958fc0f7df2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (at 2.5s, the transparent glass lid suddenly turns into silver stainless steel) (from 1.05 to 3.3s, the water in the pot boils and the bubbles on the surface are distributed too evenly and uniformly).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02383", "filename": "bdb499bf071cf2dc4058066721043ef820cb1ca911c6ed36037eadf4e25f6352_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the entire candle has a completely consistent shape, no burning or consumption, the flame is completely still, without shaking or flickering) (the lower half of the candle undergoes a sudden color change (cyan \u2192 blue \u2192 purple), but the upper half remains completely unchanged)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02384", "filename": "bded6d1c50d39a87da6c73628c4f52308793c36ed68b7aa54b577f22dadc7ddd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the grass and leaves in the video are blurry and flickering, appearing as countless particles).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02386", "filename": "bf5c93d6ba606ae2e84b5b88b06d7c9743efd2a2ef77e518c895b75abbc6ebf9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the entire rainbow stripe moves too fast and in the same direction, the film flows too fast, which violates the high viscosity characteristics; the color change of the bubble film interference should be slow, random, and localized).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02387", "filename": "bffbbf81acc40cb09fbee1f7bc7b4fc585e3d620fbc9dbd2c041b7c9ef99359a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 0.2s to 1.1s, the silver metal block on the left slides to the right on its own without the hand touching it) (at 1.5s, the metal block held by the fingers suddenly splits into two).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02388", "filename": "c17d24a6124b5adb689d83e3dd2f7169fa5e07f0fc543111a2836b3cf41a47ec_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (from the start to 1.9s, the surrounding iron blocks rotate rapidly around the central iron block, but the speed suddenly slows down at 1.9s) (at 1.8s, the silver iron block below suddenly darkens in color, turning brown).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02389", "filename": "c41b0f2331b5a3c2bf4c350fa83b2e686b221629468b89ca3d603cf47b2ccc6f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the entire segment of golden particles remains undisturbed, adhering to the spiral and liquid surface; however, movement should cause particles to detach and redistribute). (The spiral exhibits periodic expansion and contraction, like breathing, but the movement here is too smooth and lacks inertia.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02390", "filename": "c91fc4e35c0a985bda71faaeae60b68574ff82bc4b4ed6a2196f1bd127e56f59_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02392", "filename": "c816a14920dfa12d20923cedb9374c81ee9925164760eba3d8b7a36e1d5c2076_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (from 0.7s to 2.2s, the doll sways left and right without wind or any force, which does not conform to the law of interaction of forces). Time continuity (at 2.6s, the doll suddenly falls off and explodes).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02393", "filename": "c132876ba4499ad147db9829061616bab065e9ff3746d8b188da8ad4bb91bebe_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the entire ice block remains completely unchanged, showing no signs of melting; the melting process should show obvious shrinkage, rounding of corners, and roughening of the surface) (the air bubbles inside the ice block are completely still and do not move with melting; melting should cause the air bubbles to be released and their positions to change)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02394", "filename": "c718667776c7529edcd0ed0006c6a41bee37282e6f689993bfebb40e99fea1b1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (the entire diamond exhibits a continuous high-frequency iridescent flash without any change in light source; the diamond reflection should be stable, changing only with the light source or viewing angle). Physical behavior (the chain is completely stationary, hanging without gravity; the suspended chain should have a natural curve and slight movement).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02395", "filename": "cbd832589653a6531032543c21ef5d65c543e2f59d4fbf7d1fe859219be3c539_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (at the start - 3.7s, the droplet changes from dark red to orange; the color of the same liquid should be consistent, with no instantaneous color change). (At 2.7s, the splash forms a symmetrical crown shape, which is too perfect; a realistic splash should be asymmetrical, random, and irregular.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02396", "filename": "cc1f7b898939b61564e6eaa2658e6fc85aba201f82d899e575c5a3cf593854cf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (0.9s-3s, the strawberries remain intact, without breaking or squeezing out juice) (3s-end, the surface of the blender is too smooth and symmetrical, with no splashing or bubbles. High-speed blending should produce violent splashing and foaming).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02397", "filename": "0f45e6a30b8262c80b0ee24370b9ab67bb56c98158985ce822a928b57fb48a57_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is unusual: the time frame is continuous (within the range of 1.19-3.09, the shape of the land surface did not change before and after the explosion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02398", "filename": "0f190b3328d3a314bbb9dc7a3639c4ea1b6844644f54c7c7b210dc63520c008c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: the waterfall's flow appears unnatural throughout the video; although a waterfall is a liquid, its descent resembles that of gas.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02399", "filename": "0fbd5eb2d0038ff21b7dbed9e58bd6a1204b16c5d43a49feeb176e38b9925fad_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to physical behavior (within 0-8 seconds, a feather falling into water will not sink immediately; it will first absorb water at the surface and slowly sink only when its weight exceeds the surface tension of the water. This violates the theorem that the density of a feather is less than that of water.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02400", "filename": "0fbdd536dda1a2b409573409feaea2b91bf6393d9d9ad937fbc17f6c3e7aae31_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior: (From 0.25 to 8 seconds, the bubbles move to the right without any external force. At 3.3 seconds, the two bubbles collide, but instead of bursting, they penetrate each other.)", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02401", "filename": "1a9b8a2d8e953ab69c555dd1457afb863d50e26b984f37c7f3f3e50e77b3d0dd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (within 0-8 seconds, the ice in the left cup should sink to the bottom, not float on the surface, because ice is denser than water.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02403", "filename": "1a52039cda52cdcf3fd2e52ed45a783b25cafaa1c15e9cb4c7179d4f712886ca_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02404", "filename": "1ac5cdfea7cfa26dd72ee94dc9c3e5c37f6b8c6b5ee6dcad9cc716e8706b548a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior: (Within 0-8 seconds, the package moves on a non-operational conveyor belt, violating Newton's First Law.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02406", "filename": "1b3bc1d832b1261e5c328eab84c1f429666bda56984dcf13998a08b5e394cfd7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02407", "filename": "1b7c3914e79b3fff16e0b73f7abbcbb06b357bf9d7c1b39c24ec346499c2edc0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity: (The entire video has a snowflake effect, but the scene is inside a house, and the style is more like a comic book than reality.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02408", "filename": "1b8c5096f41262243491233743f500a60396985abf2955ce5e7fca2547344e3d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual abnormality (flickering issue with the ship's hull).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02409", "filename": "1b55b6cbf1129a222744f8bf5e0f6c13c93c22a1ba1646094c6b4fa345a42ead_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02410", "filename": "1b2026ee6fdc2bdc589c0fb5d492c514591bd4cd1c5cf49da7eec047b34a563e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Between 2.23 and 8 seconds, the blue smoke exhibited an abnormal trajectory, lingering in the air for an extended period.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02411", "filename": "1b076029a6a18a9e1a5434ea6afd93894b20c46b6a2e107011dae3df22c9fa07_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the ground deforms at 1.7 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02412", "filename": "1ba420a4d223d5bc6634d245900a585549b1a53fefc94914a74ec1347786c3f4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (smoke and hammer penetrate at 3.5s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02413", "filename": "1bd6f4b437e0ef7f89139c77cc8bd771b43b11172611ae8ad6a8f8abaf35c1e9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Between 5.06 and 8 seconds, the ball's color changed from orange to light orange.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02414", "filename": "1c2ee2b7e95992780ac56dc1bfcc1312a8e1ce40e04d1499b8680b5dfc1786b2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Between 0 and 7.2 seconds, the lighthouse in the lower right corner deformed.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02415", "filename": "1c9e94dbb3e9f31aab95c29a7ba5600682864a935568fa6d7a120b129b46593a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: The image is too perfect; the petals are brightly colored and translucent, whereas real flowers are not that vibrant.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02416", "filename": "1c62f8cbc14466c440dbd57575ed75b632a92c3f98f79fa3500ac5e58ea42e37_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (within 0-6.5s, the lighter has already ignited, but the gears are rotating without any external force, violating Newton's first law.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02417", "filename": "1c662437ac36a05e6b6d1e90358cab8a8d7fa3ea18018d9ad72b8b37ae6a83af_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (a flame that had been extinguished at 7.2s suddenly reignited.)", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02418", "filename": "1cbe18216eda223b1cd786f92fddda5e6e4bfd0721d3e5dc89d441e45bea5700_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual abnormality (flickering in the image).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02419", "filename": "1ce2f55f3cf7a2bb08ea00ea09069dc9c3843dadc0de211a3f523e3d01f3e010_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02420", "filename": "1d11ef147d96c26533baf7804b4bf3b399df62512a07873d0f274e43ad276cea_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02422", "filename": "1d60505c9b260716a8a5e2783fa857c32ab6e32b5df13e8a36d224642d29c992_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.4s, the tip of the blue object suddenly appears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02423", "filename": "1dd1e18e063fbbb2ad1bd0f98d74facc5f34c8d211b1aab82ecdf8b9ef8ab525_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1.5s, the block in the hand suddenly disappears without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02424", "filename": "1e1f9d81a8f5f2a35ca497e0a8473684b1d197f1aef2bbb1d547055fb87b07da_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the object on the left moves spontaneously without any external force, violating Newton's First Law.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02425", "filename": "1e88d69d690cef3a44f3aa7d16fd56d265a9c0186c8a7c1c46d54c39272fa8cb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the glass is full of liquid at 8 seconds, but the liquid doesn't flow down the sides; instead, it remains at the rim, violating the law of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02426", "filename": "1ed733af6f68cb107ba92b81bcf905896ff0b5dd205dce7bbaae1a34cf118fc5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual abnormality (objects are flickering).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02427", "filename": "ab0e8c119565e0e806eb326e831cb45be5bce3d76e41c453c3882f0b53845e3d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (0.3s, the yellow block at the top of the leftmost device, which was present in the previous frame, disappears abruptly without transition in the 0.3s frame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02428", "filename": "ab0e8c119565e0e806eb326e831cb45be5bce3d76e41c453c3882f0b53845e3d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 4.7s, the yellow ball in the purple pipe of the leftmost device suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02429", "filename": "ab0e8c119565e0e806eb326e831cb45be5bce3d76e41c453c3882f0b53845e3d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity error (the green light on the device suddenly turns blue without any transition at 5.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02430", "filename": "ab4ebb6415cb79b8ad6818480d2843af47a502711e56dd1ea03097d4a57801ef_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (At 1.1s, the flame of number candle 0 suddenly dims. However, the size and brightness of the bright area it creates on the cake surface do not change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02431", "filename": "ab4ebb6415cb79b8ad6818480d2843af47a502711e56dd1ea03097d4a57801ef_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (after 0.7s, the candle on number 2 abruptly changes from a normal yellow flame to spraying white sparks resembling sparklers).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02432", "filename": "ab4ebb6415cb79b8ad6818480d2843af47a502711e56dd1ea03097d4a57801ef_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (the sparkler is constantly shooting sparks and burning throughout the video, but its length shows no signs of shortening).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02433", "filename": "ab4ebb6415cb79b8ad6818480d2843af47a502711e56dd1ea03097d4a57801ef_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 0.6s, in addition to the sparkler in the middle, another sparkler shooting sparks appeared without warning).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02434", "filename": "ab6a6606f5de742dca8e87affbf9294b4e132d3fa5b57bfdab9557424cc53e22_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical anomaly (around 3.5s, the white steam and black smoke from the train, which should have drifted in one direction, suddenly dispersed in the opposite direction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02435", "filename": "ab6a6606f5de742dca8e87affbf9294b4e132d3fa5b57bfdab9557424cc53e22_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 5.4s, the smoke from the locomotive suddenly changes from a pale grayish-white color to extremely black without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02436", "filename": "ab403d414cb9d129536b8cf9e0ed90d6173bf577b221a82fd9fe875fbae4c2ab_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 3.1s, the originally bright, warm-toned clouds in the sky suddenly turn black and gray without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02437", "filename": "ab403d414cb9d129536b8cf9e0ed90d6173bf577b221a82fd9fe875fbae4c2ab_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (around 2.3s, the originally clear and bright sun with a warm halo suddenly darkens, and at the same time, the outline of the power transmission tower on the left side of the screen and the fog density also change without transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02438", "filename": "ab403d414cb9d129536b8cf9e0ed90d6173bf577b221a82fd9fe875fbae4c2ab_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02443", "filename": "ab2948632eadf7ed7054e3f15b632d5711377c61cfc1a21fe4eab6c68ec1d0f5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: The cake exhibits abnormal physical behavior (it expands and bounces erratically throughout the video without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02444", "filename": "ab2948632eadf7ed7054e3f15b632d5711377c61cfc1a21fe4eab6c68ec1d0f5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (the chocolate sauce added at 0.8s did not blend with the existing liquid on the cake surface, but instead directly covered it).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02445", "filename": "ab2948632eadf7ed7054e3f15b632d5711377c61cfc1a21fe4eab6c68ec1d0f5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02446", "filename": "abc3552694d21f47ac522853fb8c6e5fbd983954ce8d57aa219705556e4b377d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the visuals: The continuity of time is abnormal (at 4.7s, the glass shards that had been shattered by the bullet have returned to their original, intact state).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02447", "filename": "abc3552694d21f47ac522853fb8c6e5fbd983954ce8d57aa219705556e4b377d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical anomaly (Throughout the video, high-speed flying glass shards continuously impact the glass panel standing behind, yet the panel itself does not shake or vibrate in any way).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02448", "filename": "abc3552694d21f47ac522853fb8c6e5fbd983954ce8d57aa219705556e4b377d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: The physical behavior is abnormal (in the entire video, the glass shards that were pierced by the bullet did not fall due to gravity, but instead hovered in the air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02451", "filename": "ac3adc5ffcdc8c4acec8b411f907162fb2683f3aa058efc0695f0a5856ff161e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Abnormal physical behavior (the entire video footage shows water with ice cubes in a glass, and the liquid level in the glass fluctuates irregularly up and down without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02452", "filename": "ac3adc5ffcdc8c4acec8b411f907162fb2683f3aa058efc0695f0a5856ff161e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 2.9s, the amount of ice water in the cup suddenly decreases without overflowing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02453", "filename": "ac3adc5ffcdc8c4acec8b411f907162fb2683f3aa058efc0695f0a5856ff161e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 7s, the white ice water in the glass suddenly turned into a yellow liquid without the addition of any other substance).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02454", "filename": "ac3fb7160e63fdc112e542cf14ed696382697b5aa5b3cc1e0a3724a0576a5a7d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (the light band above the city moves ridiculously fast throughout the video. It doesn't drift by gradually; it suddenly jumps to the next position).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02455", "filename": "ac3fb7160e63fdc112e542cf14ed696382697b5aa5b3cc1e0a3724a0576a5a7d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (the purple and pink halos in the image are not natural city light scattering effects; their color transitions are too uniform and have a strong sense of layering; the fog effect does not show natural attenuation with changes in terrain and distance, but rather looks like a semi-transparent filter covering the city, lacking the sense of layering of real atmospheric scattering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02456", "filename": "ac3fb7160e63fdc112e542cf14ed696382697b5aa5b3cc1e0a3724a0576a5a7d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 3.2s, the sky above the city, which was originally full of clouds, suddenly becomes blank, with no transition process of clouds dissipating, as if it was cleared with one click).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02457", "filename": "300c08acab0973c0f07d9262514366c2b8fdd32bbad3cab94e700a9290e52697_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly occurred in the video: the rightmost water column, appearing after 4.2 seconds, showed a break in its flow.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02458", "filename": "309c66632871a1b5cffd23d1c4fcf406b6026db79f7e673a3d852745520611c3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02459", "filename": "309c66632871a1b5cffd23d1c4fcf406b6026db79f7e673a3d852745520611c3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Duration: (The video is generally dark from 0-0.5s, and suddenly becomes bright at 0.6s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02460", "filename": "309c66632871a1b5cffd23d1c4fcf406b6026db79f7e673a3d852745520611c3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02461", "filename": "309c66632871a1b5cffd23d1c4fcf406b6026db79f7e673a3d852745520611c3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02462", "filename": "310a4befdc8e0f3071af2c89354f4e4a63d0fa32cd6d3a3718018778e8ba8ce1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the liquid in the pot is boiling, but the orange items on the surface of the liquid are still piled up together and not dispersed near the pot wall).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02463", "filename": "310a4befdc8e0f3071af2c89354f4e4a63d0fa32cd6d3a3718018778e8ba8ce1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the liquid in the image boils for 0.8 seconds and then gradually becomes clear; and the bubbles in the upper left corner of the image do not push away the orange floating on the surface of the liquid after they burst the surface, but instead attract them, which violates the law of forces on objects).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02464", "filename": "310a4befdc8e0f3071af2c89354f4e4a63d0fa32cd6d3a3718018778e8ba8ce1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02465", "filename": "310a4befdc8e0f3071af2c89354f4e4a63d0fa32cd6d3a3718018778e8ba8ce1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is due to the following physical behavior: (At 4.3 seconds, a large number of bubbles are generated in the liquid, but chili skin remains in the center of the bubbles instead of being dispersed, which violates the kinetic energy theorem and the momentum theorem.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02466", "filename": "316d7c95190476a19afca40c41f5d422d060aff501c529fb2257acfae3beb4cf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video behavior: Physical behavior (the wooden block located at the angle between the ground and the wall in the video moves randomly from beginning to end without being subjected to any external force, and finally returns to its original position. At 1.3s, the wooden block passes through the green block in the center of the screen, violating Newton's first law and the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02467", "filename": "316d7c95190476a19afca40c41f5d422d060aff501c529fb2257acfae3beb4cf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (a wooden block suddenly appears in the center of the screen between 0-1.6s in the video, and then all the small balls and another block in the screen suddenly start moving without any external force, violating Newton's first law).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02468", "filename": "316d7c95190476a19afca40c41f5d422d060aff501c529fb2257acfae3beb4cf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The duration of the event (at 3.5 seconds, the green square in the center of the screen transforms into a sphere, which then splits into two spheres after 4.1 seconds) and physical behavior (the spheres in the video are colliding with each other, but the collisions clearly indicate the presence of external forces, which does not conform to the law of conservation of momentum).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02469", "filename": "321df789e81b0c7b8367edea554db04d75fbd1f36fde082e8aea5d0f9ee33820_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 2.2s, the sphere inside the cube appears to be embedded in the mirror rather than inside the sphere, and at 1.4s, the mirror shows a yellow reflection, but this reflection does not appear on every surface during subsequent rotations, which does not conform to the law of reflection of light).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02470", "filename": "321df789e81b0c7b8367edea554db04d75fbd1f36fde082e8aea5d0f9ee33820_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the duration is inconsistent (the light is still cyan between 0.2s and 0.7s, but the cube is already reflecting blue light).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02471", "filename": "321df789e81b0c7b8367edea554db04d75fbd1f36fde082e8aea5d0f9ee33820_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02472", "filename": "321df789e81b0c7b8367edea554db04d75fbd1f36fde082e8aea5d0f9ee33820_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (starting at 0.7s, the balls on the mirror surface suddenly begin to emerge from the mirror and their numbers increase)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02473", "filename": "328b3c9bade99c0a973aa846c21d2e30d396947c16b11df809c4fcbe880787e3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the trajectory of the soccer ball returning at 1.4s does not conform to the law of rotation of objects; at 3.6s, when the soccer ball returns to the person's leg, it suddenly begins to rotate without external force; at 4.7s, when the person lifts the ball, the soccer ball's takeoff trajectory is different from its force conditions).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02474", "filename": "328b3c9bade99c0a973aa846c21d2e30d396947c16b11df809c4fcbe880787e3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the video, when the soccer ball leaves the person's hand, the second bounce is higher than the first, and the fourth bounce is too low, which does not conform to the law of conservation of momentum).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02475", "filename": "333c434a7a7cc01ca9ae711146c6132f46134a98077bf5dbc3025c2fa1eb26cd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: duration (at 0.6s, the rectangle in the video suddenly turns into an irregular polygon).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02476", "filename": "333c434a7a7cc01ca9ae711146c6132f46134a98077bf5dbc3025c2fa1eb26cd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02477", "filename": "333c434a7a7cc01ca9ae711146c6132f46134a98077bf5dbc3025c2fa1eb26cd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the block initially reflects light on the wall, but no shadow is cast, violating the principle that light travels in straight lines).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_02478", "filename": "333c434a7a7cc01ca9ae711146c6132f46134a98077bf5dbc3025c2fa1eb26cd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time delay (the image shows a square crystal rotating, but at 5.8 seconds the crystal transforms into a triangular prism).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02479", "filename": "352ac61997187d249917cac2c15344974c610042890104cbe1a85636424d2b94_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (at 0s, when the balloon lands on the snow, a patch of blue liquid suddenly appears on the snow and gradually grows larger; at 2.6s, the blue liquid begins to cover the snow and gradually shrinks until it gathers under the black balloon).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02480", "filename": "352ac61997187d249917cac2c15344974c610042890104cbe1a85636424d2b94_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (in the video, the black balloon falls onto the snow at 0.6 seconds and turns into a water ring, then at 4.2 seconds it turns into a pattern resembling an animal footprint, which does not conform to the laws of physics).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02481", "filename": "352ac61997187d249917cac2c15344974c610042890104cbe1a85636424d2b94_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The duration is prolonged (in the footage, after 2.2 seconds, the balloon falls into the snow and then sprays out a large amount of unidentified blue liquid from the point of impact).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02482", "filename": "353bb8d163a6c3a53eb65c91a047d90e3e5ab8dfa4d657d45c8997f96334849d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal behavior: Physical behavior (at 3.1s, the amount of water in the dropper tube suddenly increased, violating the law of conservation of mass).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02483", "filename": "353bb8d163a6c3a53eb65c91a047d90e3e5ab8dfa4d657d45c8997f96334849d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is due to physical behavior (1.2 seconds after the dropper begins adding blue liquid to the beaker, but the dropper does not draw in that much liquid, and the liquid level in the beaker does not rise due to the addition of liquid from the dropper, violating the law of conservation of mass).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02484", "filename": "353bb8d163a6c3a53eb65c91a047d90e3e5ab8dfa4d657d45c8997f96334849d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the scene at 3.4s, the character adds liquid to a beaker with a dropper. The amount of liquid in the dropper does not decrease as liquid is added to the beaker, nor does the liquid level in the beaker rise, violating the law of conservation of mass).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02485", "filename": "353bb8d163a6c3a53eb65c91a047d90e3e5ab8dfa4d657d45c8997f96334849d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 2.1 seconds, the dropper starts adding blue liquid to the beaker, but the blue liquid comes out from the cap; the liquid level in the beaker does not rise as liquid is added).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02486", "filename": "357a5bf22712a4f68c76d8173b5906d763aa4fa8d2aab8d6fdc1bd7a4ced2d4c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the clouds in the image are constantly moving, but the waterfall-like cloud formation in the center does not move in response to the movement, violating the laws of motion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02487", "filename": "fa7f0d3dfaadc59641d62086c576c929658ce2c5084418bc6692bd8409e5e9be_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (at 3.5s, the water does not flow out of the bottle opening but flows out of the bottle body, resulting in clipping).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02489", "filename": "fafd9c9ad7ba78eb2aea5df4c2cea3496721cbaa43f07f069ff571b4a0f1cedc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (from 0.7s to 1.7s, the ball's trajectory on the slope deviates from the law of inertia, resulting in chaotic motion without external interference). Time continuity (and the ball suddenly disappears and reappears at 1.3s, showing no consistency).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02490", "filename": "fb36fb0c0df1a072dcf2505792286fc78a56517bd4b23168d7590a1d8251b280_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the edges of clouds in the entire video frame flicker and shake).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02491", "filename": "fb81dffa4d348a433a8809b0f220a4f542609c9198acca044db07e7b9127feb5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.2s, the bottom of the mattress in the lower right corner of the screen appears to merge with the long object).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02492", "filename": "fb89ed7f5d987ec3804a638063577876e9631628b4ca83fe57c5100f1bb1b0a7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (water droplets in a heated pot exhibit the Leidenfrost effect, where the droplets bounce and roll on the pot surface and do not evaporate easily. This is because the high temperature of the pot surface causes the bottom of the water droplets to vaporize instantly, forming a layer of water vapor that lifts the droplets and reduces direct contact between the droplets and the pot surface, thus causing the bouncing and rolling phenomenon. However, in the entire video, only some water droplets exhibit this bouncing and rolling phenomenon).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02494", "filename": "fc3ece43f425eacef2642dc2c6d3fc767e6113a14aaaea7238005a4feab6c74f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 5.4s, the water flow continues to increase, and the volume of liquid in the upper left corner should exceed the overflow of the bowl, but the liquid in the video stops rising and does not overflow the bowl. When the water column touches the water surface in the bowl throughout the video, there is no dent at the point where the water column hits the water surface, the water ripples are too smooth, there is no water droplet splashing under the impact, and the composite effect is obvious).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02495", "filename": "fc85d9e1b8422c76452bec2adbfe10269b2b3dd14d86e073e29bdc50b177f4c4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (in the video, two table legs start to tread on the ground like human feet, and the composite effect is obvious).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02496", "filename": "fd3fe9118eca25641ceb8ddc0a4ed237fe6993bb4404c337805b2d3eb77aaca2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 0s to 8s, the polar bear in the video only shows part of its body underwater, but the body above the water disappears; at 3.9s, the polar bear's head suddenly deforms; and from 4s onwards, the polar bear's entire body twists and deforms in the water, showing no animal form whatsoever).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02497", "filename": "fdbc18aa485cbfe4c4e07579fa25b962021af183c0326e424fb9e4b7c4d5f965_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (at 0.2s, the flame penetrates the cup, but the cup is not damaged; at 2.6s, the flame burns the upper half of the bottle, but there is no flow of burning plastic liquid).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02498", "filename": "fdbf52cbaa45664f55a85ec9b7bc999fea1757624c38848f06fb1dfe207a878a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video error: overall visual error (the exposure of the video is extremely abnormal, with overexposed white stripes appearing on the right side; the video completely violates the laws of light propagation and reflection, with no light refraction and the white light directly blocking the asphalt road).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02499", "filename": "fdf6282870e38192f5660f7fcf786f8b25fa62ad66f93ace553eea49c40bedcf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: The overall visual presentation is off. (The video shows a very bright, sun-like light source on the right side, but the surrounding clouds appear thick and dark gray, lacking a natural transition from being evenly illuminated by sunlight. In reality, clouds near the sun are directly illuminated, appearing dazzling white or golden yellow, unlike the image where large areas of dark, gloomy clouds appear directly below and around the light source. Furthermore, the left side of the image shows a large, horizontally extending layer of thick clouds with an overall dark tone, while the right side features a strong point light source and radiating rays. This combination is unlikely to occur in reality: with such strong direct sunlight, the brightness and color of the clouds in the sky should be more uniform, and there shouldn't be completely gloomy cloud areas and areas penetrated by strong light simultaneously in the same field of view, with no reasonable gradual transition between the two. It's as if cloud formations under different weather and lighting conditions have been forcibly spliced together.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_02501", "filename": "feaf3639c7574b0f077814ba469dff5bb01c86c04e9fe50e2430a0eb3eba3cca_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (there are several flames in the image that appear unnaturally superimposed on the firewood. For example, in the middle right, there is a yellow flame whose outline completely violates the physical law that flames should burn upwards. The brightness of some flames does not match the burning state of the surrounding firewood. Some firewood appears to be charred, but the flames on it do not show the corresponding dynamism and layering. The overall image appears stiff and uncoordinated.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02502", "filename": "ff3c7d7aba01138ada2e99da986b8e5fe908a33d944efba3df60e13fa528865b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (between 4.5s and 6.8s, the butter spread on the bread in the video does not spread out with the spreading action).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02503", "filename": "ff5ef4942f0fed9656914d82caa52d1054a3decc745f393fa6cd0fcad659696f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (the vibration of the speaker drum should be a slight undulating vibration, but between 1.3s and 3.1s, the vibration of the speaker drum is an irregular wave-like vibration, and the shape of the speaker drum is severely distorted with obvious distortion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02504", "filename": "ffc86587dc1401ec56c40e2fbf05a1b5f97b32c0044a04c3870d7badff8acd3c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02505", "filename": "P01_102_113_babb379c10836c19_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (a black vertical line suddenly appears on the left side of the bottom of the pool between 1.8s and 4.1s, with no consistency between the beginning and end; at 4s, there is a clipping issue when the hands are crossed). Overall visual anomalies (the reflection of the metal sink, the texture of the wooden planks, and the water stains on the pots throughout the video lack consistent lighting logic, and the reflections of people appear stiff and unrealistic).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02506", "filename": "P01_103_63_684e316af4e498d8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: The timing is continuous (at 2.3s, there is a severe clipping between the hand and the plastic bag in the video; at 4s, the plastic bag under the right hand suddenly disappears and then suddenly reappears at 4.3s; starting at 4.5s, the outstretched right hand fingers disappear, the hand shape is strange and unnatural, and the whole video has a clear sense of being composited).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02507", "filename": "P01_105_144_d1a8f6feb96d9e8d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (Throughout the video, a wristwatch is worn on the left hand. Normally, a watch should be worn on the wrist near the palm for a comfortable fit, but in the video, the watch is worn on the bottom of the palm near the center, and the strap does not naturally conform to the contours of the arm; instead, it appears to be stiffly stuck to the skin. At 5.3s, the shadow in the lower right corner of the video shows a hand holding nothing, but at 6.2s, a substance appears out of thin air in the right hand and is poured into the pot, showing a lack of consistency).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02508", "filename": "P01_105_230_94a512d90806569b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (the figure in the video stands in an odd and uncoordinated posture, with only one foot visible in the lower body, while the upper body is upright, which does not conform to the natural standing posture and body coordination of the human body; throughout the video, the knife slides on the object without breaking it, and the entire movement is too smooth with obvious composite effects).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02509", "filename": "P01_105_235_7d01e9dbf9c15b20_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (from 3s to 5.6s, the right hand holds a knife and repeatedly cuts the same spot on the object without any change in the object. In addition, the light and shadow of the figure on the cutting board are very abrupt and there is no natural gradual transition. This does not conform to the laws of diffuse reflection of light in reality).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02510", "filename": "P01_105_239_9bf1aeace7c084ef_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is continuous (1.8s: after the right hand cuts the object, the object suddenly appears inside the blade; 2.8s: the object in the left hand splits into small pieces without any external force, and the edges of the cut food do not have natural texture or compression deformation, but look as if they are stiffly stuck together, without the sense of real cutting layers).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02511", "filename": "P01_105_264_3edd594b6c52126c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (in the entire video, when a person wipes their hand with a towel, the finger joints bend backwards, the palm and fingers are threaded through the towel, some hand structures directly penetrate the surface of the towel, the hand makes meaningless sliding motions on the towel, there are no real pressing or rubbing movements, it looks more like the hand is floating and moving horizontally on the surface of the towel, the towel loses its fabric texture in motion and becomes a blurry color block, or after repeated rubbing, it does not show natural wrinkles or deformations)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02512", "filename": "P01_105_738_fb6bbabdd0e60c5d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (In the entire video, when the hand pulls the towel, there is no realistic sense of wrinkles and support as if the fabric were being pulled. When the towel is pulled, the direction and tightness of the wrinkles do not match the direction of the force applied by the hand. The fabric does not undergo natural stretching and deformation due to the pulling force. The contact edge between the fingers and the towel is blurry, and there is no realistic sense of skin texture and fabric fiber adhesion. It looks like the towel is stuck to the surface rather than being grasped. Between 6.4s and 7.4s, the right index finger passes down through the left index finger, resulting in clipping).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02513", "filename": "P01_106_233_cdc637b47067452a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (At 1.5s, the towel is thrown by the right hand but does not fall due to inertia. Instead, it sticks to the hand. Throughout the video, after the towel is pulled, the wrinkles do not unfold in the direction of the pull, or there are floating wrinkles without external support. This does not conform to the natural drape of fabric under gravity and tension. The fabric texture appears distorted and blurred during movement.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02514", "filename": "P01_107_45_5906d61cc58fa757_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (During the entire video, the fingers are stiff and claw-like when the person is grasping the object, without the natural bending and close contact of a real grasp. The hand is only using a few fingers to grasp, making it look like it is floating on the surface of the object rather than actually holding it. At 2.8 seconds, the object slips, but the contact area between the hand and the object is small, yet the object does not fall, which does not conform to the laws of gravity and inertia).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02515", "filename": "P01_108_51_56b0b0ce0690a49e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (from 0s to 4s, the water glass remains filled with water without overflowing; from 2.7s to 3.8s, water flows into the glass, but water ripples appear out of nowhere at the bottom of the sink; at 5.6s, the water flows over a person's hand without creating any splashing or splashing; and throughout the video, the water jet falling into the sink does not produce splashing or splashing patterns consistent with the water volume and speed, and the ripples are too smooth and distorted).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02516", "filename": "P01_109_97_6b79d6427d968e3d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (from 1s to 5.7s, the object that the person dropped suddenly reappears in the person's hand; throughout the video, the fingers of the right hand are in an unnatural bent state, and there is no real grasping posture with the peeler, lacking the force deformation and fit of the hand when in contact with the object).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02517", "filename": "7b7d320f6051517cc4fca71a6ac51d15823748dfa6318db90600c85aa2001c6a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (At 4.5s in the video, without any change in the camera angle, when the liquid covers the groove on the edge of the plate, the groove suddenly disappears. When the liquid overflows the plate, it does not flow from the edge of the plate to the ground, but flows directly from under the plate).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02518", "filename": "7b7d320f6051517cc4fca71a6ac51d15823748dfa6318db90600c85aa2001c6a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video content: Physical behavior (the jelly-like object sways left and right on its own without any external force throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02519", "filename": "7b95afb64fd31ac71611fba1de7132ce18b8a3e32301c3e24685a2468537bdc1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02520", "filename": "7b95afb64fd31ac71611fba1de7132ce18b8a3e32301c3e24685a2468537bdc1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.4 seconds into the video, the person pours the yellow liquid from the bottle into the cup, and before the liquid in the bottle reaches the mouth, yellow liquid is already flowing out of the mouth).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02521", "filename": "7b7891aaa787ad717df5f6ab6b5f97c3e069347b59e635b2d3a6a3a5172c0cf7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (at 4.6s in the video, the iron block penetrates the white pipe, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02522", "filename": "7b7891aaa787ad717df5f6ab6b5f97c3e069347b59e635b2d3a6a3a5172c0cf7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (at 4 seconds, the white tube in the person's hand suddenly shortens without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02523", "filename": "7b7891aaa787ad717df5f6ab6b5f97c3e069347b59e635b2d3a6a3a5172c0cf7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.6s in the video, the smaller iron block in the left hand suddenly becomes larger without any camera movement).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02524", "filename": "7b13220fc2652ea3f569690fb37565cf2be48dfe00b8780f55d5f8b96e376da7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02525", "filename": "7b13220fc2652ea3f569690fb37565cf2be48dfe00b8780f55d5f8b96e376da7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (in the video, at 2.4 seconds, the water surface near the camera suddenly turns into a mudflat without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02526", "filename": "7b13220fc2652ea3f569690fb37565cf2be48dfe00b8780f55d5f8b96e376da7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the stone at the bottom of the screen remains stationary on the river surface throughout the entire scene, neither sinking to the bottom due to gravity nor being carried away by the river's flow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02527", "filename": "7b13220fc2652ea3f569690fb37565cf2be48dfe00b8780f55d5f8b96e376da7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 0.9s in the video, without any change in camera angle, the upstream waves have not yet flowed downstream, but a layer of waves suddenly appears downstream).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02528", "filename": "7b575514b599cfc8c42120afe255f786e51726fca827dd2000170fe91a1d29f8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 1.2 seconds into the video, as the camera moves to the left, a tree branch suddenly appears out of nowhere in the upper right corner of the frame. The mountains and lake exhibit flickering and jerking artifacts throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02529", "filename": "7b575514b599cfc8c42120afe255f786e51726fca827dd2000170fe91a1d29f8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (a tree branch appears on the left side of the screen at the beginning of the video, and disappears out of thin air when the camera moves to the left 1.0s later).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02530", "filename": "7b575514b599cfc8c42120afe255f786e51726fca827dd2000170fe91a1d29f8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual presentation is off (the video is too choppy and jerky, and the movement of the lake water doesn't resemble real water flow, lacking random splashes and natural branching).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02531", "filename": "7b575514b599cfc8c42120afe255f786e51726fca827dd2000170fe91a1d29f8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02532", "filename": "7be9fb0c2a24093009bc16ea4b2e643decceee5c3529de76d144d6106116eaa0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous movement (the texture on the bottom of the container appears to wriggle throughout the entire video without any change in camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02533", "filename": "7be9fb0c2a24093009bc16ea4b2e643decceee5c3529de76d144d6106116eaa0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Continuous timing (at 2.1s in the video, without any change in the camera angle, water droplets suddenly appear on the finger) Physical behavior (at 4.2s, two water ripples in different directions on the water surface do not overlap after colliding).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02534", "filename": "7be9fb0c2a24093009bc16ea4b2e643decceee5c3529de76d144d6106116eaa0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02535", "filename": "7bee47a24f7d3e4d4c637b6cf41a4e6872af9d2ab97d41b4b7c68cde95074a69_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.9 seconds, the white flashing spot on the chandelier suddenly disappears, and the chandelier has obvious flickering and twitching defects throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02536", "filename": "7bee47a24f7d3e4d4c637b6cf41a4e6872af9d2ab97d41b4b7c68cde95074a69_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the video suddenly stops at 3.6s, and then continues until 3.6s, remaining frozen at the 3.6s mark without any changes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02537", "filename": "7bee47a24f7d3e4d4c637b6cf41a4e6872af9d2ab97d41b4b7c68cde95074a69_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02538", "filename": "7bf6354495d215047966d871a73c0f13def707da8e6f0c5465dd0385e7ed373a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Physical behavior (at 0.1s, the water splash caused by the round object falling into the cup passes directly through the cup and appears on the outside of the cup, which violates the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02539", "filename": "7bf6354495d215047966d871a73c0f13def707da8e6f0c5465dd0385e7ed373a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 0.4s in the video, without any change in the camera angle, the ice cube on the right side of the glass disappears out of thin air, and at 3.6s, the bottom of the transparent glass suddenly explodes, spraying out white liquid).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02540", "filename": "7bf6354495d215047966d871a73c0f13def707da8e6f0c5465dd0385e7ed373a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 0.5s in the video, the white sphere falls into the cup, and the water inside the cup is squeezed and the splashing water directly penetrates the cup, violating the principle that solids are impermeable). Time continuity (at 0.5s in the video, the two ice cubes that were originally in the cup disappear into thin air after the white sphere falls into the cup).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02541", "filename": "7bf6354495d215047966d871a73c0f13def707da8e6f0c5465dd0385e7ed373a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the white pill sinks rapidly after contacting the cup wall at 1.4s, generating a large number of bubbles; under the influence of density and tension, the pill should float against the cup wall).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02545", "filename": "7c07d7db8e379a74691962fdcaf4b5288a2e31f85290b0e58da9e217992a3b3f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (the smoke produced by the bursting bubble at 2.2s is chaotically evaporating upwards; the smoke should be ring-shaped or radial). Time continuity (the surface of the bubble that exploded at 1.8s still shows reflections).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02546", "filename": "7c07d7db8e379a74691962fdcaf4b5288a2e31f85290b0e58da9e217992a3b3f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (the smoke produced by the bursting bubble should be ring-shaped or radial; in the video at 2.4s, after the bubble bursts, the smoke shrinks downwards without any external force) Causality (at 2.1s, without any downward force applied to the cup, the bubble in the cup automatically collapses downwards and explodes).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02547", "filename": "4549bfa0c885a7e0175556148d0e5bdac76722370262ac106d0930573fcd7959_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the water in the video should be flowing down a slope, but the water ripples are flowing uphill.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02548", "filename": "4598b8a8c345aed3308ae36f5bdab710af39427d9e4e51506507569cbd54ea41_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the texture of the fabric behind the glass in the image is flickering and continuously shaking).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02549", "filename": "4629c89ef2b8a854ad4abce74dc826c3bf690ed3fe248912534d0072b2ef21c6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the image quality is unclear and the screen keeps shaking; the wood has burned out and is in the form of charcoal but is still burning).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02550", "filename": "4717d4d5b493ca29af8a55141d42965f97d4288f17edd27e12d3fcfc1e61ff98_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02551", "filename": "4768fd05d4ef2798b7fc79ffac58d4727c08a8f1b1a0aef3e20b194eb1213fb5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: physical behavior (the mask in the image is not strong enough to support the weight of the car, but when the tires run over it, the car stops noticeably and the plastic mask is not flattened, which does not conform to the principle of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02552", "filename": "5078fb1e8545a6035500e1ad86acadf5ee4eccaf4560fb8f0acc0c0c170fb4b1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time extension (the water droplets on the cup in the video appear to merge, flicker, and twitch, and although the water volume should increase after the ice melts, the water in the cup in the video gradually decreases).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02553", "filename": "5110f62c8bc7cd411d06db0830a34c8020e85c502f0645aaa313b13f6a73141f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is distorted due to a lack of continuity (the textures of the grass, ground, trees, and leaves in the video appear to flicker and twitch, and the entire video is noticeably shaky and distorted).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02554", "filename": "5311d8d8ae300c229a558722c7e55a33b12c3cbec0f1e07bba629a6c5b461fe8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the texture and leaves of the tree in the upper left corner of the screen show obvious flickering and jerking throughout the entire segment).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02555", "filename": "5360f3f758b7e32c33329022f47b1a03ca4e8d63c63d7d57c7348e8d52ebfef9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a car appears on a road that was empty at 5.7 seconds in the video, with no consistency between the preceding and following frames).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02556", "filename": "5474f8db66dfd7827e2510b440f8d5a62450aec1e71e1c3747135f2f3a20669a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (a hand suddenly appears inside a closed washing machine in a 1.8s video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02557", "filename": "5520a0d6b2d6ef92a7bbbbff5509e6c4ceb087c8207175f0de05d509f67ce822_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the pomegranates in the right plate of the entire video show obvious flickering and twitching, and the nuts in the left plate of the video appear to merge at 0.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02559", "filename": "5818cdd8e8a030041597f076862e4f0afdff7e085a5d1cefa902b3308d58d326_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal; the timing is inconsistent (the ice blocks in the entire video are flickering and the image quality is unstable).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02560", "filename": "6016db4612ae3a699fd8c9c72bde4b4250bbb8204f2739d318c458fd88cdfb29_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 2.7 seconds, the brick suddenly starts to shatter and explode without being subjected to pressure from the hydraulic press).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02561", "filename": "6352df4dad3dd0ae4ba03358bf139701e77030b5970141196857d09b36f03bc6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02562", "filename": "6466ff93ab75c236d2d0e31434ae2d315cdbe3aa4071332112e8c010d441935c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02564", "filename": "06635b932ce1935b2b6978051bf742b58626769563e9b4b3b1c53b1c9e03519b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (1.9s) and many small black dots suddenly appear out of nowhere in the video, and the movement of the white plastic is obviously choppy and unnatural.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02565", "filename": "6654d2ac6a7bab880d7da9a9c515efd2593c7a75d4ffa2f3c322684e2b724c20_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous (the video suddenly stutters and jerks at 3.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02566", "filename": "6976afbf24c38e94d52108187a3754a0c57608e09db343405d22ffa3958abb47_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02567", "filename": "7034feded29f204b142705bb8d8bda93bb606c0185e77ca10873c9506d2bb9b4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 5.6s, saliva suddenly moves upwards in the character's mouth).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02568", "filename": "7159eb6915a61a821bc7cafb38ca39b175c8c4a62daf3fe1b615779ca6f87d3b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (the wind blows the flames to the right in the video, but the thin tree branches on the right side of the video show no signs of burning).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02569", "filename": "7444b462a2fae5f03b7791573ad4b55538b1d599d04d1950d835f79f2695fa3c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Cause and effect (multiple blocks move on the desktop without any external force between 0.8s and 7s in the video)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02570", "filename": "7658a0d993e6ce995847d020cb3694a4e5816f24b249c0d8512b963ef0c3c7e5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is continuous (a black car appears in the rearview mirror at 7.3 seconds and merges with the second-to-last image of the vehicle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02571", "filename": "7748d08cf32cac6c86ec1eaae591ebee48ef40378bafa3aed1d6bce1b30655c0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (a break occurs between the springs at 0.6s and 2.8s, then suddenly reconnects at 1.1s and 3.2s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02572", "filename": "7803e60972f329ef5e6db0775cfc214ea764d0de44bd5ab3a40a0f20171198fe_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02573", "filename": "7826b5f162370c3078985eaaaf198ad0b7ac0d326c71020d510284a87f1d5ae3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02575", "filename": "7924a9fcd5aabffd139d09f7acb1bfabac9244297da2644f31ec98de7f9ffeb8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The time sequence is not continuous (in the 5.9s video, the animal on the right suddenly becomes larger and taller, showing a significant change without consistency).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02576", "filename": "07975a76b745c0b8b5f0afc44a0bf0283ed05ea9dbbd9bfbc44e10f6c4e4ca43_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02577", "filename": "3e09cffabeadda5eb0e27db36eae7ef69bb27b2e7b2c8ed55932f3c49b954a9a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (a pool of liquid vibrates on the diaphragm of a speaker, but a bubble appears at 0.7s and 1.8s respectively. Vibration only transfers energy and not gas, so it does not produce gas).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02578", "filename": "3e09cffabeadda5eb0e27db36eae7ef69bb27b2e7b2c8ed55932f3c49b954a9a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the liquid on the speaker diaphragm in the image spontaneously explodes from the center to both sides at 3s and 5.3s respectively, but the shape of the image looks more like something being thrown into the liquid rather than spontaneously occurring).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02579", "filename": "3e09cffabeadda5eb0e27db36eae7ef69bb27b2e7b2c8ed55932f3c49b954a9a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02580", "filename": "3e09cffabeadda5eb0e27db36eae7ef69bb27b2e7b2c8ed55932f3c49b954a9a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Right side of the page: Overall intuition (the trajectory of the liquid splash in the speaker diaphragm in the image is too perfect, and the height of each part of the liquid splashing in all directions is very similar).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02581", "filename": "3e6667f5d51f1f4bfd88db729959c7a82a7968fdb7aeebddd7303fe87855432c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the smoke in the image appears to spread horizontally, with an unusually clear horizontal boundary at the bottom. In reality, smoke would rise due to the rising of hot air.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02582", "filename": "3e6667f5d51f1f4bfd88db729959c7a82a7968fdb7aeebddd7303fe87855432c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02583", "filename": "3e06798a73e429a42a5918b9e77626e8dda3ff902d73e8602a590cc633045571_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (When ice melts, water flows down the ice surface, leaving wet streaks. However, in this image, the melting is only shown as a depression in the background, without any water stains or wet reflections, completely contradicting the physical process of ice melting.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02584", "filename": "3e06798a73e429a42a5918b9e77626e8dda3ff902d73e8602a590cc633045571_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Physical behavior (the ice in the video is melting too fast, and it can be seen that the ice on the right is already transparent, with fewer impurities and a higher temperature, so it should melt first, but the video shows them melting together, which violates the process of ice melting.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02585", "filename": "3e06798a73e429a42a5918b9e77626e8dda3ff902d73e8602a590cc633045571_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The duration of the event (between 2.4s and 3.4s, the ice block suddenly becomes brighter without any additional light source)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02586", "filename": "3e06798a73e429a42a5918b9e77626e8dda3ff902d73e8602a590cc633045571_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (the ice cubes, which were not heated at 0.7s, suddenly start boiling and then melt rapidly).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02587", "filename": "3ea3c768d8c248b289b3b2ad999dcead249e5287c7ec6ca07febff3cce42b3f7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the upper and lower layers of clouds in the image move in different directions).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02588", "filename": "3ea3c768d8c248b289b3b2ad999dcead249e5287c7ec6ca07febff3cce42b3f7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (clouds in the center of the screen appear out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02589", "filename": "3ea3c768d8c248b289b3b2ad999dcead249e5287c7ec6ca07febff3cce42b3f7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02593", "filename": "3eb335dbc22a6bb973cec5dae5d43d1802a3487962685059ae000a120a147fef_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02594", "filename": "3eb335dbc22a6bb973cec5dae5d43d1802a3487962685059ae000a120a147fef_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 0.6s in the video, the object bounces back without touching the ground as it prepares to bounce a second time).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02595", "filename": "3eb335dbc22a6bb973cec5dae5d43d1802a3487962685059ae000a120a147fef_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The duration is prolonged (the ball suddenly passes through the wall and gradually increases in size between 0 and 0.2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02596", "filename": "3ec6c96f61445e890dd2b973055ba2eab7650978a51081c1d4a559f9b8fe210e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02597", "filename": "3ec6c96f61445e890dd2b973055ba2eab7650978a51081c1d4a559f9b8fe210e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (the water surface becomes like a mirror at 3.2 seconds, without any ripples caused by wind).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02598", "filename": "3ec6c96f61445e890dd2b973055ba2eab7650978a51081c1d4a559f9b8fe210e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02602", "filename": "3ed5839ee03c2cc03910447970a33723248cc49e7c68fd7dfb66ebd423abee18_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02603", "filename": "3ed5839ee03c2cc03910447970a33723248cc49e7c68fd7dfb66ebd423abee18_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02604", "filename": "3ed5839ee03c2cc03910447970a33723248cc49e7c68fd7dfb66ebd423abee18_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02605", "filename": "3ed5839ee03c2cc03910447970a33723248cc49e7c68fd7dfb66ebd423abee18_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02606", "filename": "3edfe964f3afcacfd8de61df5a217a216e9172cdedcb1aac3ace87352ae39393_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall impression (the clouds in the image have a texture more like smooth plastic than clouds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02607", "filename": "6a2141646e2f04eeef6075a261dccf633788d25cc5d9979ed7cca04e8d0715eb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical anomaly (the smoke released by the candle and match in the entire video appears to be deliberately curved; real hot smoke would flow upwards due to the rising hot air, and its shape would be more smooth and continuous).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02608", "filename": "6aa96c70e37a0f45362e6af3b18a3e1331d2b2c2464afad791997a8bf71ccc59_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (The smoke emitted from the pipe in the entire video is too concentrated, lacking a smooth transition of natural diffusion. The smoke concentration is too uniform during diffusion, without the gradual decay caused by air mixing, and lacks the blurred sense of natural smoke diffusion.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02609", "filename": "6aa96c70e37a0f45362e6af3b18a3e1331d2b2c2464afad791997a8bf71ccc59_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (at 1 seconds into the video, without any change in camera angle, a large amount of white fog appears out of nowhere below the device).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02610", "filename": "6aa96c70e37a0f45362e6af3b18a3e1331d2b2c2464afad791997a8bf71ccc59_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 0.6s in the video, a metallic object suddenly appears below the device without any change in camera angle; at 0.8s, the metallic object suddenly deforms without being subjected to any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02611", "filename": "6ac210a83631531f23f5964fd4975416ef0f3d022a210a6b17418f7852cb61d4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02612", "filename": "6ac210a83631531f23f5964fd4975416ef0f3d022a210a6b17418f7852cb61d4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: The time sequence is continuous (at 0.1 seconds into the video, without any external interference, the white crystalline substance inside the bottle suddenly emits white light and continues to spread and fill the entire bottle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02613", "filename": "6ac210a83631531f23f5964fd4975416ef0f3d022a210a6b17418f7852cb61d4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the table, bottles, and black background in the entire video show flickering and jerking artifacts).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02614", "filename": "6ac210a83631531f23f5964fd4975416ef0f3d022a210a6b17418f7852cb61d4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (at 0.1 seconds in the video, without any change in camera angle, the black object in the bottle suddenly grows larger; throughout the video, the table, bottle, and black background exhibit flickering and jerking artifacts).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02615", "filename": "6ad5c1351a22741de513214848365587b619d7594c170956f391836372559eb4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Temporal continuity is abnormal (the trees in the video are swaying in the wind, but the flames and grass are not affected by the wind; the equipment in the video is placed horizontally, with the outlet on the left side of the equipment, but the flames are shooting out from above the equipment in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02616", "filename": "6ad5c1351a22741de513214848365587b619d7594c170956f391836372559eb4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 4s in the video, without any camera movement, the smoke does not appear from the muzzle, but instead comes out directly from the middle of the barrel).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02617", "filename": "6ad5c1351a22741de513214848365587b619d7594c170956f391836372559eb4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.2s in the video, flames suddenly appear below the device on the right, and after the device explodes at 6s, there are no traces of the explosion or any remains of the device on the table).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02618", "filename": "6ada68731ee220aefcaa910fb7e01b7dcb2fd91b1728b05119b650cbb7bb033e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the cause-and-effect relationship is unreasonable (the candle does not melt or deform during the burning process, and there is no change after burning).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02619", "filename": "6ada68731ee220aefcaa910fb7e01b7dcb2fd91b1728b05119b650cbb7bb033e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (starting at 1.4 seconds in the video, the candle automatically extinguishes from left to right without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02620", "filename": "6ada68731ee220aefcaa910fb7e01b7dcb2fd91b1728b05119b650cbb7bb033e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3s in the video, the candle in the middle suddenly produces a lot of smoke without any external interference, and at 4.2s, the two candles on the left also produce a lot of smoke).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02621", "filename": "6ae332915b83e72ac47e73f0380bbd16dc5236d810e8041f8293ef64148ff5e9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Causality (the paper did not change as it passed the burning flame below at the beginning of the video at 3.6s); Overall visual anomalies (smoke was generated directly from the flame as it burned).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02622", "filename": "6ae332915b83e72ac47e73f0380bbd16dc5236d810e8041f8293ef64148ff5e9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.1s in the video, the object on the right suddenly bursts into flames without being subjected to any external force, and at 1.8s, a large amount of smoke suddenly appears around the object).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02623", "filename": "6ae332915b83e72ac47e73f0380bbd16dc5236d810e8041f8293ef64148ff5e9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0s in the video, a large amount of smoke appears before the flames have even started burning).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02624", "filename": "6aeed3a576074f3354aaa98491e50f5f9cbd100e168a8c9e71594005b07f3d19_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the blurry halo in the background and the glowing effect of the flames lack natural transitions between light and dark, making the overall visual appearance more like a digitally composited video).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_02625", "filename": "6aeed3a576074f3354aaa98491e50f5f9cbd100e168a8c9e71594005b07f3d19_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Cause and effect (the gunpowder in the match head did not change after the match burned throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02626", "filename": "6aeed3a576074f3354aaa98491e50f5f9cbd100e168a8c9e71594005b07f3d19_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02627", "filename": "6b2ce64fd3c240a081caa549c5b4237beca7f70eb0616ecc3e29fcc0f49b5bea_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The continuity of time is abnormal (after the explosion at 2.9s, a white object suddenly appears in the middle of the screen without the camera changing, and then at 4.7s, a flash of light appears out of nowhere on the ground, causing another explosion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02628", "filename": "6b2ce64fd3c240a081caa549c5b4237beca7f70eb0616ecc3e29fcc0f49b5bea_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 0.1s of the video, without any change in camera angle, a mound suddenly appears in the middle of the video, and the layer of soil left by the explosion only appears after the explosion at 0.8s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02629", "filename": "6b2ce64fd3c240a081caa549c5b4237beca7f70eb0616ecc3e29fcc0f49b5bea_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1s, burning material appears out of thin air below the flames; at 1.6s, burning material suddenly appears at the bottom of the screen; at 4.5s, the white powder produced by the explosion suddenly disappears after contact with the ground).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02630", "filename": "6b2ce64fd3c240a081caa549c5b4237beca7f70eb0616ecc3e29fcc0f49b5bea_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (starting at 4.4 seconds, soil is slowly falling from the mushroom cloud produced by the explosion. The soil stays in the air for too long, which violates the law of gravity. At the time of the explosion, no crater was formed in the video, but a crater appeared out of nowhere after the mushroom cloud rose).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02631", "filename": "6bc2fb489a1568ad7630455af1540de7b3ca985c612dc1fdf607477abeab3a84_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 0.5s in the video, without any change in the camera angle, a large amount of pink dust appears out of nowhere below the black iron pillar).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02632", "filename": "6bc2fb489a1568ad7630455af1540de7b3ca985c612dc1fdf607477abeab3a84_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 1s in the video, without any change in the camera angle, a large amount of pink dust appears out of thin air above the pumpkin).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02633", "filename": "6bc2fb489a1568ad7630455af1540de7b3ca985c612dc1fdf607477abeab3a84_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.4 seconds in the video, a pink powder explosion suddenly appears on the pumpkin, then the pumpkin disappears, and at 3.6 seconds the pumpkin suddenly reappears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02634", "filename": "6bc09bc7eadb0667aa9b1441d31c205b7cca8f41d829d927d65a8e24aa9e3732_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior anomalies (when the flames are burning in the video, only the right side is lit, while the left side is not, which violates the principle that light travels in straight lines). Overall visual anomalies (there are three white flashes jumping on the left side throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02635", "filename": "6bc09bc7eadb0667aa9b1441d31c205b7cca8f41d829d927d65a8e24aa9e3732_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the flames in the entire scene have the same brightness and color, whereas real flames would change brightness and color depending on their temperature).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02636", "filename": "6bc09bc7eadb0667aa9b1441d31c205b7cca8f41d829d927d65a8e24aa9e3732_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02637", "filename": "d5d13db9d8eb59293163f3af0469690291aeec7c124fb32e5ca63e05fb44fe82_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the water surface in the upper left corner of the entire video is below a small waterfall. The water should be rushing and splashing, but the water surface remains calm. The water surface in the upper right corner of the video is also still).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02638", "filename": "d7ce7ce1f9f02c0eb907e3b93df13db86d0f659035df2d70c5bb915a387446df_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: Cause and effect (in the entire video, when water is poured into the cup, small round bubbles are generated in the cup and float around the water column to the surface and burst, but the bubbles in the video are oval and too large and exaggerated).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02639", "filename": "d9a26685cde8a77403d87a9f47e0a42cb43aa9e5679d638dec93d82761e8a4f3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.7s, a red car suddenly appears out of nowhere on the left track of the video; at 0.8s, a car outside the track crosses the edge of the track and enters the track; at 3.6s, the car outside the track suddenly deforms; at 6.2s, a car appears out of nowhere in the upper right corner of the video; at 6.7s, the car in the upper left corner of the video suddenly splits into two cars; at 6.8s, the car on the track suddenly splits into two cars).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02640", "filename": "d9f6ed8022c9c2f417a0133d8a1a8302b2bd13113837a4645c8b8aa8d2ce0b72_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect (the clouds are supposed to drift with the wind, and the wind only blows to one side, but the clouds in the entire video appear to move from the edges towards the center).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02641", "filename": "d14face55e11a39b8a3bebb807b5ec8a1fc2a1f27f6856e2877bef9890d9393f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (clouds in the sky should be constantly moving, but the clouds in the video remain calm).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02642", "filename": "d19b230dc4e4dda82d3a2ffc91d5767f44aedabee70d9c37d32ce940d17c653a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02643", "filename": "d21dc247f5e9674b72e6669c8f637a5d926c05561d798a4f9d6cdd9472bd54df_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 2.1s, the mechanical clamp has been released, but the green cube's trajectory deviates without any force, which does not conform to the law of inertia; at 4.8s, the mechanical clamp has been released, but the green cube found above moves to the left on its own to align with the green cube below; at 7.3s, the red cube in the upper right corner, which was moving to the left, suddenly moves to the right without any external force, which does not conform to the law of inertia).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02644", "filename": "d24a652b1961c893716129a1764daf85470ddc1543ce667b2b6cd1ebc9fd2776_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 3.6s to 7.9s, the water in the video is boiling, but the yellow food in the pot does not move significantly due to the rolling water; at 7.9s, the yellow food in the plate penetrates each other).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02645", "filename": "d46cddd836b917d0b68ba0009610bc262ed7bc375fa4cc257533c201fdfb1296_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (starting at 1.5s, a curved streak of fire appears continuously in the air, moving upwards, but there is no flammable material in the air; the small match remains burning, but the charred marks on the match do not change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02646", "filename": "d49a97b7dc2b8481e12c7fe3deab2aaf26615e325cf2e17980c5e327eba22b3c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to physical behavior (during the period from 6s to 7s, the ball was not held by the hand, but it flew off the ground without the hand moving, which does not conform to the laws of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02647", "filename": "d56aab3a5ea94f6a0fcb66f57f1c690b9b30857c2a5264ca6470a3ef26dfea8c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Causality (In the video, a hand is placed into the water in the cup, and the water surface should show obvious shaking, but the water surface in the video remains stable. Between 2.4s and 8s, a large amount of white smoke suddenly appears out of thin air on the hand, and the white smoke remains at the bottom of the cup without floating upwards.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02650", "filename": "d063e1d3c82fae68c8d79c8209393f6430e04b8504c88f7878f0d2dde3f707e2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (from start to finish, the hand does not rotate the object in its hand, but the object in the hand rotates in different directions, which does not conform to the laws of inertia).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02651", "filename": "d72a7f95d06096925b63bd548322ee0e170e68fb80234e493159b510f5dfc7cd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect (when the bubble is frozen, the crystals it produces spread outwards from the center in a snowflake-like pattern, but in the video, three sharp, spike-like crystals appear in the upper right corner of the bubble).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02652", "filename": "d96e879e077ecd1732d3936904b4e1f34b2c701b8853a3f6c59bcc325265c348_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Causality (The smoke produced after the explosion should exhibit turbulence under the influence of the impact force, but at 3.4 seconds in the video, the smoke from the explosion shows a slow diffusion without any turbulence).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02653", "filename": "d97a0e417f13015a525e804e40307a6b1135206ebbfa5b0243fe170a05886ede_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect (the flame of the flame gun is very hot and the candle is highly flammable. The candle should melt quickly under the flame gun, but the candle does not show any obvious change in the whole video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02654", "filename": "d511a9623f0eb36c5a4d068786ea93d0e5ba87602783c9482ca73348c84705ec_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02655", "filename": "d661d255b5726c4803988bc44cd65c813e94ba3b794fc5dd882b2b01ea8d08f2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02657", "filename": "d669f7c4f6bcf61aca6a72e9bd5e13257883e7537cda491b5e8cd3ec014c65a6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (multiple bubbles emitted by the bubble machine suddenly merge together without bursting between 0.7s and 8s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02659", "filename": "d987bc6ea7cd5b89f78193bf975a83d6298c2c27dc7e1b2f329d11d8b01a4373_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (The video shows a high-temperature lava environment that would severely affect plants in the surrounding environment, but the green plants in the video are not affected at all).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02660", "filename": "d989dec55511802aaa196096f3dc0b0a909cbeb3c800bd173060952802237d8e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (at 3.1s, the hydraulic press has not yet made contact with the blue car, but the blue car suddenly breaks).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02661", "filename": "d991b1c90bf3eb73e0c716b00ef98a6e333b34bd0bdd6638102883f4d3857907_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (two figures suddenly appear in the distance directly in front of the viewer at 1.2 seconds in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02663", "filename": "d1501a3792890010c813721f32432d6eab2df97caa9fbdd70acc7cdd8d42d82a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02664", "filename": "d1967f59dd3dc26f37a57502ddd51f5af50f3d3508872b49a48ab391b4242ac1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "at 7.4s, the burning flames suddenly become a regular grid pattern", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02665", "filename": "d4767fca373c19baf905bed6b04feb54fac75f23b2628344b269ea7f5d5614a4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (between 4.4s and 8s, the taut rope suddenly jumps on its own without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02666", "filename": "d8669ba6eac1692458c9a5f39cb87d08b1c814909735d2056b8997d45310d76f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02667", "filename": "521f08548e5960b00ba6c2dd8fe8380c0584195646cd3264d06ddc5167afb8f1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 3.3 seconds in the scene, after the character uses tongs to scoop up the food, the food in the oil floats to the surface, but before that, no food floats to the surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02668", "filename": "522aa0380cf1e809a55d6246231360176bd185f85c63834cc63fac6d13cc6480_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (a large flame is burning on the back of a large piece of firewood in the image, but there are no signs of burning on the front of the firewood, which is completely inconsistent with the actual burning behavior of firewood.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02669", "filename": "522aa0380cf1e809a55d6246231360176bd185f85c63834cc63fac6d13cc6480_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the firewood begins to roll without any external force at 4.4 seconds in the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02670", "filename": "522aa0380cf1e809a55d6246231360176bd185f85c63834cc63fac6d13cc6480_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (This piece of firewood, directly surrounded by flames, neither ignited nor produced ash).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02671", "filename": "522aa0380cf1e809a55d6246231360176bd185f85c63834cc63fac6d13cc6480_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the burning of a flame causes hot air to rise and cold air to flow downward, creating an air convection cycle. The curtain should sway slightly, but this is not observed in the footage.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02672", "filename": "525c8eb9515637d25a90f2841c5d9bde0fafde2346cc56df2e27bd77b78d3db3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 2.2 seconds in the video, the blue ball should have been suspended on the surface after falling into the water, but it suddenly started rolling towards the shore without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02673", "filename": "525c8eb9515637d25a90f2841c5d9bde0fafde2346cc56df2e27bd77b78d3db3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time duration (the white ball suddenly disappears after hitting the ground at 0.7s). Physical anomalies (the blue ball can be observed floating on the water at the end, but at 2.6s, the blue ball creates a large splash on the water).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02674", "filename": "525e4a5d091538d8109e8047840788ffd98b8df32e1b12aeec55830a1f0c1642_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (in the video, the hydraulic press pushes the sponge downwards, then rises between 2.9s and 5s, but the sponge does not spring back).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02675", "filename": "525e4a5d091538d8109e8047840788ffd98b8df32e1b12aeec55830a1f0c1642_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (sudden increase in the number of columns on the hydraulic press)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02676", "filename": "525e4a5d091538d8109e8047840788ffd98b8df32e1b12aeec55830a1f0c1642_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02677", "filename": "525e4a5d091538d8109e8047840788ffd98b8df32e1b12aeec55830a1f0c1642_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (at 1.7s in the video, the hydraulic press rotates with the sponge, and at 2.4s, the sponge's material changes, becoming whiter and brighter, but the rotation does not change the material's texture).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02678", "filename": "535f184fe99f61eadc545cebf529905bb324cc286c0e1e376091a35e76b576b3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the city in the scene is illuminated by sunlight, but the sea is very dark and gray, with no light).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02679", "filename": "535f184fe99f61eadc545cebf529905bb324cc286c0e1e376091a35e76b576b3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02680", "filename": "535f184fe99f61eadc545cebf529905bb324cc286c0e1e376091a35e76b576b3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02681", "filename": "541a24e1515a5d6c69c2648a4d7a11827af1aece583e70cb76ce1af2e644f329_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 0s, a large number of bubbles begin to emerge from the cup and rise to the rim, but the water level in the cup does not change, and the foam at the rim does not change either.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02682", "filename": "541a24e1515a5d6c69c2648a4d7a11827af1aece583e70cb76ce1af2e644f329_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the liquid in the cup rises as the bubbles inside rise.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02683", "filename": "541a24e1515a5d6c69c2648a4d7a11827af1aece583e70cb76ce1af2e644f329_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (bubbles rise in the video, but the liquid level does not drop, violating the law of conservation of mass).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02684", "filename": "542b4f470fe429b19c49df894429049610a34376a14dd8f47f469e213ebab2ad_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (at 0s in the scene, the character's index fingernail is blue, but at 1.9s, when the hand reappears, the index fingernail has turned purple).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02685", "filename": "542b4f470fe429b19c49df894429049610a34376a14dd8f47f469e213ebab2ad_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the spoon and cup clipped through each other at 2.1s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02686", "filename": "542b4f470fe429b19c49df894429049610a34376a14dd8f47f469e213ebab2ad_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02687", "filename": "542b4f470fe429b19c49df894429049610a34376a14dd8f47f469e213ebab2ad_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the figure in the scene is stirring the water with a spoon, the amplitude is not large enough to produce bubbles, but very obvious bubbles are produced at 2.8s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02688", "filename": "544a5cbb8f6b5e2ac23923b601fd4021750ff2c2ae5d2e1431eb0f06213c8fe6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: The video is abnormal (at 4.9 seconds, the grenade being pressed by the hydraulic press did not explode or break, but fragments appeared).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02689", "filename": "544a5cbb8f6b5e2ac23923b601fd4021750ff2c2ae5d2e1431eb0f06213c8fe6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the grenade penetrated the hydraulic press at 2.6 seconds in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02690", "filename": "544a5cbb8f6b5e2ac23923b601fd4021750ff2c2ae5d2e1431eb0f06213c8fe6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02691", "filename": "556a580475c4f05eceb211195634208a005980991e4fc24d5d6ebd2ff4b7d83e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (between 3.8s and 4.1s in the video, the water jet from the pipe suddenly flows upwards from a low position).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02692", "filename": "556a580475c4f05eceb211195634208a005980991e4fc24d5d6ebd2ff4b7d83e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the water spraying from the pipe at 0.3s is sewage, but when the pipe is lifted at 2.7s, it sprays clean water).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02693", "filename": "556a580475c4f05eceb211195634208a005980991e4fc24d5d6ebd2ff4b7d83e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall behavior (1.6 seconds after the start of the video, water sprays from the pipe onto the clean part of the metal plate, but the upper part of the sprayed water is sewage).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02694", "filename": "556a580475c4f05eceb211195634208a005980991e4fc24d5d6ebd2ff4b7d83e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (in the video, water is flowing out of the pipe, but the stains on the iron plate seem to multiply as the water flows).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02695", "filename": "556ba46ae7e36c555b491cd05488d5a03a62c7861e62881ac9ace78e0ae65a36_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02696", "filename": "556ba46ae7e36c555b491cd05488d5a03a62c7861e62881ac9ace78e0ae65a36_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (smoke is billowing out from the small hill in the center of the video, and the smoke flies to the right of the video, but the smoke on the mountain behind the video does not move at all)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02697", "filename": "af5da802ddf36e69c59dd160d922d355f0d93715be8efc8f6461996a766d8a8e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Cause and effect (clouds in the sky move and float in one direction due to airflow, but in the entire video, the clouds in the sky do not move but float in place and the direction of the cloud floats is chaotic)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02698", "filename": "af5da802ddf36e69c59dd160d922d355f0d93715be8efc8f6461996a766d8a8e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (clouds in the sky, mist on the mountain, and the white and black object in the lower left corner are affected by airflow and drift in one direction, but in the entire video, the clouds in the sky, the mist rising from the mountain, and the white and black object in the lower left corner drift in opposite directions).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02699", "filename": "af5da802ddf36e69c59dd160d922d355f0d93715be8efc8f6461996a766d8a8e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the clouds at the top of the video have a noticeable flatness and repetitive texture; the texture is monotonous and lacks the rich layers of real clouds, as well as the random details and volume of real clouds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02700", "filename": "af5da802ddf36e69c59dd160d922d355f0d93715be8efc8f6461996a766d8a8e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02701", "filename": "af548aeb7ab0b0d214a7f5e02255ae4b48acdc31e0e333c895a36280b149bc2b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.4s, the silver spoon had already left the brown powder, but the amount of brown powder in the image suddenly decreased).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02702", "filename": "af548aeb7ab0b0d214a7f5e02255ae4b48acdc31e0e333c895a36280b149bc2b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02703", "filename": "af861e35c1c898c2d2793405ffe9df4910c5f033199089ebbba34be691ce5b9f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the shoelaces on the person's shoes should swing with the person's continuous jumping in the entire video, but the shoelaces on the person in the picture do not swing obviously, making the correspondence between the person's continuous jumping and the actual jumping too awkward).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02704", "filename": "af861e35c1c898c2d2793405ffe9df4910c5f033199089ebbba34be691ce5b9f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the person in the entire video is suspended in the air and jumping, and their feet do not touch the ground, which is contrary to the laws of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02705", "filename": "af861e35c1c898c2d2793405ffe9df4910c5f033199089ebbba34be691ce5b9f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02706", "filename": "af928dbc80e837e69e611188ea68eb7661197e4a53ebe8544e5d41558f889b31_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Cause and effect (In the entire video, the smoke produced by the burning flames should be generated from the burning material, but the smoke and fire appear to be layered in the footage, showing the smoke coming out of the iron frame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02707", "filename": "af928dbc80e837e69e611188ea68eb7661197e4a53ebe8544e5d41558f889b31_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02708", "filename": "af928dbc80e837e69e611188ea68eb7661197e4a53ebe8544e5d41558f889b31_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02709", "filename": "af1513ada60b31f98f0bda3055452e46792dc69201794f41c4f531f0870ec95d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 0s, the silver object on the left side of the video suddenly disappears into thin air; at 0.3s, the yellow object suddenly breaks without any external force; at 3.1s, the shattered yellow object in the video suddenly returns to its original state).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02710", "filename": "af1513ada60b31f98f0bda3055452e46792dc69201794f41c4f531f0870ec95d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 1.7s, the egg suddenly breaks without any force, and at 4.5s, after the egg breaks, a perfectly intact egg appears out of nowhere inside).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02711", "filename": "af1513ada60b31f98f0bda3055452e46792dc69201794f41c4f531f0870ec95d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02712", "filename": "af1513ada60b31f98f0bda3055452e46792dc69201794f41c4f531f0870ec95d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.1s, the silver object on the left side of the video suddenly transforms into a small bee).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02713", "filename": "afd128288486ec198fb565117bf590188d050dbfa3a5d9b9ee83384b46f9c39e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows a continuity error (at 1 second, when the hand touches the golden cylinder, the golden cylinder suddenly disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02714", "filename": "afd128288486ec198fb565117bf590188d050dbfa3a5d9b9ee83384b46f9c39e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time is continuous (at 1.7s, the golden cylinder below suddenly disappears into thin air, and at 0.6s, the rolling golden cylinder suddenly stops moving due to external force, which does not conform to the law of inertia).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02715", "filename": "afd128288486ec198fb565117bf590188d050dbfa3a5d9b9ee83384b46f9c39e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.1s, the moving golden cylinder in the video suddenly disappears out of thin air; from 0s to 1.1s, the yellow cylinder rolls back and forth without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02716", "filename": "afd128288486ec198fb565117bf590188d050dbfa3a5d9b9ee83384b46f9c39e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02727", "filename": "6ada68731ee220aefcaa910fb7e01b7dcb2fd91b1728b05119b650cbb7bb033e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is as follows: the candle is tilted to the left without any wind, and the flame doesn't flicker, making it look too rigid and unrealistic.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02728", "filename": "6ae332915b83e72ac47e73f0380bbd16dc5236d810e8041f8293ef64148ff5e9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02729", "filename": "6aeed3a576074f3354aaa98491e50f5f9cbd100e168a8c9e71594005b07f3d19_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the match is lit but there is no change, violating the law of conservation of energy.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02730", "filename": "6b2ce64fd3c240a081caa549c5b4237beca7f70eb0616ecc3e29fcc0f49b5bea_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Abnormal physical behavior. The surrounding environment did not change during the ground explosion, which does not conform to the law of conservation of energy.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02731", "filename": "6bc09bc7eadb0667aa9b1441d31c205b7cca8f41d829d927d65a8e24aa9e3732_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02732", "filename": "6bdad997537b8235dfc42906f2b0a125ee3bcf00338bd897f7cb8014321c8c93_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02733", "filename": "6c4d5d3267b8909c917cf6500ec66ff1a82ba63183b797b185cbaecc971f367b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: at 3 seconds, the hydraulic press crushes the dry wood, causing it to burst with juice.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02734", "filename": "6cacb4d9e32014d81a4b4c21d2f522113c00c48cc799d66a3f2b0dba7f8c1090_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly: The high-pressure water gun impacts the water, creating bubbles. These bubbles do not move rapidly and appear to solidify.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02735", "filename": "6cc229035eb25cce8cda46f1766f828e3591774633644eabe1e780eba1d4f049_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02736", "filename": "6cd47390a363feeb74cb45dd9191a553d02c659d3c3653dfe3813d78bbc26441_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: The physical behavior is abnormal. The sun in the image is concave near the water surface, and the heat wave is moving, which does not conform to the laws of air movement.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02737", "filename": "6ce193d6556fbedc07109264ec37b99306db449370bca748e7befd5d9e488159_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02739", "filename": "6d79a177b6b0fa2901efc627d3295dde159e195c50d96c24cb08710c32a77a3e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the characters picking up and putting down objects lack a natural, jarring feel and appear unrealistic; also, the number of particles in the bowl suddenly decreases at 2.3 seconds, which is inconsistent with the preceding visuals.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02740", "filename": "6d6347bd719afe0125ed87bc5c103a3e541aad8cf2ce9f301797c4eee9672cc6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the visuals: Inconsistency in motion (the object is not being moved by the finger without any force applied, but rather it is spinning on its own in the hand, which does not conform to the law of conservation of energy).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02741", "filename": "6da06a0e65219a5ef08a7d3f82c685547fb61c50f98697ad0b0be963831b5f32_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous (the floor next to the tractor dents at 4.3s, which is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02742", "filename": "6dc7594ccecf0dbfca21a285b036be90c0224c95b76666f3599afe84cb471dce_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Inconsistent movements (Two people are talking in the video, but their mouths are not moving, inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02743", "filename": "6dd3e2864bc00e9772cf6357c9155cf1f6619dd7fbd3f66b3e1cec298364727a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly involves abrupt and continuous changes in timing: the bubbles in the glass bottle appear to grow larger and larger as they fall, inconsistently.", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02744", "filename": "6e33d4370c2bbd3998412439e256e3bfd68da060fb6abe7170796ab2ac113497_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is inconsistent (the match remains unchanged during combustion, whereas in reality, a match burns out slowly, violating the law of conservation of energy).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02745", "filename": "6e1919496e6b540b62e62f18b7a6ddaa80e90d709b9ab308e607e7176e868a47_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The overall visuals are off: the burning wood is too stiff, the flames are all the same color and lack vibrancy, making the whole scene look unrealistic.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02746", "filename": "6ef8dae2ea3f0e8a59976880012059366620a64f26f0fbfbc048ee0e48e42835_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02747", "filename": "6f1fa2103113d9ee7e573a80366eea26effaaf5d8669ef020c9b98e25d660f11_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02748", "filename": "6f27ec24220afb2c322ae75194a6ae4bb83f5a71fa1cda117fcb09b177c3af7b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02749", "filename": "6f99e46e737009e58ef01c51108ba97e27625509e2d7ba247e86f6851ae342f1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals and physical behavior are inconsistent: the seawater in front of the figure is constantly rippling, but the water behind the figure is not rippling.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02750", "filename": "6ffb5c9502ccf266f5c27d13f67af530deb56ac579bf23a061a01e6bfe33960c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality with sudden and continuous changes: The video footage is disjointed, with a noticeable pause at 5 seconds.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02751", "filename": "07bb1e3cf7cc7d33244bf2c11fb14bfe268e4601edb6152cf5ac5ba4ae7af8e9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02752", "filename": "07c4dd59618c2edbe1f6874bf650e2af7b235e511cf228bcfa4805b8d14a312c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals and physical behavior are abnormal (during the period from 0.4s to 3.8s, the upper part of the wooden block did not deform under the pressure of the hydraulic press, while the lower part of the wooden block deformed, violating the law of conservation of energy).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02753", "filename": "07e3699e35112ed08a050d965d300f579333daabf909064185f441e7bc6b299c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals and physical behavior are abnormal: the coffee overflowed the cup at 7 seconds but did not fall, violating the law of gravity.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02754", "filename": "7a0d78a197b60f00322df87268929cba70676d8b62c8217f4a6ca351f489bfb2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video quality is inconsistent: there is a noticeable stutter at 6 seconds, which looks unrealistic.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02755", "filename": "7aaa101fb712e2f6f4754c75be5d1ea9ff7ca7a34d7ebb5abf65b32f4649dab8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The overall visuals are off: the burning wood is too stiff, the flames are all the same color and lack vibrancy, making the whole scene look unrealistic.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02756", "filename": "7ab8b72463b207d2de5ebb42412f1c9ab2cef70a5cbd31ad299ef40759311447_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: At 2.7s, the ice cube moved on its own on the table without being subjected to any force, violating the law of conservation of energy.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02758", "filename": "9d889f6b73df1cdedca2c11484db42c98a8875a625c061b19542a1e4da9ef33e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is due to physical behavior (a newly falling water droplet at 4.5s collides with a water droplet that was still on the petal at 3.2s. The colliding water droplet does not shift or change shape, and is unaffected by external forces, violating the law of conservation of momentum and the collision laws of fluid mechanics).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02759", "filename": "9dc770e0dfd55c3d20580c4aa1648ff47b510efdc2f56c3c3f21e88799371902_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02760", "filename": "9ddd0e35f04ca2a80ee84bbf1c7e9b0fe44a75c40918638b029a7774799e82f4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: The physical behavior is abnormal. (At 2s, the basin shifted, but the liquid and flowers did not move with the basin. There was no ripple or displacement of the liquid surface, which violates the law of inertia and the laws of fluid motion.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02761", "filename": "9f8f6bb0a73b559ab312e6988ebcac4ae2116bca9c025222be22db1edd531923_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (the candle burns continuously throughout the video, but the wax does not melt or produce any wax residue, which violates the thermophysical law that wax liquefies when heated during candle burning).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02762", "filename": "9f3474ac9f58a72aa0e871e39761c1dcda72e401354f3cdf78d3e8ab3f068a52_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Abnormal physical behavior (at 4.7s, a particulate object with a falling trajectory passed through the coffee liquid surface without producing a drainage reaction, and the liquid surface had no depression or ripples, which violates the mechanical law of object intrusion into fluid in fluid mechanics).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02763", "filename": "10cf4ffb6c92b005763d9b306a916914b60f16433b7bc323e51177891ab5cfde_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (at 1.5s, the cloud flow pattern undergoes an unnatural and abrupt change, violating the continuity equation in fluid mechanics, which is contrary to the principle of continuity and gradual change in atmospheric fluid motion).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02765", "filename": "15ccb4fca0a90a728f61b932559364ff9f0d065ece0ae67110c53b08a76a883a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the microwave pattern generated by the ship's movement is too regular, lacking a natural diffusion and attenuation process, which does not conform to the dynamic ripple pattern formed by real fluid under the influence of velocity and resistance, and is more like an unnatural water surface effect synthesized by static special effects).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02766", "filename": "017c7437ba088a591169513746f6ad3fdb41d4a1912b8887cb9000e325af75a7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Abnormal physical behavior (at 2.6s, the sea of clouds exhibits unnatural flow with layered breaks; the movement speeds of the upper and lower clouds are completely disconnected, violating the continuous law of atmospheric fluid movement).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02767", "filename": "17ec12da5069e06c9e63d22bc4346e2ea821301f5e96b322c44d478495f94784_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (at 2.6 seconds, the hand directly passes through the glass wall and touches the liquid, violating the impermeability of solids and the spatial occupancy rules of objects).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02769", "filename": "21ea1f1f75a5540c0faf461c1d339d7c985310d1ef0297660b2151484e083de9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior is abnormal. At 1.9s, the bright white cloud in the center of the image disappears unnaturally, and the light and shadow of the sea of clouds show unnatural discontinuities, violating the continuity of atmospheric flow.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02771", "filename": "23c6fdb9b9519f61c071f99f8d687323c730d48480ac60e77319daf01d15fa79_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02774", "filename": "33f75948ff199bafbe29849470f3e01feaf78320a4c30bec24572c6f6122f295_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Abnormal physical behavior (Throughout the video, the empty glass on the left continuously flows into the glass on the right, with a stiff, straight flow of water, which violates both the law of conservation of mass and the natural motion of fluids under the influence of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02775", "filename": "34e222a79effcefaa31e17ea2ed1e22d132205ccbf07ccf40a16fe88728406c2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is inconsistent (at 3 seconds, the end of the lever is above the left of the right knob, but at 3.6 seconds it jumps to the top of the knob, the position change is abrupt and there is no rotation process).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02777", "filename": "42dbb623f038be639a5a1212d4a8dde5d0165ef5c08810e46078c3153388b76b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (At 2.6s, at the interface between the upper horizontal and lower glass containers, two transparent components that should be independent completely overlap at their edges, causing the overlapping area to fail to produce a refraction or occlusion effect that conforms to optical principles, violating the spatial occupancy and optical reflection laws of objects).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02778", "filename": "47cace0577315eaf805c173da1a60d130085b0f29b7e8fed11c7d5037bc0ea74_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: The physical behavior is abnormal (throughout the video, the filter tube inside the container does not refract or shift at the point where it meets the water surface, and the visual transition between the tube wall in the air and water is abrupt, violating the law of refraction of light and the principle of optical continuity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02779", "filename": "49cfd9ddea9bc3a1b8473b17de5a867859ae429c930ae2e9dbcfd62b5943f331_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: The axe and wood do not exhibit any lifting or relative motion throughout the video. However, the contact area continuously produces a cyclical effect of wood chips flying and returning to their original positions. This process has no source of force and does not conform to the logic of motion after an object is subjected to force, violating the physical laws of mechanical motion and force application.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02780", "filename": "49fa2edbbdae5452876857e737b621058a528461217a4eaaa9c203bf526a1abd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 3.5s, the wispy clouds in the sky suddenly disappeared without any gradual dissipation process).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02781", "filename": "50abe57c681988d4964df1279cb663c17a2e75cdce3754ebe4b87d925db27bc0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (Throughout the video, the smoke emitted from multiple chimneys does not exhibit any airflow disturbance or merging effect between fluids. Each smoke column moves independently, and there is no natural blurring or diffusion at the edges, violating the fluid dynamics laws of gas diffusion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02782", "filename": "54c0787645ac1b00e60de9a49a94ef9c3a65729766e5f6bbaf37954fa9406b8a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Abnormal physical behavior (at 5.1s, the metal sheet with the circular hole overlaps with the metal rod below, and the metal rod passes directly through the metal sheet without obstruction or perspective change, which violates the principle of the impermeability of solids and the principle of optical obstruction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02783", "filename": "056b84357411f94d92532133a3b07d8a885e46d85ec455d2ec3c9b7daedb41cc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (at 3.7s, the flame shape and brightness undergo an instantaneous jump, exhibiting an explosive enhancement without gradual energy change, but the charcoal below does not simultaneously show an expansion of the red-hot area of intensified combustion or a spark-splashing effect, violating the synchronous law of energy transfer and material change in the combustion reaction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02784", "filename": "57d7fd5406b87e3c9ac775afbc035f9171f0a376815d2ebebbd689981664298c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (at 1.7 seconds, the orange pipe overlaps with the white circular handle. The pipe is not obscured by the handle but instead directly covers it. The spatial positions of the two objects overlap, violating the principle of the impermeability of solids).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02785", "filename": "58f2522c892b5f6aef44e1d9fcd482943ca4bae2d9e251309919f3caadf3a3b0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (when the water floats in the video, the edges are hard and rigid, completely lacking the transparency and softness of real water, more like a piece of transparent plastic moving. Moreover, when the bubbles in the water burst, the surrounding water does not react at all, not even a small ripple is splashed, which does not conform to the logic of water flow that we see in our daily lives)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02786", "filename": "59fd4d72916676819755f099e0b712e9e8d904efe100591762ea89edb10cc0af_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (Throughout the video, the steam above the cup does not exhibit the natural rising and diffusion effect of thermal convection; it remains a clear strip with no change in volume density. This violates the flow characteristics of hot gases and the laws of gas diffusion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02787", "filename": "52ee4af6be931b47b4058c33d641f07f9762e6e44507f6f6a356e212cf34437f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02788", "filename": "53c2eb51ccefdfef1ccd54e5c307d52978298cbd1f57c85555f46911bb0d98a6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (At 0.6s, a white pancake appears out of thin air on the table when both hands leave; at 1.1s, the pancake in one hand merges instantly with another when placed on top of it; at 2.1s, the pancake suddenly turns into a flatbread when picked up; at 2.4s, the flatbread in one hand suddenly develops texture when placed on the table; at 3.5s, a flatbread appears out of thin air in one's hand).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02789", "filename": "53cf13c7f08421ea7f9ebdaf1cc5f07f888b37f23c579169d857cfb56adc321d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0s, the bullet on the left disappears out of thin air instead of hitting the object in the scene; at 1.1s, when the object explodes, two iron rods appear inside, and then disappear during the second explosion; at 2.8s, the pupil in the eyeball suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02790", "filename": "53d8d78b76b71e1006c8e386f39250a4c45264e15f870d0c5a5a44bc08bc8a65_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.9s, letters suddenly appear on the side of the light; at 1.3s, even though all four sides of the light opening are straight, the illuminated edge of the light appears to be uneven).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02791", "filename": "54a34c343b6491ceb6f1984d97f536f4175833a8e193d230643306b0a868277d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02792", "filename": "54a34c343b6491ceb6f1984d97f536f4175833a8e193d230643306b0a868277d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous timing (the image flickers or wriggles throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02793", "filename": "54a34c343b6491ceb6f1984d97f536f4175833a8e193d230643306b0a868277d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Cause and effect relationship (the bowl is on a bamboo frame with no heating source underneath, and the water in the bowl boils within 1.4s-8s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02794", "filename": "54c0787645ac1b00e60de9a49a94ef9c3a65729766e5f6bbaf37954fa9406b8a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02795", "filename": "54c0787645ac1b00e60de9a49a94ef9c3a65729766e5f6bbaf37954fa9406b8a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 1s, a small iron piece grows out of the end of the steel pipe as it approaches the machine on the left).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02796", "filename": "56a0f2963f70c949e3ced1a1755e8ad65f7b5a4c2e4bb4f30a8b303c6b738571_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The time sequence is continuous (the front wheel hub suddenly deforms at 0.4s, and at 0.9s the car explodes with a sharp object on the ground, but the object shows no signs of explosion damage).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02797", "filename": "56a0f2963f70c949e3ced1a1755e8ad65f7b5a4c2e4bb4f30a8b303c6b738571_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is unusual: the time sequence is continuous (the car was already compressed and deformed before the explosion, but after the explosion from 3.5s to 8s, the car body was restored to its original shape).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02798", "filename": "56dde3db70d6f10c8899efde3bb231da9f9328afecc9d5b01c7d35eaa04d1ab8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02800", "filename": "56ead60d8bdffdaaf350e3ac3fa8c5982aedc4f03131cc61743a9dfaad4577e6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (only the camera is moving throughout the entire sequence; the light source remains stationary, yet the refracted light appears to be moving).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02801", "filename": "57bfde2b4b7bb85c6aaf261a25a58406e7a1d751a9f26873ae67512d932d47c0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.6s, the red berry on the right suddenly bursts into water droplets in mid-air, and then the water droplets that were originally on its left side also disappear into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02802", "filename": "57bfde2b4b7bb85c6aaf261a25a58406e7a1d751a9f26873ae67512d932d47c0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.5s, when the two red fruits collide, water sprays out of thin air between them, and at 6.1s, another red fruit appears out of thin air on the water surface).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02803", "filename": "58f2522c892b5f6aef44e1d9fcd482943ca4bae2d9e251309919f3caadf3a3b0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the large bubble at 3.5s in the video exhibits an irregular twisted and concave shape, while real underwater bubbles, under the influence of surface tension, tend to be perfectly spherical and would not show this internal collapse, which does not conform to the principle of pressure).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02804", "filename": "58f2522c892b5f6aef44e1d9fcd482943ca4bae2d9e251309919f3caadf3a3b0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Cause and effect (water splashes appear out of nowhere at 3.2s without any external force)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02805", "filename": "59e94a5a37f6342492e9e04033d6178fa46f84e2dadb24dd4d0f15d4cae6d901_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (from 2.2s to 8s, the right side of the object remains bright even without a light source).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02806", "filename": "59e394f1f4b56d502a830119e7fec54d29f6fd393970ae5dce07a9025171c042_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.2s, a stream of water flows from the middle of a bucket filled with water to the bottom; in reality, water would not flow directly to the bottom but rather appear on the surface). Causality (at 0.5s, a vortex appears in the bucket before the rod inside it has even turned).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02807", "filename": "8f534da5e533d39b366ffdae260d52aada118a7852e29ef6ed76d8e0fbde1c86_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (In a dark environment, when the color of the luminous object switches between white and pink, the surrounding sofa and walls do not exhibit any light projection effect or brightness change)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02808", "filename": "8f534da5e533d39b366ffdae260d52aada118a7852e29ef6ed76d8e0fbde1c86_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: continuous flickering/jumping next to the luminous object (4s-5.8s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02809", "filename": "8f534da5e533d39b366ffdae260d52aada118a7852e29ef6ed76d8e0fbde1c86_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the background in the video keeps flickering and jumping).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02810", "filename": "09b0d26d0067b1e8809cf56f3f68d55165dbbb6af0b32e254e2d2432b728e970_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (when water boils, it vaporizes violently, producing a large amount of water vapor, but there is no water vapor in the image).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02811", "filename": "09b0d26d0067b1e8809cf56f3f68d55165dbbb6af0b32e254e2d2432b728e970_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to physical behavior (the water surface tumbles evenly and symmetrically when boiling, lacking the irregular disturbances caused by local temperature differences during natural boiling).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02812", "filename": "09b0d26d0067b1e8809cf56f3f68d55165dbbb6af0b32e254e2d2432b728e970_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (when the water boils, the bubbles are all the same size and rise vertically upwards only from the center of the bottom of the pot).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02813", "filename": "09b0d26d0067b1e8809cf56f3f68d55165dbbb6af0b32e254e2d2432b728e970_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02817", "filename": "09e02961b529cd7105a68d3ebfc1b459e19a40ba5d4b07a2332877f740299ce0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02818", "filename": "09e02961b529cd7105a68d3ebfc1b459e19a40ba5d4b07a2332877f740299ce0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (1.9s-5.8s When the hydraulic press just came into contact with the iron block, the iron block cracked on its own without being subjected to obvious pressure. After breaking, it also exhibited a foamy texture that violated the physical properties of metal and its own volume also increased.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02819", "filename": "09e02961b529cd7105a68d3ebfc1b459e19a40ba5d4b07a2332877f740299ce0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (1.1s-5s) When the hydraulic press applies pressure to the metal block, the metal block does not exhibit the compressive or ductile deformation that is consistent with the characteristics of metal. Instead, it breaks directly like a brittle material, and the shape of the break does not match the stress distribution pattern after being subjected to force.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02820", "filename": "9a91659ee65dcbdada32611126a5a0f1af8b30294fdadca55d836212f29a7a80_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the burning hay at the bottom shows no signs of being consumed; it neither turns black, carbonizes, nor forms ash, and it remains in its original burning state).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02821", "filename": "9a91659ee65dcbdada32611126a5a0f1af8b30294fdadca55d836212f29a7a80_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (1.2s-5s, only a small flame appears in the haystack, and the person's hand does not move the haystack, but the fire suddenly bursts out).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02827", "filename": "9ab3412f9c876405b671b7e7ec2edb6dd372bd0e0809a283fd7b1ea43fa8d800_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02828", "filename": "9ab3412f9c876405b671b7e7ec2edb6dd372bd0e0809a283fd7b1ea43fa8d800_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the video exhibits noticeable stuttering and choppy transitions).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02829", "filename": "9ab3412f9c876405b671b7e7ec2edb6dd372bd0e0809a283fd7b1ea43fa8d800_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02830", "filename": "9ad1ef172c9ce7921f330c4fee915f8dcba787232fce9f741518b8caee2c108b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (water in a plastic container sways spontaneously without any external force) Continuous time (the ambient light changes from 0.3s to 5s are illogical, and the scene suddenly switches between bright and dark repeatedly without any transition process of moving or obstructing the light source).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02831", "filename": "9ad1ef172c9ce7921f330c4fee915f8dcba787232fce9f741518b8caee2c108b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the changes in ambient light are illogical, the scene suddenly switches between bright and dark repeatedly without any transition process of moving or blocking the light source; the plastic container becomes semi-invisible from 4.1s to 5.8s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02832", "filename": "9ad1ef172c9ce7921f330c4fee915f8dcba787232fce9f741518b8caee2c108b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (The water in the box will suddenly and noticeably shake and ripple without any external interference; the brightness of the entire screen will suddenly darken and then immediately recover without any transition process of changing light source).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02835", "filename": "9b000bf46954de6585ee7eba224a71a96120d56384a41868bf7d4c94062cc351_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02836", "filename": "9b000bf46954de6585ee7eba224a71a96120d56384a41868bf7d4c94062cc351_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical phenomena (1.4s: colored straw directly penetrates the glass bottle; 1.6s-3.1s: water is injected into the glass bottle out of thin air without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02837", "filename": "b472b4589b1fc6ff384ce608715bdc54f2437663acb0fed48cbb770e21cdb461_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 2.3s, without any camera movement, the black dot above the bubble on the left side of the screen disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02838", "filename": "b597b9e7fa8847351eee9fa63ddb7d3b5d7c129bcca9379b2cc1268d3ae4f980_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (Under the condition of no force or external interference, the object in the middle of the screen jumps on its own at 1.1s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02839", "filename": "b597b9e7fa8847351eee9fa63ddb7d3b5d7c129bcca9379b2cc1268d3ae4f980_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (Under the premise of no external force or interference, at 1.3s, a part of the object in the middle of the screen appears out of thin air in the upper left corner).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02840", "filename": "b597b9e7fa8847351eee9fa63ddb7d3b5d7c129bcca9379b2cc1268d3ae4f980_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: Time continuity (the last digit of the phone screen is abnormally distorted throughout the entire frame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02842", "filename": "b744df7162e8d408269f070a32e6495a2f110cb12ded5118289d5426f0e2dd8e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (with the light source and illumination intensity remaining constant, the green light reflected from the lens suddenly intensifies at 1.7 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02843", "filename": "b744df7162e8d408269f070a32e6495a2f110cb12ded5118289d5426f0e2dd8e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera or the light source, a green light suddenly appears on the right side of the screen at 0.2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02844", "filename": "b744df7162e8d408269f070a32e6495a2f110cb12ded5118289d5426f0e2dd8e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle or lighting conditions, at 3.9s, a beam of green light appears out of nowhere behind the second green light in the lower left corner of the screen).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02845", "filename": "b744df7162e8d408269f070a32e6495a2f110cb12ded5118289d5426f0e2dd8e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02846", "filename": "b897bed9cea88fe740b2b82b9f45410d287946d00f1e6070b9671e9e8a31ee8c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, a white object appears out of thin air in the upper right corner of the teapot at 2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02847", "filename": "b897bed9cea88fe740b2b82b9f45410d287946d00f1e6070b9671e9e8a31ee8c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (between 3.3s and 5.8s, the teapot is already full of water, but a large amount of water is still being poured into the teapot, and the water in the teapot does not overflow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02848", "filename": "b897bed9cea88fe740b2b82b9f45410d287946d00f1e6070b9671e9e8a31ee8c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02849", "filename": "b897bed9cea88fe740b2b82b9f45410d287946d00f1e6070b9671e9e8a31ee8c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 0.6s, white smoke appears out of nowhere in the upper left corner of the small teapot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02850", "filename": "b994d9f4328ed1f99431d9282c2cceb79e58d41c8b69508a94d81fb6986c0949_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 3.4 seconds, the sun suddenly moves upwards on its own).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02851", "filename": "b994d9f4328ed1f99431d9282c2cceb79e58d41c8b69508a94d81fb6986c0949_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the clouds in the video look like a static, smooth sticker, moving across the sky at a uniform speed, without any fine textures created by the wind or any natural changes in shape).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02852", "filename": "b2102dc5ed0a7bdebcfdd74572f3b212a2c0d97f914250336bc1c75253b2d914_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the clouds in the image move rapidly across the entire screen, but their outlines and lighting remain unchanged throughout, like a static texture gliding across the blue sky, lacking the dynamism of real clouds.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02853", "filename": "b2102dc5ed0a7bdebcfdd74572f3b212a2c0d97f914250336bc1c75253b2d914_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.8s, real clouds suddenly and abruptly transform into cartoon-style hand-drawn clouds without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02854", "filename": "b2871d7038cb23bfee66ffbb086dac3c8076458ed7894cc4b66e44cdb91992d6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the small text on the white object in the lower left corner of the screen twists abnormally throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02855", "filename": "b2871d7038cb23bfee66ffbb086dac3c8076458ed7894cc4b66e44cdb91992d6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, 5 copper wires suddenly appear in the character's hand at 2.9 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02856", "filename": "b2871d7038cb23bfee66ffbb086dac3c8076458ed7894cc4b66e44cdb91992d6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (Under the condition of no force or external interference, at 2.6s, the turntable in the character's hand suddenly starts to rotate backward on its own).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02857", "filename": "b2871d7038cb23bfee66ffbb086dac3c8076458ed7894cc4b66e44cdb91992d6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 0.6s, the wooden turntable in the center of the frame suddenly transforms into a copper wire turntable wrapped with copper wire).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02858", "filename": "b3341fae0bfeb4b12964effd17d3ed86c82574d316b0d6408c155a3abdc153c8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02859", "filename": "b3341fae0bfeb4b12964effd17d3ed86c82574d316b0d6408c155a3abdc153c8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the flames at the bottom of the image appear stiffly layered, the smoke lacks a natural diffusion, and the overall image resembles a static, pieced-together pattern.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02860", "filename": "b3341fae0bfeb4b12964effd17d3ed86c82574d316b0d6408c155a3abdc153c8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Continuous time (without adding fuel or a sudden increase in oxygen, the flame of a burning object suddenly brightens without a gradual transition; the brightness jump is unnatural.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02861", "filename": "b3341fae0bfeb4b12964effd17d3ed86c82574d316b0d6408c155a3abdc153c8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02862", "filename": "b5091a3807e2a9d5a081b4a24df029aa0fe08479b1ee4308eaf01ce5238433ee_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly: Time continuity (Under the premise of no camera change and no external interference, the ice cream melts at 4.5 seconds but instantly returns to its original state.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02863", "filename": "b5091a3807e2a9d5a081b4a24df029aa0fe08479b1ee4308eaf01ce5238433ee_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 3.4 seconds, the rough, icy surface of an ice cream scoop suddenly transforms into a smooth liquid and flows immediately without any gradual transition.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02864", "filename": "b5091a3807e2a9d5a081b4a24df029aa0fe08479b1ee4308eaf01ce5238433ee_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: Time continuity (Under the condition of no external force or interference, the circular object in the center of the screen moves upward on its own at 0.6s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02865", "filename": "b5091a3807e2a9d5a081b4a24df029aa0fe08479b1ee4308eaf01ce5238433ee_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (Under the premise of no camera movement and no external force or object interference, a crack appears out of nowhere on the circular object in the middle of the frame at 0.6s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02866", "filename": "b7674e7a99d422100cc19b900ec2d24a9c92e4d78c06db0bf84772787661e1ec_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without camera movement or external interference, all white dots in the footage suddenly disappear at 0.5 seconds without any fading process.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02867", "filename": "869c04540e880d31112f9a5976def470df0d71fc2db05186fd378cf285af145b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At time 0.09, there is a problem with the connection of the magnetic spheres. When the gold sphere approaches the silver structure, the magnetic spheres that should attract each other do not form a continuous magnetic chain. Instead, a long silver rod appears suspended in the air. This rod is neither attached to the surface of the gold sphere nor held by the hand, which completely violates the physical property of magnetic spheres being connected by magnetic force.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02868", "filename": "869c04540e880d31112f9a5976def470df0d71fc2db05186fd378cf285af145b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (at 0.5s, there is a problem with the connection between the copper magnetic ball in my hand and the silver star-shaped structure in the middle. When I move the copper ball towards the silver structure, there is a noticeable gap between the two balls that should be magnetically attracted together, and they do not stick together).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02869", "filename": "869c04540e880d31112f9a5976def470df0d71fc2db05186fd378cf285af145b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is as follows: During the continuous time frame (0.1s-5.6s), the single rod extending from the silver star-shaped structure stands independently without the magnetic sphere's attraction and can even attract the copper sphere, which doesn't conform to the logic of magnetic spheres. Even stranger, when you attach the copper sphere, the silver rod can pass directly through it, as if the two objects have \"passed through\" each other.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02870", "filename": "869e0a839a85242d380b29408d3e5d293d12ce6c6687e603da16be19d9c0ddcc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the fire and smoke in this video have obvious looping anomalies. The fire and smoke in the video do not dissipate or spread naturally over time. Instead, they completely repeat the same shape and movement trajectory at a time point of about 1.4s-3.6s, as if the video clips were seamlessly spliced together and played in a loop).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02871", "filename": "869e0a839a85242d380b29408d3e5d293d12ce6c6687e603da16be19d9c0ddcc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the leaves in the background of the screen are abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02872", "filename": "869e0a839a85242d380b29408d3e5d293d12ce6c6687e603da16be19d9c0ddcc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the leaves in the background of the image are abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02876", "filename": "921c160e9df0b97ed817e80521c42dccb850ce8224d0123b77386eb024446ebd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video exhibits anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (the cloud movement in the video is illogical; normal clouds move or change at a constant speed with airflow, but here the clouds show rapid localized rotation at 2.8 seconds. The cloud cluster in the upper left corner even appears to be forced to suddenly converge towards the center of the frame, completely violating the laws of atmospheric circulation. Furthermore, the beams of light penetrating the clouds are problematic; during the rapid changes in the clouds, the angle and brightness of the beams remain unchanged, resembling a static effect added in post-production, lacking the realistic sense of light changing with the clouds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02877", "filename": "921c160e9df0b97ed817e80521c42dccb850ce8224d0123b77386eb024446ebd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02878", "filename": "921c160e9df0b97ed817e80521c42dccb850ce8224d0123b77386eb024446ebd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video exhibits a clear temporal and spatial distortion in its depiction of the sun and its shadows. Firstly, the sun's position shifts instantaneously at 2.5 seconds, jumping directly from a gap in the clouds into the completely unobstructed sky, and its size suddenly increases. Simultaneously, the changes in light and cloud cover are completely disconnected. As the sun moves rapidly, the warm light illuminating the mountains and the angle of the beams in the sky remain fixed in the same position, as if footage taken at different times and angles has been forcibly spliced together.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02879", "filename": "924d96b81485a4bd78621117fbb5ee0210e96fa02c945c73e62ea26d7e8b2c6f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is not continuous (firstly, the shape of the flames does not match the fuel; the fuel in the scene is hay, but the flames have a flowing appearance that only occurs when a viscous liquid is burning, which does not match the fluffy, leaping flames of burning hay. Secondly, the movement directions of the flames and smoke are contradictory; some of the white smoke that should rise due to heat is sinking downwards, which is completely opposite to the upward-burning direction of the flames).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02880", "filename": "924d96b81485a4bd78621117fbb5ee0210e96fa02c945c73e62ea26d7e8b2c6f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (The flames in this video exhibit a clear temporal and spatial anomaly. Normally burning hay would gradually carbonize and accumulate ash, but here, at 2.7 seconds, a section of the video suddenly reverses direction, and the previously charred area returns to the color of hay, while the flames also shrink in the opposite direction.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02881", "filename": "924d96b81485a4bd78621117fbb5ee0210e96fa02c945c73e62ea26d7e8b2c6f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is inconsistent (the anomaly is mainly in the shape of the flames and the combustion logic; the flames of normal burning hay are scattered and jumping, but in the video, the flames coalesce into a regular circular ring at 2.3s, with an unburned hole in the center. This shape is completely inconsistent with the characteristics of burning hay. Moreover, the brightness and range of the flames suddenly freeze between 3.2s and 4.4s, without continuing to spread or shrink, as if it were paused).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02882", "filename": "924d96b81485a4bd78621117fbb5ee0210e96fa02c945c73e62ea26d7e8b2c6f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is unusual due to a noticeable spatial jump in the timing of the flames and burn marks on the ground. Initially, the footage shows a close-up of a small patch of burning dry grass, but at 2.4 seconds, the camera suddenly cuts to a large, charred open field of grass where the fire instantly transforms into a fierce ground fire, completely lacking the natural spread of the fire from a single point to a wider area. Even more strangely, in the distant area of scorched black earth, there are several flames suspended in mid-air, burning without any flammable material attached.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02883", "filename": "925efca5994097a0ec1a42392ccb671e6c20cb3dc8f4c2b9ca035b57df4899c5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the base beneath the flames is abnormally distorted throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02884", "filename": "925efca5994097a0ec1a42392ccb671e6c20cb3dc8f4c2b9ca035b57df4899c5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (the flame and the glass cover of the kerosene lamp in the video are clipped through; normally, the flame should be completely enclosed inside the glass cover, but in the video, part of the flame on the left side penetrates directly through the left side wall of the glass cover and burns outside the lamp cover. Moreover, the shape of this independent flame outside is also abnormal; it does not float upwards like a normal flame, but remains stationary in a fixed cone shape, and its brightness and size do not change at all).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02885", "filename": "925efca5994097a0ec1a42392ccb671e6c20cb3dc8f4c2b9ca035b57df4899c5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02886", "filename": "925efca5994097a0ec1a42392ccb671e6c20cb3dc8f4c2b9ca035b57df4899c5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (the kerosene lamp flame in the video exhibits anomalies that contradict the principles of combustion. A normal kerosene lamp flame should be a stable central column of flame, but this flame splits into two independently burning flames at 3.6 seconds. Furthermore, without external force, the two flames slowly cross and exchange positions within the lampshade, violating the physical laws that a flame is constrained by the wick's position and airflow. Simultaneously, the flame's brightness also abruptly changes, suddenly increasing to an almost invisible level at 5.4 seconds before instantly returning to normal brightness. This abrupt change also does not conform to the logic of real flame combustion.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02887", "filename": "927df21421c0124f08254f3614095c9fbd87b62efdb0d53e556674e6d6e1f3dd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (between 3.2s and 4.5s, the movement of the white ball in the video shows obvious abnormalities. When it enters the wooden spiral track from the blue track, it should gradually decelerate due to gravity and the friction of the track, but it suddenly accelerates at 3.2s and even passes directly through the wooden partition in the middle of the track, completely unaffected by physical collisions.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02888", "filename": "927df21421c0124f08254f3614095c9fbd87b62efdb0d53e556674e6d6e1f3dd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the white ball in the video exhibits noticeable pauses and teleportations. After entering the spiral track, it should have continued rolling forward, but between 1.4s and 2.4s, it suddenly got stuck at the first bend of the track and didn't move at all. After 1 second, it suddenly teleported to the next position and continued rolling).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02889", "filename": "927df21421c0124f08254f3614095c9fbd87b62efdb0d53e556674e6d6e1f3dd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time is continuous (the white ball's motion in the spiral track is obviously abnormal. It should have been constantly changing its speed due to the curvature of the track and friction, but it suddenly stopped at 2.4s. It neither continued to roll forward nor slid backward due to gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02890", "filename": "927df21421c0124f08254f3614095c9fbd87b62efdb0d53e556674e6d6e1f3dd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (The white ball exhibits a noticeable motion anomaly after entering the spiral track. It should have rolled continuously along the track's curved path, but at 3.4 seconds, it suddenly breaks free from the track's restraints and passes directly through a gap without encountering any physical contact. Simultaneously, the ball's speed also changes irrationally; just before entering the blue track at 5 seconds, its speed suddenly slows drastically, almost pausing for a second before continuing.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02891", "filename": "941a9c18422613eb5e1d4030cc5ccb39d9c08050160d0596cd42627c76d18e70_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video exhibits an anomaly: The timing is inconsistent (the metal debris in the video violates the law of conservation of mass. Normally, during drilling, the drill bit continuously produces new debris as it cuts the metal block. However, in this video, the total amount of metal debris suddenly decreases at 3.5 seconds; a large patch of debris that was previously piled on top of the metal block disappears without any apparent falling or being cleared away. Then, at 4.9 seconds, some debris suddenly appears between the drill bit and the metal block, as if it were added out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02892", "filename": "941a9c18422613eb5e1d4030cc5ccb39d9c08050160d0596cd42627c76d18e70_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the metal debris in the video disappeared and appeared abnormally twice. The first time was at 2.4 seconds, when the debris that was originally splashed out suddenly disappeared completely on the right side of the screen without any falling or scattering process; then at 3.1 seconds, a large number of debris appeared out of nowhere below the drill bit, forming a new splashing effect, and the direction of movement of these newly appeared debris was completely different from the previous trajectory).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02893", "filename": "943a332c7661897dcb87cc7e096cdf7e9bd9dff22fd75ee4a45cf3a916424a75_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is due to a lack of continuity in time. (The movement and shape of the blue balloon exhibit significant abnormalities. First, without any external force, it suddenly begins to rotate at 2.7 seconds, and the rotation speed increases rapidly, violating the physical law that a stationary object remains stationary when no force is applied. Simultaneously, the balloon's shape undergoes unreasonable changes; at 3.4 seconds, its bottom suddenly caves in, then instantly returns to a complete spherical shape. This deformation occurs without any external force or energy transfer.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02894", "filename": "943a332c7661897dcb87cc7e096cdf7e9bd9dff22fd75ee4a45cf3a916424a75_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Time Continuity (The blue balloon's gravity behavior is abnormal. Normally, placing it on sand would leave a dent due to its weight, but this balloon not only doesn't leave any indentation, but also exhibits slight levitation at 2.9 seconds\u2014a visible gap appears between its bottom and the sand, as if it's floating unaffected by gravity. Simultaneously, the balloon's color and brightness are also problematic; at 3.9 seconds, its blue suddenly deepens, and the surface reflection disappears. This change is not supported by any change in light source, suggesting that the image's colors were directly modified in post-production.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02895", "filename": "943a332c7661897dcb87cc7e096cdf7e9bd9dff22fd75ee4a45cf3a916424a75_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is the lack of continuity in time. (At 2.4 seconds, the blue balloon undergoes a spontaneous shape change without any external force. Its right side suddenly caves in, forming a pit, and then instantly returns to a full spherical shape. This elastic deformation is not triggered by any external force or involves any energy transfer. Furthermore, during the deformation, the sand beneath the balloon is not affected by any pressure changes, and the ground corresponding to the dent does not show the expected depression or displacement. The interaction between the two is completely disconnected.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02896", "filename": "943a332c7661897dcb87cc7e096cdf7e9bd9dff22fd75ee4a45cf3a916424a75_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (The lighting and interaction of this blue balloon are noticeably abnormal. First, the part where its bottom contacts the sand does not form the expected indentation; instead, it appears to be floating above the sand, lacking a realistic sense of weight. Second, the balloon's reflection shifts instantaneously at 3.1 seconds; the highlight that was originally on the left side of the balloon suddenly jumps to the right, while the direction of the light source in the image remains unchanged.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02897", "filename": "f9508eb7b7a29a3ab4249a6a603bceb1f8b14eff2c52cdbba6f161f2f9fd1ecf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02898", "filename": "f22941d4010b8cb898bec1edb8e1b29bd2cb7953c6dd52c048ab7715af41f48a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 4.4s, the rising flames from the explosion suddenly begin to fall and contract in the opposite direction; the explosives and the ground do not produce the expected vibrations after the explosion; the shape of the flames after the explosion is an elliptical fireball, which does not conform to the natural diffusion of flames when they are burning; and there is no transition in the color of the flames).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02899", "filename": "f27126b8c57803bcf67fe24d7601575ed2336a4ad833ae389427675faeb33a59_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the sky is covered with clouds throughout the video, completely blocking out the sunlight, but the ground shows obvious shadows and large areas of highlights, which is inconsistent with the changes in the cloud cover).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_02900", "filename": "f89178c8a2055d54939844482fff288d041ff80851e69d5c9d199c4487845fc0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.5 seconds, the water droplet suddenly expands into a snowflake, which does not conform to the natural process of snowflake formation).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02901", "filename": "f825931677fe83114a3358d33f06294cacd0a9049b1617db6e886e9ea99a59c5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (in the entire video, the person in the middle is gliding on the crest of a wave, but the crest of a wave is the part of the wave that begins to break up due to the release of energy. Here, there are only rolling white waves and turbulent currents. Without the support of a stable wave wall, not only can one not glide with the push of the wave, but the surfboard will also lose control. In addition, the edge of the wave that is raised on the left is smooth without any splashes).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02902", "filename": "fa5dd566b121d7282c79b59e92d70fc8d8a1fd20e3e42ea08f0cc1666c885a66_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is distorted: (The movement of smoke in the entire video is chaotic. The smoke at the bottom of the video drifts forward, while the smoke at the top drifts to the right, which does not conform to the natural transition and spread of real smoke.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02903", "filename": "fa4556d59fe198f85a1d3bcee9032d53ed91d795dcd8eb364f7d3126d17ac7a9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal Scene: Cause and Effect (In the entire video, the background is constantly raining, but the leaves in the foreground are completely still, neither shaken by the wind nor affected by the raindrops. They are completely still, and even the dew on the leaves does not fall naturally, remaining completely static.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02904", "filename": "fb81dffa4d348a433a8809b0f220a4f542609c9198acca044db07e7b9127feb5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (based on the direction of the fire flames throughout the video, it can be determined that the wind is blowing to the left, but the grass on the lawn is not affected by the wind and does not sway noticeably).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02905", "filename": "fbb409f97b796033761e4f6938ca7804b098e56faebe829e9607ee899dd67039_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (at 0s, the white powder on the transparent tube begins to spontaneously combust without external force; at 2.1s, the flame suddenly grows larger when it comes into contact with the paper roll, but the paper does not start to grow larger or spread from the ignition point due to the flame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02906", "filename": "fbdea7621a6add8c49ba10df7db52b6a4efd45fe11627cfcc74da8137a2ca6c5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the waves appear to come from the upper right corner of the entire video, but the foam from the remaining waves in the lower left corner appears to spread from left to right).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02907", "filename": "fbfa5f83a292db601ce0564727106efb30f0e8b9e18ebbab4652c90185479dd7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.9 seconds, a water droplet falls on the water surface and creates ripples, but the ripples disappear quickly, and then the lake surface returns to calm without any waves or ripples. The lake surface is too smooth and stiff).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02908", "filename": "fbfa5f83a292db601ce0564727106efb30f0e8b9e18ebbab4652c90185479dd7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.7s, a water droplet suddenly appears out of nowhere in the center of the screen, and at 1.6s, a water droplet falling from a leaf on the left suddenly becomes smaller and leaves only a small ripple on the water surface, with no consistency between the two).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02909", "filename": "fcb56cdaa7440eeed7dc8f169ebe86f6ec4b1e178387d1c1264b8527db605235_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02910", "filename": "fcc6f6274ba463949667bf2ad8b8a0352926fdbf7d8ac8e90e09b7785076fcbe_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is distorted: the timing is continuous (the snow at the bottom edge of the cup keeps flickering and jumping after it is lifted from the cup).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02911", "filename": "fd0cbaf1f4aa59645f47ab9c881651239d9952bd72acc444681f3e55f9bbff51_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (the hydraulic press did not touch the toothbrush at 2.8 seconds, and the toothbrush suddenly broke).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02912", "filename": "fd5da80ac241ba49b9596702a3e24d429895b89515fba6f66314f196090f7ee9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.5s, the section of the rope on the right side near the boat suddenly disappears, and then the end fixed to the boat clips through the hull; the object in the hand of the red figure in the middle of the video appears at 0.8s and disappears at 1.9s; and the person standing in the turbulent current in the upper left corner is not affected by the water flow and stands very steadily).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02913", "filename": "fd940a54a629173b09ffdbd32eb2bcc76a2996406de0cf8553f7a1a0aa96693f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the hand suddenly disappears at 0.8s, and a small iron block appears out of thin air at 6.8s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02914", "filename": "fdade95db5a4c0768a37c34e9944f05154a895c1a47d32966ecb405d14263021_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the boundaries of the flames in the video are unnatural, there is no color transition from the core to the tongue of the flame when a real flame is burning, the flames move erratically and do not have the consistency of a real flame, and there is no smoke between the flames).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02915", "filename": "fdade95db5a4c0768a37c34e9944f05154a895c1a47d32966ecb405d14263021_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Overall intuition anomaly (the flames in the video appear to break but are still burning; the flame boundaries are unnatural; there is no color transition from the core to the tongue of the flame as in a real fire; the flames move erratically without the consistency of a real fire; and there is no smoke between the flames).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02916", "filename": "fdbf52cbaa45664f55a85ec9b7bc999fea1757624c38848f06fb1dfe207a878a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (between 0s and 0.3s, the flashlight in the middle of the image is overexposed, and the reflection on the ground is unrealistic, like a white ball of light, without the clear and transparent propagation of a real flashlight beam).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02917", "filename": "64210ee877c0e1f12bf16be03baeb4264222967678109d8cdd4ee4943669818d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows a continuous sequence of events (the oven door is open, but the snowflake crisps inside melt rapidly between 1s and 5.8s and then turn into cookies).", "glitch_severity": 8, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02918", "filename": "64210ee877c0e1f12bf16be03baeb4264222967678109d8cdd4ee4943669818d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows a continuity error: when the oven is opened, no steam is emitted, but steam suddenly appears out of nowhere at 0.7 seconds.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02919", "filename": "70351fe6eb4902f4ace568aeabf93430ac7d7efced78980cfc6406fd5f4c4a62_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Continuous timing (the video flickers at 0s, and at 2.5s, the fire on the stove suddenly decreases without any apparent disruption).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02920", "filename": "70351fe6eb4902f4ace568aeabf93430ac7d7efced78980cfc6406fd5f4c4a62_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal; the timing is continuous (at 0 seconds, the entire screen suddenly appears white, similar to a sudden increase in contrast).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02921", "filename": "70351fe6eb4902f4ace568aeabf93430ac7d7efced78980cfc6406fd5f4c4a62_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02922", "filename": "71863e20f0c177b25471a0c264e6f06ef8c082cb32f655096869dfb983ba7e91_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02923", "filename": "71863e20f0c177b25471a0c264e6f06ef8c082cb32f655096869dfb983ba7e91_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (from 3.4s to 5.8s in the video, the liquid in the cup has overflowed and covered the rim like a lid, but it defies gravity and does not flow down.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02924", "filename": "71863e20f0c177b25471a0c264e6f06ef8c082cb32f655096869dfb983ba7e91_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows a continuous sequence of events (at 0.7 seconds, the smooth metal surface of the coffee machine suddenly turns red, then disappears and returns to its original state at 3.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02925", "filename": "71863e20f0c177b25471a0c264e6f06ef8c082cb32f655096869dfb983ba7e91_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is continuous (between 0s and 1.8s in the video, blue flames are shooting out from the coffee dispenser of the coffee machine).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02926", "filename": "71920eae821726d227d15e645288cafcb91c429e66a28475cdc495f9e6a33436_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the duration is continuous (4.4 seconds, the previously sparse clouds in the sky suddenly become more numerous and dense).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02927", "filename": "71920eae821726d227d15e645288cafcb91c429e66a28475cdc495f9e6a33436_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (Throughout the video, the clouds in the sky gradually disappear as they move until they vanish completely.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02928", "filename": "71920eae821726d227d15e645288cafcb91c429e66a28475cdc495f9e6a33436_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the water surface moves up and down rhythmically throughout the video, whereas in reality, water ripples do not move in a uniform rhythm and have natural density.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02929", "filename": "73440e5e17a0734789e4acaf44c4a6acb5f854071320a0132ce57ef37408c124_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is continuous (the vehicle explodes in the video, but between 4s and 5s, the windshield appears intact).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02930", "filename": "73440e5e17a0734789e4acaf44c4a6acb5f854071320a0132ce57ef37408c124_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the entire rear half of the car disappears out of thin air between 3.5s and 5.8s after the explosion in the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02931", "filename": "73440e5e17a0734789e4acaf44c4a6acb5f854071320a0132ce57ef37408c124_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the entire interior of the vehicle explodes, but the windshield remains intact; at 4.2 seconds, a long black object suddenly appears on the top of the car).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02932", "filename": "073771a2ff1bc59c885f19d346f921a03c364a09f4dd9316ca2c58678c5d224c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 0.5s, a stream of water flows down from above the petal, but it does not carry away some of the water droplets as it flows over them. After the water flows away, the original water droplets remain attached to the petal.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02933", "filename": "073771a2ff1bc59c885f19d346f921a03c364a09f4dd9316ca2c58678c5d224c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02934", "filename": "77996eb81486c31b484a04a3e5e298a5599984992bdc5dc777cb7f0b1a6f66ec_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 2.4 seconds in the video, text suddenly appears on the left side of the white border of the shot.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02935", "filename": "77996eb81486c31b484a04a3e5e298a5599984992bdc5dc777cb7f0b1a6f66ec_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (horizontally distributed rainbow-colored interference fringes appear on the lower half of the entire video lens, with distinct color layers and a periodic arrangement, transitioning from blue-purple at the top to red-yellow at the bottom, which is completely different from the normal uniform appearance of the lens).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02936", "filename": "77996eb81486c31b484a04a3e5e298a5599984992bdc5dc777cb7f0b1a6f66ec_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Continuous timing (the overall brightness of the video suddenly increases at 0.5s, and the amplitude of the frame shaking and the amplitude of the color aperture changes are inconsistent between 2.1s and 8s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02941", "filename": "79253f01844ae5d2fda452fb0d4c4b6fc659d6d6d7d95dd3c7997130c8f947e1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (the sparkler is constantly burning throughout the video, but the burning location remains unchanged.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02942", "filename": "79253f01844ae5d2fda452fb0d4c4b6fc659d6d6d7d95dd3c7997130c8f947e1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is discontinuous (the entire video features sparkler-like fireworks burning, but the sparklers appear smooth and have a plastic-like texture).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02943", "filename": "79253f01844ae5d2fda452fb0d4c4b6fc659d6d6d7d95dd3c7997130c8f947e1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (some spark lines in the video appear mechanical and repetitive, whereas the spark trajectories of real explosions or fireworks are random and natural.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02944", "filename": "79253f01844ae5d2fda452fb0d4c4b6fc659d6d6d7d95dd3c7997130c8f947e1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The time frame is continuous (from 0.6s to 4.4s in the video, the area below the spark source gradually returns to its original unburned state after burning and turning red).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02945", "filename": "80279e732e7fd30fd02a7b7d2fbd14541b5fa2387b9453fe868896dc5b1e449e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the lines of rooftops and walls of buildings are blurred throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02946", "filename": "80279e732e7fd30fd02a7b7d2fbd14541b5fa2387b9453fe868896dc5b1e449e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02947", "filename": "c132876ba4499ad147db9829061616bab065e9ff3746d8b188da8ad4bb91bebe_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal in several ways: The timing is unpredictable (the entire video shows the ice melting, with more water on the table, but the ice remains unchanged). The physical behavior is also inconsistent (the water on the table remains clumped together like a colloid, which does not conform to the principles of liquid flow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02948", "filename": "c0661699f8cfb2069723c9874eb0e209c436ccf08ab255d9a210231f49989fe4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video flickers at 2.2 seconds (the flames of the two candles remain in the same position throughout the entire video, swaying together too neatly and synchronously).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02949", "filename": "c0661699f8cfb2069723c9874eb0e209c436ccf08ab255d9a210231f49989fe4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.4s, the green cup is swaying above the candle flame, but the flame itself does not change).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02950", "filename": "c0661699f8cfb2069723c9874eb0e209c436ccf08ab255d9a210231f49989fe4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 2.01, when the green cup is quickly brought close to the candle, the flame does not swing in the direction the cup is moving, but remains upright, which does not conform to the principle of gas flow).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02951", "filename": "c2632296db4073089e3016e44da06c8897e7edd0aed2e9813ab20f95f6a9f7b3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: (The aquatic plants and trees in the entire video are too blurry and flickering, and the image appears grainy.) (After the explosion at 4.8 seconds, the water surface returned to calm and then suddenly exploded again out of nowhere.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02952", "filename": "c2632296db4073089e3016e44da06c8897e7edd0aed2e9813ab20f95f6a9f7b3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the debris that was blown up at 3.2 seconds disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02953", "filename": "c2632296db4073089e3016e44da06c8897e7edd0aed2e9813ab20f95f6a9f7b3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (at 3.8s, debris flying in the air after the explosion disappears into thin air as it falls, and the quantity decreases).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02954", "filename": "c9943188dac0278a125bd8d94c4cdc3bc39f2d8189b84e993e5d5221a9cd2928_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 0.1s, the right eye of the fake head disappears out of thin air) (at 0.3s, the bullet undergoes a sudden change, becoming much larger)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02955", "filename": "c9943188dac0278a125bd8d94c4cdc3bc39f2d8189b84e993e5d5221a9cd2928_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (at the beginning - 1.1s, the bullet on the dummy head automatically returns to the barrel without any force, which does not conform to the law of interaction of forces) Time continuity (at 2.4s, the bullet has not yet hit the dummy head, but the dummy head suddenly breaks apart)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02956", "filename": "c9943188dac0278a125bd8d94c4cdc3bc39f2d8189b84e993e5d5221a9cd2928_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (a bullet appears out of nowhere on the dummy head's eye at 0.6s) (a bullet on the dummy head's nose disappears out of nowhere at 1.5s) Physical behavior (the bullet bounces horizontally from 1.2s onwards without falling, which does not conform to the law of gravity)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02957", "filename": "c9943188dac0278a125bd8d94c4cdc3bc39f2d8189b84e993e5d5221a9cd2928_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (at 2.5s, the dummy head suddenly explodes without being subjected to any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02958", "filename": "c718667776c7529edcd0ed0006c6a41bee37282e6f689993bfebb40e99fea1b1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (the entire diamond exhibits a continuous high-frequency iridescent flash without any change in light source; the diamond reflection should be stable, changing only with the light source or viewing angle). Physical behavior (the chain is completely stationary, hanging without gravity; the suspended chain should have a natural curve and slight movement).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02959", "filename": "c718667776c7529edcd0ed0006c6a41bee37282e6f689993bfebb40e99fea1b1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02960", "filename": "ca2c029e5dedd66cc9e483405ef963c1dbbd32ba5b72b1bbd065f6517979e48a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (colors appear as stripes throughout the video, but the colored stripes on the bubbles should appear as circles).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02961", "filename": "ca2c029e5dedd66cc9e483405ef963c1dbbd32ba5b72b1bbd065f6517979e48a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 4.1s, the extra thread attached to the ball disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02962", "filename": "ca2c029e5dedd66cc9e483405ef963c1dbbd32ba5b72b1bbd065f6517979e48a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (3.2s - end when the water surface is calm, under no force, the buoy on the water surface has a pulling force that drags the rope to the right, which does not conform to the law of interaction of forces).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02963", "filename": "ca2c029e5dedd66cc9e483405ef963c1dbbd32ba5b72b1bbd065f6517979e48a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_02964", "filename": "ca8e2767823ecd0b666955f189b9e6ba5a319f94ad1619236ba0f2159d5df3f1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02965", "filename": "ca8e2767823ecd0b666955f189b9e6ba5a319f94ad1619236ba0f2159d5df3f1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 5.6s, the diamond in the hand suddenly changes from a rhombus shape to an oval shape).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02966", "filename": "ca8e2767823ecd0b666955f189b9e6ba5a319f94ad1619236ba0f2159d5df3f1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 2.4 seconds, the diamond changes from a full state to a flat state, and the color changes from blue to pink).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02967", "filename": "ca8e2767823ecd0b666955f189b9e6ba5a319f94ad1619236ba0f2159d5df3f1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.8 seconds, the diamond suddenly changed from a teardrop shape to a button shape).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02968", "filename": "caa7a073405292f87261000ec493460869dc20798c3e33d202eb11443e39f327_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time is continuous (after the explosion at 1.8 seconds, the area before the explosion point remains unchanged, the grass is still intact, and there are no traces of the explosion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02969", "filename": "caa7a073405292f87261000ec493460869dc20798c3e33d202eb11443e39f327_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to physical behavior (an explosion occurred at 0.8 seconds, but the grass and trees around the explosion point remained still and were not affected by the strong air pressure generated by the explosion, which does not conform to the principle of gas pressure).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02970", "filename": "caa7a073405292f87261000ec493460869dc20798c3e33d202eb11443e39f327_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (after the explosion in the entire video, a large amount of white smoke gathered together and rose like a cloud without dissipating, which does not conform to the principles of gas flow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02971", "filename": "cadede47c765da8a0893c43e36a921ce5dacdaf0f85461e1bae6a6fcbc629779_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (from the start to 1.5 seconds, the orange card keeps flipping over in the same position) (from 3.8 seconds to the end, the orange card still keeps flipping over in the same position)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02972", "filename": "cadede47c765da8a0893c43e36a921ce5dacdaf0f85461e1bae6a6fcbc629779_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02973", "filename": "cadede47c765da8a0893c43e36a921ce5dacdaf0f85461e1bae6a6fcbc629779_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02974", "filename": "caf5199479ccdde6e9c0641141fb862e24a8635fc440b2f6e926b84437bbaf44_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02975", "filename": "caf5199479ccdde6e9c0641141fb862e24a8635fc440b2f6e926b84437bbaf44_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 4.3s, the complete disc suddenly splits into two halves).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02976", "filename": "caf5199479ccdde6e9c0641141fb862e24a8635fc440b2f6e926b84437bbaf44_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02977", "filename": "15402c6b79ca967bde81dd5f05995871465a33b43f0f44497f35fcea6477bc88_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows a cutting machine cutting an iron block, but there are no cutting marks on the block. In reality, a cutting machine would leave marks on an iron block after it has been cut.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02978", "filename": "15402c6b79ca967bde81dd5f05995871465a33b43f0f44497f35fcea6477bc88_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the video uses a cutting machine to cut an iron block, but there are no cutting marks on the iron block. Furthermore, the sparks in the video are generated in the middle of the iron block, whereas in reality, a cutting machine would leave marks on the iron block after it is cut; the sparks are generated at the contact surface between the cutting machine and the iron block).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02979", "filename": "16899ec9c7f343a1782852fefb750d1f18f253995d8f9acf6328043fe7bca3d8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (during the period from 3.2s to the end, the pattern near the center on the upper left of the light shows a diffusion phenomenon, and the adjacent patterns gradually disappear).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02980", "filename": "16899ec9c7f343a1782852fefb750d1f18f253995d8f9acf6328043fe7bca3d8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02981", "filename": "16899ec9c7f343a1782852fefb750d1f18f253995d8f9acf6328043fe7bca3d8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02982", "filename": "16899ec9c7f343a1782852fefb750d1f18f253995d8f9acf6328043fe7bca3d8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall realism is abnormal (the chandelier in the video gradually brightens from 2.3 seconds to the end. In real life, the brightness of a chandelier does not change after it is turned on).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02983", "filename": "0018093ca41461afcd98411a13662786a43095ced498ca7fccbbe44e91e58519_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.7 seconds, the elephant's leg on the right is bent unnaturally).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02984", "filename": "0018093ca41461afcd98411a13662786a43095ced498ca7fccbbe44e91e58519_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (at 3.9s, a black object suddenly appears near the left-side foreleg); Physical behavior (from the start until 1.3s, the left-side elephant's tail remains raised in the air and stationary, whereas in real life, an elephant's tail usually hangs down behind its rump).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02985", "filename": "0018093ca41461afcd98411a13662786a43095ced498ca7fccbbe44e91e58519_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.8s, the elephant's trunk on the left suddenly shortens).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02986", "filename": "0018093ca41461afcd98411a13662786a43095ced498ca7fccbbe44e91e58519_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (in the entire video, the heads of the two elephants appear to have a rubbery texture and reflect light, and the tips of the elephants' tails are made of plastic. In reality, the tips of an elephant's tail are a tuft of hair, and the head does not reflect light).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02987", "filename": "19322b6c49800cd6e387151b9605b03ab5a25fc3a6add1f9aef0eb06f2290568_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_02988", "filename": "19322b6c49800cd6e387151b9605b03ab5a25fc3a6add1f9aef0eb06f2290568_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the reflections of trees and houses on the shore in the video are too blurry on the calm lake surface, whereas in reality, reflections on a calm lake surface are more complete and clear).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02989", "filename": "19322b6c49800cd6e387151b9605b03ab5a25fc3a6add1f9aef0eb06f2290568_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.9s, a person on the left bank suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02990", "filename": "19322b6c49800cd6e387151b9605b03ab5a25fc3a6add1f9aef0eb06f2290568_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is unusual: the overall realism is abnormal (the video was taken by moving the camera close to the lake, but no ripples were created on the lake surface. When drones or other similar machines are used for aerial filming, the wind generated by the rotating wings of the drone will create ripples on the lake surface when filming at close range).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_02991", "filename": "19546f7aa27dd67147e87b4575625168a7ed16d81fe85065596177765c80a9ca_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (flickering appears in the upper right corner of the video); Physical behavior (the diamond reflects a light blue light in the video, but when it disappears, the light reflected by the transparent diamond is multicolored).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02992", "filename": "19546f7aa27dd67147e87b4575625168a7ed16d81fe85065596177765c80a9ca_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the light reflected from the diamonds around the hand in the video is too intense. In reality, the light reflected from diamonds is not so intense that it is only a few millimeters away from the diamond surface, but only on the surface of the diamond).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02993", "filename": "19546f7aa27dd67147e87b4575625168a7ed16d81fe85065596177765c80a9ca_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.5 seconds, a blinding blue light suddenly appears on the diamond on the left side of the ring).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_02994", "filename": "19546f7aa27dd67147e87b4575625168a7ed16d81fe85065596177765c80a9ca_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (a dazzling light was produced on the ring at 2.9s and 6s, while in reality, diamonds only produce a faint luster on the surface).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_02998", "filename": "21853cb38238016759ad84906ec46c4d0c1e7467623e3a1ff691529c6b6f76ea_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the liquid residue on the spoon suddenly disappears at 2.1 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_02999", "filename": "21853cb38238016759ad84906ec46c4d0c1e7467623e3a1ff691529c6b6f76ea_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (the small spoon in the pot changes into a large soup spoon at 0.6s, and the thick liquid in the pot thins at 2.3s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03000", "filename": "21853cb38238016759ad84906ec46c4d0c1e7467623e3a1ff691529c6b6f76ea_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the small spoon in the video changes to a large soup spoon at 0s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03007", "filename": "P22_111_43_504ff964ebce8762_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03008", "filename": "P22_111_57_3a6386f30a6cf2c3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (at 2.7 seconds, the person did not hit the two middle switches, yet the two middle switches turned on simultaneously).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03009", "filename": "P22_111_57_3a6386f30a6cf2c3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is inconsistent (at 3.2 seconds, the person uses their right hand to touch the right side of the still-flaming stove's flame outlet and adjust the size of the left flame outlet).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03010", "filename": "P22_111_91_9ee0d6d56ce87aff_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is inconsistent (at 3.5 seconds, the amount of meat in the pot decreases due to stirring, which is inconsistent with the preceding and following moments).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03011", "filename": "P22_111_91_9ee0d6d56ce87aff_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the video quality is blurry and the details are unclear; the meat in the pan flickers and shakes while being stir-fried).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03012", "filename": "P22_111_91_9ee0d6d56ce87aff_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing changes abruptly (starting at 1.9s, the oil in the pot suddenly foams more and turns into water when stirred, with no consistency between the beginning and end).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03013", "filename": "P22_111_137_1280401792f267d1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: there are abrupt changes in time (at 0.9 seconds from the start of the video, the eggs in the person's hand suddenly merge from two into one without any consistency).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03014", "filename": "P22_111_137_1280401792f267d1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timeline changes abruptly (at 0.8s, the bottle cap on the person's right hand turns into a plastic bag; at 2.1s, one of the eggs in the person's hand suddenly disappears; at 6.9s, an egg picked up by the person in the video vanishes into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03015", "filename": "P22_111_198_018e3da92f55a882_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal; the timing is continuous (at 1.5s, the tomato pieces cut by the character are not cut while moving but turn into broken tomatoes; at 3.7s, the large tomato breaks into smaller pieces on its own without any external force, and the scene changes abruptly).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03016", "filename": "P22_111_198_018e3da92f55a882_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal; the timing is continuous (in the video, the tomato pieces that the person cuts each time are not cut while moving, but instead turn into tomato cubes, which is a mutation).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03017", "filename": "P22_111_199_7c9405134902379b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal; the timing is inconsistent (at 1.7s and 3.4s, the tomato pieces cut by the character are not cut while moving but suddenly turn into many tomato pieces; at 4.7s, the two pieces of tomato turn into one whole tomato without any consistency).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03018", "filename": "P22_111_201_2df9c5eeae72d58b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal; the timing is inconsistent (each time the person cuts a tomato, the tomato pieces are not cut while moving, but they all turn into tomato chunks, which is a sudden change; at 4.3s, the person picks up a whole tomato and suddenly turns it into tomato chunks, which is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03019", "filename": "P22_111_302_c37fb49e1adf54b2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are inconsistent: the time sequence is continuous (at 1.6s and 3.3s, the number of characters cutting granular objects on the cutting board increases out of nowhere, with no consistency between the two).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03020", "filename": "P22_111_564_acd641a55b08730d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03021", "filename": "P22_111_564_acd641a55b08730d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (the pot only starts heating and emitting steam after being removed from the stove in 2 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03022", "filename": "P22_111_659_f772b7e878f03bef_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is inconsistent (at 4.3s, the person in the video starts to flip a piece of solid food in the pot, which suddenly breaks into two pieces without any external force; at 5.5s, it merges back into one piece. The video has no consistency).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03023", "filename": "P22_111_659_f772b7e878f03bef_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.6s, the spatula and the handle of the pan suddenly merge into one, at 3.1s, the pancake in the pan turns from one to two, and at 6.6s, the spatula appears out of nowhere without any consistency).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03024", "filename": "P22_112_66_84635d2a3381122c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.5s, the faucet turns on automatically, and the plastic spoon-like object in the character's hand suddenly disappears; at 7.4s, the brush passes through the transparent cup without any consistency).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03025", "filename": "P22_112_93_497e8073356b26f1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (1.3s: the white paper towel on the bottle is torn open and turns into silver foil, a sudden change occurs)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03026", "filename": "P22_112_170_90ec8c1b9670e54f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (at 0.7 seconds, the towel on the floor suddenly deforms and moves without the person touching it).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03027", "filename": "P22_112_170_90ec8c1b9670e54f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is distorted: the timing is continuous (at 2.4 seconds, the person's fingers pass through the towel, causing clipping).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03028", "filename": "P22_112_170_90ec8c1b9670e54f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.1s, the towel in the character's hand begins to blend into the carpet on the ground, and the scene lacks consistency).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03029", "filename": "P22_113_105_762f014ffd0f9934_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: there are abrupt changes in timing (after 1.7 seconds in the video, while the eggs in the pan are being stirred, the number of eggs in the pan increases without any food being added, and there is no consistency between the beginning and end of the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03030", "filename": "P22_113_105_762f014ffd0f9934_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03031", "filename": "P22_113_105_762f014ffd0f9934_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.6s, the egg pieces being stir-fried with a spatula suddenly turn into liquid egg, and at 2.3s, the leaked liquid egg disappears, showing no consistency).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03032", "filename": "P22_113_201_5dc7138eeaf921cf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video behavior: Physical behavior (at 4.8s in the video, the person vertically inverts the pot, but the meat in the pot does not fall into the bowl, which violates the laws of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03033", "filename": "P22_115_109_e37d6fb701bf7c01_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the water stains on the pot lid in the upper left corner of the screen suddenly shake and distort, and the bubbles in the pool on the right suddenly enlarge at 0.6s without any consistency).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03034", "filename": "P22_115_163_25574eb31c86c55e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03036", "filename": "P22_115_163_25574eb31c86c55e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning due to a lack of continuity in time (after the person in the video puts the white cylinder in the box, a white hairdryer suddenly appears at 3.3 seconds; the video lacks consistency).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03037", "filename": "P35_104_762_cb4de7718b0c684f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is continuous (at 4.5 seconds into the video, the lid is thrown into the air, and the edge, which was originally close to a perfect circle, suddenly twists irregularly, with a local inward deformation on the right side, changing from a smooth arc to a shape with a folded corner).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03038", "filename": "P35_105_2_5b968481a4d5087c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.4 seconds, the position of the pot appears to shift instantly, jumping directly from near the center of the screen to the right edge without any transition between shots).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03039", "filename": "P35_105_9_7505a98b60a18a74_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03040", "filename": "P35_105_61_2dcd2af969f11e93_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03041", "filename": "P35_105_61_2dcd2af969f11e93_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 1.2 seconds, the folds of the plastic bag undergo a sudden change without external force, and the originally deep folds instantly flatten; at 2.4 seconds, there is a frame jump in the position of the hand and the bag)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03042", "filename": "P35_105_104_b05b530342a5c755_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (when igniting at approximately 0.7 seconds, the flame is noticeably biased to the left side of the burner, failing to burn evenly in the center, which does not conform to the normal ignition logic of a gas stove.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03043", "filename": "P35_105_104_b05b530342a5c755_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are erratic: the timing is discontinuous (at 4.7 seconds, the fork in the left hand suddenly disappears, and at 5.1 seconds, it reappears out of thin air in the right hand. At the same time, an extra hand that does not belong to the operator is seen adjusting the position of the pot. The appearance and disappearance of these elements are not connected by reasonable actions).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03044", "filename": "P35_105_136_cc292dc248dd73d7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (At 1 seconds, the white object in the hand is still being held normally; at 2.1 seconds, its lower half suddenly disappears into the clutter in the cabinet without any deformation caused by pressure, as if it passed directly through the object, which is contrary to the laws of physics.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03045", "filename": "P35_105_137_315039f7200947d0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03046", "filename": "P35_105_137_315039f7200947d0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (4.2 seconds before the hand even touched the blue object, it moved on its own.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03047", "filename": "P35_105_139_e3079e4c16be3b16_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the gas stove is not ignited in the video, but the food in the pot appears to be heated; the flame and heating effect are mismatched, which does not conform to real cooking logic.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03048", "filename": "P35_105_139_e3079e4c16be3b16_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (the gas stove flame suddenly appears completely from nothing at 1.1 seconds, without ignition and gradual combustion, which does not conform to the logic of real flame combustion.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03049", "filename": "P35_105_139_e3079e4c16be3b16_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (In the video, the gas stove has two switches. The person is only operating one of the gas stove switches, but flames are coming out of both the upper and lower burners at the same time. This does not conform to the basic logic of a gas stove where each switch independently controls its corresponding burner. Moreover, the burner below, where no cooking utensils are placed, is also ignited. This is neither in line with usage habits nor with the working principle of the equipment.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03050", "filename": "P35_105_268_a9977f2cac5aa00d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03051", "filename": "P35_105_268_a9977f2cac5aa00d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (In the video, after the tablecloth that was originally covering the table is lifted at 1.8 seconds, no actual tabletop support appears underneath, and the solid part of the table completely disappears.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03052", "filename": "P35_105_286_f19c434dbd652b0b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03053", "filename": "P35_105_395_d96ee1f1e6d9a3cd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning due to a causal relationship issue. (The first two seconds of the video show the action of packaging food, and then it jumps directly to the finished product being heated on the gas stove without any transition. The lack of footage of the cooking process in between creates a logical break between the actions and the result, making it impossible to establish a reasonable causal relationship.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03054", "filename": "P35_105_395_d96ee1f1e6d9a3cd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: (At approximately 3.5 seconds, when the hand reaches for the spoon next to the stove, the spoon starts moving on its own before the hand even touches it. This action does not conform to the logic of real force.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03055", "filename": "P35_105_395_d96ee1f1e6d9a3cd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (2.4 seconds ago the character was at the table where food was packaged, and 2.4 seconds later the character suddenly appeared in front of the kitchen stove without any movement in between. This is a teleportation-style camera jump, which violates the normal logic of spatial movement.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03056", "filename": "P35_105_408_9f9b2fc3a05effdc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly: The timing is continuous (around 3 seconds later, before the spoon has even placed the food on the plate, a piece of food identical to the one in the spoon has already appeared on the plate).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03057", "filename": "P35_105_408_9f9b2fc3a05effdc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (6.5 seconds in, a plate that was not originally in the frame suddenly appears out of nowhere with a pattern on it.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03058", "filename": "P35_107_24_b71d1b96e0d418b9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 4.4 seconds, the proportions of the wrist and fingers of the hand holding the cup are strange, and the palm is clearly twisted, which does not conform to normal human anatomy.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03059", "filename": "P35_107_136_b2000258034e87a1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03060", "filename": "P35_107_149_9f1a9d4dbddb07c9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (at 1.5 seconds, the knife in the left hand suddenly disappears; at 2.2 seconds, a knife appears out of thin air in the right hand, and then this knife merges with another knife already in the scene.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03061", "filename": "P35_107_149_9f1a9d4dbddb07c9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 2 seconds, the item the hand takes out of the drawer is not a knife, but at 2.5 seconds, the item instantly transforms into a knife, without any transitional change in form in between.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03062", "filename": "P35_107_239_d920028633c54326_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (1.2 seconds ago, the faucet was closed without any manual operation; at 1.2 seconds, water suddenly started flowing out on its own; at 3.1 seconds, it automatically shut off again without any human intervention.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03063", "filename": "P35_107_239_d920028633c54326_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 7.1 seconds, a hand reaches to turn off the faucet, but the hand is not positioned on the faucet's control knob; instead, it presses on the faucet's metal rod. This position is insufficient to turn off the faucet, yet the faucet is still turned off.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03064", "filename": "P35_107_241_aca224349a2909d3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03065", "filename": "P35_107_241_aca224349a2909d3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the video, there is no obvious change in the cleanliness of the area on the table that was wiped before 3.4 seconds and the area that was not wiped; the interaction between the cloth and the table appears unrealistic.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03066", "filename": "P35_107_331_86d13ae6ac1d0141_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (between 1 second and 1.1 seconds in the video, the state of the towel's wrinkles changed abruptly. In the previous frame, it was in a relatively relaxed state, but in the next frame, it was suddenly filled with dense horizontal wrinkles. There was no transitional action of rubbing or pressing with the hand in between, which violated the logic of the change in the shape of the object.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03070", "filename": "e92ae6bfef2d02ab60936d226a83a675e2619fa8b791abc4cc3ad6712051316d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.5 seconds, water sprays upwards from the pool in a manner resembling boiling, but the hot spring water does not reach a boiling state).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03071", "filename": "e92ae6bfef2d02ab60936d226a83a675e2619fa8b791abc4cc3ad6712051316d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (the hot spring is shown boiling throughout the entire sequence, whereas hot springs do not actually boil).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03072", "filename": "e92ae6bfef2d02ab60936d226a83a675e2619fa8b791abc4cc3ad6712051316d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous (the video stutters between 1.2s and 5s, and the hot spring appears to be boiling throughout the entire segment, whereas hot springs do not actually boil).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03073", "filename": "e92ae6bfef2d02ab60936d226a83a675e2619fa8b791abc4cc3ad6712051316d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (water sprays out of thin air from the water surface between 0.3s and 2s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03074", "filename": "e95d971e400de5f79f0d27dd5cc08556de94b5b37a6bf25be46a6577db905358_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (with more crystals seemingly spreading out from left to right throughout the entire sequence).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03075", "filename": "e95d971e400de5f79f0d27dd5cc08556de94b5b37a6bf25be46a6577db905358_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (in reality, ice crystals are visible to the naked eye but are thin and fragile, while in the video they appear as heavy metal with strong reflections and a three-dimensional effect, which is inconsistent with the properties of metal in reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03076", "filename": "e111a0db83061ead33d1d97fdf89abb991684c43b1189d863eeebddab2763258_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (realistic waterfalls have subtle water ripples and dynamic blur, but the edges of the water in the video are too sharp, lacking the softness and dynamic blur of real water).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03077", "filename": "e111a0db83061ead33d1d97fdf89abb991684c43b1189d863eeebddab2763258_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the direction of the white water curtain and splashes at the edge of the waterfall, as well as the texture of the water flow, all appear to be gushing upwards rather than naturally cascading downwards).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03078", "filename": "e111a0db83061ead33d1d97fdf89abb991684c43b1189d863eeebddab2763258_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03079", "filename": "e111a0db83061ead33d1d97fdf89abb991684c43b1189d863eeebddab2763258_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03080", "filename": "e142afb15282b1569ca0cffe0f5ce1bbdc4683ae37f2fa6f0b4f1bef3a956796_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (there is no transition process of fireworks flying into the air in the entire video, but fireworks keep appearing out of thin air and exploding in the air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03081", "filename": "e142afb15282b1569ca0cffe0f5ce1bbdc4683ae37f2fa6f0b4f1bef3a956796_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (two bright streaks resembling a meteor shower appear in spacetime at 2.5 seconds, but their reflections are not visible on the water surface).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03082", "filename": "e202d244ae2368ef1880e19872872b21d43de47dbc9cbb3d4712547324572b13_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall impression is abnormal (the kayak's movement is completely disconnected from the impact of the surrounding water flow throughout the entire segment; the hull does not exhibit the expected swaying and rocking motion due to the impact of rapids; the interaction with the water surface is extremely unnatural, as if the hull is moving independently of the water flow).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03083", "filename": "e202d244ae2368ef1880e19872872b21d43de47dbc9cbb3d4712547324572b13_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the changes in light and shadow on the water, boat and rocks are irregular, and there are sudden changes in light and shadow in some areas. There is no natural gradual change in light as the object moves and the water ripples. The overall texture is stiff and lacks the light and shadow layers of a real scene).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03084", "filename": "e250b9560515059c0a0ef9b50273b78c7008565240829ff23a3b0c6140a7e502_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Physical behavior (the entire sky is filled with aurora, but the water surface below only shows a reflection, without any reflection traces of normal aurora light and shadow).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03085", "filename": "e250b9560515059c0a0ef9b50273b78c7008565240829ff23a3b0c6140a7e502_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the aurora moves continuously in the air throughout the entire segment, but its reflection on the water surface is not synchronized; the reflection on the right side of the water surface disappears between 4s and 5.8s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03086", "filename": "e250b9560515059c0a0ef9b50273b78c7008565240829ff23a3b0c6140a7e502_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the light bands of the real aurora are diffuse and irregular rays with blurred edges that change rapidly over time, while the light bands in the video have overly clear and symmetrical edges, lacking the fluidity and randomness of the natural aurora).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03087", "filename": "e303a96e46985d0ee1a6d6373d607035eb23c5c96f57c3337e520c80f11bad98_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: physical behavior (the sun itself is too bright, and the transition between the orange-red gradient of the surrounding sky is abrupt, while the dark areas of the scenery below are not illuminated by the sun, but are directly black, which does not conform to the light reflection of a real sunrise or sunset).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03088", "filename": "e303a96e46985d0ee1a6d6373d607035eb23c5c96f57c3337e520c80f11bad98_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the entire video is fast-forwarded, but the tree on the right and the power line on the left are stationary and do not have the effect of swaying due to wind in reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03089", "filename": "e303a96e46985d0ee1a6d6373d607035eb23c5c96f57c3337e520c80f11bad98_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the entire video plays at normal speed, but the sun sets too fast, far exceeding the actual speed).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03090", "filename": "e303a96e46985d0ee1a6d6373d607035eb23c5c96f57c3337e520c80f11bad98_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the entire sequence, as the sun sets and completely disappears, the color of the clouds illuminated by the sun remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03091", "filename": "e535a102f29b6ee7125e1662c00f403a52d40f8cedbdf9a53f3daa70e82ffdcb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.3s, when the green light from the building shines on the people on the left side of the ground, the people appear to be bathed in white light).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03093", "filename": "e662ca7ff71c526d771b5d66284223e09ec7975a26ab8fbbbf6d60ef0bcbdc73_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.6 seconds, when the hand dryer is pushed over the wet carpet, the carpet on its left side is not pushed over but also dries).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03094", "filename": "e662ca7ff71c526d771b5d66284223e09ec7975a26ab8fbbbf6d60ef0bcbdc73_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (when the towel is flipped up at 2.2 seconds, another layer of the towel appears out of thin air and flips up).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03095", "filename": "e662ca7ff71c526d771b5d66284223e09ec7975a26ab8fbbbf6d60ef0bcbdc73_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the towel in the hand turns into a glove at 7s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03096", "filename": "e690e0ee6b68e3a4fe97bae15e82d0c3e15d1fb01891411c70ca2b28ae242ecd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03097", "filename": "fbb409f97b796033761e4f6938ca7804b098e56faebe829e9607ee899dd67039_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (without camera movement or external force interference, flames suddenly appear on the stainless steel spoon at 0.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03099", "filename": "fbdea7621a6add8c49ba10df7db52b6a4efd45fe11627cfcc74da8137a2ca6c5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the clouds in the image are abnormally uniformly distributed, without the natural density and shape differences of clouds in reality, and remain completely still throughout, without any dynamic changes such as drifting, stretching or dissipating).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03100", "filename": "fbdea7621a6add8c49ba10df7db52b6a4efd45fe11627cfcc74da8137a2ca6c5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the water surface in the scene is abnormally flat, without any natural ripples or waves, and there is no subtle dynamic movement affected by the environment, completely lacking the dynamic texture of the water surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03101", "filename": "fbdea7621a6add8c49ba10df7db52b6a4efd45fe11627cfcc74da8137a2ca6c5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is the lack of continuity in time (the clouds in the entire video are distributed in an unusually uniform manner, without any natural variation in density or shape, and remain completely still throughout. There is no dynamic change of drifting, spreading, or dissipating. At the same time, the water surface below is unusually flat, without any natural ripples, waves, or other dynamic movements influenced by the environment).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03102", "filename": "fbdea7621a6add8c49ba10df7db52b6a4efd45fe11627cfcc74da8137a2ca6c5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, many water droplets suddenly appear in the lower left corner of the screen at 2.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03103", "filename": "fbfa5f83a292db601ce0564727106efb30f0e8b9e18ebbab4652c90185479dd7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 0.4s, water droplets suddenly appear out of thin air in the upper left corner of the screen and fall downwards).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03104", "filename": "fbfa5f83a292db601ce0564727106efb30f0e8b9e18ebbab4652c90185479dd7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03105", "filename": "fc3ece43f425eacef2642dc2c6d3fc767e6113a14aaaea7238005a4feab6c74f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (without camera movement or external interference, the amount of liquid in the cup suddenly increases and its color suddenly darkens at 1.3 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03106", "filename": "fc3ece43f425eacef2642dc2c6d3fc767e6113a14aaaea7238005a4feab6c74f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (without camera movement or external interference, the amount of liquid in the cup suddenly increases and its color suddenly darkens at 1.3 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03107", "filename": "fc3ece43f425eacef2642dc2c6d3fc767e6113a14aaaea7238005a4feab6c74f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, bubbles suddenly appear on the water surface at 5.2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03108", "filename": "fc85d9e1b8422c76452bec2adbfe10269b2b3dd14d86e073e29bdc50b177f4c4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 0.5 seconds, a round table suddenly becomes a square table).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03109", "filename": "fc85d9e1b8422c76452bec2adbfe10269b2b3dd14d86e073e29bdc50b177f4c4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time discontinuity (the outline of a person's feet in the image is abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03110", "filename": "fc85d9e1b8422c76452bec2adbfe10269b2b3dd14d86e073e29bdc50b177f4c4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (under the premise of no external force and no camera change, the toy train track suddenly swings downward on its own at 1.1s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03111", "filename": "fc85d9e1b8422c76452bec2adbfe10269b2b3dd14d86e073e29bdc50b177f4c4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (Under the premise of no camera change and no external force interference, the character's right foot twists abnormally, and the twist returns to normal after 0.9 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03114", "filename": "fcb56cdaa7440eeed7dc8f169ebe86f6ec4b1e178387d1c1264b8527db605235_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03115", "filename": "fcb56cdaa7440eeed7dc8f169ebe86f6ec4b1e178387d1c1264b8527db605235_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (under the premise of no camera change and no external force or object interference, the third string disappears out of thin air at 2.2s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03116", "filename": "fcb56cdaa7440eeed7dc8f169ebe86f6ec4b1e178387d1c1264b8527db605235_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (without external interference, the strings vibrate spontaneously at 2.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03117", "filename": "fcb56cdaa7440eeed7dc8f169ebe86f6ec4b1e178387d1c1264b8527db605235_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (the strings vibrate spontaneously at 0.1s without camera changes or external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03118", "filename": "fcc6f6274ba463949667bf2ad8b8a0352926fdbf7d8ac8e90e09b7785076fcbe_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (without camera changes or external force interference, the table shakes on its own at 2.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03119", "filename": "fcc6f6274ba463949667bf2ad8b8a0352926fdbf7d8ac8e90e09b7785076fcbe_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the scene shows a cup of hot water in direct contact with the snow, but the snow at the contact point does not show any signs of melting or sinking, and there is no physical feedback of hot water melting and thawing the snow at low temperature).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03120", "filename": "fcc6f6274ba463949667bf2ad8b8a0352926fdbf7d8ac8e90e09b7785076fcbe_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera shift, smoke appears out of nowhere on the side of the cup at 5.6s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03121", "filename": "fd0cbaf1f4aa59645f47ab9c881651239d9952bd72acc444681f3e55f9bbff51_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (Under the premise of no external interference, the toothbrush placed flat under the hydraulic press rotates on its own at 1:29).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03122", "filename": "fd0cbaf1f4aa59645f47ab9c881651239d9952bd72acc444681f3e55f9bbff51_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the toothbrush vibrates on its own at 2.9 seconds without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03123", "filename": "fd0cbaf1f4aa59645f47ab9c881651239d9952bd72acc444681f3e55f9bbff51_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (Under the condition of no external force interference, at 4.7s, the toothbrush moves upward on its own and touches the hydraulic press)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03124", "filename": "fd3fe9118eca25641ceb8ddc0a4ed237fe6993bb4404c337805b2d3eb77aaca2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (the polar bear is on the surface of the water, but there is no corresponding reflection on the water below it).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03125", "filename": "fd3fe9118eca25641ceb8ddc0a4ed237fe6993bb4404c337805b2d3eb77aaca2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera transition, at 0.9s, an additional animal appears out of nowhere above the aquatic animals).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03126", "filename": "fd3fe9118eca25641ceb8ddc0a4ed237fe6993bb4404c337805b2d3eb77aaca2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera transition, the small fish in the animal's hand disappears out of thin air at 1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03127", "filename": "e2db6cd480c9f6b6241c4f015901ddaea12ab149d342bc701aed09b840b8e0c5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, at 1.9 seconds, mist appears out of nowhere on the water surface).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03128", "filename": "e2f813cbc7a6420905ccac6be8a065cf7f3940cb3e6d433fb461f8975af84df3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time is continuous (in reality, fog gradually fades and dissipates, but in the video, the fog appears to have been cut straight through with a knife, with sharp and clean edges separating the mountains and lakes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03129", "filename": "e2f813cbc7a6420905ccac6be8a065cf7f3940cb3e6d433fb461f8975af84df3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is not continuous (there is a superimposed dividing line between the light above the fog and the fog layer, and the boundary is very sharp, completely lacking the soft feeling of light slowly spreading out like in real fog).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03130", "filename": "e2f813cbc7a6420905ccac6be8a065cf7f3940cb3e6d433fb461f8975af84df3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03131", "filename": "e3c590f62833a8400ed15d3c2a2c54adf1ec4b50e2c40bf6d5fa07ee08044eea_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is unusual: the timing is discontinuous (when a real pine tree is burned, its branches will be charred and damaged, but the branches in the video appear intact without any signs of charring).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03132", "filename": "e3c590f62833a8400ed15d3c2a2c54adf1ec4b50e2c40bf6d5fa07ee08044eea_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement or external force or interference, the fire in the footage suddenly moves to the right at 3.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03133", "filename": "e3c590f62833a8400ed15d3c2a2c54adf1ec4b50e2c40bf6d5fa07ee08044eea_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (the camera did not move or there was any external interference. The burning branches and plants in the footage, which should have shown signs of charring, curling, and damage, showed no signs of burning at all. They remained intact and showed no signs of being burned.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03134", "filename": "e4a9dfc382de8d4df466753b701cd8a763cfe1616b9a49c7bb65b7de78afc8bf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (Under conditions of no external force or interference, the flow of liquid in the image suddenly accelerates at 3.9 seconds.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03135", "filename": "e4a9dfc382de8d4df466753b701cd8a763cfe1616b9a49c7bb65b7de78afc8bf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: physical behavior (high-temperature molten metal should be a viscous, flowing liquid metal, but the molten metal in the picture does not have the thick, flowing physical texture of a molten metal).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03136", "filename": "e4a9dfc382de8d4df466753b701cd8a763cfe1616b9a49c7bb65b7de78afc8bf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: Physical behavior (high-temperature molten metal is a viscous, uniform liquid metal, and it flows in a thick liquid form, but the molten metal in the image has a foamy, flame-like texture, completely lacking the thick, uniform flow characteristics of liquid metal).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03137", "filename": "e4da568251a7d238daff09d237d0c5c105f45fb415110cc7a6b7b3e82c58b799_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time sequence is not continuous (in reality, windshield wipers are attached to the windshield and work continuously, but in the video, the wipers appear to be floating in the air without any obvious contact with the windshield).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03138", "filename": "e4da568251a7d238daff09d237d0c5c105f45fb415110cc7a6b7b3e82c58b799_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Abrupt change in time continuity (without any camera movement, a large amount of water appears out of nowhere above the windshield between 1.5s and 4.4s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03139", "filename": "e4da568251a7d238daff09d237d0c5c105f45fb415110cc7a6b7b3e82c58b799_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Temporal continuity is abnormal (without any camera transition, the thin ice melts instantly at 3.9 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03140", "filename": "e4ff8169bb629304128b797ba30da8ad47a9384c227ab9a677b3bd8bcc8602fa_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (under the premise of no external force or interference, the toy at the top of the screen suddenly accelerates between 2.4s and 2.9s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03141", "filename": "e4ff8169bb629304128b797ba30da8ad47a9384c227ab9a677b3bd8bcc8602fa_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 0.9s, a car appears out of nowhere in the background).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03142", "filename": "e4ff8169bb629304128b797ba30da8ad47a9384c227ab9a677b3bd8bcc8602fa_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (Under the premise that the camera does not change and there is no external force or interference, the toy car rotates backward on its own at 2.5s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03143", "filename": "e4ff8169bb629304128b797ba30da8ad47a9384c227ab9a677b3bd8bcc8602fa_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity error (the track in the scene disappears out of thin air at 2.9s without any camera movement or external force or interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03144", "filename": "e05be368a1e41488e8de76186badb207538260332af7c173b5ba2dd1b8c51fa3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Continuous time (The ambient light is very dim at night, but the inside of the cup is unusually bright, which is completely inconsistent with the dark night environment.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03145", "filename": "e05be368a1e41488e8de76186badb207538260332af7c173b5ba2dd1b8c51fa3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: The time sequence is not continuous (normally, light shining on a cup will cause reflection or refraction, but here the cup is illuminated, and these phenomena are not observed at all).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03146", "filename": "e05be368a1e41488e8de76186badb207538260332af7c173b5ba2dd1b8c51fa3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03147", "filename": "e05ff3928dc28dd5b92aaf67b581d80dbdf518ede71d85f6de451b164bdb8767_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03148", "filename": "e05ff3928dc28dd5b92aaf67b581d80dbdf518ede71d85f6de451b164bdb8767_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03149", "filename": "e05ff3928dc28dd5b92aaf67b581d80dbdf518ede71d85f6de451b164bdb8767_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without camera movement, external force, or interference, the latte art in the coffee suddenly becomes larger at 4.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03150", "filename": "e5bdcaac3ee2654a30b222c6e84744b1668e6b57bd792aedffa7e5e998d37342_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (without camera movement, external force or interference, a portion of the white object in the pot disappears out of thin air in the upper left corner in 0.2 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03151", "filename": "e5bdcaac3ee2654a30b222c6e84744b1668e6b57bd792aedffa7e5e998d37342_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, at 5.6s, the area of the thin white layer in the footage suddenly increases in size).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03156", "filename": "e5d1551d26d821165975543004cf1d771f2366b3076d319eac487d4a9e030c64_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time is continuous (the camera is not moving and there is no external interference. The burning cardboard box in the footage should have shown signs of charring, curling, and damage, but it is completely intact and has not been burned at all.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03157", "filename": "P26_119_15_8b6e1dc2a9149e7e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (the cabinet opened automatically between 3.4s and 3.8s in the video without being touched by a hand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03158", "filename": "P26_119_45_36803179ef20d5ca_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Causality (the clothes suddenly caught fire at 0.5s without any tools being used to ignite them, while a lighter appeared out of thin air at 0.8s, and the flame that started at 4.9s extinguished itself without interference); Physical behavior (the cloth in a person's hand remained intact after being ignited).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03159", "filename": "P26_119_45_36803179ef20d5ca_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Continuity of time (a lighter appears out of thin air in a person's hand at 2.3 seconds); Physical phenomena (the cloth in the person's hand remains intact after being lit).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03160", "filename": "P26_119_45_36803179ef20d5ca_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Causality (the stove automatically turns on without contact at 1.6s in the video); Time continuity (a blurry black lighter suddenly appears in the person's hand at 0.3s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03161", "filename": "P26_119_58_b7683a98e3cb75a2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning due to a continuous timing issue (during the 0.8s-1.5s interval, the food is cut only once but breaks into many pieces).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03162", "filename": "P26_119_58_b7683a98e3cb75a2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (from the beginning to 1.3 seconds, the knife appears to have cut the finger, but the finger remains intact afterward, and at 2.5 seconds, the hand has already made the cutting motion, but the object under the knife is not damaged).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03163", "filename": "P26_119_58_b7683a98e3cb75a2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Overall, the video appears to be erratic (at 2.1s and 4.4s, the knife pierces the fingers while chopping vegetables, yet there is no injury or bleeding); the timing is continuous (at 0.2s, the knife that was originally held in the left hand suddenly disappears and reappears on the right hand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03164", "filename": "P26_119_137_4c1a32897fbbf2ae_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (in the video, from 3.9s to 5s, a box of unsealed tomatoes is thrown out, but the tomatoes do not scatter).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03165", "filename": "P26_119_137_4c1a32897fbbf2ae_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the white object in the hand disappears out of thin air between 0.8s and 1s in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03166", "filename": "P26_119_137_4c1a32897fbbf2ae_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (between 7s and 8s, the tomato transforms into objects of various sizes and colors as it falls).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03167", "filename": "P26_124_18_6f3da8e1e9b04009_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the faucet is constantly running in the video, but the water level in the pot doesn't increase).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03168", "filename": "P26_124_48_bcf2ac1827238562_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video contains the following anomalies: The timing is continuous (several sausages appear in the jar between 0.2s and 1.6s); the physical behavior is inconsistent (a person's finger pierces the bottle while washing it, which is inconsistent with the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03169", "filename": "P26_124_50_f24bba4d74c15a69_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall intuition is abnormal (in the video, the water in the first plate is constantly boiling without increasing or overflowing, while the water in the bottom plate continuously increases); physical behavior (at 4.6s, the finger clearly passes through the plate, which does not conform to the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03170", "filename": "P26_124_82_c73d8fcbea3d2413_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03171", "filename": "P26_124_82_c73d8fcbea3d2413_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.1s, the green sponge in the left hand turns blue and the two blue cloths disappear into thin air between 2.1s and 2.2s in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03172", "filename": "P26_124_100_b107dbfd7b20ef0f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the visuals: The timing is discontinuous (at 3.6s in the video, the head and tail of the fish in the character's hand suddenly switch positions, and at 7.1s, a fish appears out of thin air in the character's hand); the overall realism is abnormal (at 7.7s, there is a fish with two heads and a fish with two tails in the tank).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03173", "filename": "P26_124_104_486b7c7f8b2fef24_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Physical behavior (the green cloth in the video did not absorb water or compress under the influence of water rinsing and rubbing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03174", "filename": "P26_124_104_486b7c7f8b2fef24_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is inconsistent (from 0.8s to 1.4s in the video, a green rag in the person's hand separates from a handful of vegetables).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03175", "filename": "P26_124_114_34a61d09b467d3ce_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is discontinuous (in the video, the green rag in the character's hand suddenly turns into a cucumber within 0.1 seconds); the overall realism is abnormal (the cucumber is being peeled with a knife, but the peel doesn't actually disappear).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03176", "filename": "P26_124_114_34a61d09b467d3ce_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the video shows a person using a fork to continuously scrape the skin off a green object in their hand, and skin is produced in the sink, but the object in the person's hand remains intact).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03177", "filename": "P26_124_114_34a61d09b467d3ce_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is discontinuous (at 0.2 seconds, the green item in the person's hand suddenly turns into a cucumber); the overall realism is abnormal (during the entire video, the person is peeling cucumbers from top to bottom, but the cucumber peels suddenly fly out of the peeler).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03178", "filename": "P27_101_13_d5dedd3c17dde493_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03179", "filename": "P27_101_13_d5dedd3c17dde493_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (two pot handles appear on top of the first pot in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03180", "filename": "P27_101_13_d5dedd3c17dde493_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 0.3s, an iron frame appears out of thin air when the character takes a pot from the cabinet); Physical behavior (starting at 1.2s, the cabinet falls down on its own without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03181", "filename": "P27_101_248_8da7574dd509bf6c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the blue cup turns silver at 2s and the silver cup suddenly appears out of nowhere under the faucet at 6.4s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03182", "filename": "P27_101_363_cf1042e57cc57cd7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the cloth on the table disappears out of thin air at 2.2 seconds in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03183", "filename": "P27_103_46_86b57c1c31019182_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03184", "filename": "P27_103_85_8b8bc94044e79a61_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03185", "filename": "P27_103_85_8b8bc94044e79a61_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the image in the book appears three-dimensional from 2.3s to 4s in the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03186", "filename": "P27_103_85_8b8bc94044e79a61_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (an egg suddenly appears out of thin air in the person's hand at 6.2s in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03187", "filename": "dd074ba93ce1f3f1183cdec06711fbcf677b52ddc85c792c3af6edd7b02cc89e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (6.2s, a stick appears out of thin air in the left hand of the third person on the left).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03188", "filename": "dd5520dbd4b2d37094af3f68a2d454b7749570e0254ed035406729ac708f36c1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: The time sequence is continuous (water droplets appear out of nowhere on the glass surface at 0.2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03189", "filename": "dd5520dbd4b2d37094af3f68a2d454b7749570e0254ed035406729ac708f36c1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The event was continuous (the glass surface suddenly froze over without any external force between 1.6s and 5.8s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03190", "filename": "dd5520dbd4b2d37094af3f68a2d454b7749570e0254ed035406729ac708f36c1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03191", "filename": "dd5520dbd4b2d37094af3f68a2d454b7749570e0254ed035406729ac708f36c1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (0.9s-3s: the water vapor on the glass suddenly disappears; 6.2s: ice forms on the glass surface out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03192", "filename": "ddaff6cb4d55ed2cfe35506d39b2bc5e2cae187a43f9adb7b9780a71346cf412_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0s the float suddenly turns into a fish, 0.2s the fish passes through the frozen water, resulting in clipping).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03193", "filename": "ddaff6cb4d55ed2cfe35506d39b2bc5e2cae187a43f9adb7b9780a71346cf412_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0s, a black fish appears out of nowhere at the bottom of the water).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03194", "filename": "ddaff6cb4d55ed2cfe35506d39b2bc5e2cae187a43f9adb7b9780a71346cf412_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time frame is continuous (0.2s-0.9s, water suddenly explodes and splashes, and the ice melts and cracks automatically without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03195", "filename": "ddaff6cb4d55ed2cfe35506d39b2bc5e2cae187a43f9adb7b9780a71346cf412_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: In a continuous sequence (0s-1.9s), the fishing float, which was sparking, suddenly turns into a yellow fish.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03196", "filename": "ddbd9547f320939503e5d03ce2c249e82c4b8940f56d6c3a0539e4301e382b27_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At night, when the building lights are shining, the light appears hazy due to atmospheric conditions, rather than shining directly on the ground.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03197", "filename": "ddbd9547f320939503e5d03ce2c249e82c4b8940f56d6c3a0539e4301e382b27_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the small boat in the lower right corner disappears out of thin air in 0.6 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03198", "filename": "ddbd9547f320939503e5d03ce2c249e82c4b8940f56d6c3a0539e4301e382b27_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03199", "filename": "ddbd9547f320939503e5d03ce2c249e82c4b8940f56d6c3a0539e4301e382b27_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03200", "filename": "dde0c775d7af5198c7ba179f774ccbfaaf1494b3043d9250e173b015361dbe0b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (the mouse wheel exhibits abnormal distortion for 3.2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03201", "filename": "dde0c775d7af5198c7ba179f774ccbfaaf1494b3043d9250e173b015361dbe0b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: The duration is continuous (3.5 seconds, the mouse wheel light automatically turns off without external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03202", "filename": "dde0c775d7af5198c7ba179f774ccbfaaf1494b3043d9250e173b015361dbe0b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03203", "filename": "dde0c775d7af5198c7ba179f774ccbfaaf1494b3043d9250e173b015361dbe0b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03204", "filename": "dde158c6c2a5a0c304261f08bb18cc50533198d7f290796c537e29be9ab295a1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (0.1s) A stationary yellow cup on the table automatically rolls and jumps without any external force.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03205", "filename": "dde158c6c2a5a0c304261f08bb18cc50533198d7f290796c537e29be9ab295a1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0.1s) Two yellow cups roll automatically without external force, one of the cups suddenly turns into a small blue ball.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03206", "filename": "dde158c6c2a5a0c304261f08bb18cc50533198d7f290796c537e29be9ab295a1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the yellow and red cups on the table are rolling automatically without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03207", "filename": "dde158c6c2a5a0c304261f08bb18cc50533198d7f290796c537e29be9ab295a1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time sequence (0.9s: Two yellow cups appear out of nowhere in the upper right corner, then merge into one cup. 1.1s: Two red cups suddenly merge into one cup.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03208", "filename": "de0f45309a3a872699a51cafa0823af97757a0bcbe4edfd8ae3a22561132a38c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (1.3s) A green sphere rolling on the ground suddenly comes to a stop without any external force.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03209", "filename": "de0f45309a3a872699a51cafa0823af97757a0bcbe4edfd8ae3a22561132a38c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a small ball bouncing on the ground disappears into thin air after 0 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03210", "filename": "de0f45309a3a872699a51cafa0823af97757a0bcbe4edfd8ae3a22561132a38c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (2.7 seconds, the green ball scrolls from left to right, automatically scrolling from back to front without external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03211", "filename": "de9001dec3bb8c3b3973eafe325f74c5723f1aeac7982fa1a0d613566d9c1ae2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (a flame is burning on the water surface even though there are no flammable materials on it.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03212", "filename": "de9001dec3bb8c3b3973eafe325f74c5723f1aeac7982fa1a0d613566d9c1ae2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (a flame is burning on the water surface even though there are no flammable materials on it.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03213", "filename": "de9001dec3bb8c3b3973eafe325f74c5723f1aeac7982fa1a0d613566d9c1ae2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the light on the left side of the water surface appears to flicker and wriggle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03214", "filename": "de9001dec3bb8c3b3973eafe325f74c5723f1aeac7982fa1a0d613566d9c1ae2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03215", "filename": "de9914e8cec406666d9a410156eaf11d3c34d475b0b93eb3fbfec6e567d829b2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the rushing river in the image flows too smoothly, lacking the realistic effect of turbulent waves).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03216", "filename": "de9914e8cec406666d9a410156eaf11d3c34d475b0b93eb3fbfec6e567d829b2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual impression is off: (The water in the image lacks the smooth, flowing quality of clear water; it has a viscous, glue-like texture.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03218", "filename": "e7f84b8407c74e64220b50eafcf671889b9ed66ed4f12377de8c2b33895630f3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (the entire image exhibits dynamic flickering and other artifacts).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03219", "filename": "e7f84b8407c74e64220b50eafcf671889b9ed66ed4f12377de8c2b33895630f3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03220", "filename": "e8e0e10b0d79f6a16fdf1584f7d8f7e3862525f8bdd434476193482393e664b5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03221", "filename": "e9ef4ca2a19bb297edf8a3cf1eade935066fb5f141a26769f5bba294331870df_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to physical behavior (the balloon came into contact with the fire at 0.1s and 1.3s without exploding, which is inconsistent with the balloon exploding immediately upon contact with the high temperature).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03222", "filename": "e9ef4ca2a19bb297edf8a3cf1eade935066fb5f141a26769f5bba294331870df_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the balloon did not burst upon contact with the fire between 0s and 2.8s, which is inconsistent with the balloon exploding immediately upon contact with the high temperature), and causal relationship (the small balloon exploded at 3.2s and then suddenly became a large balloon).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03223", "filename": "e9ef4ca2a19bb297edf8a3cf1eade935066fb5f141a26769f5bba294331870df_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the visuals: Physical behavior (the front stick disappears at 1.6s, the balloon surface is scorched by fire at 0.5s but does not explode and enlarge, which is inconsistent with the balloon exploding immediately upon contact with high temperature and not enlarging without air being blown in), Causal relationship (the balloon suddenly connects to the flame nozzle while suspended at 0.5s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03224", "filename": "e56b6c9a2751f9e8a22a015258f3eba9afedb11e293b8a4425b06498f0dbbad2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the ice crystals on the right side show branching, breakage, and crystal face distortion, while the ice crystals on the left side are relatively regular in shape. This may be because the bubbles were slightly shaken during growth, or there was a local fluctuation in water vapor flow on the right side, resulting in uneven stress during crystal growth and structural defects).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03225", "filename": "e56b6c9a2751f9e8a22a015258f3eba9afedb11e293b8a4425b06498f0dbbad2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (The iridescent sheen on the surface of the ice crystal on the right is extremely uneven, with abnormally strong white reflections in some areas. This is not a normal thin-film interference effect, but rather an abnormal manifestation of unstable interfacial phases due to tiny liquid water droplets adhering to the surface of the ice crystal, which disrupts the optical interference conditions.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03226", "filename": "e1415c0ab271599971dadc858814c2d198901223b4da8aabbc72d7c5ac43b8cc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (comparing the movement of clouds in consecutive frames, the clouds at the top of the screen (especially in the upper left corner) move significantly faster than the clouds in the middle and lower parts of the screen. Under normal circumstances, clouds within the same air layer should move at roughly the same speed.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03227", "filename": "e1600e6e94b961da064339228ee781f358a5b81fdf228c6adbe62413560f584c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03228", "filename": "e3488df2cc870fd7b3b683e31076df510245fd31a8eeccb6b36d0fcdca2e3d09_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Timing continuity (the cardboard box shattered into pieces instantly, which doesn't match the actual situation where there's only a crack and an opening; also, stones suddenly appear on the road at 2.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03230", "filename": "e6384cbd3f392fa7f2ca0b2d14167439bf05b4b707ac799eddc138b65feb4796_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (the cloud formations reflected by the glass curtain wall on the right have a trajectory that does not match the clouds in the real sky. Normally, the direction and speed of the reflected clouds should be consistent with the real clouds, but here there is a significant phase difference. This indicates that there may be layer misalignment during post-production compositing of the video.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03231", "filename": "e6956f519f9ccf4b204dfabbc10bede5cbb889a0f9f1cce9a681e41a61690af5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03233", "filename": "e235739e9ba0cc7d12a01eb0fd891e531ed6b6eb3cc0b647089d4bccc1fba2bf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the car shouldn't fly this far due to gravity and inertia), temporal continuity (the entire screen flickers).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03234", "filename": "e235739e9ba0cc7d12a01eb0fd891e531ed6b6eb3cc0b647089d4bccc1fba2bf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: timing and continuity (2.7s, 3.9s: the car reaches the end of the bridge and suddenly the bridge appears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03235", "filename": "e288037a3f371cb6b4cd1e475c9ba74e756be915c737460f10a9fe9cc0ceb9e4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the ice cube is very slippery; without a support point, it should fall to the ground).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03236", "filename": "e49ff33a013d048933f2000772211bbdb3f628151eb90af46dd31464284eccc9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03237", "filename": "ad6750f18cc81d5a3f3291b5e1b24cdd20adcbe513a371c4f51a5bddd1229cf4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (Clouds and fog are mobile; existing clouds and fog in nature will move to another place, but the clouds and fog on the mountainside from 6.3 seconds to the last second of the video appear out of thin air.) Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (Light travels in a straight line in a uniform medium; in the video at 6.9 seconds, the light has passed over the mountainside, but after 6.9 seconds, the red bushes at the foot of the mountain are illuminated by the light again.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03238", "filename": "adb0ff37015a1d833cf4cfed8b136569eeb38bf5c451d5b0239af7ced0a139f0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03239", "filename": "adca059a4e8a43bb3aaf352a8cbbd03e6f8d6149178ee615c37daf549132bd39_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (From 1.1 seconds to 8 seconds in the video, the bottom of the ice cream melts and overflows, but the volume of the ice cream itself does not change.) Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (From 5.2 seconds to 8 seconds in the video, it can be slightly seen that the ice cream is slightly lifted by the melted liquid at the bottom. Under normal circumstances, the buoyancy of the melted ice cream is insufficient to support the ice cream.) Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (From 1.1 seconds to 8 seconds in the video, the ice cream melts and overflows from the bottom. Under normal circumstances, ice cream should melt from the surface first.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03241", "filename": "ae7560621c36211ef52d05fa81098a4f95eb13def50545a7b6ddc7cbe1820769_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physics (objects falling under gravity have acceleration, so their falling speed increases, but the water table in the entire video falls at a constant speed in a straight line).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03242", "filename": "ae7560621c36211ef52d05fa81098a4f95eb13def50545a7b6ddc7cbe1820769_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (when an object falls under gravity alone, it moves vertically downwards. However, at 4.1 seconds into the video, the water droplet on the left falls diagonally to the right, while the water droplet on the right falls diagonally to the left, causing the two water droplets to collide.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03243", "filename": "aedac5f59523719b3f260b016844697ff478b3f247d07dbbe6e2f9bdeda2dca2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (both the burned trees and the trees themselves are solid, but after 0.4 seconds the top of the burned trees collapses and the falling burning material falls like liquid.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03244", "filename": "aeb250c1c68c7e42d5b925752c3cfb88adf5e142b71c232011f285578d049e92_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03245", "filename": "aedac5f59523719b3f260b016844697ff478b3f247d07dbbe6e2f9bdeda2dca2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the trees closest to the fire source in the middle were unaffected by the flames and remained intact while burning.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03246", "filename": "aef528ed8a667d6fc0947d61ae79df23f8b139d541955b430dd6351655221655_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03247", "filename": "af548aeb7ab0b0d214a7f5e02255ae4b48acdc31e0e333c895a36280b149bc2b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 7.1 seconds into the video, sand grains poured from the spoon blend perfectly into the existing sand pile on the table due to video shake, making the originally uneven sand pile become flat.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03248", "filename": "af548aeb7ab0b0d214a7f5e02255ae4b48acdc31e0e333c895a36280b149bc2b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 3.8 seconds in the video, when the spoon scoops up sand from the table and lifts it up, it is obvious that the volume of sand in the spoon is much smaller than the volume of sand that was removed from the sand pile on the table.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03249", "filename": "af861e35c1c898c2d2793405ffe9df4910c5f033199089ebbba34be691ce5b9f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03251", "filename": "b0c6a28366315205893874eba113dc7ff5265368f93e9a2450e2797d30ff0818_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03252", "filename": "b0c6a28366315205893874eba113dc7ff5265368f93e9a2450e2797d30ff0818_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03253", "filename": "b0c6a28366315205893874eba113dc7ff5265368f93e9a2450e2797d30ff0818_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03255", "filename": "b0d2d4998b769e7c1ebc6f8703dc70fffb71ac1df470b33659e4bf4a949e8e3c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03256", "filename": "b1a4920f4e63087ca35549c9012c25eccc5f2b002a48ebdd806775e70ca6a1cf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 2.3 seconds in the video, a large amount of red powder appears out of thin air when the tennis ball touches the racket.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03258", "filename": "dc2cda7bfcded19e9fd4aac0682cc491593735f90b64113b32820076089fed5d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (The liquid on the right is stationary on the vertical wall; due to gravity, the liquid should flow downwards)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03259", "filename": "dc2cda7bfcded19e9fd4aac0682cc491593735f90b64113b32820076089fed5d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Due to gravity, the viscous liquid on the wall should flow downwards along the wall, not just the bottom of the liquid flowing downwards while the upper part remains stationary on the wall.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03260", "filename": "dc2cda7bfcded19e9fd4aac0682cc491593735f90b64113b32820076089fed5d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03261", "filename": "dc2cda7bfcded19e9fd4aac0682cc491593735f90b64113b32820076089fed5d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03262", "filename": "dc7effb3b696aa60044f6cb6d59954199c96a0c586fd1258192568196010e5e4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Physical behavior (The image shows plastic being burned intensely, but no smoke is being produced; burning plastic should produce blackish-yellow smoke.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03263", "filename": "dc7effb3b696aa60044f6cb6d59954199c96a0c586fd1258192568196010e5e4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Physical behavior (the liquid produced after the plastic was burned and melted in 5.8 seconds disappeared into thin air without leaving any residue.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03264", "filename": "dc7effb3b696aa60044f6cb6d59954199c96a0c586fd1258192568196010e5e4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (When plastic objects are burned, they should liquefy and shrink, not remain unchanged in shape.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03265", "filename": "dc7effb3b696aa60044f6cb6d59954199c96a0c586fd1258192568196010e5e4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03266", "filename": "dcb6b4aa1619627247fa50ed638efc5a9c9f02184de7810cf03ec264b3e6fcf4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (abnormal distortion of the right glass of the petri dish from 4 to 29 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03267", "filename": "dcb6b4aa1619627247fa50ed638efc5a9c9f02184de7810cf03ec264b3e6fcf4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (the liquid dripping from the dropper is initially clear, but at 3.8 seconds, the clear liquid suddenly turns brown without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03268", "filename": "dcb6b4aa1619627247fa50ed638efc5a9c9f02184de7810cf03ec264b3e6fcf4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (2.7s). After a transparent liquid is added to a black liquid, the liquid suddenly changes from black to transparent without any external force.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03269", "filename": "dcb6b4aa1619627247fa50ed638efc5a9c9f02184de7810cf03ec264b3e6fcf4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (2.4s). The liquid dripping from the dropper turns into ice without any external force.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03270", "filename": "dd0a8f7f0bc9cc7575dd3cc409e2f049fdd9d39864cca82182a2720ef41d4062_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual intuition is off: (When the clouds move in the scene, their movement is too smooth and mechanical, lacking the feeling of real clouds drifting with the wind, unlike a realistic scene.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03271", "filename": "dd0a8f7f0bc9cc7575dd3cc409e2f049fdd9d39864cca82182a2720ef41d4062_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual intuition is off: (When the clouds are moving, their distribution lacks depth, their movement is too smooth and mechanical, and they don't resemble the natural movement of clouds in the wind.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03272", "filename": "dd0a8f7f0bc9cc7575dd3cc409e2f049fdd9d39864cca82182a2720ef41d4062_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual inconsistency (the clouds in the entire video appear flattened and their movement is overly repetitive and mechanical, violating the randomness of atmospheric motion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03273", "filename": "dd0a8f7f0bc9cc7575dd3cc409e2f049fdd9d39864cca82182a2720ef41d4062_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03274", "filename": "dd7cb024e7da691c0956b28fde35806df1083f6b023b28d1505260592b3e1123_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous duration (0.1s-3.1s) - Without any external force affecting the bushes on the left, numerous bright spots suddenly appear above the bushes, bursting with intense light.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03275", "filename": "dd7cb024e7da691c0956b28fde35806df1083f6b023b28d1505260592b3e1123_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time frame is continuous (1.3s-4.6s, the streetlights rapidly change from dim to extremely bright without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03276", "filename": "dd7cb024e7da691c0956b28fde35806df1083f6b023b28d1505260592b3e1123_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: A series of spark-like light spots appear out of thin air in mid-air without any external force (2.1s-6.8s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03277", "filename": "dd9bcac1469adc7d06a2dd97192634b33b23f146fdf8adbc2b5e7c5e8aeda844_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.1 seconds into the video, the horse on the grass suddenly transforms into a dog.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03278", "filename": "dd9bcac1469adc7d06a2dd97192634b33b23f146fdf8adbc2b5e7c5e8aeda844_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical behavior (0.5s-5.8s) cloud layer lacks layering and its movement is too repetitive and mechanical, violating the randomness and inertia of atmospheric motion; the horizon color has no gradual transition and does not conform to the color superposition and reflection principles of natural light.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03279", "filename": "dd9bcac1469adc7d06a2dd97192634b33b23f146fdf8adbc2b5e7c5e8aeda844_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0 seconds into the video, the horse on the grass suddenly turns into a dog. The clouds lack depth and their movement is too repetitive and mechanical, violating the randomness of atmospheric motion.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03284", "filename": "dd074ba93ce1f3f1183cdec06711fbcf677b52ddc85c792c3af6edd7b02cc89e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The vertical sparkler exhibits an abnormal twisting phenomenon for 2.8 seconds.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03285", "filename": "dd074ba93ce1f3f1183cdec06711fbcf677b52ddc85c792c3af6edd7b02cc89e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (2.1s-3.4s, the stick held high in the air on the left suddenly disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03286", "filename": "dd074ba93ce1f3f1183cdec06711fbcf677b52ddc85c792c3af6edd7b02cc89e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (After the fireworks explode in mid-air, the sparks should fall downwards due to gravity, but instead they continue to rise.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03287", "filename": "e69f04da03ebf607069d4684ff0e141209fd142b89f2e1605cdbc068fcc76489_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (an item covered in transparent pebbles appears to have the pebbles disappear after 0.9 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03289", "filename": "e76c984f6cadcbb50122a2b07ff93d5fe2fedaabad84fafd22692b0422b27683_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (dynamic flickering artifacts in the clouds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03290", "filename": "e76f801cf66821149fe5eaf7f93910275b5f9c2ff8ed2fd4a5c06c7d45d539fc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is due to the physical behavior (the doll being squeezed between 5.4s and 8s exhibits a liquid-like, diffused collapse pattern, whereas the doll, being a solid rigid material, does not exhibit the fracture and elastic deformation patterns that solids undergo under stress).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03291", "filename": "e78bbfc49bd509777d96b151bd4b2768c20bf26b5d5628c521edfee8b1925d3b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the water droplets from melting ice cones condensing at the bottom drip down quickly, unlike the visual anomaly where a large amount of water accumulates at the bottom).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03292", "filename": "e78bbfc49bd509777d96b151bd4b2768c20bf26b5d5628c521edfee8b1925d3b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (the entire image exhibits dynamic flickering and other artifacts).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03293", "filename": "e95d971e400de5f79f0d27dd5cc08556de94b5b37a6bf25be46a6577db905358_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the color of the left blade suddenly brightens at 0.7s; at 4.3s, without the two blade-shaped flying objects making physical contact, there is an unnatural pause and a brief state of obstructed motion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03294", "filename": "e95d971e400de5f79f0d27dd5cc08556de94b5b37a6bf25be46a6577db905358_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (dynamic flickering artifacts on the left side of the image).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03295", "filename": "e95d971e400de5f79f0d27dd5cc08556de94b5b37a6bf25be46a6577db905358_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.2s, when the camera moves to the far left, an unidentified white blurry object appears. The sudden appearance of this element lacks prior logical support, disrupting the temporal and spatial continuity of the image and the integrity of visual information).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03296", "filename": "e142afb15282b1569ca0cffe0f5ce1bbdc4683ae37f2fa6f0b4f1bef3a956796_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (The fireworks exhibit no visible trajectory during their ascent, appearing to explode out of thin air, a non-natural state inconsistent with the physical process of pyrotechnic combustion. The explosion at 0.9s shows a highly regular, perfectly circular shape, completely contradicting the random diffusion characteristics of a real fireworks explosion influenced by aerodynamics.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03297", "filename": "e142afb15282b1569ca0cffe0f5ce1bbdc4683ae37f2fa6f0b4f1bef3a956796_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the trajectory of the fireworks is not shown), temporal continuity (the fireworks suddenly appear at 6.9s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03298", "filename": "e202d244ae2368ef1880e19872872b21d43de47dbc9cbb3d4712547324572b13_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (during the 2.5s rowing motion, the oars do not make contact with the water surface. In a real physical scenario, without the support of the water's reaction force, the boat cannot maintain balance and propel itself in a flowing water with speed).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03299", "filename": "e202d244ae2368ef1880e19872872b21d43de47dbc9cbb3d4712547324572b13_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 2.3 seconds, the character's position suddenly changes, moving from a crevice in the mountain to an open area).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03301", "filename": "e250b9560515059c0a0ef9b50273b78c7008565240829ff23a3b0c6140a7e502_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the overall image flickers, and at 2.7 seconds, the aurora on the right side of the sky shows a regular rightward arc shape, which is seriously inconsistent with the random and diffuse distribution characteristics of real auroras affected by geomagnetic and atmospheric disturbances).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03302", "filename": "e535a102f29b6ee7125e1662c00f403a52d40f8cedbdf9a53f3daa70e82ffdcb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 0.7s, the light source interrupts its illumination; the light continues to reflect even after the interruption, which does not conform to the principles of light illumination. At 4s, the postures of the performers in the concert audience are uniform).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03303", "filename": "e535a102f29b6ee7125e1662c00f403a52d40f8cedbdf9a53f3daa70e82ffdcb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical phenomena (at 3.4s, the light source interrupts its illumination, yet the light still reflects after the interruption, which does not conform to the principles of light illumination; at 6s, the performers in the concert audience are stiff and motionless).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03304", "filename": "e662ca7ff71c526d771b5d66284223e09ec7975a26ab8fbbbf6d60ef0bcbdc73_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (3.2s, 4.4s: the hair dryer is blowing sand but there is no movement).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03305", "filename": "e736f8650969ab1696441504b24a9efe5c864d9e429c02a74a0682f20367937b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03307", "filename": "dfc0d70059bc3467084d9f7caee6d25ba8cbbd2d64608b0a5531d1eee87a6a49_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (the camera doesn't move, the paddling motion doesn't change, but the kayak suddenly shifts a distance to the left at 2.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03308", "filename": "dfc0d70059bc3467084d9f7caee6d25ba8cbbd2d64608b0a5531d1eee87a6a49_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03309", "filename": "dfc0d70059bc3467084d9f7caee6d25ba8cbbd2d64608b0a5531d1eee87a6a49_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the black object in the lower right corner of the screen disappears out of thin air at 2.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03310", "filename": "dfd23253cb9e84c64429eb150afb2d5c1a1e893a99c09f44bf63e4d3d9fc1ed3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, a person's finger passes directly through the disc at 2.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03311", "filename": "dfd23253cb9e84c64429eb150afb2d5c1a1e893a99c09f44bf63e4d3d9fc1ed3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the disc shape twists abnormally under the premise of no force or external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03312", "filename": "dfd23253cb9e84c64429eb150afb2d5c1a1e893a99c09f44bf63e4d3d9fc1ed3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the disc in the middle of the frame disappears abruptly at 3.9 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03313", "filename": "dfd23253cb9e84c64429eb150afb2d5c1a1e893a99c09f44bf63e4d3d9fc1ed3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03314", "filename": "dff550be613b1789aae3088e09f5701437bfbac9453a0113a75b057e8d31e5a4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the car body is moving forward in the scene, but the rear wheels are completely still and show no signs of turning).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03315", "filename": "dff550be613b1789aae3088e09f5701437bfbac9453a0113a75b057e8d31e5a4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, a car appears out of nowhere in the background at 0.9 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03316", "filename": "dff550be613b1789aae3088e09f5701437bfbac9453a0113a75b057e8d31e5a4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, at 5.8 seconds, the positions of the front and rear of the car switch instantly).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03317", "filename": "e0a979f603c6b5d29e7502da841bffb8c28a2e47efae9269f6ddcc219570d8f2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (the light source shines on the objects in the image, but their brightness is the same as the unlit areas, indicating that they are not receiving any light at all)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03318", "filename": "e0a979f603c6b5d29e7502da841bffb8c28a2e47efae9269f6ddcc219570d8f2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 0.6 seconds, the white, sticky substance next to the character's hand instantly teleports to the character's hand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03319", "filename": "e0a979f603c6b5d29e7502da841bffb8c28a2e47efae9269f6ddcc219570d8f2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 4.5 seconds, the amount of toothpaste being squeezed out in the footage suddenly increases).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03323", "filename": "e1ce3196a50352b216b8938d64122c4e96a2f3484b6f6bc047fa9ca3e42cd82f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 1.7s, after the camera zooms in, the reflective effect of the object actually decreases; the metal that looks shiny from a distance suddenly becomes matte when you get closer).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03324", "filename": "e1ce3196a50352b216b8938d64122c4e96a2f3484b6f6bc047fa9ca3e42cd82f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (the light source shines on the objects in the image, but their brightness is the same as the unlit areas, indicating that they are not receiving any light at all)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03325", "filename": "e1ce3196a50352b216b8938d64122c4e96a2f3484b6f6bc047fa9ca3e42cd82f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle or the light source, the object is illuminated, and the reflected colors keep changing).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03326", "filename": "e1d002a1b346138ab7f2378c4b4b9da7a1b52e313cd6fec56cd07f01f52869f7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the black object in the lower right corner of the screen disappears out of thin air at 2.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03327", "filename": "e1d002a1b346138ab7f2378c4b4b9da7a1b52e313cd6fec56cd07f01f52869f7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (without camera movement or external interference, at 4.4 seconds, many bubbles suddenly appear in the milk).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03328", "filename": "e1d002a1b346138ab7f2378c4b4b9da7a1b52e313cd6fec56cd07f01f52869f7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03329", "filename": "e1d002a1b346138ab7f2378c4b4b9da7a1b52e313cd6fec56cd07f01f52869f7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the bubbles in the image look like they are made of plastic granules, with each granule very obvious, and they don't have the delicate and soft feel of real foam at all).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03330", "filename": "e1e6cec5403c7099318e158ff61b7bbf34a0518b47fe5f5512144f8ce30179ed_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (Under normal circumstances, water mist, as a gas, should drift gently or disperse slowly, but the water mist in the image is as if it is firmly stuck to the object with glue, without moving at all, and has no sense of drifting or diffusion that a gas should have)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03331", "filename": "e1e6cec5403c7099318e158ff61b7bbf34a0518b47fe5f5512144f8ce30179ed_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, at 1.9 seconds, mist appears out of nowhere on the water surface).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03332", "filename": "e1e6cec5403c7099318e158ff61b7bbf34a0518b47fe5f5512144f8ce30179ed_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, a white object suddenly appears on the stool in the frame at 3.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03333", "filename": "e1e6cec5403c7099318e158ff61b7bbf34a0518b47fe5f5512144f8ce30179ed_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03334", "filename": "e2db6cd480c9f6b6241c4f015901ddaea12ab149d342bc701aed09b840b8e0c5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (the daytime environment is already very bright, but the light on the stool in the image is glaringly overexposed and completely mismatched with the surrounding brightness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03335", "filename": "e2db6cd480c9f6b6241c4f015901ddaea12ab149d342bc701aed09b840b8e0c5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03336", "filename": "e2db6cd480c9f6b6241c4f015901ddaea12ab149d342bc701aed09b840b8e0c5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (Under conditions of no external force or interference, the leaves in the background of the image are abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03337", "filename": "P26_104_166_c94a305fb8c35bf1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the hand and towel clipped through each other at 3.2s); Physical behavior (the water in the mineral water bottle, which was stationary on the table from 3.2s to the end, showed obvious shaking, which does not conform to the laws of fluid motion); Abnormal realism of the stove (strong reflections appeared on the stove, and when a person approached, the light from the stove was not blocked).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03338", "filename": "P26_105_37_5cb7dcc3c3eb8621_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the overall realism is abnormal (the lighter is not lit and is still a distance from the stove, but the fire on the stove suddenly ignites and continues to produce a large number of flames).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03339", "filename": "P26_105_37_5cb7dcc3c3eb8621_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03340", "filename": "P26_105_37_5cb7dcc3c3eb8621_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Overall realism is abnormal (during the video from the start to 2.7s, flames ignite around the stove while the hand is twisting it, and then suddenly ignite again at 6.5s after the hand touches the metal frame); timing is inconsistent (the flames suddenly go out at 2.9s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03341", "filename": "P26_105_38_e98efe13f809f53a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the red substance in the pot is boiling throughout the entire process, but the bubbles produced by boiling remain stationary and do not burst while the pot is shaken).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03342", "filename": "P26_105_38_e98efe13f809f53a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03343", "filename": "P26_105_87_d75f9a0f4f43a510_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not realistic (the person's hands are stiff and uncoordinated when opening the cardboard box, and the strips of paper that are opened are too regularly shaped).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03344", "filename": "P26_105_87_d75f9a0f4f43a510_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video contains several visual inconsistencies: The timing is discontinuous (in the video, the box is initially torn open from the side, but at 5.9 seconds it's torn open from the sealed opening, and the box appears larger); the overall realism is off (the entire video shows the person violently tearing open the side of the box, but the final opening appears to be from the sealed opening).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03345", "filename": "P26_105_131_cb6dc81bc7572b17_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall intuitive feeling is abnormal (the process of folding the fabric is too silky smooth).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03346", "filename": "P26_105_131_cb6dc81bc7572b17_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is continuous (a ring suddenly appears on the left hand at 0.9s); the physical behavior is inconsistent (during the 0.5s-0.7s period, the person's hands do not touch the fabric, yet the fabric moves forward without any force applied, violating the rules of force); the overall realism is abnormal (in the video, only the part of the fabric held by the hand moves with the hand's movement, while the untouched part remains stationary; in reality, when folding fabric, the untouched part will slightly change with the force applied).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03347", "filename": "P26_105_131_cb6dc81bc7572b17_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is inconsistent (at 0.9s, the smooth, thin fabric at the beginning of the video changes to a plush fabric, and at 5.4s, the folds created by the previous folds disappear); the overall realism is abnormal (when the plush fabric is folded for the first time in the video, it rolls inwards once, but the folds created by the second fold at 4.5s are folds created by folding outwards).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03348", "filename": "P26_105_143_603779bd4c2891e7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (at 4.6s, the porcelain plate was dropped on the ground but did not break and instead bounced slightly, which does not conform to the laws of elasticity); Abnormal overall realism (at 2.7s, the plate in the hand, which was originally concave, appeared convex in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03349", "filename": "P26_105_143_603779bd4c2891e7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the porcelain plate was dropped on the ground at 4.7s but did not break and bounced twice, which does not conform to the laws of elasticity).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03350", "filename": "P26_105_143_603779bd4c2891e7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 4.3s, the two plates during the fall become one, and at 4.6s, the round bowl suddenly turns into a plate); Overall realism is abnormal (at 5.1s, the porcelain plates fall to the floor without breaking and are all neatly stacked on the floor).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03351", "filename": "P26_108_10_ffce54d8eb2acea3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03352", "filename": "P26_108_10_ffce54d8eb2acea3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (at 1.5s, the button was only turned slightly in an empty space next to the ignition button, but the fire on the stove was still lit).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03353", "filename": "P26_108_35_5f291453d270bd03_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the blue item in the left hand suddenly disappears at 0.4s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03354", "filename": "P26_112_52_42547f2bb4e3363d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (at 2.4s, the water in the bottle has not yet reached the opening but has already flowed out; during the entire pouring process, the original water content in the bottle is very low, but the amount of water poured out is much more than the amount of water in the bottle, and the water content in the bottle never decreases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03355", "filename": "P26_112_52_42547f2bb4e3363d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the video stutters from the start to 2s, and at 2.6s the rag in the person's right hand changes to a plastic brush).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03356", "filename": "P26_112_52_42547f2bb4e3363d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (at 0s, the pale yellow liquid in the bottle in the left hand turns green; at 0.3s, the rag in the right hand and other tableware in the sink transform into a large plastic spoon); the overall realism is abnormal (the large amount of foam produced when the green liquid is poured into the spoon in the video looks very unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03357", "filename": "P26_115_31_a1b42c0b2275a5b7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical behavior (from the start to 0.6s, the left hand's fingers continuously clip through the plastic packaged item in the hand); continuous time (the bag suddenly catches fire at 4.6s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03358", "filename": "P26_115_35_412c7051789d86a6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (from 3.1 seconds to the end, the fabric lacks the softness of fabric, is too stiff, and does not drape, which is very unnatural. In the video, the fabric is simply picked up from the left and right sides and folded towards the middle once, but the fabric in the middle after folding is not the edge of the fabric).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03359", "filename": "P26_115_35_412c7051789d86a6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.4s, the fabric is suddenly folded without the hand moving, and at 4.2s, the folds on the fabric disappear).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03360", "filename": "P26_116_15_101de60b7e541986_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 1.4s to 2.1s, a knife is used to scrape the plate and a lot of yellow food appears; at 2.4s, the fork in the right hand disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03361", "filename": "P26_116_15_101de60b7e541986_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomalies are as follows: the timing is continuous (at 2.9s, food suddenly appears on the plate while the bag is being placed over it); the physical behavior is also problematic (at 3.1s, the bag and plate are not being held by the hands, yet they float in the air without being subjected to any force, which does not conform to the laws of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03362", "filename": "P26_117_76_addd6463c21bb230_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03363", "filename": "P26_117_76_addd6463c21bb230_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.7s, a fork suddenly appears on the right hand and at 3s, the two pieces of meat on the right hand become one; at 6.6s, the small piece of meat suddenly becomes larger and at 7s, the fork in the left hand disappears).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03364", "filename": "P26_117_88_fbf9fcfd02854f70_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The timing is continuous (the two pieces of meat merge into one at 2.2s and the pot handle detaches at 4.7s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03365", "filename": "P26_118_26_7248997c5fc4c69b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03366", "filename": "P26_118_81_fdf9168b54dbe580_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: The timing is continuous (the screen suddenly changes at 0.1s, and the inconsistency before and after; a sponge suddenly appears in the right hand at 1.7s; and a plate suddenly appears in the left hand at 5.7s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03367", "filename": "fa7f0d3dfaadc59641d62086c576c929658ce2c5084418bc6692bd8409e5e9be_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the white desktop in the image is abnormally twisting).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03368", "filename": "fa7f0d3dfaadc59641d62086c576c929658ce2c5084418bc6692bd8409e5e9be_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Continuous time (In the display, water is continuously poured out of the bottle, but the amount of water in the bottle does not decrease at all. There is no normal state where the liquid level in the bottle gradually drops as water is poured out).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03369", "filename": "fa7f0d3dfaadc59641d62086c576c929658ce2c5084418bc6692bd8409e5e9be_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03370", "filename": "fa7f0d3dfaadc59641d62086c576c929658ce2c5084418bc6692bd8409e5e9be_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without camera changes, external forces, or external interference, the ice block suddenly bulges out from the upper left at 3.6 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03375", "filename": "fa4556d59fe198f85a1d3bcee9032d53ed91d795dcd8eb364f7d3126d17ac7a9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is inconsistent (the raindrops in the footage hit the leaves at the exact moment, but there is no splashing or soaking effect upon impact, and the water stains disappear instantly without warning).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03376", "filename": "fa4556d59fe198f85a1d3bcee9032d53ed91d795dcd8eb364f7d3126d17ac7a9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03377", "filename": "fa4556d59fe198f85a1d3bcee9032d53ed91d795dcd8eb364f7d3126d17ac7a9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (when raindrops fall on the leaves in the footage, the leaves do not show any shaking, denting or soaking from being hit by the raindrops, and the raindrops themselves do not change shape after impact; they disappear into thin air the instant they touch the leaves).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03378", "filename": "fa4556d59fe198f85a1d3bcee9032d53ed91d795dcd8eb364f7d3126d17ac7a9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, at 2.3s, a large amount of water appears out of nowhere on the leaves).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03379", "filename": "fafd9c9ad7ba78eb2aea5df4c2cea3496721cbaa43f07f069ff571b4a0f1cedc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the ball's movement in the scene is smooth and continuous, without any noticeable jerking or abrupt changes in speed and trajectory due to physical factors such as gravity, friction, and air resistance, as is common in reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03380", "filename": "fafd9c9ad7ba78eb2aea5df4c2cea3496721cbaa43f07f069ff571b4a0f1cedc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 1.3 seconds, without any camera movement, two small silver balls suddenly appear out of nowhere in the middle of the frame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03381", "filename": "fafd9c9ad7ba78eb2aea5df4c2cea3496721cbaa43f07f069ff571b4a0f1cedc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (Under the premise that the scene does not change and there is no external force or interference, at 0.2s, the two silver balls in the scene suddenly merge together and become one silver ball)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03382", "filename": "fafd9c9ad7ba78eb2aea5df4c2cea3496721cbaa43f07f069ff571b4a0f1cedc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera shift, the iron ball in the frame disappears out of thin air at 3.3 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03383", "filename": "fb36fb0c0df1a072dcf2505792286fc78a56517bd4b23168d7590a1d8251b280_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the sky in the image shows obvious distortion, the movement of clouds in the sky is excessively smooth and continuous, and the clouds appear to be moving in an infinite clock pattern, with natural pauses, drifts, undulations, and shape changes due to airflow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03384", "filename": "fb36fb0c0df1a072dcf2505792286fc78a56517bd4b23168d7590a1d8251b280_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera transition, the white clouds in the sky disappear out of thin air at 4.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03385", "filename": "fb36fb0c0df1a072dcf2505792286fc78a56517bd4b23168d7590a1d8251b280_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the clouds in the sky are abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03386", "filename": "fb36fb0c0df1a072dcf2505792286fc78a56517bd4b23168d7590a1d8251b280_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (Under the premise of no camera change, no external force or external object interference, at 4.8s, the object in the lower left corner of the screen instantly moves to the right side)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03387", "filename": "fb81dffa4d348a433a8809b0f220a4f542609c9198acca044db07e7b9127feb5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the grass and trees in the background are abnormally distorted, the fire in the scene continues to burn and the flames jump normally, but the burning wood does not show any changes in shape such as burning, carbonization or cracking, and always remains in its initial state).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03388", "filename": "fb89ed7f5d987ec3804a638063577876e9631628b4ca83fe57c5100f1bb1b0a7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (without any camera shift, liquid suddenly appears in the pot at 4.9 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03389", "filename": "fb89ed7f5d987ec3804a638063577876e9631628b4ca83fe57c5100f1bb1b0a7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (without camera movement, at 3.9s, the water droplets in the pot suddenly become larger, and there are no external objects or forces interfering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03390", "filename": "fb89ed7f5d987ec3804a638063577876e9631628b4ca83fe57c5100f1bb1b0a7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (Under the premise of no camera change and no external force interference, at 0.2s, the water droplets in the footage suddenly move upwards instantaneously)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03391", "filename": "fb89ed7f5d987ec3804a638063577876e9631628b4ca83fe57c5100f1bb1b0a7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03395", "filename": "fbb409f97b796033761e4f6938ca7804b098e56faebe829e9607ee899dd67039_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera transition, a white object appears out of nowhere in the flames at 0.5s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03396", "filename": "fbb409f97b796033761e4f6938ca7804b098e56faebe829e9607ee899dd67039_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the flames in the scene are burning without the natural leaping, light and shadow and shape changes that a flame should have in real time. The overall burning effect is stiff and unnatural. The paper on the table starts to burn out of thin air without any external force or object interference, without any open flame, high temperature contact or other ignition conditions. There is no reasonable cause for the fire to start).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03397", "filename": "5818cdd8e8a030041597f076862e4f0afdff7e085a5d1cefa902b3308d58d326_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (after the ice melts completely in the entire video, no water marks or liquid water are produced).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03398", "filename": "5818cdd8e8a030041597f076862e4f0afdff7e085a5d1cefa902b3308d58d326_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (4.8s-8s, the ice block's volume spontaneously expands and changes shape without external intervention, gradually transforming from an initial elliptical shape into a cube shape)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03399", "filename": "5947d38ada897d55fc8aaf9bbe01474f62446fc7afcddd29b71ab39be85c5971_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior (the rubber cylinder and impression cylinder of the offset printing machine are not properly engaged; the paper is merely moving on the idle conveyor without completing the actual transfer step, yet the image appears directly on the paper).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03400", "filename": "5947d38ada897d55fc8aaf9bbe01474f62446fc7afcddd29b71ab39be85c5971_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (the offset printing press is not engaged, the paper is spinning without transfer but a printed pattern appears; at 3.9s, the metal rollers of the printing press and the paper pass through each other directly without any contact or obstruction).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03401", "filename": "5947d38ada897d55fc8aaf9bbe01474f62446fc7afcddd29b71ab39be85c5971_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Physical behavior (in the video, the metal roller of the printing press and the paper are spatially interpenetrating, and the pink printed pattern that should have been covered by the roller is not covered and is fully displayed on the paper below the roller).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03402", "filename": "5947d38ada897d55fc8aaf9bbe01474f62446fc7afcddd29b71ab39be85c5971_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (a metal roller at the bottom of the image is pressing on the pink pattern on the paper, but the pattern, which should be obscured, is clearly visible, indicating an anomaly of spatial permeation).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03403", "filename": "6016db4612ae3a699fd8c9c72bde4b4250bbb8204f2739d318c458fd88cdfb29_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical behavior (6.1s-5s, after the hydraulic press crushes the bricks, it rises, and the broken bricks are pulled upwards in sync, resulting in an unnatural follow-up traction phenomenon).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03404", "filename": "6016db4612ae3a699fd8c9c72bde4b4250bbb8204f2739d318c458fd88cdfb29_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (the hydraulic press head crushes the bricks, and the brick-breaking effect is distorted and unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03405", "filename": "6016db4612ae3a699fd8c9c72bde4b4250bbb8204f2739d318c458fd88cdfb29_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the physical behavior (the shape and force of the brick breaking are unnatural, and the brick is unnaturally attracted by the pressure head at 4.8 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03406", "filename": "6016db4612ae3a699fd8c9c72bde4b4250bbb8204f2739d318c458fd88cdfb29_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (3.8s: the brick suddenly explodes after the hydraulic press head lifts away from the brick, with a breaking effect without external force; 5.6s-8s: the crushed brick fragments pile up into an overly regular pyramid shape).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03407", "filename": "6352df4dad3dd0ae4ba03358bf139701e77030b5970141196857d09b36f03bc6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (a black figure suddenly appears on the river at 2.8s and disappears abruptly at 2.9s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03408", "filename": "6352df4dad3dd0ae4ba03358bf139701e77030b5970141196857d09b36f03bc6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the video is playing at an accelerated pace, but the clouds in the sky are moving very slowly, completely out of sync with the fast-paced action on the ground; flickering occurs in the lower right corner of the screen at 3.1s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03409", "filename": "6352df4dad3dd0ae4ba03358bf139701e77030b5970141196857d09b36f03bc6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03410", "filename": "6466ff93ab75c236d2d0e31434ae2d315cdbe3aa4071332112e8c010d441935c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the ice melts abnormally fast, and after melting, it forms water clumps that sway randomly in the glass).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03411", "filename": "6466ff93ab75c236d2d0e31434ae2d315cdbe3aa4071332112e8c010d441935c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (a piece of ice suddenly appears in the cup in 2.5 seconds). Physical behavior (the ice will only slowly release a small number of bubbles during the heating and melting process; it is impossible for a large number of bubbles to be generated spontaneously).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03412", "filename": "6466ff93ab75c236d2d0e31434ae2d315cdbe3aa4071332112e8c010d441935c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time sequence (0.8s: the ice block falling from the air merges with the original ice block in the cup; 3.8s: the ice block at the bottom of the cup melts abnormally and produces a large number of bubbles)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03419", "filename": "06635b932ce1935b2b6978051bf742b58626769563e9b4b3b1c53b1c9e03519b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Physical behavior (2.3s: The drone's wing did not make contact with the red object, but a piece of it fell off the red object).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03420", "filename": "06635b932ce1935b2b6978051bf742b58626769563e9b4b3b1c53b1c9e03519b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The time sequence is continuous (0.4s: a component suddenly appears on the right side of the drone's wing; 1s: a component on the drone's wing suddenly becomes semi-invisible).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03421", "filename": "06635b932ce1935b2b6978051bf742b58626769563e9b4b3b1c53b1c9e03519b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (2.3s-5s, the drone did not make contact with the red object, but the object suddenly bounced away and scattered several pieces of debris).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03422", "filename": "06635b932ce1935b2b6978051bf742b58626769563e9b4b3b1c53b1c9e03519b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03423", "filename": "6654d2ac6a7bab880d7da9a9c515efd2593c7a75d4ffa2f3c322684e2b724c20_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical behavior (the part of the cloud illuminated by sunlight in the video does not move normally over time, its shape does not change at all, and even the angle and range of the beam of light are completely fixed).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03424", "filename": "6654d2ac6a7bab880d7da9a9c515efd2593c7a75d4ffa2f3c322684e2b724c20_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the cloud in the image is slowly deforming, but the Tyndall beam below does not adjust its angle and range to follow the cloud's shape change at all).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03425", "filename": "6654d2ac6a7bab880d7da9a9c515efd2593c7a75d4ffa2f3c322684e2b724c20_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall realism is abnormal (the sun in the video \"bursts\" out directly from inside the clouds, which does not conform to the real-world pattern of clouds being illuminated by sunlight and the sun slowly moving out from behind the clouds. The angle of the beam of light after the sun comes out does not adjust with the movement of the clouds, which seems very unrealistic).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03426", "filename": "6976afbf24c38e94d52108187a3754a0c57608e09db343405d22ffa3958abb47_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior (moving the metal frame causes the lens to change angle, and the colored stripes will also shift or deform synchronously, but the shift of the colored stripes is inconsistent with that of the metal frame)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03427", "filename": "c5dd4a1a5168876a5b105f14215bafe188c0a56c9cf25bf037221318c26b1f13_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (In the entire video, the egg is placed in the pot. Since the buoyancy of the egg is less than its weight, it should sink to the bottom, but in the video, the egg floats, which violates Archimedes' principle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03428", "filename": "c5e91179588547edae1485b72336383b0d8789c58a577257becf7c82358faedf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03429", "filename": "c5e91179588547edae1485b72336383b0d8789c58a577257becf7c82358faedf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is due to physical behavior (the smoke that appears at 1.1s rises first and is then blown to the right by the wind, but the smoke should be affected by the wind and blown to the right as it comes out of the chimney. At 3.8s, the smoke suddenly sinks and disperses, which violates the principle of thermal buoyancy in fluid mechanics).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03430", "filename": "c5e91179588547edae1485b72336383b0d8789c58a577257becf7c82358faedf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Temporal continuity (the smoke in the scene is drifting to the right, while the smoke from the chimney is drifting to the left; there is no consistency in the direction of the smoke drifting in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03431", "filename": "c5e91179588547edae1485b72336383b0d8789c58a577257becf7c82358faedf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the continuity of time (white smoke appears and spreads irregularly at 1.1s. Natural smoke should spread slowly and slightly in all directions, with the edges becoming blurry and gradually merging into the air until it completely dissipates. Moreover, the smoke is always white and there is no natural transition like in natural smoke).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03432", "filename": "c6c8f4aad6018160f0e4ad53f8d92b9ac7511271b36a323a34a42ac7f91eb410_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Temporal continuity (at 0.6s 1.6s 2.1s 3.8s 4.9s, the diamond suddenly becomes a circular flat reflection, which does not match the flashes reflected by the facets of a diamond).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03433", "filename": "c6c8f4aad6018160f0e4ad53f8d92b9ac7511271b36a323a34a42ac7f91eb410_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the overall outline of the video shows that the person is wearing a standard round brilliant-cut diamond, but at 3.3s, the reflective surface of the diamond is not round).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03434", "filename": "c6c8f4aad6018160f0e4ad53f8d92b9ac7511271b36a323a34a42ac7f91eb410_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03435", "filename": "c6c8f4aad6018160f0e4ad53f8d92b9ac7511271b36a323a34a42ac7f91eb410_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (the overall outline of the video shows that the person is wearing a standard round brilliant-cut diamond, which has 58 facets, but the reflective points are not shown; only the top round facet is reflecting light).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03436", "filename": "c6c8f5bc66cac4692e89703b4a73bfa9098b7385b8036c49a3f0429cce46d195_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows smoke and water spraying out of the pipe at the same time. In reality, only when the water in the pipe reaches its boiling point and evaporates rapidly due to the temperature difference will white smoke rise around the water flow, instead of smoke and water spraying out together as shown in the video.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03437", "filename": "c6c8f5bc66cac4692e89703b4a73bfa9098b7385b8036c49a3f0429cce46d195_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03438", "filename": "c6c8f5bc66cac4692e89703b4a73bfa9098b7385b8036c49a3f0429cce46d195_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Continuous time (0s-0.3s, at 0.1s the wire mesh clips through the clothing, the lower left corner of the wire mesh suddenly blurs and disappears, then reappears at 2.5s, showing no consistency). Causal relationship (0.1s the water flow switch suddenly stops flowing without external force, without any cause or effect).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03443", "filename": "c7bfd4458e5eea2d60c08dc932fbf9ea33078555c688ab9850365bef3345b78e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the filament in the light bulb is not emitting light throughout the entire video, but a cluster of light appears at the bottom of the light bulb).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03444", "filename": "c7bfd4458e5eea2d60c08dc932fbf9ea33078555c688ab9850365bef3345b78e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (a faint green light moves with the camera throughout the footage and gradually appears to resemble letters, but there is no green light source in the footage, so there cannot be any green reflection).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03445", "filename": "c7bfd4458e5eea2d60c08dc932fbf9ea33078555c688ab9850365bef3345b78e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (a faint green light moves with the camera throughout the footage, and the light becomes brighter and brighter, but there is no green light source in the footage, so there cannot be any green reflection).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03446", "filename": "c7bfd4458e5eea2d60c08dc932fbf9ea33078555c688ab9850365bef3345b78e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: The time sequence is continuous (at 3.8s, as the camera rotates, the flame in the center of the image splits into many clusters, and the flame continues to burn and twist, while the flame in the reflective glass behind is very small and does not change at all).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03447", "filename": "c7dc883128f612ad025f632661d804c821a91ab4c2f5096bc39d678165846df2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the wooden root in the cup appears distorted and twisted due to the refraction of water throughout the entire frame, and the liquid appears uniform, yet there is a break in the flow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03448", "filename": "c7dc883128f612ad025f632661d804c821a91ab4c2f5096bc39d678165846df2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The video is continuous in time (the video is stopped before 4.9 seconds, and at 4.9 seconds, the wooden stick suddenly shakes without any external force. In the entire video, the wooden stick in the cup is deformed and twisted due to the refraction of water, and the liquid is not obviously different, but there is a break in the flow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03449", "filename": "c7dc883128f612ad025f632661d804c821a91ab4c2f5096bc39d678165846df2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the wooden root in the cup appears distorted and twisted due to the refraction of water throughout the entire frame, and the liquid appears uniform, yet there is a break in the flow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03450", "filename": "c7dc883128f612ad025f632661d804c821a91ab4c2f5096bc39d678165846df2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0s-0.7s) The water in the glass, which is layered, suddenly changes and merges, and many bubbles appear.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03451", "filename": "c08e3f471656434930fd301fad4ae02beed1825425bb54b1ee73591e0f77292c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0s, the middle of the hand and the basketball merge to reveal the color of the grass behind; at 0.4s, the middle hand merges and deforms; at 4.8s, the back hand splits and deforms).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03452", "filename": "c08e3f471656434930fd301fad4ae02beed1825425bb54b1ee73591e0f77292c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Time continuity (the basketball appears to be distorted and blurred multiple times throughout the video, with the surface changing color repeatedly, and the person's hand blending into the basketball, even though the person's hand is not actually touching the basketball and the dribbling is always done through a transparent layer of air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03453", "filename": "c08e3f471656434930fd301fad4ae02beed1825425bb54b1ee73591e0f77292c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomalies in the footage: Time continuity (the hand is severely clipped through at 2.2s, the basketball is deformed and blurred multiple times throughout the video, the surface changes color multiple times, and the hand and basketball are merged together).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03454", "filename": "c8cafce4b50f59ed06d41da0197333493ab4118510b5c783c80dab46e9665f6d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the left finger merges at 0.1s, the light source is fixed, but the reflective points on the gemstone are distorted, inconsistent with the real light source).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03455", "filename": "c8cafce4b50f59ed06d41da0197333493ab4118510b5c783c80dab46e9665f6d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 2.5s to 5.8s, the gem loses its luster and turns off-white after flipping as the person moves, with no consistency between the beginning and end).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03456", "filename": "c8cafce4b50f59ed06d41da0197333493ab4118510b5c783c80dab46e9665f6d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the light source is fixed throughout the video, but the reflective points on the gemstone distort as the person rotates the gemstone, which is inconsistent with the real light source).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03457", "filename": "P35_107_331_86d13ae6ac1d0141_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (around 4.2 seconds, the black plate suddenly moved a distance to the left of the screen without any hand contact or other external force; from 5.01 to 5.8 seconds, when the dough was stretched, the texture in the middle part showed momentary breaks and splicing marks, which was not a natural stretching effect.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03458", "filename": "P35_107_336_55fee8fe65753a1f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (1.6 seconds to 5 seconds, the yellow door automatically closes inward without any external force, and there is no hand contact or other object pushing during the entire process.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03459", "filename": "P35_107_336_55fee8fe65753a1f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03460", "filename": "P35_107_336_55fee8fe65753a1f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 4s to 8s, the box begins to move on its own without any external force, and the speed of movement is uniform with no change in acceleration, which does not conform to the laws of motion; at the same time, there is no visual effect of friction between the box and the ground during the movement, as if the box is floating and sliding.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03461", "filename": "P35_108_76_2f20bc98fa8c4f15_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 3.1 seconds, the knife in the character's hand suddenly transforms into a fork without any switching action, which is an illogical instantaneous movement of objects, disrupting the continuity and realism of the scene.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03462", "filename": "P35_108_76_2f20bc98fa8c4f15_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Footage anomaly: Time continuity (At 2.5 seconds, the knife being washed suddenly becomes a fork after a camera cut. At 5.2 seconds, the fork being picked up from the pile of cutlery, which was initially bent, suddenly straightens the instant it is picked up.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03463", "filename": "P35_108_127_60887e240d904661_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (the originally silver water pipe turns white in an instant of 2.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03464", "filename": "P35_108_127_60887e240d904661_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 6.1 seconds, the water pipe falls rapidly downwards and disappears before it is completely out of the frame, instead of moving out of view naturally).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03465", "filename": "P35_108_127_60887e240d904661_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 0.3 seconds, the water pipe suddenly disappears during its rapid descent; at 1.1 seconds, after the plate is flipped, the patterns on both sides are completely identical, including the distribution of the yellow, green, and blue blocks and the number of yellow dots, which does not conform to the design logic of a plate in reality.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03466", "filename": "P35_108_174_d392889b239be248_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the hose on the faucet in the video disappears abruptly at 0.2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03467", "filename": "P35_108_211_d5f90343573ce0d4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03468", "filename": "P35_108_221_9903ef1446045098_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from the beginning of the video to 4.1 seconds, the water in the sink gradually increases even though the tap is not turned on.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03469", "filename": "P35_108_221_9903ef1446045098_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 3.3 seconds, the lower half of the spoon disappears immediately after being grasped by a hand, without any sense of obstruction, and then reappears completely the next second.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03470", "filename": "P35_108_221_9903ef1446045098_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (From 0 to 0.5 seconds at the beginning of the video, the spoon held in the hand suddenly transforms into a fork, with no transitional movement.) Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (At 4.4 seconds, when the fork flips, the tail that should be at the bottom instantly moves to the head position at the top.) Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (At 1.3 seconds, the fork suddenly disappears from the frame without being completely covered by the sponge or being moved out of the frame.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03471", "filename": "P35_108_267_4a97ba77d70a7170_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Footage anomaly: Time continuity (The transparent cup, still covered in clear liquid, disappears instantly during the camera cut, leaving even the inner surface clean.) Footage anomaly: Time continuity (The cup \"jumps\" from the left hand to the right hand in 0.6 seconds, without any hand-to-hand transfer or movement in between.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03472", "filename": "P35_108_267_4a97ba77d70a7170_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03473", "filename": "P35_108_277_2c50f65d7115f9a1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from the beginning of the video to 0.7 seconds, the hand reaching for the cup only touched the surface of the cup, yet the cup moved upwards along with the hand.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03474", "filename": "P35_108_277_2c50f65d7115f9a1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (the hose on the faucet suddenly disappears at 0.3 seconds at the beginning of the video; at 4.2 seconds, when the cup is flipped over for washing, the bottom and rim of the cup instantly switch positions without any rotational transition; at 1.8 seconds, the faucet automatically dispenses water without any external force acting on the switch.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03475", "filename": "P35_108_291_6a804b0beb3fb726_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03476", "filename": "P35_108_291_6a804b0beb3fb726_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03477", "filename": "P35_108_402_8e67d318695c52e0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the video, when the plate is flipped at 2.8s, the pattern on the plate seems to be fixed and does not rotate with the plate, causing the pattern that was originally at the bottom to appear directly at the top.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03478", "filename": "P35_108_402_8e67d318695c52e0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the faucet is constantly running water, but the water level in the sink neither increases nor overflows; the water level remains completely unchanged.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03479", "filename": "P35_108_408_5b13ed13cd7231a5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03480", "filename": "P35_108_408_5b13ed13cd7231a5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03481", "filename": "P35_108_516_88b84e77f20fe794_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the plate under the bowl disappears instantly at 1 second in the video). Video anomaly: Time continuity (the bottom of the bowl instantly teleports to the top at 5.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03482", "filename": "P35_108_588_9e46eca0cb81830d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the rag in the hand disappears into thin air at 0.9 seconds and then reappears at 1.2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03483", "filename": "P35_108_588_9e46eca0cb81830d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03484", "filename": "P35_108_632_5470acc36afb477e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is discontinuous (at the beginning of the video, the person holding a purple lid suddenly transforms into a plate at 2.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03485", "filename": "P35_108_658_361dec93bf37aefb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03486", "filename": "P35_108_658_361dec93bf37aefb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (The hair dryer plug was not inserted into the power strip, but the hair dryer started operating normally at 3.6 seconds.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03487", "filename": "e690e0ee6b68e3a4fe97bae15e82d0c3e15d1fb01891411c70ca2b28ae242ecd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: duration (at 1.4 seconds in the image, the light did not pass through the gaps in the leaves, and the outline of the light was not consistent).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03488", "filename": "e690e0ee6b68e3a4fe97bae15e82d0c3e15d1fb01891411c70ca2b28ae242ecd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior (the size of the gaps between the leaves in the image is disproportionate to the size of the sunlight).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03489", "filename": "e690e0ee6b68e3a4fe97bae15e82d0c3e15d1fb01891411c70ca2b28ae242ecd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03490", "filename": "e706ddd7b8735652457151fa7230a0823b69a0bc907a74b3d021ad623b24d1ca_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03491", "filename": "e706ddd7b8735652457151fa7230a0823b69a0bc907a74b3d021ad623b24d1ca_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (the mountain on the left side of the screen changes from gold to white between 3.1s and 4.7s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03492", "filename": "e706ddd7b8735652457151fa7230a0823b69a0bc907a74b3d021ad623b24d1ca_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03493", "filename": "e706ddd7b8735652457151fa7230a0823b69a0bc907a74b3d021ad623b24d1ca_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03494", "filename": "e736f8650969ab1696441504b24a9efe5c864d9e429c02a74a0682f20367937b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time is continuous (dark clouds move from afar towards the shooting location, but the ground does not darken or change in any way due to the arrival of the clouds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03495", "filename": "e736f8650969ab1696441504b24a9efe5c864d9e429c02a74a0682f20367937b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time-lapse (when the dark clouds in the footage approach the shooting point, the clouds in the background change from black to gold at 1.3 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03496", "filename": "e736f8650969ab1696441504b24a9efe5c864d9e429c02a74a0682f20367937b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03500", "filename": "e1415c0ab271599971dadc858814c2d198901223b4da8aabbc72d7c5ac43b8cc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03501", "filename": "e1415c0ab271599971dadc858814c2d198901223b4da8aabbc72d7c5ac43b8cc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the trees in the image are constantly flashing); Overall intuition (the movement of the clouds in the image is too smooth, unlike a realistic scene, lacking the sense of dynamism found in reality).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03502", "filename": "e1415c0ab271599971dadc858814c2d198901223b4da8aabbc72d7c5ac43b8cc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the sky in the image is not a unified whole, showing color layering, and the saturation of blue in the sky is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03503", "filename": "e1600e6e94b961da064339228ee781f358a5b81fdf228c6adbe62413560f584c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the duration is continuous (at 1.8 seconds, a gap appears in the foam in the cup, and when water is used to hit the surface of the cup, the foam does not change).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03504", "filename": "e1600e6e94b961da064339228ee781f358a5b81fdf228c6adbe62413560f584c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03505", "filename": "e1600e6e94b961da064339228ee781f358a5b81fdf228c6adbe62413560f584c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03506", "filename": "e3488df2cc870fd7b3b683e31076df510245fd31a8eeccb6b36d0fcdca2e3d09_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Cause and effect (at 1.4s, 1.5s, 2s, and 2.3s, the car tires did not contact the cardboard box, but the cardboard box had already begun to deform).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03507", "filename": "e3488df2cc870fd7b3b683e31076df510245fd31a8eeccb6b36d0fcdca2e3d09_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time duration is continuous (at 2 seconds, the cardboard box located at the far right of the screen suddenly starts flying towards the car tire without any external force, and at 3.6 seconds, the cardboard box splits into three cardboard shells on its own).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03508", "filename": "e3488df2cc870fd7b3b683e31076df510245fd31a8eeccb6b36d0fcdca2e3d09_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (at 1.4s, 1.5s, 2s, and 2.3s, the car tire was not in contact with the cardboard box, but the box had already begun to deform).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03509", "filename": "e06023d78f6cf8f6060421f248cd340a057adc136944e156dfeefe8e9009f00b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical behavior (dry leaves are flammable, the flames are burning intensely, but the fire in the pile of trees does not spread).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03510", "filename": "e06023d78f6cf8f6060421f248cd340a057adc136944e156dfeefe8e9009f00b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (a large amount of thick smoke is generated next to the flame in the picture, but the place where the smoke originates remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03511", "filename": "e06023d78f6cf8f6060421f248cd340a057adc136944e156dfeefe8e9009f00b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03512", "filename": "e06023d78f6cf8f6060421f248cd340a057adc136944e156dfeefe8e9009f00b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03516", "filename": "e6384cbd3f392fa7f2ca0b2d14167439bf05b4b707ac799eddc138b65feb4796_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall impression (the shapes of the clouds in the real sky on the right are completely different from their reflections on the glass curtain wall on the left).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03517", "filename": "41057413b80cef511a6ead880b42c0ba3e211fc63e25ce3c1ac9f26391316950_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the second piece of melon that fell down at 1.5 seconds suddenly split into two pieces).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03518", "filename": "67980352c819e8ae3ccec7bac8aa2034c1a4eb3b3dead639883ece096ef33f62_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the sunlight in the image is shining through the clouds, but the thick, dark clouds on the right are not illuminated at the edges, which is inconsistent with the dark and shadowy layers that would appear when clouds are illuminated in reality; the sunlight rays appear to be too regular in their radial pattern)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03519", "filename": "259657786bbdf36b0a1b3848da397d45658ab25590c4e451e16ec60b38f59a64_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the water flow on the cliff in the image is too smooth and does not reflect the actual water flow pattern of the terrain).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03520", "filename": "618887273f40e1016acbad78ec95bc92343729320470377b8726bae67f9913a0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The duration is continuous (5.4s - end). The cookie is crushed and then returns to its original shape.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03521", "filename": "686148856f3e3514b4f6815317b6e15a0d697f3dccaef12a470706634b3d7750_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the falling sand is small but dispersed in a large and regular manner, and then rotates in the air in a shaped manner)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03522", "filename": "708722434ac4fddf9fb244eba8fab716516e398163be035f8a9882cb4352e55d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the steam clumps in the image are too regular and have clear boundaries, lacking the light and airy texture of real geothermal steam drifting in the wind).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03523", "filename": "708722434ac4fddf9fb244eba8fab716516e398163be035f8a9882cb4352e55d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the water jet is too regular in shape, stiff like sand, and the boundaries of the surrounding steam clumps are too clear).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03524", "filename": "928362386cbd121ff8c4583b70ceaa9b5d600259a7b23e66dc0c08e59def10ed_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the color of the car exhaust in the image is too white, and the quantity is excessive; normal car exhaust is grayish rather than pure white).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03525", "filename": "6554279989b396b92d3e4c07472527bf32c38506e4b23f139f9f7a4a9a6ae154_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the outline of the ice cube is too blurry, the edges are smooth, and it lacks the sharp edges and translucent texture of a real ice cube).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03526", "filename": "9933058110d2b51baed8fb556a6419e9c8c473637adca595178ca05b0669ed0e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the outline of the flames is too regular, and the ashes of the burning cardboard box in the 1.2s-end scene look more like burning wood).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03527", "filename": "18334341676fa40ea1aac660518e74c8365258bd1606a03a3fc386c3599cbc24_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (3s - end, the regular shape in the screen gradually shrinks and disappears)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03528", "filename": "72195232190d16befcfb6498658829b84e489aacf463b8e55513e84ddb321b75_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The scene suddenly changes at 0.2s, with an extra person suddenly appearing and the fish's position abruptly changing from the lower left to the center.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03531", "filename": "4949992559379f60cc8a7b016d30c20cc543c967823f77ec7f819059bd7635b3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Overall realism (the glass lacks transparency, and the glass wall does not have the environmental reflection and refraction details that a real glass should have).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03532", "filename": "4949992559379f60cc8a7b016d30c20cc543c967823f77ec7f819059bd7635b3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (3.1s - the cup was already full, but no water flowed out of the cup during the subsequent pouring process).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03533", "filename": "4949992559379f60cc8a7b016d30c20cc543c967823f77ec7f819059bd7635b3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (in the 2.1s frame, milk flows directly through the cup wall instead of flowing out of the rim)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03534", "filename": "09056677926468626304dbe4f82f17f2491094bf6e9a5a54f037c9f800844f9c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03537", "filename": "P06_101_107_3cac1f3beca0ff34_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 3.2s, the red item held in the right hand passes through the packaging and is taken out).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03538", "filename": "P06_101_107_3cac1f3beca0ff34_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical behavior (at 5.6s, the left hand suddenly passes through the cabinet containing the items).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03539", "filename": "P06_101_134_a8687dba41c55a29_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomalies in the frame: Time continuity (At 0.1s, objects on the cutting board experience inter-frame content loss, and some items suddenly disappear without any reasonable cause; at 0.3s, the remaining objects on the cutting board exhibit abrupt changes in size between frames, with their volume increasing abnormally and irregularly; at 3.1s, white dot-like elements on the surface of the cutting board disappear with inter-frame characteristics and are removed from the frame without any transition; at 4.4s, yellow items suddenly appear in the area in front of the cutting board).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03540", "filename": "P06_101_177_cc8321f225e6848e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (at 1.9s, the black dot-like texture in the right water tank area disappears between frames; at 4.1s, the jagged structure on the knife surface loses its geometric features between frames, and its edge texture becomes smooth without transition).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03541", "filename": "P06_101_389_048468e6c66a6d79_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity error (at 2.5s, a timing and color consistency error occurs; multi-colored items thrown into the trash can uniformly turn yellow without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03542", "filename": "P06_101_389_048468e6c66a6d79_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (items disappear from the lower right side at 2.4s; white items change color to yellow at 2.9s; number of falling items is missing at 4.9s); Physical behavior (trash can lid closes automatically without trigger at 6s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03543", "filename": "P06_101_417_14f706526aa67c74_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the water in the tank only shows a physical reaction at 0.2s, which does not match the timing of the preceding actions)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03544", "filename": "P06_102_39_7739e47eee44a4fe_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time sequence is continuous (2s packaging debris disappears without a transition; 2.3s the right side of the packaging experiences an illogical and abnormal increase in volume).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03545", "filename": "P06_102_39_7739e47eee44a4fe_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (the packaging bag was not torn at 4.5 seconds, but the hand directly took out the contents).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03546", "filename": "P06_102_39_7739e47eee44a4fe_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (3.7s: packaging is torn open without producing debris; 5.8s: blue item clips through yellow packaging; 7.7s: a spatial anomaly appears in the yellow packaging bag)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03547", "filename": "P06_102_49_65ef08b3fc57fd28_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (2.4s water suddenly comes out of the faucet without being triggered; 2.7s the liquid in the white container undergoes a sudden property change without transition, turning into water).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03548", "filename": "P06_102_49_65ef08b3fc57fd28_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time sequence is continuous (2.2s: water flow from the faucet suddenly stops without triggering; 2.9s: water flow suddenly appears on the right side without any source; 4.7s: water flow suddenly appears on the right side and flows to the left).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03549", "filename": "P06_102_49_65ef08b3fc57fd28_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.2s, the yellow glove in the lower left suddenly saturates; at 1.4s, the yellow glove appears on the right hand without transition; at 3.4s, the white object below the character disappears between frames; at 3.4s, a second handle appears on the white object without any logic; at 3.8s, the left handle suddenly disappears; at 4s, the left glove disappears between frames).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03550", "filename": "P06_102_75_9535d3d9233c8e5c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03551", "filename": "P06_102_97_f250ba16844f2aba_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time sequence is continuous (a black object suddenly appears on the microwave oven at 2.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03552", "filename": "P06_102_97_f250ba16844f2aba_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The video feed is continuous (no transition occurs at 1.2s, and water stains suddenly appear on the desktop at 1.3s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03553", "filename": "P06_102_97_f250ba16844f2aba_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The video footage shows no transition at 2.7s (the knife blade suddenly changes shape at 4.1s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03554", "filename": "P06_102_118_0a09355f5f7fedc7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The timing is continuous (3.7s: the plastic wrap on the left hand disappears between frames; 5.6s: the plastic wrap on the right hand suddenly shows a tear without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03555", "filename": "P06_102_119_b633ab4ada7683e0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (1.4s the white circular feature on the plastic wrap disappears between frames; 2.1s the plastic wrap under the bowl disappears downwards without transition; 4.6s a second layer of plastic wrap is added without any logic).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03556", "filename": "P06_103_15_73d2d7f5a9629785_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (3.7s drawer closes automatically without external force; 4.3s screen transitions without transition; 6.8s shovel pierces through mold and lid)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03557", "filename": "P06_103_171_17ed61e60dd55888_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: The timing is continuous (3.5s, an unexplained white light artifact appears on the surface of the packaging bag).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03558", "filename": "P06_103_171_17ed61e60dd55888_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03559", "filename": "P06_103_171_17ed61e60dd55888_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: The time is continuous (2.3s, the packaging bag does not show any external force causing shape distortion or abnormal volume increase).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03560", "filename": "P06_106_45_3a50c019b97eec5c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Causality (the yellow object in the entire video did not produce any debris after being rubbed).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03561", "filename": "P06_107_29_ca8b1207dec45171_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time sequence (the shape of the white object changes at 0.4s, the shape of the object in hand changes at 1.3s, and the damaged object suddenly becomes whole again at 3.5s without any repair process).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03562", "filename": "P06_107_29_ca8b1207dec45171_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (1.1s the shape of the item changes illogically; 4.5s dough appears out of nowhere under the plastic wrap; 6.5s the dough transfers without transition and appears in the bag).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03563", "filename": "P06_108_0_5a1eaacd9e5b318b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.6s, the top door of the refrigerator opens, and the bottom door also opens at the same time; at 2.7s, the bottom door of the refrigerator suddenly appears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03564", "filename": "P06_108_0_5a1eaacd9e5b318b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (at 0.9s, the refrigerator door opens automatically when a hand is pressed on it; at 2.1s, a bottle cap suddenly appears on the right side of the refrigerator door; at 2.3s, the physical behavior of the object suddenly occurs (at 3.5s, the bottle on the refrigerator door remains suspended in mid-air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03565", "filename": "P06_108_5_161ff4ec96c0d9f0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (1. At 1.5s, the red dot suddenly lights up while the hand is turning the button; 2. At 0.2s, a small red dot suddenly appears on the right-hand object; 4. At 1.4s, the dot on the left-hand side suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03566", "filename": "P06_108_67_af1dd90706354a80_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03568", "filename": "6952816c204af8a3ef1914bceba175d69c3e1291fca9bb6efa0ae7b373e8faec_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video is continuous in time (the entire video is still, then the liquid suddenly flows and stops at 4.1 seconds, showing no consistency).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03569", "filename": "7089983d2a2c031eb591f136f46f786087c2b6f69acb039376464c346e3fcfcc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the large cloud layer in the middle of the video is moving slowly, while the clouds at the top and bottom of the screen are moving rapidly, resulting in inconsistent visuals).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03570", "filename": "7089983d2a2c031eb591f136f46f786087c2b6f69acb039376464c346e3fcfcc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the large cloud cover in the background of the video is stationary throughout the entire video, while the clouds in the foreground are moving rapidly. The background clouds are large and continuous, while the clouds in the foreground are scattered in patches, resulting in a lack of continuity in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03572", "filename": "9058487d8b32ea62d52e615106a32768fba98ed5ae77f1fccb983da73e504038_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video footage is abnormal: (In the entire video, the clouds around the lightning are not illuminated by the edges of the lightning, but are instead a blurry mess. The warm light of the sun and the cold purple light of the thunderstorm are present at the same time. The light and shadow of the two light sources are not blended, the transition is abrupt and unnatural, and the overall visual effect is abnormal.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03573", "filename": "9534744d9a02038d43d502367ab2caf47b51303d8f616740032331ccb884e7a7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: (In the entire video, there are no ripples or splashes on the surface of the coffee liquid due to the impact of the milk flow. When the milk and coffee are blended, the color should be gradual, from pure white to light brown to dark brown, and then blend naturally. However, in the video, the liquid color has no transition, and the bubbles are small and numerous, like sand.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03574", "filename": "9881632a611e617c4020d2aa9bf3af63d6c742a376b8a10c8d48b7452b4b47f4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (in the entire video footage, the flames are only concentrated in a few scattered areas on the ground, and there is no sign of the flames on the right spreading to the surrounding dry vegetation and trees).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03575", "filename": "9881632a611e617c4020d2aa9bf3af63d6c742a376b8a10c8d48b7452b4b47f4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the black smoke above the flames in the entire video is too thick and disproportionate to the size of the fire below, lacking a natural sense of diffusion and layering; and while sparks usually appear around the flames, there are a lot of sparks flying around in the smoke in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03576", "filename": "21941993cce06ccf039bf877cd0966500067b91849377aa03062383c710e8a9e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03577", "filename": "37540883f4b60983300c564a98e142d9d7f8505bbedf6d7c05b335a77115580c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0s, the purple ball on the ground jumps up and hits the wall without any external force, then rolls down and disappears; at 2.4s, the ball that rolled down appears out of thin air again without any external force, jumps up and hits the wall, then rolls down and disappears; at 6.4s, the ball reappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03578", "filename": "37540883f4b60983300c564a98e142d9d7f8505bbedf6d7c05b335a77115580c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: continuous time (at 5.6s, two purple balls collide in the video, and suddenly fly up and hit the wall without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03579", "filename": "040565470df65ba7b00ebd198168ca051c740117e464c12219464b0a018edc41_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the spatial relationship between the bubbles and the Buddha statue is blurred throughout the video, and the Buddha statue seems to be floating in front of the bubbles, but at 0.1 seconds in the middle, the bubbles and the left face of the Buddha statue are stuck together, and the spatial sense of the whole video is chaotic).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03580", "filename": "fdbf52cbaa45664f55a85ec9b7bc999fea1757624c38848f06fb1dfe207a878a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.2s, the white wall on the right suddenly disappears and turns into a street; the beam ratio is incorrect and there is no sense of the propagation and transparency of a real beam; the beams on the left and right sides are different; at the beginning of the video, the flashlight is exposed on the ground without refraction, like a white ball of light that does not illuminate the road ahead).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03582", "filename": "feaf3639c7574b0f077814ba469dff5bb01c86c04e9fe50e2430a0eb3eba3cca_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video footage is abnormal due to physical behavior (no smoke is produced in the fire throughout the entire video, which does not conform to the physical laws of hot air carrying particles).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03583", "filename": "ff3c7d7aba01138ada2e99da986b8e5fe908a33d944efba3df60e13fa528865b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03586", "filename": "ffc86587dc1401ec56c40e2fbf05a1b5f97b32c0044a04c3870d7badff8acd3c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03587", "filename": "9b000bf46954de6585ee7eba224a71a96120d56384a41868bf7d4c94062cc351_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the light and shadow of the colored straw falling on the ground in the 0.5s frame is only one color); temporal continuity (the position of the transparent colored rod changes when it falls on the table at 1.1s); causal relationship (the red glass rod in the cup suddenly changes position at 2.7s in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03588", "filename": "9b000bf46954de6585ee7eba224a71a96120d56384a41868bf7d4c94062cc351_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the glass tube suddenly transforms into a glass sheet at 0s); Time continuity (the glass tube in hand changes color at 0.7s); Physical behavior (at 3.7s, the transparent rod in hand passes through the bottle and enters it); Time continuity (water suddenly appears in the bottle when it was empty at 3.1s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03593", "filename": "9b7aaca74c4915849dde0e232ca783a03b439d6ea3041514d0ce489ccc39d3d6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (ghosting appears on the screen at 3.8s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03594", "filename": "9b7aaca74c4915849dde0e232ca783a03b439d6ea3041514d0ce489ccc39d3d6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall realism (2.1s - end of image) The color of the crystals gradually deepens, lacking the smoothness of crystals and resembling the colors of an oil painting.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03595", "filename": "9b7aaca74c4915849dde0e232ca783a03b439d6ea3041514d0ce489ccc39d3d6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (2.4s - the end of the screen) when a new object suddenly appears, slowly growing outward in a regular shape, which is not the shape of a broken crystal.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03596", "filename": "9b7aaca74c4915849dde0e232ca783a03b439d6ea3041514d0ce489ccc39d3d6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall realism (1.4s - end of scene shows ice forming and black patches appearing, the final color effect is similar to the texture of oil paint, which is significantly different from real natural phenomena)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03601", "filename": "9b96eab4a9ab78023911bca5ca737826cec27c14be324f24e919a1d16b40960c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the water droplets falling from the ice in the image before it melts due to high temperature are too large, lacking the natural feel of water droplets from melting ice in reality).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03602", "filename": "9b96eab4a9ab78023911bca5ca737826cec27c14be324f24e919a1d16b40960c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the melting rate of the ice suddenly accelerates at 4.6s); Physical behavior (the ice cone appears to be swaying as if blown by the wind, but ice cones cannot be blown by the wind).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03603", "filename": "9b96eab4a9ab78023911bca5ca737826cec27c14be324f24e919a1d16b40960c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physics behavior (the texture and lighting effects of the icicles appear too uniform).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03604", "filename": "9b96eab4a9ab78023911bca5ca737826cec27c14be324f24e919a1d16b40960c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the sunlight in the image is too regular and radiates outwards).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03608", "filename": "9b412015ce9e23267cadccb4cf4a0b28e1ffb079527cc6afed82c0f4c06cf1be_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is continuous (the middle part of the 4.4s frame keeps flickering); Physical behavior (the highlight reflections on the transparent hemisphere are too regular, lacking the complex light and shadow variations of a realistic curved surface).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03609", "filename": "9b412015ce9e23267cadccb4cf4a0b28e1ffb079527cc6afed82c0f4c06cf1be_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical behavior (the specular reflection on the transparent hemisphere is too regular and lacks the complex light and shadow variations of a real curved surface).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03613", "filename": "9bd2157e83932228a1fc627f398c176e96f5ca43dc2435b2888afb9c9abd0dd1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (objects in the scene are melting and liquid is flowing downwards, but there is no liquid on the table).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03614", "filename": "9bd2157e83932228a1fc627f398c176e96f5ca43dc2435b2888afb9c9abd0dd1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (1.8s - end). The object melts into liquid at an extremely fast speed without any high temperature.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03617", "filename": "b7674e7a99d422100cc19b900ec2d24a9c92e4d78c06db0bf84772787661e1ec_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a black object appears out of nowhere in the upper left corner of the screen at 4.9 seconds without the camera changing).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03618", "filename": "b7674e7a99d422100cc19b900ec2d24a9c92e4d78c06db0bf84772787661e1ec_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera cuts, at 1.4s, several beams of light suddenly shoot out from the bottom of the frame. Instead of traveling in a straight line, they move rapidly along an arc, like solid objects being thrown out).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03619", "filename": "b9607b38bcecb38ead4260251eb80752907d1587d44a974708ecde7c26c1f4d0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (without any camera movement, the snowflakes in the video are continuously floating in place, and none of them fall to the ground or accumulate on the fence).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03620", "filename": "b9607b38bcecb38ead4260251eb80752907d1587d44a974708ecde7c26c1f4d0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time is continuous (the camera is not moving, and the snowflakes on the right side keep floating in place without falling to the ground or the fence).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03621", "filename": "b9620c1f66b8f4784eaf335b5af685e5d893d009d3ac0c86a4fe39f48a017783_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, a rock appears out of nowhere in the upper right corner of the screen at 3.5 seconds.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03622", "filename": "b9620c1f66b8f4784eaf335b5af685e5d893d009d3ac0c86a4fe39f48a017783_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (The concrete structure of the building spontaneously breaks and collapses at 1.7 seconds without being subjected to external force from the excavator bucket.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03623", "filename": "b9817cfe71439bb40d5cadf634707ae46d324474befbd34973a803ba0867c89b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, at 1.8 seconds, the dirt on the upper right side of the wooden board in the scene disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03624", "filename": "b9817cfe71439bb40d5cadf634707ae46d324474befbd34973a803ba0867c89b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 0.2s, the debris on the lower right of the black panel in the middle of the frame disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03625", "filename": "b9817cfe71439bb40d5cadf634707ae46d324474befbd34973a803ba0867c89b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (Under conditions where there is no force or external interference, the black strip-shaped object on the white paper on the right side of the image is abnormally twisting).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03626", "filename": "b9817cfe71439bb40d5cadf634707ae46d324474befbd34973a803ba0867c89b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, at 4.4 seconds, the white paint on the panel suddenly turns into white paper).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03630", "filename": "b096031fead03fc7f8756af46917e2fcadc4051710f8c98c6c809a19233f9e4a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (The torque generated by the rotation of the helicopter's main rotor and tail rotor in the image is superimposed and does not cancel each other out. In this situation, the fuselage should be rotating uncontrollably at high speed, rather than flying smoothly as it is now.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03631", "filename": "b096031fead03fc7f8756af46917e2fcadc4051710f8c98c6c809a19233f9e4a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is too continuous (the smoke in the video is too regular, lacking the random flow and layering of natural smoke, like a painted-on special effect).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03632", "filename": "b096031fead03fc7f8756af46917e2fcadc4051710f8c98c6c809a19233f9e4a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 3.8 seconds, without any camera movement, the helicopter suddenly appears on the right side of the screen from the left, without any smoke or dust on its fuselage).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03633", "filename": "b096031fead03fc7f8756af46917e2fcadc4051710f8c98c6c809a19233f9e4a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera shift, at 6.8s, small, fragmented objects appear out of thin air in the lower left corner of the plane).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03634", "filename": "b3487526e04297d2f90a6cc94c2a61603209fad4d274416c6fda0f755690ec53_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, a white dot appears out of nowhere in the upper right corner of the strawberry label at 0.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03635", "filename": "b3487526e04297d2f90a6cc94c2a61603209fad4d274416c6fda0f755690ec53_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03636", "filename": "b3487526e04297d2f90a6cc94c2a61603209fad4d274416c6fda0f755690ec53_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03637", "filename": "b3487526e04297d2f90a6cc94c2a61603209fad4d274416c6fda0f755690ec53_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the small print on the strawberry label twists abnormally throughout the entire frame).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03638", "filename": "b7525989e01f8814396629e954eb3c56d2ec8fc10bb54508ab4b6c1f88809e06_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the surface of the towel hanging in the upper right corner of the screen is abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03639", "filename": "b7525989e01f8814396629e954eb3c56d2ec8fc10bb54508ab4b6c1f88809e06_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (without camera movement or external interference, at 2.4 seconds into the video, the colored sheen on the surface of the bubble suddenly jumps from a flowing, wavy pattern to clearly defined, blocky color patches, without any natural transition.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03640", "filename": "b7525989e01f8814396629e954eb3c56d2ec8fc10bb54508ab4b6c1f88809e06_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.7s, the colored reflections on the bubble surface suddenly disappeared, and the originally bright and shiny bubble suddenly became like a transparent glass ball).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03641", "filename": "b7525989e01f8814396629e954eb3c56d2ec8fc10bb54508ab4b6c1f88809e06_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, blue liquid suddenly emerges from the container below the bubble at 4.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03646", "filename": "b9800476e05034a291ba2ca0fe26ff8dc7320aed87475b35710b17242568c8c3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: continuous time (without any camera movement, the water in the cup on the right rises from half full to full in 3.5 seconds without any external force, far exceeding the amount of water produced by melting ice).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03647", "filename": "952e902795beeb3f742119d6cf6a216e08f097166ed518c6433604010e0d40ae_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: the time sequence is continuous (in the video, the large bubble does not drift away or shrink due to air resistance and weight after it is generated; instead, it seems to be pulled by an invisible thread, repeatedly rising, bursting, and regenerating in the same spot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03648", "filename": "952e902795beeb3f742119d6cf6a216e08f097166ed518c6433604010e0d40ae_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (2.4s-5.5s after the start of the video, the huge colored bubble on the left side of the screen, after completely detaching from the bubble wand, did not drift away with the wind or burst naturally. Instead, it seemed to be subjected to an invisible force, suspending in place and slowly rotating, and the rainbow sheen on its surface remained fixed in the same position without change.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03649", "filename": "952e902795beeb3f742119d6cf6a216e08f097166ed518c6433604010e0d40ae_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (In the left-center position of the screen, a person wearing a dark top walks from left to right, and their body periodically \"teleports\" to repeat a walking motion, with the stride length and position completely overlapping within a short period of time).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03654", "filename": "963e38a1e2cf8561e1d4201e24d300a21c20a56af23eb197fe618151ae695ab2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is unusual: the timing is continuous (the fireball and smoke from the explosion between 4.5s and 5s are not affected by the desert airflow during their ascent, their shapes are too regular, and no craters or burn marks are left on the ground after the explosion, even the dust raised disappears instantly).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03655", "filename": "963e38a1e2cf8561e1d4201e24d300a21c20a56af23eb197fe618151ae695ab2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.3 seconds, the fireball and smoke from the explosion in the video expand rapidly, but the large amount of dust that should have been lifted by the shock wave is only slightly raised near the explosion point, without forming an outward-spreading air wave and dust cloud, and the cars on the ground in the distance are not affected by the impact of the explosion at all).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03656", "filename": "963e38a1e2cf8561e1d4201e24d300a21c20a56af23eb197fe618151ae695ab2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.9 seconds, the fireball on the left has the dynamic movement of rolling flames, but it does not produce the shock wave and debris flying that a real explosion should have, and it looks more like an independent fire animation; while the white smoke explosion on the right explodes directly without obvious flames and deflagration process, and the trajectory of the debris also shows an unnatural radial pattern).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03657", "filename": "1061e2155dc47bf5fa52b647704645fc7097464c138f32b86bd7187747964ea4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (between 0.7s and 2.6s, at the moment the racket is swung, several clumps of red and yellow powder do not disperse in the direction of the swing, but instead fly backward against the trajectory of the racket's movement. Some particles also suddenly accelerate and teleport in the footage).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03658", "filename": "1061e2155dc47bf5fa52b647704645fc7097464c138f32b86bd7187747964ea4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (between 1s and 4.8s, the racket has not yet made contact with the liquid puff before the liquid explodes prematurely, and the exploded colored liquid does not follow the downward splashing of gravity. Instead, a large number of color blocks scatter upward and in all directions in a disorderly manner, contrary to the parabolic trajectory. Some colors also appear to hover and split unnaturally in the air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03659", "filename": "1061e2155dc47bf5fa52b647704645fc7097464c138f32b86bd7187747964ea4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time is continuous (between 0.3s and 1.3s, the yellow and blue powders should have fallen quickly after exploding, but they appear to be suspended and drifting at a uniform speed in the footage, and the direction of movement of some powder particles is completely opposite to the direction of the force of the racket swing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03660", "filename": "1061e2155dc47bf5fa52b647704645fc7097464c138f32b86bd7187747964ea4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (between 1.7s and 6.2s, when the racket hits the liquid, it explodes evenly from the center outwards like fireworks, and the color layering is too regular).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03661", "filename": "1197c2434367caea83bb052202a29a5d1a42c4376763379fc93f668497542f78_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: the flow of water over mossy rocks, which should have been separated by the rocks, is instead flowing backwards and converging behind the rocks, forming an impossible closed-loop eddy.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03662", "filename": "1197c2434367caea83bb052202a29a5d1a42c4376763379fc93f668497542f78_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the white waves in the dark water on the left side of the screen keep repeating the same rolling trajectory without changing over time, forming a static dynamic loop).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03663", "filename": "1197c2434367caea83bb052202a29a5d1a42c4376763379fc93f668497542f78_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is not continuous (the tree trunks in the scene appear too \"stable\" in the water flow, without any shaking or displacement caused by the impact of the water flow, and even the moss on the tree trunks does not show any dynamic changes of being wetted by the water flow, creating a sense of disconnect with the surrounding flowing river).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03664", "filename": "1277c81a9fc08439adfe8c6966105399a74ac0b346ae7368c32f39c98701a112_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not working properly: the steam above the mug does not rise and dissipate due to the rising hot air; some of the steam sinks down and gathers towards the rim of the mug, and the shape is too regular and lacks a sense of dynamic dissipation.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03665", "filename": "1277c81a9fc08439adfe8c6966105399a74ac0b346ae7368c32f39c98701a112_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03666", "filename": "1277c81a9fc08439adfe8c6966105399a74ac0b346ae7368c32f39c98701a112_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (normal hot steam will continue to rise due to its low density, but the steam at the mouth of the cup rises to a certain height and then suddenly flows backward, with some steam wisps still in mid-air or even curled in the opposite direction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03667", "filename": "1605e43f0f93c91d57d3f1cd5194f62419867a3718dc00b55ed88d9b760584c2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time is continuous (the liquid poured on the ice does not melt the ice, but instead seems to be \"absorbed\" by the ice, and the volume and shape of the ice do not change at all).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03668", "filename": "1605e43f0f93c91d57d3f1cd5194f62419867a3718dc00b55ed88d9b760584c2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is unusual because the time sequence is continuous (the object being poured on does not melt or deform under the impact of the liquid; instead, it seems to \"grow\" as if it has a self-healing ability. Throughout the process, there are no signs of the liquid splashing, flowing, or evaporating).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03669", "filename": "1605e43f0f93c91d57d3f1cd5194f62419867a3718dc00b55ed88d9b760584c2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (the ice in the cup does not melt after being poured on by the liquid, but instead grows rapidly as if it is alive and overflows the cup; secondly, the ice suddenly disappears at 4.1 seconds, leaving no water stains).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03670", "filename": "1656fb7cbaae4ad4ae22a5f96761be54a412d3f52e73daf7cfd2447b904b5109_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: The timing is continuous (the boiling bubbles and ripples on the liquid surface in the video exhibit a periodic, cyclical movement, without the random dynamic changes that occur during normal boiling; secondly, without adding any ingredients, the color and concentration of the liquid suddenly darken at 2.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03671", "filename": "1656fb7cbaae4ad4ae22a5f96761be54a412d3f52e73daf7cfd2447b904b5109_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (under normal circumstances, the surface of a boiling liquid will continuously roll and burst, and bubbles will rise and burst on the surface, but in this video, the bubbles and ripples on the surface appear to be repeating in a cycle).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03672", "filename": "1656fb7cbaae4ad4ae22a5f96761be54a412d3f52e73daf7cfd2447b904b5109_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Time continuity (The abnormality in the video is that while the liquid in the pot is being continuously heated, the boiling bubbles are not constantly being generated and bursting, but are repeating the same trajectory in a fixed position).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03673", "filename": "1656fb7cbaae4ad4ae22a5f96761be54a412d3f52e73daf7cfd2447b904b5109_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03674", "filename": "1717bf2a1ce06c8842fad4d800c0472666aa3338b3f87361c720955c7b2983a2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the shape and brightness of the flame suddenly increase without additional fuel between 0.9s and 5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03675", "filename": "1717bf2a1ce06c8842fad4d800c0472666aa3338b3f87361c720955c7b2983a2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the person in red on the right side of the screen is in the intense heat wave from the explosion, but their clothes and hair are not being blown by the airflow).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03676", "filename": "1717bf2a1ce06c8842fad4d800c0472666aa3338b3f87361c720955c7b2983a2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (the shockwave from the explosion did not affect the people and objects around it, and the characters' movements and clothing were not disturbed by the airflow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03677", "filename": "59e394f1f4b56d502a830119e7fec54d29f6fd393970ae5dce07a9025171c042_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Cause and effect (the water in the bucket forms a vortex without any external force at 1.2s) Time continuity (the vortex is significantly curved between 4.1s and 8s)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03678", "filename": "59e394f1f4b56d502a830119e7fec54d29f6fd393970ae5dce07a9025171c042_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (at 1.8s, the water in the bucket creates a vortex without any external force, causing the black rod inside the bucket to rotate).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03679", "filename": "59ec80b4353f55c0e9cab5a34f80ca8d600640a007220b9085bf39b4d88c82b5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (no splashes when water falls onto the surface below, and the wood flickers and wriggles throughout the segment).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03680", "filename": "061a05485a8c4b836405bf8fb42bd206b2187e6346876cf90729ccc828928a3e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03681", "filename": "061a05485a8c4b836405bf8fb42bd206b2187e6346876cf90729ccc828928a3e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the water droplets suddenly flow horizontally between 2.9s and 8s. When real rainwater slides down the glass, it will form random and natural meandering water marks due to the fine dust on the glass surface, the curvature and gravity. It will not show such clear, straight lines that intersect into a geometric grid).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03682", "filename": "61cc6f0e3111a1b0192aedcdf7468d97343700111f63ca2eb69dbc2aa4a1fcde_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (the bucket explodes at 4.7s, yet shows no signs of damage). Physical behavior (the coin hits the bucket at 1.4s but does not bounce, violating the law of conservation of energy).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03683", "filename": "61cc6f0e3111a1b0192aedcdf7468d97343700111f63ca2eb69dbc2aa4a1fcde_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Continuous time (the pattern on the coin changes continuously between 0.4s and 0.7s); Physical behavior (the coin explodes upon hitting the metal bucket between 0.8s and 2.9s, but the coin remains completely still).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03684", "filename": "61e4372782ae472479cf6d4d38aacd91fa1053726234f9921cc2bad5812cb9a3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: continuous motion (the trees in the video are flickering and writhing throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03685", "filename": "63dbfdfff65a044bfde76010f50f2ed60f025ce90d72ffcfefbcfc931f291016_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.7s, the flames on the left and right sides are burning in different directions; the left flame is burning directly upwards while the right flame is tilting to the right).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03686", "filename": "64f00f210f3332f13acc5ff989619e8afd559f4d8ee429accc35be42bfaa0b5b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 1s, when the hydraulic press hits the object below, the object does not react at all).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03687", "filename": "65b5395df576889ba103ee96b99fc436cfa679f49f37a13b653ddde073aa94f1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03688", "filename": "65b471917e4e9ac6883ecbe9b1eb489dcc153a7a1e403a67ef43c0edcdceddcf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.2s, the tail of a black and orange fish turns into a head, and from 1.4s to 6.8s, the entire body of a large white fish floats on the surface of the water and swims).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03689", "filename": "65e8ee1d1aaf8e72996116a167a3a21d622f95ed5ac883641eb31581e3328cff_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The sequence is too continuous (the clouds are too regular throughout; large areas of highly similar repeating stripes would not appear in reality, the regularity is too strong, and there is a lack of natural randomness).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03690", "filename": "65e467721f7efeea3d16b5ee520c1a43edf453b586617679bcd24c7a7194eb90_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03691", "filename": "782e6e58e25be1b76c2e560b5805954ccb633aa91e0ad4a2fa8aba4a31f46a29_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (at 2.3s, the train tracks appear out of thin air on the vegetable field, and at 1s, the train engine changes from pure gray to black, and an orange stripe appears below the train engine).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03692", "filename": "783c546b0a8f2cee4db849f439b6e370a429949cb0e3f3db1cfec68f5bf3d386_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous timing (the entire frame of the video flickers or wriggles).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03693", "filename": "783c546b0a8f2cee4db849f439b6e370a429949cb0e3f3db1cfec68f5bf3d386_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 0.2s to 4.6s, the ice cube turns into a large water droplet, and at 5.1s, water from above hits the droplet but the droplet does not disperse).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03694", "filename": "787f1720704d6e68f8b321f464428e2e147ddfb08ac74811cf9480f51e729f2c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the butter in the pot does not melt during heating, but the amount of butter in the pot keeps increasing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03695", "filename": "801e7319dacbc25d091c1050f3e2267324c8ec402eb0567177f553a13a1e741b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (Throughout the entire sequence, clouds and mist continuously appear out of nowhere from inside the mountain and drift to the right).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03696", "filename": "806be68d232d662b30e4d95b8033d1d0d0d7c196db5a0b88a271febb56dbfbfe_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (at the beginning of the video, the hand is constantly pressing the switch, but at 1.8 seconds, the hand does not remove the switch, yet the light goes out before the switch is released).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03697", "filename": "533681d7a9f719d068fac13091e113f2439a77dc288dabfba36984e6085838b9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03698", "filename": "533681d7a9f719d068fac13091e113f2439a77dc288dabfba36984e6085838b9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (the light bulb is not affected by any interference throughout the video. At 0.9s, the light bulb suddenly dims. From 0.9s to 5.8s, the light bulb gradually brightens from the bottom to the top of the wick. At 5.8s, the light bulb suddenly becomes a large ball of light.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03699", "filename": "533681d7a9f719d068fac13091e113f2439a77dc288dabfba36984e6085838b9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03700", "filename": "537703e215c4ff4404577f468c02c164660df132849a7c805eaa5628297d0118_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the smoke drifting from the bucket in the entire video appears to move more like liquid than real smoke, lacking the sense of movement that real smoke should have when it drifts).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03701", "filename": "537703e215c4ff4404577f468c02c164660df132849a7c805eaa5628297d0118_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (at 0.6s, a large amount of smoke suddenly sprays out of the bucket. At 6.8s, the smoke disappears out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03702", "filename": "552363b5bafb38d377c4b2144045390b74034cfd094976220804c7b2a87c21e3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (between 1.18 and 3.5 seconds, the diamond bow in the image rotates 180 degrees without any external force.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03703", "filename": "552363b5bafb38d377c4b2144045390b74034cfd094976220804c7b2a87c21e3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual effect is abnormal (the luster and lighting effects of the diamonds in the image are too exaggerated, the reflections of the diamonds and metal parts are unnatural, and it has a strong digital rendering feel, making it more like a virtual 3D model than real jewelry).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03704", "filename": "552363b5bafb38d377c4b2144045390b74034cfd094976220804c7b2a87c21e3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03705", "filename": "552363b5bafb38d377c4b2144045390b74034cfd094976220804c7b2a87c21e3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: The overall visual presentation is abnormal (the bow section exhibits a distorted, three-dimensional, floating effect; while a normal ring's metal band is closed, this ring's band is completely integrated with the bow decoration, and a semi-transparent mirror image is superimposed on the image, disrupting the spatial logic of a realistic object. The luster of the diamonds and metal is excessively exaggerated, and the reflections have a strong digital rendering feel, especially the diamond cluster at the center of the bow, whose refraction effect resembles a virtual 3D model effect rather than the natural reflection of real jewelry.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03706", "filename": "565269a921d4caa443603865a626db63e375db8ba6169db180b96bf0a83c2c98_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03707", "filename": "565269a921d4caa443603865a626db63e375db8ba6169db180b96bf0a83c2c98_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (Normal light reflection on water should be a continuous, soft, ripple-like pattern. However, the reflection in the image presents a clear array of pixel blocks, with colors separated into discrete red, green, and blue dots, resembling the pixel structure of a digital screen rather than the natural reflection of real water.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03708", "filename": "565269a921d4caa443603865a626db63e375db8ba6169db180b96bf0a83c2c98_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03709", "filename": "565269a921d4caa443603865a626db63e375db8ba6169db180b96bf0a83c2c98_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03710", "filename": "581043ba9072a9788fc124d904e26ab7eb6fb4bf8a446cfc4bdd522475480b2a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.4s, the hand of the figure on the left side of the glass bowl suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03711", "filename": "613939fcb3f44aa4b0901a3317ef601ee06799371ccb83b6115567ce53e94794_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is continuous (the entire video shows a wheel running over five bananas in sequence, but after the wheel runs over the bananas, the shape of the five bananas does not change at all).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03712", "filename": "613939fcb3f44aa4b0901a3317ef601ee06799371ccb83b6115567ce53e94794_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (A normally crushed banana should have a realistic, moist, and soft texture in its flesh and peel, but the banana in the image has clear pixelated textures. The tearing and stretching of the flesh and peel after being crushed should be random and natural, but the edges of the banana in the image are too regular, and the texture on the peel has a clear digital drawing feel, unlike a realistic image. It lacks the irregular wrinkles and sticky effects of a real object being crushed.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03713", "filename": "613939fcb3f44aa4b0901a3317ef601ee06799371ccb83b6115567ce53e94794_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Abnormality: Overall visual abnormality (In a real crushed banana, the peel and flesh would stick together and appear soft and broken. However, the banana in the picture maintains a complete separation of \"peel\" and \"flesh,\" and some banana peels even retain an almost intact strip shape. This is completely inconsistent with the physical state after being crushed. A normally crushed banana would have a moist and sticky texture.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03714", "filename": "688413cdcc7d6cd0e6bb88df388e66800fd1f90637cea553d24eb8bdd7378b61_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual appearance is abnormal (the movement of the water does not resemble real water flow; it looks more like a viscous liquid, lacking the random splashing and natural branching that real water flow should have).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03715", "filename": "688413cdcc7d6cd0e6bb88df388e66800fd1f90637cea553d24eb8bdd7378b61_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual appearance is abnormal (the movement of the water does not resemble real water flow; it looks more like a viscous liquid, lacking the random splashing and natural branching that real water flow should have).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03716", "filename": "688413cdcc7d6cd0e6bb88df388e66800fd1f90637cea553d24eb8bdd7378b61_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual appearance is abnormal (the movement of the water does not resemble real water flow; it looks more like a viscous liquid, lacking the random splashing and natural branching that real water flow should have).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03717", "filename": "688413cdcc7d6cd0e6bb88df388e66800fd1f90637cea553d24eb8bdd7378b61_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03718", "filename": "692018d1ff0846151035e05fa0b7a80fd35d10b7d6756ff7a1bf015a8b477932_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual presentation is abnormal (the movement of the smoke from the hot spring in the entire video resembles the movement of flowing water, lacking the realistic sense of smoke drifting).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03719", "filename": "692018d1ff0846151035e05fa0b7a80fd35d10b7d6756ff7a1bf015a8b477932_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual presentation is abnormal (the movement of the smoke from the hot spring in the entire video resembles the movement of flowing water, lacking the realistic sense of smoke drifting).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03720", "filename": "692018d1ff0846151035e05fa0b7a80fd35d10b7d6756ff7a1bf015a8b477932_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03721", "filename": "0707006bc4943c020ea2ecd70d02763c13cbc216df5a82331615f19bde843656_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03722", "filename": "0707006bc4943c020ea2ecd70d02763c13cbc216df5a82331615f19bde843656_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (Real lava flows viscous and slowly, with natural undulations and a solidified crust on the surface. However, the lava in the image has overly sharp edges, and its color shows a uniform gradient from bright white to yellow, lacking the rough texture and viscous flow of real lava.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03723", "filename": "0707006bc4943c020ea2ecd70d02763c13cbc216df5a82331615f19bde843656_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (real lava flows viscous and slowly, with natural undulations and a solidified crust on the surface; the lava in the image flows very fast, more like the movement of water, lacking the rough texture and viscous feel of real lava.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03724", "filename": "0707006bc4943c020ea2ecd70d02763c13cbc216df5a82331615f19bde843656_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (real lava flows viscous and slowly, with natural undulations and a solidified crust on the surface; the lava in the image flows very fast, more like the movement of water, lacking the rough texture and viscous feel of real lava.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03725", "filename": "709881af7a7f86fc383d5c5f1fc120babfc3435a62cb1d3d3d5b16f072abc3e3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.2 seconds, the flames from the explosion suddenly disappeared).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03726", "filename": "709881af7a7f86fc383d5c5f1fc120babfc3435a62cb1d3d3d5b16f072abc3e3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Time Continuity (A real explosion would produce strong light and impact marks on the surrounding ground and rocks, but the ground and background in the image show no signs of being illuminated or damaged by the explosion.) Physical Behavior (In a real explosion, flames are high-temperature burning gases that burst instantly and dissipate quickly, while smoke is composed of burning particles that rise slowly into the air; however, in the image, the flames are completely attached to the smoke and rise synchronously.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03729", "filename": "57afa1e67071c41adc9dca4f762d41dee0a8b09b3eb906ba8a64979c774bde3d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03730", "filename": "57afa1e67071c41adc9dca4f762d41dee0a8b09b3eb906ba8a64979c774bde3d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the overall visuals are abnormal (starting at 0.8 seconds, the video shows chicken being grilled, but the raw chicken suddenly becomes cooked).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03731", "filename": "57afa1e67071c41adc9dca4f762d41dee0a8b09b3eb906ba8a64979c774bde3d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03732", "filename": "57afa1e67071c41adc9dca4f762d41dee0a8b09b3eb906ba8a64979c774bde3d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Overall, the visuals are abnormal: (When grilling chicken, the fire suddenly intensifies and does not immediately subside but persists for a period of time).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03733", "filename": "57bfde2b4b7bb85c6aaf261a25a58406e7a1d751a9f26873ae67512d932d47c0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Abnormal physical behavior: (There is too much water on the two cherries; the water on the cherries did not move during their movement before the collision, it should have slid or even fallen off; the water ejected between the two cherries after the collision does not have the spray-like effect shown in the video.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03734", "filename": "57bfde2b4b7bb85c6aaf261a25a58406e7a1d751a9f26873ae67512d932d47c0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Abnormal physical behavior (the water droplets attached to the two cherries showed no signs of movement before the collision; the deformation of the two cherries upon impact was exaggerated, resembling rubber balls rather than fruits).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03735", "filename": "57bfde2b4b7bb85c6aaf261a25a58406e7a1d751a9f26873ae67512d932d47c0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical anomalies: (Water droplets showed no movement before the two cherries collided; excessive water was produced during the collision, unlike the amount of water adhering to the surface; the water on the collision surface remained unchanged after the collision.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03736", "filename": "57d7fd5406b87e3c9ac775afbc035f9171f0a376815d2ebebbd689981664298c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall, the visuals are unusual (the third dancer in the wall image has no hands, and the fourth dancer has no left hand).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03737", "filename": "57d7fd5406b87e3c9ac775afbc035f9171f0a376815d2ebebbd689981664298c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The imagery is unusual: the overall impression is off (there are two girls in the photo on the wall, but only one person's leg is visible).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03738", "filename": "57d7fd5406b87e3c9ac775afbc035f9171f0a376815d2ebebbd689981664298c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall, the visual impression is off (the light from the bedside lamp is too glaring).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03739", "filename": "57dffd2b72c28013c2abdbf44f6222cddf101439a0a96a398b0a9e9ef64f8774_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual intuition is abnormal (fingers are too brightly colored, and only the thumbs have fingernails while the other thumbs do not).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03740", "filename": "57dffd2b72c28013c2abdbf44f6222cddf101439a0a96a398b0a9e9ef64f8774_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual intuition is abnormal (fingers are too brightly colored, and only the thumbs have fingernails while the other thumbs do not).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03741", "filename": "57dffd2b72c28013c2abdbf44f6222cddf101439a0a96a398b0a9e9ef64f8774_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (fingers are too brightly colored, and only the thumbs have fingernails while the other thumbs do not).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03742", "filename": "57dffd2b72c28013c2abdbf44f6222cddf101439a0a96a398b0a9e9ef64f8774_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03743", "filename": "57e540581b04a66e7a9db5e4188599d23dc724a2e9d59506930f51e3a8d40ac1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the clouds in the video are moving too fast, exceeding the normal range for cloud movement, and the Tyndall effect in the video lasts for an excessively long time; in reality, the Tyndall effect does not last for an extended period.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03744", "filename": "57e540581b04a66e7a9db5e4188599d23dc724a2e9d59506930f51e3a8d40ac1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Abnormal physical behavior: (At 1.3s in the video, only two beams of light from the sky move in the opposite direction to their original propagation path, violating the principle of light propagation; the clouds in the video move faster than the speed range of cloud movement.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03745", "filename": "57e540581b04a66e7a9db5e4188599d23dc724a2e9d59506930f51e3a8d40ac1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (the speed of the clouds in the video is too fast, which exceeds the speed range of cloud movement and does not conform to the natural laws of cloud movement).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03746", "filename": "57e540581b04a66e7a9db5e4188599d23dc724a2e9d59506930f51e3a8d40ac1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the clouds suddenly thin out and the scene transitions directly to a sunset, which is contrary to natural laws; the overall lighting in the scene does not resemble natural light but rather the light emitted by a searchlight).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03747", "filename": "58f2522c892b5f6aef44e1d9fcd482943ca4bae2d9e251309919f3caadf3a3b0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Abnormal physical behavior (the large water bubbles appearing in the water between 0.4s and 2.8s do not conform to inertial motion and could not have occurred without contact).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03748", "filename": "59b1243dae22faa4ab9ca633c18839c3905a8eef717b74bd20ffa7b5df750ec7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03749", "filename": "59b1243dae22faa4ab9ca633c18839c3905a8eef717b74bd20ffa7b5df750ec7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (the white plastic rod in the image gradually shortens without external force, the green object on the right expands out of thin air, and the green object on the left shrinks out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03750", "filename": "59b1243dae22faa4ab9ca633c18839c3905a8eef717b74bd20ffa7b5df750ec7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (the green object on the right stands up on its own at 2 seconds without any external force, which does not conform to the laws of motion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03751", "filename": "59b1243dae22faa4ab9ca633c18839c3905a8eef717b74bd20ffa7b5df750ec7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03752", "filename": "59e94a5a37f6342492e9e04033d6178fa46f84e2dadb24dd4d0f15d4cae6d901_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the prism displays both blue and yellow colors at 0.4s, but only blue after 0.4s, which does not conform to the principles of light propagation and reflection).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03753", "filename": "59e94a5a37f6342492e9e04033d6178fa46f84e2dadb24dd4d0f15d4cae6d901_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (the yellow light appears in the wrong location and at the wrong time; no actual yellow light is visible, only a mirror image is displayed.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03754", "filename": "59e94a5a37f6342492e9e04033d6178fa46f84e2dadb24dd4d0f15d4cae6d901_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the light in the video is flashing, but the light reflected in the prism is constantly on).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03755", "filename": "59e394f1f4b56d502a830119e7fec54d29f6fd393970ae5dce07a9025171c042_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical anomaly (the whirlpool in the water should be formed by the wooden stick in the water rotating from bottom to top, not appearing out of thin air from top to bottom).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03756", "filename": "59e394f1f4b56d502a830119e7fec54d29f6fd393970ae5dce07a9025171c042_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical anomaly (In the bucket, the whirlpool should be caused by the stick rotating and moving the water, not the water moving the stick. The color of the whirlpool should be white, not blue).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03757", "filename": "59ec80b4353f55c0e9cab5a34f80ca8d600640a007220b9085bf39b4d88c82b5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03758", "filename": "59ec80b4353f55c0e9cab5a34f80ca8d600640a007220b9085bf39b4d88c82b5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03759", "filename": "59ec80b4353f55c0e9cab5a34f80ca8d600640a007220b9085bf39b4d88c82b5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03760", "filename": "59ec80b4353f55c0e9cab5a34f80ca8d600640a007220b9085bf39b4d88c82b5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03761", "filename": "59fb0763f22e2390650017d65c6a39d79aeee9799abaa1541d41d7207a0f1375_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (the rubber band in the image is clipping through the hand).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03762", "filename": "59fb0763f22e2390650017d65c6a39d79aeee9799abaa1541d41d7207a0f1375_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical anomaly (at 2 seconds, the yellow rubber band on the character's left hand suddenly pierces through the character's left thumb, which is inconsistent with the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03763", "filename": "59fb0763f22e2390650017d65c6a39d79aeee9799abaa1541d41d7207a0f1375_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03764", "filename": "59fb0763f22e2390650017d65c6a39d79aeee9799abaa1541d41d7207a0f1375_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03765", "filename": "59fd4d72916676819755f099e0b712e9e8d904efe100591762ea89edb10cc0af_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03766", "filename": "59fd4d72916676819755f099e0b712e9e8d904efe100591762ea89edb10cc0af_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03767", "filename": "4d2460e7173fd0461286590cea07d13a5ea2dda5929db2484934197284122f92_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality: When the container rotates, the white object inside does not rotate with the container.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03768", "filename": "4d2460e7173fd0461286590cea07d13a5ea2dda5929db2484934197284122f92_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03769", "filename": "4d2460e7173fd0461286590cea07d13a5ea2dda5929db2484934197284122f92_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: In a continuous sequence of events, a white object inside a container spontaneously enlarges without any external force.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03770", "filename": "4d2460e7173fd0461286590cea07d13a5ea2dda5929db2484934197284122f92_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: During the continuous time frame, from 2.9s to 3.3s, the area below the white object in the container disappears and merges with the area above it.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03771", "filename": "4d182135f12a719f61590fb919ef2a612e9a8777203e48b4b25e41a772b81d71_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: In a continuous sequence of events, at 0.1 seconds, a magnet suddenly appears in the palm of the character's left hand. Between 0.2 seconds and 0.4 seconds, of the four magnets originally in the hand, the two closest to the left hand suddenly disappear.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03772", "filename": "4d182135f12a719f61590fb919ef2a612e9a8777203e48b4b25e41a772b81d71_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: During the continuous time frame (0.2s-5.8s), the four magnets near the character's left hand twist, and the two magnets near the right hand suddenly disappear at 2.8s.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03773", "filename": "4d182135f12a719f61590fb919ef2a612e9a8777203e48b4b25e41a772b81d71_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly occurred: During continuous time, a black dot suddenly appeared on the left side of the liquid surface at 0.6 seconds and disappeared at 0.9 seconds.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03774", "filename": "4dc521176861484c61b6527d9f29b817cb8f131f610cd0ca39ff2ebee765544e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time frame is continuous; between 2.4s and 5.8s, the liquid changes from light brown to dark brown.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03775", "filename": "4dc521176861484c61b6527d9f29b817cb8f131f610cd0ca39ff2ebee765544e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03776", "filename": "4dc521176861484c61b6527d9f29b817cb8f131f610cd0ca39ff2ebee765544e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The sequence is continuous, with liquid being added to the cup repeatedly, yet the water level in the cup does not rise.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03777", "filename": "4e4c1b7e1ebf2ecceb5a97e132d24698ae6ed4b64020f099ba0d5e85c399863a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03778", "filename": "4e4c1b7e1ebf2ecceb5a97e132d24698ae6ed4b64020f099ba0d5e85c399863a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Due to physics, between 1.4s and 1.7s, the water glass in the character's hand is tilted, and the water has reached the rim, but it remains there instead of being poured out. This creates a visual contradiction. Furthermore, after a dark liquid is poured into a transparent beaker, the brightness of the obscured white checkerboard pattern appears unchanged.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03779", "filename": "4e4c1b7e1ebf2ecceb5a97e132d24698ae6ed4b64020f099ba0d5e85c399863a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: In physical terms, when a transparent object obscures the background, the visual information of the background should change due to the transparency of the object. However, in this demonstration, the beaker's obstruction did not affect the visual effect of the checkerboard pattern in the background.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03780", "filename": "4e4c1b7e1ebf2ecceb5a97e132d24698ae6ed4b64020f099ba0d5e85c399863a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physically, when a transparent object obscures a background, the background's visual information should change in brightness or color due to the passage of the object. However, in this demonstration, even after water was poured in, the checkerboard pattern behind the beaker appeared exactly the same as the unobscured checkerboard pattern, violating this physical intuition.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03781", "filename": "4e8ff0987e4b03a3d3e83e42120e96047b33bbe1264c77178d0435c4309fada6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: In a continuous sequence, a cloud suddenly appears in the upper left corner of the frame; its size, position, and shape remain unchanged even when the camera zooms in.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03782", "filename": "4e8ff0987e4b03a3d3e83e42120e96047b33bbe1264c77178d0435c4309fada6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: The overall visual effect is abnormal. The image creates a sense of depth as if viewed from above, but this is actually a visual illusion created by the 2D screen through color gradations and texture variations. Real-world depth perception relies on physical mechanisms such as binocular parallax and atmospheric perspective, while the screen only simulates this effect through a flat image, lacking true spatial depth.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03783", "filename": "4e86fa4bd2058dda2a4aa8d081ee09dba84ca8f25aef63df8e9f291da577be0b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image appears to be nonsensical: During the continuous time frame (1.5s-7.9s), the lake water near the glacier spontaneously creates waves, giving the impression of a \"high-altitude view\" of depth. However, this is actually a visual illusion created by the 2D screen through color gradations and texture variations. Real-world depth perception relies on physical mechanisms such as binocular parallax and atmospheric perspective, while the screen only simulates this effect through a flat image, lacking true spatial depth.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03784", "filename": "4e86fa4bd2058dda2a4aa8d081ee09dba84ca8f25aef63df8e9f291da577be0b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03785", "filename": "4e86fa4bd2058dda2a4aa8d081ee09dba84ca8f25aef63df8e9f291da577be0b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal; the time sequence is continuous, and between 0s and 5s, water is seen flowing from a glacier in the background into a lake. As the glacier collapses, the water becomes part of the glacier and falls into the lake.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03786", "filename": "4e722dc8da229c4148fb1774be5311044e280f20e010a6fb4a8aa48554e583e9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03787", "filename": "4e722dc8da229c4148fb1774be5311044e280f20e010a6fb4a8aa48554e583e9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: During a continuous period of time, from 1.5s to 5.8s, while the flame intensity remained unchanged, the emitted light suddenly dimmed.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03788", "filename": "4e722dc8da229c4148fb1774be5311044e280f20e010a6fb4a8aa48554e583e9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: During the continuous time frame from 1.3s to 5s, a pink object spontaneously stands upright in the fire without any external force.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03789", "filename": "4e722dc8da229c4148fb1774be5311044e280f20e010a6fb4a8aa48554e583e9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly: the timeline is continuous, but at 6.1 seconds, the burning cardboard box suddenly shrinks, appearing disjointed and pieced together rather than seamlessly.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03790", "filename": "4eb4c2b49d96942604a8be72324e10ee6c16fa673b5a4ab4575a6137444d74e0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior. Normally, the steam from hot drinks flows upwards, but the steam texture in this image appears to flow downwards, presenting a visual effect similar to smoke settling, which violates the basic physical law that hot air, being less dense, should float upwards.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03791", "filename": "4eb4c2b49d96942604a8be72324e10ee6c16fa673b5a4ab4575a6137444d74e0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: Physically, steam from hot drinks is normally a mixture of hot air and small water droplets, less dense than the surrounding cool air, and would continuously rise and diffuse. However, in the image, some steam patterns appear to sink downwards and converge towards the rim of the cup, which is completely contrary to the basic physical laws of thermal convection.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03792", "filename": "4eb4c2b49d96942604a8be72324e10ee6c16fa673b5a4ab4575a6137444d74e0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03793", "filename": "4eb4c2b49d96942604a8be72324e10ee6c16fa673b5a4ab4575a6137444d74e0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous; between 6.1s and 6.4s, additional smoke suddenly appears in the upper right corner of the smoke area.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03796", "filename": "4ece64eebfb8af653f1f0b67295337f07902a6e80a7d05b9ae208f68d9ce492e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly occurred in the video: during a continuous sequence of events (0.8s-1.3s), the small ball in the middle of the water glass indented to the lower left without any external force, and then returned to normal.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03797", "filename": "5bb4050858bd034d5674db7da1411761ff29ab59638cf24aab292bc9d0e28df7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03798", "filename": "5bc1032dc996cfc78b660d3f161e3768e0dea03408b648ce11a8f1aaba38719e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (When a candle is burning, the flame will sway in the wind, but will not bend in the still air. However, the flame in the image does not sway and appears to be bent.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03799", "filename": "5be5b105468cd4a08ae38c18a0355ea9c351808e7a84b1e42bdbf2bf68d02ca5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (the object produces no smoke during the entire combustion process, which does not conform to the gasification theorem in physics).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03800", "filename": "5bec4141447f7a1dbf16d2f8a5be77225d0ba77ae498a4a9f887200c3ba64864_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Physical behavior (between 2 and 8 seconds, no refraction occurs when the object is placed in the water, which does not conform to the law of refraction in physics; between 2.28 and 8 seconds, the object penetrates the bottom of the cup.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03801", "filename": "5bff4939deee32ae2d114f78f6ac01a76b631115d9d4ff3c04847f06794ebef3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03802", "filename": "5c3b8cc175e6d2ef93c75f5dd2894719a67ad56f590d388be3a1645df80068d1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (within 2.24-8 seconds, the object is distorted in the middle).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03803", "filename": "5c291a99873028d0cc1fd31ab463cdae647a8ac1076b8ff54c9fb3892386f0f8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03807", "filename": "5cd0bb476ef03e22290b279bc06d2e161952fa5382506232e08408af6cf85d80_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (changes from a flowing state to a static state at 4.4s)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03808", "filename": "5cf597b49a0dfde8ca5f957036064a6ac0956cda896fae0304eaef8707e275a3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Physical behavior (at 3.6s, the light beam bends, which does not conform to the physical property that light travels in a straight line).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03809", "filename": "5d0b42bbf68d92d767697afbe6149e844def30d2905f7fb677826799369e8675_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the snowy area in the foreground of the entire video exhibits flickering and distortion).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03811", "filename": "5d66ab2fd0b8507d83dbf24b28bc7f0a8bd4f0f3558c8a4e0a44330be7cbc511_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03812", "filename": "5d790b4257420da8dfa17ed077df26f88a48b8e4c3d0e0b33f0a634c0e8d80ac_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03813", "filename": "5d8853e9dc79afad21045263bcf195e3675a360b51c8d5ab50bc190f882c5089_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the waterfall is a liquid, but the trajectory of its descent resembles that of a gas, which does not conform to the laws governing the movement of solids, liquids, and gases).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03814", "filename": "5d87270375ab5ef2c4bb235e61933dda4b0909e846389782143d1ff9414d46f8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03815", "filename": "5de81eedc589ee05a26563882a35abc011e2e5b88dcfe6b8ddf3e066bd3d61ff_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03816", "filename": "5e38e39c35fc075bf1dc793329231e2f39352d60bacec05faf198adde59e14b9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the object is melting and liquid is flowing out from the beginning to the end of the video, but the size of the object does not change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03817", "filename": "5eb3ea4cd579d4b459838b5e71b56e4fb1710bda0ee205e6bd2f888dffcc2a09_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03818", "filename": "5ee459265392af27485b7a19358b4b4fff8d925a2933029fc97e2dce43de42cc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03819", "filename": "5f82a107111e9ffb3c290e1cd43de6f0118774be0cc99f90372b77a669595c9e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (0-1.4s, the object falls from a low height, but explodes upon landing, which does not conform to the law of conservation of energy)", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03820", "filename": "5fae34f56a2a0f550f9aac8dd1243803a7bb57b422ad9cc2b39e27c1ed7e4fb1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03822", "filename": "06e82a11a7891004b69c9da17a6a68c8904b3db7141f7604146ee76abd4bc998_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the shape of the clouds in the entire video, and the surface of the clouds is too flat and smooth).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03823", "filename": "6a0dc5a4da39e2360717ed6c884f5cd5f421a2cf3ce5f1675716cfb915d1f132_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual abnormality (screen flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03824", "filename": "6a6e49bbe749eb20fb78016877d02762f105ce59aa0265f3a88d528109e6db2e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: During the continuous time frame (0-3.3 seconds, the liquid sprayed from the bottle did not appear in the water tank).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03825", "filename": "6aa96c70e37a0f45362e6af3b18a3e1331d2b2c2464afad791997a8bf71ccc59_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03826", "filename": "6ad5c1351a22741de513214848365587b619d7594c170956f391836372559eb4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (flickering on the ground) Physical behavior (2s after the turret fires a shell, the turret does not move, the action and reaction forces are mismatched, violating Newton's third law)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03827", "filename": "6bc09bc7eadb0667aa9b1441d31c205b7cca8f41d829d927d65a8e24aa9e3732_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (After 1.6 seconds, the flame in the video is too stable, bright, and uniform, lacking the slight shaking, brightness changes, and transitions between light and dark that a natural flame should have.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03828", "filename": "6bc8132ea58815dc1b43422c6c816b6631c2c994197f0a30f06e783c5d325674_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to physical behavior (in reality, thick clouds would significantly block sunlight, and even if light could penetrate, the edges of the beams would be soft and blurry due to scattering, while the beams of light under the clouds in the video are sharp and bright).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03829", "filename": "6bc8132ea58815dc1b43422c6c816b6631c2c994197f0a30f06e783c5d325674_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the clouds move throughout the process, but the trees below remain stationary. In the video, clouds in the same area move erratically and at excessive speeds under the same atmospheric circulation.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03830", "filename": "6bc8132ea58815dc1b43422c6c816b6631c2c994197f0a30f06e783c5d325674_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4s, the clouds in the upper left corner of the screen suddenly spread in the opposite direction).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03831", "filename": "6bdad997537b8235dfc42906f2b0a125ee3bcf00338bd897f7cb8014321c8c93_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (between 0s and 0.1s, the pillar in the lower right corner of the sea suddenly disappears); Physical behavior (as the clouds move in the video, the cloud surface does not spread out with the movement, but disappears abruptly).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03832", "filename": "6bdad997537b8235dfc42906f2b0a125ee3bcf00338bd897f7cb8014321c8c93_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual intuition is abnormal (the cloud formations in the video show obvious and rapid changes in shape within a short period of time, with an exaggerated sense of dynamism, while in reality, the cloud formations are relatively stable within a short period of time). Physical behavior (after 1.9 seconds, the center of the sun appears too white, lacking the light diffusion of a real sun).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03833", "filename": "6bdad997537b8235dfc42906f2b0a125ee3bcf00338bd897f7cb8014321c8c93_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (in the video, two layers of clouds appear during the movement, and their directions of movement are inconsistent). Time continuity (between 0s and 2.2s, an unidentified object appears moving irregularly in the lower left corner of the screen).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03834", "filename": "6bdad997537b8235dfc42906f2b0a125ee3bcf00338bd897f7cb8014321c8c93_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03836", "filename": "6c4d5d3267b8909c917cf6500ec66ff1a82ba63183b797b185cbaecc971f367b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.1s, the object below the hydraulic press in the image undergoes a sudden change, with two sharp spikes appearing out of thin air on the object).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03837", "filename": "6c4d5d3267b8909c917cf6500ec66ff1a82ba63183b797b185cbaecc971f367b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (at 1.8s, during the downward pressing of the hydraulic press in the video, the iron block below rapidly breaks into a regular cuboid upon contact, the deformation speed is too fast).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03838", "filename": "6c4d5d3267b8909c917cf6500ec66ff1a82ba63183b797b185cbaecc971f367b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video exhibits the following anomalies: physical behavior (at 0.4s, 4.7s, and 3.5s, the steel block in the video springs back to its original shape after being subjected to pressure from the hydraulic press, but in reality, steel does not shrink under heavy pressure). Causality (at 0.9s, the white object begins to shrink before the hydraulic press even contacts it. At 3.1s, the large iron block automatically compresses before the hydraulic press even contacts it). Temporal continuity (at 0.9s, the iron block below the hydraulic press suddenly disappears; a white object appears without transition; at 2.9s, the white object below the hydraulic press suddenly disappears, and a silver iron block appears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03839", "filename": "6c4d5d3267b8909c917cf6500ec66ff1a82ba63183b797b185cbaecc971f367b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the hydraulic press did not descend and apply force between 0.7s and 1.5s, but the iron blocks automatically increased outwards) was continuous in time (at 1.8s, cylinders suddenly appeared on the surface of the hydraulic press; at 2.5s, the iron blocks suddenly turned into white objects; at 5.4s, the irregular white objects suddenly turned into regular thin sheets).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03845", "filename": "6c876bc4dbe5199790b6ca00bbde901d3a45372cd27c78110c482b41e8daf709_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Temporal continuity (At 1.5s, five spheres of different colors suddenly appear at the track bend. At 3s, the positions of the initial pink and yellow spheres suddenly reverse.) Physical behavior (At 2s, the two yellow spheres behind the blue sphere merge.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03848", "filename": "6cacb4d9e32014d81a4b4c21d2f522113c00c48cc799d66a3f2b0dba7f8c1090_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (the bubbles in the video rise like viscous liquid, and their shapes are too regular and uniform. In reality, the shape of bubbles will vary depending on factors such as the properties of the liquid and surface tension, and their sizes will also vary).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03849", "filename": "6cacb4d9e32014d81a4b4c21d2f522113c00c48cc799d66a3f2b0dba7f8c1090_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the unidentified water column in the middle of the glass appears and disappears intermittently, disappearing abruptly at 3.1 seconds). The overall feeling is abnormal (the bubbles should be produced intermittently, and the rising speed should vary depending on the size of the bubbles, but in this video, the bubbles are produced too quickly, and the movement is too regular and consistent).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03850", "filename": "6cacb4d9e32014d81a4b4c21d2f522113c00c48cc799d66a3f2b0dba7f8c1090_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the rising path of bubbles in a liquid is dispersed due to liquid flow, container wall effect, etc., but in the video, the bubbles form a concentrated and continuous upward flow in the liquid.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03851", "filename": "6cc229035eb25cce8cda46f1766f828e3591774633644eabe1e780eba1d4f049_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 4.2s, the lion outside the cage suddenly passes through the cage, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03852", "filename": "6cc229035eb25cce8cda46f1766f828e3591774633644eabe1e780eba1d4f049_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the lions outside the cage move somewhat stiffly, lacking natural and coherent behavior. When the lions outside approach the cage, the lions inside remain motionless).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03853", "filename": "6cc229035eb25cce8cda46f1766f828e3591774633644eabe1e780eba1d4f049_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 1.3s, the wooden stake in the upper right corner moves without any external force) and temporal continuity (at 0.3s, the lion's mane outside the cage in the scene suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03857", "filename": "d30682a6072771f6c5ebb2d3b5aa5bf62f568d3f37df04bda6b1a9741c481131_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03858", "filename": "d42631e16e783bda7ef1c0dbf03016483030ab6b015b11833a0c5d708fbbbfdc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (In a natural environment, the water surface would fluctuate due to external factors such as wind and aquatic animals, but the lake surface in the entire video remains calm).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03859", "filename": "d793547c663c634a6211a0d1d736a2a47c3d1bd345eb5cd786a4887ffd67414e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video suddenly stutters and drops frames between 3.7s and 8s.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03860", "filename": "d965703a27c573015b93b123261855473949e4b5c194236b3e2874e4b23eb0e7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (between 5.3s and 8s in the video, the penguin is not experiencing any upward force but suddenly floats into the air, which does not conform to the laws of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03861", "filename": "d48181086e7b9ec7fcee98fa824576c1b4e07695f06d1258c29fe999f8f058bb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (sunlight shining on the fog in the sky produces wisps of translucent silk that change slightly as the fog moves, but no changes are observed on the fog in the video, and the halo produced by the sunlight is unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03862", "filename": "d950809243a9d260e1690b27eef4b80317cb5edfc40f55588fa69f003164db0f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1.3s, the number of black particles in the upper left corner of the liquid suddenly increases out of nowhere, and at 4.9s, the number of black particles in the liquid suddenly decreases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03863", "filename": "d4971375213aba0cca30eb10d45cfc6615fb3af6b780a6df77a31be50945beee_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Physical behavior (the video shows two liquids of different colors. When these two different liquids come into contact, they should float due to their different surface tensions, but in the video, the liquids are in a relatively static state.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03864", "filename": "da6740fce7ae54ac9cedf6c8cd75099c41c2de8c5ebe26031fd39ce659c20b64_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Cause and effect (when water in a pot is heated to boiling, the bubbles produced in the pot will expand and burst due to the heat, but the bubbles produced in the video appear to be getting bigger and smaller and remain in contact with the water surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03865", "filename": "da7979ed8be3d8469ef576cdec590b2e3420052c1e6f2d51255014887135bd93_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.7s, when the index fingers of the person on the left side of the video are interlocked, a piercing effect occurs between their index fingers).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03866", "filename": "da69203e561e5e62d95da11a84a9129583e120bee7e2dee161c75e176cf3e404_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect relationship (the distance between the reflections of the two deer in the water is the same as their real distance, but the distance between the shadows of the two deer directly below in the video does not match their real distance).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03867", "filename": "daf232ff326b010f5cc6045a7da50ddc461fcd169151a03ee338f9250c5f2962_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03868", "filename": "db25a5c8bd07b8ac7bcbaa1528ad94651be517871823e46837f5d4e60259e736_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (in the entire video, the water droplets hitting the water surface should create ripples from the center outwards, but in the video, the water surface only ripples at the top, while the bottom remains calm).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03870", "filename": "dba9b205ce48942afe572eed7b10a754ac3a1532e3922ec5dabcfa35773d005a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (the meat on the grill evaporates moisture due to the temperature, producing steam, but the meat on the left side of the video does not emit smoke).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03871", "filename": "dc2cda7bfcded19e9fd4aac0682cc491593735f90b64113b32820076089fed5d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 6.2s, the downward-flowing liquid in the video suddenly flows upward without any force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03872", "filename": "dc7effb3b696aa60044f6cb6d59954199c96a0c586fd1258192568196010e5e4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: continuous time (the white and blue object remains burning throughout the entire video, but the burn marks on the object do not change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03873", "filename": "dcb6b4aa1619627247fa50ed638efc5a9c9f02184de7810cf03ec264b3e6fcf4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 4.1 seconds, no liquid was dripped into the container, but the amount of liquid in the container suddenly increased; throughout the video, liquid was dripped into the container, but the liquid in the container remained calm).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03874", "filename": "dd7cb024e7da691c0956b28fde35806df1083f6b023b28d1505260592b3e1123_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Cause and effect (In heavy rain, leaves and twigs under the rain will sway due to the water, but the leaves and twigs in the video remain still).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03875", "filename": "dd9bcac1469adc7d06a2dd97192634b33b23f146fdf8adbc2b5e7c5e8aeda844_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03876", "filename": "dd074ba93ce1f3f1183cdec06711fbcf677b52ddc85c792c3af6edd7b02cc89e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (0s-3.9s). There are no horizontal lights shining in the air, but segments of horizontal light beams appear out of nowhere and keep flashing.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03877", "filename": "ddaff6cb4d55ed2cfe35506d39b2bc5e2cae187a43f9adb7b9780a71346cf412_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03878", "filename": "dde0c775d7af5198c7ba179f774ccbfaaf1494b3043d9250e173b015361dbe0b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03879", "filename": "de0f45309a3a872699a51cafa0823af97757a0bcbe4edfd8ae3a22561132a38c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03880", "filename": "de9914e8cec406666d9a410156eaf11d3c34d475b0b93eb3fbfec6e567d829b2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (the entire video shows a waterfall and a rushing river, but the river in the video is slow and the flow is too smooth).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03881", "filename": "decd0ee4997328cf9fce20eaddca0e198634550352a6086f99b0c412278dd2af_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the video footage shows noticeable stuttering and frame drops after 3 seconds, and after 3.3 seconds, the naturally spreading smoke suddenly changes from messy to orderly).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03882", "filename": "df007c4975c17c0a1e5fcc264123b09b26744dad0c265ff748698e7a2d0fd044_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the entire video frame is static and the generated bubbles do not float upwards).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03883", "filename": "df33a9c505f502e60b53756df440a0fc7fd67ac014c7ee13913e800d7c51bc98_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 7.1s, the bubble that was launched breaks apart, but the bubble itself does not burst).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03884", "filename": "df62ac74d515eca4c5e613b9b1eb8203bfdfb0cdd550ea21e4846f319e2e1930_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (Everything in the entire video frame is static).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03885", "filename": "df599587eaa53a73ac8a06d7d60eb3d1efe6fe8abbb29831e86b7601879b99ea_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03886", "filename": "dfd23253cb9e84c64429eb150afb2d5c1a1e893a99c09f44bf63e4d3d9fc1ed3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03887", "filename": "556ba46ae7e36c555b491cd05488d5a03a62c7861e62881ac9ace78e0ae65a36_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03888", "filename": "556ba46ae7e36c555b491cd05488d5a03a62c7861e62881ac9ace78e0ae65a36_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (at 2.6 seconds in the video, the hill is breached by the water inside, but there are no rocks around it, and the water nozzle is too smooth).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03889", "filename": "557b44c9dae7e737aa766b628922e51311bd1f2724d873283c217de8ade09a7b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time duration (the hydraulic press hits the fork at 2.5 seconds, and the fork suddenly vibrates; the space between the hydraulic press and the worktable is too small for the fork to vibrate).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03890", "filename": "557b44c9dae7e737aa766b628922e51311bd1f2724d873283c217de8ade09a7b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (at 3.5 seconds in the video, the fork on the workbench suddenly begins to deform and continues until the end).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03891", "filename": "557b44c9dae7e737aa766b628922e51311bd1f2724d873283c217de8ade09a7b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03892", "filename": "557b44c9dae7e737aa766b628922e51311bd1f2724d873283c217de8ade09a7b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the duration is inconsistent (the fork breaks and crumbles when the hydraulic press hits it at 4.2 seconds, but the fork remains intact after the hydraulic press lifts up at 5.3 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03893", "filename": "557c14b4775b11d57739f0c39403a66ce3d85a121d0003ec1ca5fcf474974de5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03894", "filename": "557c14b4775b11d57739f0c39403a66ce3d85a121d0003ec1ca5fcf474974de5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03895", "filename": "557c14b4775b11d57739f0c39403a66ce3d85a121d0003ec1ca5fcf474974de5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (at 0.8s, one vehicle on the road suddenly becomes two, and at 1s, the two vehicles turning around changes to a coasting turn).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03896", "filename": "557fca6e1f02f20fa5aa5d3f18fb81a0ec4e328b308466dbcd6370ba404dd227_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is unusual: the overall impression is that the light in the center of the pink flower clusters in the image is not sunlight but rather the bright light emitted by an electric light bulb.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03897", "filename": "557fca6e1f02f20fa5aa5d3f18fb81a0ec4e328b308466dbcd6370ba404dd227_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall impression (the light spot in the center of the flower cluster is too glaring, while the background is entirely white).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_03898", "filename": "557fca6e1f02f20fa5aa5d3f18fb81a0ec4e328b308466dbcd6370ba404dd227_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03899", "filename": "557fca6e1f02f20fa5aa5d3f18fb81a0ec4e328b308466dbcd6370ba404dd227_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (petals fall between 3.4s and 6.2s, but the wind was weak in the video, and petals wouldn't fall so suddenly if the wind was insufficient).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03900", "filename": "580c1cb9ae04cf631700672487bd3b6204c35a81b65a34a169fedbf975a174bc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the squid placed on the far right at 0.3 seconds turns golden brown at 4.4 seconds, the change is too rapid).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03901", "filename": "580c1cb9ae04cf631700672487bd3b6204c35a81b65a34a169fedbf975a174bc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (after the character places the squid in their hand onto two other squid skewers on the grill at 1.2 seconds, all the squid skewers merge together).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03902", "filename": "580c1cb9ae04cf631700672487bd3b6204c35a81b65a34a169fedbf975a174bc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03903", "filename": "580c1cb9ae04cf631700672487bd3b6204c35a81b65a34a169fedbf975a174bc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.5s in the scene, when the character picks up the skewers, the number of bamboo skewers suddenly decreases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03904", "filename": "583d7b0ec2f782cf2313f003335ea6129556de6ff9d86fd88d3c875645fb562a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: during the 0-0.9s interval, the foam on the ice suddenly returns to the ice, and although the container appears to be square, the liquid in the final image is cylindrical.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03905", "filename": "583d7b0ec2f782cf2313f003335ea6129556de6ff9d86fd88d3c875645fb562a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: During the duration of the event (0-0.4s, the foam in the center of the screen suddenly turns into ice, and after 1.3s, the ice suddenly starts to spray water outwards and produces a large number of bubbles).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03906", "filename": "583d7b0ec2f782cf2313f003335ea6129556de6ff9d86fd88d3c875645fb562a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (the bubble in the center of the screen suddenly turns into ice and stabilizes at 2.7s; at 3s, the ice begins to melt and produce bubbles).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03907", "filename": "583d7b0ec2f782cf2313f003335ea6129556de6ff9d86fd88d3c875645fb562a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the duration is prolonged (the water column comes into contact with the ice at 2s and produces a large amount of water vapor and bubbles, but the water added is not hot water).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03911", "filename": "596a8c989a831dbf7b94246f228f80e70638bd6d1db844a4887a2e0dfaa1db35_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the image shows cavities appearing in the liquid inside the pot, and the objects moving erratically, which does not conform to the principles of motion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03912", "filename": "596a8c989a831dbf7b94246f228f80e70638bd6d1db844a4887a2e0dfaa1db35_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 1.8 seconds in the video, the ice in the pot had not completely melted, but boiling began to occur at the rim of the pot).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03913", "filename": "596a8c989a831dbf7b94246f228f80e70638bd6d1db844a4887a2e0dfaa1db35_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly: Time continues (the ice in the pot melts completely in 2.4 seconds, but the water in the pot continues to decrease after the ice melts).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03914", "filename": "596a8c989a831dbf7b94246f228f80e70638bd6d1db844a4887a2e0dfaa1db35_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 2.8s in the scene, the character slightly tilts the pot and then straightens it. At this moment, the water in the pot suddenly boils, but the ice in the water has not completely melted).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03915", "filename": "600e2f941c28e4b15f4e2812e5c2c668c2af44a41cc2200a8db57a9a40985a74_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Sunlight is simultaneously illuminating both the high clouds above and the sea of clouds below, which is impossible because sunlight cannot penetrate two layers of clouds at different altitudes at the same time and create uniform illumination.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03916", "filename": "600e2f941c28e4b15f4e2812e5c2c668c2af44a41cc2200a8db57a9a40985a74_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (The image simultaneously displays two different cloud levels. The lower level is typically the top of low-level cumulus clouds, while the upper level is high-level stratocumulus clouds. It's impossible to clearly see both levels of clouds at the same time.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03918", "filename": "b0c6a28366315205893874eba113dc7ff5265368f93e9a2450e2797d30ff0818_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the halo produced by the burning candle flame in the entire video is too regular, lacking the irregular halo diffusion that a real burning candle flame would produce).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03919", "filename": "b0c6a28366315205893874eba113dc7ff5265368f93e9a2450e2797d30ff0818_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is too continuous (the flame produced by the burning candle in the entire video is too regular, and the flame is burning steadily without the random jumping of a real flame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03920", "filename": "b0d2d4998b769e7c1ebc6f8703dc70fffb71ac1df470b33659e4bf4a949e8e3c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (in the video, the ocean is affected by air currents, creating waves that flow to the right, but the clouds in the sky remain stationary, unaffected by air currents).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03921", "filename": "b0d2d4998b769e7c1ebc6f8703dc70fffb71ac1df470b33659e4bf4a949e8e3c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the waves are turbulent in the foreground of the video, but the sea is calm in the distance).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03922", "filename": "b0d2d4998b769e7c1ebc6f8703dc70fffb71ac1df470b33659e4bf4a949e8e3c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03923", "filename": "b0d4f7118547f9dc05df943491fe3c921abc66b08959f72d3b972409e2965028_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (there is a black line on the shore in the entire video. This black line does not have the natural transition of cracks or water stains in the ground in reality. The edges are sharp and the direction is distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03924", "filename": "b0d4f7118547f9dc05df943491fe3c921abc66b08959f72d3b972409e2965028_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Cause and effect (the waves on the shoreline should be continuous and naturally connected, but the waves on the left and right sides in the whole video do not form a coherent shoreline shape, and the shape of the shoreline waves is very stiff. It lacks the natural arc of real waves crashing onto the beach, as well as the dynamic details of foam spreading with the water flow).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03925", "filename": "b0d4f7118547f9dc05df943491fe3c921abc66b08959f72d3b972409e2965028_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the foam texture of the waves in the entire video is too uniform, lacking the dynamic layering of real ocean waves from crest to trough. There is no natural transition between the foam and the water below, making it look like a texture that has been stiffly pasted onto the surface of the waves, lacking the brokenness and transparency of real waves).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03926", "filename": "b0d4f7118547f9dc05df943491fe3c921abc66b08959f72d3b972409e2965028_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the foam marks on the shore in the entire video appear as overly regular stripes, lacking the natural randomness of real foam spreading with the water flow. Real ocean waves have varying density and size of foam).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03927", "filename": "b1a4920f4e63087ca35549c9012c25eccc5f2b002a48ebdd806775e70ca6a1cf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the grid of the pink racket appears distorted in the video between 3.6s and 4s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03928", "filename": "b1a4920f4e63087ca35549c9012c25eccc5f2b002a48ebdd806775e70ca6a1cf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (between 0.6s and 3.5s, after the green ball comes into contact with the pink racket, neither object breaks, but a large amount of red powder suddenly appears at the point of contact; at 5.8s, the grid on the pink racket becomes distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03929", "filename": "b1a4920f4e63087ca35549c9012c25eccc5f2b002a48ebdd806775e70ca6a1cf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (During the 0s-3.9s interval, the green ball in the video lands diagonally on the pink racket. Due to inertia, the green ball should bounce back in the direction of motion, but in the video, the green ball bounces back in the opposite direction, which does not conform to the laws of inertia).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03930", "filename": "b1bbd32055cd09d8ba7d6a341eacd318592b96918f5f909f7c8d6f593cf30f23_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3 seconds, a gray object explodes into a lot of debris, then suddenly returns to its original state).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03931", "filename": "b1bbd32055cd09d8ba7d6a341eacd318592b96918f5f909f7c8d6f593cf30f23_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 2.4 seconds, the helmet suddenly breaks before the silver object hits it).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03932", "filename": "b1bbd32055cd09d8ba7d6a341eacd318592b96918f5f909f7c8d6f593cf30f23_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (at 0.7s, the two small stones on the right side of the helmet suddenly merged; at 1.4s, one of the two small stones on the right side of the helmet suddenly deformed, and the other suddenly disappeared into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03933", "filename": "b1bbd32055cd09d8ba7d6a341eacd318592b96918f5f909f7c8d6f593cf30f23_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 4.7s, a yellow substance appears out of nowhere on the black debris produced by the black object breaking, and at 5.1s, the broken black object suddenly returns to its original state).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03938", "filename": "b2b6b30d936cd5d64f1b61a1c55acfff142fb6a2ab06226572bdf5b75462abb0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Cause and effect (the trees in the upper left corner of the video are obviously shaking, but the trees on the right side of the video do not show obvious shaking, and the images do not correspond to each other).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03939", "filename": "b2b6b30d936cd5d64f1b61a1c55acfff142fb6a2ab06226572bdf5b75462abb0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Cause and effect (the trees and branches in the rushing river in the video will sway noticeably due to the impact of the river, but the trees and branches in the river in the video remain stable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_03940", "filename": "b2b6b30d936cd5d64f1b61a1c55acfff142fb6a2ab06226572bdf5b75462abb0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the water flow of the waterfall in the entire video is a blurry, noisy texture, lacking the sense of layering and dynamic details of real water flow, especially in the area near the top, where the water shape blends awkwardly with the surrounding scenery, and there is a sense of shaking in the image under the white bridge).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03941", "filename": "b2b6b30d936cd5d64f1b61a1c55acfff142fb6a2ab06226572bdf5b75462abb0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03942", "filename": "b2b79f36c1796ac74b75b651c1e2c6534392eb5e57644c175a78983635969ca8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (the water droplets adhering to the glass should slide down the glass due to gravity, but the water droplets remain stationary in the video, which does not conform to the laws of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03943", "filename": "b2b79f36c1796ac74b75b651c1e2c6534392eb5e57644c175a78983635969ca8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the texture of the water droplets in the entire video is a random, noisy bump, lacking the transparency and surface tension of real water droplets. Although the light spots in the background are the effect of out-of-focus imaging, the superposition logic with the water droplets is chaotic, and there is no refraction or distortion effect when real light passes through the water droplets).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03944", "filename": "b2b79f36c1796ac74b75b651c1e2c6534392eb5e57644c175a78983635969ca8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Cause and effect (Due to the influence of gravity and airflow, water droplets on the glass will slide diagonally downwards in one direction, but between 3.2s and 5.2s, water droplets appear to flow in opposite directions on the glass).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03945", "filename": "b2ba9d0da6280b568ef7c662330defe557a07254a4f649cfe805e87ed06e5aa2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The heating did not stop at 2.4 seconds, but the boiling of the water in the pot suddenly and noticeably weakened.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03946", "filename": "b2ba9d0da6280b568ef7c662330defe557a07254a4f649cfe805e87ed06e5aa2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the bubbles in the boiling water in the pot throughout the video are too regular, lacking the details of real boiling bubbles rolling and water splashing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03948", "filename": "3e6667f5d51f1f4bfd88db729959c7a82a7968fdb7aeebddd7303fe87855432c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the normal smoke texture is light, semi-transparent and soft, and the texture is a gradual and blurred transition, while the smoke texture in the video is hard, with clear, almost solid boundaries between the strands, and some areas even have a reflective texture similar to metal or glass wires, especially the smoke strands on the right, which have lost the hazy and soft characteristics that smoke should have).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03949", "filename": "3ea3c768d8c248b289b3b2ad999dcead249e5287c7ec6ca07febff3cce42b3f7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual inconsistencies (In reality, clouds are affected by the atmosphere and have a faint light gray or off-white tone, with light blue edges due to scattering; in the video, the clouds are glaringly pure white, without any color bias, creating an unnatural high contrast with the pure blue background). Continuous timing (Clouds appear out of nowhere below the large clouds on the right side of the screen between 3.7s and 5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03951", "filename": "3eb335dbc22a6bb973cec5dae5d43d1802a3487962685059ae000a120a147fef_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03952", "filename": "3ec6c96f61445e890dd2b973055ba2eab7650978a51081c1d4a559f9b8fe210e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (in reality, due to the reflection and refraction of light from the ripples on the water surface, the reflection is bound to be blurry and lose details compared to the actual scene, and it becomes fainter as it gets farther away. However, in the video, the reflection is clearer than the actual scene, and the outlines and textures of the trees and clouds are even sharper than the actual sky and shoreline, like a directly copied and flipped layer, without any natural blur).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03953", "filename": "3f04bc68c0af960b3ddf771dd575ebec1d376bfa07eda733778c780e5e2f7da9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error was continuous (at 1.9 seconds, the two steel balls below the right hand instantly merged into one steel ball).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03954", "filename": "3f04bc68c0af960b3ddf771dd575ebec1d376bfa07eda733778c780e5e2f7da9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to physical behavior (the two steel balls penetrate each other at 1.3s, which violates the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03955", "filename": "3f0041c4ade08b8a2f3c3232dae0d649856d06a20e4325569ee48104d418aa4f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: continuous time (the vibration principle of the bronze basin is that the hands rub the two handles on the rim of the basin to generate mechanical vibration, which is transmitted to the water through the basin body. However, the hands did not rub the two handles on the rim of the bronze basin during the whole segment, but bubbles kept rising out of thin air around the entire edge of the water in the basin).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03956", "filename": "3f0041c4ade08b8a2f3c3232dae0d649856d06a20e4325569ee48104d418aa4f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (The vibration principle of the bronze basin is that the hands rub the two handles on the rim of the basin to generate mechanical vibration, which is transmitted to the water through the basin body. However, the hands did not rub the two handles on the rim of the bronze basin in the entire segment, but the water in the basin was rippled out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03957", "filename": "65faf655c9847a82c4c4f56c85796e763ebe600489a42f866781f7b95289a489_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the reflections of the river and the shore are blurry and misaligned, the water surface texture is unnatural, lacks realistic ripples and flow and is too smooth; in reality, there should be ripples. The leaves and branches of the trees are messy and disorderly, some leaves are blurred into a clump, without clear outlines and layers).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03960", "filename": "66b966676eadef26e2e34c0fa18cad72eea07d81e61368d20da9410bc68ce33d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (when the deep pot is actually boiling in the video, the bubbles should rise from the bottom of the pot, and the liquid surface should rise steadily from the center, rather than the splashing, wave-like boiling shown in the video, which is more like the state of clear water in a shallow pot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03961", "filename": "66decd8a9313d3ac42157ee5316244ee970ba30fbdedac29787c95d0b737682e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous movement (the floor on the left side of the entire video is constantly flickering and writhing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03962", "filename": "66decd8a9313d3ac42157ee5316244ee970ba30fbdedac29787c95d0b737682e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03963", "filename": "66e1fbd731c1a0a261dd78093b441e503c37ab3d461c89052b5cd7f2cfdf9a1b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the image of the gem slowly disappears between 3.2s and 8s, while a normal image will only move and will not disappear out of thin air. The reflection of the image and the gem's reflective spot do not match).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03964", "filename": "66e1fbd731c1a0a261dd78093b441e503c37ab3d461c89052b5cd7f2cfdf9a1b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (in reality, diamonds are high-hardness crystals and cannot gradually change from a pear shape to a heart shape without external force (cutting)). Physical behavior (throughout the entire segment, the refracted light spots and facet reflections of the reflection are out of sync with the main subject, and there are even instances where the main subject is illuminated while the reflection is not).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03965", "filename": "067dcb5ca0592448fb99d6ce27fa251dd2fd1634a30197e0ef52b737e144c7c1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is abnormal (in reality, water surfaces are dynamic with ripples, and reflections are blurry, distorted, and broken; in the video, the reflections and the sky, clouds, and ground scenery are exactly the same, like a direct copy of a mirror, without any water surface texture or attenuation). Time continuity (clouds appear out of nowhere in the upper left corner of the screen between 0.9s and 5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03966", "filename": "067dcb5ca0592448fb99d6ce27fa251dd2fd1634a30197e0ef52b737e144c7c1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (clouds appear out of nowhere in the upper left corner of the screen between 4.9s and 8s). The overall visual effect is abnormal (in reality, there would be tiny ripples on the water surface, and the reflection would be blurry, distorted, and intermittent, but the shape of the reflection in the video is exactly the same as the clouds in the sky, as smooth as a mirror, without any natural shaking or distortion).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03967", "filename": "68e2e801b7dad50496c75fc910d609ccdb48c22fac7a0b11c9869cfc97ae05a7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is discontinuous (the sky at the beginning of the video is orange-yellow, but at 2 seconds the sky suddenly turns white; the video would not change so quickly if the playback speed were normal). The overall visual impression is abnormal (real flames are jumping and bursting with irregular edges, but the flames in the video are like flowing liquid, with smooth and overly regular edges that lack the sense of bursting and the agitation and graininess that flames should have).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03968", "filename": "68edbd5940b2b926b89f5f2259b6437d691af366ede2e7b4e07a393481edafcf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (at 2.4s, irregular misty ice on the water surface suddenly transforms into transparent square ice blocks; at 2.7s, irregular misty ice on the right side of the water surface suddenly transforms into transparent square ice blocks; at 6.2s, an ice block appears out of thin air). Physical behavior (at 2.3s, the water droplets penetrate the cup, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03969", "filename": "68f4b134eeda7650e8d2ee6d1894f10090a410ea711ca4d3c45587451cdecd10_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Physical behavior (at 5s, an orange slice attached to the side of the knife penetrates another orange slice on the cutting board, violating the principle that solids are impermeable). Time continuity (at 6.3s, there is no transition between video feeds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03972", "filename": "70a3fb395f189f81085381670514ebec6513562ba76e66f5cc52e013ec72d8bd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.8s, the spinning coin suddenly stands upright). Causality (the coin had stopped spinning and was lying on the ground; between 4.6s and 5.6s, the coin moved without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03973", "filename": "70a3fb395f189f81085381670514ebec6513562ba76e66f5cc52e013ec72d8bd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly: Time continuity (a pattern suddenly appears out of nowhere on the coin's surface between 3.4s and 8s, when there was no pattern before).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03974", "filename": "71e9e3d24d7e812b6023e02d322e8a4c915510f0af280ad126bd47b402a3f2d0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The screen is abnormal: the time is continuous (the wooden block on the table disappears out of thin air at 0.5s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03976", "filename": "72f88092ebf650ad5106e16e79331583e7801eec6ab957df207d9bbca6b6c46c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.9s, 2.8s, and 4.1s, there are no fireworks shooting upwards, but fireworks explode in the air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03977", "filename": "73b1cfe62b01e8e4244bd5110e466a140d7d4f613fa24de38ce508169f21a6ae_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the fingerprints of the hand appear and disappear intermittently throughout the entire sequence).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03978", "filename": "73b1cfe62b01e8e4244bd5110e466a140d7d4f613fa24de38ce508169f21a6ae_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the gem moves on its own without the hand rotating it throughout the entire sequence).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03981", "filename": "74c1d4da47a0c8b8a9bf5628e9083329e113a185544810ecaf27b4b36916a6a4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is that the time sequence is continuous (at 3.1s, the mark left by the hot melt tool after it scratches the surface of the colloid is liquid, whereas in reality, the hot melt tool will only leave a hot melt scratch after it scratches the colloid, not a liquid).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03982", "filename": "75ade813dc058fc4c3236ac29f4f3f741fe29eb2cd2aa2383e6c73ac2edf84d5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03983", "filename": "75ae49e1ba63fe6ce9d53465d6d1be1f5c75abcbc1bfb9befb2d963e68e4e9b3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the sun is at the bottom of the screen, and the light should be penetrating the clouds from bottom to top and from right to left, but the bright and dark parts of some cloud blocks in the video are randomly distributed, and the logic of light moving with the clouds and creating shadows is not followed).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03984", "filename": "75ae49e1ba63fe6ce9d53465d6d1be1f5c75abcbc1bfb9befb2d963e68e4e9b3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (in reality, the edges of clouds are gradually blurred and cotton-like, but in the video, the edges of some cloud blocks are sharp and distinct, as if they have been cut, lacking the soft and fluffy feel of real clouds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03985", "filename": "75b7bc772d5e93c91ea31dbd31275b0926aadcfc5f4b0e02c8c8f3fae3c7027f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (ice flowers appear out of nowhere and slowly grow larger in the 0.5s and 2.3s frames).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03986", "filename": "76b5e391287a5d9ff2a24c733a59ad572ab4eeec1a39893ae7c039896c6d1574_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (real flames are affected by airflow and temperature differences, resulting in messy, flickering, and blurry edges, while the flames in the video have smooth, stiff, and overly neat outlines, extremely high brightness, no gradual halo of thermal radiation, and excessively high and harsh edge brightness, rather than the thermal emission of a real flame).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03987", "filename": "76b5e391287a5d9ff2a24c733a59ad572ab4eeec1a39893ae7c039896c6d1574_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (in reality, flames sway dynamically with blurred edges, but in the video, the flame edges are too sharp, and the flame stops swaying between 3.5s and 8s, without any natural gradation or shaking).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03989", "filename": "78aa41426c504997d77fd4bc7d811afd2e94f97ce9fe0f3664ec2e6a98c4fe62_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.2s and 2.8s, no objects fall onto the water surface on the right side or bottom of the screen, but water splashes appear out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03990", "filename": "78aa41426c504997d77fd4bc7d811afd2e94f97ce9fe0f3664ec2e6a98c4fe62_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 2s to 8s, the water droplets fall continuously while water crowns appear intermittently on the surface).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_03992", "filename": "80bf880071151c848f5d531293710d020c77c783a0792af4f0c163bdd913785e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal because the timing is continuous (the firewood in the video has been burned to a charred black, and the charred layer will cut off the oxygen. In reality, this type of wood cannot produce such a strong and bright open flame. It will only have a weak ember or continuous smoke. However, in the video, the charred area is burning with a blinding flame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03993", "filename": "81a5df86433b2b6355185ca15b5239f7e64246e1f2c7adfb7e755134187fe476_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.5s, the tongs in the hand flips over and suddenly turns into a shovel, and at 3.9s, a small white piece appears out of nowhere and gets stuck in the hole in the shovel).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_03994", "filename": "82ac4768de614fc97afe6ef34a050658022c7d0992862732169df5f0c987847d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the water and ice blocks in the circle on the left of the entire segment flow without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03995", "filename": "82ac4768de614fc97afe6ef34a050658022c7d0992862732169df5f0c987847d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03996", "filename": "82d8cf2c55d012b30cd50d810c55ccd3dd1d8d3511eb7f93e7acb5db78af5641_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The timing is continuous (at 3.5s, water falls above the whole apple on the right and forms a stream in an arc-shaped wave shape as it approaches the apple, splashing water droplets everywhere).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03997", "filename": "82ec18a86cd766c92b400a02f405aa48686c4b414683a32b81bd32cc4664f64e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is unpredictable (in reality, it takes several minutes for the sun to rise completely from the horizon, a slow and gradual process. However, in the video, the sun leaps out of the horizon and grows rapidly in a very short time, with a rising speed far exceeding reality. In reality, during the 0.8s-5s sunrise period, the silhouettes of city buildings gradually emerge from dark to bright, with details becoming clearer. However, in the video, the silhouettes of buildings show almost no gradual change in brightness, and the change in brightness is completely out of sync with the rhythm of the sun's rise).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_03998", "filename": "83a6822f1d4958133c07594f03c350c6e58fdddab65be90afb03bcb052a17c0f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_03999", "filename": "85aeece7277217e0edc595b0778c95a55cdb666f421fac7f4f1f4f6fa12242db_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.7s, a green ball appears out of thin air on the right side of the humanoid toy; at 1.1s, another green ball appears out of thin air as the green ball collides with the red block; at 1.2s, the green ball disappears out of thin air as it collides with the blue block; between 3.8s and 4.2s, a ball appears out of thin air on the curved path on the red block).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04000", "filename": "85cd04e8a6a76c5d397b4a183b65b24d7585d4601dbb5f9451fa9400484d5daa_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the upper half of the right middle finger disappears out of thin air at 1.6s). Physical behavior (the steel ball passes through the finger every time it passes through the finger, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04001", "filename": "86a487c5a07151bada4ef4ddb5263d3e484466b048f20d9ef4e8da16162ee4fa_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the ice cubes in the two glasses rotate and move in the water without any external force throughout the entire segment).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04002", "filename": "86ccf021adb7777a048e126d04f3d4514db13832d0385499bcbe9b187e9c70c3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual inconsistency (In reality, rainfall is a continuous curtain of rain falling from the bottom of the clouds. Raindrops are affected by air resistance and wind, and the rain column will have a tilted, diffused, and blurred edge effect. However, in the video, the rain column looks like a straight beam of light with sharp edges, falling vertically without natural diffusion and gradation.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04003", "filename": "86ccf021adb7777a048e126d04f3d4514db13832d0385499bcbe9b187e9c70c3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual intuition is abnormal (in reality, rain curtains exhibit perspective changes with distance, appearing wider and narrower towards the near and denser towards the far, and the density of raindrops gradually decreases from the cloud base to the ground; however, the rain columns in the video are uniform in thickness and density, with no visual difference between the rain columns near and far). Temporal continuity (the entire video plays at a normal speed, but the speed at which the clouds move in the video is too fast, which is inconsistent with the actual speed of cloud movement).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04004", "filename": "86d5393c65dc6419c046d59754c67ca69ae8c03ebea9ad117cc7340cd8e3fb5a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (in reality, water splashes are scattered and irregular, and they will spread due to gravity and air resistance when falling, but in the video, the water splashes are blocky, uniform white mists with a stiff shape, without splashing trajectory or gradual dissipation).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04005", "filename": "87a7ce41535bf5dc68946a26da6fc7338570ee2f0ca3fc5844fbe71401afe608_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the upper part of the watermelon disappears when the foot on the watermelon is lifted at 1.9s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04006", "filename": "87a7ce41535bf5dc68946a26da6fc7338570ee2f0ca3fc5844fbe71401afe608_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.5s, the elephant's foot slowly transforms into two bear paws, and at 3.7s, the watermelon cracks). In reality, when a watermelon is pressed, the crack extends irregularly outward from the point of force, unlike the straight, symmetrical, knife-cut-like main crack seen in the video. It looks more like the main crack was artificially cut. The fine cracks on both sides of the main crack are also too regular, lacking the messy and uneven depth of a natural crack.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04007", "filename": "87f7ae7a19ad98d816cb5a67c9c85b14512ea9287e0321f2e6599ddf786a9c42_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04008", "filename": "088bf1dc14b98261de43b317b993299abb68fc086fb31aa9b63b6e4b0d2565e4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04010", "filename": "88c6a46c2ffb56e596e1685e859ec1b7b9f1a82b6d9b6acf15e1e9fefaa8aa22_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (a glass of water filled with water is placed inside a container. If all the air in the container is removed, the water will only boil and bubble violently, but the bubbles are small and scattered, and the water will churn as a whole. It is impossible for a vortex to occur).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04011", "filename": "88c6a46c2ffb56e596e1685e859ec1b7b9f1a82b6d9b6acf15e1e9fefaa8aa22_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the yellow pattern on the side of the ping-pong ball disappears out of nowhere at 0.1s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04012", "filename": "89aa2997c32353f2bf709cc16325e6ff723681b808af7ccacfa013c1d6487814_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04013", "filename": "89dbc5bdc0451c20ed0620ca8e6d86c5d2cf51f736ad2c799f530af0c868678d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the sugar cube in the bowl shrinks rapidly until it disappears between 1.9s and 3.4s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04014", "filename": "89dbc5bdc0451c20ed0620ca8e6d86c5d2cf51f736ad2c799f530af0c868678d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (between 2.9s and 3.5s, the sugar cubes and onion slices in the bowl slowly disappear while a hand holding an onion slice slowly emerges).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04015", "filename": "89e8fee66b8e5a969a37457f49c8ac0b51c3501dfd3a4d57d4419b15d3a8dbf8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the fire's burning area shrinks instead of expanding despite the ground being covered in pine needles throughout the entire sequence).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04016", "filename": "90d47c33f06fc7c47f05e10c07b26ae2496ff15282112d820d7d6f02f80627a4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is off (the edges of the fireplace flames are too sharp and the glow is unnatural, lacking the dynamic blur and smoke of real flames; the transition of light and shadow inside the fireplace is harsh and lacks the sense of depth of real combustion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04017", "filename": "90dc0025d2223cd05c159aff8fab1a75499915fea3b4892459bb22702b33beaa_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04018", "filename": "90f4878f75bd0b1dbd02623e353224dce63de42d1138f27a0e4dad8158dab126_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the black object on the right side of the screen disappears out of thin air at 0.2s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04019", "filename": "91c3c500704262a8c0d895709b16081ab37931c15272ec59b98b42d3658220cd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (when the white string in the circle is broken at 3.9 seconds, the soap film inside does not disappear).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04020", "filename": "91c3c500704262a8c0d895709b16081ab37931c15272ec59b98b42d3658220cd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.1s, a small circle appears out of thin air at the top of the stick in the hand, and at 2.9s, when the stick touches the soap film, the soap film does not explode or disappear).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04021", "filename": "093f897e52a99f9071ab4b3afdfd030d2f9b4989cc07b8e6173d52c06be09a41_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous movement (the wall is constantly flickering and writhing throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04022", "filename": "093f897e52a99f9071ab4b3afdfd030d2f9b4989cc07b8e6173d52c06be09a41_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (in reality, steam is hazy and diffused with blurred edges, but in the video it looks like a white solid line of smoke with a clear outline, a sense of entanglement and a lack of blur).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04025", "filename": "096b2912c15ea8174411d7873c788b3df53faaaeeac5965488f14bbe3c0911b2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the hydraulic press penetrates the base at 6.2s, violating the principle that solids are impermeable); Time continuity (the sand flows out in a liquid state when the hydraulic press presses down on it at 6.9s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04026", "filename": "96bb27947a7e8f09dbe431617db92018e97a0f2f4de4affa994a39aded595a5b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the right thumb penetrates the pink heart at 1.9s, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04027", "filename": "97b75b911fd053ee74804cff00956fa26d0ce43dcdf737d7ad65cfcf311e5008_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.7s, the ice cube did not melt but a large amount of water suddenly appeared under the ice cube; at 6.3s, the ice cube hit the edge of the plate and instantly shrank).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04028", "filename": "97dae0b769c7c6b7c23f3c6e1512557fede7d5faab3da754ce9845fade6e97c1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.2s, the sausage pushed to the right disappears out of thin air; at 4.1s, the two sausages merge into one; at 5.9s, when the spatula is about to scoop up one sausage, another sausage appears out of thin air in the pot).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04029", "filename": "98e2949474e77119e7d7781354f24a303a3fa5ea95370baaef94f53c92a29ed9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 6.6s, a white egg appears out of nowhere above the pink egg, and at 6.6s, the white egg disappears while a yellow egg appears out of nowhere above the pink egg).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04030", "filename": "99a2de9336b1d70d23ca4f528f1185a3cf6d7802e31920187882a25ae863ddcb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (water crowns continuously rise from the mud in the entire mud pit).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04031", "filename": "103aa70df0707db4ce3aaf053b35d70c36b40b3150b7f5efedb635b54a055e6c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the water flow is continuous (between 1.2s and 2.1s, the water droplets do not disperse but remain suspended in the air and do not fall).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04032", "filename": "120e98d9f8ba4c27f37b551767b3e49cb3e10afea6c7f08b877224c6496b11f2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual intuition is abnormal (the intense heat generated by the fire would cause uneven air density in the surrounding area, resulting in a visually distorted and slightly shaky effect in the smoke passing through the heat field. However, the smoke is flat and stable throughout, without any distortion or shaking. Moreover, the overall texture is too thick and stiff, lacking the fluffy and ethereal feel of real smoke. It looks more like a solid mass than suspended gaseous particles.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04033", "filename": "133fda5b5f13dd8da8e9f1541ea7b52457d5bc290c4931740eac14a74870f94d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.5s, when the hydraulic press hits the white object, the white object cracks instantly with a grid-like crack. In reality, the pressure is continuously applied, and the main crack extends and branches out rapidly but sequentially in all directions. The number and length of the cracks gradually increase, forming a local crack grid. At 1.8s, when the hydraulic press hits the object, debris is ejected out of thin air from the contact point between the object and the hydraulic press).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04034", "filename": "133fda5b5f13dd8da8e9f1541ea7b52457d5bc290c4931740eac14a74870f94d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (at 2.3s, the hydraulic press penetrates the white ceramic object, violating the principle that solids are impermeable). Time continuity (at 7.7s, when the hydraulic press presses down again, a complete piece of white ceramic appears out of thin air on the base of the hydraulic press).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04035", "filename": "143f1312d52a70e5cfe3899098fa49515aa295170bd8cd5520a5d4729de5ec97_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04036", "filename": "153e3dc0fba27e4ac32f726e29abf62cf17ee5f41f93951f6fa8d1f3c94965c8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Cause and effect (at 0.9s, the hydraulic press had not yet pressed down on the object, but the object was deformed; at 5.6s, the hydraulic press had completely pressed down on the thick paper, but the paper did not explode in all directions).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04037", "filename": "155c64a4f3e03bb0ddfc88d7f8c7f1a561c571f301bb21ecf610751f720879e7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall, the visuals are abnormal (the smoke can maintain a complex spiral vortex shape for a long time from 1.6s to 3.4s. In reality, smoke carried by hot air would quickly spread and deform, and would not be able to maintain this regular and lasting curled structure).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04038", "filename": "155c64a4f3e03bb0ddfc88d7f8c7f1a561c571f301bb21ecf610751f720879e7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.7s, smoke appears out of nowhere from the bottom of the flame. In reality, smoke would come out from the top of the flame. From 4.2s to 8s, the smoke should rise vertically with the hot airflow in reality, but in the video, the smoke shoots out diagonally to the upper left from the side of the flame, forming a straight column of smoke, rather than a naturally rising and spreading trajectory. The outline is straight and the boundary is clear, like a cigarette butt, without the thin, dispersed and gradually dissipating characteristics of natural smoke).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04039", "filename": "164d0a09cdf998ea5890c6c7e61e727556b91335419663dae4f5756459eba92c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 5.4s to 8s, the light source on the ground should cast shadows upwards (towards the air) or spread outwards to the ground, but in the video, the shadows of the people are cast downwards towards the ground, completely opposite to the direction of light propagation from the ground light source).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_04040", "filename": "170dfeaf4b5dbabf38971a67ef2a200dddf62d2bdf4f8d7d5d60c7444791384e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the edges of the erupting lava in the entire segment are too clear and straight, lacking the breaking, splashing, and twisting characteristics of a real lava eruption, and the shape remains almost unchanged during the eruption).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04041", "filename": "176b14b5e11b597096dc2e9e55f7f44480733b642d88c210be6fa8e2c80d00dc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is off (in reality, water reflections (especially those with ripples) are blurred, distorted, and broken due to the ripples, but the edges of the reflections in the video are too sharp and smooth, even more regular than in real life, without any trace of ripples or disturbances on the natural water surface, resembling a mirror reflection rather than a real water reflection). Temporal continuity (from 1.9s to 5s, the clouds in the sky on the left side of the frame are pale orange, while the reflections in the lake are dark orange).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04042", "filename": "180cc16709f7794290acc114cf98ab0a2fc1bff4d3d4b518e07c768bb6bad8f1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04044", "filename": "183f3f7cd1b16c0f56fa89bc22724a79314f1a51c3783973135ea6843ad179d1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04046", "filename": "194c8ee8da4f94938c81000faf163e0a9e24d9f966baa7b6909c318584b181e0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 3.2s, the blade did not make a cutting motion but moved to the left, and the object below the blade suddenly cracked open).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04047", "filename": "aa5bc75e97260521693b0520ca50f6e178c6e43bf82bcffa484af22c905e3772_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (1.6s, the clouds in the lower part of the image are shifting to the left, while the thick cumulonimbus clouds above are churning to the right, indicating inconsistent atmospheric circulation in the same area).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04048", "filename": "aa5bc75e97260521693b0520ca50f6e178c6e43bf82bcffa484af22c905e3772_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (at 5.4s, the direction of the tornado cyclone generated on the ground is completely opposite to the rotation direction of the clouds above).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04049", "filename": "aa5e9f62207bbb96d7fdabdca9d41c37e70a4d1663beb44c617417d7ca141e87_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (2.5s, the coffee machine suddenly emits a large amount of white smoke when no water is coming out of the extraction head and no red light is emitted from the heating element).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04050", "filename": "aa5e9f62207bbb96d7fdabdca9d41c37e70a4d1663beb44c617417d7ca141e87_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04051", "filename": "aa5e9f62207bbb96d7fdabdca9d41c37e70a4d1663beb44c617417d7ca141e87_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04052", "filename": "aa6ef9fb8c78e481a95ed5fca66973dad15d1c248efab9a385e66bb371a49c80_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Abnormal physical behavior (the blue component at the bottom of the video continues to rotate throughout the entire video, but no whirlpool or water flow disturbance is formed on the water surface it is in contact with).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04053", "filename": "aa6ef9fb8c78e481a95ed5fca66973dad15d1c248efab9a385e66bb371a49c80_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Abnormal physical behavior (1.6s - End of the process) The glass, which was stationary and not subjected to any external force, moves synchronously with the egg inside the glass when the finger on the outside of the glass moves downwards without contact.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04054", "filename": "aa6ef9fb8c78e481a95ed5fca66973dad15d1c248efab9a385e66bb371a49c80_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Abnormal physical behavior (from 1.2s to 4.5s, the egg that was originally floating on the water surface sank to the bottom on its own without any change in liquid density or volume or any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04055", "filename": "aa6ef9fb8c78e481a95ed5fca66973dad15d1c248efab9a385e66bb371a49c80_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Abnormal physical behavior (1.2s, when the finger is pointing at the egg from the outside of the glass without touching it, the egg inside the glass immediately begins to sink).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04056", "filename": "aa8d76f79dc43b7009f2cb65cb5f256e101b01fe468a6ab9461d861644dbd741_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (2.2s-4.3s, the tomato on the left side originally had a crack, which suddenly disappeared without external repair, and the skin returned to its smooth and intact state).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04057", "filename": "aa8d76f79dc43b7009f2cb65cb5f256e101b01fe468a6ab9461d861644dbd741_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Abnormal physical behavior (the tomato was still moving 3.6 seconds after entering the water, but the ripples on the water surface were almost still, and the tomato did not continue to sink or float due to inertia after entering the water but came to a complete stop).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04058", "filename": "aa8d76f79dc43b7009f2cb65cb5f256e101b01fe468a6ab9461d861644dbd741_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Abnormal physical behavior (at 1s, when the second falling tomato came into contact with the first tomato that had already sunk to the bottom, it did not collide, bounce, or deform, but instead passed directly through and overlapped with it).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04059", "filename": "aa8d76f79dc43b7009f2cb65cb5f256e101b01fe468a6ab9461d861644dbd741_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Abnormal physical behavior (at 4.7s, the water splashing outwards around the tomato on the right suddenly and spontaneously returned to the surface of the tomato without any external force, and left no watermarks).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04060", "filename": "aa190d7b67960ea4483eaf308db5106e73501be238d1359f90c47c03c033a175_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal time continuity (2s to 3.1s. The white line on the left side of the screen suddenly disappears and then reappears without warning).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04061", "filename": "aa190d7b67960ea4483eaf308db5106e73501be238d1359f90c47c03c033a175_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (2.3s When trying to break the magnetic ball with both hands, the ball did not first crack and then disperse; instead, it split cleanly in half from the middle. The two separated parts did not reconnect due to the magnetic force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04062", "filename": "aa190d7b67960ea4483eaf308db5106e73501be238d1359f90c47c03c033a175_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (3.8s, several small balls in the red magnetic ball area separated and floated on their own without any external force pulling them, without any magnetic attraction or gravity causing them to fall).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04063", "filename": "aa190d7b67960ea4483eaf308db5106e73501be238d1359f90c47c03c033a175_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04068", "filename": "aaad36a31a8f57231a5bfa4e6127cc6739ff60318bb93607dff1d78709d92b55_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Abnormal physical behavior (the dolphin keeps wagging its tail throughout the video, but the water surface does not produce corresponding ripples as a result of its wagging).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04069", "filename": "aaad36a31a8f57231a5bfa4e6127cc6739ff60318bb93607dff1d78709d92b55_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (at the beginning of the video, the dolphin's tail floats on the surface of the water, then without any transition, its head floats on the surface. Furthermore, when it enters and exits the water, it does not create the strong splash that should be present for its size, and the water surface remains balanced).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04070", "filename": "aaad36a31a8f57231a5bfa4e6127cc6739ff60318bb93607dff1d78709d92b55_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the continuity of time is abnormal (at 0.6s, the dolphin's body posture suddenly changes, and the tail that was originally on the surface of the water suddenly turns into the head facing the surface of the water, without a transition process).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04071", "filename": "aabc249d5f8e43462539ce96beded17dee39ed105bc6f7169c2c8fb0d9d63601_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical anomaly (the flames of the three candles in the bowl in the entire video are violently and synchronously shaking. However, the dry grass on the right side of the screen, adjacent to the flames, shows no signs of being blown by the wind, creating a contradiction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04072", "filename": "aabc249d5f8e43462539ce96beded17dee39ed105bc6f7169c2c8fb0d9d63601_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (1.4s) The intensity of the flame of the blue crystal candle slightly to the left of the bowl suddenly increases out of nowhere.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04073", "filename": "aabc249d5f8e43462539ce96beded17dee39ed105bc6f7169c2c8fb0d9d63601_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04074", "filename": "aabf4462d952f9329457507545c432670c2ee9d1df93fa5075a9e61d33aa5f6d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: The fish is swimming in the sea throughout the video. However, no ripples are generated around its body, and the ripples in the sea are completely unaffected by the fish's movement.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04075", "filename": "aabf4462d952f9329457507545c432670c2ee9d1df93fa5075a9e61d33aa5f6d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (0.4s) The originally clear light green seawater suddenly turned dark blue without any transition of light or depth change.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04076", "filename": "aabf4462d952f9329457507545c432670c2ee9d1df93fa5075a9e61d33aa5f6d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04077", "filename": "aabf4462d952f9329457507545c432670c2ee9d1df93fa5075a9e61d33aa5f6d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Abnormal time continuity (3.2s, the fish\u2019s body posture suddenly changed from the original swimming posture with its head in front and tail behind to a posture with its head behind and tail in front without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04078", "filename": "aac48e488c384cb6f3d9dd0fb2bf7a46218142db90a827b05e71b08ef909482b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (2.4s The shape of the clouds on the left side of the screen changes abruptly, the originally loose cumulus clouds suddenly become regular flocculent without any airflow transition)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04079", "filename": "aac48e488c384cb6f3d9dd0fb2bf7a46218142db90a827b05e71b08ef909482b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (2.1s: the clouds on the left side of the screen move to the right, and the clouds on the right side move to the left; the directions of movement of the clouds on both sides are completely opposite).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04080", "filename": "aac48e488c384cb6f3d9dd0fb2bf7a46218142db90a827b05e71b08ef909482b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (2:20s, there are splicing marks on the clouds on the right side of the screen, the edges of a bright white cloud are too neat, completely different from the fluffy round texture of the surrounding clouds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04081", "filename": "aac48e488c384cb6f3d9dd0fb2bf7a46218142db90a827b05e71b08ef909482b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04082", "filename": "aaf914ae6523fd4100567a8f0572bd21e9ad7f3ba97c1ba5fab57c17584083a8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (coffee continuously flows from the coffee machine into the cup throughout the video, but the amount of coffee in the cup does not gradually increase).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04083", "filename": "aaf914ae6523fd4100567a8f0572bd21e9ad7f3ba97c1ba5fab57c17584083a8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (3s) The coffee liquid flowing from the two outlets of the coffee machine did not mix together after falling into the cup, and each maintained its own independent liquid pouring pattern.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04084", "filename": "aaf914ae6523fd4100567a8f0572bd21e9ad7f3ba97c1ba5fab57c17584083a8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04085", "filename": "aaf914ae6523fd4100567a8f0572bd21e9ad7f3ba97c1ba5fab57c17584083a8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (5.6s, the coffee machine continues to pour coffee into the glass, but the thickness of the coffee foam inside the glass decreases instead of increasing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04086", "filename": "ab0e8c119565e0e806eb326e831cb45be5bce3d76e41c453c3882f0b53845e3d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (2.2s-3.3s, the orange block at the top of the leftmost colored light-emitting device suddenly disappears without transition and then reappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04087", "filename": "256a669c812771c395cfd88ed550abffa2cf605225a8cf3ed1e7885ffa285167_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the entire video shows water being heated and evaporating in an air fryer, but the shape and size of the bubbles produced by the evaporation do not change at all from beginning to end. Under normal circumstances, the bubbles should gradually disappear as the water evaporates.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04088", "filename": "256a669c812771c395cfd88ed550abffa2cf605225a8cf3ed1e7885ffa285167_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (at 5 seconds, the water bubbles in the air fryer suddenly turn into yellow pancake-shaped food).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04089", "filename": "256ae6883da4a846016a85a0e88eacd73f085cf384a097787c6452bd8db40288_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Time Continuity (At 3.1 seconds, the reflection of the upper diamond suddenly disappears. Throughout the video, the shape and size of the upper diamond continuously change as it rotates.) Physical Behavior (Throughout the video, the upper diamond floats on the sloping surface of the lower diamond without any supporting structure, violating the law of gravity.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04090", "filename": "256ae6883da4a846016a85a0e88eacd73f085cf384a097787c6452bd8db40288_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (ghosting occurs between the diamonds and their reflections throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04091", "filename": "256ae6883da4a846016a85a0e88eacd73f085cf384a097787c6452bd8db40288_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (ghosting occurs between the diamonds and their reflections throughout the video). Physical behavior (the two diamonds reflect on a smooth surface throughout the video, and the reflections are asymmetrical with respect to the original objects, and the reflections are blurry and distorted. Normally, the reflections should be symmetrical and clear with respect to the original objects).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04092", "filename": "256ae6883da4a846016a85a0e88eacd73f085cf384a097787c6452bd8db40288_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical behavior (In the entire video, the two diamonds reflect on a smooth surface, and the reflections are not asymmetrical with respect to the original objects, and the reflections are blurry and distorted. Under normal circumstances, the reflections should be symmetrical with respect to the original objects).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04093", "filename": "261d0bffa041536f94eb53981b4e0bbec439de3be6b85d49988f44e9f172feb1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the movement of the water is too smooth, unlike real water flow, lacking the random splashes and natural branching that water flows, and water droplets falling on the water surface only produce ripples, without producing random splashes).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04094", "filename": "261d0bffa041536f94eb53981b4e0bbec439de3be6b85d49988f44e9f172feb1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04095", "filename": "261d0bffa041536f94eb53981b4e0bbec439de3be6b85d49988f44e9f172feb1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04096", "filename": "263c50096b73bfc3a74b8baef411399ed988cea49ad467e4c2e01fafac482fc6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (Throughout the entire video, even when the camera remains stationary, the light reflected from the diamond keeps changing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04097", "filename": "266bb2c9336f82058a0061749ef98f8b7542598afb113d77455fef6aab97caae_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is continuous (at 0 seconds, the small steel balls on the sand below the basin suddenly disappear. Throughout the video, steel balls are continuously poured into the basin, but the number of steel balls in the basin remains unchanged.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04098", "filename": "266bb2c9336f82058a0061749ef98f8b7542598afb113d77455fef6aab97caae_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the sand next to the basin flickers throughout the video). Overall visual anomalies (the sand next to the basin in the video is too dense and orderly, unlike real sand, lacking the chaotic feel of real sand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04099", "filename": "266bb2c9336f82058a0061749ef98f8b7542598afb113d77455fef6aab97caae_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The video is continuous in time (3.4s-8s, showing sandstorms and obvious changes in the terrain of the beach next to the basin, but no trace of sand entering the basin). Overall visual anomalies: (The sand next to the basin in the video is too dense and orderly, unlike real sand, lacking the chaotic feel of real sand.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04100", "filename": "281b3fe9e6514bedf03d431c5e5f342633fc67d84c829040d45f911ff647709b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (at 1.2s, the tea poured into the teacup suddenly disappears. From 0 to 1.3s, tea continues to be poured into the teacup, but there is no change in the teacup's appearance.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04101", "filename": "281b3fe9e6514bedf03d431c5e5f342633fc67d84c829040d45f911ff647709b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04102", "filename": "281b3fe9e6514bedf03d431c5e5f342633fc67d84c829040d45f911ff647709b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04107", "filename": "297a4ec4ba3c3a00aa3a6f191323996c8123e3649a4af7d0409752e28a714da1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is inconsistent (the clouds in the sky move in different directions throughout the video; the upper clouds move forward while the lower clouds move backward. Normally, clouds in the same environment should move in the same direction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04108", "filename": "297a4ec4ba3c3a00aa3a6f191323996c8123e3649a4af7d0409752e28a714da1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04109", "filename": "297a4ec4ba3c3a00aa3a6f191323996c8123e3649a4af7d0409752e28a714da1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (at 4.1 seconds, a portion of the clouds on the left suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04110", "filename": "297a4ec4ba3c3a00aa3a6f191323996c8123e3649a4af7d0409752e28a714da1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04111", "filename": "300b4ab6c4d9dc8381348d4b89bae6ab89276c38e51d2a05f8ec59d7a9c7519d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the entire video shows the burning process of paper, but the burn marks on the paper remain unchanged throughout). Physical behavior (throughout the entire video, no smoke is produced during the burning process).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04112", "filename": "300b4ab6c4d9dc8381348d4b89bae6ab89276c38e51d2a05f8ec59d7a9c7519d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (Throughout the entire video, no smoke was produced during the burning of the paper.)", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04113", "filename": "300b4ab6c4d9dc8381348d4b89bae6ab89276c38e51d2a05f8ec59d7a9c7519d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the entire video shows the burning process of paper, during which the paper is visibly deformed, but the burn marks on the paper remain unchanged throughout the entire process.) Physical behavior (throughout the entire video, no smoke is produced during the burning process.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04114", "filename": "300b4ab6c4d9dc8381348d4b89bae6ab89276c38e51d2a05f8ec59d7a9c7519d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (Throughout the entire video, no smoke was produced during the burning of the paper.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04115", "filename": "300c08acab0973c0f07d9262514366c2b8fdd32bbad3cab94e700a9290e52697_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04116", "filename": "300c08acab0973c0f07d9262514366c2b8fdd32bbad3cab94e700a9290e52697_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (in the entire video, water appears to flow out of thin air from the right arm of the child statue above the two human statues.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04117", "filename": "07bb1e3cf7cc7d33244bf2c11fb14bfe268e4601edb6152cf5ac5ba4ae7af8e9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time frame is continuous (the fire did not increase in size between 0.4s and 0.5s, but the flames suddenly became brighter).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04118", "filename": "07bb1e3cf7cc7d33244bf2c11fb14bfe268e4601edb6152cf5ac5ba4ae7af8e9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Cause and effect relationship (the object in the image is burning, and there should be signs of carbonization, shrinkage, or ash falling off, but the object does not change at all).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04119", "filename": "07c4dd59618c2edbe1f6874bf650e2af7b235e511cf228bcfa4805b8d14a312c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous. (At 2 seconds, just as the hydraulic press crushes the wood and the debris has not yet completely dispersed, a whole long piece of wood flies out diagonally from the lower right side of the screen, on the right edge of the hydraulic press platform, which violates the law of force. This abrupt ejection does not conform to the logic of compression mechanics.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04120", "filename": "07c4dd59618c2edbe1f6874bf650e2af7b235e511cf228bcfa4805b8d14a312c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 1.3s, when the hydraulic press head contacts the wood block, the force that should be vertically downward causes the left side of the wood to break first, and the debris does not fly outward as during normal pressing, but instead is drawn towards the center of the press head, which clearly violates the stress dispersion principle in mechanics of materials.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04121", "filename": "07c4dd59618c2edbe1f6874bf650e2af7b235e511cf228bcfa4805b8d14a312c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (there are two obvious anomalies in the baseball bat's breaking process between 1.5s and 5.5s: first, when the hydraulic press just goes down, the baseball bat is not squeezed and bent first, but explodes into fragments directly from the point of force, which does not conform to the characteristic of wood deforming before breaking under pressure; second, the exploded fragments and wood chips do not fly downwards or outwards, but instead gather in the area between the hydraulic press and the base as if they are being attracted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04126", "filename": "07e3699e35112ed08a050d965d300f579333daabf909064185f441e7bc6b299c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the milk latte art in the video has obvious physical anomalies; the ripples of freshly poured milk blending with coffee do not change dynamically, but rather appear to be a static pattern playing in a loop).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04127", "filename": "07e3699e35112ed08a050d965d300f579333daabf909064185f441e7bc6b299c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (there is a noticeable jump in the latte art pattern between 0s and 3.4s: the original spiral pattern suddenly becomes a symmetrical leaf shape, without the transition process of milk flowing and forming in the middle).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04128", "filename": "07e3699e35112ed08a050d965d300f579333daabf909064185f441e7bc6b299c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04129", "filename": "7a0d78a197b60f00322df87268929cba70676d8b62c8217f4a6ca351f489bfb2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (0.2s-2.7s screen reset; the originally rich, colorful spiral pattern suddenly turns into a blurry monochrome disk, then instantly jumps back to the previous complex pattern; the entire process lacks a smooth, fluid transition).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04130", "filename": "7a0d78a197b60f00322df87268929cba70676d8b62c8217f4a6ca351f489bfb2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (two anomalies occurred between 0.2s and 5.8s: first, the colorful spiral pattern was instantly and completely covered by a pure green plane without any color transition; then the green plane immediately jumped back to the same colorful pattern as before, with even the details of the pattern completely overlapping, clearly indicating that the image was forcibly replaced.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04131", "filename": "7a0d78a197b60f00322df87268929cba70676d8b62c8217f4a6ca351f489bfb2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.6s, the movement of the colored fluid exhibits a logical break: the spiral patterns that were originally converging towards the center suddenly reverse and diffuse in the opposite direction without external interference, and all color layers and flow trajectories change direction synchronously in an instant, violating the principles of inertia and continuity of fluid motion.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04132", "filename": "7a0d78a197b60f00322df87268929cba70676d8b62c8217f4a6ca351f489bfb2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (between 1.4s and 2.2s, the originally dispersed colored spiral patterns instantly transformed into symmetrical patterns radiating outwards from the center without any flow process. Not only did the fluid's motion inertia completely disappear, but the symmetry of the pattern also violated the random laws of natural diffusion.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04133", "filename": "7a50ae7489c8db11ecb99b00ebc14ec33408d35143a853bfc082f0be1d5f60d7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the movement of the smoke is obviously abnormal (normal hot smoke should continue to rise and gradually spread, but the smoke here does not dissipate naturally after rising to the top of the screen. Instead, it repeatedly shows the same curling and rebounding shape in the same position, like a fixed 3D animation playing in a loop).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04134", "filename": "7a50ae7489c8db11ecb99b00ebc14ec33408d35143a853bfc082f0be1d5f60d7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (an unusual spatial jump at 4.8s: the burning incense stick and the white ash at the top suddenly shifted nearly one centimeter to the right of the screen, while the incense stick itself remained completely still. This is equivalent to the incense stick detaching from the stick and teleporting independently, violating the structural continuity of the object.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04135", "filename": "7a50ae7489c8db11ecb99b00ebc14ec33408d35143a853bfc082f0be1d5f60d7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is as follows: (3.8s-4.6s) First, the ash from the incense stick suddenly flies vertically upwards without any external force, violating the laws of gravity; then, the smoke that was originally drifting naturally instantly condenses into a perfect circle and remains stationary for two seconds, which is completely inconsistent with the motion characteristics of fluids.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04136", "filename": "7aa1f6f8bc42e29f41efe5432ae7d00b81de4c9f4e61d661b4d1ec7027575819_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Continuous time (abnormal changes in the mass of objects throughout the video: originally only half a spoonful of minced meat, after being poured onto the steamed egg custard, suddenly doubled in volume, and the newly added minced meat did not flow out of the spoon, but seemed to \"grow\" out of thin air from the surface of the steamed egg custard, violating the law of conservation of mass and the logic of spatial occupancy of objects.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04137", "filename": "7aa1f6f8bc42e29f41efe5432ae7d00b81de4c9f4e61d661b4d1ec7027575819_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04138", "filename": "7aa1f6f8bc42e29f41efe5432ae7d00b81de4c9f4e61d661b4d1ec7027575819_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.7s, some of the minced meat in the spoon appeared directly in the pile of meat on the steamed egg custard before it even touched the surface of the custard, without any falling process in between).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04139", "filename": "7aa1f6f8bc42e29f41efe5432ae7d00b81de4c9f4e61d661b4d1ec7027575819_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (after the minced meat in the spoon is poured out between 1.5s and 5.5s, there is no more sauce left, but the next second a large amount of dark brown sauce suddenly gushes out from the pile of meat. Not only does it have no source, but it also instantly \"submerges\" the original half bowl of minced meat into a full bowl, which violates the law of conservation of mass and the logic of spatial occupancy of objects.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04140", "filename": "7aaa101fb712e2f6f4754c75be5d1ea9ff7ca7a34d7ebb5abf65b32f4649dab8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04141", "filename": "7aaa101fb712e2f6f4754c75be5d1ea9ff7ca7a34d7ebb5abf65b32f4649dab8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the visuals: Time continuity (Although the surface of the object appears to be scorched by flames, there is no carbonization, shrinkage, or ash falling off. Instead, it continues to grow and split in the flames, and even new spike structures grow on the burning parts).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04142", "filename": "7aaa101fb712e2f6f4754c75be5d1ea9ff7ca7a34d7ebb5abf65b32f4649dab8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 2.3s, a black silhouette of a human figure suddenly appears in the red vines, but this silhouette neither obscures nor is obscured by the vines. The pixels of the two completely overlap, forming a \"passing through\" effect, which violates the spatial occlusion relationship of objects in reality.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04143", "filename": "7ab8b72463b207d2de5ebb42412f1c9ab2cef70a5cbd31ad299ef40759311447_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04145", "filename": "7ab8b72463b207d2de5ebb42412f1c9ab2cef70a5cbd31ad299ef40759311447_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.4s, the ice cube that was originally on the right side of the glass appeared directly on the far left of the screen without sliding or rolling, and its reflection also moved instantaneously).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04146", "filename": "7b7d320f6051517cc4fca71a6ac51d15823748dfa6318db90600c85aa2001c6a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the ice is melting, but unlike normal ice, it does not start melting from the point of contact with the plate and form a puddle. Instead, a large number of bubbles are generated inside and they are gathering towards the center, as if the inside is \"boiling\" rather than the surface absorbing heat and melting).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04147", "filename": "1f122703236d3a8c11ff42b285eec658e24d812e928556d47d3e7dcfc146e91f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.5s, the liquid being heated boils, and the surface of the liquid suddenly becomes smooth and uniform, which is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04151", "filename": "02bddc7e968b2a887fe769f216d95cc536269a2672e3e9bc9b8d720ac3fa0e1e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (water falls into the glass at 0.5s without creating a splash).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04152", "filename": "02c65189c5e417dbee9311831c6f51777c0d763e19a91f0f7e539a4d81e55790_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (at normal playback speed, the fireworks explosions rise and fall slowly and sluggishly).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04153", "filename": "2a3f5f9f024a9865280ad0a7aa521e426576920a32d335e1538bb7c99960f572_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior (the light source is in front, so the object's shadow should appear behind it instead of to the side, violating the principle that light travels in straight lines).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04154", "filename": "2a39c67849bf1e4087bd65b4c19f663453b41c5695c947bf3004b9a951772e57_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The overall visual is abnormal: the time sequence is not continuous (the bamboo forest in the image is abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04155", "filename": "2a56e801b4b099e0dee02e9ce6931aae04b73a9bc920c690d352f9a85fbf6afe_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (The movement of bubbles in the liquid showed obvious abnormalities: Under normal circumstances, bubbles near the cup wall should continue to rise due to buoyancy, but at 5.4s in the video, a string of bubbles on the left side of the screen that had already risen to the waist of the cup suddenly began to move downwards, and even overlapped with newly generated small bubbles below without merging, which clearly violated the basic principles of fluid mechanics.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04156", "filename": "2aef961e242b33653290b624dd0c879c8b880f23653310fdc7e7d9f0b9331a4b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time sequence is continuous (at 4.1 seconds, the water flow suddenly slows down, violating the laws of gravity and inertia).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04157", "filename": "2b2ab8e048d46836a37eeac7a6c0e6f6287fdfdc9948029425dcc89a78f45a7e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the purple portion of the image is abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04158", "filename": "2b2cb5179a52f6549b3bccd433c14f748c288163fd01166200b30a043bc9e230_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04159", "filename": "2b4c88c81484dc0499d788d9251a6d8cda02d77c8b245afe7a4f1af1b145a0fe_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is not continuous (the smoke from the explosion does not dissipate, there is no movement, the visuals are stiff and unrealistic).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04160", "filename": "2b58e2aabf3a4221f14f32ac857e2a5c36b04243fa01d63e6598cd934910058f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (between 2.5s and 3.4s, a layer of fine colored ripples suddenly appeared in the beams of sunlight passing through the grass blades. These ripples did not change with the movement of the grass blades or the flow of air, like static stickers on the screen, which does not conform to the real Tyndall effect where light changes dynamically with the environment).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04161", "filename": "2b164b6caaca33b49114de313c265859e5be85f7f1de170031f93d783df5d665_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (firecrackers suddenly appear at 1s, and unlit firecrackers explode automatically at 6.1s, so the causal relationship is not valid).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04162", "filename": "2b43645631179a97c030e5e601be35dca5b5e49c30c3941f9b8e5cd42a1588c5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04163", "filename": "2bc51a0f77a612c90822812902a7910406373da53d3e62c97a5dcaf814a60cae_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.5 seconds, the scraper has not yet touched the chocolate, but the chocolate has already started to twist, which is inconsistent with the force it is subjected to).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04164", "filename": "2c4fc2ada08eabc0225b40352c64d4d95e0492b4c1615761f5bdac7d8b4382cc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04165", "filename": "2c10d3e5cc44a6ee32be682a9a0545b2c20333a8002ba4b858526344344f8be4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is that the time is continuous (the barbell passes through the blue object at 1.6s, which violates the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04166", "filename": "2c1260f556002c03e963ccbef8f6db45b9c69993dfab9cfd3735ade32d98aeb9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is not continuous (the candle does not change at all during the burning process, which violates the law of conservation of energy, and the flame's movement is too regular and not realistic).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04168", "filename": "2d71ce0466baee5bad69c668d32f578f936e8eb098d922602f85ff32b2fcdadb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is too continuous (the fireworks release is too regular, lacking randomness, resulting in a stiff and unrealistic visual appearance).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_04169", "filename": "2d4510153af05d451c633fd7d5f15fe343e1b69747d9ffe49888de4f98fb076d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04170", "filename": "2dae7a57563fb6ae35a7cb4c1d7f52148cc6a691da85f42935d67180d9c8c822_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04171", "filename": "2dbf2ac94163f3a800f9e4bbb5776a566df9262d7dcf343a9b76e25a9397f813_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is discontinuous (the candle flame in the scene is too rigid and lacks the realistic flickering of burning).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04172", "filename": "2dde096d4114da0c0e18f5645e9bdb5f23f08759510ca14fafcd3ffb1b16fa52_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 3.2s, colorful radial light patterns suddenly appeared above the sun. These patterns did not move with the clouds, nor did they correspond to the reflections on the sea surface. They were static effects superimposed on the screen out of thin air, and their appearance and disappearance were very abrupt, completely inconsistent with real optical phenomena.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04173", "filename": "2e2a748fe18e8c6bdf755a4acf289f6b93d51f2ff4d3bbd227c66e53306148db_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not smooth: the timing is too abrupt (the bubbles freeze too quickly, the video is not smooth, and the bubbles suddenly grow larger at 7s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04175", "filename": "2e54b9a2b9d648eeefe737f5a966dc00fa005c933187cb000e6ac85e53c83cb4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04176", "filename": "2e66cb82ebb641ee1cc61c99dc83587321bb90064c6c73ce190e22022954ae93_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous, (the changes in the smoke do not conform to the laws of physics: normal dry ice smoke will flow downwards continuously due to low temperature and high density, fill the water tank and then overflow, but the smoke in the video disappears into thin air as quickly as if it has been deleted after being poured into the water tank, without a natural dissipation or settling process, and the boundary when it disappears is very abrupt, as if the special effects layer was erased in post-production.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04177", "filename": "37a32282f028a9c092eb792a8dcbd1624c39b5d1891e5c25c6213e406c3f1ed5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity: (Without changing the camera angle, at 2.1 seconds, the tangled string in the upper left corner of the yo-yo suddenly becomes a single line.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04178", "filename": "38f5756e330f54ee00af2a45a752f69411d39b1b26e31e74d5ab4ccd221ced5a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04179", "filename": "40f43731b8ef868e3d488b6f8f64aa1b813a421743227d5b9b417bbf12762c5b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity: (The light clusters on the left side of the screen appear repeatedly and irregularly, with perfectly synchronized shapes, positions, and rhythms, without any natural changes or transitions; it's a single, looping segment. The repetitive trajectory is rigid and jarring.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04181", "filename": "41c70230b27863f2091eee3c34e9909e991a1b4442c350583d9ea7fdfae57d68_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity: (Throughout the video, the flames did not spread through contact ignition, but rather spread in a non-contact manner, and the burned areas did not show any curling or rolling ash, nor any signs of carbonization or blackening.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04182", "filename": "41f1dd7cd6cf8925fd3c69826dcaa7c2bc89f7d34db8860c23ca2c56233a3112_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity: (The texture of the ice in the image is distorted. The surface lacks the natural rough texture and crack texture unique to real ice. The overall image is too flat and smooth, lacking the textural details of real ice.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04183", "filename": "42dbb623f038be639a5a1212d4a8dde5d0165ef5c08810e46078c3153388b76b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity: (Without any camera movement, at 3.6 seconds, the shadow above the container disappears out of thin air)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04184", "filename": "42fdecc7f14adbb094e923192839a79a96c8a15cd157766c4be3a8e1fd2fd019_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity: (Without any camera movement, at 1.2 seconds, a yellow object appears out of thin air in the character's hand holding the knife handle.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04185", "filename": "43e49dda84b16c83ddf0e8beacc91458243ed579c3ae97ce2f7fb5c2cd92b959_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity: (The shockwave from the violent explosion in the scene did not affect nearby objects. The objects showed no physical reaction of shaking or displacement, nor any change in shape after being impacted.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04186", "filename": "43f6388f0530d0e912b2a3e6bf5efec7ede47fccd87672214735b6fdec51dc21_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity: (Under the premise of no camera change, no external force or interference, the object in the lower right corner of the screen moves backward on its own at 0.4s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04187", "filename": "43fc78f8b3bbffb08b2df5ae7426e4b52aa84b0154989c4aefc4b5a2d82f3791_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity: (The bubbles in the image do not have the transparent texture or natural light and shadow refraction effect of normal bubbles. Instead, they are covered with mixed and distorted textures, with colors intertwined and tangled, just like paint that has been deliberately mixed together.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04188", "filename": "44f504299ad74e2f5c852890c93f90dc08dec86fdeed96cac4f4234e198da18f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity: (Under the premise of no external force or interference, the sheet metal is flat at 3.2s, and then bends instantly in the next frame)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04189", "filename": "45a06c414324da336e7e6bba58efb2c24c46eefe3dc7b1de540c98f480585a8b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity: (Without any camera transition, at 1.7s, a white dot appears out of nowhere on the object in the upper right corner of the screen.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04190", "filename": "45c0dae4f5ef70fc78f0d10d9bc553e09830952108b454cdaa1062e2c709afa7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity: (The water mist in the image remains suspended in the air for an extended period without dissipating, and it does not exhibit the expected dispersion and softness of water mist. There is no normal diffusion or drifting process. Furthermore, the water mist has a harsh, blocky appearance, and the edges are too neat and rigid.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04191", "filename": "46d9bc583dac29485aec819dd400d37292c55a3573a848622321b6ef9b013b4b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04192", "filename": "47cace0577315eaf805c173da1a60d130085b0f29b7e8fed11c7d5037bc0ea74_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image quality: Time continuity: (Under the premise of no camera movement and no external force or interference, the vent in the upper right corner of the image closes automatically at 3.2 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04193", "filename": "48f143ea6f444760886dd863a0b1245b8476be66596ca740bccf5ef5ec8ae8fc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity: (When the liquid flows in the image, the surface does not show the ripples, waves, and undulations that a natural liquid should have; it is flat throughout and there are no dynamic texture changes.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04194", "filename": "49d18ec3495c6c65b68e80406c7e26568858261c44e779eb99469250d70f9789_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity: (The right rear of the image in the entire video is abnormally distorted)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04195", "filename": "49ee5d02bbd0fd12ea72b6c608a2706fd824096b3664775dd3d749111f56b16e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the entire aurora in the video is not continuous; it lacks the flowing and graceful feel characteristic of the aurora, the light band remains stationary, and the edges of the laser beams appear somewhat harsh, lacking a natural, hazy blur. Furthermore, the transitions between light and shadow in some areas lack smooth gradations).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04196", "filename": "49ee9b019a21543d2ecad487c11cf23d0abd5230c291d6f578fed1d7c3234496_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity: (Under the premise of no camera change and no external force interference, no water seeps out or flows from the melting point during the entire process of the ice melting, and no water accumulates in the melting area)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04197", "filename": "49fa2edbbdae5452876857e737b621058a528461217a4eaaa9c203bf526a1abd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity: (Without any camera transition, at 1.3s, a white fog appears out of nowhere to the left of the sun)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04198", "filename": "49fb8801b94439ce89ea3e8e866fdaebb3637afdb65f49fec24a53fd7e381367_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity: (Without any camera movement, at 0.1s, the oil droplet disappears instantly to the left of the screen)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04199", "filename": "50c72f0a80197dcb60ba8affd3b31a007d1273f78e65a02b2134baae6a831394_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Time continuity: (Under the premise of no external force or interference, the kayak moves against the current on its own)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04200", "filename": "50feb246ebe6eba69d76525e94f8ab01d846a78e107515ec1a7c85cd81b2dcef_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity: (The surface of the object on the left side of the screen always has a noticeable reflective effect, and the light and shadow are consistent, but at 3.4s, the reflection disappears out of nowhere without any cause.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04202", "filename": "52e4145aff90cfa45355439f8259f27d70e866af89918f5ba74e275c2df27f60_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the visuals: Time continuity: (Sunlight reflecting off the water surface does not rise and fall with the water ripples, the ripples are scattered, and there is no corresponding swaying or breaking effect. It always maintains a fixed shape and is completely disconnected from the dynamics of the water surface.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04203", "filename": "53c2eb51ccefdfef1ccd54e5c307d52978298cbd1f57c85555f46911bb0d98a6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity: (Without any camera transition, a face appears out of thin air under the character's hand at 1.7 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04204", "filename": "53cf13c7f08421ea7f9ebdaf1cc5f07f888b37f23c579169d857cfb56adc321d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity: (Under the condition of no external force or object interference, the object rotates on its own at 0.1s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04205", "filename": "53d8d78b76b71e1006c8e386f39250a4c45264e15f870d0c5a5a44bc08bc8a65_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity: (At 3.8s, without any camera transition, the character's left middle finger disappears out of thin air)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04206", "filename": "54c0787645ac1b00e60de9a49a94ef9c3a65729766e5f6bbaf37954fa9406b8a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity: (Without any camera shift, at 3.6s, the knife in the frame suddenly becomes thinner)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04207", "filename": "cccb3be0a67694a6a1c51f5c646ab70582167e01e77cfcdcc3ce5e2e606be954_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Physical behavior (4.8s - at the end, the diamond surface changed abruptly from \"crystal clear\" to \"frosted plastic texture\", the reflective properties were completely changed, the transparency disappeared, which does not conform to the optical principle)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04208", "filename": "ce51ab327cb522e4bdfc1c186fa8c7cb9612c565e1bbf449d99ea071a68ce0c9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (there are no signs of \"burning\" at the point where the flames contact the firewood throughout the entire video, and the firewood remains unchanged). (At the beginning - 2.4 seconds, the sky color changes drastically (sunset accelerates), but the state of the flames and firewood remains almost unchanged.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04209", "filename": "cf250f8bce224874a1893a24f7b297dfd0aa6eea6a85ce3b5658650b24a30e91_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (the polar bear's movement is blurred at 2.4s, and its limbs appear to be stretched unnaturally); Time continuity (the polar bear is paddling in the water throughout the video, but the water surface remains mirror-like and calm).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04210", "filename": "d14face55e11a39b8a3bebb807b5ec8a1fc2a1f27f6856e2877bef9890d9393f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (4.8 seconds, the color scheme changes from warm to cool instantly, and the intermediate transition colors are missing) (the position of the sun remains almost unchanged throughout the entire segment, but the direction and intensity of the light and shadow on the ground change drastically).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04211", "filename": "d56aab3a5ea94f6a0fcb66f57f1c690b9b30857c2a5264ca6470a3ef26dfea8c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (4.3s - at the end, the smoke is too dense and suspended without spreading, violating the laws of buoyancy and diffusion). Time continuity (at 1.4s, a large amount of smoke is generated out of thin air the instant the hand is immersed, and no reaction occurs).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04213", "filename": "d511a9623f0eb36c5a4d068786ea93d0e5ba87602783c9482ca73348c84705ec_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical anomaly (the person's hand was not holding the kettle lid at 0.8s, but the kettle lid was opened, which does not conform to the law of interaction of forces).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04214", "filename": "d987bc6ea7cd5b89f78193bf975a83d6298c2c27dc7e1b2f329d11d8b01a4373_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (4s - showing flow and crack patterns at the end of lava flow) (deformation occurs on the distant hills).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04217", "filename": "d926169efa86c1ff560bab34c62f0d8476dfc995c99cf889b1d417ad20d65ca7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.2 seconds, the sky abruptly changes from overcast to clear blue, with a complete change in cloud formation) (The entire snowfall is completely still, showing no weathering, melting, or shape change).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04218", "filename": "d4971375213aba0cca30eb10d45cfc6615fb3af6b780a6df77a31be50945beee_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a perfect concentric vortex suddenly appears in the lower right corner at 1.8s, but there is no inlet flow, no rotation source, and no energy input).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04219", "filename": "da597961fc01282b8df3d40a815f2b0d08cb23cd016d1ed8bb0967b4880b5cbb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 2.3s, the gas stove behind the match suddenly ignites, and the match disappears) (at 3s - end, a row of matches appears out of thin air on the table and starts burning).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04220", "filename": "db2345fe607a7083567172c6560945563b1eebdfd60dad5ee802fe11b555c977_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.2s, the small balls gathered together on the left suddenly scatter). Physical behavior (at 3.1s onwards, the two colors of the balls are completely and uniformly mixed, but the magnetic force should cause the like poles to repel and the unlike poles to attract, resulting in layering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04222", "filename": "de0f45309a3a872699a51cafa0823af97757a0bcbe4edfd8ae3a22561132a38c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to the following physical behavior: (After a glass ball is dropped vertically from a height, it suddenly rolls forward rapidly after 0.2 seconds, which does not conform to the law of conservation of energy.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04223", "filename": "decd0ee4997328cf9fce20eaddca0e198634550352a6086f99b0c412278dd2af_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (at 3.4s, the flame suddenly changes to red-hot carbonization, but there is no transition phase) (at 5.7s, the open flame suddenly goes out, but there is still paper and oxygen).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04224", "filename": "dff550be613b1789aae3088e09f5701437bfbac9453a0113a75b057e8d31e5a4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at the beginning - 0.9s, the lightweight toy car experiences a huge impact with the sand pile, but it does not decelerate or deform). Physical behavior (at 2.5s, after the toy car hits the pipe, the pipe flies up without inertial delay, which does not conform to the law of interaction of forces).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04225", "filename": "e05ff3928dc28dd5b92aaf67b581d80dbdf518ede71d85f6de451b164bdb8767_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04226", "filename": "e5bdcaac3ee2654a30b222c6e84744b1668e6b57bd792aedffa7e5e998d37342_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (from the start to 2.8 seconds, the melting butter in the pot gradually increases in size).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04227", "filename": "e5e056825cde73dbb7241ae009499d350b203535ea9af10d5f3feadd2cf23431_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (as time progresses, the ice cubes in the two cups on the left melt and float to the top, but the ice cubes in the cup on the far right do not change).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04228", "filename": "e56b6c9a2751f9e8a22a015258f3eba9afedb11e293b8a4425b06498f0dbbad2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the ice flowers in the entire bubble remain stationary and do not spread).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04229", "filename": "e535a102f29b6ee7125e1662c00f403a52d40f8cedbdf9a53f3daa70e82ffdcb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (the entire laser beam penetrates the singer's body without obstruction or scattering) (the laser beam suddenly terminates in mid-air without scattering, attenuation, or obstruction).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04230", "filename": "e1600e6e94b961da064339228ee781f358a5b81fdf228c6adbe62413560f584c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time was continuous (at 3.5 seconds, the left edge of the filter suddenly flickered and deformed).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04231", "filename": "e377893c31a30a8126598e0dc9c5e83f81773c7d0a523a742ff6b07cf688a147_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the water surface remains still despite the impact of the water flow as it flows into the bottle).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04232", "filename": "ea1ac4b622d7b43fb228fbad1f4861c3b98d746379ab3bbd778f9259ba72b2cc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (the entire column of steam rises in a column shape and then suddenly diffuses horizontally, without any sustained buoyancy). Physical behavior (the steam does not form water droplets, frost, or whiten in cold air, which does not conform to the law of conservation of energy).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04234", "filename": "ec04849beb21bc00fb8f8b1c84c1b90289b7aa6acae5234ffad0c873281d96ec_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomalies are as follows: the time sequence is continuous (after the explosion at 1.9s, there are no traces of the explosion left on the snow); the physical behavior is as follows (from 1.9s to the end, the smoke does not rise or spread, but instead spreads horizontally and sinks, violating thermodynamics).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04235", "filename": "f05d47ab3f4d96eafe3e5c7788a02bd1a143c3247d61ee74324d98180c23a0bb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal because the timing is continuous (the ice gradually melts and flows throughout the video, but the size of the ice does not change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04236", "filename": "f5b4799213511dbf80faed6e87045fa4468c9170904dbd1aa8421d039effbb11_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the entire sky changes from dark to blue) (at 0 seconds, a ship on the distant sea suddenly disappears)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04239", "filename": "04265b4c942969de7cfa9cc5f643f9c9a57db7ffa300e7b138b5af692b274d9e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The continuity of time is abnormal (in the footage from 2.5 seconds to the end, the sun has already set behind the mountains, but the sun suddenly rises again without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04240", "filename": "04265b4c942969de7cfa9cc5f643f9c9a57db7ffa300e7b138b5af692b274d9e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity error (the video stutters noticeably at 2.6 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04241", "filename": "04265b4c942969de7cfa9cc5f643f9c9a57db7ffa300e7b138b5af692b274d9e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (throughout the video, the grass near the camera is constantly being blown around by the wind, but the grass further away from the camera is too still and lacks a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04242", "filename": "04265b4c942969de7cfa9cc5f643f9c9a57db7ffa300e7b138b5af692b274d9e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04243", "filename": "4301f6f9ced8079cefefebc6c020abdc7a173cf45b5b889b5947d3a19f9723cd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (in the scene, the white liquid is constantly being blown around by the wind, but the transparent liquid around it remains still and does not change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04244", "filename": "4301f6f9ced8079cefefebc6c020abdc7a173cf45b5b889b5947d3a19f9723cd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Temporal continuity is abnormal (between 0.7s and 1.5s in the video, the volume of the white liquid in the video suddenly increases without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04245", "filename": "4421d797c72a5ed06d4999a36f4bb2ca84777d258339a1686099034fc91f0b97_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (at 0.3s in the video, the ice block volume suddenly increases, and after 3.3s, the ice block volume begins to decrease again).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04246", "filename": "4421d797c72a5ed06d4999a36f4bb2ca84777d258339a1686099034fc91f0b97_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 2s until the end of the video, the water from the melting ice did not flow onto the ground, but remained directly on the perforated netting).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04247", "filename": "4421d797c72a5ed06d4999a36f4bb2ca84777d258339a1686099034fc91f0b97_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 1s to the end of the video, the water from the melting ice did not flow onto the ground, but remained directly on the perforated netting).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04248", "filename": "4426ae07aafd12a86db2fb6427caaa670323e9f2c09b15a093dd78f59857c4af_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (water mist dynamically interacts with the surrounding air, such as localized concentration changes and slight drifting. However, the water mist in the image shows no obvious dynamic changes and is completely separated from the background, which does not conform to the characteristics of fluid motion).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04249", "filename": "4426ae07aafd12a86db2fb6427caaa670323e9f2c09b15a093dd78f59857c4af_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 4.3s to the end of the video, the smoke from the smoke machine passes directly through the character's arm and drifts out).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04250", "filename": "4426ae07aafd12a86db2fb6427caaa670323e9f2c09b15a093dd78f59857c4af_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04251", "filename": "4549bfa0c885a7e0175556148d0e5bdac76722370262ac106d0930573fcd7959_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Continuous time (water that appears out of thin air from the upper wall in the entire video disappears out of thin air as it flows down to the lower wall; the iron bucket in the video appears to move on its own without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04252", "filename": "4549bfa0c885a7e0175556148d0e5bdac76722370262ac106d0930573fcd7959_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 1.7 seconds into the video, the flowing water in the footage transforms into steps without any change in camera angle, and the entire ground continues to rise slowly).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04253", "filename": "4549bfa0c885a7e0175556148d0e5bdac76722370262ac106d0930573fcd7959_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 0.6s in the video, a water outlet suddenly appears on the wall and water flows out without the camera changing position).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04254", "filename": "4598b8a8c345aed3308ae36f5bdab710af39427d9e4e51506507569cbd54ea41_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 4.1 seconds into the video, the watermelon falling from the air and the watermelon in the cup suddenly merge into one piece without any change in the shot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04255", "filename": "4598b8a8c345aed3308ae36f5bdab710af39427d9e4e51506507569cbd54ea41_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 1.3s in the video, watermelon juice directly penetrates the glass and flows onto the ground, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04256", "filename": "4629c89ef2b8a854ad4abce74dc826c3bf690ed3fe248912534d0072b2ef21c6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the fire in the frame sways due to the wind, but the trees and grass remain stationary and unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04257", "filename": "4629c89ef2b8a854ad4abce74dc826c3bf690ed3fe248912534d0072b2ef21c6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Overall, the visual impression is abnormal: (Throughout the video, the burning flames appear grainy, and the entire image exhibits flickering and other flaws.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04258", "filename": "4629c89ef2b8a854ad4abce74dc826c3bf690ed3fe248912534d0072b2ef21c6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the fire in the frame sways due to the wind, but the trees and grass remain stationary and unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04259", "filename": "4629c89ef2b8a854ad4abce74dc826c3bf690ed3fe248912534d0072b2ef21c6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04263", "filename": "4717d4d5b493ca29af8a55141d42965f97d4288f17edd27e12d3fcfc1e61ff98_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (starting at 1.2s in the video, the candle held by the character passes directly through the paper without burning it).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04264", "filename": "4717d4d5b493ca29af8a55141d42965f97d4288f17edd27e12d3fcfc1e61ff98_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (there is no smoke from burning throughout the video, and the paper turns black without burning, lacking the sense of order and randomness of flames burning).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04265", "filename": "4717d4d5b493ca29af8a55141d42965f97d4288f17edd27e12d3fcfc1e61ff98_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormality in the footage: Physical behavior (Throughout the entire video, the flames burning on the paper did not change at all, nor did they cause any damage to the paper).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04266", "filename": "4717d4d5b493ca29af8a55141d42965f97d4288f17edd27e12d3fcfc1e61ff98_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (from 3s to the end of the video, the burning paper in the frame keeps getting longer without the camera changing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04267", "filename": "4768fd05d4ef2798b7fc79ffac58d4727c08a8f1b1a0aef3e20b194eb1213fb5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (at 0.5s in the video, the mask on the ground was already distorted before it was run over by the wheel; at 1.7s, the wheel hub suddenly appeared outside the tire without the camera changing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04268", "filename": "4768fd05d4ef2798b7fc79ffac58d4727c08a8f1b1a0aef3e20b194eb1213fb5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 4.8s in the video, without any change in camera angle, many flying particles suddenly appear under the mask).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04269", "filename": "4768fd05d4ef2798b7fc79ffac58d4727c08a8f1b1a0aef3e20b194eb1213fb5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 1.2s in the video, before the wheel touches the mask on the ground, the mask suddenly moves on its own; at 4.4s, the damaged mask suddenly tilts upwards).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04270", "filename": "4958b02137633e06f034a0b79cc0ae76accd79a48bada2ab5dea20a5602c333a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows a series of vertical reflections of balloons on the water's surface. However, these reflections are symmetrical mirror images of the objects and would not appear as if the balloons were suspended in the water.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04271", "filename": "4958b02137633e06f034a0b79cc0ae76accd79a48bada2ab5dea20a5602c333a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the underwater balloons do not exhibit underwater refraction effects, and their luster and color do not conform to the visual characteristics of light propagating in water).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04272", "filename": "5078fb1e8545a6035500e1ad86acadf5ee4eccaf4560fb8f0acc0c0c170fb4b1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to physical behavior (the ice cube is spinning in the water without slowing down, but instead continuously increasing its potential energy, violating the law of conservation of energy).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04273", "filename": "5078fb1e8545a6035500e1ad86acadf5ee4eccaf4560fb8f0acc0c0c170fb4b1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the ice in the glass does not melt throughout the entire video, but the water in the glass keeps increasing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04274", "filename": "5078fb1e8545a6035500e1ad86acadf5ee4eccaf4560fb8f0acc0c0c170fb4b1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: continuous time (throughout the entire video, without any change in camera angle, the ice in the glass did not melt, but the water in the glass kept increasing, and small bubbles appeared out of thin air in the glass).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04275", "filename": "5078fb1e8545a6035500e1ad86acadf5ee4eccaf4560fb8f0acc0c0c170fb4b1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 1.9 seconds into the video, without any change in camera angle, the ice cubes in the glass suddenly melt together).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04276", "filename": "5110f62c8bc7cd411d06db0830a34c8020e85c502f0645aaa313b13f6a73141f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (flickering artifacts are present throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04277", "filename": "be23faf80750bf5f3a2812fbb4d33fd7506678858efb2d291a9195b8ad3fce92_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the blue tarpaulin was not ignited and showed no signs of melting or carbonization, but the flames were close to the edge of the tarpaulin. In reality, plastic would melt and burn quickly and produce black smoke when exposed to an open flame, but the tarpaulin in the video was intact).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04278", "filename": "be23faf80750bf5f3a2812fbb4d33fd7506678858efb2d291a9195b8ad3fce92_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (between 1.1s and 2.3s, flames appear out of nowhere on the unburnt firewood in the center of the bonfire, appearing and disappearing intermittently). Overall visual anomalies (the flames in the entire scene are overexposed and have repetitive textures, lacking the dynamic feel of real flames).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04279", "filename": "be23faf80750bf5f3a2812fbb4d33fd7506678858efb2d291a9195b8ad3fce92_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (plastic baskets and waterproof tarpaulins should melt and shrink quickly when exposed to fire, emitting black smoke and even catching fire, but in the video, only the waterproof tarpaulin has a regular hole, and the edges are not melted or charred).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04280", "filename": "be064c98135b3d4c428b88843197fdea783c05ad89760b987168185a86a7116c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the texture and rhythm of the clouds are too uniform and regular, lacking the chaotic and layered feel of real thunderstorm clouds, and the speed of cloud movement is disproportionate to the movement of rain columns and ground objects, appearing deliberate).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04281", "filename": "be064c98135b3d4c428b88843197fdea783c05ad89760b987168185a86a7116c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is off (the rain curtain, clouds, and ground are three separate visual layers with harsh edge transitions, lacking the darkness of clouds and the warm light of the horizon in a real scene, far exceeding the natural color range of a thunderstorm, and the rhythm of the rain column's contraction and deformation is out of sync with the cloud movement).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04282", "filename": "be064c98135b3d4c428b88843197fdea783c05ad89760b987168185a86a7116c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is abnormal (there are thick, dark thunderstorm clouds above, which would completely block out light near the ground, but there is an unusually bright band of warm light on the horizon. In reality, it is impossible for there to be such an extreme contrast of dark clouds overhead but a clear and bright horizon).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04283", "filename": "be384afc5f64cc4279cf058f5f2bab19c8453a33ef5258d838918e6dba5e1ad1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the highly fragmented shape of a real flame changes constantly and cannot be repeated, but the rolling and jumping rhythm of the flames in the video is highly consistent, and the flame shape shows obvious signs of repetition, rather than the random dynamics of real burning).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04284", "filename": "be384afc5f64cc4279cf058f5f2bab19c8453a33ef5258d838918e6dba5e1ad1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the charcoal fire is completely still throughout the entire process, there is no shaking of charcoal pieces or falling of ash due to burning, the flames do not have a natural sense of continuity of fuel, and some flames even seem to be floating above the oven).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04285", "filename": "be384afc5f64cc4279cf058f5f2bab19c8453a33ef5258d838918e6dba5e1ad1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the edges of real flames gradually fade and become blurry, with a clear semi-transparent transition, and there is no sharp and clear outline, while the edges of the flames in the video are as clear as if they were drawn, and there are even hard edges).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04286", "filename": "be384afc5f64cc4279cf058f5f2bab19c8453a33ef5258d838918e6dba5e1ad1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall impression is abnormal (the flames of a real flame will constantly split, curl and dissipate, and the edges are messy, irregular and rough, but the flame outline in the video is smooth, symmetrical and neat, without the random breaking feeling of natural burning).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04289", "filename": "bf5c93d6ba606ae2e84b5b88b06d7c9743efd2a2ef77e518c895b75abbc6ebf9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the graininess and texture of the image are too uniform, and there is no variation in local brightness and transparency caused by the angle of light).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04291", "filename": "bf5c93d6ba606ae2e84b5b88b06d7c9743efd2a2ef77e518c895b75abbc6ebf9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04292", "filename": "bf13e8a41b875779efceed49fb423d737256fd559663d0bca291187b3effcee9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (Throughout the entire segment, the water in the bowl clearly shows a boiling state with bubbling and rising bubbles, but there is no visible heat source in or around the bowl, and the boiling lacks the most basic energy source).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04293", "filename": "bf13e8a41b875779efceed49fb423d737256fd559663d0bca291187b3effcee9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04294", "filename": "bf13e8a41b875779efceed49fb423d737256fd559663d0bca291187b3effcee9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the water in the bowl is constantly agitated without any external force throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04295", "filename": "bf13e8a41b875779efceed49fb423d737256fd559663d0bca291187b3effcee9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.7s, a small white dot appears out of nowhere on the right wall of the screen and then disappears instantly).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04299", "filename": "bffbbf81acc40cb09fbee1f7bc7b4fc585e3d620fbc9dbd2c041b7c9ef99359a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a small iron stone appears out of nowhere in the lower left corner at 3.1s, and disappears out of nowhere in the upper left corner at 2.6s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04300", "filename": "bffbbf81acc40cb09fbee1f7bc7b4fc585e3d620fbc9dbd2c041b7c9ef99359a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to the physical behavior (the small iron stone penetrates the middle finger at 2.1 seconds, which violates the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04301", "filename": "bffbbf81acc40cb09fbee1f7bc7b4fc585e3d620fbc9dbd2c041b7c9ef99359a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.7s, two cylindrical iron blocks appear out of thin air in the hand; at 2.4s, the small iron block under the thumb disappears out of thin air; at 4.9s, when all the small iron blocks fall onto the table, they suddenly turn into cylindrical iron blocks; at 6.7s, when a flat wooden board is placed on the table with cylindrical iron blocks, it is not lifted up by these iron blocks).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04302", "filename": "c00f1873318cdbf7c1071876cf7ac0fbf321e231403f1a608d4f173e26f18b51_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04303", "filename": "c00f1873318cdbf7c1071876cf7ac0fbf321e231403f1a608d4f173e26f18b51_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (between 2.5s and 5.8s, the ice in the bowl rotates out of thin air without any external force, and water appears out of thin air without the ice melting).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04304", "filename": "c00f1873318cdbf7c1071876cf7ac0fbf321e231403f1a608d4f173e26f18b51_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04305", "filename": "c00f1873318cdbf7c1071876cf7ac0fbf321e231403f1a608d4f173e26f18b51_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the ice cube in the left bowl jumps up into the air without any external force between 0.1s and 0.8s) Time continuity (at 2.9s, a large amount of water vapor is generated in the stainless steel bowl on the right and adheres to the inner wall of the bowl; the ice cube in the right bowl is irregularly shaped and suddenly becomes square at 6.3s)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04306", "filename": "c0e64cc7edbf45aed7ed579560b9f666129d405ecb76a9b4320b66c7e97851d9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04307", "filename": "7dc55acf9d236090fcf59e9492fa80cec7c5a4ea422028e04902b3b1547f3556_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a single, unidentified white dot appears in the center of the screen, and suddenly disappears at 3.8 seconds.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04308", "filename": "7de41606fb5e79a07b54d4a3eb85fd18653a57d5dfc6555bb4b7dbe71ea877db_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is distorted: The overall impression is that only the lower half of the video, where the goose is located, shows water movement, while the upper half, where the water and floating objects are, remains still, making the overall image appear unnatural.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04309", "filename": "7de41606fb5e79a07b54d4a3eb85fd18653a57d5dfc6555bb4b7dbe71ea877db_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the entire sequence of footage, as the water waves spread, the floating objects on the water surface did not move with the waves and remained stationary).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04310", "filename": "7de41606fb5e79a07b54d4a3eb85fd18653a57d5dfc6555bb4b7dbe71ea877db_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Overall impression (only the lower half of the video, where the goose is located, shows water movement, while the upper half, including the floating objects, remains still) Physical behavior (when water ripples are generated on the surface, the floating objects passing through the ripples do not sway with the waves)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04311", "filename": "7de41606fb5e79a07b54d4a3eb85fd18653a57d5dfc6555bb4b7dbe71ea877db_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall impression is that when the goose floats in the video, only the lower half of the water is moving, while the upper half of the water and floating objects remain still, making the overall visuals appear jarring.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04312", "filename": "7dec2725a239488dc76c4acfd290ae43e4179b5eeef6a8d27b93ccaadfb9721a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Physical behavior (between 2.6s and 5s, the sparks from the explosion in the footage burn at a large angle to the right, indicating that there is a strong wind in the video, but the tree branches and leaves in the footage are almost stationary).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04313", "filename": "7dec2725a239488dc76c4acfd290ae43e4179b5eeef6a8d27b93ccaadfb9721a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomalies are as follows: The explosion occurred in sequence (at 1.4s, the explosive in the middle detonated before even touching a spark). The physical behavior at 3.3s shows an excessively bright orange-red flame and a regular column of smoke, inconsistent with the physical characteristics of a natural explosion. At 1.1s, the massive explosion caused no damage to surrounding vegetation or the ground.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04314", "filename": "7dec2725a239488dc76c4acfd290ae43e4179b5eeef6a8d27b93ccaadfb9721a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the explosive material remains unchanged after the explosion ends, from 1.5s onwards). Physical behavior (at 2.2s, the giant mushroom cloud flames formed by the explosion are too concentrated, too large, and too brightly colored. From 2.5s to 4.5s, the upward movement of the mushroom cloud flames is too smooth and rapid).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04315", "filename": "7e8aafd17a31aad51279eb97539bae1c36fda1eb2dfafd8085edd1f6c3606a14_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.7s and 3.4s, only one firework rises into the sky, but two fireworks explode in the sky one after the other).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04316", "filename": "7e8aafd17a31aad51279eb97539bae1c36fda1eb2dfafd8085edd1f6c3606a14_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall intuition (the smoke from normal fireworks displays is usually relatively dispersed and gradually dissipates, but the smoke in this video appears as relatively concentrated, dark-colored clouds floating in the air) Physical behavior (fireworks falling under the influence of gravity should have a certain acceleration and a relatively smooth trajectory, but the falling trajectories of some fireworks in the video appear rather abrupt)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04317", "filename": "7e8aafd17a31aad51279eb97539bae1c36fda1eb2dfafd8085edd1f6c3606a14_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Physical behavior (between 4.8s and 7.9s, the smoke produced after a normal fireworks display is usually relatively dispersed and gradually dissipates, but in this video, the smoke appears as a relatively concentrated, dark-colored cloud floating in the air without dissipating).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04318", "filename": "7e17e50a0289988e67e3b64c2f971981235648c3e6a8c63aad2d6788d16cbd16_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is that the waterfall's flow pattern and texture are highly uniform, lacking the dynamic changes and randomness of natural water flow; the surrounding water and related objects show no change in position or shape, resulting in an overly static overall environment.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04319", "filename": "7e17e50a0289988e67e3b64c2f971981235648c3e6a8c63aad2d6788d16cbd16_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the distribution pattern of the waterfall mist remains fixed for a long time, failing to show the diffusion and drift under the influence of wind and temperature; the light and shadow effects on the water surface and waterfall remain unchanged throughout, failing to demonstrate the dynamic effects of the natural environment on the objects.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04320", "filename": "7e17e50a0289988e67e3b64c2f971981235648c3e6a8c63aad2d6788d16cbd16_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the waterfall's cascading speed appears uniform, violating the law of velocity variation caused by gravitational acceleration.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04321", "filename": "7e26512037c6b4613b06988bc22d266d17c5094e1f73b1b0ab6456ba2458114e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (at 1.9s, 3.2s, and 4.9s, after the drill bit leaves the iron block, no marks are left on the iron block).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04322", "filename": "7e26512037c6b4613b06988bc22d266d17c5094e1f73b1b0ab6456ba2458114e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (the drill bit suddenly becomes thinner at 2.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04323", "filename": "7e26512037c6b4613b06988bc22d266d17c5094e1f73b1b0ab6456ba2458114e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (drill bit did not make contact with silver object during the period from 1.6s to 8s, but iron block produced debris).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04324", "filename": "7edbbe2839bb80f2f021034352d73ea61495813657852c58a1350120ffde7bb9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (only the clouds in the middle of the image are constantly moving, while the clouds around the mountain remain stationary).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04325", "filename": "7edbbe2839bb80f2f021034352d73ea61495813657852c58a1350120ffde7bb9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the clouds in the video are swirling and turning too quickly and smoothly, indicating strong airflow in the environment, while the surrounding vegetation remains stationary.)", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04326", "filename": "7edbbe2839bb80f2f021034352d73ea61495813657852c58a1350120ffde7bb9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Only the clouds in the middle of the image are constantly moving, while the clouds and vegetation around the mountain remain stationary.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04327", "filename": "7edbbe2839bb80f2f021034352d73ea61495813657852c58a1350120ffde7bb9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Only the clouds in the middle of the image are constantly moving, while the clouds and vegetation around the mountain remain stationary.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04328", "filename": "7ee4e5c5a99c51126f0048755a3d9ff68f26a74ad195e04c088f451814f5244b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (between 2.4s-2.9s and 4.5s-4.9s, when the character faces the disc mirror towards themselves, only their fingers are reflected in the disc while their shadow is not, which does not conform to the laws of optics) Time continuity (the bottom of the disc becomes transparent at 3s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04329", "filename": "7ee4e5c5a99c51126f0048755a3d9ff68f26a74ad195e04c088f451814f5244b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: During the continuous time intervals (0.6s-1.3s and 2.6s-5.8s, the lower half of the disc in the image becomes transparent, revealing fingers on the back of the disc).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04330", "filename": "7ee4e5c5a99c51126f0048755a3d9ff68f26a74ad195e04c088f451814f5244b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the lower half of the disc becomes transparent in the entire image, revealing fingers on the back of the disc.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04331", "filename": "7ee4e5c5a99c51126f0048755a3d9ff68f26a74ad195e04c088f451814f5244b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (during 1.5s-4.6s, the disc did not move, but the shadow reflected inside the disc was shaking and rotating); Time continuity (the lower half of the disc became transparent in the entire screen, revealing fingers on the back of the disc).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04332", "filename": "7ee16b0ec9737b606249d18cf8f9f800c3861f6ad3731566364c2bc89dc0e96d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 0.1s, the cue stick penetrates the ball, violating the principle that solids are impermeable. At 3.1s, when the white ball strikes the stationary red ball, the stationary red ball does not move in the direction of acceleration under the impact, but moves in the opposite direction.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04333", "filename": "7ee16b0ec9737b606249d18cf8f9f800c3861f6ad3731566364c2bc89dc0e96d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.7s, the white ball suddenly turns into a red flower ball).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04334", "filename": "7ee16b0ec9737b606249d18cf8f9f800c3861f6ad3731566364c2bc89dc0e96d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the cue stick hadn't even touched the cue ball at 2.1 seconds when the ball started rolling, violating the principle of force interaction. Throughout the video, the size and shape of the ball's shadow did not change as the ball moved.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04335", "filename": "7f1ce975def67cc8178244ce5a52007e822c7e8c3e41b79df720b28ea1944191_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (4.5s) The ground on the right side of the riverbank suddenly increases without the water level dropping.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04336", "filename": "7f1ce975def67cc8178244ce5a52007e822c7e8c3e41b79df720b28ea1944191_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: The overall image is abnormal (only the lake surface is slightly swaying, while the surrounding vegetation remains still. Some trees have light and shadow, while others do not, resulting in an overall jarring image).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04337", "filename": "P02_121_40_934595e1d8681715_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (at 2.7s, the bottommost of the two layers of paper on the left disappears out of thin air, and at 3.7s, the bottom layer of paper on the left reappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04338", "filename": "P02_121_70_f4ae32588f42fb6a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Physical behavior (at 0.3s, liquid automatically flows into the container opening and falls into the smaller container at the bottom without any external force); Time continuity (at 2.3s, the video feed transitions smoothly to the next frame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04339", "filename": "P02_122_162_22ab21fd3c87b1e5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is continuous (at 7.5 seconds, the tip of the fork on the right side of the video disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04340", "filename": "P02_123_19_fe6c9949542039dc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Continuous timing (the desktop screen flickers in the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04341", "filename": "P02_123_177_d40610b38558bc5b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.1s, the handkerchief at the bottom of the screen merges, and the desktop screen in the video flickers).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04342", "filename": "P02_123_210_1fb8a7d871b343d1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (at 0.6s, the right glove on the hand is put on by itself without external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04343", "filename": "P02_123_251_d2fcffd728703f9d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Physical behavior (at 4.9s, the right hand's fingers pierce through the ceramic bowl); Time continuity (at 6.8s, a black object appears out of thin air inside the ceramic bowl).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04344", "filename": "P02_124_79_dc7bc50033f3e196_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows several anomalies: Time continuity (at 0.6s, the charging cable in the left hand is embedded in the object in the right hand; at 0.9s, the white object released by the left hand floats out of thin air); Time continuity (at 0.9s, the metal object on the plug disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04345", "filename": "P02_129_150_595e20947c511dff_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (at 0.9s, the pot in the video moves slightly to the left without any external force)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04346", "filename": "P02_129_177_5f0f6a859867e84c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.7s, the black object in the video is suspended without support and does not show any free fall motion).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04347", "filename": "P02_129_354_7137e79e5c8230ae_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video is continuous in time (there is no transition to the next frame at 3.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04348", "filename": "P02_129_431_460d10ba56f5463e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (the text above the blue object disappears at 3.3 seconds, and the desktop screen in the video flickers).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04349", "filename": "P02_131_14_6004236093653ee0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Causality (the figure in the video presses down on the meat paste with both hands, but the paste does not show any indentation or pressing marks, the action and result are inconsistent); Time continuity (flickering occurs on the table and the surface of the meat paste in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04350", "filename": "P02_132_42_9d5f47b6ed7515b0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is inconsistent (the overall video image flickers)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04351", "filename": "P02_132_47_5e1684ba8ba72e19_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04352", "filename": "P02_132_52_1c10f97c2f6e9203_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Continuous timing (flickering throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04353", "filename": "P02_132_74_90326c3fd0540065_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the foil in my hand and the foil on the table merge at 0.6 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04354", "filename": "P02_135_92_b591e54d8957af6a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.2 seconds, the jam on top of the bread slice disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04355", "filename": "P03_101_255_137b432bdb4caea6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the jam on the knife disappears out of thin air at 1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04356", "filename": "P03_101_266_77c1196dbb551ac2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time sequence is continuous (at 1.8s, 3.9s, and 5.4s, an object appears out of thin air to the right of the knife).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04357", "filename": "P03_101_271_f03ab98004d6118b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (the cut yellow object in the left hand is restored at 2.4 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04358", "filename": "P03_101_278_b3e8398e97d402f3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the triangular ham slice cut off at 6.2s suddenly becomes a trapezoid)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04359", "filename": "P03_101_283_d91dd050eb827ec7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the white bar on the lower right disappears at 1.8s, and the white lines on both sides of the packaging tape appear out of thin air at 4.3s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04360", "filename": "P03_101_323_076fb2eafbf3f536_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04361", "filename": "P03_109_46_d6eb7e3feef07559_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the shape of the sponge changes from trapezoid to square at 0.8s, and foam appears out of thin air in the spoon at 3.9s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04362", "filename": "P03_109_146_4788408f985894ae_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the object below the sea surface on the right disappears into thin air at 0.7s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04363", "filename": "P03_109_292_dc435ca3dce51838_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Continuous flickering (the entire video screen is constantly flashing).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04364", "filename": "P03_109_318_24bf90fdcacc85f9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.9s, the jam on the bread spread on the right side of the knife suddenly decreases, and at 1.1s, the jam on the knife disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04365", "filename": "P03_109_321_bd3f45ea44ea64fe_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (from 1.9s to 8s, the jam on the tool has been completely spread on the bread slice, and there is no subsequent action of adding new jam, but the amount of jam on the bread slice appears to increase out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04366", "filename": "P03_109_342_fc9925db0f44f975_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the jam on the knife tip appears out of nowhere at 3.5s, and the triangular object being cut grows larger out of nowhere at 6.5s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04367", "filename": "0ba50e8a7dbba5a2ea95d9a75d997eb157968d4c87663b70bfb3b38af8305802_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (a small white square appears out of nowhere on the left side of the video at 0.2s, the white sphere explodes without touching an obstacle at 1.5s, and the small white square disappears abruptly at 2.6s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04369", "filename": "0c6a76538bfbb9d00de0fd03f196b86af22d0de974d9d8e6ea60f7584bf08222_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is inconsistent. At the beginning of the video, the fire is inside the iron ring, but at 5.8 seconds, a stove appears outside the fire in addition to the iron ring.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04370", "filename": "0c6389e0e6822f8739e1698dec8afaf333495ce25d733cfc1354981478f17dae_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (the black wheel keeps getting bigger from the start to 0.9 seconds, and the red wheel suddenly appears on the right side of the video at 1.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04371", "filename": "0d95a1f23988768d65e4fb7595c2ff471ecc5470ed333528610d534400c2c496_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the hot pot was boiling from the start to 3.6 seconds but no steam was produced until 4.1 seconds when steam appeared on screen).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04372", "filename": "0e184d67b5a24606676bb0f263620300bc911ef2b3f3acecf275188e79dc4ed4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: Time continuity (white grime suddenly appears on the disc in the middle of the screen at 5.4 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04373", "filename": "1a5f6214acac586908adafec06b2a2b0c486d1e0f9d73a78a42311de79ba3dbc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (the clouds in the upper left corner of the video suddenly disappear at 0.4s, and the clouds in the upper left corner of the video suddenly turn blue at 3.5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04374", "filename": "1ac5cdfea7cfa26dd72ee94dc9c3e5c37f6b8c6b5ee6dcad9cc716e8706b548a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04375", "filename": "1b55b6cbf1129a222744f8bf5e0f6c13c93c22a1ba1646094c6b4fa345a42ead_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity anomaly (the character is missing a finger at 2s); Physical behavior anomalies (the character is holding a balloon, which inflates without being blown up, contradicting the laws of gas flow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04376", "filename": "1d60505c9b260716a8a5e2783fa857c32ab6e32b5df13e8a36d224642d29c992_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity error (the white lead on the pink candle in the middle suddenly disappears at 1.3 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04377", "filename": "02c65189c5e417dbee9311831c6f51777c0d763e19a91f0f7e539a4d81e55790_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is abnormal (at 1.4s, the fireworks below were still rising into the air, but by this time the fireworks in the sky had already exploded).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04378", "filename": "2a3f5f9f024a9865280ad0a7aa521e426576920a32d335e1538bb7c99960f572_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the light is dispersed by the refraction of the prism throughout the video, but the prism itself is very small. The colored light band seen through the prism should be relatively narrow instead of filling the entire screen as shown in the video, which violates the principle of light refraction through a prism).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_04379", "filename": "2a6cb41001ed9af45087e325488c47f988b0d302c465fa7c1d3acf7adfa8d2af_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 0.7s, when the white crystal was picked up, it passed through the glass, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04380", "filename": "2b4c88c81484dc0499d788d9251a6d8cda02d77c8b245afe7a4f1af1b145a0fe_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity anomalies (the water surface remains stable after the explosion at 3s) Physical behavior anomalies (the explosion in the water at 0.6s produces a large amount of dust without splashing water, which violates basic principles of fluid dynamics).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04381", "filename": "2b2629dc2f64939c10b37026f218cc67bfe6fb3ea348216ca182ac72c10314c8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to the following physical behavior: (The ice cream melts during the period from the start to 1.7 seconds, but its volume does not change, which violates the basic understanding that the volume changes when the state of an object changes).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04382", "filename": "2b2338239f73491643af1c24503436ba9f1c6ca3704227561622e043a60fae18_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the sun in the image is getting bigger and brighter, but the trees below remain black).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_04383", "filename": "2bd6a2b278c74e328e2da4f2919dba062c1d40377c73e8cafaef1e71027086a3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The abnormal behavior is due to physical behavior (the harvester's header is continuously cutting and conveying grain, but the amount of grain in the grain bin behind it is not increasing, which violates the principle of conservation of mass).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04384", "filename": "2d71ce0466baee5bad69c668d32f578f936e8eb098d922602f85ff32b2fcdadb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.4s, there is no firework light source in the upper right corner of the screen, but a cloud of smoke suddenly appears, indicating that the smoke was generated before the fireworks were launched).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04385", "filename": "2d4510153af05d451c633fd7d5f15fe343e1b69747d9ffe49888de4f98fb076d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time frame is continuous (start - 5.3s). Without proper operation, the ring of the light abruptly and continuously increases in size, while the brightness increases simultaneously.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04386", "filename": "2dbf2ac94163f3a800f9e4bbb5776a566df9262d7dcf343a9b76e25a9397f813_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the melting patterns of the candle are too regular, presenting a uniform spiral shape, which does not conform to the physical characteristics of wax flowing irregularly under the influence of random hot air currents in a real environment).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04387", "filename": "2eeae6d1d5dad217beb9f9b2a9b78bed432ae1a6611aaa3c39380c0439a157f6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the fan blades are rotating at high speed, but the smoke that should be carried by the airflow is completely unaffected. It is neither pushed away by the blades nor does it produce any local airflow disturbance. The flow trajectory of the smoke and the movement of the blades are completely disconnected, which violates the law of conservation of momentum).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04388", "filename": "3aeeab03424a6aad7ecd30371337463441a6cb7c414613291896631b5b5833ba_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Physical Behavior (At 2s, the dynamic changes in the clouds and mist are unnatural. The clouds and mist in front of the mountain peaks lack the gradual transition of airflow, abruptly changing form and violating the continuity and gradual change laws of fluid motion. The water reflection is out of sync with the real scene. When the clouds and mist and light and shadow on the mountain change, the reflection on the lake does not change at all, which does not conform to the physical laws of the linkage between reflection and real scene in the real world.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04389", "filename": "3d28eb5307024a83a032cf3431176fca36ea92ef8979b59544bbd66adc9aa25e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall impression is off (the river's surface lacks normal flowing ripples and dynamic changes. It doesn't look like real river water, but rather like a still, blue-green plastic sheet covering the pebbles at the bottom, completely devoid of the fluidity and depth of flowing water.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04390", "filename": "3e6667f5d51f1f4bfd88db729959c7a82a7968fdb7aeebddd7303fe87855432c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (At 1.2s until the end, the white smoke that suddenly surged in from the bottom of the screen exhibited inconsistent fluid movement. This smoke and the original smoke above it were completely disconnected from the dynamic logic of the text, without a natural diffusion and merging process. It was as if a separate static smoke texture was forcibly superimposed, which did not conform to the continuous laws of natural fluid flow.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04391", "filename": "3eb335dbc22a6bb973cec5dae5d43d1802a3487962685059ae000a120a147fef_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous (at 1.6s, the ball suddenly appears on the ground without the complete motion of rolling off the hand, and the key transition frame of the object falling under gravity is missing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04393", "filename": "3edfe964f3afcacfd8de61df5a217a216e9172cdedcb1aac3ace87352ae39393_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the colors of this sea of clouds jump around illogically, and the flowing ripples repeat in a fixed cycle, lacking the random and delicate dynamic feel of real clouds. It looks more like a color-distorted live wallpaper than a real natural landscape).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04394", "filename": "3f04bc68c0af960b3ddf771dd575ebec1d376bfa07eda733778c780e5e2f7da9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals and physical behavior are abnormal (at 1.3s, two independent solid steel balls suddenly merge without the action of extreme external forces such as high temperature and high pressure, which violates the physical property that rigid bodies cannot be deformed and does not conform to the physical characteristics and interaction logic of solids in the real world).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04396", "filename": "3fb0a1849865ba13f413f35aab93ff48df086d5901662499d100cf16db870992_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal behavior: Physical behavior (at 1.9s, the soap bubble was stretched into an extremely thin and elongated shape, but did not burst, which violates the surface tension limit of the soap bubble liquid film).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04397", "filename": "59fd4d72916676819755f099e0b712e9e8d904efe100591762ea89edb10cc0af_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (between 4s and 4.5s, the steam rising from the rim of the coffee cup exhibits a stiff, columnar shape, lacking the fluffiness, dispersion, and dynamic changes characteristic of natural hot steam).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04398", "filename": "061a05485a8c4b836405bf8fb42bd206b2187e6346876cf90729ccc828928a3e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is due to physical behavior (the rain streaks are not the continuous falling trajectories of real raindrops under the influence of gravity, but rather appear and disappear randomly and irregularly, with some rain streaks even jumping horizontally).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04399", "filename": "061a05485a8c4b836405bf8fb42bd206b2187e6346876cf90729ccc828928a3e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Temporal continuity anomalies (at 3s, water droplets suddenly appear on the window even though it is not raining) Physical behavior (from 3.7s to 5.8s, in reality, water droplets on glass are naturally stretched due to gravity, with the droplets being smaller at the top and larger at the bottom, but in the video, some droplets appear to be of the same thickness at the top and bottom and are twisted irregularly).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04400", "filename": "061a05485a8c4b836405bf8fb42bd206b2187e6346876cf90729ccc828928a3e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Physical behavior (in reality, water droplets on glass are naturally stretched due to gravity, with a smaller top and a larger bottom, but in the image, some water droplets appear to be of the same thickness at both ends and flow downwards in a regular pattern).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04401", "filename": "61bda3afbf9eeae5aa47c00c3e73a8700e6692f984b93012bb44245686420ea2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall visual impression is abnormal (between 0.2s and 4.8s, the water plants next to the bird are blown by the wind, indicating that the wind is strong, but only one feather on the bird's body is moving, while the other feathers do not change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04402", "filename": "61bda3afbf9eeae5aa47c00c3e73a8700e6692f984b93012bb44245686420ea2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical behavior (at 2.9s, the bird\u2019s tail flicked out a large splash of water, but the water plants floating around the bird did not move slightly with the splash).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04403", "filename": "61bda3afbf9eeae5aa47c00c3e73a8700e6692f984b93012bb44245686420ea2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04404", "filename": "61bda3afbf9eeae5aa47c00c3e73a8700e6692f984b93012bb44245686420ea2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.9s, the white floating objects on the water surface suddenly disappear. Between 0.7s and 2.3s, bubbles suddenly appear on the water surface without any force acting on them).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04405", "filename": "61cc6f0e3111a1b0192aedcdf7468d97343700111f63ca2eb69dbc2aa4a1fcde_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (from 3.3s to 4.4s, an object that was originally falling and causing an explosion suddenly rose again intact along its falling trajectory. From 3.2s to 5s, after the explosion, the object that caused the explosion did not break or deform).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04406", "filename": "61cc6f0e3111a1b0192aedcdf7468d97343700111f63ca2eb69dbc2aa4a1fcde_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the boundary between the yellow smoke and white haze generated by the explosion under pressure between 1.9s and 5s is too smooth, with no diffusion or merging).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04407", "filename": "61cc6f0e3111a1b0192aedcdf7468d97343700111f63ca2eb69dbc2aa4a1fcde_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04408", "filename": "61e4372782ae472479cf6d4d38aacd91fa1053726234f9921cc2bad5812cb9a3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not normal: The overall feeling is abnormal (the ripples and waves in the video do not show the continuous flow of a real stream, and some ripples repeat irregularly or disappear suddenly).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04409", "filename": "61e4372782ae472479cf6d4d38aacd91fa1053726234f9921cc2bad5812cb9a3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the cause and effect relationship is abnormal (the river in the video is flowing between 0.23 and 3.8 seconds, but no water splashes are produced under the surging water, and some ripples will repeat irregularly or disappear suddenly).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04410", "filename": "61e4372782ae472479cf6d4d38aacd91fa1053726234f9921cc2bad5812cb9a3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall feel is off (the vegetation textures on both sides of the waterfront lack natural micro-movements in the video, presenting a static texture texture that lacks the vividness of a realistic natural environment).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04411", "filename": "61e4372782ae472479cf6d4d38aacd91fa1053726234f9921cc2bad5812cb9a3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall impression is off (the ripples created by the water's flow are too homogeneous, lacking the diverse details of ripples produced by changes in underwater topography and flow velocity in a real stream).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04412", "filename": "61ea7174f87e9338254bc73673acbdba416745182c4a7a208420c9caf73988c8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The abnormality in the image is due to physical behavior (at 3s, the sheet-like structure of the liquid splash is too regular, even showing a hollow design. In reality, liquid splashes will only appear as flowing droplets or liquid columns, and will not form this kind of solid film-like structure).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04413", "filename": "61ea7174f87e9338254bc73673acbdba416745182c4a7a208420c9caf73988c8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (between 0s and 1.6s, the red liquid on the right side of the screen remains stationary in mid-air without any force acting upon it.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04414", "filename": "61ea7174f87e9338254bc73673acbdba416745182c4a7a208420c9caf73988c8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (between 0s and 1.7s, the splashed dark red liquid did not change shape or size as it moved through the air. At 4.1s, the red liquid exhibited a net-like structure. In reality, the surface tension of liquids would cause splashed liquids to coalesce into droplets or columns, not form this fragile branching resembling solid crystals).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04415", "filename": "61ea7174f87e9338254bc73673acbdba416745182c4a7a208420c9caf73988c8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (between 0.3s and 1.8s, the liquid in the video suddenly explodes without being subjected to any force, violating the interaction of forces).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04416", "filename": "62b7511b94ed7d42f614df329988e2de28e35c9258d052750efc10d25578b72b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (If the porcelain is compressed between 0.4s and 2.2s, the fragments should fly out instead of falling from a height.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04417", "filename": "62b7511b94ed7d42f614df329988e2de28e35c9258d052750efc10d25578b72b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (between 3.7s and 4.4s, the bottom cup suddenly explodes without being subjected to gravity).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04418", "filename": "62b7511b94ed7d42f614df329988e2de28e35c9258d052750efc10d25578b72b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 2.8s, the second cup above, which had previously exploded, suddenly reappears intact, and its color changes from brown to red.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04419", "filename": "62b7511b94ed7d42f614df329988e2de28e35c9258d052750efc10d25578b72b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (all the cups in the scene have shattered, but several intact new cups suddenly appear between 4.1s and 5.9s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04424", "filename": "63dbfdfff65a044bfde76010f50f2ed60f025ce90d72ffcfefbcfc931f291016_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Between 3.5s and 5s, the flame in the video suddenly moved rapidly to the other side and circled around without any burning material.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04425", "filename": "63dbfdfff65a044bfde76010f50f2ed60f025ce90d72ffcfefbcfc931f291016_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video exhibits several unusual characteristics: Firstly, the timing is inconsistent (the flames in the lower right corner of the video suddenly disappear completely at 2.5 seconds, leaving no trace of burning). Secondly, the overall visual presentation is inconsistent (between 1.1 seconds and 4.9 seconds, the flames in the video burn too smoothly and regularly, unlike the natural movement of flames that sway slightly with the wind or airflow).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04426", "filename": "63dbfdfff65a044bfde76010f50f2ed60f025ce90d72ffcfefbcfc931f291016_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (within 0.1s-0.7s, there was no fuel or similar substance between the two flames, but the two flames automatically connected).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04427", "filename": "709881af7a7f86fc383d5c5f1fc120babfc3435a62cb1d3d3d5b16f072abc3e3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.1s, smoke suddenly appears on the ground to the right of the explosion point. After the explosion at 0.8s, the ground and rocks around the explosion point remain unchanged; a real explosion would affect the surrounding environment.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04428", "filename": "709881af7a7f86fc383d5c5f1fc120babfc3435a62cb1d3d3d5b16f072abc3e3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at the beginning of the video, there are no objects at the explosion point, but at 5.2 seconds, after the explosion, debris flies out of the smoke; normally, it should be soil or rocks flying out).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04429", "filename": "729892b8440230e9d78878aea891dd1ad31ca11832e43c4472d54f2d30404fb5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous timing (the gemstone ring on the person's hand flickers throughout the video; a normal gemstone ring would not flicker under light, but rather exhibit a uniform, soft, and symmetrical halo effect.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04430", "filename": "729892b8440230e9d78878aea891dd1ad31ca11832e43c4472d54f2d30404fb5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04431", "filename": "729892b8440230e9d78878aea891dd1ad31ca11832e43c4472d54f2d30404fb5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.3s, the gemstone ring on the character's hand changes from transparent to light blue.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04432", "filename": "744378a2b103c9d45b332720a7f0e710294cfe8fbd3acbd9a8ff4b912f72f6e7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the sea of clouds in the image is suspended in front of distant mountains; normally, this type of fog is close to the ground and covers valleys.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04433", "filename": "744378a2b103c9d45b332720a7f0e710294cfe8fbd3acbd9a8ff4b912f72f6e7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04434", "filename": "744378a2b103c9d45b332720a7f0e710294cfe8fbd3acbd9a8ff4b912f72f6e7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04435", "filename": "752562c5bab03fc8f6f9030fa7a2651f05789ca0f1d05a722d18f8d4a3452404_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the smoke generated after the rocket launch moves too smoothly, more like liquid, unlike realistic footage, lacking the drifting motion that real smoke should have).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04436", "filename": "752562c5bab03fc8f6f9030fa7a2651f05789ca0f1d05a722d18f8d4a3452404_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (At the beginning of the video, a huge object is seen flying rapidly out of the frame due to the shockwave of an explosion, but the powerful blast does not shake the red metal frame at all. In reality, such a powerful impact would inevitably cause an effect within a certain range, causing the object to shake, vibrate, or be thrown away.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04437", "filename": "752562c5bab03fc8f6f9030fa7a2651f05789ca0f1d05a722d18f8d4a3452404_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (During a normal rocket launch, the exhaust plume and smoke are ejected downwards because the thrust must overcome gravity. However, the smoke in the video is rising upwards, which is inconsistent with real rocket launches.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04438", "filename": "752562c5bab03fc8f6f9030fa7a2651f05789ca0f1d05a722d18f8d4a3452404_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (At the beginning of the video, a huge object is seen flying rapidly out of the frame due to the shockwave of an explosion, but the powerful blast does not shake the red metal frame at all. In reality, such a powerful impact would inevitably cause an effect within a certain range, causing the object to shake, vibrate, or be thrown away.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04439", "filename": "768499dcd3efe001b8fa20fb65bc94cac64d1171008808fb67d29dcfb8da212e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the entire video shows the burning process of a cigarette, but the shape and length of the cigarette do not change throughout the burning process).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04440", "filename": "768499dcd3efe001b8fa20fb65bc94cac64d1171008808fb67d29dcfb8da212e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is continuous (the entire video shows the burning process of a cigarette, but there is no obvious burning residue or spread of the cigarette until the end of the video. At 1.4s and 3s, flames suddenly appear on the cigarette. Under normal circumstances, cigarettes do not produce flames when burning.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04441", "filename": "768499dcd3efe001b8fa20fb65bc94cac64d1171008808fb67d29dcfb8da212e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (at 2.7 seconds, a flame suddenly appears where the cigarette is burning; normally, cigarettes don't produce flames). Overall visual anomalies (the smoke from the burning cigarette is too smooth and regular, unlike realistic footage; it lacks the drifting and disordered feel of real smoke movement).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04442", "filename": "802913dfd607315dfc4b7c0b0c2a7405a25b808035842154fbbd837baeea4b7d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video content: Physical behavior (the foam in the petri dish is jumping up and down without any external force throughout the video, violating Newton's First Law.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04443", "filename": "802913dfd607315dfc4b7c0b0c2a7405a25b808035842154fbbd837baeea4b7d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.3s, the water poured into the petri dish suddenly turned into foam).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04444", "filename": "802913dfd607315dfc4b7c0b0c2a7405a25b808035842154fbbd837baeea4b7d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.5s, the viscous liquid in the petri dish suddenly turned into foam).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04445", "filename": "823327eef58bdee3292b80d493f16d80028a7ef1cde908f7cd283b6f4a0d7bc6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the entire video shows flames burning in a pile of wood, but the burning wood does not show obvious carbonization or deformation. Normally, when wood is ignited, there will be obvious carbonization marks on the surface, and the wood will also deform as it burns.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04446", "filename": "823327eef58bdee3292b80d493f16d80028a7ef1cde908f7cd283b6f4a0d7bc6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the entire video shows flames burning in a pile of wood, but the burning wood does not show obvious carbonization or deformation. Normally, when wood is ignited, there will be obvious carbonization marks on the surface, and the wood will also deform as it burns.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04447", "filename": "823327eef58bdee3292b80d493f16d80028a7ef1cde908f7cd283b6f4a0d7bc6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04448", "filename": "827146cea7a746741742f91fb28bbab8b8fdd2b76ce50bcf7ec52db746d34e06_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual effect is abnormal (the waterfall in the image flows too smoothly and regularly, unlike a realistic scene, lacking the random splashing and natural branching that a real waterfall should have).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04449", "filename": "827146cea7a746741742f91fb28bbab8b8fdd2b76ce50bcf7ec52db746d34e06_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: The overall visual presentation is off (the waterfall's movement doesn't resemble real water flow; it's more like a viscous liquid, lacking the random splashing and natural branching of a real waterfall. The grass below the camera moves too smoothly, unlike a realistic scene, lacking the feeling of real grass swaying in the wind.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04450", "filename": "827146cea7a746741742f91fb28bbab8b8fdd2b76ce50bcf7ec52db746d34e06_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04451", "filename": "832701c336bbe3010c0298be98490248590a0a8e62b3a1853ac7e12ffe5f5d04_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the smoke from the burning wooden stake in the entire video drifts along the surface of the stake; normally, smoke from a burning object drifts randomly into the air, not along the surface of the object).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04452", "filename": "832701c336bbe3010c0298be98490248590a0a8e62b3a1853ac7e12ffe5f5d04_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (When blue-white light and orange-red flames overlap, glaring bright white spots appear in localized areas, creating a superimposed luminous effect and exhibiting abnormal brightness peaks.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04453", "filename": "832701c336bbe3010c0298be98490248590a0a8e62b3a1853ac7e12ffe5f5d04_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous duration (at 1 second, without any light source, the charcoal suddenly brightens, displaying a glaring bright white spot.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04454", "filename": "842783b1ee8103db4155dc8f1397169c9794408f4cd8886f7d3d372b458ee1e1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 2.1s, the bubble twists and deforms). Physical behavior (at 1.2s, the character's head penetrates the bubble, violating the impermeability of solids).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04455", "filename": "842783b1ee8103db4155dc8f1397169c9794408f4cd8886f7d3d372b458ee1e1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is continuous (at 2.4 seconds, the bubbles suddenly enlarge). Overall visual anomalies (the bubble movement is too smooth, unlike realistic footage, lacking the feeling of real bubbles drifting in the wind).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04456", "filename": "855772e78272938c4716971c67fe4f063830bd39119a8e4d52aaeecc0ecf0852_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Continuous timing (from the beginning to the end of the video, beverages are continuously poured into the glass, but the volume of the beverages in the glass does not change significantly.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04457", "filename": "4949992559379f60cc8a7b016d30c20cc543c967823f77ec7f819059bd7635b3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (2.6s-5.8s). The cup is full of milk, but it does not overflow. The height of the milk in the cup does not change significantly.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04458", "filename": "09056677926468626304dbe4f82f17f2491094bf6e9a5a54f037c9f800844f9c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (1.9s-5s). The bowling ball is crushed by the hydraulic press. The texture of the cracks on the left and right sides is different. The left side is similar to plastic, while the right side is like wood.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04459", "filename": "09056677926468626304dbe4f82f17f2491094bf6e9a5a54f037c9f800844f9c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (4.3s-4.7s). After the crushed bowling pin rolls to the right, the tail of the crushed bowling pin suddenly appears out of thin air on the table.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04460", "filename": "09056677926468626304dbe4f82f17f2491094bf6e9a5a54f037c9f800844f9c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Time sequence (1.6s-2s: before the bowling pins are broken, fragments appear out of thin air) Physical behavior (2.9s-5s: after the bowling pins are crushed in half and fall to both sides, the left bowling pin becomes the bowling pin mouth and suddenly flies towards the table without any external force)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04461", "filename": "a0ba97f840f2f73bba5ce2d633d1c18ef6d490d161fec4ff8a80c55a0bf82f47_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (between 3.1s and 3.2s, two objects in the lower middle of the video suddenly merge into one after the sea recedes). The overall visual impression is abnormal (the beach in the video is smooth and flat, unlike real footage, and lacks the texture and unevenness that a beach should have).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04462", "filename": "a0ba97f840f2f73bba5ce2d633d1c18ef6d490d161fec4ff8a80c55a0bf82f47_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (in a real coastal sunrise scene, there is a natural transition of light and shadow between the sunlit sea and the unlit areas. However, in the video footage from 1.7s to 5.8s, the water on the right side appears as a uniform, saturated deep blue, without any gradual transition between it and the warm yellow sea on the left side exposed to sunlight. The color boundaries are too harsh and do not resemble a realistic scene).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04463", "filename": "a0ba97f840f2f73bba5ce2d633d1c18ef6d490d161fec4ff8a80c55a0bf82f47_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04464", "filename": "a0ba97f840f2f73bba5ce2d633d1c18ef6d490d161fec4ff8a80c55a0bf82f47_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (0.6s-8s). One of the black objects on the coast at the bottom of the video disappears out of thin air. Then, the remaining black object suddenly turns into two, and then another one disappears out of thin air.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04467", "filename": "a01e2d8d326e35751733a0970f7c8b25a4950861ba9dcc5c7ddc4e2349389cea_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04468", "filename": "a01e2d8d326e35751733a0970f7c8b25a4950861ba9dcc5c7ddc4e2349389cea_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (real streams would naturally create ripples, eddies, and splashes due to terrain and resistance, but the water flow in the video looks like stars, unlike real scenes, and lacks the splashes and ripples that a river would create).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04469", "filename": "a01e2d8d326e35751733a0970f7c8b25a4950861ba9dcc5c7ddc4e2349389cea_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the splashes and ripples of a normal stream change randomly with the terrain, but the water flow in the entire video is too uniform, lacking the randomness and depth of natural water bodies, unlike a realistic scene).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04474", "filename": "a2b6156f0c4f108fd7ae9faf7abaed237cad292f1092707bb3a03ff6c69022ef_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the hand in the video is floating and holding a soda bottle, without an arm, which does not look like a real scene). The time is continuous (from 0s to 1.4s, the sparkling water in the video is continuously poured out, but the liquid in the bottle does not decrease, and the liquid in the cup does not increase).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04475", "filename": "a2b6156f0c4f108fd7ae9faf7abaed237cad292f1092707bb3a03ff6c69022ef_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall visual impression is abnormal (the hand in the video is floating and holding a soda bottle, without an arm, which does not look like a real scene). The time is continuous (from 0s to 4.3s, the sparkling water in the video is continuously poured out while the liquid in the bottle does not decrease).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04476", "filename": "a2b6156f0c4f108fd7ae9faf7abaed237cad292f1092707bb3a03ff6c69022ef_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall, the visuals appear abnormal (the hand in the video is floating and holding a soda bottle, without an arm, unlike real footage). The timing is continuous (0.8s, liquid from the bottle is continuously added to the glass, but the liquid in the glass not only doesn't increase but actually decreases; 2s-5s, the ice cubes in the glass suddenly appear to grow larger out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04477", "filename": "a2b6156f0c4f108fd7ae9faf7abaed237cad292f1092707bb3a03ff6c69022ef_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (0.2s-1.4s: liquid flows through the cup wall onto the table, violating the principle that solids are impermeable; 1.4s-2.7s: liquid is slowly poured into the bottle, yet a high splash is created; normally, water would only splash large under gravity if it flows very high). Time continuity (2.5s-8s: the bottle continuously pours liquid into the cup, but the amount of liquid in the bottle does not decrease, nor does the amount of liquid in the cup increase).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04478", "filename": "a2c2648c1109f395fcfe68fc86ca156843337d75b4333ed0f21eed36064e169f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video footage is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (by observing the other four fingers tearing at the object in the video footage, it was found that the object has a certain degree of toughness, but the middle finger is tearing the object too much, causing a large deformation).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04479", "filename": "a2c2648c1109f395fcfe68fc86ca156843337d75b4333ed0f21eed36064e169f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (2.3s-3.7s) and a finger that was fiddling with the red object suddenly appears out of nowhere.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04480", "filename": "a2c2648c1109f395fcfe68fc86ca156843337d75b4333ed0f21eed36064e169f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0.6s) and physical behavior (0.6s-0.7s) where the finger that was touching the red object suddenly appears out of nowhere.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04481", "filename": "a2d7abccc00a87d3e97d346678e75071df9fe9367d718112deb2a3c62187250b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (0.8s-1.1s, the car in the rearview mirror gradually disappears from the mirror, which should be an overtaking vehicle, but the car in the rearview mirror appears to rush out of the mirror; the road the vehicle is traveling on in the video does not match the road in the rearview mirror).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04482", "filename": "a2d7abccc00a87d3e97d346678e75071df9fe9367d718112deb2a3c62187250b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (the road the vehicle is traveling on in the video does not match the road in the rearview mirror, and the orange-red light and shadow produced in the rearview mirror does not match the environment outside the rearview mirror).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_04483", "filename": "a2d7abccc00a87d3e97d346678e75071df9fe9367d718112deb2a3c62187250b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The time frame is continuous (2.5 seconds). A car passing by in the opposite lane does not appear in the rearview mirror, and the car reflected in the rearview mirror is traveling in the same direction as this car.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04484", "filename": "a2d7abccc00a87d3e97d346678e75071df9fe9367d718112deb2a3c62187250b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The time frame is continuous (2.3 seconds). A car passing by in the opposite lane does not appear in the rearview mirror, and the road in the rearview mirror is different from the road the car is traveling on.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04485", "filename": "a3ac304792f8e46063eb8aa4dbf80b0c4f3b81eae7eb12a831cc6f98c6cea6d9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is inconsistent (2.8s-5s) as the fireworks reflected on the lake surface are different from the actual fireworks.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04486", "filename": "a3ac304792f8e46063eb8aa4dbf80b0c4f3b81eae7eb12a831cc6f98c6cea6d9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is abnormal (real fireworks explosions produce a large amount of smoke that spreads outwards with the shockwave, but the fireworks in the video show almost no accompanying smoke diffusion, with only a small amount of static smoke in the background, unlike real footage).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04487", "filename": "81a5df86433b2b6355185ca15b5239f7e64246e1f2c7adfb7e755134187fe476_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.7s in the video, before the spatula has even touched the chestnut, the chestnut moves on its own without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04488", "filename": "81a5df86433b2b6355185ca15b5239f7e64246e1f2c7adfb7e755134187fe476_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (within 0.5 seconds of the video, without any change in the camera angle, several chestnuts suddenly appear in the pot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04489", "filename": "82ac4768de614fc97afe6ef34a050658022c7d0992862732169df5f0c987847d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the video, two ice blocks are in the same environment, but the ice block on the left melts too quickly, while the ice block on the right does not change at all).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04490", "filename": "82ac4768de614fc97afe6ef34a050658022c7d0992862732169df5f0c987847d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the entire scene, two melting ice blocks keep getting bigger for no reason, the water in the left box increases, while the water in the right box disappears. This violates the inertia that ice blocks shrink as they melt, and the melted water is higher than the boxes but does not overflow).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04491", "filename": "82ac4768de614fc97afe6ef34a050658022c7d0992862732169df5f0c987847d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 0s and 1.4s in the video, the two ice blocks move on their own without any external interference; at 7.3s, an extra ice block appears out of nowhere in the left box).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04492", "filename": "82d8cf2c55d012b30cd50d810c55ccd3dd1d8d3511eb7f93e7acb5db78af5641_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video behavior: physical behavior (throughout the entire video, the left half of the apple remains suspended on the other apple without falling to the ground, even though the camera angle remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04493", "filename": "82d8cf2c55d012b30cd50d810c55ccd3dd1d8d3511eb7f93e7acb5db78af5641_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (1.8s-3.2s, the water flow hits surrounding objects without splashing or branching, which is inconsistent with the natural flow of water) Temporal continuity (at 3.5s, the water falling on the left disappears into thin air without any change in the camera angle)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04494", "filename": "82d8cf2c55d012b30cd50d810c55ccd3dd1d8d3511eb7f93e7acb5db78af5641_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1 seconds into the video, without any change in camera angle, the table beneath the apple suddenly transforms into water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04495", "filename": "82ec5e44e8cd14582a144530ecf68795305ebac990d4560e5dce1489d5ec15c7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (in the entire video, the impurities in the middle flow downwards, while the impurities on the sides flow upwards, which is contradictory).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04496", "filename": "82ec5e44e8cd14582a144530ecf68795305ebac990d4560e5dce1489d5ec15c7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the right side appears to flow downwards while the left side appears to flow horizontally, which is contradictory).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04497", "filename": "82ec5e44e8cd14582a144530ecf68795305ebac990d4560e5dce1489d5ec15c7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior (In the image, the dark-colored impurities in the middle appear to flow downwards, while the lighter-colored impurities on both sides flow upwards).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04498", "filename": "82ec5e44e8cd14582a144530ecf68795305ebac990d4560e5dce1489d5ec15c7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (In a real connected fluid, the flow rate of incompressible fluid must remain continuous. However, the purple band in the middle of the image exhibits a flow characteristic of \"maintaining a regular linear shape without a continuous source,\" and the orange fluid on both sides does not show a corresponding flow trend of mass replenishment, which will lead to a lack of mass conservation in local areas.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04499", "filename": "82ec18a86cd766c92b400a02f405aa48686c4b414683a32b81bd32cc4664f64e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the sun moves horizontally in a straight line, which violates the Earth's rotation; the sun's trajectory is arc-shaped).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04500", "filename": "82ec18a86cd766c92b400a02f405aa48686c4b414683a32b81bd32cc4664f64e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (During a real sunrise and sunset, sunlight is scattered by the atmosphere, creating an arc-shaped halo that is bright at the center and gradually dims outwards. However, the light in the image is a horizontal, uniform band without a brightness gradient that varies with the sun's altitude angle, which does not conform to the physical characteristics of atmospheric scattering.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_04501", "filename": "82ec18a86cd766c92b400a02f405aa48686c4b414683a32b81bd32cc4664f64e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04502", "filename": "83a480a542eae27c1f521a5b9c02a22311cfd0a8602eb5584c10bd4525ae2c51_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Temporal continuity (a transparent object moves on its own throughout the entire video without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04503", "filename": "83a480a542eae27c1f521a5b9c02a22311cfd0a8602eb5584c10bd4525ae2c51_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Temporal continuity (at 0.1s in the video, the ice suddenly sprays out water); Physical behavior (from 1.4s to 5.8s, more water melts from the ice, but the ice cubes continue to grow larger).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04504", "filename": "83a480a542eae27c1f521a5b9c02a22311cfd0a8602eb5584c10bd4525ae2c51_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (from 0.1 seconds to the end of the video, a transparent object in the video shakes dramatically on its own without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04505", "filename": "83a480a542eae27c1f521a5b9c02a22311cfd0a8602eb5584c10bd4525ae2c51_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 0.4 seconds into the frame, a transparent gel-like object in the frame suddenly transforms into a spherical ice block without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04506", "filename": "83a6822f1d4958133c07594f03c350c6e58fdddab65be90afb03bcb052a17c0f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Timing continuity (flickering artifacts exist in the middle of the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04507", "filename": "83a6822f1d4958133c07594f03c350c6e58fdddab65be90afb03bcb052a17c0f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the volume of the ice cube increases as it melts, which contradicts the inertia that ice cubes shrink as they melt).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04508", "filename": "83a6822f1d4958133c07594f03c350c6e58fdddab65be90afb03bcb052a17c0f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: temporal continuity (from 0.9s to 1.8s in the video, the ice blocks suddenly grow larger and move closer together; from 0.9s to 2s, three ice blocks appear out of nowhere in the frame; from 2.2s to 8s, the ice blocks suddenly turn into a gelatinous object and continuously increase in size, eventually changing from a square to a triangle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04509", "filename": "85aeece7277217e0edc595b0778c95a55cdb666f421fac7f4f1f4f6fa12242db_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: temporal continuity (at 0.7 seconds into the video, with no change in camera angle, the blue and red track suddenly turns black and white, and the previously chaotic beads suddenly become orderly).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04510", "filename": "85aeece7277217e0edc595b0778c95a55cdb666f421fac7f4f1f4f6fa12242db_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0.7s-3.4s, without any camera movement, the number of rolling beads suddenly increases, and the obstacle on the right suddenly transforms into a black square object; at 4.7s, the pink bead suddenly changes from one to two; at 5.2s, a green bead appears out of nowhere on the floor).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04511", "filename": "85aeece7277217e0edc595b0778c95a55cdb666f421fac7f4f1f4f6fa12242db_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.4s, the green bead on the left side of the screen disappears out of thin air; at 1.9s, the green bead appears out of thin air; the yellow bead suddenly disappears; at 3.3s, the black object suddenly shortens).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04512", "filename": "85cd04e8a6a76c5d397b4a183b65b24d7585d4601dbb5f9451fa9400484d5daa_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Newton's cradle relies on metal balls on the same straight line to transfer momentum through elastic collisions. However, in the device shown in the image, the balls on the left and right sides are not on the same horizontal straight line, so they cannot transfer momentum through collisions and therefore cannot achieve the swinging effect of Newton's cradle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04513", "filename": "85cd04e8a6a76c5d397b4a183b65b24d7585d4601dbb5f9451fa9400484d5daa_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the angle at which the spheres sway after the collision remains unchanged, violating the law of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04514", "filename": "85cd04e8a6a76c5d397b4a183b65b24d7585d4601dbb5f9451fa9400484d5daa_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (2s-2.8s, the two balls on the right merge into one without any change in the camera angle; at 3.6s, the five balls in the frame suddenly become six; at 4.2s and 6.2s, the two balls on the left suddenly merge into one).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04515", "filename": "85f0744b02870e9d24aa0be0bc76492f0b860ed7f8412e1d8a50c6a39a77c5f3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04516", "filename": "85f0744b02870e9d24aa0be0bc76492f0b860ed7f8412e1d8a50c6a39a77c5f3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0s in the video, without any change in the camera angle, the garlic cloves on the knife disappear out of thin air; at 5.3s, the amount of minced garlic on the cutting board increases out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04517", "filename": "4ece64eebfb8af653f1f0b67295337f07902a6e80a7d05b9ae208f68d9ce492e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity error (at 0.7s in the video, a white liquid appears out of thin air at the bottom of a water glass filled with water and flows upwards without the camera changing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04518", "filename": "4ece64eebfb8af653f1f0b67295337f07902a6e80a7d05b9ae208f68d9ce492e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Temporal continuity anomaly (at 1s in the video, numerous air bubbles appear out of thin air in the left-hand glass without any external interference with the iron ball). Physical behavior anomalies (between 1.1s and 3.3s, the magnet penetrates the glass surface and enters the interior of the glass).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04519", "filename": "4eebe0271667525a99503efcb689c856837d2271c0c3d61dbdea510e39892d34_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04520", "filename": "4eebe0271667525a99503efcb689c856837d2271c0c3d61dbdea510e39892d34_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (Throughout the video, the cup is clearly emitting steam, but the steam from hot water should consist of fine, floating water droplets.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04521", "filename": "4eebe0271667525a99503efcb689c856837d2271c0c3d61dbdea510e39892d34_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (the smoke in the entire video appears as irregularly regular columns, lacking the curvature and random texture of natural smoke; it resembles a static texture rather than a dynamic fluid.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04522", "filename": "4efc4e97965e114bfae6749a259c25add5467d6773c0ffe9a3e4ea0b7a8f34b3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (between 0.7s and 4.4s in the video, the ice block is slowly melting, and without any external interference, regular water ripples are constantly emanating from the stationary ice block. At 0s, the ice block is in a semi-transparent state, half-melted. At 0.4s, the melted ice block has solidified again.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04523", "filename": "4efc4e97965e114bfae6749a259c25add5467d6773c0ffe9a3e4ea0b7a8f34b3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (between 1.3s and 3.8s, the ice should be a transparent liquid after melting, but there are bright, shimmering paste-like substances in the footage, which are obviously added later. Starting at 2.2s, as the ice slowly melts, a layer of milky white liquid appears around it and keeps expanding outwards.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04524", "filename": "4efc4e97965e114bfae6749a259c25add5467d6773c0ffe9a3e4ea0b7a8f34b3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 4.9s in the video, the ice cube on the table rotates once on its own without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04525", "filename": "4f0a1ee3ef19640aed6010d64ff9a5741caf32d3439649f1d451e74f3f7c8d8b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: The physical behavior is abnormal (throughout the video, the water and yellow liquid in the cup do not move despite the stick's disturbance; they remain stationary, and the stick does not refract within the cup).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04526", "filename": "4f0a1ee3ef19640aed6010d64ff9a5741caf32d3439649f1d451e74f3f7c8d8b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Temporal continuity anomaly (the water in the cup suddenly boils without any external interference between 2.5 seconds and the end of the video). Physical anomalies: At 0.8 seconds, the stick in the cup has already touched the bottom, but the person in the video is still putting the stick into the water.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04527", "filename": "4f0a1ee3ef19640aed6010d64ff9a5741caf32d3439649f1d451e74f3f7c8d8b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (Throughout the video, a person continuously moves a stick up and down inside a cup, but the water and yellow liquid in the cup do not move due to the stick's movement.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04528", "filename": "4f0a6bb9dc3c314e9869351becae1f27ae69af0b084bdecc287d5487cb25f515_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity error (a time-lapse photography technique was used throughout the video, but the power lines above the eaves on the left side of the screen consistently exhibit flickering and twitching imperfections, rather than a messy appearance caused by wind).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04529", "filename": "4f0a6bb9dc3c314e9869351becae1f27ae69af0b084bdecc287d5487cb25f515_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly in the footage: (From 0.7s to 4.4s, the footage shows a winter park at night, but the person on the right is holding a device and filming houses. The device in the person's hand displays a predominantly blue scene, but the houses he is filming in the video do not have any blue lights or background.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04532", "filename": "4f35dbdbbef59efc5928e38f444999cee95bfcbb190fdc75eca765ddea0c0b3f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (all the clouds in the sky move as a whole throughout the video, too synchronously, lacking the natural feel of wind blowing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04533", "filename": "4f35dbdbbef59efc5928e38f444999cee95bfcbb190fdc75eca765ddea0c0b3f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity error (flickering and jerking artifacts appear on the sea surface throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04534", "filename": "4f35dbdbbef59efc5928e38f444999cee95bfcbb190fdc75eca765ddea0c0b3f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04535", "filename": "4f35dbdbbef59efc5928e38f444999cee95bfcbb190fdc75eca765ddea0c0b3f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (all the clouds in the sky move as a whole throughout the video, too synchronously, lacking the natural feel of wind blowing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04536", "filename": "4f43bc2e31928c5dfdd98edc032e53f39bf2d132225c930f98f8b692b968f817_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall visual presentation is off (normally, the flames of burning firewood are predominantly yellow or orange, while blue light is generally seen in the combustion of natural gas or in high-temperature, pure oxygen environments. However, the video shows a distinct area of blue flame within the firewood pile, which does not conform to the normal color distribution of burning firewood. Throughout the video, the flames continuously burn the wood without producing smoke).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04537", "filename": "4f43bc2e31928c5dfdd98edc032e53f39bf2d132225c930f98f8b692b968f817_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04538", "filename": "4f43bc2e31928c5dfdd98edc032e53f39bf2d132225c930f98f8b692b968f817_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04539", "filename": "4f1822f41aa431de5e3a4892cc70f500d8a1729b7fd7d0adced2386abd9c2883_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (at 1.2s in the video, all the water droplets on the window have frozen into ice, but dew is still flowing down the window on the right side, and the water droplets can freeze into the same piece of ice even without water flow connecting them).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04540", "filename": "4f1822f41aa431de5e3a4892cc70f500d8a1729b7fd7d0adced2386abd9c2883_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the image: Abnormal physical behavior (between 0.4s and 4.3s, the water on the glass surface either remains liquid due to a temperature \u22650\u2103 or freezes into ice crystals due to a temperature <0\u2103; neither of these can be produced in large quantities in the same area in a short period of time). Abnormalities in the continuity of time: (at 1.9s, the water droplets on the window suddenly changed from transparent droplets to silver liquid without any change in the lens).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04541", "filename": "4f1822f41aa431de5e3a4892cc70f500d8a1729b7fd7d0adced2386abd9c2883_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Abnormal physical behavior occurs between 2.4s and 5.5s (water on the glass surface either remains liquid due to a temperature \u22650\u2103 or freezes into ice crystals due to a temperature <0\u2103; neither of these can be produced in large quantities in the same area within a short period of time).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04542", "filename": "4f2270b6888db37ea165ea7d7ce701f6db8de8af2ef16babd88c4ce121deaa46_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: The iron ball in the cup on the right side of the video is shaking with an increasingly larger arc without being subjected to any external force.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04543", "filename": "4f2270b6888db37ea165ea7d7ce701f6db8de8af2ef16babd88c4ce121deaa46_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Abnormal physical behavior (the iron ball in the bottle moves up and down on its own without any external force between 1.3s and 5.8s, violating the principle of inertia).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04544", "filename": "4f2270b6888db37ea165ea7d7ce701f6db8de8af2ef16babd88c4ce121deaa46_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: The iron ball in the transparent glass bottle on the right rises on its own without being affected by any external force, which violates the principle of inertia.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04545", "filename": "4f2270b6888db37ea165ea7d7ce701f6db8de8af2ef16babd88c4ce121deaa46_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 2.3s in the video, when the person lifts the iron ball, the iron ball suddenly adheres to the glass bottle without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04547", "filename": "3fe6eaa56fb6ae84954ef28f8b0cc11e7a5754a4c24e1497fd26cf7ea014c9dd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is due to physical behavior: (At 1.8s, the nail penetrates the glass block, violating the principle that solids are impermeable. At 4.4s, the first square glass cylinder in the middle rotates on its own without any external force.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04548", "filename": "3fe7ad2221e0737b3b027cfc2f679ce0760136355f1039976bca90b6a97b497e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: (At 4s, the video flickers) The overall visual effect is abnormal (a dotted light spot appears on the wall directly below the central lamp. Its arrangement is the same as the dotted light of the lamp beads, but it is not a reflection of the lamp and appears abruptly in the picture).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_04549", "filename": "3fe7ad2221e0737b3b027cfc2f679ce0760136355f1039976bca90b6a97b497e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: The overall visual impression is off. (Normally, the light from this type of long, narrow bathroom mirror light is diffused, creating a soft and even diffuse reflection on the wall, not producing such a clear and regular projection. Directly below the central light, a dotted light spot appears on the wall, its arrangement perfectly matching the dotted pattern of the light bulbs, but it is not a reflection of the light bulb and appears abruptly in the image.)", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04550", "filename": "3fe7ad2221e0737b3b027cfc2f679ce0760136355f1039976bca90b6a97b497e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the background is a wall, but there are water ripples in the image, which doesn't look like a real scene). Causality: Throughout the video, the light reflected on the wall is constantly shaking even without any external force moving the light.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04551", "filename": "3fe9974416306a51d653818b649b56efe5c8df3e89475e83e616e5cb49759981_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual presentation is off (in the video, the reflections of the train and the orange arched bridge in the water do not correspond to a true perspective relationship. In reality, the train is on the elevated road behind, and its reflection should appear further away, not completely aligned with the reflection of the orange arched bridge).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04552", "filename": "3fe9974416306a51d653818b649b56efe5c8df3e89475e83e616e5cb49759981_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Physical behavior (between 4s and 4.9s, under normal circumstances, when a train moves from near to far, the train should appear larger when it is near and smaller when it is far. However, in the entire video, the train appears to be suddenly shrunk, and the shrunk state is unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04553", "filename": "3fe9974416306a51d653818b649b56efe5c8df3e89475e83e616e5cb49759981_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the moving train on the left in the video causes the solid railing on the bridge to shake).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04554", "filename": "3fe9974416306a51d653818b649b56efe5c8df3e89475e83e616e5cb49759981_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the train on the right is stationary on the tracks while the train on the left is moving throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04559", "filename": "4a4b8985768502f59a9bfe59dc3a595714de7005ef5947262c9316e4be8297aa_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall feeling is abnormal (it's raining lightly in the scene, but apart from the rain, the entire scene feels static).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04560", "filename": "4a4b8985768502f59a9bfe59dc3a595714de7005ef5947262c9316e4be8297aa_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 3.6s, the fog rapidly spread across the entire screen from nothing, and the diffusion speed was uniform, failing to show the dynamic process of natural fog formation where it gradually spreads from a localized area, violating the natural formation and diffusion patterns of fog.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04561", "filename": "4a4b8985768502f59a9bfe59dc3a595714de7005ef5947262c9316e4be8297aa_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is off (the colors of the fields, trees, and distant mountains in the video lack natural gradation and transition. Under the fog, the colors of the various objects appear too harsh and monotonous, which does not match the soft gradations that colors should have in a real foggy environment, giving people an unreal visual experience.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04562", "filename": "4a4b8985768502f59a9bfe59dc3a595714de7005ef5947262c9316e4be8297aa_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the fog in the image has a clear sense of movement, but the trees remain stationary and do not sway due to the wind, which does not conform to the natural interaction between wind and objects.)", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04563", "filename": "4a8a6a1eb3182454c8f003072a16c3681f2d17473721c61badd7fd6de9b616e5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is due to physical behavior: (At 0.7s, the explosion produces a huge white smoke cloud under strong impact, which is inconsistent with the only small burn marks on the brick wall, indicating a severe degree of damage. Furthermore, the explosion did not produce any flying brick fragments, violating the physical laws governing the destruction of explosive energy. At 0.8s, the smoke produced by the explosion and combustion is only white, lacking the gray or other dust components that should appear during combustion. After the explosion on the wall at 4.1s, the wall surface shows no change.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04564", "filename": "4a8a6a1eb3182454c8f003072a16c3681f2d17473721c61badd7fd6de9b616e5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly: (At 0.7s, blue smoke erupts from the hole in the brick wall and spreads rapidly, its flow pattern and diffusion speed differing from the laws of real fluid motion.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04565", "filename": "4a8a6a1eb3182454c8f003072a16c3681f2d17473721c61badd7fd6de9b616e5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical anomalies: (At 0.6s, the ground explodes without any explosive materials, and there is no flying dirt or dust.) Time continuity (At 2.1s, the wall inexplicably emits smoke without any burning materials.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04566", "filename": "4a8a6a1eb3182454c8f003072a16c3681f2d17473721c61badd7fd6de9b616e5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 1.8s, a blue flame suddenly appears on the wall and rapidly burns it without any apparent burning); Physical behavior (at 4.8s, there is obvious open flame burning inside the wall, but at 7.2s, there are no burn marks on the wall).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04567", "filename": "4a18e992d4a73f57f863c98f84e39a36459050beabfb623b645ba7d21e27eb09_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (In the video, although the clouds exhibit some dynamic effects, their movement follows a predetermined path, lacking the randomness and unpredictability of natural cloud movement. Overall, it appears too static and uniform, lacking the complexity and diversity that natural clouds should possess.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04568", "filename": "4a18e992d4a73f57f863c98f84e39a36459050beabfb623b645ba7d21e27eb09_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall impression is off (the proportions between the towering buildings in the foreground and the distant cityscape are noticeably disproportionate; the distant city doesn't appear to change visually due to distance or building height).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04569", "filename": "4a18e992d4a73f57f863c98f84e39a36459050beabfb623b645ba7d21e27eb09_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.5s, a cloud suddenly appears vertically upwards next to the tower, surging upwards. At 4.4s, a sharp needle suddenly appears on top of the tower.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04570", "filename": "4a226073e9416329e67d0a0d6fcdab4a69be87c0f6cc975e58ac7834d76df6d9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (the water surface in the video exhibits unusually uniform and regular ripples and light reflections, lacking the randomness and dynamic changes commonly found in natural water bodies.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04571", "filename": "4a226073e9416329e67d0a0d6fcdab4a69be87c0f6cc975e58ac7834d76df6d9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video behavior: Physical behavior (the floating object in the upper right corner of the video does not change shape or position with the movement of the water waves).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04572", "filename": "4a226073e9416329e67d0a0d6fcdab4a69be87c0f6cc975e58ac7834d76df6d9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals and physical behavior are abnormal. (When light reflects off the water surface, the varying undulations and angles of the water waves create diverse and rich light and shadow effects. However, in this video, the texture of the water waves under the reflected light appears somewhat mechanical and repetitive, lacking the randomness and dynamic changes of natural water waves.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04573", "filename": "4a226073e9416329e67d0a0d6fcdab4a69be87c0f6cc975e58ac7834d76df6d9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 6.6s, when the water wave hits the floating object, the object does not float towards the direction of the impact, but floats in the opposite direction). Overall visual intuition is abnormal (when the water wave hits the shore, the image is too smooth and lacks the jolts that a realistic image should have).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04574", "filename": "4aa255f15879611add3a39caf2f018a72e098824721a2cc14aac37a7c4318d19_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Abnormal physical behavior (between 2.5s and 3.8s, the central circular sphere underwent irregular deformation under external force).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04575", "filename": "4aa255f15879611add3a39caf2f018a72e098824721a2cc14aac37a7c4318d19_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 1.1s, red debris penetrates the blue sphere, violating the principle that solids are impermeable. At 1.8s, the red sphere on the left suddenly deforms without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04576", "filename": "4aa255f15879611add3a39caf2f018a72e098824721a2cc14aac37a7c4318d19_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is continuous (at 0.4s, the light blue ball on the left suddenly dents into a hole without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04577", "filename": "143f1312d52a70e5cfe3899098fa49515aa295170bd8cd5520a5d4729de5ec97_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (The dandelion-like substance inside the glass sphere rotates with it, and their rotation directions and speeds should be completely consistent. The white filamentous substance on the left floats in the air but rotates on its own, which is an anomaly).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04578", "filename": "143f1312d52a70e5cfe3899098fa49515aa295170bd8cd5520a5d4729de5ec97_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the dandelion floats stably on the glass container and cannot move back and forth rapidly on its own without external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04579", "filename": "153e3dc0fba27e4ac32f726e29abf62cf17ee5f41f93951f6fa8d1f3c94965c8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (1.8s: before the hydraulic press has even touched the white cube below, the cube suddenly bounces up and adheres to the hydraulic press, creating a gap; 3.9s: while the cube is being continuously compressed by the hydraulic press, it suddenly changes from being compressed and deformed to rebounding after being released from the force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04580", "filename": "153e3dc0fba27e4ac32f726e29abf62cf17ee5f41f93951f6fa8d1f3c94965c8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the visuals: Physical behavior (the white cube continues to penetrate the metal disc below. Referring to the hydraulic press's recovery speed, the white cube should descend slowly and should not deform drastically upon contact with the metal object below.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04581", "filename": "153e3dc0fba27e4ac32f726e29abf62cf17ee5f41f93951f6fa8d1f3c94965c8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (The wire mesh sways up and down on its own when stationary and without any additional force. The deformation of the white cube when the hydraulic press compresses it indicates that the cube is a flexible material. During the compression process, it should deform slowly along with the hydraulic press, and the cube should not jump.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04582", "filename": "153e3dc0fba27e4ac32f726e29abf62cf17ee5f41f93951f6fa8d1f3c94965c8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the white cube being compressed and broken indicates that the material itself is not flexible, which contradicts the flexible bending characteristics below the cube).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04583", "filename": "155c64a4f3e03bb0ddfc88d7f8c7f1a561c571f301bb21ecf610751f720879e7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (0.3s-4.1s, gas is continuously and rapidly ejected from the bottom of the flame. During this process, the flame should be violently shaken, deformed, or even extinguished by the ejected gas).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04584", "filename": "155c64a4f3e03bb0ddfc88d7f8c7f1a561c571f301bb21ecf610751f720879e7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the flame is still burning and has not been extinguished; the smoke produced by the flame should not suddenly increase rapidly. At 1.8s, the smoke suddenly moves downwards, indicating a downward wind; the flame should be affected by the wind and sway).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04585", "filename": "155c64a4f3e03bb0ddfc88d7f8c7f1a561c571f301bb21ecf610751f720879e7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (4s, a large amount of smoke is rapidly ejected upwards from the bottom of the flame. At this time, the changes in the flame show that the airflow is moving from top to bottom, which is contradictory).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04586", "filename": "164d0a09cdf998ea5890c6c7e61e727556b91335419663dae4f5756459eba92c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall intuition (the area illuminated by the flashlight fluctuates abnormally throughout the process, and the knees of the character bend outward abnormally while walking; at 2.6s, the character's legs appear to be tangled and twisted).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04587", "filename": "164d0a09cdf998ea5890c6c7e61e727556b91335419663dae4f5756459eba92c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the video only shows the flashlight as the light source, and each tree should only cast one shadow).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_04588", "filename": "164d0a09cdf998ea5890c6c7e61e727556b91335419663dae4f5756459eba92c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04589", "filename": "170dfeaf4b5dbabf38971a67ef2a200dddf62d2bdf4f8d7d5d60c7444791384e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (magma on a steep slope should flow downwards under the influence of gravity and the increasing pressure from the magma within the crater, and should not flow back and forth).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04590", "filename": "170dfeaf4b5dbabf38971a67ef2a200dddf62d2bdf4f8d7d5d60c7444791384e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the height of the magma level inside the crater changes continuously and drastically, and the speed at which the magma flows out of the crater should change along with the level change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04591", "filename": "170dfeaf4b5dbabf38971a67ef2a200dddf62d2bdf4f8d7d5d60c7444791384e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04592", "filename": "176b14b5e11b597096dc2e9e55f7f44480733b642d88c210be6fa8e2c80d00dc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The following are visual anomalies: (2.9s: The reflection of the rightmost arch of the two arches of the bridge suddenly disappears in the water; 3.2s: The sky, which was gradually darkening due to the sunset, suddenly brightens; The uppermost layer of clouds sways back and forth, which does not match the sense of rapid passage of time shown by the lower layer of clouds.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04593", "filename": "176b14b5e11b597096dc2e9e55f7f44480733b642d88c210be6fa8e2c80d00dc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time appears continuous (the rapid movement of clouds and vehicles should indicate that time is passing quickly, and the sun should show a clear rise or fall).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04594", "filename": "176b14b5e11b597096dc2e9e55f7f44480733b642d88c210be6fa8e2c80d00dc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the scene shows the sky gradually darkening during the sunset, and the lights in the windows of the building on the right should be randomly lit up in one or more households, with the number of lit windows increasing intermittently as the sky darkens).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04595", "filename": "180cc16709f7794290acc114cf98ab0a2fc1bff4d3d4b518e07c768bb6bad8f1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Continuous time (holding a laser paper above a bright table and making regular back-and-forth swings; the ambient light does not change during the process, so the reflection on the laser paper will change regularly with the swing angle, and the reflection on the laser paper remains consistent at the same swing angle).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04596", "filename": "180cc16709f7794290acc114cf98ab0a2fc1bff4d3d4b518e07c768bb6bad8f1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is inconsistent (1.8s the laser paper changes from a sheet to a block as it flips, 2.4s it changes back to a sheet, the timing is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04597", "filename": "180cc16709f7794290acc114cf98ab0a2fc1bff4d3d4b518e07c768bb6bad8f1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04598", "filename": "183f3f7cd1b16c0f56fa89bc22724a79314f1a51c3783973135ea6843ad179d1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (as the camera moves, nearby objects appear to be panning, while distant objects appear to be rotating to the right, which is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04599", "filename": "183f3f7cd1b16c0f56fa89bc22724a79314f1a51c3783973135ea6843ad179d1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (in reality, the position of a rainbow moves slightly as the viewpoint moves, but in the video, the camera moves very slowly while the rainbow moves very quickly, which is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04600", "filename": "183f3f7cd1b16c0f56fa89bc22724a79314f1a51c3783973135ea6843ad179d1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (near objects appear to be panning to the right, while distant objects appear to be rotating to the right, which is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04603", "filename": "194c8ee8da4f94938c81000faf163e0a9e24d9f966baa7b6909c318584b181e0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (when cutting a plastic film ball with a knife, the slicing effect produced by the film ball being cut is not synchronized with the actual cutting position).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04604", "filename": "194c8ee8da4f94938c81000faf163e0a9e24d9f966baa7b6909c318584b181e0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Overall Intuition (When the knife cuts the sphere, the surface of the sphere contracts and cracks from the cutting point to both sides, and the material exhibits the characteristics of elastic plastic in this state; however, during the period of 3.6s-5.1s, some areas of the sphere are pulled by the knife and deform as the blade moves, which shows that the material has the strong plasticity of wax. The two material characteristics are clearly contradictory.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04605", "filename": "194c8ee8da4f94938c81000faf163e0a9e24d9f966baa7b6909c318584b181e0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is continuous (the plastic cut by the knife suddenly passes through the top of the knife and reappears below it after 3.6 seconds. When the knife cuts the sphere, it is perpendicular to the sphere's surface, so the cutting effect should be a slit, not a peel).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04606", "filename": "197f92f77321a379bdda77524fbbf9587286559e67c063bbc1590f93deeb183a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (flames appear on the right side of the burning material in 0.6s. The burning material is placed on the ground and there is no heat source on the right side of the burning material, so it should not be burning out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04607", "filename": "a03347ef507a2cba84f532ff0e6fc9d1df2b326855bcd503e0735b76f53762f7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the hands and object surfaces in the video are too smooth, unlike a realistic image).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04608", "filename": "a3411e27377b225efa9c16df38671611b8038fb9871f925a473bd3d5c04d0693_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the white spherical object in the upper left corner disappears out of thin air at 0s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04609", "filename": "a3411e27377b225efa9c16df38671611b8038fb9871f925a473bd3d5c04d0693_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the five-pointed star at the top of the Christmas tree suddenly increases in size at 0.3 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04610", "filename": "a3411e27377b225efa9c16df38671611b8038fb9871f925a473bd3d5c04d0693_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04611", "filename": "a3411e27377b225efa9c16df38671611b8038fb9871f925a473bd3d5c04d0693_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the lights on the Christmas tree suddenly went out at 7:00 when there was no interference).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04612", "filename": "a4999c4883990f4b93bf2f18f30ddedfc3a8baebdb63887728b20a2ad3f38240_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Physical behavior (the water droplets in the video are shaking without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04613", "filename": "a4999c4883990f4b93bf2f18f30ddedfc3a8baebdb63887728b20a2ad3f38240_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (in the video, the water droplet absorbs water as it slides down, yet the volume of the water droplet does not change at all).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04614", "filename": "a4999c4883990f4b93bf2f18f30ddedfc3a8baebdb63887728b20a2ad3f38240_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the water droplets in the video slide too smoothly and the surface of the water droplets is too smooth, unlike a realistic scene).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04615", "filename": "a4999c4883990f4b93bf2f18f30ddedfc3a8baebdb63887728b20a2ad3f38240_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 2.2s, the water droplet in the upper left corner suddenly decreases in size, at 2.7s, the water droplet in the middle suddenly appears, at 4.7s, the water droplet on the left suddenly increases in size, and at 6.4s, the water flow at the top suddenly appears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04616", "filename": "a5486cede2f36e00bf1067b41408e8425ee17ca6c1a0cdf8adfcde2548ce0380_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time frame is continuous (the liquid volume suddenly increases between 2.4s and 4.7s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04617", "filename": "a5486cede2f36e00bf1067b41408e8425ee17ca6c1a0cdf8adfcde2548ce0380_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The time frame is continuous (the liquid volume increases from 0.6s to 5.8s, and the yellow light on the right side of the liquid in the video suddenly disappears at 5.4s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04618", "filename": "a5486cede2f36e00bf1067b41408e8425ee17ca6c1a0cdf8adfcde2548ce0380_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Physical behavior (increased appearance of liquid flowing upwards in the video footage).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04619", "filename": "a5486cede2f36e00bf1067b41408e8425ee17ca6c1a0cdf8adfcde2548ce0380_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time sequence is continuous (bubbles suddenly appear in the liquid above at 0.1s; from 0.7s to 8s, the bubbles merge, disappear, suddenly appear, and suddenly disappear again).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04620", "filename": "a6937a80e618075cbb226f8ff837e6072568b923832490a7f228b9a463d7629a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video content: Physical behavior (the movement of clouds in the entire video is irregular, with lower-level clouds moving upwards, middle-level clouds moving to the left, and upper-level clouds moving forwards).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04621", "filename": "a6937a80e618075cbb226f8ff837e6072568b923832490a7f228b9a463d7629a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is continuous (the clouds at the top of the video move faster than those at the bottom, and the changes in the clouds are too regular), and the overall visual impression is abnormal (the movement of the clouds in the video is too smooth and lacks the jerky feeling that clouds should have).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04622", "filename": "a6937a80e618075cbb226f8ff837e6072568b923832490a7f228b9a463d7629a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: continuous time (clouds move rapidly and appear and disappear throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04623", "filename": "a6937a80e618075cbb226f8ff837e6072568b923832490a7f228b9a463d7629a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 2.1 seconds, a thick white cloud suddenly appears in the upper right corner, and the clouds turn black throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04624", "filename": "a7051e49e44d487f0fb2462896ae598218c91bab1e5ea0ba40f1f4a89ab33b6e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04625", "filename": "a7051e49e44d487f0fb2462896ae598218c91bab1e5ea0ba40f1f4a89ab33b6e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The flow of water appears grainy throughout the entire video.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04626", "filename": "a7051e49e44d487f0fb2462896ae598218c91bab1e5ea0ba40f1f4a89ab33b6e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (bubbles created by water flowing down the water surface appear, disappear, or merge throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04627", "filename": "a7051e49e44d487f0fb2462896ae598218c91bab1e5ea0ba40f1f4a89ab33b6e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 4s, a water column suddenly appears out of thin air at the top of the video screen, and the bubbles generated on the surface of the water appear, disappear, and merge throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04631", "filename": "a8043f115f38d39d1cf8aa1d3e10c1e4a6a97540ced39027d73bb139b3bab251_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (the small black boat on the sea did not move with the ocean current throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04632", "filename": "a8043f115f38d39d1cf8aa1d3e10c1e4a6a97540ced39027d73bb139b3bab251_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Continuous time (the entire video footage changes from bright to dark); Causal relationship (the small black boat on the sea does not move with the ocean current throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04633", "filename": "a8043f115f38d39d1cf8aa1d3e10c1e4a6a97540ced39027d73bb139b3bab251_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the sea on the left and right sides of the screen move in opposite directions throughout the video), and the overall visual impression is abnormal (the sea moves too fast throughout the video, lacking the proper sense of pause).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04634", "filename": "a8043f115f38d39d1cf8aa1d3e10c1e4a6a97540ced39027d73bb139b3bab251_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the left side of the sea moves in the opposite direction to the right side of the video frame throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04635", "filename": "a8888e600276d178b7d25e3a16349d5527f0aa58f3bf6915ba2ac18a8858c097_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Cause and effect (the straw was stirring the liquid between 0s and 1.9s, but the tiny bubbles in the liquid did not change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04636", "filename": "a8888e600276d178b7d25e3a16349d5527f0aa58f3bf6915ba2ac18a8858c097_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Time sequence (bubbles appear granular in the liquid at 0.7s) Causal relationship (water in the cup suddenly boils without heating at 3.2s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04637", "filename": "197f92f77321a379bdda77524fbbf9587286559e67c063bbc1590f93deeb183a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (the object in the image only shows carbonization and no change in volume when it is burned; intense burning should cause shrinkage, embrittlement, and carbonization).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04638", "filename": "197f92f77321a379bdda77524fbbf9587286559e67c063bbc1590f93deeb183a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (3.6s) The cardboard box did not change in volume or shape when it was burned by the flame; the box should have shrunk and carbonized.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04639", "filename": "198c0068f9d00820dd860254a13ea441ec1a6487da24ef37fd790060230cd874_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: The time continuity (0s of direct laser light without obstruction, a sudden break appears in the middle).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04640", "filename": "198c0068f9d00820dd860254a13ea441ec1a6487da24ef37fd790060230cd874_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (2.5 seconds, five laser beams are emitted from four stage lights, and an extra laser beam appears out of nowhere.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04641", "filename": "198c0068f9d00820dd860254a13ea441ec1a6487da24ef37fd790060230cd874_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (4.9s) A row of stage lights emitting green lasers suddenly appeared out of thin air in the middle of the wall.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04642", "filename": "201e0061d39bb69eadfbe19b4841053eab15d572619f04159f4627bdd2d022f2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (the black box in the lower left corner of the video is automatically swaying left and right without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04643", "filename": "201e0061d39bb69eadfbe19b4841053eab15d572619f04159f4627bdd2d022f2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04644", "filename": "209fa41a73c149835404b7381549ccc0792a276acb69f469509df937af8ef4aa_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The time sequence is continuous (1.9s-4.8s, the tip of the wooden stick twists abnormally).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04645", "filename": "209fa41a73c149835404b7381549ccc0792a276acb69f469509df937af8ef4aa_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time sequence is not continuous (the smoke produced by the burning stick does not conform to the laws of natural physics. Normally, the smoke from a burning stick should be thin, straight, and naturally drifting upwards in wisps. However, the smoke in the image is thick and ribbon-like, without any dynamic changes in natural drifting. It only shows a static state of vertical upward movement, which contradicts the fluid diffusion characteristics of smoke in reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04646", "filename": "209fa41a73c149835404b7381549ccc0792a276acb69f469509df937af8ef4aa_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04647", "filename": "209fa41a73c149835404b7381549ccc0792a276acb69f469509df937af8ef4aa_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04648", "filename": "210e82e66e4ab8dca3d66d833c0153ef03320b16d5448c7d1b2c3515a00e4242_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a small puddle of water in the lower left corner is automatically swaying and flowing left and right without any external force.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04649", "filename": "210e82e66e4ab8dca3d66d833c0153ef03320b16d5448c7d1b2c3515a00e4242_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (1.9s). The water produced by the melting of the transparent ice should be transparent, not brown.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04650", "filename": "210e82e66e4ab8dca3d66d833c0153ef03320b16d5448c7d1b2c3515a00e4242_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The sequence of events is uninterrupted (the ice cube is swaying automatically from side to side without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04651", "filename": "210e82e66e4ab8dca3d66d833c0153ef03320b16d5448c7d1b2c3515a00e4242_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04652", "filename": "222b7649ebf1c560d71fbc25f31fa9634b57c812be40cbbf04528efb08d2817a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the teapot keeps pouring tea into the teacup, but the water level in the teacup does not rise and remains at a constant level).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04653", "filename": "222b7649ebf1c560d71fbc25f31fa9634b57c812be40cbbf04528efb08d2817a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (4s) The teapot has stopped pouring tea, and the tea at the spout has been poured out, but tea is still flowing out of the spout.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04654", "filename": "222b7649ebf1c560d71fbc25f31fa9634b57c812be40cbbf04528efb08d2817a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04655", "filename": "230e73f4c3eeedd029d25f3d86b4df9018a370572b7f698251d2d877ed6ecf05_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (3.7s-5s). When a huge wave crashes against a reef, the water should explode and splash, not slowly flow over the reef.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04656", "filename": "230e73f4c3eeedd029d25f3d86b4df9018a370572b7f698251d2d877ed6ecf05_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.6 seconds, the wave had not yet hit the reef when it struck the rock, causing a huge splash).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04657", "filename": "230e73f4c3eeedd029d25f3d86b4df9018a370572b7f698251d2d877ed6ecf05_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the waves in the distance of the video move forward in a continuous wave crest pattern, without the rolling of the waves or the splashing of water as the waves hit the surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04658", "filename": "230e73f4c3eeedd029d25f3d86b4df9018a370572b7f698251d2d877ed6ecf05_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (the deep blue sea suddenly turns turquoise at 3.5s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04659", "filename": "234f7bb2b32dbfe1fdcba4c2c9314caf063d587318b67d77d7586119bee597bd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (3.1s later, an extra carriage appears out of nowhere after the green toy train).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04660", "filename": "234f7bb2b32dbfe1fdcba4c2c9314caf063d587318b67d77d7586119bee597bd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04661", "filename": "242c5bb8c3af7b0558f424624f69260747f9a55b2f3f4448abc10dc1f83c36e0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0.9s) A violent explosion occurs at the center of the pumpkin-shaped object, but the position and shape of the pumpkin-shaped object remain unchanged.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04662", "filename": "242c5bb8c3af7b0558f424624f69260747f9a55b2f3f4448abc10dc1f83c36e0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (5.6s) The remains of the pumpkin-shaped object, blown away by the explosion, vanish into thin air without any external interference.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04663", "filename": "242c5bb8c3af7b0558f424624f69260747f9a55b2f3f4448abc10dc1f83c36e0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (an explosion occurs at the center of a pumpkin-shaped object, scattering sand and gravel across the ground, but the object's position and shape remain unchanged.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04664", "filename": "242c5bb8c3af7b0558f424624f69260747f9a55b2f3f4448abc10dc1f83c36e0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04665", "filename": "256a669c812771c395cfd88ed550abffa2cf605225a8cf3ed1e7885ffa285167_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the visuals: The time sequence is continuous (a small puddle is being heated by an object resembling an induction cooker, and a large number of bubbles are forming and churning on the surface. The water should evaporate when heated, and the puddle should decrease in size instead of remaining constant.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04666", "filename": "256a669c812771c395cfd88ed550abffa2cf605225a8cf3ed1e7885ffa285167_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (When a small body of water is heated, a large number of bubbles are generated and churning on the surface. The volume of the water decreases due to evaporation, rather than increasing.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04667", "filename": "a8888e600276d178b7d25e3a16349d5527f0aa58f3bf6915ba2ac18a8858c097_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (2.9s, a large-scale, high-intensity vortex suddenly appears in the water in the cup while the frequency of stirring the straw by hand remains unchanged, which does not conform to the law of conservation of energy).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04670", "filename": "a9979f0cb50e01fe6bbbceeace0410a1a5ed49396b724a1859d927b0f2355263_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (4.6s, the vehicle will show no structural damage, deformation, or burn marks after being subjected to a violent explosion at close range. This is completely consistent with its initial state before the explosion.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04671", "filename": "a9979f0cb50e01fe6bbbceeace0410a1a5ed49396b724a1859d927b0f2355263_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (After the vehicle exploded violently at 4.8 seconds, the surrounding weeds did not show any fluctuation or collapse due to the shock wave).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04672", "filename": "a9979f0cb50e01fe6bbbceeace0410a1a5ed49396b724a1859d927b0f2355263_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical anomaly (1,19s: The debris from the vehicle explosion lacks the reflectivity and texture of metallic parts; it consists entirely of dark, mud-like fragments).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04673", "filename": "a29431a81fe1135b6d83806d10fa7fedf244557cc68a1d1e8233e35ac9357d40_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Abnormal physical behavior (starting from 0 seconds into the video, the flames maintain a symmetrical burning pattern with left and right mirror images throughout, without any random or irregular jumping patterns).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04674", "filename": "a29431a81fe1135b6d83806d10fa7fedf244557cc68a1d1e8233e35ac9357d40_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: The physical behavior is abnormal (starting from 0 seconds into the video, the flames always exhibit a symmetrical burning pattern with the center of the screen as the axis).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04675", "filename": "a29431a81fe1135b6d83806d10fa7fedf244557cc68a1d1e8233e35ac9357d40_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04676", "filename": "a29431a81fe1135b6d83806d10fa7fedf244557cc68a1d1e8233e35ac9357d40_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (at 0.3s, the flame color jumps abruptly from a reddish hue to a yellowish hue).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04677", "filename": "a75443bf2a7c19d95e0bf897dce8a08b5d3148ecfdc85b3af63278c3be86f8aa_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical anomaly (At 1.3s, a pill falls into a glass containing two pills. However, in subsequent shots, the number of pills in the glass remains at two, and the number of pills does not increase due to the addition of the new pill.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04678", "filename": "a75443bf2a7c19d95e0bf897dce8a08b5d3148ecfdc85b3af63278c3be86f8aa_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04679", "filename": "a75443bf2a7c19d95e0bf897dce8a08b5d3148ecfdc85b3af63278c3be86f8aa_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (at 5.5s, the tablet reacts violently with water, producing a large number of bubbles and smoke. However, from the beginning of the video to this point, the volume and shape of the photograph have not changed at all, showing no dissolution or reduction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04680", "filename": "a128395dd88951d2152ba7247401fc9ee84544493503bb56b3152564e330b2fd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity error (At 2 seconds into the video, the flame suddenly brightens in a large area without any transition. Furthermore, there is no visible movement of the air beneath the flame, which is unusual when food is burning).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04681", "filename": "a128395dd88951d2152ba7247401fc9ee84544493503bb56b3152564e330b2fd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04682", "filename": "a128395dd88951d2152ba7247401fc9ee84544493503bb56b3152564e330b2fd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (at 1.2s, the cup-shaped container wall that was originally present on the left side of the candle suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04693", "filename": "aa0b44f838c76f67c6e1f5c4fbec96e036c260afcbc92971bdbd183a99541cec_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 0s, there is no syringe on the ground. At 0.1s, a syringe suddenly appears on the ground).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04694", "filename": "aa0b44f838c76f67c6e1f5c4fbec96e036c260afcbc92971bdbd183a99541cec_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (1.3s - end: The white-glowing lamp inside the previously stationary syringe suddenly moves a short distance towards the needle without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04695", "filename": "aa0b44f838c76f67c6e1f5c4fbec96e036c260afcbc92971bdbd183a99541cec_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 0.3s, a syringe with a needle appears on the screen on the ground).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04696", "filename": "aa5bc75e97260521693b0520ca50f6e178c6e43bf82bcffa484af22c905e3772_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04697", "filename": "P01_109_165_0326944abcac026c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: causal relationship (the right hand that was holding a towel in the video at 0.7s is not holding a towel at 2.7s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04698", "filename": "P01_109_203_bfefc4dbbca6065b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (the object in the left hand disappears in the video at 0.8s, and the object in the box flickers and wriggles at 3.5s); Physical behavior (the lid moves to the right without any external force even though the hand did not touch it at 3.2s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04699", "filename": "P01_109_425_e2ddc881aa635e8c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Continuous timing (no transition from one frame to the next at 1.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04700", "filename": "P01_109_531_bda8b5d04c85a185_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (at 1.3s, the object next to the spatula in the video pot disappears out of thin air; at 3.2s, the object in the video pot reappears out of thin air, and the object in the video pot flickers).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04701", "filename": "P01_109_685_c0cfbecd7d53578b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04702", "filename": "P01_109_783_c9d7a897f1828a56_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 3.7s, combined with the shadow in the upper right corner, it can be determined that the object originally connected to the character's head broke. The broken object did not fall due to gravity, but floated in the air and swayed synchronously with the head's movements.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04703", "filename": "P01_109_894_80006ed195f217d2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (at 5.5 seconds, a finger from the left hand is severed and remains on the right hand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04704", "filename": "P02_101_70_798a80cef8946580_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (at 0.5s, the spread on the top of the bread slice in the video does not disappear out of thin air; at 4.4s, some of the spread on the bread slice appears out of thin air; the desktop screen in the video flickers).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04705", "filename": "P02_102_77_c73b0d8a649c1bc4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (at 1.5s, the liquid poured into the container in the middle of the video disappears out of thin air; at 3.1s, the bottle cap in the hand in the video deforms; and the desktop screen in the video flickers).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04706", "filename": "P02_104_83_5b95e253501eec35_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Continuous time (water flows into a container but the water level in the container does not change, and the desktop screen on the left side of the video flickers).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04707", "filename": "P02_104_111_ff2113d2018334c8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the screen on the desktop flickers in the video); Causality (the surface of the meat slices in the hot oil shows no change).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04708", "filename": "P02_104_124_34d3bb60f5ef7fcd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the lower half of the video shows flickering and wriggling).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04709", "filename": "P02_105_68_6dd450c698ad8b36_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is continuous (at 3.6s, a bubble appears out of thin air at the handle connection point in the video, and the desktop screen flickers).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04710", "filename": "P02_105_85_a184128bbf06f580_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.8s, the curved object held in the left hand in the video becomes a straight cylinder, and at 6.5s, the object in the right hand appears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04711", "filename": "P02_105_178_a199dc8af81930a6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Physical behavior (at 5.4s, the plastic bag between the hands in the video is suspended without any support and shows no free fall motion) Time continuity (the desktop screen in the video flickers).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04712", "filename": "P02_107_31_c6e03c2415bf383d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04713", "filename": "P02_108_447_6b7ebbc070e4e336_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Continuous timing (the desktop screen flickers in the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04714", "filename": "P02_109_11_ebeea9587724c17c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_04715", "filename": "P02_109_151_0ed950841e20cbb7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (the entire video image flickers)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04716", "filename": "P02_112_82_3b31bfed099ad502_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Continuous time (the desktop screen in the video shows flickering and wriggling).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04717", "filename": "P02_112_259_ac9d40cb6699550d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_04718", "filename": "P02_112_287_d75a65a1fb4aea48_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous timing (the entire video image flickers).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04719", "filename": "P02_113_85_2b8374b0951930c2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (at 2.9s, a gap suddenly appears in the glove and a finger pierces through the gap; at 3s, a ring appears out of thin air on the left ring finger; at 4.8s, an extra finger sleeve appears out of thin air on the glove).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04720", "filename": "P02_113_183_46c9d5ab54892174_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The video exhibits continuous motion (flickering on the desktop); the overall movement is abnormal (the hand movements in the video are too stiff).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04721", "filename": "P02_118_33_8466fd97f10fc4d7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The video flickers throughout (the entire video frame flickers).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04722", "filename": "P02_118_59_87761b1f2e19020d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 7.8s, the shape of the rectangular object on the left side of the video abruptly changes to a square object).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04723", "filename": "P02_118_128_a84ea3834b0c8733_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (the right-hand glove in the video deforms at 2.2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04724", "filename": "P02_120_187_9043e21d84129864_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 0.7s, liquid appears out of thin air in the upper right corner of the rotating container).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04725", "filename": "P02_121_2_4d0ab7ec9b9385a3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The time sequence is continuous (0.5s video, paper penetrates the edge of the cardboard box and is pulled out from below).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04726", "filename": "P02_121_11_bf59d17382c3b41d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 5.1s, a layer of paper appears out of thin air below the paper on the right side of the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04727", "filename": "7c07d7db8e379a74691962fdcaf4b5288a2e31f85290b0e58da9e217992a3b3f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (in the video, when the bubbles burst at 1.9 seconds, the champagne glass becomes a wine glass).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04728", "filename": "7c8413db7f41b79599b5ec1cf28722b2d171b5a54ae40c8142ef0fe1989a6c23_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04729", "filename": "7c8413db7f41b79599b5ec1cf28722b2d171b5a54ae40c8142ef0fe1989a6c23_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04730", "filename": "7c8413db7f41b79599b5ec1cf28722b2d171b5a54ae40c8142ef0fe1989a6c23_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04731", "filename": "7c8413db7f41b79599b5ec1cf28722b2d171b5a54ae40c8142ef0fe1989a6c23_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (the stone in the image is initially smooth, but at 1.8 seconds, when the right hand joins in and begins to rotate, the stone's surface becomes rough).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04732", "filename": "7cc166e90a996630dcfdb632e6813f5bf12f73a90da18b8f616e9c7d771a5cee_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04733", "filename": "7cc166e90a996630dcfdb632e6813f5bf12f73a90da18b8f616e9c7d771a5cee_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04734", "filename": "7cc166e90a996630dcfdb632e6813f5bf12f73a90da18b8f616e9c7d771a5cee_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04735", "filename": "7cd96662ce0e73249ebe419773d5f39d8442f28ebf644c7ee7b518474022332c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (the bubbles in the pot appear unnaturally and do not rise to the surface).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04736", "filename": "7cd96662ce0e73249ebe419773d5f39d8442f28ebf644c7ee7b518474022332c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: physical behavior (the bubbles generated by the water in the pot about to boil are concentrated in the center of the pot, while the bubbles around the pot wall are not obvious, and all the bubbles are shaking in a regular manner but none of them rise, which does not conform to the physical laws of water boiling).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04737", "filename": "7cd96662ce0e73249ebe419773d5f39d8442f28ebf644c7ee7b518474022332c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04738", "filename": "7cd96662ce0e73249ebe419773d5f39d8442f28ebf644c7ee7b518474022332c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Duration (the water in the pot suddenly starts boiling at 2.3 seconds in the video) Physical behavior (no steam is produced when the water boils in the video, which does not conform to the physical laws of water boiling).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04739", "filename": "7cfc5c4b2a11735ca6a3ad90e20ee697cc4bc549cd7a57e4c691138c09c83d3a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal for a period of time (the video gradually brightens from 0s to 2s, darkens from 2s to 4.2s, and brightens again from 4.2s to the end).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04740", "filename": "7cfc5c4b2a11735ca6a3ad90e20ee697cc4bc549cd7a57e4c691138c09c83d3a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the river in the lower left corner doesn't flow like real water, lacking ripples on the surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04741", "filename": "7cfc5c4b2a11735ca6a3ad90e20ee697cc4bc549cd7a57e4c691138c09c83d3a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Duration: (Vehicles in the lane in the video will suddenly disappear and then suddenly reappear)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04742", "filename": "7cfc5c4b2a11735ca6a3ad90e20ee697cc4bc549cd7a57e4c691138c09c83d3a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04743", "filename": "7d013d2b4f598ba1549f8083ffae89c9c73e676779dc3e1386ceb4c68f2ac147_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (in the same environment, only a small part of the lake near the shore shows ripples, while the rest does not).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04744", "filename": "7d013d2b4f598ba1549f8083ffae89c9c73e676779dc3e1386ceb4c68f2ac147_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the lake surface in the scene does not show the ripples of real water flow; at 5.1 seconds, ripples suddenly appear on the lake surface and then quickly disappear).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04746", "filename": "7d013d2b4f598ba1549f8083ffae89c9c73e676779dc3e1386ceb4c68f2ac147_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (ripples appear on the water surface at 3.5s, but the reflection of the tree on the water does not change, violating the law of reflection of light).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04747", "filename": "7d22ef56254ba99efc2730341b473942fcf6e3d4dfc56e18b01daa665cfbdaae_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the flame burning effect is too smooth, lacking the dynamic layering and irregular burning state of a real flame, resulting in distorted visual texture).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04748", "filename": "7d22ef56254ba99efc2730341b473942fcf6e3d4dfc56e18b01daa665cfbdaae_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04749", "filename": "7d73b8846bbd84a8d43b5fef96d3471a4d7ba79580a7c3e76f3866a1df2914bc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall impression (starting at 0.8s, the sky appears to be layered, the edges of objects at the bottom of the screen are blurred and the transitions are unnatural, and there is a noticeable splicing effect at the junction with the sky).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04750", "filename": "7d6709776d93d1db8511a2239ebad72ff289261e1ee16b3c29524c704e842992_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Physical Behavior (A normal lighter flame has a gradient from blue at the bottom to yellow at the top. However, the flame in the image is clearly divided into two sections: one is the lighter's own blue flame, and the other is a yellow flame that appears out of nowhere above, with no natural transition between the two; the ignited red object in the image does not exhibit the proper combustion characteristics of combustible materials (such as turning red, carbonizing, or smoking), but only has a \"suspended\" spark at the point of contact with the flame, which does not conform to the physical laws of combustion; the range and brightness of the lighter flame's illumination, and the transition between light and shadow in the surrounding environment, are not natural.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04751", "filename": "7d6709776d93d1db8511a2239ebad72ff289261e1ee16b3c29524c704e842992_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to physical behavior (the burning part of the stick passed through the lighter in 4.5 seconds, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04752", "filename": "7d6709776d93d1db8511a2239ebad72ff289261e1ee16b3c29524c704e842992_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04753", "filename": "7d6709776d93d1db8511a2239ebad72ff289261e1ee16b3c29524c704e842992_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04754", "filename": "7dc55acf9d236090fcf59e9492fa80cec7c5a4ea422028e04902b3b1547f3556_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: Physical Behavior (The sun is located at the bottom center of the image; its light should bathe the lower part of the clouds near the horizon in a warm yellow hue, while the higher clouds should appear in darker shadows. However, in this image, the high-altitude clouds are also evenly illuminated, and the color transition does not conform to natural lighting patterns.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04755", "filename": "7dc55acf9d236090fcf59e9492fa80cec7c5a4ea422028e04902b3b1547f3556_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: Physical Behavior (The sun is located at the bottom center of the image. A normal lens flare should radiate outwards from the center of the sun, especially a vertical flare that passes through the sun itself. However, in the image, a halo appears that is completely separated from the sun and extends diagonally. It neither connects to the sun nor conforms to the natural formation of a lens flare.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_04756", "filename": "7dc55acf9d236090fcf59e9492fa80cec7c5a4ea422028e04902b3b1547f3556_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04757", "filename": "P04_109_304_2de7337a5c985ecd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04758", "filename": "P04_109_304_2de7337a5c985ecd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (when the hand touches the cup at 3s, a handle suddenly appears out of thin air on the cup).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04759", "filename": "P04_109_312_b96e0912ddf0ea37_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Timing continuity (a gap suddenly appears in the plastic wrap at 0.2 seconds before the hand even touches it; the plastic wrap in the upper left and lower right corners of the cauliflower suddenly disappears between 0.18 and 5.1 seconds). Overall visual anomalies (the broccoli in the video lacks the natural granular, uneven floret structure of broccoli; its surface is very smooth and uniform, resembling kneaded dough or clay).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04760", "filename": "P04_109_395_79e7cb2657a9191d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual presentation is off (in the everyday storage scenario of a refrigerator, all items should be ordinary food or containers without self-illuminating capabilities. The constantly glowing food container in the video appears particularly jarring).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04761", "filename": "P04_109_395_79e7cb2657a9191d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall intuition is abnormal (the finger was not pulled back at the moment it was pressed at 3.2 seconds, which is not like a real scene and lacks the instinctive reaction that a real person should have).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_04762", "filename": "P04_109_395_79e7cb2657a9191d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (0.1s-2s: the refrigerator is open but the light is off; in reality, the internal light automatically turns on when the refrigerator door is opened; 1.8s: the white sealing strip on the refrigerator suddenly disappears, and a black sealing strip suddenly appears at 4s; at 5.7s: the light suddenly dims automatically).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04763", "filename": "P04_109_438_cfa2648f37faee78_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (0.4s) A black condiment bottle suddenly appears below the handle of a pot in the sink and is taken out through the handle, which violates the principle that solids are impermeable.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04764", "filename": "P04_109_438_cfa2648f37faee78_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_04765", "filename": "P04_109_438_cfa2648f37faee78_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical phenomena (5.7s-6.8s: the dishwasher drawer and the glass on the countertop in the lower left corner slide on their own without any external force; 7.7s: the person's finger in the video passes through the cabinet door, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04766", "filename": "P04_110_109_273fcf24cf795b96_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (2.8s-5s, the right hand passes through the pot lid, violating the principle that solids are impermeable) and temporal continuity (1.6s, the lid handle in the hand suddenly changes from left to right).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04767", "filename": "P04_110_109_273fcf24cf795b96_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (the water droplets on the lid suddenly disappeared from the air between 1.4s and 4.4s; between 1.2s and 8s, when the steamer is in normal use, the high-temperature steam inside the pot will liquefy and form water droplets on the pot wall/inside the lid when it cools down, but there are no water droplets inside the steamer in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04768", "filename": "P04_110_200_7636b51b1aaa41e3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: Time continuity error (0.8s) The white button indicator on the induction cooker control suddenly turns into two red numbers 0.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04769", "filename": "P04_113_2_938d875a4eca20b1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (2.5s-3s: The towel hanging on the oven handle did not hang down as the oven door opened downwards. Normally, the towel should hang down under the influence of gravity.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04770", "filename": "P04_113_2_938d875a4eca20b1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Physical behavior (the oven door was opened without the hand touching it for 0.5 seconds) and continuous time (the black and white marble on the countertop was abnormally distorted throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04771", "filename": "P04_113_47_3f60158ce48b90ee_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04772", "filename": "P04_113_47_3f60158ce48b90ee_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the silver fork on the cutting board suddenly disappears into thin air at 0.1s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04773", "filename": "P04_113_96_a955d2810849126e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is discontinuous (the pattern on the blue and white plates in the lower right corner of the cupboard appears abnormally distorted throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04774", "filename": "P04_113_96_a955d2810849126e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the white bowl suddenly disappears from the screen at 2.7s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04775", "filename": "P04_113_169_a288a06243c7df55_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The overall impression is off: the way the figure in the picture picks up the sauce with their hand is too smooth, unlike a realistic scene, lacking the cadence and rhythm that should be present in reality.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04776", "filename": "P04_113_179_99eee426a7e49cdd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Physical behavior (the water in the pot spontaneously bursts open within 3.8s-5s without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04777", "filename": "P04_113_179_99eee426a7e49cdd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (the black object on the socket suddenly disappears into thin air in 2.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04778", "filename": "P04_113_216_b934a4c7704bb53f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the visuals: Time continuity (0.9s: the large black plate in the sink suddenly disappears; 0.8s: the spoon in the sink disappears out of thin air; 2.9s: a black dot suddenly appears on the pink spoon; 5.3s: the two spoons in the hand merge into one and shrink between 5.9s and 8s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04779", "filename": "P04_113_224_a38fafa2d2d339a9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the marble in the entire video frame is abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04780", "filename": "P04_113_224_a38fafa2d2d339a9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (1.9s-3.5s: A silver cabinet door suddenly appears and is moved and installed onto another cabinet that already has a door).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04781", "filename": "P04_113_356_9fd6526f7ce70bf1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (2.1s-3.2s: finger passes through spoon and rag, violating the principle that solids are impermeable). Temporal continuity: (3.3s: right foot toes suddenly disappear into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04782", "filename": "P04_113_356_9fd6526f7ce70bf1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the black and white marble on the tabletop appears abnormally distorted). Overall visual anomalies: The action of a person wiping a spoon with a towel in the scene is too smooth and doesn't resemble a realistic scene, lacking the cadence that should be present in reality.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04783", "filename": "P04_113_356_9fd6526f7ce70bf1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the spoon in the hand suddenly grows larger between 2.9s and 3.6s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04784", "filename": "P04_113_407_99e898d45f6c866d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_04785", "filename": "P04_113_407_99e898d45f6c866d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (after 5.3 seconds of hand-flipping the knife, the shape of the knife changes from both sides being blades to one side being a blade and the other side being a back blade).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04786", "filename": "P04_113_433_edb06f70cfad8838_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (2s: the yellow sponge cube suddenly disappears out of thin air; 3.3s: the brush dipped in water from the pool suddenly sweeps out of thin air, producing a large number of yellow particles).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04787", "filename": "2aef961e242b33653290b624dd0c879c8b880f23653310fdc7e7d9f0b9331a4b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04788", "filename": "2aef961e242b33653290b624dd0c879c8b880f23653310fdc7e7d9f0b9331a4b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the image of flowing water is full of afterimages and double images, unlike a realistic scene).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04789", "filename": "2aef961e242b33653290b624dd0c879c8b880f23653310fdc7e7d9f0b9331a4b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04790", "filename": "2aef961e242b33653290b624dd0c879c8b880f23653310fdc7e7d9f0b9331a4b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04791", "filename": "2b2ab8e048d46836a37eeac7a6c0e6f6287fdfdc9948029425dcc89a78f45a7e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: (4s-4.5s The hemispherical spoon changes to a cylindrical shape.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04792", "filename": "2b2ab8e048d46836a37eeac7a6c0e6f6287fdfdc9948029425dcc89a78f45a7e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: (From 2.1s to 4.5s, the sand pile did not deform when it was pressed down hard with a spoon.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04793", "filename": "2b2ab8e048d46836a37eeac7a6c0e6f6287fdfdc9948029425dcc89a78f45a7e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04794", "filename": "2b2cb5179a52f6549b3bccd433c14f748c288163fd01166200b30a043bc9e230_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04795", "filename": "2b2cb5179a52f6549b3bccd433c14f748c288163fd01166200b30a043bc9e230_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04796", "filename": "2b2cb5179a52f6549b3bccd433c14f748c288163fd01166200b30a043bc9e230_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04797", "filename": "2b2cb5179a52f6549b3bccd433c14f748c288163fd01166200b30a043bc9e230_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04798", "filename": "2b4c88c81484dc0499d788d9251a6d8cda02d77c8b245afe7a4f1af1b145a0fe_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly has occurred: (The water surface at the bottom of the video is exhibiting flickering and wriggling motions.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04799", "filename": "2b4c88c81484dc0499d788d9251a6d8cda02d77c8b245afe7a4f1af1b145a0fe_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: (At 0.9s, the leaves on the lakeside are affected by the violent explosion of the lake water, but the leaves remain still; the leaves should shake due to the impact.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04800", "filename": "2b4c88c81484dc0499d788d9251a6d8cda02d77c8b245afe7a4f1af1b145a0fe_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual intuition is off: (The explosion on the water surface at 2.8 seconds produces a huge mushroom cloud. The edges of the mushroom cloud are too smooth, and the smoke during its formation is too fluid, lacking the varied textures of realistic smoke.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04801", "filename": "2b58e2aabf3a4221f14f32ac857e2a5c36b04243fa01d63e6598cd934910058f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the entire video clip shows flickering exposure).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04802", "filename": "2b58e2aabf3a4221f14f32ac857e2a5c36b04243fa01d63e6598cd934910058f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly in the footage: (From 2.9s to 4.6s, the wheat ears are violently shaking when blown by the wind, but their shadows remain stationary.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04803", "filename": "2b58e2aabf3a4221f14f32ac857e2a5c36b04243fa01d63e6598cd934910058f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: (Sunlight shines through the wheat ears throughout the entire video, but the wheat ears are opaque.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04804", "filename": "2b58e2aabf3a4221f14f32ac857e2a5c36b04243fa01d63e6598cd934910058f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04805", "filename": "2b164b6caaca33b49114de313c265859e5be85f7f1de170031f93d783df5d665_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04806", "filename": "2b164b6caaca33b49114de313c265859e5be85f7f1de170031f93d783df5d665_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The duration of the firecracker, which was placed in place, suddenly increases from 0.7s to 4s.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04807", "filename": "2b164b6caaca33b49114de313c265859e5be85f7f1de170031f93d783df5d665_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: (The firecracker should have started exploding from the fuse at 2.1 seconds, and the explosion effect should have been like a balloon bursting, not like a fireworks display.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04808", "filename": "2b164b6caaca33b49114de313c265859e5be85f7f1de170031f93d783df5d665_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: (From 0.2s to 3.4s, after the firecracker fuse is lit, the firecracker should explode, instead of a large amount of smoke bursting out from the fuse.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04809", "filename": "2b2498eeff47af2f5707f37fc7d2eb08d263fbc2036ee12c48eabf524e059be9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is distorted: (The trees on the right side of the video are shaking violently, indicating strong winds, while the trees on the left side remain still.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04810", "filename": "2b2498eeff47af2f5707f37fc7d2eb08d263fbc2036ee12c48eabf524e059be9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: (The source of the stream is flowing rapidly, but the lower part of the stream is still.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04811", "filename": "2b2498eeff47af2f5707f37fc7d2eb08d263fbc2036ee12c48eabf524e059be9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is distorted: (The trees in the lower left corner of the video are swaying, indicating wind, while the trees closer to the camera are stationary.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04812", "filename": "2b2629dc2f64939c10b37026f218cc67bfe6fb3ea348216ca182ac72c10314c8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: (The popsicle, which had melted by 0.8s to 1.8s, suddenly returned to its original state.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04813", "filename": "2b2629dc2f64939c10b37026f218cc67bfe6fb3ea348216ca182ac72c10314c8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the melted liquid around the popsicle gradually increases, but the popsicle's volume remains unchanged.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04814", "filename": "2b2629dc2f64939c10b37026f218cc67bfe6fb3ea348216ca182ac72c10314c8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (an ice pop that was stationary in the dish for 3.9 seconds suddenly flew into the air without any external force.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04815", "filename": "2b2338239f73491643af1c24503436ba9f1c6ca3704227561622e043a60fae18_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04816", "filename": "2b2338239f73491643af1c24503436ba9f1c6ca3704227561622e043a60fae18_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04817", "filename": "b9800476e05034a291ba2ca0fe26ff8dc7320aed87475b35710b17242568c8c3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (0.4s-4.7s: the ice in the left cup suddenly changes from full to three large ice cubes within 0-1 seconds, with the melting process missing; 5.8s-7.6s: a section of ice in the right cup abruptly disappears within 2-3 seconds, appearing abrupt and resulting in frame skipping); Physical behavior (2.3s-7.6s: the ice cubes in both cups rotate automatically without any force, violating the law of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04818", "filename": "b51321216bddc1c1dd94d5b6a54d321bb12e5cde999664153bc08de9f7eeee79_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (from 1.4s to 4.5s, the object on the left side of the screen appears to be shaking and softening, which is inconsistent with the characteristics of a solid; the sunlight beams passing through the tree trunk and shooting out out of thin air throughout the video violates the principle that light travels in straight lines).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04819", "filename": "b51321216bddc1c1dd94d5b6a54d321bb12e5cde999664153bc08de9f7eeee79_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (the sunlight beams passing through the tree trunk and shooting out out of thin air throughout the video violates the principle that light travels in straight lines; the transition between light and dark in the area directly under the sun from 2.2s to 5.9s is unnatural and does not conform to the physical characteristics of exposure under strong light)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04820", "filename": "b51321216bddc1c1dd94d5b6a54d321bb12e5cde999664153bc08de9f7eeee79_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical behavior (1.5s-5s: the sunlight beam passing through the tree trunk and shooting out into the air violates the principle that light travels in straight lines)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04821", "filename": "b51321216bddc1c1dd94d5b6a54d321bb12e5cde999664153bc08de9f7eeee79_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04822", "filename": "b72652830b8271bb797c71b9a62bffafdd78d1b614435a16b81102716bcc9d0a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: Physical behavior (1.2s-5.7s) The brightness of the metal reflection is inconsistent. The metal ball reflects the cool ambient light, but the gold square on the base and the background are warm-toned. The colors are somewhat disjointed, which violates the laws of light propagation and projection. The transition between light and dark on the metal parts is unnatural, which violates the light and shadow transition logic of the glossy material.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04823", "filename": "b72652830b8271bb797c71b9a62bffafdd78d1b614435a16b81102716bcc9d0a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (0.9s-2.4s: inconsistent brightness changes in the reflective properties of metal parts during object rotation; noticeable abrupt changes in the gloss of the right-side metal rod, suddenly darkening from its original bright silver color, with an unnatural transition that violates the light and shadow transition logic of specular materials); Temporal continuity (4.4s-5.8s: sudden appearance of bright light on the metal sphere).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04824", "filename": "b72652830b8271bb797c71b9a62bffafdd78d1b614435a16b81102716bcc9d0a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Physical behavior (the metal block rotates suddenly between 2.7s and 4.8s, while the intensity of the reflected light from other spherical metal objects does not change, violating the light and shadow transition logic of specular materials).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04825", "filename": "ba8f5230931c4eec3b2bf4da1fc44e46f4aea2217bd0bf3bf7d8bd859644b50b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the flames in the entire video are uniform in shape, burn without smoke, and there are no char marks on the objects during combustion, which violates the laws of conduction and oxidation reactions in combustion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04826", "filename": "ba8f5230931c4eec3b2bf4da1fc44e46f4aea2217bd0bf3bf7d8bd859644b50b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (0.1s-3s: the flame shape is regular and uniform, burning without smoke; the object has no scorch marks during combustion, violating the laws of conduction and oxidation reactions; 0.7s-2.2s: the flame is bright, but the surrounding light is dim, violating the principle of light refraction); Continuous time (3.1s-5.1s: the flame suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04827", "filename": "ba8f5230931c4eec3b2bf4da1fc44e46f4aea2217bd0bf3bf7d8bd859644b50b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the flame is the main subject in the image from 1.3s to 3.2s, but the background and the edge of the flame are blended together without being blurred, resulting in the visual focus not being prominent enough).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04828", "filename": "ba8f5230931c4eec3b2bf4da1fc44e46f4aea2217bd0bf3bf7d8bd859644b50b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04829", "filename": "ba21d82546c53a1357c1fd0bea02c775e4ab1297d7d8039b1caf7545396bde98_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (0.2s-1.3s). After the tree on the right falls down, it suddenly disappears, and after the barrel breaks, it suddenly breaks a second time.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04830", "filename": "ba21d82546c53a1357c1fd0bea02c775e4ab1297d7d8039b1caf7545396bde98_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (within 0.7s-0.9s, the black car reverses on its own without any force applied).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04831", "filename": "ba21d82546c53a1357c1fd0bea02c775e4ab1297d7d8039b1caf7545396bde98_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 4.2s, after three explosions, neither of the two vehicles nor the surrounding oil drums were damaged, and the white car's headlights were still on).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04835", "filename": "ba61cc59c8b71d04ca0208946e6b880ed3982a240c5244ee7b48a790526ec69a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: physical phenomena (the stick in the person's hand shortens from 3.5s to 4.3s); continuous time (the bubble on the right suddenly disappears from 6.6s to 7.7s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04836", "filename": "bb4db348c25de1db9a421e93d5862d2e0b62862076640692d203dc5f969ff851_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Physical behavior (between 1.1s and 5s, the brightness of the rain streaks in the footage blends with the bright parts of the background clouds, lacking the sense of depth that comes from sunlight penetrating the rain, and the raindrops fall too regularly, lacking randomness, and the raindrops do not splash up the fine sand or water vapor that is characteristic of the desert when they hit the ground).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04837", "filename": "bb4db348c25de1db9a421e93d5862d2e0b62862076640692d203dc5f969ff851_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior (1.5s-4.2s: the desert and cacti are blurred, and there is no difference in layering with the sharp sand in the foreground, making the sense of space seem very flat. The sky is full of heavy dark clouds, but the ground and cacti are shrouded in a layer of warm soft light. The color tone and lighting are disconnected, making it look like two images were hard-composited.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04841", "filename": "bbe4c4262fe9662234069c3f123a8c2962fabddaec66cfd63960dbc2705190bc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (1.8s-4.9s: The texture of the foreground water surface and the background waterfall are out of sync. The water surface has too strong a grainy texture, like mud rather than flowing water. Also, the waterfall does not create corresponding splashes and ripples on the water surface when it rushes down. It looks like two static images are spliced together.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04842", "filename": "bbe4c4262fe9662234069c3f123a8c2962fabddaec66cfd63960dbc2705190bc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (0.1s-4.4s) After the waterfall rushes down, it does not form natural spreading ripples on the water surface, and the light and shadow of the water flow are also very flat, lacking a sense of flowing layers.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04843", "filename": "bbe4c4262fe9662234069c3f123a8c2962fabddaec66cfd63960dbc2705190bc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (1.5s-4.7s: The interaction between water flow and smoke is unnatural; the smoke does not have the effect of being dispersed or deformed by the water flow when passing through the waterfall).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04844", "filename": "bbe4c4262fe9662234069c3f123a8c2962fabddaec66cfd63960dbc2705190bc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04845", "filename": "bbeff6b7ffba4806ad956ad01e60b35c6e7bf8cb64cd45061a2149a5402362e8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (0.2s-4.6s: no fluid diffusion of extinguishing agent and dynamic blurring, violating the motion law of water jet; flame shape remains unchanged throughout the video, violating the principles of combustion and fire extinguishing).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04846", "filename": "bbeff6b7ffba4806ad956ad01e60b35c6e7bf8cb64cd45061a2149a5402362e8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time interval is continuous (the water volume in the basin suddenly increases in 4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04847", "filename": "d511a9623f0eb36c5a4d068786ea93d0e5ba87602783c9482ca73348c84705ec_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04848", "filename": "d511a9623f0eb36c5a4d068786ea93d0e5ba87602783c9482ca73348c84705ec_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.2s, the teapot in the person's hand suddenly turns into a kettle, and at 6.3s, the kettle produces smoke out of thin air and it dissipates).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04853", "filename": "d599dd9d324f4970c452f0499baf0dd1e63dd0184ea952316c0f73b9f2e7bb41_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the smoke's movement and range of motion are too regular throughout the video, lacking a natural sense of randomness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04854", "filename": "d599dd9d324f4970c452f0499baf0dd1e63dd0184ea952316c0f73b9f2e7bb41_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04855", "filename": "d599dd9d324f4970c452f0499baf0dd1e63dd0184ea952316c0f73b9f2e7bb41_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 2.3s in the video, without any external interference, the smoke gains potential energy out of thin air and moves upwards; at 3.4s, smoke appears out of thin air in the lower left corner of the screen).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04856", "filename": "d599dd9d324f4970c452f0499baf0dd1e63dd0184ea952316c0f73b9f2e7bb41_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 7s in the video, the smoke from the exhaust suddenly stops without any change in the camera angle, and then disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04857", "filename": "d661d255b5726c4803988bc44cd65c813e94ba3b794fc5dd882b2b01ea8d08f2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (flickering artifacts appear throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04858", "filename": "d661d255b5726c4803988bc44cd65c813e94ba3b794fc5dd882b2b01ea8d08f2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal because of the continuous time frame (the fire continues to burn throughout the entire video, but the burning material remains stationary without any change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04859", "filename": "d661d255b5726c4803988bc44cd65c813e94ba3b794fc5dd882b2b01ea8d08f2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (flickering artifacts appear throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04864", "filename": "d669f7c4f6bcf61aca6a72e9bd5e13257883e7537cda491b5e8cd3ec014c65a6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.3s in the video, the handle of the bubble gun suddenly moves backward on its own without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04865", "filename": "d669f7c4f6bcf61aca6a72e9bd5e13257883e7537cda491b5e8cd3ec014c65a6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is continuous (at 0.7 seconds in the video, the number of bubbles suddenly increases and the left side of the screen suddenly becomes blurry). The overall visual impression is abnormal (throughout the video, the flow trajectory and size of the bubbles ejected by the bubble machine are too regular and lack a natural sense of randomness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04866", "filename": "d669f7c4f6bcf61aca6a72e9bd5e13257883e7537cda491b5e8cd3ec014c65a6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04867", "filename": "d669f7c4f6bcf61aca6a72e9bd5e13257883e7537cda491b5e8cd3ec014c65a6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.9s in the video, the black border around the trigger of the bubble gun disappears out of thin air without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04872", "filename": "d987bc6ea7cd5b89f78193bf975a83d6298c2c27dc7e1b2f329d11d8b01a4373_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 3.4s in the video, a red orb of light appears out of nowhere in the upper left corner of the screen, and at 4.6s, shadows from other scenes suddenly appear in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04873", "filename": "d987bc6ea7cd5b89f78193bf975a83d6298c2c27dc7e1b2f329d11d8b01a4373_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (all objects in the entire frame remain stationary without any change, and the image exhibits constant flickering).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04874", "filename": "d987bc6ea7cd5b89f78193bf975a83d6298c2c27dc7e1b2f329d11d8b01a4373_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (at 4.1s in the video, the volcanic mud on the right side of the screen, which had already cooled down, suddenly boiled again without any change in the shot).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04875", "filename": "d989dec55511802aaa196096f3dc0b0a909cbeb3c800bd173060952802237d8e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (at 3.3s in the video, the trunk behind the car suddenly shrinks in size without the camera angle changing, and at 4.6s, the trunk folds down on its own).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04876", "filename": "d989dec55511802aaa196096f3dc0b0a909cbeb3c800bd173060952802237d8e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 1.5s in the video, the hydraulic press has not yet made contact with the car, but the car has already started to press down on its own; at 4.7s, the car hood suddenly twists on its own).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04877", "filename": "d991b1c90bf3eb73e0c716b00ef98a6e333b34bd0bdd6638102883f4d3857907_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the clouds in the entire video keep moving, dispersing, and forming in one area, which is too regular and lacks a natural sense of disorder).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04878", "filename": "d991b1c90bf3eb73e0c716b00ef98a6e333b34bd0bdd6638102883f4d3857907_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04879", "filename": "d991b1c90bf3eb73e0c716b00ef98a6e333b34bd0bdd6638102883f4d3857907_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 1.2 seconds into the video, without any change in camera angle, the sun suddenly changes from a downward trend to an upward trend).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04880", "filename": "d991b1c90bf3eb73e0c716b00ef98a6e333b34bd0bdd6638102883f4d3857907_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (in real natural scenes, clouds move, deform, or spread with atmospheric flow, but the cloud formations in the image are fixed and lack any signs of dynamic change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04884", "filename": "d1501a3792890010c813721f32432d6eab2df97caa9fbdd70acc7cdd8d42d82a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (flickering artifacts exist throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04885", "filename": "d1501a3792890010c813721f32432d6eab2df97caa9fbdd70acc7cdd8d42d82a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (between 0s and 5.3s in the video, the metronome in the video randomly jumps and rotates without any external interference. At 5.3s, the metronome stops jumping and returns to stillness).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04886", "filename": "d1501a3792890010c813721f32432d6eab2df97caa9fbdd70acc7cdd8d42d82a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04887", "filename": "b44c3d20ca9b926d1d17ed3d97eeb033ab7464c7f37affc7fec91387eee59c64_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows a continuous sequence of events (at 2.5 seconds into the video, a large amount of black smoke suddenly appears out of nowhere, even where there is no flame contact).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04888", "filename": "b72e11a03fd86f1c10f2ca80a07ea71f361a67b77f8897ca4fcd6768d913f92d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04889", "filename": "b75e10c9631abee900800a9f0167eaa1c3d60804811eb8348441438cc932f0e2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (from the beginning of the video to 4.2 seconds, the clouds in the video are dark and white, but at 4.2 seconds, everything in the sky turns golden.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04890", "filename": "b75e609eab9523c5c1bcbe169316a45e6b741ae24faec7db7a45459a744383d8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04891", "filename": "b75e609eab9523c5c1bcbe169316a45e6b741ae24faec7db7a45459a744383d8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (in the video, two diamonds placed on a mirror only have one diamond's reflection on the mirror.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04892", "filename": "b76bcc17d3470c166d021f73e7e260aa9895c469caace67761e56cfcaec0ab71_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04893", "filename": "b76bcc17d3470c166d021f73e7e260aa9895c469caace67761e56cfcaec0ab71_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04894", "filename": "b472b4589b1fc6ff384ce608715bdc54f2437663acb0fed48cbb770e21cdb461_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (around the 4-second mark in the video, during the merging of the two bubbles, there is a momentary pixel distortion at the edge of the right bubble, and the color transition appears discontinuous. Normally, it should be a smooth, gradual merging effect.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04895", "filename": "b897bed9cea88fe740b2b82b9f45410d287946d00f1e6070b9671e9e8a31ee8c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video content: Physical behavior (water is being added to the kettle from the beginning of the video to 0.8 seconds, but the water level in the kettle does not change.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04896", "filename": "b994d9f4328ed1f99431d9282c2cceb79e58d41c8b69508a94d81fb6986c0949_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.6 seconds into the video, the upper clouds in the video suddenly disappear while the lower clouds appear out of nowhere.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04897", "filename": "b2102dc5ed0a7bdebcfdd74572f3b212a2c0d97f914250336bc1c75253b2d914_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 3 seconds, the shape of the clouds in the image changes abruptly without a natural gradual transition. The originally soft and smooth cloud outlines suddenly become hard and fragmented, and the light and shadow layers also change abruptly.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04898", "filename": "b2102dc5ed0a7bdebcfdd74572f3b212a2c0d97f914250336bc1c75253b2d914_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 2.5 seconds, the scene jumps directly from bright yellow clouds to darker purple clouds, and the transition of color and light is abrupt and without gradation; at 5.1 seconds, the shape and density of the clouds change abruptly, and the small scattered clouds on the left suddenly gather into a thick cloud).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04899", "filename": "b7674e7a99d422100cc19b900ec2d24a9c92e4d78c06db0bf84772787661e1ec_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 2.6 seconds, a rapidly flashing white spot appears on the left side of the screen; its shape and trajectory do not conform to the overall particle movement logic. At 4.2 seconds, the brightness of some particles suddenly increases and then immediately returns to normal, without a natural transition process.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04900", "filename": "b9607b38bcecb38ead4260251eb80752907d1587d44a974708ecde7c26c1f4d0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 3.1 seconds, an irregularly shaped dark patch suddenly appears on the left side of the screen. It is completely out of sync with the tone and texture of the surrounding snow scene, lacking both the fluffiness that snow should have and the integration into the overall lighting environment.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04901", "filename": "b9620c1f66b8f4784eaf335b5af685e5d893d009d3ac0c86a4fe39f48a017783_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (at 1.2 seconds, the bucket of the excavator on the left is still some distance from the wall, but there are already holes and flying debris on the wall, which does not conform to the real physical sequence of events. At the same time, the movement trajectory of the excavator's robotic arm on the right is also jerky and inconsistent with the overall operation rhythm.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04903", "filename": "b096031fead03fc7f8756af46917e2fcadc4051710f8c98c6c809a19233f9e4a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 3.3 seconds, the helicopter rotor blades suddenly exhibit a stuttering and overlapping visual effect; at 4.7 seconds, the brightness of the background clouds undergoes illogical jumps, and the bright areas expand instantaneously without presenting a natural transition of light and shadow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04904", "filename": "b7525989e01f8814396629e954eb3c56d2ec8fc10bb54508ab4b6c1f88809e06_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (At 2.5 seconds, the surface gloss of the bubble abruptly changes; the previously uniform iridescent sheen suddenly becomes dull. At 3.7 seconds, the texture of the bookshelf in the background becomes distorted; the clarity and continuity of the lines are disrupted.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04905", "filename": "b9800476e05034a291ba2ca0fe26ff8dc7320aed87475b35710b17242568c8c3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 1.9 seconds, a piece of ice in the left glass suddenly disappears without melting or any transition in the water; at 3.8 seconds, the ice-water level in the right glass jumps from a lower position to almost the rim).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04906", "filename": "b72652830b8271bb797c71b9a62bffafdd78d1b614435a16b81102716bcc9d0a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04907", "filename": "de9914e8cec406666d9a410156eaf11d3c34d475b0b93eb3fbfec6e567d829b2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (throughout the entire video, ripples from the movement of the boat are continuously visible beneath its hull, but the boat itself remains stationary).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04908", "filename": "de477205e31123b698df73db7d2441d29f92199a7d503a0464dad371becdc852_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is discontinuous (at 1.7 seconds, when the camera suddenly switches to a distant view of the sea, the light and shadow on the beach and the texture of the waves are completely disjointed; the golden reflective foam and wet sand texture of the previous second suddenly become a smooth beach with rainbow stripes, the transition is very abrupt).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04909", "filename": "de477205e31123b698df73db7d2441d29f92199a7d503a0464dad371becdc852_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is unpredictable (at 1.5 seconds, the camera cuts to a distant view, and the texture of the beach changes abruptly from wet sand with a golden sheen to smooth sand with rainbow stripes).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04910", "filename": "de477205e31123b698df73db7d2441d29f92199a7d503a0464dad371becdc852_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the waves exhibit a non-fluid, clumpy structure with a noticeable granular surface, resembling a fog or cloud-like formation, lacking the fluid dynamics and detail characteristic of seawater.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04911", "filename": "de477205e31123b698df73db7d2441d29f92199a7d503a0464dad371becdc852_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04912", "filename": "decbe03844a3ecffe0ab9763b2be443b55ee425cdd899573fa18da09f0e72668_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 3.8 seconds, the nut in the middle of the frame suddenly turns into a blade).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04913", "filename": "decbe03844a3ecffe0ab9763b2be443b55ee425cdd899573fa18da09f0e72668_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, when the foam board is destroyed at 1.5s, it does not tear or break normally, but directly turns into a large amount of powder).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04914", "filename": "decbe03844a3ecffe0ab9763b2be443b55ee425cdd899573fa18da09f0e72668_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: During the continuous cutting of the foam board (1.4s-5.6s), the volume of the debris that fell out was much larger than the part that was cut off.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04915", "filename": "decd0ee4997328cf9fce20eaddca0e198634550352a6086f99b0c412278dd2af_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Continuous time (no common ash, scorched edges, or falling debris appeared during the paper burning process, and no traces were left after the paper was completely burned.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04916", "filename": "decd0ee4997328cf9fce20eaddca0e198634550352a6086f99b0c412278dd2af_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 3 seconds, the white object in the lower right corner of the screen suddenly turns gray)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04917", "filename": "decd0ee4997328cf9fce20eaddca0e198634550352a6086f99b0c412278dd2af_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (Under the premise that the camera does not change and there is no external force or interference, the fire in the scene moves to the right on its own between 3.4s and 6.9s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04918", "filename": "df007c4975c17c0a1e5fcc264123b09b26744dad0c265ff748698e7a2d0fd044_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (under the premise that the camera does not change, there is no external force or interference, and there is no substance in the water that produces oxygen, the water in the whole scene keeps bubbling out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04919", "filename": "df007c4975c17c0a1e5fcc264123b09b26744dad0c265ff748698e7a2d0fd044_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the bubbles on the lemon slice do not rise or dissipate naturally throughout the entire process, but instead keep jerking irregularly in place, as if they are fixed on the screen and being repeatedly pulled).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04920", "filename": "df007c4975c17c0a1e5fcc264123b09b26744dad0c265ff748698e7a2d0fd044_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04921", "filename": "df007c4975c17c0a1e5fcc264123b09b26744dad0c265ff748698e7a2d0fd044_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04922", "filename": "df33a9c505f502e60b53756df440a0fc7fd67ac014c7ee13913e800d7c51bc98_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (Without any camera movement, at 3.8 seconds when the large bubble floats to the right side of the screen, there is a sudden, noticeable stutter and teleportation, as if the frame rate has jumped.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04923", "filename": "df33a9c505f502e60b53756df440a0fc7fd67ac014c7ee13913e800d7c51bc98_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (The beach in the image lacks the random bumps and small debris that natural sand should have; all textures are arranged in a fixed, repetitive pattern, and the edges are as neat as if they had been cut, completely lacking the messiness and natural texture of a real beach.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04924", "filename": "df33a9c505f502e60b53756df440a0fc7fd67ac014c7ee13913e800d7c51bc98_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without camera movement, external force, or interference, at 1.4 seconds, the large bubble on the right side of the screen suddenly disappears from its complete elliptical shape without any gradual shrinking or bursting process.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04925", "filename": "df62ac74d515eca4c5e613b9b1eb8203bfdfb0cdd550ea21e4846f319e2e1930_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the texture and color of the top horizontal piece of wood suddenly change at 2.5 seconds; the originally charred dark brown area instantly turns into an unburnt light brown wood grain).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04926", "filename": "df62ac74d515eca4c5e613b9b1eb8203bfdfb0cdd550ea21e4846f319e2e1930_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the cross-section of the topmost piece of wood suddenly changes from charred black to the light yellow of brand-new wood without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04927", "filename": "df62ac74d515eca4c5e613b9b1eb8203bfdfb0cdd550ea21e4846f319e2e1930_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the flame in the upper right corner of the screen does not show the dynamic changes of natural burning; it keeps repeating a vertical shaking cycle, and its burning position does not correspond to the wood below. It is an animation effect that is independently superimposed on the screen.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04928", "filename": "df62ac74d515eca4c5e613b9b1eb8203bfdfb0cdd550ea21e4846f319e2e1930_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04929", "filename": "df88a60ab14e681793324e8302f77b9585507c4ea79a93d1841aaf4ec55515e2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 1 seconds, the lower right part of the floating object in the liquid in the cup disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04930", "filename": "df88a60ab14e681793324e8302f77b9585507c4ea79a93d1841aaf4ec55515e2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time discontinuity (the bubbles on the surface of the liquid in the entire image do not rise or burst naturally; they remain stuck and jittery, completely disconnected from the flow of the liquid below.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04931", "filename": "df88a60ab14e681793324e8302f77b9585507c4ea79a93d1841aaf4ec55515e2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04932", "filename": "df88a60ab14e681793324e8302f77b9585507c4ea79a93d1841aaf4ec55515e2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (Under the premise that the camera did not change and there was no external force or interference, at 2.6s, the fine bubbles on the liquid surface did not go through the process of merging or breaking, but directly and illogically jumped into sparse large bubbles.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04933", "filename": "df599587eaa53a73ac8a06d7d60eb3d1efe6fe8abbb29831e86b7601879b99ea_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 2.5 seconds, the sky's color undergoes a sudden, seamless change, with a purplish-blue patch instantly transforming into a highly saturated pinkish-orange, while the movement of the clouds is accompanied by stuttering and repetitive frames.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04934", "filename": "df599587eaa53a73ac8a06d7d60eb3d1efe6fe8abbb29831e86b7601879b99ea_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 1.7s, the colors of the sunset transition without any abrupt change between warm pink-orange and highly saturated blue-violet).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04935", "filename": "df599587eaa53a73ac8a06d7d60eb3d1efe6fe8abbb29831e86b7601879b99ea_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04936", "filename": "dfc0d70059bc3467084d9f7caee6d25ba8cbbd2d64608b0a5531d1eee87a6a49_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time is continuous (there is no interaction between the character's paddling action and the water surface - when the paddle enters the water, there is no water flow or splash, and the water surface around the boat does not produce any ripples or eddies due to the paddling, and remains in a still mirror state).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04937", "filename": "P01_105_264_3edd594b6c52126c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: continuous time (starting at 1.9s in the video, without any change in camera angle, the towel in the hand suddenly changes from one to two).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04938", "filename": "P01_105_264_3edd594b6c52126c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Continuous timing (in the video, from 7.2s to 7.6s, the wrinkles on the towel suddenly disappear without any change in camera angle); Physical behavior (in the footage, the spoon bends at 0s without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04939", "filename": "P01_105_347_03fddc60c4be8497_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 1s in the video, without any change in the camera angle, the size of the cut vegetable is inconsistent with the size shown before cutting, with an extra portion of the vegetable; at 3.1s, part of the cut vegetable disappears out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04940", "filename": "P01_105_347_03fddc60c4be8497_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 4.1s and 5.1s in the video, the chopped vegetables disappear into thin air without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04941", "filename": "P01_105_347_03fddc60c4be8497_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.4s in the video, without any change in the camera angle, the vegetables cut by the knife disappear out of thin air, and at 6.5s, dried vegetables suddenly appear in the character's left hand).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04942", "filename": "P01_105_354_28d686bec7ee21ed_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.5s in the video, when the camera is cutting vegetables, the vegetable leaves cut by the knife disappear out of thin air without changing the camera angle; at 4.7s in the video, an extra piece of vegetable falls out while the camera is cutting vegetables).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04943", "filename": "P01_105_354_28d686bec7ee21ed_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.6 seconds into the video, without any change in the camera angle, a single cut produces many extra vegetable leaves, and the cut leaves disappear into thin air before 3.9 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04944", "filename": "P01_105_443_23d45e749b5187f7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04945", "filename": "P01_105_443_23d45e749b5187f7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_04946", "filename": "P01_105_593_ae7d4836fcbf0a6a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04947", "filename": "P01_105_593_ae7d4836fcbf0a6a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_04948", "filename": "P01_105_593_ae7d4836fcbf0a6a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: continuous time (at 1.3s in the video, the cabinet suddenly deformed and automatically opened its doors without being subjected to any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04949", "filename": "P01_105_642_72c6b778bc37cf3a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_04950", "filename": "P01_105_642_72c6b778bc37cf3a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (during the video from 1.2s to 6.6s, the blade bends without being subjected to any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04951", "filename": "P01_105_738_fb6bbabdd0e60c5d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (from 1s to 5s in the video, there is no water in the bowl, but it keeps boiling. The hot steam from the spatula drifts too smoothly and lacks a natural sense of chaos).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04952", "filename": "P01_106_146_74770cc9d40625be_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3s, the blue lid in the hand deforms without any external force, and at 3.4s, the bowl in the hand suddenly changes from one to two).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04953", "filename": "P01_106_146_74770cc9d40625be_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_04954", "filename": "P01_106_146_74770cc9d40625be_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 1s in the video, without any change in the camera angle, the refrigerator door suddenly detaches from the refrigerator and flies out of the frame; at 2.8s, a refrigerator drawer appears out of thin air at the bottom of the screen; at 4.9s, the box in the hand suddenly multiplies from one to two; and at 5.7s, the drawer that appeared out of thin air suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04955", "filename": "P01_106_233_cdc637b47067452a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (at 6 seconds, without any change in camera angle, the towel that was fixed in the person's hand suddenly collapsed and disappeared from the upper left corner).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04956", "filename": "P01_106_243_e562bbeddbcc56f9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (when the clothing is folded at 2.1s in the video, the triangular shape of the clothing at the bottom suddenly twists and deforms without any change in the camera angle. Between 3.0s and 4.3s, the clothing automatically retracts in the frame).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04957", "filename": "P01_106_243_e562bbeddbcc56f9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 1.4s in the video, without any change in camera angle, the towel automatically extends downwards and becomes longer; at 7.1s, the towel automatically attaches to the person's left foot).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04958", "filename": "P01_106_243_e562bbeddbcc56f9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (at 6.5s in the video, the long towel in the frame deforms into a square towel on its own without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04959", "filename": "P01_108_5_fedbace56eb4b0f0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.3s in the video, without any change in camera angle, the towel suddenly appears to be layered; at 3s, the blue striped towel suddenly turns into a green striped towel).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04960", "filename": "P01_108_5_fedbace56eb4b0f0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 2.7s in the video, without any change in camera angle, the upper right corner of the square towel suddenly changed from a folded state to a smooth state; at 3.7s, the upper left corner of the towel automatically shrank).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04961", "filename": "P01_109_34_3da78901a9412c5b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 1.4s in the video, a towel placed on a shelf suddenly appears in the person's hand without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04962", "filename": "P01_109_97_6b79d6427d968e3d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 2.9 seconds to the end of the video, without any change in the camera angle, the peeler did not scrape the part of the potato that the fingers were holding, but after the peeling was finished, the skin of the part that the fingers were holding was scraped off. At 4.8 seconds, the peeler scraped the fingers, but the fingers were not injured).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04963", "filename": "P01_109_97_6b79d6427d968e3d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (from 6.9s to the end of the footage, without any change in camera angle, the skin was not scraped on the part of the potato that the fingers were holding while peeling, but after the skin was finished, the skin on the part that the fingers were holding was scraped off).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04964", "filename": "P01_109_165_0326944abcac026c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Physical behavior (at 1.8s in the video, two potato peels next to the stove stand upright without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04965", "filename": "P01_109_165_0326944abcac026c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 1.9s, without any change in camera angle, the towel in the character's right hand disappears out of thin air; at 4.8s, the cutting board and knife on the stove disappear out of thin air; at 6.5s, the towel in the character's hand suddenly changes from one piece to two pieces).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04966", "filename": "P01_109_203_bfefc4dbbca6065b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 0.4s in the video, without any change in camera angle, the item in the person's left hand disappears out of thin air; at 3.8s, the object inside the box suddenly changes from black to green).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04968", "filename": "d661d255b5726c4803988bc44cd65c813e94ba3b794fc5dd882b2b01ea8d08f2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The time frame is continuous (at 5.9 seconds, no more burning material is added, but the fire suddenly intensifies).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04969", "filename": "d989dec55511802aaa196096f3dc0b0a909cbeb3c800bd173060952802237d8e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (at 1s, the car model moves backward without external force; at 1.3s, the hydraulic press has not yet contacted the car model, but the car model suddenly moves downward); Time continuity (at 1.9s, the bottom of the car model's door suddenly dents and disappears; at 4.1s, the front of the car model changes abruptly, and the fender of the car model suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04970", "filename": "d989dec55511802aaa196096f3dc0b0a909cbeb3c800bd173060952802237d8e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time sequence (at 3s, the car model's window suddenly shatters; at 4s, cracks suddenly appear on the car model; at 4s, the car suddenly explodes with increasing debris; at 5.5s, a large amount of blue debris suddenly appears below the car model). Physical behavior (at 3.5s, the car door dents without external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04971", "filename": "d1967f59dd3dc26f37a57502ddd51f5af50f3d3508872b49a48ab391b4242ac1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the fire burns inside the cardboard box throughout the video while the box remains unchanged) Physical behavior (from 0s to 3.5s, the flames appear to pass through the cardboard box on the right).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04972", "filename": "d1967f59dd3dc26f37a57502ddd51f5af50f3d3508872b49a48ab391b4242ac1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Time continuity (the letters on the right side of the cardboard box appear distorted at 4.7s), Causality (the fire burns inside the cardboard box throughout the video while the box itself remains unchanged), Physical behavior (the right side of the cardboard box moves rapidly to the right without any external force at 5.9s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04973", "filename": "d2317d16af7a7c6c7e75eb0b8b1c96fc5fbf968d853d149ae969cb7e18bbf018_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: continuous time (reflection appears on the lens at 1.6 seconds even when there is no light source).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04974", "filename": "d2317d16af7a7c6c7e75eb0b8b1c96fc5fbf968d853d149ae969cb7e18bbf018_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The time frame is continuous (the white characters above the lens appear to be wriggling between 3.8s and 5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04975", "filename": "d5069bc8d3bd52625cd34edd3ba66aae4310b9c4440cb081c733b80158c74f85_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the mountains and buildings in the entire video are distorted).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04976", "filename": "d9317fe04e1d6809bccd90c7b6f8e8b09974b9380e7ca57390cea4df8473b330_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Time continuity (the rice noodles appear broken and fused together throughout the video); Physical behavior (the rice noodles in the entire video frame are insufficient to support the vehicle's movement, while the rice noodles in the video frame support the vehicle's movement).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04977", "filename": "d9317fe04e1d6809bccd90c7b6f8e8b09974b9380e7ca57390cea4df8473b330_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time sequence (at 2.1s, a long, thin noodle suddenly appears out of nowhere below the noodle) Causality (at 2.1s, the noodle breaks but the wheel does not fall downwards)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_04978", "filename": "d42631e16e783bda7ef1c0dbf03016483030ab6b015b11833a0c5d708fbbbfdc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the green duckweed on the lake appears granular throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04979", "filename": "d793547c663c634a6211a0d1d736a2a47c3d1bd345eb5cd786a4887ffd67414e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the clouds move rapidly throughout the video while the sunset remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04980", "filename": "d926169efa86c1ff560bab34c62f0d8476dfc995c99cf889b1d417ad20d65ca7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the entire video shows snow falling, but no snowflakes are falling on the plane below the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04981", "filename": "d965703a27c573015b93b123261855473949e4b5c194236b3e2874e4b23eb0e7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (from 0s to 0.8s, the black object under the wooden stake deforms and turns into a penguin).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04982", "filename": "d950809243a9d260e1690b27eef4b80317cb5edfc40f55588fa69f003164db0f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the colored bubbles throughout the video lack a natural feel).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04983", "filename": "da7979ed8be3d8469ef576cdec590b2e3420052c1e6f2d51255014887135bd93_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.6s, the person's left hand only has four fingers, while at 1.1s, the left hand has five fingers; at 0.7s, the person's fingers appear to be twisted).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04984", "filename": "da597961fc01282b8df3d40a815f2b0d08cb23cd016d1ed8bb0967b4880b5cbb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (at 0.2s, the shape of the flame changes to resemble the flame of a burning stove; at 2.2s, the video feed shows a match being lit without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04985", "filename": "da597961fc01282b8df3d40a815f2b0d08cb23cd016d1ed8bb0967b4880b5cbb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The video feed is continuous (at 2s, there is no transition between the video and the next frame; at 3.3s, there is no transition between the video and the next frame; between 4s and 5s, a yellow connecting object appears in the middle of the match in the video feed).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04986", "filename": "db2345fe607a7083567172c6560945563b1eebdfd60dad5ee802fe11b555c977_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04987", "filename": "f6869d0a7fb443fa67e48b38a8166c3c93507f81508305dcdb8eab70fb22b3b4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 1.7 seconds, a large amount of water and ice blocks suddenly appear behind the metal block being pressed by the machine in the scene).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04988", "filename": "f9508eb7b7a29a3ab4249a6a603bceb1f8b14eff2c52cdbba6f161f2f9fd1ecf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, at 0.6s, the cardboard that was blown up disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04989", "filename": "f9508eb7b7a29a3ab4249a6a603bceb1f8b14eff2c52cdbba6f161f2f9fd1ecf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without changing camera angles, many wooden planks appear out of thin air in the lower right corner of the screen after the explosion at 2.12).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04990", "filename": "f9820c7f980d275190e2eb37c224c7755e8251e5f20c83a9377094bbdd49f34a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the flames in the image only appear on the right side of the fire and do not spread outwards naturally, which does not conform to the normal burning pattern of flames spreading naturally with the fire).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04991", "filename": "f9820c7f980d275190e2eb37c224c7755e8251e5f20c83a9377094bbdd49f34a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the campfire in the scene is only a single piece of wood burning, while the other pieces of wood do not show any signs of burning. The burning of a single piece of wood produces a strong flame that is inconsistent with the amount of burning, and the shape of the flame is like a fluid shaking, without the jumping texture of a flame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04992", "filename": "f9820c7f980d275190e2eb37c224c7755e8251e5f20c83a9377094bbdd49f34a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04993", "filename": "f9820c7f980d275190e2eb37c224c7755e8251e5f20c83a9377094bbdd49f34a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: continuous time (without any new firewood added, any additional fuel, or any change in oxygen supply, the flames suddenly and violently ignite in 3.4 seconds without any warning, and without any pre-heating process).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04994", "filename": "f22941d4010b8cb898bec1edb8e1b29bd2cb7953c6dd52c048ab7715af41f48a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without camera changes, external forces, or external interference, at 0.2s, the bucket in the frame suddenly turns into a sphere).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_04995", "filename": "f22941d4010b8cb898bec1edb8e1b29bd2cb7953c6dd52c048ab7715af41f48a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without external force or interference, and without any camera movement, flames suddenly appear behind the 3:10 barrel).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_04996", "filename": "f22941d4010b8cb898bec1edb8e1b29bd2cb7953c6dd52c048ab7715af41f48a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (Under the premise that the camera does not change and there is no external force or interference, the iron bucket suddenly turns into an iron ball in 3.4 seconds, and twists abnormally throughout the process)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04997", "filename": "f27126b8c57803bcf67fe24d7601575ed2336a4ad833ae389427675faeb33a59_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (the clouds in the footage exhibit obvious layered movement anomalies, with the lower half of the clouds moving rapidly and the upper half moving slowly. Clouds in the same airspace show drastically different rates of movement).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04998", "filename": "f27126b8c57803bcf67fe24d7601575ed2336a4ad833ae389427675faeb33a59_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (strong winds are seen moving the clouds rapidly, while the trees at the bottom of the screen remain still without any swaying or shaking).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_04999", "filename": "f27126b8c57803bcf67fe24d7601575ed2336a4ad833ae389427675faeb33a59_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the trees in the lower left corner of the screen disappear out of thin air at 1.4 seconds without any camera movement).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05000", "filename": "f60954fcf7fc7c553eadd76b74d486ab08ae03a993cafc4d2454a27468f2fd9d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, at 2:29, the illuminated light stick suddenly extends beyond the background).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05001", "filename": "f60954fcf7fc7c553eadd76b74d486ab08ae03a993cafc4d2454a27468f2fd9d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (under the premise that the camera does not change and there is no force or external interference, the long strip of light suddenly turns into a sphere in 3.5 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05002", "filename": "f60954fcf7fc7c553eadd76b74d486ab08ae03a993cafc4d2454a27468f2fd9d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (the light rays that should be straight are actually twisting and bending irregularly).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05003", "filename": "f60954fcf7fc7c553eadd76b74d486ab08ae03a993cafc4d2454a27468f2fd9d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, a green light suddenly appears behind the white light at 0.9 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05004", "filename": "f89178c8a2055d54939844482fff288d041ff80851e69d5c9d199c4487845fc0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (under the premise of no camera change and no external force interference, the liquid sprayed in the scene suddenly turns into a solid at 2.4s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05005", "filename": "f89178c8a2055d54939844482fff288d041ff80851e69d5c9d199c4487845fc0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the liquid sprayed out in the scene falls at a noticeably slow speed, and the liquid shape remains uniform without naturally dispersing; the trajectory of the liquid is also too regular and uniform).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05006", "filename": "f89178c8a2055d54939844482fff288d041ff80851e69d5c9d199c4487845fc0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05007", "filename": "f1516533ac121249729038ecdeb27fe1edc06b1287123f7a999ec4e638b0c31b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the button on the upper left of the remote disappears out of thin air at 1.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05008", "filename": "f1516533ac121249729038ecdeb27fe1edc06b1287123f7a999ec4e638b0c31b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the remote control indicator light turns on prematurely and without the person's hand touching or pressing any buttons).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05009", "filename": "f1516533ac121249729038ecdeb27fe1edc06b1287123f7a999ec4e638b0c31b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the person has not touched the screen or pressed any buttons on the remote control, yet the lights on the screen change color prematurely, and the device triggering and the operation are completely disconnected)", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05012", "filename": "f825931677fe83114a3358d33f06294cacd0a9049b1617db6e886e9ea99a59c5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the surfing movements in the scene are too smooth and continuous, completely lacking the jerky and swaying sensations that come with real surfing, caused by the impact of waves and the adjustment of the body's center of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05014", "filename": "fa5dd566b121d7282c79b59e92d70fc8d8a1fd20e3e42ea08f0cc1666c885a66_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the smoke in the image is abnormally concentrated, without natural dissipation or diffusion, and it does not form the layers and changes in sharpness that real smoke should have).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05015", "filename": "fa5dd566b121d7282c79b59e92d70fc8d8a1fd20e3e42ea08f0cc1666c885a66_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, a large amount of smoke appears out of nowhere in the upper half of the 3.5s frame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05016", "filename": "fa5dd566b121d7282c79b59e92d70fc8d8a1fd20e3e42ea08f0cc1666c885a66_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, white smoke suddenly appears on the left and right sides of the screen at 1.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05017", "filename": "c8cafce4b50f59ed06d41da0197333493ab4118510b5c783c80dab46e9665f6d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the intuition is off (the opal in the video is a hybrid of cabochon and top facet, but in reality, most opals are pure cabochons. This cutting method is neither in line with the processing techniques of opals, nor does it destroy the optical effect of play-of-color).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05018", "filename": "c8f2b995ec6f91114b970a6c8f1a025a227eff53516bfd20fb167212210e3712_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Physical behavior (real steam rises and slowly spreads outwards as white mist, but the smoke in the entire video is sprayed horizontally close to the ground and intermittently, which does not conform to the basic principle that thermal buoyancy makes steam rise).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05019", "filename": "c8f2b995ec6f91114b970a6c8f1a025a227eff53516bfd20fb167212210e3712_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (at 3.1s, a black object suddenly disappears and reappears in the upper right corner of the screen; the previous frame and the next frame are not continuous and lack consistency).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05020", "filename": "c8f2b995ec6f91114b970a6c8f1a025a227eff53516bfd20fb167212210e3712_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.7s, the smoke in the image no longer spreads outwards, but instead only sprays outwards to the lower left, with no consistency in the smoke pattern).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05021", "filename": "c8f2b995ec6f91114b970a6c8f1a025a227eff53516bfd20fb167212210e3712_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (at 3.1s, the water stain on the bottom right tile is blown away by the smoke; at 6.8s, the water stain in the bottom right corner moves on its own without the smoke's influence).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05022", "filename": "c9bc1436450d346852d07a5d96dedf4796a35550f306ecd3a76cafdea7b852c0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is inconsistent (when the hydraulic press hits the glass, the glass does not shatter instantly, but rather appears as if splashing water, with a dent appearing in the middle of the glass and glass shards flying out from it. At 4.4 seconds, the damaged glass suddenly returns to its original state, showing no consistency).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05023", "filename": "c9bc1436450d346852d07a5d96dedf4796a35550f306ecd3a76cafdea7b852c0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (at 2.1s, the hydraulic press merges with the glass it passes through; at 4.4s, the glass suddenly explodes; at 5.5s, the hydraulic press column disappears after the glass explodes).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05024", "filename": "c9bc1436450d346852d07a5d96dedf4796a35550f306ecd3a76cafdea7b852c0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is unusual: the visuals are not intuitively clear (in the entire video, the hydraulic press does not immediately shatter the glass when it is pressed; instead, a gel-like substance is squeezed out from the dent, which does not match the appearance of glass shards).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05025", "filename": "c9bc1436450d346852d07a5d96dedf4796a35550f306ecd3a76cafdea7b852c0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (at 0.9s, the hydraulic press is embedded in the glass during the downward pressing process, but the glass is intact. However, at 2.7s, the glass suddenly explodes. Except for the top glass, which explodes normally, the rest of the glass suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05026", "filename": "c9f06a6df48e32a66a06738cf73d19b9c50aebdfd589ea7c914b3d1064f8b02f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (steel balls keep flying out of the white card before 2.8s, and then disappear one after another after 4.3s).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05027", "filename": "c9f06a6df48e32a66a06738cf73d19b9c50aebdfd589ea7c914b3d1064f8b02f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05028", "filename": "c17d24a6124b5adb689d83e3dd2f7169fa5e07f0fc543111a2836b3cf41a47ec_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: (The iron block moves on its own without any external force acting on it throughout the entire video.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05029", "filename": "c17d24a6124b5adb689d83e3dd2f7169fa5e07f0fc543111a2836b3cf41a47ec_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: (The iron block moves on its own without any external force acting on it throughout the entire video.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05030", "filename": "c17d24a6124b5adb689d83e3dd2f7169fa5e07f0fc543111a2836b3cf41a47ec_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (in the entire video, the iron block falling from a person's hand merges, disappears, deforms, and abruptly changes during the fall).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05031", "filename": "c18bd91ec8828e1440af527001d4327546ab3fa0c7924f8c7a96a0727c243fbf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the intuition is abnormal (the thickness and curvature of the coffee column remain unchanged throughout the entire video, lacking the softness and dynamism of fluid; in reality, a poured coffee column will dynamically change from thick to thin depending on the angle of pouring).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05032", "filename": "c18bd91ec8828e1440af527001d4327546ab3fa0c7924f8c7a96a0727c243fbf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the intuition is abnormal (the surface of the coffee liquid does not change significantly when it is poured into the cup, whereas there should be ripples and splashes when the coffee liquid is poured into the cup).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05033", "filename": "c18bd91ec8828e1440af527001d4327546ab3fa0c7924f8c7a96a0727c243fbf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: causality (the amount of coffee poured into the cup does not match the amount of water rising in the bowl; more coffee is poured in, but less rises in the cup).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05034", "filename": "c18de7b629467cdc7707146cba99a651cba78d0f9a01165a5245af65e40f647d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous time (the sparkler remains burning throughout the entire video, but the position of the sparkler does not change, and the burning core does not descend with the burning).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05035", "filename": "c18de7b629467cdc7707146cba99a651cba78d0f9a01165a5245af65e40f647d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the sparks from the sparkler fluctuate in intensity throughout the video, and at 5.8 seconds, the sparkler suddenly goes out, but the burning core of the sparkler has not yet burned out).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05036", "filename": "c18de7b629467cdc7707146cba99a651cba78d0f9a01165a5245af65e40f647d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is uninterrupted (the sparkler is burning continuously and is unstable throughout the entire video, with the sparkler burning at different intensities and the difference in intensity is too large).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05037", "filename": "c18de7b629467cdc7707146cba99a651cba78d0f9a01165a5245af65e40f647d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Cause and effect (the burning point remains fixed throughout the video, and the sparks burn with varying intensity; in a real sparkler, the burning point would slowly move from the top towards the hand, the burning core of the stick would gradually blacken and shorten, and the range of the sparks would slightly decrease as the burning point moves downward).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05038", "filename": "c23c305d3e758718ad1bf775636327f9fe3fe8ec39f8adf808b146bd37993b6e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (in the whole video, the direction of the water ripples in the distance is downward, while the direction of the water ripples in the foreground is upward, and the direction of the water ripples on the entire water surface is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05039", "filename": "c23c305d3e758718ad1bf775636327f9fe3fe8ec39f8adf808b146bd37993b6e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the overall color tone changes too quickly throughout the video, from a low-saturation, cool image to a high-saturation image, but there is no sign of the video being sped up, the difference between the beginning and the end of the video is too large, and there is no consistency between the beginning and the end).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05040", "filename": "c23c305d3e758718ad1bf775636327f9fe3fe8ec39f8adf808b146bd37993b6e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the grass on the right side of the video is not affected by the wind and does not sway, but the water surface is fluctuating greatly, and the wooden sticks soaked in the water do not move with the waves and remain stationary).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05041", "filename": "c23c305d3e758718ad1bf775636327f9fe3fe8ec39f8adf808b146bd37993b6e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05042", "filename": "c34d987d43475766ecd16751637e7757a367ce39473e078c2a79834586d8c816_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the upper and lower red lines in the entire video are inconsistent, and the entire video is blurry, choppy, and flickering).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05043", "filename": "c34d987d43475766ecd16751637e7757a367ce39473e078c2a79834586d8c816_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (there is a vertical shadow on the right side of the wall in the entire video, but there is no corresponding object in the picture).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_05044", "filename": "c34d987d43475766ecd16751637e7757a367ce39473e078c2a79834586d8c816_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (a vertical shadow appears on the right side of the wall in the entire video frame, but there is no corresponding object in the frame, and the video track and the shadow on the wall are inconsistent, or there is a missing object reflection or distortion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05045", "filename": "c34d987d43475766ecd16751637e7757a367ce39473e078c2a79834586d8c816_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.4s, a small car appears out of nowhere on the track; at 1.1s, the small car and the yellow object clip through each other, and the track is bent and deformed).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05046", "filename": "c40e8befdfd2e7ca665af7ac493c94aed7536dedcdf8db8dc0052d795db9a65f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Intuitive abnormality (the pool suddenly explodes at 0 seconds. If it is water, the conditions for fire to burn on water are not met. If it is a flammable liquid, the splashing fire will ignite the surrounding environment).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05047", "filename": "6976afbf24c38e94d52108187a3754a0c57608e09db343405d22ffa3958abb47_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior (the colored stripes in the image are uniform and parallel; this perfect regularity is more like a digitally synthesized texture than an imaging defect of a real optical device).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05048", "filename": "6976afbf24c38e94d52108187a3754a0c57608e09db343405d22ffa3958abb47_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the metal frame should remain stable in a real scene; however, the outline, texture, and lighting of the frame are distorted in the image, and the curvature and shadows of the edges are not consistent).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05049", "filename": "6976afbf24c38e94d52108187a3754a0c57608e09db343405d22ffa3958abb47_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: The time is continuous (1.9s - end). In the interference of light, the lens does not deform and the ripples do not suddenly change into a ring-like pattern.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05050", "filename": "7034feded29f204b142705bb8d8bda93bb606c0185e77ca10873c9506d2bb9b4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the visuals: The duration is continuous (1.4s - end). The small tongue in the throat suddenly enlarges, whereas the organs in the human throat only move and do not enlarge.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05051", "filename": "7034feded29f204b142705bb8d8bda93bb606c0185e77ca10873c9506d2bb9b4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Physical behavior (the texture of the oral mucosa appears blurred, and there is also jumping mucus, which does not match the actual physiological structure)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05052", "filename": "7034feded29f204b142705bb8d8bda93bb606c0185e77ca10873c9506d2bb9b4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05053", "filename": "7055aaacb92b339f8696272814769788aefc4107ff314db7e3af35a125dc7b8b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the camera is shaking, but the cup is not subjected to any force, yet the water inside is jumping); Time continuity: (at 2.2s, the rim of the cup appears round, but at 4.9s, the rim appears deformed and discontinuous).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05054", "filename": "7055aaacb92b339f8696272814769788aefc4107ff314db7e3af35a125dc7b8b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the background seen through the glass should change as the camera moves, but it doesn't in the image).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05055", "filename": "7055aaacb92b339f8696272814769788aefc4107ff314db7e3af35a125dc7b8b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the camera is moving, the cup is not subjected to any force, yet the water inside is shaking).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05056", "filename": "7111b9eef0ca95ba837f0df8ee5641684c87e653718098fef58ba91d6b4649ff_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: The time was continuous (at 4.3s, the halo around the light showed irregular jumping and flickering, resembling a firelight).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05057", "filename": "7111b9eef0ca95ba837f0df8ee5641684c87e653718098fef58ba91d6b4649ff_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the light emitted by real neon tubes should be uniform and stable, but the color and brightness of the tubes in the image show illogical gradations).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05058", "filename": "7111b9eef0ca95ba837f0df8ee5641684c87e653718098fef58ba91d6b4649ff_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (Real neon tubes should emit uniform and stable light, but the colors and brightness of the tubes in the video show illogical gradual changes).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05059", "filename": "7159eb6915a61a821bc7cafb38ca39b175c8c4a62daf3fe1b615779ca6f87d3b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the shape of the cardboard remains completely unchanged during the burning process, whereas burning cardboard should produce ash).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05060", "filename": "7159eb6915a61a821bc7cafb38ca39b175c8c4a62daf3fe1b615779ca6f87d3b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (4.7s - end). The cardboard appearing in the scene shows no signs of being burned on the flame.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05061", "filename": "7159eb6915a61a821bc7cafb38ca39b175c8c4a62daf3fe1b615779ca6f87d3b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Physical behavior (cardboard is a flammable material, and fire should slowly burn around the perimeter of the cardboard, but in the image, there is no burning around the cardboard near the fire on the right side).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05062", "filename": "7159eb6915a61a821bc7cafb38ca39b175c8c4a62daf3fe1b615779ca6f87d3b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (3.1s - ends with the burning fire suddenly exploding, the fire suddenly getting bigger, and a large pile of charcoal appearing out of nowhere. The firewood in the footage is small, and there shouldn't be such a large amount of ash).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05066", "filename": "7392fb10a64a751563acbf16cc95f604b04b9d5a4a6cb1df101a4ec3bf8bd3a1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 2.7s, the yolk of the broken egg, just as it was about to fall from the left after contacting a small area of metal, flows upward; the bottom of the egg, which should be oval, appears flat in the image).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05067", "filename": "7444b462a2fae5f03b7791573ad4b55538b1d599d04d1950d835f79f2695fa3c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (4.3s, the cube on the right side does not emit red light, but it reflects red light on the table).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05068", "filename": "7444b462a2fae5f03b7791573ad4b55538b1d599d04d1950d835f79f2695fa3c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the reflection and color superposition of the transparent cube completely violate optical principles; the color reflection of the cube is not supported by a uniform light source; the reflection below does not match the shape of the cube).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05069", "filename": "7444b462a2fae5f03b7791573ad4b55538b1d599d04d1950d835f79f2695fa3c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (The reflection and color superposition of the transparent cube completely violate the principles of optics; the color reflection of the cube is not supported by a uniform light source; the reflection below does not match the shape of the cube.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05070", "filename": "7658a0d993e6ce995847d020cb3694a4e5816f24b249c0d8512b963ef0c3c7e5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2s, the white portion of the pillar that was originally white on top and black on the bottom suddenly disappears)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05071", "filename": "7658a0d993e6ce995847d020cb3694a4e5816f24b249c0d8512b963ef0c3c7e5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the car's forward speed in the video is significantly slower than its movement speed in the rearview mirror).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05072", "filename": "7658a0d993e6ce995847d020cb3694a4e5816f24b249c0d8512b963ef0c3c7e5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time frame is continuous (in the 3.7s footage, the people in the rearview mirror appear as double images; some figures are visible but their heads are not).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05073", "filename": "7658a0d993e6ce995847d020cb3694a4e5816f24b249c0d8512b963ef0c3c7e5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Overall lack of realism (the outlines of distant vehicles in the image are blurry and distorted, lacking the detail and texture of real vehicles).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05074", "filename": "7748d08cf32cac6c86ec1eaae591ebee48ef40378bafa3aed1d6bce1b30655c0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (the number of wire loops increases at 1.5 seconds); Overall realism (the surface of the wire loops in the image is too smooth and lacks clear layering texture).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05075", "filename": "7748d08cf32cac6c86ec1eaae591ebee48ef40378bafa3aed1d6bce1b30655c0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (0.6s: the right side of the steel ring appears distorted and blurry); Overall realism (3.1s - end: the half of the steel ring near the hand becomes soft and lacks texture).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05076", "filename": "7748d08cf32cac6c86ec1eaae591ebee48ef40378bafa3aed1d6bce1b30655c0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.7s, the part of the wire held by the hand is very thin, and at 4.7s it suddenly becomes very thick).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05077", "filename": "1c2ee2b7e95992780ac56dc1bfcc1312a8e1ce40e04d1499b8680b5dfc1786b2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05078", "filename": "1c2ee2b7e95992780ac56dc1bfcc1312a8e1ce40e04d1499b8680b5dfc1786b2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (between 2s and 4.1s, a bright chain of light appears out of nowhere from the top of the central pillar and then disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05079", "filename": "1c9e94dbb3e9f31aab95c29a7ba5600682864a935568fa6d7a120b129b46593a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05080", "filename": "1c9e94dbb3e9f31aab95c29a7ba5600682864a935568fa6d7a120b129b46593a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a flower slightly to the left of center in the image, in the absence of wind, its petals suddenly stretch and deform dramatically to the left, and then instantly spring back to their original shape, which does not conform to the physical characteristics of plants).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05081", "filename": "1c9e94dbb3e9f31aab95c29a7ba5600682864a935568fa6d7a120b129b46593a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05082", "filename": "1c9e94dbb3e9f31aab95c29a7ba5600682864a935568fa6d7a120b129b46593a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning (flowers would normally move due to the wind, but in the video only the flowers closer to the camera are moving, while those farther away remain stationary).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05083", "filename": "1c62f8cbc14466c440dbd57575ed75b632a92c3f98f79fa3500ac5e58ea42e37_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05084", "filename": "1c62f8cbc14466c440dbd57575ed75b632a92c3f98f79fa3500ac5e58ea42e37_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (a white light appears in the upper right corner between 0.2s and 0.3s and then disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05085", "filename": "1c662437ac36a05e6b6d1e90358cab8a8d7fa3ea18018d9ad72b8b37ae6a83af_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly occurred in the video: (between 1.6s and 5s, water from a pot was poured onto the fire, but the fire did not go out, and no steam was produced as expected.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05086", "filename": "1c662437ac36a05e6b6d1e90358cab8a8d7fa3ea18018d9ad72b8b37ae6a83af_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Causality (at 1.1s, part of the fire was not doused with water from the pot and still went out, so the causal relationship is not valid).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05087", "filename": "1c662437ac36a05e6b6d1e90358cab8a8d7fa3ea18018d9ad72b8b37ae6a83af_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is discontinuous (when water is poured on a fire, it should quickly extinguish the flames and produce white steam, but the flames in the video do not show a clear extinguishing process, nor can steam be produced. The entire action of pouring liquid is completely disconnected from the changes in the flames).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05088", "filename": "1c662437ac36a05e6b6d1e90358cab8a8d7fa3ea18018d9ad72b8b37ae6a83af_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect (when the water is poured on the flame between 2.5s and 6s, the flame should produce a lot of white smoke due to the heat absorption of the vaporized water. Simultaneously, the flame should exhibit a noticeable struggle, shrinking, and then extinguishing. However, in the video, no white steam vaporizes after the liquid is poured, and the flame disappears almost instantly, even extinguishing the surrounding burning debris. This is completely different from the actual reaction of water extinguishing a flame.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05089", "filename": "1cbe18216eda223b1cd786f92fddda5e6e4bfd0721d3e5dc89d441e45bea5700_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (between 2.7s and 3.3s, the two objects on the right begin to twist and merge together).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05090", "filename": "1cbe18216eda223b1cd786f92fddda5e6e4bfd0721d3e5dc89d441e45bea5700_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05091", "filename": "1ce2f55f3cf7a2bb08ea00ea09069dc9c3843dadc0de211a3f523e3d01f3e010_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05092", "filename": "1ce2f55f3cf7a2bb08ea00ea09069dc9c3843dadc0de211a3f523e3d01f3e010_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Overall visual anomaly: Time continuity (the tire swing in the video shows obvious abnormalities between 3.7s and 5.3s. Without any external force, it first suddenly twitches slightly without any inertia, and then when it is still, it shows localized deformation that should only occur when someone is sitting on it. Moreover, the swing's swaying and deformation are not projected synchronously in the reflection on the water, and are disconnected from the real physical feedback).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05093", "filename": "1ce2f55f3cf7a2bb08ea00ea09069dc9c3843dadc0de211a3f523e3d01f3e010_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05094", "filename": "1ce2f55f3cf7a2bb08ea00ea09069dc9c3843dadc0de211a3f523e3d01f3e010_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Causality (At 2.3s, the object in the footage was not in contact with the water surface, but ripples had already formed in the water, which would only occur upon contact, so the causal relationship is not valid).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05095", "filename": "1d11ef147d96c26533baf7804b4bf3b399df62512a07873d0f274e43ad276cea_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05096", "filename": "1d11ef147d96c26533baf7804b4bf3b399df62512a07873d0f274e43ad276cea_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (there are obvious frame skips and logical breaks in the hand movements in the video between 1s and 4s: the right thumb and index finger suddenly \"teleport\" above the knife without exerting any force, and the object being cut does not deform or shift synchronously when the knife moves, and there is no sense of real mechanical interaction between the tool and the material).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05097", "filename": "1d11ef147d96c26533baf7804b4bf3b399df62512a07873d0f274e43ad276cea_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The screen is malfunctioning; the time is continuous (the shavings from the knife disappear automatically at 0.7 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05098", "filename": "1d11ef147d96c26533baf7804b4bf3b399df62512a07873d0f274e43ad276cea_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly occurred: (between 1.2s and 1.4s, the wood chips shaved off by the knife disappeared automatically from the blade).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05099", "filename": "1d69a0187868f2ae793e4ef0efc4a0a83094a882d9e749eac3e2b1eb368e55f5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (liquid is added to the cup, but the amount of liquid in the cup does not increase from 0.2s to 3.6s; instead, it decreases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05100", "filename": "1d69a0187868f2ae793e4ef0efc4a0a83094a882d9e749eac3e2b1eb368e55f5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (between 0.7s and 5.8s, the yellow object in the cup gradually disappears as water is added to the cup and the water level rises).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05101", "filename": "1d69a0187868f2ae793e4ef0efc4a0a83094a882d9e749eac3e2b1eb368e55f5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 3s to 4.6s, the water column formed by the yellow liquid being poured into the cup gradually disappears from the bottom of the cup upwards).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05102", "filename": "1d69a0187868f2ae793e4ef0efc4a0a83094a882d9e749eac3e2b1eb368e55f5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is unusual because of the continuity of time. (The unusual part of this video is the process of the liquid being poured in and disappearing: brown liquid is poured into a glass of water, but it does not mix or spread with the water. Instead, it disappears shortly after being poured in, and the water surface instantly returns to a calm and transparent state.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05106", "filename": "1d60505c9b260716a8a5e2783fa857c32ab6e32b5df13e8a36d224642d29c992_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the crayon melts on its own without any external force throughout the entire scene, and the red melted part on the far left grows back from 4.2 seconds to the end).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05107", "filename": "33fcdead0f26faa900ec5d3c9c206a50cfcfaa0e5d90b8a5efb71d5d0b320e72_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the texture of the sparks in the entire video is like dotted light spots, rather than the granular texture of burning debris. Some sparks even appear in the high-temperature area of the flame core, which violates the physical logic that sparks are debris splashed after burning. In addition, the black area below is blurry and cannot be determined whether it is firewood, charcoal or other burning materials. The flame is suspended on a black background without any solid structure, lacking a sense of support).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05108", "filename": "33fcdead0f26faa900ec5d3c9c206a50cfcfaa0e5d90b8a5efb71d5d0b320e72_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the lit and shadowed sides of the firewood in the entire video have no natural transition between light and shadow, and are always dark blocks of color. The flame is a strong light source, but it does not create natural light and shadow projection on the background around the firewood. The background is pure black with no reflection, and the firewood does not have any light and shadow levels illuminated by the flame. The overall light and shadow are disjointed).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_05109", "filename": "33fcdead0f26faa900ec5d3c9c206a50cfcfaa0e5d90b8a5efb71d5d0b320e72_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Temporal continuity is abnormal (the fire suddenly intensifies at 1.9s). Overall Visual Anomalies: The overall visual presentation is abnormal (bright areas are overexposed, dark areas are completely black, lacking the realistic transition from orange-yellow to dark red of a flame; the overall color is monotonous and lacks texture; realistic sparks are burning wood chips and ash, their trajectories should be parabolic, varying in size, and gradually dissipating; the sparks are uniformly dotted or short, like randomly sprinkled gold dust, lacking the dynamic sense of burning and the dissipation process; there is no realistic charred gradation of ash, embers, and firewood after a campfire; there is no faint reflection of flames illuminating the surrounding environment; the overall image only shows fire and firewood, lacking any sense of environmental interaction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05110", "filename": "34e222a79effcefaa31e17ea2ed1e22d132205ccbf07ccf40a16fe88728406c2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall visual impression is abnormal (in the entire video, the water boils without the natural process of preheating and the formation of small and large bubbles, but without any change, and there is no generation, rising and bursting of bubbles).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05111", "filename": "34e222a79effcefaa31e17ea2ed1e22d132205ccbf07ccf40a16fe88728406c2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (at 5.2s, there is absolutely no liquid water inside the pot in the video. The inside of the pot is dry and hollow, yet steam continues to emerge from it. The steam is not supported by any water source, which violates the most basic physical principle that water vapor is formed by the vaporization of water when heated. Without a water source, there is no premise for vaporization. In addition, the pot in the video is continuously heated by the flame of the gas stove, but the pot body, especially the bottom, does not show any high-temperature reaction. In reality, dry-heating an empty pot would cause the bottom to gradually turn red and yellow, which violates the principle that metals oxidize when exposed to high temperatures.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05113", "filename": "34eccf18e6e2b993d1635cf04717f994f22b5301c84c8df2184d24ab38d377f6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall impression is off (the explosion flames in the video are perfectly spherical, but in reality, the flames of flammable liquids or powder explosions are irregularly diffused. The sparks from the explosion ball have a dotted light pattern rather than the granular texture of burning debris. Furthermore, the connection between the spherical flames and the container below is too abrupt, without any transitional splashing or smoke from the combustion process. The container only shows slight discoloration at the bottom, without any charring, deformation, or cracking from high temperatures, which is completely inconsistent with the high-temperature impact of a violent explosion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05114", "filename": "34eccf18e6e2b993d1635cf04717f994f22b5301c84c8df2184d24ab38d377f6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Overall visual intuition is abnormal (the entire video shows a mushroom cloud-like flame resembling a nuclear explosion. In reality, a mushroom cloud is formed by the rising high-temperature gases from a large nuclear explosion; ordinary combustion does not have this propulsion. Furthermore, the connection between the flame and the burning material on the ground is abrupt. The columnar mushroom-shaped structure of the flame completely contradicts the logic of diffusion and ascent in combustion. Additionally, the sparks and debris mixed in with the flame have no reasonable splashing trajectory and conflict with the high-temperature form of the flame. Some debris is not engulfed by the flame but remains suspended within it.) Time Continuity (at 2.1s, sparks appear out of nowhere at the bottom of the flame; at 4.2s, sparks appear out of nowhere in the middle of the video container.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05115", "filename": "34eccf18e6e2b993d1635cf04717f994f22b5301c84c8df2184d24ab38d377f6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (at 0.9s, the broken can is restored to its original state; at 2.6s, fragments around the can appear out of nowhere). Overall visual anomalies (the ratio of black smoke to flame is unbalanced throughout the video; the black smoke is too dense and stiff, lacking a natural, layered effect; the sparks fly outwards with an overly uniform and dense trajectory, lacking any sense of gravity; in reality, sparks fall in a parabolic trajectory due to gravity, and their density decreases with distance, rather than appearing as evenly scattered points of light; furthermore, the size and brightness of the sparks are completely uniform, whereas in reality, sparks vary in size and brightness, and burning sparks gradually dim and extinguish).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05120", "filename": "35db58abfde63bbcfd9277a6018913d92171b67870d48e8b95536fd7ce83d952_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the white foam of the waves in the foreground is distributed haphazardly throughout the video. What should be a continuous band of foam formed by the surge of the waves is instead a patchy, broken foam. Even on calm water without waves, foam appears out of nowhere, which violates the natural pattern of waves breaking apart. The waves in the midground are fine and gentle, but the foreground suddenly shows abruptly high waves. The transition between wave height and wave distance is extremely unnatural. There is no gradual change logic from far to near like real waves. Moreover, the outline of the wave crest is blurry and the edges are harsh, lacking the soft curve of real waves).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05121", "filename": "35db58abfde63bbcfd9277a6018913d92171b67870d48e8b95536fd7ce83d952_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the reflections on the sea surface in the entire video are chaotic and disorderly, without a clear direction of light source such as the main light source at sunrise or sunset. The brightness and color tone of the reflections in different areas are disjointed. There is no transition between the pale white reflections in the distance and the cool blue reflections in the foreground. The horizon of the sky and the sea is blurred. In some areas, the sky color is even directly blurred onto the sea surface. There is no clear horizon outline. The waves rise and fall irregularly, and the height and spacing of the wave crests and troughs change abruptly. There is no gradual change logic of the waves being smaller and larger in the distance and slower and faster in the distance).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05122", "filename": "35db58abfde63bbcfd9277a6018913d92171b67870d48e8b95536fd7ce83d952_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall impression is abnormal (the sea surface has a golden reflection throughout the video, but there is no corresponding sunlight in the sky, and the reflected area does not match the undulations of the clouds and sea surface at all. There is no natural light and shadow gradation, the direction and height of the waves are chaotic, some wave crests are suspended, the connection between different wave layers is abrupt, the size ratio of the waves is chaotic, and some wave crests appear abnormally flat, giving people a strong sense of incongruity visually).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05123", "filename": "36acf8262bc1bb7bb68127f2d9c853743d7feb527c01b8481f534208e70d2f8e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall impression is off (the aurora and starlight are the main light sources in the video, but the brightness, color and shape of the aurora and starlight reflected on the water are completely out of sync with the sky. There is no real shimmering effect. It looks more like a blurry block of color that has been directly copied. Furthermore, the shadows on the ice surface of the mountain are not affected by the aurora. The transition between light and dark is harsh. The proportion and perspective of the mountain violate the principle of near objects appearing larger and far objects appearing smaller. The size, detail and density of distant peaks and nearby ice walls are out of balance, and the sense of spatial depth is chaotic).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05124", "filename": "36acf8262bc1bb7bb68127f2d9c853743d7feb527c01b8481f534208e70d2f8e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is off (the lines of the snow-capped mountain ridges in the entire video are too plastic-like, lacking the rock texture and snow thickness variations of a real mountain; the distribution of stars in the starry sky is too uniform and dense, lacking the brightness and density variations of a real Milky Way, and the stars are all the same size and lack a sense of depth; the color transitions of the aurora are abrupt, lacking the flowing and diffused feel of a real aurora; the three-dimensionality of the snow-capped mountain is flat and stretched, lacking the natural depth of field of near objects appearing larger and far objects smaller; the edges of the green light bands of the aurora are too sharp and uniform, lacking the hazy feel of a real aurora; and the two auroras appear from two different directions, with no continuous light band connecting the two segments, appearing as two aurora segments that are abruptly independent light effects, which does not conform to the banded structure of a real aurora).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05125", "filename": "36de8f22fafbf554bff5fd98229870f9ccae5aaf639c518be13c8a4af40326e9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual presentation is off (the fountain's water jets in the entire video do not exhibit natural water flow; they resemble solid, luminous pillars of light, lacking the dynamic feel of splashing, misting, and falling water. The edges are stiff, and the light emission is overly uniform, like a plastic pillar being forcibly illuminated. A fountain is water and cannot spontaneously emit such intense, cold white light. In reality, light reflects off water, but the water jets in the image appear to be self-luminous, violating common sense about optics).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05126", "filename": "36de8f22fafbf554bff5fd98229870f9ccae5aaf639c518be13c8a4af40326e9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall visual impression is off (the fountain appears to be suspended in a columnar water column trajectory throughout the video, violating the laws of fluid dynamics; the fountain's reflection on the ground is not only completely misaligned with the water column, but also has the counterintuitive effect of being brighter and more blurred than the actual water; the reflective areas on the ground do not reflect the dynamics of the water flow, resembling a smooth plastic sheet without any ripples or splashes of water reflecting light; the purple cool light on the person is completely out of sync with the cool white light of the fountain and the warm yellow light and shadow of the streetlights in the background, and the person is not illuminated by the light from the fountain or the streetlights).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05127", "filename": "36de8f22fafbf554bff5fd98229870f9ccae5aaf639c518be13c8a4af40326e9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual presentation is inconsistent (the water splashes and ripples from the fountain are unrelated to the impact of the water jet; for example, when the water jet hits the surface hard, there are no corresponding ripples or natural dissipation; the silhouette of the person is harsh and lacks a natural transition with the light and shadow of the purple fountain, appearing as if the person is pasted onto the screen rather than actually standing next to the fountain; the person's reflection on the water is distorted and disproportionate, and the light and shadow do not match the person's actual body; the person is standing in the middle of the fountain, which would splash water in reality, and it is impossible for the person to stand so dry in the water; the scene logic is completely invalid).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05131", "filename": "37a32282f028a9c092eb792a8dcbd1624c39b5d1891e5c25c6213e406c3f1ed5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0s, there is a rope on the left hand; at 0.3s, the rope on the left hand disappears; at 0.4s, the rope in the middle of the video suddenly merges; from 0.7s to 5s, the rope in the middle splits into multiple strands and continues to merge and abruptly change direction; at 0.9s, the left hand merges, blurs, and abruptly changes direction).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05132", "filename": "37a32282f028a9c092eb792a8dcbd1624c39b5d1891e5c25c6213e406c3f1ed5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (1.1s, the left hand fingers and the object merge, the length of the finger joints does not conform to human anatomy, the bending angle of the thumb and other fingers is strange, the palm shape is distorted, the logic of the fingers and the yo-yo string is chaotic, there is no reasonable centrifugal force or tension support, it seems to float in the air, the string winding trajectory is chaotic, some sections of the string show clipping, and the thickness and tension of the string are inconsistent in different sections, lacking a realistic sense of physical pulling).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05133", "filename": "37a32282f028a9c092eb792a8dcbd1624c39b5d1891e5c25c6213e406c3f1ed5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time is continuous (1.2s, the yo-yo is suspended above the right hand without any support point, the Chinese characters on the hoodie are distorted, the radicals are missing, the characters are messed up and cannot be recognized as meaningful Chinese characters, the green rope is erratic, some rope segments appear out of nowhere and cross illogically, there is no physical trajectory that conforms to the way yo-yos are played, and the connection point between the rope and the yo-yo in the hand is also unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05134", "filename": "37a32282f028a9c092eb792a8dcbd1624c39b5d1891e5c25c6213e406c3f1ed5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the rope in the entire video does not have a realistic stretching, swinging, or winding motion; it appears as a stiff green line throughout, with no actual force connection to the yo-yo's hand. When the yo-yo spins, the rope does not have an arc due to inertia, nor does it have a natural sense of drooping when stationary. The yo-yo's trajectory is chaotic. When performing classic moves such as tossing, catching, spinning, and finger looping, the yo-yo appears to float in mid-air. The yo-yo's spinning motion is distorted, and there are no realistic changes in light and shadow during the yo-yo's rotation. The direction and speed of rotation are completely inconsistent with the force exerted by the hand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05135", "filename": "37d70c98fb8c34ccfa95aa1dc6f98db07c7967b451265a5356853c91407ea570_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the orange balloon is inflated throughout the video. The balloon itself is a taut ellipsoid, but there is no transition of light and shadow from the rubber. The black tubular object connected to the bottom of the balloon has no sealing details at all. It looks like it is directly glued to the balloon, which violates the physical connection logic of inflation).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05136", "filename": "37d70c98fb8c34ccfa95aa1dc6f98db07c7967b451265a5356853c91407ea570_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the black tubular object connecting to the bottom of the ball has no sealing details at all, as if it is directly glued to the balloon, which violates the physical connection logic of inflation and spraying. In addition, the ball bounces when it is inflated, but its volume does not change. If it is affected by wind, it will not swing slowly and randomly as in the video. The reflective points on the balloon do not change significantly with the shaking).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05137", "filename": "19d91c1c5dbb3a456bfb36e7c2b67ba6581497667e6efa32008297207ca9f7f6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In a dark environment, with a flame as the sole light source, the brightness of surrounding objects should change with the size of the flame. The fluctuating size of the flame appears unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05138", "filename": "19d91c1c5dbb3a456bfb36e7c2b67ba6581497667e6efa32008297207ca9f7f6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the sudden appearance of a flame in the lower left corner at 1.1s does not conform to \"temperature\" in the three elements of combustion. In a dark environment, if a flame is the only light source, the brightness of surrounding objects should change with the size of the flame).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05139", "filename": "19d91c1c5dbb3a456bfb36e7c2b67ba6581497667e6efa32008297207ca9f7f6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05140", "filename": "19e41c63a6f1dc51ea302116628f80a67cbc3e6a0560c8eb5466db06d1e0eaf7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: The timing is inconsistent (the rhythm of the change in brightness as sunlight penetrates through the leaves is not in line with the rhythm of the leaves swaying).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05141", "filename": "19e41c63a6f1dc51ea302116628f80a67cbc3e6a0560c8eb5466db06d1e0eaf7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.7s, the sunlight suddenly moves from the right to the left, and at 4.6s, the swaying of the tree branch slightly to the right of the center is similar to a self-twisting motion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05142", "filename": "19e41c63a6f1dc51ea302116628f80a67cbc3e6a0560c8eb5466db06d1e0eaf7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the sunlight penetrating through the gaps in the leaves is too strong, and the brightness does not change with the movement of the leaves).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05143", "filename": "19e41c63a6f1dc51ea302116628f80a67cbc3e6a0560c8eb5466db06d1e0eaf7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall realism is poor (the texture of the leaves is blurry and lacks individual differences; there are no texture details like those of real plants).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_05144", "filename": "20d27383bebe4b3b8f850e216675e3b2e9966f93b0d358e11b2cdc9e0eb19bdc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (blue smoke suddenly expands and jumps at 0.9s, inconsistent with the previous and subsequent expansion speeds); Physical behavior (a transparent box moves left and right without external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05145", "filename": "20d27383bebe4b3b8f850e216675e3b2e9966f93b0d358e11b2cdc9e0eb19bdc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall realism (the outline of the blue smoke lacks a smooth transition from light to dark, appearing too harsh; the diffusion of the blue smoke is too smooth and even).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05146", "filename": "20d27383bebe4b3b8f850e216675e3b2e9966f93b0d358e11b2cdc9e0eb19bdc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (blue liquid penetrates the glass box from 1.4s to 5.9s; the appearance of the blue liquid at 1.4s is too abrupt, lacking elements such as an exit).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05150", "filename": "21a1c21ee41c4e1806479a4eb54045bafbe67a65c60a6a1a505da30ff8701d60_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall realism is inconsistent (the rapid flickering and small size of the flames are characteristics consistent with the burning of coal in a stove, but not with the burning of wood).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05151", "filename": "21a1c21ee41c4e1806479a4eb54045bafbe67a65c60a6a1a505da30ff8701d60_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall realism (the wood is burning in the dark, and the surrounding stones should appear to be illuminated by the firelight, with the brightness changing according to the size of the firelight).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05152", "filename": "21e0f67731c0c861cab2719256b2bef07727f9793749b2210b83f98bf1732c13_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall lack of realism (the outline of the topmost black square is too blurry and lacks definition).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05153", "filename": "21e0f67731c0c861cab2719256b2bef07727f9793749b2210b83f98bf1732c13_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physics behavior (0.2s: Lack of external force during block fall. When the upper block falls and hits the lower standing block, the lower block remains motionless, showing no linkage. The block should only be subject to gravity during its fall and should not bend.) Time continuity (Block disappears into thin air during its fall.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05154", "filename": "21e0f67731c0c861cab2719256b2bef07727f9793749b2210b83f98bf1732c13_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall lack of realism (the outline of the topmost black square is too blurry and lacks definition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05155", "filename": "21ea1f1f75a5540c0faf461c1d339d7c985310d1ef0297660b2151484e083de9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time sequence (two suns appear at 2.5 seconds. Sunset suddenly turns into sunrise at 4.5 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05156", "filename": "21ea1f1f75a5540c0faf461c1d339d7c985310d1ef0297660b2151484e083de9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall realism (the environment is set for evening, at which point the sunlight shouldn't be too strong; the contrast between the speed of cloud movement and the speed of the setting sun is too great).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05157", "filename": "21f6a78d0cb7c1f0de49df4ab46ca597b301ef610fb2ed1ec1eb4ff56abaa61b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall lack of realism (the character's fingers are continuously burned, but the character shows no reaction. From 0s to 0.8s, the fingers and the objects held by the fingers are too blurry and lack outline).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05158", "filename": "21f6a78d0cb7c1f0de49df4ab46ca597b301ef610fb2ed1ec1eb4ff56abaa61b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (1.5s: A piece of wood appears out of thin air in the character's left hand. 4.4s: The wood in the left hand disappears out of thin air)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05159", "filename": "21f6a78d0cb7c1f0de49df4ab46ca597b301ef610fb2ed1ec1eb4ff56abaa61b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1.1s, a piece of wood appears out of thin air in the character's left hand; at 2.6s, the two pieces of wood merge into a strip of wood; at 4s, the wood in the hand disappears out of thin air; at 5.3s, the small stick in the left hand instantly turns into a large stick of wood).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05160", "filename": "22e4e454d760fb8ca7c6cfd07faf2bf2bc1817c4d2bef0416ce97d3a669ace5b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (smoke rising at the same time and place, some of which rises almost vertically and some of which drift almost horizontally, which does not conform to the phenomenon of smoke drifting with the wind).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05161", "filename": "22e4e454d760fb8ca7c6cfd07faf2bf2bc1817c4d2bef0416ce97d3a669ace5b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05162", "filename": "22e4e454d760fb8ca7c6cfd07faf2bf2bc1817c4d2bef0416ce97d3a669ace5b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is inconsistent (the sprayed material sometimes rises and sometimes falls back, which is contradictory).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05163", "filename": "22e4e454d760fb8ca7c6cfd07faf2bf2bc1817c4d2bef0416ce97d3a669ace5b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05164", "filename": "23b3a0ee3784cc7fdbcf6a908118f887992dcf6900b809c187f9f9b2f619877b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall lack of realism (the color of the fluid changes back and forth when it is stirred. The wrinkles behind the stirrer during stirring are inconsistent with the texture of the fluid in the bowl).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05165", "filename": "23b3a0ee3784cc7fdbcf6a908118f887992dcf6900b809c187f9f9b2f619877b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is that the time sequence is continuous (a stirrer in the bowl continuously rotates the fluid, while an orange area in the upper part of the bowl continuously reciprocates, and the motion patterns conflict with each other).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05166", "filename": "23b3a0ee3784cc7fdbcf6a908118f887992dcf6900b809c187f9f9b2f619877b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05167", "filename": "50feb246ebe6eba69d76525e94f8ab01d846a78e107515ec1a7c85cd81b2dcef_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (the duck is swimming throughout the video, but its feet are not paddling, yet it is able to swim on calm water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05168", "filename": "50feb246ebe6eba69d76525e94f8ab01d846a78e107515ec1a7c85cd81b2dcef_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the ripples created by the duck swimming in the water in the entire video are too regular, unlike the chaotic feeling of the wake and traveling waves created by a duck swimming in reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05169", "filename": "50feb246ebe6eba69d76525e94f8ab01d846a78e107515ec1a7c85cd81b2dcef_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05170", "filename": "50feb246ebe6eba69d76525e94f8ab01d846a78e107515ec1a7c85cd81b2dcef_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05171", "filename": "51a1a11c50fb647ce4f9e15c62ae79fbd92fc0581b90f4acc464af56109cc2e7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the bubbles in the video should move in the direction of the airflow, but they are spinning in the air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05172", "filename": "51a1a11c50fb647ce4f9e15c62ae79fbd92fc0581b90f4acc464af56109cc2e7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Cause and effect (The shape of the bubbles will be constantly fine-tuned due to the difference in internal and external air pressure and surface tension, but the color texture on the bubbles in the image is too stable. There is no bubble bursting due to thinning, nor is there a color gradient due to changes in thickness.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05173", "filename": "51a1a11c50fb647ce4f9e15c62ae79fbd92fc0581b90f4acc464af56109cc2e7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (the shape of the bubble is constantly fine-tuned due to the pressure difference between the inside and outside and the surface tension, but the color and texture of the bubble in the video are too stable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05174", "filename": "51a1a11c50fb647ce4f9e15c62ae79fbd92fc0581b90f4acc464af56109cc2e7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time is continuous (at 4.9 seconds, the white line below the balloon suddenly disappears, and the bubbles in the picture are moving very fast, which shows that the wind is strong in the environment, but the trees in the background do not sway and remain still. The pictures do not correspond to each other and give people a sense of splicing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05177", "filename": "52b538a0f9d08831f92319bf7b49370a0c2f44a2c6ecb75b0fe258a497f2883f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.6s, the black debris below the hammer suddenly disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05178", "filename": "52b538a0f9d08831f92319bf7b49370a0c2f44a2c6ecb75b0fe258a497f2883f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.1s, the hammer in the hand suddenly deforms, and from 1.1s to 5.8s, the object being hit is not destroyed, but a large number of fragments appear out of thin air on the object being hit).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05179", "filename": "52b538a0f9d08831f92319bf7b49370a0c2f44a2c6ecb75b0fe258a497f2883f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (from 0.8s to 5s, white powder appears out of thin air under the silver object in the hand, and at 3.8s, the silver object in the hand suddenly passes through the iron buckle under the silver object).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05180", "filename": "52e4145aff90cfa45355439f8259f27d70e866af89918f5ba74e275c2df27f60_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (there are obvious color bands at the junction of blue and orange-yellow in the sky, lacking the softness of gradation, and the yellow saturation of the clouds is too high, presenting an unreal plastic feel).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05181", "filename": "52e4145aff90cfa45355439f8259f27d70e866af89918f5ba74e275c2df27f60_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (Throughout the video, the sun in the sky is constantly setting, and the sunlight conditions in the sky are constantly changing, but the color of the clouds does not gradually change before suddenly becoming dark).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05182", "filename": "52e4145aff90cfa45355439f8259f27d70e866af89918f5ba74e275c2df27f60_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05183", "filename": "52ee4af6be931b47b4058c33d641f07f9762e6e44507f6f6a356e212cf34437f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Cause and effect (bubbles are constantly rising to the surface of the water in the four cups throughout the video. The water should be shaking due to the bubbles, but the water in the four cups remains calm.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05184", "filename": "52ee4af6be931b47b4058c33d641f07f9762e6e44507f6f6a356e212cf34437f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (between 1.1s and 5.8s, a large number of bubbles suddenly appear in the liquid in the four cups without any external influence, and the amount of liquid in the cups increases out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05185", "filename": "52ee4af6be931b47b4058c33d641f07f9762e6e44507f6f6a356e212cf34437f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05186", "filename": "52ee4af6be931b47b4058c33d641f07f9762e6e44507f6f6a356e212cf34437f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (from 1.2s to 8s, after a black object falls into the green and transparent liquids, a large number of bubbles suddenly appear in the water glass, but a large number of bubbles also suddenly appear in the red and blue liquids even though no black substance has fallen into them).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05187", "filename": "53c2eb51ccefdfef1ccd54e5c307d52978298cbd1f57c85555f46911bb0d98a6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (1.1s-5s) as the character kneads the dough, the fingers of the left hand are constantly twisted and deformed.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05188", "filename": "53c2eb51ccefdfef1ccd54e5c307d52978298cbd1f57c85555f46911bb0d98a6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the white object in the entire video suddenly deforms after being picked up).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05189", "filename": "53c2eb51ccefdfef1ccd54e5c307d52978298cbd1f57c85555f46911bb0d98a6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.2s, the white object in the hand suddenly deforms, and at 7.7s, the dough suddenly changes shape when flipped).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05190", "filename": "53cf13c7f08421ea7f9ebdaf1cc5f07f888b37f23c579169d857cfb56adc321d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.2 seconds, the bullet did not make contact with the object, but the object in the video suddenly breaks).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05191", "filename": "53cf13c7f08421ea7f9ebdaf1cc5f07f888b37f23c579169d857cfb56adc321d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (a bullet fired straight at 0.9s suddenly starts spinning in the air without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05192", "filename": "53cf13c7f08421ea7f9ebdaf1cc5f07f888b37f23c579169d857cfb56adc321d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (in the entire video, after a solid object breaks, the fragments produced are in a liquid state, and the object breaks before the bullet hits it at 0.1 seconds, which does not conform to the laws of force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05193", "filename": "53d8d78b76b71e1006c8e386f39250a4c45264e15f870d0c5a5a44bc08bc8a65_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall visual impression is off (the lights in the video are very bright, but the light and shadow projections on the hands and the table are very unnatural, and there is no transition between light and dark or shadow layers that conform to the laws of physics).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_05194", "filename": "53d8d78b76b71e1006c8e386f39250a4c45264e15f870d0c5a5a44bc08bc8a65_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.6s, the silver object on the side of the lamp suddenly disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05195", "filename": "53d8d78b76b71e1006c8e386f39250a4c45264e15f870d0c5a5a44bc08bc8a65_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the lamp in the hand suddenly deforms at 0.3s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05196", "filename": "54a34c343b6491ceb6f1984d97f536f4175833a8e193d230643306b0a868277d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05197", "filename": "36735f8a8561b3c84eb8c1ec0bf2eda884bb0329189ab0abc1e1ecc289c82ea1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical behavior (0.5s: after being impacted by water, a large piece of the can is directly missing without any natural deformation or tearing process; 1.3s-5.8s: the amount of liquid splashed out of the can far exceeds the actual volume of the can itself)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05198", "filename": "37607f53f1fbde3e1e241d51401d722f99010b141d0af65d305d979597e915ab_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the ring-shaped feather lamp itself has no light source, but it creates obvious halos and reflections on the wall, ceiling, and its own feather structure; the light does not have a natural transition between light and dark, the brightness of the inner and outer rings of the lamp is completely the same, and there is no realistic feather shadow layer below)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05199", "filename": "37607f53f1fbde3e1e241d51401d722f99010b141d0af65d305d979597e915ab_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (feathers are porous, gap-filled solid materials; the light emitted by the lamp will inevitably shine through the gaps in the feathers, creating diffused light rather than making the lampshade shine evenly). Time continuity (at the 1.5s camera cut, the sky background outside the curtain changes abruptly from blue to white without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05200", "filename": "37607f53f1fbde3e1e241d51401d722f99010b141d0af65d305d979597e915ab_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (during the camera movement from 3.2s to 5s, the ring-shaped feather light rotates on its own without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05201", "filename": "37607f53f1fbde3e1e241d51401d722f99010b141d0af65d305d979597e915ab_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at the moment the camera zooms out at 4.4s, the ring-shaped feather light suddenly brightens and turns yellow without any user interaction).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05202", "filename": "38062ed8866218346df3a13b821783778dea3c702ca254c894947ce7fba46dd8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Physical behavior (at low temperatures, the liquid film of soap bubbles will quickly freeze and become brittle, and due to the expansion stress of the ice and the supporting force of the tree branches, it will break before freezing).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05203", "filename": "38062ed8866218346df3a13b821783778dea3c702ca254c894947ce7fba46dd8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the liquid film of a soap bubble is very thin and will burst instantly when it comes into contact with the tip of a branch, but in the video, the bubble not only did not burst after contacting the branch, but also froze directly on the branch tip).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05204", "filename": "38062ed8866218346df3a13b821783778dea3c702ca254c894947ce7fba46dd8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the snowflake suddenly changes from transparent to snow-white in 1.2 seconds; the snowflake floats in mid-air without any support)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05207", "filename": "38453e40b365798f42b775a88272867f16ce742a7dd8ee42ac7925e9c51410a2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05208", "filename": "38453e40b365798f42b775a88272867f16ce742a7dd8ee42ac7925e9c51410a2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the basketball suddenly disappears after 7.7 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05209", "filename": "38710c9da03c76794abacc403f6ad3a8d148fb9415078a489333bfebde040c63_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (0.9s: When the hydraulic press just comes into contact with the cucumber, the cucumber automatically flips once without any force; 3s: The metal pressure head of the hydraulic press is very hard, but it exhibits a soft deformation state when squeezing the cucumber)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05210", "filename": "38710c9da03c76794abacc403f6ad3a8d148fb9415078a489333bfebde040c63_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (1.1s: the hydraulic press does not contact the cucumber, and the cucumber is split in two; 5.6s: the hydraulic press head suddenly shortens).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05211", "filename": "38710c9da03c76794abacc403f6ad3a8d148fb9415078a489333bfebde040c63_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Causality (at the moment the frozen cucumber was crushed by the hydraulic press at 0.8s, fresh cucumber slices were exposed instead of frozen fragments and solid tissue).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05212", "filename": "38710c9da03c76794abacc403f6ad3a8d148fb9415078a489333bfebde040c63_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Overall intuition (1.3s: The cucumber surface has only a small amount of thin ice, but when the hydraulic press squeezes it, large chunks of ice suddenly break off; 2.7s: The cucumber is squeezed by the hydraulic press and is divided into four equal sections; 3.8s: A small amount of cucumber is squeezed out to produce a mud-like substance far exceeding its original volume, and cucumber mud is generated out of thin air at the hydraulic press head)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05213", "filename": "038783fa63bb973ff30938bc40044c38df83d70d73e8117a728b95e724b1488c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the bubble stretches and deforms significantly but never bursts).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05214", "filename": "038783fa63bb973ff30938bc40044c38df83d70d73e8117a728b95e724b1488c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (1.8s-5.8s, without any external force, the bubble suddenly changes from an irregular shape to a smooth shape and expands on its own, becoming larger and larger)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05215", "filename": "038783fa63bb973ff30938bc40044c38df83d70d73e8117a728b95e724b1488c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall impression (the movement of the bubbles is stiff and unnatural, and the colors suddenly change to bright colors without any transition; the bubble in the upper left corner remains stationary).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05216", "filename": "038783fa63bb973ff30938bc40044c38df83d70d73e8117a728b95e724b1488c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (two bubbles merge into one in 1.5 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05220", "filename": "42084a0f225b896537e84a539e69fd2936f03a374f3233643eb0d29b5c8d523a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall impression (the sparks from the explosion formed an overly regular mushroom cloud shape); Time continuity (the sparks suddenly disappeared after 3.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05221", "filename": "42084a0f225b896537e84a539e69fd2936f03a374f3233643eb0d29b5c8d523a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall intuition (1s-5s) suggests that an extremely small explosive device could not possibly produce a spark far exceeding its size; the smoke produced exhibits an overly regular mushroom cloud shape.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05222", "filename": "42367d383f26e7c2dd0b124b554c2c217be9fd2fde435bf423084a730b388260_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the bubble is violently shaken but does not break at all; at 0.7s, two bubbles naturally merge into one without any external force)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05223", "filename": "42367d383f26e7c2dd0b124b554c2c217be9fd2fde435bf423084a730b388260_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (during merging, the smaller bubbles below were not deformed or burst by the weight of the larger bubble above; instead, they directly penetrated and merged into a single large bubble; during the movement of the bubble, the colored stripes on the surface did not flow due to changes in the film thickness, and the color distribution remained static throughout).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05224", "filename": "42367d383f26e7c2dd0b124b554c2c217be9fd2fde435bf423084a730b388260_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the bubble did not flatten into a sphere due to gravity after leaving the liquid surface, but remained a perfect circle throughout; the colored stripes on the surface remained stationary, whereas the thin film of a normal bubble would change thickness due to airflow and gravity, and the colored patterns would move accordingly).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05225", "filename": "42784a69d99c13e836e2c40bb60f12c756a2451f5698ccf4c55c09b4588a13fe_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05226", "filename": "42784a69d99c13e836e2c40bb60f12c756a2451f5698ccf4c55c09b4588a13fe_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The flickering and jumping at the bottom of the bottle occurs continuously (0.3s-2.3s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05236", "filename": "cd44f2eb9b38e6ea350e81f1ef8dbe5e2173925bdc9fb8b38841192328bab35a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the clouds, sun and light in the sky remain still as time goes on throughout the video, and the ripples on the water are too regular).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05237", "filename": "cd44f2eb9b38e6ea350e81f1ef8dbe5e2173925bdc9fb8b38841192328bab35a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (throughout the entire video, the sunlight remains in the same direction without changing due to the changing cloud cover, and the sea surface is too blurry and has a grainy appearance).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05238", "filename": "cd44f2eb9b38e6ea350e81f1ef8dbe5e2173925bdc9fb8b38841192328bab35a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05239", "filename": "cd58e9dd6600107dc364a9ba08e22e0a7b92873fdb80c74f565b4a0e36054931_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (at 2.3 seconds, a large number of burned tissues suddenly appear).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05240", "filename": "cd58e9dd6600107dc364a9ba08e22e0a7b92873fdb80c74f565b4a0e36054931_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (at 4.6s, the yellow smoke that was initially emitted suddenly turned into white smoke, and the burning material below did not burn).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05241", "filename": "cd58e9dd6600107dc364a9ba08e22e0a7b92873fdb80c74f565b4a0e36054931_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05242", "filename": "cd25452e4aa799bf405006cec1ca509d92e2b0b88afa183a7a0b972cedcffa6d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video content: Physical behavior (the paper was continuously burning at the washing machine opening throughout the video, but the opening was never blackened or ignited, which does not conform to the principle of the flammability of plastic).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05243", "filename": "cd25452e4aa799bf405006cec1ca509d92e2b0b88afa183a7a0b972cedcffa6d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05244", "filename": "cd25452e4aa799bf405006cec1ca509d92e2b0b88afa183a7a0b972cedcffa6d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (at 1.3s, there is no flame burning under the paper, but it suddenly catches fire) (from 1.6s to the end, the position of the burning paper does not change, which is inconsistent with the flammability of paper).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05245", "filename": "cddc69ace7f6d28d1ab03d0444b1f22411a01d7adc7504113e1958ad53dd2e2f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1 seconds, the five-pointed star on the Ferris wheel suddenly twists and deforms).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05246", "filename": "cddc69ace7f6d28d1ab03d0444b1f22411a01d7adc7504113e1958ad53dd2e2f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (in the entire video, when the cable car on the Ferris wheel turns to the left, the cable car disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05247", "filename": "cddc69ace7f6d28d1ab03d0444b1f22411a01d7adc7504113e1958ad53dd2e2f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05248", "filename": "cddc69ace7f6d28d1ab03d0444b1f22411a01d7adc7504113e1958ad53dd2e2f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The video stutters at 4.1s, and the houses next to the disc appear distorted. (At 6.7s, the screen, which was rotating counterclockwise, suddenly starts rotating clockwise, with a missing transition.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05249", "filename": "cdfa50b45d657fa9c0f873be41cb59765eee78ab6bdd13559b625c1b8f3b90d0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05250", "filename": "cdfa50b45d657fa9c0f873be41cb59765eee78ab6bdd13559b625c1b8f3b90d0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 3.2 seconds, the originally flowing lake surface suddenly turns completely into ice, and the intermediate transition process is missing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05251", "filename": "cdfa50b45d657fa9c0f873be41cb59765eee78ab6bdd13559b625c1b8f3b90d0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (a large amount of white smoke suddenly appears on the water surface at 2.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05252", "filename": "cdfb8924f40923b73597cf7c19492b30ba401325e9d46755effe188535ecb9f9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1.9 seconds, a large amount of white smoke appears out of nowhere on the intact tile on the left, and there is no burning on the left).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05253", "filename": "cdfb8924f40923b73597cf7c19492b30ba401325e9d46755effe188535ecb9f9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (1s - ends: After the open flame has burned out, thick smoke suddenly billows from the roof)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05254", "filename": "cdfb8924f40923b73597cf7c19492b30ba401325e9d46755effe188535ecb9f9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05255", "filename": "ce01b05add5d1a003b913f727aab440e89e8920928d481f8614222e37b58fc8e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the paper is constantly burning, but the paper above the flames is never ignited, and the burning position on the paper does not change, which is inconsistent with the flammability of paper).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05256", "filename": "ce01b05add5d1a003b913f727aab440e89e8920928d481f8614222e37b58fc8e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the paper above 1.4s-3.1s is rapidly carbonized, but it is never ignited) (at 5s, the burned paper does not turn into ash, but suddenly turns into black particles that fall down).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05257", "filename": "96423ab3817c4ffd6c05495801990180afad98b7fa895b37c91bab9177c39c4c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the water droplets in the image slide down the glass with long tails, like tadpoles, unlike real water droplets sliding down glass).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05258", "filename": "96423ab3817c4ffd6c05495801990180afad98b7fa895b37c91bab9177c39c4c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the entire video, three small streams of water flow upwards along the glass from the bottom, defying gravity.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05259", "filename": "97123d0e71b884cd48989647b00bab8539bdbdfbc9ffc743cfd53c14d5b01159_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (the entire video crystal displays a radial, needle-like crystal structure against a black background, and the crystal is constantly flickering.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05260", "filename": "97123d0e71b884cd48989647b00bab8539bdbdfbc9ffc743cfd53c14d5b01159_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (the crystals in the video change from silvery-white to a mixture of pink, green, blue, and yellow colors).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05268", "filename": "99697ca9c93dcfe64dc20cb336a7e74c8f1b86cf528449a2d40c0bc72f3eae92_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual effect is abnormal (the movement of the water in the image does not resemble real water flow; natural water flow varies in volume, and the waves and ripples on the water in the image are too fixed, lacking the feeling of random splashing and natural branching).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05269", "filename": "99697ca9c93dcfe64dc20cb336a7e74c8f1b86cf528449a2d40c0bc72f3eae92_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05270", "filename": "99697ca9c93dcfe64dc20cb336a7e74c8f1b86cf528449a2d40c0bc72f3eae92_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05271", "filename": "127466b3e7ec2ddd0f18273b61cccc841afe61a82e9e8e35b85720c001ade654_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (between 2s and 2.5s in the video, the bubbles rising in the water appear to shrink without any external force, whereas they should actually be getting larger or remaining essentially unchanged.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05272", "filename": "127466b3e7ec2ddd0f18273b61cccc841afe61a82e9e8e35b85720c001ade654_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows a continuous flow of time (from 0.3s to 4.4s, the water surface forms a vortex without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05273", "filename": "178874f84d6f180439cb7a6293557a09358f87a495347897b134cfbd3217a1d8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual presentation is abnormal (the video shows a localized downpour, but the image appears to show fog drifting randomly downwards; in reality, it should appear to be falling vertically).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05274", "filename": "178874f84d6f180439cb7a6293557a09358f87a495347897b134cfbd3217a1d8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.9s, the clouds suddenly glow and several clusters of glowing rain fall; at 3.1s, a large patch of fog suddenly falls to the ground from the clouds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05278", "filename": "212232e747cd1e3f91adcfb879d7120b5afaf5be6224362cedd7f0c749f6421c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.9s in the video, the white strip-shaped object to the left of the diamond suddenly disappears; throughout the video, the pear-shaped diamond, after rotating, transforms into a round brilliant-cut diamond with symmetrical geometric facets.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05279", "filename": "212232e747cd1e3f91adcfb879d7120b5afaf5be6224362cedd7f0c749f6421c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the original pink, purple, yellow and other colorful reflective diamonds suddenly disappear at 0 seconds, leaving only the original blue and white. Throughout the video, the diamonds continuously emit refracted light without any light source.)", "glitch_severity": 44, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05280", "filename": "212232e747cd1e3f91adcfb879d7120b5afaf5be6224362cedd7f0c749f6421c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05281", "filename": "212232e747cd1e3f91adcfb879d7120b5afaf5be6224362cedd7f0c749f6421c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.4 seconds in the video, the pear-shaped diamond turns into a loose diamond).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05282", "filename": "222883f077cadb7ba85987bc77052362e0d3b05e5d2d96492bd83ea05e99c372_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.9s, a white object suddenly flies up between two logs above without any external force, and at 1.1s, light suddenly appears on the logs).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05283", "filename": "222883f077cadb7ba85987bc77052362e0d3b05e5d2d96492bd83ea05e99c372_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (from 0s to 4.8s in the video, the frost on the lower half of the log spreads upwards; at 4.5s, the frost in the footage disappears partially without any external force, while some floats into the air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05284", "filename": "222883f077cadb7ba85987bc77052362e0d3b05e5d2d96492bd83ea05e99c372_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05285", "filename": "222883f077cadb7ba85987bc77052362e0d3b05e5d2d96492bd83ea05e99c372_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (snow suddenly appears above the log at 1.4s in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05286", "filename": "234814b435562b5a2f60c1e594d5cc15c350ec1e49065693a7c5fcffd80a49f9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 1.3s to 1.9s, a long white object in the right hand passes through the ring; at 2.6s, a blue light suddenly appears above the ring).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05287", "filename": "f00b29a02120b1df16392e2da21064e84c0a8234ada9cff549051d161cc3e7ff_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (Under conditions where the camera does not change direction and there is no force or external interference, the ice melts, but the amount of water melted does not increase, while the volume of the ice keeps decreasing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05288", "filename": "f00b29a02120b1df16392e2da21064e84c0a8234ada9cff549051d161cc3e7ff_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera shift, the ice cube suddenly shrinks at 1.6 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05289", "filename": "f00b29a02120b1df16392e2da21064e84c0a8234ada9cff549051d161cc3e7ff_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05290", "filename": "f00b29a02120b1df16392e2da21064e84c0a8234ada9cff549051d161cc3e7ff_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the ice block in the image is in an environment without external light source illumination, yet it emits light on its own. Moreover, the light emission is uniform, without any reasonable light source).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05291", "filename": "f0d6012fc7e6f4ee1648aa6397134bce06c8d593a50510db6c36139df85baea2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal picture: continuous time (at 1.4 seconds, the TV exploded, but the TV body was completely undamaged, remaining intact without any cracks or component damage).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05292", "filename": "f0d6012fc7e6f4ee1648aa6397134bce06c8d593a50510db6c36139df85baea2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: The time sequence is not continuous (the smoke from the TV explosion lacks the natural fluffiness and chaotic movement of real explosion smoke. The overall shape is too regular, the drift trajectory is stiff, and there is no variation in the density of the smoke).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05293", "filename": "f0d6012fc7e6f4ee1648aa6397134bce06c8d593a50510db6c36139df85baea2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 1.5 seconds, the upper left part of the debris from the TV explosion suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05294", "filename": "f0d6012fc7e6f4ee1648aa6397134bce06c8d593a50510db6c36139df85baea2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal picture: Time continuity (the screen shattering after the TV exploded is very unnatural, the cracks are too regular, without a natural sense of irregular branching and diffusion, and the edges of the shattered parts do not have a rough texture).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05295", "filename": "f0d8714cf3fffd276e49439577e570e054940ee6c57c959d5c199310a2aec9d4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is not continuous (the flames in the visuals only appear at the top and bottom, and the shape of the flames is too regular and uniform, without the natural jumping, spreading and shape changes of real flames).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05296", "filename": "f0d8714cf3fffd276e49439577e570e054940ee6c57c959d5c199310a2aec9d4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (Under the premise that the camera does not change and there is no external force or interference, a large number of flames suddenly burst out from above the brick at 1.4 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05297", "filename": "f0d8714cf3fffd276e49439577e570e054940ee6c57c959d5c199310a2aec9d4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the flame shape in the image is too regular and uniform, lacking the natural jumping, spreading, and shape changes of real flames).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05298", "filename": "f0f92e4f8200e6abc9f2d71d2d42e9ea8d2acd0a4dadc063fba8ea5880b2210a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the visuals: The timing is uninterrupted (when the flames are blown by the wind, the directions of the individual flames are chaotic and there is no unified direction).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05299", "filename": "f0f92e4f8200e6abc9f2d71d2d42e9ea8d2acd0a4dadc063fba8ea5880b2210a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without camera changes or external interference, a flame suddenly appears in the upper left corner of the screen at 4.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05300", "filename": "f0f92e4f8200e6abc9f2d71d2d42e9ea8d2acd0a4dadc063fba8ea5880b2210a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05303", "filename": "f2bd8e3ae36c50cf397f9353f3c52fcda5b032efbe2a92f3a9888d4d9059447f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the bubbles created by melting butter disappear out of nowhere at 3.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05304", "filename": "f2bd8e3ae36c50cf397f9353f3c52fcda5b032efbe2a92f3a9888d4d9059447f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Continuous time (with a sufficiently high heat, the butter in the pot is continuously heated, but it does not melt or soften at all, remaining in its initial state without any change)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05305", "filename": "f1bc54cec06a77fc6ff3ab97b10da5dc38c582fcae6c3b30b5301a29b4b2ce1b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05306", "filename": "f1bc54cec06a77fc6ff3ab97b10da5dc38c582fcae6c3b30b5301a29b4b2ce1b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (without external force or interference, the popcorn moves downwards from the pot on its own at 2.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05307", "filename": "f1bc54cec06a77fc6ff3ab97b10da5dc38c582fcae6c3b30b5301a29b4b2ce1b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the corn suddenly turns into beans at 3.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05308", "filename": "f1bc54cec06a77fc6ff3ab97b10da5dc38c582fcae6c3b30b5301a29b4b2ce1b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Time continuity (the surface of the water flowing from the instrument is excessively smooth, without any natural ripples or splashes, nor any natural dynamism or shape changes as the water flows down).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05309", "filename": "f1a705e41ef02233566600293f1b1df1ed03592a00b0a74dde9278e1d16a7783_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (under the premise of no external force or object and no camera change, the gas ejected by the object instantly turns into liquid at 2.4s without any transition phase)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05310", "filename": "f1a705e41ef02233566600293f1b1df1ed03592a00b0a74dde9278e1d16a7783_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (at 2.5s, without any camera movement, water stains suddenly appear behind the mop).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05311", "filename": "f1a705e41ef02233566600293f1b1df1ed03592a00b0a74dde9278e1d16a7783_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (In an environment without external interference, the smoke in the image suddenly increases in speed, becomes chaotic and disorderly, and lacks any natural fluffiness or smoothness. The surface is also abnormally stiff and smooth, without normal gradation and layering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05314", "filename": "f02fec8a907cde0d01f9b8caf319d1027d6562b2a85afae4a91e8ab65b1f32fd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05315", "filename": "f02fec8a907cde0d01f9b8caf319d1027d6562b2a85afae4a91e8ab65b1f32fd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the clouds disappear out of thin air at 4.6 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05316", "filename": "f02fec8a907cde0d01f9b8caf319d1027d6562b2a85afae4a91e8ab65b1f32fd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without changing camera angles, the sky color instantly changes from blue to red at 3.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05317", "filename": "P30_107_691_8884d85c528480a3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly occurred: (1.2s - 1.3s) The food in the pot disappeared into thin air.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05318", "filename": "P30_107_695_cfea7aa496bfa4f6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (from 2.11 to 6.6 seconds, yellow particles suddenly appear and increase from one to three; at 2.4 seconds, the food in the center of the pot disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05319", "filename": "P30_107_715_7dbe8d0d68775444_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (1.5s, the blue cup turns into a blue dishcloth).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05320", "filename": "P30_107_715_7dbe8d0d68775444_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scenes: Continuous time (0.3s: the sponge in the bowl disappears into thin air; 4.3s: there is no action of turning off the faucet or baffle the hose, the water suddenly stops flowing; 6.2s: the dishcloth disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05321", "filename": "P30_107_721_3a5a9a5bd0c4fb8f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: The timing is continuous (2.8s) as the rag and bowl pass through each other, violating the principle of impermeability. At 4.1s, the bowl is placed under a tap, water is flowing over it, but no water accumulates inside, and there's no sign of leaks or overflow; the water flow seems to vanish into thin air.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05322", "filename": "P30_107_721_3a5a9a5bd0c4fb8f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (there are bubbles in the pool, and water flows into the surface, but the surface does not ripple, and the bubbles are not washed away or broken. In the 2.2s footage, there is no action of pressing or hitting the plate, but the plate suddenly deforms without a slow bending or denting process, and there are no signs of force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05323", "filename": "P30_107_731_9f5c3b8089220f4e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time sequence is continuous (2.4s: the sponge inside the plate disappears out of thin air; 2.9s: the plate passes through the shelf, violating the principle that objects are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05324", "filename": "P30_107_745_4135eb23726394d0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is continuous (the spoon in the right hand disappears out of thin air in the 1.9s video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05325", "filename": "P30_107_793_d25b1e5ff2797bc5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_05326", "filename": "P30_107_813_538d8e8cce74b642_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (3.1s: water from the faucet hits the hand, but there is no water accumulation on the hand, nor is there any visible water dripping down; the water disappears into thin air, failing to demonstrate the visual effect of water hitting the hand in reality; 4.1s: there is no action of rinsing with water or wiping the cutting board with a cloth; the foam on the cutting board simply disappears and becomes clean, without any cleaning process.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05327", "filename": "P30_107_846_d1963f701df1167b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: (The rice in the scene is flickering, the light source and the camera are not changing, the rice suddenly alternates between bright and dark irregularly, and the color is also dark and light, without a gradual brightening and darkening process.) The egg is not being hit with anything or pressed to break the shell; it is being broken open with both hands.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05328", "filename": "P30_107_863_5d808505b1a0f304_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: (At 2.5 seconds, there was no processing action whatsoever; the spoon did not melt or dissolve, but simply turned into soy sauce out of thin air.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05329", "filename": "P30_107_863_5d808505b1a0f304_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal (the light source and camera angle remain unchanged, but the rice suddenly and irregularly alternates between bright and dark, with colors that fluctuate in color without a natural transition in brightness, and the flickering is abrupt and jarring).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05330", "filename": "P30_107_863_5d808505b1a0f304_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (3s the bowl held in the left hand disappears into thin air; 5.2s there is no action of twisting or prying open the soy sauce bottle cap, the cap does not slowly open or pop open, it opens directly by itself, without any force or movement).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05331", "filename": "P30_107_865_c066572da495a252_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: (In the 3.4s frame, there is no action of pouring liquid into the container, nor is there any other water supply, yet the amount of liquid in the container suddenly increases, and the liquid level does not rise slowly.)", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05332", "filename": "P30_107_865_c066572da495a252_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: (The light source and camera angle remain unchanged, but the rice suddenly and irregularly alternates between bright and dark, with colors that are sometimes dark and sometimes light, without a natural transition in brightness, and has a flickering effect, appearing harsh and abrupt.)", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05333", "filename": "P30_107_880_e2e1437729af5577_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time frame is continuous (the video shows eggs being stirred in 3.9 seconds, without any additional action of beating eggs or pouring egg liquid, yet the amount of egg liquid in the bowl inexplicably increases without any replenishment process).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05334", "filename": "P30_107_880_e2e1437729af5577_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomalies were observed: (At 2.7 seconds, eggs were being stirred, but there were no additional actions of beating eggs or pouring egg mixture. However, the amount of egg mixture in the bowl inexplicably increased without any replenishment. At 6 seconds, rice fell out of the spoon and did not fall normally. It neither hovered in the air nor followed a natural falling trajectory.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05335", "filename": "P30_108_28_daedb9a67e92b52d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: The time is continuous (0.3s, there is no hand-switching or handing over of the rag in the scene. The rag that was originally in the right hand suddenly appears in the left hand without any movement or handover process. The connection between the body movement and the holding of the object is extremely abrupt. 2.9s, the rag appears out of thin air. When it falls, a blue rag appears out of thin air. 3.5s, the pink rag disappears out of thin air and then a basin appears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05336", "filename": "P30_108_36_6eb242985d5e93df_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: In a continuous 0.3s frame, there is no squeezing, pressing, or bumping of the cup, nor any external impact such as water flow, yet the cup suddenly deforms without gradually denting or swelling. The process of bulging shows no signs of stress, completely contradicting the cup's physical characteristics. Water from the faucet continuously flows into the sink, without any leakage or overflow, yet the water level in the sink remains unchanged; the water disappears as if it were flowing in.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05337", "filename": "P30_108_36_6eb242985d5e93df_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The sequence of events (6.6 seconds) shows no action of changing props or picking up a brush; the original rag simply transforms into a brush without any change in shape or replacement process.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05338", "filename": "P30_108_36_6eb242985d5e93df_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (0s there is no action of changing props or operating in the scene, the original rag suddenly turns into a bowl, there is no complete transformation process, 2.7s a lot of foam appears out of nowhere in the pool).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05339", "filename": "P30_108_43_9930d05ead378dab_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: In the 1.5s frame, the two bowls are not squeezed or melted; they simply merge together after touching, without any deformation or adhesion process, which is completely inconsistent with the physical characteristics of a rigid bowl.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05340", "filename": "P30_108_43_9930d05ead378dab_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: (In the 5.5s footage, there is no hand touching, water flow impact, or object hitting the bowl, yet the bowl moves on its own without any starting or movement process. In the 4.2s footage, there is no action of changing cutlery or picking up the bowl; the original plate directly becomes a bowl without any bending of the plate's edge or change in shape.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05341", "filename": "P30_108_84_93c1012d7aaba020_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (5.1 seconds) and a (sieve-like) foreign object appears out of nowhere in the container being cleaned.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05342", "filename": "P30_108_110_28d16962eb3583b2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time frame is continuous (within 1.1 seconds, there is no manual turning or pressing of the faucet, no external force touching it, the faucet turns on by itself, and there is no process of the switch turning or the valve opening).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05343", "filename": "P30_108_118_a70ea358fdea15c1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (in the 3.3s video, the pink cloth and spoon are not squeezed or melted, but directly merge into each other without any deformation or adhesion process, which completely violates the physical properties of the soft cloth and the hard spoon).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05344", "filename": "P30_108_118_a70ea358fdea15c1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: continuous time (there is no pushing or hitting of the faucet in the scene, but the faucet moves to the left by itself without any starting or moving process. The water from the faucet keeps rushing into the pool, but the pool water is not rippled at all. It is abnormally calm throughout the whole process.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05345", "filename": "P30_108_156_7dbd4855fdb07ca7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (there is no water running from a tap, water being stirred by hand, or other external interference in the footage, yet the surface of the pool is shaking and rippled on its own).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05346", "filename": "P30_108_156_7dbd4855fdb07ca7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is the lack of continuity in time (when the thumb touches the green cloth, there is no pressing motion; it simply blends into the cloth without any visible outline of the thumb or any deformation of the cloth. The contact between the limb and the cleaning tool is extremely strange).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05347", "filename": "a01e2d8d326e35751733a0970f7c8b25a4950861ba9dcc5c7ddc4e2349389cea_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (distorted physical behavior, the rhythm of the branches swaying in the upper left corner is rigid and repetitive, lacking the randomness and dynamism of natural wind movement, the movements are mechanical and do not conform to the logic of real wind effects)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05348", "filename": "a01e2d8d326e35751733a0970f7c8b25a4950861ba9dcc5c7ddc4e2349389cea_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (the water's trajectory is a single, regular pattern, lacking natural turbulence, stratification, and splashing effects; the flow is regular and mechanical, contradicting the physical characteristics of fluid movement in reality, resulting in a severe lack of visual realism).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05349", "filename": "a2b6156f0c4f108fd7ae9faf7abaed237cad292f1092707bb3a03ff6c69022ef_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall realism is abnormal (only one hand is suspended in the air, and the arm that should be connected is missing); Physical behavior (after the sparkling water is filled with water, the bubbles do not follow the laws of buoyancy and gravity and fall along the glass wall, but remain stiffly in place).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05350", "filename": "a2c2648c1109f395fcfe68fc86ca156843337d75b4333ed0f21eed36064e169f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (it's impossible for the figure in the image to cause significant deformation of the sheet metal with a light touch of their hand).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05351", "filename": "a3ac304792f8e46063eb8aa4dbf80b0c4f3b81eae7eb12a831cc6f98c6cea6d9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the brilliant moment of fireworks blooming in the night sky did not create a synchronized light and shadow reflection on the lake surface; the water only reflected scattered spots of light after the fireworks dissipated).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05352", "filename": "a5f306603b17359110b64f7c01ded4987f03e30169fb8be196d096c0fc092009_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05353", "filename": "a6bb0ab9116d711c73cbab02641193105bd2ee7d5990b57caddd0188003ba912_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior (real bubbles reflect ambient light, but the bottom of this image only shows uniform white light, lacking details of ambient reflection and the light and shadow distortion that should be present on the bubble surface.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05354", "filename": "a6bb0ab9116d711c73cbab02641193105bd2ee7d5990b57caddd0188003ba912_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Physical behavior (the sudden change in the color of the bubbles in the image does not follow the law of film thickness change; the bubble film does not break after landing from 4.6s to 8s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05358", "filename": "a7b5cf04a8c7dbe20e622b1086aa5037dc08dbb9286cc1f7acb0ad8aad9d0dc2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (two rubber bands merge into one in the 4.7s-8s frame); overall lack of realism (the rubber bands appear stuck together and dragged like clay, resulting in a lack of visual realism).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05359", "filename": "a8c072fd498b978602b0a0fcbd5523a57167732bcc69f1e691e21fbc97e42e4f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (0.7s-2.3s) The small steel ball itself has no adsorption properties, but it exhibits abrupt adsorption and speed changes while rolling, and the overall movement is stiff.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05360", "filename": "a8cffe72c3091f5aba63b4f3eb3c535bdec8be1188474a864330c64da9338c6a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the water in the pot is not boiling, but a large amount of water droplets have condensed on the lid; from 1s to 2.3s, some water droplets slide unnaturally and unevenly down the lid).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05361", "filename": "a9ac81e3759063866319e740571ee968411075e481bb2b4109a16e241f444ac8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Physical behavior (2.4s When the yacht was violently hit by a giant wave, its direction of travel did not change at all, and there was no dynamic behavior of force deviation; 5.5s-8s When it directly collided with the reef, the hull did not show any damage).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05363", "filename": "a9f00967fc84763d19671658b11982270b9f0b4512e1ecf30b96a1ed5d67f024_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (0.5s-4.2s: The stick leans against the wall, and its position does not move at all, but the position of its shadow on the wall changes for no reason; 0s-1s: The shortest stick shakes and moves in position without any force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05364", "filename": "a30e4ec6c75ff1db7f267fcc4380eb691050e72e8114dbe455501ebf8c85e25e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the plant roots behind the small fish suddenly disappear between 4.3s and 8s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05368", "filename": "a55f89010997db46a4e38fa29480f667040ddb1439bb9e6e5dd7022a4fabeb36_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical behavior (0s-0.6s: debris falls from the sky before the house explodes; no debris flies out during the collapse of the house, but debris falls from the sky; throughout the entire process, a piece of debris is suspended in the air without any force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05369", "filename": "a70bab5820dc3dbebab26e2c9846140bc7ea18be8215288c3f363bb4a087442b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (smoke suddenly appears on the left-hand rock at 3.8s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05370", "filename": "a96f5ac706a5fa877f04346d515926fa3b9c7fee5f4788aeb392e20775e6f66a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05371", "filename": "a140eac8f2f6684f68365b013efa50b908a9b44f58bfa8a544d473bf1b0b30b7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the object rotates automatically without any external force throughout the entire process, which is impossible in real life).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05372", "filename": "a140eac8f2f6684f68365b013efa50b908a9b44f58bfa8a544d473bf1b0b30b7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image; physical behavior (the outline in the middle of the prism is transparent and cannot be observed at 0.9s, but suddenly becomes clear after the prism rotates at 1.6s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05373", "filename": "a182da47014398968fab46adf12bf8b8629a9aff1e1a17938060745b5fffffe3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (5.2s, the train originally came out from the right but suddenly came out from the left).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05374", "filename": "a191aed5a51301b1164ea4ae1ef2577016c02a39c1c8d3cd711d3669f742b66f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (multiple beams of light appeared on the glass above the object from 0.8s to 1.6s; the luminous point disappeared without any physical intervention at 3.2s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05375", "filename": "a341d7f4f01b36f968abdf2cf194894aa22229cfef5170a3f3360b943595e934_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (smoke suddenly appears at the bottom of the 1.1s video and rises upwards).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05376", "filename": "a351f065b46af9a60c0dff79ae831e338852b2d8ef209d5a31e62763617f59e8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05377", "filename": "a487a710a81d879d3b3e3c05fb12d6248fda7d464b307246e7f568c558572a1f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (1.7s, the blue part on the toy turns yellow after the water ripples).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05378", "filename": "a487a710a81d879d3b3e3c05fb12d6248fda7d464b307246e7f568c558572a1f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the yellow toy slides forward without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05379", "filename": "a572e8d30495f666f317194e917e73e70b7d9b79c991cc6d68bd62253fabc12c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (2.1s-5s: the red cracks on the object's surface begin to spread and grow outwards, ending at 5s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05380", "filename": "a572e8d30495f666f317194e917e73e70b7d9b79c991cc6d68bd62253fabc12c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 4.1s, the bubbles had not disappeared, and the areas on the cheese where the bubbles were originally began to blur).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05383", "filename": "a916aa261f8aa0369b36ee5025ad886672899d7c7b444cde982a40ea1b92a1e1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: physical behavior (1.18-2.6s, the hydraulic press compresses the aluminum can and flattens it, but the shape of the can does not change during the upward movement. In real life, an aluminum can should be flattened after being compressed).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05384", "filename": "a916aa261f8aa0369b36ee5025ad886672899d7c7b444cde982a40ea1b92a1e1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Physical behavior (4.7s: the shape of the can is flattened by the hydraulic press; 5.3s-8s: the hydraulic press itself changes without any external factors).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05385", "filename": "a942c6da66056680a744e8862151beb2b39efab0916c04fec28c75b4c1663942_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the video shows flames burning paper, but the paper shows no obvious signs of burning).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05387", "filename": "80279e732e7fd30fd02a7b7d2fbd14541b5fa2387b9453fe868896dc5b1e449e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05388", "filename": "80878f5a8a753380861efe6a1a40750c28dc5f0a2683b97ff274ced70ea255dc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (the color flow speed in the upper and lower areas of the image differs greatly; the texture changes slowly in the lower area, while the upper area changes rapidly with changing shapes; the color gradation is completely disordered, and there is no stable gradation pattern.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05389", "filename": "80878f5a8a753380861efe6a1a40750c28dc5f0a2683b97ff274ced70ea255dc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the colors are constantly changing as they flow throughout the video. The original complete and continuous rainbow gradient gradually becomes more cool purple, dark green and fluorescent pink, and has a wrinkled feel like a rag.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05390", "filename": "80878f5a8a753380861efe6a1a40750c28dc5f0a2683b97ff274ced70ea255dc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05391", "filename": "82984fcf7c1ef863ace8bbc15dc09f4c4ea9e94246d3979776b072753e1ba2b3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 1.4s in the video, the silver-white scissor blade and the black scissor blade appear to clip through each other).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05392", "filename": "82984fcf7c1ef863ace8bbc15dc09f4c4ea9e94246d3979776b072753e1ba2b3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (at 4.7s in the video, the scissors did not touch the red heart-shaped object, but the object split in two and moved to the sides).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05393", "filename": "82984fcf7c1ef863ace8bbc15dc09f4c4ea9e94246d3979776b072753e1ba2b3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall visual impression is abnormal (between 0.3s and 1.9s in the video, the scissors did not cut the blue heart-shaped object, but the blue heart-shaped object separated into two halves on its own without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05394", "filename": "82984fcf7c1ef863ace8bbc15dc09f4c4ea9e94246d3979776b072753e1ba2b3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05399", "filename": "87890a282e621fd841af388af6318a5e0f9b85aa2008580b2c9ffddf6f2e6e3f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 0.4 seconds in the video, a container seemingly filled with water can be seen inverted on top of a sphere, with water overflowing around the container's opening. However, after 0.4 seconds, the water flows down in one direction instead of flowing down in all directions.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05400", "filename": "87890a282e621fd841af388af6318a5e0f9b85aa2008580b2c9ffddf6f2e6e3f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video behavior: Physical behavior (water continuously leaks out of the container throughout the video, but the water level inside the container does not change at all.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05401", "filename": "87890a282e621fd841af388af6318a5e0f9b85aa2008580b2c9ffddf6f2e6e3f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05402", "filename": "91890a6a4d6b686207dfb192e839a33c2eddce9e353f7aa89e722f2f4f859022_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (between 2s and 5s in the video, the water overflowing from the cup exhibits an anti-gravity state under zero external force, first strangely suspending in mid-air, and then splashing upwards in the opposite direction.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05403", "filename": "91890a6a4d6b686207dfb192e839a33c2eddce9e353f7aa89e722f2f4f859022_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual appearance is abnormal (the water splashing out of the cup in the entire video does not look like real water, but more like a viscous liquid; there is no random splashing or natural branching, it looks like a piece of cloth splashing out of the cup).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05404", "filename": "91890a6a4d6b686207dfb192e839a33c2eddce9e353f7aa89e722f2f4f859022_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05405", "filename": "91890a6a4d6b686207dfb192e839a33c2eddce9e353f7aa89e722f2f4f859022_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (water splashes out of the cup in a regular pattern and trajectory).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05406", "filename": "92119b340680356444ac65584c6f0b55b3a31c0d1e607f99eb553e29ff56a30f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (The grapes being compressed in the image are in a sealed container, but during the 1s compression, liquid flies out of the container's glass. From 1.4s to 5s, the compression surface undergoes condensation through the glass above it.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05407", "filename": "92119b340680356444ac65584c6f0b55b3a31c0d1e607f99eb553e29ff56a30f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 1.6s to 3.9s in the video, the grapes gradually increase in size and slowly pass through the glass around and above the container.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05408", "filename": "92726a2d3fb21b0c329a640f350be09c044194a6124e1abd2d0c1864827ffc41_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (The entire video shows reddish-brown liquid flowing straight into a glass full of liquid, but the light red liquid does not spread, the speed does not change, and the color of the liquid in the glass does not change.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05409", "filename": "92726a2d3fb21b0c329a640f350be09c044194a6124e1abd2d0c1864827ffc41_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows a continuous flow of reddish-brown liquid being poured into a full glass, but without any diffusion, as if it were being poured into an empty glass. The reddish-brown liquid level is seen slowly rising.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05410", "filename": "92726a2d3fb21b0c329a640f350be09c044194a6124e1abd2d0c1864827ffc41_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal because of the continuous timing (from 3.4s to 5.3s in the video, the reddish-brown liquid is poured through the oil layer, briefly accumulating into a full droplet at the oil-water interface, and then breaking through the oil layer, falling into the water below like a smooth thin line. This phenomenon was not observed before 3.4s.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05411", "filename": "92726a2d3fb21b0c329a640f350be09c044194a6124e1abd2d0c1864827ffc41_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is continuous (at 6.7 seconds in the video, the pouring of the reddish-brown liquid has stopped, but the color in the glass continues to deepen).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05412", "filename": "94460cbfb777d833b9f040f4efee87e88259cf063c93d00b3a7cd9e6dec7bf74_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (in the video, at 0.4s and 4.5s, colored paint splashes upwards defying gravity without any external force.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05413", "filename": "94460cbfb777d833b9f040f4efee87e88259cf063c93d00b3a7cd9e6dec7bf74_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (The colored paint above the circular pit and the edge of the opening in the entire video splashes and then gathers towards the center, finally falling into the very center of the pit.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05414", "filename": "94460cbfb777d833b9f040f4efee87e88259cf063c93d00b3a7cd9e6dec7bf74_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05415", "filename": "94460cbfb777d833b9f040f4efee87e88259cf063c93d00b3a7cd9e6dec7bf74_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05416", "filename": "96423ab3817c4ffd6c05495801990180afad98b7fa895b37c91bab9177c39c4c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05417", "filename": "f2fe61cc27b6b7ea8ff5d52bd7b83e30b58ffe312ec1ce06964dd8a9157846bb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the falling debris on the screen disappears out of thin air at 3.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05418", "filename": "f2fe61cc27b6b7ea8ff5d52bd7b83e30b58ffe312ec1ce06964dd8a9157846bb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, at 5.5s, a portion of the debris on the right side of the camera suddenly turns white)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05419", "filename": "f2fe61cc27b6b7ea8ff5d52bd7b83e30b58ffe312ec1ce06964dd8a9157846bb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 1.4 seconds, debris suddenly appears from the rear left of the frame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05420", "filename": "f2fe61cc27b6b7ea8ff5d52bd7b83e30b58ffe312ec1ce06964dd8a9157846bb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without changing camera angles, an extra portion appears out of nowhere in the middle of the blue object at 3.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05421", "filename": "f3bfe95682baca3770ca1b683bd092c07f97a3bcbd64d9f13c9ab201128277fb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, at 1.7 seconds, a person suddenly appears out of nowhere on the right side of the bridge).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05422", "filename": "f3bfe95682baca3770ca1b683bd092c07f97a3bcbd64d9f13c9ab201128277fb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the characters' movements are excessively smooth and continuous, lacking the pauses and hesitations that should exist in real-life physical movements; the transitions between movements are distorted, lacking the texture of physical movement, and appearing unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05423", "filename": "f3bfe95682baca3770ca1b683bd092c07f97a3bcbd64d9f13c9ab201128277fb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the rotating windmill in the scene is abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05425", "filename": "f3cf65998aa40c69baae16448bbf16d755fcf9a5248c578dc29683052e7078dd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (Under the premise that the camera does not change and there is no force or external interference, at 2.5s, the bubble in the middle of the screen suddenly becomes larger).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05426", "filename": "f3cf65998aa40c69baae16448bbf16d755fcf9a5248c578dc29683052e7078dd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Continuity of time (the water from the water gun directly impacts the surface of the bubbles. Thin bubbles, when subjected to external force, should deform or even burst, but the bubbles in the footage show no change in shape or damage).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05427", "filename": "f3cf65998aa40c69baae16448bbf16d755fcf9a5248c578dc29683052e7078dd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05431", "filename": "f4aaf500b8fbef8d951269fb3cb4c97c421074e5fd367efba562cce33b9510ed_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (The ground in the scene is abnormally distorted. Furthermore, the burning wood in the fire shows no physical changes, no carbonization, charring, or ash formation as is expected in real-world burning, and no cracking, peeling, or erosion as is typical of burning wood.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05432", "filename": "f4aaf500b8fbef8d951269fb3cb4c97c421074e5fd367efba562cce33b9510ed_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without camera changes or external interference, at 2.4 seconds, the charcoal fire in the footage moves towards the tree branch on its own).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05433", "filename": "f4aaf500b8fbef8d951269fb3cb4c97c421074e5fd367efba562cce33b9510ed_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 1.6s, an extra branch suddenly appears in the middle of the tree branches).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05434", "filename": "f4aaf500b8fbef8d951269fb3cb4c97c421074e5fd367efba562cce33b9510ed_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (Under the premise that the camera does not change and there is no force or external interference, the fire suddenly splits into two at 3.3s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05435", "filename": "f05d47ab3f4d96eafe3e5c7788a02bd1a143c3247d61ee74324d98180c23a0bb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the ground and walls in the image are abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05436", "filename": "f05d47ab3f4d96eafe3e5c7788a02bd1a143c3247d61ee74324d98180c23a0bb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05437", "filename": "f05e71366726cb967b6f96cbd834fb36e4d4929db31d6095cbddf85e4226bfd6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the green background and colorful balls in the image are abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05438", "filename": "f05e71366726cb967b6f96cbd834fb36e4d4929db31d6095cbddf85e4226bfd6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (Under the premise of no camera movement, no force or external interference, the colored ball suddenly becomes larger at 0.7s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05439", "filename": "f05e71366726cb967b6f96cbd834fb36e4d4929db31d6095cbddf85e4226bfd6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the green background in the image is abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05440", "filename": "f05e71366726cb967b6f96cbd834fb36e4d4929db31d6095cbddf85e4226bfd6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, at 5.5 seconds, a black object suddenly appears on the colored ball).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05445", "filename": "f5b4799213511dbf80faed6e87045fa4468c9170904dbd1aa8421d039effbb11_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, a small boat suddenly appears on the water at 0.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05446", "filename": "f5b4799213511dbf80faed6e87045fa4468c9170904dbd1aa8421d039effbb11_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the clouds in the sky in the image are abnormally twisting).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05447", "filename": "P30_108_156_7dbd4855fdb07ca7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: (At 0.8s, the faucet switch was not activated and there was no external force touching it, yet water flowed out on its own, without any start-up process. At 2.8s, the bowl did not collide or flip, but the plate flipped on its own, without any flipping, start-up, or movement process.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05448", "filename": "P30_108_215_65f205f34b2d811c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (In the 2.3s footage, when the towel touches the hook, there is no external force applied; it passes directly through the hook without any obstruction or deformation. In the 3.8s footage, there is no hand-rubbing, wrapping, or any other action, yet the towel rolls up on its own and completes the wrapping action without any natural rolling or wrinkling process.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05449", "filename": "P30_108_215_65f205f34b2d811c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal; the time is continuous (in the 6.3s footage, there are no actions such as hand kneading or wrapping, but the towel rolls up and completes the wrapping action on its own, without any natural rolling or wrinkling process).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05450", "filename": "P30_109_132_9567ae7876caaad3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The video is continuous in time (1.1s). When the kettle moves, the socket base is not unplugged, but it moves along with it. At the same time, the charger disappears without any reason, without any loosening or removal process.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05451", "filename": "P30_109_162_54d23070d0af47db_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 0.5s, the object in the upper left corner of the palm floats in mid-air without any support); temporal continuity (at 2.9s, the plastic film on the surface of the object picked up disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05452", "filename": "P30_109_162_54d23070d0af47db_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Time continuity (the can below the object appears out of thin air at 2.7s); Physical behavior (the object below is removed in the video at 3.2s while the object above floats without support).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05453", "filename": "P30_109_162_54d23070d0af47db_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the pancake held in the left hand disappears into thin air at 2.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05454", "filename": "P30_109_186_73659980585fb905_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.7s, an object appears out of nowhere on the right slice of bread; at 3.7s, the sticky substance attached to the spoon increases out of nowhere; at 4.1s, the sticky substance appears out of nowhere on the left slice of bread).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05455", "filename": "P30_109_186_73659980585fb905_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (the spoon in the left hand appears out of thin air at 1.3s); Physical anomalies (the spoon penetrates the side of the glass jar at 2.1s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05456", "filename": "P30_109_186_73659980585fb905_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.8s, the red towel below the left hand disappears and the metal box appears out of thin air with the right hand's fingers; at 2.6s, the metal box suddenly turns into a disc).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05457", "filename": "P30_110_89_4040d8fcb1eaa968_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (water flowing into the cup disappears into thin air at 1.9s); Physical anomalies (the white cup in the upper left corner embeds into the blue cup at 3.1s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05458", "filename": "P30_110_89_4040d8fcb1eaa968_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (water that flows into the cup at 4.6s does not flow out when it is poured out).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05459", "filename": "P30_110_89_4040d8fcb1eaa968_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.6s, the originally concave rim of the cup suddenly becomes a flat bottom).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05460", "filename": "P30_111_75_fbd1d18b86556659_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (at 5.2s, the oil was not flowing out of the bottle opening, but instead flowed out through the bottom of the bottle opening).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05461", "filename": "P30_111_75_fbd1d18b86556659_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Continuous timing (no transition from the first to the next frame at 1.7 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05462", "filename": "P30_111_127_191656c899fcacf4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.6s, the shredded paper appears out of nowhere below the left hand, and at 4.3s, the number of falling shredded paper increases out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05463", "filename": "P30_111_127_191656c899fcacf4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: The time is continuous (the screen switches to the next scene without transition at 2.2s, and paper scraps appear out of nowhere in the upper right corner of the trash can at 4s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05464", "filename": "P30_111_219_d288aee4bb34c84b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the powder sprinkled into the pot at 1.8 seconds appears to increase out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05465", "filename": "P30_111_251_5de5056b0021782f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Cause and effect (the stove turned on by itself even though both hands did not turn it on at 2.6s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05466", "filename": "P30_111_283_b290c5e3f6f83143_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical behavior (left middle finger penetrates the lid at 0.3s, container starts shaking at 1.4s while the object inside remains stationary)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05467", "filename": "P30_111_314_54f9c076ae66f4d0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1s, the brush in the right hand suddenly shrinks in size, and at 2s, the brush rope on the left side of the brush disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05468", "filename": "P30_111_314_54f9c076ae66f4d0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (at 1.4s, the wooden stick in the left hand suddenly turns into a white sphere; at 2.8s and 3.8s, white dots appear out of nowhere on the left sink).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05469", "filename": "P30_111_319_5c06974cfa9a4b97_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 2s, the originally straight cup in the left hand bends, and at 4.4s, a stream of water flows into the cup, but the water in the cup disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05470", "filename": "P30_111_319_5c06974cfa9a4b97_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.5s, the sea of noodles on the right suddenly expands, at 4.8s, the bottom of the cup on the left becomes the rim, and at 5.6s, the cup stem that was originally on the right moves to the left).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05471", "filename": "P30_111_319_5c06974cfa9a4b97_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (the cup in the hand twists at 0.2s, the handle remains attached to the bottom of the cup at 3.3s); Physical anomalies (water flows through the bottom of the cup at 5.4s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05472", "filename": "P30_111_333_60c654bdbb5c7427_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical behavior (the water column between the hands in the video continuously penetrates the cup and falls into the sink), continuous time (at 1.1s, two of the three sponges on the left side of the video disappear out of thin air, and one of them changes from a rectangle to a pentagon).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05473", "filename": "P30_111_333_60c654bdbb5c7427_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (at 1.4s, the bottom of the cup in the left hand becomes the rim of the cup, and the rim slowly widens; at 2.3s, the originally green sponge in the right hand turns white); Physical anomalies (at 3.6s, the sponge in the right hand penetrates the right side of the cup).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05474", "filename": "P30_111_343_7de5c8132d98879a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the cup appears out of thin air beneath the right-hand sponge at 0.1s, and merges with it at 1.8s); Physical behavior (the right-hand sponge penetrates the right side of the cup at 2.4s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05475", "filename": "P30_111_460_55d6cbff38012c7d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.6s, the object in the right hand, which was originally a semicircle, merges into a circle).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05476", "filename": "P30_111_461_e8a59446c08f9002_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (particles sprinkled at 2.2s suddenly increase out of nowhere)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05477", "filename": "017c7437ba088a591169513746f6ad3fdb41d4a1912b8887cb9000e325af75a7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall impression is off (the outlines of the mountains in the video are too smooth and stiff, lacking the texture, folds and staggered feel of real mountains; the proportions of some mountains are strange, some are abrupt and some are out of proportion, lacking the natural transition of real karst landforms; the boundary between the clouds and the mountains is either too hard or too blurry, lacking a natural sense of envelopment).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05478", "filename": "017c7437ba088a591169513746f6ad3fdb41d4a1912b8887cb9000e325af75a7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the direction of cloud movement is inconsistent and chaotic throughout the video, the texture of the sea of clouds is repetitive and lacks depth, the edges are blurred and there is no sense of movement or thickness variation of real clouds and fog, the overall color tone is cold blue, but the logic of light and shadow is chaotic, the light and shadow of the mountains and the light-receiving surfaces of the clouds and fog do not have a unified light source, making them look very flat and fake).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05479", "filename": "017c7437ba088a591169513746f6ad3fdb41d4a1912b8887cb9000e325af75a7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the clouds in the entire video flow like a looping animation, without the random undulation, dissipation and aggregation of real clouds and fog, lacking natural turbulence and gradation, the edges of the cloud clusters are either sharply cut or excessively blurred, without the fluffy feeling and boundary gradation of real clouds and fog, the layers of the mountains in the foreground, middle ground and background are chaotic, there is no real atmospheric perspective, the near are warm and the far are cold, the near are solid and the far are blurred, all the mountains seem to be pasted on the same plane, lacking a sense of depth).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05480", "filename": "17e47e0a06ec019e9cdfc17939c2baebc3af2e4dfc6a474890e09e08201015ac_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the sun on the sea surface in the entire video is not a complete circle, but is cut into irregular bright blocks by the clouds, with blurred edges and no gradation, which does not conform to the outline and halo of the sun at a real sunset. The distribution of golden reflections on the sea surface does not match the direction of the waves. Some areas of reflection are abrupt and do not have the natural connection of reflections from the waves. The ripples on the near and far sea surfaces do not have a smooth transition, resulting in a severe sense of disjointedness).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05481", "filename": "17e47e0a06ec019e9cdfc17939c2baebc3af2e4dfc6a474890e09e08201015ac_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the golden reflection on the sea and the warm light in the sky have no unified light source throughout the video; the transition between bright and dark areas is abrupt; the orange-yellow gradient in the sky changes color abruptly in some areas; the changes in the light and shadow colors of the sunset and the reflection on the sea are arrhythmic and completely out of sync with the speed of the setting sun; the middle section of the sea lacks realistic shimmering water ripples and details, and is overly smooth like a plastic film; the waves in the foreground and background lack layering, and the near and far views are blurred while the distant views are sharp; all the water surfaces seem to be pasted on the same plane, lacking a sense of depth; the boundary between the sea and the sky is too smooth, lacking a realistic sense of atmospheric perspective; the island on the right is always a black mass, without the changes in light and shadow at sunset, like a static background).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05482", "filename": "17e47e0a06ec019e9cdfc17939c2baebc3af2e4dfc6a474890e09e08201015ac_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: The overall visual presentation is abnormal (the overall image is overly smooth, lacking the graininess, noise, and subtle dynamics of real video, such as a gentle breeze, shimmering clouds, and flickering light and shadow. All elements appear plasticky, fake, and flat. The wave textures resemble repeatedly copied textures, lacking the natural turbulence of random undulations and varying sizes. The distant sea surface moves at a uniform speed like a conveyor belt, lacking the dynamic breaking, churning, and dissipating movements of real waves. The mechanical repetition of golden reflections on the sea surface does not match the direction of the waves or the position of the sun. The edges of the reflections are blurred into a single mass, lacking the natural reflective texture of real seawater drifting with the waves and alternating light and shadow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05483", "filename": "17ec12da5069e06c9e63d22bc4346e2ea821301f5e96b322c44d478495f94784_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 0.1s, an ice cube suddenly appears out of nowhere in the glass; at 0.3s, a thin column of water suddenly appears below the hand; at 0.6s, the hand in the upper left corner suddenly changes, with more fingers and a blurred palm without natural hand texture). Physical behavior (the ice cube's water depth is abnormal, the ratio of the submerged part to the above-water part is severely imbalanced, the ice cube sinks into the water but still floats, violating the physical property that ice is less dense than water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05484", "filename": "17ec12da5069e06c9e63d22bc4346e2ea821301f5e96b322c44d478495f94784_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (at 0.5s, a water droplet suddenly jumps out of the cup and disappears without external force; at 1.2s, an ice cube falls into the cup without obvious splashing; at 0s, an unusual semi-transparent blending effect appears on the arm, resembling overlapping layers, distorted skin texture, and blurred hand skin texture). Physical behavior (abnormal water depth of the ice cube; the ice cube sinks halfway and then floats upwards, violating the physical property that ice is less dense than water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05485", "filename": "17ec12da5069e06c9e63d22bc4346e2ea821301f5e96b322c44d478495f94784_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 0.8s, the arm in the picture appears to have an abnormal semi-transparent blending effect, like overlapping layers, and the skin texture is distorted and the skin texture of the hand suddenly becomes blurred; at 0.8s, an ice block appears out of thin air in the lower right corner of the picture and floats in the air). Physical behavior (at 6.8s, the ratio of the part of the ice block submerged in water to the part above water is severely imbalanced, with most of the ice block sinking into the water but still floating, which violates the physical property that the density of ice is less than that of water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05490", "filename": "17ee049554770ab552cd2f68d77e65d013a038a66ecf69d001f587659567def8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (In the entire video, in reality, when a straw is inserted into water, the refraction of light creates a visual effect where the underwater part bends and shifts upwards. However, in the image, the straw is straight through the water surface. The transparency, reflection, and shadows of the green straw are completely distorted. It lacks the transparency and light and shadow layers of a real plastic straw. The edges are blurry, resembling color blocks. The boundary between the water and the cup wall is blurred. There is no curved liquid surface formed by the surface tension of a real liquid. The water surface is too flat. There are no real bubbles or light refraction inside the liquid. It looks like a transparent color block, lacking fluidity and texture.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05491", "filename": "17ee049554770ab552cd2f68d77e65d013a038a66ecf69d001f587659567def8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (the cup's lines are irregular, the wall thickness varies, the transition between the stem and body is abrupt, the glass texture of the base is blurry, lacking the transparency and refractive layers of real glass, the straw's refraction effect in the water is completely wrong, not following the laws of light refraction and appearing abrupt, the water in the cup lacks a natural curvature, the boundary between the water surface and the cup wall is abrupt, and the reflection is completely inconsistent with the proportions and angles of the real object, lacking the diffuse reflection and refraction texture of real water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05492", "filename": "018dac349bbb1555e1767214f2a5f0406b758e057a2f8b6ce66818f7cc02d35e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the visuals: Physical behavior (In the entire video, the liquid flowing from the bottle does not follow the law of gravity falling downwards, but instead solidifies vertically upwards into a white columnar object, violating the common sense of fluid mechanics and gravity. The solidification shape of the liquid is strange, lacking natural crystallization texture, with a smooth and layered surface, completely inconsistent with the form of a real chemical solidification reaction. The connection between the liquid at the bottle opening and the flowing columnar object is abrupt, without the sense of transition of liquid flow, as if it were directly spliced together.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05493", "filename": "018dac349bbb1555e1767214f2a5f0406b758e057a2f8b6ce66818f7cc02d35e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (in the entire video, the transparent liquid in the cup suddenly turns into a white substance after being poured out, and it appears as a spiral stacked spring shape, which violates the physical properties of liquid substances. Such substances should flow and diffuse, rather than be in a regular spiral column shape. The substance poured out in the experiment showed no dynamic traces of splashing or flowing. The spiral was completely still and showed no deformation under the influence of gravity, which violated the physical laws of substance reaction and pouring in chemical experiments. It looked like a static model generated out of thin air.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05494", "filename": "018dac349bbb1555e1767214f2a5f0406b758e057a2f8b6ce66818f7cc02d35e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: (The outline label on the glass bottle is blurry, the light and shadow refraction between the bottle and the liquid is chaotic, and the texture of the liquid inside the bottle does not match the optical effect of a real glass container.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05495", "filename": "019c2446b47f1125aaedced3fb5cae96a66e8bd476f3f34642821a8025d569f1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (the shape of the flames and smoke in the entire video violates the laws of real physics; the brightness and color transition of the flames are unnatural; the boundary between the core bright area and the outer orange-yellow area is blurred; it lacks the sense of depth of a real explosion; the flying debris and smoke are randomly distributed with irregular size and density; some debris looks like suspended noise without any trajectory of movement due to the impact of the explosion; and the integration of debris with the flames and smoke is extremely low, appearing stiff and abrupt). Causality (the white objects on both sides were still present after the explosion at 4.2s, and were not affected by the shock wave of the explosion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05496", "filename": "019c2446b47f1125aaedced3fb5cae96a66e8bd476f3f34642821a8025d569f1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visuals are abnormal (the explosion in the entire video violates the laws of physics; there is no upward shock wave, but rather it looks like a floating, glowing cotton candy. There are no signs of burning or rising smoke at the point where the bottom contacts the ground, and there is no impact or light diffusion effect that an explosion should have. The texture is more like a 3D model of a luminous object than a real flame. Furthermore, the colors and light and shadow are disjointed. The bright yellow and orange of the flames and the red reflection on the ground are too harsh and lack natural light and shadow transitions. Moreover, there are no light and dark layers inside the flames, and they lack the dynamic sense of real combustion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05497", "filename": "019c2446b47f1125aaedced3fb5cae96a66e8bd476f3f34642821a8025d569f1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visuals are abnormal (the texture of the flames and smoke from the explosion is stiff; the cloud texture of the mushroom cloud looks like a patchwork of cotton balls, lacking the dynamic layering of a real explosion and the physical logic of smoke diffusion; the small black objects flying in the air are chaotic in shape, neither like explosion debris nor natural objects, and have no clear physical trajectory; the size of the mushroom cloud far exceeds the spatial logic of the image, as if a nuclear explosion scene has been forcibly crammed into a small grassy area, with incorrect spatial perspective).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05498", "filename": "019c2446b47f1125aaedced3fb5cae96a66e8bd476f3f34642821a8025d569f1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: The overall visual presentation is abnormal. The mushroom cloud during the explosion is overly bright in color and has a cartoonish flame texture, lacking the layered effect of a realistic explosion's smoke. A real mushroom cloud is a mixture of thick smoke and flames, not a pure bright orange. The size distribution of the flying debris and soil is irregular, with some fragments suspended and falling without gravity. Furthermore, there is a lack of coordination between the flying debris and the blast wave. The smoke after the explosion is stiff and has overly regular edges, like a pasted-on effect, lacking the dynamic diffusion and dispersal of realistic smoke. Flames only appear sporadically at the bottom, which is inconsistent with the intensity of the burning of the dense black smoke above. In a real explosion, flames spread synchronously with the thick smoke, rather than a combination of localized small fires and massive amounts of black smoke.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05502", "filename": "19ca5fb16cfc04e5bbc2c7ce8ac085de7ce814fb0896b8fe5ab6c3dfa98ee12d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the fog in the mountains in the whole video has a harsh boundary, without natural gradation and dispersion. In some areas, the fog looks like a piece of color that has been pasted on, with very low integration with the mountains and forests. The distribution of the fog is irregular. Fog penetrates areas that should be covered by the mountains, and the spatial layers are chaotic).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05503", "filename": "19ca5fb16cfc04e5bbc2c7ce8ac085de7ce814fb0896b8fe5ab6c3dfa98ee12d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the foreground of the video is a dense evergreen coniferous forest, but a large area of leafless dead forest suddenly appears in the middle and background. The distribution of the two vegetation types has no natural transition. The perspective ratio of the foreground forest, the middle ground mountains, and the distant snow-capped mountains is out of proportion. The details of the snow accumulation and mountain texture of the distant snow-capped mountains are too clear, which creates a reverse depth of field with the blurry forest in the foreground. Visually, the snow-capped mountains seem to be pasted into the background of the screen, without a real sense of spatial depth. The snow accumulation is only concentrated on the mountaintop without a natural snow gradient, and the size and shape of the snow accumulation area are irregular. The fog blends awkwardly with the trees and mountains, and some fog directly penetrates the tree trunks).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05504", "filename": "19ca5fb16cfc04e5bbc2c7ce8ac085de7ce814fb0896b8fe5ab6c3dfa98ee12d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the fog in the mountains in the entire video is distributed in stiff clumps with no transition between the edges, and it does not have the light and diffused feeling of real fog).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05505", "filename": "19ca5fb16cfc04e5bbc2c7ce8ac085de7ce814fb0896b8fe5ab6c3dfa98ee12d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is abnormal (there is no transition between evergreen forests and dead trees in the snowy landscape, no traces of snow on the branches, and no natural snow details in the white forest, such as scattered snow clumps, icicles on the branches, or snow traces on the ground).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05506", "filename": "19d91c1c5dbb3a456bfb36e7c2b67ba6581497667e6efa32008297207ca9f7f6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual presentation is abnormal (the flames emitted from the nasal cavity throughout the video appear as stiff columns, lacking the natural swaying and layering of flames, the dynamic feel of the inner and outer flames, and the harsh edges, unlike real burning flames. The flames emerge directly from inside the skull, but the skull's surface lacks corresponding burning marks such as carbonization cracks and high-temperature discoloration. The flames are only a single orange-red, lacking the blue-purple flame core that should be present at high temperatures, and there is no diffuse reflection effect of the flames illuminating the surroundings. The light and shadow of the flames are completely isolated against the black background).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05507", "filename": "54a34c343b6491ceb6f1984d97f536f4175833a8e193d230643306b0a868277d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (0.3s-5.8s). The bowl is not heated, but the water in the upper right corner of the bowl keeps bubbling and appears to be boiling.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05508", "filename": "54c0787645ac1b00e60de9a49a94ef9c3a65729766e5f6bbaf37954fa9406b8a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is continuous (at 0.8s, the metal piece in the upper right corner of the video twists and deforms, and at 2.3s, the metal piece in the upper left corner of the video suddenly deforms).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05509", "filename": "54d2d1975d266a9da9432af7ae8a81708a9b3faac7e75220375b46402fc73348_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (clouds and grass in the sky move in the direction of airflow, but the movement of clouds and grass in the sky is inconsistent throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05510", "filename": "54d2d1975d266a9da9432af7ae8a81708a9b3faac7e75220375b46402fc73348_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05511", "filename": "54d2d1975d266a9da9432af7ae8a81708a9b3faac7e75220375b46402fc73348_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: Cause and effect (the clouds in the sky are moving with the wind and in the same direction due to airflow, but the clouds in the sky move erratically throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05512", "filename": "54d2d1975d266a9da9432af7ae8a81708a9b3faac7e75220375b46402fc73348_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: Cause and effect (the clouds in the sky are moving with the wind and in the same direction due to airflow, but from 2.4s to 8s, the upper and lower clouds in the video are not moving in the same direction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05513", "filename": "055c1477161ef647fd42c5a70da6d6f9e69a0314107da89a4feddb2ca9267830_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 0.8s, two figures on the road directly in front of the video suddenly disappear; at 3s, a vehicle on the road in the upper left corner of the video suddenly deforms).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05514", "filename": "055c1477161ef647fd42c5a70da6d6f9e69a0314107da89a4feddb2ca9267830_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.4 seconds, one of the three figures on the road directly in front of the video suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05515", "filename": "055c1477161ef647fd42c5a70da6d6f9e69a0314107da89a4feddb2ca9267830_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time frame is continuous (from 1.7s to 5s, a white vehicle on the road directly in front of the camera suddenly deforms while driving).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05516", "filename": "055c1477161ef647fd42c5a70da6d6f9e69a0314107da89a4feddb2ca9267830_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05517", "filename": "056b84357411f94d92532133a3b07d8a885e46d85ec455d2ec3c9b7daedb41cc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the fusion of flames and firewood in the image is too abrupt, lacking the natural pulsation and layering of a real burning scene).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05518", "filename": "056b84357411f94d92532133a3b07d8a885e46d85ec455d2ec3c9b7daedb41cc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05519", "filename": "056b84357411f94d92532133a3b07d8a885e46d85ec455d2ec3c9b7daedb41cc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05521", "filename": "56a0f2963f70c949e3ced1a1755e8ad65f7b5a4c2e4bb4f30a8b303c6b738571_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: The timing is continuous (the red car has two chassis in the whole video and the front and rear wheels are in opposite positions. At 2.1s, the position of the red car's front wheels suddenly changes and the broken car door returns to the left side. At 1.6s, a large amount of colored debris appears out of nowhere in the car).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05526", "filename": "56dde3db70d6f10c8899efde3bb231da9f9328afecc9d5b01c7d35eaa04d1ab8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.8 seconds, one of the bird's feet in the water suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05527", "filename": "56dde3db70d6f10c8899efde3bb231da9f9328afecc9d5b01c7d35eaa04d1ab8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time frame is continuous (the size of the bird in the water suddenly increases between 1.4s and 3.4s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05528", "filename": "56dde3db70d6f10c8899efde3bb231da9f9328afecc9d5b01c7d35eaa04d1ab8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The time sequence is continuous (0s-0.2s, the bird in the water suddenly twists and deforms).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05532", "filename": "56ead60d8bdffdaaf350e3ac3fa8c5982aedc4f03131cc61743a9dfaad4577e6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the edges of the transparent object continuously distort and deform as it rotates to the upper left of the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05533", "filename": "56ead60d8bdffdaaf350e3ac3fa8c5982aedc4f03131cc61743a9dfaad4577e6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05534", "filename": "56ead60d8bdffdaaf350e3ac3fa8c5982aedc4f03131cc61743a9dfaad4577e6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (the colored light in the video is caused by scattering from a transparent object. The colored light spot changes as the transparent object moves and the light source changes. However, when the transparent object is stationary in the video, the colored light rotates around the transparent object.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05535", "filename": "56ead60d8bdffdaaf350e3ac3fa8c5982aedc4f03131cc61743a9dfaad4577e6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Causality (The colored light in the video is caused by scattering from a transparent object. The colored light produced by the change of the light source position should change color gradually as the position of the transparent object changes, but the colored light spots in the video are too stable.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05537", "filename": "0cf241a42970b86582ab80e90e1cbc5a742ed6d3331f06457490a45a7267409b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to physical behavior (no ash was seen flying in the video 2.2 seconds after the explosion, which is inconsistent with an actual explosion as there would always be ash flying).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05538", "filename": "0cf241a42970b86582ab80e90e1cbc5a742ed6d3331f06457490a45a7267409b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Time continuity (explosion debris suddenly disappears between 0s and 0.7s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05539", "filename": "0cf241a42970b86582ab80e90e1cbc5a742ed6d3331f06457490a45a7267409b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (during the explosion from 0.8s to 4.1s, white bones emitted plumes of smoke; while the house shifted due to the explosion, the astronaut sculpture within remained stationary without being subjected to any force, violating the mechanical transmission logic of the explosion shockwave.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05540", "filename": "0d88bef9b61d743eb239f35399dd1dd477c22594234c1d6d3ea604cb4736c75a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to the physical behavior (the brick fragments should be in the form of fine powder and hard lumps when crushed between 1.8s and 5s, not a paste-like consistency as seen in the video; the image appears unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05541", "filename": "0d88bef9b61d743eb239f35399dd1dd477c22594234c1d6d3ea604cb4736c75a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (between 1.4s and 2.5s, the fragment in the lower left corner jumps and flips without any external force, which does not conform to the law of inertia).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05542", "filename": "0d88bef9b61d743eb239f35399dd1dd477c22594234c1d6d3ea604cb4736c75a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05543", "filename": "0d88bef9b61d743eb239f35399dd1dd477c22594234c1d6d3ea604cb4736c75a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (disturbance should spread evenly in all directions between 4.1s and 5.2s, instead of just towards the sides).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05544", "filename": "0d95a1f23988768d65e4fb7595c2ff471ecc5470ed333528610d534400c2c496_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the absence of bubbles on the left side of the pot contradicts the boiling state on the right, violating the physical characteristic of uniform bubble formation during liquid boiling. No steam is produced during boiling, and there are no signs of boiling in the upper left corner of the liquid).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05545", "filename": "0d95a1f23988768d65e4fb7595c2ff471ecc5470ed333528610d534400c2c496_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the liquid in the pot is boiling without producing any steam, and the liquid on the left side is still and not boiling).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05546", "filename": "0d95a1f23988768d65e4fb7595c2ff471ecc5470ed333528610d534400c2c496_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is as follows: The overall impression is that the liquid in the pot is boiling violently but no steam is being produced, which violates the physical characteristic of evenly generated bubbles when the liquid is boiling.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05547", "filename": "0da846ef02e97603c1cdf653947a63e5ad0473956674a62233948ef813972d99_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: The overall impression is that the reflection of the snow-capped mountain in the water is irregularly jumping, which is completely inconsistent with the ripples on the water surface. This disrupts the dynamic relationship between the reflection and the water surface, making the image appear obviously composite.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05548", "filename": "0da846ef02e97603c1cdf653947a63e5ad0473956674a62233948ef813972d99_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: Overall, the water surface ripples are strong and irregular within the 1s\u20135.5s timeframe, which does not conform to the gradual changes and transmission of real water surface ripples under the influence of external forces such as gravity and wind.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05549", "filename": "0da846ef02e97603c1cdf653947a63e5ad0473956674a62233948ef813972d99_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is unusual: the overall visual impression is that there are no ripples on the water surface at the bottom of the video, which is inconsistent with the movement of the surrounding water.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05550", "filename": "0da846ef02e97603c1cdf653947a63e5ad0473956674a62233948ef813972d99_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is that the reflection of moving clouds on the water at the bottom of the video is constantly changing, while there are no clouds in the sky.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05551", "filename": "0e2cbd152accbd8aa1ffc8d923e0260dd838a66dd56f4c12a84ff02920d13d6c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (within the period of 4.6s\u20135s, the sky in the video suddenly brightens during a sunset scene, which violates the natural sequence of time and visual perception that the sky should gradually darken during sunset).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05552", "filename": "0e2cbd152accbd8aa1ffc8d923e0260dd838a66dd56f4c12a84ff02920d13d6c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (within the period of 2.5s\u20134.8s, the sky did not follow the natural sequence of gradually darkening at sunset, but instead showed a sudden change from blue to purple, directly disrupting the temporal continuity and natural logic of the scene).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05553", "filename": "0e2cbd152accbd8aa1ffc8d923e0260dd838a66dd56f4c12a84ff02920d13d6c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall, the water surface ripple frequency is unnatural and inconsistent with the surrounding water surface ripples between 1.8s and 5s.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05554", "filename": "0e2cbd152accbd8aa1ffc8d923e0260dd838a66dd56f4c12a84ff02920d13d6c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (during the 6.5s\u20138s period, the number of layers and lighting effects of the lights reflected in the water are inconsistent with the actual lights, disrupting the visual correspondence between the reflection and the real scene).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05555", "filename": "0e05dac027dea308237e2904da6bb47735d08f56beb20c030864e950f40fe470_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is due to physical behavior (the water droplets on the outer wall of the glass do not drip normally during the fall; instead, they shrink or even disappear in the final stage, which does not conform to the natural movement of water droplets falling and merging under the influence of gravity. This is a typical sign of post-production compositing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05556", "filename": "0e05dac027dea308237e2904da6bb47735d08f56beb20c030864e950f40fe470_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (when water is poured from the glass, the water on the table does not spread outwards naturally, but spreads at an unnatural, slow speed, which does not conform to the physical characteristics of liquid wetting and diffusion on a solid surface).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05557", "filename": "0e05dac027dea308237e2904da6bb47735d08f56beb20c030864e950f40fe470_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the movement of water on the table doesn't resemble real water flow; it looks more like a viscous liquid).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05558", "filename": "0e05dac027dea308237e2904da6bb47735d08f56beb20c030864e950f40fe470_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (during the period of 1.1s\u20135.9s, the poured water appeared to be in a viscous liquid state, which does not conform to the physical property of water's fluidity).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05559", "filename": "0e5c8041e176454b17038afbb321d379eb65dfb7fc6f3851676cb22d95f48dc5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (during the period from 2.3s to 5s, clouds suddenly appeared to the left of the sun).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05560", "filename": "0e5c8041e176454b17038afbb321d379eb65dfb7fc6f3851676cb22d95f48dc5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the character in the lower left corner suddenly disappears between 0s and 0.4s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05561", "filename": "0e5c8041e176454b17038afbb321d379eb65dfb7fc6f3851676cb22d95f48dc5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall impression (the water ripples where the sun's reflection is on the sea surface remain still, while the surrounding water surface is undulating, violating the physical principle of the interaction between the reflection and the water surface, giving the image a distinctly composite appearance).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05562", "filename": "0e5c8041e176454b17038afbb321d379eb65dfb7fc6f3851676cb22d95f48dc5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (between 6.8s and 8s, several black objects at the bottom of the video shrank into a ball).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05563", "filename": "0e7c239053e75c219ec6a08911aa4ee9f1e40babb31b0ab8b4677fa0626091e7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall intuition (within the 0.2s\u20132.8s timeframe, the waterfall's fluid dynamics are stiff, the water texture is unrealistic, and the movement trajectory is too rigid, lacking the soft dynamics and natural form of real water flow).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05564", "filename": "0e7c239053e75c219ec6a08911aa4ee9f1e40babb31b0ab8b4677fa0626091e7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall, between 3.5s and 5.8s, the water mist from the waterfall suddenly increases in size, lacking a gradual transition.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05565", "filename": "0e7c239053e75c219ec6a08911aa4ee9f1e40babb31b0ab8b4677fa0626091e7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall impression (the overall flow rate of the waterfall is too slow, which does not conform to the visual characteristics of a real waterfall that is turbulent and rapid due to its high drop).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05568", "filename": "25072ecb4ebef0c3adfcb43a796eb27971e6b01c891a551b92a9091586635a36_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: physical behavior (the transition between black smoke and flames is abrupt, lacking the gradual change from thick to thin smoke and the dissipation of smoke as seen in a real fire; the flames are extremely bright, but there is no corresponding strong light reflection in the surrounding environment, and the contrast between light and dark does not conform to the laws of optics).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05569", "filename": "25072ecb4ebef0c3adfcb43a796eb27971e6b01c891a551b92a9091586635a36_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the boundary between the scorch marks on the ground and the open flame area in the fire zone is too clear; in a real fire, there would be a transition zone when plants are burned). Overall realism (the amount of smoke in the image is excessive and too smooth).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05570", "filename": "25072ecb4ebef0c3adfcb43a796eb27971e6b01c891a551b92a9091586635a36_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the flame is extremely bright, but there is no corresponding strong light reflection from the surrounding environment, and the contrast between light and dark does not conform to the laws of optics).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05571", "filename": "25072ecb4ebef0c3adfcb43a796eb27971e6b01c891a551b92a9091586635a36_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows abnormal behavior due to physical phenomena (the video shows a large amount of smoke produced from 3.2 seconds until the end of combustion, which is an effect that can only be produced by an explosion; normal combustion would not produce this much smoke).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05572", "filename": "26881b5a8fcc6f23b43fed8706e2f5cc8477fc0b1272c63d3c631426927035c3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical phenomena (the white smoke from fireworks in the sky remains suspended in the air without dissipating, and people on the lake stand steadily on the water without using any buoyancy aids).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05573", "filename": "26881b5a8fcc6f23b43fed8706e2f5cc8477fc0b1272c63d3c631426927035c3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is continuous (the fireworks suddenly appear and then explode from 0.4s to 0.5s, without the normal upward rising process of fireworks); the physical behavior is also abnormal (the white smoke from the fireworks in the air remains suspended in the air without slowly dissipating).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05574", "filename": "26881b5a8fcc6f23b43fed8706e2f5cc8477fc0b1272c63d3c631426927035c3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (fireworks stay in the air for too long, and the shape of the bloom is too regular).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05575", "filename": "26881b5a8fcc6f23b43fed8706e2f5cc8477fc0b1272c63d3c631426927035c3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the fireworks stayed in the air for too long, and the shape of the explosion was too regular).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05576", "filename": "26942ec721af9ecc2882e33a026d81bbe168b1c24d3db5212229abf0964a1723_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the liquid becomes transparent and bright at 2.2s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05577", "filename": "26942ec721af9ecc2882e33a026d81bbe168b1c24d3db5212229abf0964a1723_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (the bottle cap suddenly disappears at 2.5s); Physical behavior (the water's rotation speed is too fast and too regular as the person slowly picks up the bottle from 4.6s onwards).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05578", "filename": "26942ec721af9ecc2882e33a026d81bbe168b1c24d3db5212229abf0964a1723_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 6.1s, the water in the left half of the bottle in the frame suddenly starts moving).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05579", "filename": "29171a29dba94edad1aacf98877d9d0df6c3af2cde745d2acb590b2328f1437b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the sparkler does not decrease in size during combustion and remains burning in the same spot).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05580", "filename": "29171a29dba94edad1aacf98877d9d0df6c3af2cde745d2acb590b2328f1437b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual error: Physical behavior (the sparkler does not decrease in size during combustion and remains burning in the same place).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05581", "filename": "29171a29dba94edad1aacf98877d9d0df6c3af2cde745d2acb590b2328f1437b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05582", "filename": "33673d82441319606c8fb001f6c276eae3ff9144586b62a47189ff53edfe7fe4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (0.2s, the plastic duck appears to have grown feet and is swimming in the water).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05583", "filename": "33673d82441319606c8fb001f6c276eae3ff9144586b62a47189ff53edfe7fe4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical phenomena (ice cubes in the glass are melting rapidly without high temperature, and water in the glass is sloshing without external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05584", "filename": "33673d82441319606c8fb001f6c276eae3ff9144586b62a47189ff53edfe7fe4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.2s, the plastic duck lying on its side suddenly stands up, and at 3.3s, a piece of ice suddenly appears in the water).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05585", "filename": "34109efa884ba350f53cd2c6ae7c37c59353e0112c9e0ffaf27a56b2864b916e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (clouds would not move so rapidly and orderly under natural wind).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05586", "filename": "34109efa884ba350f53cd2c6ae7c37c59353e0112c9e0ffaf27a56b2864b916e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (clouds would not move so rapidly and regularly under natural wind, and the distribution and scattering of light through the clouds are also too regular).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05587", "filename": "34109efa884ba350f53cd2c6ae7c37c59353e0112c9e0ffaf27a56b2864b916e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05592", "filename": "36555f2773efe3020a9c861a9a06faacd3298998009f6384eeaab94149a2a2d6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the water in the image moves too regularly, without the ripples that would normally occur when the wind blows).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05593", "filename": "36555f2773efe3020a9c861a9a06faacd3298998009f6384eeaab94149a2a2d6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Overall lack of realism (the water texture in the image is too rough and does not resemble the state of real water).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05594", "filename": "36555f2773efe3020a9c861a9a06faacd3298998009f6384eeaab94149a2a2d6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05596", "filename": "36735f8a8561b3c84eb8c1ec0bf2eda884bb0329189ab0abc1e1ecc289c82ea1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (0.6s - end: The tipped-over can stands up on its own without any force and the beverage inside sprays out).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05597", "filename": "caf5199479ccdde6e9c0641141fb862e24a8635fc440b2f6e926b84437bbaf44_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 0.5s, the disc in the right hand suddenly transforms into a transparent circular cover).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05598", "filename": "cbd832589653a6531032543c21ef5d65c543e2f59d4fbf7d1fe859219be3c539_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (the liquid in the video from 2.1s to 3.8s is suspended in the air and moves upward at a constant speed without any force, which does not conform to the law of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05599", "filename": "cbd832589653a6531032543c21ef5d65c543e2f59d4fbf7d1fe859219be3c539_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (at 1.5s, the coffee hasn't dripped into the lower coffee cup yet, but the coffee surface below suddenly splashes outwards).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05600", "filename": "cbd832589653a6531032543c21ef5d65c543e2f59d4fbf7d1fe859219be3c539_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (at 6.3 seconds, the originally brown liquid suddenly turns into white transparent water droplets).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05601", "filename": "cc0dcee8eb706efa79e76cc77f9595b723b010ce50940e19080927e70f50253d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 4.5s, the sunflower seeds that were originally crushed by the tire suddenly reassembled and gathered together).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05602", "filename": "cc0dcee8eb706efa79e76cc77f9595b723b010ce50940e19080927e70f50253d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.1s, the sunflower seeds on the ground and under the tires are too blurry and appear to be flashing in a granular manner) (at 5.6s, after the wheel runs over the sunflower seeds, the sunflower seeds on the ground obviously disappear and decrease in size).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05603", "filename": "cc0dcee8eb706efa79e76cc77f9595b723b010ce50940e19080927e70f50253d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05604", "filename": "cc0dcee8eb706efa79e76cc77f9595b723b010ce50940e19080927e70f50253d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 5.3s, the sunflower seeds that were run over by the tires on the ground disappear into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05605", "filename": "cc1f7b898939b61564e6eaa2658e6fc85aba201f82d899e575c5a3cf593854cf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (from 1.8s to 4.2s, the strawberries that fell into the blender disappeared out of thin air, and the liquid level in the blender not only did not rise after adding strawberries, but the liquid level in the blender dropped sharply).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05606", "filename": "cc1f7b898939b61564e6eaa2658e6fc85aba201f82d899e575c5a3cf593854cf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 2.2s, the viscous colloid suddenly turns into water droplets as the strawberry falls in) (at 3.5s, the counterclockwise rotating liquid suddenly turns clockwise)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05607", "filename": "cc1f7b898939b61564e6eaa2658e6fc85aba201f82d899e575c5a3cf593854cf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 4.1s, the purple liquid in the cup suddenly turns pink) (at 4.7s, the liquid that splashed off the cup wall disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05612", "filename": "cc276b253efbcc7750c818148eb7bf201b0a59f971ba2ce299df8bc4eeef727a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 2.8 seconds, the cat's tail in the mirror disappears out of thin air, but the cat's tail was always there and there was no obstruction).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05613", "filename": "cc276b253efbcc7750c818148eb7bf201b0a59f971ba2ce299df8bc4eeef727a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (1. At 10s, the kitten's left ear disappears out of nowhere in the mirror, without any obstruction) (2. At 21s, the kitten's left ear reappears out of nowhere)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05615", "filename": "cc276b253efbcc7750c818148eb7bf201b0a59f971ba2ce299df8bc4eeef727a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: The timing is discontinuous (at 3.7s, the kitten's left paw appears crossed and misaligned with its reflection in the mirror).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05616", "filename": "cca104e5eb8c531152a1caa530c19bc6a20f237532e8a74eb0769be757a29349_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.2s, the toy car in my hand suddenly appears out of thin air on the blue lid) (the ice and melted water in the blue box remain still throughout the entire scene; the ice does not melt and the liquid does not flow).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05617", "filename": "cca104e5eb8c531152a1caa530c19bc6a20f237532e8a74eb0769be757a29349_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.4s, the box that originally contained only a small piece of ice suddenly filled with water). Physical behavior (from 0.4s to the end, the ice block remained stationary at the bottom of the blue box and did not float in the water).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05618", "filename": "cca104e5eb8c531152a1caa530c19bc6a20f237532e8a74eb0769be757a29349_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05619", "filename": "cca104e5eb8c531152a1caa530c19bc6a20f237532e8a74eb0769be757a29349_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.5s, the blue basin in the video flickers and distorts) (at 2.2s, the ice in the box has not melted, but a lot of water suddenly comes out from the left side of the box).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05620", "filename": "cccb3be0a67694a6a1c51f5c646ab70582167e01e77cfcdcc3ce5e2e606be954_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: continuous time (a diamond in a 0.2s video, which is deformed and full, suddenly becomes flat).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05621", "filename": "cccb3be0a67694a6a1c51f5c646ab70582167e01e77cfcdcc3ce5e2e606be954_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the shape of the entire shadow is inconsistent with the direction of sunlight, and the shadow appears unnaturally elongated and distorted).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05627", "filename": "e49ff33a013d048933f2000772211bbdb3f628151eb90af46dd31464284eccc9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (in reality, during the 1s-2.3s interval, the number of rotations does not change when only compressed or stretched; in the video, the number of rotations increases, and the wire length appears to increase out of nowhere). Physical behavior (during the 0.9s-2.7s interval, the wheels are pushed upwards by the springs while the vehicle body remains motionless; in reality, the vehicle body should also be lifted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05628", "filename": "e52e2beb5c70c3e5162dfe639f1a9ac5d25ddfd77bf0e4eb4ac7d3982b455120_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the entire segment shows a transparent glass filled with water moving back and forth on a black and white checkerboard table, but the glass does not show the black and white squares that should be in the background; instead, it only shows a long black square and a long white square).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05629", "filename": "e52e2beb5c70c3e5162dfe639f1a9ac5d25ddfd77bf0e4eb4ac7d3982b455120_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05630", "filename": "e52e2beb5c70c3e5162dfe639f1a9ac5d25ddfd77bf0e4eb4ac7d3982b455120_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the stripes reflected from the water appear to shift instantaneously at 0.5s and 3.3s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05631", "filename": "e52e2beb5c70c3e5162dfe639f1a9ac5d25ddfd77bf0e4eb4ac7d3982b455120_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (from 0.9s to 2.1s, the stripes reflected from a transparent glass filled with water moving on a black and white checkerboard table appear to move in a spiral pattern; at 7.1s, a glass filled with water appears out of thin air on the right side of the table).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05632", "filename": "e56b6c9a2751f9e8a22a015258f3eba9afedb11e293b8a4425b06498f0dbbad2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall visual impression is off (in reality, when a soap bubble freezes, the ice crystals usually start from the edge or bottom, and the overall structure is a continuous ice crystal structure. There are no large, independent, sharply defined ice crystals. However, the video shows large, geometrically sharp ice crystals, which is completely inconsistent with the fine, continuous dendritic ice crystals that naturally form when a soap bubble freezes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05636", "filename": "e59f29549f38d51b75127f2130c7fd3cb96d5296d4226592bb1c4e6a728667b0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is abnormal (the water surface is calm throughout the video, and the reflection is blurry and lighter than the real scene due to the refraction of light by the water ripples, but the reflection in the video is almost identical in clarity to the real scene, and even details such as people and flower petals are completely replicated).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05637", "filename": "e59f29549f38d51b75127f2130c7fd3cb96d5296d4226592bb1c4e6a728667b0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (in reality, reflections will have slight perspective distortion due to slight ripples on the water surface, but in the video, the reflection is completely symmetrical to the actual scene in terms of proportion and perspective, without any natural distortion or deviation, which does not match the visual characteristics of real water reflections).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05638", "filename": "e59f29549f38d51b75127f2130c7fd3cb96d5296d4226592bb1c4e6a728667b0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05639", "filename": "e59f29549f38d51b75127f2130c7fd3cb96d5296d4226592bb1c4e6a728667b0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal because the time sequence is not continuous. (The rocks, grass, bushes, and people in the foreground on the shore can obscure the water surface, preventing the reflections of the objects behind them and the people in the distance from being fully and unobstructed. However, in the video, the reflections of the cherry blossom trees and the people completely penetrate the foreground objects without any obstruction.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05640", "filename": "e69f04da03ebf607069d4684ff0e141209fd142b89f2e1605cdbc068fcc76489_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.4s, a small pile of white particles appears out of nowhere on the red object on the far right of the screen).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05641", "filename": "e69f04da03ebf607069d4684ff0e141209fd142b89f2e1605cdbc068fcc76489_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the red subject simultaneously presents two conflicting textures, with both a high-gloss, smooth liquid feel and a rough, grainy solid feel. In reality, no single substance can possess both the contradictory properties of a smooth liquid and a rough solid).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05646", "filename": "e76c984f6cadcbb50122a2b07ff93d5fe2fedaabad84fafd22692b0422b27683_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall visual impression is off (when the sun shines, the clouds will produce varying shades and light and shadows due to differences in thickness and height. In the video, the overall lighting on the clouds is too uniform, with almost no natural transitions between light and shadow, making it appear very flat).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05647", "filename": "e76c984f6cadcbb50122a2b07ff93d5fe2fedaabad84fafd22692b0422b27683_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the overall movement of the clouds in the image is too uniform and smooth without any breaks. All parts of the cloud move steadily at a nearly uniform speed and direction, completely lacking the natural dynamics of breaking up upper-air currents in reality).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05648", "filename": "e76c984f6cadcbb50122a2b07ff93d5fe2fedaabad84fafd22692b0422b27683_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall impression is abnormal (realistic high-altitude clouds are fluffy, thick, with soft edges and random textures, and the clouds have undulations and natural folds; the clouds in the video are flat, without thickness, and have repetitive textures, lacking the three-dimensionality and dynamic texture of real clouds, and are too regular overall).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05649", "filename": "e76f801cf66821149fe5eaf7f93910275b5f9c2ff8ed2fd4a5c06c7d45d539fc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05650", "filename": "e76f801cf66821149fe5eaf7f93910275b5f9c2ff8ed2fd4a5c06c7d45d539fc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Cause and effect (the hydraulic press did not press down on the blue toy at 1.1s, but the blue toy was shaking).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05651", "filename": "e76f801cf66821149fe5eaf7f93910275b5f9c2ff8ed2fd4a5c06c7d45d539fc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to physical behavior (during the period from 2.9s to 5s, when the hydraulic press presses down on the colloid toy, the colloid toy expands outwards, whereas in reality, colloid expands outwards when pressed).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05652", "filename": "e76f801cf66821149fe5eaf7f93910275b5f9c2ff8ed2fd4a5c06c7d45d539fc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 5.4 seconds, the gel toy instantly transforms into a cloth toy).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05653", "filename": "e78bbfc49bd509777d96b151bd4b2768c20bf26b5d5628c521edfee8b1925d3b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the surface of the second icicle from the left is constantly wriggling between 0s and 2.3s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05654", "filename": "e78bbfc49bd509777d96b151bd4b2768c20bf26b5d5628c521edfee8b1925d3b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time is continuous (between 0.7s and 5.8s, the tips of the three longest icicles suddenly turn into a small stream of water flowing downwards, whereas in reality, icicles would only slowly melt and drip water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05655", "filename": "e78bbfc49bd509777d96b151bd4b2768c20bf26b5d5628c521edfee8b1925d3b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (between 1.8s and 8s, the tip of the third icicle from the left suddenly turns into a small stream of water that keeps flowing downwards).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05657", "filename": "c40e8befdfd2e7ca665af7ac493c94aed7536dedcdf8db8dc0052d795db9a65f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.3s, flames suddenly appear in the pool, the flames do not burn and appear on the surface of the pool like a texture, and at 5.6s, the water in the pool suddenly increases and the pool widens without any consistency).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05658", "filename": "c40e8befdfd2e7ca665af7ac493c94aed7536dedcdf8db8dc0052d795db9a65f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (at 0.3s, flames suddenly appear on the surface of the pool and explode, but it does not explode from the water and appears out of thin air; at 1.8s, it explodes again and produces a large amount of smoke).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05659", "filename": "c41b0f2331b5a3c2bf4c350fa83b2e686b221629468b89ca3d603cf47b2ccc6f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.1s and 4.1s, water droplets suddenly appear out of nowhere in mid-air above the water surface and fall to the surface, creating ripples).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05660", "filename": "c41b0f2331b5a3c2bf4c350fa83b2e686b221629468b89ca3d603cf47b2ccc6f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: continuous ripples (the water surface suddenly ripples on its own without any external force in the entire video footage).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05661", "filename": "c56f98a70fa8f63d0a88548a5fe46b87399c996fef503a18ddc63d07046b0e8a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the intuition is abnormal (the curling arc of the smoke in the whole video is too symmetrical, some smoke has abrupt turns without connection, and does not follow the natural trajectory of the spiraling upward and gradually dissipating of the hot airflow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05662", "filename": "c56f98a70fa8f63d0a88548a5fe46b87399c996fef503a18ddc63d07046b0e8a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the intuition is off (the steam in the entire video maintains a uniform opacity and density after rising from the rim of the cup, without any thinning process, which violates the physical laws of heat convection and gas diffusion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05663", "filename": "c56f98a70fa8f63d0a88548a5fe46b87399c996fef503a18ddc63d07046b0e8a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05664", "filename": "c56f98a70fa8f63d0a88548a5fe46b87399c996fef503a18ddc63d07046b0e8a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is too smooth (the smoke rises too smoothly throughout the video, lacking the gradual change of real smoke, and the outline of the smoke is abnormally clear throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05665", "filename": "c061adc2b8cb4b3ee341bf8fbaca305d3ff292ce9e7c83ab1c50f9a4c1078652_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Time continuity (the large bubble in front of the lens deforms and distorts at 0.1s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05666", "filename": "c061adc2b8cb4b3ee341bf8fbaca305d3ff292ce9e7c83ab1c50f9a4c1078652_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (the bubbles rise at inconsistent speeds throughout the video, some fast and some slow, and the bubbles keep merging and splitting).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05667", "filename": "c061adc2b8cb4b3ee341bf8fbaca305d3ff292ce9e7c83ab1c50f9a4c1078652_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous timing (the bubble machine continuously emits a series of connected bubbles of the same size throughout the video, which do not break up after rising but instead suddenly become a series of large bubbles, with no consistency between the beginning and end).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05668", "filename": "c061adc2b8cb4b3ee341bf8fbaca305d3ff292ce9e7c83ab1c50f9a4c1078652_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Intuitive anomaly (the bubbles produced by the bubble machine in the entire video rise upwards like bubbles in water, lacking the lightness of real bubbles, and their shape is inconsistent with the surrounding floating bubbles)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05669", "filename": "c66e9a1b8b157977c7cbe406132ba0311ee5c736b926aa253266f4a72c2f98db_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Intuitive anomaly (the halo effect of sunlight throughout the video is harsh, lacking the transition between the lit and shadowed sides of the leaves under natural light, creating the impression that strong light is directly blurring the leaves, and lacking realistic light and shadow layers).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05670", "filename": "c66e9a1b8b157977c7cbe406132ba0311ee5c736b926aa253266f4a72c2f98db_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the bright areas in the entire video are pure white dead light without any layers, without the gradual change of the sun's circular outline halo, and look more like white blocks that are directly pasted on rather than real light sources, and the leaves are blurry and stuck together, lacking the clear veins of real leaves).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05671", "filename": "c66e9a1b8b157977c7cbe406132ba0311ee5c736b926aa253266f4a72c2f98db_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the upper layer of leaves in the whole video shakes more violently than the lower layer of leaves, and the leaf outlines are blurred, lacking the clear veins of real leaves, and lacking the texture and layering of real leaves).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05672", "filename": "c66e9a1b8b157977c7cbe406132ba0311ee5c736b926aa253266f4a72c2f98db_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: (The sunlight is overexposed throughout the video, and the leaves above the leaves are completely white due to the lack of sunlight and the natural transition of color. The tree trunk and leaves are blurred throughout the video, and the veins of the leaves and the texture of the tree trunk are not visible.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05673", "filename": "c70bd67c0a4360dae4ca72fb3867fe4814365bee60db94b8a919ced0f6c8c2fc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (the spring is shaking on its own without any external force in the entire video footage).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05674", "filename": "c70bd67c0a4360dae4ca72fb3867fe4814365bee60db94b8a919ced0f6c8c2fc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (the trajectory of the spring's jitter in the diagnostic video is inconsistent with the spring's reflection in the sunlight).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05675", "filename": "c70bd67c0a4360dae4ca72fb3867fe4814365bee60db94b8a919ced0f6c8c2fc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05676", "filename": "c70bd67c0a4360dae4ca72fb3867fe4814365bee60db94b8a919ced0f6c8c2fc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal behavior: Physical behavior (at 0.5s, the right spring detaches from its fixed position but does not retract like the left spring, which does not conform to Hooke's Law, and at 3s, the spring suddenly expands without external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05677", "filename": "c79e56d9cb61ccd1bc5045d34a8f25d6f0ad3939e58f4007afb450bdb5df870a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05678", "filename": "c79e56d9cb61ccd1bc5045d34a8f25d6f0ad3939e58f4007afb450bdb5df870a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05679", "filename": "c79e56d9cb61ccd1bc5045d34a8f25d6f0ad3939e58f4007afb450bdb5df870a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.2s, the light on the light strip does not change, but the ambient light and shadow suddenly darken, showing no consistency).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05680", "filename": "c79e56d9cb61ccd1bc5045d34a8f25d6f0ad3939e58f4007afb450bdb5df870a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05681", "filename": "c85fe42f10fe62ae8e12d08da63b76d62d28edce02b17b66d89874bea73d72af_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: (The transition between the red glow on the horizon and the pinkish-purple gradient in the sky is abrupt and lacks the softness of real atmospheric scattering.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05682", "filename": "c85fe42f10fe62ae8e12d08da63b76d62d28edce02b17b66d89874bea73d72af_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: (The light source on the horizon in the entire video does not have a normal sun outline, the cloud texture in the sky is repetitive and the edges are blurry, lacking the sense of layering and dynamism of real clouds.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05683", "filename": "c85fe42f10fe62ae8e12d08da63b76d62d28edce02b17b66d89874bea73d72af_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: (The light source at the horizon in the entire video does not have a natural transition, and the color of the sky does not have a natural gradation. A real sunset is a soft transition from red, orange, pink, purple and blue from the horizon upwards.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05684", "filename": "c85fe42f10fe62ae8e12d08da63b76d62d28edce02b17b66d89874bea73d72af_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence appears to be continuous (in the entire video, the sun at the horizon moves from left to right while the camera remains fixed; a real sunrise or sunset would be from bottom to top and from top to bottom).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05685", "filename": "c91fc4e35c0a985bda71faaeae60b68574ff82bc4b4ed6a2196f1bd127e56f59_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the fluid curls and folds throughout the video, violating the laws of liquid surface tension and gravity).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05686", "filename": "c91fc4e35c0a985bda71faaeae60b68574ff82bc4b4ed6a2196f1bd127e56f59_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05687", "filename": "7803e60972f329ef5e6db0775cfc214ea764d0de44bd5ab3a40a0f20171198fe_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous flickering throughout the video (thick clouds in the video move rapidly from left to right and then disappear).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05688", "filename": "7803e60972f329ef5e6db0775cfc214ea764d0de44bd5ab3a40a0f20171198fe_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the video, the clouds on the right side are thinner than the clouds in the lower left corner, and the sky turns black after the lower left clouds appear, while the right side remains clear, creating an overly strong sense of separation. In real life, clouds in a clear sky are thin and drifting, and the texture of clouds in the same space is consistent.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05689", "filename": "7803e60972f329ef5e6db0775cfc214ea764d0de44bd5ab3a40a0f20171198fe_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05690", "filename": "7803e60972f329ef5e6db0775cfc214ea764d0de44bd5ab3a40a0f20171198fe_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.6 seconds, the clouds on the left side of the video suddenly appear in the shape of clouds. Before 1.6 seconds, the clouds on the left side were in the form of dense fog. In real life, the shape of clouds appears slowly, not suddenly).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05691", "filename": "7826b5f162370c3078985eaaaf198ad0b7ac0d326c71020d510284a87f1d5ae3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is continuous (an orange-yellow light suddenly appears in the sky on the left at 0.3s, disappears abruptly at 0.6s and 0.8s, and at 1.7s there are no traces of fireworks launches in the middle of the screen, but fireworks explode in the sky); Physical behavior (from the start to 4.1s, the smoke and traces from the fireworks explosions in the sky do not disappear and remain stationary in the same position; in real life, the smoke from fireworks explosions slowly diffuses and disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05692", "filename": "7826b5f162370c3078985eaaaf198ad0b7ac0d326c71020d510284a87f1d5ae3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.7 seconds, an orange-yellow ball of light suddenly appears in the sky on the left and explodes); the overall realism is abnormal (the traces and smoke from the fireworks explosion remain stationary in the same position in the sky throughout the entire video, without dissipating, whereas in real life, the smoke and traces from fireworks explosions would slowly dissipate).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05696", "filename": "7924a9fcd5aabffd139d09f7acb1bfabac9244297da2644f31ec98de7f9ffeb8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.5s, the head of the swan on the right deforms; at 1.5s, the beak of the swan on the right changes from light yellow to dark yellow; at 2s, a small fish suddenly appears in the beak of the swan on the right); and the physical behavior is abnormal (no ripples are produced on the water surface when the swan on the right moves on the water surface).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05697", "filename": "7924a9fcd5aabffd139d09f7acb1bfabac9244297da2644f31ec98de7f9ffeb8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall realism is abnormal (at 3.4s, the swan on the right does not create a splash when it treads water on its left horn, whereas in real life, a swan would create a splash when it treads water; the bird on the left moves its upper body, but its feet remain stationary, whereas in reality, when a bird moves its upper body, its feet should slightly sway to create ripples on the water); the timing is continuous (at 1.8s, the head of the bird on the left deforms; at 1s, the left foot of the swan on the right turns red; at 3.6s, the left foot of the swan on the right turns red plastic).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05698", "filename": "7924a9fcd5aabffd139d09f7acb1bfabac9244297da2644f31ec98de7f9ffeb8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (the bird's head on the left is exposed between 2.5s and 3.5s, the beak of the bird on the left becomes smaller at 3.6s, and the beak of the swan on the right becomes larger at 0.1s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05699", "filename": "7924a9fcd5aabffd139d09f7acb1bfabac9244297da2644f31ec98de7f9ffeb8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (during the period from 0s to 0.4s, the bird on the left transforms into a larger swan; the swan on the right undergoes head deformation).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05700", "filename": "07975a76b745c0b8b5f0afc44a0bf0283ed05ea9dbbd9bfbc44e10f6c4e4ca43_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (the rushing stream in the picture does not produce water splashes when it flows, and the water surface in the lower left corner is blue, whereas in reality, a rushing stream would produce a lot of water splashes and the water surface would be white).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05701", "filename": "07975a76b745c0b8b5f0afc44a0bf0283ed05ea9dbbd9bfbc44e10f6c4e4ca43_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05702", "filename": "07975a76b745c0b8b5f0afc44a0bf0283ed05ea9dbbd9bfbc44e10f6c4e4ca43_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05703", "filename": "07975a76b745c0b8b5f0afc44a0bf0283ed05ea9dbbd9bfbc44e10f6c4e4ca43_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the image shows leaves in a stream being swayed by the water, but the leaves do not drift away with the current despite the huge impact).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05704", "filename": "8040a1e9368f316d279c8deea161b912269ba8fa90c38f30bc163839fff7cef9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (continuous deformation occurs on the rope on the right).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05705", "filename": "8040a1e9368f316d279c8deea161b912269ba8fa90c38f30bc163839fff7cef9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.4s, it is clear that the rubber bands on the person's two hands are separated, and at 2.5s, a knot appears on the rubber bands without them being tied).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05706", "filename": "8040a1e9368f316d279c8deea161b912269ba8fa90c38f30bc163839fff7cef9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 1.3s, the rubber band merges with the finger, causing clipping); Time continuity (at 2.4s and 6s, a section of the rubber band disappears, and at 3.3s, a section of the rubber band reappears on the finger).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05711", "filename": "8095a384cffe043e847c6b0d8ad81c54dfa7b99721374aad61a11234c70c7a8a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05712", "filename": "8095a384cffe043e847c6b0d8ad81c54dfa7b99721374aad61a11234c70c7a8a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the overall realism is abnormal (during the period from 3.9s to 5.4s, the surface of the mineral water bottle can be clearly seen to be uneven, whereas in real life, the surface of a mineral water bottle is smooth).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05713", "filename": "8095a384cffe043e847c6b0d8ad81c54dfa7b99721374aad61a11234c70c7a8a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05717", "filename": "1e7aac88494208a267416cefaaae3495f303cfede3c15711ab70cb1b5d460942_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Causality (the hydraulic press squeezes the object from 1.7s to 2.4s without changing the object) and continuity of time (white powdery substances suddenly appear on both sides of the black object at 2.1s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05718", "filename": "1e7aac88494208a267416cefaaae3495f303cfede3c15711ab70cb1b5d460942_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 2.3s, the compressed object extends in four directions; at 3.9s, the compressed object bulges and expands upwards).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05719", "filename": "1e88d69d690cef3a44f3aa7d16fd56d265a9c0186c8a7c1c46d54c39272fa8cb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (no small white light spots appear in the image at 0.4s)", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05720", "filename": "1e88d69d690cef3a44f3aa7d16fd56d265a9c0186c8a7c1c46d54c39272fa8cb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the yellow item melts faster from 1.2s to 5.8s) Causality (the volume of the melted liquid from the yellow item during the 1.2s to 5.8s period is inversely proportional to the volume of the item).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05721", "filename": "1e88d69d690cef3a44f3aa7d16fd56d265a9c0186c8a7c1c46d54c39272fa8cb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 0.8s, the liquid is on the yellow object, and the yellow object suddenly becomes dented) Cause and effect (from 0.3s to 2s, the volume of the liquid poured is greater than the container itself, but the container is not full; at 4.2s, the container is full of liquid, but the liquid does not overflow)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05722", "filename": "1e88d69d690cef3a44f3aa7d16fd56d265a9c0186c8a7c1c46d54c39272fa8cb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.5s, the black dot to the left of the yellow object suddenly disappears and the surface of the yellow object becomes smooth)", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05723", "filename": "1ea5397a7c87be41b7063115783fd086400843329071427961a406e19b5a841a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time sequence is continuous (at 1.1s, a lens suddenly appears in the upper right corner and the image on the lens flickers). Physical behavior (at 3s, the wheels are stationary and the car slides backward).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05724", "filename": "1ea5397a7c87be41b7063115783fd086400843329071427961a406e19b5a841a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.1s, the shape of the yellow object on the left changes from round to oval).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05725", "filename": "1ea5397a7c87be41b7063115783fd086400843329071427961a406e19b5a841a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Cause and effect (at 2s, the tire starts moving from a standstill without any black marks appearing on the ground) Time sequence (at 3s, an air intake hole suddenly appears on the wheel hub; at 3.6s, an air intake hole suddenly appears on the wheel hub; at 5s, a small white light spot suddenly appears on the inner left side of the wheel hub; at 5.5s, an air intake hole suddenly appears on the wheel hub)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05726", "filename": "1ed733af6f68cb107ba92b81bcf905896ff0b5dd205dce7bbaae1a34cf118fc5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the object under the finger breaks at 2s, and the ball under the finger suddenly attaches at 2.9s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05727", "filename": "1ed733af6f68cb107ba92b81bcf905896ff0b5dd205dce7bbaae1a34cf118fc5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 3.1s, the magnetic bead in front of the right hand suddenly moves instantaneously) Physical behavior (at 4.4s, the object stops rotating while the potential energy of the surrounding pendants does not decrease)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05728", "filename": "1ed733af6f68cb107ba92b81bcf905896ff0b5dd205dce7bbaae1a34cf118fc5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (at 0.1s, the volume of the pendant on the left suddenly increases; at 0.4s, a second item appears on the left and its shape is distorted; from 4.8s to 7s, the item suddenly moves backward and its shape is distorted).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05732", "filename": "1f122703236d3a8c11ff42b285eec658e24d812e928556d47d3e7dcfc146e91f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Causality (the flames in the video footage continue to burn while the objects above them remain unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05733", "filename": "1f122703236d3a8c11ff42b285eec658e24d812e928556d47d3e7dcfc146e91f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the visuals: Physical behavior (liquid is poured out at 2s and the liquid suspends itself in mid-air), Time continuity (the flame suddenly increases in size without any gradual change at 1.5s), Causality (the liquid poured in between 1.5s and 3.8s fills the container below, but the container's volume is greater than the liquid's).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05734", "filename": "1f122703236d3a8c11ff42b285eec658e24d812e928556d47d3e7dcfc146e91f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time sequence (at 1.5s, the flame suddenly turns into liquid; at 1.8s, small bubbles appear in the liquid on the metal object; at 2.1s, the liquid in the container undergoes a sudden change, turning into a solid shape).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05743", "filename": "1fe91c1b45f87ca28c325e9e168793bbe27c0e3766cf1bb856b14129e18ac457_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 0.3s, debris suddenly appears in the lower right corner of the fire and twists and jumps); Physical behavior (at 3.3s, the pile of firewood in the lower left corner moves to the right without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05744", "filename": "1fe91c1b45f87ca28c325e9e168793bbe27c0e3766cf1bb856b14129e18ac457_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the fire flames suddenly decrease at 0.9s, the pile of firewood next to the left suddenly blurs at 2.3s, and the wood held in the left hand suddenly disappears at 3.9s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05745", "filename": "1fe91c1b45f87ca28c325e9e168793bbe27c0e3766cf1bb856b14129e18ac457_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.5 seconds, a small flame suddenly appears on the pile of firewood above the campfire).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05746", "filename": "1fe91c1b45f87ca28c325e9e168793bbe27c0e3766cf1bb856b14129e18ac457_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.3s, the pile of firewood in the hand just touches the flame and starts burning; from 1.8s onwards, the fire grows larger even without any additional fuel, which is unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05747", "filename": "37d70c98fb8c34ccfa95aa1dc6f98db07c7967b451265a5356853c91407ea570_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall visuals are abnormal (the black tubular object connecting the bottom of the ball in the entire video has no sealing details at all, as if it is directly glued to the balloon, which violates the physical connection logic of inflation and ejection. In addition, the ball bounces while inflated, but its volume does not change. If it were affected by wind, it would not be swaying slowly and randomly as in the video. The reflective points on the balloon do not change significantly with the shaking).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05748", "filename": "37d70c98fb8c34ccfa95aa1dc6f98db07c7967b451265a5356853c91407ea570_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Overall intuitive anomaly (the black tubular object connecting the bottom of the balloon in the entire video has no sealing details at all, as if it is directly glued to the balloon, which violates the physical connection logic of inflation and ejection. In addition, the balloon bounces while inflated, but its volume does not change. If the swing is affected by wind, it will not sway slowly and randomly as in the video. The reflective points on the balloon do not change significantly with the shaking).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05749", "filename": "37f82c5450aa2c1327ede30449c7a600c65812c5ff486915afa34fb6881830a5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall impression is off (the flames on the left side of the video appear as an unnatural arc, with harsh edges and no gradual transition, unlike the spread of a real wildfire. Real flames spread naturally with the wind, rather than following a regular geometric curve. The ground is covered with dry grass ash, and the intensity of the flames does not match the flammability of the dry grass. Some areas of the flames are too thick, lacking the light and rapid spread of burning dry grass. The smoke density is unevenly distributed and does not show a natural gradual transition with the size of the burning area and the wind direction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05750", "filename": "37f82c5450aa2c1327ede30449c7a600c65812c5ff486915afa34fb6881830a5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is off (the transition between flames and smoke is abrupt throughout the video; the direction and density of the smoke's diffusion do not match the heat field of the burning flames; the smoke next to the flames lacks the dynamic upward movement caused by the heat wave and the natural sense of layering, resembling static fog clinging to the ground; in some areas, the boundary between smoke and scorched ground is blurred, lacking the transitional texture of smoke and ash after a real fire; the texture of the weeds on the ground is repetitive and lacks detail; in some areas, the grass stalks blend into the scorched ground, lacking the texture of real plants and the details of the burnt remains).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05755", "filename": "38f5756e330f54ee00af2a45a752f69411d39b1b26e31e74d5ab4ccd221ced5a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the relationship between the fingers and the drumsticks is completely disordered throughout the video, the shape of the fingers is distorted and the proportion of the fingers is out of proportion, the connection between the wrist and the arm is unnatural, the contact point between the drumsticks and the drumhead is blurred, the perspective and length proportion of the drumsticks are out of proportion, the metal hardware of the snare drum on the right side is out of proportion, and the number, spacing and shape of the drumsticks are chaotic).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05756", "filename": "38f5756e330f54ee00af2a45a752f69411d39b1b26e31e74d5ab4ccd221ced5a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the swing trajectory and length ratio of the drumsticks do not conform to the physical laws of human playing, the sense of linkage with the hand movements is completely lost, and the drumsticks do not strike the drum surface, but appear to be floating on the drum surface without making contact).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05757", "filename": "38f5756e330f54ee00af2a45a752f69411d39b1b26e31e74d5ab4ccd221ced5a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05758", "filename": "38f5756e330f54ee00af2a45a752f69411d39b1b26e31e74d5ab4ccd221ced5a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Overall visual anomaly (the drumsticks and cymbals have no contact point; they are completely suspended in the air with no dynamic trajectory of being struck or any trace of physical collision. There is a clear gap between the drumsticks and the drumhead; there is no contact, rebound, or displacement when being struck. The whole thing presents a static and suspended state, which is incongruous. The logic of the entire performance is confused. When the drum stand on the right is not being struck, it moves up and down without any external support).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05759", "filename": "39d82f6d502eea422deb3eb7b3809938c01b9c8bb6516a41c4dab15baf823e0f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the water droplets in the entire video are extremely uneven in size; in some areas the water droplets are so dense that they overlap, while in other areas there are abruptly huge water droplets, and there are no signs of gravity causing them to flow, converge, or drip. Normal water droplets would converge downwards due to gravity, and the water droplets at the edges should be larger and easier to drip. Although the size distribution of the stationary water droplets is different, none of them show any tendency to deform, converge, or drip under the influence of gravity, creating a spliced and disjointed feel with the dynamic sense of flowing lines).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05760", "filename": "39d82f6d502eea422deb3eb7b3809938c01b9c8bb6516a41c4dab15baf823e0f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is off (in the entire video, the water droplets lack clear highlights; real water droplets would form bright spots due to the reflection of ambient light from their curved surfaces. Some droplets have blurred edges that blend into the background, lacking the transparency and three-dimensionality of independent droplets and the stickiness of the surface they adhere to. The water droplets converge and roll in inconsistent directions, creating a chaotic rolling motion and a sense of separation between flowing and still parts. The trailing direction of the flowing water droplets is also erratic, disrupting the realistic dynamic logic of fluids).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05761", "filename": "39d82f6d502eea422deb3eb7b3809938c01b9c8bb6516a41c4dab15baf823e0f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Overall visual anomaly (all water droplets in the entire video are completely still, without any flow, sliding, gathering, or deformation caused by gravity, which violates the law of real physics that water droplets on an inclined plane will inevitably flow downwards under the influence of gravity. The water droplets maintain a round and isolated static shape, without the dynamic characteristics of downward trailing edges stretching or merging together, which does not conform to the natural state under the combined action of liquid surface tension and gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05762", "filename": "39d82f6d502eea422deb3eb7b3809938c01b9c8bb6516a41c4dab15baf823e0f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (the large water droplet at the center of the image has a blurred and unnatural outline, and its fusion with the surrounding smaller water droplets does not follow the physical laws of surface tension. Some water droplets appear to be stuck to the surface without forming a normal liquid film connection, and there are even unreasonable breaks and overlaps, violating the continuity of liquid surface tension. The size and spacing of the smaller water droplets are completely random, without the natural gradation of density from condensation. The area near the large water droplet should be denser, but some areas have excessively high water droplet density while others are too sparse, lacking a realistic physical distribution logic).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05765", "filename": "40f43731b8ef868e3d488b6f8f64aa1b813a421743227d5b9b417bbf12762c5b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual effect is abnormal (the sunlight beams in the entire image (Tyndall effect) present a harsh, striped, discontinuous appearance with sharp edges and uneven thickness. In reality, the beams should be soft, gradually diffused with airborne dust, rather than straight lines as seen in the image. The water spray on the left is not a natural mist or column, but rather a harsh patchwork of white mist and striped beams of light. It lacks the granular texture of water droplets, the dynamic trajectory of splashing water, and the arc-like diffusion of water flow. It resembles a blurry white block rather than a realistic water spray).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05766", "filename": "40f43731b8ef868e3d488b6f8f64aa1b813a421743227d5b9b417bbf12762c5b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall visual perception is abnormal (the Tyndall effect should naturally decrease as the concentration of water mist and air dust decreases, but the beam of light gradually disappears completely to the upper right throughout the video, which does not conform to the visual phenomenon of light being scattered by colloidal particles).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05767", "filename": "40f43731b8ef868e3d488b6f8f64aa1b813a421743227d5b9b417bbf12762c5b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual effect is abnormal (there is no transition between the lit and shadowed sides of the leaves in the entire image; the bright parts of the leaves illuminated by the beams are directly exposed and white without any gradation of light and dark, while the unlit leaves are completely black, lacking the sense of layering of ambient light reflection. In reality, the light and shadow on the leaves are softly transitioned, and the beams of light have a flowing misty feel, but the leaves are still and lack the dynamic details of wind blowing, making the combination of movement and stillness extremely harsh).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05768", "filename": "40f43731b8ef868e3d488b6f8f64aa1b813a421743227d5b9b417bbf12762c5b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual perception is abnormal (in the entire video, the smoke and water droplets appear suddenly from left to right and then gradually disappear. The Tyndall effect should naturally decrease as the concentration of water mist and air dust decreases, but in the entire video, the beam of light gradually disappears completely to the upper right, which does not conform to the visual phenomenon of light being scattered by colloidal particles).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05776", "filename": "41ac07c071f7512ffacba80fc14f87444476b000903adf0afac77af4b56a7851_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is off (in the entire video, the waterfall on the right appears to flow out of the rocks out of nowhere despite the broken water flow; the water flow is too rigidly layered and mechanical, lacking the randomness and dynamism of real water flow; some water flows are rigidly distributed in blocky, stepped shapes, without natural splashing or misting effects; the lighting and shadows on the water flow are chaotic, with excessively bright highlights and excessively dark shadows appearing in the same area, violating the physical laws of light and shadow; the connection between the water flow and the rocks is blurry, lacking the wetness and texture of water washing over rocks; the texture of the large rocks in the foreground is repetitive and blurry, lacking the cracks and weathering marks of real rocks, and the surface looks like painted blocks of color, lacking three-dimensionality and rough texture; the edges of the rocks are jagged, blurred, and without clear outlines).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05777", "filename": "P01_102_113_babb379c10836c19_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Water started flowing without the tap being turned on at 0s, and from 2.8s to 8s, the amount of foam on the hands increased as the water was rinsed.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05778", "filename": "P01_102_117_3799ecce1897a87e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the movement of the figure wiping their hands with a towel is too smooth, unlike a realistic scene, lacking the cadence and nuances expected in real life).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05779", "filename": "P01_102_117_3799ecce1897a87e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05780", "filename": "P01_102_117_3799ecce1897a87e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (in the video, the towel in the person's hand suddenly disappears at 4.4s and suddenly reappears in the person's left hand at 6.6s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05781", "filename": "P01_102_118_d49aea32331bb1fb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the person is wiping their hands in the entire video, and the towel gradually shrinks during the wiping process).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05782", "filename": "P01_102_118_d49aea32331bb1fb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (Throughout the video, a person is wiping their hands with a towel, and the water on their hands cannot be wiped away. At 6.9 seconds, the towel suddenly disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05783", "filename": "P01_104_3_592b19e3e375f65d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual intuition is abnormal (the towel folding action in the scene is too smooth, unlike a realistic scene, lacking the cadence that should be present in reality). Time continuity (the towel deforms from a triangle to a square between 3.2s and 3.6s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05784", "filename": "P01_104_3_592b19e3e375f65d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05785", "filename": "P01_104_42_caaed8c31c5cc884_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (0.1s-0.4s). The foam in the pot does not flow with the tilt of the pot. Under normal circumstances, the liquid will move due to the flow driven by gravity.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05786", "filename": "P01_104_42_caaed8c31c5cc884_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (during the process of washing dishes, from 1.5s to 2.9s, the person's left thumb penetrates the pot, violating the principle that solids are impermeable). Overall intuitive anomalies: (The person's movements while washing dishes are too smooth, unlike realistic scenes, lacking the necessary pauses and jolts).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05787", "filename": "P01_104_42_caaed8c31c5cc884_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.1s, the handle of the cup in the hand suddenly disappears, and at 1.5s, the handle suddenly reappears and changes position; from 6.1s to 8s, the water from the faucet continuously impacts the pot, but there is neither splashing nor any diffusion or rebound of the water after being blocked. In reality, when high-speed flowing water impacts a solid surface, it will inevitably produce splashes, ripples, or dispersion of water flow due to the transfer of kinetic energy and the breaking of surface tension.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05788", "filename": "P01_104_91_94ef0a01f09ef94b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_05789", "filename": "P01_105_76_30c1fcc614565a35_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (in the scene, a person is cutting a cucumber, and after 5.7 seconds, the cucumber disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05790", "filename": "P01_105_76_30c1fcc614565a35_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the scene shows a person cutting a cucumber; at 2.2s, a single slice is cut completely, but at 2.4s, it becomes many slices; the same pattern repeats from 4.3s to 8s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05791", "filename": "P01_105_220_3307b9418c09282c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal; the timing is continuous (at 0s, the box in the person's hand turns into two boxes, and from 1.7s to 2.6s, the square box in the person's hand suddenly turns into a banknote).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05792", "filename": "P01_105_220_3307b9418c09282c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.5s, a banknote without any creases is taken out of the empty box in the scene, and the banknote is longer than the box. Normally, if the paper taken out is larger than the container, there will be some creases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05793", "filename": "P01_105_220_3307b9418c09282c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is continuous (at 0.1s, the box suddenly closes and changes from a cube to a cuboid). The overall visual effect is abnormal (the action of the character taking out the paper from the box after 2.2s is too smooth, unlike a realistic scene, lacking the jarring effect that should be present in reality).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05794", "filename": "P01_105_230_94a512d90806569b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.1s, the person in the video uses a knife to cut the packaging bag but fails to cut it open; at 3.8s, the blade passes right through it, as if the packaging bag did not exist).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05795", "filename": "P01_105_235_7d01e9dbf9c15b20_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the object cut off between 3.3s and 3.9s is pushed aside with the knife, and its thickness is obviously increased).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05796", "filename": "P01_105_235_7d01e9dbf9c15b20_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05797", "filename": "P01_105_239_9bf1aeace7c084ef_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing changes abruptly (from 0.4s to 0.5s, the potato suddenly becomes longer and cracked; from 1.8s to 2.1s, the knife hasn't even touched the potato yet, but suddenly many potato pieces appear).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05798", "filename": "P27_104_114_aa6f860acff80dcb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.7s, the fabric suddenly turns into a ball without any external force, and after being thrown at 3s, the fabric does not disperse but turns into a ball; at 3.1s, the fabric hits a cup on the table, but the cup does not move).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05799", "filename": "P27_104_114_aa6f860acff80dcb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_05800", "filename": "P27_104_114_aa6f860acff80dcb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity: (The cloth ball becomes regular in shape after being thrown at 5.1 seconds. The cloth spreads out instead of remaining in its original shape. The core reason is the flexible nature of the cloth + the uneven effect of external force and air resistance, plus the lack of a fixed rigid structure, which makes it unable to maintain its shape.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05801", "filename": "P27_104_116_c404ded844b3a3a5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (the dark red floral fabric increases in size and turns bright red after being taken out of the bag at 1.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05802", "filename": "P27_104_116_c404ded844b3a3a5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.5s, the dark red floral fabric in the bag suddenly turns into a red and white striped fabric; at 4.1s, the lighter on the table turns into a brand new small mat made of cloth-like gel; at 6.8s, an apple appears out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05803", "filename": "P27_104_117_4b9cd38922f5030f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the letters on the green jar inside the bag distort during the packing process from 3.7s to 4.5s; the apple inside the bag disappears out of thin air from 2.1s to 5.1s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05804", "filename": "P27_104_117_4b9cd38922f5030f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (0s-1.1s, without any camera transition, the red speckled fabric in the bag suddenly turns off-white and has a patterned design).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05805", "filename": "P27_104_145_7325cbbfe99440c3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (two towels removed at 2.4s suddenly merge into one after being placed on the table at 6.7s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05806", "filename": "P27_104_255_93554b15de52d053_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05807", "filename": "d5d13db9d8eb59293163f3af0469690291aeec7c124fb32e5ca63e05fb44fe82_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05809", "filename": "d07f15bd00ca8a2f84e3e267c6b0c98144b3287831bdb292862387ea3f2bfd3b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (flickering occurs throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05810", "filename": "d07f15bd00ca8a2f84e3e267c6b0c98144b3287831bdb292862387ea3f2bfd3b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (from 1.4s to 8s, a white object suddenly bulges upwards and its volume slowly increases).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05811", "filename": "d7d3041b287ffcc01f81fc6f7861f8be85f8ef2f31cf124db083240530115268_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Causality (the cardboard on the left burns throughout the video without any change in its appearance); Overall intuition is off (the flames in the video burn too smoothly, lacking a natural feel).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05812", "filename": "d7d3041b287ffcc01f81fc6f7861f8be85f8ef2f31cf124db083240530115268_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the burning scene flickers throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05813", "filename": "d8ce6bbf89655cdbe262b3f19b6d10272f250c819eb7de1372fe7c99a32b0484_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the water flow in the entire video is too smooth and lacks a natural feel).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05814", "filename": "d9a26685cde8a77403d87a9f47e0a42cb43aa9e5679d638dec93d82761e8a4f3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the two cars merge at 3s, and a car model shadow suddenly appears on the model track at 4.3s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05815", "filename": "d9f6ed8022c9c2f417a0133d8a1a8302b2bd13113837a4645c8b8aa8d2ce0b72_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (clouds appear granular throughout the entire sequence).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05816", "filename": "d33c1b51cec5b34a8711f156a4c1e331380c02575d05af4fed661e253e9b3d42_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Causality (coffee is continuously poured into the cup throughout the video, but the amount of coffee in the cup does not increase).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05817", "filename": "d33c1b51cec5b34a8711f156a4c1e331380c02575d05af4fed661e253e9b3d42_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (at 4.7 seconds, a support suddenly appears at the bottom of the coffee container).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05818", "filename": "d56aab3a5ea94f6a0fcb66f57f1c690b9b30857c2a5264ca6470a3ef26dfea8c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (a white cotton-like object suddenly appears at the finger at 1.9s) and physical phenomena (the middle finger passes through the bottom of the cup at 2.5s, and the white cotton-like object appears through the cup wall at 4.7s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05820", "filename": "d063e1d3c82fae68c8d79c8209393f6430e04b8504c88f7878f0d2dde3f707e2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Cause and effect (the crystal rotated at 3.2s, but the color light in the mirror did not change).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05821", "filename": "d80dfea480a9249bd210014864d6b8efcd2b28ca9c15d3c5ff16d03738b5b15f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the white paper-like object at the bottom of the container moves upward without external force at 0.9s) is continuous in time (the white granular shadow in the upper left part of the container flickers when the video is rotated).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05824", "filename": "d97a0e417f13015a525e804e40307a6b1135206ebbfa5b0243fe170a05886ede_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the blue flame at the igniter tip suddenly disappears at 0.9s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05825", "filename": "d275e889d82ab365d990be9ddf3909ed0126bbd029c7e085a31db900c576b750_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the surface of the gear teeth in the entire video frame appears grainy).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05826", "filename": "d275e889d82ab365d990be9ddf3909ed0126bbd029c7e085a31db900c576b750_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 3.6s, the shadow of another gear appears on the left gear) Causal relationship (at 4.4s, the left gear is above the right gear, and the two gears disengage but still move)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05827", "filename": "f465fc2020613b653d0b0e86869adef2eeadef1772c1e937906a6a1a929ab6e1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the wires of the small and large mousetraps clipped through at 1.9 seconds in the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05828", "filename": "f465fc2020613b653d0b0e86869adef2eeadef1772c1e937906a6a1a929ab6e1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the character's left hand moves too stiffly and unnaturally when putting down the small mousetrap, lacking continuity; at 2.5s, the character's little finger and ring finger appear to be glued to the bottom of the mousetrap)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05829", "filename": "f465fc2020613b653d0b0e86869adef2eeadef1772c1e937906a6a1a929ab6e1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05830", "filename": "f465fc2020613b653d0b0e86869adef2eeadef1772c1e937906a6a1a929ab6e1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the duration is continuous (at the beginning of the video, the small mousetrap is much smaller than the large mousetrap, but at 1.9 seconds, when the small mousetrap falls, its size suddenly becomes the same as the large mousetrap).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05831", "filename": "f556aaeebf27b845abb1dbe03807a0a1660940633a54e7458915575c626c4821_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the flow speed of the seawater in the image is inconsistent with the flow speed of the clouds in the sky; the seawater has been sped up, but the clouds in the sky flow at a normal speed).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05832", "filename": "f556aaeebf27b845abb1dbe03807a0a1660940633a54e7458915575c626c4821_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time-lapse (the seawater in the lower right corner of the screen keeps flashing at a high frequency).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05833", "filename": "f556aaeebf27b845abb1dbe03807a0a1660940633a54e7458915575c626c4821_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (at 3.5s in the video, the distant sea surface begins to become smooth, without the ripples that should be present on the ocean surface).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05834", "filename": "f556aaeebf27b845abb1dbe03807a0a1660940633a54e7458915575c626c4821_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continues (at 1.9 seconds, a new character suddenly appears in the lower left corner of the screen).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05835", "filename": "f588f1026f3351cc83b53afb88f4ece77118f5bc2cc6b46c9a2e9df520ac9e02_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05836", "filename": "f588f1026f3351cc83b53afb88f4ece77118f5bc2cc6b46c9a2e9df520ac9e02_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the edges of the snowball in the image appear to have an abnormally uniform granular texture when melting, instead of the natural shape of a melting snowball where the edges gradually become wet and soft).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05837", "filename": "f588f1026f3351cc83b53afb88f4ece77118f5bc2cc6b46c9a2e9df520ac9e02_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05838", "filename": "f960fdf2fa14fb80702f198bc68f3da7f95ea0196f1dc070e763073ae0467b54_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (at 4.9 seconds, the wood on the fire suddenly carbonized into charcoal and then suddenly disappeared).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05839", "filename": "f960fdf2fa14fb80702f198bc68f3da7f95ea0196f1dc070e763073ae0467b54_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (the flames at the bottom of the fire in the image are too bright, looking more like a sticker than a normal flame).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05840", "filename": "f960fdf2fa14fb80702f198bc68f3da7f95ea0196f1dc070e763073ae0467b54_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The duration is prolonged (at 1 seconds, a piece of firewood suddenly appears in the upper left corner of the screen).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05841", "filename": "f960fdf2fa14fb80702f198bc68f3da7f95ea0196f1dc070e763073ae0467b54_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 1.5 seconds in the video, the firewood suddenly charred and started burning as soon as it was placed on the flame, and the burning speed was too fast).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05846", "filename": "f3414d32d41f4028aab9214417c3fd858b2118fb08af429f57a61cdd3faf01dd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (the water level in the bowl suddenly drops out of nowhere at 0.5 seconds in the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05847", "filename": "f3414d32d41f4028aab9214417c3fd858b2118fb08af429f57a61cdd3faf01dd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the movement of ice blocks in the scene is too smooth; even when two ice blocks meet, they can pass each other very easily without any sense of abruptness in reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05851", "filename": "f6767a9e04fd8095d4c31be44e224e4c8f39da878e52d697856504922a186eb9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the water in the pot is boiling very violently, but the bubbles on the pot wall do not change at all).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05852", "filename": "f6767a9e04fd8095d4c31be44e224e4c8f39da878e52d697856504922a186eb9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time-lapse (the bubbles produced by the boiling water in the pot in the image are too smooth, more like plastic, and lack the realism of water bubbles).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05853", "filename": "f6767a9e04fd8095d4c31be44e224e4c8f39da878e52d697856504922a186eb9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05854", "filename": "f6869d0a7fb443fa67e48b38a8166c3c93507f81508305dcdb8eab70fb22b3b4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The duration is continuous (at 1.1 seconds in the video, a black object suddenly appears between the hydraulic press and the battery).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05855", "filename": "f6869d0a7fb443fa67e48b38a8166c3c93507f81508305dcdb8eab70fb22b3b4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (the battery below suddenly expands and deforms when the hydraulic press lifts up in 0.9 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05856", "filename": "178874f84d6f180439cb7a6293557a09358f87a495347897b134cfbd3217a1d8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (during the entire video, as the clouds in the sky expand, the area covered by the rain gradually increases, but the ground is not wet; instead, it is swallowed up by white mist).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05858", "filename": "537703e215c4ff4404577f468c02c164660df132849a7c805eaa5628297d0118_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the white steam diffuses in clumps throughout the video, which does not conform to the principles of gas diffusion). Continuous timing (from 5.1 seconds to the end, steaming kitchen utensils pass directly through the water pipe on the table).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05859", "filename": "581043ba9072a9788fc124d904e26ab7eb6fb4bf8a446cfc4bdd522475480b2a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 0.6s, an object floating underwater suddenly rises and grows larger); Physical behavior (at 3.5s, white dry ice sinks underwater without any force, which does not conform to the law of interaction forces).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05860", "filename": "729892b8440230e9d78878aea891dd1ad31ca11832e43c4472d54f2d30404fb5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the finger rotates too smoothly throughout the entire video, without any shaking).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05861", "filename": "953558abceccaaf23ca13c0140e295aa3b1ca6d75c099e7af090c411acf6d639_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.7s, the people in the sea on the far left suddenly become two) (at 5.8s, the people on the shore disappear into thin air and decrease in number).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05862", "filename": "2220045b73786a29b1686e09cab6d75e451c8b83141be56b9f79dfe78a495b2c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the flock of birds in the lower right corner disappears out of thin air at 3.6s) (the ripples on the lake surface are too regular and do not conform to real life)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05863", "filename": "8738977bd46f7b131572f684b608dada85e09fbc83000198bdbd1f7a1013cf7b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (flickering appears below the flames throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05864", "filename": "618887273f40e1016acbad78ec95bc92343729320470377b8726bae67f9913a0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The time is continuous (2.5s - at the end, during the process of the tire running over the biscuit, the biscuit did not break into pieces but turned directly into powder).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05865", "filename": "9933058110d2b51baed8fb556a6419e9c8c473637adca595178ca05b0669ed0e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video is blurry and flickering throughout (4.2 seconds - the burned blue plastic returns to its original state).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05866", "filename": "a4e22238e6cf9ff10ccbd1473a46b84b23db09654e8e76e89a0361f6a0781262_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time sequence (the white filter in beaker suddenly darkens at 0s) (the filter in the beaker suddenly becomes flat at 0.1s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05867", "filename": "a8dcbf689ba92562ce810f96831b25211b55f2beccdf289919df4e071a04bab7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05869", "filename": "a51adf5a456018ae07832eed75363afe46ec67788ee37cfa3a54aaafbb365223_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the bird appears and disappears out of thin air in different locations throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05870", "filename": "a53c0e1abcd6bb73172b36347354529c6453851b989c482795ddd14f0400627e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (3.8s - after the sea lion leaves the water, it crawls on the shore, still splashing water) (the bushes in the entire video are too blurry and flickering).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05871", "filename": "a572e8d30495f666f317194e917e73e70b7d9b79c991cc6d68bd62253fabc12c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the yellow object in the pot gradually thickens throughout the video, and the black spots disappear).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05873", "filename": "a75443bf2a7c19d95e0bf897dce8a08b5d3148ecfdc85b3af63278c3be86f8aa_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (1.6s: the ice block that was almost completely melted suddenly returned to its original position). Physical behavior (4.5s: the ice block did not melt, but floated upwards, which does not conform to the law of interaction).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05874", "filename": "a128395dd88951d2152ba7247401fc9ee84544493503bb56b3152564e330b2fd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (from the start to 5.3s, the position of the candle flame on the left moves upward, and the wax below gradually returns to its original position) (from 4.4s to the end, the candle flame on the right sways from side to side, but there is a glass cover above the right candle)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05875", "filename": "aa5e9f62207bbb96d7fdabdca9d41c37e70a4d1663beb44c617417d7ca141e87_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: The time is continuous (at 1.4s, the image suddenly zooms in, and except for the machine spraying mist in the middle, everything else becomes blurry instantly).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05876", "filename": "ab6a6606f5de742dca8e87affbf9294b4e132d3fa5b57bfdab9557424cc53e22_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (white smoke suddenly appears on the wheels under the front of the car at 3.6 seconds) (the corn on the right side of the video shakes, but the trees remain still throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05877", "filename": "abff16193a5a9eb4f48c080fa44da6c4c0aa46bdec30f050292cd5ea98c3d332_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The video shows a car moving backward on its own without anyone driving it, from 0.8 seconds to the end.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05878", "filename": "ac3fb7160e63fdc112e542cf14ed696382697b5aa5b3cc1e0a3724a0576a5a7d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Continuous time display (at 5.8s, the night scene suddenly changes to a daytime scene) (at 4.9s, the light at the top of the video disappears out of nowhere)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05879", "filename": "ac9c3db11c269db53b6342b6ca0cdb0e3ecfa225e2c99f8a035bac765457140a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05880", "filename": "ac00127a75db387743f3646f0e49ac3e2c1174e663c6447f397293ffc961c05f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is too smooth (the ship moves too smoothly throughout the entire video, and the water surface is calm without waves) (the ripples on the water surface from 3.8s to the end are too neat).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05881", "filename": "ac359a7c04efb5ea07efe17f32bc756d1adb34ccf53ef9d14cdbc6438f9282a1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (after the snow on the umbrella falls off at 4s, there is still a thick layer of snow covering the umbrella).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05882", "filename": "acb97c8fe4b552b2f2d613c23606d8e3b1d677afafc2454d0065dde11aba8e47_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the ice cream does not melt throughout the entire video; it only flows, which is inconsistent with real life).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05883", "filename": "ad47ddd51e028c75a61b30299c587a30b7d8f8fe8070e0809aa2d8ac20adce02_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (from the start to 2.3s, the spreading water droplets gradually return to complete droplets). Physical behavior (at 2.4s, ripples appear on the water surface even without any force acting on it, which does not conform to the law of interaction of forces).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05884", "filename": "ad901a941db57025c64a415618dc2084884e67a372c6c938006b7bdf2640eda7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.9 seconds, the video suddenly turns yellow and bright, which is unnatural, but the size of the flame does not change).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05887", "filename": "b2b6b30d936cd5d64f1b61a1c55acfff142fb6a2ab06226572bdf5b75462abb0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the video, the waterfall falls into the river without affecting the river surface, and the waterfall appears to disappear directly into the river.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05888", "filename": "b2b79f36c1796ac74b75b651c1e2c6534392eb5e57644c175a78983635969ca8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05890", "filename": "b2fa0be060db8e5c3f76e2326456841b29a4ee8f1c81a1b0bd915012bf2068a9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (The same piece of ice should melt at the same rate under the same environment, but at 2.4 seconds in the video, only the lower half of the ice starts to melt, while the upper half remains unchanged.) Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (At 4.3 seconds in the video, the upper right side of the ice melts and then disappears without turning into water.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05891", "filename": "b2fa0be060db8e5c3f76e2326456841b29a4ee8f1c81a1b0bd915012bf2068a9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 4.9 seconds in the video, after the ice below melts, the ice above should fall due to gravity, but it appears to float in the air.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05892", "filename": "b2fa0be060db8e5c3f76e2326456841b29a4ee8f1c81a1b0bd915012bf2068a9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (In the video, from 0.4 seconds to the lower part of 2.4 seconds, the ice melts, producing a large amount of water, but the original area of the ice remains unchanged.) Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (At 3.3 seconds, the ice on the table disappears instantly.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05893", "filename": "b3d0de871a6c412d682d6fe056d34f427402b77d4154796fc3c7a030b3f23c95_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (The clouds in the video moving from right to left indicate wind in this scene, but the trees in the video are not moving.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05894", "filename": "b3ed0243e92c1574a4403bad2509ceafb1093680ef8dd0fe828741281bef2851_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (At 0.3 seconds, a straw appears out of thin air in the character's hand.) Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (At 2.7 seconds, the character stirs the cup with the straw; at 3.8 seconds, the original red straw in the cup disappears instantly.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05895", "filename": "b05b99e6d2e92a3c85fa06764f04985a31d23def5d40a63025eca75c4fdd5af4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the ripples should spread throughout the pool, but at 1 seconds in the video, the area above the pool does not show ripples.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05896", "filename": "b6da9968acc670423b4cda74554891a0a8010356f3f20a85914ebd7d17bd649c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly in the video: the timing is discontinuous (in the video, at 4.1 seconds, two of the green balls merge into one small ball as they roll off the track and hit the basket).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05897", "filename": "b7e3b2f08ac98af4efeeb7b9165370549c3cd225b7b0cb5df157ef6506ed8935_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (From the beginning of the video to 1.9 seconds, the solid steel pipe on the right passes directly through the solid steel pipe on the left and merges into one.) Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (At 5.2 seconds, the slider in the video instantly splits into two, one is picked up and the other remains on the table.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05898", "filename": "b7e378cc18ddccffcec642e4534717e0b7e4ec91343f0e12775ff907eff6d0d7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video behavior: Physical behavior (the entire structure connecting the steel frame and the ball in the video moves on its own even when no force is applied.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05900", "filename": "b8c44fc163e22c1bb4724805236a0283d88f678d1b65992ebc6478cd170c1943_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05901", "filename": "b11cd35579431784836492c532e72d0ef31fcceb0174b8b00a6c0d6ddce7a1b5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is inconsistent (the melting of the popsicle is a gradual process, but at 3.1 seconds, the ice on the table melts instantly into a puddle of liquid).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05902", "filename": "b11cd35579431784836492c532e72d0ef31fcceb0174b8b00a6c0d6ddce7a1b5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 3.4s to 6.7s in the video, the popsicle on the table automatically flips over without any force applied.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05903", "filename": "b26bc26eb97157c36f84415c3c8c44095d2bc1e32b53743ed78be240d50ab709_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05904", "filename": "b44c3d20ca9b926d1d17ed3d97eeb033ab7464c7f37affc7fec91387eee59c64_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the swaying flames and smoke in the video prove that there is wind in this situation, but the trees in the background of the video remain stationary even in windy conditions.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05905", "filename": "b44c3d20ca9b926d1d17ed3d97eeb033ab7464c7f37affc7fec91387eee59c64_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the smoke from the fire in the video drifts from right to left, indicating that the wind direction is from right to left, but the flames in the video rise straight up).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05908", "filename": "d063e1d3c82fae68c8d79c8209393f6430e04b8504c88f7878f0d2dde3f707e2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (throughout the entire video, the black metal plate on which the person's fingers are placed repeatedly shows holes that then disappear without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05909", "filename": "d063e1d3c82fae68c8d79c8209393f6430e04b8504c88f7878f0d2dde3f707e2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 1s, the small iron bar connected to the right side of the iron block suddenly detaches and flies into the air; at 3.1s, the green object on the table moves and disappears on its own without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05910", "filename": "d063e1d3c82fae68c8d79c8209393f6430e04b8504c88f7878f0d2dde3f707e2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 0.9s in the video, the small iron bar connected to the right side of the iron block disappears out of thin air without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05911", "filename": "d72a7f95d06096925b63bd548322ee0e170e68fb80234e493159b510f5dfc7cd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (at 2.1 seconds into the video, white flocculent material suddenly appears inside the bubbles without any change in the camera angle, and then disappears without a trace).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05912", "filename": "d72a7f95d06096925b63bd548322ee0e170e68fb80234e493159b510f5dfc7cd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Overall intuition (the bubbles in the image lack natural shape and slight distortion; frozen bubbles, affected by cold and gravity, will slightly flatten and bulge in some areas, rather than being perfectly spherical, and their shape is too regular).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05913", "filename": "d72a7f95d06096925b63bd548322ee0e170e68fb80234e493159b510f5dfc7cd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 2.3s in the video, large patches of ice flowers suddenly appear on the surface of the bubbles without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05914", "filename": "d72a7f95d06096925b63bd548322ee0e170e68fb80234e493159b510f5dfc7cd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (Throughout the video, numerous ice flowers continuously appear out of thin air on the surface of the bubble, covering it until it is completely enveloped).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05915", "filename": "d80dfea480a9249bd210014864d6b8efcd2b28ca9c15d3c5ff16d03738b5b15f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (within the entire frame, without any stirring, the tissue inside the glass moves erratically in the water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05916", "filename": "d80dfea480a9249bd210014864d6b8efcd2b28ca9c15d3c5ff16d03738b5b15f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (starting at 1.4 seconds, the tissue in the cup moves dramatically on its own without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05917", "filename": "d80dfea480a9249bd210014864d6b8efcd2b28ca9c15d3c5ff16d03738b5b15f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (in the video from 0s to 4.3s, the tissue in the water suddenly went from a blurry state to a smooth state and then floated on its own without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05918", "filename": "d80dfea480a9249bd210014864d6b8efcd2b28ca9c15d3c5ff16d03738b5b15f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: temporal continuity (at 3.3s in the video, the tissue in the cup suddenly changes from a semi-transparent state to a solid state without any change in the shot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05925", "filename": "d96e879e077ecd1732d3936904b4e1f34b2c701b8853a3f6c59bcc325265c348_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.6s in the video, an explosion occurs out of nowhere on an empty field, and at 4.8s, the surrounding rocks remain unchanged after the explosion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05926", "filename": "d96e879e077ecd1732d3936904b4e1f34b2c701b8853a3f6c59bcc325265c348_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.4s in the video, an explosion occurs out of nowhere on an empty field, and at 4.2s, an extra layer of smoke appears out of nowhere below the mushroom cloud).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05927", "filename": "d96e879e077ecd1732d3936904b4e1f34b2c701b8853a3f6c59bcc325265c348_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05928", "filename": "d96e879e077ecd1732d3936904b4e1f34b2c701b8853a3f6c59bcc325265c348_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05929", "filename": "d97a0e417f13015a525e804e40307a6b1135206ebbfa5b0243fe170a05886ede_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.8s in the video, the candle flame on the far right disappears out of thin air without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05930", "filename": "d97a0e417f13015a525e804e40307a6b1135206ebbfa5b0243fe170a05886ede_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (between 0.1s and 2.4s, a purple pattern appears out of thin air on the rightmost candle without the camera changing position).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05931", "filename": "d97a0e417f13015a525e804e40307a6b1135206ebbfa5b0243fe170a05886ede_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 0.4s in the video, a wax line appears out of nowhere on the candle without the camera changing direction; the first and second candles in the entire video are burning but no smoke is emitted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05932", "filename": "d275e889d82ab365d990be9ddf3909ed0126bbd029c7e085a31db900c576b750_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (at 2.9s in the video, the right gear directly penetrates the left gear, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05933", "filename": "d275e889d82ab365d990be9ddf3909ed0126bbd029c7e085a31db900c576b750_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous time movement (during the video from 0.3s to 3.1s, the gear at the top keeps changing position without the camera moving).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05934", "filename": "d275e889d82ab365d990be9ddf3909ed0126bbd029c7e085a31db900c576b750_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 1.4s and 2.1s in the video, gears penetrate each other, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05935", "filename": "d511a9623f0eb36c5a4d068786ea93d0e5ba87602783c9482ca73348c84705ec_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the entire video has flickering artifacts, and at 1.7s, steam suddenly appears from the spout of the kettle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05936", "filename": "600e2f941c28e4b15f4e2812e5c2c668c2af44a41cc2200a8db57a9a40985a74_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (after 5.6 seconds, the video suddenly darkens without acceleration). Video anomaly: (The cloud formations in the video have the same shape and no irregularity. In reality, clouds are not stationary; due to airflow, their shapes should be diverse.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05937", "filename": "603cdad55da9e5ad6ed1b6fb96b04fb3e4c78e9973e9cf09506cac793e78b87e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: (From 0.4s to 3.1s, the fireworks did not rise and exploded directly in mid-air. Fireworks should have a flight path before exploding.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05938", "filename": "618e0bdaf9d3417711cace9bd2834336d7dc7032b22e120775270447d94356f0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05939", "filename": "623c7addf3acb0fdb202585a5384eab61dd22eb20be6cfe00fdcf4007fcf0288_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal (the video shows a small river with an uneven surface; due to gravity, the water should be flowing, but it is stationary).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05941", "filename": "0656fe333c0604dd951032ebb418fd129bc9c4091e82fb145209c8b1d5085490_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: (From 0.8s to 1.9s, the black object starts burning without smoke, but suddenly produces a large amount of smoke without any external force, which does not conform to the law of conservation of mass.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05942", "filename": "656bdf6a094277ee229416d9018437adb0df9be238614f8a7c9f5ec76a3fe938_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (5.2s-6.6s, the fireworks on the left side of the sky are flying straight upwards. Due to gravity, the fireworks should fall downwards after reaching their highest point, instead of continuing to fly upwards).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05944", "filename": "692c2ce9a1e0cbdae754a95cb6f409b2a410adb5476941cfa8eda153e8a664ff_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (At 2.4s, the hydraulic press had not yet pressed down on the nut, and the nut deformed without being under force. Without force, the nut would not deform. At 3.5s, the nut exhibited abnormal twisting.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05945", "filename": "702d8c431145505ec55a5000978b3b325ee409b8a4942841ff9d182c5549ce0e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The anomaly in the footage is due to the laws of physics (at 3.4 seconds, liquid droplets spontaneously appeared above the ice block without any external force and fell onto the ice block. However, due to the law of conservation of mass, matter cannot be created out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05946", "filename": "704e8cca80ebba11580c52e8365bd8caf36d2ae4a019f6a67b4dc1b555919c23_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: (Water enters the bottle from the unbroken bottle body between 0.3s and 7.6s, a phenomenon known as clipping.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05947", "filename": "711e0c836a16a4644823bcc563986fc24dbca98c4dcc4b715066978c0372fd44_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05948", "filename": "746d7893bfdc6565429c80f2cfb14e8fc0f77f7f26411b67067a5b18e42748ff_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05949", "filename": "754d1b868f64a84803976e2feccb16651fc9ca30e262900beaa48b6b08a6b985_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05950", "filename": "756b80d8aa04a9e4cd1354c56d30a76097bc6092eab99cc16cb230a6ca213fd2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05951", "filename": "756b450dfb0625024ae6045e4e6ed6f7224720c792d4324aa1c8f6f4da00adc9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (during 1.1s-2.6s, the ice cream is melting; when the stick is picked up with the left hand, the top of the ice cream stretches. The ice cream and the stick separate into two independent entities; the force of picking up the stick cannot be transmitted to the ice cream, so the ice cream does not stretch.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05952", "filename": "0758d8034416177a54d980913160a8903db4beee779d9b131740d8404b0b0071_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05953", "filename": "762ca6da86ed00c299ab366d123a79b6685fadaa2059dc0ee89b08fe208dec40_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05954", "filename": "764c8212d82f3277d1fa5c92e357d50eb8c1e59ddd6616d9ad0a370fb0b27851_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (between 0.5s and 2.5s, the flames appear to drift from left to right, indicating that the wind is blowing to the right, but the fireworks sparks drift in the opposite direction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05955", "filename": "782e6e58e25be1b76c2e560b5805954ccb633aa91e0ad4a2fa8aba4a31f46a29_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is as follows: (From 1.1s to 7.2s, there are no carriages at the beginning of the train; multiple carriages appear out of thin air. This violates the law of conservation of mass.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05956", "filename": "787f1720704d6e68f8b321f464428e2e147ddfb08ac74811cf9480f51e729f2c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly in the image: (The image shows a cast iron pot heating solid butter. Some of the solid butter has melted into a liquid state, and the liquid butter is boiling and bubbling, indicating a high temperature. However, the remaining solid butter does not change volume, meaning the butter should have melted.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05957", "filename": "788b81550b1fc6db7ac40bb9375e9295fedea3bf51ce5847584d0ee17ac0d3db_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly in the image: (The fishing net is being dragged through the seawater, but there are no ripples around it. Since forces are reciprocal, the net being dragged generates a force, which in turn affects the seawater, causing ripples.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05958", "filename": "790aa1ee3590b7af4886e9408b214b99e48ea13dafce837b04909f64181a700d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05959", "filename": "801e7319dacbc25d091c1050f3e2267324c8ec402eb0567177f553a13a1e741b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (The smoke on the mountaintop in the image is stationary. In reality, smoke on a mountaintop is subject to airflow and should move or dissipate.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05960", "filename": "805d445525769371c4310bbc0354edb13c665b558cc5bbffeae41353310f0759_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05961", "filename": "824baa26bc86e7ce72dd9fa55a5bbb88fd63d5bf0e9c5086ea1e37bcc835c9ab_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05962", "filename": "835d532991a8031a0533503ca968b5a87b3bb6cb4ea6bee7d04b11b1fd693dee_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (The streetlights in the scene are illuminating an area only the size of their shades during heavy rain. Due to the refraction and reflection of light by raindrops, the light should be brighter than on a sunny day, not dim.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05963", "filename": "842ca2b030111a455a5c5da2aac06e59923b824427dd1e3dbea8d4236a86d169_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly in the video: (The bubbles in the video are motionless in mid-air. Due to air movement, the bubble's surface has a thin elastic membrane, so the bubble should float up and down in mid-air, not remain stationary.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05964", "filename": "864d8e74a9c374df06624de4eadb662321e8731a09885573f0c8cf891e6394a0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05965", "filename": "869a831655f2acfba8a54c6f7c5dd93123352085a6d723439cde533de54699ba_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an abnormal image: (The aurora in the video appears as a stationary blue-purple band, which is inconsistent with reality. Because auroras are composed of charged particles, the Earth's magnetic field generates a magnetic force that carries the aurora in a spiral motion along the magnetic field. Therefore, auroras should drift slowly, not remain stationary.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05966", "filename": "3c982f0d5e9c5d5e99c7e8d51c701e246d421f15c1cb82b7e15d038591787c71_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The yellow doll's mouth disappears out of nowhere in the scene between 0.8s and 5s.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05967", "filename": "3c982f0d5e9c5d5e99c7e8d51c701e246d421f15c1cb82b7e15d038591787c71_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (Under normal circumstances, the ball will deform and rebound when subjected to tire pressure. In the wheel section from 5.16 to 5.26, when the character passes over the green part on the yellow doll's head, there is no normal feedback of being crushed.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05968", "filename": "3c982f0d5e9c5d5e99c7e8d51c701e246d421f15c1cb82b7e15d038591787c71_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (between 4.3s and 5.3s, the red doll spontaneously transforms into two yellow dolls).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05973", "filename": "3c23844cdec2426aa3933ba101c6aadd3ec8e93ddc5a61860b800f8c66b68e92_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (green matter in the scene is suspended in mid-air, violating the rules of gravity and completely destroying the realism of the physical scene).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05974", "filename": "3c23844cdec2426aa3933ba101c6aadd3ec8e93ddc5a61860b800f8c66b68e92_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the amount of liquid in the glass increases, but the size of the ice cubes does not change).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05975", "filename": "3c23844cdec2426aa3933ba101c6aadd3ec8e93ddc5a61860b800f8c66b68e92_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the liquid in the cup is rotating rapidly on its own without being subjected to external force).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05976", "filename": "3c23844cdec2426aa3933ba101c6aadd3ec8e93ddc5a61860b800f8c66b68e92_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (the dripping of green ice cubes is incorrectly displayed as orange; at 4.5s, the ice cubes in the glass automatically flip and increase in number; from 4s to the end, after water is poured and freezes, the ice cubes rotate abnormally).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05977", "filename": "3c38429672c1aedfbe131b66cdac2eceaf8076cb98be5e69a4e37b1e4cecd5fc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the clouds in the sky, as dynamic background elements, have their animation-driven logic not activated, or the animation frame sequence is not loaded correctly, causing the clouds to remain completely still throughout the video, which violates the visual perception of clouds moving slowly in reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05978", "filename": "3c38429672c1aedfbe131b66cdac2eceaf8076cb98be5e69a4e37b1e4cecd5fc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (At 2.6s, the water surface, which was originally in a dynamic, fluctuating state, abruptly switches from a continuously flowing effect to a completely still, mirror-like state, and this static effect persists until the end of the video. This anomaly disrupts the visual continuity and physical realism of the footage.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05979", "filename": "3c38429672c1aedfbe131b66cdac2eceaf8076cb98be5e69a4e37b1e4cecd5fc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05980", "filename": "3c38429672c1aedfbe131b66cdac2eceaf8076cb98be5e69a4e37b1e4cecd5fc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05981", "filename": "3c1256832944090b81d1f767d97362028720853b5fd362814013c126219a5593_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the cylinder rolls backward without any external force at 4.7s in the image).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05982", "filename": "3c1256832944090b81d1f767d97362028720853b5fd362814013c126219a5593_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (At the beginning of the scene, the green substance is in a dry state, and at 0.1 seconds, it suddenly undergoes a morphological change, switching directly from a dry state to a dilute state. This anomaly breaks the natural logic of the change in the substance's form, disrupting the visual continuity and physical realism of the scene.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05983", "filename": "3c1256832944090b81d1f767d97362028720853b5fd362814013c126219a5593_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (from 0.5s to the end of the video, the position of the hydraulic truck in the frame shifts without external force, violating the principle of inertia and destroying the sense of physical realism).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05984", "filename": "3ca0a3eec4a99f929af839f4fa8d6190d4c767a62aa97295446141e7c0807e5a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is inconsistent in timing (at the beginning of the video, the flames burn a yellow object and liquid flows down, but at 4.4 seconds, the flames burn the object again and no liquid flows down; the timing is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05985", "filename": "3ca0a3eec4a99f929af839f4fa8d6190d4c767a62aa97295446141e7c0807e5a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.2s, the yellow liquid produced by burning does not appear to be flowing and melting naturally, but rather it directly oozes out of the object, which violates the visual logic of material change).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05986", "filename": "3ca0a3eec4a99f929af839f4fa8d6190d4c767a62aa97295446141e7c0807e5a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_05991", "filename": "3cf83c31b941251fd64495f0b272832bbf61ec33f54d4ff866c5294c1aaf94c3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals and physical behavior (from 1.9 seconds to the end of the video, the height of the wooden plank that bounces in the video shows a continuous upward trend, which violates the law of conservation of energy).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05992", "filename": "3cf83c31b941251fd64495f0b272832bbf61ec33f54d4ff866c5294c1aaf94c3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the wooden plank automatically flips and breaks without any external force from 2.3 seconds to the end).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05993", "filename": "3cfa49a5e1302a46771909479b3e21def43152d0708423444f00b11422f301b4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Physical behavior (the pot slides on its own at 4.9s without any external force)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05994", "filename": "3cfa49a5e1302a46771909479b3e21def43152d0708423444f00b11422f301b4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal. The timing is continuous (3.3s - the pan in the video disappears suddenly after being pressed down).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05995", "filename": "3cfa49a5e1302a46771909479b3e21def43152d0708423444f00b11422f301b4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.5s, the road roller runs over the frying pan, but the frying pan does not deform at all, which completely violates the physical law that metal kitchen utensils will deform significantly under heavy machinery in reality, destroying the physical realism of the footage).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_05996", "filename": "448b93d96c9b71a09456347ca8c124f751557968201c4af834a0928136f90ccc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a hazy visual effect of fog obscuring the bottom of the screen appears, then suddenly becomes clear, with the two visual effects switching back and forth).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_05997", "filename": "448b93d96c9b71a09456347ca8c124f751557968201c4af834a0928136f90ccc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (7.8s-8s, and there is a twisting and deformation below the metal wheel).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_05998", "filename": "456fe202211b9a604c70672b9d0b8281f8e749c392c8ce513620a0619fd6608e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Cause and effect (the finger holding the ring makes a very small movement, while the ring is rotated at a large angle; the ring's movement trajectory should follow the finger).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_05999", "filename": "456fe202211b9a604c70672b9d0b8281f8e749c392c8ce513620a0619fd6608e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Cause and effect (the finger holding the ring makes a very small movement, while the ring is rotated at a large angle; the ring's movement trajectory should follow the finger).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06000", "filename": "456fe202211b9a604c70672b9d0b8281f8e749c392c8ce513620a0619fd6608e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (as the ring is turned on the finger, numerous and scattered light spots in the gemstone of the ring do not match the reflection of gemstones in reality).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06001", "filename": "456fe202211b9a604c70672b9d0b8281f8e749c392c8ce513620a0619fd6608e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time sequence is continuous (1.1s, the ring suddenly shrinks by one size. The fingers holding the ring make very small movements, while the ring rotates at a large angle; the ring's movement should follow the fingers).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06002", "filename": "460c17241986fcfd54ea72a8bd0588cb0abc8bb1e7f22f7c77297edde51071cb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Physical behavior (a fireball-like light source in the air drifts erratically despite being subject to gravity, violating the principle of inertia); Time continuity (the video begins with only a white bag, then two dogs gradually appear around the bag, the sequence is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06003", "filename": "460c17241986fcfd54ea72a8bd0588cb0abc8bb1e7f22f7c77297edde51071cb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (the legs of the human-bodied, dog-headed creature on the right appear and disappear out of thin air multiple times. At the beginning of the video, there is only a white cloth bag, followed by a dog and a human-bodied, dog-headed creature appearing out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06007", "filename": "467cd6eeb0b446c4e277b2c8aa925fdfc9f43187d608766ac34a4319017baac4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal due to physical behavior (there are many thick clouds in the sky, but the sky reflected in the water only has a few clouds, which does not conform to the principle of reflection imaging).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06008", "filename": "467cd6eeb0b446c4e277b2c8aa925fdfc9f43187d608766ac34a4319017baac4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal due to physical behavior (there are many thick clouds in the sky, but the sky reflected in the water only has a few clouds, which does not conform to the principle of reflection imaging).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06009", "filename": "467cd6eeb0b446c4e277b2c8aa925fdfc9f43187d608766ac34a4319017baac4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal due to physical behavior (there are many thick clouds in the sky, but the sky reflected in the water only has a few clouds, which does not conform to the principle of reflection imaging).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06010", "filename": "467cd6eeb0b446c4e277b2c8aa925fdfc9f43187d608766ac34a4319017baac4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Physical behavior (the footage shows slight ripples on the water surface, but the reflection of the small white tree in the same pool is very calm, which does not conform to the laws of water ripple movement).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06011", "filename": "481d376ed63239b5aafbb8d335f2c04ddd880cde8cdb354b14ca109a7d1130dc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (In the same environment, the black object on the left casts a shadow, while the black object on the right does not; the two are inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_06012", "filename": "481d376ed63239b5aafbb8d335f2c04ddd880cde8cdb354b14ca109a7d1130dc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual discrepancy: Cause and effect (In the same environment, the black object on the left casts a shadow, while the black object on the right does not; the two do not match).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_06013", "filename": "487dc0f6356238cfca10d74adf1330d09d470162a931e2af99ae611b6db6f9b4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the gemstone moves irregularly on its own without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06014", "filename": "487dc0f6356238cfca10d74adf1330d09d470162a931e2af99ae611b6db6f9b4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Cause and effect (the gemstone's reflection indicates strong sunlight at the scene, while the area around the gemstone appears very dark; the two are inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_06015", "filename": "487dc0f6356238cfca10d74adf1330d09d470162a931e2af99ae611b6db6f9b4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the white solid beneath the diamond changes its shape abnormally as it rotates; its shape remains fixed when no force is applied).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06016", "filename": "507cd81b87cd26133e6b6a6002cdf3726929abec4260e790933f5867d87eeb83_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (Explosions are destructive; objects around the explosion point should be destroyed or moved along with the explosion. The dust and flames from the explosion have different centers and occur at different times.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06019", "filename": "518d40437cb117b67bcb62eacc48f3944e2fbc88ef31a0c36e3159420287c063_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Physical behavior (In the image, the angle at which the diamond is viewed changes only slightly; the reflection on the diamond should change slightly with the viewing angle, not drastically).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06020", "filename": "518d40437cb117b67bcb62eacc48f3944e2fbc88ef31a0c36e3159420287c063_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (a diamond placed on a stationary platform is slowly rotating on its own without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06021", "filename": "518d40437cb117b67bcb62eacc48f3944e2fbc88ef31a0c36e3159420287c063_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (the diamond is stationary, and the camera moves back and forth regularly above the diamond. The reflection of the diamond should also change regularly with the camera, but the reflection of the diamond in the video is irregular).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06022", "filename": "518d40437cb117b67bcb62eacc48f3944e2fbc88ef31a0c36e3159420287c063_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06023", "filename": "521f08548e5960b00ba6c2dd8fe8380c0584195646cd3264d06ddc5167afb8f1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The time sequence is continuous (the shelf hasn't clamped the object yet at 3.9s, but the object suddenly appears in a clamp).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06024", "filename": "521f08548e5960b00ba6c2dd8fe8380c0584195646cd3264d06ddc5167afb8f1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (2s-3.2s: the clip moves upwards, but its shadow moves downwards. 0.2s-0.4s: the clip hasn't touched the food yet, but the food moves against gravity following the clip).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06025", "filename": "521f08548e5960b00ba6c2dd8fe8380c0584195646cd3264d06ddc5167afb8f1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Physical behavior (the tongs are stirring inside the pot, causing the food to flip over, but the tongs are very thin and the flipping motion is not large, so the energy provided is not enough to cause such a large flipping motion inside the pot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06026", "filename": "P04_113_433_edb06f70cfad8838_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is as follows: the time sequence is continuous, the entire desktop is abnormally distorted and writhing, and at 6.1 seconds, the cup moves abnormally to the right.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06027", "filename": "P04_113_433_edb06f70cfad8838_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous, but at 1.3 seconds, the sponge on the table is hit by a broom and suddenly crumbles into pieces, with many small pieces of trash appearing on the table. The amount of trash on the table also increases, and the video is inconsistent.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06028", "filename": "P04_113_434_d969a22e9e9c4020_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is inconsistent; at 1.7 seconds, many small fragments suddenly appear on the shovel in the character's hand, which is inconsistent with the preceding and following moments.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06029", "filename": "P04_113_434_d969a22e9e9c4020_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: The video is continuous in time, but the desktop twists and distorts abnormally throughout. At 0.9 seconds, the trash in the shovel suddenly disappears, and at 3.4 seconds, a yellow spot suddenly appears in the upper left corner of the shovel.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06030", "filename": "P04_113_435_6b88c9662b559b97_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous, and the tabletop is abnormally distorted and writhing throughout the entire video. At 6.1 seconds, the person is dumping an object inside the shovel, but the object is not dumped out and remains on the surface of the shovel.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06031", "filename": "P04_113_435_6b88c9662b559b97_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is inconsistent in its timing. At 0.4 seconds, many yellow, sawdust-like objects suddenly appear under the broom. At 4.9 seconds, the broom in the hand suddenly transforms into a shovel, and a broom suddenly appears inside the shovel.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06032", "filename": "P04_113_507_901fff4dfa130ce1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is as follows: the time sequence is continuous, but the entire desktop is abnormally distorted and writhing. Between 1.7s and 5.8s, the horizontal knife mark on the far right slowly appears. At 5.8s, the third cut on the pancake shows no knife mark.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06033", "filename": "P04_115_16_ef88130859b6edad_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: In terms of physics, at 2.2 seconds, the hand moving left and right touches the bottom of the metal plate. If there were a collision, the metal plate should move upwards, not backwards.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06034", "filename": "P04_115_16_ef88130859b6edad_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous, but the towels on the table and under the metal tray move irregularly and twist throughout the video.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06035", "filename": "P04_115_16_ef88130859b6edad_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is inconsistent: the sequence of events is continuous, but from the beginning to 0.3 seconds, a brush appears out of thin air in the hand.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06036", "filename": "P04_115_49_529e31318c065d42_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous, and the towel on the tiled table is constantly twisting irregularly.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06037", "filename": "P04_115_49_529e31318c065d42_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06038", "filename": "P04_116_48_77e1f7022c42e07d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06039", "filename": "P04_116_48_77e1f7022c42e07d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time is continuous, the tile tabletop twists and wriggles abnormally throughout the segment, and when the spatula is used to stir the food, the items in the pot do not move or change, so the causal relationship is not established.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06040", "filename": "P04_116_48_77e1f7022c42e07d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is inconsistent: at 4.4 seconds, the liquid in the pot, which was not heated, suddenly appears to have been heated, and at 3.1 seconds, something resembling flour suddenly appears floating in the pot.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06041", "filename": "P04_116_169_7730b25837e07dcb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous, and at 2.4 seconds, the seasonings that were originally in the spice bottle suddenly appear out of thin air in the pot.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06042", "filename": "P04_117_48_daedd11cbff5cbe2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is as follows: During the continuous timeframe from 5.4s to 2.7s, the cup moves off-screen to the lower left without any apparent force. Furthermore, at 2.9s, the character cuts bread with a knife, but there are no knife marks after putting the knife down. Therefore, the causal relationship is invalid.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06043", "filename": "P04_117_63_706aa8ad6cdfe7b5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is as follows: During the continuous flow of time, at 2.8 seconds, the character is holding a bottle, and the seasoning inside has not yet reached the bottle opening, yet it is poured out, and the amount of seasoning in the bottle does not decrease.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06044", "filename": "P04_117_63_706aa8ad6cdfe7b5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous; throughout the entire sequence, the tiles on the table twist and turn irregularly, and the seasonings in the pot also twist abnormally. At 0.6 seconds, the seasonings suddenly appear out of nowhere in the pot.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06045", "filename": "P04_117_100_e532aaf7ec4cc36f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is continuous, but at 4.7 seconds, the butter on the bread changes shape, with a portion protruding from the upper left. At 2.8 seconds, the knife failed to retrieve any butter from the bowl, and suddenly there is more butter on the knife.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06046", "filename": "P04_117_100_e532aaf7ec4cc36f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous, the amount of butter on the knife suddenly increases, and the butter spread on the bread is abnormally twisted and wriggling.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06047", "filename": "P04_118_53_288c1f0339d229ca_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: During the continuous time frame (4.1s-4.7s), the box initially contained two items, but when held in hand, they magically transformed into one.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06048", "filename": "P04_119_24_f52d6da77154d972_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the book on the table moves to the right on its own without any external force for 2.3 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06049", "filename": "P04_119_24_f52d6da77154d972_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06050", "filename": "P04_119_101_5435628e9627b2ce_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is continuous, the tiles on the table and the book next to the bowl are abnormally twisted and writhing, and at 7.3 seconds, an object suddenly appears in the bowl.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06051", "filename": "P04_119_101_5435628e9627b2ce_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous, but at 5.3s the knife doesn't cut the pocket, and the pocket opens directly, so the causal relationship doesn't hold. At 3.7s, the blue object passes through the yellow plastic bag below the hand, violating the principle that solids are impermeable.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06052", "filename": "P04_119_148_798120eb046ef868_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous; at 1.7 seconds, a towel can be seen wiping the bottom of the pot from the side, and then the bottom of the pot suddenly concaves out and becomes the rim of the pot when it is turned sideways.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06053", "filename": "P04_119_161_aa85b4e657521c62_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06054", "filename": "P04_119_230_f017c70d93dd0beb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06055", "filename": "P04_119_230_f017c70d93dd0beb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is continuous, the entire tabletop tile is abnormally twisted and writhing, the water bottle in the scene is shaking even without any force applied, the knife did not pick up the butter from the bowl at 2.3 seconds, but at 3.3 seconds, the amount of butter spread on the bread suddenly increased.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06057", "filename": "9b412015ce9e23267cadccb4cf4a0b28e1ffb079527cc6afed82c0f4c06cf1be_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the fluid in the bowl in the image moves on its own without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06058", "filename": "9bd2157e83932228a1fc627f398c176e96f5ca43dc2435b2888afb9c9abd0dd1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (after the green solid in the picture melts, the amount of liquid on the table does not increase).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06060", "filename": "9c8d2b84d47f1a27c36c8cb479fd208cb554d5e4d07060551bd85c2935a77e1e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity is abnormal (the entire image is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06062", "filename": "9c102ea67d8fff8161847c2c51df08d184a091de4636c318ce6f86408adb24cd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (violation of the law of conservation of energy; the ashes in the image are from burned paper, but the ashes have become larger and have not fallen).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06063", "filename": "9d4ad6ca106c55686266d342ca127297b855ba23861c6af6a367cdb653d68b57_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (the plastic object in the image, while being heated by fire, did not melt further, and the black substance produced by the continued burning adhered to the surface of the plastic; the grass in the image flickered).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06064", "filename": "9d889f6b73df1cdedca2c11484db42c98a8875a625c061b19542a1e4da9ef33e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (violation of the law of gravity; at 1.9s, the water droplets on the petals do not exhibit free fall motion under the influence of gravity), temporal continuity (the entire screen flickers).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06065", "filename": "9ddd0e35f04ca2a80ee84bbf1c7e9b0fe44a75c40918638b029a7774799e82f4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the overall video flickers, and the video changes color at 3.9 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06066", "filename": "9decbc62bd7bb91dc024123ae018e3a5229db450ec71ad91ee6c16dbcbf2087a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity issue (the entire screen flickers).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06068", "filename": "9e5dd44606406abe9588eaad054a14349d680d6b6e3df0db248d482f46a63c1c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06069", "filename": "9eb3dbb41bfde84e65ae163b5e3b5e6e5fd91f6551003e5283480813e2d3a505_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity error (the sand around the flames is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06070", "filename": "9eb36c5f235fe5ec139050303e4b9380b7bc1760b8b7c635da687a2d49d50256_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly: The image shows wood being heated over a flame, but the surface of the wood shows no change.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06071", "filename": "9ee37626316595035b6439ecf631e308acd2b5931b9c96df273b49b70e070dff_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (when the white flocculent object in the water glass is descending in the water, at 4.8s, the descent speed suddenly slows down, and the overall screen flickers).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06072", "filename": "9f8f6bb0a73b559ab312e6988ebcac4ae2116bca9c025222be22db1edd531923_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity error (the wooden board behind the candle in the image is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06073", "filename": "9f2688b090695b906ead22e584cd777f52769f3d8d72f17ab121e3cac7c152a1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (2.7s-3.4s: Blue bricks exploded without being subjected to force)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06074", "filename": "9fb1a7e7c193441794ce9c89a531b4afa0ae1d6834f9963e6d95c722cb5025ef_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity error (the table in the image flickers).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06075", "filename": "9ff879e8c5a085e0c4f4418994e98e5b4a02132039d8df7ff3f1391125973f46_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Causality (a white light suddenly appears at the edge of the circular mirror in the middle of the black object at 7.2s), temporal continuity anomalies (the entire screen flickers).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06076", "filename": "010c905955a6b883943ecc0b210df3f84b39b5b636ee3488fdd32342914d1780_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity error (overall screen flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06077", "filename": "10cf4ffb6c92b005763d9b306a916914b60f16433b7bc323e51177891ab5cfde_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (overall screen flickering).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06079", "filename": "12c866274bf004fd035de31a62e33d89af1e358122eb0b9501820cde1e18ec51_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity error (overall screen flickering).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06080", "filename": "12f4871336fafac4955650e3c9995fee39fad1e6027abfd2d258aed95474de8f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity error (the entire screen is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06081", "filename": "13b282fa6d8dce7943fb6b7753a0a544ea9e645a8ed4fde98e5afd7e0f0a390e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual inconsistencies (the flame remains stationary for 0s-3s, contradicting the realistic appearance of a flowing flame), and inconsistent temporal continuity (the candle beneath the flame flickers).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06082", "filename": "13fb3c0dadd2382d452660c957886cefa86dd840b9f5db6ef0a1de529af93c02_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity error (flickering is present throughout the image).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06083", "filename": "14f6f91b70dd5f7754b039926613830f876d8cfbf089dc33244a52f7d5572331_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity error (flickering is present throughout the image).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06085", "filename": "17e47e0a06ec019e9cdfc17939c2baebc3af2e4dfc6a474890e09e08201015ac_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity error (the lake surface in the image is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06086", "filename": "00c8db34810bc6e2276bb10cdc90bede1935d1695d09b8c6f3c4d645d1af5591_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06087", "filename": "0a89e9659744927ec20a96cfdc893db14dfec74485333c96094b651a8f2a2eb6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (at 7.9 seconds, there is a clipping effect at the point where the car collides with the pickup truck).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06088", "filename": "0aa667cde1f24ebd0a46a4325b4aeb88127b107a0c46026b56f7cfbe59380405_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (The candle flame in the video is stationary, and there is no sign of melting wax. Wax should melt from a solid to a liquid state when heated.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06089", "filename": "0abbd056b2b5b680e88f3cc59b24e0f71058885f222db47eacd764209b66e94c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous timing (between 4.6s and 6.3s, the flour in the hands suddenly increases without external force.) Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 5.7s, no chemical reaction occurs in the hands, so the flour should not explode.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06090", "filename": "0b0f7cc733b5f6400e1e2ad29c24570f757fa9dec42909554c7a222e30037045_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is discontinuous (the waves in the entire video appear to be suspended in mid-air. Seawater has inertia; it should flow forward instead of remaining stationary.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06091", "filename": "0b4ea9d77c441e25d2b320ce00e40d1303143b5d8a31b66b7d9ded29104037d3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The duration is continuous (6s-7.3s, the sun on the left side keeps disappearing and reappearing during its ascent without any obstruction, causing flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06092", "filename": "0b9f1c59dca3a073d3a0bca303cc173a89c7a13eee98061a9d11978594d389f7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the video, raindrops fall onto the car window and remain stationary without sliding down; due to gravity, raindrops would slide down.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06093", "filename": "0b65a12b4da9e7d7ebf7b8103c9e6c2655768b780b6a1b369602ea5a731abd89_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the 5.2s-7.6s scene, after the wheel runs over the bread, the bread is not flattened and returns to its original shape.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06094", "filename": "0b70f0ee8ed98158dfda53ba26f31c7cfe1314e8455acc227845ed90980a62f3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06095", "filename": "0ba50e8a7dbba5a2ea95d9a75d997eb157968d4c87663b70bfb3b38af8305802_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06096", "filename": "0bbd07c00bf7de0efcd7a38edf3ad1b53dcc7afdb4ab2a7ff3d4daec8111f13d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition is abnormal (at 4.5s, when a person picks up a snack, their fingers are not bent, the snack seems to be stuck to their palm, and the movement is uncoordinated.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06098", "filename": "0c0cf0b446e848f7ad01d8487e5e5db45fbd0a5cf227def2ddd030b457d480a3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time is continuous (0.2s-3.2s). When the ceramic bowl is squeezed by the hydraulic press, it shows a deformation similar to rubber being flattened. In reality, ceramic bowls are brittle and will fracture brittlely when subjected to excessive pressure, rather than stretching like rubber.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06099", "filename": "0c6389e0e6822f8739e1698dec8afaf333495ce25d733cfc1354981478f17dae_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06100", "filename": "0cbde1d199113216e08006c0ca5a3306eb652763fd14a0465745e53486392123_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (At 7.5s, a person walking against the light is seen having light passing through their body. The human body is opaque.) Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (From 0s to 8s, the movement of the person in the scene appears jerky and uncoordinated.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06101", "filename": "0cf241a42970b86582ab80e90e1cbc5a742ed6d3331f06457490a45a7267409b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: (During the 0.3s-1.8s interval, a violently burning object suddenly extinguishes without any external force.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06102", "filename": "0d88bef9b61d743eb239f35399dd1dd477c22594234c1d6d3ea604cb4736c75a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The time frame is continuous (0.9s-3.9s). The soil clod at the top, which was being squeezed by the hydraulic press, was not flattened and remained in its original shape.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06104", "filename": "0da846ef02e97603c1cdf653947a63e5ad0473956674a62233948ef813972d99_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: (From 0.3s to 2.2s, the lake surface is flowing but no ripples are observed. In reality, a flowing lake surface would produce ripples due to the forces acting upon it.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06105", "filename": "0e05dac027dea308237e2904da6bb47735d08f56beb20c030864e950f40fe470_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The water flow is continuous (0.5s-7.2s) and there is no splashing when water is poured onto a white object.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06106", "filename": "0e5c8041e176454b17038afbb321d379eb65dfb7fc6f3851676cb22d95f48dc5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (from day to evening, the positions of the sun and clouds in the sky do not change. The sun should set over time, and the clouds should drift and dissipate.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06107", "filename": "0e7c239053e75c219ec6a08911aa4ee9f1e40babb31b0ab8b4677fa0626091e7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (1s-4.6s). The water flowing from the lower left of the waterfall is seen flowing upwards along the rock face, whereas due to gravity, water should flow downwards along a rock face.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06108", "filename": "0e89d9663e549854155bb506c14aef69efacb1a507191f2013d94c58f973a528_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06109", "filename": "0e184d67b5a24606676bb0f263620300bc911ef2b3f3acecf275188e79dc4ed4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06110", "filename": "0ea1c9ae1a134fb84d98003627672e23a6dc37e2ec0df073e74828de6ceb39d8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06111", "filename": "0eb01ddb8a6a3920ec1190033524555fc25bf1b41e5a9e2ef24f03515d1ee462_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06114", "filename": "0f9cb357f8ac5acd99480fc427d0bd0bd836700cfd7e2dbbfcf8d0714e1c83d5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (2s-7.8s) - An object in the plate passes through the plate, creating a lenticular effect. Solids are impermeable.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06115", "filename": "0f25b57a3432b1fb91f9473a9624c67d4cbd163c72f517f0b812e0a937306b0b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06116", "filename": "3edfe964f3afcacfd8de61df5a217a216e9172cdedcb1aac3ace87352ae39393_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is not continuous (the sea of clouds appears to be moving at high speed, while the trees remain stationary throughout, and the movement logic of the visual elements is contradictory, which does not conform to the physical representation of reality).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06117", "filename": "3edfe964f3afcacfd8de61df5a217a216e9172cdedcb1aac3ace87352ae39393_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The overall visual appearance is also abnormal (the cloud movement in the video is too smooth, which doesn't match the realistic visual effect).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06118", "filename": "3f04bc68c0af960b3ddf771dd575ebec1d376bfa07eda733778c780e5e2f7da9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: In a continuous sequence (3.2s), the bead next to the finger shifts without any external force; a sphere appears out of thin air on the character's right hand, and the sphere in the center of the palm simultaneously enlarges.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06119", "filename": "3f9ac9e6c98d847d8f501fde56e2180373f0f68835c4b9528f684136025497ea_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the flame in the center of the image flickers like jelly, unlike a realistic image.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06120", "filename": "3f9ac9e6c98d847d8f501fde56e2180373f0f68835c4b9528f684136025497ea_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.9s, the flames transform into translucent cracks, and from 1.9s to 5.8s, the central area continuously brightens, and the light in the burning area also continuously intensifies throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06121", "filename": "3f9ac9e6c98d847d8f501fde56e2180373f0f68835c4b9528f684136025497ea_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: The duration is continuous (the burning flames suddenly disappear after 4.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06122", "filename": "3f9ac9e6c98d847d8f501fde56e2180373f0f68835c4b9528f684136025497ea_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (from 0s to 7.4s, the fluff is burning, but no smoke is produced. Black smoke suddenly appears at the end).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06123", "filename": "3f0041c4ade08b8a2f3c3232dae0d649856d06a20e4325569ee48104d418aa4f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical effect (ripples appear in the water inside the basin without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06124", "filename": "3f0041c4ade08b8a2f3c3232dae0d649856d06a20e4325569ee48104d418aa4f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the ripples in the water are too regular, rather than the more random diffusion of natural ripples, which are not so clear).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06125", "filename": "3f0041c4ade08b8a2f3c3232dae0d649856d06a20e4325569ee48104d418aa4f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06126", "filename": "3f921fea93ab2e2ede379fbd8cad14f0dd93b70ace446650df80eb3736ff80f4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.4s, when the character walks out in the lower left corner, the image clips directly through the car mirror, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06127", "filename": "3f999c966080d773966438c598f117f24ae206d05b1fa864652ab7c396bf075e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The footage shows ice melting in a basin, but between 1.8s and 2.6s, the water suddenly shakes without any external force.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06128", "filename": "3f999c966080d773966438c598f117f24ae206d05b1fa864652ab7c396bf075e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06129", "filename": "3f999c966080d773966438c598f117f24ae206d05b1fa864652ab7c396bf075e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06130", "filename": "3f999c966080d773966438c598f117f24ae206d05b1fa864652ab7c396bf075e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06131", "filename": "3fb0a1849865ba13f413f35aab93ff48df086d5901662499d100cf16db870992_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Abnormal physical behavior (the bubbles in the 0.6s-5s video are too large. Such large soap bubbles would deform and burst due to their own weight and airflow, and it would be difficult for them to maintain such stability).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06132", "filename": "3fb0a1849865ba13f413f35aab93ff48df086d5901662499d100cf16db870992_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (1.9s-5.7s: the large bubble splits into two, each larger than the original).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06133", "filename": "3fc4ceff5cea04ebd72494f53ab4820f0ee981a1a1c21c191d9b529df0cf124a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0.1s without any external force, a small black ball appears out of thin air on the character's right hand)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06134", "filename": "3fc4ceff5cea04ebd72494f53ab4820f0ee981a1a1c21c191d9b529df0cf124a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06135", "filename": "3fc4ceff5cea04ebd72494f53ab4820f0ee981a1a1c21c191d9b529df0cf124a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (two small black balls appear in the character's hand at 3.7 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06136", "filename": "3fd8beebcc2f458c4129feba110cc41aac0bae1531577ab40b3216fef2b9fddd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the trees in the scene are being blown by the wind, but the clouds in the sky remain completely still).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06137", "filename": "3fd8beebcc2f458c4129feba110cc41aac0bae1531577ab40b3216fef2b9fddd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06138", "filename": "3fd8beebcc2f458c4129feba110cc41aac0bae1531577ab40b3216fef2b9fddd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the video shows water spraying from a pipe, but during the spraying process, a lot of smoke appears out of nowhere and disperses into the sky).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06139", "filename": "3fd8beebcc2f458c4129feba110cc41aac0bae1531577ab40b3216fef2b9fddd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (in the same environment, the bushes on the left are being blown by the wind, while the bushes in the middle and on the right remain stationary).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06140", "filename": "3fdac7ec93a848a4b82d31edffce1196e9c8712151670566c4fc590920c325b1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the smoke from the chimney is stationary and should be dissipating into the sky).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06141", "filename": "3fdac7ec93a848a4b82d31edffce1196e9c8712151670566c4fc590920c325b1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.2 seconds, the smoke on the bridge suddenly changes direction; under the same conditions, the chimney and cloud should move in the same direction).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06142", "filename": "3fdac7ec93a848a4b82d31edffce1196e9c8712151670566c4fc590920c325b1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06143", "filename": "3fdac7ec93a848a4b82d31edffce1196e9c8712151670566c4fc590920c325b1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06144", "filename": "3fe6eaa56fb6ae84954ef28f8b0cc11e7a5754a4c24e1497fd26cf7ea014c9dd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (the crystals in the image flicker in the absence of a light source).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06145", "filename": "3fe6eaa56fb6ae84954ef28f8b0cc11e7a5754a4c24e1497fd26cf7ea014c9dd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (the crystals in the image gradually brighten in the absence of a light source).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06147", "filename": "98e2949474e77119e7d7781354f24a303a3fa5ea95370baaef94f53c92a29ed9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.1s, a yellow oval object suddenly appears on the left; at 1.5s, a blue oval object suddenly becomes two; at 1.6s, the oval blue object merges with the oval yellow object; at 2.7s, the two pink oval objects on the left merge).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06148", "filename": "98e2949474e77119e7d7781354f24a303a3fa5ea95370baaef94f53c92a29ed9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.4s, the pink oval object on the left suddenly appears and cracks suddenly appear; at 1.4s, the blue oval object suddenly cracks suddenly appear).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06149", "filename": "98e2949474e77119e7d7781354f24a303a3fa5ea95370baaef94f53c92a29ed9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2s, a white mark suddenly appears on the oval blue object on the left; at 3.4s, the shape of the falling oval pink object on the right becomes distorted).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06150", "filename": "98e2949474e77119e7d7781354f24a303a3fa5ea95370baaef94f53c92a29ed9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2s, the black dot on the left oval pink item suddenly disappears; at 3.5s, two oval green items suddenly appear; at 4s, the yellow oval item merges with the green oval item).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06151", "filename": "99a2de9336b1d70d23ca4f528f1185a3cf6d7802e31920187882a25ae863ddcb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the boiling scenes in the video are too smooth and lack a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06152", "filename": "99a2de9336b1d70d23ca4f528f1185a3cf6d7802e31920187882a25ae863ddcb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time was continuous (at 3.3 seconds, the mud suddenly stopped flowing and the boiling state abruptly stopped).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06153", "filename": "99a2de9336b1d70d23ca4f528f1185a3cf6d7802e31920187882a25ae863ddcb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (a mud column suddenly appears in the mud pool at 4.1s, and the number of air bubbles on the left side of the mud pool suddenly increases at 5.5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06154", "filename": "99c49099afa17e9fd2784ade2090d01914a031416d78c32ac833622c0ed79531_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (at 2.1 seconds, the tire suddenly flickers and undulates).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06155", "filename": "99c49099afa17e9fd2784ade2090d01914a031416d78c32ac833622c0ed79531_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Continuous timing (water suddenly appears in the lower right corner of the video at 0.4s; light suddenly intensifies at 1.6s); Physical behavior (the shoes move on their own without external force at 2.7s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06156", "filename": "99c49099afa17e9fd2784ade2090d01914a031416d78c32ac833622c0ed79531_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (the wheel suddenly jumps upward at 2.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06157", "filename": "99c49099afa17e9fd2784ade2090d01914a031416d78c32ac833622c0ed79531_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (at 2.6s, the wheel moves to the left without external force) Time continuity (at 3.4s, white foam suddenly appears on the lower left side of the shoe; at 4.4s, the water baffle above the wheel changes to the internal structure of a washing machine; at 6.6s, the black tire suddenly disappears)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06158", "filename": "99ea03724c13d4e11be949a540d22fc3f1474bb1c5ebe6119c06d7b5e225eac1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time sequence (the water droplets on the iron plate suddenly decrease at 0s, and water stains suddenly appear on the iron plate at 4.4s); Causal relationship (the water droplets on the heated iron plate do not disappear during the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06159", "filename": "99ea03724c13d4e11be949a540d22fc3f1474bb1c5ebe6119c06d7b5e225eac1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time sequence (the water stains on the right iron plate suddenly decrease at 0s, and the white water stains turn transparent at 1.5s) Causality (the water droplets on the heated iron plate do not disappear during the entire video)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06160", "filename": "99ea03724c13d4e11be949a540d22fc3f1474bb1c5ebe6119c06d7b5e225eac1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Cause and effect (liquid suddenly sprays upwards at 0s without decreasing volume) and overall visual inconsistencies (the white liquid in the center of the video boils too smoothly, lacking a natural feel).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06161", "filename": "99ea03724c13d4e11be949a540d22fc3f1474bb1c5ebe6119c06d7b5e225eac1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (at 1.9s, the water splashing around is larger than the water dripping; at 2.1s, the smoke dissipates with the water, increasing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06162", "filename": "0102b01bb8d99510fa5d8dfe0109580067497c67b7ff21382197978307fcb74a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the white ball clips through the gray object at 0.8s), Time continuity (the gray object suddenly disappears at 1.5s, a white object suddenly appears in the character's hand at 1.6s, and a dent suddenly appears on the ball at 1.8s), Physical behavior (the ball rolls out of its trajectory at 1.6s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06163", "filename": "0102b01bb8d99510fa5d8dfe0109580067497c67b7ff21382197978307fcb74a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 0s, the black semicircle on the blue item in the lower left corner suddenly disappears; at 1.6s, the gray item turns into a white ball; at 3.4s, the yellow item in the hand suddenly turns gray; at 4.6s, the blue item suddenly disappears). Physical behavior (at 0.3s, the gray item moves to the left without external force and does not follow the trajectory; at 1.6s, the ball moves in the opposite direction; at 2s, the yellow item on the train track model suddenly moves to the right; at 2.5s, the cylindrical item moves without external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06164", "filename": "0102b01bb8d99510fa5d8dfe0109580067497c67b7ff21382197978307fcb74a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (0.3s: gray object turns into white ball; 4.6s: white ball suddenly disappears; 4.9s: white ball suddenly appears in the lower right corner of the train track model; 5.2s: white ball suddenly appears in the upper left corner of the train track model; 5.4s: white ball suddenly turns into gray object; 5.8s: number of items in the character's hand suddenly increases). Physical behavior (0.4s: white ball moves downwards and to the left without external force; 1.8s: white ball suddenly teleports; 4.1s: white ball moves in the opposite direction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06165", "filename": "103aa70df0707db4ce3aaf053b35d70c36b40b3150b7f5efedb635b54a055e6c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the water flow in the video is too smooth and lacks a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06166", "filename": "103aa70df0707db4ce3aaf053b35d70c36b40b3150b7f5efedb635b54a055e6c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the water flow from the showerhead appears blurry throughout the video); Physical behavior (the water from the showerhead passes through leaves throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06167", "filename": "103aa70df0707db4ce3aaf053b35d70c36b40b3150b7f5efedb635b54a055e6c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06172", "filename": "120e98d9f8ba4c27f37b551767b3e49cb3e10afea6c7f08b877224c6496b11f2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 2.6 seconds, a black figure suddenly appears in front of the white object in the upper right corner; the figure in the entire video walks in an unnatural and distorted manner).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06174", "filename": "133fda5b5f13dd8da8e9f1541ea7b52457d5bc290c4931740eac14a74870f94d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (at 1.2s, the hydraulic press has not yet touched the white object, but the white object suddenly moves downwards; at 1.4s, a white object suddenly appears above the white object and connects to the hydraulic press; at 2.2s, debris adheres to the white object).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06175", "filename": "143f1312d52a70e5cfe3899098fa49515aa295170bd8cd5520a5d4729de5ec97_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous timing (the video image darkens and the objects become thinner at 0.5s) and physical behavior (the objects inside the glass bead do not move under any external force throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06176", "filename": "a572e8d30495f666f317194e917e73e70b7d9b79c991cc6d68bd62253fabc12c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (at 0.9 seconds, the yellow pancake in the video suddenly increases in size).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06181", "filename": "a682cb37dc040e324fbfa49af5eccf4ad330ba952b1f8e1067f1989b66977447_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the fireworks in the video explode out of thin air without any ascent).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06182", "filename": "a682cb37dc040e324fbfa49af5eccf4ad330ba952b1f8e1067f1989b66977447_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06183", "filename": "a682cb37dc040e324fbfa49af5eccf4ad330ba952b1f8e1067f1989b66977447_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06184", "filename": "a682cb37dc040e324fbfa49af5eccf4ad330ba952b1f8e1067f1989b66977447_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06190", "filename": "a916aa261f8aa0369b36ee5025ad886672899d7c7b444cde982a40ea1b92a1e1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06191", "filename": "a916aa261f8aa0369b36ee5025ad886672899d7c7b444cde982a40ea1b92a1e1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 5.7 seconds, a squeezed aluminum can turns into plastic).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06192", "filename": "a916aa261f8aa0369b36ee5025ad886672899d7c7b444cde982a40ea1b92a1e1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (from 3.2s to 4.7s, the squeezed can begins to recover).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06193", "filename": "a942c6da66056680a744e8862151beb2b39efab0916c04fec28c75b4c1663942_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 4.2 seconds, the burning part of the paper suddenly returned to normal).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06194", "filename": "a942c6da66056680a744e8862151beb2b39efab0916c04fec28c75b4c1663942_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (at 5.3s, the paper on the lower left side of the burning area, which was not burning, showed a burning reaction).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06195", "filename": "a942c6da66056680a744e8862151beb2b39efab0916c04fec28c75b4c1663942_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: continuous time (flames and burning ash flowed like liquid on both sides of the paper in the video, and the burning part of the paper in the upper left corner did not change at 1.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06196", "filename": "a942c6da66056680a744e8862151beb2b39efab0916c04fec28c75b4c1663942_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 3.1 seconds, the dust from the burning paper in the upper right corner suddenly increases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06200", "filename": "a2902b4454eef4dd5829aec7b6ed031d48dd5582d19ded229e16f7b3355c6d89_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the ice block in the middle is melting while the water below it remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06201", "filename": "a2902b4454eef4dd5829aec7b6ed031d48dd5582d19ded229e16f7b3355c6d89_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the time sequence is continuous (the amount of water produced by melting ice appears to increase out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06202", "filename": "a2902b4454eef4dd5829aec7b6ed031d48dd5582d19ded229e16f7b3355c6d89_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06203", "filename": "a3148ab980f80847edaced1a114c88c4aa4e5b06a9e76be22d35f6adcba85ce4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (the horse in the middle of the video disappears out of thin air at 0s, the horse on the left side of the video disappears out of thin air at 2s, and a black object appears out of thin air above the horse in the video at 2.5s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06204", "filename": "a3148ab980f80847edaced1a114c88c4aa4e5b06a9e76be22d35f6adcba85ce4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 2.1s, a horse suddenly appears out of nowhere in the video; at 2.5s, a horse suddenly disappears from the left side; at 3.9s, the head of the small horse in the upper left corner breaks off).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06205", "filename": "a03347ef507a2cba84f532ff0e6fc9d1df2b326855bcd503e0735b76f53762f7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical behavior (the kettle shifted without external force at 1.4s, and the hand lifted the kettle without any point of force at 3.3s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06206", "filename": "adca059a4e8a43bb3aaf352a8cbbd03e6f8d6149178ee615c37daf549132bd39_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Cause and effect (Throughout the video, melting liquid was constantly oozing out around the popsicle. As it was melting, the popsicle should have been getting smaller, but it didn't change at all in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06207", "filename": "adca059a4e8a43bb3aaf352a8cbbd03e6f8d6149178ee615c37daf549132bd39_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (at 3.5s, an ice pop suddenly splits into two ice pops) Physical behavior (the ice pops appear out of thin air between 3.5s and 5.5s and fly upwards without any force, which does not conform to the laws of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06208", "filename": "ade07fce7c5dd10ed97d6200a5108c1602187c0a0ad7f8e2913d89770ea9cf69_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Cause and effect (the clouds in the sky should be drifting in one direction due to airflow, but in the entire video, the clouds in the sky are rotating rapidly, and although the clouds are moving very fast, the grass on the ground is not swaying obviously, and the images do not correspond to each other).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06209", "filename": "ade07fce7c5dd10ed97d6200a5108c1602187c0a0ad7f8e2913d89770ea9cf69_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Cause and effect (the rapidly moving dark clouds in the sky prove that the wind is strong, but the grass on the ground remains still, and the images do not correspond to each other).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06210", "filename": "ade07fce7c5dd10ed97d6200a5108c1602187c0a0ad7f8e2913d89770ea9cf69_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the grass on the ground should be swaying in one direction due to airflow, but the direction of swaying of the grass on the ground suddenly changes between 7.4s and 8s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06214", "filename": "ae7560621c36211ef52d05fa81098a4f95eb13def50545a7b6ddc7cbe1820769_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual experience is abnormal (the falling process of objects exhibits a repetitive pattern without any physical basis; the trajectory, speed, and posture are highly homogenized, lacking the random variations found in real-world scenes).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06215", "filename": "ae7560621c36211ef52d05fa81098a4f95eb13def50545a7b6ddc7cbe1820769_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Cause and effect (the trajectory of the falling object shows a relatively uniform vertical motion trend, but the orientation and distribution of the falling object in the whole video are completely disordered, presenting a falling trajectory without physical laws)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06216", "filename": "ae7560621c36211ef52d05fa81098a4f95eb13def50545a7b6ddc7cbe1820769_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (in the middle of the 2.4s video, a falling water droplet suddenly disappears, and then the spot where it disappeared suddenly explodes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06217", "filename": "aeb250c1c68c7e42d5b925752c3cfb88adf5e142b71c232011f285578d049e92_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the shadows cast by white objects throughout the video do not have a unified light source direction, resulting in chaotic and harsh shadows).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06218", "filename": "aeb250c1c68c7e42d5b925752c3cfb88adf5e142b71c232011f285578d049e92_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (As the white object moves, the shadow cast by the white object should change, but in some areas of the video, the shadows are too harsh and do not change with the movement of the white object).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06219", "filename": "aeb250c1c68c7e42d5b925752c3cfb88adf5e142b71c232011f285578d049e92_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06220", "filename": "aeb250c1c68c7e42d5b925752c3cfb88adf5e142b71c232011f285578d049e92_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06221", "filename": "aeb5105fc4fb0ae8289609a5a412c1343e7280195bda34b0b23973d7e9001e8c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall visual impression is off (the water flow from the waterfall directly in front of the video is detached from the waterfall itself, and some trees in the video remain stationary, which is inconsistent with the windy and rainy weather in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06222", "filename": "aeb5105fc4fb0ae8289609a5a412c1343e7280195bda34b0b23973d7e9001e8c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (the entire video was taken during windy and rainy weather, and the trees should have been swaying due to the raindrops and airflow, but the trees in the video remained stationary).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06223", "filename": "aeb5105fc4fb0ae8289609a5a412c1343e7280195bda34b0b23973d7e9001e8c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Cause and effect (the water mist produced by the waterfall should be in a stable state, but in the video, the water mist produced by the waterfall suddenly increases dramatically, and the trees under the rain are frozen in a very stiff state).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06224", "filename": "aeb5105fc4fb0ae8289609a5a412c1343e7280195bda34b0b23973d7e9001e8c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (a sudden leftward gust of wind appears between 4.06 and 6.1 seconds, but the water mist near the waterfall remains unaffected and continues to drift slowly to the right).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06225", "filename": "aedac5f59523719b3f260b016844697ff478b3f247d07dbbe6e2f9bdeda2dca2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Cause and effect (in the entire video, the trees in the fire are constantly swaying and the smoke they produce is blown to the right by the wind, but the trees on the left and right sides of the video remain still, and the images do not correspond to each other).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06226", "filename": "aedac5f59523719b3f260b016844697ff478b3f247d07dbbe6e2f9bdeda2dca2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (there is no obvious change in the airflow in the video, but at 1.1 seconds, the fire of the tree that was burning steadily in front of us suddenly increases dramatically).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06227", "filename": "aedac5f59523719b3f260b016844697ff478b3f247d07dbbe6e2f9bdeda2dca2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.4 seconds, a small burning tree suddenly appears out of nowhere next to the large burning tree on the right side of the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06228", "filename": "aef528ed8a667d6fc0947d61ae79df23f8b139d541955b430dd6351655221655_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06229", "filename": "aef528ed8a667d6fc0947d61ae79df23f8b139d541955b430dd6351655221655_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (the upper background portion of the image shows noticeable shaking throughout the entire time segment).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06230", "filename": "aef528ed8a667d6fc0947d61ae79df23f8b139d541955b430dd6351655221655_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06231", "filename": "aef528ed8a667d6fc0947d61ae79df23f8b139d541955b430dd6351655221655_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (one of the bird's feet disappears out of thin air between 0s and 0.1s, and the bird's size suddenly increases at 0.1s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06232", "filename": "af1d3b0b1c82e8861872ea9f1140f382d069f027a1c671f6ed3b060309daa64e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Cause and Effect (Throughout the video, the water in the pot is boiling, and a lot of steam should be produced on the surface, but the steam produced in the pot is sparse and barely visible in the video)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06233", "filename": "af1d3b0b1c82e8861872ea9f1140f382d069f027a1c671f6ed3b060309daa64e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: Cause and effect (the water in the pot was already boiling between 1s and 3.1s, and a lot of steam should have been produced on the surface, but no steam was seen coming out of the pot in the video. The steam in the pot suddenly increased dramatically between 3.4s and 5.8s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06234", "filename": "af1d3b0b1c82e8861872ea9f1140f382d069f027a1c671f6ed3b060309daa64e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Cause and effect (the water in the pot is boiling throughout the video, and a lot of steam should be produced on the surface, but the steam produced in the pot is sparse and barely visible, and the bubbles produced by the boiling water are too regular).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06235", "filename": "af1d3b0b1c82e8861872ea9f1140f382d069f027a1c671f6ed3b060309daa64e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: cause and effect (the smoke from boiling water in the pot should slowly rise and spread, but in the video from 4.7s to 6.9s, the hot air mass generated on the right side of the pot moves neatly to the left).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06236", "filename": "fd3fe9118eca25641ceb8ddc0a4ed237fe6993bb4404c337805b2d3eb77aaca2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 0.1 seconds, an object on the water surface suddenly transforms into a polar bear).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06237", "filename": "fd5da80ac241ba49b9596702a3e24d429895b89515fba6f66314f196090f7ee9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, a blue object suddenly appears in the lower left corner of the screen at 1.7 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06238", "filename": "fd5da80ac241ba49b9596702a3e24d429895b89515fba6f66314f196090f7ee9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without camera movement or external interference, the oar is abnormally twisted below, and at 0.9s, a rope appears out of thin air in the character's hand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06239", "filename": "fd5da80ac241ba49b9596702a3e24d429895b89515fba6f66314f196090f7ee9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without changing camera angles, at 0.6s, a paddle appears out of thin air in the hand of a yellow figure at the bottom of the screen).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06240", "filename": "fd940a54a629173b09ffdbd32eb2bcc76a2996406de0cf8553f7a1a0aa96693f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the ring on the left side of the screen disappears out of thin air at 1.2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06241", "filename": "fd940a54a629173b09ffdbd32eb2bcc76a2996406de0cf8553f7a1a0aa96693f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, an object in the lower left corner of the frame disappears out of thin air at 1.3 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06242", "filename": "fd940a54a629173b09ffdbd32eb2bcc76a2996406de0cf8553f7a1a0aa96693f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, iron blocks appear sequentially from left to right at the bottom of the screen between 1.3s and 3.9s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06243", "filename": "fd940a54a629173b09ffdbd32eb2bcc76a2996406de0cf8553f7a1a0aa96693f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (Under the condition of no external force or interference, the iron block moves to the right on its own at 3.8s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06244", "filename": "fdade95db5a4c0768a37c34e9944f05154a895c1a47d32966ecb405d14263021_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the color of the flame at the center of the flame is noticeably different from the surrounding flames, and the flame's burning process is smooth and continuous, completely lacking the natural, irregular movement and shape changes of the surrounding flames).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06245", "filename": "fdade95db5a4c0768a37c34e9944f05154a895c1a47d32966ecb405d14263021_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (without any external interference or triggering conditions. The flame in the scene brightens without warning at 0.4 seconds, without the natural process of the flame gradually changing brightness during combustion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06246", "filename": "fdade95db5a4c0768a37c34e9944f05154a895c1a47d32966ecb405d14263021_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (under the premise of no camera change and no external force interference, the fire in the footage suddenly becomes larger at 3.4s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06247", "filename": "fdbc18aa485cbfe4c4e07579fa25b962021af183c0326e424fb9e4b7c4d5f965_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the plastic bottle in the image is burning, but it does not show the physical changes that plastic should undergo when exposed to high temperatures, such as softening, deformation, or concentration; it remains in its intact form).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06248", "filename": "fdbc18aa485cbfe4c4e07579fa25b962021af183c0326e424fb9e4b7c4d5f965_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (without any external force or interference, the flame suddenly brightens at 0.2s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06249", "filename": "fdbc18aa485cbfe4c4e07579fa25b962021af183c0326e424fb9e4b7c4d5f965_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (the plastic in the image is burning but does not undergo the physical changes that plastic should undergo when exposed to high temperatures, such as softening, deformation, or concentration; it remains in its original shape).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06250", "filename": "fdbc18aa485cbfe4c4e07579fa25b962021af183c0326e424fb9e4b7c4d5f965_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (under conditions of no camera movement and no external force interference, the burning and deformed plastic bottle instantly returns to its original shape at 6.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_06251", "filename": "fdbf52cbaa45664f55a85ec9b7bc999fea1757624c38848f06fb1dfe207a878a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (Under the condition of no external interference, at 0.6 seconds, the strong light at the top of the screen disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06252", "filename": "fdbf52cbaa45664f55a85ec9b7bc999fea1757624c38848f06fb1dfe207a878a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, an object appears out of nowhere in the light-filled area at 2.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06253", "filename": "fdf6282870e38192f5660f7fcf786f8b25fa62ad66f93ace553eea49c40bedcf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (Under the condition of no external interference and without camera movement, a cloud appears out of nowhere in the sky at 3.9 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06254", "filename": "fdf6282870e38192f5660f7fcf786f8b25fa62ad66f93ace553eea49c40bedcf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (under the premise of endless transformation, at 1s, the clouds on the left side of the sky suddenly increase in number and their shapes become abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06255", "filename": "fdf6282870e38192f5660f7fcf786f8b25fa62ad66f93ace553eea49c40bedcf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, three white dots appear out of nowhere on the horizon at 0.7 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06256", "filename": "fdf6282870e38192f5660f7fcf786f8b25fa62ad66f93ace553eea49c40bedcf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the movement of clouds in the scene is obviously too fast and the overall movement is too smooth and continuous, without any of the natural undulations, drifts and staggered dynamics of clouds affected by air currents in reality.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06260", "filename": "feaf3639c7574b0f077814ba469dff5bb01c86c04e9fe50e2430a0eb3eba3cca_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time sequence is continuous (the burning wood in the entire scene does not undergo any physical changes, and there are no signs of carbonization, blackening, scorching and cracking at the edges, nor is there any process of the wood peeling off and gradually losing volume under the burning flames. It always maintains its original complete shape and color).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06261", "filename": "feaf3639c7574b0f077814ba469dff5bb01c86c04e9fe50e2430a0eb3eba3cca_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (the wood in the burning state does not change at all, there is no carbonization and blackening, no signs of charred and cracked edges, and no process of wood peeling off and gradually losing volume under the burning).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06262", "filename": "feaf3639c7574b0f077814ba469dff5bb01c86c04e9fe50e2430a0eb3eba3cca_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (without camera movement or external interference, a large number of sparks suddenly appear in the fire at 0.3 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06263", "filename": "ff3c7d7aba01138ada2e99da986b8e5fe908a33d944efba3df60e13fa528865b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, a white shadow suddenly appears on the blade at 0.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06264", "filename": "ff3c7d7aba01138ada2e99da986b8e5fe908a33d944efba3df60e13fa528865b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06265", "filename": "ff5ef4942f0fed9656914d82caa52d1054a3decc745f393fa6cd0fcad659696f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (abnormal distortion along the left side of the screen).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06266", "filename": "ff5ef4942f0fed9656914d82caa52d1054a3decc745f393fa6cd0fcad659696f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any change in camera angle, at 0.3s, an object on a flat surface suddenly deforms, with a small sphere protruding from its smooth surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06267", "filename": "ff5ef4942f0fed9656914d82caa52d1054a3decc745f393fa6cd0fcad659696f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without changing the camera angle, an object appears out of thin air in the lower left corner of the screen at 1.7 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06268", "filename": "ff5ef4942f0fed9656914d82caa52d1054a3decc745f393fa6cd0fcad659696f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Time continuity (Under the premise that the camera does not change and there is no external force interference, at 0s, a bulge suddenly appears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06272", "filename": "ffc86587dc1401ec56c40e2fbf05a1b5f97b32c0044a04c3870d7badff8acd3c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (Under the premise of no external force or object interference, the objects on the table in the image are abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06274", "filename": "a3ac304792f8e46063eb8aa4dbf80b0c4f3b81eae7eb12a831cc6f98c6cea6d9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06275", "filename": "a3ac304792f8e46063eb8aa4dbf80b0c4f3b81eae7eb12a831cc6f98c6cea6d9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06280", "filename": "a4e22238e6cf9ff10ccbd1473a46b84b23db09654e8e76e89a0361f6a0781262_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, smoke appears out of nowhere above the cup at 0.9 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06281", "filename": "a4e22238e6cf9ff10ccbd1473a46b84b23db09654e8e76e89a0361f6a0781262_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (Under the premise of no camera changes, no force, and no external interference, the cup is stationary throughout the video, but the water inside the cup is constantly shaking).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06282", "filename": "a4e22238e6cf9ff10ccbd1473a46b84b23db09654e8e76e89a0361f6a0781262_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06283", "filename": "a5f306603b17359110b64f7c01ded4987f03e30169fb8be196d096c0fc092009_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without any camera movement, between 1.7s and 3.3s, smoke passes directly through a solid iron pot lid without any obstruction or dispersion, appearing very unrealistic.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06284", "filename": "a5f306603b17359110b64f7c01ded4987f03e30169fb8be196d096c0fc092009_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (Although the flame is burning on the surface of the object, the object does not show any signs of charring, blackening, or deformation, and there is no physical reaction of being exposed to high temperature).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06285", "filename": "a5f306603b17359110b64f7c01ded4987f03e30169fb8be196d096c0fc092009_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (smoke appears out of nowhere above the iron pot at 2.7 seconds without any camera movement).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06290", "filename": "a6b86e9e1d962d8cf68a8b3c4635b1ec8ee5f3994c884cb36065ee70533da99a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any change in camera angle, at 0.9s, the right side of the man's shadow on the ground suddenly dents).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06291", "filename": "a6b86e9e1d962d8cf68a8b3c4635b1ec8ee5f3994c884cb36065ee70533da99a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is too smooth (the man's movements while riding the bicycle are too fluid throughout the entire video, lacking the jerky feeling of exerting force in reality, and the bicycle remains completely still, moving forward at a constant speed in a straight line, which does not conform to the physical feedback of real riding).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06292", "filename": "a6b86e9e1d962d8cf68a8b3c4635b1ec8ee5f3994c884cb36065ee70533da99a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06293", "filename": "a6b86e9e1d962d8cf68a8b3c4635b1ec8ee5f3994c884cb36065ee70533da99a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (there is wind while the person is riding the bike throughout the scene, but the ribbons on both sides of the backpack remain suspended without any sign of being blown by the wind).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06294", "filename": "a6bb0ab9116d711c73cbab02641193105bd2ee7d5990b57caddd0188003ba912_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: The time sequence is continuous (the glass ball is illuminated by a light source, but no reflection or light spot is formed, like a non-reflective plastic ball).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06295", "filename": "a6bb0ab9116d711c73cbab02641193105bd2ee7d5990b57caddd0188003ba912_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (without changing camera angles, at 1.8 seconds, the sphere at the bottom of the screen suddenly enlarges).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06296", "filename": "a6bb0ab9116d711c73cbab02641193105bd2ee7d5990b57caddd0188003ba912_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the camera is not moving, but at 2.9 seconds the colored halo suddenly changes from dense fine stripes to a wide rainbow shape; the change in color and texture is not a natural transition, but an abrupt jump).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06297", "filename": "a6ce6a49604c7942ebe4b3f25c1a701dd258a9797b337f67ffa73a521c25e000_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, the upward-moving ice block disappears out of thin air at 0.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06298", "filename": "a6ce6a49604c7942ebe4b3f25c1a701dd258a9797b337f67ffa73a521c25e000_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (without any camera movement, the water in the cup freezes, but the edges of the ice lack the sharpness and clear boundaries of normal ice; instead, they appear blurry and fluffy).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06299", "filename": "a6ce6a49604c7942ebe4b3f25c1a701dd258a9797b337f67ffa73a521c25e000_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 1.6 seconds, the water in the cup suddenly turned into a fluffy white substance like foam without the camera moving).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06300", "filename": "a6ce6a49604c7942ebe4b3f25c1a701dd258a9797b337f67ffa73a521c25e000_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06303", "filename": "a7a261e82dd674eee87ecf421bcd63c7bea73b42e024ed88002dbdec18756203_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (without any camera movement, at 1.9 seconds, the amount of wood chips in the lower right corner of the frame suddenly increases).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06304", "filename": "85f0744b02870e9d24aa0be0bc76492f0b860ed7f8412e1d8a50c6a39a77c5f3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06305", "filename": "85f0744b02870e9d24aa0be0bc76492f0b860ed7f8412e1d8a50c6a39a77c5f3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 5.3s in the video, without any change in the camera angle, a knife suddenly appears on the table, and at 4.8s, the amount of garlic on the cutting board suddenly increases).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06306", "filename": "86a487c5a07151bada4ef4ddb5263d3e484466b048f20d9ef4e8da16162ee4fa_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (between 0.8s and 3.7s in the video, the ice melts but the water level in the glass does not rise).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06307", "filename": "86a487c5a07151bada4ef4ddb5263d3e484466b048f20d9ef4e8da16162ee4fa_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the texture of the ice edges during the melting process from 0.6s to 4.5s is too stiff, and the water vapor on the left side of the cup does not change for a long time, while the water vapor flow on the right side of the cup is too stiff).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06308", "filename": "86a487c5a07151bada4ef4ddb5263d3e484466b048f20d9ef4e8da16162ee4fa_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (during the video from 3.4s to 6.6s, the cup on the right did not crack, but water flowed directly through the cup, violating the principle that solids are impermeable) and continuous time (during the video from 4.2s to 7.6s, the cup on the right suddenly rotated on its own without being subjected to any force; during the video from 2.7s to 4.6s, the ice in the cup on the left suddenly melted in an instant).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06309", "filename": "86ccf021adb7777a048e126d04f3d4514db13832d0385499bcbe9b187e9c70c3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (in the video from 0.2s to 4.3s, the cloud distribution is not layered, the flow direction is unidirectional and the position is fixed, and the propagation of natural light is irregular) and temporal continuity (flickering artifacts exist on the ground throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06310", "filename": "86ccf021adb7777a048e126d04f3d4514db13832d0385499bcbe9b187e9c70c3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (between 0.8s and 5.2s in the video, the cloud flow texture is too mechanical and repetitive, lacking the randomness and regularity of material forms in natural scenes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06311", "filename": "86ccf021adb7777a048e126d04f3d4514db13832d0385499bcbe9b187e9c70c3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual presentation is off (normal rain should extend naturally from the bottom of the clouds, with a gradual and blurred transition at the edges, rather than forming a clearly defined dark blue patch as seen in the image. In addition, the clouds on the left are thick cumulonimbus clouds, but there is no corresponding rain at their bottom, and they are logically inconsistent with the rainfall area on the right).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06312", "filename": "86d5393c65dc6419c046d59754c67ca69ae8c03ebea9ad117cc7340cd8e3fb5a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06313", "filename": "86d5393c65dc6419c046d59754c67ca69ae8c03ebea9ad117cc7340cd8e3fb5a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual inconsistencies (the flowing water in the entire video is too smooth, lacking the realistic pauses and jolts) and continuity issues (the upstream river water in the entire video exhibits flickering and other imperfections).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06314", "filename": "86d5393c65dc6419c046d59754c67ca69ae8c03ebea9ad117cc7340cd8e3fb5a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall visual impression is unusual (from 0.3s to 4.8s in the video, the water texture is uniform, the edges are too stiff, there are no splashes in the video, the water flow is too repetitive and mechanical, and it lacks the randomness and regularity of the material forms in natural scenes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06315", "filename": "86d5393c65dc6419c046d59754c67ca69ae8c03ebea9ad117cc7340cd8e3fb5a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the water flow of a normal waterfall will show a continuous downward dynamic due to gravity, but the edges of the water flow in the image are too sharp and harsh, lacking the dynamic blur and natural transition that real water flow should have).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06316", "filename": "87a7ce41535bf5dc68946a26da6fc7338570ee2f0ca3fc5844fbe71401afe608_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 0.5 seconds into the video, the elephant's foot had not yet touched the watermelon, yet the watermelon opened on its own without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06317", "filename": "87a7ce41535bf5dc68946a26da6fc7338570ee2f0ca3fc5844fbe71401afe608_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the visuals: The timing is continuous (at 2s in the video, the foot has not yet touched the watermelon, and the watermelon opens on its own without any external interference). The overall visual effect is abnormal (at 2.8s, the juice splashing out of the watermelon is too uniform, like water being poured from a basin, lacking a natural sense of dispersion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06318", "filename": "87ea24f8c18b0da3d7cfffc67810454b1d8efa618efee2e7c9d630ea683c6f5b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06319", "filename": "87ea24f8c18b0da3d7cfffc67810454b1d8efa618efee2e7c9d630ea683c6f5b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (at 0.7 seconds into the video, without any change in the camera angle, a concave spherical object in the frame instantly becomes a smooth spherical object).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06320", "filename": "87ea24f8c18b0da3d7cfffc67810454b1d8efa618efee2e7c9d630ea683c6f5b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06321", "filename": "87ea24f8c18b0da3d7cfffc67810454b1d8efa618efee2e7c9d630ea683c6f5b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (at 0.1s in the video, the ball in the person's hand suddenly shrinks in size without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06322", "filename": "87f7ae7a19ad98d816cb5a67c9c85b14512ea9287e0321f2e6599ddf786a9c42_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the gas vaporization throughout the video does not exhibit natural dissipation, which violates the principles of gas flow and light dispersion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06323", "filename": "87f7ae7a19ad98d816cb5a67c9c85b14512ea9287e0321f2e6599ddf786a9c42_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Cause and effect (from 0.7s to 3.5s, the smoke is blown away by the wind at an accelerated rate, but the water surface remains still without any ripples).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06324", "filename": "87f7ae7a19ad98d816cb5a67c9c85b14512ea9287e0321f2e6599ddf786a9c42_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the gas vaporization does not exhibit natural dissipation, violating the principles of gas flow and light dispersion).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06325", "filename": "088bf1dc14b98261de43b317b993299abb68fc086fb31aa9b63b6e4b0d2565e4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 2.3s in the video, before the car wheel even hits the garlic root on the ground, the garlic root wrinkles on its own without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06326", "filename": "088bf1dc14b98261de43b317b993299abb68fc086fb31aa9b63b6e4b0d2565e4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (the garlic roots on the ground sway up and down on their own throughout the entire video without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06327", "filename": "088bf1dc14b98261de43b317b993299abb68fc086fb31aa9b63b6e4b0d2565e4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 1.7s in the video, two green leaves suddenly appear out of nowhere on the garlic sprouts without the camera changing direction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06331", "filename": "88c6a46c2ffb56e596e1685e859ec1b7b9f1a82b6d9b6acf15e1e9fefaa8aa22_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 2.6s in the video, a blue button appears out of thin air on the right side of the yellow base without any change in the camera angle; throughout the video, the device in the frame rotates on its own without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06332", "filename": "88c6a46c2ffb56e596e1685e859ec1b7b9f1a82b6d9b6acf15e1e9fefaa8aa22_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (at 5.2s in the video, the bottle cap in the water suddenly transforms into a long cylindrical object without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06333", "filename": "88c6a46c2ffb56e596e1685e859ec1b7b9f1a82b6d9b6acf15e1e9fefaa8aa22_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (at 4.6s in the video, a long iron bar appears out of thin air on the side of the bottle inside the cup without the camera changing position); Physical behavior (at 4.8s, the long iron bar passes directly through the cup, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06334", "filename": "aa190d7b67960ea4483eaf308db5106e73501be238d1359f90c47c03c033a175_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 7s, some of the small steel balls deformed without being subjected to any force, which violates Newton's first law).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06336", "filename": "aabc249d5f8e43462539ce96beded17dee39ed105bc6f7169c2c8fb0d9d63601_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is discontinuous (the flame of the entire red candle drifts to the left, while the flames of the other two candles rise upwards, and the flame shapes are stiff, lifeless, and unrealistic).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06337", "filename": "aac48e488c384cb6f3d9dd0fb2bf7a46218142db90a827b05e71b08ef909482b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06338", "filename": "aaf914ae6523fd4100567a8f0572bd21e9ad7f3ba97c1ba5fab57c17584083a8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is inconsistent (liquid should reflect light and refract as it passes through the glass, but in the video, the liquid is poured straight into the glass).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06339", "filename": "ab0e8c119565e0e806eb326e831cb45be5bce3d76e41c453c3882f0b53845e3d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Inconsistency (the light inside the mirror and the light outside the mirror emit different colors).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06340", "filename": "ab6a6606f5de742dca8e87affbf9294b4e132d3fa5b57bfdab9557424cc53e22_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (train movement is choppy, video is not smooth, train emits smoke and moves slowly, which does not conform to the law of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06341", "filename": "ab403d414cb9d129536b8cf9e0ed90d6173bf577b221a82fd9fe875fbae4c2ab_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06342", "filename": "ab2948632eadf7ed7054e3f15b632d5711377c61cfc1a21fe4eab6c68ec1d0f5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06343", "filename": "ac3adc5ffcdc8c4acec8b411f907162fb2683f3aa058efc0695f0a5856ff161e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: (At 2.7 seconds, something suddenly appears moving in the upper right corner of the cup, and the movement is inconsistent before and after.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06344", "filename": "ac3fb7160e63fdc112e542cf14ed696382697b5aa5b3cc1e0a3724a0576a5a7d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06345", "filename": "ac9c3db11c269db53b6342b6ca0cdb0e3ecfa225e2c99f8a035bac765457140a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06346", "filename": "ac00127a75db387743f3646f0e49ac3e2c1174e663c6447f397293ffc961c05f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time continuity is not continuous (the water trails from the cruise ship are completely disconnected from the hull, the ship is moving forward but the wake is not moving at all, as if it were static material that was pasted on later; in addition, the smoke from the cruise ship's smokestacks does not dissipate or change shape with the air flow, but remains in a fixed clump suspended in mid-air, which violates the basic laws of fluid motion.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06347", "filename": "acb97c8fe4b552b2f2d613c23606d8e3b1d677afafc2454d0065dde11aba8e47_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: (The ice cream image is shaky and distorted, appearing unrealistic.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06348", "filename": "acbd488ed5e8332a91c5f0d9e07a415962b9d574dcbb7a76895053d1b28e0fbd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is inconsistent (at 3.9s, the lit flame and the smoke from the burning are blown to the left, while the flame on the single pile of matches in front remains upright and still, which is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06349", "filename": "acff745a2791928daf6aa32dc7468bb799865a97684c8e7be7244716915fd613_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is that the time sequence is continuous (at 6.5 seconds, the last small steel ball on the blue plate bounces off automatically without any force, which does not conform to the law of conservation of energy).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06350", "filename": "ad0d913cc20e74e38c2bf67bb01fc9fc35688da446f8abc886ede36a61019843_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06351", "filename": "ad4bc350e26905bb7c7c87f115afa0233cf8c0542f6c2bfbf1686fa885c3521f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity: (The background forest flickers and distorts irregularly, making the image appear unrealistic and unnatural)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06352", "filename": "ad09f218d8bbc4ea2541852cc512ad5c9a1980bfc082a1af06966449cb7d73f4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06353", "filename": "ad47ddd51e028c75a61b30299c587a30b7d8f8fe8070e0809aa2d8ac20adce02_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the water droplet is placed on the paper at 2 seconds, but the paper does not change at all. The paper should be soaked in water and darken in color, so the cause and effect relationship is unreasonable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06354", "filename": "ad49d048142ed1937cdf64bfa8fbb01566c87bcba44b68d82ef9317c14c3db91_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06355", "filename": "ad901a941db57025c64a415618dc2084884e67a372c6c938006b7bdf2640eda7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (the dynamics of the flame are not right. A real flame will jump and deform with the hot air flow, and the brightness will also change slightly. But the flame in the video looks like it is doing a cyclical twisting motion. Moreover, it does not have the temperature layering of a normal flame with a bright outer flame and a dark inner flame. The edges are also too clear and sharp).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06356", "filename": "ad6750f18cc81d5a3f3291b5e1b24cdd20adcbe513a371c4f51a5bddd1229cf4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the clouds in the sky do not change, the smoothness of the image is too harsh, the color saturation of the vegetation below is too high, and the image is unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06357", "filename": "adc75f86f98c987fac0e8dd06f93de3583fa187ed91f6362639cde658a4d0521_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not working properly. There are two main anomalies in the video: First, at 4.4 seconds, the kimchi suddenly appears and disappears without being placed and does not blend with the oil on the grill pan; second, the oil bubbles on all the grilled meat do not change dynamically throughout the process, and the doneness and position of the raw meat in the upper right corner do not change at all during the heating process, as if it is embedded in the screen like a static texture.", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06358", "filename": "ade07fce7c5dd10ed97d6200a5108c1602187c0a0ad7f8e2913d89770ea9cf69_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06359", "filename": "aeb5105fc4fb0ae8289609a5a412c1343e7280195bda34b0b23973d7e9001e8c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is not continuous (the clouds in the visuals do not change, which is not in accordance with the natural laws of cloud movement, and the surrounding objects are not affected when it rains, so the cause-and-effect relationship does not match).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06360", "filename": "af1d3b0b1c82e8861872ea9f1140f382d069f027a1c671f6ed3b060309daa64e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (the water is being heated but only a few bubbles appear, whereas in reality, many bubbles should appear consecutively).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06361", "filename": "af5da802ddf36e69c59dd160d922d355f0d93715be8efc8f6461996a766d8a8e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the clouds in the sky are not changing, which is not in accordance with the natural laws of cloud movement.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06362", "filename": "af861e35c1c898c2d2793405ffe9df4910c5f033199089ebbba34be691ce5b9f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06363", "filename": "af928dbc80e837e69e611188ea68eb7661197e4a53ebe8544e5d41558f889b31_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (the flame only starts to flicker at 2.3s, stops again at 3.1s, and only resumes normal flickering at 5.8s, stopping at 7s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06370", "filename": "4fead74497d9ee7d41e822554edec41a2e77821d565a176c87e339e4d7e05ad1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect (the starburst effect produced by sunlight is caused by the diffraction of the lens aperture blades. Its shape and number correspond strictly to the aperture structure. However, the starburst lines in the video are too uniform and the radial pattern is too perfect. It lacks the subtle flaws and randomness of real lens flare. Real sunlight halos are mainly white and pale yellow, caused by atmospheric scattering, but obvious purple, pink and even green dispersion stripes appear in the video.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06371", "filename": "4fead74497d9ee7d41e822554edec41a2e77821d565a176c87e339e4d7e05ad1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.2s, the color of the sky suddenly changes and the solar aperture suddenly shrinks; from 0.2s to 5.8s, the direction of the sea of clouds is inconsistent with the movement of the clouds in the sky, which does not conform to the airflow pattern).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06372", "filename": "05a289cd7326b5e0594ef3de356c8983e24f6679c9ea0701ab0f4ae0c5516217_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect (the shape of the bubbles will be constantly adjusted due to the pressure difference between the inside and outside and the surface tension, but the color and texture of the bubbles in the video change too quickly, and the black color of the bubbles on the left side of the video is too stable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06373", "filename": "05a289cd7326b5e0594ef3de356c8983e24f6679c9ea0701ab0f4ae0c5516217_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: Cause and effect (in reality, bubbles are thin films, but the bubbles in the image appear as thick as liquids. The shape of the bubbles is constantly adjusted by the pressure difference between the inside and outside and the surface tension. However, the bubbles in the video are constantly increasing in size and do not burst as the bubbles become thinner).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06374", "filename": "05a289cd7326b5e0594ef3de356c8983e24f6679c9ea0701ab0f4ae0c5516217_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06375", "filename": "05a289cd7326b5e0594ef3de356c8983e24f6679c9ea0701ab0f4ae0c5516217_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the black holes on the surface of the bubble and the surrounding color textures are very stiff and heavy, rather than a thin and fragile liquid film. The refraction and reflection of light and shadow do not conform to the physical characteristics of a soap bubble).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06376", "filename": "05ebae72e1b15b5fb5cc7ea403e51025ff37e5e3c9d4c0c49165aad635ab986b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 1.9s, when the Time Butterfly is picked up, it suddenly passes through the yellow clasp and the yellow clasp suddenly disappears); Physical behavior (from 2.4s to 5s, the hand is not holding the disc, but the disc is suspended in the air and rotating, which does not conform to the laws of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06377", "filename": "05ebae72e1b15b5fb5cc7ea403e51025ff37e5e3c9d4c0c49165aad635ab986b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the yellow clip on the right side of the disc packaging box suddenly disappears during the 0.1s video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06378", "filename": "05ebae72e1b15b5fb5cc7ea403e51025ff37e5e3c9d4c0c49165aad635ab986b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the yellow clasp on the disc packaging suddenly deforms at 0.3 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06379", "filename": "05ebae72e1b15b5fb5cc7ea403e51025ff37e5e3c9d4c0c49165aad635ab986b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (at 0s, the yellow clasp on the left side of the disc packaging box suddenly disappears; at 3.1s, when the hand presses on the brown object in the middle of the disc, the brown object suddenly disappears; from 4s to 8s, three reflected lights suddenly appear on the disc and rotate with the disc, which does not conform to the laws of light reflection).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06380", "filename": "05f2b96c1c31490ff634a3289e8e8f588a7a5074113f90d9ab3403cb8f607bcf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Continuous time (boats moving in the river throughout the video suddenly disappear and reappear out of thin air) Causal relationship (clouds in the sky drift in one direction due to the wind, but the clouds above the video remain stationary)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06381", "filename": "05f2b96c1c31490ff634a3289e8e8f588a7a5074113f90d9ab3403cb8f607bcf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.5s, the boats moving in the river suddenly disappear out of thin air, and at 2.4s, the number of boats on the river above the video suddenly increases out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06382", "filename": "05f2b96c1c31490ff634a3289e8e8f588a7a5074113f90d9ab3403cb8f607bcf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (clouds in the sky and mountains may float due to airflow, but the clouds in the video remain stable).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06383", "filename": "5a0a308c9b786ab30f9b9c96c5ac08017a4bc73ffce3412c8f7a0e0e7ecfb008_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 3.9s, the yellow debris that fell onto the table in the lower right corner of the video suddenly twists and deforms, and at 4.4s, the yellow debris in spacetime suddenly deforms).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06384", "filename": "5a0a308c9b786ab30f9b9c96c5ac08017a4bc73ffce3412c8f7a0e0e7ecfb008_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Cause and effect (the deformation and fracture of a solid under pressure is a continuous energy transfer process. The fracture surface will have a rough texture, and the direction of the flying fragments is highly related to the direction of the impact force. However, when the yellow object in the image breaks, its shape change lacks a gradual deformation process, the fracture surface is too smooth, and the direction of the flying fragments is not related to the direction of the pressure).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06385", "filename": "5a0a308c9b786ab30f9b9c96c5ac08017a4bc73ffce3412c8f7a0e0e7ecfb008_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (at 0.2s, the hydraulic press presses down on the yellow object, which is intact but suddenly produces a lot of debris).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06386", "filename": "5a172a12238edf4d77c678ec70e33c70428d2ae82085027972a33dc2c96fd44b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (from beginning to end, the hydraulic press flattens the soccer ball. The air pressure inside the soccer ball should continuously increase, and the pressure gauge needle should rotate in the direction of the higher air pressure value and the pressure should continue to increase. The outer skin of the soccer ball should crack due to the high pressure and eventually be completely crushed or flattened into a piece of material. However, in the entire video, the air pressure gauge needle remains stationary and the soccer ball does not break due to the increase in pressure.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06387", "filename": "5a172a12238edf4d77c678ec70e33c70428d2ae82085027972a33dc2c96fd44b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is continuous (the barometer needle in the upper right corner of the video suddenly becomes distorted between 2.3s and 5.8s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06388", "filename": "5a172a12238edf4d77c678ec70e33c70428d2ae82085027972a33dc2c96fd44b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: Cause and effect (as pressure continues to increase, the outer skin of the soccer ball will crack due to the immense pressure, eventually bursting or flattening into a flat piece of material. This is because the air inside the soccer ball is rapidly compressed under high pressure, and when the internal pressure exceeds the outer skin's tolerance limit, it will rupture. However, the surface of the soccer ball in the video does not show any obvious changes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06389", "filename": "5a172a12238edf4d77c678ec70e33c70428d2ae82085027972a33dc2c96fd44b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal Footage: Causality (In the video, the soccer ball is continuously compressed, and the internal pressure of the ball is constantly increasing. The pressure gauge needle should rotate, but from 0s to 3.2s in the video, the pressure gauge needle remains stationary. As the pressure continues to increase, the outer skin of the soccer ball will crack due to the immense pressure and eventually burst completely. However, after 5.3s, the hydraulic press lifts the soccer ball, reducing the internal pressure, and the soccer ball should rebound. But in the video, after the hydraulic press is lifted, the soccer ball suddenly explodes, and the needle on the pressure gauge does not rotate in the direction of decreasing pressure.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06390", "filename": "5a6610c638ec737878052bfffa2575c470ebf8f81533691633b6c38162b84c8b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Cause and effect (the direction, density, and amplitude of natural ripples are not completely regular, but rather present natural and irregular changes, but the water surface in the video is too regular and rhythmic).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06391", "filename": "5a6610c638ec737878052bfffa2575c470ebf8f81533691633b6c38162b84c8b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous (the waves on the water in the lower left corner of the video stutter and drop frames between 0s and 3.7s. If the entire video is rotated 180 degrees, the positions of the objects and reflections will return to normal as long as it is rotated back. However, the reflections in the entire video appear messy, and there is no correspondence between the reflections of some light sources and objects. They seem to be randomly spliced together).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06392", "filename": "5a6610c638ec737878052bfffa2575c470ebf8f81533691633b6c38162b84c8b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06393", "filename": "5a6610c638ec737878052bfffa2575c470ebf8f81533691633b6c38162b84c8b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: Cause and effect (when multiple objects fall onto the water, the water surface should form ripples that spread outwards from the center at each drop point, and each ripple should be intertwined and chaotic, but in the video below, when multiple objects fall onto the water surface, only a single circular ripple is formed).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06394", "filename": "64aa70b3c4a57fd3b784900f8e5b49f0969508037b7c661f4740b6c033c7504f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual effect is abnormal (the lighting in the video is a bottom-emitting, layered light source. Under normal physical logic, the upper layer of light should be brighter than the lower layer. However, in the video, the brightness of the upper and lower layers of light is completely the same, with no reasonable brightness attenuation layer).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06395", "filename": "64aa70b3c4a57fd3b784900f8e5b49f0969508037b7c661f4740b6c033c7504f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (during the 2.8s-3.5s video lighting change phase, the lower part of the light source did not change brightness first; instead, the upper part of the light changed brightness first. In real physical logic, the light source should complete the brightness change first before transmitting it to the upper area.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06396", "filename": "64aa70b3c4a57fd3b784900f8e5b49f0969508037b7c661f4740b6c033c7504f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physics-driven behavior (the flames at 2s have excessively high saturation, appearing more like textures than realistic flames.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06397", "filename": "64aa70b3c4a57fd3b784900f8e5b49f0969508037b7c661f4740b6c033c7504f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the video, when light passes through the water inside the model candle, the light undergoes refraction and reflection. However, while the water in the video is flowing and contains bubbles, different colors of light are not reflected onto the ground and walls when different lights shine on the water.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06398", "filename": "64f00f210f3332f13acc5ff989619e8afd559f4d8ee429accc35be42bfaa0b5b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: The video shows paper exhibiting a very regular, arc-shaped indentation when compressed under a hydraulic press, with the edges of the paper neatly curling inwards. After the pressure is released, the paper gradually returns to its original shape. In contrast, real paper, when subjected to such immense pressure, would typically suffer irreversible wrinkles or damage.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06399", "filename": "64f00f210f3332f13acc5ff989619e8afd559f4d8ee429accc35be42bfaa0b5b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (at 3.7s, the paper in the image forms a very symmetrical indentation when compressed, whereas real paper would crack, tear, or deform irregularly under great pressure, rather than curling so neatly.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06400", "filename": "64f00f210f3332f13acc5ff989619e8afd559f4d8ee429accc35be42bfaa0b5b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal time continuity (the object suddenly expands to a size far exceeding its normal size after being compressed between 3.8s and 8s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06401", "filename": "65b5395df576889ba103ee96b99fc436cfa679f49f37a13b653ddde073aa94f1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 3.5s, a row of small circular holes suddenly appears on the tank jacket).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06402", "filename": "65b5395df576889ba103ee96b99fc436cfa679f49f37a13b653ddde073aa94f1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06403", "filename": "65b5395df576889ba103ee96b99fc436cfa679f49f37a13b653ddde073aa94f1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06404", "filename": "65b471917e4e9ac6883ecbe9b1eb489dcc153a7a1e403a67ef43c0edcdceddcf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (1.4 seconds after the fish surfaces, when it turns its head, only one of its two barbels remains.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06405", "filename": "65b471917e4e9ac6883ecbe9b1eb489dcc153a7a1e403a67ef43c0edcdceddcf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is unusual: Overall intuition (the heads of two fish near the shore are above the water, but their bodies are not moving. It is impossible for fish to keep their heads above the water for a long time if their bodies are not moving).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06406", "filename": "65b471917e4e9ac6883ecbe9b1eb489dcc153a7a1e403a67ef43c0edcdceddcf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06407", "filename": "65e8ee1d1aaf8e72996116a167a3a21d622f95ed5ac883641eb31581e3328cff_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06408", "filename": "65e8ee1d1aaf8e72996116a167a3a21d622f95ed5ac883641eb31581e3328cff_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the video is not sped up, but the sunlight changes too quickly, which does not conform to the laws of natural change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06409", "filename": "65e8ee1d1aaf8e72996116a167a3a21d622f95ed5ac883641eb31581e3328cff_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the duration is inconsistent (a large number of white clouds suddenly appear in the sky at 1.3s and then suddenly disappear at 7.5s, which does not conform to the basic pattern of cloud appearance).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06410", "filename": "65e467721f7efeea3d16b5ee520c1a43edf453b586617679bcd24c7a7194eb90_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (at 2.6s, the character easily stretches the material, but at other times the material does not change when the character presses with their finger).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06411", "filename": "65e467721f7efeea3d16b5ee520c1a43edf453b586617679bcd24c7a7194eb90_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the process of the character touching the material is too smooth and fluid, without any sense of pause or error, and the composite effect is too heavy).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06412", "filename": "65e467721f7efeea3d16b5ee520c1a43edf453b586617679bcd24c7a7194eb90_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06413", "filename": "65faf655c9847a82c4c4f56c85796e763ebe600489a42f866781f7b95289a489_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (The scene is set in the early morning, but the blue of the sky is overly saturated, exhibiting an unnatural high brightness that does not match the true color tone of the sky in a misty early morning environment.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_06414", "filename": "65faf655c9847a82c4c4f56c85796e763ebe600489a42f866781f7b95289a489_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are off: Overall, the proportions of the tower and main building on the right are unbalanced; the top structure of the tower and the roof lines of the main building appear overly simplified, lacking the detail and texture that a realistic building should have. The shadows on the building are also unnatural, not aligned with the direction of the low-angle morning sunlight.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_06415", "filename": "65faf655c9847a82c4c4f56c85796e763ebe600489a42f866781f7b95289a489_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06416", "filename": "65faf655c9847a82c4c4f56c85796e763ebe600489a42f866781f7b95289a489_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the size and proportions of the town buildings in the distance are completely distorted; the houses are arranged too regularly and lack a sense of three-dimensionality, appearing more like randomly placed color blocks during generation than a realistic town layout.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06417", "filename": "66a6519958ed7d77a3965ec7c226f6218eab0dd39a31fb513cbd0a955cf74779_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall impression (the connection between the figure's waist and yoga pants is unnatural, the yoga pants look like a sticker).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06418", "filename": "66a6519958ed7d77a3965ec7c226f6218eab0dd39a31fb513cbd0a955cf74779_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Overall Intuition (After the figure raises their left leg back, the rest of their body does not follow the movement; the figure is too stiff, and the movement lacks fluidity)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06419", "filename": "66b966676eadef26e2e34c0fa18cad72eea07d81e61368d20da9410bc68ce33d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (in the video, the water in the pot starts to boil from the pot wall, so the heat source should be near the pot wall, but there are no flames near the pot wall, so the water in the pot should not be boiling at the pot wall).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06420", "filename": "66b966676eadef26e2e34c0fa18cad72eea07d81e61368d20da9410bc68ce33d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continues (the footage shows something resembling beans cooking in a pot, but after the water boils completely at 1.6 seconds, nothing is seen rising to the surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06421", "filename": "66b966676eadef26e2e34c0fa18cad72eea07d81e61368d20da9410bc68ce33d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06422", "filename": "66decd8a9313d3ac42157ee5316244ee970ba30fbdedac29787c95d0b737682e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06423", "filename": "66decd8a9313d3ac42157ee5316244ee970ba30fbdedac29787c95d0b737682e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the light emitted by the text at 4.1s is too bright, obscuring the original shape of the text; and the light in some areas is different from the overall shape of the text).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06424", "filename": "855772e78272938c4716971c67fe4f063830bd39119a8e4d52aaeecc0ecf0852_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual presentation is abnormal (in reality, when red wine is poured, the liquid stream is continuous, but the red wine stream in the video appears to flow in an unnatural, broken, layered manner, unlike a real scene, and lacks the viscosity that a real liquid should have.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06425", "filename": "855772e78272938c4716971c67fe4f063830bd39119a8e4d52aaeecc0ecf0852_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (In reality, when red wine is poured, the liquid stream is continuous, but the red wine stream in the video shows an unnatural, broken, layered flow, unlike real footage, lacking the viscosity that real liquid should have.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06426", "filename": "855772e78272938c4716971c67fe4f063830bd39119a8e4d52aaeecc0ecf0852_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06431", "filename": "914817a8aad893cc7af950d7a3de29c6ff69fb40183d3ab78d2cb4fff06e9ea4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous timing (Throughout the video, golden sparks are constantly generated on the building walls. In reality, architectural waterfall fireworks are launched from neatly arranged devices on the top of buildings, and the fireworks are generated from these devices, not directly from the building walls.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06432", "filename": "914817a8aad893cc7af950d7a3de29c6ff69fb40183d3ab78d2cb4fff06e9ea4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the fireworks in the video appear abrupt, lacking a clear upward trajectory, and the explosions produce overly regular patterns, not a realistic image).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06433", "filename": "914817a8aad893cc7af950d7a3de29c6ff69fb40183d3ab78d2cb4fff06e9ea4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06434", "filename": "914817a8aad893cc7af950d7a3de29c6ff69fb40183d3ab78d2cb4fff06e9ea4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06435", "filename": "923378e6d58ff694c8f4aca970de16eef1ee639297e84036245a05959074531a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is unusual: the sequence of events is continuous (at 2.6 seconds, there are obvious fragments and dirt flying out after the car explodes, but at 4.5 seconds, after the smoke dissipates, there are no traces of the explosion on the ground or the car).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06436", "filename": "923378e6d58ff694c8f4aca970de16eef1ee639297e84036245a05959074531a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The sequence of events is continuous (at 4.4 seconds, a large amount of black smoke suddenly appears from the front of a car behind the explosion point. At 4.4 seconds, after the explosion ends, no trace of the explosion remains on the ground at the explosion point.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06437", "filename": "923378e6d58ff694c8f4aca970de16eef1ee639297e84036245a05959074531a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (at 3.3 seconds, the front of the car that exploded suddenly returned to its original state).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06438", "filename": "923378e6d58ff694c8f4aca970de16eef1ee639297e84036245a05959074531a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 6.6 seconds, the car suddenly bursts into flames and gets dirty. The explosion in the video occurs behind the car; normally, a car would only get dirty and shake, not be directly ignited). The overall visual is abnormal (real explosion smoke usually spreads chaotically, while the black smoke in the image presents a regular mushroom cloud shape with a stable upward trajectory, which is not a real scene).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06439", "filename": "0949263d3435d72ea7e4b2507552a0ab3eaa125f144688cf1afb0331c8c326cd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: The overall visual presentation is abnormal. (Real underwater light beams are formed by sunlight penetrating the water surface. The beams extend downwards from the water and are bent due to refraction. However, the beams in the image are uniformly downward parallel lines, lacking the scattering and depth of real underwater light.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06440", "filename": "0949263d3435d72ea7e4b2507552a0ab3eaa125f144688cf1afb0331c8c326cd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (the water surface in the image lacks the reflective and ripple details of realistic water, resembling more like blurry clouds, and there are no suspended particles or water flow patterns underwater.) Physical Behavior (real underwater light beams exhibit a soft gradation due to water scattering, and the edges of the beams have a subtle grainy texture. However, the light beams in the image are uniform parallel lines, lacking the layering and scattering details of realistic underwater light.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06441", "filename": "0949263d3435d72ea7e4b2507552a0ab3eaa125f144688cf1afb0331c8c326cd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06442", "filename": "953558abceccaaf23ca13c0140e295aa3b1ca6d75c099e7af090c411acf6d639_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (normal coastline perspective converges into the distance, but the edge of the beach in the image extends unnaturally horizontally, completely disconnected from the direction of the waves.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06443", "filename": "953558abceccaaf23ca13c0140e295aa3b1ca6d75c099e7af090c411acf6d639_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06444", "filename": "953558abceccaaf23ca13c0140e295aa3b1ca6d75c099e7af090c411acf6d639_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the waves on the left side of the sea have a noticeable golden reflection in the sunlight, while the texture and direction of light and shadow on the right side of the beach are completely disconnected from the sea surface, lacking both the texture of being illuminated by sunlight and the fine texture that a beach should have.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_06445", "filename": "1530489a34f09f8496ba6d741e57e9723bd85509649ce381e47bb8406f22faf4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the flames are burning the right side of the green sugar substance, but the left side of the substance shows burn marks while the right side remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06446", "filename": "1530489a34f09f8496ba6d741e57e9723bd85509649ce381e47bb8406f22faf4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: The overall visual appearance is abnormal (real sugar melting transforms from crystals into a viscous liquid syrup with a uniform texture and no foam. However, the left half of the sugar in the image shows fluffy foam filled with tiny air bubbles.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06447", "filename": "1530489a34f09f8496ba6d741e57e9723bd85509649ce381e47bb8406f22faf4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (real sugar melting transforms from crystals into a viscous liquid syrup with a uniform texture and no foam. However, in the video, the left half of the sugar is filled with fine air bubbles.) Temporal Continuity (Throughout the video, even when the sugar is being burned, only the left half shows signs of melting, while the right half shows no obvious change.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06448", "filename": "1530489a34f09f8496ba6d741e57e9723bd85509649ce381e47bb8406f22faf4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (Real sugar melting transforms from crystals into a viscous liquid with a uniform texture and no bubbles. The image, however, is filled with fine bubbles, a characteristic of a chemical reaction producing a large amount of gas, completely different from the liquid texture of melting sugar.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06449", "filename": "1652765f2ee431eb22c674bb55bf9e197fec101e6f6162f293120304a48b6483_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06450", "filename": "1652765f2ee431eb22c674bb55bf9e197fec101e6f6162f293120304a48b6483_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is continuous (at 1.9 seconds, a large amount of black smoke suddenly billows from the completely burned vehicle). Overall visual anomalies (the movements of people in the entire video are too smooth, unlike realistic footage, lacking the abrupt pauses expected in real life).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06451", "filename": "1652765f2ee431eb22c674bb55bf9e197fec101e6f6162f293120304a48b6483_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (at 0.4 seconds, flames suddenly appear inside the vehicle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06452", "filename": "1939039e4b71f7ee4c92aa89a6caaddd7500fb229e2c957cc1f0935b2fc0bec0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (Throughout the entire video, the ice cubes and ice water in the glass are constantly rotating inside the glass without any interference, violating Newton's First Law of Motion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06453", "filename": "1939039e4b71f7ee4c92aa89a6caaddd7500fb229e2c957cc1f0935b2fc0bec0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 2.7s, the ice cube in the glass is suspended in the air. Normally, the ice cube would fall directly into the ice water due to gravity. The water and ice cube in the glass are constantly rotating without any external force.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06454", "filename": "46fb0e5a2189eb602527c638f5bad9e1eed163ec8f1d5c32276e9123cc430f5d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06455", "filename": "46fb0e5a2189eb602527c638f5bad9e1eed163ec8f1d5c32276e9123cc430f5d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.3s, a small stream of water appears out of nowhere, falling without any downward movement; instead, a stream of water appears out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06456", "filename": "46fb0e5a2189eb602527c638f5bad9e1eed163ec8f1d5c32276e9123cc430f5d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The duration is continuous (smoke appears out of nowhere at the water outlet between 0.4s and 3.7s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06457", "filename": "47d15058e1a101c7f7ce0d9f69c871efc2aaff773bb464bb9ec0d42cd240a5ed_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.7s, the ice cubes teleport and change shape, and the entire video flickers noticeably).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06458", "filename": "47d15058e1a101c7f7ce0d9f69c871efc2aaff773bb464bb9ec0d42cd240a5ed_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Time continuity (water suddenly rises from underwater within the transparent frame at 1.3s); Causality (ice blocks move without any external force between 1.7s and 7.5s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06459", "filename": "48f143ea6f444760886dd863a0b1245b8476be66596ca740bccf5ef5ec8ae8fc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous (the amount of water poured from the kettle does not match the amount of water rising in the cup, and the steam in the kettle should disappear when it is submerged in tea).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06460", "filename": "49cfd9ddea9bc3a1b8473b17de5a867859ae429c930ae2e9dbcfd62b5943f331_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (3.4s: the axe chops down the wood and collides with it, but the wood chips on the wood do not completely shake off, which does not conform to the law of conservation of momentum).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06461", "filename": "49cfd9ddea9bc3a1b8473b17de5a867859ae429c930ae2e9dbcfd62b5943f331_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the video flickers noticeably throughout).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06462", "filename": "49d18ec3495c6c65b68e80406c7e26568858261c44e779eb99469250d70f9789_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06463", "filename": "49fb8801b94439ce89ea3e8e866fdaebb3637afdb65f49fec24a53fd7e381367_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: continuous time (during the entire segment, the oil for frying the steak is boiling and bubbling, but the steak shows no signs of cooking).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06464", "filename": "50abe57c681988d4964df1279cb663c17a2e75cdce3754ebe4b87d925db27bc0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the smoke appearing throughout the segment is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06466", "filename": "50d45b5d35648f992db3901d57e6771d6a98427a963623354e10832f95d922e2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (from 0.2s to the end, the clouds to the left of the sun are constantly getting bigger).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06467", "filename": "50d45b5d35648f992db3901d57e6771d6a98427a963623354e10832f95d922e2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: continuous time (the image flickers throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06468", "filename": "51a1a11c50fb647ce4f9e15c62ae79fbd92fc0581b90f4acc464af56109cc2e7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the trees in the background are flashing throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06471", "filename": "52b538a0f9d08831f92319bf7b49370a0c2f44a2c6ecb75b0fe258a497f2883f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (the hammer strikes the steel plate throughout the entire segment, but the steel plate shows no signs of any collision with other objects). Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the video flickers or wriggles throughout the entire segment).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06472", "filename": "52b538a0f9d08831f92319bf7b49370a0c2f44a2c6ecb75b0fe258a497f2883f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (sparks are produced under the iron block when the hammer is lightly tapped between 1.8s and 7.2s; this would not happen in reality when lightly tapping an iron block).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06473", "filename": "52e4145aff90cfa45355439f8259f27d70e866af89918f5ba74e275c2df27f60_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is not continuous (the brightness of the sun in the sky does not match the intensity of the reflection on the water surface. In a real scene, the bright part of the sun would form a stronger highlight attenuation on the water surface, but the reflection band here appears too uniform).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06477", "filename": "8e0148fa1af00416eb6abda085d8c08f98cffede9ba2d18eb60942fa401b65b9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the hands of the clock start rotating without any external influence during the period from the start to 1 seconds, whereas in reality, a weight should be placed on top for them to rotate); Time continuity (the markings on the left side of the clock disappear at 1.9 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06478", "filename": "8e0148fa1af00416eb6abda085d8c08f98cffede9ba2d18eb60942fa401b65b9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Physical behavior (at 4.5s, it is clearly visible that the scale is not being touched by the machine, but it starts to break on its own, and the pointer on the dial rotates very quickly during the machine's descent); Abnormal overall realism (the scale is quite resilient and feels soft during the machine's operation).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06479", "filename": "8e0148fa1af00416eb6abda085d8c08f98cffede9ba2d18eb60942fa401b65b9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Continuous timing (flickering appears on the dial at 0.8s, and the small hand on the dial enlarges at 4s); Physical behavior (at 4s, the scale in the video is crushed by the machine, producing a large amount of debris, but the shape and size of the scale remain unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06480", "filename": "8e2063d9f6cdf06ce2dacaf50c1c1f3679abb4cfb2f4d8bf09142652ef19b8c8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (in the video, a person can blow a very large bubble simply by holding a stick, while in reality, to blow a bubble the same size as the one in the video, a very large circle is required).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06481", "filename": "8e2063d9f6cdf06ce2dacaf50c1c1f3679abb4cfb2f4d8bf09142652ef19b8c8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall realism is abnormal (the video shows a large bubble being blown using only a stick, and the bubble's texture is very similar to glue); Physical behavior (the bubbles in the video are constantly getting smaller, and they don't burst when the stick is thrust forward).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06482", "filename": "8e2063d9f6cdf06ce2dacaf50c1c1f3679abb4cfb2f4d8bf09142652ef19b8c8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall realism is abnormal (the video shows a large bubble being blown out using only a stick, and the bubble's texture is very similar to glue; at 4.6s, the bubble appears to float in the air like silk, which is different from the fragile nature of real bubbles); the timing is discontinuous (the originally complete large bubble splits into two bubbles, and the bubble on the right suddenly reconnects to the stick at 2.4s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06483", "filename": "8e2063d9f6cdf06ce2dacaf50c1c1f3679abb4cfb2f4d8bf09142652ef19b8c8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not normal: the timing is not continuous (at 7.2 seconds, many small bubbles suddenly appear in the video); the overall realism is not normal (the bubbles in the video have a texture very similar to a tough plastic material when blown by the wind, and they do not burst, while real bubbles are more likely to break).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06484", "filename": "8eedf098fa301e8c0f58afe849a04496479986ed29f4eb60a774aff0308c2202_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (0.4s: the person's two lower legs merge into one); Physical behavior (at 0.6s: the two ropes in the video suddenly separate from their tangled state without any external influence); Unnatural overall realism (the bubble in the lower left corner of the video remains floating above the bucket without moving up or down, maintaining a very unnatural height).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06485", "filename": "8eedf098fa301e8c0f58afe849a04496479986ed29f4eb60a774aff0308c2202_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (the two tangled lines suddenly break at 0.2s); Physical behavior (the lines in the video slowly lengthen between 3.3s and 5s); Unrealistic overall feel (a large bubble appears at the top of the lines in the video after they break).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06486", "filename": "8eedf098fa301e8c0f58afe849a04496479986ed29f4eb60a774aff0308c2202_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (at 0.1s, the person in the video is clearly a young man wearing a black hoodie and gray pants, but after 0.1s, the person changes to an older woman wearing a gray cotton-padded jacket and light blue jeans; at 4s, the ropes at both ends of the stick suddenly disappear and turn into yellow circles; at 7s, the two sticks in the video become one stick); Overall realism is abnormal (at 0.8s, many bubbles suddenly appear between the two sticks, and when the stick is used to hit those bubbles, the bubbles do not burst but instead produce many smaller bubbles).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06487", "filename": "8efb541a71ca71433e9a091b49afa7d1e2683bc73f455b2c3b0aa29a46475b7e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall realism is abnormal (the bubbles under the water in the video look very much like mercury); the timing is continuous (at 1.4 seconds, the bubbles on the left side of the screen turn into fish and swim briefly before turning back into bubbles).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06488", "filename": "8efb541a71ca71433e9a091b49afa7d1e2683bc73f455b2c3b0aa29a46475b7e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall realism is abnormal (the bubbles under the water in the video have a very mercury-like texture; under the same water surface, the bubbles on the left sink downwards while the bubbles on the other side float upwards).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06489", "filename": "8efb541a71ca71433e9a091b49afa7d1e2683bc73f455b2c3b0aa29a46475b7e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (a large number of bubbles are rising to the surface in the video, and the ripples on the water surface are too large and very unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06490", "filename": "8eff513ec4abd60eb8ea2aaf825ff7366625c9ffa3e5df9217c116622fe1d053_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06491", "filename": "8eff513ec4abd60eb8ea2aaf825ff7366625c9ffa3e5df9217c116622fe1d053_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (objects in the video begin to melt rapidly without being heated during the period from 1.8s to 5.7s); Abnormal overall realism (the liquid in the left half of the same foil dish remains stationary and its content does not increase as the object melts and produces liquid).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06492", "filename": "8eff513ec4abd60eb8ea2aaf825ff7366625c9ffa3e5df9217c116622fe1d053_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the overall realism is abnormal (the melting process of objects in the video looks very much like it is crawling and moving slowly).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06493", "filename": "8f3a9c870d7f9d17ef7ad3f7da6dc259c570e48cc750792a38c7cbc8e66a5657_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the fog in the video is drifting rapidly to the right, but the boats and floating objects on the water do not move to the right); Overall realism is abnormal (there is a distinct line of light in the sky in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06494", "filename": "8f3a9c870d7f9d17ef7ad3f7da6dc259c570e48cc750792a38c7cbc8e66a5657_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the visuals: Physical behavior (ripples are clearly visible on the water surface, but the duckweed in the lower left corner does not move and the trees next to it do not sway); Abnormal overall realism (at 3.5s, the fog appears as the sun rises, but the obvious light in the sky does not dissipate as the sun rises).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06495", "filename": "8f3a9c870d7f9d17ef7ad3f7da6dc259c570e48cc750792a38c7cbc8e66a5657_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06496", "filename": "8f3a9c870d7f9d17ef7ad3f7da6dc259c570e48cc750792a38c7cbc8e66a5657_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (the boat on the left side of the screen is moving slowly to the left but there are no ripples on the water, while there are obvious ripples on the water on the right side of the screen but the adjacent water on the left side remains still).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06500", "filename": "8f80ccd2bf3f498e3ff2573efd034671b8296f95d87b1f744887b663a6ae5428_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06501", "filename": "8f80ccd2bf3f498e3ff2573efd034671b8296f95d87b1f744887b663a6ae5428_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall realism is abnormal (the flames on the right suddenly begin to go out during the period from 1.4 seconds to the end); Physical anomalies (during the period from 1.4 seconds to the end, a large number of sparks suddenly start to appear on the ground that was originally burned to ashes).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06502", "filename": "8f80ccd2bf3f498e3ff2573efd034671b8296f95d87b1f744887b663a6ae5428_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall realism is abnormal (the flames produced by the burning in the video are too regular and the smoke they produce is also very uniform).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06503", "filename": "8f80ccd2bf3f498e3ff2573efd034671b8296f95d87b1f744887b663a6ae5428_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 3.2s, the flames in the video suddenly become more intense without any added flammable material); Overall realism is abnormal (the smoke in the video is too dense from 1.2s to the end).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06504", "filename": "P12_104_86_5d1137aab2eacdbe_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the water in the sink moves on its own without any external force, even though the faucet is not dispensing water throughout the entire segment).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06505", "filename": "P12_104_104_2a9af31fd33f1c18_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is continuous (at 3 seconds, the left thumb bends backward dramatically, which is impossible for a human hand to bend to such an extent in reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_06506", "filename": "P12_104_174_4aebe81e4ade5154_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (the water does not splash or spread outwards as it falls from the tap into the sink throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06507", "filename": "P12_104_176_7e9a5a039e578ea5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the circuit board in the lower right corner of the screen and the transparent bowl on the left side of the screen are flickering and wriggling throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06508", "filename": "P12_104_194_0c078fb0f0d988e2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06509", "filename": "P22_101_122_d884d0ffe919cc1b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06510", "filename": "P22_102_137_71deadc21e397e91_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06511", "filename": "P22_103_181_80344a1f4df9a36b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (at 0.1s, the left thumb instantly lengthens and then returns to its original size; the little finger, which was not initially displayed, suddenly appears out of nowhere at 4.3s). Physical behavior (at 3.3s, the right index finger passes through the cutting board, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06512", "filename": "P22_103_319_23a1c139863044be_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06513", "filename": "P22_104_76_4ad85ac03498c2c2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.3s, a small piece of fruit peel appears out of thin air on the right side of the fruit knife; at 6.2s, a black grape appears out of thin air in the cutting board below the fruit knife; at 0.8s, a grape in the cutting board below the left hand has been cut but remains intact).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06514", "filename": "P22_104_82_863a7ff5e8d531e5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (every time the knife cuts out half a grape, that half grape becomes a whole grape, and the original grape is simultaneously restored to its whole state, causing the number of grapes to increase with the number of cuts).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06515", "filename": "P22_108_29_d97afd20450aa322_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is inconsistent (at 3.5 seconds, when the camera pans back to the door, the sofa and table disappear; at 5.8 seconds, when the camera pans back to the stove, the stove disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06516", "filename": "P22_108_102_630e653c46c84d26_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (between 5.3s and 5.5s, the tiles in front of the sink gradually become level, instead of being aligned at the edges; at 5.8s, the sink suddenly expands outwards).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06517", "filename": "P22_109_160_12636db4d59215ee_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video feed is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the tamper ring on the bottle neck disappears out of nowhere at 4.6s, and the bottle cap suddenly pops out of the bottle neck at 4.7s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06518", "filename": "P22_109_445_07d2bed21d737221_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is due to physical behavior (at 3.1s, the entire right hand and towel pass through, and at 5.7s, the left hand fingers emerge from the towel, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06519", "filename": "P22_109_473_c8504107e5af6dde_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.6 seconds, when the towel is used to wipe the water droplets on the left edge of the pool, the water droplets on top do not change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06520", "filename": "P22_110_52_4035aa7de5db6cf9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (at 2.2s, a ring appears out of thin air on the left index finger; between 1.1s and 3.4s, a white column appears out of thin air on the ground and suddenly moves forward; at 6.9s, the white column on the ground disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06521", "filename": "P22_110_100_e4e6b27f06a65fc0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (1.6s, when the plate is flipped, the center of the plate suddenly becomes the bottom of the plate, and the front and back are suddenly reversed).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06522", "filename": "P22_111_137_1280401792f267d1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (the drain holes in both water tanks are constantly flickering and wriggling throughout the entire segment).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06523", "filename": "P22_111_199_7c9405134902379b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 7.2 seconds, when the knife lightly touches the tomato in the upper left corner of the cutting board, the tomato suddenly splits open horizontally).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06524", "filename": "P22_111_201_2df9c5eeae72d58b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the crack left by the knife when it cuts the tomato disappears out of thin air at 0.7s, and a small piece of tomato appears out of thin air at the tip of the knife at 7.6s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06525", "filename": "P22_111_302_c37fb49e1adf54b2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.7s, as the knife cuts down and pushes the object away, the number of cut objects increases out of thin air; at 7.6s, a small black circle appears out of thin air on the blade).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06526", "filename": "P22_111_624_5cd992150cf25590_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (the surface of the pancake in the pan is constantly writhing throughout the entire segment).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06527", "filename": "P22_112_93_497e8073356b26f1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.3s, the tip of the object in the right hand disappears into thin air and then reappears on the right).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06528", "filename": "P22_116_10_9f5d3b1f7b6ceab1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (from 2.1s to 8s, the tip of the paper on the right side of the right hand swings up and down without any external force) Time continuity (at 7.4s, when the right hand folds the paper, it automatically returns to its original shape when the hand is released; in reality, folded paper will remain folded after being released).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06529", "filename": "P22_116_87_da68427d2658c3d4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is due to physical behavior (at 5.7 seconds, the right thumb penetrates the cup, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06530", "filename": "P22_117_137_200474f5df4ea63a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 2.9s, the black stripe and the spoon penetrate it, which violates the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06531", "filename": "P22_117_220_cd0d742ed1773ac4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 2.3s and 3.3s, the sliced eggplant suddenly rolled automatically, and at 3.2s, eggplant slices appeared out of thin air on the side of the knife).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06532", "filename": "P22_117_390_2778ae454f7fad4a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 4s, the left index finger and right thumb penetrate each other, which violates the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06533", "filename": "P23_101_252_836f52e56a99eb3b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.9s, the chili flakes torn off by the left hand disappear into thin air; at 4.5s, the right hand only makes the action of tearing chili flakes but does not tear off any chili flakes, but chili seeds are sprinkled out of thin air when sprinkled into the pot).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06534", "filename": "be064c98135b3d4c428b88843197fdea783c05ad89760b987168185a86a7116c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06537", "filename": "c00f1873318cdbf7c1071876cf7ac0fbf321e231403f1a608d4f173e26f18b51_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06538", "filename": "c0e64cc7edbf45aed7ed579560b9f666129d405ecb76a9b4320b66c7e97851d9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (3 seconds ago, the movement of the waves and the shape of the foam appear to be repeating unnaturally.)", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06539", "filename": "c2e2ac19573aa9d04d8efd63b1cb2d38131f8e61c440e723515aefb33ef74c17_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (When the light and shadow of the diamond in the video flips at 3.8 seconds, its surface reflection does not produce a subtle change in brightness and darkness as the angle changes. It is as if it jumps directly to another set of fixed light and shadow effects, lacking the natural transition of light flowing and refracting between different facets when a real diamond rotates.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06540", "filename": "c2e2ac19573aa9d04d8efd63b1cb2d38131f8e61c440e723515aefb33ef74c17_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to physical behavior (when a real diamond rotates, the reflection from each facet creates a continuous and subtle transition between light and dark as the angle changes, and the brightness of adjacent facets also varies significantly due to different angles of refraction. However, in this video, at 3.8 seconds, the reflection from the facet of the pink diamond on the left abruptly changes without a natural transition).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06541", "filename": "c2fa7c6e9f8b263c72f5932560fbe31df6a445226970d8582605771f76b88c64_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (between 2.5 seconds and 4.2 seconds, the distribution of glitter inside the sphere showed an irregular and abrupt change. The glitter, which was originally concentrated on the left side, suddenly shifted to the right side in a large area. Instead of showing a natural flow as the sphere rotated, it looked more like the scene was directly replaced.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06542", "filename": "c2fa7c6e9f8b263c72f5932560fbe31df6a445226970d8582605771f76b88c64_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is inconsistent (at 3.8 seconds into the video, the glitter inside the crystal ball suddenly changes from fine fragments to large, bubble-like particles).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06544", "filename": "c3c2dd97d173a555f3d2fca10d5eda65b2c407eded92e27e98d1377776c31d88_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 1.1 seconds, the water in the pot suddenly boils, but there is no dynamic movement of rolling or bursting bubbles on the surface. At the same time, the steam becomes dense and fixed instantly, without the effect of naturally dissipating.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06545", "filename": "c3d780c8c7205bdd7843f85e6498848e194c97f3b3228faf96bd953498862429_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06546", "filename": "c3d780c8c7205bdd7843f85e6498848e194c97f3b3228faf96bd953498862429_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 2.6 seconds, the paddle suddenly appears in the frame without any entry process; at 2.7 seconds, the paddle blades pass through the water without creating ripples or splashes; at 4.6 seconds, the paddle suddenly disappears without any movement out of the frame.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06547", "filename": "c5dd4a1a5168876a5b105f14215bafe188c0a56c9cf25bf037221318c26b1f13_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06548", "filename": "c6c8f5bc66cac4692e89703b4a73bfa9098b7385b8036c49a3f0429cce46d195_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 1.5 seconds, the water flow suddenly breaks unnaturally, like a spliced image; at 2.0 seconds, the smoke in the background pauses for a moment, inconsistent with the dynamic rhythm of the water flow.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06549", "filename": "c6c8f5bc66cac4692e89703b4a73bfa9098b7385b8036c49a3f0429cce46d195_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (around 3.5 seconds, the edge of the water flow near the camera shows pixelated distortion, which does not conform to the optical refraction effect of real water flow; moreover, the connection between the water flow and the faucet in the entire video does not have natural water splashing, which appears very stiff.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06550", "filename": "c08e3f471656434930fd301fad4ae02beed1825425bb54b1ee73591e0f77292c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 1.8 seconds, the basketball's falling speed and rebound height do not conform to the laws of gravity. In a real basketball, the falling speed would accelerate due to gravity, and the rebound height would decrease due to energy loss, but the trajectory of this ball seems to be controlled at a constant speed; at 3 seconds, the lateral movement of the basketball from left hand to right hand lacks a gradual change in force, and the basketball does not move upward due to the ground's reaction force at 1.8 seconds, but directly touches the ground.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06551", "filename": "c9f06a6df48e32a66a06738cf73d19b9c50aebdfd589ea7c914b3d1064f8b02f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06552", "filename": "c18bd91ec8828e1440af527001d4327546ab3fa0c7924f8c7a96a0727c243fbf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (in the video, the poured liquid does not blend with the liquid in the cup; at 3.5 seconds, foam suddenly appears without any aggregation process and its shape remains fixed without change).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06553", "filename": "c34d987d43475766ecd16751637e7757a367ce39473e078c2a79834586d8c816_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06554", "filename": "d1501a3792890010c813721f32432d6eab2df97caa9fbdd70acc7cdd8d42d82a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image error: Time continuity (the connection between the metronome pointer and the metronome body should be in the center of the metronome, not on the left side of the body.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06555", "filename": "d1967f59dd3dc26f37a57502ddd51f5af50f3d3508872b49a48ab391b4242ac1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (When a cardboard box is burned in a fire, its shape should carbonize, become brittle, and shrink, rather than remaining unchanged.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06556", "filename": "d1967f59dd3dc26f37a57502ddd51f5af50f3d3508872b49a48ab391b4242ac1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the flames in the image are blown by the wind from left to right, while the cardboard box is blown from front to back).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06557", "filename": "d2317d16af7a7c6c7e75eb0b8b1c96fc5fbf968d853d149ae969cb7e18bbf018_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (3.4s-4.5s, the front of the lens suddenly changes to the back, and the rotation changes from counterclockwise to clockwise).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06558", "filename": "d2317d16af7a7c6c7e75eb0b8b1c96fc5fbf968d853d149ae969cb7e18bbf018_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Physical behavior (the lens placed on the table suddenly flies into the air; the lens is affected by gravity and cannot fly out of thin air.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06559", "filename": "d2317d16af7a7c6c7e75eb0b8b1c96fc5fbf968d853d149ae969cb7e18bbf018_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06560", "filename": "d4767fca373c19baf905bed6b04feb54fac75f23b2628344b269ea7f5d5614a4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: For 0.2 seconds, a rubber band suddenly splits into two, and then after 4.4 seconds, the two rubber bands merge back into one.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06561", "filename": "d4767fca373c19baf905bed6b04feb54fac75f23b2628344b269ea7f5d5614a4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (The image shows a rubber band stretched to a very long length; the elastic rubber band suddenly becomes an inelastic rope. When the rubber band is stretched beyond its elastic deformation range, it should break, not lose its elasticity.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06562", "filename": "d4767fca373c19baf905bed6b04feb54fac75f23b2628344b269ea7f5d5614a4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (2.6 seconds, one rubber band suddenly becomes two rubber bands).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06563", "filename": "d4767fca373c19baf905bed6b04feb54fac75f23b2628344b269ea7f5d5614a4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (1.3s, the rubber band suddenly turns into a cotton-like rope).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06564", "filename": "d5069bc8d3bd52625cd34edd3ba66aae4310b9c4440cb081c733b80158c74f85_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06565", "filename": "d5069bc8d3bd52625cd34edd3ba66aae4310b9c4440cb081c733b80158c74f85_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the reflection in the lake water in the image keeps flickering and blurry).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06566", "filename": "d5069bc8d3bd52625cd34edd3ba66aae4310b9c4440cb081c733b80158c74f85_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time interval is continuous (4.1s-4.5s, the turquoise lake water suddenly becomes clear and transparent).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06567", "filename": "d5069bc8d3bd52625cd34edd3ba66aae4310b9c4440cb081c733b80158c74f85_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (the light on the lake's surface appears to flicker and wriggle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06568", "filename": "d8669ba6eac1692458c9a5f39cb87d08b1c814909735d2056b8997d45310d76f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the visuals: Continuous time (clouds in the sky appear and disappear in the same location repeatedly without changing position. Due to airflow, clouds should disperse in all directions instead of remaining stationary.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06569", "filename": "d8669ba6eac1692458c9a5f39cb87d08b1c814909735d2056b8997d45310d76f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06570", "filename": "d8669ba6eac1692458c9a5f39cb87d08b1c814909735d2056b8997d45310d76f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (as the clouds move, the surface of the clouds continuously flickers and wriggles).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06571", "filename": "d8669ba6eac1692458c9a5f39cb87d08b1c814909735d2056b8997d45310d76f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06572", "filename": "d9317fe04e1d6809bccd90c7b6f8e8b09974b9380e7ca57390cea4df8473b330_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (2.2s-4s, the dried noodles that were broken by the wheel suddenly return to their original shape).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06573", "filename": "d9317fe04e1d6809bccd90c7b6f8e8b09974b9380e7ca57390cea4df8473b330_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (dry noodles do not break when they are run over by the wheel from 2.5s to 3.5s, but break automatically after the wheel leaves the noodles. The actions are out of sync).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06574", "filename": "d9317fe04e1d6809bccd90c7b6f8e8b09974b9380e7ca57390cea4df8473b330_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 2.8 seconds, the dried noodles that were broken suddenly turned into small stones).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06575", "filename": "d30682a6072771f6c5ebb2d3b5aa5bf62f568d3f37df04bda6b1a9741c481131_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the wood in the image is burning intensely; the flames of charcoal in the intense burning stage should be bright white or pale yellow, not pure red).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06576", "filename": "d30682a6072771f6c5ebb2d3b5aa5bf62f568d3f37df04bda6b1a9741c481131_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (at 0.9 seconds, the burning charcoal suddenly explodes violently without any external force, and the flames increase in size).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06577", "filename": "d30682a6072771f6c5ebb2d3b5aa5bf62f568d3f37df04bda6b1a9741c481131_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06578", "filename": "d30682a6072771f6c5ebb2d3b5aa5bf62f568d3f37df04bda6b1a9741c481131_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (5.8 seconds). The fire suddenly bursts into a large number of sparks like fireworks without any external force.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06579", "filename": "d42631e16e783bda7ef1c0dbf03016483030ab6b015b11833a0c5d708fbbbfdc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the lake surface suddenly becomes like fabric, as if fabric is being pulled and swayed from side to side.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06580", "filename": "d42631e16e783bda7ef1c0dbf03016483030ab6b015b11833a0c5d708fbbbfdc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the lake surface and its reflection are too smooth, unlike a realistic scene, resembling a comic book texture).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06581", "filename": "d42631e16e783bda7ef1c0dbf03016483030ab6b015b11833a0c5d708fbbbfdc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06583", "filename": "30e28978cab14c2686ec9e3d6d35ed6dfde03e7a74afa164ab7092c1455c3bbb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: (A yellow and white fish swimming out from the right side of the video at 0.6s is swimming on the surface, which is not in line with natural ecology).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06584", "filename": "30e28978cab14c2686ec9e3d6d35ed6dfde03e7a74afa164ab7092c1455c3bbb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity issue (the lotus leaves in the image are flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06585", "filename": "32fd0c50e2fec1e13da7e9153a2d9827c0c6ee999cd3220eaf192a663054adfd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06586", "filename": "33d8e05007db7dbdb69f72cca71e37addfd42aed862e64e4abf129d2ace0f40b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (water boiling should spread outwards from the center, but the image shows steam rising fixedly to one side), overall visual inconsistencies (steam should form above the kettle after boiling), and temporal continuity issues (the background of the image flickers).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06587", "filename": "33d8e05007db7dbdb69f72cca71e37addfd42aed862e64e4abf129d2ace0f40b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (no water vapor appears before the water boils in the 0s-4.6s video, which violates common sense in physics)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06588", "filename": "33f84ce51f68d60de82cc0d9786645258ec7485c2c95035de08224b737a06786_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (there should be dirt flying at the moment of explosion at 0.4s, but this is not shown in the image), and temporal continuity (the entire image flickers).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06589", "filename": "33f75948ff199bafbe29849470f3e01feaf78320a4c30bec24572c6f6122f295_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (4s-5s) shows the straw sliding noticeably downwards in the right glass without any external force, which does not conform to the physical behavior between solids.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06590", "filename": "33fcdead0f26faa900ec5d3c9c206a50cfcfaa0e5d90b8a5efb71d5d0b320e72_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (the flame in the upper left corner disappears between 0s and 0.1s), and the overall visual presentation is abnormal (the way the Mars flies out is too regular, and the fact that the Mars gradually dims during its ascent does not match the fact that the Mars is always present in the scene).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06591", "filename": "34e222a79effcefaa31e17ea2ed1e22d132205ccbf07ccf40a16fe88728406c2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (water vapor appears from 0s to 2.5s, but disappears after continuous heating for 2.5s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06592", "filename": "35db58abfde63bbcfd9277a6018913d92171b67870d48e8b95536fd7ce83d952_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity issue (overall screen flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06593", "filename": "35db58abfde63bbcfd9277a6018913d92171b67870d48e8b95536fd7ce83d952_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06594", "filename": "36acf8262bc1bb7bb68127f2d9c853743d7feb527c01b8481f534208e70d2f8e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06595", "filename": "36acf8262bc1bb7bb68127f2d9c853743d7feb527c01b8481f534208e70d2f8e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06596", "filename": "36de8f22fafbf554bff5fd98229870f9ccae5aaf639c518be13c8a4af40326e9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06598", "filename": "37d70c98fb8c34ccfa95aa1dc6f98db07c7967b451265a5356853c91407ea570_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity issue (overall screen flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06599", "filename": "37f82c5450aa2c1327ede30449c7a600c65812c5ff486915afa34fb6881830a5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06600", "filename": "37f82c5450aa2c1327ede30449c7a600c65812c5ff486915afa34fb6881830a5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06602", "filename": "39d82f6d502eea422deb3eb7b3809938c01b9c8bb6516a41c4dab15baf823e0f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity issue (overall screen flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06603", "filename": "P23_101_151_31ed65929ff2bce6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is inconsistent (the video abruptly changes at 4.3s, and the inconsistency before and after).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06604", "filename": "P23_102_9_a2d324e5afafff26_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (from 0.9s to the end, the water poured into the sink suddenly turns into dry rice grains, and at 1.5s, the foamy water in the pot suddenly turns into rice grains).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06605", "filename": "P23_102_9_a2d324e5afafff26_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the scene from 2.3s to the end, the character pours water into a metal basin full of water in a trough, but the water does not overflow, and very turbid water appears out of nowhere in the trough).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06606", "filename": "P23_102_9_a2d324e5afafff26_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (from the beginning to 3.3s, the water in the pot was not steaming, but from 3.3s to the end, when water was poured into the water tank, a large amount of water vapor appeared, and from 2.6s to 5.1s, the beans in the pot that were originally soaking in water were all dry beans in the video when water was poured in, and the number of beans increased significantly).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06607", "filename": "P23_102_13_29e622adb88f1bb3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (in the entire video, the water in the pot was not steaming at the beginning, but a large amount of steam appeared when water was poured into the sink); Time continuity (from 4.6s to 6s, the beans were not poured into the pot but into the sink, yet a large amount of beans appeared in the pot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06608", "filename": "P23_102_108_189bf359ac960c98_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (1.7s) The character is cutting an onion, but after one cut, two whole onion slices come out.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06609", "filename": "P23_102_108_189bf359ac960c98_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video contains the following anomalies: Time continuity (the onion deforms when pressed at 7.2 seconds); Physical behavior (the person's finger pierces the knife while cutting the onion, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06610", "filename": "P23_102_114_cfa95fdc2da9fea7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 5.6s, a piece of onion suddenly appears on the cutting board and sticks to the knife without any force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06611", "filename": "P23_102_114_cfa95fdc2da9fea7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (when cutting an onion with a knife, it should appear as slices, but the video shows it as crumbs); Temporal continuity (at 4.3s, the onion skin changes from brown to white; from the beginning to 2.4s, the onion is cut with a knife but remains intact and produces a lot of onion crumbs; at 6.4s, a piece of onion in the person's hand suddenly turns into onion crumbs).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06612", "filename": "P23_102_153_d8e259fe94e6f7de_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video contains several visual inconsistencies: the timing is inconsistent (the chili pepper suddenly enlarges at 2 seconds); the overall realism is off (it's highly improbable that the chili pepper is cut multiple times in one spot before a single ring is created).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06613", "filename": "P23_102_153_d8e259fe94e6f7de_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a person is cutting chili peppers in the scene, but chili pepper pieces appear before the knife even touches the cutting board).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06614", "filename": "P23_102_253_e8f8fd0bff18d300_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall impression (the figure in the image is wiping the table, and the body movements are too smooth and unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06615", "filename": "P23_102_253_e8f8fd0bff18d300_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (no shadow appears on the character's arm in the water tank from 3.2s to the end); Time continuity (the shape of the yellow object held by the character suddenly changes at 2.5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06616", "filename": "P23_102_253_e8f8fd0bff18d300_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall impression (the figure's movements while wiping the table are too smooth and unnatural, giving the impression that the rag is floating on the table).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06617", "filename": "P23_102_378_db33e4ad74844e8d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.1s, the top of the plastic bag in the hand suddenly appears sealed).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06618", "filename": "P23_102_378_db33e4ad74844e8d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_06619", "filename": "P25_101_43_b827484e853feabc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (at 2.5s, the food suddenly merges into one piece after separating into two, and at 6.4s, the food suddenly turns black).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06620", "filename": "P25_101_57_f9b7a9f4a0e93071_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06621", "filename": "P25_101_57_f9b7a9f4a0e93071_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.2s, the food suddenly turns yellowish-brown, and at 6.1s, after the person uses a fork to lift the food, the shape of the food changes significantly).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06622", "filename": "P25_101_95_3cb1c063da24b3ba_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 6.6s, the previously blurry lower right floor suddenly becomes clear).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06623", "filename": "P25_102_1_826a5b5a5d5742f4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (during the period from 0.4s to 2.6s, the pot in the video shows obvious light and shadow, but the light and shadow disappear after it is removed from the pot).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06624", "filename": "P25_102_109_266aa4baf7428523_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (in the video, a person is using a sponge to clean a pot; at 3.6s, the sponge suddenly disappears, and during the period from 2.1s to 2.6s, when the pot is being cleaned and then flipped over, the back suddenly becomes the front).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06625", "filename": "P25_103_35_24224309fe86e974_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unsettling: the timing is discontinuous (the folds created by the origami suddenly disappear at 1.9 seconds); the overall effect is unrealistic (the shape of the paper doesn't change during the person's handling of it, making it appear unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06626", "filename": "P25_103_35_24224309fe86e974_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall realism is abnormal (the movements of people in the video, such as clenching their fists, are very stiff and unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06627", "filename": "P25_103_52_4b763c7d975a6f43_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the object on the left side of the screen did not come into contact with the heat source but still produced a boiling reaction, and at 2.4 seconds, the food in the pot flipped onto the fork without any force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06628", "filename": "P25_103_52_4b763c7d975a6f43_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (only the right half of the food is being fried in the same pan, while the left half remains still).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06629", "filename": "P25_103_52_4b763c7d975a6f43_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (a spoon suddenly appears in the character's left hand at 5.1s); Unrealistic overall feel (from 1.1s to 2.3s, when deep-frying food in a pan, there's an effect of water boiling away and a lot of bubbles appearing).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06630", "filename": "P25_103_108_a2b8d1a12b26393b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (food changes from rectangle to triangle from 3.9s to 5.2s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06631", "filename": "P25_104_104_84e28be07a226329_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall realism is abnormal (the color of the tomato sauce on the spoon after stirring it is inconsistent with that in the pot); Physical behavior (the pot on the left remains boiling even without being heated, which does not conform to heating rules).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06632", "filename": "P25_104_104_84e28be07a226329_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.3s, the clip appears as a ghost image, and from 3.4s to the end, the ketchup bottle becomes transparent, and the person in the scene uses the clip and puts it down with the spoon; the two objects merge together in the next frame).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06635", "filename": "cf558ac7b13c20192dfa5f256fbe3239c20345d54d8b0b555fe0ce8570e1689d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (the burning wood moves downwards without external force at 1.7s) and continuous time (an explosion suddenly appears in the video at 1.8s without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06636", "filename": "cf558ac7b13c20192dfa5f256fbe3239c20345d54d8b0b555fe0ce8570e1689d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06637", "filename": "cf680fed4a1be18fe2735547f3615844e7ef52f7f220d2181ba815522c45b2f3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Time continuity (the burning white paper suddenly disappears at 4.9s) and causal relationship (the white paper moves upwards without external force at 4.6s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06638", "filename": "cfd96a8199e34632598cf7f279d768e5170f9df666d228d597eeedd9315c1299_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (at 0.1s, smoke passes through the cup, and the flash at the rim of the cup does not change with the movement of the camera throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06639", "filename": "d1c45706b98c24104c3474841ef30bc4c926773f721e03c260cfd4d1e308e5c2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Time continuity (bubbles suddenly appear at the bottom of the cup at 0.2s) Physical behavior (the ice cubes in the cup rotate to the left without external force at 1.3s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06640", "filename": "d1c45706b98c24104c3474841ef30bc4c926773f721e03c260cfd4d1e308e5c2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Time sequence (a white mist layer appears at the bottom of the cup at 0.6s; a water droplet suddenly appears at the top of the cup at 1.1s; bubbles suddenly appear on the top of the ice at 1.3s; the ice in the cup changes from three to two at 2s; bubbles suddenly appear at the bottom of the cup at 2.1s) Physical behavior (the ice moves to the left without external force at 1.4s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06641", "filename": "d2ab516a0d5ee6e9f25db885dc74d2457c8461eaff7ae9cfac314abfe5fc33fd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (at 0.6s, the video feed shows no transition, bubbles appear in front of the muzzle and two bullet casings appear above the explosion; at 0.7s, bullet casings suddenly appear at the top of the video; at 4.8s, the flame below the muzzle does not follow the trajectory of the gun barrel).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06642", "filename": "d2ab516a0d5ee6e9f25db885dc74d2457c8461eaff7ae9cfac314abfe5fc33fd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The video feed is continuous (at 0.8s, there is no transition and the muzzle flashes; at 1.1s, the flames from the muzzle turn into smoke and continue to be emitted; at 2.2s, a bullet appears out of nowhere on the barrel; at 2.7s, the bullet splits and a third bullet casing appears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06643", "filename": "d2af3ce7683ff1c5e365dd43c2fc05c27e9c40e53369a9ed096c2729c97fef5d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06644", "filename": "d2d9084dee705b19855e66d684109586828bee014891b12a28ec31e2b8db6888_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous timing (the video flickers throughout and the ground in the lower right corner appears to be wriggling).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06645", "filename": "d2d9084dee705b19855e66d684109586828bee014891b12a28ec31e2b8db6888_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the black vehicle on the right moves backward without external force at 1.8s) Time continuity (the teardrop-shaped icon in the lower right corner suddenly disappears at 1.27ss)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06646", "filename": "d2f963ba992af317954b9efd1de1e2e284759d0a1804111924d969340e802012_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Continuous timing (white smoke suddenly appears in the pot at 1.1s, and the thermometer reading suddenly jumps at 5.7s) Cause and effect (the boiling point of water is only 100 degrees Celsius at 4.4s, but the thermometer in the video measures over 800 degrees Celsius).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06647", "filename": "d3e9f33dc9274851ef6f3ae838f18a11a3188d517602c49d5f31470cc30c360c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (from 1s to 2.1s, the shape of the diamond at the bottom changes to the same shape as the diamond at the top; at 2.5s, a green light and shadow suddenly appears on the upper right of the diamond on the left). Physical behavior (the diamonds in the entire video are moving without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06648", "filename": "d3e9f33dc9274851ef6f3ae838f18a11a3188d517602c49d5f31470cc30c360c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (at 2.1s, the diamond's texture changes to another material; at 2.6s, a green light suddenly appears in the upper right corner of the diamond; at 6.1s, the green beam of light suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06649", "filename": "d4e19c146c71c4851da4e2f535e56fe67677df799b8c1d065df77173aabd3ed7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (the waves in the entire video do not move forward but remain stationary).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06650", "filename": "d5ca337cef8e108a26cd2de46f1e8f6bdd34c0b36291152f956c28d3268487ee_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time sequence (the coffee surface is still at 0.7s when it is being stirred, the black dots on the right side of the inside of the cup suddenly disappear at 1.5s, and the black dots suddenly reappear on the right side of the inside of the cup at 2.9s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06651", "filename": "d5ca337cef8e108a26cd2de46f1e8f6bdd34c0b36291152f956c28d3268487ee_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous timing (the coffee liquid changes from diluted to viscous without the addition of a thickener throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06652", "filename": "d5ca337cef8e108a26cd2de46f1e8f6bdd34c0b36291152f956c28d3268487ee_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (the surface of the coffee liquid suddenly becomes still after being continuously stirred for 6.3 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06653", "filename": "f43d995fb1a82a9f9da5dd2f39d9c0c72eca5d3aadde6b3d2888315110400199_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (small bubbles in the video are connected together, and the distribution of bubbles is too uniform, which does not conform to the basic laws of liquid boiling under normal circumstances).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06654", "filename": "f58b5ff81fa67dbc2972b5ae438dbf67f1a1c10e23a0a846b521cd9f0ead1276_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06655", "filename": "f58b5ff81fa67dbc2972b5ae438dbf67f1a1c10e23a0a846b521cd9f0ead1276_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continues (no steam is produced when the water in the pot in the image boils).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06656", "filename": "f58b5ff81fa67dbc2972b5ae438dbf67f1a1c10e23a0a846b521cd9f0ead1276_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1.4 seconds, the ice in the pot turns into bubbles filled with white smoke, and at 2.7 seconds, the bubbles suddenly burst, and the water in the pot suddenly starts to boil after the bubbles burst).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06657", "filename": "f88c9a10f4c5191dba82a704c749b9d0ecdf4da38b819e947d313e1fd09ace09_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The duration is continuous (at 1.4 seconds, the cloud formation on the left side of the screen suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06658", "filename": "f88c9a10f4c5191dba82a704c749b9d0ecdf4da38b819e947d313e1fd09ace09_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is unusual: the overall impression is that at 1.6s, the ground is completely covered by dark clouds, but the ground is still golden yellow from the sunlight, without any change.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_06659", "filename": "f88c9a10f4c5191dba82a704c749b9d0ecdf4da38b819e947d313e1fd09ace09_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06660", "filename": "f88c9a10f4c5191dba82a704c749b9d0ecdf4da38b819e947d313e1fd09ace09_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Duration (at 4.3 seconds in the video, clouds suddenly begin to appear above the rainbow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06661", "filename": "f91f07c2412e52ac0a8448a20af08ba4aa5726189af8aa1533fe395d01ce162d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time is continuous (the left-side rearview mirror of the car in the footage swings very flexibly from side to side without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06662", "filename": "f91f07c2412e52ac0a8448a20af08ba4aa5726189af8aa1533fe395d01ce162d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Physical behavior (the thick smoke in the footage is mainly coming from the middle left of the vehicle, but the extent of the fire in this area is not as severe as that at the front of the vehicle, so the smoke should be coming from the front of the vehicle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06663", "filename": "f91f07c2412e52ac0a8448a20af08ba4aa5726189af8aa1533fe395d01ce162d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 3.5 seconds in the video, the water from the water gun clips through the car door).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06664", "filename": "f94edbaf6a78e1d44cb4491ae7dba0881cc8e06a7e2445ebcdfb81b19970c6a8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (During combustion, smoke should rise directly above the flames, but the thick white smoke in the image is coming from the open space to the left of the fire, completely separate from the flames on the right, and does not correspond to the burning area.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06665", "filename": "f94edbaf6a78e1d44cb4491ae7dba0881cc8e06a7e2445ebcdfb81b19970c6a8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The duration is continuous (at 1.2 seconds, the grass next to the campfire begins to turn white and spreads outwards without any external influence until the end of the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06666", "filename": "f94edbaf6a78e1d44cb4491ae7dba0881cc8e06a7e2445ebcdfb81b19970c6a8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Duration (at 1.1 seconds, an irregular white object flashes across the bushes in the background).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06667", "filename": "f238f2746c031f8775c50a3fdc381c4de9e155d8ffb8648931d7d9f588da1c20_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall impression (the folds of the trouser hems do not change as the figure walks).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06668", "filename": "f238f2746c031f8775c50a3fdc381c4de9e155d8ffb8648931d7d9f588da1c20_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (a very obvious crack appears on the zebra crossing at 1.4 seconds, but disappears at 3.3 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06669", "filename": "f400f472a0ccbb3d4621ce82cc4df7c5f579fc4b36e724f152f2ce323f3ed046_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06670", "filename": "f400f472a0ccbb3d4621ce82cc4df7c5f579fc4b36e724f152f2ce323f3ed046_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06671", "filename": "f400f472a0ccbb3d4621ce82cc4df7c5f579fc4b36e724f152f2ce323f3ed046_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration continues (the induction cooker is not turned on in the video, but the water in the cup placed on the induction cooker shows signs of about to boil).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06672", "filename": "f400f472a0ccbb3d4621ce82cc4df7c5f579fc4b36e724f152f2ce323f3ed046_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Duration (the steam on the glass suddenly disappears at 7.5 seconds in the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06673", "filename": "f406be6872d553e192f0658464d52165b485ae64c5439f0fccb4772548bb77bf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The duration of the scene (from 0.9s to 2.4s, the left side of the ice cream changes from dark brown to light yellow and then back to dark brown)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06674", "filename": "f406be6872d553e192f0658464d52165b485ae64c5439f0fccb4772548bb77bf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time delay (the ice cream in the video starts melting rapidly at 0.9s, producing a large amount of liquid chocolate that flows downwards, but the ice cream itself only reacts at 4.6s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06675", "filename": "f406be6872d553e192f0658464d52165b485ae64c5439f0fccb4772548bb77bf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06676", "filename": "f410b1e976cebf27acafc92d46b262dfd2270dd942cd3438f8b3b9a06bb7f220_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06677", "filename": "f410b1e976cebf27acafc92d46b262dfd2270dd942cd3438f8b3b9a06bb7f220_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Duration (at 3.2 seconds in the video, the water jet from the water gun suddenly turned into a mist).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06678", "filename": "f410b1e976cebf27acafc92d46b262dfd2270dd942cd3438f8b3b9a06bb7f220_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (the water droplets sprayed at 2.6 seconds in the video suddenly disappeared).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06679", "filename": "f423d748e0b41e30d63a7bd8333a4626dfcecb5e0f60c4a9a238bc26668755f3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continues (the diamond rotating counterclockwise in the image for 1.8 seconds suddenly flashes and starts rotating clockwise, and the round diamond also turns into an oval diamond at the same time).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06680", "filename": "f423d748e0b41e30d63a7bd8333a4626dfcecb5e0f60c4a9a238bc26668755f3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the diamond is displayed on a mirror, but the reflection in the mirror is much larger than the actual diamond).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06681", "filename": "f423d748e0b41e30d63a7bd8333a4626dfcecb5e0f60c4a9a238bc26668755f3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the steel pipe and its reflection in the mirror appear to merge at 1.5 seconds in the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06682", "filename": "f423d748e0b41e30d63a7bd8333a4626dfcecb5e0f60c4a9a238bc26668755f3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06683", "filename": "8165e4d6e925fd634f513d1d734afb0dba814315502d2e4e764ca3ecec50f675_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (water in a river spontaneously circulates and surges upwards, defying gravity)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06684", "filename": "8165e4d6e925fd634f513d1d734afb0dba814315502d2e4e764ca3ecec50f675_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (the water sprays in the image appear as smoke in the air, lacking the graininess and dynamic layers of splashing).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06685", "filename": "8165e4d6e925fd634f513d1d734afb0dba814315502d2e4e764ca3ecec50f675_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the water droplets falling on the rocks suddenly disappear; the ripples on the water surface and the trajectory of the splashing water droplets are completely repeated, lacking natural random variation).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06686", "filename": "8819ec65021ba80b3838d27bf835e47d9dbcae295a5d0a7dcbf5b5d84501d5b3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the sun is a complete circular light source, and even with atmospheric refraction, it will only exhibit slight shape distortion and will not split into two independent luminous circles). Overall realism is abnormal (the edges of the red light spots in the sky are too regular and sharp, lacking the soft gradation of a realistic sunset).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06687", "filename": "8819ec65021ba80b3838d27bf835e47d9dbcae295a5d0a7dcbf5b5d84501d5b3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (despite the environmental features of wind blowing, the trees remain completely still with no natural movement of branches or leaves).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06688", "filename": "8819ec65021ba80b3838d27bf835e47d9dbcae295a5d0a7dcbf5b5d84501d5b3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (the bird in the frame suddenly disappears at 3.2 seconds); Physical behavior (the sun suddenly splits into two independent circular light sources during its descent, then merges back into one and continues its descent).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06689", "filename": "8867c0626f77206dd00ae0ce04d9f5d716c1a0850be0d6234e97435e45f5ca1f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: The overall realism is abnormal (the water flow in the image does not have natural ripples or spread, and the edges are too regular; there are no wet marks or puddles on the ground).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06690", "filename": "8867c0626f77206dd00ae0ce04d9f5d716c1a0850be0d6234e97435e45f5ca1f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (after the water falls to the ground from 2.1s to 5s, it does not follow the natural properties of liquids to spread outwards, but instead remains in a gathered state without reasonable support). Overall realism is abnormal (the water flow is too straight and stiff, lacking the sense of undulation).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06691", "filename": "8867c0626f77206dd00ae0ce04d9f5d716c1a0850be0d6234e97435e45f5ca1f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06692", "filename": "8889a695e4b6ab221d98469b6e92500f792897f6e147492ab84c2af019573a02_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (0s-1.2s: obvious flames are emitted from the tail of the aircraft, but the surrounding clouds remain completely still).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06693", "filename": "8889a695e4b6ab221d98469b6e92500f792897f6e147492ab84c2af019573a02_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time sequence is not continuous (in the distance, the aircraft is flying among the snow-capped mountains and clouds at a high altitude, but when the camera cuts to a close-up, the terrain below the aircraft suddenly becomes a low-altitude valley with a road, and the lighting and atmosphere in the two shots are completely mismatched).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06694", "filename": "8930f6e7869155b6da204fa5486f5ea0135091aa5705e5f27cb9c8724b084afc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the smoke above the fire is too concentrated and stiff, lacking the dynamic sense of naturally spreading and rising with the airflow; the remaining flames at 4.3s are too small to produce a secondary violent explosion)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06695", "filename": "8930f6e7869155b6da204fa5486f5ea0135091aa5705e5f27cb9c8724b084afc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Continuous timing (the plate on the table suddenly disappears at 2.8s); Physical behavior (the sparks from the explosion at 0s-3s do not scatter or fall naturally, but instead spray continuously into the air like water).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06696", "filename": "8930f6e7869155b6da204fa5486f5ea0135091aa5705e5f27cb9c8724b084afc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall realism is abnormal (the outlines of the flame column and the mushroom cloud at the top are too regular and stiff between 0s and 5s; such a violent flame jet did not produce any obvious heat wave disturbance or scorching marks on the surrounding dry grass and wooden table, and even the grass clippings on the ground did not move at all).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06697", "filename": "8930f6e7869155b6da204fa5486f5ea0135091aa5705e5f27cb9c8724b084afc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (1.2s-8s). There was only a pot on the table before the explosion, and after the explosion, wooden sticks and iron frames appeared out of thin air.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06698", "filename": "8965c28c3e5b73877bb8ebf0b5ab73956d7802d8fd4e81c6cc9cfcd498a72e47_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the clouds in the image do not surge, spread, or slowly dissipate with the airflow, but disappear directly; only the leaves in the lower right corner are swaying, while the rest remain still)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06699", "filename": "8965c28c3e5b73877bb8ebf0b5ab73956d7802d8fd4e81c6cc9cfcd498a72e47_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (the clouds in the image are ejected in a jet-like manner, and instead of moving according to the natural diffusion and drift of gas, they suddenly disappear without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06700", "filename": "8965c28c3e5b73877bb8ebf0b5ab73956d7802d8fd4e81c6cc9cfcd498a72e47_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (the clouds and fog suddenly disappear and then suddenly reappear in the scene between 1.6s and 8s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06701", "filename": "9090c5dd0e0af93739b17cd7270b70002e530cd2affcbbb6a822917ff6cd8ba8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (1.3s-5s) When the hydraulic press is pressed down, the sheet metal is compressed and deformed, but it immediately returns to its original shape when the pressure is released.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06702", "filename": "9090c5dd0e0af93739b17cd7270b70002e530cd2affcbbb6a822917ff6cd8ba8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Lake surface anomaly: physical behavior (2.3s-5.8s) When the sheet metal was compressed, it did not show normal plastic deformation, bending or breakage. Instead, its volume increased out of thin air and extended downward and overlapped.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06703", "filename": "9090c5dd0e0af93739b17cd7270b70002e530cd2affcbbb6a822917ff6cd8ba8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (2.2s-5s: The volume of the compressed sheet metal increases out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06704", "filename": "9090c5dd0e0af93739b17cd7270b70002e530cd2affcbbb6a822917ff6cd8ba8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (4.5s-8s). During the process of the hydraulic press crushing the sheet metal, the sheet metal is directly transformed into a book with a regular shape.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06709", "filename": "9186d51d96e4eb74036fb12bcd9223eaaca31d411404caee92762e2a869774cc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the water is continuously flowing, but the ice blocks on it remain in a fixed shape, without melting, breaking, or moving due to the water flow); Overall realism is abnormal (the texture of the water flow is unnatural, the ripples and reflections during the flow are too uniform, lacking randomness and a sense of depth in the water flow).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06710", "filename": "9186d51d96e4eb74036fb12bcd9223eaaca31d411404caee92762e2a869774cc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the water is flowing continuously, but the shape of the ice blocks on it remains unchanged, without melting, breaking or moving due to the water flow; from 4.5s to 5.8s, when the ice blocks are impacted by the water flow and touched by external forces, they exhibit a soft and elastic deformation like jelly).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06711", "filename": "9186d51d96e4eb74036fb12bcd9223eaaca31d411404caee92762e2a869774cc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical behavior (the water source has a small outlet diameter and weak water volume, but the water volume suddenly increases as it flows downstream).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06712", "filename": "9186d51d96e4eb74036fb12bcd9223eaaca31d411404caee92762e2a869774cc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the footage from 2.4s to 6.1s shows a combination of flowing water and ice blocks; it's impossible for hot air to be emanating from it).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06719", "filename": "c223bdcf69c33fab2c3820aed62d3de351a7bad631ed5a041122c8849187c11d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the stove under the sparkler suddenly switches to a black background at 2.5s, then suddenly reappears at 4s, and then suddenly disappears at 4.8s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06720", "filename": "c223bdcf69c33fab2c3820aed62d3de351a7bad631ed5a041122c8849187c11d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Intuitive anomaly (Throughout the video, the edges of the blue flames are too symmetrical, smooth, and perfect, lacking the natural transition from sparks to flames seen in real flames).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06721", "filename": "c223bdcf69c33fab2c3820aed62d3de351a7bad631ed5a041122c8849187c11d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 2.6s, the stick held by the person in the video touches the furnace and suddenly emits sparks like a fairy wand; at 4.5s, it suddenly returns to a normal flame, which gradually gets smaller and smaller until it goes out).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06722", "filename": "c676c92e2fe93dc780b8423a524d83c43e9c45dc3a32986d6632a44b4edb1768_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (At 2.3s, the metal ball rolling down the stairs suddenly teleports back two steps without any external force; at 2.5s, the hand of the person touching the ball deforms; the ball teleports from the third step onto the iron basin as it rolls down; at 4.5s, the ball clips through and merges with the edge of the iron basin; the ball then teleports back and disappears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06723", "filename": "c676c92e2fe93dc780b8423a524d83c43e9c45dc3a32986d6632a44b4edb1768_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity (the ball rolls slowly throughout the video, but suddenly speeds up at 2.9s, showing no consistency).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06724", "filename": "c676c92e2fe93dc780b8423a524d83c43e9c45dc3a32986d6632a44b4edb1768_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the ball deforms and twists multiple times while rolling throughout the video, and suddenly stops rolling without any external force or buffer when it reaches the last step).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06725", "filename": "c676c92e2fe93dc780b8423a524d83c43e9c45dc3a32986d6632a44b4edb1768_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06726", "filename": "c714a8806d58bc4c7ef7ce73a4b5da7868507c95a442b5bf5fa022eac0a36424_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is discontinuous (the sun in the middle of the sky and the clouds passing by in the entire video appear to merge and overlap multiple times, and there is no normal cloud shadow passing through the sun).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06727", "filename": "c714a8806d58bc4c7ef7ce73a4b5da7868507c95a442b5bf5fa022eac0a36424_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is inconsistent (the clouds in the sky and the shadows on the ground are inconsistent throughout the video; at 0.5s, the ground is completely covered by shadows, but the clouds in the sky are not enough to have this effect on the ground).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06728", "filename": "c714a8806d58bc4c7ef7ce73a4b5da7868507c95a442b5bf5fa022eac0a36424_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is inconsistent (the clouds in the sky and the shadows on the ground are inconsistent throughout the video; at 2.4s, the ground is completely covered by shadows, but the clouds in the sky are not enough to have this effect on the ground).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06729", "filename": "c714a8806d58bc4c7ef7ce73a4b5da7868507c95a442b5bf5fa022eac0a36424_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (the clouds in the sky and the shadows on the ground are inconsistent throughout the video. The ground is completely covered by shadows, but the clouds in the sky are in clusters, while the entire ground is covered by shadows).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06733", "filename": "c816a14920dfa12d20923cedb9374c81ee9925164760eba3d8b7a36e1d5c2076_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Causality (After the explosion occurred in the entire video, the doll that was standing before the explosion remained in place, completely unaffected by the explosion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06734", "filename": "c816a14920dfa12d20923cedb9374c81ee9925164760eba3d8b7a36e1d5c2076_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Causality (1.5s After the object was blown up, no fragments appeared in the same spot, and no objects flew up during the explosion)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06735", "filename": "c816a14920dfa12d20923cedb9374c81ee9925164760eba3d8b7a36e1d5c2076_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Causality (at 0.8s, the doll in the video moves without external force; after the doll explodes, it appears in the lingering smoke at 3.8s; at 5.1s, the doll falls to the ground, breaks into pieces, and disappears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06736", "filename": "c876d5f51964f91d2b8717a414f3f6324a763d7c248f7a407b664f904fd820a1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The time sequence is continuous (at 0.1 seconds, an orange ball suddenly appears out of nowhere at the bottom of the transparent tube in the video, and the ball floats up and down in the water as the liquid shakes without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06737", "filename": "c876d5f51964f91d2b8717a414f3f6324a763d7c248f7a407b664f904fd820a1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Cause and effect (Throughout the video, an unidentified substance falls into the water from inside the transparent tube, but the water does not change due to the volume of the object).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06738", "filename": "c876d5f51964f91d2b8717a414f3f6324a763d7c248f7a407b664f904fd820a1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (there is obvious reflection on the top of the transparent tube in the diagnostic video, but there is no reflection of the orange object below the transparent tube).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06739", "filename": "c876d5f51964f91d2b8717a414f3f6324a763d7c248f7a407b664f904fd820a1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The time sequence is continuous (at 0.9 seconds, orange balls suddenly appear out of nowhere at the bottom of the transparent tube, accompanied by bubbles, and the liquid in the water suddenly increases and rises without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06743", "filename": "27d4fe782033afe8cc8e4ededefef77d7044b0994a00ee5d22f51fd0f636548a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06744", "filename": "27fe065de2f8b4e9c8f81cf838e4ddd542e3b8da86333b86ff66f5e8a4a8e747_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the ketchup under the spoon appears out of thin air at 0.1s and disappears out of thin air at 0.3s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06745", "filename": "27fe065de2f8b4e9c8f81cf838e4ddd542e3b8da86333b86ff66f5e8a4a8e747_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.6s, the ketchup in the spoon suddenly increases out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06746", "filename": "27fe065de2f8b4e9c8f81cf838e4ddd542e3b8da86333b86ff66f5e8a4a8e747_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06747", "filename": "28ac59ce74e8bc2df7c3e60d28d0c6fda873865f71645c1a1137edc9c6289cdd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the tree branches in the upper left corner of the video are swaying, but their reflections in the lake are not).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06748", "filename": "28ac59ce74e8bc2df7c3e60d28d0c6fda873865f71645c1a1137edc9c6289cdd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timeline is discontinuous (the lake in the lower left corner of the video is blurry).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06749", "filename": "28ac59ce74e8bc2df7c3e60d28d0c6fda873865f71645c1a1137edc9c6289cdd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.5s, the smoke on the lake surface in the lower left corner suddenly increases).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06750", "filename": "28ac59ce74e8bc2df7c3e60d28d0c6fda873865f71645c1a1137edc9c6289cdd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly due to physical behavior (at 6.2 seconds, the lake surface in the middle of the video shows ripples even without external force or wind. Real water mist consists of small gaseous water droplets that diffuse, evaporate, and dissipate with airflow, and will not appear to increase instead of dissipating).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06751", "filename": "28b185e9205732a49f0e27a0a157a1c0cb1b351a6a65e87a7a9c3604123d10da_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (no changes were observed on the surface of the fingers when the hand pressed the gemstone in the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06752", "filename": "28b185e9205732a49f0e27a0a157a1c0cb1b351a6a65e87a7a9c3604123d10da_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.2 seconds, the rough surface of the left finger suddenly becomes smooth).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06753", "filename": "28b185e9205732a49f0e27a0a157a1c0cb1b351a6a65e87a7a9c3604123d10da_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the green object that was originally in the gem disappeared at 3.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06754", "filename": "28b185e9205732a49f0e27a0a157a1c0cb1b351a6a65e87a7a9c3604123d10da_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Physical behavior (the gem in the hand rotates on its own without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06758", "filename": "029f1a347e8434d4d60e2505278baff6546a087b4add4eeadf75c0a5645b1b03_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the small boat in the lower left corner of the video does not produce ripples that spread outwards as it slides).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06759", "filename": "029f1a347e8434d4d60e2505278baff6546a087b4add4eeadf75c0a5645b1b03_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the small boat in the lower left corner disappears out of thin air at 0.1s, reappears out of thin air at 0.2s and merges into one, and the small boat in the middle of the video appears out of thin air at 0.6s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06760", "filename": "029f1a347e8434d4d60e2505278baff6546a087b4add4eeadf75c0a5645b1b03_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is continuous (the clouds directly above the video disappear out of thin air at 0.3 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06761", "filename": "029f1a347e8434d4d60e2505278baff6546a087b4add4eeadf75c0a5645b1b03_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the small boat in the lower left corner disappears out of thin air at 4s and 6s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06762", "filename": "29d2d4cda10fe79d993df40ac4c9029dd1e3f8e11b8758abadaf6c65c4dcd558_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 1.5s, an object falls from the left side of the video and then appears out of thin air; at 2.1s, an object falls from the left side of the video and then appears out of thin air again).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06763", "filename": "29d2d4cda10fe79d993df40ac4c9029dd1e3f8e11b8758abadaf6c65c4dcd558_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (at 4.3s, objects falling to the left of the main object appear out of thin air; at 4.6s, debris appears out of thin air at the bottom of the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06764", "filename": "29d2d4cda10fe79d993df40ac4c9029dd1e3f8e11b8758abadaf6c65c4dcd558_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: The timing is continuous (at 2.9 seconds, the object falling from below the hydraulic press disappears into thin air); causality is unclear (at 3.5 seconds, the object breaks without the hydraulic press touching it).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06768", "filename": "30e28978cab14c2686ec9e3d6d35ed6dfde03e7a74afa164ab7092c1455c3bbb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Continuous timing (flickering of the water surface throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06769", "filename": "30e28978cab14c2686ec9e3d6d35ed6dfde03e7a74afa164ab7092c1455c3bbb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is continuous (a small fish appears out of nowhere in the middle of the video at 0.3 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06770", "filename": "30e28978cab14c2686ec9e3d6d35ed6dfde03e7a74afa164ab7092c1455c3bbb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is continuous (a small fish appears out of nowhere on the left side of the video at 0.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06773", "filename": "1a9b8a2d8e953ab69c555dd1457afb863d50e26b984f37c7f3f3e50e77b3d0dd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (1.2s\u20133.3s, no liquid is being poured into the left cup, yet the liquid level continues to rise; 3.9s, no liquid is being poured into the right cup, which was initially not full, suddenly becomes full.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06777", "filename": "1a3013fbd7ffb7ca95fcc0ea22f322382d930ec420b701e33382562c15638ff1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.2s in the video, the surfboard below the figure suddenly changes color from white to yellow without any external intervention.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06778", "filename": "1a3013fbd7ffb7ca95fcc0ea22f322382d930ec420b701e33382562c15638ff1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.3s in the video, the character's movements are abrupt, changing directly from lying on the surfboard to standing, without any natural transition. The movement is stiff and shows obvious signs of splicing.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06779", "filename": "1a3013fbd7ffb7ca95fcc0ea22f322382d930ec420b701e33382562c15638ff1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is inconsistent (at 1.5s, the figure's legs suddenly disappear without any reasonable cause; at 1.9s, the figure changes abruptly from lying on the surfboard to a half-squatting standing position without any transition process, and the transition is abrupt).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06780", "filename": "1a3013fbd7ffb7ca95fcc0ea22f322382d930ec420b701e33382562c15638ff1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is inconsistent (at 1.8s, the person has their left foot on the surfboard while their right foot is dangling in the air; at 2.1s, the left foot becomes the right foot, and the left foot steps onto the surfboard from its dangling position).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06781", "filename": "1a52039cda52cdcf3fd2e52ed45a783b25cafaa1c15e9cb4c7179d4f712886ca_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: (0s-2.4s, the ball moves at a constant speed in a straight line. From 2.4s onwards, the ball suddenly deflects to the right without any external force, and its trajectory becomes an arc. At 4s, the ball, which was originally moving in a straight line, suddenly comes to a stop, and then starts moving again on its own and changes its direction of motion.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06782", "filename": "1a52039cda52cdcf3fd2e52ed45a783b25cafaa1c15e9cb4c7179d4f712886ca_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (The ball rolls at a constant speed from left to right, ignoring frictional resistance and not slowing down; although it continues to approach the light source throughout the process, starting at 3.1s, its shadow moves in the opposite direction to its actual position.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06783", "filename": "1a52039cda52cdcf3fd2e52ed45a783b25cafaa1c15e9cb4c7179d4f712886ca_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (at 5.8s in the video, the ball stops abruptly after hitting the black side cloth, and then bounces back in the opposite direction without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06784", "filename": "1ac5cb51fd867f7b3eb61a7c8191e2cea8a8fe323c4bb69e03dfa83ec7d0f773_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 3 seconds in the video, the drone hovers and flies in the opposite direction on its own while the hand is off the remote controller).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06785", "filename": "1ac5cb51fd867f7b3eb61a7c8191e2cea8a8fe323c4bb69e03dfa83ec7d0f773_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous time (the entire video shows something resembling a knob on the remote control spinning continuously, even when the hand is not touching it).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06786", "filename": "1ac5cb51fd867f7b3eb61a7c8191e2cea8a8fe323c4bb69e03dfa83ec7d0f773_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06787", "filename": "1ac5cb51fd867f7b3eb61a7c8191e2cea8a8fe323c4bb69e03dfa83ec7d0f773_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 0.1s, the bent index finger straightens instantly without any movement in between; at 2.9s, the front dual propeller blades of the drone suddenly rotate in the opposite direction.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06788", "filename": "1ac5cdfea7cfa26dd72ee94dc9c3e5c37f6b8c6b5ee6dcad9cc716e8706b548a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (4.7s, a single box next to the green basket on the left conveyor belt instantly splits in two, and the newly formed box accelerates forward.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06789", "filename": "1ac5cdfea7cfa26dd72ee94dc9c3e5c37f6b8c6b5ee6dcad9cc716e8706b548a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Continuous time (the entire video stream is shown with the conveyor belt stationary in the middle; realistically, the boxes above it should not move, but they move on their own without any external force or gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06790", "filename": "1ac5cdfea7cfa26dd72ee94dc9c3e5c37f6b8c6b5ee6dcad9cc716e8706b548a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (0.7s, the right conveyor belt suddenly stops, but the box on it continues to slide at a constant speed despite inertia, and the second half of the conveyor belt is still running abnormally. The left conveyor belt is stationary throughout the process, but the object moves on its own without any external force.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06795", "filename": "1b3bc1d832b1261e5c328eab84c1f429666bda56984dcf13998a08b5e394cfd7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06796", "filename": "1b3bc1d832b1261e5c328eab84c1f429666bda56984dcf13998a08b5e394cfd7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (from 4.2s to 5.6s in the video, the rising water vapor ignores the principles of buoyancy and airflow, and instead of spreading upwards, it abnormally gathers towards the center.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06797", "filename": "1b3bc1d832b1261e5c328eab84c1f429666bda56984dcf13998a08b5e394cfd7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06798", "filename": "1b3bc1d832b1261e5c328eab84c1f429666bda56984dcf13998a08b5e394cfd7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (from 1.6s to 8s in the video, the steam produced by the boiling liquid does not rise in wispy strands, but instead, contrary to the principle of thermal convection, it abnormally gathers towards the center.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06799", "filename": "1b7c3914e79b3fff16e0b73f7abbcbb06b357bf9d7c1b39c24ec346499c2edc0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Physical behavior (the entire video light source shines into the room through the window, but the shadows of the table and chairs are all pointing towards the window, which does not conform to the principle that light travels in a straight line).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_06800", "filename": "1b7c3914e79b3fff16e0b73f7abbcbb06b357bf9d7c1b39c24ec346499c2edc0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Light sweeps across a framed window from left to right and projects onto the ground; however, as the light moves, the shape and position of the window frame's shadow remain fixed.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06801", "filename": "1b7c3914e79b3fff16e0b73f7abbcbb06b357bf9d7c1b39c24ec346499c2edc0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06802", "filename": "1b7c3914e79b3fff16e0b73f7abbcbb06b357bf9d7c1b39c24ec346499c2edc0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Continuous time (smoke suddenly appears on the right side of the screen without any reasonable cause at 0.4 seconds, and the light shining through the window suddenly disappears at 4.3 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06803", "filename": "44f504299ad74e2f5c852890c93f90dc08dec86fdeed96cac4f4234e198da18f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06804", "filename": "44f504299ad74e2f5c852890c93f90dc08dec86fdeed96cac4f4234e198da18f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect (after the white object is bent by the hydraulic press, the volume of the white object should shrink, but in the video, the white object suddenly expands into a fluffy, wrapped shape, which is completely inconsistent with the physical process of the hydraulic press continuously applying pressure. In addition, the white object instantly becomes completely crushed and explodes in all directions. The normal compression transition process is missing, and there are obvious jumps and logical contradictions in the deformation process of the object.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06805", "filename": "45a06c414324da336e7e6bba58efb2c24c46eefe3dc7b1de540c98f480585a8b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (the transparent object in the upper left corner of the video disappears out of thin air between 0s and 0.3s, the object in the upper left corner moves to the right without any external force at 0.2s, and then moves to the upper left without any external force at 2.9s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06806", "filename": "45a06c414324da336e7e6bba58efb2c24c46eefe3dc7b1de540c98f480585a8b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the entire video is clearly divided into two areas with completely different tones and brightness, with the left side being a light-colored lit area and the right side being a dark shadow area, the transition is abrupt and does not conform to the gradual logic of real light and shadow).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_06807", "filename": "45a06c414324da336e7e6bba58efb2c24c46eefe3dc7b1de540c98f480585a8b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (without changing the lighting conditions, the shadow angles of the objects on the right and left sides of the image are different, making it look like two spliced images).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_06808", "filename": "45a06c414324da336e7e6bba58efb2c24c46eefe3dc7b1de540c98f480585a8b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the sealed transparent bottle disappears out of thin air between 2.9s and 3.9s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06809", "filename": "45a41e070bb7bef7f24dab1d6af33c06af44351e23bbbaf39be90c2cac7defb6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06810", "filename": "45a41e070bb7bef7f24dab1d6af33c06af44351e23bbbaf39be90c2cac7defb6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (Under the influence of airflow, the flag and clouds should be moving in the same direction, but in the entire video, the clouds are moving to the left, while the flag is moving to the right).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06811", "filename": "45a41e070bb7bef7f24dab1d6af33c06af44351e23bbbaf39be90c2cac7defb6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.8s, a car on the left side of the road leaves the road and drives away, and at 4.4s, a vehicle on the road suddenly disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06812", "filename": "45a41e070bb7bef7f24dab1d6af33c06af44351e23bbbaf39be90c2cac7defb6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06813", "filename": "45c0dae4f5ef70fc78f0d10d9bc553e09830952108b454cdaa1062e2c709afa7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is continuous (the water mist is generated by a water gun throughout the video. The water gun does not spray the groove on the right side of the car body, but water mist keeps coming out of the groove. At 1.3s, the hand grip does not change, but the yellow color of the water gun below the hand suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06814", "filename": "45c0dae4f5ef70fc78f0d10d9bc553e09830952108b454cdaa1062e2c709afa7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.5s, the position of the hand holding the water gun did not change, but the tail of the water gun suddenly became longer).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06815", "filename": "45c0dae4f5ef70fc78f0d10d9bc553e09830952108b454cdaa1062e2c709afa7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.7s, the hand grip on the water gun did not change, but the water gun part below the hand disappeared into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06820", "filename": "46d9bc583dac29485aec819dd400d37292c55a3573a848622321b6ef9b013b4b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect relationship (when real paint splashes, it forms droplets of different sizes with natural edges and splash trajectories, but the pink paint in the entire video screen presents an overly regular sheet-like distribution, lacking the randomness and sense of layering of dynamic splashes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06822", "filename": "46d9bc583dac29485aec819dd400d37292c55a3573a848622321b6ef9b013b4b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the blue and pink liquid droplets in the entire video float upwards without any force, which does not conform to the laws of gravity; at 1.3s, a large amount of pink liquid bursts out of thin air below the brown object).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06824", "filename": "46fb0e5a2189eb602527c638f5bad9e1eed163ec8f1d5c32276e9123cc430f5d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect (the water droplets emerging from the pipe should form a smooth arc under the influence of water surface tension, but the water droplets produced at the pipe opening in the video are blurry and distorted in shape, lacking both the transparency of real water droplets and the smooth arc formed by liquid surface tension).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06825", "filename": "46fb0e5a2189eb602527c638f5bad9e1eed163ec8f1d5c32276e9123cc430f5d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual intuition is off (the water droplets coming out of the pipe in the entire video are too smooth, and when real water drips from wood, it will show natural arcs and changes in thickness due to gravity and surface tension, while the water flow in the picture is too straight and stiff, like a piece of stretched transparent plastic, lacking the softness and dynamic fluctuation of liquid).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06826", "filename": "47cace0577315eaf805c173da1a60d130085b0f29b7e8fed11c7d5037bc0ea74_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (in the entire video, the water container emits mist through the nozzle, but the mist keeps coming out of the bottle itself, which violates the principle of impermeability of solids).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06827", "filename": "47cace0577315eaf805c173da1a60d130085b0f29b7e8fed11c7d5037bc0ea74_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.1s, the ring on the character's left ring finger suddenly disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06828", "filename": "47cace0577315eaf805c173da1a60d130085b0f29b7e8fed11c7d5037bc0ea74_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.3s, the ring on the character's left hand disappears out of thin air; at 1.3s, the upper part of the intact water container suddenly deforms, creating a gap, and the red vent suddenly deforms).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06829", "filename": "47d15058e1a101c7f7ce0d9f69c871efc2aaff773bb464bb9ec0d42cd240a5ed_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Cause and effect (although the ice appears transparent throughout the video, its shape and texture are very unnatural. Real ice has natural cracks and irregularly distributed air bubbles, while the texture of the ice in the video is more like glass or plastic, lacking the transparency and internal ice crystal details of real ice).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06830", "filename": "47d15058e1a101c7f7ce0d9f69c871efc2aaff773bb464bb9ec0d42cd240a5ed_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous (the transparency of the ice cube and the distribution of the bubbles inside are inconsistent in different frames, sometimes looking like glass and sometimes like plastic, lacking the constant texture of real ice).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06831", "filename": "47d15058e1a101c7f7ce0d9f69c871efc2aaff773bb464bb9ec0d42cd240a5ed_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the contact boundary between the ice and the water surface lacks realistic liquid tension and refraction effects, making it look more like a translucent solid being placed directly inside a container rather than floating in water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06832", "filename": "48f143ea6f444760886dd863a0b1245b8476be66596ca740bccf5ef5ec8ae8fc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Cause and effect (the liquid in the teapot is constantly being poured into the cup throughout the video, so the liquid in the teapot should decrease, but there is no obvious change in the liquid in the teapot in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06833", "filename": "0bf75496e65721b8b42f0a13873d4d414aa21493feb8cc2ca8ee176572da760c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is inconsistent (in the beginning of the video, the shark is in the deep sea, but at 5.3 seconds, the splashing water from the shark's tail appears to be on the surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06834", "filename": "0bf75496e65721b8b42f0a13873d4d414aa21493feb8cc2ca8ee176572da760c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.1 seconds, the same shark suddenly has two heads).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_06835", "filename": "0c0cf0b446e848f7ad01d8487e5e5db45fbd0a5cf227def2ddd030b457d480a3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (the bowl itself has weight, and under the action of the hydraulic press, the fragments of the bowl should scatter in all directions, but in the video from 1.5s to 4.4s, the fragments on the left side appear to be dancing in the wind).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06836", "filename": "0c0cf0b446e848f7ad01d8487e5e5db45fbd0a5cf227def2ddd030b457d480a3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The time sequence is not continuous (as a brittle material, the bowl should crack and break the moment it comes into contact with the hydraulic press, but the video shows a delayed deformation process of \"maintaining integrity first and then breaking later,\" which is inconsistent with the principles of material mechanics and contradicts the physical process of the hydraulic press applying pressure).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06837", "filename": "0c0cf0b446e848f7ad01d8487e5e5db45fbd0a5cf227def2ddd030b457d480a3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time sequence is continuous (at 1.3s, after the bowl shatters, the two upper fragments remain intact, while the other fragments have cracked. This completely contradicts the principle of \"synchronous stress transmission and synchronous failure\" when brittle materials break).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06838", "filename": "0c0cf0b446e848f7ad01d8487e5e5db45fbd0a5cf227def2ddd030b457d480a3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the bowl, made of brittle material, only shows cracks at 1.9 seconds, rather than exploding instantly under pressure. This is completely inconsistent with the mechanical properties of brittle materials, which are expected to break instantly upon stress concentration).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06839", "filename": "0c4c9cdd4428b3d954880b9a03a3b9d9b36e0a0f8c3d7e1a0f7c4b3f0238d390_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (based on the law that light travels in straight lines, the position of the rainbow in the video has changed, but the reflection in the water remains in the same position).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06840", "filename": "0c4c9cdd4428b3d954880b9a03a3b9d9b36e0a0f8c3d7e1a0f7c4b3f0238d390_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall impression (the \"water flow\" in the entire video lacks the texture and shape of real water, and is more like the fluffy and diffused state of clouds and mist, and the continuous and heavy visual characteristics of waterfall water flow).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06841", "filename": "0c4c9cdd4428b3d954880b9a03a3b9d9b36e0a0f8c3d7e1a0f7c4b3f0238d390_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (the water splash produced when the waterfall falls is too small, which is completely inconsistent with the obvious water splash and splashing effect that should be formed when a body of water falls from a height and hits the water surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06842", "filename": "0c4c9cdd4428b3d954880b9a03a3b9d9b36e0a0f8c3d7e1a0f7c4b3f0238d390_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: According to the basic physical rules of gravity, waterfall water should show a clear downward flow trend, but the upper part of the waterfall in the video does not have any sense of downward flow, which completely violates the logic of natural fluid movement.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06843", "filename": "0c6a76538bfbb9d00de0fd03f196b86af22d0de974d9d8e6ea60f7584bf08222_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is that the timing is continuous (at 1.4s, the middle part of the fire extends to the right; in reality, the fire would not suddenly extend outwards if no explosion had occurred).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06844", "filename": "0c6a76538bfbb9d00de0fd03f196b86af22d0de974d9d8e6ea60f7584bf08222_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.4s, a circular object suddenly appears in the middle of the flame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06845", "filename": "0c6a76538bfbb9d00de0fd03f196b86af22d0de974d9d8e6ea60f7584bf08222_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (an object that was standing still suddenly stands up out of thin air at 2.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06849", "filename": "0c648c1adf3ee2f36570c92045d698474a5e53f60956907a66f9b5f3939e0bc7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Based on the principle of light refraction, the reflection of objects on the shore in the water will change in size and shape due to the refraction of light, and will not maintain a proportional size relationship with the real object).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06850", "filename": "0c648c1adf3ee2f36570c92045d698474a5e53f60956907a66f9b5f3939e0bc7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Cause and Effect (As a celestial body, the sun's movement follows stable celestial motion laws and would not exhibit an unnatural state of \"suddenly turning black from the middle.\" This visual representation completely violates the physical laws governing the sun's movement and the continuity of natural phenomena.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06851", "filename": "0c648c1adf3ee2f36570c92045d698474a5e53f60956907a66f9b5f3939e0bc7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06852", "filename": "0c6389e0e6822f8739e1698dec8afaf333495ce25d733cfc1354981478f17dae_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.7 seconds, a vertical piece of tape suddenly appears at the end of the topmost bottle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06853", "filename": "0c2956428d4a6797a892a9ad09e73d4a594a5c5ce779d3c2474743898e2fabbf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (According to the momentum theorem, the thin mud on the left should overflow when squeezed by the slightly drier mud on the right, but this did not happen in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06854", "filename": "0c2956428d4a6797a892a9ad09e73d4a594a5c5ce779d3c2474743898e2fabbf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image shows an anomaly: the time sequence is continuous (at 2.8 seconds, the small black portion of the mud suddenly undergoes irregular color changes).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06855", "filename": "0cbde1d199113216e08006c0ca5a3306eb652763fd14a0465745e53486392123_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (in the opening scene, the character walks forward but suddenly starts walking backward without turning around at 4.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06856", "filename": "0cbde1d199113216e08006c0ca5a3306eb652763fd14a0465745e53486392123_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video content: Physical behavior (at 2s, the light in the video passes directly through the human body, which does not conform to the principle that light travels in a straight line).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06857", "filename": "0cbde1d199113216e08006c0ca5a3306eb652763fd14a0465745e53486392123_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (when walking towards sunlight, the light shines directly on the body, and the shadow only gets longer and longer instead of disappearing, which violates the principle that light travels in straight lines).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06858", "filename": "0cbde1d199113216e08006c0ca5a3306eb652763fd14a0465745e53486392123_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the movement is too smooth (the human body movements in the entire video are not like real footage and lack the pauses and jolts that should be present in real life).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06859", "filename": "0cedca3800c7a51d98f135750e265ed499bf36a5c80eb9ef1672c331f6786506_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06860", "filename": "0cedca3800c7a51d98f135750e265ed499bf36a5c80eb9ef1672c331f6786506_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the trees in the video appear grainy, as if composed of countless particles, which is completely inconsistent with the texture and feel of real trees. Real trees in videos should show continuous leaf texture and natural visual layers.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06861", "filename": "0cedca3800c7a51d98f135750e265ed499bf36a5c80eb9ef1672c331f6786506_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06862", "filename": "0cf241a42970b86582ab80e90e1cbc5a742ed6d3331f06457490a45a7267409b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.7 seconds, the white smoke in the video suddenly turns black without a natural gradation or transition, and there is a clear explosion scene, but the debris in the fire is not blown apart, and the broken screen on the ground remains unchanged. This is completely inconsistent with the physical effect of a real explosion, where \"shock waves will impact and propel objects and destroy surrounding objects\").", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06865", "filename": "13fb3c0dadd2382d452660c957886cefa86dd840b9f5db6ef0a1de529af93c02_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.9s, the left pinky finger suddenly passes through the right middle finger; at 2.6s, the top of the transparent box suddenly deforms; at 2.9s, the left pinky finger suddenly deforms; at 4.2s, the upper part of the transparent box suddenly deforms, and the right finger passes through the left pinky finger).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06866", "filename": "13fb3c0dadd2382d452660c957886cefa86dd840b9f5db6ef0a1de529af93c02_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The duration is continuous (0s-0.6s, the pink and yellow particles in the transparent box are distorted and deformed, and then return to normal after 0.6s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06867", "filename": "13fb3c0dadd2382d452660c957886cefa86dd840b9f5db6ef0a1de529af93c02_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the upper left corner of the transparent box twists and deforms even though it is not under any force between 0.9s and 3.1s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06868", "filename": "13fb3c0dadd2382d452660c957886cefa86dd840b9f5db6ef0a1de529af93c02_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.8s, the shape of the pink and yellow particles in the transparent box suddenly changes, and their number suddenly decreases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06875", "filename": "14f6f91b70dd5f7754b039926613830f876d8cfbf089dc33244a52f7d5572331_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1.2s, a person suddenly appears out of nowhere on the roadside, at 1.9s, the figures on the roadside suddenly become chaotic, and at 2.1s, a person suddenly disappears out of nowhere on the roadside).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06876", "filename": "14f6f91b70dd5f7754b039926613830f876d8cfbf089dc33244a52f7d5572331_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causal inertia (1.9s-5.8s: The Baroque building on the left side of the screen is covered by a large area of unnatural red light. This red color is not normal night scene lighting, but more like post-processing, which is too exaggerated).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06877", "filename": "14f6f91b70dd5f7754b039926613830f876d8cfbf089dc33244a52f7d5572331_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (from 3.7s to 4.2s, a car in the right lane suddenly splits and suddenly moves to the right-hand sidewalk).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06878", "filename": "14f6f91b70dd5f7754b039926613830f876d8cfbf089dc33244a52f7d5572331_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.4 seconds, a red and green building suddenly appears out of nowhere in the distance).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06882", "filename": "15ccb4fca0a90a728f61b932559364ff9f0d065ece0ae67110c53b08a76a883a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the ripples on the lake caused by the movement of the small boat are too neat and smooth, and the ripples move with the boat, making them too harsh).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06883", "filename": "15ccb4fca0a90a728f61b932559364ff9f0d065ece0ae67110c53b08a76a883a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual inconsistency (the wake of the boat in the entire video is too regular and lacks obvious white splashes, making it more like a dynamic effect simulated by post-production compositing or static images, which does not match the dynamic water flow of a real pontoon boat moving).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06884", "filename": "15ccb4fca0a90a728f61b932559364ff9f0d065ece0ae67110c53b08a76a883a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Cause and effect (the boat in the video is constantly generating a wake, and the water surface near the wake should change due to the wake and splash, but the water surface at the wake and splash area in the footage remains stable and unaffected).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06885", "filename": "15fc0ae1544e982a134aa3f64402c2c3eb0ec79f741b576f41f698d67f8a0a3c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Cause and Effect (The liquid surface is in a flowing state throughout the video. Bubbles in the liquid should float due to the liquid flow, but the bubbles in the video are in a calm state.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06886", "filename": "15fc0ae1544e982a134aa3f64402c2c3eb0ec79f741b576f41f698d67f8a0a3c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At the beginning of the video, the blue textures on the left side of the screen were in a continuous flowing vortex shape, but these textures suddenly turned into a cell-like mesh structure, and the originally continuous fluid textures underwent a broken and reorganized process).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06887", "filename": "15fc0ae1544e982a134aa3f64402c2c3eb0ec79f741b576f41f698d67f8a0a3c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (between 2.9s and 4.6s, a bubble-like object suddenly appears on the stable liquid surface in the video and keeps getting bigger).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06888", "filename": "15fc0ae1544e982a134aa3f64402c2c3eb0ec79f741b576f41f698d67f8a0a3c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (the flow of the yellow liquid on the left side of the video is not like that of a viscous liquid, but more like drifting smoke; the flow of the liquid on the right side is as smooth and even as silk, neither of which conforms to the flow pattern of a viscous liquid).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06893", "filename": "cf5088fccd4949eb42ce676ccc218c6e8cc5032a8a5f9c4cb293b9fb9bf60588_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 5.6s, the burnt paper scraps on the ground suddenly disappear and decrease).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06894", "filename": "cf5088fccd4949eb42ce676ccc218c6e8cc5032a8a5f9c4cb293b9fb9bf60588_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (at 1.6s, the burnt debris on the ground suddenly catches fire) (at 4.5s, the bottom of the cardboard box appears twisted and deformed)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06895", "filename": "cf5088fccd4949eb42ce676ccc218c6e8cc5032a8a5f9c4cb293b9fb9bf60588_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.7s, the bottom of the cardboard is not burning, but many burnt ashes appear out of nowhere) (at 6.1s, the burning paper scraps suddenly turn into wood chips).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06896", "filename": "cfb13c063c77c6b0d5bd8f6f0947ab08def54bd485226e25762b261b9dd64617_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.2s, the white iron balls merge together) (at 5s, the second cube composed of white iron balls disappears into thin air)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06897", "filename": "cfb13c063c77c6b0d5bd8f6f0947ab08def54bd485226e25762b261b9dd64617_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06898", "filename": "cfb13c063c77c6b0d5bd8f6f0947ab08def54bd485226e25762b261b9dd64617_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 5.4 seconds, the small ball on the white cube disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06899", "filename": "cfd96a8199e34632598cf7f279d768e5170f9df666d228d597eeedd9315c1299_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 0.3s, the rising steam in the cup is suddenly cut off and disappears into thin air)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06900", "filename": "cfd96a8199e34632598cf7f279d768e5170f9df666d228d597eeedd9315c1299_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 0.9s, white steam suddenly comes out from the middle handle of the cup, but there is no hot water on the table).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06901", "filename": "cfd96a8199e34632598cf7f279d768e5170f9df666d228d597eeedd9315c1299_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06902", "filename": "d000ce114e0de1a775c93f92fdd9c2eeb3ed54419c72cfe7f20a206f5d3f32d5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06903", "filename": "d000ce114e0de1a775c93f92fdd9c2eeb3ed54419c72cfe7f20a206f5d3f32d5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the flames reflected on the tiles remain stationary throughout the entire video, without any movement, which does not conform to the principles of gas flow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06904", "filename": "d000ce114e0de1a775c93f92fdd9c2eeb3ed54419c72cfe7f20a206f5d3f32d5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06905", "filename": "d000ce114e0de1a775c93f92fdd9c2eeb3ed54419c72cfe7f20a206f5d3f32d5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The video flickers and is distorted at 0.7s (no bubbles appear on the surface when the water boils at 2.3s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06910", "filename": "d1c45706b98c24104c3474841ef30bc4c926773f721e03c260cfd4d1e308e5c2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the ice at the bottom of the cup is melting rapidly throughout the video, but the water in the cup remains unchanged and the water level does not rise).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06911", "filename": "d1c45706b98c24104c3474841ef30bc4c926773f721e03c260cfd4d1e308e5c2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06912", "filename": "d2ab516a0d5ee6e9f25db885dc74d2457c8461eaff7ae9cfac314abfe5fc33fd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is continuous (the bullet fired at 0.6s disappears into thin air) (a bullet appears out of thin air below the muzzle at 1.1s) (two bullets appear out of thin air at 2s)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06913", "filename": "d2ab516a0d5ee6e9f25db885dc74d2457c8461eaff7ae9cfac314abfe5fc33fd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (at 3.8 seconds, after the shot is fired, three bullets appear out of thin air above the gun barrel).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06914", "filename": "d2ab516a0d5ee6e9f25db885dc74d2457c8461eaff7ae9cfac314abfe5fc33fd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The timing is continuous (after firing at 1.6s, another bullet appears out of nowhere in front of the barrel) (At 4.9s, no bullet is fired from the barrel during the second firing, but two bullets appear out of nowhere above the barrel)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06915", "filename": "d2af3ce7683ff1c5e365dd43c2fc05c27e9c40e53369a9ed096c2729c97fef5d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous (at 3.2s, the fog that was moving to the left suddenly changes to moving to the right, and the transition process in between is missing).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06916", "filename": "d2af3ce7683ff1c5e365dd43c2fc05c27e9c40e53369a9ed096c2729c97fef5d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The video flickers and the rope twists and deforms at 4.7 seconds.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06917", "filename": "d2af3ce7683ff1c5e365dd43c2fc05c27e9c40e53369a9ed096c2729c97fef5d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06922", "filename": "54661d3b585a6579fedde7183767526558bb0e1d3ec6c4fd6cee8fa95d40e9dd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (two cherry tomatoes merge into one at both 2s and 3.2s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06923", "filename": "54661d3b585a6579fedde7183767526558bb0e1d3ec6c4fd6cee8fa95d40e9dd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (4.2s: tomato and pepper merge into one, tomato size increases).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06924", "filename": "55091e6afb9a198667ccd8ac27a4aaa7a25892e684579c6b950651ca83fb373a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the lines in the image move with the compass as a whole, and it is always impossible to draw a closed, complete circle around the fixed center).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06925", "filename": "55091e6afb9a198667ccd8ac27a4aaa7a25892e684579c6b950651ca83fb373a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (during the process of drawing a circle with a compass from 1.7s to 5.8s, the trajectory changed from a standard circle to an ellipse).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06926", "filename": "55091e6afb9a198667ccd8ac27a4aaa7a25892e684579c6b950651ca83fb373a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (4.6s-8s, the compass leg that only serves a fixed function begins to move and ink appears, while the other leg does not move along the original trajectory)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06927", "filename": "56118cf35e889f5ac553d7c27e9119e24842b4d88bad3ce32c9cc898451fd011_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0.2s) Fish scales suddenly disappear and become smooth.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06928", "filename": "56118cf35e889f5ac553d7c27e9119e24842b4d88bad3ce32c9cc898451fd011_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06929", "filename": "56118cf35e889f5ac553d7c27e9119e24842b4d88bad3ce32c9cc898451fd011_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Continuous timing (the knife blade suddenly narrows at 0.3s); Physical behavior (the knife is removed from the water at 6.3s-8s, only a small amount of water droplets are stirred up, and the water surface ripples slightly without producing violent waves; the gloves are dry and do not drip after being immersed in water).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06932", "filename": "56336ab0998eddb699c62dc0ef63f688868347935bc01980530b96525ef93f4b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (1.1s-5s: a stationary rocking horse moves on its own without any force)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06933", "filename": "57032cba6c7092a048c7faec980f0cb86d90e42ca300b8b3a5692521578f0ccf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (when the grip strengthener is squeezed, its metal spring does not undergo any compression deformation and remains in its original state without participating in the grip strengthener's pressing process).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06934", "filename": "57032cba6c7092a048c7faec980f0cb86d90e42ca300b8b3a5692521578f0ccf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (although the spring of the hand gripper is compressed, it does not rebound naturally after the hand is released, but jumps directly back to the initial position)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06935", "filename": "57032cba6c7092a048c7faec980f0cb86d90e42ca300b8b3a5692521578f0ccf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06936", "filename": "57093a17989eab683bd49c8b6ae97d3a8baf9767664f20034aafb72beef809e8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (when sharpening a pencil with a pencil sharpener, the amount of pencil shavings remains constant and does not increase with the cutting action).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06937", "filename": "57093a17989eab683bd49c8b6ae97d3a8baf9767664f20034aafb72beef809e8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal behavior: Physical behavior (pencil shavings are ejected and the pencil is sharpened even though it is not inserted into the cutting hole of the pencil sharpener; shavings fly off automatically without any force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06938", "filename": "58777c439cd8f5060d58356e064b4794dd7ca58e12a2d82253339fa65792228d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the background of the screen continues to flicker and jump).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06939", "filename": "58777c439cd8f5060d58356e064b4794dd7ca58e12a2d82253339fa65792228d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time frame is inconsistent (0.3s-5.8s) between the trees themselves and their reflections in the water.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06940", "filename": "58777c439cd8f5060d58356e064b4794dd7ca58e12a2d82253339fa65792228d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the right side of the lake is swaying, while the left side remains still).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06941", "filename": "58777c439cd8f5060d58356e064b4794dd7ca58e12a2d82253339fa65792228d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (0.1s the bird suddenly disappears; 1.1s-8s a large number of leaves suddenly fall from the sky, but only a few are on the lake surface).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06942", "filename": "60234bc3d4c6a274add900fbb5bd710ce295ddfda0e2c8989236a3bcb0bbdc86_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (0.2s the magnetic beads pass through the hand; 2.2s the magnetic beads move autonomously and become aligned; 3.1s when two identical triangular magnetic beads are placed together, they merge into one; 4.5s when the magnetic beads are picked up, the two strings of beads separate again, but the lower layer of magnetic beads is missing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06943", "filename": "60234bc3d4c6a274add900fbb5bd710ce295ddfda0e2c8989236a3bcb0bbdc86_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (the object suddenly straightens from a curved shape at 2.1 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06944", "filename": "63228e5fc0ad7e9adf2a8ef0ff9f8bdc92cd35c8fcf198c870f937f58f925b6b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06945", "filename": "63228e5fc0ad7e9adf2a8ef0ff9f8bdc92cd35c8fcf198c870f937f58f925b6b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the bubbles generated by the boiling liquid in the pot suddenly disappear at 2s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06946", "filename": "63228e5fc0ad7e9adf2a8ef0ff9f8bdc92cd35c8fcf198c870f937f58f925b6b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (0.4s, an extra spoon handle appears; 2.2s, the bubbles in the pot turn into solid glass).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06947", "filename": "63627b8bc93aeb91eb9dee1a301cc1fb7e44ba8ddc7c78c4b0d6eff60ff66713_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Physical behavior (when a blue laser flashlight shines at high altitude, the infrared rays emitted are not aligned with the direction of the flashlight).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06948", "filename": "63627b8bc93aeb91eb9dee1a301cc1fb7e44ba8ddc7c78c4b0d6eff60ff66713_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the outline of the flashlight beam is flashing and jumping rapidly).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06949", "filename": "63627b8bc93aeb91eb9dee1a301cc1fb7e44ba8ddc7c78c4b0d6eff60ff66713_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Physical behavior (0.5s-5s) The light emitted by the flashlight does not travel in a straight line at the end, but instead bends upward in an arc like a soft ribbon; the beam of a flashlight should become more diffused and fainter as it moves away, but this blue light maintains the same brightness and clear boundaries throughout.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06950", "filename": "63627b8bc93aeb91eb9dee1a301cc1fb7e44ba8ddc7c78c4b0d6eff60ff66713_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (The flashlight beam deviates from the normal beam shape, twisting and bending dramatically like a soft and highly elastic blue fluid strip).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06951", "filename": "64210ee877c0e1f12bf16be03baeb4264222967678109d8cdd4ee4943669818d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (the small cake undergoes abrupt changes during baking - from square to ellipse in 0.5s, expands and shrinks into a small circle in 2.8s, and then instantly returns to its original shape in 5s, with no natural transition throughout).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06952", "filename": "ed59b9bd047ba54ccf050699a708824f7eb805e1491780cf7acfa68599ffade8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.8s in the video, the image suddenly becomes blurry and ghosting occurs).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06953", "filename": "ed59b9bd047ba54ccf050699a708824f7eb805e1491780cf7acfa68599ffade8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06954", "filename": "ed59b9bd047ba54ccf050699a708824f7eb805e1491780cf7acfa68599ffade8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous flickering (the entire video shows noticeable flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06955", "filename": "eda610d4b7810da410476b440e02db2e5081f1c818efd62b16b791d060f08ac0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (throughout the video, water flowing from the pipe bounces off the ground upon contact, with no water remaining on the surface); Temporal continuity (the ground in the video exhibits flickering artifacts).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06956", "filename": "eda610d4b7810da410476b440e02db2e5081f1c818efd62b16b791d060f08ac0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (water keeps flowing out of the bottle throughout the entire video, but the water level inside the bottle does not change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06957", "filename": "eda610d4b7810da410476b440e02db2e5081f1c818efd62b16b791d060f08ac0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 2.6s in the video, the water on the ground in the footage increases out of nowhere without the camera angle changing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06958", "filename": "eda610d4b7810da410476b440e02db2e5081f1c818efd62b16b791d060f08ac0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (Throughout the video, a large amount of yellow liquid flows out of the bottle, but the amount of water flowing out of the bottle is not proportional to the amount of water spraying out of the bottle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06961", "filename": "edb6ba5b92ba5884c233f0f17624258687ba693eb4802d38e1f1790d12112751_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06963", "filename": "edfb4670ea15fd29c3867ecbb167d11ce6cc7df32acc3f20a1cd8c7aa1fa4c2c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous flickering (obvious flickering occurs throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06964", "filename": "edfb4670ea15fd29c3867ecbb167d11ce6cc7df32acc3f20a1cd8c7aa1fa4c2c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (in the entire video, the shape of the flames appears discontinuous as they rise, the flames are too regular and lack a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06965", "filename": "edfb4670ea15fd29c3867ecbb167d11ce6cc7df32acc3f20a1cd8c7aa1fa4c2c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the shape of a real flame is affected by airflow, resulting in irregular swaying and flickering, and the color changes naturally with temperature. However, the flame in the image is too smooth, the shape is deliberate, and it lacks the dynamic randomness and color transitions of real combustion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06966", "filename": "edfb4670ea15fd29c3867ecbb167d11ce6cc7df32acc3f20a1cd8c7aa1fa4c2c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Temporal continuity is abnormal (at 3.9s in the video, sparks suddenly appear out of thin air on the right side of the trees in the frame without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06967", "filename": "ee0df3c166f925fc8ca1c1a955497bec4b34830f8d80bcb31723455ae2cc2bdb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (Throughout the entire video, the ring on the person's finger in the image shows a noticeable flickering flaw).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06968", "filename": "ee0df3c166f925fc8ca1c1a955497bec4b34830f8d80bcb31723455ae2cc2bdb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity error (at 0.1s in the video, the ring suddenly flickers, and at 1.7s, the ring in the frame reflects light out of thin air without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06969", "filename": "ee0df3c166f925fc8ca1c1a955497bec4b34830f8d80bcb31723455ae2cc2bdb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06970", "filename": "ee0df3c166f925fc8ca1c1a955497bec4b34830f8d80bcb31723455ae2cc2bdb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Temporal continuity is abnormal (at 2s in the video, the ring in the video inexplicably reflects light without being subjected to any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06971", "filename": "ee7f04e7294c254b66ad29a072314288fc1f48b1be91b5ccc3f6c1636540097d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (at 4.4s in the video, the object in the glass is crushed and then suddenly returns to its original shape).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06972", "filename": "ee7f04e7294c254b66ad29a072314288fc1f48b1be91b5ccc3f6c1636540097d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 2.6s in the video, a purple object appears out of nowhere in the lower right corner of the glass; from 4.1s to the end, the crushed object in the glass suddenly sprays out liquid without the camera changing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06973", "filename": "ee7f04e7294c254b66ad29a072314288fc1f48b1be91b5ccc3f6c1636540097d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06974", "filename": "ee7f04e7294c254b66ad29a072314288fc1f48b1be91b5ccc3f6c1636540097d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (at 5.1s in the video, small fragments crushed in the glass penetrate the glass directly, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06975", "filename": "ee8f53e2ee712efe3e3e1648218b4aa2cde297227aa15028df701e1436e51ed1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (when frying an egg, the egg white should gradually solidify from a liquid state, with slight shrinkage or burnt marks at the edges due to uneven heating, and the yolk should have a fine texture. However, the egg white and yolk in the image are too uniform in color and lack the sense of solidification).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06976", "filename": "ee8f53e2ee712efe3e3e1648218b4aa2cde297227aa15028df701e1436e51ed1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (at 4.6s in the video, the eggs in the pot suddenly increase in size without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06977", "filename": "ee8f53e2ee712efe3e3e1648218b4aa2cde297227aa15028df701e1436e51ed1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06978", "filename": "ee8f53e2ee712efe3e3e1648218b4aa2cde297227aa15028df701e1436e51ed1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (at 3.9s in the video, the protein in the pot appears to increase out of nowhere without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06979", "filename": "ee862cd098bbb403f1a4946f2fa64196aa72020091cfb019200c59818088bb96_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (between 0.6s and 1.6s in the video, white debris around the golf ball moves on its own without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06980", "filename": "ee862cd098bbb403f1a4946f2fa64196aa72020091cfb019200c59818088bb96_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 0.4s in the video, the golf ball is compressed on its own before the hydraulic press has even made contact with it).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06981", "filename": "eed6dddaa1218ae4685e5f4c17fd1908c5f0fe2dd210d77e8628e1a0e6cd176c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06982", "filename": "P28_113_134_32859922741ab9bb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "From 1.2 seconds to 2.9 seconds, the character takes a red object out of the bucket twice. During this process, the object is not triggered by any external force, its shape is distorted, and there is no physical action linkage such as kneading or bending to change its shape. There is a failure of the shape jump between the physical frames, which is completely disconnected from the physical characteristics of the object. From 3.4 seconds to 5 seconds, the red object held by the hand disappears suddenly out of thin air without any physical occlusion, removal, or release of the hand. After disappearing, it is not reproduced at 5 seconds. There is no transition process between the disappearance and blurring, which shows the distortion of the physical frame cancellation, which is disconnected from the body action and the physical logic of the scene.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06983", "filename": "P28_113_134_32859922741ab9bb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06984", "filename": "P28_113_139_540cee08a34eb97f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (0.7s-1.2s, scallion segments are cut with the side of the knife instead of the blade, the cutting action does not conform to physical logic; 6.7s-7.8s, a single scallion segment is spontaneously multiplied into three without triggering, the number of entities increases between frames).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06985", "filename": "P28_113_139_540cee08a34eb97f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0.6s: The knife in the character's left hand disappears out of thin air without any trigger, the entity vanishes without transition, and there is no linkage with the hand gripping action, exhibiting an inter-frame jump glitch. 0.5s: A sudden form distortion occurs without any trigger, with the green leaves and onions changing directly from their original form without any physical transition trajectory.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06986", "filename": "P30_101_96_7712bac6d6b3ef10_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (The soap undergoes a sudden, non-physical distortion without any external force applied; its shape changes abruptly without a gradual process.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06987", "filename": "P30_101_96_7712bac6d6b3ef10_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: (Normal foam disperses naturally and loosely after entering the water, slowly spreading evenly in all directions with the water flow. The bubbles gradually merge with the water and dissipate layer by layer. The edges fade gently and gradually, without concentrated accumulation or abrupt disappearance. Small bubbles will float slightly with the water flow and gradually break. The overall dispersion rhythm is slow and conforms to the laws of fluid dynamics.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_06988", "filename": "P30_101_155_1b0aa6d278a61699_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_06989", "filename": "P30_104_73_b7b375be4b1c1bc5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (1.8 seconds, the faucet opens automatically without being touched, the valve does not rotate smoothly, and the water flows out synchronously without pressure change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06990", "filename": "P30_104_84_3b254db2c08e998b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: The time is continuous (3.9s, the basket switches from the reverse side to the front side out of thin air without any trigger, and there is no rotation transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06991", "filename": "P30_104_84_3b254db2c08e998b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (2.8 seconds, the rag passes through the object out of thin air without triggering, breaking through the physical space barrier, without any physical transition trajectory. 5.6 seconds, the vegetable basket and faucet simultaneously sink into the contact surface without triggering, without any support surface depression or the object sinking)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_06992", "filename": "P30_104_84_3b254db2c08e998b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: The time is continuous (6.9s, the basket switches from the reverse side to the front side out of thin air without any trigger, and there is no rotation transition).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06993", "filename": "P30_104_88_3059c3a3f6579090_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The time sequence is continuous (0.1s, the lid has no physical contact with the water surface, water splashes up out of thin air, triggered by no contact impact, and the fluid feedback is completely disconnected from the physical action).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06994", "filename": "P30_104_117_448392e2c5e8cc8d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (the towel disappears without warning at 2.2s, reappears without warning at 2.4s, and the entity disappears and reappears in a short loop without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06995", "filename": "P30_104_136_bb9070f93f1559c4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (0.9s-1.9s: During the process of the hand taking the blue apron hanging on the door, the apron directly turns into a white cloth bag without any external force, without the physical gradual process of disassembly and fusion of the form; 1s: The two ends of the blue apron are hung on the hooks, but the apron itself has no corresponding support points, no force support logic, and floats in mid-air at the hooks.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_06996", "filename": "P30_104_136_bb9070f93f1559c4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Time continuity (2.2s: The towel has no physical gaps, its own deformation triggers, and it directly penetrates the hook, breaking through the rules of physical space occupation and volume obstruction. There is no compression of the shape of the penetration, no contour fitting transition, and there is physical inter-frame spatial penetration distortion.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06997", "filename": "P30_107_54_3026d02bd42bd4bf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (3.5s: the water penetrates the medium without any external force, and the cup is not broken. This violates the rules of solid-liquid barrier and force transmission. There is no penetrating form penetration and the cup body is deformed and transitioned. There is inter-frame spatial penetration distortion of the fluid).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06998", "filename": "P30_107_54_3026d02bd42bd4bf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (4.4s, the water penetrates the medium without any external force, and the cup is not broken, which violates the rules of solid-liquid barrier and force transmission. There is no penetrating form penetration and the cup body is deformed and transitioned, indicating that there is spatial penetration distortion between the fluid frames).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_06999", "filename": "P30_107_86_4efe6c9bedeb2444_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (3.4s, the lid is not cut, broken, deformed or otherwise triggered by external force, the number of corners is reduced from three to two, there is no physical gradual process of structural damage or corner falling off, which violates the law of force and the law of conservation of matter.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07000", "filename": "P30_107_86_4efe6c9bedeb2444_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene (3.9s: During the cleaning of the teapot, there is no external force triggering such as teapot displacement or hand adjustment operation. The cleaning part switches directly from the bottom to the top without the physical gradual process of teapot rotation trajectory or hand operation posture linkage. 2.2s: There are no triggering conditions such as valve opening or external force operation of the faucet. Water suddenly flows out of the outlet out of nowhere.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07001", "filename": "P30_107_96_e4fb6c0295cad84e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal (3.5s). The rag held in the left hand has no hand transfer, displacement trajectory, or right hand grasp posture as triggering conditions. It suddenly teleports across the hand and appears out of thin air in the right hand. There is no gradual process of spatial trajectory of rag movement and linkage with limb movement. There is spatial jump distortion between physical frames.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07002", "filename": "P30_107_141_135e6c245bb9c0a0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: In the continuous time (7.8s), the second to last right side of the object in the image suddenly cracks without any external force, cutting, impact or other triggering conditions. There is no physical gradual change process of crack extension and material damage. There is no deformation feedback of the force point linkage at the crack. There is structural damage and distortion between the frames, which violates Newton's first law (no change of state without external force) and the physical logic of solid material damage under force.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07003", "filename": "P30_107_141_135e6c245bb9c0a0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: 3.4s The box suddenly disappears without any external force, without any occlusion or fading process, and without any interactive feedback. 6.1s Two objects suddenly collapse in number without any external force, the two objects become one out of thin air, without merging, and there is no interactive feedback for occlusion.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07004", "filename": "P30_107_147_02ae01157d5a6933_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The screen display is abnormal: the time is continuous (3s). The plastic disc suddenly undergoes a shape distortion without external force. The groove flattens out of thin air without any force. During the reset transition process, there is no feedback from any linkage action.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07005", "filename": "P30_107_147_02ae01157d5a6933_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07006", "filename": "P30_107_147_02ae01157d5a6933_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (0.5s: faucet suddenly stops flowing water without external force, no valve core closing action, no water flow attenuation transition, and no linkage feedback. 0.6s-3.8s: box suddenly undergoes shape distortion without external force, the box body twists without force feedback, and there is no deformation transition trajectory.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07007", "filename": "P30_107_214_221a127e894ab1ce_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal; the time sequence is as follows: (3.6s) The faucet suddenly stops flowing without any external force, there is no valve core closing action, no water flow attenuation transition, and no linkage feedback. (1.4s-2.8s) The vegetables suddenly exhibit morphological distortion without any external force, the vegetable body twists without force feedback, and there is no deformation transition trajectory.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07008", "filename": "P30_107_262_f0c806a3a601fa8b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The time sequence is continuous (4.7 seconds). The bowl suddenly appears out of thin air without any external force, and there is no action or feedback when it is picked up or interacts with the video.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07009", "filename": "P30_107_262_f0c806a3a601fa8b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The screen is abnormal: the time is continuous (6.7s). The mushroom in the bowl suddenly flickers irregularly without any trigger, the brightness changes gradually, there is no interaction with the ambient light and shadow, and the flickering process is abrupt.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07010", "filename": "P30_107_265_6b9874c6dac9ac2d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The screen is malfunctioning; (The number of radish strips in the bowl suddenly increases without any external force, appearing out of thin air, without any external addition or any corresponding action feedback.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07011", "filename": "P30_107_265_6b9874c6dac9ac2d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous flashing (the radish strips in the bowl suddenly and continuously flash without any external trigger, without gradual brightness changes, without ambient light and shadow interaction, and without any action feedback.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07018", "filename": "399194e5849a94eae7d18dff77f6b1a8ad5ad38525f9d0b3dc2d19b4c11a874a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (In a real film, when a straw is inserted into a layered liquid, there is a noticeable misalignment at the interface between the two liquids due to light refraction. However, in the image, the straw does not show a natural refraction shift at the boundary between the yellow and transparent liquids; the line remains continuous.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07019", "filename": "399194e5849a94eae7d18dff77f6b1a8ad5ad38525f9d0b3dc2d19b4c11a874a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (In a real film, when a straw is inserted into a layered liquid, there is a noticeable misalignment at the interface between the two liquids due to light refraction. However, in the image, the straw does not exhibit this natural refraction shift at the boundary between the yellow and clear liquids; the line remains continuous.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07020", "filename": "399194e5849a94eae7d18dff77f6b1a8ad5ad38525f9d0b3dc2d19b4c11a874a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (At 0.9s, a large number of bubbles suddenly appear in the yellow liquid in the cup.) Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (When a real straw is inserted into a layered liquid, there will be a noticeable misalignment at the interface between the two liquids due to light refraction. However, in the image, the straw does not show a natural refraction shift at the boundary between the yellow and clear liquids; the line is continuous.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07021", "filename": "414803b81e6dacf906dfd75c207767ccead6bba8319548866767448b8485b2a7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal in several ways: The timing is inconsistent (the entire video shows flames burning on a piece of paper, but no burn marks spread across the paper). Physically, the paper burns without producing any smoke, whereas normally a large amount of smoke should be generated.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07022", "filename": "414803b81e6dacf906dfd75c207767ccead6bba8319548866767448b8485b2a7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: The timing is continuous (the entire video shows flames burning on a piece of paper, but no burn marks spread across the paper throughout). Physical behavior (the paper burns without producing any smoke, whereas normally a large amount of smoke should be produced. At 3.6 seconds, the paper suddenly tilts and stands upright without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07023", "filename": "414803b81e6dacf906dfd75c207767ccead6bba8319548866767448b8485b2a7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal in several ways: The timing is inconsistent (the entire video shows flames burning on a piece of paper, but no burn marks spread across the paper). Physically, the paper burns without producing any smoke, whereas normally a large amount of smoke should be generated.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07024", "filename": "414803b81e6dacf906dfd75c207767ccead6bba8319548866767448b8485b2a7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (at 2.7 seconds, smoke suddenly appears on the ground. Normally, smoke should originate from combustible materials, not appear out of thin air from the ground.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07025", "filename": "426536f2fb9ddc092dd21e3f9486ab7c433030028e665201e3c020633c9d35ad_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 2.4s, the liquid in the jar suddenly increases, and at 5s, it returns to normal.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07026", "filename": "426536f2fb9ddc092dd21e3f9486ab7c433030028e665201e3c020633c9d35ad_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time frame is continuous (0-5.9s, the liquid in the jar produces bubbles without any interference, and the amount of liquid gradually increases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07027", "filename": "426536f2fb9ddc092dd21e3f9486ab7c433030028e665201e3c020633c9d35ad_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (0-5s, the liquid in the container gradually decreases without any disturbance.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07028", "filename": "426536f2fb9ddc092dd21e3f9486ab7c433030028e665201e3c020633c9d35ad_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (0-4.3s, the liquid in the jar gradually increases and then decreases without any disturbance. At 4.3s, the liquid in the jar suddenly turns into a transparent crystalline solid.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07029", "filename": "428307c22384cce1580e9d75a66d25121e388b0f88d0ffb3930a018e464c30ae_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (2.25-5s, the metal rod and ball in the image twist and rotate without any external force, violating Newton's first law of motion.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07030", "filename": "428307c22384cce1580e9d75a66d25121e388b0f88d0ffb3930a018e464c30ae_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (In a realistic geometric structure, each metal rod should have a clear and stable connection to the nodes. However, in the image, some metal rods are misaligned or suspended from their nodes, failing to form a genuine load-bearing connection.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07031", "filename": "428307c22384cce1580e9d75a66d25121e388b0f88d0ffb3930a018e464c30ae_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (Although the overall texture is made to resemble metal, closer inspection reveals that the reflections and textures are repetitive and uniform, lacking the light and shadow variations that occur in the complex structure of real metal due to different angles, resulting in a strong mechanical feel.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07032", "filename": "428307c22384cce1580e9d75a66d25121e388b0f88d0ffb3930a018e464c30ae_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (A real reflection would be perfectly symmetrical with the structure above, but the reflection in the image is not only distorted, but also has additional structures that do not match the original.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07033", "filename": "0450533ed4273623f9723c58656e2a067d1fa556921289b471a35b77bf025887_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: The overall visual effect is off. (Real sunlight in a forest is formed by beams of light filtering through the leaves, creating a soft, gradual transition with the dust and moisture in the air. However, the light lines in this image are too sharp, and the mist below doesn't interact naturally with the beams of light.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07034", "filename": "0450533ed4273623f9723c58656e2a067d1fa556921289b471a35b77bf025887_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (A true lens flare's color and shape would strictly correspond to the sun's position. However, the blue-green halo on the left side of the image completely mismatches the sun's position on the right; the colors are intense and the shape is stiff, resembling a crudely superimposed color block rather than a genuine optical effect.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07035", "filename": "0450533ed4273623f9723c58656e2a067d1fa556921289b471a35b77bf025887_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (When the camera moves, the perspective changes, and beams of light passing through the gaps in the leaves appear, disappear, or change shape. The beams of light change with the camera movement and do not maintain a fixed line or shape, but in the video, the light passing through the leaves does not change at all as the camera moves.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07036", "filename": "0450533ed4273623f9723c58656e2a067d1fa556921289b471a35b77bf025887_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (When the camera moves, the perspective changes, and beams of light passing through gaps in the leaves appear, disappear, or change shape. The beams change with the camera's movement and do not maintain a fixed line or shape. However, in the video, the beams of light passing through the trees on the left remain unchanged; only the beams of light passing through the trees on the right change.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07037", "filename": "450909ea8c6ef802e64dfb3371a1f7a39e1df65cac0ac002ae512545e1694b35_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.2s, the crystals in the image suddenly disappear.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07038", "filename": "450909ea8c6ef802e64dfb3371a1f7a39e1df65cac0ac002ae512545e1694b35_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the crystal in the frame moves without any external force, violating Newton's First Law.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07039", "filename": "509566beafbd407bed6c3e6815058abbea59bf7e0c654f1c8cdf587912230621_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (Real flames burn upwards and have clear contact and dynamic consumption with the combustible material below. However, the connection between the flame and the combustible material in the image is blurry, lacking realistic combustion layers, appearing as a static pattern floating above the combustible material.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07040", "filename": "509566beafbd407bed6c3e6815058abbea59bf7e0c654f1c8cdf587912230621_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the flames burning on the combustible material produced no smoke. Real flames would cause noticeable light and heat deformation to the surrounding ground and firewood, and the firewood would be blackened and charred. However, the combustible material and ground in the video show no signs of being heated by the flames.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07041", "filename": "509566beafbd407bed6c3e6815058abbea59bf7e0c654f1c8cdf587912230621_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "A real campfire flame will have a dynamic, irregular, flickering shape, and the size and brightness of the flame will naturally vary in different locations. However, the flame lines in the video are too regular, and the flame shapes on the left and right sides even repeat, lacking the dynamic randomness of a real flame.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07042", "filename": "a2902b4454eef4dd5829aec7b6ed031d48dd5582d19ded229e16f7b3355c6d89_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal behavior: Physical behavior (the ice block, which was sitting still on the table, suddenly shook during the period of 2.4s-3.3s, and a large amount of water suddenly gushed out from the bottom of the ice block at 4.8s, but the volume of the ice block did not change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07043", "filename": "a3148ab980f80847edaced1a114c88c4aa4e5b06a9e76be22d35f6adcba85ce4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is distorted: the timing is inconsistent (the sun suddenly appears at 0.6s, clouds appear in the upper right corner of the video at 1.1s, and the light on the clouds suddenly dims without diminishing the sunlight at 4.2s); the overall realism is abnormal (the clouds in the video are too close to the ground, while in reality, the distance between clouds and the ground on a plain should be much greater).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07044", "filename": "a3148ab980f80847edaced1a114c88c4aa4e5b06a9e76be22d35f6adcba85ce4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video exhibits several anomalies: a continuous timeline (two horses suddenly appear in the frame at 0.5 seconds, repeatedly disappearing and reappearing during the running of the three small animals); and an overall lack of realism (the animals in the video run at extremely high speeds throughout the entire sequence).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07045", "filename": "a03347ef507a2cba84f532ff0e6fc9d1df2b326855bcd503e0735b76f53762f7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (during the 3.1s-3.6s interval, the induction cooker simply rests its foot on the kettle without applying any force, yet the kettle moves to the left); Time continuity (at 0.3s, all the numbers on the induction cooker change without being manually adjusted).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07046", "filename": "a03347ef507a2cba84f532ff0e6fc9d1df2b326855bcd503e0735b76f53762f7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall realism is abnormal (at 3.7s, the steam in the video suddenly increases, and the silhouette of a person projected by the kettle in the video is too clear, whereas it would be blurry in real life).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07047", "filename": "a03347ef507a2cba84f532ff0e6fc9d1df2b326855bcd503e0735b76f53762f7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 2.7s, the person is lifting the kettle by the lid, not by the handle); Time continuity (at 5.9s, one handle is missing); Overall realism is abnormal (in the video, steam is not only coming out of the spout but also from the body of the kettle, while in real life, steam would only come out of the spout or the gap next to the lid).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07048", "filename": "a8888e600276d178b7d25e3a16349d5527f0aa58f3bf6915ba2ac18a8858c097_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the video, water is simply placed on a table, and no bubble-generating substance is added, yet a large number of bubbles are appearing in the water).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07049", "filename": "a8888e600276d178b7d25e3a16349d5527f0aa58f3bf6915ba2ac18a8858c097_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07052", "filename": "a9979f0cb50e01fe6bbbceeace0410a1a5ed49396b724a1859d927b0f2355263_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall realism is abnormal (the debris from the explosion in the video is distributed too regularly; in real life, debris from an explosion should fly randomly in all directions); Physical behavior (in the video, the car explodes and produces a large amount of debris, yet it remains undamaged and continues to drive)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07055", "filename": "aa0b44f838c76f67c6e1f5c4fbec96e036c260afcbc92971bdbd183a99541cec_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video activity: Physical behavior (the light bulb in the fallen tube in the video moves slowly to the left without being affected by any external factors).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07056", "filename": "aa5bc75e97260521693b0520ca50f6e178c6e43bf82bcffa484af22c905e3772_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (in the same space, the upper and lower clouds move in opposite directions); overall realism is abnormal (the clouds in the video are too thick, and in the right half, the smoke on the ground and the dark clouds in the sky are connected, and the clouds are too close to the ground).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07057", "filename": "aa6ef9fb8c78e481a95ed5fca66973dad15d1c248efab9a385e66bb371a49c80_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (the egg is spherical instead of oval from the start to 1.7 seconds; after 2.7 seconds, both ends of the egg are pointed, whereas in real life an egg is pointed at one end and wider at the other).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07058", "filename": "aaad36a31a8f57231a5bfa4e6127cc6739ff60318bb93607dff1d78709d92b55_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the overall realism is abnormal (the shark in the video is moving vertically up and down in the air with its tail pointing upwards, and the shark moves from underwater to the surface of the water without using its tail to gain momentum).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07059", "filename": "aabc249d5f8e43462539ce96beded17dee39ed105bc6f7169c2c8fb0d9d63601_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall realism is abnormal (the flame on the left in the video is curved, but the flame on the right is straight); physical behavior (the candle shows no signs of melting while burning in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07060", "filename": "aabf4462d952f9329457507545c432670c2ee9d1df93fa5075a9e61d33aa5f6d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (the water droplets change color from blue to transparent and there are many regular grid-like lines in the water; the color of the ray in the water changes from black to reddish-brown); the overall realism is abnormal (the ray's tail should swing when it swims, and the tail of a real ray is thicker and shorter than that in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07061", "filename": "ab6a6606f5de742dca8e87affbf9294b4e132d3fa5b57bfdab9557424cc53e22_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (in real life, smoke only comes from chimneys, but in the video, smoke is also coming out of the train); Overall realism is abnormal (the smoke in the video is too dense and the color of the smoke is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07062", "filename": "P35_104_266_cd0c5c2341b0c4da_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (at 1.9 seconds, the towel pierces through the center of the plastic bowl, causing a clipping phenomenon).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07063", "filename": "P35_104_269_03941604ca082189_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (4.6s-5.6s, the pink lid suddenly turns into a pink bowl).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07064", "filename": "P35_104_280_2f352341a1d4a63b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: A sticker suddenly appears out of nowhere on the lid surface from 5.9s to 7.5s and is then torn off.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07065", "filename": "P35_104_499_3bd6c02b819a29ae_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the movement of the hand opening the can lid is too smooth, lacking the jerky, jarring feeling of the lid opening).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07066", "filename": "P35_104_691_ebf7a4e28908410f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the surface of the yellow food in the box on the table in the image flickers and wriggles).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07067", "filename": "P35_104_704_f83a3adfddf4c7ec_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (The plastic wrap should be soft, not as stiff as cardboard.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07068", "filename": "P35_105_9_7505a98b60a18a74_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07069", "filename": "P35_105_136_cc292dc248dd73d7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (4.2s, white particles appear out of thin air in the center of the palm).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07070", "filename": "P35_105_158_da2dd4912131bf46_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the mole's movement as it climbs from the ground onto the table is too smooth, lacking any sense of abruptness, unlike a realistic scene).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07071", "filename": "P35_105_259_502ee52f9e4604ca_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the mushrooms in the pot in the image are elements, and they are exhibiting a flickering and wriggling phenomenon).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07072", "filename": "P35_105_408_9f9b2fc3a05effdc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The food in the pot is automatically tumbling without any external force during the continuous time (1.7s-2.6s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07073", "filename": "P35_107_145_594a8658fca5d317_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is continuous (at 0.9s, three spoons become one spoon, and at 2.4s, one spoon becomes two spoons again).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07074", "filename": "P35_107_239_d920028633c54326_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (no splashing water is produced when the tap water is rinsing the purple object.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07075", "filename": "P35_107_331_86d13ae6ac1d0141_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (7.3s) The soft dough being shaken in the hand suddenly hardens, resembling cardboard.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07076", "filename": "P35_108_174_d392889b239be248_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (1.5s-2.8s, two stacked paper cups turn into one plastic cup).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07077", "filename": "P35_108_516_88b84e77f20fe794_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (4.7s, the water from the faucet flows directly through the center of the plate, violating the plate's impermeability).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07078", "filename": "P35_108_582_4f78440b10a95d19_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous flow (water flows from the faucet into the sink without splashing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07079", "filename": "P35_108_632_5470acc36afb477e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (1.9 seconds of water flowing from the faucet through the middle of the pipe, violating the impermeability of the pipe).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07080", "filename": "P35_109_137_2789bb16369d3312_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the light on the left wall of the screen is flickering and creeping).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07081", "filename": "P37_101_200_e3b8426b372835b8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (from 6.5s to 6.8s, two cloves of garlic become one).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07082", "filename": "P37_101_216_6efbe5e55f430595_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07083", "filename": "P37_101_257_61f23b78389a5a06_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: A continuous flickering and wriggling phenomenon appears on the surface of the vegetables between 4.6s and 5.6s.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07084", "filename": "P37_101_260_c0045cc880cf0801_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (2.5s: water flows directly through the middle of the object, creating a clipping effect. 3.7s-4.7s: the garlic pieces exhibit a flickering/creeping effect.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07085", "filename": "P37_101_269_b4f6e76f42c0fc85_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous flow (water flows from the tap into the basin, the surface of the water remains calm, and there is no splashing).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07086", "filename": "P37_101_273_be6086e5555bb29d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (from 3.5s to 6.5s, the goosebumps on my hand suddenly disappear).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07087", "filename": "P37_102_4_5ec7030a5e723696_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the blue and white bag on the left is an element flickering and wriggling phenomenon.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07088", "filename": "P37_102_39_be495176738657b2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (5.1s, the knife cuts directly through the finger area, creating a clipping effect).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07089", "filename": "P37_102_77_4ad2e573398bc280_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (5.4s-6.2s: the carrot, cut in half, is restored to one piece).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07090", "filename": "P37_102_89_52322bc1d032c9df_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (missing motion; from 1.7s to 2.7s, chunks of carrots abruptly turn into carrot puree without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07091", "filename": "P37_102_101_08455f59502f13da_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (The carrot automatically breaks into smaller pieces without being cut by a knife.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07092", "filename": "P37_102_114_293e812131e7a810_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The cut carrot suddenly returns to its original shape and the cut marks disappear automatically (1.5s-2.2s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07093", "filename": "P37_102_130_5671271f4027c582_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (when water flows from the tap into the bowl, the amount of water in the bowl does not change, and no splashes are produced.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07094", "filename": "P37_103_35_4cfa29d0feec755a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous movement (the chicken leg on the plate on the right side of the screen keeps flashing and wriggling).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07095", "filename": "P37_103_42_5f6effc318fb1e63_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07096", "filename": "P37_103_52_f9abd6779dfbb113_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual inconsistency (The hand movements while tearing the chicken are too smooth, lacking realistic abruptness.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07097", "filename": "2220045b73786a29b1686e09cab6d75e451c8b83141be56b9f79dfe78a495b2c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.7s, four small birds suddenly fly out from the end of the flock. From 4.6s to 5s, the video rewinds.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07098", "filename": "2220045b73786a29b1686e09cab6d75e451c8b83141be56b9f79dfe78a495b2c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.2 seconds, the number of birds suddenly increases the instant the flock flies over the building).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07099", "filename": "2220045b73786a29b1686e09cab6d75e451c8b83141be56b9f79dfe78a495b2c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07100", "filename": "2482921f780861749c251f7f3dac4d72b35c88f698d330b889b15a5d9c5f768e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07101", "filename": "2482921f780861749c251f7f3dac4d72b35c88f698d330b889b15a5d9c5f768e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 5.2 seconds, the sand on the beach suddenly turns into ocean waves).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07102", "filename": "2482921f780861749c251f7f3dac4d72b35c88f698d330b889b15a5d9c5f768e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07103", "filename": "2482921f780861749c251f7f3dac4d72b35c88f698d330b889b15a5d9c5f768e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (normal sea waves advance from a distance to a closer view, but in the video, the distant sea is calm, with waves only appearing near the beach, which is completely inconsistent with real sea waves.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07104", "filename": "2628707c6cdfe398d8897f4e9a6e5974a96f35e800318847a60ada2b2a4870e4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the water flowing from the yellow pressure vessel does not resemble real water flow; it looks more like a viscous liquid, lacking random splashes and natural branching.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07105", "filename": "2628707c6cdfe398d8897f4e9a6e5974a96f35e800318847a60ada2b2a4870e4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Continuous timing (Throughout the video, smoke from the bottom of the pressure vessel gathers and swirls on the ground; normally, smoke should disperse with the wind, not gather and swirl on the ground. At 1.4 seconds, the water flow from the pressure vessel suddenly forks.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07106", "filename": "2628707c6cdfe398d8897f4e9a6e5974a96f35e800318847a60ada2b2a4870e4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07107", "filename": "2628707c6cdfe398d8897f4e9a6e5974a96f35e800318847a60ada2b2a4870e4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The incident occurred continuously for 0.4 seconds (when the pressure gauge showed no change, the metal pipe suddenly burst and sprayed water).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07108", "filename": "3338908b2ec2d7101ccf7134a2b6b9d8ca055e9eecf9040f4b6c335bb1ba2758_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (1.24-5s, the hair dryer is blowing in front of the paper, but the paper is drifting in the direction of the hair dryer. Under normal circumstances, due to the pressure of the airflow, the paper should drift in the opposite direction of the hair dryer.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07109", "filename": "3338908b2ec2d7101ccf7134a2b6b9d8ca055e9eecf9040f4b6c335bb1ba2758_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 2.3s, the paper penetrated the rope, violating the principle of impermeability of solids.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07110", "filename": "3338908b2ec2d7101ccf7134a2b6b9d8ca055e9eecf9040f4b6c335bb1ba2758_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Physical behavior (at 4.9s, the cardboard penetrates the rope, violating the principle of impermeability of solids.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07111", "filename": "3338908b2ec2d7101ccf7134a2b6b9d8ca055e9eecf9040f4b6c335bb1ba2758_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Physical behavior (between 2.14 and 8 seconds, the paper penetrates the rope and becomes embedded in the rope during a tumbling motion, violating the principle of impermeability of solids.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07112", "filename": "4349657d5434352296edd2b4d7a86cad3fe6afe842cfa7a8094c9f4490bbc6ff_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the movement of clouds and fog in the entire video is too smooth, and the motion is more like that of liquid, unlike realistic footage.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07113", "filename": "4349657d5434352296edd2b4d7a86cad3fe6afe842cfa7a8094c9f4490bbc6ff_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.4 seconds, the fog floating above the grassland suddenly disappears.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07114", "filename": "4349657d5434352296edd2b4d7a86cad3fe6afe842cfa7a8094c9f4490bbc6ff_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07115", "filename": "4366505b32989f95c0c26372d9679191d8a2f15fad9ee232d2705ccb1121650c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: At 2.7s, a distinct black horizontal band appears at the bottom of the frame, interrupting the waves on the sea surface. In a real sunset scene at the seaside, the horizon and the sea should blend seamlessly and naturally, without this abrupt layering.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07116", "filename": "4366505b32989f95c0c26372d9679191d8a2f15fad9ee232d2705ccb1121650c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the transition of waves on the sea surface in the entire video is unnatural, exhibiting a layered appearance. In a real sunset scene at the beach, the horizon and the sea should blend seamlessly and naturally, without this abrupt layering.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07117", "filename": "4366505b32989f95c0c26372d9679191d8a2f15fad9ee232d2705ccb1121650c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07121", "filename": "5329724f7bf095c806d50efc7e2e9aebaec1686efa33c141afd1b0dbdd6a32e0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the clouds in the video appear to be moving in one place in the sky, whereas normal cloud movement should involve drifting with the wind, not moving in one place).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07122", "filename": "5329724f7bf095c806d50efc7e2e9aebaec1686efa33c141afd1b0dbdd6a32e0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.5 seconds, two white clouds in the sky suddenly merge into one black cloud.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07123", "filename": "5329724f7bf095c806d50efc7e2e9aebaec1686efa33c141afd1b0dbdd6a32e0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07124", "filename": "5329724f7bf095c806d50efc7e2e9aebaec1686efa33c141afd1b0dbdd6a32e0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07125", "filename": "6952816c204af8a3ef1914bceba175d69c3e1291fca9bb6efa0ae7b373e8faec_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous time (water is continuously poured into the glass from beginning to end, but the volume of liquid in the glass does not change significantly.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07126", "filename": "6952816c204af8a3ef1914bceba175d69c3e1291fca9bb6efa0ae7b373e8faec_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (The entire video shows water being poured into a cup, but the water does not splash when poured into the cup; normally, water poured into a cup should splash.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07127", "filename": "66e1fbd731c1a0a261dd78093b441e503c37ab3d461c89052b5cd7f2cfdf9a1b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Temporal continuity anomalies (during the 0s-0.6s interval of the video, the diamond in the frame flips and moves on its own without any external interference). Physical behavior: (during the 0.3s-1.4s interval, the diamond in the frame suddenly refracts light without the lens changing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07128", "filename": "66e1fbd731c1a0a261dd78093b441e503c37ab3d461c89052b5cd7f2cfdf9a1b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (between 1.4s and 2.4s, the diamond in the image suddenly appears as a flash of light and then disappears without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07129", "filename": "66e1fbd731c1a0a261dd78093b441e503c37ab3d461c89052b5cd7f2cfdf9a1b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (Throughout the video, the diamond's reflection is not only misplaced, but its shape and angle also do not match the diamond. A reflection should be symmetrical to the real object and clearly reflect the diamond's facets. However, the reflection in the video appears more like a separate, distorted image, failing to follow the optical principles of specular reflection.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07130", "filename": "067dcb5ca0592448fb99d6ce27fa251dd2fd1634a30197e0ef52b737e144c7c1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07131", "filename": "067dcb5ca0592448fb99d6ce27fa251dd2fd1634a30197e0ef52b737e144c7c1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (you can see some textures of aquatic plants or ripples on the water surface, but these textures are completely \"disconnected\" from the cloud reflections, without interfering with or distorting each other, which does not conform to the optical effects of a real water surface. In real water, ripples would cause the reflections to be distorted accordingly, rather than existing independently).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07132", "filename": "67b63e24231362ac93c11e36f99cd1703c4fc5f5c3d6187b5032c056d1017218_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 2 seconds into the frame, the carp in the middle of the frame appears out of nowhere without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07133", "filename": "67b63e24231362ac93c11e36f99cd1703c4fc5f5c3d6187b5032c056d1017218_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Temporal continuity (at 0.1 seconds into the video, the two carp in the frame suddenly appear larger without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07134", "filename": "67b63e24231362ac93c11e36f99cd1703c4fc5f5c3d6187b5032c056d1017218_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 0.7s in the video, without any change in camera angle, two blue fish suddenly appear in the frame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07142", "filename": "68e2e801b7dad50496c75fc910d609ccdb48c22fac7a0b11c9869cfc97ae05a7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07143", "filename": "68e2e801b7dad50496c75fc910d609ccdb48c22fac7a0b11c9869cfc97ae05a7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Physical behavior (between 1.1s and 2.7s in the video, the fire in the footage grows larger, but the light emanating from it dims, which does not conform to the principles of light propagation).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07144", "filename": "68e2e801b7dad50496c75fc910d609ccdb48c22fac7a0b11c9869cfc97ae05a7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07145", "filename": "68e2e801b7dad50496c75fc910d609ccdb48c22fac7a0b11c9869cfc97ae05a7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity (flickering artifacts are present throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07146", "filename": "68edbd5940b2b926b89f5f2259b6437d691af366ede2e7b4e07a393481edafcf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.6s in the video, the white object that fell into the cup disappears out of thin air without any change in the shot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07147", "filename": "68edbd5940b2b926b89f5f2259b6437d691af366ede2e7b4e07a393481edafcf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 1s in the video, the ice cubes in the glass suddenly turn into white circular objects without any change in the camera angle; at 1.4s, the white circular objects that fell into the glass disappear into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07148", "filename": "68edbd5940b2b926b89f5f2259b6437d691af366ede2e7b4e07a393481edafcf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.9s in the video, the ice cubes in the glass disappear out of thin air without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07149", "filename": "68f4b134eeda7650e8d2ee6d1894f10090a410ea711ca4d3c45587451cdecd10_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (between 0.6s and 1.3s in the video, the carrot under the person's arm disappears into thin air without any external interference; at 3.5s, the cut orange disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07150", "filename": "68f4b134eeda7650e8d2ee6d1894f10090a410ea711ca4d3c45587451cdecd10_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly occurred in the video between 2s and 3.2s, when the lemon in the person's hand suddenly changed from a round slice to a triangular block shape without any change in the camera angle.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07151", "filename": "68f4b134eeda7650e8d2ee6d1894f10090a410ea711ca4d3c45587451cdecd10_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07152", "filename": "69c0ac57de0328f9bdde61961c412771f431f876e782ac0ba21d919ae7ea475f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07153", "filename": "69c0ac57de0328f9bdde61961c412771f431f876e782ac0ba21d919ae7ea475f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the water surface is too calm and smooth throughout the video, lacking ripples and a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07154", "filename": "69c0ac57de0328f9bdde61961c412771f431f876e782ac0ba21d919ae7ea475f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the water surface is too calm and smooth throughout the video, lacking ripples and a sense of nature, and the trees in the video remain completely still).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07155", "filename": "69c0ac57de0328f9bdde61961c412771f431f876e782ac0ba21d919ae7ea475f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Temporal continuity (between 4s and 4.3s in the video, a white flash appears out of nowhere on the road in the upper left corner of the screen without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07157", "filename": "75b7bc772d5e93c91ea31dbd31275b0926aadcfc5f4b0e02c8c8f3fae3c7027f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (Throughout the entire video, the snowflakes on the window rotate on their own without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07158", "filename": "75b7bc772d5e93c91ea31dbd31275b0926aadcfc5f4b0e02c8c8f3fae3c7027f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (window frost flowers are formed by the sublimation of water vapor on glass. They grow along the microscopic texture of the glass, presenting a branching structure like tree branches, feathers, and needles. The texture has natural variations in thickness and irregular branching. However, in the video, they are completely regular starburst shapes, and the length and angle of each frost flower are consistent, which violates the natural growth law of frost flowers).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07159", "filename": "75b7bc772d5e93c91ea31dbd31275b0926aadcfc5f4b0e02c8c8f3fae3c7027f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: The overall visual impression is abnormal (natural ice flowers will preferentially grow densely on the edges, corners or areas with minor flaws where the glass temperature is lower, and the overall distribution is uneven with variations in density, and the textures will intertwine and spread, but the ice flowers in the image are evenly distributed with clear boundaries between them).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07160", "filename": "75b7bc772d5e93c91ea31dbd31275b0926aadcfc5f4b0e02c8c8f3fae3c7027f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual presentation is inconsistent (frost flowers are formed by the sublimation of water vapor on glass, growing along the glass's microscopic texture, exhibiting branching structures like tree branches, feathers, and needles, with natural variations in thickness and irregular branching; however, the video shows perfectly regular starburst patterns, with each frost flower having the same length and angle, violating the natural growth pattern of frost flowers).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07161", "filename": "75b09ef13d83d2665cba3388dd4132d38b1f5e869e4c5eb5468ee083f863bff2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the entire footage, the polar bear's lower body is in the pool, while its neck and body are above the water. When the polar bear moves, the body movements above and below the water are discontinuous and fragmented, violating the principle of discontinuity in visual composition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07162", "filename": "75b09ef13d83d2665cba3388dd4132d38b1f5e869e4c5eb5468ee083f863bff2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the video, the polar bear's lower body is in the pool, while its neck and body are above the water. The polar bear then turns its neck, which keeps extending, but the body remains unchanged. Only the neck is moving, which violates the principle of discontinuity in the visuals).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07163", "filename": "75b09ef13d83d2665cba3388dd4132d38b1f5e869e4c5eb5468ee083f863bff2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07164", "filename": "75b09ef13d83d2665cba3388dd4132d38b1f5e869e4c5eb5468ee083f863bff2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (at 4.6 seconds in the video, the water splashed by the polar bear slapping the water surface directly penetrates the glass, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07165", "filename": "75e248a728b7c2f7b5bf6501b215162baa134be80c7e11f41fb4f4a8bf99521c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (within 0.3 seconds of the video, without any change in camera angle, the hat on the person's head disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07166", "filename": "75e248a728b7c2f7b5bf6501b215162baa134be80c7e11f41fb4f4a8bf99521c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Physical behavior (A real water reflection should be strictly symmetrical with the posture of the person, but in the image the person is in the posture of arms outstretched upwards, while the reflection is in the posture of arms bent downwards. The two postures are completely mismatched, which violates the physical laws of mirror reflection).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07167", "filename": "75e248a728b7c2f7b5bf6501b215162baa134be80c7e11f41fb4f4a8bf99521c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 1 seconds, without any change in camera angle, the hat on the person's head disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07168", "filename": "75e248a728b7c2f7b5bf6501b215162baa134be80c7e11f41fb4f4a8bf99521c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (without any change in camera angle throughout the entire video, the person in the video is slowly getting taller and their arms are getting longer).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07169", "filename": "76b5e391287a5d9ff2a24c733a59ad572ab4eeec1a39893ae7c039896c6d1574_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07170", "filename": "76b5e391287a5d9ff2a24c733a59ad572ab4eeec1a39893ae7c039896c6d1574_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the flames in the entire video lack a natural upward arc, appearing too rigid and attached to the surface of the firewood, which does not conform to the physical property that hot air rising and causing the flames to rise).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07171", "filename": "76b5e391287a5d9ff2a24c733a59ad572ab4eeec1a39893ae7c039896c6d1574_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07179", "filename": "78aa41426c504997d77fd4bc7d811afd2e94f97ce9fe0f3664ec2e6a98c4fe62_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (real water surfaces reflect ambient light, creating interplay of light and shadow and color gradations, but the blue in the image is too uniform, lacking natural light and shadow layers and the transparency of light penetrating the water surface; the overall impression is more like a digital texture).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07180", "filename": "78aa41426c504997d77fd4bc7d811afd2e94f97ce9fe0f3664ec2e6a98c4fe62_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the bulge at the bottom of the image does not have the curvature and dynamic trajectory of natural water waves, nor does it have the texture of wave diffusion or the shape change under the action of gravity, which does not conform to the physical characteristics of liquid flow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07181", "filename": "78aae24bd7e8dce0cf67600af8fc8e645e856feb4794b394fd419a5aab27257e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior (the reflection of the kerosene lamp flame on the lampshade in the image is separated and has an unnatural shape, violating the principle of mirrors).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07182", "filename": "78aae24bd7e8dce0cf67600af8fc8e645e856feb4794b394fd419a5aab27257e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the flame of the kerosene lamp is blocked by the wire fence of the lampshade in the image, which violates the principle of mirror image).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07183", "filename": "78aae24bd7e8dce0cf67600af8fc8e645e856feb4794b394fd419a5aab27257e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the intense light from the flame does not create natural reflections or shadows on the surrounding cup walls or tea strainer; the light and shadow are confined to the flame itself and are completely detached from the environment).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07184", "filename": "78aae24bd7e8dce0cf67600af8fc8e645e856feb4794b394fd419a5aab27257e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the video switches scenes abruptly at 1.2s without transition). Physical behavior: (At 2.6s, the person's hand passes directly through the glass, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07187", "filename": "67980352c819e8ae3ccec7bac8aa2034c1a4eb3b3dead639883ece096ef33f62_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (the initial colored cloud light is a static effect pasted onto the screen; it does not move with the clouds nor is it obscured by other clouds. At 3.7 seconds, the camera pans, and the colored light suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07188", "filename": "67980352c819e8ae3ccec7bac8aa2034c1a4eb3b3dead639883ece096ef33f62_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (at 1.4s, the video does not play sequentially along the timeline, but suddenly jumps directly from a cool-toned purple-pink sky to a warm-toned orange-yellow sunset scene, with no transition between the two jumps).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07189", "filename": "68483896cedc56df1728f9e3783fe086dd77a152840d3eeaa70cde37affd1cf5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: continuous time (honey started dripping from the stirring stick at 2.4 seconds, and then \"jumped\" back onto the stirring stick after dripping only halfway down).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07190", "filename": "68483896cedc56df1728f9e3783fe086dd77a152840d3eeaa70cde37affd1cf5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (just as the honey is about to drip into the bowl, the scene suddenly jumps back to the moment when the stirring stick is lifted and the honey has not completely detached, which is equivalent to rewinding the scene of \"about to drip\". Moreover, the whole process has no natural transition and the scene is just repeating in a loop.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07191", "filename": "68483896cedc56df1728f9e3783fe086dd77a152840d3eeaa70cde37affd1cf5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (when the honey on the stirring stick is lifted, the resulting strands do not fall when they break; instead, they \"stick\" back to the stirring stick, and the entire process is not affected by gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07192", "filename": "68483896cedc56df1728f9e3783fe086dd77a152840d3eeaa70cde37affd1cf5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07193", "filename": "77322347b934193967ab8b2bf1a1d190973e3c74cd41fbafea3fa22d9ba27863_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07194", "filename": "77322347b934193967ab8b2bf1a1d190973e3c74cd41fbafea3fa22d9ba27863_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.3s, the particles that were initially stationary in the video suddenly start rolling like waves without any external force, and the texture changes from dry sand to flowing liquid).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07195", "filename": "77322347b934193967ab8b2bf1a1d190973e3c74cd41fbafea3fa22d9ba27863_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the particles in the video appear to be moving, but in reality, it's just the same segment of footage playing in a seamless loop without any new changes or progression; it's more like a live wallpaper repeating itself.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07196", "filename": "77322347b934193967ab8b2bf1a1d190973e3c74cd41fbafea3fa22d9ba27863_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: the time sequence is continuous (at 2.4 seconds, the particles in the video suddenly turn into blades of grass that begin to sway in the wind, and the form of matter changes directly).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07197", "filename": "259657786bbdf36b0a1b3848da397d45658ab25590c4e451e16ec60b38f59a64_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the flow of water is not continuous (in the video, the water flow of the waterfall does not flow continuously forward, but flows repeatedly in a loop at the edge).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07198", "filename": "259657786bbdf36b0a1b3848da397d45658ab25590c4e451e16ec60b38f59a64_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.03, the water on the right side of the screen, which should have flowed down the edge of the waterfall, suddenly bounced upwards and began to churn repeatedly).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07199", "filename": "259657786bbdf36b0a1b3848da397d45658ab25590c4e451e16ec60b38f59a64_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (in the video, the water at the top of the waterfall, just as it is about to fall, suddenly seems to be held back and gets stuck at the edge, surging repeatedly without pouring down or continuing to flow forward).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07200", "filename": "259657786bbdf36b0a1b3848da397d45658ab25590c4e451e16ec60b38f59a64_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.8s, the mist behind the waterfall suddenly disappeared completely, as if the delete key had been pressed).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07201", "filename": "308434157e771d333433c425f1de43bcc64d6d8da2dbe336ee06c820832906de_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is the lack of continuity in time (during the period from 2.9s to 3.5s, when the sunlight brightens and a circular halo appears, the mist floating above the forest shows no change whatsoever\u2014it is neither illuminated with depth nor \"broken\" open by the light, as if two unrelated images have been superimposed).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07202", "filename": "308434157e771d333433c425f1de43bcc64d6d8da2dbe336ee06c820832906de_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is unpredictable (at 4.5 seconds, a patch of fog in the middle of the video is suddenly \"wiped away,\" with a very clear boundary between it and the surrounding fog, which is not a natural dissipation).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07203", "filename": "308434157e771d333433c425f1de43bcc64d6d8da2dbe336ee06c820832906de_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.1 seconds, several straight beams of sunlight suddenly appear out of nowhere in the video, and the edges of the beams and the surrounding fog are very abruptly separated, as if it were a special effect added in post-production.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07204", "filename": "308434157e771d333433c425f1de43bcc64d6d8da2dbe336ee06c820832906de_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.4s, a large cloud of mist above the forest suddenly turned into a completely opaque white entity with a very regular shape, which was completely different from the texture of the naturally flowing mist around it).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07205", "filename": "618887273f40e1016acbad78ec95bc92343729320470377b8726bae67f9913a0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (after the cookie is run over by the car tire between 1s and 4.3s, it doesn't break or crack, but instead is flattened and stretched like playdough).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07206", "filename": "618887273f40e1016acbad78ec95bc92343729320470377b8726bae67f9913a0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 1.3s to 4.1s, the cookie is crushed into a jam-like liquid by the tire and spread out on the ground. After the tire is lifted, the cookie returns to its original shape).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07207", "filename": "618887273f40e1016acbad78ec95bc92343729320470377b8726bae67f9913a0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 5.3 seconds, the cookie crumbs under the tire suddenly disappear).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07208", "filename": "634324962e3eae1cfc832abb9de7b8f2e6bfad2513e0529597e5851dc85724f5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical behavior (a white object in the water moves up and down inside the bottle without any force applied).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07209", "filename": "634324962e3eae1cfc832abb9de7b8f2e6bfad2513e0529597e5851dc85724f5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 2.5s, the bottom of the white object in the bottle on the left suddenly becomes flat, as if it has been cut by an invisible blade).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07210", "filename": "634324962e3eae1cfc832abb9de7b8f2e6bfad2513e0529597e5851dc85724f5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07211", "filename": "634324962e3eae1cfc832abb9de7b8f2e6bfad2513e0529597e5851dc85724f5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (there is a very neat dividing line between the white liquid and the transparent liquid in the bottle on the left, without any natural blurring).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07212", "filename": "686148856f3e3514b4f6815317b6e15a0d697f3dccaef12a470706634b3d7750_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the amount of black powder emitted by the small square in the image far exceeds its own volume).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07213", "filename": "686148856f3e3514b4f6815317b6e15a0d697f3dccaef12a470706634b3d7750_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the black powder is not thrown up by the block, but actively rushes upward and envelops the orange block, similar to the active behavior of a creature).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07214", "filename": "686148856f3e3514b4f6815317b6e15a0d697f3dccaef12a470706634b3d7750_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (between 0.1s and 5s, the black powder spontaneously exploded into symmetrical wing shapes without being touched, representing autonomous special effects movement without external force.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07215", "filename": "708722434ac4fddf9fb244eba8fab716516e398163be035f8a9882cb4352e55d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.8 seconds, the steam from the hot spring did not dissipate normally, but instead repeatedly rose and diffused from the same location, entering an infinite loop.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07216", "filename": "708722434ac4fddf9fb244eba8fab716516e398163be035f8a9882cb4352e55d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is inconsistent (a dark shadow appears on the steam without moving with it, and at 3.6 seconds, the colored area near the hot spring suddenly changes color and texture in the middle of the video, which looks very abrupt).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07217", "filename": "5aa96dac823315987344c9b412f8e990a1c3a0a76283d285bf343ded98af2f25_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (the fireworks in the entire video show jagged, broken outlines after they explode, petal-shaped sparks float in a weightless direction, some fireworks do not have a natural spark diffusion process after they explode, the trajectory of the fireworks is radially upward, the altitude of the fireworks is seriously mismatched with the scale of the explosion, low-altitude fireworks explode into extremely large flower shapes, the timing of the explosion is irregular, and there are cases of explosions before they even ascend, the sparks and fragments of the fireworks do not have a downward trend affected by gravity after they explode, and they lack the fine, granular feel of fireworks).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07218", "filename": "5aa96dac823315987344c9b412f8e990a1c3a0a76283d285bf343ded98af2f25_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (the fireworks exploded irregularly throughout the video, sometimes breaking off and disappearing midway through their ascent; the lighting effects lacked the transitional layers of a true firework, such as a core bright spot, a mid-level halo, and outer sparks; the fireworks were mostly of a single brightness and color, without any halo or gradual color transition; after exploding, they looked like colored paper pieces pasted into a black sky, lacking a transparent sense of light; and there was no natural decay process from bright to dark as the fireworks bloomed).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07219", "filename": "5aa96dac823315987344c9b412f8e990a1c3a0a76283d285bf343ded98af2f25_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (there is no ambient light or shadow feedback in the entire video; when the fireworks bloom in the dark, their bright light does not produce any reflection or shadow on the surrounding environment; the sky remains pure black and dull; the fireworks appear as textures independent of the scene and completely detached from the background).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07220", "filename": "5abe1b81216c733c0ed5e2ad8f4632e21d0ae6deb4d2f01b9e797070cf3d2ae5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (In the entire video, when the metal is squeezed, there is no localized elastoplastic deformation, but it is directly pressed into the lower half of the metal. There are no details of stress concentration at the deformation point, which violates the yield strength and tensile strength laws of different metals. Moreover, the upper metal deforms while the lower metal remains completely unchanged, and the transmission of force is blocked out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07221", "filename": "5abe1b81216c733c0ed5e2ad8f4632e21d0ae6deb4d2f01b9e797070cf3d2ae5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (the metal is not subjected to hydraulic pressure or other external forces in the entire video, but the metal begins to deform, and it is as soft as putty when deforming, without the sense of deformation resistance that comes with the density of metal).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07222", "filename": "5abe1b81216c733c0ed5e2ad8f4632e21d0ae6deb4d2f01b9e797070cf3d2ae5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (In the entire video, the metal wrinkles and depressions caused by compression do not have texture; the stretched and overlapping textures remain flat and are disconnected from the deformation shape. When compressing metal, there should be metal fragments flying and breaking apart, but no metal fragments appear in the video. When the hydraulic press head descends, there is shaking and deviation in the descent trajectory. Normally, it should descend vertically and at a constant speed.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07223", "filename": "5abe1b81216c733c0ed5e2ad8f4632e21d0ae6deb4d2f01b9e797070cf3d2ae5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (the hydraulic press head descends without uniform and gradual acceleration throughout the entire video; there is no localized indentation or elastic-plastic deformation when the hydraulic press squeezes the metal; at 4.6s, the hydraulic press suddenly indents and contracts without external force after leaving the metal; at 5.8s, the metal suddenly expands and contracts again without external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07231", "filename": "5afbc91874e36031113c3563afb6b45bd437dfed17643f274f4dcea83d1b4d5b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 1.6s, the first person's arm suddenly appears out of nowhere, and the figures in the entire video are obviously distorted and deformed).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07232", "filename": "5afbc91874e36031113c3563afb6b45bd437dfed17643f274f4dcea83d1b4d5b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (the figures in the entire video are obviously distorted and shaken, the walking movements of the figures lack natural center of gravity fluctuations and limb swings, the angles of the legs and arms of some figures are distorted, such as the arm swing amplitude being completely disconnected from the stride, and water ripples are generated on the mirror surface, but it is impossible for a person to walk on water, which violates Archimedes' principle of buoyancy).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07233", "filename": "5afbc91874e36031113c3563afb6b45bd437dfed17643f274f4dcea83d1b4d5b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (a real water surface reflection would be completely synchronized with and mirror-symmetrical to the person's movements, but in the entire video the person is in a walking motion, while the reflection presents a stiff, static posture, the limb angles do not match the main body's movements, and the person's leg lifting motion does not have a corresponding mirror image of lifting in the reflection).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07234", "filename": "5afbc91874e36031113c3563afb6b45bd437dfed17643f274f4dcea83d1b4d5b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.6s, a yellow figure suddenly appears in the red figure in the video, without any consistency. The clothing and posture of multiple figures are highly similar, and the actions and color schemes of some figures are almost completely repeated, lacking the natural differences of people in a real scene).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07235", "filename": "5b9dc9b11a0cbdf2056a9509873a7367cbac5d1a7b18854ee6194f5f081c57ce_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.8 seconds, the mound of earth after the explosion suddenly appears intact).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07236", "filename": "5b9dc9b11a0cbdf2056a9509873a7367cbac5d1a7b18854ee6194f5f081c57ce_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (the smoke and dust formed instantly during the explosion in the entire video, the direction of smoke and dust diffusion was disconnected from the direction of the explosion, the soil clods flew outwards while the smoke and dust gathered towards the center, the diffusion of the smoke and dust did not have a gradual process caused by air resistance, the edges always maintained a clear outline, and there was no reasonable floating attenuation).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07237", "filename": "5b9dc9b11a0cbdf2056a9509873a7367cbac5d1a7b18854ee6194f5f081c57ce_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at the end of the video, the pile of earth after the explosion suddenly appears intact, the outline of the explosion cloud does not have a natural fluffy feel, and the whole is in a rigid blocky splicing state. There is no turbulent, irregular diffusion outline of real explosion smoke and dust. The edges are too smooth and there is no gradual layering of dense core and thin periphery. The material or dust produced by the explosion should be irregularly splashed in all directions, but at 2.9 seconds, the explosion dust falls vertically from the explosion cloud like rain).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07238", "filename": "5b9dc9b11a0cbdf2056a9509873a7367cbac5d1a7b18854ee6194f5f081c57ce_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (the color of the explosion cloud in the entire video remains unchanged, lacking the color transition of the initial fire, smoke, dust and fog dissipation in a real explosion, and the explosion cloud lacks the flash and heat radiation bright spots at the time of detonation. The heat wave of the explosion in the video is intense and covers a large area, but the pile of wheels next to the explosion point remains completely still and is not affected by the explosion at all).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07239", "filename": "5b3051a4ffeed7289e461f5a3aaaaecb1cf8406b1a32d8b866b9cfb7b65d924d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 0.1 seconds, the fireworks in the video suddenly ignite without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07240", "filename": "5b3051a4ffeed7289e461f5a3aaaaecb1cf8406b1a32d8b866b9cfb7b65d924d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the fireworks are on fire and accompanied by sparks throughout the video, continuing to burn into the blackened parts where the fuel has burned out).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07241", "filename": "5b3051a4ffeed7289e461f5a3aaaaecb1cf8406b1a32d8b866b9cfb7b65d924d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (multiple anomalies exist in the entire video footage; the fireworks spontaneously combusted and sprayed without any external force, and although the flames were intense, there were only a few sparks, with no dynamic correlation between the two).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07242", "filename": "5b3051a4ffeed7289e461f5a3aaaaecb1cf8406b1a32d8b866b9cfb7b65d924d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (without any external force affecting the entire video, the firework spontaneously combusts at the point where it has already burned out, and the sparks do not have a natural burning-out and dissipation process; they appear and disappear instantly).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07243", "filename": "5bb12dd191b69ceda72701d9d921348b712e1e299e8f09cd507e0d3c3800dd42_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (the entire video footage is abnormally shaky and choppy, and smoke rises directly from the snow without warning, without any physical cause or action to trigger the smoke, such as open flames, heat sources, or human or object movements, which contradicts the logic of real physics)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07244", "filename": "5bb12dd191b69ceda72701d9d921348b712e1e299e8f09cd507e0d3c3800dd42_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the smoke rises directly from the snow without warning throughout the video, without any physical cause or action that could trigger the smoke, such as open flames, heat sources, or human or object movements, which contradicts the logic of reality. Moreover, in the low temperature and well-ventilated outdoor environment of the snow, the smoke does not naturally sink slowly or diffuse gently, but rises upward in a columnar shape).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07245", "filename": "5bb12dd191b69ceda72701d9d921348b712e1e299e8f09cd507e0d3c3800dd42_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07246", "filename": "5bb12dd191b69ceda72701d9d921348b712e1e299e8f09cd507e0d3c3800dd42_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "the video only shows one area of snow being blown by the wind, and the shape is like smoke drifting away. The snowflakes blown by the wind do not have the natural fine, fluffy, granular texture, nor the fluffy and broken feeling of snowflakes being torn apart by the wind. There is also no dust-like swirling effect of the snow on the ground being blown by the wind. The snow surface remains flat without any depressions or changes in texture caused by wind scraping.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07247", "filename": "2220045b73786a29b1686e09cab6d75e451c8b83141be56b9f79dfe78a495b2c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 6.9 seconds, the sky color suddenly changes and the birds in the sky suddenly disappear).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07248", "filename": "2482921f780861749c251f7f3dac4d72b35c88f698d330b889b15a5d9c5f768e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the waves on the upper right side of the sea remain still throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07249", "filename": "2628707c6cdfe398d8897f4e9a6e5974a96f35e800318847a60ada2b2a4870e4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video error: Time continuity (the entire video is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07250", "filename": "3338908b2ec2d7101ccf7134a2b6b9d8ca055e9eecf9040f4b6c335bb1ba2758_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.7s, the paper suddenly passes through the white line, and between 0.6s and 2.8s in the video, the paper floats in the opposite direction while being blown by the hair dryer).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07251", "filename": "4349657d5434352296edd2b4d7a86cad3fe6afe842cfa7a8094c9f4490bbc6ff_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the clouds in the video suddenly become fewer and sparser at 3.9s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07252", "filename": "4366505b32989f95c0c26372d9679191d8a2f15fad9ee232d2705ccb1121650c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the entire video is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07253", "filename": "5329724f7bf095c806d50efc7e2e9aebaec1686efa33c141afd1b0dbdd6a32e0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the clouds and sea remain static throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07254", "filename": "7089983d2a2c031eb591f136f46f786087c2b6f69acb039376464c346e3fcfcc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07255", "filename": "7535087af198f72cd3366f94fe3a1c42962c52abb1d511fb6b66406e0bd7884a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.9s in the video, the white ball in the lower left corner suddenly disappears, and at 6.6s in the video, the second stick from the top moves without being touched).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07256", "filename": "8565312dcfec53f7b5287b8696957bd1cbb48c048184b5484830a8f7792d2927_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect (the frost crystals have a clear transparent texture and light refraction effect, but the white spots at the bottom of the video are solid and non-reflective, which is completely disconnected from the transparent texture of the frost and does not follow the same light and shadow logic).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07257", "filename": "8738977bd46f7b131572f684b608dada85e09fbc83000198bdbd1f7a1013cf7b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the color of the flame suddenly changes at 2.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07258", "filename": "9058487d8b32ea62d52e615106a32768fba98ed5ae77f1fccb983da73e504038_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the clouds in the video remain stationary, which is inconsistent with real-world phenomena).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07259", "filename": "9534744d9a02038d43d502367ab2caf47b51303d8f616740032331ccb884e7a7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07260", "filename": "9881632a611e617c4020d2aa9bf3af63d6c742a376b8a10c8d48b7452b4b47f4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the trees in the distance have been burned down to their bare branches, but the trees and vegetation in the foreground have not been affected by the flames, creating a clear boundary. This effect of precisely burning a specific area is more like a man-made controlled burning or a scene created in post-production than a naturally spreading wildfire).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07261", "filename": "16129543ed6b68e7979f5143488896924c89e6da6692276f02678c0ad3810f2e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Cause and effect (The swan's feathers in the entire video have soft tonal gradations, but the color and texture of the reflection are too harsh, lacking the transparency and slight ripple blur effect that water reflection should have, and are completely different from the reflective texture of the surrounding water surface) Physical behavior (There are natural ripples on the water surface, but the reflection does not deform accordingly with the ripples, appearing abnormally stiff)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07262", "filename": "30504124a7514f4d8874f01c48fe006de053e7732dbf2f2f417fd93a31e3ecdc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall impression is off (the orange-yellow tones of the sky and the pure black silhouettes of the trees lack a natural transition, the edges of the trees do not have the light and shadow levels created by the sunlight, and the whole thing looks more like a stiff splicing of two pieces of footage than a real sunset scene. In addition, the halo around the sun appears as an overly regular horizontal band, and the color transitions are abrupt).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07263", "filename": "040565470df65ba7b00ebd198168ca051c740117e464c12219464b0a018edc41_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the visuals: The sequence of events is continuous (the bubbles in the entire video have holes in the middle and are stuck to the Guanyin statue, but they do not break and are swaying from side to side).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07264", "filename": "41057413b80cef511a6ead880b42c0ba3e211fc63e25ce3c1ac9f26391316950_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.6 seconds into the video, the knife cuts into the finger, but the hand is not injured).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07265", "filename": "48169022bc0eea1da1c29e0618964db54856712aaf46fecb96661c9aa5aeaf61_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (between 2.7s and 8s in the video, after the two spherical objects explode, all the yellow particles suddenly stop and the light from the explosion suddenly moves to the left).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07266", "filename": "52769912cae9a03fd8794953c2fcb92063a78c8ea050ac057745f0fdb70b3421_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (during the video from 0.7s to 8.3s, when the water is poured down on top of the crystal, it only flows in one direction, it should flow in all directions, and the white crystal on the table gradually gets bigger).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07267", "filename": "54133464f599f87bec37bea10219240229a236106cf04d64f9cda827a3de811f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the eye at the top of the screen is not being held by a hand but is suspended in the air and moves with the hand, which does not conform to the laws of gravity, and the candle still appears to be doubled after the eye is removed).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07268", "filename": "68483896cedc56df1728f9e3783fe086dd77a152840d3eeaa70cde37affd1cf5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (during the video from 2.7s to 8s, after the honey spoon scoops up the honey, the amount of honey in the container does not increase but decreases as it flows down).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07269", "filename": "77322347b934193967ab8b2bf1a1d190973e3c74cd41fbafea3fa22d9ba27863_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07270", "filename": "308434157e771d333433c425f1de43bcc64d6d8da2dbe336ee06c820832906de_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1.1 seconds, the tree on the left side of the video suddenly deforms).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07271", "filename": "634324962e3eae1cfc832abb9de7b8f2e6bfad2513e0529597e5851dc85724f5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the leaves in the background of the video keep flickering throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07272", "filename": "686148856f3e3514b4f6815317b6e15a0d697f3dccaef12a470706634b3d7750_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time sequence is continuous (from 1.2s to 8s, the iron filings that were sucked up suddenly turned into liquid; from 6.8s to 8s, the number of iron filings that were sucked up increased significantly during their fall).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07273", "filename": "708722434ac4fddf9fb244eba8fab716516e398163be035f8a9882cb4352e55d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the flow of water in the river on the left side of the entire video is too regular and does not conform to natural phenomena.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07274", "filename": "777613865b39134e54ca77c74ca480997f3a3568598c8b4f6a09052c5222541f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07275", "filename": "928362386cbd121ff8c4583b70ceaa9b5d600259a7b23e66dc0c08e59def10ed_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07276", "filename": "6554279989b396b92d3e4c07472527bf32c38506e4b23f139f9f7a4a9a6ae154_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07277", "filename": "4bf5f9ba65522008ed143b0d3956fafe877d68fd2ac816578dfb3a29fa15e7f1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (0s-8s: a large number of corn kernels on the corncob are heated and popped into popcorn, but the corncob cannot stand upright. However, the gas expansion force generated by the large number of corn kernels being heated and popped into popcorn will cause the corncob to fall down).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07282", "filename": "4c4bf08b3420453d7cd8ef4e4e4d9902616df8ea77ccfd6c7a551b95c7668cba_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the water surface, acting as a reflective surface, does not display the dynamic light and shadow mapping effect that flames should have).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07283", "filename": "4c4bf08b3420453d7cd8ef4e4e4d9902616df8ea77ccfd6c7a551b95c7668cba_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07284", "filename": "4c4bf08b3420453d7cd8ef4e4e4d9902616df8ea77ccfd6c7a551b95c7668cba_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (0.4s-5s, water flows into the pool in the lower right corner, the pool remains calm, and there are no obvious ripples or splashes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07285", "filename": "4c4bf08b3420453d7cd8ef4e4e4d9902616df8ea77ccfd6c7a551b95c7668cba_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: The overall visual presentation is inconsistent (realistic flames are dynamic fluids with distinct rising, curling, and turbulent textures. However, the flames in the image appear stiff and lack natural dynamic changes; some areas even exhibit a \"static texture\" effect, failing to convey the fluidity of flames rising with the hot airflow.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07286", "filename": "4c554e3369db38b45edbc1bdb3c4923d5aae14b0e167d9e89643a693b541aace_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (in the entire video, the weeds under the rock in the lower left corner are swaying violently. The rock blocks most of the impact of the water flow and the wind, and the grass below it is in a relatively still environment and will not be directly blown by the rapid water flow or strong wind.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07287", "filename": "4c554e3369db38b45edbc1bdb3c4923d5aae14b0e167d9e89643a693b541aace_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the water surface in some areas appears blurry and \"frozen,\" lacking the dynamic details of splashing and ripples that should be present in real flowing water, creating a clear visual disconnect from the realistic texture of the surrounding rocks).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07288", "filename": "4c554e3369db38b45edbc1bdb3c4923d5aae14b0e167d9e89643a693b541aace_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07289", "filename": "4c554e3369db38b45edbc1bdb3c4923d5aae14b0e167d9e89643a693b541aace_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the rushing river in the lower right corner of the entire video does not submerge the rocks or the water does not flow onto the surface of the rocks).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07290", "filename": "4cf1b60a6112c10b50a6ad4a7d07e15fe70ad6f0c861924f780247ea4d9229d5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual intuition is off (between 4.4s and 4.7s, the movement of the human flipping the disc is too smooth and lacks the abrupt pauses that should be present in reality).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07291", "filename": "4cf1b60a6112c10b50a6ad4a7d07e15fe70ad6f0c861924f780247ea4d9229d5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the disc in the 1.3s-4.9s video appears uneven; a real disc has a smooth, glossy surface where reflections transition naturally with the viewing angle. However, the colors on this disc resemble a static gradient texture applied to a flat surface, lacking the nuanced reflective variations expected from a curved disc).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07292", "filename": "4cf1b60a6112c10b50a6ad4a7d07e15fe70ad6f0c861924f780247ea4d9229d5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior (1.1s-1.3s, 3.7s-3.8s: the light source is reflected in the hole in the middle of the disc, but the hole in the middle of the disc does not have a reflective function).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07293", "filename": "4cf1b60a6112c10b50a6ad4a7d07e15fe70ad6f0c861924f780247ea4d9229d5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The object in hand undergoes abnormal distortion and deformation over a continuous period of time (0s-0.3s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07294", "filename": "4d48d0f68ed3d6a0737ed8c1fbf82a2b2cc0242c7c8a325f726dbd27335d45f1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Overall Visual Abnormality (The shape of the light cluster at the top of the tower in the entire video does not conform to atmospheric optical characteristics. Even in foggy or cloudy weather, the scattering of city lights would present a soft halo consistent with the direction of the light source. However, this blue light cluster is an independent, suspended luminous body, with a blurry shape and abnormal brightness, unlike a real phenomenon.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07295", "filename": "4d48d0f68ed3d6a0737ed8c1fbf82a2b2cc0242c7c8a325f726dbd27335d45f1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the clouds move from left to right throughout the video, and when they reach the area around the tower, they start moving upwards, and at 3.9 seconds the clouds at the top of the tower turn into a dazzling blue light, after which the overall image changes from yellow to blue)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07296", "filename": "4d48d0f68ed3d6a0737ed8c1fbf82a2b2cc0242c7c8a325f726dbd27335d45f1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (The spire is a closed, solid structure and would not produce such a strong upward beam of light. There is a clearly visible, vertically upward-pointing band of light directly above the building in the image, extending into the clouds. This \"beam of light\" lacks a corresponding light source and does not conform to the projection logic of artificial light sources such as searchlights; it does not appear to be a real phenomenon.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07297", "filename": "4d96c5e8712d6f3b399e35619ea57ef6606704fe001eca66e08a1783209bf1e7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (4.2s-5s, the red oil drum that was blown away suddenly returns to its original position; 4.2s, the red oil drum on the right undergoes severe deformation).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07298", "filename": "4d96c5e8712d6f3b399e35619ea57ef6606704fe001eca66e08a1783209bf1e7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Physical Behavior (1.1s-5.8s: The explosion shockwave contradicts the forces acting on the objects. A real explosion shockwave would spread evenly in all directions, exerting an outward pushing force on the surrounding oil drums, causing them to tilt or scatter away from the explosion center. However, some oil drums in the image (such as the one on the right) appear to be tilted towards the explosion center, with the direction of force completely opposite to the physical laws of the shockwave.) Time Continuity (1.1s-1.8s: The sixth and seventh oil drums suddenly split into two).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07299", "filename": "4d96c5e8712d6f3b399e35619ea57ef6606704fe001eca66e08a1783209bf1e7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The sequence of events is continuous (1.6s-2.1s, after the explosion, additional red oil drums appear out of nowhere). Physical behavior (1.2s-2.6s, a real explosion's flames would rapidly spread outwards with the shockwave, exhibiting a radial dynamic pattern. However, the flames in the image resemble a suspended cloud, lacking the outward expansion force and fluidity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07300", "filename": "4d605c95cbd54893050b2407d23935008e0a5592d72eb1ca3794739554156c58_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (realistic sunlight scattering in a forest would only produce soft, irregular beams of light, not this uniform texture).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07301", "filename": "4d605c95cbd54893050b2407d23935008e0a5592d72eb1ca3794739554156c58_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall visuals are unusual (the lighting in the scene from 1.1s to 5.8s changes suddenly, quickly switching from warm yellow sunlight to cool blue light, and the brightness of the fog and trees in the forest also changes instantly when the lighting changes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07302", "filename": "4d605c95cbd54893050b2407d23935008e0a5592d72eb1ca3794739554156c58_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: The overall visual impression is off. (While the Tyndall effect beams in the background create atmosphere, the overall brightness and color transitions are too uniform, lacking the nuanced variations of light and shadow in a real forest. The edges of the trees and the texture of the mist also appear somewhat harsh.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07303", "filename": "4d605c95cbd54893050b2407d23935008e0a5592d72eb1ca3794739554156c58_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (In a real physical scene, when the camera moves forward, the clouds and fog in the foreground would appear magnified and clearer due to the change in perspective, and the clouds and fog in the distance would also show changes in layering. But here the clouds and fog remain static and uniform, without any perspective distortion due to the camera moving forward, nor any dynamic flow or density changes, as if they were static textures pasted onto the screen.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07304", "filename": "4d640d4f600688e719c131131fbccc51e9824b2733ffe610f767101bb55b522f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (the drill bit's spiral grooves in the entire video did not perform their chip removal function; the wood chips were not carried out along the grooves but instead accumulated around the drill hole, which is different from the physical process of actual drilling; moreover, when the wood was drilled, it did not vibrate or deform normally due to the force applied, and the drill bit seemed to \"melt\" into the wood.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07305", "filename": "4d640d4f600688e719c131131fbccc51e9824b2733ffe610f767101bb55b522f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (3s-4.5s) When the drill bit is drilling into an object, the debris is not splashed up with the drill bit but is squeezed out. The spiral grooves of the drill bit act as \"guide channels\" for the debris. As the drill bit continues to rotate, the debris produced by cutting is discharged outward and upward along the spiral grooves, and will not accumulate in the borehole.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07306", "filename": "4d640d4f600688e719c131131fbccc51e9824b2733ffe610f767101bb55b522f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Time continuity (0s-2.1s: no debris is produced when the drill bit enters the object) Physical behavior (2.2s-8s: when the drill bit is rotating at high speed, the wood chips are not thrown away by centrifugal force, but are instead \"adsorbed\" near the drill hole.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07308", "filename": "a66da3652a0f904266a5b70ffbcfd0e602766cf1c10f2bd28c90242086c9bc2e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 0s, the stones on the left side of the video appear granular; in the extended video segment, only the right side of the water surface shows ripples).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07309", "filename": "a66da3652a0f904266a5b70ffbcfd0e602766cf1c10f2bd28c90242086c9bc2e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the left railing and stones in the entire video appear granular and flicker).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07310", "filename": "a66da3652a0f904266a5b70ffbcfd0e602766cf1c10f2bd28c90242086c9bc2e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video footage is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the white light on the railing appears to wriggle between 0s and 3s, and ripples suddenly appear on the water surface in the video at 2.5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07311", "filename": "a66da3652a0f904266a5b70ffbcfd0e602766cf1c10f2bd28c90242086c9bc2e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the rocks and railings on the shore flicker throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07312", "filename": "a70bab5820dc3dbebab26e2c9846140bc7ea18be8215288c3f363bb4a087442b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the smoke on the white smoke disappears without external force moving downwards between 0s and 0.6s); Overall visual intuition is abnormal (the movement of the white smoke in the entire video is too regular and unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07313", "filename": "a70bab5820dc3dbebab26e2c9846140bc7ea18be8215288c3f363bb4a087442b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the smoke's movement in the entire scene is smooth and regular, lacking a natural feel).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07314", "filename": "a70bab5820dc3dbebab26e2c9846140bc7ea18be8215288c3f363bb4a087442b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the white smoke in the middle of the entire video increases upwards while disappearing on the left)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07315", "filename": "a96f5ac706a5fa877f04346d515926fa3b9c7fee5f4788aeb392e20775e6f66a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Cause and effect (the wind blows through the leaves throughout the video, but the lake surface in the video does not show any ripples due to the wind).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07316", "filename": "a96f5ac706a5fa877f04346d515926fa3b9c7fee5f4788aeb392e20775e6f66a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (the branch-like object on the water surface in the video disappears without any external force between 0s and 3.3s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07317", "filename": "a96f5ac706a5fa877f04346d515926fa3b9c7fee5f4788aeb392e20775e6f66a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07318", "filename": "a140eac8f2f6684f68365b013efa50b908a9b44f58bfa8a544d473bf1b0b30b7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the shape of the gemstone appears distorted in the middle of the entire video frame); Physical behavior (the gemstone moves irregularly without any external force in the entire video frame).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07319", "filename": "a140eac8f2f6684f68365b013efa50b908a9b44f58bfa8a544d473bf1b0b30b7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the colors reflected by the gemstones in the entire video are unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07320", "filename": "a140eac8f2f6684f68365b013efa50b908a9b44f58bfa8a544d473bf1b0b30b7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous (the colors reflected by the gems in the entire video are unnatural, and the shapes of the gems are distorted).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07321", "filename": "a182da47014398968fab46adf12bf8b8629a9aff1e1a17938060745b5fffffe3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 1.6s, the right-hand cart model does not follow the track but moves to the left across the track) Time continuity (from 2.6s to 3.1s, the green model of the right-hand cart appears behind the train model)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07322", "filename": "a182da47014398968fab46adf12bf8b8629a9aff1e1a17938060745b5fffffe3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The timing is continuous (at 0.7s, gravel suddenly appears on the left side of the track in the lower right corner; from 3s to 3.3s, the train model suddenly changes direction and moves to the right).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07323", "filename": "a182da47014398968fab46adf12bf8b8629a9aff1e1a17938060745b5fffffe3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07324", "filename": "a182da47014398968fab46adf12bf8b8629a9aff1e1a17938060745b5fffffe3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (the train model in the entire video is very light, but when the train passes over the track, the track as a whole is compressed downwards and then bounces upwards).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07325", "filename": "a191aed5a51301b1164ea4ae1ef2577016c02a39c1c8d3cd711d3669f742b66f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous time (water appears to flow across the surface of the diamond throughout the video, causing the diamond surface and its reflection below to jump erratically, and the white flash in the lower left corner continues to flicker).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07326", "filename": "a191aed5a51301b1164ea4ae1ef2577016c02a39c1c8d3cd711d3669f742b66f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.1s, the green beam of light in the upper left corner of the diamond suddenly disappears; at 0.8s, a shadow from another scene suddenly appears; at 2.6s, a blue light spot suddenly appears in the upper left corner; at 4.1s, a blue light spot suddenly appears in the upper left corner).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07327", "filename": "a191aed5a51301b1164ea4ae1ef2577016c02a39c1c8d3cd711d3669f742b66f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.1 seconds, a white circular shadow suddenly appears in the upper left corner of the video; at 2.9 seconds, a water stain-like shadow suddenly appears at the two corners above the gemstone; at 4.5 seconds, the light and shadow in the upper left corner of the diamond suddenly increases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07328", "filename": "a191aed5a51301b1164ea4ae1ef2577016c02a39c1c8d3cd711d3669f742b66f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (from 0.3s to 1.5s, the right corner of the square diamond disappears and its shape changes from square to round; at 6.2s, the white haze on the diamond suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07329", "filename": "a341d7f4f01b36f968abdf2cf194894aa22229cfef5170a3f3360b943595e934_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the smoke disappears by moving downwards without external force between 0s and 3.6s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07330", "filename": "a341d7f4f01b36f968abdf2cf194894aa22229cfef5170a3f3360b943595e934_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous (the smoke in the entire video appears grainy and lacks the smooth, natural movement of the smoke).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07331", "filename": "a341d7f4f01b36f968abdf2cf194894aa22229cfef5170a3f3360b943595e934_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the movement of the smoke in the entire scene is too smooth and perfect, and the smoke appears in a four-dimensional pattern, lacking the irregularity and naturalness of its movement).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07332", "filename": "a351f065b46af9a60c0dff79ae831e338852b2d8ef209d5a31e62763617f59e8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (in the entire video, only the area on the right side of the lake with the shadow of tree branches moves, while the lake surface reflecting the sky remains still).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07333", "filename": "a351f065b46af9a60c0dff79ae831e338852b2d8ef209d5a31e62763617f59e8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (in the entire video, only the area on the right side of the lake with the shadow of tree branches moves, while the tree branches above the lake do not move).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07334", "filename": "a351f065b46af9a60c0dff79ae831e338852b2d8ef209d5a31e62763617f59e8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (from 0s to 4s, the two thread-like objects in the middle of the lake appear to twist and disappear).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07335", "filename": "a487a710a81d879d3b3e3c05fb12d6248fda7d464b307246e7f568c558572a1f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (at 0s, the video feed shows another scene without transition and a long orange track appears; at 0.4s, the ball turns into a yellow car) Physical behavior (at 2.4s, the yellow car suddenly moves backward without any external force)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07336", "filename": "a487a710a81d879d3b3e3c05fb12d6248fda7d464b307246e7f568c558572a1f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Continuous time (the ball suddenly turns into a yellow car at 0.2s); Physical behavior (the yellow car jumps upwards without external force at 0.2s; the yellow car suddenly moves backwards at 2.6s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07341", "filename": "95b890a29e63db07c1f4ec4f77fe127918f332ba3f891662f1bff840e4ebf06b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07342", "filename": "95b890a29e63db07c1f4ec4f77fe127918f332ba3f891662f1bff840e4ebf06b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: continuous time (at 3.6 seconds in the video, water suddenly overflows from the pipe in the center of the frame until the end of the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07343", "filename": "95b890a29e63db07c1f4ec4f77fe127918f332ba3f891662f1bff840e4ebf06b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07344", "filename": "95b890a29e63db07c1f4ec4f77fe127918f332ba3f891662f1bff840e4ebf06b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07348", "filename": "096b2912c15ea8174411d7873c788b3df53faaaeeac5965488f14bbe3c0911b2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time duration (after 2.7 seconds in the video, the crushed items begin to automatically reassemble after the hydraulic press lifts up).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07349", "filename": "096b2912c15ea8174411d7873c788b3df53faaaeeac5965488f14bbe3c0911b2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07350", "filename": "096b2912c15ea8174411d7873c788b3df53faaaeeac5965488f14bbe3c0911b2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: At 1.9 seconds, the soil being pressed by the hydraulic press transforms into a cement-like substance, different from the original.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07351", "filename": "96bb27947a7e8f09dbe431617db92018e97a0f2f4de4affa994a39aded595a5b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07352", "filename": "96bb27947a7e8f09dbe431617db92018e97a0f2f4de4affa994a39aded595a5b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video error: The video became blurry after 4.3 seconds.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07353", "filename": "96bb27947a7e8f09dbe431617db92018e97a0f2f4de4affa994a39aded595a5b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07354", "filename": "96d91664d71d7eec106ae9066c8743aebfd05d9e306277096af6dc5dafc65f26_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the physical properties are distorted, the straw does not refract or deform when it enters the water, which violates the physical law of light refraction.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07355", "filename": "96d91664d71d7eec106ae9066c8743aebfd05d9e306277096af6dc5dafc65f26_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (after 4.8 seconds, bubbles rush across the water surface and appear in the air; after 5.1 seconds, the part of the second straw inserted into the water above the water surface turns into bubbles and then disappears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07356", "filename": "96d91664d71d7eec106ae9066c8743aebfd05d9e306277096af6dc5dafc65f26_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (no refraction occurs after the straw is inserted into the water, violating the laws of physics).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07357", "filename": "96d91664d71d7eec106ae9066c8743aebfd05d9e306277096af6dc5dafc65f26_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07358", "filename": "97b75b911fd053ee74804cff00956fa26d0ce43dcdf737d7ad65cfcf311e5008_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.2s in the image, the tail of the second hand is not in a straight line with the second hand; and the hour hand does not move with the movement of the second and minute hands).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07359", "filename": "97b75b911fd053ee74804cff00956fa26d0ce43dcdf737d7ad65cfcf311e5008_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall visuals are abnormal (at 0.3s, the second hand suddenly turns red and becomes longer, and then the second hand keeps rotating randomly; the minute hand does not rotate; after 1.4s, the ice cubes in the blue plate grow larger over time, and the water in the plate also increases over time, which does not conform to the laws of physics).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07360", "filename": "97b75b911fd053ee74804cff00956fa26d0ce43dcdf737d7ad65cfcf311e5008_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (a shadow slides across the back of the clock between 0s and 2.3s in the video; and the minute and hour hands do not move with the second hand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07361", "filename": "97dae0b769c7c6b7c23f3c6e1512557fede7d5faab3da754ce9845fade6e97c1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time is continuous (at 3.2 seconds, a sausage suddenly appears out of nowhere in the pot in the footage).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07362", "filename": "97dae0b769c7c6b7c23f3c6e1512557fede7d5faab3da754ce9845fade6e97c1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (the sausages in the pan cook too quickly in the video) and abnormal duration (an extra sausage appears out of nowhere at 3.3s and 3.9s in the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07363", "filename": "97dae0b769c7c6b7c23f3c6e1512557fede7d5faab3da754ce9845fade6e97c1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07367", "filename": "e05ff3928dc28dd5b92aaf67b581d80dbdf518ede71d85f6de451b164bdb8767_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (at 5.9 seconds, the coffee overflows from the cup, but remains stationary on the cup wall. Due to gravity, the coffee should flow down the cup wall.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07368", "filename": "e5bdcaac3ee2654a30b222c6e84744b1668e6b57bd792aedffa7e5e998d37342_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0.6s-4.8s) shows liquid oil increasing in a heated pan, while the volume of solid butter remains constant.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07370", "filename": "e5d1551d26d821165975543004cf1d771f2366b3076d319eac487d4a9e030c64_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the video shows a cardboard box being violently burned, but the box retains its shape. Cardboard boxes should rapidly carbonize, shrink, and become brittle when subjected to intense burning).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07371", "filename": "e5e7ef49cfc6674dbc569cc0cf6d870b571e74634d501780d49bedd1ccfcb9db_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the paper is not moving, but the reflected object in the cup is slowly decreasing in size).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07372", "filename": "e6c1d2be91faec605d456c62a8dd1455de01f5a69009ce4180da9614f70cf90d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the edges of the houses and plants in the image are too rounded, resembling a cartoon rather than a realistic scene).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07373", "filename": "e6ee4b54d0a3c28c94893b69fb58e862b122d8e1c48bc66b9be73e55e57bd604_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (a transparent liquid suddenly turns blue without external force between 0.3s and 1.3s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07374", "filename": "e7a90ab893a60d79142294c14cacccae999c722e989c954d999883c07f2940a5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the entire video shows noticeable stuttering and frame drops as the clouds drift across the sky.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07375", "filename": "e7b03a570e87b3923cb10ddfefe61db345c32125d8af71bf8ae640ecb950dd5b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly: (The liquid in the cup in the character's hand is not decreasing as it is poured out).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07377", "filename": "e08a67ae7b5452668a10e6b770a61edcdcb92c0e6e28c4b3daf0797eccc37184_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07378", "filename": "e8e0e10b0d79f6a16fdf1584f7d8f7e3862525f8bdd434476193482393e664b5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (0.2s-6.2s). The duck in the center of the lake appears to be visibly stuck while swimming, and the surface of the lake does not ripple as the duck swims.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07379", "filename": "e8e813dc3f89d172c5196a713758eeecd7737c2f31af6b1e10a4229e56a71b1b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is unusual because of its continuous timing (the entire video is an overhead shot of a thin mist in the mountains, which appears stationary. Due to airflow, the mist may appear to move slowly or dissipate).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07380", "filename": "e52e2beb5c70c3e5162dfe639f1a9ac5d25ddfd77bf0e4eb4ac7d3982b455120_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: During the continuous time frame (from 0.4s to 3.7s, the water glass on the table rolls automatically without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07381", "filename": "e56b6c9a2751f9e8a22a015258f3eba9afedb11e293b8a4425b06498f0dbbad2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (dynamic flickering defects on the surface of the crystal ball).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07382", "filename": "e59f29549f38d51b75127f2130c7fd3cb96d5296d4226592bb1c4e6a728667b0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (trees appear as flickering, wriggling elements).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07383", "filename": "e69f04da03ebf607069d4684ff0e141209fd142b89f2e1605cdbc068fcc76489_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07385", "filename": "e76c984f6cadcbb50122a2b07ff93d5fe2fedaabad84fafd22692b0422b27683_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (The sun is positioned above the horizon of the sea of clouds, its sunlight is orange-red and directly hitting the clouds, while the clouds are dark blue. High-altitude clouds have reflective properties, so the clouds should appear bright red-orange.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07387", "filename": "e92ae6bfef2d02ab60936d226a83a675e2619fa8b791abc4cc3ad6712051316d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the water level in the pool drops rapidly between 4.1s and 7.9s, indicating that the pool is being drained. During the draining process, due to the Coriolis effect, the water should descend in a vortex and produce many ripples, rather than descending smoothly.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07388", "filename": "e111a0db83061ead33d1d97fdf89abb991684c43b1189d863eeebddab2763258_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the calm lake surface of the waterfall is dark blue, while the rapidly cascading water at the cliff edge is turquoise, and there is a clear dividing line where the calm lake surface meets the cliff-cut water flow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07389", "filename": "e142afb15282b1569ca0cffe0f5ce1bbdc4683ae37f2fa6f0b4f1bef3a956796_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (The video shows fireworks exploding directly in mid-air without any upward trail. Fireworks are launched from the ground into the sky; as they rise, the gunpowder burns, producing incandescent particles that, due to gravity, create a trailing effect.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07390", "filename": "e250b9560515059c0a0ef9b50273b78c7008565240829ff23a3b0c6140a7e502_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous in time (real auroras are blocked or penetrated by clouds, but the aurora in the video is layered and superimposed with the clouds, without any real light and shadow interaction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07391", "filename": "e303a96e46985d0ee1a6d6373d607035eb23c5c96f57c3337e520c80f11bad98_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (In the image, the setting sun's rays are unobstructed, with only one beam directly hitting the earth. The sunlight, refracted and reflected by atmospheric water droplets, should diffuse in all directions, illuminating the surrounding area.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07392", "filename": "e662ca7ff71c526d771b5d66284223e09ec7975a26ab8fbbbf6d60ef0bcbdc73_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Cause and effect (In the image, a large amount of water vapor from a water gun is sprayed onto a towel on the ground, yet the towel shows no signs of being soaked. If the towel were heavily soaked, most of it should appear light black.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07393", "filename": "e690e0ee6b68e3a4fe97bae15e82d0c3e15d1fb01891411c70ca2b28ae242ecd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (the image does not change as the sunlight shines on the leaves, even when the leaves are swaying).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07394", "filename": "e706ddd7b8735652457151fa7230a0823b69a0bc907a74b3d021ad623b24d1ca_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07395", "filename": "e736f8650969ab1696441504b24a9efe5c864d9e429c02a74a0682f20367937b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07396", "filename": "e1415c0ab271599971dadc858814c2d198901223b4da8aabbc72d7c5ac43b8cc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is inconsistent (the movement of the brown leaves in the lower left corner of the video is noticeably choppy and the light is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07398", "filename": "6cd47390a363feeb74cb45dd9191a553d02c659d3c3653dfe3813d78bbc26441_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the entire video screen flickers and the image is blurry).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07399", "filename": "6cd47390a363feeb74cb45dd9191a553d02c659d3c3653dfe3813d78bbc26441_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the sun appears as a uniform orange-yellow patch without a gradual halo, and the sea is dark and not illuminated by sunlight).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07400", "filename": "6ce193d6556fbedc07109264ec37b99306db449370bca748e7befd5d9e488159_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Based on the principle of molecular diffusion, the hot steam rising from the pot in the image is diffusing too quickly).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07401", "filename": "6ce193d6556fbedc07109264ec37b99306db449370bca748e7befd5d9e488159_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 3.5s, without any external force, the hot steam coming out of the pot suddenly changed direction and spread to the upper right).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07403", "filename": "6ce193d6556fbedc07109264ec37b99306db449370bca748e7befd5d9e488159_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (Based on the principle of random molecular motion, without any external force, the gas suddenly rotates inward in a vortex shape from 1.2s to 2.4s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07404", "filename": "6d2e0094efa932e858db291d5d5c0ee7c0e004ccb2509fb40a1c7bbd447e6221_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.4s, no smoke comes out from the burning part of the cigarette butt, but a cloud of smoke appears out of nowhere from the middle of the cigarette).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07405", "filename": "6d2e0094efa932e858db291d5d5c0ee7c0e004ccb2509fb40a1c7bbd447e6221_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (between 2s and 5.8s, the burning portion of the cigarette butt spontaneously moves towards the already burned ash).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07406", "filename": "6d2e0094efa932e858db291d5d5c0ee7c0e004ccb2509fb40a1c7bbd447e6221_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the shape of the smoke is too clear and sharp, which does not match the blurry and dynamic shape of natural smoke diffusion).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07407", "filename": "6d2e0094efa932e858db291d5d5c0ee7c0e004ccb2509fb40a1c7bbd447e6221_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (at 2.1 seconds, the red-hot area of the burning cigarette butt suddenly shifts from the burning position to the tip of the ash, disrupting the temporal continuity and spatial plausibility of the burning process).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07408", "filename": "6d60fb7619e590bc65b8956768944d948091f3cfb2c4cef3f69e8d698b58a612_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.3s, a white dot flickers slightly below the colored liquid in the image).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07409", "filename": "6d60fb7619e590bc65b8956768944d948091f3cfb2c4cef3f69e8d698b58a612_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Cause and Effect (The liquids in the image are noticeably more yellow and orange, with less purple; after the liquids blend together, the overall color of the image gradually turns purple starting at 3.3 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07410", "filename": "6d60fb7619e590bc65b8956768944d948091f3cfb2c4cef3f69e8d698b58a612_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (According to the molecular diffusion theorem and the law of conservation of energy, the diffusion rate of molecules should be the same under the same environment. In the image, the liquid at the bottom is moving slowly, while the liquid at the top is moving rapidly.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07411", "filename": "6d79a177b6b0fa2901efc627d3295dde159e195c50d96c24cb08710c32a77a3e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (between 2.7s and 3s, when the hand grabs the small yellow cube and drops it into the cup, there is no impact sensation when it falls into the cup, and the image is blurry).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07412", "filename": "6d79a177b6b0fa2901efc627d3295dde159e195c50d96c24cb08710c32a77a3e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (According to the law of gravity, the finger only touches the small yellow square in 0.6s, but the small square spontaneously floats up with the finger).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07413", "filename": "6d79a177b6b0fa2901efc627d3295dde159e195c50d96c24cb08710c32a77a3e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07414", "filename": "6d79a177b6b0fa2901efc627d3295dde159e195c50d96c24cb08710c32a77a3e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 7s, when the hand pinches the green square, the green square suddenly disappears and then suddenly reappears at 7.5s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07415", "filename": "6d81c2f27f7275d15ca54b27cac18a4fdfb1b4ded8654bb088baf7c725d0544e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Time continuity (the video image flickers violently, and the speed of the flame movement far exceeds the dynamic characteristics of real combustion, disrupting the temporal continuity and natural movement logic of the visual content).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07416", "filename": "6d81c2f27f7275d15ca54b27cac18a4fdfb1b4ded8654bb088baf7c725d0544e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Based on the characteristic of flames to emit light and heat, at 4.04, the flame is still burning, but the wooden block in the middle of the flame has darkened).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07417", "filename": "6d81c2f27f7275d15ca54b27cac18a4fdfb1b4ded8654bb088baf7c725d0544e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07418", "filename": "6d81c2f27f7275d15ca54b27cac18a4fdfb1b4ded8654bb088baf7c725d0544e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the wood is continuously burning on both sides in the video, but the main body of the wood remains black, without any visual characteristics such as discoloration or carbonization caused by being baked by the flames).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07419", "filename": "6d2865de888497ceb80f6dbbcbc965afe5f3720d1b8ee4bbe3b54dc0f2cc2de9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (Throughout the entire video, the water in the pot was about to boil, but no steam was coming out of the surface).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07420", "filename": "6d2865de888497ceb80f6dbbcbc965afe5f3720d1b8ee4bbe3b54dc0f2cc2de9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07421", "filename": "6d6347bd719afe0125ed87bc5c103a3e541aad8cf2ce9f301797c4eee9672cc6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the image of the small beads that make up the small ball, visible through the holes in the middle of the ball, spontaneously distorts and warps).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07422", "filename": "6d6347bd719afe0125ed87bc5c103a3e541aad8cf2ce9f301797c4eee9672cc6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.7 seconds, the shape of the ball being held in the hand changes abruptly without any external force, and at 0.8 seconds, the video flickers momentarily, as if it were a connection between two video segments).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07423", "filename": "6d6347bd719afe0125ed87bc5c103a3e541aad8cf2ce9f301797c4eee9672cc6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07424", "filename": "6d6347bd719afe0125ed87bc5c103a3e541aad8cf2ce9f301797c4eee9672cc6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07427", "filename": "1717bf2a1ce06c8842fad4d800c0472666aa3338b3f87361c720955c7b2983a2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is abnormal (the trajectory of the sparks and light in the video is typical of fireworks, with the sparks exploding in a regular radial pattern, extremely bright and golden in color, which is the form of a fireworks explosion, rather than sparks that naturally burst out in a fire).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07431", "filename": "1984bf96c80acf0e62c6a50af012b80afa4913d1ebf63f5cb1f7628a3ab96aa2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 2.9 seconds into the video, a yellow object on the waves disappears out of thin air without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07432", "filename": "1984bf96c80acf0e62c6a50af012b80afa4913d1ebf63f5cb1f7628a3ab96aa2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 1.6s to the end of the video, the waves are surging and crashing, but the people swimming on the waves are not propelled by the waves and are still swimming in a normal posture, which violates the interaction of forces).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07433", "filename": "1984bf96c80acf0e62c6a50af012b80afa4913d1ebf63f5cb1f7628a3ab96aa2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 3.2 seconds into the video, a person suddenly appears out of nowhere on the waves on the right side of the screen without the camera changing direction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07434", "filename": "1984bf96c80acf0e62c6a50af012b80afa4913d1ebf63f5cb1f7628a3ab96aa2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (at 1.2s in the video, the person on the right side of the screen suddenly changes from standing in the water to kneeling on a surfboard without the camera changing position).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07435", "filename": "2175ab31176cf6d841d7e8cdde90a4fa268fa20c56136dfee9ca64dd121d5b22_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical effect (Throughout the video, the stone pillar remains suspended above the water, violating the law of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07436", "filename": "2175ab31176cf6d841d7e8cdde90a4fa268fa20c56136dfee9ca64dd121d5b22_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, there are no ripples on the water surface, but the reflection of the stone pillar keeps twitching, which violates the principle of light reflection).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07437", "filename": "2175ab31176cf6d841d7e8cdde90a4fa268fa20c56136dfee9ca64dd121d5b22_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video is not continuous (at 3.7 seconds into the video, there is a noticeable stutter).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07438", "filename": "2424a1a6e62c500614e265914416d83ded2784f34b29df3d87f2f4c6bdc3c6a2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the butter is heated and melted in the pot throughout the video, and the amount of melted oil in the pot is constantly increasing, but the volume of the butter block remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07439", "filename": "2424a1a6e62c500614e265914416d83ded2784f34b29df3d87f2f4c6bdc3c6a2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall impression (the butter melts too quickly and the melting is too smooth, lacking physical texture and natural dynamic layering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07440", "filename": "2424a1a6e62c500614e265914416d83ded2784f34b29df3d87f2f4c6bdc3c6a2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 3.1s to the end of the video, the oil layer left after the butter slids showed obvious breaks and did not naturally re-merge, violating the principle of liquid fluidity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07441", "filename": "2424a1a6e62c500614e265914416d83ded2784f34b29df3d87f2f4c6bdc3c6a2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is continuous (at 4.9s in the video, the scene switches abruptly without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07442", "filename": "2434db1fc08b4bd85cba7d42b742678e29ff5ec829269104de07cc1f45cd4c4f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The time sequence is continuous (from 1.7 seconds to the end of the video, white debris appears out of thin air above the computer in the video without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07443", "filename": "2434db1fc08b4bd85cba7d42b742678e29ff5ec829269104de07cc1f45cd4c4f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07444", "filename": "2434db1fc08b4bd85cba7d42b742678e29ff5ec829269104de07cc1f45cd4c4f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 3.6s to the end of the video, the monitor on the left is suspended in the air, violating the law of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07445", "filename": "2434db1fc08b4bd85cba7d42b742678e29ff5ec829269104de07cc1f45cd4c4f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (in the video, the clock's time keeps changing irregularly).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07446", "filename": "2435fc51f6224a3de844b34f4c4cee34657aa8603fc82f9fcf85c2794745e8d5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical effects (at 1.6s in the video, the small bead on the left side of the screen directly passes through the large bead, violating the principle that solids are impermeable) and temporal continuity (at 1.7s, the two beads in the screen suddenly merge into one without any change in the camera angle, and at 4s, the green object in the large bead disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07447", "filename": "2435fc51f6224a3de844b34f4c4cee34657aa8603fc82f9fcf85c2794745e8d5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (In the entire video, when the white transparent ball falls to the ground, a large amount of sand appears out of nowhere and flies up; at 4.4 seconds, the two falling transparent balls suddenly merge into one).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07448", "filename": "2435fc51f6224a3de844b34f4c4cee34657aa8603fc82f9fcf85c2794745e8d5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: The overall visuals are abnormal (at 2.2s in the video, without any change in the camera angle, the floor suddenly becomes liquid; at 3.5s, the red object in the large water droplet disappears into thin air the instant it touches the ground).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07449", "filename": "2435fc51f6224a3de844b34f4c4cee34657aa8603fc82f9fcf85c2794745e8d5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.7s, the three transparent balls on the left suddenly develop white patterns inside after landing, without the camera changing; at 2.4s, the fourth transparent ball suddenly develops yellow patterns inside).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07454", "filename": "2694aade132f4fbd5f391f8c546bb9fbbdecf675327f265d9ce0315bf4c4c082_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.2s in the video, two small insects on the left side of the screen suddenly merge into one without the camera changing, and at 2.5s, the merged insect disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07455", "filename": "2694aade132f4fbd5f391f8c546bb9fbbdecf675327f265d9ce0315bf4c4c082_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (at 0.6 seconds into the video, the a small fish at the bottom of the screen disappears out of thin air without any change in camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07456", "filename": "2694aade132f4fbd5f391f8c546bb9fbbdecf675327f265d9ce0315bf4c4c082_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07457", "filename": "P04_106_41_4c252a66c1b13d6d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (4.4s-5s). The dough was kneaded without leaving fingerprints, and the surface was too smooth with no indentations.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07458", "filename": "P04_106_41_4c252a66c1b13d6d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07459", "filename": "P04_106_109_d65292f24b2e8104_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (in the footage from 2.9s to 5.1s, a finger touches the marinated meat, but the finger is too clean and has no oil residue).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07460", "filename": "P04_106_109_d65292f24b2e8104_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time sequence is continuous (4.2s-6.3s). When the single-layer aluminum foil, which was not fixed, was pressed by hand, the foil did not deform.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07461", "filename": "P04_107_23_576dcbfb3e1b9c35_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07462", "filename": "P04_107_70_1a288fce546cb48a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (2.8s-4.4s: the screen shows scissors cutting paper, but only half of the paper is cut; the paper then automatically separates into two sheets.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07463", "filename": "P04_107_70_1a288fce546cb48a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07464", "filename": "P04_107_70_1a288fce546cb48a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 3.9 seconds, the paper was only cut halfway, and the entire sheet of paper automatically split into two parts.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07465", "filename": "P04_107_241_f189aea03aa7f347_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (3.7s-4.6s, the hand has stopped spreading the dough, but the dough is still stretching).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07466", "filename": "P04_107_241_f189aea03aa7f347_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition is abnormal (uncoordinated body movements; the left hand is kneading dough, but it's floating in mid-air without touching the dough).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07467", "filename": "P04_107_241_f189aea03aa7f347_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07468", "filename": "P04_107_328_0ef61777df5c80f1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual error: The timing is continuous (from 1.1s to 1.8s, the rolling pin is used only with the right hand, and the force is insufficient to turn the dough into a sheet).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07469", "filename": "P04_107_328_0ef61777df5c80f1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the human movements in the image are too smooth, lacking the sense of force and pauses characteristic of rolling dough in real life).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07470", "filename": "P04_107_330_d35f7c7e22ee678c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the dough does not deform when rolled out with a rolling pin in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07471", "filename": "P04_107_330_d35f7c7e22ee678c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07472", "filename": "P04_107_354_4e7748a34ef819ac_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07473", "filename": "P04_107_354_4e7748a34ef819ac_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (between 3.8s and 4.4s, the rolling pin in the left hand suddenly flashes to the right hand.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07474", "filename": "P04_107_357_c3b6e9ab1ed72310_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07475", "filename": "P04_107_405_bc093441d06e111d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (between 1.3s and 3.4s, a piece of dough suddenly splits into two pieces without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07476", "filename": "P04_107_405_bc093441d06e111d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07477", "filename": "P04_107_405_bc093441d06e111d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07478", "filename": "P04_107_440_3ecbd3778c211fcf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07479", "filename": "P04_107_475_099c8cf14be753a6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is illogical: the timing is inconsistent (from 1.2s to 1.6s, the scene suddenly changes from a hand picking something up from a table to a plate of dumplings on the ground).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07480", "filename": "P04_107_475_099c8cf14be753a6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (3.4s-4.6s, with the left hand empty, a plate of dumplings appears out of thin air in the left hand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07481", "filename": "P04_107_482_3999590abc0aff09_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07482", "filename": "P04_107_482_3999590abc0aff09_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07483", "filename": "P04_107_491_7dc5a85c8d06ec8f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07484", "filename": "P04_107_559_82e0189225300ef7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the figure's movements while rolling out dough are too smooth, lacking the jerky, forceful motion of rolling, unlike a realistic scene).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07485", "filename": "P04_107_689_d8b57a30d8421e93_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 2.6s to 4.5s, the hand is not holding the rolling pin, but the rolling pin is still rolling).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07486", "filename": "P04_104_279_e86cd0128a49949b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (between 3.9s and 5.1s, while the hand is still inside the cabinet, the door closes directly through the hand).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07487", "filename": "5561c32c6ca36c943946a0e0cc891ff5b616d917fdcc6fd17e12a6d45bb5ca9b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The sequence of events is continuous (an explosion occurs at 3.6 seconds, but there are no traces of the explosion on the ground, and the forest in the background is abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07488", "filename": "5561c32c6ca36c943946a0e0cc891ff5b616d917fdcc6fd17e12a6d45bb5ca9b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The sequence of events is continuous (the scene begins with no objects on the ground, then an explosion occurs out of thin air, and at 4.5 seconds, the white dust produced by the explosion suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07490", "filename": "5721a2fcc29c17e9a1830709cdda3c132dadc693ca83d72c49723ed84a470549_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Physical Abnormalities (This video exhibits looping and physical anomalies. The scene repeatedly switches between two images: one showing someone splashing water to create mist in front of a green house, and the other showing two red toy cars parked on the snow. There are no transition frames, suggesting the scenes were forcibly edited and spliced together. Furthermore, the mist created by the splashed water is incorrect. Normally, splashed water mist would quickly disperse due to gravity and air resistance, but here the mist remains in a clump and floats slowly without any noticeable change in shape.)", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07491", "filename": "5818cdd8e8a030041597f076862e4f0afdff7e085a5d1cefa902b3308d58d326_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07492", "filename": "5947d38ada897d55fc8aaf9bbe01474f62446fc7afcddd29b71ab39be85c5971_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen error: The timing is continuous (at 1.4s, the paper in the printer and the printed paper below connect at both ends to form a complete sheet of paper).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07493", "filename": "6466ff93ab75c236d2d0e31434ae2d315cdbe3aa4071332112e8c010d441935c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time frame is continuous (without external force and no oxygen-generating substances in the water, bubbles appear out of thin air in the glass from beginning to end).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07494", "filename": "6654d2ac6a7bab880d7da9a9c515efd2593c7a75d4ffa2f3c322684e2b724c20_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: (With continuous time and no change in shooting angle, the movement of the sun in the video is abnormal. It rises rapidly from below the clouds to above the clouds and then quickly falls back below the clouds, which does not conform to the normal trajectory of the sun.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07495", "filename": "7034feded29f204b142705bb8d8bda93bb606c0185e77ca10873c9506d2bb9b4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (at 2.4s, the tongue in the mouth connects with the right cheek, forming a single unit; at 2.9s, the connection suddenly disappears without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07496", "filename": "7055aaacb92b339f8696272814769788aefc4107ff314db7e3af35a125dc7b8b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the yellow object on the left wall in the entire image is abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07498", "filename": "7111b9eef0ca95ba837f0df8ee5641684c87e653718098fef58ba91d6b4649ff_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the wires of the light tube in the video do not form a complete closed circuit. According to circuit principles, charges cannot move in a direction to form a current, yet the light tube is still lit, which does not conform to the basic working conditions of a circuit. Moreover, when the light tube is lit, there are no signs of slight flickering or electric field interference that should be present due to gas discharge. The entire lighting process appears to be an energy output without any loss.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07499", "filename": "7111b9eef0ca95ba837f0df8ee5641684c87e653718098fef58ba91d6b4649ff_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Continuous time (the light color of the lamp can switch from yellow to white irregularly, which does not conform to the working logic of a gas discharge lamp).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07501", "filename": "7392fb10a64a751563acbf16cc95f604b04b9d5a4a6cb1df101a4ec3bf8bd3a1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1.8 seconds, the eggshell in the upper left corner suddenly turns into a stone).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07502", "filename": "7392fb10a64a751563acbf16cc95f604b04b9d5a4a6cb1df101a4ec3bf8bd3a1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the egg breaks before the bullet even hits it at 2.1s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07503", "filename": "7392fb10a64a751563acbf16cc95f604b04b9d5a4a6cb1df101a4ec3bf8bd3a1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the bullet hits the egg at 2.5s and hangs in mid-air at the left end of the egg).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07504", "filename": "7444b462a2fae5f03b7791573ad4b55538b1d599d04d1950d835f79f2695fa3c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: In a continuous time frame (with a constant light source), the color of the glowing blocks in the image deepens between 0.6s and 8s.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07505", "filename": "7748d08cf32cac6c86ec1eaae591ebee48ef40378bafa3aed1d6bce1b30655c0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the middle part of the spring suddenly disappears between 0.1s and 6.7s, and then reappears after the spring returns to its original state).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07506", "filename": "7826b5f162370c3078985eaaaf198ad0b7ac0d326c71020d510284a87f1d5ae3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The overall visual is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the fireworks and reflections in the video show obvious signs of repeated cycles, and the fireworks do not dissipate naturally after exploding; before the previous round of fireworks has faded, the next round of identical fireworks explodes in the same location, which does not conform to the normal physical process of fireworks burning, emitting light, and extinguishing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07507", "filename": "7826b5f162370c3078985eaaaf198ad0b7ac0d326c71020d510284a87f1d5ae3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The overall visual is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the fireworks and reflections in the video show obvious signs of repeated cycles, and the fireworks do not dissipate naturally after exploding; before the previous round of fireworks has faded, the next round of identical fireworks explodes in the same location, which does not conform to the normal physical process of fireworks burning, emitting light, and extinguishing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07509", "filename": "8040a1e9368f316d279c8deea161b912269ba8fa90c38f30bc163839fff7cef9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is due to physical behavior (at 2.9s, the white cloth bag in the person's hand passes through their fingers and onto the back of their hand, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07510", "filename": "8095a384cffe043e847c6b0d8ad81c54dfa7b99721374aad61a11234c70c7a8a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07511", "filename": "8889a695e4b6ab221d98469b6e92500f792897f6e147492ab84c2af019573a02_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is as follows: (During the period from 0s to 1.1s, the glider and the trailing smoke suddenly appear in the valley without any warning, without any takeoff or release process; secondly, his flight attitude is completely unaffected by gravity, as if he is suspended in mid-air, and the shape of the smoke behind him does not dissipate or change due to airflow, maintaining a fixed relative position with the glider, which violates the laws of fluid dynamics and gravity.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07512", "filename": "8889a695e4b6ab221d98469b6e92500f792897f6e147492ab84c2af019573a02_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the mountain on the left side of the video appears to be twisting and writhing abnormally throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07513", "filename": "8889a695e4b6ab221d98469b6e92500f792897f6e147492ab84c2af019573a02_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is inconsistent (0s-0.1s, when the character is gliding through the clouds, a new piece of clothing suddenly appears on their body, which is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07514", "filename": "8965c28c3e5b73877bb8ebf0b5ab73956d7802d8fd4e81c6cc9cfcd498a72e47_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (In the entire video, when the hydraulic press is pressed down, although the metal block bends, the compressed part does not extend outward, maintaining a neat edge, and there are no cracks or wrinkles commonly seen when metal is under pressure. It looks like it is being folded rather than crushed, which does not conform to the plastic deformation law of metal materials under high pressure.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07515", "filename": "9090c5dd0e0af93739b17cd7270b70002e530cd2affcbbb6a822917ff6cd8ba8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the upper left part of the hydraulic press is abnormally distorted in the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07516", "filename": "9186d51d96e4eb74036fb12bcd9223eaaca31d411404caee92762e2a869774cc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (the entire video shows water jets hitting the water like ice blocks).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07517", "filename": "9280bd8ccb93ce7e07cc10862e7addda4ebffbd48fab55c03dfd55c470d2165a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07518", "filename": "9280bd8ccb93ce7e07cc10862e7addda4ebffbd48fab55c03dfd55c470d2165a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous in time (at 3.1 seconds, the amount of liquid flowing down from the burning candle suddenly increases, which is inconsistent with the preceding and following scenes).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07519", "filename": "9547b92811284d22a9538c8b51a0b430d896402fb3f93ee4dbe62b4b3239c3bd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07520", "filename": "9866edde11467c0ee8cc23aa069c02c5e00edee398159bb3df63eee504186e10_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07521", "filename": "012357b8a5e57726ed5e84c718772a3f65489ba792a5e85b6df6a5d42719d881_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07522", "filename": "3aeeab03424a6aad7ecd30371337463441a6cb7c414613291896631b5b5833ba_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the lake surface has ripples, while the trees by the lake and the clouds in the sky remain completely still, which is unrealistic).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07523", "filename": "3aeeab03424a6aad7ecd30371337463441a6cb7c414613291896631b5b5833ba_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the clouds in the upper right corner and the clouds on the mountainside do not move as the camera zooms in, which is unrealistic).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07524", "filename": "3af2dcb09a625df6f7c3e8cc2c847817f2f68b52112c08ff5060d0e211c002bd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07525", "filename": "3af2dcb09a625df6f7c3e8cc2c847817f2f68b52112c08ff5060d0e211c002bd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.7 seconds into the video, a large amount of smoke is emitted from the chimney, but the connection between the smoke and the chimney is semi-transparent, unlike real footage).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07526", "filename": "3af2dcb09a625df6f7c3e8cc2c847817f2f68b52112c08ff5060d0e211c002bd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the entire screen is filled with smoke at 2.4s and 4.4s, and white granular substances are also appearing out of nowhere from the chimney).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07527", "filename": "3b49df62fd61c89e4db1eaa248d4707c6af4da4d4e8f51c2e6e0b311bcebfc5d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not working properly: the timing is too long (the first two lightning bolts in the video lasted too long, continuing until the end. Lightning should be instantaneous. At 5 seconds, the clouds were still, but lightning appeared, which is not realistic).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07528", "filename": "3b49df62fd61c89e4db1eaa248d4707c6af4da4d4e8f51c2e6e0b311bcebfc5d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07529", "filename": "3b49df62fd61c89e4db1eaa248d4707c6af4da4d4e8f51c2e6e0b311bcebfc5d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: (The clouds in the lower right corner of the image appear out of thin air and are not part of the actual image.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07530", "filename": "3b49df62fd61c89e4db1eaa248d4707c6af4da4d4e8f51c2e6e0b311bcebfc5d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07531", "filename": "3be7c792ed7354a72a3f6fd38650c7237214f96699781d982e58c31f8ef369ec_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: physical behavior (the yellow object enters the water at 2.1s, grows larger and then shrinks again, which does not match the real image).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07532", "filename": "3be7c792ed7354a72a3f6fd38650c7237214f96699781d982e58c31f8ef369ec_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07533", "filename": "3be7c792ed7354a72a3f6fd38650c7237214f96699781d982e58c31f8ef369ec_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to the physical behavior (the water level did not change after an object was placed in the water between 1.4s and 3.3s, which violates Archimedes' principle).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07537", "filename": "3bfd3417f1d85fa3be06f39b53a5dfc8b52bc91ac729c15038a3dade1ebfaebb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (from 1.7s to 4.5s, the bushes in the center of the frame are swaying, unlike when they are being blown by the wind).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07538", "filename": "3bfd3417f1d85fa3be06f39b53a5dfc8b52bc91ac729c15038a3dade1ebfaebb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07539", "filename": "3bfd3417f1d85fa3be06f39b53a5dfc8b52bc91ac729c15038a3dade1ebfaebb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07540", "filename": "3c01b3531330e3fb6f90e27fbc540816a84552dce63e1a121765d558595fbef3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (during the period of 0.6s-4.6s, the writing trajectory of the pen does not match the font presented on the paper).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07541", "filename": "3c01b3531330e3fb6f90e27fbc540816a84552dce63e1a121765d558595fbef3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: Time continuity (characters suddenly appear on the paper at 0.3s, and the pen's movement trajectory does not correspond to the characters generated on the paper from 0.3s to 4.4s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07542", "filename": "3c01b3531330e3fb6f90e27fbc540816a84552dce63e1a121765d558595fbef3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (2.5s-2.9s, the pen moves on the paper without leaving any trace).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07543", "filename": "3c01b3531330e3fb6f90e27fbc540816a84552dce63e1a121765d558595fbef3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a semi-circular stroke suddenly appears at 6.6s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07544", "filename": "3c1d33cfe288740b5a3bc74bb5e19b057d291df7f8ba238dbd84fa7f4f88a1db_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (0s-0.9s, the object on the right moves without being subjected to force). Abnormal physical behavior: (1.9s, the spring coil on the left pierces through the steel plate).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07545", "filename": "3c1d33cfe288740b5a3bc74bb5e19b057d291df7f8ba238dbd84fa7f4f88a1db_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (the steel plates that were raised on both sides of the spring coil suddenly disappeared at 0.2s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07546", "filename": "3c1d33cfe288740b5a3bc74bb5e19b057d291df7f8ba238dbd84fa7f4f88a1db_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (4.6s, the first coil connecting the left side of the spring to the steel plate of the trolley suddenly disappears)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07547", "filename": "3c1d33cfe288740b5a3bc74bb5e19b057d291df7f8ba238dbd84fa7f4f88a1db_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07552", "filename": "d14face55e11a39b8a3bebb807b5ec8a1fc2a1f27f6856e2877bef9890d9393f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the light and colors in the image are too saturated and distorted, especially the large areas of blue-purple clouds and orange-yellow sky, and the color transitions lack realism).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07553", "filename": "d14face55e11a39b8a3bebb807b5ec8a1fc2a1f27f6856e2877bef9890d9393f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the shape of the sunlight remains static throughout the video, and the edges of the light source are too harsh and lack a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07554", "filename": "d19b230dc4e4dda82d3a2ffc91d5767f44aedabee70d9c37d32ce940d17c653a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (Throughout the video, the river and trees in the frame exhibit flickering artifacts).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07555", "filename": "d19b230dc4e4dda82d3a2ffc91d5767f44aedabee70d9c37d32ce940d17c653a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 3.3s to the end, the water droplets falling from the flamingo onto the water surface did not create ripples, and no changes occurred on the water surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07556", "filename": "d19b230dc4e4dda82d3a2ffc91d5767f44aedabee70d9c37d32ce940d17c653a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07557", "filename": "d19b230dc4e4dda82d3a2ffc91d5767f44aedabee70d9c37d32ce940d17c653a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (Throughout the video, the river and trees in the frame exhibit flickering artifacts).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07558", "filename": "d21dc247f5e9674b72e6669c8f637a5d926c05561d798a4f9d6cdd9472bd54df_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous timing (the video flickers throughout; at 0.7s, the green object moves on its own before the device touches it; at 1.6s, the green object on the device suddenly turns blue).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07559", "filename": "d21dc247f5e9674b72e6669c8f637a5d926c05561d798a4f9d6cdd9472bd54df_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 0.4s in the video, the block on the slide rotates on its own without any external interference; at 2.3s, the green block on the table moves upward on its own).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07560", "filename": "d21dc247f5e9674b72e6669c8f637a5d926c05561d798a4f9d6cdd9472bd54df_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior anomalies (at 2.4s, the green block on the conveyor belt passes directly through the yellow barrier, violating the impermeability of solids); Temporal continuity anomalies (at 4.1s, the green object on the robotic arm suddenly turns red).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07561", "filename": "d21dc247f5e9674b72e6669c8f637a5d926c05561d798a4f9d6cdd9472bd54df_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 4.1s in the video, the green cube disappears out of thin air when the robotic arm releases it) Physical behavior (at 5.1s, the blue block on the conveyor belt passes directly through the yellow barrier, violating the impermeability of solids)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07562", "filename": "d24a652b1961c893716129a1764daf85470ddc1543ce667b2b6cd1ebc9fd2776_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual intuition is off (the boiling bubbles in the entire video are too regular and lack a sense of randomness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07563", "filename": "d24a652b1961c893716129a1764daf85470ddc1543ce667b2b6cd1ebc9fd2776_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (at 2.1s, the boiling water in the pot suddenly stops boiling without any change in the camera angle, and the food in the pot rotates on its own at 2.2s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07564", "filename": "d24a652b1961c893716129a1764daf85470ddc1543ce667b2b6cd1ebc9fd2776_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Temporal continuity is abnormal (at 1.3 seconds into the video, without any change in camera angle, a long, yellow object suddenly appears in the water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07565", "filename": "d24a652b1961c893716129a1764daf85470ddc1543ce667b2b6cd1ebc9fd2776_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.2 seconds into the video, the boiling water at the bottom of the frame suddenly stops boiling without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07566", "filename": "d33c1b51cec5b34a8711f156a4c1e331380c02575d05af4fed661e253e9b3d42_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (Throughout the entire video, coffee is continuously being added to the cup, but the level of coffee in the cup remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07567", "filename": "d33c1b51cec5b34a8711f156a4c1e331380c02575d05af4fed661e253e9b3d42_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07568", "filename": "d33c1b51cec5b34a8711f156a4c1e331380c02575d05af4fed661e253e9b3d42_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07569", "filename": "d46cddd836b917d0b68ba0009610bc262ed7bc375fa4cc257533c201fdfb1296_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is inconsistent (at 0.3 seconds into the video, a flame suddenly appears beneath the matchstick, burning the matchstick); the causal relationship is unreasonable (the matchstick does not change at all during the burning process).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07570", "filename": "d46cddd836b917d0b68ba0009610bc262ed7bc375fa4cc257533c201fdfb1296_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the cause and effect relationship is unreasonable (at 0.3s in the video, when the flame just touches the matchstick, the matchstick has already been carbonized and burned, while the blue fuse does not change during the burning process).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07571", "filename": "d46cddd836b917d0b68ba0009610bc262ed7bc375fa4cc257533c201fdfb1296_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07572", "filename": "d49a97b7dc2b8481e12c7fe3deab2aaf26615e325cf2e17980c5e327eba22b3c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 2.3s to the end of the video, when the basketball spins in the air and lands, the ground generates tangential friction, which changes the direction of the basketball's motion, making it impossible for the ball to maintain the vertical upward trajectory shown in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07573", "filename": "d49a97b7dc2b8481e12c7fe3deab2aaf26615e325cf2e17980c5e327eba22b3c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: continuous time (from 1.2 seconds to the end of the video, after the basketball bounces off the ground, it suddenly spins automatically without any external interference, and the basketball is constantly deforming irregularly throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07574", "filename": "d49a97b7dc2b8481e12c7fe3deab2aaf26615e325cf2e17980c5e327eba22b3c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity is abnormal (at 2.4s in the video, the surface pattern of the basketball suddenly changes, and at 3.6s, the basketball suddenly gains secondary potential energy and moves upward on its own without being disturbed by external forces).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07575", "filename": "d49a97b7dc2b8481e12c7fe3deab2aaf26615e325cf2e17980c5e327eba22b3c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Temporal continuity is abnormal (at 4.4s in the video, the basketball suddenly gains secondary potential energy and bounces upwards on its own without any external interference). Physical behavior (from 1.6s to the end, the trajectory of the basketball when it bounces off the ground is irregular).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07576", "filename": "d56aab3a5ea94f6a0fcb66f57f1c690b9b30857c2a5264ca6470a3ef26dfea8c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (at 0.3s in the video, a person puts their hand into a glass of water, and without changing the camera angle, white flocculent material appears out of thin air in the water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07577", "filename": "d56aab3a5ea94f6a0fcb66f57f1c690b9b30857c2a5264ca6470a3ef26dfea8c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 0.9s in the video, white flocculent material suddenly appears on the surface of the person's hand and freezes without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07582", "filename": "4d96c5e8712d6f3b399e35619ea57ef6606704fe001eca66e08a1783209bf1e7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (the lawn flickers in the video, and the red objects on both sides of the video disappear out of thin air at 0.9 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07583", "filename": "4d182135f12a719f61590fb919ef2a612e9a8777203e48b4b25e41a772b81d71_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The shape of the object in the hand changes abruptly in the 2.9s video.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07584", "filename": "4dc521176861484c61b6527d9f29b817cb8f131f610cd0ca39ff2ebee765544e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is inconsistent (at 5s, the water bubbles in the cup disappear out of nowhere in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07585", "filename": "4e8ff0987e4b03a3d3e83e42120e96047b33bbe1264c77178d0435c4309fada6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual presentation is abnormal (the surface of the clouds in the video is too smooth, unlike realistic footage, lacking the smoothness and detail expected in real life).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07586", "filename": "4e8ff0987e4b03a3d3e83e42120e96047b33bbe1264c77178d0435c4309fada6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video exhibits the following anomalies: continuity in time (flickering of the clouds throughout the video); and physical anomalies (the clouds are not illuminated after the sun appears at 7.4 seconds, contradicting the principle that light travels in a straight line).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07587", "filename": "4e8ff0987e4b03a3d3e83e42120e96047b33bbe1264c77178d0435c4309fada6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07588", "filename": "4eb4c2b49d96942604a8be72324e10ee6c16fa673b5a4ab4575a6137444d74e0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07591", "filename": "4eebe0271667525a99503efcb689c856837d2271c0c3d61dbdea510e39892d34_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time display (flickering appears on the left side of the desktop in the video).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07592", "filename": "4efc4e97965e114bfae6749a259c25add5467d6773c0ffe9a3e4ea0b7a8f34b3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the ice below is melting while the ice above remains unchanged, which does not conform to the physical properties of ice).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07593", "filename": "4efc4e97965e114bfae6749a259c25add5467d6773c0ffe9a3e4ea0b7a8f34b3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the shadow of the ice cube in the video has sharp angles, while the ice cube itself is flat; the shape of the shadow and the shape of the ice cube are different, which does not conform to the fact that light travels in straight lines).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07594", "filename": "4f43bc2e31928c5dfdd98edc032e53f39bf2d132225c930f98f8b692b968f817_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the fire in the middle and lower right corner of the 2.8s video is distorted and appears to be added out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07595", "filename": "4f1822f41aa431de5e3a4892cc70f500d8a1729b7fd7d0adced2386abd9c2883_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the silver liquid did not change after the collision of the liquids on the left side of the video at 4.1s); Time continuity (the liquid on the left side of the video appeared out of thin air at 3.7s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07596", "filename": "4f1822f41aa431de5e3a4892cc70f500d8a1729b7fd7d0adced2386abd9c2883_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is continuous (at 2.4 seconds, the crystals in the lower corner of the video do not form slowly but appear suddenly, and the image flickers at the crystallization point throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07598", "filename": "4fead74497d9ee7d41e822554edec41a2e77821d565a176c87e339e4d7e05ad1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (clouds move to the light source in the video without any change in the light source); Time continuity (at 4.5 seconds, there is no object reflecting light on the left side of the video, yet a light spot appears out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07599", "filename": "4fead74497d9ee7d41e822554edec41a2e77821d565a176c87e339e4d7e05ad1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (sunlight needs to pass through a large amount of atmosphere, and should appear as a soft circle, not as a sharp starburst; the transition of light around the sun and the edge treatment of the clouds appear slightly harsh).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07600", "filename": "05f2b96c1c31490ff634a3289e8e8f588a7a5074113f90d9ab3403cb8f607bcf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the small boat in the middle of the river moves on the water without creating ripples, violating the principle of conservation of kinetic energy).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07601", "filename": "5a0a308c9b786ab30f9b9c96c5ac08017a4bc73ffce3412c8f7a0e0e7ecfb008_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (at 3.8s, debris from the yellow object below the hydraulic press appears out of nowhere; at 4.4s, fragments from the yellow object in the middle of the video disappear out of nowhere; at 4.5s, the shape of the fragments in the middle object changes abruptly and the upper right corner of the yellow object breaks out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07602", "filename": "d5d13db9d8eb59293163f3af0469690291aeec7c124fb32e5ca63e05fb44fe82_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is unusual: The overall visual impression is unusual (the light and shadow and texture of the surrounding rocks and vegetation are clear and realistic, but the texture and color of the water flow are excessively blue, completely disconnected from the environment, and lacking details of light and shadow reflection).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07603", "filename": "d5d13db9d8eb59293163f3af0469690291aeec7c124fb32e5ca63e05fb44fe82_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07611", "filename": "d07f15bd00ca8a2f84e3e267c6b0c98144b3287831bdb292862387ea3f2bfd3b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity (flickering artifacts exist in the video throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07612", "filename": "d07f15bd00ca8a2f84e3e267c6b0c98144b3287831bdb292862387ea3f2bfd3b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 3.8 seconds, the white object in the bowl suddenly rises higher without the camera changing position).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07613", "filename": "d07f15bd00ca8a2f84e3e267c6b0c98144b3287831bdb292862387ea3f2bfd3b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 3.5s in the video, without any change in the camera angle, the food in the bowl suddenly increases in quantity and gradually darkens in color).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07614", "filename": "d7ce7ce1f9f02c0eb907e3b93df13db86d0f659035df2d70c5bb915a387446df_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Cause and effect (Throughout the entire video, water is continuously added to the glass, but the water level in the glass does not change at all).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07615", "filename": "d7ce7ce1f9f02c0eb907e3b93df13db86d0f659035df2d70c5bb915a387446df_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the water in the cup increases too quickly from 0.1s to 1.4s, disproportionate to the amount of water poured in) and continuity of time (at 1.5s, the water flow on the cup wall does not change and remains adhered to the cup wall).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07616", "filename": "d7ce7ce1f9f02c0eb907e3b93df13db86d0f659035df2d70c5bb915a387446df_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior: (The water, as it enters the glass, does not exhibit the arc and dynamic blur that would occur when it falls naturally; instead, it maintains an overly straight and rigid line.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07617", "filename": "d7ce7ce1f9f02c0eb907e3b93df13db86d0f659035df2d70c5bb915a387446df_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 6.8s in the video, the tabletop suddenly transforms into a water surface with ripples, even though the camera angle remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07618", "filename": "d7d3041b287ffcc01f81fc6f7861f8be85f8ef2f31cf124db083240530115268_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Causality (Throughout the video, the flames continuously burn the cardboard, yet the cardboard itself remains unchanged); Temporal continuity (Flickering artifacts exist on the ground throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07619", "filename": "d7d3041b287ffcc01f81fc6f7861f8be85f8ef2f31cf124db083240530115268_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.7 seconds into the video, the flames of the burning fire suddenly go out without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07620", "filename": "d7d3041b287ffcc01f81fc6f7861f8be85f8ef2f31cf124db083240530115268_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.3s in the video, the paper on the left side of the screen, which had no flames burning, suddenly carbonizes without any external interference; at 5.9s, a piece of burning cardboard appears out of nowhere in the fire).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07621", "filename": "d8ce6bbf89655cdbe262b3f19b6d10272f250c819eb7de1372fe7c99a32b0484_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 1s, the grass on the rocks disappears out of thin air without any change in the shot) Overall visual anomalies (the water flowing down the edge of the waterfall in the video is too regular and lacks a sense of naturalness)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07622", "filename": "d8ce6bbf89655cdbe262b3f19b6d10272f250c819eb7de1372fe7c99a32b0484_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the waterfall in the image shows an upward trend, flowing from the lower right corner to the upper left corner, which is completely contrary to the natural law of water flowing downhill)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07623", "filename": "d8ce6bbf89655cdbe262b3f19b6d10272f250c819eb7de1372fe7c99a32b0484_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the water flows slowly and smoothly throughout the video, lacking any sense of randomness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07624", "filename": "d8ce6bbf89655cdbe262b3f19b6d10272f250c819eb7de1372fe7c99a32b0484_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07625", "filename": "d9a26685cde8a77403d87a9f47e0a42cb43aa9e5679d638dec93d82761e8a4f3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.9s in the video, the pink car suddenly falls apart and then reassembles without any external interference, and its size suddenly shrinks).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07626", "filename": "d9a26685cde8a77403d87a9f47e0a42cb43aa9e5679d638dec93d82761e8a4f3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 0.9s in the video, the toy car directly passes through the track, violating the principle that solids are impermeable) and temporal continuity (at 3.8s, the toy car at the bottom of the frame suddenly merges into the background without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07627", "filename": "d9a26685cde8a77403d87a9f47e0a42cb43aa9e5679d638dec93d82761e8a4f3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.1s, a toy car appears out of nowhere on the track; at 1.6s, the toy car disappears out of nowhere; at 2.2s, another toy car appears out of nowhere on the track; and at 3.9s, two more toy cars appear out of nowhere on the track).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07628", "filename": "d9f6ed8022c9c2f417a0133d8a1a8302b2bd13113837a4645c8b8aa8d2ce0b72_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 4 seconds into the video, the sun suddenly moves its position without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07629", "filename": "d9f6ed8022c9c2f417a0133d8a1a8302b2bd13113837a4645c8b8aa8d2ce0b72_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 3.8s in the video, the color of the sky suddenly darkens without any change in the shot).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07630", "filename": "d9f6ed8022c9c2f417a0133d8a1a8302b2bd13113837a4645c8b8aa8d2ce0b72_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity (flickering artifacts exist in the clouds throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07631", "filename": "d14face55e11a39b8a3bebb807b5ec8a1fc2a1f27f6856e2877bef9890d9393f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the shape of the sunlight remains static throughout the video, and the edges of the light source are too harsh and lack a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07632", "filename": "03fded8c4137cc0d28fb9d4059ca5af9cd376d4fe2e3a5d7ca5597894ccc930d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (throughout the video, the ice in the iron bowl on the right maintains a constant volume but continuously produces liquid, which contradicts the principle that mass cannot be created out of thin air, and also violates the correspondence between changes of state and energy/volume changes).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07633", "filename": "03fded8c4137cc0d28fb9d4059ca5af9cd376d4fe2e3a5d7ca5597894ccc930d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the water surface in the middle of the iron bowl on the right fluctuates wildly up and down without any additional energy input or external interference, violating the law of conservation of energy. It also does not conform to the principle in the second law of thermodynamics that energy will develop towards disorder in a spontaneous process and will not spontaneously produce continuous and regular macroscopic motion.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07634", "filename": "03fded8c4137cc0d28fb9d4059ca5af9cd376d4fe2e3a5d7ca5597894ccc930d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 5s in the video, water droplets on the right side of the iron bowl appear suddenly and in large quantities without any process, and there is no rapid supply of external water vapor, violating the kinetic laws of liquefaction and the law of conservation of mass). Temporal continuity (at 0.2s, two ice cubes falling into the bowl suddenly merge with the four ice cubes in the bowl; at 0.6s in the video, the ice cubes in the bowl change from cuboids to cubes).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07635", "filename": "3a9c3ec44131a3d6fe6f7f97c8030a83001052d80fc7f5dcfb990a143b2eb71b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image quality: Overall visual abnormality (the entire image exhibits significant and noticeable shaking).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07636", "filename": "3a9c3ec44131a3d6fe6f7f97c8030a83001052d80fc7f5dcfb990a143b2eb71b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous (there is a noticeable frame drop at 2.8 seconds in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07637", "filename": "3a9c3ec44131a3d6fe6f7f97c8030a83001052d80fc7f5dcfb990a143b2eb71b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07638", "filename": "3a9c3ec44131a3d6fe6f7f97c8030a83001052d80fc7f5dcfb990a143b2eb71b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Overall visual inconsistency (When burning firewood, sparks from wood are mostly small, irregular particles, occasionally with extremely fine, fluffy sparks. These sparks from a fire mainly occur near the combustion interface where the flame and wood come into contact. At 3 seconds in the video, the sparks appear out of nowhere and are some distance from the wood, which is inconsistent with reality.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07639", "filename": "3a41e2dee4c49b66aaa4436c37441f21ddb52485c74e8c23f7372511a096feea_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (At the beginning of the video, the left area is only an irregular shadow without any facial structure, but at about 0.1 seconds, the shadow suddenly transforms into a clear human face blowing air into the bubble, which is a discontinuous morphological abrupt change. Furthermore, due to surface tension and film stability limitations, it is impossible for a person to continuously blow air into the bubble while it is attached to the surface of their mouth without the bubble bursting.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07640", "filename": "3a41e2dee4c49b66aaa4436c37441f21ddb52485c74e8c23f7372511a096feea_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual inconsistencies (there is no real contact or connection between the bubbles and the person's mouth in the video, and gas could not possibly be blown into the bubbles). Temporal continuity (from 0.8s to 3.1s in the video, the person's mouth suddenly changes into a finger).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07641", "filename": "3a41e2dee4c49b66aaa4436c37441f21ddb52485c74e8c23f7372511a096feea_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (the bubbles in the video change color too smoothly after 2.1 seconds; the color effect on the bubble surface should originate from the interference and scattering of the thin film, and its change should be related to surface deformation. However, the bubble color in the video changes drastically with \"gas flow,\" exhibiting dynamic behavior that does not conform to physical mechanisms). Overall, the visual impression is inconsistent (in the left side of the video, a noticeably protruding spherical object appears at the philtrum, which is inconsistent with real-world human anatomy).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07643", "filename": "3a89b6071ef1298afaf312aceac56c09839f3d784ccfa33c7e49f8f31db966b0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off; the water in the bottle appears viscous like jelly, unlike a realistic image.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07644", "filename": "3a89b6071ef1298afaf312aceac56c09839f3d784ccfa33c7e49f8f31db966b0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (white ice suddenly appears on the red surface on the left at 2.2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07645", "filename": "3a89b6071ef1298afaf312aceac56c09839f3d784ccfa33c7e49f8f31db966b0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Overall visual anomaly (at 0.8s in the video, bubbles suddenly appear on the top of the red object on the right).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07646", "filename": "3a89b6071ef1298afaf312aceac56c09839f3d784ccfa33c7e49f8f31db966b0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical behavior (in the video at 2.2s, the salt precipitation process of the red object on the right is too fast, a bubble appears on the top of the object and then pops out strangely; in the video from 5.9s to 8s, the precipitated salt melts abnormally and disappears without heating or adding water).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07647", "filename": "3a1076b0080dba5758ac0a43d78f1d0042976f0f3b1c793ef9b04ea3e6f1b4f8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07648", "filename": "3a1076b0080dba5758ac0a43d78f1d0042976f0f3b1c793ef9b04ea3e6f1b4f8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07649", "filename": "3a1076b0080dba5758ac0a43d78f1d0042976f0f3b1c793ef9b04ea3e6f1b4f8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Overall intuition anomaly (the reflection of the Ferris wheel's lights on the left window in the video does not match the shape of the Ferris wheel at all; the lights are a regular square structure, but the Ferris wheel is a wheel-shaped structure).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07650", "filename": "3a1076b0080dba5758ac0a43d78f1d0042976f0f3b1c793ef9b04ea3e6f1b4f8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07651", "filename": "3a8470e840d7f19b097cfe536ebdbdc7442a393cdf91931aa3f1601151dba142_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (In the image, the bottom of the ice block is a smooth plane, but as the object at the bottom rotates, the melting water from the ice block does not spread outwards, which is inconsistent with the phenomenon in reality where water spreads outwards as it rotates due to gravity.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07652", "filename": "3a8470e840d7f19b097cfe536ebdbdc7442a393cdf91931aa3f1601151dba142_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is as follows: The physical behavior and motion are severely distorted (the ice block in the image moves on its own without any visible external force or reasonable driving mechanism, and exhibits significant deformation and a sudden increase in volume under conditions of no gravity or unchanged gravity. At the same time, the amount of water beneath the ice block also increases synchronously, resulting in both the ice block and the water volume \"increasing\" simultaneously. This phenomenon violates the law of conservation of mass and basic physical laws, and lacks a reasonable physical explanation.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07653", "filename": "3a8470e840d7f19b097cfe536ebdbdc7442a393cdf91931aa3f1601151dba142_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the ice melts in the video, but the water level below doesn't increase).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07654", "filename": "3a8470e840d7f19b097cfe536ebdbdc7442a393cdf91931aa3f1601151dba142_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (In a naturally still surface, melting ice does not spontaneously exhibit a regular counter-clockwise rotation; this phenomenon does not conform to conventional physical laws. In the video, from 2.4s to 6.5s, the ice floats on the water's surface. During the melting process, only the part in contact with the water absorbs heat and melts first, causing the ice's center of gravity to shift slowly, resulting in a slight tilt and sway, but not a continuous counter-clockwise rotation. Only when there is directional water flow on a flat surface, uneven temperature distribution creating convection, or the application of an external force, can the ice possibly rotate.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07655", "filename": "3a686187291ccced7a895db9fdff42b4d6028658efee9ddc725b1e926fa4bb1f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the flames in the image have four colors\u2014purple, pink, blue, and orange\u2014that are too psychedelic and the colors change in a very colorful and varied way).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07656", "filename": "3a686187291ccced7a895db9fdff42b4d6028658efee9ddc725b1e926fa4bb1f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (in the 3s video frame, the flame is purple one second, and suddenly turns pink the next second without any transition. At 2s in the video, the right-side nozzle suddenly changes shape, showing two white lines).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07657", "filename": "3a686187291ccced7a895db9fdff42b4d6028658efee9ddc725b1e926fa4bb1f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.6s in the video, the flames in the video were originally blue, but suddenly turned purple without any transition; at 5.3s in the video, the purple flames turned blue without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07662", "filename": "99a2de9336b1d70d23ca4f528f1185a3cf6d7802e31920187882a25ae863ddcb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual abnormality (flickering on the ground).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07663", "filename": "99c49099afa17e9fd2784ade2090d01914a031416d78c32ac833622c0ed79531_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the shoe surface does not change when the foot is stepping on the tire, the action and reaction forces are not matched, which does not conform to Newton's third law).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07664", "filename": "99ea03724c13d4e11be949a540d22fc3f1474bb1c5ebe6119c06d7b5e225eac1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the water flow on the plane is too smooth).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07665", "filename": "0102b01bb8d99510fa5d8dfe0109580067497c67b7ff21382197978307fcb74a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (the object moves spontaneously without any external force, which does not conform to Newton's first law).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07666", "filename": "103aa70df0707db4ce3aaf053b35d70c36b40b3150b7f5efedb635b54a055e6c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior: (The leaves do not move when being sprayed with water, and there is no water droplet falling, which does not conform to the law of gravity)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07667", "filename": "120e98d9f8ba4c27f37b551767b3e49cb3e10afea6c7f08b877224c6496b11f2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Smoke is a gas, but the movement of the smoke on the right side is more like that of a liquid. This does not conform to the laws of motion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07668", "filename": "133fda5b5f13dd8da8e9f1541ea7b52457d5bc290c4931740eac14a74870f94d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07669", "filename": "143f1312d52a70e5cfe3899098fa49515aa295170bd8cd5520a5d4729de5ec97_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the object on the right moves spontaneously without being subjected to any external force, which does not conform to Newton's First Law).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07670", "filename": "170dfeaf4b5dbabf38971a67ef2a200dddf62d2bdf4f8d7d5d60c7444791384e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (flickering issues in the image, unnatural lava formations).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07671", "filename": "176b14b5e11b597096dc2e9e55f7f44480733b642d88c210be6fa8e2c80d00dc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the house appears distorted throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07672", "filename": "180cc16709f7794290acc114cf98ab0a2fc1bff4d3d4b518e07c768bb6bad8f1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07673", "filename": "201e0061d39bb69eadfbe19b4841053eab15d572619f04159f4627bdd2d022f2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07674", "filename": "209fa41a73c149835404b7381549ccc0792a276acb69f469509df937af8ef4aa_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07675", "filename": "222b7649ebf1c560d71fbc25f31fa9634b57c812be40cbbf04528efb08d2817a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07676", "filename": "230e73f4c3eeedd029d25f3d86b4df9018a370572b7f698251d2d877ed6ecf05_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the upper half of the video shows a turbulent sea, while the lower half shows a calm sea).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07677", "filename": "242c5bb8c3af7b0558f424624f69260747f9a55b2f3f4448abc10dc1f83c36e0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to physical behavior (the energy generated by the explosion at 1.6 seconds did not move the nearby bushes, which does not conform to the law of energy propagation).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07678", "filename": "256a669c812771c395cfd88ed550abffa2cf605225a8cf3ed1e7885ffa285167_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal and the timing is continuous (two pie charts suddenly appear in the video at 0.1s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07679", "filename": "256ae6883da4a846016a85a0e88eacd73f085cf384a097787c6452bd8db40288_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the object has two reflections, which does not conform to the law of reflection of light)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07680", "filename": "261d0bffa041536f94eb53981b4e0bbec439de3be6b85d49988f44e9f172feb1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07681", "filename": "263c50096b73bfc3a74b8baef411399ed988cea49ad467e4c2e01fafac482fc6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (the color of the upper right corner of the object keeps changing from the beginning to the end of the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07682", "filename": "281b3fe9e6514bedf03d431c5e5f342633fc67d84c829040d45f911ff647709b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07683", "filename": "300b4ab6c4d9dc8381348d4b89bae6ab89276c38e51d2a05f8ec59d7a9c7519d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image shows an anomaly: between 0 and 2.4 seconds, a person is seen directly holding the burning part of a burning object. In real life, one should avoid holding a burning part to prevent injury.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07684", "filename": "300c08acab0973c0f07d9262514366c2b8fdd32bbad3cab94e700a9290e52697_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual abnormality (screen flickering).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07685", "filename": "309c66632871a1b5cffd23d1c4fcf406b6026db79f7e673a3d852745520611c3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07686", "filename": "310a4befdc8e0f3071af2c89354f4e4a63d0fa32cd6d3a3718018778e8ba8ce1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07687", "filename": "316d7c95190476a19afca40c41f5d422d060aff501c529fb2257acfae3beb4cf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07688", "filename": "321df789e81b0c7b8367edea554db04d75fbd1f36fde082e8aea5d0f9ee33820_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the sphere deforms at 4.1s); Overall visual anomalies (flickering occurs after the object stops).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07689", "filename": "328b3c9bade99c0a973aa846c21d2e30d396947c16b11df809c4fcbe880787e3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual abnormality (flickering issue in the video background).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07690", "filename": "333c434a7a7cc01ca9ae711146c6132f46134a98077bf5dbc3025c2fa1eb26cd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (the light spots in the footage seem to rotate with the camera, but in a real environment, the light source is fixed, and the position of the light spots should remain unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07691", "filename": "353bb8d163a6c3a53eb65c91a047d90e3e5ab8dfa4d657d45c8997f96334849d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: From 2.27 to 8 seconds, liquid continued to drip from the dropper into the beaker, but the amount of liquid inside the dropper did not decrease.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07692", "filename": "P04_107_692_8baf366a7ccd9b92_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time frame is too smooth (the process of rolling the dough from 3.09 to 5 seconds is too fluid, unlike a realistic video, and lacks the pauses and jolts that should be present in real life).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07693", "filename": "P04_107_692_8baf366a7ccd9b92_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (between 6.18 and 8 seconds, the shape of the rolled dough does not change).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07694", "filename": "P04_107_693_e820b3deeaecf9f7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (within 2.09-3 seconds, the flat dough turns into a five-pointed star shape without being affected by external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07695", "filename": "P04_107_693_e820b3deeaecf9f7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07696", "filename": "P04_107_697_827fd9b20c90a35a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal; the time sequence is continuous (between 0-4.4 seconds, the character's right thumb is missing).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07697", "filename": "P04_107_731_fd85798d6e425f00_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The duration is continuous (within 1.27-2.7 seconds, the dough automatically bounces a short distance when the finger merely touches it).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07698", "filename": "P04_107_731_fd85798d6e425f00_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 5.3s, the rolling pin penetrates the finger, violating the principle of impermeability of solids.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07699", "filename": "P04_107_731_fd85798d6e425f00_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 1.7s, the dough suddenly enlarges as it is placed down).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07700", "filename": "P04_107_841_e78e4efac2b162fc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is too smooth (between 0 and 3.5 seconds, the process of the dough being rolled by the rolling pin is too smooth, unlike real footage, and lacks the pauses that should be present in real life).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07701", "filename": "P04_107_841_e78e4efac2b162fc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The duration is continuous (from 2.06 to 3.1 seconds, there is a noticeable twisting of the right thumb).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07702", "filename": "P04_107_841_e78e4efac2b162fc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07703", "filename": "P04_107_844_a14adda509924415_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (2.7-5s: the rolled dough is too flat, unlike realistic footage). Physical anomalies (1.22-4.4s: during the rolling process, the dough moves with the rolling pin, violating the principle of friction).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07704", "filename": "P04_107_844_a14adda509924415_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time frame is continuous (5.19-8 seconds; the dough was repeatedly rolled over without changing its shape).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07705", "filename": "P04_107_844_a14adda509924415_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07706", "filename": "P04_107_880_922cf2a7a5e57d77_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the dough remained unchanged in shape and size despite being rolled multiple times from start to finish).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07707", "filename": "P04_107_880_922cf2a7a5e57d77_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07708", "filename": "P04_108_42_71c7eb21b98d01dd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.2s, the character's wrist suddenly rotates 360 degrees without the character's arm rotating).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07709", "filename": "P04_108_42_71c7eb21b98d01dd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07710", "filename": "P04_108_44_a5949b9fbee49681_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The time frame is continuous (1.10-2.2s, the pot suddenly flips over without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07711", "filename": "P04_108_44_a5949b9fbee49681_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.9 seconds, the food in the pot suddenly appears out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07712", "filename": "P04_109_133_7b71b040189ed07e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (a cucumber suddenly appears at two time points, 3.6s and 4.7s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07713", "filename": "P04_109_138_02a21fca291edcdb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.8 seconds, the cucumber placed on the cutting board is suddenly cut in half).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07714", "filename": "P04_109_138_02a21fca291edcdb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (at 7.6s, the slice of melon appears out of thin air, and at 4s, the slice of melon that was cut off disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07715", "filename": "P04_109_174_115912896c53c07e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time frame is continuous (0-5s). During the stirring process, the amount of cucumber shreds decreases as the radish and cucumber shreds are stirred.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07716", "filename": "P04_109_174_115912896c53c07e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07717", "filename": "P04_109_231_a5d439fb5cf0ec8e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (between 2.8s and 5s, objects in the image appear solid but flow like liquid during stirring, unlike a realistic scene.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07718", "filename": "P04_109_234_954f8bec3f013410_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07719", "filename": "P04_109_234_954f8bec3f013410_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the finger penetrates the shredded carrot at 4.6s, violating the impermeability of solids).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07720", "filename": "P04_109_234_954f8bec3f013410_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the radish shreds penetrated the cup wall at 1.8 seconds, violating the principle of impermeability of solids).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07721", "filename": "P04_109_304_2de7337a5c985ecd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07722", "filename": "222883f077cadb7ba85987bc77052362e0d3b05e5d2d96492bd83ea05e99c372_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect (normal frost is a needle-like or crystalline structure formed by water vapor condensing at low temperatures. Although it has a crystalline feel, the frost in the video has overly sharp edges and a uniform texture, making it look more like a digital composite or a post-production effect).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07723", "filename": "235667d9c2929ed8777006b44431e1882be9298da6a238bd10c042b1f2503b7b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 6.3 seconds, a string of letters suddenly appears on the refrigerator above the oxygen tube of the firefighter on the left).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07725", "filename": "244415e6b9f30cf205141dba4c85be4863d9e2635a9e89b8f2c608fafd43fcb0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (In the video, the sun is high in the position, but the reflection on the water surface presents an abnormally straight and constant brightness band of light. In a real environment, this reflection will change in brightness with the movement of the water surface, and the width and brightness of the light band will also naturally decrease due to the viewing angle and atmospheric scattering.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07726", "filename": "251700c6157943bebea055852b76c73f77d69487b0c63fc88b83b230d62e12de_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07727", "filename": "260601fe820c7e70518a14c4feddec96ecb5afb574506a9989c3f3368d75545e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07729", "filename": "399194e5849a94eae7d18dff77f6b1a8ad5ad38525f9d0b3dc2d19b4c11a874a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to physical behavior (the yellow stick stirring the liquid has inertia, but the liquid in the cup continues to move when stirring stops, while the liquid becomes still after the yellow stick stops stirring, which does not conform to the law of inertia).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07730", "filename": "414803b81e6dacf906dfd75c207767ccead6bba8319548866767448b8485b2a7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07731", "filename": "450909ea8c6ef802e64dfb3371a1f7a39e1df65cac0ac002ae512545e1694b35_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (The background is a gradient of blue, purple, and orange light, but the shadows and reflections of the objects do not match the background lighting effect. For example, the dark areas of the objects are not affected by the ambient color, and the reflections appear too uniform.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07732", "filename": "509566beafbd407bed6c3e6815058abbea59bf7e0c654f1c8cdf587912230621_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (the frame suddenly drops at 7.3s where the flame is visible). Cause and effect (the flame is very bright throughout the video, but the surrounding ground and burning materials do not show the strong light and shadow contrast that a real flame should have. The warm color of the flame does not create obvious reflections on the surrounding ground, and the metallic texture of the burning materials does not show real physical changes such as reddening or deformation due to high temperature. The overall scene looks more like a superimposed special effects rather than a real burning scene).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07733", "filename": "533681d7a9f719d068fac13091e113f2439a77dc288dabfba36984e6085838b9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (The strong light emitted by the light bulb in the entire video should have produced obvious contrast and shadows on the surrounding objects, but in addition to the special effects glare, the light and shadow transitions on the desktop and equipment are too soft and lack the layered changes under real strong light illumination.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07734", "filename": "552363b5bafb38d377c4b2144045390b74034cfd094976220804c7b2a87c21e3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07735", "filename": "565269a921d4caa443603865a626db63e375db8ba6169db180b96bf0a83c2c98_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (between 5s and 8s, the ripples on the water surface suddenly change while the light remains the same, but the reflection on the water surface moves with the waves).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07736", "filename": "581043ba9072a9788fc124d904e26ab7eb6fb4bf8a446cfc4bdd522475480b2a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the image remains static from 0s to 1.3s, then suddenly moves after 1.3s, showing inconsistency).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07737", "filename": "613939fcb3f44aa4b0901a3317ef601ee06799371ccb83b6115567ce53e94794_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (in the video from 1.4s to 4.9s, multiple bananas should have been flattened under the tire's weight, instead of remaining as multiple neatly rounded bananas).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07738", "filename": "688413cdcc7d6cd0e6bb88df388e66800fd1f90637cea553d24eb8bdd7378b61_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Causality (Real water flow, when sprayed, follows a natural parabolic shape due to gravity and air resistance, but the water flow in the video from 0.7s to 8s maintains a rigid, net-like outline, without any natural changes such as splashing or disintegration; the texture is more like solidified foam or a plastic model.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07739", "filename": "692018d1ff0846151035e05fa0b7a80fd35d10b7d6756ff7a1bf015a8b477932_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the ground in the entire video is constantly flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07740", "filename": "0707006bc4943c020ea2ecd70d02763c13cbc216df5a82331615f19bde843656_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07741", "filename": "709881af7a7f86fc383d5c5f1fc120babfc3435a62cb1d3d3d5b16f072abc3e3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Causality (The flames produced by the explosion between 0s and 2s are very bright, but the surrounding ground and background vegetation are almost unaffected by the strong light, and there is no obvious contrast between light and dark or reflection, indicating that the flame effects are not naturally integrated with the real environment.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07742", "filename": "752562c5bab03fc8f6f9030fa7a2651f05789ca0f1d05a722d18f8d4a3452404_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (after 2.5 seconds, the rocket's thrusters did not stop after ascent, but the clouds below remained calm, which does not conform to the laws of inertia).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07743", "filename": "768499dcd3efe001b8fa20fb65bc94cac64d1171008808fb67d29dcfb8da212e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.3s, the smoke from the steadily burning smoke suddenly appears as a regular spiral shape without any change in external conditions).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07744", "filename": "823327eef58bdee3292b80d493f16d80028a7ef1cde908f7cd283b6f4a0d7bc6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous in time (the pile of wood at the campfire in the entire video does not show the charring marks that would occur during actual burning).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07745", "filename": "832701c336bbe3010c0298be98490248590a0a8e62b3a1853ac7e12ffe5f5d04_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07746", "filename": "855772e78272938c4716971c67fe4f063830bd39119a8e4d52aaeecc0ecf0852_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: causality (the video shows red wine being poured into a glass continuously, but the amount of red wine in the glass does not increase).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07747", "filename": "914817a8aad893cc7af950d7a3de29c6ff69fb40183d3ab78d2cb4fff06e9ea4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the smoke is constantly flashing throughout the video, and the fireworks in the sky explode without producing any light).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07748", "filename": "923378e6d58ff694c8f4aca970de16eef1ee639297e84036245a05959074531a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: continuous time (the entire video is flickering, and at 1.2 seconds, the flashes from the explosion suddenly appear in a net-like pattern, and the objects around the explosive remain calm after the explosion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07749", "filename": "953558abceccaaf23ca13c0140e295aa3b1ca6d75c099e7af090c411acf6d639_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the gradient from yellow to blue in the sky is too uniform, lacking the color gradation brought by clouds and atmospheric scattering at dusk; at the same time, the reflection on the sea surface is too smooth, without the light and shadow texture that should be present in the undulations of waves).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07750", "filename": "1530489a34f09f8496ba6d741e57e9723bd85509649ce381e47bb8406f22faf4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Causality (The candy should have melted and the bubbles should have burst when the blowtorch was burning it in the entire video, but this was not shown in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07751", "filename": "1652765f2ee431eb22c674bb55bf9e197fec101e6f6162f293120304a48b6483_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous flickering (the entire video is constantly flashing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07752", "filename": "4acc8c618e1d253e1042ac2b80086f2c9dade53933a916a77039718b1892ad9b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall impression is off (in reality, the height and width of the snow-capped mountain reflection are consistent with the actual scene, but in the video, the reflection is excessively stretched and enlarged, almost filling the lower half of the lake surface, far exceeding the proportion of the actual snow-capped mountain).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07753", "filename": "4acc8c618e1d253e1042ac2b80086f2c9dade53933a916a77039718b1892ad9b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the sky has no obvious shadows and direct light, but the mountains have strong sidelight shadows, and the water surface has diffused soft light; the overall direction of light and shadow is chaotic, and the sunlight source is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07754", "filename": "4acc8c618e1d253e1042ac2b80086f2c9dade53933a916a77039718b1892ad9b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the reflection is brighter and clearer than the actual scene, and the details of the snow-capped mountain are even more prominent than the mountain itself).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07755", "filename": "4ae96481656e3d49f0fb58f7b875d45ebb8af7158b8298f04f9cfb6e6d13e964_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is continuous (the tilted grill and the meat on top of it slowly fade away from the screen between 0.1s and 0.5s, while the whole grilled meat and the flat grill slowly appear on the screen). The overall visual impression is abnormal (the texture of the flames shows signs of repeated splicing, lacking the irregular and dynamic feeling of flames in reality).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07756", "filename": "4ae96481656e3d49f0fb58f7b875d45ebb8af7158b8298f04f9cfb6e6d13e964_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is not continuous (in reality, flames move with the air, burn, sway, spread, and contract dynamically, with blurred edges that are constantly changing, but the flame outline in the video is too regular, like a static texture, simply stretched up and down, lacking the dynamism and sense of depth of a real flame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07757", "filename": "4ae96481656e3d49f0fb58f7b875d45ebb8af7158b8298f04f9cfb6e6d13e964_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to physical behavior (in reality, the high temperature of a flame would cause food to sizzle, ooze oil, and char, resulting in a gradual change in color, but in the video, the food remains fresh and reddish, without any change due to heat).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07758", "filename": "4af73cff1d8509073cabdffe4711829e0bbc8405b371df87a5885ad41cf5c3dd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the ice crystal structure of natural ice is chaotic and irregular. The light transmittance varies depending on the arrangement of ice crystals and the distribution of air bubbles, resulting in localized transparency and localized turbidity. In addition, the blue tone of the ice in the video is too uniform, the surface reflection is smooth and lacks the graininess of natural ice crystals, and the transparency is also perfected, lacking the texture and layers of natural ice).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07759", "filename": "4af73cff1d8509073cabdffe4711829e0bbc8405b371df87a5885ad41cf5c3dd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the time sequence is continuous (the ice changes from light blue and cloudy to dark blue and clear in 0s-0.6s. In reality, the color of ice is determined by the thickness of the air bubbles in the ice crystal structure, and the change is slow and continuous. Such abrupt color and texture changes would not occur).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07760", "filename": "4af73cff1d8509073cabdffe4711829e0bbc8405b371df87a5885ad41cf5c3dd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07761", "filename": "4b1efea0e69b090d53244c73df515f67a2309561c5d444bc31669bb0fd8fe05b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (At 2.1s, a droplet fell out of thin air from the far left of the crystal without being heated or melted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07762", "filename": "4b1efea0e69b090d53244c73df515f67a2309561c5d444bc31669bb0fd8fe05b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (in reality, the melting of a crystal by heat is a continuous and gradual process of softening the surface edges and gradually liquefying, but in the video from 2.1s to 5.8s, the crystal has no softening transition. While the solid edges remain intact, it instantly liquefies into a smooth liquid state. There are even instances of solid crystals turning into liquid states out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07763", "filename": "4b1efea0e69b090d53244c73df515f67a2309561c5d444bc31669bb0fd8fe05b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07764", "filename": "4b1efea0e69b090d53244c73df515f67a2309561c5d444bc31669bb0fd8fe05b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the right side of the crystal disappears out of thin air at 0.1s). The physical behavior is also abnormal (from 0.6s to 5.2s, the flame only touches the bottom of the crystal. In reality, the bottom should melt first and the heat should be slowly conducted upwards. However, in the video, the upper part of the crystal is not directly heated by the flame, but it liquefies rapidly in sync with the bottom).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07765", "filename": "4b9d4d496bd7c45d0e43cda3855c7f491da516ada64e60d1b9173669827febd5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07766", "filename": "4b9d4d496bd7c45d0e43cda3855c7f491da516ada64e60d1b9173669827febd5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1s, a small stick above the crossbar suddenly disappears into thin air, and at 2.6s, the small piece of wood above the crossbar deforms and suddenly becomes longer).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07767", "filename": "4b9d4d496bd7c45d0e43cda3855c7f491da516ada64e60d1b9173669827febd5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the edges of the flames throughout the segment are jagged and sharp, lacking the blurred edges created by air mixing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07768", "filename": "4b9d4d496bd7c45d0e43cda3855c7f491da516ada64e60d1b9173669827febd5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 5.9s, a piece of charcoal appears out of thin air above the crossbar and falls down, while a section of the middle part of the crossbar disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07769", "filename": "4b0817062094ac51fe75b4296c67cf0a155af92db1d8f02b6362cee2f2c43d67_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07770", "filename": "4b0817062094ac51fe75b4296c67cf0a155af92db1d8f02b6362cee2f2c43d67_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 5.1s, cars traveling in opposite directions on the bridge pass through each other, which violates the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07771", "filename": "4ba99d059ccc850359293fe13e693ffea58bf283f205fc2f8779aa4f37588dc2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (between 2.4s and 4.4s, the leftmost tree among the trees at the bomb's explosion point suddenly moves to the right and then returns to its original position). Physical behavior (at 2.1s, the bomb explodes under the tree trunk, but the tree is not knocked down or broken).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07772", "filename": "4ba99d059ccc850359293fe13e693ffea58bf283f205fc2f8779aa4f37588dc2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the black block that flew out from the explosion point at 4.9s fell to the ground and then disappeared into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07773", "filename": "4ba99d059ccc850359293fe13e693ffea58bf283f205fc2f8779aa4f37588dc2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.9s, the tree branch on the right slowly bends downwards without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07774", "filename": "4ba99d059ccc850359293fe13e693ffea58bf283f205fc2f8779aa4f37588dc2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (a massive explosion occurs beneath the tree trunk at 6.9s, blowing away the soil while the tree only shakes slightly); Time continuity (blue flames suddenly appear beneath the tree trunk between 1s and 3.4s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07775", "filename": "4bc52744c02a78c9741a844a05b653778a871f964e511b0f60eae06f29852360_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (water splashes appear out of nowhere on the water surface at 1.2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07776", "filename": "4bc52744c02a78c9741a844a05b653778a871f964e511b0f60eae06f29852360_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (water on the floor slowly spreads outwards from nowhere throughout the entire segment, and the ice particles in the scene continuously change shape between 0.1s and 2.8s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07777", "filename": "4bc52744c02a78c9741a844a05b653778a871f964e511b0f60eae06f29852360_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (water suddenly appears out of nowhere in the water that was already on the floor between 2.1s and 6.3s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07778", "filename": "4bf5f9ba65522008ed143b0d3956fafe877d68fd2ac816578dfb3a29fa15e7f1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.6s, the whole piece of corn pops into popcorn without the cob appearing; at 4.1s, another piece of corn suddenly appears out of nowhere; at 4.1s, the scene changes abruptly without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07779", "filename": "4bf5f9ba65522008ed143b0d3956fafe877d68fd2ac816578dfb3a29fa15e7f1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (in the video, popcorn pops out of the cob like an explosion, but in reality, corn kernels pop individually and dispersedly, not all the kernels on the whole cob popping out at once. After the whole cob has popped at 3.8 seconds, another cob appears out of nowhere in the same spot).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07780", "filename": "4bf5f9ba65522008ed143b0d3956fafe877d68fd2ac816578dfb3a29fa15e7f1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the timing is continuous (at 1.7s, the corn kernels suddenly shorten, and at 1.9s, a large amount of popcorn is generated instantly, appearing fluffy and detached from the corn cob. In reality, popcorn pops gradually as individual kernels burst open, and this kind of mass, instantaneous bursting effect does not occur).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07781", "filename": "a9f5b3778a34decd37de77b3bda0f015be1b2da4f57e92470605b78fdcbf03d6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 3.6s, the item in the right hand suddenly disappears; at 3.8s, the shadow on the surface of the item suddenly turns black without transition; at 4.3s, the shape of the item in the hand becomes distorted).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07782", "filename": "a9f5b3778a34decd37de77b3bda0f015be1b2da4f57e92470605b78fdcbf03d6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the surface of the object on the left becomes blurry at 0.6s; the object in the right hand suddenly shrinks in size at 1.1s; the object in the hand twists at 3.2s; the object in the hand twists and deforms and increases in size at 3.5s, becoming a polygonal object). Physical behavior (the object rotates without external force from 4.4s to 5s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07783", "filename": "a9f00967fc84763d19671658b11982270b9f0b4512e1ecf30b96a1ed5d67f024_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (flickering appears on the wall to the right of the stick in the enlarged video frame).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07784", "filename": "a9f00967fc84763d19671658b11982270b9f0b4512e1ecf30b96a1ed5d67f024_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the sunlight in the entire video frame appears unnatural, transitioning from bright to dark).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07785", "filename": "a9f00967fc84763d19671658b11982270b9f0b4512e1ecf30b96a1ed5d67f024_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is unnatural (the lighting in the entire video is unnatural, and the lighting changes from bright to dim).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07786", "filename": "a30e4ec6c75ff1db7f267fcc4380eb691050e72e8114dbe455501ebf8c85e25e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (unnatural refracted light in the entire video frame, with refraction relationships suddenly disappearing and reappearing, appearing unnaturally).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07787", "filename": "a30e4ec6c75ff1db7f267fcc4380eb691050e72e8114dbe455501ebf8c85e25e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video is continuous in time (the white cotton-like object in the entire video does not shake, but small cotton-like objects appear around it; the lighting in the entire video is unnatural, changing from dark to bright).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07788", "filename": "a30e4ec6c75ff1db7f267fcc4380eb691050e72e8114dbe455501ebf8c85e25e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (the water flows to the right throughout the video, while the cotton wadding in the video moves to the left).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07789", "filename": "a35c4c76e547a46918fcad79c443864fb54d050f7716e068e84d0164659f051c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.1 seconds, liquid suddenly flows down from the top of the cup and the color of the liquid is inconsistent; the beginning of the liquid is yellow and the latter part is white and transparent).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07790", "filename": "a35c4c76e547a46918fcad79c443864fb54d050f7716e068e84d0164659f051c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is continuous (the white smoke on the left side of the cup suddenly decreases at 3.3 seconds), and the overall visual impression is abnormal (the movement of the white mist in the entire video is too smooth and lacks a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07791", "filename": "a35c4c76e547a46918fcad79c443864fb54d050f7716e068e84d0164659f051c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07792", "filename": "a35c4c76e547a46918fcad79c443864fb54d050f7716e068e84d0164659f051c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07795", "filename": "a51adf5a456018ae07832eed75363afe46ec67788ee37cfa3a54aaafbb365223_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (from 0s to 1s, the black shadow in the video footage becomes distorted and deformed into a bird shape; at 0.2s, a black shadow suddenly appears in the lower left corner of the video footage).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07796", "filename": "a51adf5a456018ae07832eed75363afe46ec67788ee37cfa3a54aaafbb365223_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the video is too smooth, and the seagulls' flight movements are too stiff and lack a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07797", "filename": "a51adf5a456018ae07832eed75363afe46ec67788ee37cfa3a54aaafbb365223_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 0.2s, a black dot suddenly appears in the middle of the video; at 2s, the number of black shadows in the lower left corner suddenly increases and the black shadows become distorted and deformed, turning into a bird shape).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07798", "filename": "a51d73ab18c05b8d9760e48fba594f512b050916b27f923e6c0fa5c3d9456ecc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (Throughout the video, the butter in the pot was heated but did not change at all).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07799", "filename": "a51d73ab18c05b8d9760e48fba594f512b050916b27f923e6c0fa5c3d9456ecc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (between 0s and 1.2s, the white bubbles in the pot decrease and the butter sinks to the bottom of the pot); Causality (the butter in the pot is heated throughout the video but does not change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07800", "filename": "a51d73ab18c05b8d9760e48fba594f512b050916b27f923e6c0fa5c3d9456ecc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (the volume of the butter in the pot did not decrease after heating throughout the entire video; on the contrary, the volume of the butter gradually increased).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07801", "filename": "a51d73ab18c05b8d9760e48fba594f512b050916b27f923e6c0fa5c3d9456ecc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time interval is continuous (from 2s to 8s, the color of the butter in the pan changes from light yellow to brown and the oil temperature in the pan increases rapidly).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07802", "filename": "a53c0e1abcd6bb73172b36347354529c6453851b989c482795ddd14f0400627e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 0.2s, a black object suddenly appears on the sea surface; at 1.1s, the object transforms into a seal; at 3.4s, the video footage has no transition; a seal's tail suddenly appears behind the seal).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07803", "filename": "a53c0e1abcd6bb73172b36347354529c6453851b989c482795ddd14f0400627e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07804", "filename": "a53c0e1abcd6bb73172b36347354529c6453851b989c482795ddd14f0400627e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (1.5s-3s, the rocks on the coast suddenly transform into seals).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07805", "filename": "a55f89010997db46a4e38fa29480f667040ddb1439bb9e6e5dd7022a4fabeb36_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (fragments generated throughout the video frame are distorted, deformed, suddenly appear, and suddenly disappear; at 3.6 seconds, fragments suddenly appear in the lower left corner of the video frame).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07806", "filename": "a55f89010997db46a4e38fa29480f667040ddb1439bb9e6e5dd7022a4fabeb36_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The time sequence is continuous (from 0s to 0.9s, the debris in the video footage is distorted, deformed, appears suddenly, and disappears suddenly; at 4.4s, the collapsed roof becomes a broken building).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07807", "filename": "a55f89010997db46a4e38fa29480f667040ddb1439bb9e6e5dd7022a4fabeb36_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (fragments appearing or disappearing suddenly in the entire video frame due to distortion, deformation, or other unusual occurrences).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07811", "filename": "90dc0025d2223cd05c159aff8fab1a75499915fea3b4892459bb22702b33beaa_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: physical behavior (the plate shakes slightly between 3.9s and 5.8s, but the water in the plate remains still without any movement).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07812", "filename": "90dc0025d2223cd05c159aff8fab1a75499915fea3b4892459bb22702b33beaa_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07813", "filename": "90e0efa3905ba75e8f51423b094bcb7050a2ff73726588b71a98485f9cbc163b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the oyster remains still between 0s and 0.8s, but the water inside the shell is agitated without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07814", "filename": "90e0efa3905ba75e8f51423b094bcb7050a2ff73726588b71a98485f9cbc163b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous timing (from 0.3s to 4.5s, the juice flowing from the lemon doesn't drip like it would in reality; instead, it flows out in thin streams). Causality (the lemon doesn't squeeze at 0.3s, yet juice flows out).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07815", "filename": "90e0efa3905ba75e8f51423b094bcb7050a2ff73726588b71a98485f9cbc163b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 7.9s, when the lemon pieces are placed on the table, the lemon pieces suddenly turn into a whole lemon).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07816", "filename": "90f9c9387e0289211e9fcb5b1897f4e071df182368476705c4e1ed9deb42057d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (throughout the entire segment, milk is continuously poured into a glass already filled with milk, but the amount of milk in the glass does not increase and it does not overflow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07817", "filename": "90f9c9387e0289211e9fcb5b1897f4e071df182368476705c4e1ed9deb42057d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (between 1.5s and 5s, the milk in the cup suddenly boils and bubbles continuously).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07818", "filename": "90f9c9387e0289211e9fcb5b1897f4e071df182368476705c4e1ed9deb42057d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is discontinuous (the cup is full of milk at the beginning of the video, but the milk disappears out of thin air at 0.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07819", "filename": "90f4878f75bd0b1dbd02623e353224dce63de42d1138f27a0e4dad8158dab126_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1.6s, the right wheel of the toy car disappears out of thin air, and the toy car is driving on a bumpy road without any shaking, as if it is driving on a flat road).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07820", "filename": "90f4878f75bd0b1dbd02623e353224dce63de42d1138f27a0e4dad8158dab126_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the toy train traveling from the right disappears out of thin air at 1.3s); Causality (the sand to the right of the train shakes without any external force between 1.6s and 4.8s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07822", "filename": "91c3c500704262a8c0d895709b16081ab37931c15272ec59b98b42d3658220cd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 2s, the tip of the stick in the hand separates out of thin air, and at 4.3s, the head of the stick suddenly becomes bent).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07823", "filename": "91c3c500704262a8c0d895709b16081ab37931c15272ec59b98b42d3658220cd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (in the range of 1s-5.8s, the real reflection is mostly silver or white, while the soap film reflection is a rainbow of alternating blue, yellow and orange stripes. Ordinary reflections do not show this kind of interference color).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07824", "filename": "92f0c956974d402472e09f20d12fb67946c3c5a9e1fddd906d1fc66069205698_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the fog at the bottom of the entire image is flat, even, and has a sense of thickness, like a white cloth, while real fog is a fluffy, flowing, and granular gaseous state, not so flat and rigid).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07825", "filename": "92f0c956974d402472e09f20d12fb67946c3c5a9e1fddd906d1fc66069205698_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the fog remains stationary in the air from 0s to 3.7s, whereas in reality fog would drift slowly in the air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07826", "filename": "92f0c956974d402472e09f20d12fb67946c3c5a9e1fddd906d1fc66069205698_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07827", "filename": "093f897e52a99f9071ab4b3afdfd030d2f9b4989cc07b8e6173d52c06be09a41_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the water in the cup shakes in mid-air without any external force throughout the entire segment).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07828", "filename": "093f897e52a99f9071ab4b3afdfd030d2f9b4989cc07b8e6173d52c06be09a41_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (when sunlight shines on the cup at 1.3s, the spoon inside the cup does not cast the expected shadow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07829", "filename": "093f897e52a99f9071ab4b3afdfd030d2f9b4989cc07b8e6173d52c06be09a41_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the water in the cup boils out of thin air without any heating, even though the cup is placed on the table).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07837", "filename": "94a18dd9f507249a2fd17f244b7b6ca7da5501f7d2c683cc1e489406ccc9b1fd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (in reality, when the sun is close to the sea level, the light is scattered by the atmosphere, and the sun itself should appear orange-red and be much brighter than it is in the video, not as dazzlingly bright as it is in the video. At the same time, the glow of the surrounding sky would not be so uniform without any gradual changes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07838", "filename": "94a18dd9f507249a2fd17f244b7b6ca7da5501f7d2c683cc1e489406ccc9b1fd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the clouds and fog appear out of nowhere between 1.7s and 4.2s), and the overall visual impression is abnormal (the color of the lake surface is completely consistent with the sky's glow without any deviation, which violates the laws of diffuse reflection and refraction of water, like a mirror copy rather than natural reflection).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07839", "filename": "94a18dd9f507249a2fd17f244b7b6ca7da5501f7d2c683cc1e489406ccc9b1fd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall visual impression is abnormal (in the entire video, the sun should appear as a soft orange-red with blurred edges due to atmospheric scattering at sunset, and its brightness should be greatly reduced, but the sun in the video is dazzlingly bright with a sharp outline like a light bulb, and it still maintains extremely high brightness when it is close to the horizon).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07840", "filename": "94a18dd9f507249a2fd17f244b7b6ca7da5501f7d2c683cc1e489406ccc9b1fd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07844", "filename": "5ca3ace9e1ee502378b51613e0d571858ad31b671f259254ff7c44035a5f9a92_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (ice should melt into water when heated, instead of shrinking and then returning to its original shape.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07845", "filename": "5ca3ace9e1ee502378b51613e0d571858ad31b671f259254ff7c44035a5f9a92_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (when ice melts, its volume should shrink, not expand out of thin air.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07846", "filename": "5ca3ace9e1ee502378b51613e0d571858ad31b671f259254ff7c44035a5f9a92_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (an ice cube placed on a table rotates automatically without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07853", "filename": "5cd0bb476ef03e22290b279bc06d2e161952fa5382506232e08408af6cf85d80_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (In the image, smoke resembling dry ice overflows from a bucket. The diffusion of smoke is a continuous dynamic process, and its shape changes should present a smooth evolutionary trajectory. However, the smoke in the image exhibits abrupt shape changes, lacking a continuous movement trajectory consistent with the laws of fluid diffusion, and also failing to dynamically interact with the surrounding environment.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07854", "filename": "5cd0bb476ef03e22290b279bc06d2e161952fa5382506232e08408af6cf85d80_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The duration is continuous (1.3s-4.6s). The smoke, similar to dry ice, should drift outwards when it overflows, rather than suddenly increasing and accumulating like foam.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07855", "filename": "5cd0bb476ef03e22290b279bc06d2e161952fa5382506232e08408af6cf85d80_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07860", "filename": "5cf597b49a0dfde8ca5f957036064a6ac0956cda896fae0304eaef8707e275a3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07861", "filename": "5cf597b49a0dfde8ca5f957036064a6ac0956cda896fae0304eaef8707e275a3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07863", "filename": "5d0b42bbf68d92d767697afbe6149e844def30d2905f7fb677826799369e8675_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (the light on the orange house wall on the right side of the video is flickering and wriggling.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07864", "filename": "5d0b42bbf68d92d767697afbe6149e844def30d2905f7fb677826799369e8675_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (the light reflected from the walls of the house in the image is constantly flickering, while the lights and the house are stationary; therefore, the reflected light should be still.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07865", "filename": "5d0b42bbf68d92d767697afbe6149e844def30d2905f7fb677826799369e8675_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07866", "filename": "5d0b42bbf68d92d767697afbe6149e844def30d2905f7fb677826799369e8675_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is discontinuous (snowflakes are only visible very close to the streetlights in the video, while they are not visible around the streetlights).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07872", "filename": "78ee957030609bedb37501d463ef28eaf950b08a7d8293142c5cc81c3d51dcda_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (at 0.5s in the video, white snowflakes suddenly appear out of nowhere in the window without any change in camera angle; then at 4.6s, the white snowflakes suddenly disappear).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07873", "filename": "78ee957030609bedb37501d463ef28eaf950b08a7d8293142c5cc81c3d51dcda_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the branches of a natural snowflake will show subtle shape changes due to differences in moisture environment, and will not be completely uniform. However, the eight branches of this snowflake in the image have completely uniform texture, length, and angle, lacking the random details of a natural snowflake).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07874", "filename": "78ee957030609bedb37501d463ef28eaf950b08a7d8293142c5cc81c3d51dcda_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: Physical behavior (natural snowflakes are based on a six-fold symmetry structure formed by the crystallization of water molecules, but this snowflake exhibits an eight-fold symmetry, which completely violates the physical and chemical laws of ice crystal growth).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07875", "filename": "78ee957030609bedb37501d463ef28eaf950b08a7d8293142c5cc81c3d51dcda_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the natural texture of a snowflake has a natural transition in density and thickness, but the texture of this snowflake is too uniform and rigid, lacking the layers and randomness of ice crystal growth).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07880", "filename": "79f1254b0517c894e1798f10a847e1b6b6aeb855c59db69f1263372b814e2725_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (at 0s in the video, the water falling from the air appears flat before even touching the water surface).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07881", "filename": "79f1254b0517c894e1798f10a847e1b6b6aeb855c59db69f1263372b814e2725_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (from 3.9s to the end of the video, without any change in the camera angle, no more liquid drips into the water, yet the water surface retains its concave shape).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07882", "filename": "79f1254b0517c894e1798f10a847e1b6b6aeb855c59db69f1263372b814e2725_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 0.2s in the video, when the green liquid flows into the water, the first contact surface suddenly turns into a droplet shape and stays on the water surface without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07883", "filename": "79f1254b0517c894e1798f10a847e1b6b6aeb855c59db69f1263372b814e2725_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.4 seconds into the video, before the green liquid has even flowed into the water, a large amount of green liquid appears out of thin air on the surface of the water).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07884", "filename": "80bf880071151c848f5d531293710d020c77c783a0792af4f0c163bdd913785e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the cause and effect relationship is unreasonable (the surface of the wood does not change at all during the burning process of the wood in the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07885", "filename": "80bf880071151c848f5d531293710d020c77c783a0792af4f0c163bdd913785e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the continuity of time is abnormal (at 4.9s in the video, the wood suddenly turns completely red during the burning process, showing a uniform and abnormally high temperature and red-hot state, which is inconsistent with the localized burning of the flames shown in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07886", "filename": "80bf880071151c848f5d531293710d020c77c783a0792af4f0c163bdd913785e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the trees in the background are blurry and semi-transparent with no clear light and shadow, while the burning wood in the foreground has a strong contrast between light and dark, and the two are completely inconsistent in terms of lighting logic and material texture).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07891", "filename": "80d7f7a1c6a14ecdaf7eff979d7926dbc547941db1275714f2166346556b8407_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 0.4s in the video, after the object in the hand is flipped, a smiley face appears out of thin air on the surface of the object).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07892", "filename": "80d7f7a1c6a14ecdaf7eff979d7926dbc547941db1275714f2166346556b8407_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (at 0.2s in the video, the video suddenly switches without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07893", "filename": "80d7f7a1c6a14ecdaf7eff979d7926dbc547941db1275714f2166346556b8407_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 3.1s in the video, the white dot on the right eye of the doll in the hand disappears out of thin air without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07894", "filename": "80d7f7a1c6a14ecdaf7eff979d7926dbc547941db1275714f2166346556b8407_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 2s in the video, the green doll in the character's hand suddenly turns into a yellow doll without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07899", "filename": "81a5df86433b2b6355185ca15b5239f7e64246e1f2c7adfb7e755134187fe476_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 0.4s in the video, without any change in the camera angle, a yellow chestnut suddenly appears in the pot).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07900", "filename": "81a5df86433b2b6355185ca15b5239f7e64246e1f2c7adfb7e755134187fe476_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 0.1 seconds into the video, without any change in camera angle, two chestnuts suddenly appear in the pot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07901", "filename": "777613865b39134e54ca77c74ca480997f3a3568598c8b4f6a09052c5222541f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is continuous (the nail of the person's left thumb in the 4.4s video becomes smaller), and the overall visual impression is abnormal (from 2.3s to 5s, the clay breaks after being stretched without any sponge-like fibrous structure; the break is smooth, unlike real footage, and lacks the fibrous structure that should be present after the clay is stretched).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07902", "filename": "777613865b39134e54ca77c74ca480997f3a3568598c8b4f6a09052c5222541f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal; the time is continuous (2.2s-5.8s). The super light clay suddenly turns into a silicone-like texture after being closed. Under normal circumstances, super light clay has fluidity and stickiness. After being shaped, it will slowly deform and spread out. It cannot maintain a fixed shape for a long time like silicone. Therefore, it cannot be opened again according to the original cut surface after being closed.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07903", "filename": "777613865b39134e54ca77c74ca480997f3a3568598c8b4f6a09052c5222541f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07904", "filename": "777613865b39134e54ca77c74ca480997f3a3568598c8b4f6a09052c5222541f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07905", "filename": "928362386cbd121ff8c4583b70ceaa9b5d600259a7b23e66dc0c08e59def10ed_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: Physical behavior (ordinary exhaust fumes are mainly composed of water vapor and carbon dioxide, which are almost invisible to the naked eye and only condense into a small amount of white mist in cold weather. However, the smoke in this video has a strong sense of particle size, high concentration, and obvious dust texture, which is more consistent with the characteristics of particles generated by rubber friction.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07906", "filename": "928362386cbd121ff8c4583b70ceaa9b5d600259a7b23e66dc0c08e59def10ed_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (normal vehicle exhaust is thin and transparent, with a small emission volume that dissipates quickly. However, the \"exhaust\" in the entire video is extremely large, appearing as a dense white smoke that lingers for a long time without dissipating, unlike real footage).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07907", "filename": "928362386cbd121ff8c4583b70ceaa9b5d600259a7b23e66dc0c08e59def10ed_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (4s-5s, the gas emitted from the car exhaust pipe does not dissipate in the surroundings, but disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07908", "filename": "6554279989b396b92d3e4c07472527bf32c38506e4b23f139f9f7a4a9a6ae154_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07909", "filename": "6554279989b396b92d3e4c07472527bf32c38506e4b23f139f9f7a4a9a6ae154_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (in the video from 5.3s to 5.8s, the ice on top of the cup suddenly melts and water flows out. At normal room temperature, the ice in the cup melts first on the side and then melts simultaneously from top to bottom. However, in the video, no liquid flows down the side of the cup).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07910", "filename": "6554279989b396b92d3e4c07472527bf32c38506e4b23f139f9f7a4a9a6ae154_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Physical behavior (3.9s-8s water flows through an intact glass onto the table, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07911", "filename": "6757335057b82c5b22f52ce02590bc1913ebce5030d7b3936b0509fe8e9caa22_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (0.2s-5s: the liquid drawn from the green liquid in the syringe turns yellow out of thin air). Physical behavior (2.6s-5s: a purple light appears out of thin air next to the syringe; all objects should not have the ability to emit light independently).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07912", "filename": "6757335057b82c5b22f52ce02590bc1913ebce5030d7b3936b0509fe8e9caa22_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (0s: the syringe suddenly becomes thicker and the scale color becomes lighter; 0.3s-5.8s: the liquid drawn from the green liquid in the syringe suddenly turns yellow; 3.2s-5.8s: the liquid in the syringe suddenly decreases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07913", "filename": "6757335057b82c5b22f52ce02590bc1913ebce5030d7b3936b0509fe8e9caa22_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (1.2s-5s, the liquid drawn from the syringe into the green liquid turns yellow out of thin air after being removed from the liquid surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07914", "filename": "6757335057b82c5b22f52ce02590bc1913ebce5030d7b3936b0509fe8e9caa22_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0.7s-8s: the liquid drawn from the green liquid by the syringe turns yellow out of thin air after being removed from the liquid surface) Physical behavior (5.4s-8s: the liquid in the syringe increases out of thin air after being removed from the container without any external force)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07915", "filename": "9933058110d2b51baed8fb556a6419e9c8c473637adca595178ca05b0669ed0e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall visual impression is abnormal (in the whole video, the flames of normal burning paper have soft edges and relatively stable outlines, while the edges of this flame are very sharp and accompanied by violent shaking and rolling, indicating that there is strong airflow disturbance in the burning area. This is usually the convection effect produced when liquid fuel evaporates and burns rapidly, unlike the actual burning of a cardboard box).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07916", "filename": "9933058110d2b51baed8fb556a6419e9c8c473637adca595178ca05b0669ed0e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall impression is off (the cardboard box used as the burning object in the video is very small, but the height of the flame patterns is 3-4 times that of the cardboard box. This imbalance of \"small fire source, high flame\" is not like a realistic scene.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07917", "filename": "10902171236ad0c0584285eb78d4f9c68946da1fdeee43537180c393d37dd7bb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (a large number of water droplets are suspended from the water outlet in the entire video footage and do not fall downwards. Under normal circumstances, water droplets would drip downwards due to gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07918", "filename": "10902171236ad0c0584285eb78d4f9c68946da1fdeee43537180c393d37dd7bb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, water droplets fall along the water column, maintaining a teardrop shape. Under normal circumstances, water droplets would not maintain a teardrop shape indefinitely due to gravity and air resistance).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07919", "filename": "10902171236ad0c0584285eb78d4f9c68946da1fdeee43537180c393d37dd7bb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07920", "filename": "10902171236ad0c0584285eb78d4f9c68946da1fdeee43537180c393d37dd7bb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07921", "filename": "18334341676fa40ea1aac660518e74c8365258bd1606a03a3fc386c3599cbc24_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is abnormal (after the explosion from 0.9s to 5s, the luminous object is a uniform bright white with a purple halo, lacking the orange-yellow high-temperature area or brightness variation of a real explosion flame, unlike a realistic scene).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07922", "filename": "18334341676fa40ea1aac660518e74c8365258bd1606a03a3fc386c3599cbc24_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall impression is off (a real explosion releases energy accompanied by shockwaves, upward-impacting flames, and flying debris, but the luminous object in the video from 1.1s to 2.6s appears as a uniform, sideways-impacting ellipsoid with no obvious signs of destruction, unlike a real explosion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07923", "filename": "18334341676fa40ea1aac660518e74c8365258bd1606a03a3fc386c3599cbc24_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: The overall visual presentation is off. (A real explosion produces high-temperature fragments driven by a shockwave, which scatter rapidly in all directions and then extinguish quickly. However, the sparks in the video from 0.9s to 3.3s appear as a uniform, dense, radial pattern, more like fireworks than a real explosion.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07924", "filename": "72195232190d16befcfb6498658829b84e489aacf463b8e55513e84ddb321b75_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is unusual: the overall visual impression is off (the manta ray in the image has a fin-like structure moving in the center of its abdomen, but the actual manta ray does not have this structure in the center of its abdomen, which is not like the real image).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07925", "filename": "72195232190d16befcfb6498658829b84e489aacf463b8e55513e84ddb321b75_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the colors of the real deep sea change with depth and light intensity, exhibiting clear gradients of light and dark. However, the blue background in the entire video is too uniform, lacking natural color transitions, unlike realistic footage).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07926", "filename": "72195232190d16befcfb6498658829b84e489aacf463b8e55513e84ddb321b75_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The time sequence is continuous (0.8s-5s). The diver's arm on the left side of the video turns into a manta ray-like pectoral fin and flaps up and down like wings.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07930", "filename": "4949992559379f60cc8a7b016d30c20cc543c967823f77ec7f819059bd7635b3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the arc of the milk being poured in the video is too stiff, the milk flows too smoothly, it doesn't look like a real scene, and it lacks the natural ripples and splashes that milk produces when it flows).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07931", "filename": "5bb4050858bd034d5674db7da1411761ff29ab59638cf24aab292bc9d0e28df7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (there is obvious water flow under the ice in the video, indicating that the ice is melting, but the size of the ice does not change from beginning to end).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07932", "filename": "5bb4050858bd034d5674db7da1411761ff29ab59638cf24aab292bc9d0e28df7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (at 4.1 seconds, ripples resembling those created by a pebble being thrown into water suddenly appear out of nowhere). Overall visual anomalies (the water appearing as the ice melts in the entire video is too smooth, unlike realistic footage, lacking the fluidity of water).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07933", "filename": "5bb4050858bd034d5674db7da1411761ff29ab59638cf24aab292bc9d0e28df7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (The entire video shows a clear flow of water beneath the ice, indicating that the ice is melting, but instead of shrinking, it gradually grows larger.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07934", "filename": "5bc1032dc996cfc78b660d3f161e3768e0dea03408b648ce11a8f1aaba38719e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07935", "filename": "5bc1032dc996cfc78b660d3f161e3768e0dea03408b648ce11a8f1aaba38719e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (in the entire video, the three candles are in the same room. Under normal circumstances, the air flow direction in the room is uniform, and the direction of the flame should also be consistent. However, the flame of each candle in the video moves in a different direction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07936", "filename": "5bc1032dc996cfc78b660d3f161e3768e0dea03408b648ce11a8f1aaba38719e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is inconsistent (the flames at the wicks of the first and last candles flicker violently, but the flames at the wicks of the middle candles only flicker slightly; normally, the flickering amplitude of the flames at the wicks of all three candles should be roughly the same).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07937", "filename": "5be5b105468cd4a08ae38c18a0355ea9c351808e7a84b1e42bdbf2bf68d02ca5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Continuity of time (the flames of the white flammable material are violently flickering throughout the video, indicating wind, but the vegetation in the background remains unchanged. There is a flickering effect in the vegetation section of the video.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07938", "filename": "5be5b105468cd4a08ae38c18a0355ea9c351808e7a84b1e42bdbf2bf68d02ca5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (at 5 seconds, the flames haven't yet spread to the bottom of the toilet paper roll, but obvious burn marks appear out of nowhere below it). Overall visual anomalies (the burn marks on the toilet paper roll spread too smoothly throughout the video, unlike realistic footage).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07939", "filename": "5be5b105468cd4a08ae38c18a0355ea9c351808e7a84b1e42bdbf2bf68d02ca5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (at 2.5s, the flames have not yet spread to the area under the toilet paper, but flames suddenly appear out of nowhere below the toilet paper. There is no smoke produced during the burning process of the toilet paper from 0 to 1.5s, and the smoke only suddenly appears at 1.5s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07940", "filename": "5be5b105468cd4a08ae38c18a0355ea9c351808e7a84b1e42bdbf2bf68d02ca5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (at 4.8 seconds, a white strip suddenly appears out of nowhere on the right side of the toilet paper roll).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07941", "filename": "5bec4141447f7a1dbf16d2f8a5be77225d0ba77ae498a4a9f887200c3ba64864_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is due to physical behavior (at 1.5s, the pencil penetrates the bottom of the glass, violating the principle that solids are impermeable; between 1.15 and 5s, the pencil is placed in a glass of water, but no refraction occurs, violating the physical law of refraction).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07942", "filename": "5bec4141447f7a1dbf16d2f8a5be77225d0ba77ae498a4a9f887200c3ba64864_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Physical behavior (at 4s, the pencil stands upright in the cup without any force applied, violating Newton's First Law).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07943", "filename": "5bec4141447f7a1dbf16d2f8a5be77225d0ba77ae498a4a9f887200c3ba64864_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 2.1s, the pencil tip disappears out of thin air in the glass). Physical behavior (at 1.8s, the pencil tip penetrates the bottom of the glass, violating the principle that solids are impermeable). Overall visual anomalies (from 4.6s to 8s, the trajectory of the pencil floating in the water-filled glass is too smooth, unlike a realistic scene).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07944", "filename": "5bff4939deee32ae2d114f78f6ac01a76b631115d9d4ff3c04847f06794ebef3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4s, there is no obvious upward trajectory of the fireworks in the sky, but the fireworks appear out of nowhere.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07945", "filename": "5bff4939deee32ae2d114f78f6ac01a76b631115d9d4ff3c04847f06794ebef3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (at 0.9s, the shape of fireworks appeared on the walls of the two buildings on the right in the video, but there were obviously no large pieces of glass on the walls, which violated the principle of light refraction).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_07946", "filename": "5bff4939deee32ae2d114f78f6ac01a76b631115d9d4ff3c04847f06794ebef3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07947", "filename": "5c3b8cc175e6d2ef93c75f5dd2894719a67ad56f590d388be3a1645df80068d1_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07948", "filename": "5c3b8cc175e6d2ef93c75f5dd2894719a67ad56f590d388be3a1645df80068d1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: The time sequence is continuous (at 1.1s, the liquid has not yet flowed to the right side of the colored solid, but there are already obvious traces of liquid flow on the right side of the colored solid.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07949", "filename": "5c3b8cc175e6d2ef93c75f5dd2894719a67ad56f590d388be3a1645df80068d1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07950", "filename": "5c3b8cc175e6d2ef93c75f5dd2894719a67ad56f590d388be3a1645df80068d1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07951", "filename": "5c8c8cf69ad79e216f3c1ac31a96832180600ca6218cb97c1dffe581706f9a52_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 2.7s, the green ball on the left floats in the air without any force applied; normally, the ball should fly directly out of the frame. From 3.20 to 5s, it suddenly moves to the right, violating the laws of gravity and Newton's first law).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07952", "filename": "5c8c8cf69ad79e216f3c1ac31a96832180600ca6218cb97c1dffe581706f9a52_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0s, the green ball to the left of the red balloon suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07957", "filename": "5c291a99873028d0cc1fd31ab463cdae647a8ac1076b8ff54c9fb3892386f0f8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 4.4s, the sky has completely turned black, but from 4.4s to 5s, the sky gradually brightens again).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07958", "filename": "5c291a99873028d0cc1fd31ab463cdae647a8ac1076b8ff54c9fb3892386f0f8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07959", "filename": "5c291a99873028d0cc1fd31ab463cdae647a8ac1076b8ff54c9fb3892386f0f8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_07960", "filename": "5c291a99873028d0cc1fd31ab463cdae647a8ac1076b8ff54c9fb3892386f0f8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (the movement of clouds in the sky throughout the video is too smooth and unnatural, unlike real footage). Continuous timing (black clouds suddenly appear in the sky at 1.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07961", "filename": "b81b42020c1b4c8dc3ca6a9a996c9ce78813ab9e115c6943868156379641a5b5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 7.2s, a piece of yellow cream in the middle of the screen moves without any external force, and the cream in the screen keeps flashing and the animation quality is unstable).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07962", "filename": "b90cf9eb40fae6580a87d97c2614572d7f4ec41fae502e10faf9981d5bf863ca_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous (the water ripples are unevenly distributed and jerky in the video; the ripples on the left are blurry, scattered, and irregular, while the ripples in the lower right corner are evenly distributed).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07963", "filename": "b93de5d386ab1fe631e2f2e6a0b3a54b6a1b24f01ac436950bba86f17e15a20b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous (the waterfall flow in the video is too abrupt, like a synthesized column of water. When the waterfall hits the rocks, it should create splashing water droplets, but this is not shown in the video. Also, the entire video flickers unnaturally).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07964", "filename": "b98ab5289ac0f7c4b1de085de61049f7abf92173557caedf6d1967275c9c7dd0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the rainbow stripes on the foil in the entire video frame flicker and shake unnaturally).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07965", "filename": "b472b4589b1fc6ff384ce608715bdc54f2437663acb0fed48cbb770e21cdb461_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: The screen flickers and stutters at 1.7s and 5s due to continuous time intervals.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07966", "filename": "b597b9e7fa8847351eee9fa63ddb7d3b5d7c129bcca9379b2cc1268d3ae4f980_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: Time continuity (the timer on the phone flickers and distorts, and at 5.6 seconds, the clock on the phone suddenly changes from 7.6 seconds to 7 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07967", "filename": "b744df7162e8d408269f070a32e6495a2f110cb12ded5118289d5426f0e2dd8e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the flashlight beam in the picture is a dot, but suddenly a diverging beam appears on the CD).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07968", "filename": "b994d9f4328ed1f99431d9282c2cceb79e58d41c8b69508a94d81fb6986c0949_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (the clouds in the high sky appear as \"delicate stripes\" but below them is the warm-toned light of the sunset. The transition between the cool-toned clouds in the high sky and the warm-toned sunset clouds in the low sky is rather abrupt, as if the clouds at different times are spliced together. Also, at 0s and 2.8s in the video, black birds suddenly appear out of nowhere and fly by in the clouds, without any consistency).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07969", "filename": "b2102dc5ed0a7bdebcfdd74572f3b212a2c0d97f914250336bc1c75253b2d914_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (clouds at the top of the screen suddenly begin to change drastically while clouds at the bottom remain stationary).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07970", "filename": "b2871d7038cb23bfee66ffbb086dac3c8076458ed7894cc4b66e44cdb91992d6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.5s, the white object in the screen suddenly turns gold and extends upwards, and the entire object begins to flicker and distort).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07971", "filename": "b3341fae0bfeb4b12964effd17d3ed86c82574d316b0d6408c155a3abdc153c8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 4.4s, the flames of the burning firewood in the video suddenly disappear and merge with the charcoal, and the whole piece of firewood is flickering and shaking).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07972", "filename": "b5091a3807e2a9d5a081b4a24df029aa0fe08479b1ee4308eaf01ce5238433ee_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (0.8 seconds). The purple sphere in the middle starts to melt rapidly and floats up and rolls down. The white sphere on the right also floats down and flows out a lot of liquid.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07973", "filename": "b7674e7a99d422100cc19b900ec2d24a9c92e4d78c06db0bf84772787661e1ec_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the moving light spot in the image suddenly stops moving at 2.9s, and the color changes at 5.6s, with the blue light gradually dimming and the white spot gradually turning yellow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07974", "filename": "b9607b38bcecb38ead4260251eb80752907d1587d44a974708ecde7c26c1f4d0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07975", "filename": "b9620c1f66b8f4784eaf335b5af685e5d893d009d3ac0c86a4fe39f48a017783_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07976", "filename": "b9817cfe71439bb40d5cadf634707ae46d324474befbd34973a803ba0867c89b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time frame is continuous (the face reflected on the blackboard in the 5.4s frame looks strange and has no facial features).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07978", "filename": "b3487526e04297d2f90a6cc94c2a61603209fad4d274416c6fda0f755690ec53_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 5.9s in the video, the strawberry on the table suddenly starts flickering and shaking).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07979", "filename": "b9800476e05034a291ba2ca0fe26ff8dc7320aed87475b35710b17242568c8c3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (the video shows 64x speed in the lower left corner, but the water in the left cup melts much slower than the water in the right cup, and the ice cubes in both cups remain unchanged while the water in the cups increases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07980", "filename": "b51321216bddc1c1dd94d5b6a54d321bb12e5cde999664153bc08de9f7eeee79_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is inconsistent (at 4.6s, the sunlight in the video suddenly weakens, and there is no consistency between the beginning and end).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07981", "filename": "b72652830b8271bb797c71b9a62bffafdd78d1b614435a16b81102716bcc9d0a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the entire object is suspended in mid-air throughout the video, which does not conform to the laws of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07982", "filename": "ba8f5230931c4eec3b2bf4da1fc44e46f4aea2217bd0bf3bf7d8bd859644b50b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (at 1.4s, the flames suddenly change color, and the entire screen gradually changes from red to dark gray; at 3.3s, the firewood does not change color, but the flames suddenly shrink without any external force, showing no consistency).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07983", "filename": "ba21d82546c53a1357c1fd0bea02c775e4ab1297d7d8039b1caf7545396bde98_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (after the explosion in the video, the black car on the left, which was very close, only shook slightly, and the blasted area returned to its original state).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07984", "filename": "bb4db348c25de1db9a421e93d5862d2e0b62862076640692d203dc5f969ff851_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the cactus in the image does not appear to be a solid object and its transparency is not high enough to blend into the background).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07985", "filename": "bbe4c4262fe9662234069c3f123a8c2962fabddaec66cfd63960dbc2705190bc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the waterfall flows rapidly in the upper half of the video, but the pond water flows slowly in the lower half, creating a strong sense of image segmentation).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_07986", "filename": "bc1067fa266551361c33027f91fead77d011466e91375f965125a2694d17201c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: The time is continuous (in the 2.6s video, a white reflective spot suddenly appears in the middle of the ring, flickering and shaking).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07987", "filename": "bce2dc099bd9a9d5e14f09489a8959810cbb487dc2c4b12813012e0fb8a4a826_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07988", "filename": "bce42a4e8f6a486af1f4125cd170a09221604b481e4558956deb941751dcf060_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (when sunlight shines through the leaves, the movement of the leaves creates subtle changes in light spots and shadows. However, throughout the entire video, the light spots and the relationship between light and shadow on the leaves remain completely fixed in all shots).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07989", "filename": "bd4e2f00ea410d960064ec7d56da945a9c5622a049090e95f46516d44849f9d6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (two types of clouds appear simultaneously in the video: thick, dark gray cumulonimbus clouds above and bright blue sky and white clouds below, creating a sense of disjointedness in the image).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_07991", "filename": "6952816c204af8a3ef1914bceba175d69c3e1291fca9bb6efa0ae7b373e8faec_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Overall timing is inconsistent (the water splashes at the rim of the glass are too regular, lacking the random detail of realistic splashing. Also, the reflection of the glass on the table and the light and shadow of the liquid inside the glass do not form a unified perspective). Temporal continuity is also inconsistent (ripples continuously appear out of nowhere at the bottom of the glass throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07992", "filename": "6952816c204af8a3ef1914bceba175d69c3e1291fca9bb6efa0ae7b373e8faec_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual presentation is abnormal (the poured red liquid column has a stiff shape, lacking the dynamic curvature of real liquid flow. The splashes and ripples inside the cup are also rough, with blurry and repetitive textures, lacking the random and natural layering of real liquid splashing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_07993", "filename": "7089983d2a2c031eb591f136f46f786087c2b6f69acb039376464c346e3fcfcc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (at 3.2 seconds, the clouds drifting in the sky suddenly disappear. Under normal circumstances, the clouds should continue to drift with the wind and should not suddenly disappear.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07994", "filename": "7089983d2a2c031eb591f136f46f786087c2b6f69acb039376464c346e3fcfcc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the distant clouds in the entire video appear out of nowhere, rather than drifting in from further away.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07995", "filename": "7535087af198f72cd3366f94fe3a1c42962c52abb1d511fb6b66406e0bd7884a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4 seconds, the third metal bar on the table suddenly disappeared.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07996", "filename": "7535087af198f72cd3366f94fe3a1c42962c52abb1d511fb6b66406e0bd7884a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 4.4s, the yellow ball in the character's hand suddenly turns blue and spins in the character's hand without any external force.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07997", "filename": "7535087af198f72cd3366f94fe3a1c42962c52abb1d511fb6b66406e0bd7884a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 4.2s, the first and second iron bars on the table twisted and deformed.) Physical behavior (at 5s, all five iron bars were penetrated, violating the principle that solids are impermeable.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_07998", "filename": "7535087af198f72cd3366f94fe3a1c42962c52abb1d511fb6b66406e0bd7884a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.7s, the green ball suddenly turns blue the instant the character places it on the table.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08002", "filename": "8565312dcfec53f7b5287b8696957bd1cbb48c048184b5484830a8f7792d2927_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (Real frost flowers are crystals formed by water vapor condensing on cold glass, typically exhibiting continuous and regular dendritic textures extending from the edges to the center. However, the dendritic textures of the ice flowers in the image are broken and random, with some lines being too straight, lacking the natural branching and delicate crystalline layers of real ice flowers.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08003", "filename": "8565312dcfec53f7b5287b8696957bd1cbb48c048184b5484830a8f7792d2927_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: The overall visual appearance is abnormal. (Real frost patterns are formed by water vapor condensing on glass. The texture of each crystal is unique, and the branching will show a natural, irregular gradient. However, the ice flower texture in the picture is highly repetitive, and the branching is too regular, like a copied and pasted template, lacking the randomness and delicate layers of real ice flowers.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08004", "filename": "8565312dcfec53f7b5287b8696957bd1cbb48c048184b5484830a8f7792d2927_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.7s, an ice flower appears out of nowhere in the center of the screen.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08005", "filename": "8565312dcfec53f7b5287b8696957bd1cbb48c048184b5484830a8f7792d2927_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: The overall visual appearance is abnormal. (Real frost patterns are formed by water vapor condensing on glass. The texture of each crystal is unique, and the branching will show a natural, irregular gradient. However, the ice flower texture in the picture is highly repetitive, and the branching is too regular, like a copied and pasted template, lacking the randomness and delicate layers of real ice flowers.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08006", "filename": "8738977bd46f7b131572f684b608dada85e09fbc83000198bdbd1f7a1013cf7b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: The overall visual presentation is abnormal (as a strong light source, flames should have a natural halo and thermal disturbance effect around them, but there is no smooth transition of light and shadow between the background and the flames in the image, and the edges are sharply defined. The scattered white dots in the background are also unrelated to the light source logic of the flames and appear to be randomly generated noise.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08007", "filename": "8738977bd46f7b131572f684b608dada85e09fbc83000198bdbd1f7a1013cf7b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (The texture of a real flame is dynamic and layered, exhibiting irregular rolling and changes in light and shadow. However, the flame in the image has blurred edges, lacks detail in its texture, and even shows repetitive color blocks, lacking the delicate dynamic wrinkles of a real flame.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08008", "filename": "8738977bd46f7b131572f684b608dada85e09fbc83000198bdbd1f7a1013cf7b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (The texture of a real flame is dynamic and irregular, with natural rolling and gradations of light and shadow. However, the flame color blocks in the image show regular repetition, with blurred edges and a lack of delicate dynamic wrinkles.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08009", "filename": "9058487d8b32ea62d52e615106a32768fba98ed5ae77f1fccb983da73e504038_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (The base of a real thunderstorm cloud exhibits complex tonal gradations due to lightning and underlying light, while the color transitions of the clouds in the image are too smooth, lacking the rich texture and light and shadow details of a realistic cloud. Additionally, the transition between the yellow light near the horizon and the dark clouds above is abrupt, lacking a natural atmospheric scattering effect.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08010", "filename": "9058487d8b32ea62d52e615106a32768fba98ed5ae77f1fccb983da73e504038_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: The overall visual presentation is abnormal (a clear rain curtain is visible in the image, but there is no natural transition between it and the thick clouds above. In a real scene, rain falls vertically from the bottom of the clouds and blends into the cloud base, while the rain curtain in the image appears as a harshly superimposed block of color below the clouds.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08011", "filename": "9058487d8b32ea62d52e615106a32768fba98ed5ae77f1fccb983da73e504038_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The time sequence is continuous (at 4.5 seconds, a large amount of black clouds suddenly appear in the sky and rapidly converge towards the center of the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08012", "filename": "9534744d9a02038d43d502367ab2caf47b51303d8f616740032331ccb884e7a7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the entire video shows white liquid being poured into a glass of black liquid, but the volume of the liquid in the glass does not change significantly, and the two different colored liquids mixed in the glass do not produce a color change).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08013", "filename": "9534744d9a02038d43d502367ab2caf47b51303d8f616740032331ccb884e7a7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior (A real reflection would be perfectly symmetrical to the shape and position of the cup, but the reflection in the image does not match the outline of the cup or the angle of the handle. The direction of the handle is clearly misaligned in the reflection, and the texture of the liquid does not form a symmetrical mirror effect.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08014", "filename": "9534744d9a02038d43d502367ab2caf47b51303d8f616740032331ccb884e7a7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 7.4 seconds, the white liquid poured into the cup and the black liquid in the cup instantly merged without stirring.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08015", "filename": "9881632a611e617c4020d2aa9bf3af63d6c742a376b8a10c8d48b7452b4b47f4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: The overall visual presentation is off. (A real ground wildfire would leave the surrounding dry grass and branches charred and carbonized. However, the vegetation around the flames in the image simply appears to darken in color, lacking the details of a real fire\u2014the vegetation collapsing and turning to ash. It looks as if the flames are simply plastered onto the ground.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08016", "filename": "9881632a611e617c4020d2aa9bf3af63d6c742a376b8a10c8d48b7452b4b47f4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4 seconds, a large fire suddenly appears on an open field in the distance.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08017", "filename": "16129543ed6b68e7979f5143488896924c89e6da6692276f02678c0ad3810f2e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (A real reflection would be perfectly symmetrical to the swan's posture and outline, but in this image, the shape of the neck and head in the reflection is severely misaligned with the swan's actual body, failing to create a natural mirror image. Furthermore, the reflection below the swan's body lacks feather details, and its transition to the water ripples is very abrupt.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08018", "filename": "16129543ed6b68e7979f5143488896924c89e6da6692276f02678c0ad3810f2e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior (A real reflection would be perfectly symmetrical to the swan's posture and outline, but in the image, the shape of the neck and head of the reflection is severely misaligned with the swan's actual body, failing to form a natural mirror image.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08019", "filename": "16129543ed6b68e7979f5143488896924c89e6da6692276f02678c0ad3810f2e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: In a realistic reflection, the swan's posture and outline would be perfectly symmetrical. However, in this image, the shape of the neck and head in the reflection is severely misaligned with the swan's actual body, failing to create a natural mirror image.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08025", "filename": "69ef43bc7e2de99f838ebea75f8473ccd6afb6ec545116f3fa131eccc948e7f6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (the water surface at the top flickers throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08026", "filename": "69ef43bc7e2de99f838ebea75f8473ccd6afb6ec545116f3fa131eccc948e7f6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual inconsistencies (the wood burning in the video appears too smooth and lacks a natural feel); Causality issues (the wood on the right side of the video shows no change after burning).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08027", "filename": "69ef43bc7e2de99f838ebea75f8473ccd6afb6ec545116f3fa131eccc948e7f6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is continuous (the water surface at the top of the entire video is flickering and jumping).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08028", "filename": "70a3fb395f189f81085381670514ebec6513562ba76e66f5cc52e013ec72d8bd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the coin moves upward and rotates without external force at 0s) Time continuity (the coin twists and deforms at 2.3s and 2.5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08029", "filename": "70a3fb395f189f81085381670514ebec6513562ba76e66f5cc52e013ec72d8bd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the coin suddenly stands upright at 1.4s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08030", "filename": "70a82fda594fcccf68a3eb166043f9ef6e84ee63a7557c3899a84f3cf5cfb942_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (at 0s, a white dot suddenly appears on the left side of the tree stump; at 0.1s, a red light suddenly appears without transition in the video; at 0.2s, the smoke above the tree stump suddenly fades; at 4s, a red light suddenly appears on the left side of the tree stump).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08031", "filename": "70a82fda594fcccf68a3eb166043f9ef6e84ee63a7557c3899a84f3cf5cfb942_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the wooden stakes produce a lot of smoke without burning throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08032", "filename": "70a82fda594fcccf68a3eb166043f9ef6e84ee63a7557c3899a84f3cf5cfb942_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 0.3s, there is no transition in the video footage, and an explosion suddenly appears above the wooden stake; at 0.4s, a flame suddenly appears in the lower right corner of the wooden stake).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08033", "filename": "70a82fda594fcccf68a3eb166043f9ef6e84ee63a7557c3899a84f3cf5cfb942_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.6s, white filaments suddenly appear on the right side of the smoke and begin to twist; at 5.1s, a large amount of black smoke suddenly emerges from under the tree stump)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08034", "filename": "70c51c4d38821d07ae35b4e828b06c03a55b578d1ec4c5950c11ea68f0cf1ada_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the entire video frame is shaking).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08035", "filename": "70c51c4d38821d07ae35b4e828b06c03a55b578d1ec4c5950c11ea68f0cf1ada_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08036", "filename": "70c51c4d38821d07ae35b4e828b06c03a55b578d1ec4c5950c11ea68f0cf1ada_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08037", "filename": "71b9c0b287bcf8298696326f55a40c42b88be370730e78067c0cd8e454d08772_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (from 0.1s to 1.9s, the hammer is squeezed and twisted, its volume shrinks, and at 1s, the front end of a hook suddenly appears on the lower left side of the hammer).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08038", "filename": "71b9c0b287bcf8298696326f55a40c42b88be370730e78067c0cd8e454d08772_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 0.7s, a cylindrical metal object suddenly appears on the hydraulic press; at 1.6s, the hammer's shape changes and its surface becomes smooth; at 3.7s, the object on the left front of the hammer shrinks and deforms; at 4.8s, the volume of the compressed object begins to increase). Causality (the hammer only appears to be compressed at 1.1s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08039", "filename": "71b9c0b287bcf8298696326f55a40c42b88be370730e78067c0cd8e454d08772_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (at 1.3s, the upper part of the hammer that was squeezed disappears; at 2.8s, the hammer returns to its original shape).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08040", "filename": "71b9c0b287bcf8298696326f55a40c42b88be370730e78067c0cd8e454d08772_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 2.1s, a white light and shadow suddenly appear on the wall behind; at 3.2s, the hammer splits in the middle; from 5.1s to 5.7s, the squeezed hammer deforms and transforms into other shapes of iron objects); Physical behavior (at 5s, the squeezed hammer suddenly jumps upwards).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08041", "filename": "71e9e3d24d7e812b6023e02d322e8a4c915510f0af280ad126bd47b402a3f2d0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 2.1s, the wooden strip above the metal object suddenly disappears; at 4.1s, wood chips suddenly appear at the tip of the right thumb).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08042", "filename": "71e9e3d24d7e812b6023e02d322e8a4c915510f0af280ad126bd47b402a3f2d0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the volume of the very tip of the wooden strip suddenly shrinks at 0.3s) Physical behavior (the object in the hand clips through the wooden strip at 3s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08043", "filename": "71ec1cbd9351409ba4b2ff84a7fefe717eee47eb3caed51fce13df36399040eb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.3s, the sun has already set, but the sky brightens up again).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08044", "filename": "71ec1cbd9351409ba4b2ff84a7fefe717eee47eb3caed51fce13df36399040eb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (the color of the image changes from light blue to dark blue, then from dark blue to light purple, and then back to dark purple throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08045", "filename": "71ec1cbd9351409ba4b2ff84a7fefe717eee47eb3caed51fce13df36399040eb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.7 seconds, the video shows a sunset, but the sun rises again).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08046", "filename": "71ec1cbd9351409ba4b2ff84a7fefe717eee47eb3caed51fce13df36399040eb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.7s, the clouds begin to darken and thicken; at 5.3s, black dots suddenly appear in the left sky; at 6.1s, black dots suddenly appear in the left sky).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08051", "filename": "b7efa13c8cea12855ecf5292810d5b479e57de7d65e84f8206b67662db4f40f2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 4.4s, the door suddenly deforms without any force, and the left door frame bulges).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08052", "filename": "b7efa13c8cea12855ecf5292810d5b479e57de7d65e84f8206b67662db4f40f2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 5.1 seconds, after the Ferris wheel's lights change color, its support structure and lights begin to rotate separately. The Ferris wheel's mechanical structure cannot allow the lights and support structure to move independently).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08053", "filename": "b08a679a4a9919b88a21597eb277f550048e8bd9428ca018d0df79745ab9d71a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomalies in the footage: Time continuity (at 2.8s, the leaves on the island are abnormally distorted; at 2.8s, without any change in camera angle, many waves appear out of nowhere on the sea surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08054", "filename": "b08a679a4a9919b88a21597eb277f550048e8bd9428ca018d0df79745ab9d71a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the waves on the sea surface are completely still throughout the entire scene, without any natural undulation or movement).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08055", "filename": "b08a679a4a9919b88a21597eb277f550048e8bd9428ca018d0df79745ab9d71a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08056", "filename": "b08a679a4a9919b88a21597eb277f550048e8bd9428ca018d0df79745ab9d71a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the waves in the entire scene do not move forward or rise and fall naturally; they simply repeat the same breaking and churning motions in place, and there are no new changes in the ripples and foam on the sea surface.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08062", "filename": "b8c44fc163e22c1bb4724805236a0283d88f678d1b65992ebc6478cd170c1943_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 2.6 seconds, without any camera movement, the upper left part of the egg in the pot disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08063", "filename": "b8c44fc163e22c1bb4724805236a0283d88f678d1b65992ebc6478cd170c1943_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.9 seconds, the lower right corner of the scrambled eggs in the pan suddenly flashes a colored stripe without being moved or obstructed by the spatula, and then the shape and position of the scrambled eggs also change).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08064", "filename": "b8c44fc163e22c1bb4724805236a0283d88f678d1b65992ebc6478cd170c1943_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08065", "filename": "b8c44fc163e22c1bb4724805236a0283d88f678d1b65992ebc6478cd170c1943_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08066", "filename": "b8d21aca68b6debd69c9840970a9f306111cc37407263e2c483762557e808d67_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 4s, the tree branch in the left rear disappears out of thin air without any camera movement).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08067", "filename": "b8d21aca68b6debd69c9840970a9f306111cc37407263e2c483762557e808d67_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.5s, the sun and clouds suddenly move rapidly to the right, while the tree branches below instantly change from pure black silhouettes to solid objects with sunlight details; the transition is very abrupt.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08068", "filename": "b8d21aca68b6debd69c9840970a9f306111cc37407263e2c483762557e808d67_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is unpredictable (at 3.4 seconds, without changing the camera angle, the sun and clouds suddenly slide rapidly to the right, while a large cloud on the left disappears abruptly, and the light and shadow on the tree branches suddenly brighten, making the entire scene jump very abruptly).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08069", "filename": "b8d21aca68b6debd69c9840970a9f306111cc37407263e2c483762557e808d67_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08070", "filename": "b9b63817e79e8de902656867e048f38455ca1f6634d9c4a47321a0de5c83ff37_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the underwater ripples and waves in the video are repeating the same motion without natural progression or change; it is clearly a single image being played in a loop).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08071", "filename": "b9b63817e79e8de902656867e048f38455ca1f6634d9c4a47321a0de5c83ff37_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (between 2.3s and 4.9s, without any camera cuts, the ripples on the seabed disappear and reappear out of nowhere.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08072", "filename": "b9b63817e79e8de902656867e048f38455ca1f6634d9c4a47321a0de5c83ff37_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08073", "filename": "b9b63817e79e8de902656867e048f38455ca1f6634d9c4a47321a0de5c83ff37_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the underwater ripples in the video keep looping the same undulating and fragmented dynamics, without any natural progression or new changes; it's clearly just repeating a few seconds of footage).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08078", "filename": "b9e967e750905af9c3d7993395acd40efcbc6583d60de39aa917df3a28ebb7d6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (the surface of the asphalt pile under construction in the footage is abnormally distorted; at 3.5 seconds, without any camera cut, the asphalt appears out of thin air in the cart).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08079", "filename": "b9e967e750905af9c3d7993395acd40efcbc6583d60de39aa917df3a28ebb7d6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (at 3.4s, without any camera cut, asphalt suddenly increases inside the car).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08080", "filename": "b9e967e750905af9c3d7993395acd40efcbc6583d60de39aa917df3a28ebb7d6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 2.6s, without any camera cut, the asphalt in the cart disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08082", "filename": "725aad3acf2630212eccfeff196ed393ef472671524924cb830d0c461568569b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical effects (the track suddenly breaks and then recovers without external force between 1.5s and 1.7s); Time continuity (an orange blurry object appears out of nowhere in the lower left corner between 1.9s and 1.9s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08083", "filename": "725aad3acf2630212eccfeff196ed393ef472671524924cb830d0c461568569b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08084", "filename": "725aad3acf2630212eccfeff196ed393ef472671524924cb830d0c461568569b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08085", "filename": "725aad3acf2630212eccfeff196ed393ef472671524924cb830d0c461568569b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08086", "filename": "746d7893bfdc6565429c80f2cfb14e8fc0f77f7f26411b67067a5b18e42748ff_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical phenomena (0.9s-1.5s: the wooden stick in the left hand spontaneously combusts without fire, which does not conform to objective physical laws; 2.7s-3.5s: the fire source in the left hand ignites the wooden stick in the right hand, which burns rapidly without producing ash, which does not conform to the physical laws of combustion of solid combustibles; 4.8s: the object in the left hand of the person in the footage moves towards the fire without external force, which violates the law of gravity; the two wooden sticks in the center of the fire throughout the video are not affected by the flames)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08087", "filename": "746d7893bfdc6565429c80f2cfb14e8fc0f77f7f26411b67067a5b18e42748ff_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the burning wooden stick remained in its pre-burning state without being damaged or consumed; only the shape of the flame changed, violating the correlation between combustion reaction and material change; from 0.8s to 1.9s, the wooden stick automatically closed together before the person's action of gathering the wooden stick had even begun).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08088", "filename": "746d7893bfdc6565429c80f2cfb14e8fc0f77f7f26411b67067a5b18e42748ff_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08089", "filename": "746d7893bfdc6565429c80f2cfb14e8fc0f77f7f26411b67067a5b18e42748ff_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the horizontally placed wooden strips in the entire video are engulfed in flames but show no damage or charring).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08090", "filename": "754d1b868f64a84803976e2feccb16651fc9ca30e262900beaa48b6b08a6b985_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08091", "filename": "754d1b868f64a84803976e2feccb16651fc9ca30e262900beaa48b6b08a6b985_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (5.6s-5.9s) The light has not yet fully moved to the lower part, but the surrounding brightness does not change with the change of the light direction.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08092", "filename": "754d1b868f64a84803976e2feccb16651fc9ca30e262900beaa48b6b08a6b985_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (4.2s-5s: The person's hand movements have no direct effect on the force exerted on the lamp body; the lamp body automatically turns in the corresponding direction, violating the law of the relationship between mechanical action and motion).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08093", "filename": "754d1b868f64a84803976e2feccb16651fc9ca30e262900beaa48b6b08a6b985_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the movements in the scene are too smooth, unlike realistic footage, lacking the cadence and nuances expected in real life).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08094", "filename": "756b80d8aa04a9e4cd1354c56d30a76097bc6092eab99cc16cb230a6ca213fd2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The screen display is abnormal: the color changes from blue to orange from 0.2s to 3.8s, and then from orange to blue from 3.9s to 5s.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08095", "filename": "756b80d8aa04a9e4cd1354c56d30a76097bc6092eab99cc16cb230a6ca213fd2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (all the ice cubes in the cup rotate automatically without any external force, violating the basic laws of mechanics); Time continuity (the sticker behind the cup gradually disappears as the screen saturation increases throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08096", "filename": "756b80d8aa04a9e4cd1354c56d30a76097bc6092eab99cc16cb230a6ca213fd2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08097", "filename": "756b450dfb0625024ae6045e4e6ed6f7224720c792d4324aa1c8f6f4da00adc9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the only change in the flow of the ice cream liquid is when the hand touches the ice cream stick, while the bubbles in the ice cream liquid do not change at all, which violates the laws of fluid motion and mechanical transmission) Time continuity (2.8s-3.1s, after the hand touches the ice cream stick and retracts, the ice cream returns to its original state)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08098", "filename": "756b450dfb0625024ae6045e4e6ed6f7224720c792d4324aa1c8f6f4da00adc9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the only change in the flow of the ice cream liquid is when the hand touches the ice cream stick, while the bubbles in the ice cream liquid do not change; the melting and flowing process of the chocolate on the surface of the ice cream spreads rapidly in all directions like watercolor paint)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08099", "filename": "756b450dfb0625024ae6045e4e6ed6f7224720c792d4324aa1c8f6f4da00adc9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: At 2.2s, the character picks up the ice cream, but the bottom of the ice cream remains clean and free of stains, violating the laws of gravity and melting flow.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08100", "filename": "0758d8034416177a54d980913160a8903db4beee779d9b131740d8404b0b0071_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video content: Physical behavior (the person rotates the bottle throughout the video, but the water droplets on the inner wall of the bottle do not move or change, violating the laws of mechanics and fluid adhesion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08101", "filename": "0758d8034416177a54d980913160a8903db4beee779d9b131740d8404b0b0071_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the bottle gradually tilts throughout the process, and ripples spread outward from the center of the water without any other object acting on it) Time continuity (at 1.4s, the two fingers in the upper left corner of the bottle disappear into thin air)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08102", "filename": "0758d8034416177a54d980913160a8903db4beee779d9b131740d8404b0b0071_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08103", "filename": "0758d8034416177a54d980913160a8903db4beee779d9b131740d8404b0b0071_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 2.8s, the white mark on the upper right side of the bottle disappears out of thin air; at 6.5s, the direction of the right hand suddenly changes)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08104", "filename": "762ca6da86ed00c299ab366d123a79b6685fadaa2059dc0ee89b08fe208dec40_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (from 0s to 3s, the melting ice in the video slowly spreads outwards like viscous liquid) and continuous time (from 3s to 4.9s, the melted ice gradually returns to its original state).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08105", "filename": "762ca6da86ed00c299ab366d123a79b6685fadaa2059dc0ee89b08fe208dec40_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (0s-0.3s: the ice gradually grows larger; 4.3s-5.9s: the ice completely melts, but the water continues to increase out of thin air); Physical behavior (4.3s-5.9s: the entire melting ice forms water droplets, but the water does not fall, which does not conform to the law of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08106", "filename": "762e28b03bc440af8059138fe10c44053c8f5bec8419222987d6eb5b129b03ec_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (water is continuously poured into the funnel throughout the video, but the volume of liquid in the conical flask below the funnel does not change; the bubbles on the surface of the coffee do not change except where the water flows over them).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08107", "filename": "762e28b03bc440af8059138fe10c44053c8f5bec8419222987d6eb5b129b03ec_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows abnormal behavior due to physical behavior (the foam on the coffee surface in the video disappears too evenly and regularly throughout the entire video) and continuous time (at 0.3 seconds, many brown particles suddenly appear in the container).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08108", "filename": "762e28b03bc440af8059138fe10c44053c8f5bec8419222987d6eb5b129b03ec_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (water is continuously poured into the funnel throughout the video, but the volume of liquid in the conical flask below the funnel does not change).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08110", "filename": "764c8212d82f3277d1fa5c92e357d50eb8c1e59ddd6616d9ad0a370fb0b27851_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (the sparkler burns throughout the video, but the burned-out parts do not break off and remain in the same complete shape as the unburned parts).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08111", "filename": "eb7df0efae1d550a425fb706c6805167ff56ba773ff64b8e9573b7795a38dbfc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (at the beginning of the video, the newspaper at the bottom is only slightly illuminated and shows no signs of being ignited, while the birch wood above it catches fire directly, which does not conform to the logic of starting a fire. The flames emerge from the internal cross-section of the birch wood out of thin air, rather than spreading upwards from the igniter newspaper at the bottom, which violates the physical law of burning from bottom to top).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08112", "filename": "eb604adf5ed3cbbd04a4dc37ae7e111ef6d2e5a0d7a1e44de1e6d0c2807667f2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (the direction of the flames burning from left to right in the entire video is inconsistent, and the shape does not conform to the actual smoke diffusion pattern of combustion. The ground mat has been partially burned to ash, but the flames are still concentrated in a small area and have not spread to the surrounding unburned areas. The transition between the ash and the unburned areas is abrupt, without the gradual process of charring.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08113", "filename": "ebe7dd55625751c066cd5678f0347daf924f48e65380ae7f1535e2a2350c5405_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous in time (parts of the road disappear into the fog without a gradual transition that conforms to perspective; the steel cables of the bridge that should be covered by fog are clearly visible; the texture of the fog is unnatural and lacks the gradual flow of real fog, making it look out of place when integrated with the bridge).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08114", "filename": "ec0a1a99ae9e3a15467cd68f57497a44a5c54d42e941cc735dd0b81e2b8ea04f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (the fog in the entire video is too uniform, and the strong light penetrating through the forest does not form a clear Tyndall effect in the fog, which does not match the transparency of real forest morning fog; the waves and ripples of the stream are chaotic, lacking the natural flow direction and impact of water; some waves appear out of nowhere without any collision with rocks, lacking the fluidity and dynamism of real water).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08115", "filename": "ec786cdb84cc4d3b495d990e9c54c82c1f22bb1b969e09d93379793c6817d9fb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous (the layers of coconut leaves are disordered throughout the video, with leaves appearing to pierce through branches and fold into knots, lacking the spatial depth of a real plant; the light and shadow boundary between the main trunk and leaves does not have a natural gradient; some areas show splicing of black and bright spots; the sunlight on the right should create a soft, translucent effect, but some leaves are directly exposed to the sunlight without obvious highlights, while some shadowed areas have false highlights; the light and shadow do not match the curvature of the leaves).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08116", "filename": "ec04849beb21bc00fb8f8b1c84c1b90289b7aa6acae5234ffad0c873281d96ec_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video footage is abnormal due to the following physical behavior: (The smoke from the explosion is pieced together in blocks throughout the video, lacking the turbulent diffusion of a real explosion and the sense of layering of gas flow. The orange-yellow flames do not match the light and shadow of the smoke and snow. The snow lacks the warm tone of the flames, and the smoke does not have the translucency of the flames. The number of flying fragments is small and the shape is uniform, lacking the dense flying effect of the initial explosion, and the edges have no broken marks, which violates the loose and irregular characteristics of real snow.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08117", "filename": "ece973a8c03fe950c0e4206b4f1d8ee5d132d44383f3586d56bb0efd2a4ddbc5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomalies in the image: Timing and continuity (At 0.2s, the paper ball on the left undergoes a sudden change, its volume suddenly increases, and at 5.3s, the paper ball on the left undergoes another sudden change, with obvious changes in both position and volume. The trajectory of the flowing paint is stiff and lacks the natural arc of gravity-induced downward movement. Some paint flows upward, and there is no natural color blending or blurring boundary between color blocks, nor is there a realistic diffusion and penetration effect of paint.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08118", "filename": "ed59b9bd047ba54ccf050699a708824f7eb805e1491780cf7acfa68599ffade8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomalies in the footage: timing and continuity (the vehicle suddenly disappears at 4.1s, the steam on the left is stiff and blocky without any natural dissipation or dilution, the interaction between the steam and the snow and rocks disappears, there are no traces of steam condensing when it cools, and there is no physical effect of blocking light).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08119", "filename": "ee862cd098bbb403f1a4946f2fa64196aa72020091cfb019200c59818088bb96_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is due to timing and continuity issues. (In the video, the ball suddenly turns into powder when the hydraulic press squeezes it at 2.4s, and then suddenly turns into powder again at 3.2s. In reality, a golf ball has a multi-layered structure with a rubber core, a wrapped outer shell, and a rubber core. When it is compressed, it will deform first and then slowly break, rather than turning directly into white powder.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08120", "filename": "ee862cd098bbb403f1a4946f2fa64196aa72020091cfb019200c59818088bb96_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to timing and continuity issues. (At 4.1 seconds, the ball suddenly breaks into pieces when the hydraulic press squeezes it. In reality, a golf ball has a multi-layered structure with a rubber core, a wrapped outer shell, and a rubber core. Under pressure, it deforms first and then slowly breaks, rather than directly turning into white pieces. At 4.1 seconds, the pieces are spraying out powder even when the hydraulic press is not squeezing. At 5.8 seconds, after the hydraulic press is lifted, the amount of pieces is clearly not proportional to the volume of the ball.)", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08121", "filename": "eed6dddaa1218ae4685e5f4c17fd1908c5f0fe2dd210d77e8628e1a0e6cd176c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: (The smoke's shape changes illogically throughout the video, suddenly transforming from a dense column into a blocky cloud, and then dissipating into fragments. The transitions are extremely unnatural, lacking the continuity of normal smoke flow. The smoke's color saturation is far higher than the environment, creating a strong sense of incongruity with the cold, low-saturation blue, white, and gray tones of winter. Some areas show overexposure and color bleeding. The light sources in the video are inconsistent: the warm light from the sky, the cold shadows on the ground, and the internal light and shadow of the smoke all conflict with each other, failing to follow a unified light source logic.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08124", "filename": "ef3d544f68bf150b648ba6575f0ad7e92671587a67a9c634c1f038e422d162fc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: (The texture of the stem on the left side of the video looks like the texture of plastic artificial fibers. The white filaments on the surface are unnaturally distributed in terms of thickness, and some of the filaments are floating in the air without being connected to the stem. In addition, the edges of the leaf veins are blurred and lack the structural layers of a real plant. The green reflection on the surface of the stem is too uniform, like a layer of varnish, rather than the natural luster of a plant.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08125", "filename": "ef3d9694ca99cee118829d7c55367c2f232311f543e4620534f9dc3e3f65bd20_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: (In the entire video, when the ice melts, the water stain on the left rises without any external force. The volume of the ice and the area of the water stain are disproportionate. The ice corresponds to a large area of dark water stain, which violates the common sense that the amount of water determines the size of the water stain. In addition, the edges of the water stain do not have a natural blurring. The ground is rough cement bricks, but the reflective texture of the ice is too smooth and lacks the feeling of real water stains adhering to a rough surface. The color of the water stain is too uniform and dark. The water stain on a real cement floor should be a mixture of wet marks and reflections, not a pure dark brown stain.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08126", "filename": "ef282027df27e661f059a0bd60a924860210cb17976ddf040c74283e41a154d0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video contains the following anomalies: (In some parts of the video, water lilies are directly inserted into the leaves, which is not in proportion or growth logic. The veins of the leaves are blurred and broken. The edges of some leaves are directly stuck into the water. There are clippings where the leaves are stacked. The edge of one leaf passes directly through another leaf without any obstruction. At the transition between dark blue and light blue on the water surface, the ripple texture suddenly breaks. Either smooth color blocks replace delicate ripples, or ripples of different densities and forms are awkwardly spliced together without gradual transition, forming obvious color block breaks.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08127", "filename": "ef282027df27e661f059a0bd60a924860210cb17976ddf040c74283e41a154d0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: (The overall direction of light and shadow is inconsistent throughout the video. There is no unified light source on the lit and shadowed sides of the flowers and lotus leaves. The transition between the reflection and ripples on the water surface is unnatural and does not reflect real water ripples. The water ripples on the edge of the lotus leaves should have a flowing and spreading texture, but the ripples on the water surface next to the flowers are blurred and disappear. The brightness and texture of the video are disconnected, and there is no natural sense of light and shadow undulating with the ripples on the real water surface.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08128", "filename": "efe792447e9859c16f93d287aec6719a81e9c1b497a41c4eb6b1be7c1f667bf3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: (The boundary lines of the bubbles are chaotic throughout the video. What should be smooth and continuous film edges have sharp, jagged lines and abrupt corners, which do not conform to the natural curvature and tension of the bubble film. The connection points between bubbles should be smooth transitions, but there are sharp right-angle misalignments. The highlights on the bubble surface do not match the direction of the light source, and some areas have strong light spots without any source, which conflict with the overall dark background.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08129", "filename": "f0d6012fc7e6f4ee1648aa6397134bce06c8d593a50510db6c36139df85baea2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: (The TV casing in the entire video is made of hard plastic and metal frame, and the picture tube is made of glass. In a normal explosion, the glass should shatter and the plastic should break. However, in the video, there are no glass fragments flying or sharp edges of metal and plastic breaking during the explosion. The transition between white smoke and orange-red flames is unnatural. The flames do not have the texture of high-temperature burning. The density and flow direction of the smoke are irregular. There is no diffusion trajectory driven by the shock wave of the explosion. The small device on the right side of the dry grass and stones on the ground, which appears to be a camera, is completely still and shows no signs of being affected by the shock wave. The scene is completely disconnected from the explosion event.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08130", "filename": "f0d8714cf3fffd276e49439577e570e054940ee6c57c959d5c199310a2aec9d4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: (Throughout the video, the intensity of the flames continuously increases, but the structure and condition of the brick tower remain unchanged. It simply amplifies the flame effect. Bricks are made of inorganic silicate material and are completely non-combustible. In reality, they would only slightly crack, heat up, and change color under high temperatures, but they could not be directly ignited by flames, allowing flames to penetrate from the inside of the brick. They would not be engulfed in flames and burn intensely. However, in the video, the flames not only adhere directly to the brick surface and burn, but also violently erupt from the gaps between the solid areas of the bricks, even penetrating the entire brick. The flame shape is too regular and rigid, lacking the randomness of the flickering, scattering, and sparks flying in real flames. In some scenes, the flames appear as columnar or clump-like shapes that rigidly envelop the brick tower, without any dynamic changes caused by airflow disturbance.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08131", "filename": "ab403d414cb9d129536b8cf9e0ed90d6173bf577b221a82fd9fe875fbae4c2ab_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the clouds in the sky are all clustered around the sun, and the clouds next to the Eiffel Tower are too thick; in reality, clouds are light and drifting under sunlight).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08133", "filename": "ab2948632eadf7ed7054e3f15b632d5711377c61cfc1a21fe4eab6c68ec1d0f5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08134", "filename": "abc3552694d21f47ac522853fb8c6e5fbd983954ce8d57aa219705556e4b377d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (0.1s-0.8s: the bullet passes through the eighth glass panel from the left to the second-to-last glass panel without breaking it; the gas flow caused by the bullet creates excessive shapes).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08135", "filename": "abc3552694d21f47ac522853fb8c6e5fbd983954ce8d57aa219705556e4b377d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (1.3s-8s: the wooden block was hit but no debris flew out and it did not hit the track. The original color of the wooden board is natural wood color, but the cross-section of the broken wooden board is the blue color of glass).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08136", "filename": "abff16193a5a9eb4f48c080fa44da6c4c0aa46bdec30f050292cd5ea98c3d332_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The anomaly in the visuals: Cause and effect (the dilapidated vehicle drove away on its own without human intervention, mostly driving on grass and generating a lot of dust, whereas in reality, grass wouldn't stir up such a large amount of dust).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08137", "filename": "abff16193a5a9eb4f48c080fa44da6c4c0aa46bdec30f050292cd5ea98c3d332_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the car did not explode after being hit by the shell. In reality, the car would have exploded immediately after being hit by the shell).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08139", "filename": "ac9c3db11c269db53b6342b6ca0cdb0e3ecfa225e2c99f8a035bac765457140a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08140", "filename": "ac00127a75db387743f3646f0e49ac3e2c1174e663c6447f397293ffc961c05f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the reflection of a boat traveling on water is elongated even without sunlight).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08141", "filename": "ac00127a75db387743f3646f0e49ac3e2c1174e663c6447f397293ffc961c05f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (starting at 2.8s, the ship's smoke becomes extremely dense, whereas in reality, the smoke emitted by a ship sailing on calm water is thin, fluffy, and gradually fades).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08142", "filename": "ac359a7c04efb5ea07efe17f32bc756d1adb34ccf53ef9d14cdbc6438f9282a1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (When a large amount of snow fell on the umbrella, the umbrella did not deform, and the snow on the umbrella did not change after the snow fell).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08143", "filename": "ac519a62566d0af1a714d6b8f6c7eb265f7270075951cb6fab17ef06e647192c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08144", "filename": "ac519a62566d0af1a714d6b8f6c7eb265f7270075951cb6fab17ef06e647192c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08145", "filename": "acb97c8fe4b552b2f2d613c23606d8e3b1d677afafc2454d0065dde11aba8e47_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the ice cream is only melting at the bottom while the top is not melting, and the volume of the ice cream remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08146", "filename": "ace338df22e1df90b14c2704585bef6b1562d411d3cc38e209c13104b747077b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (sparks at the explosion site moved with the dense smoke at 3.4s and the explosion did not produce any airflow)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08147", "filename": "ad09f218d8bbc4ea2541852cc512ad5c9a1980bfc082a1af06966449cb7d73f4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The abnormal footage shows a continuous sequence of events (the water level remains unchanged at 2.5 seconds as the ice melts and flows into the glass, but only starts to rise at 4.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08148", "filename": "ad47ddd51e028c75a61b30299c587a30b7d8f8fe8070e0809aa2d8ac20adce02_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (in reality, water droplets form first, then water stains form, but in the video, water stains form first, then water droplets form).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08149", "filename": "ad49d048142ed1937cdf64bfa8fbb01566c87bcba44b68d82ef9317c14c3db91_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08150", "filename": "ad49d048142ed1937cdf64bfa8fbb01566c87bcba44b68d82ef9317c14c3db91_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the splashing water appears as bubbles that tend to rise, whereas in reality, splashing water spreads out like an umbrella).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08151", "filename": "eed6dddaa1218ae4685e5f4c17fd1908c5f0fe2dd210d77e8628e1a0e6cd176c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the smoke is constantly being blown to the right by the wind, but the trees and other background elements remain stationary and do not change at all).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08152", "filename": "eed6dddaa1218ae4685e5f4c17fd1908c5f0fe2dd210d77e8628e1a0e6cd176c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (at 2.8s in the video, a large amount of smoke appears out of thin air without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08153", "filename": "eed09ce1a06aec0001aeb70a5cc8c27c1e7ae00395a0828a8d9eb881dcb3cbce_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (when air enters water at an angle, the straw should bend towards the normal at the water surface, but in the image, the straw is bent downwards underwater).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08154", "filename": "eed09ce1a06aec0001aeb70a5cc8c27c1e7ae00395a0828a8d9eb881dcb3cbce_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (at 1.4s in the video, the chopsticks directly penetrate the glass and move, which violates the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08155", "filename": "eed09ce1a06aec0001aeb70a5cc8c27c1e7ae00395a0828a8d9eb881dcb3cbce_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (the chopsticks move directly through the cup throughout the entire video, violating the principle that solids are impermeable) and temporal continuity (at 0.4 seconds into the video, the straw in the cup bends on its own without the camera changing direction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08156", "filename": "eed09ce1a06aec0001aeb70a5cc8c27c1e7ae00395a0828a8d9eb881dcb3cbce_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (the chopsticks move directly through the cup throughout the entire video, violating the principle that solids are impermeable) and temporal continuity (at 4.9 seconds into the video, the chopsticks fly into the air without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08160", "filename": "eee332b9941dc524469ed8f0350820f996c3bc288c409c5270024fff4df092ff_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (at 0.9s, before the hydraulic press even touches the soccer ball, the soccer ball moves on its own; at 3.7s, the surface of the soccer ball pressed by the hydraulic press suddenly turns black without any change in the lens).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08161", "filename": "eee332b9941dc524469ed8f0350820f996c3bc288c409c5270024fff4df092ff_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 1.1s in the video, the hydraulic press has not yet made contact with the soccer ball, and the soccer ball moves on its own; at 5.7s, the flattened soccer ball suddenly shatters).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08162", "filename": "eee332b9941dc524469ed8f0350820f996c3bc288c409c5270024fff4df092ff_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The timing is continuous (at 0.9s, the hydraulic press has not yet touched the football, and the football moves on its own; at 2.3s, the football that has been pressed suddenly explodes like porcelain without the camera changing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08163", "filename": "eee332b9941dc524469ed8f0350820f996c3bc288c409c5270024fff4df092ff_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (at 3.8s in the video, the flattened soccer ball suddenly explodes into glass shards without the camera angle changing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08164", "filename": "ef3d544f68bf150b648ba6575f0ad7e92671587a67a9c634c1f038e422d162fc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Continuous movement (the green leaves move spontaneously throughout the entire video without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08165", "filename": "ef3d544f68bf150b648ba6575f0ad7e92671587a67a9c634c1f038e422d162fc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (the cross-section of an object in the frame increases on its own without any change in the camera angle throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08166", "filename": "ef3d544f68bf150b648ba6575f0ad7e92671587a67a9c634c1f038e422d162fc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.8s in the video, a green leaf appears out of nowhere, and at 4.7s in the video, the flower stamen suddenly bursts open and attaches to the leaf).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08167", "filename": "ef3d9694ca99cee118829d7c55367c2f232311f543e4620534f9dc3e3f65bd20_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (at 0.7 seconds into the video, a white, viscous substance disappears out of thin air without any change in camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08168", "filename": "ef3d9694ca99cee118829d7c55367c2f232311f543e4620534f9dc3e3f65bd20_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (at 0.3s in the video, the water on the ground increases out of nowhere without the camera changing position).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08169", "filename": "ef3d9694ca99cee118829d7c55367c2f232311f543e4620534f9dc3e3f65bd20_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 1.3s in the video, the water on the floor suddenly boils on its own without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08170", "filename": "ef7490f1ef4c27869ed640f4600ab3ad0bcd8e219b533b6b615ba63c4454a46b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the figures on the ship are moving too stiffly and lack a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08171", "filename": "ef7490f1ef4c27869ed640f4600ab3ad0bcd8e219b533b6b615ba63c4454a46b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (starting at 2.1 seconds in the video, the ship in the footage flies upwards on its own without any external force or gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08172", "filename": "ef7490f1ef4c27869ed640f4600ab3ad0bcd8e219b533b6b615ba63c4454a46b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08173", "filename": "ef7490f1ef4c27869ed640f4600ab3ad0bcd8e219b533b6b615ba63c4454a46b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1s in the video, a person suddenly appears out of thin air on the small boat; at 4.5s in the video, the green vest of the person on the boat suddenly turns red; and at 4.9s in the video, the person who jumped off the large ship disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08174", "filename": "ef282027df27e661f059a0bd60a924860210cb17976ddf040c74283e41a154d0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Cause and effect (Throughout the video, many ripples were constantly generated on the surface of the lake, but the lotus flowers and leaves in the lake did not move with the waves and remained still).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08175", "filename": "ef282027df27e661f059a0bd60a924860210cb17976ddf040c74283e41a154d0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 2.1 seconds into the video, a large number of waves suddenly appear on the water surface without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08176", "filename": "ef282027df27e661f059a0bd60a924860210cb17976ddf040c74283e41a154d0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 1.9 seconds into the video, the lotus flower falling from the right side of the screen disappears out of thin air without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08177", "filename": "efe792447e9859c16f93d287aec6719a81e9c1b497a41c4eb6b1be7c1f667bf3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (bubbles piled together in the video suddenly grow larger and deform without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08178", "filename": "efe792447e9859c16f93d287aec6719a81e9c1b497a41c4eb6b1be7c1f667bf3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (the bubbles in the entire video have an overly harsh texture, with overly sharp edges, lacking a natural feel).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08179", "filename": "efe792447e9859c16f93d287aec6719a81e9c1b497a41c4eb6b1be7c1f667bf3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (the bubbles in the entire video have an overly harsh texture, with overly sharp edges, lacking a natural feel).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08180", "filename": "efe792447e9859c16f93d287aec6719a81e9c1b497a41c4eb6b1be7c1f667bf3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08181", "filename": "P30_107_265_6b9874c6dac9ac2d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08182", "filename": "P30_107_320_c2211d4ace034367_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is as follows: (2.1s 2.7s The vegetable leaf was not cut, torn, or squeezed by any external force, nor was it damaged by drying or decay. It was not a physical split; the leaf broke off directly from a single leaf without any natural gradual process of crack extension or fiber tearing. 3.6s The vegetable leaf was not touched by hand, blown by wind, impacted by water, or pushed or moved by other objects. It was completely untriggered by any external force.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08183", "filename": "P30_107_320_c2211d4ace034367_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the vegetable leaf in the lower left corner moves without any external force, the physical displacement has no power source, the speed does not match the physical logic of the object's movement).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08184", "filename": "P30_107_320_c2211d4ace034367_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (in the 5.6s video, there is no action of picking up, handing over, or placing the knife, nor is there any trajectory of the knife moving from off-screen into the frame. A knife suddenly appears out of thin air without any transition. In the 2.7s video, there is no action of adding anything, nor is the camera angle changing to reveal more objects. The original objects suddenly increase in number, and the newly added parts appear out of thin air without any transition.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08185", "filename": "P30_107_341_ffb2544226e4f69e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Timing (1.2s: The mushroom touches the back of the knife, the object disappears into thin air without any visual transition; the transition is smooth). (1.4s: The mushroom shows no touching or cutting action; there's no natural cause for damage, it simply splits into pieces without a slow tearing process; the visual transition is abrupt).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08186", "filename": "P30_107_341_ffb2544226e4f69e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: The duration is continuous (the light source and camera angle remain unchanged, but the brightness of the food suddenly and irregularly alternates between bright and dark, without a gradual transition, and the flickering is abrupt and jarring).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08187", "filename": "P30_107_341_ffb2544226e4f69e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (3.6s). Although the mushroom was triggered by an external cutting force, the number of split pieces, the fracture trajectory, the cutting force, and the blade direction are not matched.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08188", "filename": "P30_107_362_fb7ac62b0bef3de7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: The sequence of events is continuous (2.5s). There are no actions of picking up, handing over, or placing objects in the frame, nor is there any trajectory of an object moving in. The target object appears out of thin air without any visual transition, resulting in abrupt and abrupt visual changes.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08189", "filename": "P30_107_362_fb7ac62b0bef3de7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (multiple abnormalities are superimposed under the trigger of cutting, including visual imaging distortion, morphological force mismatch distortion, and quantity proliferation distortion, without gradation or reasonable linkage).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08190", "filename": "P30_107_362_fb7ac62b0bef3de7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (multiple abnormalities are superimposed under the trigger of the segmentation, including visual imaging distortion, shape and force mismatch distortion, and quantity proliferation, without gradation or reasonable linkage).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08191", "filename": "P30_107_407_750c5cc9986045ed_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (0.7s: There is no touching, cutting, or bending action in the video. The object opens on its own without any force being applied. There is no gradual opening and closing transition. 1.9s: The plastic thrown into the trash can disappears into thin air.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08192", "filename": "P30_107_407_750c5cc9986045ed_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: (0.7s) Non-physical penetration between plastic parts and plastic boxes directly breaks the impermeability of solids. This is manifested as: direct penetration without contact or compression, without material damage, and without resistance feedback, which completely violates the core physical logic of physical space occupation and mutual exclusion.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08193", "filename": "P30_107_497_25b746c75244880a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: (There are no cutting, blocking, or camera cropping actions in the image; the spoon is only half there and there is no transition between the two halves; the overall structure is incomplete and unnatural.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08194", "filename": "P30_107_500_a33b20b358461f0a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (in the 6.4s footage, the cup is not supported, there is no slow tilting process, and it does not fall down. It remains upright without support, which obviously does not conform to the law of the center of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08195", "filename": "P30_107_504_9b98ea15a71676b4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08196", "filename": "P30_107_504_9b98ea15a71676b4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (0.2s, the cup has no cracks or punctures, the water passes directly through the cup without flowing down the cup wall, and the cup does not leak or deform. The liquid and the cup overlap and penetrate each other directly, which is completely inconsistent with the laws of reality. 2.9s, the faucet stops flowing without any external force, and there is no reasonable triggering action).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08197", "filename": "P30_107_533_06cd32cfe20f540c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal; (When washing the knife at 4.3s, the water poured on the utensils did not splash up, nor did it bounce off or create ripples on the surface. The water flowed directly onto the utensils, which does not match the dynamic effect of washing water in reality.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08198", "filename": "P30_107_533_06cd32cfe20f540c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal; (the light source and camera angle are unchanged, but the pink cloth suddenly and irregularly alternates between light and dark, and the color also fluctuates between light and dark without gradually brightening. The flickering is particularly harsh and abrupt.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08199", "filename": "P30_107_563_1dc3d605296508f5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 4.8s, the pink cloth on the left deforms from a rectangle to a square).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08200", "filename": "P30_107_563_1dc3d605296508f5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal (there's no water flowing from the faucet, and nothing is stirring it, yet the bubbles are rolling erratically on their own without any external force, which is completely unrealistic; the bubbles should follow the natural flow of water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08201", "filename": "P30_107_563_1dc3d605296508f5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The screen is malfunctioning; (at 2.6 seconds, the condiment bottles on the table disappear into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08202", "filename": "P30_107_623_8cded94b40c0238d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal; (2.6s) The knife did not cut the vegetables, and the cut vegetables appeared out of thin air.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08203", "filename": "P30_107_623_8cded94b40c0238d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (4.2s a leaf of vegetable appears out of thin air on the cutting board; 7s the chopped vegetable disappears out of thin air)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08204", "filename": "P30_107_623_8cded94b40c0238d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomalies: (At 1.7s, the action of chopping vegetables can be seen in the footage, but the direction of the knife does not match the trajectory of the vegetables splitting, and the vegetables suddenly split into several pieces. At 4.1s, the vegetable leaves in the left hand disappear into thin air.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08205", "filename": "P30_107_642_3e6884258e38269b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal; the time is continuous (3.6s). There is no action of picking up, moving, or covering the spoon in the video. The spoon disappears abruptly without any reason and there is no visual transition.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08206", "filename": "P30_107_642_3e6884258e38269b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 1.1s, there is no action of picking up, moving, or covering the spoon in the scene, the spoon disappears abruptly without any reason, and there is no visual transition, the spoon reappears after 3.5s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08207", "filename": "P30_107_663_16eaee91c8d8e8d6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows a continuous flow of time (in the video, the food in the pot is being stirred with a spatula, and the amount of food in the pot seems to decrease).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08208", "filename": "P30_107_663_16eaee91c8d8e8d6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (white, round mushrooms appear out of thin air while the spatula is stirring).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08209", "filename": "P30_107_688_aa34722b939c1288_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the food in the middle of the pot disappears out of thin air in 5.6 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08210", "filename": "P30_107_688_aa34722b939c1288_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal; the timing is continuous (during the stir-frying process, there is no pulling or stretching of the vegetables, and the vegetables are not in a soaked state; they suddenly become longer out of thin air without a gradual stretching process, which is completely inconsistent with the stir-frying action).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08211", "filename": "234814b435562b5a2f60c1e594d5cc15c350ec1e49065693a7c5fcffd80a49f9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Continuous timing (a thin white line suddenly appears at 2.5s in the video; at 3.5s, the white line suddenly gets tied to the ring; from 4.3s to 5.8s, the white line shakes without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08212", "filename": "234814b435562b5a2f60c1e594d5cc15c350ec1e49065693a7c5fcffd80a49f9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is continuous (at 3.4 seconds, a thin white thread suddenly attaches to the ring without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08213", "filename": "235667d9c2929ed8777006b44431e1882be9298da6a238bd10c042b1f2503b7b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the white sedan in the image has an overly bright and smooth color and texture, which is out of place with the surrounding smoke-filled and grayish fire scene environment, making it look like it was cut out and pasted in separately.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08214", "filename": "235667d9c2929ed8777006b44431e1882be9298da6a238bd10c042b1f2503b7b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is inconsistent (in the video, the water sprayed from the water gun at 2.4 seconds suddenly turns into smoke and floats up; from 2.5 seconds to 3.6 seconds, the water sprayed from the water gun washes over the car body and windows, but no water droplets remain on the car).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08215", "filename": "235667d9c2929ed8777006b44431e1882be9298da6a238bd10c042b1f2503b7b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is continuous (flames suddenly appear on the front of the car at 1 seconds). Overall visual anomalies (no water splashes out when the high-pressure water gun hits the car body; normally, a large amount of water should splash out when a high-pressure water gun hits an object's surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08216", "filename": "235667d9c2929ed8777006b44431e1882be9298da6a238bd10c042b1f2503b7b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (at 3.4 seconds, the tinted windows on the car suddenly disappear).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08220", "filename": "244415e6b9f30cf205141dba4c85be4863d9e2635a9e89b8f2c608fafd43fcb0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the city buildings in the image are too evenly distributed, lacking the natural layers of density and sparseness of a real city, and the terrain outline is too smooth, lacking the natural undulations and details of a real landform).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08221", "filename": "244415e6b9f30cf205141dba4c85be4863d9e2635a9e89b8f2c608fafd43fcb0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the halo effect of the sun and the color transition of the sky are very abrupt, the color layering near the horizon is too obvious, and there is no soft gradation brought by real atmospheric scattering.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08222", "filename": "244415e6b9f30cf205141dba4c85be4863d9e2635a9e89b8f2c608fafd43fcb0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (realistic water reflections would strictly align with the sun's position and the direction of water ripples, but the reflected areas in the image are blurry and completely mismatched with the sun's angle, resembling harshly superimposed light spots, lacking the dynamic texture and gradation of realistic water reflections.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08223", "filename": "251700c6157943bebea055852b76c73f77d69487b0c63fc88b83b230d62e12de_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is continuous (at 3.1 seconds, the white clouds in the sky suddenly turn yellow). Overall visual anomalies (the movement of the clouds in the entire video is too smooth and orderly; normal clouds do not move in a straight line, lacking the feeling of real clouds drifting in the wind).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08224", "filename": "251700c6157943bebea055852b76c73f77d69487b0c63fc88b83b230d62e12de_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (at 0.1s, the white smoke in the upper left corner of the screen suddenly disappears; at 3.3s, the sun rising in the distance suddenly sets). Overall visual anomalies (the movement of the clouds in the entire video is too smooth, lacking the feeling of real clouds drifting in the wind).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08225", "filename": "251700c6157943bebea055852b76c73f77d69487b0c63fc88b83b230d62e12de_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: The overall visual effect is abnormal. (In a real sunset, the colors naturally transition from warm yellow at the horizon to pinkish-purple and blue, with soft layers and gradations. However, the transition between the bright orange area and the cool-colored clouds above is very abrupt, like a patchwork of color blocks, lacking the soft gradation effect of real atmospheric scattering.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08226", "filename": "251700c6157943bebea055852b76c73f77d69487b0c63fc88b83b230d62e12de_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the clouds in the sky show obvious signs of movement throughout the video, indicating wind, but the grass on the ground shows no signs of shaking).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08227", "filename": "260601fe820c7e70518a14c4feddec96ecb5afb574506a9989c3f3368d75545e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual presentation is abnormal (when real raindrops fall to the ground, the water droplets are small, random splashes that quickly dissipate and merge into water streaks after landing; however, the water droplets in the video are either stiff in shape and have blurred edges, or they repeat the same splash shape without natural dynamic changes, and some water droplets even float on the ground without a realistic sense of impact).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08228", "filename": "260601fe820c7e70518a14c4feddec96ecb5afb574506a9989c3f3368d75545e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual presentation is abnormal (real rainwater falling on the ground will form wet watermarks and spreading water stains, blending naturally with the ground texture; but the water stains in the video are either hard superpositions of color blocks, or the ground shows no signs of being wet at all, with the rain appearing and disappearing out of thin air, without any physical contact or wetting effect.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08229", "filename": "260601fe820c7e70518a14c4feddec96ecb5afb574506a9989c3f3368d75545e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The video shows no obvious water droplets falling, yet water splashes appear out of nowhere.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08230", "filename": "260601fe820c7e70518a14c4feddec96ecb5afb574506a9989c3f3368d75545e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (Real raindrops fall as lines of varying lengths with slight dynamic blur, forming small, random splashes upon impact. However, the raindrops in the video are stiff and uniform in thickness, and the splashes are merely blurry spots of light, lacking the splashing and diffusion patterns of real raindrops upon impact.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08231", "filename": "268990d987775fd305dc9da685345efe4510f8ba125daa48a73343a00a54d6bc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 0.1s, smoke was seen emanating from the Minion ceramic before it exploded; at 3.8s, the Minion ceramic, which had exploded into pieces, suddenly returned to its original state.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08232", "filename": "268990d987775fd305dc9da685345efe4510f8ba125daa48a73343a00a54d6bc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.1s, the Minion ceramic explodes behind the object, but from 2.1s to 5.9s, the Minion ceramic shatters and flies off directly. Under normal circumstances, the Minion ceramic, affected by the explosion, should fly off the table and shatter after hitting the ground.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08233", "filename": "268990d987775fd305dc9da685345efe4510f8ba125daa48a73343a00a54d6bc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.2 seconds, the Minion's clothes, which exploded and flew out, suddenly twisted and deformed, turning into a new Minion.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08234", "filename": "268990d987775fd305dc9da685345efe4510f8ba125daa48a73343a00a54d6bc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time sequence (at 0.6s, the rough Minion rubber doll suddenly transforms into the animated Minion character; at 4.5s, it is affected by an explosion and suddenly transforms back into a Minion ceramic shattering.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08241", "filename": "48f143ea6f444760886dd863a0b1245b8476be66596ca740bccf5ef5ec8ae8fc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 5.6s, the liquid in the pot did not pour out but disappeared out of thin air, and a thin liquid column with a viscous texture remained between the spout and the cup, which does not conform to the surface tension of the liquid).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08242", "filename": "48f143ea6f444760886dd863a0b1245b8476be66596ca740bccf5ef5ec8ae8fc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (a lemon slice suddenly appears out of nowhere in the cup from 0.7s to 1.5s; at 6.1s, the liquid in the teapot and the cup suddenly becomes darker, and a glass column appears out of nowhere in the teapot; from 1.3s to 7.1s, the liquid in the teapot is poured into the cup, but the water level does not change significantly; from 6.1s to 8s, the liquid level in the teapot and the liquid level at the spout are not at the same level).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08243", "filename": "49cfd9ddea9bc3a1b8473b17de5a867859ae429c930ae2e9dbcfd62b5943f331_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is inconsistent (at 0.5s, the axe did not chop the plank, but the plank suddenly produced wood chips; at 3s, the wood chips on the right side of the plank suddenly disappeared; at 4.9s, the axe moved only slightly, but a large number of wood chips appeared on the plank. The intensity of the action is inconsistent with the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08244", "filename": "49cfd9ddea9bc3a1b8473b17de5a867859ae429c930ae2e9dbcfd62b5943f331_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the time is continuous (0.7s-1.1s: the wood is hard but the axe cuts through it too easily and too smoothly; 3s-8s: the wood is chopped from the center but has bark on it).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08245", "filename": "49d18ec3495c6c65b68e80406c7e26568858261c44e779eb99469250d70f9789_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Cause and effect (the clouds in the sky are affected by airflow and move around throughout the video, but the clouds in the video remain unchanged and the video appears shaky).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08246", "filename": "49d18ec3495c6c65b68e80406c7e26568858261c44e779eb99469250d70f9789_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (from 1.8s to 5.4s, the color of the clouds in the sky suddenly changes from purplish-pink to golden yellow without any obvious gradual change. The transition from pinkish-purple to orange-yellow is a bit abrupt, and there is a slight color gap. The true colors of the sunset are a soft gradient formed by atmospheric scattering).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08247", "filename": "49d18ec3495c6c65b68e80406c7e26568858261c44e779eb99469250d70f9789_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the gradient from purple to orange-red appears soft, but upon closer inspection, the color distribution is too uniform, lacking the subtle color gradations and random variations found in real atmospheric scattering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08248", "filename": "49ee5d02bbd0fd12ea72b6c608a2706fd824096b3664775dd3d749111f56b16e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (the cloud textures in the entire video are blurry and lack depth, lacking the texture of real clouds; although the color transitions of the aurora are soft, they lack the delicate color gradations and shimmering feeling of real aurora; the overall appearance is too clean, lacking the details, noise, and random variations found in the natural atmosphere).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08249", "filename": "49ee5d02bbd0fd12ea72b6c608a2706fd824096b3664775dd3d749111f56b16e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the aurora colors in the entire video are a gradient from green to cyan, and the transition is very similar. It lacks the color gradation and flickering caused by different particle activity in real aurora. The clouds are all blurry and without layers, without the fibrous texture and brightness variation of real clouds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08250", "filename": "49ee5d02bbd0fd12ea72b6c608a2706fd824096b3664775dd3d749111f56b16e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall impression is off (as a strong light source, the aurora should have a natural light effect on the clouds and night sky below, but the cloud textures in the entire video are blurry and the colors are uniform. There is no change in brightness and darkness reflected by the aurora. The clouds, aurora and starry sky are more like three separate layers simply superimposed, lacking the light and shadow interaction of a real environment).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08251", "filename": "49ee5d02bbd0fd12ea72b6c608a2706fd824096b3664775dd3d749111f56b16e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: The overall visual presentation is abnormal (the aurora, as a strong light source, does not naturally affect the surrounding starry sky and clouds; for example, the brightness and color of the clouds do not change with the aurora. The shape of the aurora's light band does not conform to the actual geomagnetic activity. The curtain structure of a real aurora has a uniform stretching direction, while the light band in the video looks more like a random combination of color blocks).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08252", "filename": "49ee9b019a21543d2ecad487c11cf23d0abd5230c291d6f578fed1d7c3234496_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.4s, the large ice block above the water suddenly undergoes irregular deformation, and at 4.7s, the large ice block with a distorted shape suddenly becomes round and smooth. Moreover, the changes of the ice block and the thin ice on the water surface throughout the video are too smooth and regular, as if repeated scenes are spliced together).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08253", "filename": "49ee9b019a21543d2ecad487c11cf23d0abd5230c291d6f578fed1d7c3234496_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual experience is abnormal (the transparency and reflective effect of the ice are broken, the highlights and refractive details are not continuous, and the reflection and wetness of the water are disconnected from the melting process of the ice, resulting in a chaotic overall interaction of light and shadow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08254", "filename": "49ee9b019a21543d2ecad487c11cf23d0abd5230c291d6f578fed1d7c3234496_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the ice did not melt significantly throughout the video, but a large amount of water appeared out of nowhere beneath it).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08255", "filename": "49ee9b019a21543d2ecad487c11cf23d0abd5230c291d6f578fed1d7c3234496_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.4s, the surface of the ice block suddenly breaks without any force, producing a series of regular round ice blocks. The video shows the ice melting process, but at 6.1s, the water droplets suddenly turn into a round ice block, and ice blocks suddenly form on the film).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08256", "filename": "49fa2edbbdae5452876857e737b621058a528461217a4eaaa9c203bf526a1abd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect (clouds in the sky are affected by airflow and drift in one direction, but in the whole video, the clouds remain in place and roll around with a chaotic trajectory).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08257", "filename": "49fa2edbbdae5452876857e737b621058a528461217a4eaaa9c203bf526a1abd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is off (the long, strip-shaped cloud band in the upper right corner of the video is too regular and has a monotonous texture, resembling a mechanically copied pattern rather than a fluffy and layered cloud in the real atmosphere. The sun is in the center of the image, and in reality, the clouds directly below and around it would be strongly illuminated and have obvious light and shadow levels. However, the brightness and shadow transitions of some clouds in the image are harsh and lack realistic light and shadow interaction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08258", "filename": "49fa2edbbdae5452876857e737b621058a528461217a4eaaa9c203bf526a1abd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (clouds in the sky move in one direction due to airflow; the upper and lower clouds move in different directions throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08259", "filename": "49fb8801b94439ce89ea3e8e866fdaebb3637afdb65f49fec24a53fd7e381367_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: cause and effect (when frying meat in boiling oil, the moisture on the meat evaporates rapidly, producing a lot of smoke, but throughout the video, the heat generated during frying is minimal and the meat does not show any charring reaction).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08260", "filename": "49fb8801b94439ce89ea3e8e866fdaebb3637afdb65f49fec24a53fd7e381367_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (when frying meat in boiling oil, the moisture on the meat evaporates rapidly, producing a lot of smoke. However, no smoke is produced during the entire frying process in the video. Between 2.3s and 5.1s, the meat should start to char from the heated part, but in the video, charring suddenly starts from the top of the meat and spreads downwards).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08261", "filename": "49fb8801b94439ce89ea3e8e866fdaebb3637afdb65f49fec24a53fd7e381367_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08262", "filename": "50abe57c681988d4964df1279cb663c17a2e75cdce3754ebe4b87d925db27bc0_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows abnormalities: cause and effect (a large amount of smoke is coming out of the chimney. The smoke should first be ejected from the chimney opening and then drift with the wind, but the smoke emission in the video does not show any continuous discharge from a particular chimney. It seems to appear out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08263", "filename": "50abe57c681988d4964df1279cb663c17a2e75cdce3754ebe4b87d925db27bc0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is off (the connection between the smoke and the chimney in the entire video is too abrupt, as if it is directly glued to the top of the chimney, lacking the dynamic sense of smoke spreading and rising from the chimney opening in real industrial emissions, and the background sky is a gradient light of dusk, but the transition between the bright and dark sides of some chimneys is unnatural, especially the reflection of the white chimney is too uniform).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08264", "filename": "50abe57c681988d4964df1279cb663c17a2e75cdce3754ebe4b87d925db27bc0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual intuition is abnormal (the rightmost chimney in the entire video is emitting obvious smoke, but from the perspective of the image structure, this smoke is visually tied to the white chimney in the middle, and there is no natural connection with its own chimney opening. Moreover, the overall shape of the smoke is too smooth and uniform, lacking the fluffy layers and random textures produced by airflow and temperature changes in real industrial emissions).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08268", "filename": "50d45b5d35648f992db3901d57e6771d6a98427a963623354e10832f95d922e2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (the clouds in the sky and the waves on the sea are affected by airflow and the spray and fog drift in the same direction, but the clouds and fog drift in different directions throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08269", "filename": "50d45b5d35648f992db3901d57e6771d6a98427a963623354e10832f95d922e2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the sun is constantly setting in the sky throughout the video, but the colors on the clouds do not change abruptly due to the change in lighting conditions, and the ripples on the sea are too regular).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08270", "filename": "50d45b5d35648f992db3901d57e6771d6a98427a963623354e10832f95d922e2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08271", "filename": "9ff879e8c5a085e0c4f4418994e98e5b4a02132039d8df7ff3f1391125973f46_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (in the entire video, the central colored stripes are curved, which is consistent with the characteristics of Newton's rings of equal thickness, while the stripes on the left are straight, which is wedge interference. The simultaneous appearance of two different types of interference ripples indicates that there are two different microstructures on the glass surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08272", "filename": "010c905955a6b883943ecc0b210df3f84b39b5b636ee3488fdd32342914d1780_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (throughout the video, the clouds and fog are constantly churning and rolling, but the position of the sun remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08273", "filename": "010c905955a6b883943ecc0b210df3f84b39b5b636ee3488fdd32342914d1780_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the continuity of time is abnormal (the difference in altitude creates a \"valley wind effect\", which causes the clouds to spread steadily in the valley, accompanied by a certain movement, but it remains still in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08274", "filename": "010c905955a6b883943ecc0b210df3f84b39b5b636ee3488fdd32342914d1780_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08275", "filename": "010c905955a6b883943ecc0b210df3f84b39b5b636ee3488fdd32342914d1780_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Temporal continuity is abnormal (the elevation difference creates a \"valley wind effect,\" causing the clouds to spread steadily across the valley with some movement, but the video remains static throughout). Overall visual intuition is abnormal (the entire video appears too smooth and lacks a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08276", "filename": "10cc89fc8d682a9940a947603e59b678c5b61ff23b8a3d7e175c10d8d6b0c184_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08277", "filename": "10cc89fc8d682a9940a947603e59b678c5b61ff23b8a3d7e175c10d8d6b0c184_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (natural cumulus clouds will have fluffy textures and dynamic edges due to airflow, but the cloud blocks in the video have overly smooth edges and regular shapes, without the natural textures of being pulled by the wind, and look more like static textures than flowing clouds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08278", "filename": "10cc89fc8d682a9940a947603e59b678c5b61ff23b8a3d7e175c10d8d6b0c184_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (the transition between the clouds and the sky is too abrupt; in nature, the edges of clouds have a gradual blurring effect due to air refraction and airflow, but the cloud boundaries in the image are unusually clear, with no dynamic or drifting details).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08279", "filename": "10cc89fc8d682a9940a947603e59b678c5b61ff23b8a3d7e175c10d8d6b0c184_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are off: the overall impression is off (there is no clear direction of light source, and the clouds do not have corresponding changes in light and shadow to create a sense of volume).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08280", "filename": "10cf4ffb6c92b005763d9b306a916914b60f16433b7bc323e51177891ab5cfde_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (the clouds are constantly moving throughout the video, but the sun's position remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08281", "filename": "10cf4ffb6c92b005763d9b306a916914b60f16433b7bc323e51177891ab5cfde_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the upper layer of clouds in the video is finely textured wispy clouds, while the lower layer is thick, blocky dark clouds. In a natural state, different types of clouds will transition naturally with the airflow, but the boundary between the two layers of clouds in the video is too harsh).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08286", "filename": "12c866274bf004fd035de31a62e33d89af1e358122eb0b9501820cde1e18ec51_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (during the 1.1s-2.0s interval of the video, when the person is rapidly spinning the wine glass, the speed at which the smoke flows out of the glass increases in speed along with the person spinning the glass; the smoke should flow out at a normal speed).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08287", "filename": "12c866274bf004fd035de31a62e33d89af1e358122eb0b9501820cde1e18ec51_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the color transition of the smoke in the lower left corner of the video is too uniform, lacking the dynamic drift of natural smoke, and the transition with the white smoke in the center is abrupt, lacking a natural blending or obscuring relationship).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08288", "filename": "12c866274bf004fd035de31a62e33d89af1e358122eb0b9501820cde1e18ec51_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the purple liquid in the glass in the video is constantly boiling, but the hot air flowing out is constantly sinking and spreading in all directions. Because the hot air has a low density, the flow trajectory is a vertically upward columnar flow).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08289", "filename": "12c866274bf004fd035de31a62e33d89af1e358122eb0b9501820cde1e18ec51_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly. In the video, between 3.1s and 6.6s, when the person pours out the dry ice and smoke from the can, the dry ice in the can disappears into thin air, leaving only a large amount of smoke.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08290", "filename": "12f4871336fafac4955650e3c9995fee39fad1e6027abfd2d258aed95474de8f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the smoke flowing from the chimney clips through the chimney throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08291", "filename": "12f4871336fafac4955650e3c9995fee39fad1e6027abfd2d258aed95474de8f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the smoke coming out of the chimney in the entire video is too straight and vertical, lacking the irregular dispersion of smoke in reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08292", "filename": "12f4871336fafac4955650e3c9995fee39fad1e6027abfd2d258aed95474de8f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the sky above the chimney and the flowing smoke have a persistent gray shadow throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08293", "filename": "13b282fa6d8dce7943fb6b7753a0a544ea9e645a8ed4fde98e5afd7e0f0a390e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08294", "filename": "13b282fa6d8dce7943fb6b7753a0a544ea9e645a8ed4fde98e5afd7e0f0a390e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (between 0.6s and 4.7s in the video, the ground should be illuminated by the burning flames, but the light dims instead of brightening).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08295", "filename": "13b282fa6d8dce7943fb6b7753a0a544ea9e645a8ed4fde98e5afd7e0f0a390e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08301", "filename": "ce01b05add5d1a003b913f727aab440e89e8920928d481f8614222e37b58fc8e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2 seconds, the flame passes directly through the lower right corner of the paper above, but the paper is not ignited).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08302", "filename": "ce8da61eb882f0d3bf1d2f64ee5d2241f5ea9765b212b7a5ddbf28157f828007_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 3.8 seconds, the debris that fell to the ground suddenly disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08303", "filename": "ce8da61eb882f0d3bf1d2f64ee5d2241f5ea9765b212b7a5ddbf28157f828007_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (at 1.9s, the glass shards disappear into thin air) (at 2.7s, the shattered glass is suddenly restored in mid-air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08304", "filename": "ce8da61eb882f0d3bf1d2f64ee5d2241f5ea9765b212b7a5ddbf28157f828007_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (at 3.5s, the glass shards falling to the ground suddenly turned into stones); Physical behavior (at 3.9s, the car pressed down, but the car tires remained unchanged, violating the law of elasticity).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08305", "filename": "ce51ab327cb522e4bdfc1c186fa8c7cb9612c565e1bbf449d99ea071a68ce0c9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the wooden stick that burned on the flames reappears and becomes longer after 3.9 seconds from the start).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08306", "filename": "ce51ab327cb522e4bdfc1c186fa8c7cb9612c565e1bbf449d99ea071a68ce0c9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08307", "filename": "ce51ab327cb522e4bdfc1c186fa8c7cb9612c565e1bbf449d99ea071a68ce0c9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08308", "filename": "ce22325d6752d0cad3ac3bae80d213f8ea54938e56d2011abf4de2b83f7c397f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the sunlight passes directly through the tree trunk without being blocked throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08309", "filename": "ce22325d6752d0cad3ac3bae80d213f8ea54938e56d2011abf4de2b83f7c397f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08310", "filename": "ce22325d6752d0cad3ac3bae80d213f8ea54938e56d2011abf4de2b83f7c397f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08311", "filename": "cee3f60fcd7fc93ddf475c9d81756c7062c15df3c43aa636c1949bc4151764ef_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.8 seconds, the blades of the oar in the hand suddenly become noticeably smaller). (The waterfall and hills in the entire video are too blurry, appearing as fine particles.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08312", "filename": "cee3f60fcd7fc93ddf475c9d81756c7062c15df3c43aa636c1949bc4151764ef_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.8s, the person in the kayak upstream suddenly has a paddle out of thin air) (at 5.1s, the person and the kayak upstream suddenly disappear).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08313", "filename": "cef9fbbf30bb54cc973219b9519ae4a53690904b973b09d00528dc3abbc590ca_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to physical behavior (the bubbles should be floating above the water surface throughout the video, but they remain below the surface, which does not conform to the principle of density and pressure).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08314", "filename": "cef9fbbf30bb54cc973219b9519ae4a53690904b973b09d00528dc3abbc590ca_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the water surface is too smooth throughout the entire video, and there are no ripples on the water surface).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08315", "filename": "cef9fbbf30bb54cc973219b9519ae4a53690904b973b09d00528dc3abbc590ca_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08316", "filename": "cef9fbbf30bb54cc973219b9519ae4a53690904b973b09d00528dc3abbc590ca_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly: The timing is continuous (at 3.5 seconds, a sudden splash occurs on the calm water surface, but no items fall into the water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08317", "filename": "cf5e1d75c268cd6c75e706d8b43886b9945dec5f3e25af1161f0388f8761fe48_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (the water in the pot was boiling throughout the video, bubbles rose to the surface but did not burst, and hot air would form water vapor when it met cold air, but no white water vapor was emitted).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08318", "filename": "cf5e1d75c268cd6c75e706d8b43886b9945dec5f3e25af1161f0388f8761fe48_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08319", "filename": "cf5e1d75c268cd6c75e706d8b43886b9945dec5f3e25af1161f0388f8761fe48_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08320", "filename": "cf5e1d75c268cd6c75e706d8b43886b9945dec5f3e25af1161f0388f8761fe48_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08321", "filename": "cf250f8bce224874a1893a24f7b297dfd0aa6eea6a85ce3b5658650b24a30e91_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.6s, the polar bear's head suddenly changes, rotating 180 degrees backward, but the polar bear's body remains in the original orientation).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08322", "filename": "cf250f8bce224874a1893a24f7b297dfd0aa6eea6a85ce3b5658650b24a30e91_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.6 seconds, two heads of the same polar bear appear, and the polar bear's forelegs disappear out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08323", "filename": "cf250f8bce224874a1893a24f7b297dfd0aa6eea6a85ce3b5658650b24a30e91_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08324", "filename": "cf558ac7b13c20192dfa5f256fbe3239c20345d54d8b0b555fe0ce8570e1689d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: physical behavior (the burning firewood moves on its own at 4.8s without any external force, which does not conform to the law of interaction forces).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08325", "filename": "cf558ac7b13c20192dfa5f256fbe3239c20345d54d8b0b555fe0ce8570e1689d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (at 4.8 seconds, the burning flames suddenly shrink without any external force, and the burned firewood is suddenly restored).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08326", "filename": "cf558ac7b13c20192dfa5f256fbe3239c20345d54d8b0b555fe0ce8570e1689d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08327", "filename": "cf680fed4a1be18fe2735547f3615844e7ef52f7f220d2181ba815522c45b2f3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (the flames did not spread throughout the entire video, and the paper above the flames was never ignited, which is inconsistent with the flammability of paper).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08328", "filename": "cf680fed4a1be18fe2735547f3615844e7ef52f7f220d2181ba815522c45b2f3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the white paper that was burned suddenly returns to its original state at 2.9 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08329", "filename": "cf680fed4a1be18fe2735547f3615844e7ef52f7f220d2181ba815522c45b2f3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The timing is continuous (at 3.2 seconds, white smoke suddenly comes out from the lower right corner of the sheet metal, but there is no burning material in the lower right corner of the sheet metal).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08330", "filename": "cf5088fccd4949eb42ce676ccc218c6e8cc5032a8a5f9c4cb293b9fb9bf60588_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (a ball of fire is suspended in the air and burning in the upper right corner of the entire video, with no burning objects below it).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08331", "filename": "43557ad13e2e71603861541274cb2d567e9ce1fe24d99c30d2ac5dabd67ff57c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the yellow object deforms during the period from 2.8s to 3.1s), physical behavior (at 4.6s, the yellow object can be clearly seen passing through the rotating wheel, showing a clipping phenomenon).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08332", "filename": "43557ad13e2e71603861541274cb2d567e9ce1fe24d99c30d2ac5dabd67ff57c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the red object on the right deforms at 2.2s, and the top of the yellow column deforms between 2s and 3.3s); the overall realism is abnormal (in the video, the tires start to sway left and right as the gears turn, whereas in reality, tires are supposed to rotate in place along with the gears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08333", "filename": "43557ad13e2e71603861541274cb2d567e9ce1fe24d99c30d2ac5dabd67ff57c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall realism is abnormal (in the video, the large and small gears start rotating without making contact, and the speeds of all rotating objects on the same device are inconsistent. In reality, for objects to rotate, gears must be in close contact, and the rotation speeds on the same device must be consistent).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08334", "filename": "43557ad13e2e71603861541274cb2d567e9ce1fe24d99c30d2ac5dabd67ff57c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08335", "filename": "043572dd2f81bafba6c2f087f0a00cfedd7513ef383bb4b312441825634aad4c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows a toy car being run over by a large vehicle's wheel, yet the toy car is not damaged and no debris is produced. In reality, a toy car would be crushed by a vehicle's wheel.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08336", "filename": "043572dd2f81bafba6c2f087f0a00cfedd7513ef383bb4b312441825634aad4c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (in the video, the toy boat, instead of breaking when run over by a wheel, is propelled forward; in the current video, the toy car breaks when run over); Time continuity (at 0.2 seconds, the right wheel of the blue car deforms, and at 3.8 seconds, the left wheel of the green car disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08337", "filename": "45838e38158ffe3c6507a9389ca35cd1b9691326d88725398f7e639151cc7938_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (within the same sky, the upper clouds move forward, the lower clouds move to the left, and a cloud in the lower right corner remains stationary throughout the entire sequence. In reality, cloud movement should be consistent); Temporal continuity (the lower clouds appear and disappear repeatedly throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08338", "filename": "45838e38158ffe3c6507a9389ca35cd1b9691326d88725398f7e639151cc7938_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (There are numerous ripples on the water surface below in the same space, indicating wind, but the clouds in the sky remain stationary. As they disappear, the clouds are slowly moved by the wind.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08339", "filename": "46065be39e1b001d4a91e452d14533548294e3d21897b78955fb82f8ad3c2dbb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08340", "filename": "46065be39e1b001d4a91e452d14533548294e3d21897b78955fb82f8ad3c2dbb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the video, the ice cube is suspended above the bottom of the cup without any force before melting; after melting, the ice cube begins to float without touching the water surface. The ice cube produces a large amount of water, but its volume remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08341", "filename": "46065be39e1b001d4a91e452d14533548294e3d21897b78955fb82f8ad3c2dbb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (in the video, the water level in the glass decreases instead of increases after the ice melts and sinks. In reality, ice, being less dense than water, floats on the surface of water, and the water content increases as the ice melts).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08342", "filename": "46065be39e1b001d4a91e452d14533548294e3d21897b78955fb82f8ad3c2dbb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video exhibits several anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (at 1.7 seconds, the ice cubes in the glass change from one large piece to several smaller pieces, and the water changes from ice to hot; at 5.6 seconds, all the ice cubes merge into one small piece); the overall realism is inconsistent (in the video, a single drop of water forms on the glass wall, but it flows to the bottom and forms a puddle. In reality, a single drop of water flowing to the bottom of a glass would only form a small water stain).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08347", "filename": "51770d18b8e430d93abcf8985201d17dfd278d6b6ca1bb378527f58da9841662_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the white object in the water suddenly disappears at 2.3 seconds); the overall realism is abnormal (the video shows an egg falling from the air into a glass of water, but the egg does not make a splash when it falls into the glass, whereas in reality an egg falling into water would make a splash).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08348", "filename": "51770d18b8e430d93abcf8985201d17dfd278d6b6ca1bb378527f58da9841662_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is continuous (the egg, which was floating in the water, suddenly sinks to the bottom of the cup at 1.7 seconds); the overall realism is abnormal (the egg does not make a splash when it falls into the water, whereas in reality, an egg falling into water would make a small splash).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08349", "filename": "51955dd7501d4770522c9439f26c7d15b08ba766b5d6bd252c8f5e54b95e1f43_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall realism is abnormal (the video shows a leaf covered in water droplets swaying in the wind, but one droplet of water remains stationary underneath the leaf without dripping. In reality, there are many water droplets on the leaf, and the droplets should slide down the leaf or drip during swaying).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08350", "filename": "51955dd7501d4770522c9439f26c7d15b08ba766b5d6bd252c8f5e54b95e1f43_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08351", "filename": "52537bbf004c4f1e56bca44ac68622ba805fbfbfab81973974eff17321b2609b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08352", "filename": "52537bbf004c4f1e56bca44ac68622ba805fbfbfab81973974eff17321b2609b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall sense of realism is abnormal (the video begins at dusk, with the sky continuously changing color, and finally the scene changes to dawn. In reality, it is impossible for dusk to change to dawn without experiencing darkness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08353", "filename": "52537bbf004c4f1e56bca44ac68622ba805fbfbfab81973974eff17321b2609b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (clouds are moving rapidly in the same space, indicating strong winds, but the trees remain stationary.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08354", "filename": "53886df3609e00f4206c72b1119fa057ac90a51d9a6ed6b855545d20f93bc9f4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (the wooden block did not crack when it was pressed by the machine throughout the video, and the left side of the bottom wooden block did not deform during the pressing process. In reality, wooden blocks will crack and crumble when pressed).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08355", "filename": "53886df3609e00f4206c72b1119fa057ac90a51d9a6ed6b855545d20f93bc9f4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (in the video, the wooden block is pressed by the machine without cracking or splintering, and the texture of the wooden block is like clay. In reality, wooden blocks are relatively hard objects, and they would crack and splinter when pressed by a machine).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08356", "filename": "54573ddd6231b0ded425aa881d02b729831fe5d74185e82bf85e2ae91af24ef2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video content: Physical relationship (in the video, the basin for washing strawberries is full of water, and water keeps flowing into the basin, but the water droplet content in the basin does not increase without spilling out)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08357", "filename": "54573ddd6231b0ded425aa881d02b729831fe5d74185e82bf85e2ae91af24ef2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to the following issues: the timing is continuous (a strawberry stem suddenly appears on the strawberry at 3.5 seconds); the physical relationship is also problematic (the basin for washing strawberries in the video is full of water, and water keeps flowing into the basin, but the water droplet content does not increase without spilling out).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08358", "filename": "54573ddd6231b0ded425aa881d02b729831fe5d74185e82bf85e2ae91af24ef2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical relationship (In the video, the basin for washing strawberries is full of water, and water from the tap is constantly flowing into the basin, but the water droplet content in the basin does not increase without spilling out).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08359", "filename": "54573ddd6231b0ded425aa881d02b729831fe5d74185e82bf85e2ae91af24ef2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (from the start to 3.1s, the number of strawberries gradually decreases without being removed from the bowl; at 4.6s, a strawberry suddenly appears in the lower right corner of the bowl); Physical behavior (at 4.5s, a strawberry can be seen passing through the metal bowl on the right side of the screen, exhibiting a clipping phenomenon).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08360", "filename": "54661d3b585a6579fedde7183767526558bb0e1d3ec6c4fd6cee8fa95d40e9dd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the chili pepper on the clamp shrinks after being removed from the clamp at 0s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08361", "filename": "P11_107_19_fa0f4f499e08ae0c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: at 2 seconds, the scissors don't make deep enough contact with the pizza to cut it. From 2.02 to 4.7 seconds, the pizza is cut too smoothly, lacking the realistic feel and the necessary abrupt cuts. From 1.5 seconds to 4.7 seconds, the pizza remains stationary despite being subjected to force, instead of moving in the direction of the force applied.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08362", "filename": "P11_107_19_fa0f4f499e08ae0c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Timing continuity (between 2.16 and 7.8 seconds, the scissors did not touch the pizza, yet the dough was cut).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08363", "filename": "P11_107_19_fa0f4f499e08ae0c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the cut pizza suddenly disappears at 2.4s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08364", "filename": "P11_107_20_a488b600ebf8e0fa_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly: (In the image, the scissors are not touching the pizza, and they are cutting around the pizza, but the dough is splitting in the middle. Normally, the dough should separate along the path the scissors have cut.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08365", "filename": "P11_107_20_a488b600ebf8e0fa_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (from 5.20 to 6.1 seconds, the scissors cut the pizza, but the dough wasn't cut).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08366", "filename": "P12_101_11_eae70477f92b9ea0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (between 2.10 and 2.5 seconds, food appears out of nowhere in the refrigerator, and the appearance of the right hand is too abrupt).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08367", "filename": "P12_101_11_eae70477f92b9ea0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the needle-like object is not present on the box held by the box's hand between 0s and 2.7s, but suddenly appears after the refrigerator door is opened). Physical behavior (between 6.6s and 8s, more than half of the two boxes placed on the cabinet are suspended in mid-air; the cabinet's support is insufficient to support the weight of the boxes, yet the boxes do not fall but remain suspended in the air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08368", "filename": "P12_101_54_494f3a5f9edbf9b4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is as follows: During the ignition process from 1.7s to 3.7s, the ignition point of the gas stove is on the switch, not on the stove itself. The character inserts their finger into the flame to change the ignition point, which is inconsistent with normal human behavior and is therefore illogical.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08369", "filename": "P12_101_54_494f3a5f9edbf9b4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08370", "filename": "P12_101_54_494f3a5f9edbf9b4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (At 1.7 seconds into the video, the igniter on the stove suddenly appears.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08371", "filename": "P12_101_193_0fb23ec624314c8b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly occurred: (At 2.1 seconds, the meat patty placed in the pot suddenly returned to the hand. At 3.7 seconds, the object previously placed in the pot appeared out of thin air in the hand.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08372", "filename": "P12_101_193_0fb23ec624314c8b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: (5.25-8s shows a hand being put into the pot and stirred, which is not like a realistic scene. Normally, a tool should be used to stir the food in the pot.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08373", "filename": "P12_101_251_1aaaade933c2d90a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08374", "filename": "P12_101_310_b863a6b478524d26_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (From 2:15 to 3:23, the paper is cut by a fork, but the paper in the scene is suddenly torn apart; at 4:17, the fork in hand suddenly turns into a knife; from 6:04 to 7:23, when picking up the knife on the table, the two knives on the table suddenly merge into one; at 6:17, the knife in hand and the knife picked up merge into one; at 5:22, the surface of the merged knife suddenly shows the sauce from the jar.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08375", "filename": "P12_101_353_874e3e6960c41f8b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 7.5 seconds, a bottle suddenly appears in the hand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08376", "filename": "P12_101_360_81790ff2c0b9c200_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08377", "filename": "P12_101_360_81790ff2c0b9c200_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal screen display: Physical behavior (the cabinet opens automatically without any external force at 3.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08378", "filename": "P12_101_484_e1fdafaa37eedcaa_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08379", "filename": "P12_101_484_e1fdafaa37eedcaa_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (at 5.2 seconds, the igniter just ignites, and the water in the pot immediately boils).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08380", "filename": "P12_103_24_102be501324e7c4f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.5s, dough appears out of nowhere in the water tank).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08381", "filename": "P12_103_24_102be501324e7c4f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 1.7s, dough suddenly appears in the hand and in the sink).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08382", "filename": "P12_103_24_102be501324e7c4f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.9 seconds, the dough in the hand suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08383", "filename": "P12_103_49_ff8d8f7695fcb82f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time frame is continuous (between 1.03 and 4.8 seconds, the amount of food resembling minced meat in the plate increases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08384", "filename": "P12_103_100_4198f5d926ee9096_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08385", "filename": "P12_103_100_4198f5d926ee9096_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08386", "filename": "P12_103_100_4198f5d926ee9096_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (steam appeared out of thin air in the pot at 1.6 seconds before the fire was even lit).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08387", "filename": "P12_103_102_af48d5c95db28c1d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08388", "filename": "P12_103_113_a6e1b478b9c734b9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08389", "filename": "P12_103_136_d14a36c51954b17c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08390", "filename": "P12_103_136_d14a36c51954b17c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The steam suddenly disappears at 5.3 seconds when the hand is placed on the lid.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08391", "filename": "P30_111_461_e8a59446c08f9002_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the corn kernels in the pot suddenly disappear at 5.5 seconds in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08392", "filename": "P30_111_463_c424256b706c1b68_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.3 seconds in the video, the apple on the cutting board suddenly splits into two pieces).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08393", "filename": "P30_111_463_c424256b706c1b68_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals and physical behavior are abnormal (at 1 seconds, the cutting board moves on its own even though the character is not touching any objects).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08394", "filename": "P30_111_463_c424256b706c1b68_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal, and the timing is inconsistent (at 1.2 seconds, the plastic bag in the character's left hand suddenly disappears, and at 5.6 seconds 1, when the character is chopping vegetables, the amount of vegetables increases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08395", "filename": "P30_111_499_0efa292a70f6c67c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08396", "filename": "P30_111_499_0efa292a70f6c67c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal, and the time continuity is abnormal (at 0.1 seconds, there was an object in the shot, but it suddenly disappeared later).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08397", "filename": "P30_111_534_0e43096a4c6126f8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is discontinuous (at 3.3 seconds, the spoon is being rinsed under the tap without splashing water; at 4.2 seconds, the cat suddenly appears in the sink, and the water is suddenly turned off).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08398", "filename": "P30_111_534_0e43096a4c6126f8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal, and the time continuity is abnormal (at 3.4 seconds, the character did not touch the faucet switch, and the faucet suddenly stopped flowing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08399", "filename": "P30_111_608_001bcd37e12fccbc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal, and the continuity of time is abnormal (at 0.4 seconds, more and more debris appears on the ground, seemingly out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08400", "filename": "P30_111_624_ebcab3aab38c3f33_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal, and the timing is inconsistent (at 0.6 seconds, the faucet starts spraying water before the character touches the switch).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08401", "filename": "P30_112_3_b9aff79f908219bf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal, and the temporal continuity is abnormal. An oven embedded in the ground and facing the ceiling appears in the scene, and its placement violates the logic of the use of real physical space and common sense of architectural structure.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08405", "filename": "P30_113_99_92ffd4488bf3203a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image length is abnormal and the time continuity is abnormal (at 4.6 seconds, the pizza pattern in the shot shows a flickering or jerking phenomenon).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08406", "filename": "P30_113_141_414e10217a988652_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 1.4s in the display, the faucet suddenly shuts off without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08407", "filename": "P35_101_1_ba53c1fdaefd68b0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals and physical behavior are abnormal (at 1.4 seconds, the character takes a handle from below and moves it to the back; at 2.4 seconds, the handle and the pot in the character's hand automatically connect and merge).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08408", "filename": "P35_101_22_2e54cbdbae5d56fd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals and physical behavior are abnormal (at 6.4 seconds, the scissors make a small cut, but after cutting the packaging bag, they create a very large opening, which is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08409", "filename": "P35_101_39_e17ec26fea39b594_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal, and the physical behavior is abnormal (at the beginning of the video, the transparent part of the plastic bag is visible, and there is no meat in the bag, but at 0 seconds, a large piece of meat suddenly appears in the bag).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08410", "filename": "P35_103_49_e67667d5e4b41aa6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals and physical behavior are abnormal (at 4.1 seconds, the character flips the wok, but due to gravity, the food in the wok does not fall into the plate).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08411", "filename": "P35_103_49_e67667d5e4b41aa6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal, and the time continuity is abnormal (at 0.1 seconds into the video, many pieces of meat suddenly appear out of nowhere where the spoon is).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08412", "filename": "P35_103_54_be3b409977aa7274_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 7.1 seconds into the video, the water that was flowing into the pot suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08413", "filename": "P35_103_54_be3b409977aa7274_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals and physics are erratic (at 1.7 seconds, when the character is using the machine to stir, there is a spoon next to the machine, but the spoon suddenly disappears after stirring is finished).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08414", "filename": "P35_103_55_31f9a4cc0b54918e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals and physical behavior are abnormal (at 1.9 seconds, fragments from the object fall to the ground and suddenly turn into shattered tiles).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08415", "filename": "P35_103_55_31f9a4cc0b54918e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal, and the time is continuous (3.3s). The fragments produced when the object breaks do not fly out from the object itself, but appear out of thin air.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08416", "filename": "P35_103_85_9559ef40b6ac656a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal, the physical behavior is abnormal (at 1.4 seconds, the food in the picture shrinks), and the time continuity is abnormal (at 2.6 seconds, food suddenly appears out of thin air in the character's hand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08417", "filename": "P35_103_85_9559ef40b6ac656a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals and physical behavior are abnormal (at 4.5 seconds, the finger that the character is using to tear the plastic bag turns into the plastic bag itself).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08418", "filename": "P35_103_166_5d347946d32147cc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08419", "filename": "P35_103_166_5d347946d32147cc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal, and the time continuity is abnormal (the floor texture in the video shows flickering and jerking from 0 to 0.7 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08420", "filename": "P35_103_233_6f6ceeb2ca1083f0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal, and the time continuity is abnormal. (At 1.3 seconds into the scene, the character was wiping the table with their left hand, but after 1.3 seconds, they switched to their right hand.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08421", "filename": "9280bd8ccb93ce7e07cc10862e7addda4ebffbd48fab55c03dfd55c470d2165a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video content: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the foam and plastic did not ignite or melt under the flames. In real life, foam is highly flammable and would easily ignite and melt when ignited by a flamethrower).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08422", "filename": "9280bd8ccb93ce7e07cc10862e7addda4ebffbd48fab55c03dfd55c470d2165a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video exhibits the following anomalies: Physical behavior (the yellow and blue plastics did not change in volume or shape after being melted by the blowtorch); temporal continuity (a blue object appears on top of the yellow object at 1.6 seconds); and an overall lack of realism (the red and blue objects in the video are made of the same substance, but the yellow and blue objects melt quickly when heated by the blowtorch, while the yellow object does not melt).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08423", "filename": "9318bd79abf3d55412fd53909d89fc5f8039927a764c9d02f9cf8b0b1a7184bc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video exhibits the following anomalies: a continuous time frame (within 0.6 seconds, the cannon begins emitting large amounts of smoke without being ignited); and physical behavior (the cannon in the video is suspended in mid-air without any support).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08424", "filename": "9318bd79abf3d55412fd53909d89fc5f8039927a764c9d02f9cf8b0b1a7184bc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the cannon produces a lot of smoke after being ignited by the flame at the bottom, but the shape of the cannon does not change. In reality, a cannon will explode and produce sparks and debris when it is ignited).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08425", "filename": "9318bd79abf3d55412fd53909d89fc5f8039927a764c9d02f9cf8b0b1a7184bc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (no debris was produced after the cannon exploded in the video, and the cannon's shape did not change): Overall realism is abnormal (at 2.9 seconds, the cannon exploded and produced a regular, thick smoke that slowly dispersed in all directions. In real life, cannon explosions produce debris and smoke, and the smoke is much less than in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08426", "filename": "9547b92811284d22a9538c8b51a0b430d896402fb3f93ee4dbe62b4b3239c3bd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physics issues (clouds above move rapidly in the same space, but clouds below don't move as fast. In reality, clouds move at a consistent speed); Overall realism issues (clouds move rapidly in the video, but trees below remain stationary. In reality, fast-moving clouds indicate strong winds, and leaves should sway to some extent).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08427", "filename": "9547b92811284d22a9538c8b51a0b430d896402fb3f93ee4dbe62b4b3239c3bd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall sense of realism is abnormal (the sea of clouds in the video is a flat and thick layer of clouds that only forms after the sun has risen to the center of the sky, while in reality this type of sea of clouds only forms halfway up the mountain in the early morning).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08428", "filename": "9547b92811284d22a9538c8b51a0b430d896402fb3f93ee4dbe62b4b3239c3bd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall realism is abnormal (in the video, the clouds above move around the sun, while the clouds below move to the left. In reality, clouds move in a consistent direction; furthermore, the clouds in the video are too regular and lack texture).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08429", "filename": "9547b92811284d22a9538c8b51a0b430d896402fb3f93ee4dbe62b4b3239c3bd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08430", "filename": "9866edde11467c0ee8cc23aa069c02c5e00edee398159bb3df63eee504186e10_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2s, there is a flickering phenomenon on the middle floor, and at 4.3s, a large amount of water suddenly emerges from the right side of the ice block in the lower left corner, and then the water immediately disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08431", "filename": "9866edde11467c0ee8cc23aa069c02c5e00edee398159bb3df63eee504186e10_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical phenomena (in the video, the ice cube is simply placed on the floor, but it melts too quickly, and the amount of water produced is excessive. In real life, the water produced after an ice cube melts should be less than the ice cube itself); Temporal continuity (in the entire video, water suddenly appears on the floor in the lower left corner without any ice melting or water dripping).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08432", "filename": "9866edde11467c0ee8cc23aa069c02c5e00edee398159bb3df63eee504186e10_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the ice suddenly melts at 1.3s, and the ice blocks change from being vertical to being horizontal).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08433", "filename": "9866edde11467c0ee8cc23aa069c02c5e00edee398159bb3df63eee504186e10_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (In the video, the ice block on the left melts, producing a large amount of water splashing, and the volume of water is excessive. During the disappearance animation, the melting ice block does not produce water splashes.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08434", "filename": "9896cab4ea082159e0a7734716b7ff1e3397c193f2cf4e4edf2f473fa7638d84_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall sense of self is off (the horse's head-to-body ratio in the video is incorrect, and its tail is too short. In reality, horses have small heads, large bodies, and long tails).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08435", "filename": "9896cab4ea082159e0a7734716b7ff1e3397c193f2cf4e4edf2f473fa7638d84_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Throughout the entire process, the horse's shadow appears intermittently, whereas in reality, shadows change size, but they are always connected to the bottom of the object).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08436", "filename": "9896cab4ea082159e0a7734716b7ff1e3397c193f2cf4e4edf2f473fa7638d84_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08437", "filename": "9896cab4ea082159e0a7734716b7ff1e3397c193f2cf4e4edf2f473fa7638d84_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08438", "filename": "9981d106d9bd4700652cd45585139025f7ebb719606ea4f4014f3aa99b0ec5c2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (at 0.7s, the hook on the left side of the screen changes into a clip); Unrealistic overall feel (between 2.1s and 2.5s, the object on the clip suddenly attaches to a transparent object).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08439", "filename": "9981d106d9bd4700652cd45585139025f7ebb719606ea4f4014f3aa99b0ec5c2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the video, the light on the transparent object moves with the movement of the clamp, but the intensity does not change. In reality, the intensity and shape of light reflected from an object change with the object's orientation, but the position remains constant.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08440", "filename": "9981d106d9bd4700652cd45585139025f7ebb719606ea4f4014f3aa99b0ec5c2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08441", "filename": "9981d106d9bd4700652cd45585139025f7ebb719606ea4f4014f3aa99b0ec5c2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (water ripples are generated when a fine needle passes through a solid sheet between 3.4s and 4.5s); Time continuity (a fine needle suddenly flies out from the left and pierces the sheet at 7.5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08442", "filename": "012357b8a5e57726ed5e84c718772a3f65489ba792a5e85b6df6a5d42719d881_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 2.9s, the leaf that the tweezers were supposed to hold changed from one leaf to two).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08443", "filename": "012357b8a5e57726ed5e84c718772a3f65489ba792a5e85b6df6a5d42719d881_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Physical behavior (from the start to 1.6s, the pink object floats into the air and onto the tweezers without being subjected to any force)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08444", "filename": "012357b8a5e57726ed5e84c718772a3f65489ba792a5e85b6df6a5d42719d881_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the blades on the tweezers suddenly enlarge at 0.7s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08445", "filename": "15117a0295bfa0474a22c4a0a303ae8235ad3e47f242c1987b717a989a94eddb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormality in the video: Physical behavior (in the video, the toy's shape did not change after being run over by a car tire. In reality, when a toy is run over by a heavy object such as a car, it will be damaged and break into pieces).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08446", "filename": "15117a0295bfa0474a22c4a0a303ae8235ad3e47f242c1987b717a989a94eddb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (the toy in the video starts swinging up and down in place without being subjected to any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08447", "filename": "15117a0295bfa0474a22c4a0a303ae8235ad3e47f242c1987b717a989a94eddb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08448", "filename": "15117a0295bfa0474a22c4a0a303ae8235ad3e47f242c1987b717a989a94eddb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (the toy teeth move too fast in the video, causing them to become blurry, and their position does not change despite the lemon's rapid movement. In reality, toys wouldn't move that fast, and objects would actually move at high speeds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08449", "filename": "15402c6b79ca967bde81dd5f05995871465a33b43f0f44497f35fcea6477bc88_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: External force was used (a cutting machine was used to cut an iron block, but there were no cutting marks on the iron block. In reality, after an iron block is cut, the cutting machine would move downwards to leave marks on the iron block).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08450", "filename": "15402c6b79ca967bde81dd5f05995871465a33b43f0f44497f35fcea6477bc88_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall realism is abnormal (the video shows too many sparks when the cutting machine is used to cut the iron block, and after 4.7 seconds, the sparks are only produced in the lower right corner of the cutting machine. In reality, cutting an iron block will only produce fewer sparks, and the sparks will fly in all directions).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08456", "filename": "c1409e3d3afd748ee11709f8aebd3507f843702e33f04ae9085f6db5f853fbbf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (in the entire video, the green object on the ground looks like a flame, but it has no three-dimensionality; the pink lighter held by the person suddenly turns into a clamp at 1 seconds, but the part held by the person is still a pink cylinder).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08457", "filename": "c1409e3d3afd748ee11709f8aebd3507f843702e33f04ae9085f6db5f853fbbf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (in the entire video, the green object on the ground looks like a flame, but it has no three-dimensionality. The pink lighter held by the person suddenly turns into a pair of pink scissors at 0.5 seconds and picks up the green object on the ground to cut it. However, when the scissors cut the green object, they penetrate the membrane and fuse with the green object. The green object remains intact and is not cut).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08458", "filename": "c1409e3d3afd748ee11709f8aebd3507f843702e33f04ae9085f6db5f853fbbf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (in the entire video, the green object on the ground looks like a flame, but it has no three-dimensionality. The pink lighter held by the person suddenly turns into a pair of pink scissors at 0.5 seconds. The person holding the scissors passes through the green object and clips through it. When the scissors touch the green object, the green object begins to deform, shake and split).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08459", "filename": "c1409e3d3afd748ee11709f8aebd3507f843702e33f04ae9085f6db5f853fbbf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.5s, the pink lighter held by the person suddenly turns into a pair of pink scissors. When the green object on the ground is picked up by the person, the green object turns into a bag. After the person cuts it open, liquid flows out. When the bag is put down, it deforms. At 6.1s, a green object suddenly appears out of thin air in the person's right hand. When wiping the green liquid on the floor, some of the green liquid disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08460", "filename": "c1463e8e9d575a1ce9d1dfde1d21ea5520dd299d847a38898ebd98cf2db70e3f_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Time continuity (in the video, a person is holding two rods connected by a line in the middle. At 0.5 seconds, the line in the person's hand suddenly disappears, and bubbles appear out of thin air without any bubble solution).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08461", "filename": "c1463e8e9d575a1ce9d1dfde1d21ea5520dd299d847a38898ebd98cf2db70e3f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Time continuity (in the video, a person is holding two rods connected by a line in the middle. At 1.6 seconds, the line in the person's hand suddenly disappears, turning into a double-layered triangular object, and bubbles appear out of thin air without any bubble solution).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08462", "filename": "c1463e8e9d575a1ce9d1dfde1d21ea5520dd299d847a38898ebd98cf2db70e3f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Time continuity (in the video, a person is holding two sticks connected by a line in the middle. At 1.8 seconds, the person opens the sticks from both sides, and the line in their hands suddenly disappears and turns into bubbles. Moreover, the bubbles appear out of thin air without any bubble solution.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08463", "filename": "c1463e8e9d575a1ce9d1dfde1d21ea5520dd299d847a38898ebd98cf2db70e3f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Time continuity (In the video, a person is holding two rods connected by a line in the middle. At 0.8 seconds, the line in the person's hand suddenly disappears and turns into a bubble, and the top of the bubble deforms, creating an extra circle out of thin air. Bubbles appear out of thin air without any bubble solution.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08464", "filename": "c04833bf8e0277804b08d50f2aac66206be7849c92e25163474f23eaab084ff8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Cause and effect (the land after the explosion at the end of the video was charred black, and there were no sparks left from burning dry grass after the explosion. Moreover, despite such a violent explosion, the surrounding dry grass did not show any signs of being ignited or charred).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08465", "filename": "c04833bf8e0277804b08d50f2aac66206be7849c92e25163474f23eaab084ff8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Cause and effect (After the explosion in the video, a crater appeared with smoke continuously rising. The smoke rose vertically and then drifted to the left. There was no sense of the smoke being blown away by the wind, which would have been produced by a natural explosion. Moreover, despite such a violent explosion, the surrounding dry grass did not show any signs of being ignited or charred.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08466", "filename": "c04833bf8e0277804b08d50f2aac66206be7849c92e25163474f23eaab084ff8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect (the explosion flames, smoke, and flying dirt in the entire video are severely distorted, lacking the realism of a real explosion mixing dirt and slowly drifting smoke, and a lot of dirt falling down from the clouds flying to the left).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08467", "filename": "c04833bf8e0277804b08d50f2aac66206be7849c92e25163474f23eaab084ff8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video footage is abnormal: Cause and effect (the mushroom cloud that appears during the explosion in the video can only be produced by large-scale explosions such as nuclear explosions. The explosion area in the video is not large enough to produce such a large mushroom cloud, and the crater after the explosion is obviously close to the camera and is inconsistent with the initial explosion point).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08468", "filename": "c19324b839d4218bd506b32b4cf5c709e3976251023b5c2b02a4022ab8235164_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (the water in the pot is boiling throughout the video, but there is no obvious smoke rising from the pot).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08469", "filename": "c19324b839d4218bd506b32b4cf5c709e3976251023b5c2b02a4022ab8235164_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the bubbles at the bottom of the pot gradually gather and dissipate towards the top of the pot throughout the video, which does not conform to the actual boiling state, where bubbles rise from the bottom of the pot to the surface and burst upon contact with the air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08470", "filename": "c19324b839d4218bd506b32b4cf5c709e3976251023b5c2b02a4022ab8235164_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is inconsistent (the scene at 3.2s shows a small number of bubbles starting to rise in the pot, then suddenly switches to a scene of the pot reaching boiling point and the whole pot of water boiling, with no transition or consistency).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08471", "filename": "c24020df86bd736c81a56fbd6f96c573229b82d57ec5ff9b39659cc09374d973_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (there are a large number of people on the street in the whole video, and they are very close to the explosion point, but the people in the video do not run away or retreat. The crowd in the video is distorted and merged together, and the basic human outlines are not visible).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08472", "filename": "c24020df86bd736c81a56fbd6f96c573229b82d57ec5ff9b39659cc09374d973_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (in the whole video, there are a large number of people on the street, and they are very close to the explosion point, but the people in the video do not run away or retreat. The crowd in the video is distorted and merged together, and the basic human body outlines are not visible. The roadblocks in the middle of the road and on the road have no basic shape outlines).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08473", "filename": "c24020df86bd736c81a56fbd6f96c573229b82d57ec5ff9b39659cc09374d973_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the video shows a large number of people on the street, very close to the explosion point, but instead of running away, they walk towards the fire. The crowd in the video is distorted and blended together, making it difficult to see basic human outlines. The roadblocks in the middle of the road and on the road also lack basic shapes and outlines).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08474", "filename": "c35620ea420245ef4390a11e123d3e9da4672d6e4fa5099bfa47bdbf283f7f50_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (at 3.5s, another train suddenly splits out from the left in the video, and the smoke in the whole video is unnatural, without the natural transition of black and gray transparent smoke coming out of the locomotive of a real train. The white smoke in the video looks like clouds in the sky).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08475", "filename": "c35620ea420245ef4390a11e123d3e9da4672d6e4fa5099bfa47bdbf283f7f50_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The smoke in the entire video is unnatural, lacking the natural transition of black and gray transparent smoke emitted by a real train locomotive. The white smoke in the video lingers like clouds in the sky.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08476", "filename": "c35620ea420245ef4390a11e123d3e9da4672d6e4fa5099bfa47bdbf283f7f50_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Intuitive anomaly (the smoke in the entire video is unnatural, lacking the natural transition of black and gray transparent smoke emitted by a real train locomotive; the white smoke in the video lingers like clouds in the sky).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08477", "filename": "c82095a7157fe54e7696655eca762ec251c39afc2f193061d986a25373ec0e73_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08478", "filename": "c82095a7157fe54e7696655eca762ec251c39afc2f193061d986a25373ec0e73_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Intuitively unusual (the volume of water stains from melting ice is disproportionate to the volume of the ice itself, and the water stains lack realistic fluidity, appearing overly smooth).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08479", "filename": "c82095a7157fe54e7696655eca762ec251c39afc2f193061d986a25373ec0e73_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Intuitive anomaly (the ice melts too quickly throughout the video; if the water poured on the ice was hot, it would emit smoke, but the ice in the video does not produce smoke).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08480", "filename": "c132876ba4499ad147db9829061616bab065e9ff3746d8b188da8ad4bb91bebe_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Intuitive anomaly (the ice cube in the diagnostic video shows abnormal shaking at the melting edge; the ice cube moves on its own without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08483", "filename": "31f8e9e4d321d3bc4ae2c3bcd7c84e6a67dbbe0b6682ae958fbdb146166af3e4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Cause and effect (the train is moving forward in the video, but the relative positions of the clouds and the train in the sky do not change. Moreover, the clouds in the sky should be floating due to airflow, but the clouds in the video remain stationary, which is too abrupt).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08484", "filename": "31f8e9e4d321d3bc4ae2c3bcd7c84e6a67dbbe0b6682ae958fbdb146166af3e4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Cause and effect (the clouds and smoke in the video are moving in one direction, proving that the scene is in a windy environment. In a windy environment, the lake surface should be affected by the airflow and fluctuate, but the lake surface in the video remains calm).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08485", "filename": "31f8e9e4d321d3bc4ae2c3bcd7c84e6a67dbbe0b6682ae958fbdb146166af3e4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08486", "filename": "31f8e9e4d321d3bc4ae2c3bcd7c84e6a67dbbe0b6682ae958fbdb146166af3e4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect (the train generates airflow and causes the surrounding ground to vibrate during its movement. Water will ripple when affected by airflow and ground vibration, but the water surface in the video is still and the clouds in the sky do not change at all, which is too abrupt).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08487", "filename": "32d4cfe239118042e9636707ccb605ac0383ba1bbdab20aab216729aed985844_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Cause and effect (the shadow cast by the object on the right is not consistent with the overall light source direction, and the highlights on the left and the shadows on the right do not form a reasonable light and shadow correspondence).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08488", "filename": "32d4cfe239118042e9636707ccb605ac0383ba1bbdab20aab216729aed985844_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the color and texture on the liquid surface change from small, localized patterns to covering the entire surface, and then to a complete change in color and texture, without any physical triggering conditions).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08489", "filename": "32d4cfe239118042e9636707ccb605ac0383ba1bbdab20aab216729aed985844_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the colored interference patterns in the entire video frame change randomly in shape and range without any physical trigger. The real thin film interference pattern changes depend on external forces such as angle and pressure. Moreover, the colored interference effect on the circular surface should appear on an extremely thin transparent film layer, but it is attached to a thick metallic surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08490", "filename": "32d4cfe239118042e9636707ccb605ac0383ba1bbdab20aab216729aed985844_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (from the beginning to 5.1s, liquid suddenly appears out of thin air on the circular metal surface in the image).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08491", "filename": "32e23a8db8455396ef4af5b893b05cac0dfce2963c01826ea346e281df09712c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the white object on the tree on the right side of the video suddenly disappears at 0 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08492", "filename": "32e23a8db8455396ef4af5b893b05cac0dfce2963c01826ea346e281df09712c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is continuous (sunlight is fixed, and the position and brightness of the shadows of objects do not change abruptly during the rotation of the frame, but the soft diffused sunlight in the video suddenly becomes bright).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08493", "filename": "32e23a8db8455396ef4af5b893b05cac0dfce2963c01826ea346e281df09712c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the distribution of sunlight beams is too uniform, lacking the natural intensity variations caused by differences in air dust density found in real-world scenes, making it appear too harsh).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08494", "filename": "32e23a8db8455396ef4af5b893b05cac0dfce2963c01826ea346e281df09712c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2 seconds, a branch suddenly appears out of nowhere on the small tree branch at the top of the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08499", "filename": "32fd0c50e2fec1e13da7e9153a2d9827c0c6ee999cd3220eaf192a663054adfd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (from 1.9s to 5s, the small iron ball in the hand is constantly twisting and deforming as it rotates).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08500", "filename": "32fd0c50e2fec1e13da7e9153a2d9827c0c6ee999cd3220eaf192a663054adfd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the silver ball in the hand twists and deforms during rotation from 4.1s to 5.8s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08501", "filename": "32fd0c50e2fec1e13da7e9153a2d9827c0c6ee999cd3220eaf192a663054adfd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08502", "filename": "33d8e05007db7dbdb69f72cca71e37addfd42aed862e64e4abf129d2ace0f40b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (when boiling water in a kettle, bubbles should rise vertically, but in the video, the bubbles are rotating).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08503", "filename": "33d8e05007db7dbdb69f72cca71e37addfd42aed862e64e4abf129d2ace0f40b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to the following issues: physical behavior (the steam from boiling water should escape from the spout, but in the video at 4.5s, it is escaping from the kettle body, which does not conform to the principle that solids are impermeable) and continuous timing (at 2.5s, the number of bubbles in the boiling water suddenly increases dramatically without any gradual change).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08504", "filename": "33d8e05007db7dbdb69f72cca71e37addfd42aed862e64e4abf129d2ace0f40b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the amount of water in the kettle increases out of nowhere throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08505", "filename": "33f84ce51f68d60de82cc0d9786645258ec7485c2c95035de08224b737a06786_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (after the explosive device has already detonated at 4.9 seconds, a burst of fire suddenly appears out of nowhere in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08506", "filename": "33f84ce51f68d60de82cc0d9786645258ec7485c2c95035de08224b737a06786_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is unusual: Cause and effect (when a real explosion occurs in snow, the huge impact will inevitably carry a large amount of snow and soil in all directions, leaving obvious craters or marks on the ground. However, in this video, the explosion only produces flames and smoke. There is almost no sign of the surrounding snow being lifted or splashed, and there is no obvious damage to the ground.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08507", "filename": "33f84ce51f68d60de82cc0d9786645258ec7485c2c95035de08224b737a06786_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (an explosion suddenly occurs at 0.2 seconds, but the explosion looks like a cloud of smoke rising in the air without any visible flames, and the surrounding snow does not change as a result of the explosion).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08508", "filename": "33f84ce51f68d60de82cc0d9786645258ec7485c2c95035de08224b737a06786_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the black debris falling at the bottom of the video disappears out of thin air at 6.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08509", "filename": "33f75948ff199bafbe29849470f3e01feaf78320a4c30bec24572c6f6122f295_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08510", "filename": "33f75948ff199bafbe29849470f3e01feaf78320a4c30bec24572c6f6122f295_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (some of the bubbles in the cup on the right side of the video remained underwater from beginning to end without rising).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08511", "filename": "1b8c5096f41262243491233743f500a60396985abf2955ce5e7fca2547344e3d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is unusual: the water flow doesn't resemble real water flow; it's more like a viscous liquid, lacking random splashes and natural branching. (Normally, when a large cruise ship is sailing at low speed, the bow pushes aside symmetrical waves, and the stern leaves a continuous V-shaped wake. But in this image, the waves at the bow are very weak, and the wake at the stern is stiff, lacking natural spreading texture.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08512", "filename": "1b8c5096f41262243491233743f500a60396985abf2955ce5e7fca2547344e3d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the ripples on both sides of the ship are asymmetrical, there are almost no waves pushed aside by the ship on the left side, and the wake on the right side is also very stiff, as if the ship material was directly pasted onto the sea surface, without the interaction effect of a real ship sailing with the sea).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08513", "filename": "1b8c5096f41262243491233743f500a60396985abf2955ce5e7fca2547344e3d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08514", "filename": "1b8c5096f41262243491233743f500a60396985abf2955ce5e7fca2547344e3d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08515", "filename": "1b55b6cbf1129a222744f8bf5e0f6c13c93c22a1ba1646094c6b4fa345a42ead_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08516", "filename": "1b55b6cbf1129a222744f8bf5e0f6c13c93c22a1ba1646094c6b4fa345a42ead_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08517", "filename": "1b55b6cbf1129a222744f8bf5e0f6c13c93c22a1ba1646094c6b4fa345a42ead_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (at 0.1s, the balloon being pulled by both hands suddenly transforms into a complete large balloon, completing the transformation without any inflation action).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08518", "filename": "1b2026ee6fdc2bdc589c0fb5d492c514591bd4cd1c5cf49da7eec047b34a563e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: The smoke in the video flows upwards regularly for a short distance before falling back to the ground, which does not conform to the laws of air movement; it should be affected by airflow, resulting in irregular drifting and shape changes.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08520", "filename": "1b2026ee6fdc2bdc589c0fb5d492c514591bd4cd1c5cf49da7eec047b34a563e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Starting at 0.02, the smoke grenade explosion exhibits no diffusion characteristics (smoke accumulates and does not dissipate, gas is confined to low-lying areas).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08522", "filename": "1b076029a6a18a9e1a5434ea6afd93894b20c46b6a2e107011dae3df22c9fa07_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the smoke in the video rises a short distance before flowing to the lower left and then to the ground. Based on the direction of the flames in the video, the wind is blowing to the right, and the smoke should dissipate gradually with the wind.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08523", "filename": "1b076029a6a18a9e1a5434ea6afd93894b20c46b6a2e107011dae3df22c9fa07_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the human movement from the right to the campfire is too smooth, unlike a realistic scene, lacking the abrupt pauses that should be present in reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08524", "filename": "1b076029a6a18a9e1a5434ea6afd93894b20c46b6a2e107011dae3df22c9fa07_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08525", "filename": "1b076029a6a18a9e1a5434ea6afd93894b20c46b6a2e107011dae3df22c9fa07_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (starting from 0.1s, apart from one person moving, the others in the scene appear to be frozen, which is too prominent and strange; in addition, the scenery is discordant, with blood appearing on the right and no snow visible on the left).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08526", "filename": "1ba65c6a5886a14e5ec75b3f82693d30e3ab71b93c49a7bf95340e8d4827f488_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08527", "filename": "1ba65c6a5886a14e5ec75b3f82693d30e3ab71b93c49a7bf95340e8d4827f488_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the movement of the smoke is very abnormal. When it is ejected from the device, it does not spread or curl naturally, but rather surges repeatedly within a fixed range as if it is restricted by an invisible frame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08528", "filename": "1ba65c6a5886a14e5ec75b3f82693d30e3ab71b93c49a7bf95340e8d4827f488_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08529", "filename": "1ba65c6a5886a14e5ec75b3f82693d30e3ab71b93c49a7bf95340e8d4827f488_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (the metal tray at the bottom of the video, as the smoke filled the entire frame, the reflection and clarity of the tray's edges were not affected by the smoke at all, and it maintained a sharp outline throughout).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08530", "filename": "1ba420a4d223d5bc6634d245900a585549b1a53fefc94914a74ec1347786c3f4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (the hammer suddenly disappears at 0.1s in the video, and the debris from the explosion suddenly moves in one direction and then disappears abruptly).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08531", "filename": "1ba420a4d223d5bc6634d245900a585549b1a53fefc94914a74ec1347786c3f4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (in the video, when the hammer is smashing down on multiple bottles, there should be many fragments exploding or the bottles deforming, but only fuel smoke is seen, and the hammer should gradually accelerate during its descent, not fall at a constant speed).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08532", "filename": "1ba420a4d223d5bc6634d245900a585549b1a53fefc94914a74ec1347786c3f4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08533", "filename": "1bbae3bf5036f73fa4a817a6b7ad20de6c9aafad706bb2d7cd15b58a49c65cba_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: there is a problem with the lava flow. The bright lava in the center is just churning and circulating in place, without causing the surrounding gray-black lava shell to deform or shift. Real lava flow would cause the outer shell to tear and bulge.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08534", "filename": "1bbae3bf5036f73fa4a817a6b7ad20de6c9aafad706bb2d7cd15b58a49c65cba_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the superposition of blue translucent smoke and lava in the video is very abrupt, and the color transition is unnatural. Real volcanic smoke is gray or brown and will produce natural light and shadow changes with the heat radiation of lava, and will not produce this uniform, layered blue filter effect.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08535", "filename": "1bd6f4b437e0ef7f89139c77cc8bd771b43b11172611ae8ad6a8f8abaf35c1e9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (In the video, between 0s and 0s, when the hand squeezes a grape-like stress-relief ball toy, it does not exhibit the squeezing deformation that an elastic object should have. Instead, it maintains a regular spherical shape, which violates the mechanical properties of elastic materials.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08536", "filename": "1bd6f4b437e0ef7f89139c77cc8bd771b43b11172611ae8ad6a8f8abaf35c1e9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (the protruding particles on the surface of the decompressed grape balls in the video do not undergo plastic or elastic compression due to pressure during the extrusion process, nor do they displace with the deformation of the main body. Instead, they increase in number and size without external force, which does not conform to the correspondence between force and deformation.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08537", "filename": "1bd6f4b437e0ef7f89139c77cc8bd771b43b11172611ae8ad6a8f8abaf35c1e9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, when the hand squeezes the grape-shaped pressure relief ball, it does not exhibit the compression deformation that an elastic object should have. Instead, it maintains a regular spherical outline, which violates the mechanical properties of elastic materials.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08538", "filename": "1bd6f4b437e0ef7f89139c77cc8bd771b43b11172611ae8ad6a8f8abaf35c1e9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08539", "filename": "1c2ee2b7e95992780ac56dc1bfcc1312a8e1ce40e04d1499b8680b5dfc1786b2_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (only the central tower light in the video is rotating, while the surrounding scenery remains still, like a painting, which looks unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08540", "filename": "1c2ee2b7e95992780ac56dc1bfcc1312a8e1ce40e04d1499b8680b5dfc1786b2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08541", "filename": "c718667776c7529edcd0ed0006c6a41bee37282e6f689993bfebb40e99fea1b1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the necklace merges at 5.5s, and at 5.9s the necklace at the front of the left hand extends and lengthens).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08542", "filename": "caa7a073405292f87261000ec493460869dc20798c3e33d202eb11443e39f327_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (trees and smoke from the explosion appear to flicker throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08543", "filename": "caa7a073405292f87261000ec493460869dc20798c3e33d202eb11443e39f327_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the smoke from the explosion in the video moves too smoothly and lacks a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08544", "filename": "cadede47c765da8a0893c43e36a921ce5dacdaf0f85461e1bae6a6fcbc629779_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (dominoes in the entire video appear to twist, jump, and disappear); Physical behavior (dominoes in the entire video move to the left without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08545", "filename": "cbd832589653a6531032543c21ef5d65c543e2f59d4fbf7d1fe859219be3c539_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (no transitional water droplets falling into coffee at 4.5s and 6.8s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08546", "filename": "cca104e5eb8c531152a1caa530c19bc6a20f237532e8a74eb0769be757a29349_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.3s, liquid suddenly flows out of the red object in the left hand; at 6s, the bubbles in the video flicker).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08547", "filename": "cccb3be0a67694a6a1c51f5c646ab70582167e01e77cfcdcc3ce5e2e606be954_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08549", "filename": "cd44f2eb9b38e6ea350e81f1ef8dbe5e2173925bdc9fb8b38841192328bab35a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the water movement in the entire video is too smooth and lacks a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08550", "filename": "cd58e9dd6600107dc364a9ba08e22e0a7b92873fdb80c74f565b4a0e36054931_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The duration is continuous (the amount of liquid at the bottom of the container increases inexplicably throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08551", "filename": "cddc69ace7f6d28d1ab03d0444b1f22411a01d7adc7504113e1958ad53dd2e2f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous timing (trees flicker and wriggle throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08552", "filename": "cdfa50b45d657fa9c0f873be41cb59765eee78ab6bdd13559b625c1b8f3b90d0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the cloud movement in the entire video is too smooth and lacks a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08553", "filename": "cdfb8924f40923b73597cf7c19492b30ba401325e9d46755effe188535ecb9f9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.7 seconds, a ball of flame suddenly appears out of nowhere on the roof beam, and the left side of the roof and the wood show dynamic flickering flaws throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08554", "filename": "cdfb8924f40923b73597cf7c19492b30ba401325e9d46755effe188535ecb9f9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (from 1s to 5s, the flames burning on the roof beam gradually increase without adding any more fuel; at 3.5s, the roof beam on the right collapses and a wall is formed out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08555", "filename": "ce01b05add5d1a003b913f727aab440e89e8920928d481f8614222e37b58fc8e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (charcoal appears out of nowhere on the right side of the paper at 2.5s; a large amount of black burning debris suddenly appears on the left side of the smoke at 4s; a large amount of burning charcoal suddenly appears in the middle of the fire at 4.9s); Physical behavior (the paper moves backward without any external force at 4.1s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08556", "filename": "ce8da61eb882f0d3bf1d2f64ee5d2241f5ea9765b212b7a5ddbf28157f828007_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time sequence (0s: twisting at the point where the hook contacts the roof; 0.4s: sudden disappearance of the red object to the left of the hook; 3.9s: a large amount of debris suddenly appears at the point where the hook contacts the roof).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08557", "filename": "ce8da61eb882f0d3bf1d2f64ee5d2241f5ea9765b212b7a5ddbf28157f828007_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the glass shards appear grainy at 0.2s, suddenly disappear at 0.2s, and the small bright spots on the car body suddenly enlarge at 1.6s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08558", "filename": "ce51ab327cb522e4bdfc1c186fa8c7cb9612c565e1bbf449d99ea071a68ce0c9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the entire video frame is still, but the burning flame flickers).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08559", "filename": "ce22325d6752d0cad3ac3bae80d213f8ea54938e56d2011abf4de2b83f7c397f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the entire video is too smooth and lacks a sense of naturalness).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08561", "filename": "f8eb3646b949a4f8663aeaa3a2445326ba528f6e7146639500c10bd8ed6523cb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (The cup contains two different layers of transparent liquid. At their interface, light refracts, causing a noticeable misalignment of the straw. However, the background color and lines between the yellow liquid layer and the transparent area below are continuous, yet the straw shows no visual shift due to refraction.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08562", "filename": "f8eb3646b949a4f8663aeaa3a2445326ba528f6e7146639500c10bd8ed6523cb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (There are two different transparent liquids inside the cup. At their interface, light refracts, causing a noticeable misalignment of the straw. At 3.03-5s, the straw is inserted into the cup, but there is no visual shift caused by refraction.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08563", "filename": "f8eb3646b949a4f8663aeaa3a2445326ba528f6e7146639500c10bd8ed6523cb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (the \"stirring marks\" in the yellow liquid inside the glass are very stiff, unlike the natural vortexes created when liquid is stirred. Furthermore, the texture of the yellow liquid is completely unrealistic, lacking fluidity and transparency.) Physical Behavior (a real straw, when inserted at an angle into liquid, will appear to break at the surface due to light refraction. However, in the image, the straw passes through the yellow liquid without any refraction or misalignment.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08564", "filename": "f8eb3646b949a4f8663aeaa3a2445326ba528f6e7146639500c10bd8ed6523cb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is continuous (at 4.5s, during stirring, the yellow liquid suddenly decreases; at 5.8s, the stirred liquid suddenly stops rotating and returns to its original state).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08565", "filename": "f8fb4682ea7236568d58f82cc885658092314aab54a6f742845e2644cf236826_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (Throughout the video, the movement of the clouds in the sky is too smooth, more like the movement of liquid, lacking the feeling of real clouds drifting in the wind.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08566", "filename": "f8fb4682ea7236568d58f82cc885658092314aab54a6f742845e2644cf236826_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (Throughout the video, the movement of the clouds in the sky is too smooth, more like the movement of liquid, lacking the feeling of real clouds drifting in the wind.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08567", "filename": "f8fb4682ea7236568d58f82cc885658092314aab54a6f742845e2644cf236826_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08568", "filename": "f9eeeb0f7c828e1919fc4cd4a443b15be34a852102154522b4390abfb415b027_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Continuous movement (Throughout the entire video, without camera movement or change in light source, the green light cluster to the right of the streetlight keeps swaying from side to side.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08569", "filename": "f9eeeb0f7c828e1919fc4cd4a443b15be34a852102154522b4390abfb415b027_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (In the entire video, the snowflakes falling under the lights appear too regular and smooth, unlike realistic footage. Real snowflakes under streetlights have a blurred halo and a dynamic falling effect.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08570", "filename": "f9eeeb0f7c828e1919fc4cd4a443b15be34a852102154522b4390abfb415b027_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (In the entire video, the snowflakes falling under the lights appear too regular and smooth, unlike realistic footage. Real snowflakes under streetlights have a blurred halo and a dynamic falling effect.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08571", "filename": "f9eeeb0f7c828e1919fc4cd4a443b15be34a852102154522b4390abfb415b027_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08572", "filename": "f9f060837fc40a535a6f72d8e7fb98dab725b9f54237ac1281c07b8e8d3dc546_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (Throughout the video, the movement of the clouds in the sky is too smooth, more like the movement of liquid, lacking the feeling of real clouds drifting in the wind.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08573", "filename": "f9f060837fc40a535a6f72d8e7fb98dab725b9f54237ac1281c07b8e8d3dc546_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (Real crepuscular rays are formed by sunlight passing through gaps in the clouds, and the starting point of the light should correspond perfectly to the position of the cloud gap. However, the blue light in the image radiates evenly from the top of the image, completely disconnected from the position of the cloud cluster illuminated by sunlight in the center.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08574", "filename": "f9f060837fc40a535a6f72d8e7fb98dab725b9f54237ac1281c07b8e8d3dc546_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (in the entire video, the colors of the clouds in the middle are too uniform, lacking the rich shadows and transparency of realistic clouds. The outlines of houses on the ground are blurry and distorted, with edges lacking the clear lines of real buildings).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08575", "filename": "f00010aa6c7cb943d0ad2b5ba80a52fc2f6a82a50933b96df7afa1e65d32ade9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Two thin metal rulers are suspended in mid-air without any supporting structure, yet they are suspending heavy weights. In reality, such a cantilever structure would immediately bend downwards or even break due to the weight of the weights, and it would be impossible for it to remain horizontal.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08576", "filename": "f00010aa6c7cb943d0ad2b5ba80a52fc2f6a82a50933b96df7afa1e65d32ade9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Two thin metal rulers are suspended in mid-air without any supporting structure, yet they are suspending heavy weights. In reality, such a cantilever structure would immediately bend downwards or even break due to the weight of the weights, and it would be impossible for it to remain horizontal.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08577", "filename": "f00010aa6c7cb943d0ad2b5ba80a52fc2f6a82a50933b96df7afa1e65d32ade9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the two metal rulers are very loosely fixed, lacking sufficient support and stress points. Even if someone holds the weights by hand, this structure cannot stably bear the weight in reality.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08578", "filename": "f21c1f9c9aa024e2984e0397d6e50f2e68348fd6e4efebad3596149c5c08bd18_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08579", "filename": "f21c1f9c9aa024e2984e0397d6e50f2e68348fd6e4efebad3596149c5c08bd18_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is unusual: the timing is continuous (the clouds in the sky are moving and there are ripples on the water, indicating wind, but the leaves on the trees next to the lake do not show any obvious signs of shaking).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08580", "filename": "f21c1f9c9aa024e2984e0397d6e50f2e68348fd6e4efebad3596149c5c08bd18_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (In a real scene, the reflection of objects on the water's surface would be perfectly symmetrical to those on the shore, but the reflection of the trees on the left side of the image is severely misaligned with their actual shape, angle, and outline. The reflection of the clouds in the sky is also out of place compared to the real scene.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08585", "filename": "f32dfa0862e2fbe8e09f00028de3bf6e9a6c2feab79b1796944ef397f3de2292_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is unusual because the flames are continuous (the entire video shows flames burning inside a wooden crate filled with hay, but there is no sign of the fire spreading).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08586", "filename": "f32dfa0862e2fbe8e09f00028de3bf6e9a6c2feab79b1796944ef397f3de2292_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The time sequence is continuous (at 2.3s, the flames suddenly shrink without any interference; from 2.3s to 5.9s, the burning marks on the cardboard box stop spreading).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08587", "filename": "f32dfa0862e2fbe8e09f00028de3bf6e9a6c2feab79b1796944ef397f3de2292_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is unusual because the flames are continuous (the entire video shows flames burning inside a wooden crate filled with hay, but there is no sign of the fire spreading).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08588", "filename": "f32dfa0862e2fbe8e09f00028de3bf6e9a6c2feab79b1796944ef397f3de2292_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The sequence of events is continuous (the entire video shows flames burning inside a wooden crate filled with hay, but there is no sign of the fire spreading. At 5 seconds, the video suddenly changes and shakes.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08589", "filename": "f43d995fb1a82a9f9da5dd2f39d9c0c72eca5d3aadde6b3d2888315110400199_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the white granular texture at the top of the image is too uniform, lacking the natural, random texture of real underwater scenes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08590", "filename": "f43d995fb1a82a9f9da5dd2f39d9c0c72eca5d3aadde6b3d2888315110400199_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual effect is off. The white reflective dots in the image are too uniform, lacking the random variations of realistic water ripples. The white foam texture in the upper right corner is also very even, lacking the natural layers and dynamism of real waves.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08591", "filename": "ba21d82546c53a1357c1fd0bea02c775e4ab1297d7d8039b1caf7545396bde98_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (Objects within the blast radius should be blown away during the explosion, but in the video, the trees behind the car disappear instantly at 1.2 seconds.) Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (An explosion occurs on a flat dirt road, and at 3.2 seconds, a large number of boulders appear out of thin air.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08592", "filename": "bb4db348c25de1db9a421e93d5862d2e0b62862076640692d203dc5f969ff851_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (Under normal circumstances, the size of each raindrop is measured in millimeters, but in the video at 4 seconds, a raindrop can be seen falling to a size almost the size of a basketball.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08593", "filename": "bbeff6b7ffba4806ad956ad01e60b35c6e7bf8cb64cd45061a2149a5402362e8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Physical Behavior (The transition between water flow and flames in the video lacks the effect of water vapor evaporation, and details such as sparks flying and smoke changes that should occur during fire extinguishing are also missing. The overall effect is rather flat, lacking a realistic sense of dynamism and impact.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08594", "filename": "bc5e28af193ade75826ef6a06620849ab02d9b8a872be05ca74b7b198358b5a2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (water vapor is a gas that is in a flowing state in the air, but the dynamic details in the video are insufficient. The water vapor above the hot spring lacks natural flow and change effects, and the overall picture appears relatively static, failing to reflect the dynamic atmosphere that a hot spring should have.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08595", "filename": "bc1067fa266551361c33027f91fead77d011466e91375f965125a2694d17201c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (At 2.9s in the video, the light and shadow of the ring as it rotates do not change with the angle; the luster remains concentrated in the same area, making it look like a texture is moving rather than real metal rotating.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08596", "filename": "bc1427b57572aab021ace65642410db64a0853125cf70772b26a852eb93a2c08_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is inconsistent (at 5.2 seconds in the video, the action of wiping the glass and the disappearance of the glass stains are not synchronized; the stains are gone before the cloth even touches the glass, and the changes in the reflection on the glass after wiping are unnatural, lacking the masking and scratching effects that should occur when the cloth moves).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08597", "filename": "bc9399ef8f143259c2344bfdc9e4ccf7e6483f98e2ccd88dc842c7f308c0c749_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 1.9 seconds into the video, when the syrup is first poured, it doesn't have a natural fluid form; it appears to be directly applied to the surface of the green grapes without any flow, coating, or dripping, making the process seem very abrupt.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08598", "filename": "bd0bada94d636ad0cdc6ebfd5cac59696450ecdbdddd8893732e855ff00fd4b8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 0.9 seconds to the end, the ice cube in the water hardly showed any dynamic change in melting; there was no shrinkage in volume or the generation of bubbles. Moreover, the texture of the ice cube and water blended very stiffly, lacking realistic light refraction and a sense of flow.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08599", "filename": "bd0bada94d636ad0cdc6ebfd5cac59696450ecdbdddd8893732e855ff00fd4b8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08600", "filename": "bd0bada94d636ad0cdc6ebfd5cac59696450ecdbdddd8893732e855ff00fd4b8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (several translucent ice cubes can be seen sinking to the bottom of the bowl 3.9 seconds ago, but these ice cubes disappear abruptly without any transition. There is no shrinking of volume, blurring of edges, or small bubbles that would occur when ice melts, and the water surface does not ripple at all as the ice melts).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08601", "filename": "bd4e2f00ea410d960064ec7d56da945a9c5622a049090e95f46516d44849f9d6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the cloud movement in the video is illogical; thick dark clouds and smaller clouds below are moving rapidly in different directions, and the thickness and outline of the clouds do not change naturally during movement, making it look like two unrelated dynamic materials simply superimposed together.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08602", "filename": "bd8b3ecab5942c69a9c0485ea2b4c80437b72348a981f423a83019ac040acd28_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 3s in the video, the movement of the green sphere completely defies the laws of physics; it suddenly jumps without any external force and shows no realistic interaction or force feedback with the surrounding liquid, making the overall movement appear stiff and artificial.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08603", "filename": "bd29e02133e09a20b9b5f3d0792958cfb45cbf1d8e085694768b41523f3cff46_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (At 3.2 seconds, there was no steam in the cup, but at 3.2 seconds, steam suddenly appeared without warning and remained in a fixed shape, not dissipating at all, which does not conform to the physical laws of steam generation and diffusion.) Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (At 1 seconds in the video, the content on the computer screen showed illogical flickering without any operation or transition, which disrupted the continuity and realism of the video content.)", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08604", "filename": "bd109f3279e11edd3e699845dbf53a4eb335f30c4be8d18159575958fc0f7df2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to the following physical behavior: (When real water boils, the surface constantly rolls and the bubbles continuously change, but in the video, the water surface and bubble shapes remain completely consistent from 0 seconds to 5 seconds, as if a static texture is being played in a loop.)", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08605", "filename": "bd109f3279e11edd3e699845dbf53a4eb335f30c4be8d18159575958fc0f7df2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08606", "filename": "bd657e8aedcf269ad6a383bb3871ce74ce20b468d51a99aaab597bdf6f84c31a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08607", "filename": "bdad394ebf52ef78fb8697d4c9862b7a58d0aed37c8068c0df430fc47ed3ed13_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (At the beginning of the video, only a clump of fur pointing upwards can be seen; at 0.3 seconds, this clump of fur suddenly transforms into a raccoon.) Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (Starting at 1.2 seconds, the raccoon's reflection and its movements are completely out of sync; the ripples on the water surface do not change with the raccoon's movement.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08608", "filename": "bddf321be0843c4ee7fc76c672b4423ea07db7e91b43101d6f9431979273d079_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08609", "filename": "bded6d1c50d39a87da6c73628c4f52308793c36ed68b7aa54b577f22dadc7ddd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08610", "filename": "be064c98135b3d4c428b88843197fdea783c05ad89760b987168185a86a7116c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (from 0.5 seconds to the last second, a dark cloud suddenly appears in the sky and rapidly expands.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08611", "filename": "00c8db34810bc6e2276bb10cdc90bede1935d1695d09b8c6f3c4d645d1af5591_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (from 0s to 1.1s, the water droplets in the pot gradually become smaller. If the pot is not heated at high temperature, the water in the pot will not shrink in such a short time. The pot does not turn red obviously in the video, so the pot is not being heated; after 1.1s, the water droplets do not change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08612", "filename": "00c8db34810bc6e2276bb10cdc90bede1935d1695d09b8c6f3c4d645d1af5591_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: continuous time (a large amount of liquid suddenly appears in the pot throughout the video; the red light reflected from the pot gradually intensifies).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08613", "filename": "00c8db34810bc6e2276bb10cdc90bede1935d1695d09b8c6f3c4d645d1af5591_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08614", "filename": "0a89e9659744927ec20a96cfdc893db14dfec74485333c96094b651a8f2a2eb6_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: A red object resembling a fire hydrant suddenly appears next to a white vehicle in the left lane of the video (4.9s-5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08615", "filename": "0a89e9659744927ec20a96cfdc893db14dfec74485333c96094b651a8f2a2eb6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08616", "filename": "0a89e9659744927ec20a96cfdc893db14dfec74485333c96094b651a8f2a2eb6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.7s, the person in the blue pants in the lower right corner should have stepped with their left foot, but after the left foot blurred and disappeared, the right foot stepped out instead, and then the disappeared left foot reappeared).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08617", "filename": "0aa667cde1f24ebd0a46a4325b4aeb88127b107a0c46026b56f7cfbe59380405_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08618", "filename": "0aa667cde1f24ebd0a46a4325b4aeb88127b107a0c46026b56f7cfbe59380405_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (0s-0.1s: the flame color suddenly becomes bright and vivid; 0.7s-5.8s: fine hairs grow on the outer flame).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08619", "filename": "0aa667cde1f24ebd0a46a4325b4aeb88127b107a0c46026b56f7cfbe59380405_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08620", "filename": "0aa667cde1f24ebd0a46a4325b4aeb88127b107a0c46026b56f7cfbe59380405_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08624", "filename": "0abbd056b2b5b680e88f3cc59b24e0f71058885f222db47eacd764209b66e94c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08625", "filename": "0abbd056b2b5b680e88f3cc59b24e0f71058885f222db47eacd764209b66e94c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (1.2s, the flour that fell off the first knuckle of the left middle finger suddenly disappears; 1.3s, the flour suddenly appears on the first knuckle of the left middle finger and then suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08626", "filename": "0abbd056b2b5b680e88f3cc59b24e0f71058885f222db47eacd764209b66e94c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (2.1s-5s, the clump of flour disperses into flour, and the wet dough does not disperse into dry flour during the short time it falls when it is gently dropped from the hand).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08627", "filename": "0abbd056b2b5b680e88f3cc59b24e0f71058885f222db47eacd764209b66e94c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Continuous timing (1.6s-2.3s the flour in the hand suddenly increases before the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08628", "filename": "0b0f7cc733b5f6400e1e2ad29c24570f757fa9dec42909554c7a222e30037045_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the water on the beach is as smooth and reflective as a mirror, lacking the grainy texture that a beach should have, and doesn't look like a realistic scene).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08629", "filename": "0b0f7cc733b5f6400e1e2ad29c24570f757fa9dec42909554c7a222e30037045_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall visual impression is off (the water on the beach is as smooth and reflective as a mirror, and the beach after the tide recedes is flat, lacking the grainy texture that a beach should have, which doesn't look like a realistic scene).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08630", "filename": "0b0f7cc733b5f6400e1e2ad29c24570f757fa9dec42909554c7a222e30037045_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08631", "filename": "0b0f7cc733b5f6400e1e2ad29c24570f757fa9dec42909554c7a222e30037045_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08636", "filename": "0b4ea9d77c441e25d2b320ce00e40d1303143b5d8a31b66b7d9ded29104037d3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Temporal continuity (the localized heavy rain under the clouds did not move throughout the entire video, nor did it move forward with the clouds. Localized heavy rain usually moves with the movement of the clouds, because the formation and maintenance of heavy rain depends on sufficient moisture and updrafts in the clouds. The movement path of the clouds basically determines the coverage and direction of the rainfall.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08637", "filename": "0b4ea9d77c441e25d2b320ce00e40d1303143b5d8a31b66b7d9ded29104037d3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (4.8s-5.8s After the clouds disperse, the video feed emits an abnormal yellow light)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08638", "filename": "0b4ea9d77c441e25d2b320ce00e40d1303143b5d8a31b66b7d9ded29104037d3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (from 3.3s to 5s, all the clouds move to the left, and suddenly a cloud, resembling a mushroom after an explosion, rushes upwards).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08639", "filename": "0b4ea9d77c441e25d2b320ce00e40d1303143b5d8a31b66b7d9ded29104037d3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (2.1s-3.7s: two small clouds appear out of nowhere on the left side of the video; 5s-5.9s: the clouds around the light source disappear out of nowhere)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08640", "filename": "0b9f1c59dca3a073d3a0bca303cc173a89c7a13eee98061a9d11978594d389f7_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08641", "filename": "P25_107_176_8f1ced3b4176360a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is discontinuous (at 4.3s, the fork and plate on the plate turn into paper, and at 7.4s, the paper in the right hand suddenly disappears); the overall realism is abnormal (during the time from 5.7s to the end, a person uses a paper towel to flip the food in the pot).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08642", "filename": "P25_107_189_23cc153118e85013_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition is abnormal (during the period from 1.5 seconds to the end, a person uses paper to wipe the pot, but the water in the pot does not disappear and the paper is not wetted by the water in the pot. In reality, when you use a paper towel to wipe water in a pot, the original water will disappear and the paper towel will be wrinkled and somewhat damaged).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08643", "filename": "P25_107_265_4bf65d0a0757733b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 3s, the eggplant flipped over without being pierced by the fork or subjected to any external force. In reality, an eggplant needs to be subjected to a force to flip over.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08644", "filename": "P25_107_265_4bf65d0a0757733b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is continuous (the spoon in the right hand disappears instantly at 2.6s and then suddenly reappears at 2.9s, and the shape of the fork changes continuously between 3.1s and 4.8s); the overall realism is abnormal (at 3.2s, the shape of the fork does not match the shadow of the fork on the food; at this time, the fork has no gaps, but the shadow is that of a normal fork).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08645", "filename": "P25_107_265_4bf65d0a0757733b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 5.4s, the three slices of eggplant in the right pot merge into one, and at 7.1s, one slice of eggplant in the left pot splits into three); Physical behavior (at 7s, the eggplant in the left pot flips over before the fork touches it and without any force applied, which does not conform to the rules of force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08646", "filename": "P25_107_360_8ca2b90b23db7e8d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08647", "filename": "P25_107_360_8ca2b90b23db7e8d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.5 seconds, the eggplant slices in the left pot change from three to two); the overall realism is abnormal (when the fire is lit on the right, the fire on the left suddenly ignites without a lighter and the fire is always burning below the pot handle, and the person is holding the pot handle with their hand).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08648", "filename": "P25_107_367_a23cf541cb41672c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (at 3.6 seconds, as the person in the pot on the right removes a piece of eggplant from the pot, two more pieces of eggplant suddenly appear in the pot).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08649", "filename": "P25_107_367_a23cf541cb41672c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the pot on the left flickers from 3.7s to 3.9s, and the fork keeps deforming from the beginning until 1.6s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08650", "filename": "P25_107_367_a23cf541cb41672c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3s, the two slices of eggplant in the right pot merge into one, and at 7.8s, the eggplant flipped over in the left pot grows larger).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08651", "filename": "P25_107_373_c7e58caf0b7a9506_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (at 1.3s, the eggplant slices in the right-hand pan split in two); the overall realism is off (the right-hand pan initially had very little oil, but at 4.8s, the oil suddenly increases).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08652", "filename": "P25_107_373_c7e58caf0b7a9506_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to physical behavior (at 0.4s, the eggplant in the pot is not stuck by the fork and flips over on its own without any force, and at 5.6s, the pot on the left rotates to the right without any external force, which does not conform to the rules of force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08653", "filename": "P25_107_373_c7e58caf0b7a9506_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.2 seconds, flames suddenly ignite below the handle of the black pot); the overall realism is abnormal (only the right side of the pot handle is on fire, but there is also continuous frying in the left side of the pot, and the person in the video is using a towel to wrap the pot handle above the fire, but the towel is not ignited).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08654", "filename": "P25_107_445_3d6e5082eeab0922_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (the faucet is running continuously from 5.7 seconds to the end, but the water in the pot does not increase).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08655", "filename": "P25_107_445_3d6e5082eeab0922_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: causal relationship (the faucet turned on automatically even though the hand didn't touch it at 1.8s); time continuity (the hand clipped through the handle on the cabinet door at 2.3s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08656", "filename": "P25_107_509_bff83b3812cbd19e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08657", "filename": "P25_107_509_bff83b3812cbd19e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (water can be seen flowing from the faucet in the sink at 1.7s, but the water stream disappears at 2.1s; the metal block on the left side of the sink disappears at 2.3s; the fork in the plate disappears at 3.2s); Physical behavior (the faucet is pressed down and deformed when used in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08658", "filename": "P26_103_23_c3e7e067d3798760_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.1s, the transparent plastic fork in the sink disappears; at 1.4s, the water in the sink suddenly increases and turns yellow; at 4.2s, the transparent bowl in the hand suddenly turns into a yellow glass; at 4.7s, the fork in the sink disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08659", "filename": "P26_103_23_c3e7e067d3798760_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 4.4s, the yellow plate floats when it falls onto the edge of the sink, indicating an abnormality in gravity); Overall realism is abnormal (the faucet is on throughout the entire sequence, but no water appears in the sink); Time continuity (at 0.2s, the thick lid in the person's hand changes into a thin plate).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08660", "filename": "P26_103_23_c3e7e067d3798760_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.2s, the plate in the hand turns into a bottle; at 1.9s, the spoon in the lower left corner of the sink disappears; at 2.4s, a fork suddenly appears in the left hand; at 3.9s, the left hand places the fork next to the faucet, and the faucet turns into a black object while the fork disappears; at 7.5s, the black object is placed into the sink, and two spoons appear in the sink).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08661", "filename": "P26_103_33_dc2f5d4393ba16a2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (before 3.5 seconds, all the water produced during the dishwashing was clear, but afterwards, without any detergent or other foam-producing substances being applied, a lot of foam appeared in the water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08662", "filename": "P26_103_33_dc2f5d4393ba16a2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08663", "filename": "P26_103_37_02add290b4e82e2b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (sponges suddenly appear in the right and left hands at 0.3s and 1.1s, the black object that was originally in the water tank disappears at 0.4s, and the sponge in the right hand disappears at 5.2s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08664", "filename": "P26_103_109_c7572f6508668a0a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.3s, the folds of the towel disappear and merge).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08665", "filename": "P26_103_109_c7572f6508668a0a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (at 6.2 seconds, the towel suddenly becomes two and then one again); the overall realism is abnormal (the person wiping their hands in the video appears unnatural, with the left hand always clenched into a fist).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08666", "filename": "P26_104_18_b6800c2d4f1109fb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08667", "filename": "P26_104_18_b6800c2d4f1109fb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08668", "filename": "P26_104_61_dc344a6fdc53c62e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (at 0.3s, a knife suddenly appears in the right hand; at 1s, the fruit knife on the plate disappears and a large number of sliced sausages appear).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08669", "filename": "P26_104_101_4d6d3775a49ac84d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (at 2.7s, the number of black plates increases to three; at 3.5s, the three pizzas increase to four, and only one black plate remains on the ground); Physical behavior is inconsistent (during the period from 3.6s to the end, the oven closes its door on its own without any external force); Overall realism is inconsistent (the pizzas appear to float during their fall, lacking the weight and solidity expected when falling in real life).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08670", "filename": "P26_104_104_7c9dd17c6b2b645e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (there is an extra metal rack in the oven at 3.7s); the overall realism is abnormal (the video shows a clean towel being used to wipe a dirty metal rack, but there are no stains on the towel, and a hand is shown wiping the rack in a stiff, unnatural and unreasonable manner).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08671", "filename": "P06_107_29_ca8b1207dec45171_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (the table in the image is flickering) Causality (at 2.4s in the image, without the left hand touching the plastic bag, the plastic bag in the right hand automatically retracts and adheres to the hand without any external interference)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08672", "filename": "P06_108_5_161ff4ec96c0d9f0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08673", "filename": "P06_108_69_9aea7b74224b9dff_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the cause and effect are illogical (at 6.2s, the drawer moves on its own without any external force, even though the hand is not touching it; at 5.8s, the knife in the hand is rotated and put down, and the blade suddenly splits into two pieces).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08674", "filename": "P06_108_113_3b78e10b9b10525b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity is abnormal (the video flickers throughout; between 2.2s and 4.1s, after the switch button is lifted, the switch base gradually transforms into a circular hole without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08675", "filename": "P07_101_3_b707221c6fd817b4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Continuous timing (a lighter suddenly appears in the right hand at 0.5s in the video) and physical behavior (the cabinet opens automatically without any external interference before the hand touches it at the end of 7.6s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08676", "filename": "P07_101_65_f4d671a4c7536f0a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Unreasonable causal relationship (the refrigerator door automatically closes at 2.8s without any external interference). Physical behavior (from 7.4s to the end, the bread is suspended in the air and motionless without any support).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08677", "filename": "P07_107_57_61112229c2201302_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 5.8s in the video, the bottle opener suddenly opens and bounces away without being placed on the bottle cap or subjected to any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08678", "filename": "P07_110_29_8c99a271f9d4cd2e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (in the video, from 4.4s onwards, the oats, which were originally tilted to the other side, did not fall to the bottom of the bag due to gravity after the bag was turned upright). Temporal continuity anomalies (in the video, at 0s, the oats were poured into the cup, and a white object suddenly appeared on the left side of the cup without falling out).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08679", "filename": "P07_110_39_00b9f80d347cca55_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Temporal continuity anomalies (the cup, towel, and fruit on the table in the video are all flashing). Physical anomalies: Clipping issues (at 7 seconds in the video, the blue towel under the hand clips through the point of contact with the hand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08680", "filename": "P07_113_46_1a4e0a62d11a6cfd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (objects on the table and towels on the cabinet in the video are constantly flashing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08681", "filename": "P07_114_31_d87f3f495021ab1d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (in the footage, there are no vegetables at the bag opening, but at 3.2s and 7.3s, a hand can be taken out of the bag opening without reaching inside).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08682", "filename": "P09_103_11_3d5dcf160404add7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (the scene suddenly switches at 0.9s in the video; between 1.08 and 1.7s, when the character turns around, the cleaver on the silver plate suddenly tilts upwards without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08683", "filename": "P09_103_13_e07523368c51b6a5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: continuous timing (at the beginning of the video - 3.1 seconds, when the seasoning was being added, seasoning powder kept falling into the pot even though the bottle was not directly above it).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08684", "filename": "P09_103_20_21083d8008a843ca_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08685", "filename": "P09_103_23_e81a3c04e70e0086_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08686", "filename": "P09_104_75_a8ddbf4007c029a8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (at 4.2s in the video, the towel in the hand suddenly transforms into underwear after spinning once).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08687", "filename": "P11_103_17_ac7324a695c491c3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08688", "filename": "P11_104_174_f9278dd3e303cd24_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (the ground, food in the bowl, and towel shown in the video are constantly flashing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08689", "filename": "P11_105_18_0731d5dc6fd25fc6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (the food and table in the video are constantly flickering; at 2.01, the pizza shown inside after removing the top film is not the same as the pizza originally under the film).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08690", "filename": "P11_105_19_35d387f0e4c76b3f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: continuous time (after the film was peeled off at 1.3s in the video, another film appeared on the pizza without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08691", "filename": "P12_101_193_0fb23ec624314c8b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Temporal continuity is abnormal (the food in the hand, the food in the pot, and the cutting board next to it are constantly moving in the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08692", "filename": "P12_101_251_1aaaade933c2d90a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08693", "filename": "P12_101_310_b863a6b478524d26_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the cause and effect are unreasonable (when the packaging is being torn open in the footage, it is being torn from the bottom, but when the packaging is opened at 1.6s, it is being torn from the top). The timing is continuous (the hand sprinkling the seasoning is misaligned with the pot from 5.6s to the end).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08694", "filename": "P12_101_353_874e3e6960c41f8b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (at 2.5s in the video, the cabinet door under the countertop opened by itself without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08695", "filename": "P12_101_484_e1fdafaa37eedcaa_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (objects on the table, floor, and clothing of people in the scene are constantly flickering).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08696", "filename": "P12_101_487_9b91496e4b9fdfed_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous timing (5.6s - end; the right edge of the pot deforms without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08697", "filename": "P12_103_49_ff8d8f7695fcb82f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: continuous time (at 4.9 seconds in the video, without any external interference, the amount of food in the plate suddenly increased).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08698", "filename": "P12_103_102_af48d5c95db28c1d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08699", "filename": "P12_103_136_d14a36c51954b17c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (objects on the left side of the table, food in the pot, and the floor in the image are all flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08700", "filename": "P12_104_60_a237e756c03f1dca_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08701", "filename": "2e7424f4ce162d9d33ba3bc4666d6dd0a8d2505b12be1591291fddbbc6a4c790_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (flames suddenly appear and burn half of the sphere at 5.8s, and the previously burned shell of the sphere suddenly recovers at 8s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08702", "filename": "2eac771d6adffa71fd95bf0882324283643136dc459c3cefcb9ae294a24cb528_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08703", "filename": "2eeae6d1d5dad217beb9f9b2a9b78bed432ae1a6611aaa3c39380c0439a157f6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08704", "filename": "2f41ef673676b1196c893f5a87d0ed0b426e295bad5afc926ff7475aa6235acd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (it is raining throughout the entire video, but the leaves on both sides of the tree are not moving, and the kinetic energy disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08706", "filename": "03acbc583c88d2505b6f2f5f29f16064136b6847a894d49d313cbe6476ee5879_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the floor in the video is distorted and shaken).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08707", "filename": "3a9c3ec44131a3d6fe6f7f97c8030a83001052d80fc7f5dcfb990a143b2eb71b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the flames burn too uniformly, unlike real flames, lacking random movement and natural branching).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08708", "filename": "3a89b6071ef1298afaf312aceac56c09839f3d784ccfa33c7e49f8f31db966b0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (bubbles suddenly appear above the object on the right side without any external force at 5.1s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08709", "filename": "3a8470e840d7f19b097cfe536ebdbdc7442a393cdf91931aa3f1601151dba142_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08710", "filename": "3a686187291ccced7a895db9fdff42b4d6028658efee9ddc725b1e926fa4bb1f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (3.3s-4.8s) The blue strip-shaped object exhibits abnormal motion blur, which does not conform to normal physical motion patterns. Real objects do not produce this regular ripple-like motion blur effect.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08711", "filename": "3aeeab03424a6aad7ecd30371337463441a6cb7c414613291896631b5b5833ba_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08712", "filename": "3af2dcb09a625df6f7c3e8cc2c847817f2f68b52112c08ff5060d0e211c002bd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08713", "filename": "3be7c792ed7354a72a3f6fd38650c7237214f96699781d982e58c31f8ef369ec_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08715", "filename": "3c01b3531330e3fb6f90e27fbc540816a84552dce63e1a121765d558595fbef3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the number 0 suddenly turns black at 0s, the pen stroke does not match the written character at 1.2s, and the written letter becomes deformed after 4.8s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08716", "filename": "3c1d33cfe288740b5a3bc74bb5e19b057d291df7f8ba238dbd84fa7f4f88a1db_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (0s-3.3s: the car moves to the left without any external force; 6.6s-7.9s: the right car moves to the left without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08718", "filename": "3c982f0d5e9c5d5e99c7e8d51c701e246d421f15c1cb82b7e15d038591787c71_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the road surface pattern in the video flickers and distorts after the tire runs over it).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08719", "filename": "3c23844cdec2426aa3933ba101c6aadd3ec8e93ddc5a61860b800f8c66b68e92_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08720", "filename": "3c38429672c1aedfbe131b66cdac2eceaf8076cb98be5e69a4e37b1e4cecd5fc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is distorted and flickering, indicating a continuity of time. (The trees by the lake in the video appear to be twisting and flashing.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08721", "filename": "3c1256832944090b81d1f767d97362028720853b5fd362814013c126219a5593_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08722", "filename": "3ca0a3eec4a99f929af839f4fa8d6190d4c767a62aa97295446141e7c0807e5a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (a flame burns over a candle, but the red candle does not change; the crayon melts when the flame burns).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08723", "filename": "3cf83c31b941251fd64495f0b272832bbf61ec33f54d4ff866c5294c1aaf94c3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Physical behavior (3.7s the wooden board suddenly breaks into two pieces without any external force)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08724", "filename": "3cfa49a5e1302a46771909479b3e21def43152d0708423444f00b11422f301b4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (after the road roller passes over the pot in 2.9 seconds, the handle suddenly changes from right to left, and the pot's color changes from black to silver and looks brand new).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08725", "filename": "3d4cc28c5ff9eb03170752f1c042933b4ba1cd23280543dfe5e78d336223cd5a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the white cube suddenly falls over without any force at 0.1s, and the block suddenly moves to the right without any external force at 3.5s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08726", "filename": "3d28eb5307024a83a032cf3431176fca36ea92ef8979b59544bbd66adc9aa25e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the surface of the water on the right side of the video is blurry).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08727", "filename": "3d55f9fc94d3cb459ec7a5ebb10b7d4978d197a8836fff9c1e59991f95911c99_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08728", "filename": "3d835553966d97c40b19ff502100a1008caddb936237917c560034493c005762_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the diamond moves even though the finger is not in contact with it between 0s and 5s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08729", "filename": "3debc85f5347d18f2ce6d056c51ccfcf2cd42302ea145733efb96af692222dd9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the entire frame of the video is wavy and twisting).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08730", "filename": "3e09cffabeadda5eb0e27db36eae7ef69bb27b2e7b2c8ed55932f3c49b954a9a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is as follows: The timing is inconsistent. (At 2.7 seconds, the red liquid moves on its own without external force. The energy transferred to the liquid would cause fine ripples, splashes, or overall undulations on its surface. However, the liquid in the video appears to be continuously spraying upwards, forming a column, or even splitting into multiple streams. This is more like the liquid being ejected upwards under high pressure, rather than being pushed up by the high-frequency vibration of the diaphragm. The vibrational energy of a speaker diaphragm is planar, uniform, and rapidly alternating, making it impossible to continuously accumulate energy at one point, allowing the liquid to overcome gravity and form a stable upward column. After 6.8 seconds, the red liquid falls without splashing but forms a hole. In reality, under the influence of inertia and gravity, the liquid would splash after falling.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08731", "filename": "8b7c0d0170da9bb8f5ddc4464f2324b1f9527db8ca1e96af0f1a22ae63c923a9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (2.2s-8s) The clouds moved uniformly to the left without dissipating at all, like a piece of cloth being pulled back, which does not conform to the characteristic that clouds will constantly change and dissipate during their movement.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08732", "filename": "8ba0646589c05750bff5dfb7e34b4fc65d75367563dfce96e2a4e6dcbc40ca05_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08733", "filename": "8baac48847caa2f215fecfc9f0d4183f01c26d79c1149308c62cf880fc7d97ba_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the visuals: Time continuity (the ball suddenly disappears at 0.5s, many balls suddenly appear between 0.6s and 2.5s, and the balls disappear continuously between 3.8s and 5s). Causality (from 0.6s to 3.7s, many balls inexplicably appear at the hole without any prior cause or effect).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08734", "filename": "8baac48847caa2f215fecfc9f0d4183f01c26d79c1149308c62cf880fc7d97ba_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (from 2.7s to 8s, the rolling ball continuously deforms and clips through the red object); Causal relationship (from 0.5s to 8s, several balls inexplicably roll out of the track when only one ball is in the hole, without any cause or effect); Temporal continuity (at 0.1s and 1.7s, the blue ball suddenly disappears, and from 6.6s to 7s, two balls suddenly appear on the track).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08735", "filename": "8badfcff0153aec6a8aa0f84092194456783860b6e7b4faf2e129ed9d6781202_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08736", "filename": "8c671d87fcb236166daaba0f4aac695e86b1f86ec5459f6e0576606b9effefde_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the wave lines from 2.4s to 7.4s are too flat and neat, lacking the irregularity of real ocean waves).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08737", "filename": "8c8622dc4198717ea188a0be1d87d472a51b98b9a9fcdaf06e7c8588f0d4222f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (0s-2s: the light starts turning on before the switch is pressed, without any prior cause and effect).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08740", "filename": "8ce7f0248f48a3ab61f46ce49e61f05a047d098761f728603e9a90e37f0d07b9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (0.9s-5s: after the bubble lands, it doesn't burst but spills like water, which doesn't conform to the characteristic that bubbles burst instantly upon hitting the ground).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08742", "filename": "8daa6f222e0af0e5528596833d4b2581ecd112607942bd4b2f2025e55cb92748_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the clouds in the sky remain unchanged throughout the entire video, which is inconsistent with the characteristic that clouds are constantly moving and dissipating).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08743", "filename": "8daa6f222e0af0e5528596833d4b2581ecd112607942bd4b2f2025e55cb92748_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (The clouds in the sky remain completely unchanged throughout the entire video, which is inconsistent with the characteristic that clouds are constantly moving and dissipating. The water surface is smooth like a plastic film without any ripples, which is inconsistent with the state of a lake surface. In addition, the rocky beach on the left and the trees in the background appear to flicker.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08744", "filename": "8e2d766544f173c699787d1877881e5bd5115deed2ac49f8433b047877a6d1e2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Cause and effect (the basketball bounces and goes into the basket without any external force hitting it, without any prior cause and effect)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08747", "filename": "8e0148fa1af00416eb6abda085d8c08f98cffede9ba2d18eb60942fa401b65b9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (3.3s-5.3s: the iron alarm clock suddenly breaks into a large number of ceramic fragments after being crushed).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08748", "filename": "8efb541a71ca71433e9a091b49afa7d1e2683bc73f455b2c3b0aa29a46475b7e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall intuition (the bubbles in the water rise too regularly and uniformly, moving in a straight line without any sense of irregularity in their rise).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08749", "filename": "8efb541a71ca71433e9a091b49afa7d1e2683bc73f455b2c3b0aa29a46475b7e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (2.5s-8s, the rising speed of the bubbles in the water suddenly slows down, the entire bubble segment appears to be suspended in mid-air, and the speed before and after is inconsistent)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08750", "filename": "8eff513ec4abd60eb8ea2aaf825ff7366625c9ffa3e5df9217c116622fe1d053_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08752", "filename": "edfb4670ea15fd29c3867ecbb167d11ce6cc7df32acc3f20a1cd8c7aa1fa4c2c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 6.1s, the smoke behind the flames in the video suddenly stopped, and at 6.5s the smoke started to flow downwards. The fire was still burning and the density of the hot air had not decreased, so the smoke did not flow downwards).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08753", "filename": "ee0df3c166f925fc8ca1c1a955497bec4b34830f8d80bcb31723455ae2cc2bdb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0s, the facets of the three diamonds in the video merge together, and the reflections of the diamonds are flickering and unclear under the light; it is not until 3.7s that the facets of the diamonds can be clearly seen to be round brilliant cut).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08754", "filename": "ee7f04e7294c254b66ad29a072314288fc1f48b1be91b5ccc3f6c1636540097d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomalies in the video: Time continuity (at 0.7s, the clay clumps attached to the lower right of the square in the cup suddenly change shape, separate, and fall to the bottom of the cup, then suddenly disappear at 0.8s, and at 3.5s, the clay clumps that were crushed suddenly separate, creating a noticeable composite effect).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08755", "filename": "ee8f53e2ee712efe3e3e1648218b4aa2cde297227aa15028df701e1436e51ed1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: the overall impression is off (when the egg mixture is poured into the pan at the beginning of the video, there is no round omelet to hold the egg mixture in place, but the edges of the fried egg are too smooth and lack fluidity. Eggs contain moisture and air, which should expand and produce bubbles when heated, but the fried egg in the video is too perfect to look like a real fried egg).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08756", "filename": "ee862cd098bbb403f1a4946f2fa64196aa72020091cfb019200c59818088bb96_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (at 2.9s, the golf ball under the hydraulic press suddenly explodes into a reddish-brown oval object; at 3.9s, the oval object, which looks like plastic, explodes and then becomes like a piece of paper, lying flat on the hydraulic press with its edges suddenly deformed).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08757", "filename": "eed6dddaa1218ae4685e5f4c17fd1908c5f0fe2dd210d77e8628e1a0e6cd176c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (The smoke under the eaves in the upper right corner of the video remains stationary, neither spreading nor flowing despite no change in the surrounding air density. Similarly, the smoke on the right side of the video flows downwards despite no change in the surrounding air density, which does not conform to the principles of buoyancy and gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08758", "filename": "eed09ce1a06aec0001aeb70a5cc8c27c1e7ae00395a0828a8d9eb881dcb3cbce_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 6.2 seconds, the right end of the black chopstick suddenly extends while the entire black chopstick remains stationary, and the pink chopstick in the cup behind it twists).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08759", "filename": "eee332b9941dc524469ed8f0350820f996c3bc288c409c5270024fff4df092ff_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (at 3s, the hydraulic device had not yet touched the soccer ball in the video, but the soccer ball suddenly exploded, and the image of the soccer ball spread and dropped frames in the picture).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08760", "filename": "ef3d544f68bf150b648ba6575f0ad7e92671587a67a9c634c1f038e422d162fc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (2.6 seconds: the camera moves towards the object, but the object does not zoom in or become clearer; the image remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08761", "filename": "ef7490f1ef4c27869ed640f4600ab3ad0bcd8e219b533b6b615ba63c4454a46b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (The characters, ship, and buildings in the entire video are flickering, stuttering, and dropping frames, and the reflection of the blue crane on the ship is missing from the reflection on the sea surface). Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (There is no connection between the blue crane and the white rope below, but the white rope can float in mid-air, which does not conform to the principles of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08762", "filename": "f00b29a02120b1df16392e2da21064e84c0a8234ada9cff549051d161cc3e7ff_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the white plate in the entire video is higher on the left and lower on the right. Due to the influence of gravity, the water should flow to the right, but the water from the melting ice in the left side of the video clearly flows to the left, which does not conform to the principle of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08763", "filename": "f0d8714cf3fffd276e49439577e570e054940ee6c57c959d5c199310a2aec9d4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (Throughout the video, the stone bricks are continuously roasted by fire. Under high temperatures, the moisture in the stone bricks would evaporate rapidly, creating tiny water vapor pores, and the surface would appear powdery and loose. However, the stone bricks under intense fire show no change. Similarly, under high temperatures, an oxidation reaction would occur, and the color of the stone bricks would darken or become mottled. However, the color of the stone bricks in the entire video fluctuates between bright and dark, which is inconsistent with the above physical changes. Furthermore, the flames appear overly perfect and obviously composited.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08764", "filename": "f0f92e4f8200e6abc9f2d71d2d42e9ea8d2acd0a4dadc063fba8ea5880b2210a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (during the 2.6s-2.9s timeframe, the flames of the two candles in the middle of the video suddenly stop, without any slight movement. The footage of the two candles appears to be paused, but the other flames are still moving dramatically).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08765", "filename": "f1a705e41ef02233566600293f1b1df1ed03592a00b0a74dde9278e1d16a7783_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Continuous timing (between 0s and 0.2s, the mop leaves no steam marks on the wall; at 0.3s, steam marks suddenly appear on the wall). Video anomaly: Physical behavior (when the mop is pushed forward, the steam should disperse backward due to air resistance, but throughout the video, the steam is not affected by air resistance and continues to disperse forward each time the mop is pushed forward; the dispersion of the steam throughout the video is inconsistent with the speed of the mop's movement).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08766", "filename": "f1bc54cec06a77fc6ff3ab97b10da5dc38c582fcae6c3b30b5301a29b4b2ce1b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Physical behavior (at 0.2s, when the corn kernels on the right side of the screen popped, without any external force, they suddenly caused the surrounding popcorn to explode to the left in a large area. The corn kernels are small, and the air pressure when they exploded was about 13MPa, so the energy range was minimal, equivalent to the air pressure of a small air pump once, which was not enough to blow the surrounding corn kernels away).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08767", "filename": "f02fec8a907cde0d01f9b8caf319d1027d6562b2a85afae4a91e8ab65b1f32fd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Time Continuity (The sky color gradually darkens from beginning to end throughout the video, lacking consistency). Visual Anomalies: Overall Intuitive Anomalies (The overall transition of the clouds in the video is unclear, contradicting the natural fading of colors from fiery orange-red to gentle pink-orange at sunset, with high-altitude clouds briefly tinged with pale mauve and gray-blue. It also contradicts the effect of the morning sun leaping across the sky and igniting it into intense golden-red or bright orange light, where low-altitude clouds would be tinged with a translucent warm pink before gradually transitioning to clear sky blue; the composite effect is obvious).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08768", "filename": "f2bd8e3ae36c50cf397f9353f3c52fcda5b032efbe2a92f3a9888d4d9059447f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Cause and effect (oil itself has fluidity, which is determined by its liquid physical properties, but in the whole video, the oil in the pan did not increase in flow when the butter melted. At high temperature, oil bubbles will increase, but at the same time, the butter melts faster. In the whole video, the butter melts slowly, but the oil produces a lot of dense foam as if it were being fried at high temperature.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08769", "filename": "f2fe61cc27b6b7ea8ff5d52bd7b83e30b58ffe312ec1ce06964dd8a9157846bb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.9s, after the blue object in the picture is squeezed and cracked, there is obvious stuttering and frame drops in the crack of the object, and the picture looks unrealistic and has a strong sense of composite).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08770", "filename": "f3cf65998aa40c69baae16448bbf16d755fcf9a5248c578dc29683052e7078dd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (in the video footage between 2.4s and 3.4s, when the bubble is hit by a strong gas spray, it should burst instead of growing larger, because the bubble wall is an extremely thin structure composed of a water film and surfactants. The impact of the spray droplets on the bubble wall will directly break the tension balance of the water film, causing the water film to break instead of growing larger).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08771", "filename": "f4aaf500b8fbef8d951269fb3cb4c97c421074e5fd367efba562cce33b9510ed_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.4s, a piece of firewood in the scene suddenly turns into two burning pieces of firewood while flipping, and at 5.1s, the stick in the character's hand suddenly merges with the burning stick when poking it, causing the overall screen to flicker and stutter).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08772", "filename": "f05d47ab3f4d96eafe3e5c7788a02bd1a143c3247d61ee74324d98180c23a0bb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (the indoor lighting does not change significantly throughout the video, but the reflected shadow on the right side of the ice cube changes significantly, and the shadow on the upper left edge of the ice cube gradually appears and becomes complete throughout the video, without any consistency).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08773", "filename": "f05e71366726cb967b6f96cbd834fb36e4d4929db31d6095cbddf85e4226bfd6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the hydraulic press applies enormous pressure to the sphere through a pressure plate. When the sphere is compressed, the internal space shrinks, and the air or liquid inside the sphere is rapidly compressed, causing the pressure to rise sharply. When the internal pressure exceeds the material strength limit of the sphere's outer shell, it will break through the shell, releasing energy instantly and causing rupture. However, in the entire video, the inflatable plastic ball is smoothly flattened when squeezed by the hydraulic press, which violates Pascal's Law).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08774", "filename": "f5b4799213511dbf80faed6e87045fa4468c9170904dbd1aa8421d039effbb11_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (The lake water in the entire video is too calm without any ripples or water patterns, too smooth as if it is still, and the building in the center opposite is twisting, flickering and distorted)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08775", "filename": "f5d35538ae4d5794d88e2b430c7af48fe819437f4df05939da7137f60d15a03e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 7.4s, the person in the video releases the rubber band, and when the rubber band hangs on the hand, the color suddenly darkens and the material becomes clay-like. Even after it rebounds and shrinks, the texture does not suddenly become thick and soft like clay, and there is no consistency with the previous material).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08776", "filename": "f5e23eeb2e27b67b191abc53f82a93860df30485bbe1339bcef11484fdcc04c9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the visuals: The timing is inconsistent (at 5.02ss, a leaf at the bottom of the cup in the image suddenly separates out green substance and drifts to the right without any external influence; at 7.8s, the leaf on the right also suddenly starts separating out green substance, showing no consistency).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08777", "filename": "f6a80bb6e041202a84097d88372296e13ba911eeb3312f0bc7501b8dd1789a72_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is inconsistent (from 4.9s to 6.9s, the blue background in the video suddenly darkens without any obvious change in lighting; from 5.5s to 6.7s, the yellow object in the middle of the video suddenly changes from semi-transparent to solid yellow, and there is no consistency in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08778", "filename": "f7e8a50af139df04beb51b1a55b167664607a83cacd5b1a6ef203087f38f2234_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video is not continuous (at 7.1 seconds, the smoke in the video suddenly stops rising and drifting, and the video appears to be paused with delays and stutters).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08779", "filename": "f8cdee4e4274e1dcc570aa0d752fe9fb5bf190da5d392ac82823a3403009f596_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Physical Behavior (At 3.5s, the fire stick in the video leaves the person's hand, continues to rotate and gradually moves upward, which violates the law of gravity). Visual Anomalies: Overall Intuitive Anomalies (At 1.4s, the view of the person's face turning to the right suggests a back view, but at 5.4s, when the person's right hand swings to the left and the body rotates, the person appears to be facing forward again. The entire video shows a strange, uncoordinated, and obviously composited human figure).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08780", "filename": "f8df579ad7329b140f2ad3e4c9759d0523f53f29db00d3df55005c61df5f58a8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Cause and effect (oil itself has fluidity, which is determined by its liquid physical properties, but in the whole video, the oil in the pan does not flow when the butter melts, like a stop-motion animation. Only at high temperatures will oil bubbles increase, but at the same time the butter melts faster. However, in the whole video, the butter does not change, but the oil increases and even produces dense foam like that produced during high-temperature frying.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08781", "filename": "c9bc1436450d346852d07a5d96dedf4796a35550f306ecd3a76cafdea7b852c0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.8s, the crack on the right side of the glass in the video partially disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08782", "filename": "c9f06a6df48e32a66a06738cf73d19b9c50aebdfd589ea7c914b3d1064f8b02f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (at 0.8 seconds, the four small steel balls in the middle suddenly deform; at 2.1 seconds, there are more small steel balls after the one shown; at 2.8 seconds, the small steel ball disappears into thin air when the card is picked up).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08783", "filename": "c17d24a6124b5adb689d83e3dd2f7169fa5e07f0fc543111a2836b3cf41a47ec_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08784", "filename": "c18bd91ec8828e1440af527001d4327546ab3fa0c7924f8c7a96a0727c243fbf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Cause and effect (The injection of liquid column will produce a ring-shaped ripple on the liquid surface centered on the injection point, which will spread outward and decay over time. However, the ripples on the liquid surface in the video are irregular. There is neither a dynamic trend of spreading outward from the injection point nor superimposed disturbances caused by continuous injection. It is more like a static texture than a physical disturbance.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08785", "filename": "c18de7b629467cdc7707146cba99a651cba78d0f9a01165a5245af65e40f647d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (the sparkler in the video, which is always burning, does not burn downwards but remains burning in one position, which does not conform to the laws of combustion) Time continuity (at 1.7s, the flame of the burning sparkler suddenly increases, and at 5s, the video suddenly freezes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08786", "filename": "c23c305d3e758718ad1bf775636327f9fe3fe8ec39f8adf808b146bd37993b6e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (ripples on the lake surface should float on the lake and then settle, but the ripples on the lake surface appear stationary throughout the video, and the background image appears shaky).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08787", "filename": "c41b0f2331b5a3c2bf4c350fa83b2e686b221629468b89ca3d603cf47b2ccc6f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08788", "filename": "c56f98a70fa8f63d0a88548a5fe46b87399c996fef503a18ddc63d07046b0e8a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is due to the continuous time (the swirling smoke is usually caused by local air vortices, but this usually does not happen indoors without external forces, so the sudden change from irregularly rising smoke to vortexes between 2.7s and 8s looks unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08789", "filename": "c061adc2b8cb4b3ee341bf8fbaca305d3ff292ce9e7c83ab1c50f9a4c1078652_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08791", "filename": "c70bd67c0a4360dae4ca72fb3867fe4814365bee60db94b8a919ced0f6c8c2fc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (In the video, after the spring snaps inward, the forces at both ends of the spring are the same, and the spring should sway in place. In the 4.6s video, the spring is not subjected to any force to the left or right, but it sways left and right and even has an unnatural feeling of floating, which does not conform to the law of inertia).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08792", "filename": "c79e56d9cb61ccd1bc5045d34a8f25d6f0ad3939e58f4007afb450bdb5df870a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08793", "filename": "c85fe42f10fe62ae8e12d08da63b76d62d28edce02b17b66d89874bea73d72af_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (The color of the clouds in the sky should gradually change as the sun slowly sets below the horizon, but the color of the clouds does not change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08794", "filename": "c91fc4e35c0a985bda71faaeae60b68574ff82bc4b4ed6a2196f1bd127e56f59_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08797", "filename": "c223bdcf69c33fab2c3820aed62d3de351a7bad631ed5a041122c8849187c11d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (between 3.3s and 4.3s, the flame shifts but no combustible material is visible, and the smoke is too uniform; the burning marks on the thick sparkler remain unchanged; at 5.9s, the video flame does not extinguish, but the smoke on the right side of the flame suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08798", "filename": "c714a8806d58bc4c7ef7ce73a4b5da7868507c95a442b5bf5fa022eac0a36424_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the flickering of the ground and trees is too obvious throughout the video.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08799", "filename": "c816a14920dfa12d20923cedb9374c81ee9925164760eba3d8b7a36e1d5c2076_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (a violent explosion occurs in the video from 1.2s to 8s, but the puppet at the explosion site remains intact and the surrounding grass remains stable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08800", "filename": "c876d5f51964f91d2b8717a414f3f6324a763d7c248f7a407b664f904fd820a1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08802", "filename": "c1463e8e9d575a1ce9d1dfde1d21ea5520dd299d847a38898ebd98cf2db70e3f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.7s, the character shakes the rope in their hand, but suddenly an extra rope appears in the middle of the rope, and a bubble emerges from the rope).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08803", "filename": "c35620ea420245ef4390a11e123d3e9da4672d6e4fa5099bfa47bdbf283f7f50_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video content: Physical behavior (black objects keep appearing in the lower right corner of the video and are in motion without any force applied).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08804", "filename": "c82095a7157fe54e7696655eca762ec251c39afc2f193061d986a25373ec0e73_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08805", "filename": "c0661699f8cfb2069723c9874eb0e209c436ccf08ab255d9a210231f49989fe4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.8 seconds into the video, the green cup is empty and does not isolate the oxygen around the candle, but when the cup is brought close to the candle, the candle flame suddenly shrinks).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08806", "filename": "c2632296db4073089e3016e44da06c8897e7edd0aed2e9813ab20f95f6a9f7b3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the water surface remains stable after the explosion in the water from 0.7s to 8s, and the water droplets should spray in all directions, but in the video the water droplets only spray upwards).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08807", "filename": "c9943188dac0278a125bd8d94c4cdc3bc39f2d8189b84e993e5d5221a9cd2928_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: physical behavior (the head model is shot off by a bullet and flies to the right of the video, but from 3.5s to 8s the head model moves to the left of the video without being subjected to a force to the left, which does not conform to the law of inertia).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08808", "filename": "c718667776c7529edcd0ed0006c6a41bee37282e6f689993bfebb40e99fea1b1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (0s-1.3s the colored light reflected on the jewelry gradually disappears, after 1.3s the reflected light on the jewelry is chaotic and the rate of change of reflection is inconsistent with the rate of hand movement).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08809", "filename": "ca2c029e5dedd66cc9e483405ef963c1dbbd32ba5b72b1bbd065f6517979e48a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08810", "filename": "ca8e2767823ecd0b666955f189b9e6ba5a319f94ad1619236ba0f2159d5df3f1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from start to finish, the stone held in the finger starts to rotate on its own in the hand without the finger moving).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08811", "filename": "8ad58db88ef9ce5a3d54452fed1d397165cc0cb0a315991d271d8006e4f5b413_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the long wooden block in the upper right corner moves automatically without any external force between 0.3s and 2.2s) and continuous time (white tape suddenly appears on the wooden strip in the upper left corner at 4.7s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08813", "filename": "8b3fe431a9dbc6d6a187b05021754cf3c0b9d268fdc99c02ee8087b88e4feedf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08814", "filename": "8b6994a4d18b0739cfd80dc474279d38768741f39d613ad7680d72daed590dc5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time sequence is continuous (at 2.5s, the light in the upper right corner of the screen changes from a square light in the previous frame to a circle in the next frame; at 3.3s-3.5s, deformation appears on the left and right sides above the steel frame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08815", "filename": "8baac48847caa2f215fecfc9f0d4183f01c26d79c1149308c62cf880fc7d97ba_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the ball rolls upwards and disappears between 1.6s and 2.1s, violating the law of gravity); Time continuity (the pink ball suddenly appears on the lower track at 4.9s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08816", "filename": "8c671d87fcb236166daaba0f4aac695e86b1f86ec5459f6e0576606b9effefde_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08817", "filename": "8c8622dc4198717ea188a0be1d87d472a51b98b9a9fcdaf06e7c8588f0d4222f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (white light appears out of nowhere on the right side of the screen at 5.7s) Physical behavior (the light distribution is too uniform, which does not conform to the principle of light reflection)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08819", "filename": "8ce7f0248f48a3ab61f46ce49e61f05a047d098761f728603e9a90e37f0d07b9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (a large hole appears in the upper left corner of the bubble at 3.8s, but the bubble doesn't burst; two shadows appear out of nowhere on the ground at 4.9s); Physical behavior (the bubble's shape doesn't change during its movement; surface light refraction is unreasonable).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08822", "filename": "8d5801a15e62d1242ccc8685e5f2b2423dc6bdba83bfa71d1b1df28b77f94e05_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08823", "filename": "8dbcc6fb88bec69d003e79cdc77dc9cb7d420aa64151950c67582b9cd4094549_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (at 0s, the phone's timer on the right side of the screen counts down and then suddenly becomes positive, with the numbers changing irregularly. The entire video is played in slow motion, but the timer on the right side moves at a normal speed).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08824", "filename": "8e2d766544f173c699787d1877881e5bd5115deed2ac49f8433b047877a6d1e2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (0-2.4s: the basketball floats in the air without external force, violating the laws of gravity); Time continuity (2.8s: the basketball suddenly flies towards the basket without external force and deforms upon touching the basket).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08825", "filename": "8e0148fa1af00416eb6abda085d8c08f98cffede9ba2d18eb60942fa401b65b9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Cause and effect (at 3.1s, the hydraulic press had not yet made contact with the object below, and the object suddenly disintegrated without any external force, stopping disintegration at 5.7s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08826", "filename": "8e2063d9f6cdf06ce2dacaf50c1c1f3679abb4cfb2f4d8bf09142652ef19b8c8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 4.4s, when the stick in the character's hand touches the bubble, the bubble does not burst, and the distant waves remain still).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08827", "filename": "8eedf098fa301e8c0f58afe849a04496479986ed29f4eb60a774aff0308c2202_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is continuous (small bubbles appear out of nowhere above the white bucket at 0.1s), and the overall visual impression is abnormal (at 5.3s, the bubbles split open with clear lines connecting the separated bubbles).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08828", "filename": "8eff513ec4abd60eb8ea2aaf825ff7366625c9ffa3e5df9217c116622fe1d053_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the foil box flickers and jumps at the beginning of the video, disrupting the stability of the viewpoint in some parts of the image).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08829", "filename": "8f3a9c870d7f9d17ef7ad3f7da6dc259c570e48cc750792a38c7cbc8e66a5657_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (the trees and floating objects on the water in the video are constantly flickering and jumping, disrupting the stability of the viewpoint).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08830", "filename": "8f80ccd2bf3f498e3ff2573efd034671b8296f95d87b1f744887b663a6ae5428_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the video flickers and jumps throughout, disrupting the stability of the viewing angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08831", "filename": "8f534da5e533d39b366ffdae260d52aada118a7852e29ef6ed76d8e0fbde1c86_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the yellow items under the table and the objects visible in the box behind the white items are constantly flickering).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08832", "filename": "09b0d26d0067b1e8809cf56f3f68d55165dbbb6af0b32e254e2d2432b728e970_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (the objects inside the pot are constantly flickering and jumping throughout the video, disrupting the stability of the viewing angle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08833", "filename": "09e02961b529cd7105a68d3ebfc1b459e19a40ba5d4b07a2332877f740299ce0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08834", "filename": "9a91659ee65dcbdada32611126a5a0f1af8b30294fdadca55d836212f29a7a80_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the entire video frame flickers and jumps, disrupting the stability of the viewing angle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08836", "filename": "9ab3412f9c876405b671b7e7ec2edb6dd372bd0e0809a283fd7b1ea43fa8d800_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the grass and branches on both sides of the road and the lights on the eaves of the houses in the scene are constantly flashing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08837", "filename": "9ad1ef172c9ce7921f330c4fee915f8dcba787232fce9f741518b8caee2c108b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: causality (the floating objects in the box move on their own without any external force, violating the laws of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08838", "filename": "9b000bf46954de6585ee7eba224a71a96120d56384a41868bf7d4c94062cc351_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the mirror reflection and the placement of objects in the video flicker and jump at the beginning). Physical behavior: (the rolling behavior of the long objects in the video violates the principle of inertia).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08839", "filename": "9b7aaca74c4915849dde0e232ca783a03b439d6ea3041514d0ce489ccc39d3d6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the entire video image flickers and jumps, disrupting the stability of the viewing angle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08840", "filename": "9b96eab4a9ab78023911bca5ca737826cec27c14be324f24e919a1d16b40960c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the ice blocks in the video keep flickering and jumping, disrupting the stability of the viewpoint in certain parts of the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08841", "filename": "cadede47c765da8a0893c43e36a921ce5dacdaf0f85461e1bae6a6fcbc629779_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.9 seconds, the brown cards fall one by one, the cards in front have not yet fallen, but the cards behind suddenly fall without any force and in the opposite direction. At 4.5 seconds, the brown card on the left side of the video falls down for no reason without any force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08842", "filename": "caf5199479ccdde6e9c0641141fb862e24a8635fc440b2f6e926b84437bbaf44_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The timing is continuous (at 2.8s, the right hand picks up the round disc and it suddenly deforms, leaving only half of it; between 2.7s and 3.9s, the disc in the left hand is not being held but remains firmly in the hand and does not fall off).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08843", "filename": "cc0dcee8eb706efa79e76cc77f9595b723b010ce50940e19080927e70f50253d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08844", "filename": "cc1f7b898939b61564e6eaa2658e6fc85aba201f82d899e575c5a3cf593854cf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time frame is continuous (the strawberries that fall into the blender between 0.9s and 4.5s turn into strawberry juice instantly).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08846", "filename": "cc276b253efbcc7750c818148eb7bf201b0a59f971ba2ce299df8bc4eeef727a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08847", "filename": "cccb3be0a67694a6a1c51f5c646ab70582167e01e77cfcdcc3ce5e2e606be954_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the image: Physical behavior (the colored light refracted in the transparent, irregular gemstone disappears between 1.4s and 8s, which does not conform to the laws of light scattering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08848", "filename": "cd44f2eb9b38e6ea350e81f1ef8dbe5e2173925bdc9fb8b38841192328bab35a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the entire video is bright with sunlight, but the clouds above the video are always dark and gloomy).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08850", "filename": "cd25452e4aa799bf405006cec1ca509d92e2b0b88afa183a7a0b972cedcffa6d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (The paper is in a burning state throughout the video, and the paper is highly flammable, but the charred traces of the paper in the video do not change significantly.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08851", "filename": "cdfa50b45d657fa9c0f873be41cb59765eee78ab6bdd13559b625c1b8f3b90d0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08852", "filename": "ce01b05add5d1a003b913f727aab440e89e8920928d481f8614222e37b58fc8e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (Paper is highly flammable; the paper at the bottom of the screen is burning and should ignite the paper above, but the paper above does not show any signs of burning; the writing on the paper in the screen keeps flickering and distorting).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08853", "filename": "ce22325d6752d0cad3ac3bae80d213f8ea54938e56d2011abf4de2b83f7c397f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a white halo flashes continuously on the right side of the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08855", "filename": "cf5e1d75c268cd6c75e706d8b43886b9945dec5f3e25af1161f0388f8761fe48_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the boiling water in the pot suddenly slows down between 0s and 0.4s, and the entire video suddenly stutters and drops frames between 5.5s and 7.4s.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08856", "filename": "cf250f8bce224874a1893a24f7b297dfd0aa6eea6a85ce3b5658650b24a30e91_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is that the timing is discontinuous (at 0.4s, a polar bear's head appears out of nowhere on the water's surface, and there are two polar bear heads on the surface, but only one polar bear's body appears underwater, and the transition between the body and the head is exaggerated).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08857", "filename": "cf680fed4a1be18fe2735547f3615844e7ef52f7f220d2181ba815522c45b2f3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08858", "filename": "cf5088fccd4949eb42ce676ccc218c6e8cc5032a8a5f9c4cb293b9fb9bf60588_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08859", "filename": "cfb13c063c77c6b0d5bd8f6f0947ab08def54bd485226e25762b261b9dd64617_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 3.2 seconds, when the finger touches the steel ball, the steel ball suddenly twists and deforms, and two small steel balls suddenly appear as a ghost image under the thumb).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08860", "filename": "cfd96a8199e34632598cf7f279d768e5170f9df666d228d597eeedd9315c1299_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The abnormality in the image is due to physical behavior (the water vapor from the evaporation of hot water will first gather near the mouth of the cup, and the temperature difference between the inside and outside of the cup will cause the surrounding cold air to slightly surround the mouth area, preventing the water vapor from immediately dissipating in all directions, but instead causing it to rise and disperse into a dense mist-like airflow. However, between 3.9s and 8s, the mist-like airflow in the cup splits into three streams and rises and disperses, which does not conform to the principle of water vapor liquefaction).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08861", "filename": "d000ce114e0de1a775c93f92fdd9c2eeb3ed54419c72cfe7f20a206f5d3f32d5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (from the beginning to 1.3s, the water in the kettle is boiling but no steam is produced. From 5.1s to 8s, the boiling water in the kettle suddenly returns to a calm state and the steam production increases dramatically. The steam covers the kettle and does not float upwards).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08862", "filename": "d0de6b603b11f81ff712601e79c35aa71b1507d2f41c38a20a06746cce311410_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (the explosive device detonates just 2 seconds after a person walks next to it, but after the explosion dissipates, it does not cause any harm to the person, and the smoke produced after the explosion should spread in all directions, but in the video the smoke produced by the explosion rises vertically upwards).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08863", "filename": "d1c45706b98c24104c3474841ef30bc4c926773f721e03c260cfd4d1e308e5c2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08864", "filename": "d2af3ce7683ff1c5e365dd43c2fc05c27e9c40e53369a9ed096c2729c97fef5d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (everything in the entire video frame is frozen).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08865", "filename": "d2bd32fdecac4d2b3eaaea5412eea151a12c5016333bd88d5a57cf4e3aff2274_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 0s to 3.5s, waves appear directly in front of the viewer, but after 3.5s, the waves reappear from the right side of the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08866", "filename": "d2d80d897320388d23819460adbd98bf1125d80692445922ab38b85b137b21b7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the trajectory of the small iron ball changes without external interference between 5s and 5.5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08867", "filename": "d2f963ba992af317954b9efd1de1e2e284759d0a1804111924d969340e802012_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (from 1.5s to 2.4s, the water in the pot is boiling, but the thermometer shows a rapid temperature increase; at 2.4s, the water is still boiling and the temperature should not be decreasing, but the thermometer shows a rapid decrease; the temperature range shown by the thermometer is too large and does not match the temperature difference when the water is boiling; from 0s to 0.7s, when the water is continuously heated, the boiling state of the water is significantly weakened).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08869", "filename": "d3ff0f34f40292ae2e0aa8cb00f67febcadf7e16b303f9ecb41cc2ab9b942820_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.4s, the white area on the red part of the popsicle suddenly increases, and the popsicle placed on the smooth surface begins to melt faster at 5.4s, and the melted liquid only flows out from the lower half of the popsicle and does not flow out from the sides).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08870", "filename": "d4a39268edf1440e50545d0cf6f5d3faa0275daffad386cae907c55f45036081_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the lighter flame in the video remains stable, but in reality, the lighter flame will flicker due to the influence of the surrounding air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08871", "filename": "dff550be613b1789aae3088e09f5701437bfbac9453a0113a75b057e8d31e5a4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (1.04-2s, the car flies into the sky without any external force); Time continuity (the pile of earth in the middle of the video flickers continuously).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08872", "filename": "e1d002a1b346138ab7f2378c4b4b9da7a1b52e313cd6fec56cd07f01f52869f7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly in the image: Under heating conditions, the white substance around the pot should exhibit slight shrinkage, merging, or dissipation. However, the foam adhering to the pot wall in the image maintains a completely consistent shape, distribution, and size across the entire image. There is no morphological distortion caused by changes in liquid surface tension, nor any volume reduction due to evaporation, presenting a \"statically pasted\" visual effect.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08873", "filename": "e1e6cec5403c7099318e158ff61b7bbf34a0518b47fe5f5512144f8ce30179ed_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the duration is continuous (2.04-8s, the machine brushes over the stool, and with the spray, there is a clear dividing line on the stool surface, with water mist on the upper half and not on the lower half). The water mist sprayed by the machine throughout the video is viscous, the movement trajectory is abnormal, and there is a significant difference from real water mist, making it appear unrealistic.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08874", "filename": "e3c590f62833a8400ed15d3c2a2c54adf1ec4b50e2c40bf6d5fa07ee08044eea_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video content: Physical behavior (The entire video shows flames burning in a haystack, but the haystack, being flammable material, is not ignited by the flames; normally, the flames should grow larger and larger.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08875", "filename": "e4ff8169bb629304128b797ba30da8ad47a9384c227ab9a677b3bd8bcc8602fa_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (At 0.8s, the car flies from the inclined plane onto the track and travels to the right along the track without any external force. Between 4.18 and 5.3s, the car suddenly moves to the left.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08876", "filename": "e3488df2cc870fd7b3b683e31076df510245fd31a8eeccb6b36d0fcdca2e3d09_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (between 1.04 and 3.1 seconds, the three objects on the left in the video started to explode one after another before the wheel even ran over them). The boxed objects being run over by the wheel should have sprayed liquid from the sides of the objects first, not from the top.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08877", "filename": "e06023d78f6cf8f6060421f248cd340a057adc136944e156dfeefe8e9009f00b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (flickering throughout the video, particularly in the woods). The fire burning in the leaf litter did not produce smoke, and the intensity of the fire did not change significantly.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08878", "filename": "e6384cbd3f392fa7f2ca0b2d14167439bf05b4b707ac799eddc138b65feb4796_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (In the entire video, the movement of the clouds on the left and right sides of the glass is not smoothly connected; the clouds on the left move significantly faster than those on the right, as if the footage was spliced together.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08879", "filename": "e6956f519f9ccf4b204dfabbc10bede5cbb889a0f9f1cce9a681e41a61690af5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08881", "filename": "e288037a3f371cb6b4cd1e475c9ba74e756be915c737460f10a9fe9cc0ceb9e4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08882", "filename": "e377893c31a30a8126598e0dc9c5e83f81773c7d0a523a742ff6b07cf688a147_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08883", "filename": "e784931b287ff99b242f9e661d771cfa44ee9bc3137a7d60d5fe8a2ede83ed76_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Throughout the video, the match head is burning, but it remains black without turning red. Overall visual anomaly (the paper burns too smoothly after the match ignites, unlike realistic footage).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08884", "filename": "e937821e5d26a447a9c2e2db13187722c4fc69acc7b0d0717b3d274c2e728f4b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal due to physical behavior (between 4.20 and 8 seconds, the energy generated by the first bubble bursting upon contact with the lens will directly launch the second bubble, which is close to the first bubble, away. In real life, the second bubble should burst directly instead of being launched away, violating the law of conservation of momentum.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08885", "filename": "e2109806cdc00d948c69fd828be6cd6efb6af5429736e11e9ce23538a76e53c0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (0-8s, the object slowly moves to the left without being subjected to any external force, violating Newton's First Law.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08886", "filename": "ea6b1bdd9ce8ef9ea3dc3374825476fd35482a5f6712495b721a90ea0aa9b969_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (clouds move slowly and irregularly in their natural state, video footage is shaky, and there is a strong sense of compositing).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08887", "filename": "eac030e84ed18a8b333c215076b4c778fefd3384d6d128cbb3d7bbf412e7b435_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08888", "filename": "eace903553a9e749e899c04f49d22a4ccbb1d238c683e5ef2032fb5f025b42d3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (from 0 to 0.3s, the object on the left moves to the left without any external force, violating Newton's First Law); Time continuity (at 0.8s, when the character's hand touches the object on the right, the fingers suddenly disappear).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08889", "filename": "eae18c34613bb4ead8b1b36d3b7bc59d81f5c82af540d1465c07edb5c8418f82_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (At the moment of the explosion at 2.1s, the left can shattered and only one fragment flew out. Normally, fragments should have scattered everywhere. From 2.03 to 8s, the explosion should have ended, but smoke was still continuously spewing out of the broken can on the left.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08890", "filename": "eb7df0efae1d550a425fb706c6805167ff56ba773ff64b8e9573b7795a38dbfc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Overall visual anomaly: (From 3.18-8s, the flames burn too smoothly, appearing unrealistic.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08891", "filename": "eb604adf5ed3cbbd04a4dc37ae7e111ef6d2e5a0d7a1e44de1e6d0c2807667f2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08892", "filename": "eb50808eb30319631752f953a81cacd8741d9046e1d311c65ae410bde521e900_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (The video shows a scene of water spraying to extinguish a fire, but the flames rise too smoothly, giving a strong sense of being synthesized.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08894", "filename": "ec0a1a99ae9e3a15467cd68f57497a44a5c54d42e941cc735dd0b81e2b8ea04f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the leaves above the flowing water in the video are flickering, unlike real footage).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08895", "filename": "ec0d14b2dd7febecd9a05b790b816462daeab6001a1dee464bae81c9b13c8ee3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08896", "filename": "ec786cdb84cc4d3b495d990e9c54c82c1f22bb1b969e09d93379793c6817d9fb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08897", "filename": "ec04849beb21bc00fb8f8b1c84c1b90289b7aa6acae5234ffad0c873281d96ec_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The sequence of events is continuous (0-3.1s; after the explosion, there is obvious mud splashing, but the ground remains unchanged). Overall visual anomalies (3.03-8s; the smoke produced after the explosion has a very thick, unnatural appearance).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08899", "filename": "ed59b9bd047ba54ccf050699a708824f7eb805e1491780cf7acfa68599ffade8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08900", "filename": "eda610d4b7810da410476b440e02db2e5081f1c818efd62b16b791d060f08ac0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08901", "filename": "P04_113_169_a288a06243c7df55_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08902", "filename": "P04_113_216_b934a4c7704bb53f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly occurred: (between 0.6s and 1.2s, a spoon with a pink handle passed through an intact glass lid. The glass lid is a solid, and solids are impermeable.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08903", "filename": "P04_116_142_bde378ff50125e6f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The time frame is continuous (2.5s-6s). When the spatula stirs the liquid in the pot, the liquid is viscous, but the surface is smooth and there are no obvious stirring marks.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08904", "filename": "P04_116_169_7730b25837e07dcb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (from 2.3s to 4.6s, the black pepper shaker twists abnormally without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08905", "filename": "P04_117_48_daedd11cbff5cbe2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time sequence is continuous (1.4s-3.1s). After flipping the knife, the back of the blade becomes the edge, and the edge becomes the back.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08906", "filename": "P04_118_53_288c1f0339d229ca_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is inconsistent (between 3s and 4.1s, the silver object transforms into a sponge without external force. The sequence is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08907", "filename": "P04_119_148_798120eb046ef868_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is inconsistent (from 0s to 1.1s, the black bottom of the pot turns into the rim; the transitions are not uniform).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08908", "filename": "P04_119_161_aa85b4e657521c62_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall, the visuals appear unnatural (at 2.4 seconds, the spoon seems glued to the back of the hand, not naturally held; hand movements throughout the video are unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08909", "filename": "P04_119_253_97f03b97163b7b39_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time frame is continuous (from 0.2s to 1.4s, the spoon in the lower left corner grows larger without any external force, and then twists abnormally).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08910", "filename": "P04_119_265_eadce31310d52518_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08911", "filename": "P04_120_145_5995cbbfee8ec66d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the desktop and objects on it are flickering and writhing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08912", "filename": "P04_120_222_1922ee417f3ab578_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08913", "filename": "P04_120_239_cdc8caf466c82bdc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08914", "filename": "P04_120_340_b39d486c8d577a3e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08915", "filename": "P04_120_355_fa50a2ce3e7467c7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly occurred: (At 2.9 seconds, a spoon appeared out of nowhere in the bottom right corner.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08916", "filename": "P04_120_369_ae26d5efffb4516c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08917", "filename": "P04_121_13_5828d614e1f4c9bb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (objects cut in between 0.7s and 6.4s automatically recover without external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08918", "filename": "P04_121_27_172946becd329d55_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (the knife cuts through the tofu between 6.3s and 7.1s, but the tofu remains intact. The tofu would have cracked under stress.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08919", "filename": "P04_121_104_7ac78d4a80d6c373_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08920", "filename": "P04_121_246_d4090df3ba43a555_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time frame is continuous (liquid is continuously added to the bowl from 4.6s to 6.4s, but the liquid level in the bowl does not change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08921", "filename": "P04_121_438_5174c2a7006657f5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (2.1s-4.6s). Water from the bowl spills onto the table, and the water on the table disappears automatically without external force. The spilled water should remain on the table surface.", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08922", "filename": "P04_121_571_ca9df2f6ffdbed71_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08923", "filename": "P06_101_39_57e9b429eb0a763b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time frame is continuous (between 0.8s and 1.2s, the cut onion pieces change from small to large, exhibiting abnormal deformation. The size of a cut onion is fixed and does not automatically increase in size.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08924", "filename": "P06_101_100_7c2fe1303fd11810_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time frame is continuous (from 1.8s to 2.1s, the onion with skin suddenly turns into a peel-less onion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08925", "filename": "P06_101_177_cc8321f225e6848e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (at 0.9 seconds, the yellow towel in the left-hand water tank suddenly turns black and undergoes abnormal deformation).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08926", "filename": "P06_101_264_a710fc76bcf0d940_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08927", "filename": "P06_101_417_14f706526aa67c74_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08928", "filename": "P06_102_75_9535d3d9233c8e5c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: (During the kneading process, the surface of the dough is too smooth, with no fingerprints left, and the repetitive kneading movements of the person are too stiff.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08929", "filename": "P06_102_119_b633ab4ada7683e0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly occurred: (From 3.1s to 4.1s, the plastic wrap in the lower right corner, which had been opened, automatically stretched and widened without any external force.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08930", "filename": "P04_116_111_2121f5ef49de255a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08931", "filename": "0f9cb357f8ac5acd99480fc427d0bd0bd836700cfd7e2dbbfcf8d0714e1c83d5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time sequence is continuous (1.4s). Black material appears out of thin air at the center of the evaporating dish and continues to expand outward.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08932", "filename": "0f25b57a3432b1fb91f9473a9624c67d4cbd163c72f517f0b812e0a937306b0b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is inconsistent (the trees in the video are swaying from side to side, indicating that the wind is blowing horizontally, but the water mist is drifting upwards. Water mist subjected to a horizontal force should drift left and right, not upwards.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08933", "filename": "0f25b57a3432b1fb91f9473a9624c67d4cbd163c72f517f0b812e0a937306b0b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (3.5s-4.3s, the person in white in the upper left corner disappears into thin air while running).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08934", "filename": "0f25b57a3432b1fb91f9473a9624c67d4cbd163c72f517f0b812e0a937306b0b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time frame is continuous (from 0.2s to 3s, the trees in the mountains remain motionless, indicating no strong wind, but the fog in the upper left corner of the mountain dissipates rapidly. Mountain fog should drift and dissipate slowly when not being blown by strong winds.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08935", "filename": "0f25b57a3432b1fb91f9473a9624c67d4cbd163c72f517f0b812e0a937306b0b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08936", "filename": "0f45e6a30b8262c80b0ee24370b9ab67bb56c98158985ce822a928b57fb48a57_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: (The explosive detonated between 0.7s and 1.4s without a lit fuse. Without a lit fuse, no heat would have been transferred to the gunpowder, and the gunpowder would not have exploded automatically.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08937", "filename": "0f45e6a30b8262c80b0ee24370b9ab67bb56c98158985ce822a928b57fb48a57_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08938", "filename": "0f190b3328d3a314bbb9dc7a3639c4ea1b6844644f54c7c7b210dc63520c008c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08939", "filename": "0f190b3328d3a314bbb9dc7a3639c4ea1b6844644f54c7c7b210dc63520c008c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the water flow on the left side of the waterfall is too blurry and flickers and wriggles, resembling a spider web, unlike real waterfall flow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08940", "filename": "0f190b3328d3a314bbb9dc7a3639c4ea1b6844644f54c7c7b210dc63520c008c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08941", "filename": "0fbd5eb2d0038ff21b7dbed9e58bd6a1204b16c5d43a49feeb176e38b9925fad_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: A continuous sequence of events (0.5s-1.6s) shows a wooden stick being stirred in a solution suddenly transforming into a feather.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08942", "filename": "0fbd5eb2d0038ff21b7dbed9e58bd6a1204b16c5d43a49feeb176e38b9925fad_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The sequence of events is continuous (0.8s-1.9s). A feather gently falls into the water, causing a huge tremor and the feather sinks. Because the feather is extremely light and the water has surface tension, it does not sink but floats on the surface.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08943", "filename": "0fbd5eb2d0038ff21b7dbed9e58bd6a1204b16c5d43a49feeb176e38b9925fad_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly occurred: (From 4.1 seconds after the feather fell into the water until 4.5 seconds later, without any external force, an insoluble liquid appeared at the tip of the feather, remaining attached to the feather in the water. According to the law of conservation of mass, liquid should not spontaneously generate at the tip of a feather.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08944", "filename": "0fbd5eb2d0038ff21b7dbed9e58bd6a1204b16c5d43a49feeb176e38b9925fad_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08945", "filename": "0fbdd536dda1a2b409573409feaea2b91bf6393d9d9ad937fbc17f6c3e7aae31_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly occurred: (At 4.4 seconds, the small bubble at the center of the large bubble automatically split into four smaller bubbles without any external force. The small bubbles at the center of the large bubble are formed by small air spheres during blowing; these small air spheres do not split into other small bubbles.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08946", "filename": "0fbdd536dda1a2b409573409feaea2b91bf6393d9d9ad937fbc17f6c3e7aae31_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08947", "filename": "0fbdd536dda1a2b409573409feaea2b91bf6393d9d9ad937fbc17f6c3e7aae31_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08949", "filename": "01c9b0fcf594b1237c49efcb98842ac157275b0e6e7526ae0908a9ecba4145cf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is visually unusual: the overall visual perception is off (the video shows the shape changes of a local cloud layer from morning to night, but the cloud shape changes are the same from morning to night, and the cloud drift speed is the same. This does not conform to the randomness of real-world cloud shape changes.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08950", "filename": "01c9b0fcf594b1237c49efcb98842ac157275b0e6e7526ae0908a9ecba4145cf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly occurred: (At 1.8 seconds, under a clear blue sky with white clouds, a dark cloud appeared in the center of the white clouds.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08951", "filename": "01c9b0fcf594b1237c49efcb98842ac157275b0e6e7526ae0908a9ecba4145cf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08952", "filename": "1a3e80c0b452a7920b602331742087397787be2556c9bc98639c08a8fc9d5648_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08953", "filename": "1a3e80c0b452a7920b602331742087397787be2556c9bc98639c08a8fc9d5648_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: (From 0.8s to 2.8s, the sparks from the fireworks explosion should erupt from the center outwards, not all downwards; the sparks should scatter in all directions.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08954", "filename": "1a3e80c0b452a7920b602331742087397787be2556c9bc98639c08a8fc9d5648_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08955", "filename": "1a3e80c0b452a7920b602331742087397787be2556c9bc98639c08a8fc9d5648_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the sequence is continuous (the entire video shows strong winds blowing through the clouds on the mountainside, causing them to move rapidly, but the trees on the mountain remain still and do not sway. Trees should be swaying in the wind.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08956", "filename": "1a5f6214acac586908adafec06b2a2b0c486d1e0f9d73a78a42311de79ba3dbc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is unusual: (The entire shot is of clouds taken from high altitude. The clouds appear stationary, almost like a solid. However, due to airflow, gaseous clouds would drift with the wind, rather than remain stationary.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08957", "filename": "1a9b8a2d8e953ab69c555dd1457afb863d50e26b984f37c7f3f3e50e77b3d0dd_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (from 0.2s to 2.8s, the water in the left cup vibrates automatically without any external force. Without external force, a stationary object cannot directly generate force, so the water in the cup should remain still).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08958", "filename": "1a9b8a2d8e953ab69c555dd1457afb863d50e26b984f37c7f3f3e50e77b3d0dd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (within the entire video, the water in the two glasses on the left and right automatically rose from half-full to full without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08959", "filename": "1a9b8a2d8e953ab69c555dd1457afb863d50e26b984f37c7f3f3e50e77b3d0dd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly occurred: (From 2.1s to 5s, the water in the left cup rotated automatically without any external force.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08961", "filename": "dd0a8f7f0bc9cc7575dd3cc409e2f049fdd9d39864cca82182a2720ef41d4062_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical anomaly (0s-6.8s: sudden, irregular, non-external force-triggered stop of cloud and fog movement; dynamic stillness; no fluid deceleration or gradual diffusion transition trajectory).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08962", "filename": "dd7cb024e7da691c0956b28fde35806df1083f6b023b28d1505260592b3e1123_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The duration is continuous (3.3s). In the rain scene, there are sudden flashes of light in the rain curtain area without any light source. These are not ambient light sources (streetlights). The flashes of light are irregular and have no physical linkage with raindrop refraction or ambient light and shadow. There is flickering distortion.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08963", "filename": "dd9bcac1469adc7d06a2dd97192634b33b23f146fdf8adbc2b5e7c5e8aeda844_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Temporal continuity (In the 6.4s video frame, the horse undergoes a sudden change in shape without any triggering conditions. The shape of its body and head changes directly without any twisting, stretching, or deformation. This is an illogical form distortion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08964", "filename": "dd5520dbd4b2d37094af3f68a2d454b7749570e0254ed035406729ac708f36c1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08965", "filename": "ddbd9547f320939503e5d03ce2c249e82c4b8940f56d6c3a0539e4301e382b27_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video behavior: Physical behavior (the small boat in the video suddenly and irregularly moves left and right without being triggered by external force, with abrupt changes in horizontal displacement and a gradual change in motion without physical drive.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08966", "filename": "dde158c6c2a5a0c304261f08bb18cc50533198d7f290796c537e29be9ab295a1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: physical behavior (the blue ball moves at 0.9s, the red cup at 2.5s, and the ball again at 5.9s. There is no contact, wind, fluid, or other external forces. The movement is autonomous, with no physical driving logic for the displacement. The motion state exhibits a step-like positional distortion, completely deviating from the physical rules of force balance.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08967", "filename": "de9001dec3bb8c3b3973eafe325f74c5723f1aeac7982fa1a0d613566d9c1ae2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: (The leaves on the left side are flickering between frames, and the leaf texture shows high-frequency brightness jumps.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08968", "filename": "de477205e31123b698df73db7d2441d29f92199a7d503a0464dad371becdc852_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the sea surface area exhibits visual jumps between frames, triggered by no wind, waves, or external disturbances; the sea surface texture and liquid level are highly distorted; the flow is unstable and disconnected from the fluid physics linkage logic; there is a fault of inter-frame jumps in the sea surface phase field.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08969", "filename": "decbe03844a3ecffe0ab9763b2be443b55ee425cdd899573fa18da09f0e72668_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the foam melts upon contact, and the indented contact point turns into a charred, viscous melt; the foam color does not change in the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08970", "filename": "df33a9c505f502e60b53756df440a0fc7fd67ac014c7ee13913e800d7c51bc98_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08971", "filename": "f006eee3bddc08c032695d765ddb76492d596a0613889b190e92e3169ad3505e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Physical behavior (After the rocket ignites and lifts off, undesigned residual flame appears on the side of the main jet (left side of the rocket body), resulting in an asymmetrical distribution of flames on both sides. There is a continuous residual flame ejection on the left side, and the flame pattern does not converge synchronously with the rocket body's attitude.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08972", "filename": "f3414d32d41f4028aab9214417c3fd858b2118fb08af429f57a61cdd3faf01dd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the ice block suddenly rises to the surface without any apparent force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08973", "filename": "f6767a9e04fd8095d4c31be44e224e4c8f39da878e52d697856504922a186eb9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08974", "filename": "f1516533ac121249729038ecdeb27fe1edc06b1287123f7a999ec4e638b0c31b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (the light bulb in the hand disappears at 1.2s, the remote control in the hand suddenly disappears at 2.2s, and the person picks up the remote control at 0.7s, with the indicator light coinciding with the finger).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08975", "filename": "fb81dffa4d348a433a8809b0f220a4f542609c9198acca044db07e7b9127feb5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08977", "filename": "fbfa5f83a292db601ce0564727106efb30f0e8b9e18ebbab4652c90185479dd7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the leaves are shaking irregularly at high frequency, with slight trembling at the leaf tips and the leaf body swaying back and forth, without the smooth swaying rhythm driven by natural airflow).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08978", "filename": "fc3ece43f425eacef2642dc2c6d3fc767e6113a14aaaea7238005a4feab6c74f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (3.5s, the liquid area shows a dimensionless sudden expansion, and the liquid level rises without external injection).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08980", "filename": "fcc6f6274ba463949667bf2ad8b8a0352926fdbf7d8ac8e90e09b7785076fcbe_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (the area where the bottom of the cup touches the snow shows rapid, localized melting, immediately creating an indentation in the snow layer, accompanied by rising white steam. This is the process of the hot water's high temperature rapidly conducting to the snow layer, causing the solid snow to melt directly into water. This is not shown in the video footage).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_08981", "filename": "fd0cbaf1f4aa59645f47ab9c881651239d9952bd72acc444681f3e55f9bbff51_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Physical behavior (4.6s, the toothbrush body undergoes inelastic deformation, shape distortion, no external force feedback, no gradual deformation process, and non-physical shape distortion.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_08982", "filename": "ff3c7d7aba01138ada2e99da986b8e5fe908a33d944efba3df60e13fa528865b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the cheese suddenly increases without gradient and unnaturally at 1.8s, a batch of entities appear instantly, and there is no physical linkage of generation and replication).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08983", "filename": "ffc86587dc1401ec56c40e2fbf05a1b5f97b32c0044a04c3870d7badff8acd3c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (the 2s letter aperture suddenly zooms in without gradient, the outline size increases abruptly, and there is no natural scaling transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08984", "filename": "P28_111_203_d618853c86d2dd86_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (3.2s: the original damaged area of the bag closes instantly out of thin air, without any dynamic process of adhesion or contraction of the damaged edge, directly completing the healing and repair without any physical logic. 5.5s: the empty bag suddenly and unnaturally inflates without gradient, the bag volume expands, and there is no smooth transition trajectory of inflation).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08985", "filename": "P28_112_50_b9f028181c8a9888_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (sudden, unnatural deformation of small particles without gradients, smooth, distorted transitions in outlines, and altered shapes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08986", "filename": "P28_112_50_b9f028181c8a9888_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (the cleaning agent body is flickering at a high frequency, without any light source switching or scene light and shadow changes. The brightness changes abruptly, the flickering has no natural rhythm and is disconnected from the logic of linkage with the ambient light and shadow, and there is inter-frame distortion of the actual brightness.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08987", "filename": "P28_112_50_b9f028181c8a9888_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08988", "filename": "P28_113_117_185938b727fc4271_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (5.2s). The yellow pepper subject disappears suddenly out of nowhere without any physical obstruction, removal, scene camera switching, or other triggering conditions. The object disappears with distortion, and there is no natural transition process of fading, blurring, or obstruction. It is completely disconnected from the physical logic of the scene and the camera movement, indicating an inter-frame disappearance fault.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08989", "filename": "P28_113_117_185938b727fc4271_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (1.9 seconds, a single pepper splits into two peppers without transition, showing a step jump in the number of entities between frames. 4.7 seconds, two peppers directly become four without transition, showing a surge in the number of entities between frames. 6.6 seconds, a green pepper suddenly undergoes a non-physical shape replacement, transforming directly into a single scallion without transition, showing a step jump in the entity attributes between frames.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08990", "filename": "P02_132_72_90ebc8379731a1ab_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.2s, there are no breadcrumbs below the character's grasp, but breadcrumbs appear out of thin air in their hand; at 1.5s, the character's hand has not yet touched the breadcrumbs, but the breadcrumbs automatically move into the character's hand; at 2.6s, there are breadcrumbs in the character's hand and then they disappear out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08991", "filename": "P02_132_72_90ebc8379731a1ab_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08992", "filename": "P02_132_72_90ebc8379731a1ab_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_08993", "filename": "P02_132_74_90326c3fd0540065_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08994", "filename": "P02_132_74_90326c3fd0540065_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 2.1s, the middle of the foil changes from a smooth state to a bulge, and when the foil is folded, a square object appears out of thin air in the middle of the foil).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08995", "filename": "P02_135_39_397941aa39c7e281_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.2s, without any external force or obstruction, two fruit slices appear out of thin air on the cutting board; at 1.8s, another fruit slice appears out of thin air from the right; at 3.4s, the knife and hand directly pass through the mold).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08996", "filename": "P02_135_39_397941aa39c7e281_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal because the timing is continuous (from 3.08 to 7.1 seconds, the object being cut is immediately formed into a neat circular shape, whereas the cutting method in the video cannot naturally produce a neat circular shape).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_08997", "filename": "P02_135_39_397941aa39c7e281_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.2s, the knife on the cutting board disappears out of thin air without the camera moving; at 2.6s, not only do several extra slices of the banana that were cut appear out of thin air, but the banana also automatically returns to its original shape at the cut marks).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_08998", "filename": "P02_135_103_1ca975adebe26b43_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_08999", "filename": "P02_135_103_1ca975adebe26b43_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09000", "filename": "P03_101_253_a48423214d68ef31_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.2s there is only a small dollop of butter on the blade, but the amount of butter spread on the bread suddenly increases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09001", "filename": "P03_101_253_a48423214d68ef31_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09003", "filename": "P03_101_266_77c1196dbb551ac2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09004", "filename": "P03_101_269_14f2f73073acf662_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the character makes the first cut at 0.8s, the cutting action is complete, but no cheese stick falls out).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09005", "filename": "P03_101_269_14f2f73073acf662_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2s, the hand and the knife go through the mold, which violates the principle that solids are impermeable, and the overall cutting action is stiff and unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09006", "filename": "P03_101_269_14f2f73073acf662_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (at 5.1s, without any camera movement or obstruction, a small portion of a cheese slice is flipped over and suddenly becomes a large slice of cheese).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09007", "filename": "P03_101_271_f03ab98004d6118b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.8s, a yellow square object is being cut, and without any camera movement, the yellow square object directly turns into a slice of cheese and is placed on the bread).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09008", "filename": "P03_101_283_d91dd050eb827ec7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3.7s, the action of the character tearing the packaging bag is too smooth, and the tearing action lacks a realistic sense of force and resistance).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09009", "filename": "P03_101_283_d91dd050eb827ec7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall, the visual experience is abnormal (at 2.9 seconds, after the character tears open the bag, they only lightly place their thumb on the packaging, yet the packaging automatically follows their finger and completes the tearing action, lacking realistic physical interaction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09010", "filename": "P03_101_312_c9e42a2d94d0e7ed_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 6.3s, the character only shook the clothes in their hand once, and the clothes suddenly fell to the ground, while the clothes in their hand inexplicably shrank)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09011", "filename": "P03_101_346_1e3963968ea9ace9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.2s, without any obstruction or camera movement, the two socks in the character's hands suddenly turn into a pair of underwear).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09012", "filename": "P03_101_346_1e3963968ea9ace9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09013", "filename": "P03_101_346_1e3963968ea9ace9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 6s, the process of the character folding the clothes is too smooth, and there is no obvious folding action, and the clothes are already folded).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09014", "filename": "P03_107_46_64b3fb4f929cdf32_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.8s, without any external force, the food in the pot appears to increase out of nowhere in the scene).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09015", "filename": "P03_107_46_64b3fb4f929cdf32_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09016", "filename": "P03_107_90_7086ece14cb81007_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (the foam in the rice cooker remained unchanged and did not dissipate at all, violating the physical law that foam should burst and disappear over time).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09017", "filename": "P03_107_90_7086ece14cb81007_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 4.2s, the spoon inside the rice cooker rotates automatically without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09018", "filename": "P03_109_21_9b257f00ba149c1a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09019", "filename": "P03_109_146_4788408f985894ae_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 5.8s, the hand and the faucet are clipped through each other, which violates the principle of impermeability of solids).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09020", "filename": "7cd96662ce0e73249ebe419773d5f39d8442f28ebf644c7ee7b518474022332c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal; the physical behavior is such that (the liquid in the scene is boiling, but the surface of the liquid is not rippled and no bubbles are generated at the bottom of the pot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09021", "filename": "7d22ef56254ba99efc2730341b473942fcf6e3d4dfc56e18b01daa665cfbdaae_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Causality (the wood in the video continues to burn without any change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09023", "filename": "7d73b8846bbd84a8d43b5fef96d3471a4d7ba79580a7c3e76f3866a1df2914bc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (clouds appear and increase out of nowhere at 0.7s below the video)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09024", "filename": "7d73b8846bbd84a8d43b5fef96d3471a4d7ba79580a7c3e76f3866a1df2914bc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09025", "filename": "7dec2725a239488dc76c4acfd290ae43e4179b5eeef6a8d27b93ccaadfb9721a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is due to physical behavior (the shock wave from the explosion at 2.6 seconds impacts surrounding objects, but the objects remain unchanged after passing through it, violating the principle of conservation of kinetic energy).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09026", "filename": "7e8aafd17a31aad51279eb97539bae1c36fda1eb2dfafd8085edd1f6c3606a14_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09027", "filename": "7e26512037c6b4613b06988bc22d266d17c5094e1f73b1b0ab6456ba2458114e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 1.6s, debris appears out of thin air around the camera when the subject turns around; at 2.1s, an object appears out of thin air below the subject when the subject turns around).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09028", "filename": "7e26512037c6b4613b06988bc22d266d17c5094e1f73b1b0ab6456ba2458114e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the image on the surface of the object below flickers when the head is turned).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09029", "filename": "7ee16b0ec9737b606249d18cf8f9f800c3861f6ad3731566364c2bc89dc0e96d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (at 2s, the white ball is hit slowly but moves rapidly, its potential energy increasing out of nowhere, violating the law of conservation of energy).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09030", "filename": "7ee16b0ec9737b606249d18cf8f9f800c3861f6ad3731566364c2bc89dc0e96d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (the white sphere in the lower right corner of the video abruptly changes at 3.1s, and the sphere in the upper right corner of the video abruptly changes at 5.1s); Unpredictable physics (the sphere in the middle of the video moves to the left without external force at 6.2s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09032", "filename": "7f61a2e7ed5a96cbb0ce533d81cdf183973d99f97017ebd0cd6d8135fd04d055_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09033", "filename": "7f61a2e7ed5a96cbb0ce533d81cdf183973d99f97017ebd0cd6d8135fd04d055_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the surface of the trees in the video flickers).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09034", "filename": "7faefd9fde982aaad45eb655248a7343eb96b631e78bbcc1228676535951a683_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09035", "filename": "08aaddd5db94f85999429efb9891ecef4a6654f001e653cbfa1bdb89e3a64c04_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the light from the burning flame in the video does not pass through the transparent glass but instead creates a mirror image, which does not conform to the straight-line propagation of light; at 4.8s, the wire in the upper right corner of the video penetrates the glass container, which violates the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09036", "filename": "8a552979c4d51ba1c55a713ec46f6b5c2dafea787f7b1443020125f0d6761245_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (1. In the middle of the 10s video, the gear did not touch the ball, yet the ball moved on its own without any external force; 2. At 17s, the gear did not roll, yet the ball moved on its own without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09037", "filename": "8ad0e016f4e7b4dc4699a3b22f00ab2d4d5aed7635a5df0f215e3cb805736643_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09038", "filename": "8adab147334ce0facb367cbddf053dfa01468fed631ec23b9ffafe37396bd870_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall anomaly (the surfaces of objects in the video are too smooth, unlike realistic images, lacking the smoothness and judder expected in real life).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09039", "filename": "8b7c0d0170da9bb8f5ddc4464f2324b1f9527db8ca1e96af0f1a22ae63c923a9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the ground image in the video flickers).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09040", "filename": "P23_102_13_29e622adb88f1bb3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Causal relationship (during the water impact from 1.3s to 1.9s, the shovel did not undergo displacement or attitude change under the external force of the water flow impact, thus breaking the dynamic causal relationship). Physical action (during the boiler's lifting process at 6.5s, the rice grains inside did not tilt or shift due to gravity, violating the coupled motion law of rigid bodies and particulate media).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09041", "filename": "P23_102_210_666f5800277fcb5c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Physical action (the cutting board begins to levitate without external force at 0.3s; the knife pierces the thumb at 3.3s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09042", "filename": "P23_102_274_f694e62c34037339_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Temporal continuity (At 2.1s, the cutting board suddenly appears in the lower left area of the towel without any movement or obstruction, disrupting the spatiotemporal continuity of the object's existence). Causality (At 2.2s, when chopping garlic, the knife-holding posture in the chopping action does not conform to effective ergonomic force application methods; the action and the target function have no reasonable causal relationship).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09043", "filename": "P23_102_364_ff143eed27b1114e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the knife pierces the character's finger at 0.9s, 3.3s, and 6.9s)", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09044", "filename": "P25_101_43_b827484e853feabc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the two pancakes become one at 2.5s), causal relationship (the fork is not on the object between 6.3s and 7.2s, but the object flips over with the fork), physical action (the pan moves on its own without external force between 4.6s and 4.9s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09045", "filename": "P25_101_57_f9b7a9f4a0e93071_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (between 5.6s and 6s, the geometric structure of the fork's teeth is missing without external force, representing an unexpected disappearance of a visual element.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09046", "filename": "P25_101_95_3cb1c063da24b3ba_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Inconsistent lighting (the shadow of the pot did not change as the camera moved).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09047", "filename": "P25_102_1_826a5b5a5d5742f4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the cabinet door fasteners separate within a continuous frame between 6.6s and 7.1s without external force, which does not conform to the spatiotemporal stability of the object's structure.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09048", "filename": "P25_103_108_a2b8d1a12b26393b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical effect (the fork did not penetrate the food at 1.3s, but the food moved with the fork).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09049", "filename": "P25_106_129_542975dabdc19076_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Physical Effects (At 0.9s, the left switch rotates without contact or external force input, violating the force-triggered principle of rigid body motion. At 0.9s, the flame and pot handle spatially overlap, exhibiting a solid-body penetration phenomenon, violating the principle of spatial exclusivity of matter. At 3.1s, the egg liquid, when poured, does not fall into the pot but directly acts on the flame area, with the fluid movement path significantly deviating from the intended target. At 3.6s, the flame extinguishes itself without being controlled by the switch, indicating a lack of reasonable triggering mechanism for energy release.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09050", "filename": "P25_106_136_7c1c4763f510e130_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09051", "filename": "P25_106_206_ec3effca98399bdb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (at 1.6s, the paper towel enters the egg mixture but is not soaked in the egg mixture).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09052", "filename": "P25_107_176_8f1ced3b4176360a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The sequence of events (0.7s-1s) shows a person wiping a fork with a tissue, but the tissue does not actually wipe the fork during this process.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09053", "filename": "P25_107_189_23cc153118e85013_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (2.4s, the tissue in the character's hand changes from one to two tissues).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09054", "filename": "P25_107_509_bff83b3812cbd19e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Physical action (the plate moves on its own without any force at 1.4s, and the water pipe automatically dispenses water without any external trigger at 4.3s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09055", "filename": "P26_103_37_02add290b4e82e2b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The timing is continuous (the sponge in the left hand disappears at 0.3s and suddenly reappears in the hand at 4.1s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09056", "filename": "P26_104_18_b6800c2d4f1109fb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (an item suddenly appears in the left hand at 7.6 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09057", "filename": "P26_104_61_dc344a6fdc53c62e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the character did not obtain the sausage at 0.8s, but a sausage appeared out of thin air in the character's hand at 1.2s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09058", "filename": "P26_104_101_4d6d3775a49ac84d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (one of the two plates that fell at 3.1 seconds disappeared).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09059", "filename": "P26_104_104_7c9dd17c6b2b645e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Continuous time (the white object suddenly disappears at 4.1s) Physical effects (the grill automatically retracts inwards without external force between 2.9s and 3s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09060", "filename": "P26_104_166_c94a305fb8c35bf1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the number of towels in the hand decreases at 1.5 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09061", "filename": "P26_105_20_af75ad464e718551_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Continuous timing (the video is static until 0.9s, then suddenly switches to a different scene at 0.9s) Physical effect (the nozzle spontaneously sprays liquid at 5.6s without any external force)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09062", "filename": "P26_105_46_077e7cf69ce1ccad_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical effect (the plate moves on its own without external force between 0.4s and 8s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09063", "filename": "P26_108_35_5f291453d270bd03_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical action (the white object in the right hand passes through the oven at 1.7s, and again at 6.9s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09064", "filename": "P26_112_72_fd6a3a94623b3d61_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (during the video from 0.1s to 3.4s, after the water flow is injected into the plate, no physically consistent wet marks or water stains appear on the plate surface; the visual characteristics of the fluid are discontinuous.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09065", "filename": "P26_115_35_412c7051789d86a6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Overall behavioral abnormality: (At 3s, the towel was not neatly folded, and the posture of holding the towel did not conform to the ergonomic norms of daily operation, which is a deviation between behavioral logic and functional goals.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09066", "filename": "P26_116_15_101de60b7e541986_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.1s, the knife in the character's hand suddenly turns into a fork)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09067", "filename": "P26_117_88_fbf9fcfd02854f70_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal human behavior (between 6.2s and 6.8s, the character suddenly points the fork at the stove and then puts it into the pot).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09068", "filename": "P26_118_26_7248997c5fc4c69b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (during the 0s-0.8s interval of the video, when the water flow impacts the pot, there is no stagnation or accumulation phenomenon that conforms to fluid dynamics; the fluid state is discontinuous.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09069", "filename": "P26_118_81_fdf9168b54dbe580_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the foam in the water did not change during the water flow) (at 1.9s and 2.5s, the person touched the blade, but the foam and water stains on the blade did not change).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09070", "filename": "P06_101_39_57e9b429eb0a763b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (at 2.2s, the cut onion flesh suddenly disappears; at 2.7s, the cut onion suddenly becomes whole again; at 5.3s, the outer shell of the onion held in the left hand suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09071", "filename": "P06_101_100_7c2fe1303fd11810_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (0.2s - end). Garlic mince suddenly appears out of thin air. At 1.6s, the item in the left hand suddenly turns into a garlic clove. At 4.8s, the garlic clove in the left hand suddenly disappears out of thin air.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09072", "filename": "P06_101_100_7c2fe1303fd11810_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (the amount of minced garlic being chopped increases progressively throughout the video; at 1.3 seconds, the object at the tip of the knife undergoes a sudden change, with the garlic clove skin turning into minced garlic out of thin air; at 2.6 seconds, the garlic clove skin next to the knife suddenly turns into a garlic clove and is chopped).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09073", "filename": "P06_101_101_5c8057486ecf0a0c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (at 0.8s, garlic slices appear out of thin air below the cleaver; at 1.6s, the brown object on the right side of the cleaver suddenly disappears; at 2.7s, the number of garlic slices pushed by the cleaver suddenly increases; at 3.7s, the brown object on the cutting board suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09074", "filename": "P06_101_101_5c8057486ecf0a0c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time sequence (at 0.4s, the garlic skin above the knife suddenly turns into garlic cloves; at 6.9s, garlic cloves suddenly appear out of thin air on the left hand). Causality (at 2s, the knife cuts out an item, but the item's volume does not change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09075", "filename": "P37_101_357_05336d13031a78f8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Continuous timing (the video suddenly changes direction at 1.8s, and the object below the knife tip suddenly disappears at 3.9s); Physical behavior (the left hand's fingers clip through the knife at 6.1s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09076", "filename": "P37_101_357_05336d13031a78f8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (items on the table suddenly change at 0.8s; the kitchen knife on the right hand suddenly disappears at 1.4s; an onion shell suddenly appears on the right index finger at 3.6s; the onion becomes whole again at 6.2s) Physical behavior (the left index finger clips through the kitchen knife at 5.9s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09077", "filename": "P37_102_61_05929ea498cb3950_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 1.8s, a carrot slice suddenly appears on the right side of the knife; at 2.7s, the carrot in the left hand suddenly turns into a carrot slice; at 2.8s, a carrot suddenly appears below the left hand; at 4.6s, the cut carrot suddenly turns into three slices). Physical behavior (at 4.4s, the finger clips through the knife).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09078", "filename": "P37_102_61_05929ea498cb3950_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (carrot slices suddenly appear on the right side of the knife at 1.7s; carrot scraps suddenly appear on the upper right side of the carrot at 2.6s; carrot slices suddenly appear on the left side of the knife at 3.4s; carrot slices suddenly appear at 4.7s). Physical anomalies (a thumb suddenly passes through a carrot at 6.1s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09079", "filename": "P37_102_61_05929ea498cb3950_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the carrot moves to the left without external force at 0s), Time continuity (the carrot suddenly becomes a whole at 0.3s, and the carrot on the right suddenly becomes a diced carrot at 3s), Causality (the carrot is cut at 6.1s, but no cut marks are visible).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09080", "filename": "P37_102_77_4ad2e573398bc280_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Time sequence (a second carrot suddenly appears on the cutting board at 0.4s; the carrot in front of the knife suddenly disappears at 0.6s; a second carrot suddenly appears in the bowl at 1.5s; a second carrot suddenly appears on the cutting board at 3.1s) Physical behavior (the cutting board moves to the right without external force at 2.4s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09081", "filename": "P37_102_89_52322bc1d032c9df_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Physical action (at 0s, the carrot under the bowl moves to the left without external force; at 0.8s, the carrot to the left of the knife moves with the knife without external force) and continuous time (at 2.3s, the carrot to the right of the knife undergoes a sudden change, its shape suddenly becoming larger).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09083", "filename": "P37_102_101_08455f59502f13da_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Time continuity (the shape of the cleaver suddenly changes at 0.1s; the volume of the carrot on the left suddenly shrinks at 6.2s); Physical behavior (the bowl of carrot shreds also rises when the fingers pick it up at 7.6s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09084", "filename": "P37_102_114_293e812131e7a810_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The timing is continuous (at 2.3s, the amount of carrot scraps suddenly increases; at 2.8s, carrot scraps suddenly appear on the left side of the knife; at 7.5s, the carrot strip picked up by the right hand suddenly disappears into the air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09085", "filename": "P37_102_142_e1e5c5dda1d07fbd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Continuous time (at 0.2s, the carrot scraps on the right suddenly increase; at 0.5s, the carrots below the left hand twist; at 2s, the carrots on the left hand increase; at 3.4s, the carrots below the left hand suddenly increase). Physical behavior (at 3.6s, the cutting board moves to the right without external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09086", "filename": "P37_102_142_e1e5c5dda1d07fbd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.1s, the carrots on the left suddenly decrease and carrot slices suddenly appear on the knife; at 3.3s, carrot shreds suddenly appear below the knife).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09087", "filename": "P37_103_3_f21d5ed2d345d569_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual inconsistency (the chicken leg in the video lacks texture, shape, and lifelikeness); Time continuity (the torn chicken skin suddenly disappears at 4.8s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09088", "filename": "P37_103_3_f21d5ed2d345d569_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.2s, the chicken leg suddenly turns into chicken skin; at 6.1s, the torn chicken skin suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09089", "filename": "P37_103_28_2e2f23de7a52c55a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The timing is continuous (at 3.8s, the torn chicken leg meat suddenly disappears; at 5.7s, the chicken leg suddenly shrinks; at 6.6s, chicken meat suddenly appears in the right hand).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09090", "filename": "P37_103_28_2e2f23de7a52c55a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time sequence (at 0.6s, the left thumb suddenly merges with the chicken meat; at 0.8s, the chicken leg in the right hand suddenly disappears; at 3.4s, the chicken meat in the left hand suddenly turns into chicken bones; at 5.3s, the several chicken legs in the right hand suddenly become one).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09091", "filename": "P37_103_34_11f9f31a233661ec_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time sequence (1.6s: chicken bone in left hand turns into chicken meat; 2.4s: bone in right hand turns into chicken meat; 3.7s: bones in bowl undergo a sudden change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09092", "filename": "P37_103_34_11f9f31a233661ec_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 2.4s, the falling chicken suddenly disappears; at 5.1s, the chicken in the right hand suddenly increases; at 6.9s, the connected chicken suddenly disappears and breaks apart).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09093", "filename": "P37_103_35_4cfa29d0feec755a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the chicken that fell into the right bowl at 1.6s suddenly becomes whole again; the chicken that fell into the right bowl at 3.4s suddenly becomes whole again).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09094", "filename": "P37_103_35_4cfa29d0feec755a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.2s, the chicken in the hand suddenly shrinks in size; at 2.9s, the torn chicken lacks texture; at 5.6s, chicken scraps suddenly appear above the bowl on the right).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09095", "filename": "P37_103_42_5f6effc318fb1e63_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the shape of the chicken leg in the hand changes at 1s); Physical behavior (the bowl moves upwards without external force at 2.9s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09096", "filename": "P37_103_42_5f6effc318fb1e63_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the chicken bone suddenly disappears at 3.3s, the chicken meat in the right hand suddenly grows larger at 5.1s, and the chicken meat placed in the bowl suddenly becomes round at 7.4s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09097", "filename": "P37_103_46_99b4f4ad41805f07_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The timing is continuous (at 1.9s, the shape of the chicken in the right hand changes; at 3.5s, the shape of the chicken in the left hand suddenly changes and becomes a chicken leg).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09098", "filename": "P37_103_52_f9abd6779dfbb113_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 0.7s, a piece of meat suddenly appears out of thin air in the right hand; at 2.5s, the piece of meat thrown out by the right hand suddenly disappears in mid-air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09099", "filename": "P37_103_52_f9abd6779dfbb113_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time sequence (at 0.4s, the piece of meat in the right hand suddenly disappears; at 3.2s, a bone suddenly appears in the sink under the plate) Causality (at 3.3s, the piece of meat in the right plate suddenly flies off the plate without any external force)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09100", "filename": "P02_129_174_87c72cf1a33b1a74_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 6.3s, without any obstruction or transition, the knife in the character's hand disappears out of thin air when the character opens the cabinet).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09101", "filename": "P02_129_354_7137e79e5c8230ae_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09102", "filename": "P02_129_431_460d10ba56f5463e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 0.3s, the lid's shape changes from ellipse to circle, and its color changes from white to light gray;) Physical behavior (at 2.1s, the cup in the character's hand merges with the cup on the table, violating the principle that objects cannot be penetrated, and then a cup appears out of thin air in the character's hand)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09103", "filename": "P02_129_431_460d10ba56f5463e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is inconsistent (at 6.4s, there were originally only three cookies in the video, but the number of cookies suddenly increased without any action being taken; at 0.2s, the material of the blender lid suddenly changed from transparent glass to a gel-like cup, which is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09104", "filename": "P02_130_93_8ca598927b7a8e87_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 1.9s, the lid automatically adheres to the bottle opening without contact or external force, violating the law of gravity). Time continuity (at 3s, when the character picks up the lid, the power cord breaks without external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09105", "filename": "P02_130_93_8ca598927b7a8e87_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.06, a lid suddenly appears out of nowhere on the character's right-hand handle; this type of grinder usually requires manual operation to close).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09106", "filename": "P02_130_127_ecc4bf8c5d21e844_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 5.5s, the character did not press the switch, but the grinder stopped automatically. Then the character pressed the switch again, and the grinder only rotated once before stopping, which does not conform to its operating logic).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09107", "filename": "P02_130_244_6e451e0f7f5f0662_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 1.4s, the cup was initially full of food, but the amount of food gradually decreased without any external force) Physical behavior (at 2.9s, the box, without being tilted, began to leak liquid from its interior, and the amount of liquid leaking out kept increasing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09108", "filename": "P02_130_244_6e451e0f7f5f0662_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 5s, some of the liquid dug out by the character automatically flowed back into the box, violating the law of gravity; at 3.2s, the liquid dug out did not flow smoothly and its shape was too stiff, which does not conform to the natural physical properties of liquid).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09109", "filename": "P02_130_244_6e451e0f7f5f0662_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Cause and effect (the butter foamed as soon as it was put into the pot at 3.4s. Butter needs to be heated and melted first, and then it will foam due to high temperature after a period of time).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09110", "filename": "P02_130_326_e37db68c3e5d0b78_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.9s, without any transition, half of the pulled-out foil disappears into thin air; at 1.4s, after the character pulls open the foil, the amount of foil remaining is noticeably less).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09111", "filename": "P02_130_326_e37db68c3e5d0b78_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 4.1s, the foil is flipped face up and then opened, but it is still face up, violating the logic that an object flipped over must be face down). Time continuity: (at 4s, when the foil is flipped and put down, the right hand is not holding the foil, but the foil is still on the table, and there is no natural connection between the character's hand and the foil).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09112", "filename": "P02_131_8_85056be09c5edc9c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 7.7s, the person dries their hands but doesn't hang the towel properly; instead, the towel hangs automatically on the rack, violating the physical principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09113", "filename": "P02_131_8_85056be09c5edc9c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.3s, without any transition, a striped towel suddenly becomes a striped towel; at 2.7s, without any obstruction, the towel automatically folds and hangs up while the character is simply rubbing it).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09114", "filename": "P02_131_14_6004236093653ee0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Continuous time (the footage shows minced meat being kneaded, and without any external force or camera obstruction, the amount of minced meat in the bowl keeps increasing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09115", "filename": "P02_131_18_3dc04972743308ee_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09116", "filename": "P02_131_18_3dc04972743308ee_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 6.3s, without any obstruction or camera movement, the bowl suddenly turns into a plastic bag).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09117", "filename": "P02_131_263_c1ea19c1b314a945_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (at 1.2s, the railing with the towel hanging is suspended in mid-air, violating the law of gravity; at 3.5s, the railing and towel are in an upright position and do not undergo free fall).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09118", "filename": "P02_131_263_c1ea19c1b314a945_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09119", "filename": "P02_131_263_c1ea19c1b314a945_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 6.6s, the bottom of the bread in the image is flat, then suddenly becomes round).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09120", "filename": "P02_132_41_747bf80a4bea6e46_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09121", "filename": "P02_132_41_747bf80a4bea6e46_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09122", "filename": "P02_132_42_9d5f47b6ed7515b0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09123", "filename": "P02_132_47_5e1684ba8ba72e19_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity: At 2.1 seconds, without any camera transition, the character's hand and the knife merge together.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09124", "filename": "P02_132_47_5e1684ba8ba72e19_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 2.3s, the character's finger directly pierces through the knife, violating the physical property that objects are impermeable in reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09125", "filename": "P02_132_48_535fdc1538602fb6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect (at 1.2s, the cutter has not yet completely cut into the object, but the object already shows a complete cut surface, lacking the sense of abruptness that should be present in a real cutting process).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09126", "filename": "P02_132_48_535fdc1538602fb6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09127", "filename": "P02_132_48_535fdc1538602fb6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 7.1s, after the knife cuts the bread, without any external force being applied, the bread slice splits into two).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09128", "filename": "P02_132_50_c00ad0131a3d748f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 2.2s, when the knife moves in the scene, the knife is invisible, sometimes appearing and sometimes disappearing; at the same time, a piece of bread appears out of nowhere on the knife).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09129", "filename": "P02_132_50_c00ad0131a3d748f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09130", "filename": "P27_103_123_02b39c32267d2934_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (at 0.2s, the shape of the paper cup's opening twists without external force, and at 2.4s, the egg begins to crack without any force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09131", "filename": "P27_103_123_02b39c32267d2934_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 2.6 seconds, an egg without cracks automatically opens when touched by the left thumb).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09132", "filename": "P27_103_123_02b39c32267d2934_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (an egg appears out of thin air in the character's right hand at 2.1s, an egg appears out of thin air in the character's left hand at 2.6s, there is no transition at 3.4s, and the two eggs merge into one at 3.6s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09133", "filename": "P27_103_163_656193dc8209b850_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the person in the video is not holding the machine with their fingers, the machine is suspended in the air and does not have free fall motion, which violates the law of universal gravitation).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09134", "filename": "P27_103_163_656193dc8209b850_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is inconsistent (at 6.2 seconds, while egg liquid is being beaten in the bowl, before the egg liquid is broken, a large amount of white foamy cream suddenly appears, which is inconsistent with the preceding and following moments).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09135", "filename": "P27_103_170_757d61026a0d2926_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the amount of yellow liquid poured out between 0.5s and 3.6s is disproportionate to the amount of liquid in the pot, and suddenly increases; at 3.7s, yellow liquid drips out of nowhere from the edge of the pot).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09136", "filename": "P27_103_226_b7257fa7a5361777_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09137", "filename": "P27_103_229_bc2c22febe8deb7e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (from the start to 2.3s, the blender is working but the liquid in the bowl remains stable, and the blender can stand upright without support, which violates Newton's first law).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09138", "filename": "P27_103_229_bc2c22febe8deb7e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the blender is working throughout the video, but the liquid in the bowl remains stationary, which does not conform to the law of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09139", "filename": "P27_103_229_bc2c22febe8deb7e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (at 5.4s, the finger passes through the handle of the mixer, and from the beginning to 3.7s, the hand does not touch the mixer and the mixer moves on its own).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09140", "filename": "P27_103_232_3489e7563304b790_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timeline is discontinuous (abrupt). At 3.6 seconds, the character in the scene pours flour into the liquid, and the amount of flour in the bowl increases automatically, which is inconsistent with the preceding and following scenes.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09141", "filename": "P27_103_232_3489e7563304b790_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.8s, the character did not touch the mixer, but the mixer handle moved into the character's hand, violating Newton's First Law).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09142", "filename": "P27_103_267_77c7ee7cfd405336_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (abrupt change). A character in the scene is holding a bag. At 2.9 seconds, text slowly appears on the bag, and the bag changes from empty to full of flour.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09143", "filename": "P27_103_302_ed68936ca5181def_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.3s, the liquid in the bowl flows into the pot, but the surface of the liquid in the pot remains stable and still, without any corresponding increase in volume).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09144", "filename": "P27_103_302_ed68936ca5181def_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 4.7s to 8s, the liquid did not pour into the hollow part of the pot, but seeped into the pot from both sides, passing through the solid and causing a molding phenomenon. In addition, the hollow part of the pot has a bottom, which is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09145", "filename": "P27_103_325_8ae110a8160c8d46_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The screen showed an anomaly: at 2.9 seconds, the whisk stick on the egg beater detached from the screen without leaving any trace or hole, which does not conform to the principle of solid bonding.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09146", "filename": "P27_103_339_f48ebe4109b0fb44_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09147", "filename": "P27_103_411_726af87904b4e0c4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (abrupt change). At 3 seconds, a plug suddenly appears in the character's hand, and the character inserts the plug into a red solid object, which has no socket. The plug is still inserted.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09148", "filename": "P27_103_411_726af87904b4e0c4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09149", "filename": "P27_103_411_726af87904b4e0c4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.7s, the wire suddenly unravels, and the originally long wire becomes tangled together, then becomes a short and straight wire, which is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09150", "filename": "P27_103_482_3cceff37c0d6a628_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (abrupt changes); from 0s to 0.5s, the fork in the character's hand transforms into a stirring stick; at 1.9s, the water in the plate suddenly disappears, showing inconsistencies.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09151", "filename": "P27_103_482_3cceff37c0d6a628_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09152", "filename": "P27_103_547_0d0eb2e59b8b01d1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timeline is discontinuous (abruptly changes). Between 1.6s and 2s, a squid leg suddenly appears out of thin air in the hand and then disappears; the sequence is inconsistent.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09153", "filename": "P27_103_547_0d0eb2e59b8b01d1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is discontinuous (abrupt); at 2 seconds, the squid that was supposed to be in the hand does not change position with the hand and remains still, resulting in an uncoordinated and rigid visual.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09154", "filename": "P27_103_666_4f6a2b839d6e1e88_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09155", "filename": "P27_103_666_4f6a2b839d6e1e88_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (abrupt). There is only one towel hanging on the wall. After it is pulled down at 3.8s, there are two towels. One is in the hand and the other is on the wall.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09156", "filename": "P27_104_23_43be3c5020ee9e16_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09157", "filename": "P27_104_23_43be3c5020ee9e16_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09158", "filename": "P27_104_25_1bb84dd239f33d4c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (from 3.7s to 5s, the items on the table, refrigerator and stove in the room suddenly disappear, and the previously scattered sections of the stove surface automatically splice together and close without any transition, eventually forming a regular square surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09159", "filename": "P27_104_26_7a5c834a84d04c30_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09160", "filename": "P02_121_11_bf59d17382c3b41d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (at 6.2 seconds, before the scissors even touched the bottom of the cardboard box, the box suddenly broke apart out of thin air without any external force, and the falling cardboard fragments also disappeared out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09161", "filename": "P02_121_40_934595e1d8681715_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.6 seconds in the video, a piece of paper inexplicably appears above the box).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09162", "filename": "P02_121_41_ce72f033c32fe2dc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09163", "filename": "P02_121_41_ce72f033c32fe2dc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 4.7s, the figure did not touch the lower right corner of the box during the pressing process, but the paper at the bottom stuck to the box on its own, which does not conform to the natural state under the action of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09164", "filename": "P02_121_46_9094d99d7b991bce_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09165", "filename": "P02_121_47_ef3a0792a59ca8d9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.1s, a small corner appears out of nowhere on the clip; at 2.9s, a clip appears out of nowhere on the left side of the cardboard box without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09166", "filename": "P02_121_47_ef3a0792a59ca8d9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (a sudden change occurs at 0.1s when the clip on the left hand disappears out of thin air; at 3.6s, a blue clip appears out of thin air on the right hand without any transition, and then at 4.6s, another blue clip appears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09167", "filename": "P02_121_49_4b8a76ab4b42193d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.2s, the clip in the character's right hand merges with another clip, and then suddenly disappears without any external force or obstruction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09168", "filename": "P02_121_49_4b8a76ab4b42193d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09169", "filename": "P02_121_49_4b8a76ab4b42193d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.5s, the blue pen in the character's hand abruptly transforms into a clip without any transition, while the silver clip on the table suddenly disappears without any obstruction or external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09170", "filename": "P02_121_70_f4ae32588f42fb6a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 0s, the hand did not touch the basin, yet the basin was suspended in the air on its own, violating the laws of gravity). Time continuity (at 0.7s, a white shovel appeared out of nowhere without any transition, and at 4.7s, the scene transitioned from a white spoon to a silver spoon, showing obvious composite effects).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09171", "filename": "P02_121_87_e234149d2007c730_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 4.8s, the clip in the lower right corner deforms and twists without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09172", "filename": "P02_121_87_e234149d2007c730_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the movement of the spoon abruptly changes at 0.3s, lacking a natural transition before and after the movement, resulting in a noticeable composite effect).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09173", "filename": "P02_122_162_22ab21fd3c87b1e5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.7s, the number of carrots in the plate suddenly increases without any external force or obstruction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09174", "filename": "P02_122_199_a52d17d357caa51c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the pot is upside down in the video, and the non-sticky food inside is not falling freely, which violates the laws of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09175", "filename": "P02_122_199_a52d17d357caa51c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09176", "filename": "P02_122_199_a52d17d357caa51c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is inconsistent (a sudden change occurs at 1.4 seconds; the quantity of scrambled eggs with tomatoes in the pan suddenly increases without any external force or obstruction).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09177", "filename": "P02_123_19_fe6c9949542039dc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (an abrupt change occurs at 1.4s, and a yellow glove appears out of thin air on the character's right hand without any transitional movement).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09178", "filename": "P02_123_89_5fe576cc8ebc0c2b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Physical behavior (at 2.6s, the packaging bag suddenly and illogically ruptured without any external force tearing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09179", "filename": "P02_123_89_5fe576cc8ebc0c2b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: physical behavior (at 6 seconds, the flour exploded out of thin air without any ignition source or external disturbance, which violates the laws of physics).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09180", "filename": "P02_123_119_6e40cb775869fbca_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 2.8s, the amount of green food in the bowl suddenly increases without any external force or obstruction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09181", "filename": "P02_123_119_6e40cb775869fbca_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09182", "filename": "P02_123_170_62151ae4407b843f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.1s, without any external force or obstruction in the pot, green food appears out of nowhere on the spoon).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09183", "filename": "P02_123_170_62151ae4407b843f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09184", "filename": "P02_123_210_1fb8a7d871b343d1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (at 1.9 seconds, the yellow glove on the left disappears out of thin air without any obstruction or camera movement).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09185", "filename": "P02_123_210_1fb8a7d871b343d1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.4s, a glove appears out of thin air on the left hand without any camera cut; at 3.7s, the number of bowls in the sink suddenly increases without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09186", "filename": "P02_123_251_d2fcffd728703f9d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (at 1.4s, the sponge did not touch the dirt in the bowl, and the dirt disappeared out of thin air without any lens or obstruction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09187", "filename": "P02_124_79_dc7bc50033f3e196_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (there is no transition of perspective at 1.7s, and an extra socket appears out of nowhere at the point where the cable is).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09188", "filename": "P02_129_150_595e20947c511dff_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video feed is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.2 seconds, the stove's power button was not there before it was covered with a towel, and then it suddenly appeared).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09189", "filename": "P02_129_174_87c72cf1a33b1a74_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.3s, without any camera cut, the knife on the cutting board automatically floats into the character's hand; at 2.9s, without any transition, the items on the table are completely different from those in the previous scene; at 4.1s, the cabinet door opens, and two cabinet doors illogically merge into one).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09190", "filename": "P26_119_15_8b6e1dc2a9149e7e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the screen freezes at 6.9 seconds, after which a spatula appears out of thin air in the character's hand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09191", "filename": "P26_124_18_6f3da8e1e9b04009_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the water jet colliding with the hand in the scene does not cause any splashing, which does not conform to the interaction principle. The faucet is on from 0s to 5.7s, but the water in the dish does not change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09192", "filename": "P26_124_48_bcf2ac1827238562_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (four sausages appear out of nowhere in the jar at 0.1s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09193", "filename": "P26_124_50_f24bba4d74c15a69_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Continuous time (water is constantly flowing into the bowl in the video, but the water level in the bowl does not change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09194", "filename": "P26_124_100_b107dbfd7b20ef0f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the container on the left side of the screen is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09195", "filename": "P26_124_109_ceacc153e2049885_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time changes abruptly (at 2.1 seconds, the oval leaf in the character's hand changes into a clover shape).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09196", "filename": "P26_124_125_16187705b9b44950_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (at 2.6s, a water column appears out of thin air above the container and pours water into the container, but no water appears inside the container).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09197", "filename": "P26_124_145_632be6e8c4c72089_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the water column in the image penetrates the palm between 0s and 3.9s)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09198", "filename": "P26_124_153_58096bdc8e2a287e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09199", "filename": "P27_101_78_345db36e71f5e99d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (circular white spots appear out of nowhere on the cabinet between 3.1s and 3.6s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09200", "filename": "P27_101_142_7ff8a6cd9823c190_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly in the footage: The timing is continuous (from 0.6s to 8s, the foam on the character's fingers is not washed away by the water flow; in real life, the foam from washing dishes and utensils is easily rinsed off).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09201", "filename": "P27_101_248_8da7574dd509bf6c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a water column appears out of thin air above the faucet in 2.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09202", "filename": "P27_101_328_75124dd5ea9de035_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09203", "filename": "P27_101_371_6aaaeb5d96d11adf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the towel in the video appears to be of varying sizes from 0.3s to 8s.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09204", "filename": "P27_103_46_86b57c1c31019182_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09205", "filename": "P27_103_163_656193dc8209b850_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the white bag in the upper right corner of the screen is flashing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09206", "filename": "P27_103_170_757d61026a0d2926_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: At 1.7 seconds, the egg beater in the video started rotating without any external interference.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09207", "filename": "P27_103_226_b7257fa7a5361777_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09208", "filename": "P27_103_232_3489e7563304b790_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09209", "filename": "P27_103_267_77c7ee7cfd405336_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the candy packet in the 3.6s frame is opened without any external force)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09210", "filename": "P27_103_274_c906550dd90ad640_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09211", "filename": "P27_103_339_f48ebe4109b0fb44_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09212", "filename": "P27_103_377_c5f148db506231de_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09213", "filename": "P27_103_482_3cceff37c0d6a628_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09214", "filename": "P27_104_21_d82f1eabb0a8159a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (packaged food inside the refrigerator moves without any external force at 1.9s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09215", "filename": "P27_104_25_1bb84dd239f33d4c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (0.2s, the towel in the character's hand turns into a water cup)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09216", "filename": "P27_104_26_7a5c834a84d04c30_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The video feed is continuous (there is no smooth transition between the two frames at 2.1s and 3s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09217", "filename": "P27_104_116_c404ded844b3a3a5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: Continuous time display (flickering on the desktop).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09218", "filename": "P27_104_145_7325cbbfe99440c3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the gray towel in the character's hand disappears at 2.4 seconds)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09219", "filename": "P27_104_255_93554b15de52d053_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09220", "filename": "6757335057b82c5b22f52ce02590bc1913ebce5030d7b3936b0509fe8e9caa22_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (after 4.7s, the liquid drawn into the syringe in the display becomes transparent; after 1s-1.9s, the liquid in the beaker rises instead of falling after being drawn into the syringe).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09221", "filename": "9933058110d2b51baed8fb556a6419e9c8c473637adca595178ca05b0669ed0e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is continuous (the burning cardboard box shows no change, violating the principles of combustion; the ground in the video is abnormally distorted)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09222", "filename": "10902171236ad0c0584285eb78d4f9c68946da1fdeee43537180c393d37dd7bb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09223", "filename": "18334341676fa40ea1aac660518e74c8365258bd1606a03a3fc386c3599cbc24_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (nothing on the grass in the distance explodes out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09225", "filename": "09056677926468626304dbe4f82f17f2491094bf6e9a5a54f037c9f800844f9c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (abnormal twisting appears inside the damaged bowling pin that has been squeezed).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09226", "filename": "a0ba97f840f2f73bba5ce2d633d1c18ef6d490d161fec4ff8a80c55a0bf82f47_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09228", "filename": "a2c2648c1109f395fcfe68fc86ca156843337d75b4333ed0f21eed36064e169f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09229", "filename": "a2d7abccc00a87d3e97d346678e75071df9fe9367d718112deb2a3c62187250b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the first car disappears from the rearview mirror at 4.8s but does not overtake the current car, which is illogical; the road in the rearview mirror is inconsistent with the road outside the car window).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09231", "filename": "a4e22238e6cf9ff10ccbd1473a46b84b23db09654e8e76e89a0361f6a0781262_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09232", "filename": "a5f306603b17359110b64f7c01ded4987f03e30169fb8be196d096c0fc092009_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09233", "filename": "a6b3fab3df6b79ab94fd1f6c11f8dbdfa0890c01fc7d9edce569c102c1cdcb9d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09234", "filename": "a6b86e9e1d962d8cf68a8b3c4635b1ec8ee5f3994c884cb36065ee70533da99a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (objects in the video exhibit abnormal twisting and writhing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09235", "filename": "a6ce6a49604c7942ebe4b3f25c1a701dd258a9797b337f67ffa73a521c25e000_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the entire container and desktop in the image are abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09236", "filename": "a7a261e82dd674eee87ecf421bcd63c7bea73b42e024ed88002dbdec18756203_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09237", "filename": "a7b5cf04a8c7dbe20e622b1086aa5037dc08dbb9286cc1f7acb0ad8aad9d0dc2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (7.7s-7.9s: the lower right corner of the rubber band suddenly disappears; 7.9s-7.9s: the lower right corner of the rubber band moves left and right out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09238", "filename": "a7cc9fff1f9bc695013b30f1e5dc8119fb9933c305f38906ee03d337e188900c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous timing (the entire image appears pixelated and blurry).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09239", "filename": "a8c072fd498b978602b0a0fcbd5523a57167732bcc69f1e691e21fbc97e42e4f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (0.6s: finger picks up the magnet without touching it; magnet next to left thumb slides down without external force) Time continuity (2.4s: magnet appears out of thin air under right index finger; index finger disappears by one segment at 3.2s)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09240", "filename": "a8cffe72c3091f5aba63b4f3eb3c535bdec8be1188474a864330c64da9338c6a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09243", "filename": "a9f5b3778a34decd37de77b3bda0f015be1b2da4f57e92470605b78fdcbf03d6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time sequence is continuous (at 4.9s, one row of magnets disappears from the two rows, and at 6.5s, the magnet in the hand splits into multiple rows).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09244", "filename": "a9f00967fc84763d19671658b11982270b9f0b4512e1ecf30b96a1ed5d67f024_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity (overall abnormal distortion of the image).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09246", "filename": "a35c4c76e547a46918fcad79c443864fb54d050f7716e068e84d0164659f051c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09247", "filename": "a51adf5a456018ae07832eed75363afe46ec67788ee37cfa3a54aaafbb365223_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are unusual: The overall visuals are not normal (the birds in the video move too smoothly, and the first bird to fly by flies in a U-shape, lacking the characteristic features of a bird and not like a realistic scene).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09248", "filename": "a51d73ab18c05b8d9760e48fba594f512b050916b27f923e6c0fa5c3d9456ecc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09249", "filename": "a53c0e1abcd6bb73172b36347354529c6453851b989c482795ddd14f0400627e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Temporal continuity (ground texture shows slight distortion and creeping).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09250", "filename": "3d4cc28c5ff9eb03170752f1c042933b4ba1cd23280543dfe5e78d336223cd5a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly: (Throughout the video, the dominoes move erratically and over a large area without any external force.) Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly: (At the beginning of the 1.8s frame, the white block exhibits twitching, flickering, and merging phenomena during its movement.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09251", "filename": "3d4cc28c5ff9eb03170752f1c042933b4ba1cd23280543dfe5e78d336223cd5a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical anomaly: (The dominoes in the video move erratically over a large area without being subjected to any external force. At 2.8 seconds, the white blocks begin to twitch, flicker, and merge.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09252", "filename": "3d4cc28c5ff9eb03170752f1c042933b4ba1cd23280543dfe5e78d336223cd5a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical anomaly: (Starting at 1s, dominoes began to fall and move in large numbers without being subjected to any external force)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09253", "filename": "3d4d769ceb8b4804c9455111f9f8ba8dd81376d0a08fc7bc33729a60353f0348_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in visuals: Abnormalities in physical behavior: (The water ripples in the video change in a regular pattern, without the natural feeling of wind blowing, and the grass and branches in the video should be swaying in the wind. The tree on the left side of the video, which is static, keeps showing a shadow that flickers.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09254", "filename": "3d4d769ceb8b4804c9455111f9f8ba8dd81376d0a08fc7bc33729a60353f0348_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical anomalies: (The water ripples in the image change in a regular pattern, lacking a natural sense of being blown by the wind; the branches of the large tree in the center of the image remain still, while the plants next to it sway in the wind.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09255", "filename": "3d4d769ceb8b4804c9455111f9f8ba8dd81376d0a08fc7bc33729a60353f0348_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical anomalies: (The water ripples in the image change in a regular pattern, lacking the natural feel of wind; the branches of the large tree in the center of the image remain still, while the plants next to it sway in the wind.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09256", "filename": "3d4d769ceb8b4804c9455111f9f8ba8dd81376d0a08fc7bc33729a60353f0348_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical anomaly: (The water ripples in the video exhibit a regular pattern, lacking the natural feel of being dispersed by wind.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09257", "filename": "3d28eb5307024a83a032cf3431176fca36ea92ef8979b59544bbd66adc9aa25e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (the water ripples near the shore in the video flow opposite to the mainstream flow, and the overall image flickers).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09258", "filename": "3d28eb5307024a83a032cf3431176fca36ea92ef8979b59544bbd66adc9aa25e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09259", "filename": "3d55f9fc94d3cb459ec7a5ebb10b7d4978d197a8836fff9c1e59991f95911c99_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to abnormal physical behavior (the video is a time-lapse video, but the sun in the video does not rise or set; it remains stationary, and the color of the light emitted by the sun does not change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09260", "filename": "3d55f9fc94d3cb459ec7a5ebb10b7d4978d197a8836fff9c1e59991f95911c99_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (the sun's position did not change much in the time-lapse video, but it changed to a sunset state at 4.8 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09261", "filename": "3d55f9fc94d3cb459ec7a5ebb10b7d4978d197a8836fff9c1e59991f95911c99_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: chaotic physical behavior and movement (the clouds at the top and bottom of the screen move in opposite directions and the timing is abnormal; at 0.5s, a white object floating on the sea surface disappears into thin air without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09262", "filename": "3d55f9fc94d3cb459ec7a5ebb10b7d4978d197a8836fff9c1e59991f95911c99_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.9s in the video, the bird flying on the cruise ship on the left side of the screen disappears into thin air without any external interference; at 3.2s, a blurry image appears above the cruise ship).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09263", "filename": "3d71b4bfa0bba54fe1dd0af02e2e0e67a0a45e4bfdef47023cc72242221e482a_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09267", "filename": "3d835553966d97c40b19ff502100a1008caddb936237917c560034493c005762_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior anomaly (in the scene, without any external force, the amplitude of the character's hand rotation is disproportionately large compared to the amplitude of the gem's rotation).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09268", "filename": "3d835553966d97c40b19ff502100a1008caddb936237917c560034493c005762_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity anomaly: (At 0.5s in the video, the gem in the hand suddenly changed from a transparent blue gem to an opaque blue gem without any change in the camera angle.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09269", "filename": "3d835553966d97c40b19ff502100a1008caddb936237917c560034493c005762_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09270", "filename": "3debc85f5347d18f2ce6d056c51ccfcf2cd42302ea145733efb96af692222dd9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly: (The trees, lakes, and grass on the mountains in the video show flickering and jerking artifacts.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09271", "filename": "3debc85f5347d18f2ce6d056c51ccfcf2cd42302ea145733efb96af692222dd9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (the grass and trees are constantly swaying and moving in the wind throughout the video, but ripples only appear on the lake surface at 1.7 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09272", "filename": "3debc85f5347d18f2ce6d056c51ccfcf2cd42302ea145733efb96af692222dd9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09273", "filename": "3debc85f5347d18f2ce6d056c51ccfcf2cd42302ea145733efb96af692222dd9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09274", "filename": "3e4ce726cc7f462820e2f4c57445e1879dd5c334b92995b782b6fce43dc90db9_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Abnormal physical behavior (throughout the video, the purple ball inside the transparent tank moves on its own without any external interference, and the water inside the tank is also constantly flowing dynamically).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09275", "filename": "3e4ce726cc7f462820e2f4c57445e1879dd5c334b92995b782b6fce43dc90db9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning due to a continuity issue (in the video, when the purple sphere sinks at 0.1 seconds, the water level in the tank should rise as the sphere's weight compresses it downwards, but in the video, the water level drops as the sphere falls).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09276", "filename": "3e4ce726cc7f462820e2f4c57445e1879dd5c334b92995b782b6fce43dc90db9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Abnormal physical behavior (at 3.9s in the video, the purple sphere suddenly moves significantly to the right from a stationary state without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09280", "filename": "f8eb3646b949a4f8663aeaa3a2445326ba528f6e7146639500c10bd8ed6523cb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the straw passes through the cup at 0.8s, and the bottom of the straw passes through the bottom of the cup between 1.2s and 1.7s, indicating a clear clipping problem, which violates the principle that objects are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09281", "filename": "f8fb4682ea7236568d58f82cc885658092314aab54a6f742845e2644cf236826_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (a fast-moving vehicle suddenly appears in the lower left corner between 0.9s and 1s in the video, and between 1.1s and 6.1s in the video, the clouds that were separated at the top of the screen quickly disperse and merge with the clouds below, as if the video has been sped up, which is obviously inconsistent with the movement speed of the surrounding clouds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09282", "filename": "f9eeeb0f7c828e1919fc4cd4a443b15be34a852102154522b4390abfb415b027_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous in time (the amount of snowflakes in the upper left corner of the illuminated area is abnormally small, causing the snowflakes in the middle of the video to appear out of nowhere, while the snowflakes in the lower right corner of the video suddenly decrease and disappear. The snowflakes in the video fall steadily and at a uniform speed. Under such airflow, the melting speed would be more gradual, and the snowflakes would not melt during the descent. Therefore, the problem of strong airflow causing snowflakes to quickly pass through different temperature layers and accelerate melting is ruled out. So the falling snowflakes in the video look discontinuous and unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09283", "filename": "f00010aa6c7cb943d0ad2b5ba80a52fc2f6a82a50933b96df7afa1e65d32ade9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Physical behavior (the iron ruler in the entire video will undergo elastic deformation under pressure and support, but there is no obvious rebound after the person moves the left iron ruler in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09284", "filename": "f21c1f9c9aa024e2984e0397d6e50f2e68348fd6e4efebad3596149c5c08bd18_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the lake in the entire video is too calm, without any ripples or waves; it's too smooth, as if it's still).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09285", "filename": "f32dfa0862e2fbe8e09f00028de3bf6e9a6c2feab79b1796944ef397f3de2292_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (the cardboard box on the left is clearly scorched by fire between 0s and 4.3s, but between 4.3s and 8s, the left side of the box remains intact without any burn marks. Throughout the video, when the branches are burning, the combustible volatile components inside the branches undergo thermal decomposition upon heating, releasing gaseous substances. These gases do not have sufficient contact with air in the gaps and cannot burn completely, thus forming smoke. However, no smoke is released from the unburned branches below the cardboard box in the video.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09286", "filename": "f43d995fb1a82a9f9da5dd2f39d9c0c72eca5d3aadde6b3d2888315110400199_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (The entire video shows a close-up shot of a liquid boiling. Between 3.6s and 7.1s, a large amount of smoke appears to shroud the lens. However, boiling water produces water vapor, which is colorless and transparent. The white mist in the video is actually water vapor condensing into small water droplets when it cools. When shooting at close range, if the lens temperature and the water temperature are not much different, the amount of condensed water droplets will be small, only causing slight blurring at the edges of the image. If the lens is colder, the water droplets will condense on the lens surface, causing slight blurring, but not complete obstruction.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09287", "filename": "f58b5ff81fa67dbc2972b5ae438dbf67f1a1c10e23a0a846b521cd9f0ead1276_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (After the bubbles rise to the surface of the water, the water vapor inside will break through the surface tension of the water and instantly diffuse into the air. The thin film of the bubble will break at the same time, and the residue will be almost invisible to the naked eye. It will only leave a very short-lived ripple on the water surface. However, in the whole video, the bubbles rise and turn into many small water balls that gather together to the right.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09288", "filename": "f88c9a10f4c5191dba82a704c749b9d0ecdf4da38b819e947d313e1fd09ace09_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual is abnormal (the bottom of the dark gray cumulus clouds appears dark gray or even near black due to backlighting, while the top is illuminated by sunlight, showing a grayish-white or pale gold outline, creating a strong contrast with the clear blue sky next to it. However, in the entire video, the dark gray cumulus clouds appear as a dark mass without any transition to the edge of the clouds in the lower right corner of the screen. The dark background of the cumulus clouds would make the rainbow's seven colors more vivid and eye-catching, but the rainbow in the video is only half visible).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09289", "filename": "f91f07c2412e52ac0a8448a20af08ba4aa5726189af8aa1533fe395d01ce162d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the footage: Physical behavior (when the water jet from the high-pressure water gun contacts the surface of the car, it should spread out rapidly due to pressure, forming a thin water film. Some of the water should bounce off the smooth surface of the car, splashing up tiny water droplets. However, the water jet in the entire video appears stiff and unnatural, and the above phenomenon did not occur when it contacted the car. The black substance on the ground was constantly emitting smoke.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09290", "filename": "f94edbaf6a78e1d44cb4491ae7dba0881cc8e06a7e2445ebcdfb81b19970c6a8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (Throughout the video, the flames consistently drift to the left, indicating that the wind is blowing to the left. However, the thick white smoke on the left first gathers with the flames to the right before drifting to the left. Furthermore, when tree branches burn, the combustible volatile components inside undergo thermal decomposition upon heating, releasing as gas. Yet, no smoke is produced from the woodpile on the right in the entire video.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09291", "filename": "f238f2746c031f8775c50a3fdc381c4de9e155d8ffb8648931d7d9f588da1c20_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (In the entire video, the person walks with their toes pointing outwards, forming a slight V-shape. When landing, the outer side of the foot bears the weight first and then slowly returns to the center. The knees unconsciously turn inwards while walking, making the gait appear somewhat unsteady, but this is not clearly visible in the video. Furthermore, each time the person takes a step forward, the knee joint causes the lower leg to lift noticeably before the step is taken and lands, creating a noticeable sense of compositing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09292", "filename": "f400f472a0ccbb3d4621ce82cc4df7c5f579fc4b36e724f152f2ce323f3ed046_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the entire video is static, the smoke does not rise and spread, but at 7.9s the smoke becomes noticeably thicker, and there is no consistency between the beginning and end).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09293", "filename": "f406be6872d553e192f0658464d52165b485ae64c5439f0fccb4772548bb77bf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to a lack of continuity in time. (The first ice cream shell disappears at 7.1s and the second ice cream shell disappears at 7.5s. The ice cream melts too quickly throughout the video, yet there is no obvious change in the ice cream itself. The melted liquid is too smooth and perfect.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09294", "filename": "f410b1e976cebf27acafc92d46b262dfd2270dd942cd3438f8b3b9a06bb7f220_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (at 5.9s, the water flow decreased and stopped before the hand released the spray button; the water jet in the video was too perfect, with small air bubbles being carried out of the nozzle after the water jet suddenly emerged, bursting and splashing water foam as soon as it left the nozzle; the water jet would start to sway and disperse slightly after rushing forward a few centimeters; the water jet in the video was too stable and smooth).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09295", "filename": "f423d748e0b41e30d63a7bd8333a4626dfcecb5e0f60c4a9a238bc26668755f3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual appearance is abnormal (the diamond in the reflection should be symmetrical with the real object, but the diamond's reflection in the mirror is asymmetrical throughout the video, and the diamond's facets appear to be composited, with the edges not being distinct).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09296", "filename": "f465fc2020613b653d0b0e86869adef2eeadef1772c1e937906a6a1a929ab6e1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is visually abnormal: The overall visuals are abnormal (the whole video seems to be in slow motion; the object in the hand falls on its own without any external force, and there is no obvious reaction when it hits the mousetrap; at 3.2 seconds, the falling object does not roll continuously, but suddenly stands on the large mousetrap; the whole video has a clear sense of being composited).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09297", "filename": "f556aaeebf27b845abb1dbe03807a0a1660940633a54e7458915575c626c4821_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity (the waves in the entire video are abnormally unnatural. When the sea surface is generally calm, the waves are no longer surging, but instead turn into countless fine and gentle ripples, rippling from afar and spreading to the shore in circles. In the entire video, it is as if a calm sponge is suddenly churned up by a wave).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09298", "filename": "f588f1026f3351cc83b53afb88f4ece77118f5bc2cc6b46c9a2e9df520ac9e02_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual is abnormal (on a flat surface, snow would first slowly melt into small puddles with blurred edges, and the water stains would spread irregularly outwards from the point of snowfall. If the surface is slightly tilted, the melted snow water would slowly flow down the slope, forming thin water streaks. However, in the entire video, the snow stains after melting directly become thin water streaks flowing to the left, and there are no obvious melted water stains under the snowballs).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09300", "filename": "f3414d32d41f4028aab9214417c3fd858b2118fb08af429f57a61cdd3faf01dd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is visually abnormal: (After the ice cubes in the bowl start to become blunt and melt when they come into contact with water, tiny bubbles will slowly rise from the ice core and float to the surface. In the entire video, the edges of the ice cubes are too smooth and perfect, and there are no bubbles and the water surface is too calm.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09301", "filename": "f6767a9e04fd8095d4c31be44e224e4c8f39da878e52d697856504922a186eb9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 2.8s, the bubbles rising to the bottom of the pot suddenly turned into a string of small bubbles that twisted and rotated and sank to the bottom of the pot, and the bubbles in the pot underwent deformation).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09302", "filename": "f6869d0a7fb443fa67e48b38a8166c3c93507f81508305dcdb8eab70fb22b3b4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (When the hydraulic press rises and leaves the object at 6.6s, the smoke should spread horizontally, and the smoke is not sticky and will not form a stringy pattern with the smoke generated between the object)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09303", "filename": "f9508eb7b7a29a3ab4249a6a603bceb1f8b14eff2c52cdbba6f161f2f9fd1ecf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (at 1.8s, the small house in the scene is engulfed in flames and explodes violently, with the roof and door blown off and falling to the ground on the left side of the scene, but after the smoke from the explosion dissipates, only one door of the small house has fallen off). Time continuity (at 2.8s, the roof debris blown off on the left side of the scene suddenly disappears, and then suddenly reappears at 3s, with no consistency).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09304", "filename": "f9820c7f980d275190e2eb37c224c7755e8251e5f20c83a9377094bbdd49f34a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.5s, the fire is still in the background but suddenly turns black, without any transition of light and shadow).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09305", "filename": "f27126b8c57803bcf67fe24d7601575ed2336a4ad833ae389427675faeb33a59_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the tree in the middle of the entire video frame is distorted and deformed, with no consistency between the beginning and end).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09306", "filename": "f60954fcf7fc7c553eadd76b74d486ab08ae03a993cafc4d2454a27468f2fd9d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09307", "filename": "f89178c8a2055d54939844482fff288d041ff80851e69d5c9d199c4487845fc0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (at 0.5s, the water droplet suddenly deforms, its shape becoming strangely similar to a snowflake, but without the crystalline structure of a snowflake; the entire video appears heavily composited).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09308", "filename": "f1516533ac121249729038ecdeb27fe1edc06b1287123f7a999ec4e638b0c31b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (in the 2.9s video, the flashing light on the remote control changes from red to blue, and even when the person in the video is not pressing the remote control button, the infrared light on the remote control continues to flash, showing no consistency).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09309", "filename": "fa5dd566b121d7282c79b59e92d70fc8d8a1fd20e3e42ea08f0cc1666c885a66_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the smoke in the entire video stops spreading and hovers in the air with only slight changes).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09310", "filename": "1dd1e18e063fbbb2ad1bd0f98d74facc5f34c8d211b1aab82ecdf8b9ef8ab525_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.7 seconds in the video, the person's left hand was pointing at the blocks, but suddenly the right hand was pointing at the blocks without the camera changing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09311", "filename": "1dd1e18e063fbbb2ad1bd0f98d74facc5f34c8d211b1aab82ecdf8b9ef8ab525_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3s, the six small blue building blocks picked up instantly turned into one large blue building block without any external interference; at 4.7s, the small blue building blocks at the bottom of the screen suddenly turned into one large building block without any change in the camera angle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09312", "filename": "1dd1e18e063fbbb2ad1bd0f98d74facc5f34c8d211b1aab82ecdf8b9ef8ab525_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09313", "filename": "1dd1e18e063fbbb2ad1bd0f98d74facc5f34c8d211b1aab82ecdf8b9ef8ab525_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (at 3.6 seconds in the video, a block held by the character suddenly disappears without any change in camera angle; at 5.6 seconds, the hand is suspended in mid-air, yet the fingers suddenly reappear as blocks).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09314", "filename": "1e1f9d81a8f5f2a35ca497e0a8473684b1d197f1aef2bbb1d547055fb87b07da_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the ice cubes in the video move on their own between 0s and 0.6s without any external interference). Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the fibers on the towel throughout the video show continuous flickering and distortion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09315", "filename": "1e1f9d81a8f5f2a35ca497e0a8473684b1d197f1aef2bbb1d547055fb87b07da_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (1.6s - end). A large amount of water appears out of thin air on the surface of the ice block without the ice block melting or its volume changing.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09316", "filename": "1e1f9d81a8f5f2a35ca497e0a8473684b1d197f1aef2bbb1d547055fb87b07da_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time frame is continuous (between 0s and 0.6s in the video, the color of the towel under the bowl gradually fades without any change in the shot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09317", "filename": "1e1f9d81a8f5f2a35ca497e0a8473684b1d197f1aef2bbb1d547055fb87b07da_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09318", "filename": "1e7aac88494208a267416cefaaae3495f303cfede3c15711ab70cb1b5d460942_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The time is continuous (4.3s - end). During the downward press of the hydraulic press, without any change in the camera position, the screws on the upper part of the hydraulic press slowly move upwards but do not move with the downward press.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09319", "filename": "1e7aac88494208a267416cefaaae3495f303cfede3c15711ab70cb1b5d460942_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (4.03 - at the end, the volume of the film pressed by the hydraulic press becomes larger and too neat and regular).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09323", "filename": "02bddc7e968b2a887fe769f216d95cc536269a2672e3e9bc9b8d720ac3fa0e1e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (when the water flows into the bowl at 3.4s, it condenses into droplets without any transition).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09324", "filename": "02bddc7e968b2a887fe769f216d95cc536269a2672e3e9bc9b8d720ac3fa0e1e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the entire sky outside the window appears to shift and change color throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09325", "filename": "02bddc7e968b2a887fe769f216d95cc536269a2672e3e9bc9b8d720ac3fa0e1e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09326", "filename": "02bddc7e968b2a887fe769f216d95cc536269a2672e3e9bc9b8d720ac3fa0e1e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09327", "filename": "02c65189c5e417dbee9311831c6f51777c0d763e19a91f0f7e539a4d81e55790_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09328", "filename": "2a3f5f9f024a9865280ad0a7aa521e426576920a32d335e1538bb7c99960f572_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The direction of the colored astigmatism band in the prism is incorrect. After white light is dispersed by the prism, the colored light band should emerge from the other side of the prism's inclined plane. In the image, the colored astigmatism band appears to emerge from near the right-angled edge of the prism.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09329", "filename": "2a3f5f9f024a9865280ad0a7aa521e426576920a32d335e1538bb7c99960f572_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Light rays exhibiting physical dispersion must pass through the inside of a prism before exiting; there are obvious two refractions, but in the image, the light rays exit without passing through the prism.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09330", "filename": "2a3f5f9f024a9865280ad0a7aa521e426576920a32d335e1538bb7c99960f572_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "In prism dispersion, red light is deflected the least on the outer edge of the light band, while violet light is deflected the most on the inner edge. However, in the image, blue and violet are on the outer edge, and red and orange are on the inner edge, completely reversing the pattern.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09331", "filename": "2a6cb41001ed9af45087e325488c47f988b0d302c465fa7c1d3acf7adfa8d2af_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (at 1.1s in the video, a cup containing dry ice is placed in a pot, and a large amount of smoke is instantly generated even though the dry ice does not come into contact with the water in the pot).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09332", "filename": "2a6cb41001ed9af45087e325488c47f988b0d302c465fa7c1d3acf7adfa8d2af_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.4 seconds, the dry ice in the cup in the pot suddenly turns into a large amount of white mist and sprays out without touching water).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09333", "filename": "2a6cb41001ed9af45087e325488c47f988b0d302c465fa7c1d3acf7adfa8d2af_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09334", "filename": "2a39c67849bf1e4087bd65b4c19f663453b41c5695c947bf3004b9a951772e57_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The video is discontinuous in time (a white flying object suddenly appears in the middle of the frame at 1.8 seconds; the trees on the right side of the entire video show dynamic flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09335", "filename": "2a39c67849bf1e4087bd65b4c19f663453b41c5695c947bf3004b9a951772e57_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The footage is continuous (from the beginning to the end of the 3.7s frame, the lake surface shakes violently up and down without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09336", "filename": "2a39c67849bf1e4087bd65b4c19f663453b41c5695c947bf3004b9a951772e57_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The overall impression is off: the flow of the lake water, the sky, and the trees in the video are too smooth and lack depth.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09337", "filename": "2a56e801b4b099e0dee02e9ce6931aae04b73a9bc920c690d352f9a85fbf6afe_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the bubbles in the cup are too regular in the video; the bubbles appear out of thin air from the bottom of the cup).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09338", "filename": "2a56e801b4b099e0dee02e9ce6931aae04b73a9bc920c690d352f9a85fbf6afe_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the yellow liquid in the video keeps producing a large number of regular bubbles without any external interference).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09339", "filename": "2a56e801b4b099e0dee02e9ce6931aae04b73a9bc920c690d352f9a85fbf6afe_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal because the timing is continuous (yellow liquid is continuously poured into the glass throughout the entire video, but the height of the liquid in the glass remains constant).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09340", "filename": "6dd3e2864bc00e9772cf6357c9155cf1f6619dd7fbd3f66b3e1cec298364727a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 2.7s, the object in the container suddenly turns into a water bubble).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09341", "filename": "6e5a5182affe4d79745e2be735da95ed1b1ccd244160bd258d4f4ebc7ad79973_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (at 1.1s, the machine is not started in the video, but the balloon is popped).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09342", "filename": "6e5a5182affe4d79745e2be735da95ed1b1ccd244160bd258d4f4ebc7ad79973_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.1s, the blue balloon in the video suddenly changes, and at 3.6s, the water released from the bursting balloon increases out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09343", "filename": "6e1919496e6b540b62e62f18b7a6ddaa80e90d709b9ab308e607e7176e868a47_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the overall image is abnormal (the surface of the wood burning in the video is too smooth, unlike real footage, and lacks the realistic jaggedness).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09346", "filename": "6f27ec24220afb2c322ae75194a6ae4bb83f5a71fa1cda117fcb09b177c3af7b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.2 seconds, the mud behind the fish in the video disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09347", "filename": "6f97832596795382eb9396160bb261624a6f26bdefe8fb42db113a61aade85e0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the mirrored content presented by the reflective surface throughout the video is completely opposite to the physical orientation of the real scene).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09348", "filename": "007d7b5a2d12b979c37f7de38080a8eb9c4f953827a360c1e1c7ebbdbce40244_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Continuous timing (the cloud imagery flickers throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09349", "filename": "07c4dd59618c2edbe1f6874bf650e2af7b235e511cf228bcfa4805b8d14a312c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.2 seconds, the wooden block on the left below the hydraulic press falls down and then disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09350", "filename": "7a50ae7489c8db11ecb99b00ebc14ec33408d35143a853bfc082f0be1d5f60d7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is inconsistent (the ground at the bottom of the video flickers)", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09351", "filename": "7a50ae7489c8db11ecb99b00ebc14ec33408d35143a853bfc082f0be1d5f60d7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The time sequence is continuous (at 0.1 seconds, the falling incense sticks in the middle of the video disappear into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09352", "filename": "7aa1f6f8bc42e29f41efe5432ae7d00b81de4c9f4e61d661b4d1ec7027575819_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the image of the object in the middle of the bowl flickers throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09353", "filename": "7b95afb64fd31ac71611fba1de7132ce18b8a3e32301c3e24685a2468537bdc1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (1.6s-6s: Liquid is poured into the cup from the object in the right hand, but the volume of liquid in the object in the right hand does not decrease).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09354", "filename": "7b7891aaa787ad717df5f6ab6b5f97c3e069347b59e635b2d3a6a3a5172c0cf7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (at 1.8s, the object in the left hand passes through the object in the right hand in the video)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09355", "filename": "7b7891aaa787ad717df5f6ab6b5f97c3e069347b59e635b2d3a6a3a5172c0cf7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (flickering appears on the surface of the left hand in the video).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09356", "filename": "7be9fb0c2a24093009bc16ea4b2e643decceee5c3529de76d144d6106116eaa0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the water surface in the lower right corner of the video shows ripples without any external force, violating the law of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09357", "filename": "7bee47a24f7d3e4d4c637b6cf41a4e6872af9d2ab97d41b4b7c68cde95074a69_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09359", "filename": "7c07d7db8e379a74691962fdcaf4b5288a2e31f85290b0e58da9e217992a3b3f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (at 1s, the smoke in the video cup penetrates the object and leaks out, violating the principle that solids are impermeable); Temporal continuity (at 4.5s, the smoke in the video cup appears out of nowhere and erupts).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09361", "filename": "03b11462245004b77be0bad95301e2579b5e1d6ccc378f425a1e01a0034297da_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (in the video, while the size of the flames on the blue clothing remains constant, the rate at which the burning marks spread is not proportional to the size of the flames).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09362", "filename": "03b11462245004b77be0bad95301e2579b5e1d6ccc378f425a1e01a0034297da_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the white smoke generated during combustion turns black between 4.3s and 5.7s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09363", "filename": "03c1a502d0478e0373e2a23828e27d3bd66bb4933c72af555b0d3df85bdd9ad5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomalies: The timing is continuous (at 1.25ss, the distant, blurry rice grains shrink; at 2.2s, the rice grains on the right are out of focus and blurry, but the rice grains behind them are clear). Overall visual anomalies: The shapes of the rice grains in the image are uniform and don't resemble a realistic scene.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09364", "filename": "03fded8c4137cc0d28fb9d4059ca5af9cd376d4fe2e3a5d7ca5597894ccc930d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09365", "filename": "3bfd3417f1d85fa3be06f39b53a5dfc8b52bc91ac729c15038a3dade1ebfaebb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09366", "filename": "3bfd3417f1d85fa3be06f39b53a5dfc8b52bc91ac729c15038a3dade1ebfaebb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09367", "filename": "3c982f0d5e9c5d5e99c7e8d51c701e246d421f15c1cb82b7e15d038591787c71_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical behavior is erratic: The toy in the video moves on its own between 0s and 2.6s without external force or gravity.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09368", "filename": "3c1256832944090b81d1f767d97362028720853b5fd362814013c126219a5593_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Physical behavior (at 1s in the video, the green viscous substance moves on its own without the roller touching it). Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (at 3.8s, the green viscous substance on the ground being rolled thickens, and at 4.2s, the watermark on the right side of the roller suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09369", "filename": "3ca0a3eec4a99f929af839f4fa8d6190d4c767a62aa97295446141e7c0807e5a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Causality (The yellow solid in the image does not change in volume after melting in 1s-8 seconds) Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (The blue and red solids in the image show no surface change under continuous heating by the flame)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09370", "filename": "3cf83c31b941251fd64495f0b272832bbf61ec33f54d4ff866c5294c1aaf94c3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical behavior and motion disorder: The wooden plank and the two boxes in the scene move without external force or gravity between 0.4s and 5s, and the right side of the plank is suddenly shattered.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09371", "filename": "3cf83c31b941251fd64495f0b272832bbf61ec33f54d4ff866c5294c1aaf94c3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical behavior and motion disorder: At 1.1s in the video, the white board moves on its own without any external force or gravity, and the scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 3.4s in the video, a white solid appears out of thin air under the white board and explodes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09372", "filename": "3cfa49a5e1302a46771909479b3e21def43152d0708423444f00b11422f301b4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Time Continuity (the hardened road surface suddenly cracks at 2.5s). Visual Anomalies: Physical Anomalies (the frying pan in the scene shows no change under the weight and pressure of the wheel from 2.5s to 4.6s). Physical Anomalies: Clipping Through the Roller at 4s.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09373", "filename": "3d4cc28c5ff9eb03170752f1c042933b4ba1cd23280543dfe5e78d336223cd5a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior anomalies (the blocks in the video move on their own at 1.8s without external force or gravity); Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the blocks in the video split more frequently between 2s and 4.6s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09374", "filename": "3d4d769ceb8b4804c9455111f9f8ba8dd81376d0a08fc7bc33729a60353f0348_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (The trees and grass elements in the image exhibit dynamic flickering defects, and irregular brightness flickering occurs in the leaf area during movement, disrupting visual continuity).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09375", "filename": "3d28eb5307024a83a032cf3431176fca36ea92ef8979b59544bbd66adc9aa25e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (abrupt changes in the water surface, inter-frame distortion of water flow, abrupt changes in flow pattern, visual discontinuity of water flow, disordered dynamics of the liquid surface, and inter-frame jumps in the flow field)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09377", "filename": "3d835553966d97c40b19ff502100a1008caddb936237917c560034493c005762_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to physical behavior (at 4.7 seconds, the finger was not manipulating the crystal, yet the crystal rotated without any force being applied). (The luster and texture do not conform to physical characteristics. Natural opals have a waxy or vitreous luster with soft surface reflections. However, the opal in the video has an excessively strong reflection, lacking the warm texture of natural gemstones, and looks more like a 3D model or a post-production synthesized virtual gemstone.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09378", "filename": "3e4ce726cc7f462820e2f4c57445e1879dd5c334b92995b782b6fce43dc90db9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to abnormal physical behavior (reflection: a clear reflection of the sphere should be visible on the water surface, forming a symmetrical image with the underwater part. However, in the video, the upper and lower parts of the sphere are completely smoothly connected, without any bending caused by refraction or reflection from the water surface).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09379", "filename": "3e4ce726cc7f462820e2f4c57445e1879dd5c334b92995b782b6fce43dc90db9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Disordered physical behavior and motion: During the period from 0.7s to 5.8s, the sphere in the water tank moves spontaneously without external force or gravity.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09380", "filename": "194c8ee8da4f94938c81000faf163e0a9e24d9f966baa7b6909c318584b181e0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (the volume of the object being sliced by the knife noticeably increases between 2s and 8s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09381", "filename": "197f92f77321a379bdda77524fbbf9587286559e67c063bbc1590f93deeb183a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the smoke and flames appearing between 2.9s and 5s in the video are not moving in the same direction); Physical anomalies (at 1.6s, the flames of the burning object leap up from the bottom of the object).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09382", "filename": "197f92f77321a379bdda77524fbbf9587286559e67c063bbc1590f93deeb183a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity issues (the ground in the image flickers dynamically, disrupting visual continuity; only the right side of the burning object produces smoke).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09385", "filename": "201e0061d39bb69eadfbe19b4841053eab15d572619f04159f4627bdd2d022f2_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the lamp bulb area is noticeably overexposed, bright details are completely lost, and radial glare and fogging are produced around the light source).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09386", "filename": "210e82e66e4ab8dca3d66d833c0153ef03320b16d5448c7d1b2c3515a00e4242_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (during the video from 0s to 6.1s, the ice blocks did not melt and their volume decreased, then increased again).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09387", "filename": "222b7649ebf1c560d71fbc25f31fa9634b57c812be40cbbf04528efb08d2817a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the rise of the water level in the cup is not proportional to the amount of water poured in; the height of the rise is clearly less than the amount of water poured into the cup).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09389", "filename": "234f7bb2b32dbfe1fdcba4c2c9314caf063d587318b67d77d7586119bee597bd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (The sand elements in the overall image exhibit dynamic flickering artifacts; irregular brightness flickering occurs in the sand areas during movement, disrupting visual continuity.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09390", "filename": "234f7bb2b32dbfe1fdcba4c2c9314caf063d587318b67d77d7586119bee597bd_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the train's head suddenly changes direction at 7.2s in the video); Physical inertia: the toy train derails as it returns at 7.6s.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09391", "filename": "263c50096b73bfc3a74b8baef411399ed988cea49ad467e4c2e01fafac482fc6_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: Physical behavior (the fire and dispersion effect of a diamond, manifested as the decomposition of white light into red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and violet spectral colors, evenly distributed; however, the color of this diamond is interference color produced by the coating, exhibiting a clear layered gradient (outer ring blue-green-gold-orange, center deep violet), completely inconsistent with the fire and dispersion characteristics of a diamond.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09392", "filename": "263c50096b73bfc3a74b8baef411399ed988cea49ad467e4c2e01fafac482fc6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Physical behavior (the fire of natural diamonds is based on the soft colors produced by their dispersion rate, mainly white, yellow, and blue, and will not produce such a large area of high-saturation rainbow color gradient effect as seen in the image).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09393", "filename": "266bb2c9336f82058a0061749ef98f8b7542598afb113d77455fef6aab97caae_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.5 seconds, the silver sphere suddenly bursts out of the container and disappears).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09394", "filename": "266bb2c9336f82058a0061749ef98f8b7542598afb113d77455fef6aab97caae_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomalies in physical behavior: Under the influence of gravity, the small steel ball remained at the edge of the container for 0.8 seconds without moving along its trajectory. Meanwhile, the Buckyballs in the basin, without any obvious external force (such as vibration, magnetic field changes, or airflow), exhibited spontaneous, synchronous, and continuous overall motion.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09395", "filename": "281b3fe9e6514bedf03d431c5e5f342633fc67d84c829040d45f911ff647709b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the funnel opening becomes smaller at 0.5s, the funnel in the person's hand suddenly disappears at 4.1s, and the tea lid appears out of thin air at 4.5s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09397", "filename": "297a4ec4ba3c3a00aa3a6f191323996c8123e3649a4af7d0409752e28a714da1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (dynamic flickering defects appear in the cloud and fog elements in the image; irregular brightness flicker occurs in the cloud and fog areas during movement, disrupting visual continuity).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09398", "filename": "316d7c95190476a19afca40c41f5d422d060aff501c529fb2257acfae3beb4cf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical behavior and motion disorder: The sphere in the frame from 1.1s to 8s moves on its own without external force or gravity, and the frame is abnormal: the time is continuous (a sphere appears out of nowhere at 1.7s, the sphere that hits the wooden block deforms at 2s and changes its surface color and layout, and the sphere splits into more pieces at 3.3s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09399", "filename": "328b3c9bade99c0a973aa846c21d2e30d396947c16b11df809c4fcbe880787e3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "the object's motion behavior is abnormal: In the video, from 0.7s to 5s, the soft ball falls to the ground without any surface deformation.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09400", "filename": "352ac61997187d249917cac2c15344974c610042890104cbe1a85636424d2b94_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: At 0.3s, the balloon in the image is in a stable suspended state and bursts without any external force, sharp object puncture, sudden change in air pressure, or overinflation. Abnormal image: The time is continuous (the blue liquid increases and spreads between 1.1s and 5.9s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09401", "filename": "357a5bf22712a4f68c76d8173b5906d763aa4fa8d2aab8d6fdc1bd7a4ced2d4c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (Clouds and mist appear out of nowhere in the air from 0.8s to 5s in the scene) Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (There is a noticeable bright white area between the bottom of the rain column and the ground, which is either motion blur caused by rapid movement or poorly processed edge marks during compositing, making the rain column look like it is not actually falling to the ground, thus destroying the realism of the scene)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09402", "filename": "365afbb3a534cfedda08f9e88bd8371edca7b76e1bb5a3b437fdff1cba4ace23_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The overall impression is off: the entire waterfall area presents an overly uniform \"white mist\" effect, lacking the layering of water flow, splashing water, and textured details of rocks found in natural waterfalls. Real waterfalls have distinct rock outlines and variations in light and shadow in the water flow, but the waterfall in this image looks more like a blurry white curtain, severely lacking in detail.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09403", "filename": "393ed3e43e1a36f777a80478a78a82bba328847450d4b92a0dfbb002316e592f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous (the degree of indentation of the gravity cylinder at 1.1s and 7.6s is inconsistent).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09404", "filename": "0403a43eea348baedf403a1907c07639e58fd314e4f0fea2a735795624f0464c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical anomaly: Shadows appear at the two upper right corners of the object in the image, even though it is illuminated by a white light source. The specular reflection, however, appears purple, violating the basic laws of optical reflection.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09405", "filename": "0403a43eea348baedf403a1907c07639e58fd314e4f0fea2a735795624f0464c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical anomaly: Between 0.01 and 0.9 seconds, a white light source is illuminating the surface, yet the mirrored light appears purple, violating the fundamental laws of optical reflection.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09406", "filename": "405cbc110c7375d2d54473a14c54ea6e0991d465559ab3103c5194ce92a277b9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (dynamic flickering defects appear in the cloud and fog elements in the overall image; irregular brightness flicker occurs in the cloud and fog areas during movement, disrupting visual continuity).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09407", "filename": "416d3bddb1bb5691982e3f81bf396404c45366073bcc5ad1f3648b1ed8e35655_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Overall visual inconsistency: Dynamic flickering artifacts appear on the surfaces of objects in the video, producing irregular brightness flickering that disrupts visual continuity.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09408", "filename": "420e0da9121f52b19dbb8c36f90731d79b5a6bb543ccd079563770faa2973cc5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09409", "filename": "428b207557905b67828527a67b60c713a2fc61e07d3da4e56f854ff93629430a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Causal inertia (the solid melts into liquid in the pot and spreads outwards, but the volume of the solid in the pot does not change) and temporal continuity (a blue strip appears out of thin air at 3.9 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09410", "filename": "435dda98f245f62beecbfc8f364af736632c11800bc68edfd65f27c678486bed_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09411", "filename": "0438ca53923b320022518f57ed8967af593442714da558d3a840431e06b8e37c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (between 4.2s and 8s, the volume of the yellow viscous substance squeezed by the character's hand is not proportional to the volume of the juice produced).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09414", "filename": "456fe202211b9a604c70672b9d0b8281f8e749c392c8ce513620a0619fd6608e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09415", "filename": "460c17241986fcfd54ea72a8bd0588cb0abc8bb1e7f22f7c77297edde51071cb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.2s, the plastic bucket on the ground suddenly transforms into a dog, and between 1s and 4.3s, the sand dug by the dog uses a spark effect).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09416", "filename": "460c17241986fcfd54ea72a8bd0588cb0abc8bb1e7f22f7c77297edde51071cb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 3.1s, the bucket at the explosion point suddenly turns into three puppies, at 3.4s, the solid block produced by the explosion falls to the ground and disappears, and at 5.2s, one of the puppies suddenly disappears).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09417", "filename": "481d376ed63239b5aafbb8d335f2c04ddd880cde8cdb354b14ca109a7d1130dc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical behavior is abnormal; the reflections on the CD surface and the gloss of the black pillars do not maintain consistent lighting logic across different frames; the rainbow reflection angle on the CD does not change naturally with the camera's angle of view as the lens moves.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09418", "filename": "487dc0f6356238cfca10d74adf1330d09d470162a931e2af99ae611b6db6f9b4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Time continuity (the transition of objects in the image from teardrop shape to ellipse and then to elongated shape is too smooth and distorted. When a faceted gemstone is rotated, the edges and angles of each facet should maintain a stable geometric relationship and will not exhibit this flowing deformation).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09419", "filename": "507cd81b87cd26133e6b6a6002cdf3726929abec4260e790933f5867d87eeb83_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video footage is abnormal: the time continuity is unnatural (the debris from the explosion appears to float and move unnaturally in the frame. In a real explosion, debris is affected by gravity and air resistance, resulting in different parabolic trajectories. However, the debris in the video appears to be static elements pasted onto the screen, lacking a realistic sense of physical force. The color transitions of the flames and smoke from the explosion are too smooth, lacking the complex tonal gradations of real flames and the random textures of smoke).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09420", "filename": "507cd81b87cd26133e6b6a6002cdf3726929abec4260e790933f5867d87eeb83_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The explosion appears too symmetrical and smooth, from the initial fireball to the subsequent mushroom cloud, lacking the irregular textures and dynamic changes characteristic of a real explosion caused by uneven fuel-oxygen mixing. Furthermore, during the 5.5s-8s interval of the video, the flames of burning flammable material floating on the sea surface appear irregular and undulate with the waves, accompanied by abundant foam and black smoke. In contrast, the flames of burning debris in the seawater are regular and uniform in brightness.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09422", "filename": "525c8eb9515637d25a90f2841c5d9bde0fafde2346cc56df2e27bd77b78d3db3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: The timing is continuous (a white sphere appears out of nowhere at 0.3s, disappears suddenly at 0.9s, a small ball appears out of nowhere and is kicked out at 1.9s, two small balls merge into one at 2.6s, and a blue ball bounces up out of nowhere at 3.9s). Physical Anomalies: At 0.7s, the white ball does not touch the character's feet and moves forward on its own without any pushing force.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09423", "filename": "535f184fe99f61eadc545cebf529905bb324cc286c0e1e376091a35e76b576b3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the movement of the seawater in the video is too uniform and patterned; the wave shapes and repetitive textures are completely identical, without natural changes or decay). Time continuity (real seawater surfaces reflect clouds and sunlight, exhibiting dynamic changes in brightness and darkness. However, the seawater textures and lighting in the video are completely fixed, showing no fluctuations in brightness or color over time or from different viewpoints).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09424", "filename": "541a24e1515a5d6c69c2648a4d7a11827af1aece583e70cb76ce1af2e644f329_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the cup in the video continuously generates dynamic changes (bubbles) without any external energy input, violating the basic principles of energy conservation and thermodynamic equilibrium). Physical behavior anomalies: The rising speed of bubbles on the surface of the video is not proportional to the bubbles generated inside the cup.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09425", "filename": "541a24e1515a5d6c69c2648a4d7a11827af1aece583e70cb76ce1af2e644f329_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (real bubble movement goes through a complete process of generation, stabilization, and bursting. However, the bubbles in the video are an infinite loop of pseudo-dynamics, with neither a burst period of new bubble generation nor a dissipation period of old bubble bursting).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09426", "filename": "544a5cbb8f6b5e2ac23923b601fd4021750ff2c2ae5d2e1431eb0f06213c8fe6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (in the video, the hydraulic press explodes on its own at 1.4s before it even touches the object, and at 5.9s, the hydraulic press lifts the object while the fragments remain intact).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09427", "filename": "544a5cbb8f6b5e2ac23923b601fd4021750ff2c2ae5d2e1431eb0f06213c8fe6_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time continuity (the object exploded at 5.9s without further pressure, and at 7s the hydraulic press lifted the object and caused elastic deformation).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09428", "filename": "556a580475c4f05eceb211195634208a005980991e4fc24d5d6ebd2ff4b7d83e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (a regular stain appears out of thin air at 1.9s, and then suddenly disappears from the surface of the object between 3.7s and 6s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09429", "filename": "557c14b4775b11d57739f0c39403a66ce3d85a121d0003ec1ca5fcf474974de5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 6.8s, the snowflakes suddenly disappear without undergoing a matter conversion, and the car in the overall video is gliding without any people in it).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09430", "filename": "557fca6e1f02f20fa5aa5d3f18fb81a0ec4e328b308466dbcd6370ba404dd227_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time frame is continuous (the shooting angle remains unchanged and the flower does not move, but the aperture of the sunlight shining from behind the flower decreases from 0.1s to 8s and then increases again).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09432", "filename": "596a8c989a831dbf7b94246f228f80e70638bd6d1db844a4887a2e0dfaa1db35_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (dynamic flickering defects appear in the pot in the overall picture. Irregular brightness flicker occurs in the pot during the movement, which disrupts the visual continuity. In the video without transitional frames, the blocky object changes from two to three pieces at 0.5 seconds, from three to four pieces at 1.4 seconds, and then changes back to three pieces at 6.3 seconds.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09433", "filename": "600e2f941c28e4b15f4e2812e5c2c668c2af44a41cc2200a8db57a9a40985a74_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09434", "filename": "603cdad55da9e5ad6ed1b6fb96b04fb3e4c78e9973e9cf09506cac793e78b87e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is not continuous (the fireworks in the video explode into very regular circles, lacking the irregular downward drop of the upper part of the explosion in real fireworks).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09435", "filename": "614f743cb841fa8574c047d31acf35c0131af95a8d49921f1f9f5232d5b4e5e2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Cause and effect (the volume of smoke emanating from the cup is not proportional to the volume of smoke within the cup). Physical anomalies: Smoke is usually denser than air and, without external force, should sink downwards and diffuse along the surface of an object due to gravity. However, in the video, the smoke does not show a natural sinking tendency at the rim of the cup; instead, it floats upwards and hovers in front of the cup.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09436", "filename": "614f743cb841fa8574c047d31acf35c0131af95a8d49921f1f9f5232d5b4e5e2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (the cup in the footage continuously generates smoke out of thin air, and a wisp of smoke generated at 4.9s does not show any natural tendency to sink under the influence of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09437", "filename": "618e0bdaf9d3417711cace9bd2834336d7dc7032b22e120775270447d94356f0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the same liquid in the image flows downwards, and from 0.9s to 5s, the liquid on the left and the liquid on the right are inconsistent; the liquid on the left is semi-transparent and watery, while the liquid on the right is brown).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09438", "filename": "622fb983a1fc8a170efd0eb01f9c0f5082be77286fe4448e5a5553cbd12551b4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: When the sphere is compressed for 0.9s-8s, it will undergo elastic deformation. The deformation should be uniform and continuous, and gradually change with increasing pressure. However, in the video, the deformation of the sphere is more like the material being flattened rather than compressed. Its surface wrinkles and depressions are very stiff, lacking scaling or twisting, and do not reflect the elastic stress distribution that the sphere should have.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09440", "filename": "0656fe333c0604dd951032ebb418fd129bc9c4091e82fb145209c8b1d5085490_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: Real combustion smoke rises due to hot air currents and spreads and curls at the top. However, the smoke in the video exhibits unnatural shapes such as suspended smoke rings and curved smoke columns.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09441", "filename": "661bdb9ec3c0e9edd734345a3eb4c08b2ababb2c089bb18c81e3084d0de9a027_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (The trees and grass elements in the image exhibit dynamic flickering defects, and irregular brightness flickering occurs in the leaf area during movement, disrupting visual continuity).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09442", "filename": "661bdb9ec3c0e9edd734345a3eb4c08b2ababb2c089bb18c81e3084d0de9a027_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.1 seconds, the white solid becomes a square; at 1.7 seconds, the white solid changes from two to three; at 2.1 seconds, brown liquid suddenly appears at the bottom of the glass; and at 3.3 seconds, the white solid changes from three pieces to four pieces).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09443", "filename": "671a6bd483a777857ef683d7c30ad39f4111277fe9b3a017ad6b87841c7e75ff_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09444", "filename": "687b3e536cc65ae5a4b3d0f38124e9af692c71135ab1eb6719455f0c36c8b1ae_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: At 1.8s and 4.6s, under the premise of no external force, the object collides with the rigid plane and bounces up. There must be energy loss. However, the object bounces up to the same height twice in the video without any energy loss. This is completely contrary to the basic laws of collision physics. Abnormal image: The time is continuous (at 2 seconds, the water left on the ground suddenly decreases).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09445", "filename": "687b3e536cc65ae5a4b3d0f38124e9af692c71135ab1eb6719455f0c36c8b1ae_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is discontinuous (a white shadow appears out of nowhere on the ground at 2.7 seconds in the video), and the physical behavior is chaotic (at 4.3 seconds, the sphere does not contact the ground and is not subjected to any elastic force; the sphere automatically bounces upwards).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09446", "filename": "687f08c08aa088611b3f362baa5ab4da8ab3aa0aca1b7af1c6274023f05f7cbe_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (in windy conditions, the direction of cloud movement is inconsistent at 1.2s in the video, and noticeable stuttering occurs slowly at 3.4s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09447", "filename": "687f08c08aa088611b3f362baa5ab4da8ab3aa0aca1b7af1c6274023f05f7cbe_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is continuous (the clouds gradually increase in size between 1.4s and 8s). Physical anomalies: Between 2.7s and 8s, under natural conditions, as clouds move, the Tyndall effect of light beams changes shape, direction, and coverage depending on the cloud's position. However, in this video, the shape and relative position of the light beams show almost no change, showing no correlation with the cloud movement.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09448", "filename": "692c2ce9a1e0cbdae754a95cb6f409b2a410adb5476941cfa8eda153e8a664ff_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time is continuous (between 1.4s and 5s, the nut should be compressed synchronously and evenly by the upper and lower pressure plates, the overall thickness should be thinner, and the inner hole should be squeezed into a flat shape, but the change at the top of the nut in the video is not obvious).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09449", "filename": "697cdb13befbe9f6b1dfbfe19938120c1008eb3db11cbfaf52469be6c3cbd60b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.2 seconds into the video, three white objects suddenly appear and move on the grass).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09450", "filename": "702d8c431145505ec55a5000978b3b325ee409b8a4942841ff9d182c5549ce0e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (during the 0s-5s interval of the video, there is no fine water splash or water ripple on the ground at the moment of impact, the landing action is stiff, there is no natural physical feedback of water droplets hitting the ground in reality, the sense of realism is lacking, and the liquid level in the bottle does not change as the liquid in the bottle continues to drip).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09452", "filename": "725aad3acf2630212eccfeff196ed393ef472671524924cb830d0c461568569b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09453", "filename": "756b80d8aa04a9e4cd1354c56d30a76097bc6092eab99cc16cb230a6ca213fd2_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal physical behavior: The liquid added at 1.6s in the video does not fall freely under the influence of gravity; abnormal visuals: the time is continuous (the liquid added at 5s disappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09454", "filename": "756b450dfb0625024ae6045e4e6ed6f7224720c792d4324aa1c8f6f4da00adc9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09455", "filename": "762ca6da86ed00c299ab366d123a79b6685fadaa2059dc0ee89b08fe208dec40_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical behavior under gravity: The liquid that melted between 2.6s and 5s did not undergo free fall under the influence of gravity.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09456", "filename": "762ca6da86ed00c299ab366d123a79b6685fadaa2059dc0ee89b08fe208dec40_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous (the object grows larger and deforms between 0.6s and 8s, and a light source appears out of thin air in the solid at 2.2s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09457", "filename": "762e28b03bc440af8059138fe10c44053c8f5bec8419222987d6eb5b129b03ec_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (in the video, even with water being continuously added, the liquid levels in the collection bottle below and the water inlet above do not change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09458", "filename": "764c8212d82f3277d1fa5c92e357d50eb8c1e59ddd6616d9ad0a370fb0b27851_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is inconsistent (a smoke shadow appears out of nowhere at 0.6s; the smoke should originate from a burning sparkler, but at 3.3s the smoke rises from below). Physical anomalies: Obvious color layering is visible at the edges of the flames and smoke, especially the transition between yellow and orange, which is unnatural and exhibits a \"color banding\" phenomenon.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09460", "filename": "a55f89010997db46a4e38fa29480f667040ddb1439bb9e6e5dd7022a4fabeb36_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Abnormal physical behavior (smoke appears 1.8s-8s after the explosion, but the smoke moves slowly at the moment of the explosion; however, a large airflow is generated during the explosion, causing the smoke to move faster.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09462", "filename": "a66da3652a0f904266a5b70ffbcfd0e602766cf1c10f2bd28c90242086c9bc2e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09463", "filename": "a70bab5820dc3dbebab26e2c9846140bc7ea18be8215288c3f363bb4a087442b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the smoke in the video is similar to dry ice smoke, but from 5.6s to 8s the smoke appears as regular streaks of smoke. In reality, smoke is random. The ground and trees in the entire video are writhing and flickering).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09464", "filename": "a96f5ac706a5fa877f04346d515926fa3b9c7fee5f4788aeb392e20775e6f66a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual impression is off (the lake surface is too calm and smooth, there is no natural gradation between the blue-green patches of water, and the edges appear somewhat sharp). Continuous time (the trees on the shore are constantly undulating and flickering throughout the entire sequence).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09465", "filename": "a341d7f4f01b36f968abdf2cf194894aa22229cfef5170a3f3360b943595e934_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the smoke on the left side of the screen remains stationary in the air throughout the entire sequence, whereas in reality, smoke would move in the air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09466", "filename": "a351f065b46af9a60c0dff79ae831e338852b2d8ef209d5a31e62763617f59e8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual inconsistencies (real water reflections are affected by tiny ripples, appearing slightly blurred and distorted; the reflections in the video are too clear and smooth, lacking the subtle ripples of natural water). Temporal continuity (the grass and trees throughout the video appear to flicker and wriggle).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09467", "filename": "a487a710a81d879d3b3e3c05fb12d6248fda7d464b307246e7f568c558572a1f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the visuals: Physical behavior (Throughout the entire segment, the buoyancy of the water would lift the toy car upwards, reducing the friction between the wheels and the track. This would make the wheels slip easily, especially when climbing a slope, causing the car to spin freely and unable to move forward. However, the movement of the car in the water in the video, and the start of climbing the slope at 4.1 seconds, are all too smooth).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09468", "filename": "a572e8d30495f666f317194e917e73e70b7d9b79c991cc6d68bd62253fabc12c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (in the whole segment, a yellow viscous substance is heated in a pot and boils. Bubbles rise from the substance. After the bubbles explode, they should leave small holes, but in the video, no small holes are left after the bubbles rise and the surface automatically returns to the state before the bubbles rise).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09469", "filename": "a682cb37dc040e324fbfa49af5eccf4ad330ba952b1f8e1067f1989b66977447_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 7.2s, a firework suddenly explodes out of nowhere on the left side of the screen, instead of the usual upward motion of fireworks).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09471", "filename": "a2902b4454eef4dd5829aec7b6ed031d48dd5582d19ded229e16f7b3355c6d89_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Cause and effect (the ice cube moves left and right on the table without any external force throughout the segment) Time continuity (the ice cube shrinks and then suddenly grows larger between 3.6s and 5.5s, and the marble-like tabletop continuously wriggles and flickers throughout the segment)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09472", "filename": "a3148ab980f80847edaced1a114c88c4aa4e5b06a9e76be22d35f6adcba85ce4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (objects on the ground, such as the horse in the distance, are extremely blurry and lack the details of a realistic scene).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09473", "filename": "a3411e27377b225efa9c16df38671611b8038fb9871f925a473bd3d5c04d0693_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09474", "filename": "a4999c4883990f4b93bf2f18f30ddedfc3a8baebdb63887728b20a2ad3f38240_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09475", "filename": "a5486cede2f36e00bf1067b41408e8425ee17ca6c1a0cdf8adfcde2548ce0380_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal because the timing is not continuous (in the entire segment, the liquid, which resembles honey, will have slight changes in thickness and natural swaying as it flows downwards due to the interaction of gravity and surface tension; however, the liquid column in the video is completely uniform in thickness and has no fluctuations, appearing too smooth).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09476", "filename": "a6937a80e618075cbb226f8ff837e6072568b923832490a7f228b9a463d7629a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the movement of clouds throughout the segment appears as an overly regular and unnatural uniform drift, with all cloud clusters moving at the same speed, lacking the sense of random changes in clouds in a real atmosphere).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09477", "filename": "a7051e49e44d487f0fb2462896ae598218c91bab1e5ea0ba40f1f4a89ab33b6e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Time continuity (the large rocks in the entire video are wriggling and flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09479", "filename": "a8043f115f38d39d1cf8aa1d3e10c1e4a6a97540ced39027d73bb139b3bab251_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the trees, sea surface, and clouds on the left side of the entire video frame are flickering and moving).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09481", "filename": "a9979f0cb50e01fe6bbbceeace0410a1a5ed49396b724a1859d927b0f2355263_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.5s, the smoke from the car explosion shows a very symmetrical cauliflower-like layered structure, with densely packed, round smoke balls. The smoke from a real car explosion is usually irregular and chaotic, and will not form such a highly symmetrical cluster shape. At 7.9s, the smoke balls do not rise but slowly shrink in place).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09482", "filename": "a29431a81fe1135b6d83806d10fa7fedf244557cc68a1d1e8233e35ac9357d40_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the top and bottom of the flames in the entire segment present a precise mirror effect, which is impossible in reality. The burning and movement of real flames are random and irregular. The edges of the flames in the entire segment are too regular, resembling the outline of flower petals, losing the dynamics and irregularity of real flames).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09483", "filename": "a75443bf2a7c19d95e0bf897dce8a08b5d3148ecfdc85b3af63278c3be86f8aa_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: continuous motion (the entire glass and the ice cubes inside it are flickering and writhing throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09484", "filename": "a128395dd88951d2152ba7247401fc9ee84544493503bb56b3152564e330b2fd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the size of the reflected flames in the entire segment is significantly smaller, shorter, and dimmer than the main flame, and they do not match the main flame).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09486", "filename": "aa0b44f838c76f67c6e1f5c4fbec96e036c260afcbc92971bdbd183a99541cec_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09487", "filename": "aa5bc75e97260521693b0520ca50f6e178c6e43bf82bcffa484af22c905e3772_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: The overall impression is abnormal (although the precipitation from thunderstorm clouds may be localized, the rainfall we usually see is a continuous curtain of rain over a large area, but in the video, this rain falls in isolation from the thick dark clouds, without any synchronous precipitation around it, which looks unnatural). The timing is continuous (the dark clouds and the ground throughout the video are flickering and moving).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09488", "filename": "aa5e9f62207bbb96d7fdabdca9d41c37e70a4d1663beb44c617417d7ca141e87_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (when the nozzle stops spraying at 7.4s, the smoke also disappears instantly. In reality, after the nozzle stops spraying, the smoke will disappear slowly).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09489", "filename": "aa8d76f79dc43b7009f2cb65cb5f256e101b01fe468a6ab9461d861644dbd741_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (when the tomato falls into the water at 1.3s, the air bubbles that were originally in the water to its lower left are not dispersed by the water flow, but remain intact in place).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09490", "filename": "4d605c95cbd54893050b2407d23935008e0a5592d72eb1ca3794739554156c58_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (flickering of tree branches and ground throughout the video, disrupting the stability of the viewpoint).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09491", "filename": "4d640d4f600688e719c131131fbccc51e9824b2733ffe610f767101bb55b522f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09492", "filename": "4d2460e7173fd0461286590cea07d13a5ea2dda5929db2484934197284122f92_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (flickering occurs throughout the video, disrupting the stability of the viewing angle).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09493", "filename": "4d182135f12a719f61590fb919ef2a612e9a8777203e48b4b25e41a772b81d71_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (the white object in the middle of the scene suddenly disappears at 0.2s); Physical behavior (at 6.7s, a tilted magnet attracts another magnet, resulting in a tilted position, which does not conform to the law of relativity of magnetic poles).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09494", "filename": "4dc521176861484c61b6527d9f29b817cb8f131f610cd0ca39ff2ebee765544e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09495", "filename": "4e4c1b7e1ebf2ecceb5a97e132d24698ae6ed4b64020f099ba0d5e85c399863a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Continuous timing (the black grid on the paper behind the container flickers throughout the video) Causality (the liquid was poured into the container between 2.7s and 5.7s, but the amount of liquid in the container did not decrease).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09496", "filename": "4e86fa4bd2058dda2a4aa8d081ee09dba84ca8f25aef63df8e9f291da577be0b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the ship has traveled a long distance, but the wake is still clear and intact, which violates the physical law that \"the wake weakens over time\").", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09497", "filename": "4e722dc8da229c4148fb1774be5311044e280f20e010a6fb4a8aa48554e583e9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is discontinuous (the ground flickers throughout the video); the overall visual presentation is off (the flames in the video are too smooth and lack vibrancy).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09499", "filename": "4ece64eebfb8af653f1f0b67295337f07902a6e80a7d05b9ae208f68d9ce492e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09500", "filename": "4f0a1ee3ef19640aed6010d64ff9a5741caf32d3439649f1d451e74f3f7c8d8b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 0s, the yellow liquid suddenly decreases and the white liquid suddenly increases out of nowhere)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09501", "filename": "4f0a6bb9dc3c314e9869351becae1f27ae69af0b084bdecc287d5487cb25f515_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (glowing objects flicker and human movements are unnatural throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09502", "filename": "4f35dbdbbef59efc5928e38f444999cee95bfcbb190fdc75eca765ddea0c0b3f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (the water flow in the entire video shows inter-frame distortion and flickering, and the clouds also flicker, disrupting the stability of the viewpoint).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09503", "filename": "4f43bc2e31928c5dfdd98edc032e53f39bf2d132225c930f98f8b692b968f817_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09504", "filename": "4f2270b6888db37ea165ea7d7ce701f6db8de8af2ef16babd88c4ce121deaa46_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09507", "filename": "4fead74497d9ee7d41e822554edec41a2e77821d565a176c87e339e4d7e05ad1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (sunlight rays appear as lines in the main video, but as starbursts in this video); Causality (clouds move in the video while the sun remains stationary).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09508", "filename": "05a289cd7326b5e0594ef3de356c8983e24f6679c9ea0701ab0f4ae0c5516217_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09509", "filename": "05ebae72e1b15b5fb5cc7ea403e51025ff37e5e3c9d4c0c49165aad635ab986b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09510", "filename": "05f2b96c1c31490ff634a3289e8e8f588a7a5074113f90d9ab3403cb8f607bcf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (flickering appears in fields, mountains, and villages throughout the video); Physical behavior (the wake of a small boat in the water does not decay, violating the physical law that \"the wake decays over time\").", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09511", "filename": "5a6610c638ec737878052bfffa2575c470ebf8f81533691633b6c38162b84c8b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (flickering of leaves, lights, and tree trunks throughout the video disrupts the stability of the viewpoint).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09512", "filename": "5aa96dac823315987344c9b412f8e990a1c3a0a76283d285bf343ded98af2f25_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the brightness and density of the fireworks remain constant throughout the video, without showing any decay effect over time).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09513", "filename": "5abe1b81216c733c0ed5e2ad8f4632e21d0ae6deb4d2f01b9e797070cf3d2ae5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the background and the squeezed objects appear to flicker throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09516", "filename": "5afbc91874e36031113c3563afb6b45bd437dfed17643f274f4dcea83d1b4d5b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the movements of the characters throughout the video are too predictable and unnatural, lacking vibrancy).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09517", "filename": "5b9dc9b11a0cbdf2056a9509873a7367cbac5d1a7b18854ee6194f5f081c57ce_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (the explosion in the video stutters at 0.5s), Time continuity (the explosion suddenly appears at 0.5s, a black object suddenly appears in the dust at the bottom of the video at 1.3s, and the hills, fog, and ground in the entire video flicker), Causality (the surrounding objects still exist after the explosion at 2.2s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09518", "filename": "5b3051a4ffeed7289e461f5a3aaaaecb1cf8406b1a32d8b866b9cfb7b65d924d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (a flame suddenly appears at 0.3s, but the sparkler is burning in the video. The flame produced by the sparkler is short-lived, but the flame in the video is continuous).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09519", "filename": "5bb12dd191b69ceda72701d9d921348b712e1e299e8f09cd507e0d3c3800dd42_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09520", "filename": "45838e38158ffe3c6507a9389ca35cd1b9691326d88725398f7e639151cc7938_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video error: Time continuity (the entire video is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09521", "filename": "51770d18b8e430d93abcf8985201d17dfd278d6b6ca1bb378527f58da9841662_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video is continuous (at 1.9 seconds, the egg does not make a splash when it falls into the water; from 2.7 seconds to 8 seconds, the egg that fell into the water was deformed and stuck to the bottom of the cup; the entire video is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09522", "filename": "51955dd7501d4770522c9439f26c7d15b08ba766b5d6bd252c8f5e54b95e1f43_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video error: Time continuity (the entire video is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09523", "filename": "52537bbf004c4f1e56bca44ac68622ba805fbfbfab81973974eff17321b2609b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09524", "filename": "53886df3609e00f4206c72b1119fa057ac90a51d9a6ed6b855545d20f93bc9f4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal, exhibiting physical behavior (the hydraulic press is seen squeezing the wood block at 3.8 seconds, but the wood block does not show obvious signs of squeezing, and the final explosion effect of the wood block is too abrupt and does not conform to the material's natural behavior) and continuous time (the entire video is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09525", "filename": "54573ddd6231b0ded425aa881d02b729831fe5d74185e82bf85e2ae91af24ef2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: continuous time (water is continuously poured into the pot throughout the video, but the amount of water in the pot does not change, and the top of the video is constantly flashing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09526", "filename": "54661d3b585a6579fedde7183767526558bb0e1d3ec6c4fd6cee8fa95d40e9dd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.9 seconds, the chili peppers on the clamps suddenly deform, and the texture on the stone in the video keeps twitching and flickering. Also, at 7.1 seconds, the fourth chili pepper from the top shows a reduction in the area of charred meat).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09527", "filename": "55091e6afb9a198667ccd8ac27a4aaa7a25892e684579c6b950651ca83fb373a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal and the timing is continuous (the upper half of the circle drawn by the compass in the 0.6s-1.5s and 3.5s-5s intervals does not show any trace of the circle drawn after the compass is drawn; at 2.2s, the trace of the circle drawn by the compass is inconsistent with the black pen line shown; and the entire video is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09528", "filename": "56118cf35e889f5ac553d7c27e9119e24842b4d88bad3ce32c9cc898451fd011_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the background of the entire video is constantly flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09529", "filename": "56336ab0998eddb699c62dc0ef63f688868347935bc01980530b96525ef93f4b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the grass in the entire video is constantly flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09530", "filename": "57032cba6c7092a048c7faec980f0cb86d90e42ca300b8b3a5692521578f0ccf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the bottom left corner of the video is constantly flickering throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09531", "filename": "57093a17989eab683bd49c8b6ae97d3a8baf9767664f20034aafb72beef809e8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1s, the pencil shavings suddenly break and then recover; at 4.8s, there is only one ring of wood chips when the pencil is being sharpened, but two rings of wood chips appear at the same time; the background at the top of the video is constantly flickering throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09532", "filename": "58777c439cd8f5060d58356e064b4794dd7ca58e12a2d82253339fa65792228d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal and the timing is continuous (the leaves, trees, and hills in the video are twitching, flickering, and merging, and the left side of the water is calm while the right side of the water is constantly showing regular ripples).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09533", "filename": "60234bc3d4c6a274add900fbb5bd710ce295ddfda0e2c8989236a3bcb0bbdc86_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous (between 2.5s and 3.6s, the magnets attract each other, but the right side is attracted together while the left side is repelled, which is inconsistent. Also, the small iron ball in the video is constantly flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09534", "filename": "63228e5fc0ad7e9adf2a8ef0ff9f8bdc92cd35c8fcf198c870f937f58f925b6b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: continuous flickering (the upper right corner of the video is constantly flashing throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09535", "filename": "64210ee877c0e1f12bf16be03baeb4264222967678109d8cdd4ee4943669818d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: continuous timing (the bread being baked suddenly expands at 2.5 seconds, and the entire video is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09536", "filename": "71863e20f0c177b25471a0c264e6f06ef8c082cb32f655096869dfb983ba7e91_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the coffee machine countertop is constantly flickering throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09537", "filename": "73440e5e17a0734789e4acaf44c4a6acb5f854071320a0132ce57ef37408c124_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the fire on the car that exploded and caught fire between 1.3s and 4.5s, which was affected by gasoline, continued to burn but then quickly went out, which does not conform to the laws of combustion) and continuity of time (the grass and trees in the entire video are constantly flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09538", "filename": "77996eb81486c31b484a04a3e5e298a5599984992bdc5dc777cb7f0b1a6f66ec_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous time (the left side of the video is constantly flickering, and the blue light in the frame does not change with the camera movement).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09539", "filename": "78741e2cd20f573f89712018bfcf71f403bffe575ca717ba9409467f3834aa4d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal and the timing is inconsistent (details of distant grass, ground, and vehicles flicker and twitch throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09540", "filename": "79253f01844ae5d2fda452fb0d4c4b6fc659d6d6d7d95dd3c7997130c8f947e1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the burning marks on the sparkler in the video continue to rise, even after the sparkler has burned out, which does not conform to the laws of combustion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09541", "filename": "80279e732e7fd30fd02a7b7d2fbd14541b5fa2387b9453fe868896dc5b1e449e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the background of the entire video is constantly flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09542", "filename": "82984fcf7c1ef863ace8bbc15dc09f4c4ea9e94246d3979776b072753e1ba2b3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the object in the video is not being cut with the sharp end of scissors, but the cut is smooth).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09543", "filename": "92119b340680356444ac65584c6f0b55b3a31c0d1e607f99eb553e29ff56a30f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is continuous (from 2.9s to 8s, the hydraulic press crushes the grapes, but the grapes do not show obvious signs of being crushed, and the entire video is flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09544", "filename": "94460cbfb777d833b9f040f4efee87e88259cf063c93d00b3a7cd9e6dec7bf74_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows abnormal behavior due to physical behavior (the liquid that should have fallen between 0 and 2.6 seconds is suspended in the air, which does not conform to the laws of gravity, and the liquid in the video shows color mixing and flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09545", "filename": "96423ab3817c4ffd6c05495801990180afad98b7fa895b37c91bab9177c39c4c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09546", "filename": "97123d0e71b884cd48989647b00bab8539bdbdfbc9ffc743cfd53c14d5b01159_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous flickering (the crystal in the video is constantly flashing throughout).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09547", "filename": "99697ca9c93dcfe64dc20cb336a7e74c8f1b86cf528449a2d40c0bc72f3eae92_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the river is in a rapid state throughout the video, but regular ripples appear on the water surface in the upper right corner of the video, and the shore is constantly flickering throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09548", "filename": "127466b3e7ec2ddd0f18273b61cccc841afe61a82e9e8e35b85720c001ade654_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09549", "filename": "178874f84d6f180439cb7a6293557a09358f87a495347897b134cfbd3217a1d8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the clouds remain still throughout the video, and the video image keeps flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09550", "filename": "57093a17989eab683bd49c8b6ae97d3a8baf9767664f20034aafb72beef809e8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: from 0.4s to 5.6s, the pencil was not placed in the pencil sharpener hole. After the pencil was sharpened, the pencil tip remained in its original unsharpened state.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09551", "filename": "60234bc3d4c6a274add900fbb5bd710ce295ddfda0e2c8989236a3bcb0bbdc86_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09552", "filename": "63228e5fc0ad7e9adf2a8ef0ff9f8bdc92cd35c8fcf198c870f937f58f925b6b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09553", "filename": "63627b8bc93aeb91eb9dee1a301cc1fb7e44ba8ddc7c78c4b0d6eff60ff66713_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Physical behavior (the path of the flashlight's light source in the entire video does not change in brightness; there is only a strong white light source, and there is also liquid flowing back in the light source).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09554", "filename": "64210ee877c0e1f12bf16be03baeb4264222967678109d8cdd4ee4943669818d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the pastries inside the oven move up and down simultaneously, but due to slight temperature differences and varying heating times in different parts of the oven, not all pastries can complete the same action at the same time).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09555", "filename": "60234bc3d4c6a274add900fbb5bd710ce295ddfda0e2c8989236a3bcb0bbdc86_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is continuous. (At 0.1s, the magnetic balls in the hand, which were originally in three rows, suddenly become two rows after merging with the magnetic ball below. At 0.3s, the part where the magnetic balls are bent and merged suddenly deforms and twists.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09556", "filename": "70351fe6eb4902f4ace568aeabf93430ac7d7efced78980cfc6406fd5f4c4a62_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09557", "filename": "70351fe6eb4902f4ace568aeabf93430ac7d7efced78980cfc6406fd5f4c4a62_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09558", "filename": "71920eae821726d227d15e645288cafcb91c429e66a28475cdc495f9e6a33436_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical anomalies (in the video, the clouds solidify and move over time without dispersing or changing shape; in the distance of the lake, white waves are constantly surging, while in the video, the water surface closer to the viewer is abnormally calm).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09559", "filename": "71920eae821726d227d15e645288cafcb91c429e66a28475cdc495f9e6a33436_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (abrupt change), at 6s, the lake surface suddenly changes from gently rippling to an abnormally calm, stagnant pool.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09560", "filename": "073771a2ff1bc59c885f19d346f921a03c364a09f4dd9316ca2c58678c5d224c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09561", "filename": "073771a2ff1bc59c885f19d346f921a03c364a09f4dd9316ca2c58678c5d224c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (The color of the petals in the image keeps changing, indicating that time is passing, but the water droplets on the petals do not change shape, nor do they run away or evaporate).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09562", "filename": "80878f5a8a753380861efe6a1a40750c28dc5f0a2683b97ff274ced70ea255dc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (abrupt). At 1.5 seconds into the video, the color of the sphere gradually changes drastically, creating a stark contrast with its previous color.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09563", "filename": "80878f5a8a753380861efe6a1a40750c28dc5f0a2683b97ff274ced70ea255dc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (After 2.9 seconds in the video, the liquid below is subjected to external stimulation, but instead of flowing, it forms a droplet shape).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09564", "filename": "87890a282e621fd841af388af6318a5e0f9b85aa2008580b2c9ffddf6f2e6e3f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the water bottle should fall directly downwards due to gravity, instead of slowly moving up and down as shown in the scene without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09565", "filename": "87890a282e621fd841af388af6318a5e0f9b85aa2008580b2c9ffddf6f2e6e3f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09566", "filename": "91890a6a4d6b686207dfb192e839a33c2eddce9e353f7aa89e722f2f4f859022_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09567", "filename": "92119b340680356444ac65584c6f0b55b3a31c0d1e607f99eb553e29ff56a30f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The grapes were not fully squeezed in the continuous time, and juice overflowed from the side; at 3.1 seconds, whole, peeled grapes suddenly reappeared, while grapes that had already been squeezed inside the squeezer remained intact.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09568", "filename": "92726a2d3fb21b0c329a640f350be09c044194a6124e1abd2d0c1864827ffc41_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Due to physics, after 6.3 seconds, the water in the glass should overflow directly once it's full, but in the video, the water keeps rising along the shape of the glass without overflowing.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09569", "filename": "97123d0e71b884cd48989647b00bab8539bdbdfbc9ffc743cfd53c14d5b01159_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09570", "filename": "0098574af78092b7ea88cb03b55edd4a0fcae3bd36afa25ca0976149f1676c5f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 5.1 seconds, the football suddenly bounces upwards into the air before it even touches the ground, and the trajectory of the bounce is opposite to the trajectory of the first bounce).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09571", "filename": "99697ca9c93dcfe64dc20cb336a7e74c8f1b86cf528449a2d40c0bc72f3eae92_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09572", "filename": "127466b3e7ec2ddd0f18273b61cccc841afe61a82e9e8e35b85720c001ade654_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (0.3s-5s after the water surface is calm, a large number of bubbles suddenly appear out of nowhere and surge upward in the water without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09573", "filename": "127466b3e7ec2ddd0f18273b61cccc841afe61a82e9e8e35b85720c001ade654_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09574", "filename": "178874f84d6f180439cb7a6293557a09358f87a495347897b134cfbd3217a1d8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Overall visual intuition is abnormal: (irregular brightness flickering occurs in the area, disrupting visual continuity)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09576", "filename": "212232e747cd1e3f91adcfb879d7120b5afaf5be6224362cedd7f0c749f6421c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (after 1.1 seconds, the shape of the diamond changes without any external force, and the diamond continues to refract light against a black background).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09577", "filename": "234814b435562b5a2f60c1e594d5cc15c350ec1e49065693a7c5fcffd80a49f9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09578", "filename": "234814b435562b5a2f60c1e594d5cc15c350ec1e49065693a7c5fcffd80a49f9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 6.3 seconds, the person holding a spinning ring in their hand suddenly changes from a small shape to a large one).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09580", "filename": "244415e6b9f30cf205141dba4c85be4863d9e2635a9e89b8f2c608fafd43fcb0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the sunlight in the scene remains unchanged as time flows, only the color slowly fades) and continuous time (at 2.6s, the sun in the scene suddenly changes from a blazing sun to a setting sun).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09584", "filename": "399194e5849a94eae7d18dff77f6b1a8ad5ad38525f9d0b3dc2d19b4c11a874a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.3s, the straw that was not touched suddenly starts bubbling on its own; from 0.6s to 2.3s, the yellow liquid does not change shape when stirred; from 6.7s to 7.2s, the liquid returns to the yellow state it was at the beginning of the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09585", "filename": "869c04540e880d31112f9a5976def470df0d71fc2db05186fd378cf285af145b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (discontinuous action; in the previous frame, the hand moves out of the frame, and in the next frame, the right hand appears out of nowhere without any transition, resulting in an unnatural transition).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09586", "filename": "869e0a839a85242d380b29408d3e5d293d12ce6c6687e603da16be19d9c0ddcc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09587", "filename": "921c160e9df0b97ed817e80521c42dccb850ce8224d0123b77386eb024446ebd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09589", "filename": "927df21421c0124f08254f3614095c9fbd87b62efdb0d53e556674e6d6e1f3dd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (3.3s) The small green cylindrical ball in my hand disappears into thin air and turns into a black shadow.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09590", "filename": "941a9c18422613eb5e1d4030cc5ccb39d9c08050160d0596cd42627c76d18e70_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (the slag from the grinding suddenly disappears at 1.2s, the shape of the iron sheet remains unchanged after grinding at 5s, and no slag is produced during grinding from 5.6s to 8s, and the shape of the iron sheet also remains unchanged).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09591", "filename": "943a332c7661897dcb87cc7e096cdf7e9bd9dff22fd75ee4a45cf3a916424a75_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the grass in the video appears abnormally distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09593", "filename": "963e38a1e2cf8561e1d4201e24d300a21c20a56af23eb197fe618151ae695ab2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Physical behavior (after the explosion at 1.6s, the object and objects around the explosion point do not explode in all directions, violating the law of conservation of momentum).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09594", "filename": "1061e2155dc47bf5fa52b647704645fc7097464c138f32b86bd7187747964ea4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09595", "filename": "1605e43f0f93c91d57d3f1cd5194f62419867a3718dc00b55ed88d9b760584c2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to physical behavior (water is poured onto shaved ice, and the water temperature is higher than the shaved ice temperature. Under normal circumstances, the shaved ice should melt, shrink, or collapse, which violates the laws of heat transfer and the physical properties of matter).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09596", "filename": "1656fb7cbaae4ad4ae22a5f96761be54a412d3f52e73daf7cfd2447b904b5109_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09597", "filename": "1717bf2a1ce06c8842fad4d800c0472666aa3338b3f87361c720955c7b2983a2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09598", "filename": "2175ab31176cf6d841d7e8cdde90a4fa268fa20c56136dfee9ca64dd121d5b22_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09599", "filename": "2424a1a6e62c500614e265914416d83ded2784f34b29df3d87f2f4c6bdc3c6a2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09600", "filename": "2434db1fc08b4bd85cba7d42b742678e29ff5ec829269104de07cc1f45cd4c4f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 0.1s, the time display on the left suddenly changes from 10:34 to 10:39 and then to 44:11, which violates the normal pattern of time change. Under normal circumstances, time will not change so much in a short period of time).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09601", "filename": "2694aade132f4fbd5f391f8c546bb9fbbdecf675327f265d9ce0315bf4c4c082_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09602", "filename": "2747cf242c95a2301ad179f0e35de5e88736a1b6ad4c1a17efcb7927ad4ad7f6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the leaves of the maple tree on the left side of the video flicker and wriggle abnormally throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09603", "filename": "2801f27cb83e2ab1cf93a75fb1124531c936830db8a55602a0dedee8bb2e2206_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09604", "filename": "2827c2b628bd8b9ddfd496aec9befb417f16cb63445160910bea284494213379_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09605", "filename": "2850d974320243551ab9927dcd4b7a5743dae3d6c5a7d3a82458a5b1764d0c37_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09606", "filename": "3064e1c135a4e3194aeeb145c34fc062351a71c9bb76adf48965e7dfb29ab5bd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09607", "filename": "03331d9c44dfa204dd48ce3bd19a153a98f0fe3690f4f54a2998b8ce8b9d76b0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (after 1.2 seconds, the flame color turns blue and emits a bright white light, which is inconsistent with the normal burning of the flame).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09608", "filename": "3515b575c0e3502e86936d287051aab9ba375fb01441b3575a30345ded501515_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time continuity (at 0.3s, a small stick suddenly grows from the silver square on the right hand, and at 3.7s, a black disc passes through the finger and becomes a ring).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09609", "filename": "3576f0390fbbb9960c32374c4a0c77e5f3faced45110cd0e4b3ffb6faa109de7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09610", "filename": "3607c7e5fb6fa8a41b30e2e2907710cb1535f34d7da59bae8eebbf46fda66965_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: The time sequence is continuous (the camera zooms in on the island, but the size and position of the clouds in the upper left corner do not change; normally, the clouds should be moving backward).", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09611", "filename": "3761a9c419398c394f379d4017ea76901f7af2ed6e067ae091217ab1b5b2ced7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09612", "filename": "03813efcf2ad1dc620b51329f5b4a447799485231bd83c8b81c518ef22b4f0b9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the shadow of the flowerpot suddenly changes; normally, the lighting in the same scene would not change abruptly).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09613", "filename": "04265b4c942969de7cfa9cc5f643f9c9a57db7ffa300e7b138b5af692b274d9e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the reeds in the video are abnormally twisted and wriggling).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09614", "filename": "4426ae07aafd12a86db2fb6427caaa670323e9f2c09b15a093dd78f59857c4af_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to physical factors (the white mist in the entire video does not diffuse outwards, which violates the diffusion principle of molecules; normally it should drift outwards).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09615", "filename": "6aeed3a576074f3354aaa98491e50f5f9cbd100e168a8c9e71594005b07f3d19_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the match in the video is burning, but the surface of the match shows no change).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09616", "filename": "6bc2fb489a1568ad7630455af1540de7b3ca985c612dc1fdf607477abeab3a84_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09617", "filename": "6bc2fb489a1568ad7630455af1540de7b3ca985c612dc1fdf607477abeab3a84_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous timing (flickering throughout the video)", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09618", "filename": "6bc8132ea58815dc1b43422c6c816b6631c2c994197f0a30f06e783c5d325674_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (at 4.4s, the sunlight in the upper left corner of the video is not directed at any object, forming a light spot that does not conform to the straight-line propagation of light).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09619", "filename": "6bc8132ea58815dc1b43422c6c816b6631c2c994197f0a30f06e783c5d325674_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (flickering in the sky in the video).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09620", "filename": "6bf44ec533d76bbf3eb1331906f7e02010a04103309efc502fe19a4e7485355b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Continuous timing (the object behind the bowl disappears into thin air at 3.5 seconds); Physical behavior (the icicle in the bowl suddenly bounces up without any force, which does not conform to the laws of mechanics).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09625", "filename": "6c876bc4dbe5199790b6ca00bbde901d3a45372cd27c78110c482b41e8daf709_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the transparent object in the middle of the video abruptly changes at 3.5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09626", "filename": "6c876bc4dbe5199790b6ca00bbde901d3a45372cd27c78110c482b41e8daf709_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Time continuity (a sudden change in the transparency of the object at 1.8s); Physical behavior (a finger penetrating a glass bowl at 4.2s violates the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09627", "filename": "6cc229035eb25cce8cda46f1766f828e3591774633644eabe1e780eba1d4f049_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09628", "filename": "6cd47390a363feeb74cb45dd9191a553d02c659d3c3653dfe3813d78bbc26441_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the real sun emits soft light in all directions, especially near the horizon, where atmospheric scattering causes the light to diffuse outwards, creating a gradual halo, while the sun does not have this soft transition of light scattering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09629", "filename": "6d60fb7619e590bc65b8956768944d948091f3cfb2c4cef3f69e8d698b58a612_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 4.7s, the liquid in the video suddenly turns into gray dust).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09630", "filename": "6d81c2f27f7275d15ca54b27cac18a4fdfb1b4ded8654bb088baf7c725d0544e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the video is frozen at 6.7s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09631", "filename": "6d2865de888497ceb80f6dbbcbc965afe5f3720d1b8ee4bbe3b54dc0f2cc2de9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video is continuous in time (no bubbles are generated at the bottom of the pot, but bubbles appear out of thin air at the top).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09632", "filename": "6d2865de888497ceb80f6dbbcbc965afe5f3720d1b8ee4bbe3b54dc0f2cc2de9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Time continuity (at 1.5s, there is no excessive liquid in the video pot that instantly boils).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09638", "filename": "0e89d9663e549854155bb506c14aef69efacb1a507191f2013d94c58f973a528_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (2.21-5s, when the rear of the toy car is pressed down by the tire, the front of the car should lift up slightly, but the toy car in the video does not show any obvious upward lifting motion.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09639", "filename": "0e89d9663e549854155bb506c14aef69efacb1a507191f2013d94c58f973a528_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (April 1st - May 27th, after the tire runs over the toy car, the tire deforms. In real life, the reaction force exerted by the toy car on the tire is insufficient to cause the tire to deform, violating Newton's third law.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09641", "filename": "0e184d67b5a24606676bb0f263620300bc911ef2b3f3acecf275188e79dc4ed4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (0-5s: As the camera moves, the light and shadow on all the mirrors in the video do not change. In real life, the light and shadow on the mirrors should change continuously as the camera moves.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09642", "filename": "0e352a87b99f57bea55f1a5b5597d29cabd8c381759baa5301ac18973c0e64cf_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time sequence is continuous (from 0 to 2.8 seconds, the syringe is drawing liquid from the bottle, but the amount of liquid in the bottle is not decreasing; from 2.25 to 4.5 seconds, the syringe is pushing liquid into the bottle, but the amount of liquid in the bottle is not increasing).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09643", "filename": "0e352a87b99f57bea55f1a5b5597d29cabd8c381759baa5301ac18973c0e64cf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video behavior: Physical behavior (at 2.2 seconds into the video, the syringe did not draw liquid from the bottle, but the liquid flowed into the syringe on its own, violating the physical laws of liquid flow).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09644", "filename": "0e352a87b99f57bea55f1a5b5597d29cabd8c381759baa5301ac18973c0e64cf_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (0-5s, liquid is injected into the bottle by a syringe, but the volume of liquid in the bottle changes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09645", "filename": "0e352a87b99f57bea55f1a5b5597d29cabd8c381759baa5301ac18973c0e64cf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at two points, 7.1s and 0.1s, the liquid in the syringe suddenly disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09646", "filename": "0ea1c9ae1a134fb84d98003627672e23a6dc37e2ec0df073e74828de6ceb39d8_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09647", "filename": "0ea1c9ae1a134fb84d98003627672e23a6dc37e2ec0df073e74828de6ceb39d8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (As the camera moves, at 2.8s, the shadow on the right side of the object suddenly disappears. In real life, shadows should gradually disappear as the field of view moves, not suddenly.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09648", "filename": "0eb01ddb8a6a3920ec1190033524555fc25bf1b41e5a9e2ef24f03515d1ee462_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09649", "filename": "0eb01ddb8a6a3920ec1190033524555fc25bf1b41e5a9e2ef24f03515d1ee462_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (From the beginning to the end of the video, as the camera moves, only one of the stationery items in the pile on the left casts a shadow, which does not conform to the principle that light travels in straight lines.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09650", "filename": "0eb01ddb8a6a3920ec1190033524555fc25bf1b41e5a9e2ef24f03515d1ee462_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (In the entire video, the three pens at the top of the pile of stationery on the left are suspended in the air without any point of support, violating the law of gravity.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09651", "filename": "0eb01ddb8a6a3920ec1190033524555fc25bf1b41e5a9e2ef24f03515d1ee462_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (From 3.26 to 8 seconds, as the camera moves, the light and shadow of the object on the right reflected on the paper does not change. In real life, the light and shadow on the paper should change as the camera moves.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09654", "filename": "0ef1f8119a330501d17c10b696b3ac1851892d66bb2d46d48b83a5b630f85b16_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1s, a small boat suddenly appears out of nowhere above the island.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09655", "filename": "0ef1f8119a330501d17c10b696b3ac1851892d66bb2d46d48b83a5b630f85b16_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time sequence is not continuous (the footage is shot from a high altitude, only the camera is moving, and the fog is completely stopped, which violates the laws of fog movement).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09656", "filename": "0ef1f8119a330501d17c10b696b3ac1851892d66bb2d46d48b83a5b630f85b16_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time sequence is not continuous (the footage is shot from a high altitude, only the camera is moving, and the fog is completely stopped, which violates the laws of fog movement).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09657", "filename": "0ef1f8119a330501d17c10b696b3ac1851892d66bb2d46d48b83a5b630f85b16_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (from 1.26 to 8 seconds, the clouds on the right gradually disappear; in a real-world environment, clouds should continue to move rather than disappear statically).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09658", "filename": "0ef5df03a90cbeecc6a1fd105d0117623fc1f5260f585d5efe04ab7e7dd81e73_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The sequence of events is continuous (at 1.6s, a flock of birds flying above the trees suddenly disappears into thin air). Overall visual anomalies are also present (from 3.29 to 5s, the movement of the smoke from the explosion resembles the movement of flowing water, rather than smoke).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09659", "filename": "0ef5df03a90cbeecc6a1fd105d0117623fc1f5260f585d5efe04ab7e7dd81e73_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 4.7 seconds, flames suddenly appear out of nowhere in the forest.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09660", "filename": "0ef5df03a90cbeecc6a1fd105d0117623fc1f5260f585d5efe04ab7e7dd81e73_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (from 0-2s, before the explosion occurs in the forest, a large amount of black smoke is already billowing out of the forest). Overall visual anomalies (from 2.29-5s, debris from the explosion in the forest disappears into thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09661", "filename": "0ef5df03a90cbeecc6a1fd105d0117623fc1f5260f585d5efe04ab7e7dd81e73_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (at 6.5s, a flock of birds flying above the trees suddenly disappears). Overall visual anomalies (from 4.5s to 8s, as the explosion occurs, the clouds in the sky also change significantly, with the clouds suddenly increasing rapidly).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09662", "filename": "0f9cb357f8ac5acd99480fc427d0bd0bd836700cfd7e2dbbfcf8d0714e1c83d5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (0-4.3s, black substance appears in the petri dish for no reason and continues to expand outwards, and recovers in 4.11-5s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09663", "filename": "0f9cb357f8ac5acd99480fc427d0bd0bd836700cfd7e2dbbfcf8d0714e1c83d5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall visual anomaly (the movement of substances in the petri dish is too smooth, unlike a realistic image).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09664", "filename": "0f9cb357f8ac5acd99480fc427d0bd0bd836700cfd7e2dbbfcf8d0714e1c83d5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Physical behavior (At 5s, the substance in the petri dish penetrated the glass, violating the principle of impermeability of solids.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09665", "filename": "P02_109_149_21af70ea6cb45625_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (an abrupt change occurs at 2.8s, where the amount of meat in the pot in the frame increases out of nowhere, without any camera movement or addition of any action).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09666", "filename": "P02_109_151_0ed950841e20cbb7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (abrupt change occurs, with no camera movement or transition; at 4.4s, the amount of yellow food in the pot suddenly increases out of nowhere.)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09667", "filename": "P02_109_151_0ed950841e20cbb7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is discontinuous (an abrupt change occurs; the amount of meat in the pot continuously increases from the beginning to the end).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09668", "filename": "P02_112_82_3b31bfed099ad502_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time is continuous (there is a sudden change at 3.5s, and without any transition, the scene shows a hand smearing a little oil in a pot, but suddenly there is more oil in the pot).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09669", "filename": "P02_112_229_bac682be874c5e16_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.7s, there was no meat filling in her hand, but she put it on the dough and then meat filling appeared out of thin air on the dough; at 3.9s, a little more meat filling appeared out of thin air on the bun).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09670", "filename": "P02_112_281_249946ecd6b8acb2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09671", "filename": "P02_112_287_d75a65a1fb4aea48_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09672", "filename": "P02_112_318_d91aa6528fd6178b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (there is a sudden change, at 4.3s the pot does not have any external force or change in perspective, and when the pot is placed in the sink, the pot suddenly shrinks out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09673", "filename": "P02_112_318_d91aa6528fd6178b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09674", "filename": "P02_113_38_aee945ca72eabcec_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09675", "filename": "P02_113_125_2c1e1d9a2ede0a02_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (an abrupt change occurs; at 3.9 seconds, the gloves in the hands in the frame change from two to one).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09676", "filename": "P02_113_183_46c9d5ab54892174_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the visuals: Time continuity (a sudden change occurs; at 0.6s, the hand slides across the towel, and a small object appears out of thin air on the towel).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09677", "filename": "P02_113_183_46c9d5ab54892174_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (there is a sudden change at 0.9 seconds; in the video, towels are hanging on the stove, and suddenly two towels and a glove disappear, leaving only the stove).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09678", "filename": "P02_118_33_8466fd97f10fc4d7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the blades in the blender are completely stationary, but the items inside are rotating and grinding).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09679", "filename": "P02_118_33_8466fd97f10fc4d7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 1.5s, the blender has only been running for 1 second, and the contents have already become finely ground; even a high-powered blender cannot grind things up in 1 second).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09680", "filename": "P02_118_34_71c7977b55db4418_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the blades in the blender are completely stationary, but the contents inside are rotating; the contents inside will not rotate on their own when the blades are not moving).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09681", "filename": "P02_118_34_71c7977b55db4418_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to physical behavior (at 5.4s, the finger clips through the snack bag without collision or obstruction, which is illogical).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09682", "filename": "P02_118_34_71c7977b55db4418_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.9s, a blue glove appears out of thin air on the left hand without any transition or foreshadowing; then the orange bag disappears out of thin air without any obstruction or camera movement).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09683", "filename": "P02_118_58_654c17ff8e212d88_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (an abrupt change occurs at 2.5s when the buttons on the blender suddenly and inexplicably disappear from the screen).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09684", "filename": "P02_118_58_654c17ff8e212d88_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09685", "filename": "P02_118_59_87761b1f2e19020d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is continuous (between 2.6s and 3.2s, the scissors in the video appear distorted).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09686", "filename": "P02_118_127_b7bc0fa0f18ee46b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09687", "filename": "P02_118_127_b7bc0fa0f18ee46b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09688", "filename": "P02_119_15_dbd29910f8e82088_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: a yellow block suddenly appears in the bowl without any transition or foreshadowing at 4.4s.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09689", "filename": "P02_119_15_dbd29910f8e82088_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: Time continuity (at 6.4 seconds, the yellow blocks in the bowl disappear out of thin air without any obstruction or camera movement).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09690", "filename": "P02_119_15_dbd29910f8e82088_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (sudden change occurs, the amount of flour in the bowl continuously increases from the beginning to the end of the video).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09691", "filename": "P02_120_156_5d420d02cad13d30_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09692", "filename": "P02_120_156_5d420d02cad13d30_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the blender is running, but the liquid in the bowl is not rotating or shaking; the blender and the liquid are disconnected).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09693", "filename": "P02_120_156_5d420d02cad13d30_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 5.2s, there were originally only two hands holding the container in the scene, and then an extra hand appeared out of nowhere, without any transition of perspective or camera switch, and appeared directly in the scene area).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09694", "filename": "P02_120_187_9043e21d84129864_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the sudden change occurs at 3.7s, when liquid suddenly appears out of nowhere in the empty mixer and is stirred, and at 6.6s, the character picks up a white object from the mixer and then disappears into thin air without leaving any trace).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09695", "filename": "P35_109_137_2789bb16369d3312_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (a green dot suddenly appears on the index finger at 1.4s; the black handle on the character's left hand suddenly disappears at 1.9s); Physical behavior (the finger clips through the glass wall as it falls at 1.5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09696", "filename": "P35_109_148_e074d90f3322b1cd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the two glasses penetrate each other at 0s, violating the impermeability of solids); Time continuity (the black shadow effect in the white glass at 2.9s appears unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09697", "filename": "P35_109_148_e074d90f3322b1cd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09698", "filename": "P37_101_1_349d01ecc266866f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09699", "filename": "P37_101_1_349d01ecc266866f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 4.1s, the blue item inside the refrigerator suddenly disappears into thin air) Physical behavior (at 6.5s, the refrigerator door moves to the left without any external force)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09700", "filename": "P37_101_87_a0a5f1e554cde13f_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the chicken legs in the pot throughout the video lack the proper shape, texture, and lifelike appearance).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09701", "filename": "P37_101_87_a0a5f1e554cde13f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the chicken leg appearing in the frame at 0.2s lacks the expected shape, texture, and liveliness).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09702", "filename": "P37_101_87_a0a5f1e554cde13f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09703", "filename": "P37_101_94_6c47161cf517be53_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Continuous time (the boiler and lid inexplicably separate at 1.3s) Physical behavior (the hand separates from the boiler at 1.5s, and the boiler does not fall downwards without any pulling or supporting force; at 1.9s, the boiler adheres to the hand and moves with the hand's movement)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09704", "filename": "P37_101_94_6c47161cf517be53_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The timing is continuous (at 1.5s, a white connecting object suddenly appears above the cup, connecting with the black object above it); the overall visual impression is abnormal (at 2.9s, the texture of the vegetable skin that appears in the frame is too regular and lacks vividness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09705", "filename": "P37_101_94_6c47161cf517be53_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (the cabinet door handle suddenly disappears at 1.1s; the black cup taken out suddenly increases in size at 2.1s); Physical behavior (the cabinet door opens in a side-opening manner at 1.4s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09706", "filename": "P37_101_216_6efbe5e55f430595_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visuals: Time sequence (at 0.6s, the garlic clove in the hand suddenly splits into two; at 1.7s, the left finger suddenly turns black; at 1.8s, garlic cloves suddenly appear in the hand; at 4.6s, the number of garlic cloves in contact with the knife suddenly decreases) Causality (at 3.9s, the cut garlic cloves suddenly become whole again)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09707", "filename": "P37_101_226_34d3a426ae1baf0a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.1s, the garlic clove on the character's right hand appears out of thin air; at 3.7s, the two garlic cloves in the right hand suddenly become one; at 5.4s, a garlic clove suddenly appears in the right hand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09708", "filename": "P37_101_228_f2325d5d478202f1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (the video suddenly changes at 0.7s, the number of garlic cloves on the knife suddenly increases at 2.9s, and the number of garlic cloves on the knife suddenly increases at 5.1s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09709", "filename": "P37_101_257_61f23b78389a5a06_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is inconsistent (the object in the middle of the boiler suddenly disappears at 0.6s, and the video stutters at 0.8s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09710", "filename": "P37_101_257_61f23b78389a5a06_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 3s, a soup ladle appears out of thin air in the soup pot).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09711", "filename": "P37_101_273_be6086e5555bb29d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time sequence (at 0.8s, the shape of the chicken leg below the left hand changes; at 1.5s, the shape of the chicken leg in the hand suddenly changes; at 2.7s, the torn chicken meat suddenly disappears; at 4.5s, the shape of the chicken leg in the pot changes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09712", "filename": "P37_101_278_77bd38db4d98d112_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.7s, the chicken leg below the character's hand suddenly disappears; at 1.8s, the character suddenly pulls a chicken leg out of the bowl of food).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09713", "filename": "P37_101_278_77bd38db4d98d112_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.1 seconds, the chicken leg falls into the pot and suddenly appears to teleport; at 4.7 seconds, the peeled chicken leg lacks liveliness).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09714", "filename": "P37_101_278_77bd38db4d98d112_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time sequence (at 0.7s, the chicken leg in the hand suddenly turns into a piece of chicken skin; at 5s, the bowl below suddenly disappears; at 6.7s, water suddenly comes out of the faucet).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09715", "filename": "P37_101_288_4f320640fbc25fd8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.1s, the chicken leg in the hand undergoes a sudden change, the meat disappears, leaving only bones and skin; at 4s, the size of the chicken leg changes; at 4.8s, the skin of the chicken leg is easily torn apart, lacking a realistic sense of force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09716", "filename": "P37_101_288_4f320640fbc25fd8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual inconsistencies (at 2.9s, the chicken skin peeling off is too smooth and lacks liveliness; and the texture of the peeled chicken leg meat lacks liveliness; at 7s, the chicken skin reappears at the tail of the chicken leg).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09717", "filename": "P37_101_288_4f320640fbc25fd8_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: Time sequence (0.9s: water stains suddenly appear in the tank; 1.1s: chicken leg volume suddenly increases; 3.4s: chicken skin on the right hand suddenly increases; 3.9s: chicken skin suddenly falls off the right hand; 5.2s: chicken skin suddenly contracts upwards)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09718", "filename": "P37_101_304_35ac2c74987a7123_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The screen display is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.1s, a button suddenly appears below the right hand; at 1.5s, a red number suddenly appears at the right index finger; at 1.6s, the red characters on the left disappear and the characters on the right suddenly increase; at 2.2s, the characters next to the index finger become distorted).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09719", "filename": "P37_101_304_35ac2c74987a7123_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the red character on the right index finger suddenly disappears at 3.4s and a small red dot suddenly appears at 6.1s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09720", "filename": "P37_101_306_73f0d9ec074ac782_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Continuous timing (the video suddenly changes direction at 1.3s). Causal relationship: At 6.9s, there is no liquid on the bottle body, but liquid is still pouring out of the bottle opening.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09721", "filename": "P37_101_306_73f0d9ec074ac782_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time sequence is continuous (the cap at the bottle opening suddenly opens on its own at 2.2 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09722", "filename": "P37_101_319_df38435dbc815479_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The timing is continuous (at 0.7s, minced garlic suddenly appears out of thin air in the hand and under the hand; at 1.5s, minced garlic suddenly appears on the cutting board that the right hand removed from the cutting board).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09723", "filename": "P37_101_319_df38435dbc815479_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09724", "filename": "P37_101_357_05336d13031a78f8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the knife pierces the onion at 4:18) Causal relationship (only the top half of the onion is cut off at 4:20, and the cut onion returns to its whole shape)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09725", "filename": "5ecd81a89511e91b6b04c35085566b1089a76932ce46343e92bab1d923a3d794_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 3.6s, the iron balls on the left and right sides of the video split apart, and at 3.7s, the iron ball at the bottom of the video appears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09726", "filename": "5ecd81a89511e91b6b04c35085566b1089a76932ce46343e92bab1d923a3d794_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (flickering of object surfaces throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09727", "filename": "5ed0ef80917e1de8c97b4e090c6612efaf20bf12a27f0cf3131372ed71fd12c5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the object in the middle of the video disappears out of nowhere at 0.9s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09728", "filename": "5ed0ef80917e1de8c97b4e090c6612efaf20bf12a27f0cf3131372ed71fd12c5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (at 1.3s, an object appears out of thin air in the upper left corner of the video and flies out, and the entire scene behind the video flickers). Physical behavior: (at 4.1s, an explosion occurs on the ground in the upper right corner of the video, but no change occurs, violating the principle of conservation of kinetic energy).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09729", "filename": "5ed0ef80917e1de8c97b4e090c6612efaf20bf12a27f0cf3131372ed71fd12c5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (from 1.4s to 3.6s, the flames emitted by the rocket in the upper left corner of the video suddenly turn into sand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09730", "filename": "5f82a107111e9ffb3c290e1cd43de6f0118774be0cc99f90372b77a669595c9e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (debris appears out of nowhere on the left side of the video at 1.8 seconds); there is no causal relationship (there was no motorcycle debris at the explosion site in the video before, and it is impossible for motorcycle debris to appear after the explosion).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09731", "filename": "5fe4ba88b9ef16cf1ad6dbf3a54e63a593f051d85973f754e1af9ab377b7bf99_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The video is continuous in time (at 2.2 seconds, the object below the hydraulic press suddenly grows larger, and the surface of the object in the middle of the video flickers).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09732", "filename": "5fe4ba88b9ef16cf1ad6dbf3a54e63a593f051d85973f754e1af9ab377b7bf99_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.6s, the plastic film that fell off on the left side of the video disappears out of thin air; from 6.5s to 7.4s, the object on the left side below the hydraulic press cracks and then becomes intact again).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09733", "filename": "06e82a11a7891004b69c9da17a6a68c8904b3db7141f7604146ee76abd4bc998_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the cloud layer on the right side of the video suddenly changes at 0.4s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09734", "filename": "06e6892063323397663eb81061279228e68154a09199f806105c074acc4c7d9a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the ground beneath the melting object in the entire video changes abruptly).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09735", "filename": "06e6892063323397663eb81061279228e68154a09199f806105c074acc4c7d9a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 3.3s, water bubbles rising from directly above the ice surface without external force violate the law of gravity, causing the overall video to flicker).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09736", "filename": "6a0dc5a4da39e2360717ed6c884f5cd5f421a2cf3ce5f1675716cfb915d1f132_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (the drain cover in the middle of the video disappears out of thin air at 1.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09737", "filename": "6a8f7793e4a2d774b7fa72b1977f306535d973983a56951e097859f8cedeaa75_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Cause and effect (at 1.5s, the hydraulic press in the video is in contact with an object, causing the object to break; at 1.5s, the object at the bottom of the video disappears out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09738", "filename": "6a8f7793e4a2d774b7fa72b1977f306535d973983a56951e097859f8cedeaa75_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (at 2.9s, an object appears out of thin air on the right side of the hydraulic press; at 3s, fragments appear out of thin air in the middle of the video; at 4s, the cracked hydraulic press is restored to its original state; at 5s, a piece of iron appears out of thin air below the hydraulic press).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09739", "filename": "6a2141646e2f04eeef6075a261dccf633788d25cc5d9979ed7cca04e8d0715eb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (smoke appears to rise out of thin air from the edges of objects in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09740", "filename": "6a2141646e2f04eeef6075a261dccf633788d25cc5d9979ed7cca04e8d0715eb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The time sequence is continuous (smoke rises out of thin air around the object between 0s and 3.2s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09741", "filename": "6ac210a83631531f23f5964fd4975416ef0f3d022a210a6b17418f7852cb61d4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09742", "filename": "6ad5c1351a22741de513214848365587b619d7594c170956f391836372559eb4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09743", "filename": "6ada68731ee220aefcaa910fb7e01b7dcb2fd91b1728b05119b650cbb7bb033e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: continuous time (smoke appears out of nowhere in the middle of the 3s video, where two candles create smoke out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09744", "filename": "6ae332915b83e72ac47e73f0380bbd16dc5236d810e8041f8293ef64148ff5e9_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (at 0.5s, the object on the right side of the video suddenly starts burning out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09745", "filename": "2b2338239f73491643af1c24503436ba9f1c6ca3704227561622e043a60fae18_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Screen anomaly: Time continuity (a white dot appears out of nowhere in the upper left corner of the screen at 0.9s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09746", "filename": "2b43645631179a97c030e5e601be35dca5b5e49c30c3941f9b8e5cd42a1588c5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (at 1.3s, a point at the bottom of the bottle opening appears to be dented downwards, and then recovers spontaneously without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09747", "filename": "2b43645631179a97c030e5e601be35dca5b5e49c30c3941f9b8e5cd42a1588c5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the right pinky finger appears out of thin air at 5.1s) (the object in the upper left corner of the hand appears out of thin air at 1.6s and disappears at 3.6s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09748", "filename": "2b43645631179a97c030e5e601be35dca5b5e49c30c3941f9b8e5cd42a1588c5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (no scratches were observed when the device contacted the clay at 4.1s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09749", "filename": "2b43645631179a97c030e5e601be35dca5b5e49c30c3941f9b8e5cd42a1588c5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (starting from 3.9s, the middle part of the clay spontaneously changes shape without any intervention).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09753", "filename": "2bc9c37cbeac718704161fef28670116a81c5c4954e6d9220afc194606a93f17_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the colored stone in the center of the screen is spinning rapidly without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09754", "filename": "2bc9c37cbeac718704161fef28670116a81c5c4954e6d9220afc194606a93f17_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Overall, the image appears unusual (the fingers of the person in the image are too brightly colored, and the fingerprints show a natural glow).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09755", "filename": "2bc51a0f77a612c90822812902a7910406373da53d3e62c97a5dcaf814a60cae_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09756", "filename": "2bc51a0f77a612c90822812902a7910406373da53d3e62c97a5dcaf814a60cae_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the color of the chocolate suddenly changes from brown to red at 1.4 seconds in the video).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09757", "filename": "2bc51a0f77a612c90822812902a7910406373da53d3e62c97a5dcaf814a60cae_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image anomaly: Timing anomaly (at 4.2s, two fingers of the left hand are clearly pressing on the chocolate in the image, but there are no pressure marks on the chocolate; normally there should be fingerprints or deformation).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09758", "filename": "2bc51a0f77a612c90822812902a7910406373da53d3e62c97a5dcaf814a60cae_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09759", "filename": "2bd6a2b278c74e328e2da4f2919dba062c1d40377c73e8cafaef1e71027086a3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the harvester is moving forward and harvesting, but the amount of grain on the vehicle is not increasing) Time continuity (the wheel on the right rear of the machine disappears at 1.4s)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09760", "filename": "2bd6a2b278c74e328e2da4f2919dba062c1d40377c73e8cafaef1e71027086a3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the tracks left by the wheels on the ground during the harvester's movement are not realistic).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09761", "filename": "2bd6a2b278c74e328e2da4f2919dba062c1d40377c73e8cafaef1e71027086a3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09762", "filename": "2bf85a26ec613de63b9a21e3e3e3c8716e29f289009e59e580e8f58fd87d8fb5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (a blue screen flickers in the video, but the light intensity remains unchanged, as can be seen from the radiation intensity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09763", "filename": "2bf85a26ec613de63b9a21e3e3e3c8716e29f289009e59e580e8f58fd87d8fb5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (light is reflected from the rear window, but as the light moves, the reflection in the right window does not move with it).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09764", "filename": "2bf85a26ec613de63b9a21e3e3e3c8716e29f289009e59e580e8f58fd87d8fb5_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09765", "filename": "2bfc73f0039e6c4b93437c2c5012066d0d6f5b267738b4bfc2becd196b782239_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: physical behavior (underwater pressure is high, gas should exist in the form of small bubbles, and because of its low density, it should rise, but in the image, the bubbles in the seawater are moving downwards).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09766", "filename": "2bfc73f0039e6c4b93437c2c5012066d0d6f5b267738b4bfc2becd196b782239_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: physical behavior (underwater pressure is high, gas should exist in the form of small bubbles, and because of its low density, it should rise, but in the image, the bubbles in the seawater are moving downwards).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09767", "filename": "2bfc73f0039e6c4b93437c2c5012066d0d6f5b267738b4bfc2becd196b782239_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly occurred in the video between 2.2s and 4.1s: a series of numerous bubbles appeared, which is inconsistent with the physical dispersion characteristics of bubbles.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09768", "filename": "2bfc73f0039e6c4b93437c2c5012066d0d6f5b267738b4bfc2becd196b782239_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The abnormal footage indicates a causal relationship (explosive bubbles will not form deep underwater without a large injection of gas).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09769", "filename": "2c4cd2c440d09ef88fca0c000f4960fecf3b39ea35b0d91e0f69270378c0dea5_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 3.6 seconds in the footage, the little girl's arm undergoes a non-physiological twisting and deformation).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09770", "filename": "2c4cd2c440d09ef88fca0c000f4960fecf3b39ea35b0d91e0f69270378c0dea5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: In the 0.1s-0.8s frame, the little girl's left hand rationally picks up the hat, which is inconsistent with human form logic and the overall intuition is abnormal (in the 1s-2.1s frame, the little girl's action of putting on the hat is too smooth, unlike real footage, and lacks the necessary pauses).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09771", "filename": "2c4cd2c440d09ef88fca0c000f4960fecf3b39ea35b0d91e0f69270378c0dea5_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09772", "filename": "2c4fc2ada08eabc0225b40352c64d4d95e0492b4c1615761f5bdac7d8b4382cc_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the spheres appear and disappear out of thin air in the hand at 1s and 2.7s).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09773", "filename": "2c4fc2ada08eabc0225b40352c64d4d95e0492b4c1615761f5bdac7d8b4382cc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 2.2s, a finger appears out of nowhere in the middle of the screen).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09774", "filename": "2c4fc2ada08eabc0225b40352c64d4d95e0492b4c1615761f5bdac7d8b4382cc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09775", "filename": "426536f2fb9ddc092dd21e3f9486ab7c433030028e665201e3c020633c9d35ad_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time sequence (1.2s: ripples suddenly appear on the surface of the water in the container; 2.6s: the shape of the water surface changes to a honeycomb pattern; 4.6s: the shape of the water surface changes to a honeycomb pattern).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09776", "filename": "428307c22384cce1580e9d75a66d25121e388b0f88d0ffb3930a018e464c30ae_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video suddenly slows down at 3s, stutters at 5.8s, and the metal frame in the upper right corner of the screen does not connect smoothly at 5.9s.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09777", "filename": "0450533ed4273623f9723c58656e2a067d1fa556921289b471a35b77bf025887_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is not continuous (the movement of pedestrians in the lower left corner of the entire video is unnatural, and the leaves in the video are blurry and unnatural).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09778", "filename": "450909ea8c6ef802e64dfb3371a1f7a39e1df65cac0ac002ae512545e1694b35_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09779", "filename": "450909ea8c6ef802e64dfb3371a1f7a39e1df65cac0ac002ae512545e1694b35_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to physical behavior (the crystal and background light are completely still in the entire video, but the colors on the crystal surface are constantly flowing, which violates the laws of physical optics).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09780", "filename": "509566beafbd407bed6c3e6815058abbea59bf7e0c654f1c8cdf587912230621_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09781", "filename": "533681d7a9f719d068fac13091e113f2439a77dc288dabfba36984e6085838b9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (1.6s, the light bulb is short-circuited, the container is obviously closed, but there is smoke overflowing, which violates the physical properties of a closed container).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09782", "filename": "537703e215c4ff4404577f468c02c164660df132849a7c805eaa5628297d0118_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The duration is continuous (the dry ice smoke around the machine noticeably decreases at 2.4 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09783", "filename": "537703e215c4ff4404577f468c02c164660df132849a7c805eaa5628297d0118_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous timing (the fog generator suddenly stops producing fog at 4.3s; the fog at the fog generator's outlet suddenly moves downwards at 6.7s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09784", "filename": "581043ba9072a9788fc124d904e26ab7eb6fb4bf8a446cfc4bdd522475480b2a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (the liquid swings back and forth at 1.3s and jumps at the bottom right of the container at 3s).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09785", "filename": "581043ba9072a9788fc124d904e26ab7eb6fb4bf8a446cfc4bdd522475480b2a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (at 2.8s, an object in the liquid jumps upwards without external force) Time continuity (at 4.5s, the volume of the white object suddenly increases)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09786", "filename": "613939fcb3f44aa4b0901a3317ef601ee06799371ccb83b6115567ce53e94794_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Time sequence (0.8s: granular objects suddenly appear in front of the crushed banana; 1.2s: brown objects suddenly appear; 1.8s: round objects suddenly appear; 1.9s: the round object on the left suddenly disappears; 2s: the shape of the crushed banana becomes distorted; 3s: the crushed banana returns to its original shape).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09787", "filename": "692018d1ff0846151035e05fa0b7a80fd35d10b7d6756ff7a1bf015a8b477932_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09788", "filename": "729892b8440230e9d78878aea891dd1ad31ca11832e43c4472d54f2d30404fb5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09789", "filename": "744378a2b103c9d45b332720a7f0e710294cfe8fbd3acbd9a8ff4b912f72f6e7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (an abnormal purple light suddenly appears on the left side of the video at 1.6s, and an abnormal light suddenly appears on the left side of the video at 2.6s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09790", "filename": "744378a2b103c9d45b332720a7f0e710294cfe8fbd3acbd9a8ff4b912f72f6e7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.7s, a small white object suddenly appears on the road; at 3.3s, the white object on the road suddenly moves forward instantly; at 3.5s, a white shadow suddenly appears and flickers next to the black object on the side of the road).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09791", "filename": "768499dcd3efe001b8fa20fb65bc94cac64d1171008808fb67d29dcfb8da212e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Continuous timing (the cigarette suddenly ignites at 0.1s); Causal relationship (the smoke at the front should decrease when the cigarette is burning at 0.3s, but the smoke in the video feed does not decrease).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09792", "filename": "802913dfd607315dfc4b7c0b0c2a7405a25b808035842154fbbd837baeea4b7d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video stutters at 4.7 seconds.", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09793", "filename": "802913dfd607315dfc4b7c0b0c2a7405a25b808035842154fbbd837baeea4b7d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 4.2s, the object is a soft object but does not fall downwards)", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09794", "filename": "827146cea7a746741742f91fb28bbab8b8fdd2b76ce50bcf7ec52db746d34e06_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09795", "filename": "827146cea7a746741742f91fb28bbab8b8fdd2b76ce50bcf7ec52db746d34e06_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the waterfall area in the entire video has an overly uniform white mist effect, lacking the gradual flow of water, splashing water, and texture details of rocks found in a natural waterfall; details are missing).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09796", "filename": "832701c336bbe3010c0298be98490248590a0a8e62b3a1853ac7e12ffe5f5d04_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The timing is continuous (white smoke turns into flames at 0.7s, white smoke suddenly increases at 1.9s, and the flames in the lower right corner suddenly turn into white smoke at 4.4s).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09800", "filename": "0949263d3435d72ea7e4b2507552a0ab3eaa125f144688cf1afb0331c8c326cd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the water surface textures in the entire video are not clear enough).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09801", "filename": "0949263d3435d72ea7e4b2507552a0ab3eaa125f144688cf1afb0331c8c326cd_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Time continuity (the entire video frame is still, and the video image is blurry).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09802", "filename": "1652765f2ee431eb22c674bb55bf9e197fec101e6f6162f293120304a48b6483_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09803", "filename": "1939039e4b71f7ee4c92aa89a6caaddd7500fb229e2c957cc1f0935b2fc0bec0_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the ice cubes move on their own without any external force throughout the entire video) Time continuity (the ice cubes undergo a sudden change at 2.7s, and foam suddenly appears on the glass wall at 3s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09804", "filename": "1939039e4b71f7ee4c92aa89a6caaddd7500fb229e2c957cc1f0935b2fc0bec0_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous timing (the small object on the ice cube on the left side of the cup suddenly disappears at 0.1s; the shape of the ice cube suddenly changes at 4.1s); Physical behavior (the ice cube in the cup rotates to the right without any external force throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09805", "filename": "1939039e4b71f7ee4c92aa89a6caaddd7500fb229e2c957cc1f0935b2fc0bec0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (at 1.8s, the ice cube in the cup suddenly becomes one; at 6.8s, a third ice cube suddenly appears in the cup); Physical behavior (at 6.3s, a water droplet passes through the cup).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09806", "filename": "4349657d5434352296edd2b4d7a86cad3fe6afe842cfa7a8094c9f4490bbc6ff_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09807", "filename": "4366505b32989f95c0c26372d9679191d8a2f15fad9ee232d2705ccb1121650c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visuals are abnormal: the overall impression is off (the waves on the coastline in the entire video are not crashing forward, but are completely still, which does not conform to the laws of water movement).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09808", "filename": "9fce6fe9124387aa211b26c64eff95ae3a72e1f618cea5436f48d811a709f567_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (1.1s: coin deforms without external force) Causal relationship (3.2s-5.9s: the coin falling in the middle should fall backward according to inertia, but it falls forward for no reason without any pushing force, without cause and effect)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09809", "filename": "9ff879e8c5a085e0c4f4418994e98e5b4a02132039d8df7ff3f1391125973f46_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09810", "filename": "10cc89fc8d682a9940a947603e59b678c5b61ff23b8a3d7e175c10d8d6b0c184_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Temporal continuity (the overall image color changes from blue to gray between 1.4s and 2.8s); Physical behavior (flickering occurs throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09811", "filename": "10cf4ffb6c92b005763d9b306a916914b60f16433b7bc323e51177891ab5cfde_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity (2.1s-2.3s: a bright white teardrop-shaped dot suddenly appears in the middle of the cloud).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09812", "filename": "12f4871336fafac4955650e3c9995fee39fad1e6027abfd2d258aed95474de8f_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09813", "filename": "13b282fa6d8dce7943fb6b7753a0a544ea9e645a8ed4fde98e5afd7e0f0a390e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09817", "filename": "15ccb4fca0a90a728f61b932559364ff9f0d065ece0ae67110c53b08a76a883a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (the ship's hull exhibits severe flickering and distortion throughout the footage); Overall intuition (the ripples created by the ship as it sails on the water are too regular and perfect).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09818", "filename": "15fc0ae1544e982a134aa3f64402c2c3eb0ec79f741b576f41f698d67f8a0a3c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (flickering and shaking throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09819", "filename": "017c7437ba088a591169513746f6ad3fdb41d4a1912b8887cb9000e325af75a7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the clouds and fog are stationary throughout the entire scene, which does not conform to the characteristic that clouds and fog should be constantly moving and dissipating).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09820", "filename": "17e47e0a06ec019e9cdfc17939c2baebc3af2e4dfc6a474890e09e08201015ac_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the distant sea surface flickers and has a very grainy texture).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09822", "filename": "018dac349bbb1555e1767214f2a5f0406b758e057a2f8b6ce66818f7cc02d35e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (from 0.6s to 8s, the white fluid at the bottom increases inexplicably without any liquid being poured out, without any prior cause and effect). Physical behavior (throughout the entire video, liquid is continuously poured out of the cup, but the amount of liquid in the cup does not decrease but remains unchanged, which is inconsistent with the above).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09823", "filename": "018dac349bbb1555e1767214f2a5f0406b758e057a2f8b6ce66818f7cc02d35e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09825", "filename": "19ca5fb16cfc04e5bbc2c7ce8ac085de7ce814fb0896b8fe5ab6c3dfa98ee12d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09826", "filename": "20d27383bebe4b3b8f850e216675e3b2e9966f93b0d358e11b2cdc9e0eb19bdc_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The abnormality in the image: physical behavior (blue particles ejected in 0.2s passed directly through the plastic box and entered the box, which violates the fact that the plastic box is a solid and impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09828", "filename": "8040a1e9368f316d279c8deea161b912269ba8fa90c38f30bc163839fff7cef9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.2s in the video, the rubber band on the hand is between two fingers, but at 2.7s, after a rotation, it suddenly appears to be only on one finger).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09830", "filename": "8095a384cffe043e847c6b0d8ad81c54dfa7b99721374aad61a11234c70c7a8a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video footage shows noticeable jerking and stuttering at 5.2s, 5.8s, and 7.1s.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09831", "filename": "8165e4d6e925fd634f513d1d734afb0dba814315502d2e4e764ca3ecec50f675_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the shadow of the water column on the right rock suddenly disappears at 1.5s and 3.6s respectively, but the water column is still gushing out without any consistency).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09832", "filename": "8819ec65021ba80b3838d27bf835e47d9dbcae295a5d0a7dcbf5b5d84501d5b3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the cause and effect relationship is unreasonable. The video shows the sun rising, but the clouds in the picture are sunset clouds, which does not match the reality of the sun rising and the sky being bright.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09833", "filename": "8867c0626f77206dd00ae0ce04d9f5d716c1a0850be0d6234e97435e45f5ca1f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09834", "filename": "8930f6e7869155b6da204fa5486f5ea0135091aa5705e5f27cb9c8724b084afc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: Continuous timing (the grass, leaves, and other objects in the video footage flicker and twitch, and the shadow of the table under the firelight changes intermittently).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09835", "filename": "8965c28c3e5b73877bb8ebf0b5ab73956d7802d8fd4e81c6cc9cfcd498a72e47_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the position of the lights in the distance appears to shift; between 0s and 5.4s in the video, the lights in the distance are swaying).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09836", "filename": "9176e6668ccd708213f3432655e2d4cc3d786af009601006babe68cc9107c4ba_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video is not smooth and lacks consistency. (The video is static for the first 3.9 seconds, then suddenly starts moving, and then becomes static again at 5.8 seconds.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09837", "filename": "9318bd79abf3d55412fd53909d89fc5f8039927a764c9d02f9cf8b0b1a7184bc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (at 3.3s, smoke suddenly starts to come out from the left side of the object, enveloping the entire object, and the smoke suddenly changes into two large smoke rings that expand and disperse into irregular smoke).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09838", "filename": "9896cab4ea082159e0a7734716b7ff1e3397c193f2cf4e4edf2f473fa7638d84_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (the video overlapped at 0s and lasted until 0.5s, then became noticeably shorter after the ponytail swung back at 4.9s, showing no consistency).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09839", "filename": "9981d106d9bd4700652cd45585139025f7ebb719606ea4f4014f3aa99b0ec5c2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 2.7s in the video, the scene suddenly changes, the transparent piece shrinks and an additional iron object appears, and at 5.1s the iron object suddenly separates and a small iron ring falls off).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09840", "filename": "012357b8a5e57726ed5e84c718772a3f65489ba792a5e85b6df6a5d42719d881_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: The timing is continuous (at 3.2s in the video, the leaf tip suddenly turns pink after the tweezers leave the leaf, and at 0.8s, a small amount of pink substance appears and disappears intermittently in the second petri dish).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09841", "filename": "15117a0295bfa0474a22c4a0a303ae8235ad3e47f242c1987b717a989a94eddb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is inconsistent (at 5s in the video, the moment the tire runs over the toy, the scene suddenly changes to the toy breaking in two; from 5s to 7.3s, the pebbles on the ground flicker and twitch).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09842", "filename": "16899ec9c7f343a1782852fefb750d1f18f253995d8f9acf6328043fe7bca3d8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the rose pattern on the chandelier in the image shows a flickering or twitching motion).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09843", "filename": "0018093ca41461afcd98411a13662786a43095ced498ca7fccbbe44e91e58519_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the elephant's trunk on the right side suddenly shortens noticeably at 7.2 seconds, with no consistency).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09844", "filename": "19546f7aa27dd67147e87b4575625168a7ed16d81fe85065596177765c80a9ca_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (the light refraction of the diamond is uniform and not dazzling throughout the entire video, but at 0s, 0.2s, and 2.4s, dazzling blue refracted light appears, with no consistency between the beginning and end).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09846", "filename": "21853cb38238016759ad84906ec46c4d0c1e7467623e3a1ff691529c6b6f76ea_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The timing is continuous (the spoon and the smoke from the pot merge and disappear between 7.3s and 7.5s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09847", "filename": "26881b5a8fcc6f23b43fed8706e2f5cc8477fc0b1272c63d3c631426927035c3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.4s in the video, two fireworks disappear during their ascent without exploding in the night sky, and at 0.8s, a firework suddenly appears out of nowhere on the left side of the screen and explodes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09848", "filename": "26942ec721af9ecc2882e33a026d81bbe168b1c24d3db5212229abf0964a1723_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the liquid in the cup gets darker and darker as it is shaken, without any consistency, and the cup is not covered but does not spill out during shaking).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09849", "filename": "34109efa884ba350f53cd2c6ae7c37c59353e0112c9e0ffaf27a56b2864b916e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video quality: The video is not continuous (the video freezes at 1.8s and then suddenly starts to move, then freezes again at 5.6s; the entire video is choppy, not smooth, and lacks consistency).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09850", "filename": "36735f8a8561b3c84eb8c1ec0bf2eda884bb0329189ab0abc1e1ecc289c82ea1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Continuous timing (liquid sprayed from the bottle without it being damaged during the 0s-4s video segment).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09851", "filename": "37607f53f1fbde3e1e241d51401d722f99010b141d0af65d305d979597e915ab_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is discontinuous (the white feathers on the chandelier appear to twitch and flicker in the video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09852", "filename": "38710c9da03c76794abacc403f6ad3a8d148fb9415078a489333bfebde040c63_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2 seconds into the video, the ice on the cucumber suddenly disappears, and the cucumber splits into two pieces and flies to both sides even though the extruder is not pressing it).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09853", "filename": "038783fa63bb973ff30938bc40044c38df83d70d73e8117a728b95e724b1488c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.5s, the two bubbles in the video suddenly accelerate and float, and at 3.4s they suddenly decelerate, and the two balloons move in different trajectories, one going up and the other going down, without any consistency).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09855", "filename": "42367d383f26e7c2dd0b124b554c2c217be9fd2fde435bf423084a730b388260_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 5.7s in the video, the white halo inside the bubble suddenly distorts).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09856", "filename": "42784a69d99c13e836e2c40bb60f12c756a2451f5698ccf4c55c09b4588a13fe_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 4.3s, a dent suddenly appears on the top of the bottle, at 4.8s the dent suddenly disappears, and at 6.3s the dent suddenly reappears).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09857", "filename": "043572dd2f81bafba6c2f087f0a00cfedd7513ef383bb4b312441825634aad4c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: The timing is continuous (at 1.9 seconds into the video, the first red toy car moves without being touched, and throughout the video, the textures of the pebbles on the ground and the tires of the toy car flicker and twitch).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09858", "filename": "af1513ada60b31f98f0bda3055452e46792dc69201794f41c4f531f0870ec95d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.4s, the object on the left suddenly moves backward; at 1.4s, the egg suddenly breaks; at 1.5s, the egg breaks but the yolk remains intact).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09859", "filename": "afd128288486ec198fb565117bf590188d050dbfa3a5d9b9ee83384b46f9c39e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (0s-0.5s: metal cylinder moves to the right without external force) is continuous in time (the desktop flickers throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09860", "filename": "b0d4f7118547f9dc05df943491fe3c921abc66b08959f72d3b972409e2965028_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0s, water suddenly flows into the right side of the video, but the waves in the video cannot reach that area, which violates the physical logic of fluid movement).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09861", "filename": "b1a4920f4e63087ca35549c9012c25eccc5f2b002a48ebdd806775e70ca6a1cf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time sequence (at 2s, a large amount of pink dust suddenly spills out from the side when the baseball hits the baseball net) Causality (at 3s, the ball comes into contact with the pink dust, but the ball itself is not covered in pink dust)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09862", "filename": "b1bbd32055cd09d8ba7d6a341eacd318592b96918f5f909f7c8d6f593cf30f23_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the white object created after being destroyed at 1.2s suddenly disappears; at 1.3s, the shape of the debris on the left suddenly changes and the lower half of the helmet becomes intact).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09863", "filename": "b2b79f36c1796ac74b75b651c1e2c6534392eb5e57644c175a78983635969ca8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (the water stains on the glass and the light spots in the background flicker for 0.4 seconds before the shadow in the upper left corner disappears).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09864", "filename": "b2ba9d0da6280b568ef7c662330defe557a07254a4f649cfe805e87ed06e5aa2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09865", "filename": "b3d0de871a6c412d682d6fe056d34f427402b77d4154796fc3c7a030b3f23c95_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (flickering appears in the forest and grassland areas throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09866", "filename": "b3e7a52d3a94b837c0ecdb26d74e587aa7b0e4079ff15a336ab58f8c0f16f382_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (at 2s, the drill bit has not yet touched the wooden board, but debris appears out of thin air on the wooden board; at 6s, the shape of the drill bit's rotation changes, and the drill bit takes on a spring shape).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09867", "filename": "b3ed0243e92c1574a4403bad2509ceafb1093680ef8dd0fe828741281bef2851_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (at 0.2s, the finger does not touch the pink straw and the straw moves to the left without any external force; at 4s, the finger does not touch the pink straw and the straw moves instantaneously without any external force; at 5.1s, the straw is attracted to the right and the second cup on the left shakes to the right without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09868", "filename": "b4f926353605ef07d5aa13de48faa52500f9691033fb1c312c905104a1ec2d5a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09869", "filename": "b4fc7e685e3b6f55729d5e7da725d6bace298ba895bcc49b72a24f64783937a1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormalities in the video: Physical behavior (the blue object in the entire video exhibits obvious asymmetry in its horizontal motion during its reciprocating swing: the displacement amplitude to the left is significantly greater than that to the right, showing a tendency to shift to the left. At 0s, the blue object moves to the right without any external force, which violates the laws of force and inertia in the swing of an object.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09870", "filename": "b6d8fd6c49e76f9170facab92eb106224269ee640f56c0269c177c3f3992ce99_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Causality (Throughout the video, water is poured onto the fire, yet the fire does not go out and the water in the bucket does not decrease).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09871", "filename": "b6e74825217b8b3d888f3804be6f579a83f4953c55c03b1dd7b52f000ad98b12_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The timing is continuous (at 2.2s, when the screwdriver presses on the screw, the screw dents downwards like a soft object; at 2.5s, the integrated nut undergoes a sudden change, and the nut height increases; at 2.8s, the screw is removed without any twisting process).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09873", "filename": "b7e3b2f08ac98af4efeeb7b9165370549c3cd225b7b0cb5df157ef6506ed8935_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09874", "filename": "b7e378cc18ddccffcec642e4534717e0b7e4ec91343f0e12775ff907eff6d0d7_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Physical behavior (at 0.5s, the object moves to the right without external force; at 1.5s, the object in the lower right moves upward without external force; at 2.5s, the object on the left suddenly moves downward). Time continuity (at 1.5s, a long strip suddenly appears in the upper right of the object; at 2.4s, a long strip suddenly appears in the upper left; at 3s, a long strip suddenly appears above the object; at 4s, a long strip suddenly appears above the object; at 4.1s, the video frame freezes).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09875", "filename": "b7efa13c8cea12855ecf5292810d5b479e57de7d65e84f8206b67662db4f40f2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous timing (the light spot on the tree trunk in the lower right corner of the entire video flickers).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09876", "filename": "b08a679a4a9919b88a21597eb277f550048e8bd9428ca018d0df79745ab9d71a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time sequence is continuous (the color of the vegetation on the island changes from green to brown throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09878", "filename": "b8d21aca68b6debd69c9840970a9f306111cc37407263e2c483762557e808d67_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Cause and effect (the entire video is sped up, the clouds move while the sun remains unchanged) and time continuity (at 4.8s, a green halo suddenly appears through the clouds).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09879", "filename": "b9b63817e79e8de902656867e048f38455ca1f6634d9c4a47321a0de5c83ff37_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is abnormal (the seabed sand appears to undulate and move with the light throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09881", "filename": "b9e967e750905af9c3d7993395acd40efcbc6583d60de39aa917df3a28ebb7d6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Overall visual anomalies (the black object in the lower right corner of the video appears grainy throughout); Time sequence (a black object suddenly appears above the cart at 4.8s); Causal relationship (at 5.8s, there are still items remaining on the cart, while at the beginning the cart had already tipped over).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09882", "filename": "b11bc716e21c8fcf8a886ab805e1ec2ccb302de35cf1d169f2fd9e3dadbe32f3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: Physical behavior (yellow object falls to the right without external force at 0s) Time continuity (the ladder under the yellow object disappears between 1.3s and 2.6s; the video freezes at 3s)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09883", "filename": "b20d61e9b0ee85dab9e5735d7c568cf08c3a21b72b07b00baf22a3b189084283_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Causality (the amount of brown liquid beneath the object increases throughout the video while the volume of the brown object remains unchanged); Overall visual anomalies (flickering of the brown object and liquid in the video).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09884", "filename": "b28ad7ec1118dfdc23fb1de42ab5b1c705ac6e8318ac5074e539e5298395f345_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09885", "filename": "b75e10c9631abee900800a9f0167eaa1c3d60804811eb8348441438cc932f0e2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is uninterrupted (the clouds at the top of the screen are a deep blue-gray, while the area near the horizon below is a bright orange-yellow sunset, with no natural color transition between the two).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "T1_09886", "filename": "b76a78e0a9f8b1b36f4897ba6bc6ff13a221b4ea332cc45d219af936f09be6b8_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09887", "filename": "b77e3a457605fd39ea26800f8295c0909e8db39b330d1c73553a0ca3a299d2eb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous timing (the tea leaves in the tea bag gradually decrease throughout the video).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09888", "filename": "9d889f6b73df1cdedca2c11484db42c98a8875a625c061b19542a1e4da9ef33e_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 1.9s, the water droplet should be dripping under gravity instead of remaining on the petal, which does not conform to Newton's First Law; from 1.1s to 5s, the water droplet explodes and splashes out in small, individual droplets, more like the fragments of a glass ball breaking apart).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09889", "filename": "9d8523651d0cd0173f0585c29a237fcaf27d6e37207e6aad79d75053077514a1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (liquid is continuously added to the cup throughout the video, but the amount of liquid in the cup does not increase, which is inconsistent with the visual behavior).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09890", "filename": "9d8523651d0cd0173f0585c29a237fcaf27d6e37207e6aad79d75053077514a1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09892", "filename": "9dc770e0dfd55c3d20580c4aa1648ff47b510efdc2f56c3c3f21e88799371902_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (The lake surface remains completely unchanged throughout the entire video, without any ripples or waves; it's smooth like plastic, which doesn't match the state of a realistic lake surface).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09893", "filename": "9dc770e0dfd55c3d20580c4aa1648ff47b510efdc2f56c3c3f21e88799371902_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: Cause and effect (1.7s-5.8s, without anything falling in, the lake surface inexplicably explodes with water, and then the water ripples regularly, without any cause or effect).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09894", "filename": "9ddd0e35f04ca2a80ee84bbf1c7e9b0fe44a75c40918638b029a7774799e82f4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09895", "filename": "9ddfcb0496cad80f8d6de81681ca31c90742ea83925c75489f6ce08ac7d8bc47_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to physical behavior (when water boils, it spreads outwards from the center, but between 2.9s and 8s, the water does not fluctuate and the foam moves in a regular and orderly manner towards the left and decreases continuously, which does not match the actual state of boiling water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09896", "filename": "9ddfcb0496cad80f8d6de81681ca31c90742ea83925c75489f6ce08ac7d8bc47_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (from 1.8s to 8s, a lot of steam suddenly appears in the pot on the right).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09899", "filename": "9e5b380704acf28b17d309c262015655adb6e5e3b2c3c98ab3935daa15aa2d1f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09900", "filename": "9e5dd44606406abe9588eaad054a14349d680d6b6e3df0db248d482f46a63c1c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09901", "filename": "9ed856378e3c9066c5e5aff1c99b9b7608b14a6e116bba64ae8d0ed4a9b00353_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09902", "filename": "9ed856378e3c9066c5e5aff1c99b9b7608b14a6e116bba64ae8d0ed4a9b00353_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (The background halo in the entire video is very blurry, and the halo does not change at all when it rains, which is inconsistent with the state of a real halo).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09903", "filename": "9f3474ac9f58a72aa0e871e39761c1dcda72e401354f3cdf78d3e8ab3f068a52_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09905", "filename": "9f3474ac9f58a72aa0e871e39761c1dcda72e401354f3cdf78d3e8ab3f068a52_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09906", "filename": "9fca2219e22d70eb78a39278ab3a9b62baa7d7aee54b3d1a95dc3ff2ac92148b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the egg remains unchanged throughout the entire video while being fried at high temperatures, which does not conform to the characteristic that eggs change when heated).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09907", "filename": "9fce6fe9124387aa211b26c64eff95ae3a72e1f618cea5436f48d811a709f567_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09908", "filename": "357a5bf22712a4f68c76d8173b5906d763aa4fa8d2aab8d6fdc1bd7a4ced2d4c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (the vegetation in the image appears to be constantly swaying, while the clouds remain stationary).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09909", "filename": "372f0c30decc11d5d87259662343d343a67e1d6b5b78c72636a0db2ec88ad367_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Physical behavior (sunlight on the left side of the image is clipping through leaves and branches and shining directly into the image); Temporal continuity anomalies (the entire image is constantly shaking).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09910", "filename": "378fd205195c7ca3ccb2757ab9df5c388e9dea5f0caf3a7022dcf6389928ceac_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09912", "filename": "405b1ae2a3cb79203a0e61d66593a104f76d2c335f2f99514d887e99c2ede9d9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (the cigarette held in the hand and the black background in the image are constantly flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09913", "filename": "420e0da9121f52b19dbb8c36f90731d79b5a6bb543ccd079563770faa2973cc5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomalies: Temporal continuity is abnormal (the red, raspberry-like objects and drifting smoke in the image are constantly flickering). Physical behavior (clouds and fog are dispersed fluids; even in a relatively stable environment, they exhibit dynamic characteristics of edge diffusion and gradual shape changes. However, the clouds and fog in the image show neither relative movement with surrounding objects nor subtle changes in their own shape, presenting a completely static, \"solidified\" appearance, contradicting the dynamic properties of clouds and fog themselves).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09914", "filename": "428b207557905b67828527a67b60c713a2fc61e07d3da4e56f854ff93629430a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (the pot, the melting pen inside the pot, and the ground in the scene are constantly flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09915", "filename": "435dda98f245f62beecbfc8f364af736632c11800bc68edfd65f27c678486bed_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (the doll being run over by the wheel, the floor, and the entire wheel itself are constantly flickering in the scene).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09919", "filename": "448b93d96c9b71a09456347ca8c124f751557968201c4af834a0928136f90ccc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (the silver background and ground displayed in the image are constantly flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09920", "filename": "460c17241986fcfd54ea72a8bd0588cb0abc8bb1e7f22f7c77297edde51071cb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity anomalies (trees in the background flicker, and sand in front of the flames does not disperse with the force of the flames during the 3.7s flame ejection). Physical behavior (the flames disperse without external force during ejection, and the flame trajectory is chaotic).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09922", "filename": "467cd6eeb0b446c4e277b2c8aa925fdfc9f43187d608766ac34a4319017baac4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Image Anomaly: Temporal Continuity Anomaly (The trees, ground, and reflections in the water in the image are constantly flickering). Physical Behavior: The water surface appears calm, and a real reflection would be slightly blurred, stretched, or distorted by tiny ripples. However, the tree shadows in the image have abnormally sharp edges and stiff outlines, lacking any of the softness and dynamism that a natural water reflection should have, presenting a static feeling of being \"pasted\" on.", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09923", "filename": "481d376ed63239b5aafbb8d335f2c04ddd880cde8cdb354b14ca109a7d1130dc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09924", "filename": "507cd81b87cd26133e6b6a6002cdf3726929abec4260e790933f5867d87eeb83_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09925", "filename": "518d40437cb117b67bcb62eacc48f3944e2fbc88ef31a0c36e3159420287c063_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (the diamond in the image, the gray panel behind it, and the small hole above it are constantly flickering).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09926", "filename": "521f08548e5960b00ba6c2dd8fe8380c0584195646cd3264d06ddc5167afb8f1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (the white clothes in the image are flashing; the chopsticks are relatively thin at 0s, and suddenly become thicker at 0.6s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09927", "filename": "522aa0380cf1e809a55d6246231360176bd185f85c63834cc63fac6d13cc6480_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (the wood in the image, the burning object beneath the wood, and the black iron mesh on both sides are constantly flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09928", "filename": "525c8eb9515637d25a90f2841c5d9bde0fafde2346cc56df2e27bd77b78d3db3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (the grass in the screen keeps flickering; at 2.6s, when hitting the golf ball, it doesn't hit the water but instead creates a lot of water out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09929", "filename": "525e4a5d091538d8109e8047840788ffd98b8df32e1b12aeec55830a1f0c1642_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09930", "filename": "535f184fe99f61eadc545cebf529905bb324cc286c0e1e376091a35e76b576b3_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (the water surface of distant points such as bridges and houses on the shore in the video keeps flickering).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09931", "filename": "542b4f470fe429b19c49df894429049610a34376a14dd8f47f469e213ebab2ad_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Temporal continuity anomalies (flickering in the hair, spoon, and bottom of the cup in the image); Physical behavior anomalies (the image presented by the contact surface between the spoon and water does not conform to the refraction phenomenon of water).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09932", "filename": "556ba46ae7e36c555b491cd05488d5a03a62c7861e62881ac9ace78e0ae65a36_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09933", "filename": "557b44c9dae7e737aa766b628922e51311bd1f2724d873283c217de8ade09a7b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal Footage: Causal Relationship (At 4s, before the hydraulic press pressed down on the fork, the fork suddenly deformed without any external force. At 5.6s, after the hydraulic press lifted up, the fork suddenly bent again. At 6.5s, the fork automatically straightened from a bent position.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09934", "filename": "557c14b4775b11d57739f0c39403a66ce3d85a121d0003ec1ca5fcf474974de5_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity anomaly (the ground, distant houses, cars, and colored lights on the left side of the screen are all flashing).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09935", "filename": "580c1cb9ae04cf631700672487bd3b6204c35a81b65a34a169fedbf975a174bc_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity anomaly (the ground in the screen, including the oven and squid, is constantly flashing).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09936", "filename": "583d7b0ec2f782cf2313f003335ea6129556de6ff9d86fd88d3c875645fb562a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the ice cube in the image moves across the surface of the bubble without any external force) Causality (after the ice cube passes over the bubble, the bubble should be compressed and burst or separate, but the bubble in the image does not change).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09938", "filename": "2c4fc2ada08eabc0225b40352c64d4d95e0492b4c1615761f5bdac7d8b4382cc_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The abnormality in the image is due to physical factors (at 3.5s and 5.1s, when the hand leaves the object, the colloidal material does not exhibit the typical adhesion characteristics of a viscoelastic fluid. After separating from the hand surface, it does not leave any colloidal residue or deformation marks on the skin, which violates the physical laws of interfacial adhesion of non-Newtonian fluids (colloids).)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09939", "filename": "2c10d3e5cc44a6ee32be682a9a0545b2c20333a8002ba4b858526344344f8be4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (1.1s-3.4s) The fluid did not exhibit the non-uniform adhesion and irregular deformation characteristics of viscoelastic materials. Its adhesion to the hammer was too regular and smooth, and the residual amount was far lower than the physical expectation of similar fluids under the same contact conditions, which violated the laws of wetting, adhesion and flow inertia of viscoelastic fluids on solid surfaces.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09940", "filename": "2c10d3e5cc44a6ee32be682a9a0545b2c20333a8002ba4b858526344344f8be4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Temporal continuity (0.4s-2s) The process of half a hammer transforming into a screw-shaped hammer lacks a continuous spatial motion trajectory and transition frames, failing to present the smooth temporal characteristics of rigid body rotation or deformation, thus violating the principles of spatiotemporal continuity and smooth motion of the object.", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09941", "filename": "2c10d3e5cc44a6ee32be682a9a0545b2c20333a8002ba4b858526344344f8be4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual anomaly is as follows: Physical behavior (between 1s and 1.4s, the viscous material collides with the hard steel object; the viscous material should move forward, but it moves backward, which violates the law of conservation of energy in a collision. Between 3.3s and 4.2s, as the viscous material wraps around and adheres to the hammer, it maintains a regular geometric shape and uniform distribution, failing to exhibit the non-uniform stretching, wrinkling, irregular adhesion, and secondary flow expected of viscoelastic materials moving on complex solid surfaces, deviating from the natural rheological properties of viscoelastic fluids.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09942", "filename": "2c25c22c7f13faeb147c2987c66a602dcf633765495c247474c0999aaad5c71e_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the light and shadow projected onto the glass stone at the bottom does not change with the direction of the flame during combustion, which does not conform to the laws of light refraction).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09943", "filename": "2c25c22c7f13faeb147c2987c66a602dcf633765495c247474c0999aaad5c71e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to physical behavior (a normal flame should be a soft, pale blue, planar flame. However, the flame in the video is a sharp, concentrated upward shape).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09944", "filename": "2c25c22c7f13faeb147c2987c66a602dcf633765495c247474c0999aaad5c71e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal due to physical behavior (a normal flame should be a soft, pale blue, planar flame. However, the flame in the video is a sharp, concentrated upward shape).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09952", "filename": "2caa9017ac9a28dd43052297b49e8c66dd3a2fbd9fbf5ae169d3d261682df93d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (from 4.5s to 4.6s, the iron block in the hand is suspended in mid-air without external support, violating the law of gravity. At 4.9s, the iron block embeds into the iron frame, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09953", "filename": "2caa9017ac9a28dd43052297b49e8c66dd3a2fbd9fbf5ae169d3d261682df93d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the iron block in the character's hand suddenly disappears at 0.6s without any interference).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09954", "filename": "2caa9017ac9a28dd43052297b49e8c66dd3a2fbd9fbf5ae169d3d261682df93d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (the iron block in the character's left hand suddenly disappears without any interference at 2.2s); Physical behavior (the small iron block rotates on its own without external support between 0.4s and 0.6s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09962", "filename": "2d71ce0466baee5bad69c668d32f578f936e8eb098d922602f85ff32b2fcdadb_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: The overall realism is abnormal (there are no explosion marks of fireworks rising into the sky, lacking the actual trajectory). Physical behavior (white fireworks appear in the sky on the right side at 0.4s-1.3s and 1.8s-2s, but their reflections in the water are not visible, which does not conform to the laws of light and shadow).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09963", "filename": "2d71ce0466baee5bad69c668d32f578f936e8eb098d922602f85ff32b2fcdadb_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09964", "filename": "2d71ce0466baee5bad69c668d32f578f936e8eb098d922602f85ff32b2fcdadb_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09965", "filename": "2d4510153af05d451c633fd7d5f15fe343e1b69747d9ffe49888de4f98fb076d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (the wire penetrates the edge of the lamp housing throughout the video, violating the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09966", "filename": "2d4510153af05d451c633fd7d5f15fe343e1b69747d9ffe49888de4f98fb076d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (between 0.5s and 1s, the bulb reflects light and shadow even in the absence of light, which does not conform to the principle of light reflection). Causal relationship (between 1.1s and 1.5s, the bulb gradually brightens without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09967", "filename": "2d4510153af05d451c633fd7d5f15fe343e1b69747d9ffe49888de4f98fb076d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09968", "filename": "5a0a308c9b786ab30f9b9c96c5ac08017a4bc73ffce3412c8f7a0e0e7ecfb008_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (at 1.7s, the hydraulic press in the middle of the video is embedded in the yellow object, which violates the principle that solids are impermeable).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09969", "filename": "5a172a12238edf4d77c678ec70e33c70428d2ae82085027972a33dc2c96fd44b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (at 6.2s, the object below the hydraulic press in the video undergoes a sudden change; at 6.3s, the objects on the left and right sides of the white object below the hydraulic press in the video appear out of thin air).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09970", "filename": "5aa96dac823315987344c9b412f8e990a1c3a0a76283d285bf343ded98af2f25_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: The timing is continuous (fireworks explode out of thin air directly above the video at 2.1s and 2.2s).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09972", "filename": "5bb4050858bd034d5674db7da1411761ff29ab59638cf24aab292bc9d0e28df7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video feed: The timing is continuous (at 1s, a water column suddenly appears in the middle of the video; at 1.3s, water droplets suddenly appear in the middle of the video; at 1.4s, water droplets suddenly appear in the middle of the video; at 2.3s, a water column suddenly appears; at that time, the number of water droplets at the top of the video suddenly increases; at 5.6s, the ice block in the middle of the video disappears rapidly).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09973", "filename": "5bc1032dc996cfc78b660d3f161e3768e0dea03408b648ce11a8f1aaba38719e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09974", "filename": "5bec4141447f7a1dbf16d2f8a5be77225d0ba77ae498a4a9f887200c3ba64864_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (at 1.9s, the object in the cup rotates without external force, violating the law of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09975", "filename": "5bff4939deee32ae2d114f78f6ac01a76b631115d9d4ff3c04847f06794ebef3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.4s, an object appears out of thin air directly above the video without any visible object)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09976", "filename": "5c8c8cf69ad79e216f3c1ac31a96832180600ca6218cb97c1dffe581706f9a52_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Time continuity (the ground around the red object in the video flickers).", "glitch_severity": 1, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09977", "filename": "5c8c8cf69ad79e216f3c1ac31a96832180600ca6218cb97c1dffe581706f9a52_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: The timing is continuous (between 2.3s and 3.1s, the green and red objects in the lower right corner of the video break off and then reconnect).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09979", "filename": "5ca3ace9e1ee502378b51613e0d571858ad31b671f259254ff7c44035a5f9a92_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Time continuity (the object in the middle of the video changes abruptly at 4s, and water appears out of nowhere at the top of the video at 5s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09982", "filename": "5cd0bb476ef03e22290b279bc06d2e161952fa5382506232e08408af6cf85d80_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09983", "filename": "5cf597b49a0dfde8ca5f957036064a6ac0956cda896fae0304eaef8707e275a3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.3 seconds, the raised hands of the crowd in the video are distorted).", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09984", "filename": "5d66ab2fd0b8507d83dbf24b28bc7f0a8bd4f0f3558c8a4e0a44330be7cbc511_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09985", "filename": "5de81eedc589ee05a26563882a35abc011e2e5b88dcfe6b8ddf3e066bd3d61ff_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 1.7s, the small bubbles in the large bubble on the right side of the video distort and then merge; at 2.9s, the bubble on the left side of the video appears out of nowhere).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09986", "filename": "5e38e39c35fc075bf1dc793329231e2f39352d60bacec05faf198adde59e14b9_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video content: Physical behavior (at 3.5s, an object in the video is lifted without any external force, violating the law of gravity; at 5s, a piece of the yellow object that rises in the video falls off, but the object itself does not change).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09987", "filename": "5eb3ea4cd579d4b459838b5e71b56e4fb1710bda0ee205e6bd2f888dffcc2a09_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: continuous time (at 3.6s, the light beam directly above the video suddenly transforms into a bubble-like object).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09988", "filename": "2dae7a57563fb6ae35a7cb4c1d7f52148cc6a691da85f42935d67180d9c8c822_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (0.8s-3.7s: the white block below the colored block suddenly disappears. 0.9s-3.8s: the white block above the colored block moves automatically without external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09989", "filename": "2dae7a57563fb6ae35a7cb4c1d7f52148cc6a691da85f42935d67180d9c8c822_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Clipping issue (2.3s, the dark blue block passes through the light blue block from left to right, violating the principle that solids are impermeable.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09990", "filename": "2dae7a57563fb6ae35a7cb4c1d7f52148cc6a691da85f42935d67180d9c8c822_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Inconsistent timing (from 1.2s to 5.1s, all white blocks turn into colored blocks). Continuous timing (from 1.2s to 5.1s, the colored blocks that were originally white move automatically from left to right without external force).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_09991", "filename": "2dbf2ac94163f3a800f9e4bbb5776a566df9262d7dcf343a9b76e25a9397f813_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (2.2s-4.6s, the flame of the candle in the lower right corner separates from the candle without any external force, floats alone in mid-air, and then automatically flies back to the top of the candle).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09992", "filename": "2dbf2ac94163f3a800f9e4bbb5776a566df9262d7dcf343a9b76e25a9397f813_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09993", "filename": "2dde096d4114da0c0e18f5645e9bdb5f23f08759510ca14fafcd3ffb1b16fa52_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The overall visual impression is off (the waves in the image appear overly viscous, like jelly, lacking the fluidity of real seawater).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09994", "filename": "2dde096d4114da0c0e18f5645e9bdb5f23f08759510ca14fafcd3ffb1b16fa52_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: (1.8s-5.7s The sun is in the process of setting, but the sky changes from dusk to daytime in an abnormal way, which violates the natural law that the sky will gradually darken after the sun sets.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_09995", "filename": "2dde096d4114da0c0e18f5645e9bdb5f23f08759510ca14fafcd3ffb1b16fa52_processed_k", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_09996", "filename": "2dde096d4114da0c0e18f5645e9bdb5f23f08759510ca14fafcd3ffb1b16fa52_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: (After the waves crashed on the beach, they did not dissipate naturally, but instead returned to the sea along the same path, which violates the natural laws of fluid movement.)", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09997", "filename": "2e2a748fe18e8c6bdf755a4acf289f6b93d51f2ff4d3bbd227c66e53306148db_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the footage: (1.7s: Water is injected into the bubble, causing it to shake violently, but it remains intact and does not break, which violates the physical properties of bubbles.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_09998", "filename": "2e2a748fe18e8c6bdf755a4acf289f6b93d51f2ff4d3bbd227c66e53306148db_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "An anomaly occurred: (At 5.1 seconds, a small bubble bursts and turns into a large column of water that falls. A bursting bubble should spread outwards, not turn into a falling water column.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_09999", "filename": "2e2a748fe18e8c6bdf755a4acf289f6b93d51f2ff4d3bbd227c66e53306148db_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10004", "filename": "2e54b9a2b9d648eeefe737f5a966dc00fa005c933187cb000e6ac85e53c83cb4_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The time sequence is continuous (3.2s-4.1s, the ice cubes in the glass suddenly disappear and then appear out of thin air in the hand).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10005", "filename": "2e54b9a2b9d648eeefe737f5a966dc00fa005c933187cb000e6ac85e53c83cb4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time frame is continuous (3.4s-4.5s). When the ice cube enters the water, the water surface is calm without ripples or vibrations.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_10006", "filename": "2e54b9a2b9d648eeefe737f5a966dc00fa005c933187cb000e6ac85e53c83cb4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10007", "filename": "2e66cb82ebb641ee1cc61c99dc83587321bb90064c6c73ce190e22022954ae93_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_10008", "filename": "2e66cb82ebb641ee1cc61c99dc83587321bb90064c6c73ce190e22022954ae93_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The duration is continuous (0.5s-3.5s). A dry ice-like mist flows rapidly into the basin along the water pipe like water when poured in. The mist is extremely light and should drift into the basin slowly.", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10009", "filename": "2e66cb82ebb641ee1cc61c99dc83587321bb90064c6c73ce190e22022954ae93_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10010", "filename": "2e66cb82ebb641ee1cc61c99dc83587321bb90064c6c73ce190e22022954ae93_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10011", "filename": "2e7424f4ce162d9d33ba3bc4666d6dd0a8d2505b12be1591291fddbbc6a4c790_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a green sphere rolls uphill without any external force.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10012", "filename": "2e7424f4ce162d9d33ba3bc4666d6dd0a8d2505b12be1591291fddbbc6a4c790_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: The green sphere rotates and then rolls automatically without external force (1.4s-4.7s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10013", "filename": "2e7424f4ce162d9d33ba3bc4666d6dd0a8d2505b12be1591291fddbbc6a4c790_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (A green sphere with a smoke outlet at the top; as the sphere rolls, the smoke outlet remains above the sphere without any positional shift.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10014", "filename": "2e7424f4ce162d9d33ba3bc4666d6dd0a8d2505b12be1591291fddbbc6a4c790_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a small ball with a smoke outlet is rolling, and the smoke outlet remains above the ball without any positional shift.)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10015", "filename": "2e89028c2e97b9f06b9115f4504c34087fed82589552b22a8d01f7e225cf0f63_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_10016", "filename": "2e89028c2e97b9f06b9115f4504c34087fed82589552b22a8d01f7e225cf0f63_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous duration (4.9 seconds) - an opaque silver disc suddenly becomes transparent.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10017", "filename": "2e89028c2e97b9f06b9115f4504c34087fed82589552b22a8d01f7e225cf0f63_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10018", "filename": "15402c6b79ca967bde81dd5f05995871465a33b43f0f44497f35fcea6477bc88_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10019", "filename": "19322b6c49800cd6e387151b9605b03ab5a25fc3a6add1f9aef0eb06f2290568_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the time is continuous (the lake surface in the video is completely still with no ripples, which does not conform to the laws of water movement).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10021", "filename": "21853cb38238016759ad84906ec46c4d0c1e7467623e3a1ff691529c6b6f76ea_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: The time is continuous (after 0.1s, the liquid in the spoon is poured into the pot, and the liquid in the spoon does not change; after 2.6s, the spoon does not touch the liquid in the pot, the liquid in the pot splashes, and the amount of liquid in the spoon increases).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10022", "filename": "25072ecb4ebef0c3adfcb43a796eb27971e6b01c891a551b92a9091586635a36_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10023", "filename": "26942ec721af9ecc2882e33a026d81bbe168b1c24d3db5212229abf0964a1723_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (the cup is suspended and flipped over without any force between 1.7s and 4.9s, and the lid is suddenly closed without any external force at 3.1s). Time continuity: (light yellow bubbles suddenly appear in the cup at 3.6s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10024", "filename": "29171a29dba94edad1aacf98877d9d0df6c3af2cde745d2acb590b2328f1437b_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is due to physical behavior (the flame length of the sparkler does not change during combustion, which is inconsistent with the laws of combustion).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10025", "filename": "33673d82441319606c8fb001f6c276eae3ff9144586b62a47189ff53edfe7fe4_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video content: Physical behavior (the cup in the video is rotating without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10026", "filename": "34109efa884ba350f53cd2c6ae7c37c59353e0112c9e0ffaf27a56b2864b916e_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10027", "filename": "36555f2773efe3020a9c861a9a06faacd3298998009f6384eeaab94149a2a2d6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (the overall image is abnormally twisted, disrupting the stability of the viewpoint).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10028", "filename": "36735f8a8561b3c84eb8c1ec0bf2eda884bb0329189ab0abc1e1ecc289c82ea1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (after the can explodes at 1.6s, the shape of the can does not change, and the pattern on the can is inconsistent at 1.5s).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_10029", "filename": "36735f8a8561b3c84eb8c1ec0bf2eda884bb0329189ab0abc1e1ecc289c82ea1_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal footage: The time sequence is continuous (0s: the can becomes thinner and longer after hitting the stone; 1.5s: a large amount of water suddenly bursts out from under the stone).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10031", "filename": "38453e40b365798f42b775a88272867f16ce742a7dd8ee42ac7925e9c51410a2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: Cause and effect (the basketball is moving back and forth in a person's hand without actually touching it, which violates the laws of mechanics).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10033", "filename": "42084a0f225b896537e84a539e69fd2936f03a374f3233643eb0d29b5c8d523a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (the object explodes violently in 1.6s, but the objects around the explosion do not change, which violates the law of conservation of momentum).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_10034", "filename": "42084a0f225b896537e84a539e69fd2936f03a374f3233643eb0d29b5c8d523a_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 0.5s, a black burning barrel suddenly appears between the two fires).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10035", "filename": "42784a69d99c13e836e2c40bb60f12c756a2451f5698ccf4c55c09b4588a13fe_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10036", "filename": "43557ad13e2e71603861541274cb2d567e9ce1fe24d99c30d2ac5dabd67ff57c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal image: Physical behavior (the barometer in the video points to 0, so it moves without any external force, and its kinetic energy increases out of thin air)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10037", "filename": "043572dd2f81bafba6c2f087f0a00cfedd7513ef383bb4b312441825634aad4c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 0.6s, the wheels did not run over the blue and green cars, but the blue and green cars suddenly started moving). Physical behavior: (After 4.2s, the cars were not damaged by the wheels, violating the law of conservation of energy).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10038", "filename": "043572dd2f81bafba6c2f087f0a00cfedd7513ef383bb4b312441825634aad4c_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video feed is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.1s, the gray bucket of the green car turns green, and at 3.1s, the red and blue cars suddenly move closer to the large wheel).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10039", "filename": "45838e38158ffe3c6507a9389ca35cd1b9691326d88725398f7e639151cc7938_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10040", "filename": "46065be39e1b001d4a91e452d14533548294e3d21897b78955fb82f8ad3c2dbb_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10042", "filename": "51770d18b8e430d93abcf8985201d17dfd278d6b6ca1bb378527f58da9841662_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (white suspended matter in the cup disappears in 0.8s)", "glitch_severity": 2, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10043", "filename": "51770d18b8e430d93abcf8985201d17dfd278d6b6ca1bb378527f58da9841662_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10044", "filename": "51955dd7501d4770522c9439f26c7d15b08ba766b5d6bd252c8f5e54b95e1f43_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10045", "filename": "52537bbf004c4f1e56bca44ac68622ba805fbfbfab81973974eff17321b2609b_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "the clouds in the video are sped up", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10046", "filename": "53886df3609e00f4206c72b1119fa057ac90a51d9a6ed6b855545d20f93bc9f4_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The visual error is that the time sequence is continuous (the wood did not deform after being pressed for 0.4 seconds, which violates the law of conservation of energy).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_10047", "filename": "53886df3609e00f4206c72b1119fa057ac90a51d9a6ed6b855545d20f93bc9f4_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal scene: The time is continuous (4.2s, the amount of wood chips generated after being crushed by the crusher increases for no reason, and the amount generated far exceeds the volume of the original wood).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10048", "filename": "54661d3b585a6579fedde7183767526558bb0e1d3ec6c4fd6cee8fa95d40e9dd_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (2s two tomatoes merge into one, 2.3s the tomato behind the clip breaks through the clip).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10049", "filename": "55091e6afb9a198667ccd8ac27a4aaa7a25892e684579c6b950651ca83fb373a_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal display: Time continuity (the screw hole changes after the compass completes one revolution in 1.1 seconds).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10050", "filename": "56336ab0998eddb699c62dc0ef63f688868347935bc01980530b96525ef93f4b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Continuous time (at 0.5s, an object in the upper right corner of the video suddenly transforms into a person). Physical behavior: (At 1s, the water tank suddenly catches fire without any external force, violating the law of conservation of energy).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10051", "filename": "57032cba6c7092a048c7faec980f0cb86d90e42ca300b8b3a5692521578f0ccf_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (at 1.6s, the gap between the grip strengthener screws suddenly merges).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10052", "filename": "57093a17989eab683bd49c8b6ae97d3a8baf9767664f20034aafb72beef809e8_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Cause and effect (In the video, when sharpening the pencil, the pencil is inserted back and forth without any wood shavings falling off, while the pencil sharpener blade is vertical and needs to be rotated to sharpen the pencil).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10054", "filename": "8f534da5e533d39b366ffdae260d52aada118a7852e29ef6ed76d8e0fbde1c86_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the reflection in the mirror does not match the objects in front of it throughout the entire video).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10057", "filename": "09e02961b529cd7105a68d3ebfc1b459e19a40ba5d4b07a2332877f740299ce0_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical behavior (the deformed iron object does not spring back, while the iron block that was compressed and deformed returns to its original shape in 3.8s-4.4s, which does not conform to the characteristic that deformed iron objects do not spring back) Temporal continuity (the iron sheet suddenly explodes in 4.5s-5.5s, leaving a pile of cement residue)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10058", "filename": "9a91659ee65dcbdada32611126a5a0f1af8b30294fdadca55d836212f29a7a80_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomalies: Time continuity (from 2.7s to 4.7s, the burn marks on the tree branch that were originally visible suddenly disappear). Physical behavior (from 2.9s to 4.4s, the flames do not change when the tree branch is picked up and put down, which is inconsistent with the characteristic of flames being easily moved).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_10059", "filename": "9a91659ee65dcbdada32611126a5a0f1af8b30294fdadca55d836212f29a7a80_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_10061", "filename": "9aa12064965c2f2d9718d4614ac7350e6c507d71f3d18477ea1518319ad4e19c_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10062", "filename": "9ab3412f9c876405b671b7e7ec2edb6dd372bd0e0809a283fd7b1ea43fa8d800_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10063", "filename": "9ad1ef172c9ce7921f330c4fee915f8dcba787232fce9f741518b8caee2c108b_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10066", "filename": "9b412015ce9e23267cadccb4cf4a0b28e1ffb079527cc6afed82c0f4c06cf1be_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (1.2s-8s, a bubble suddenly appears in the middle without any external force)", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10067", "filename": "9bd2157e83932228a1fc627f398c176e96f5ca43dc2435b2888afb9c9abd0dd1_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Physical behavior (the ice is melting rapidly throughout the footage, but the amount of liquid produced does not increase, which is inconsistent. Also, the liquid is too smooth and resembles a viscous substance rather than a liquid).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10070", "filename": "9d3fe90d649312621ec9ed104a9f04953043f5fc21b9b9f4f7902f991cfa8ae6_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (a white object suddenly appears in the middle of the screen at 2.7s, and the upper part of the scene flickers severely).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10071", "filename": "9d31ef7fa2cb50ebb01752ff05a15ee5b09d67108c6fceb56a4cc7fe92c3ee35_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (the foam in the cup is not dispersed by the liquid and there is no water ripple when the coffee is poured in, which does not match the state of liquid being poured into water).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_10073", "filename": "bd8b3ecab5942c69a9c0485ea2b4c80437b72348a981f423a83019ac040acd28_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10074", "filename": "bd29e02133e09a20b9b5f3d0792958cfb45cbf1d8e085694768b41523f3cff46_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video: Cause and effect (the liquid in the cup should fluctuate under force, but in the video, the liquid in the cup is not under force yet it is jumping regularly on its own).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10075", "filename": "bd42aafca4a555c1e2fec7b11f788477128417513294d24e7b31f07ea1e9c180_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10076", "filename": "bd109f3279e11edd3e699845dbf53a4eb335f30c4be8d18159575958fc0f7df2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (between 1.9s and 8s, the boiling state of the pot suddenly weakens significantly, but the size of the flame does not change in the video, and the bubbles in the boiling water in the pot start to get smaller and smaller from this moment on. This situation only occurs when the heat is turned down).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10077", "filename": "bdad394ebf52ef78fb8697d4c9862b7a58d0aed37c8068c0df430fc47ed3ed13_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10078", "filename": "bdb499bf071cf2dc4058066721043ef820cb1ca911c6ed36037eadf4e25f6352_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (At 7.8s, the light on the candle in the video suddenly appears layered).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10079", "filename": "bddf321be0843c4ee7fc76c672b4423ea07db7e91b43101d6f9431979273d079_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the ripples on the lake surface are too regular and suddenly disappear when they reach the bottom of the video.", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10080", "filename": "be23faf80750bf5f3a2812fbb4d33fd7506678858efb2d291a9195b8ad3fce92_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10081", "filename": "be384afc5f64cc4279cf058f5f2bab19c8453a33ef5258d838918e6dba5e1ad1_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10083", "filename": "bf5c93d6ba606ae2e84b5b88b06d7c9743efd2a2ef77e518c895b75abbc6ebf9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (bubbles in the entire frame move slightly up and down without any force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10084", "filename": "bf13e8a41b875779efceed49fb423d737256fd559663d0bca291187b3effcee9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Video anomaly: Time continuity (At 7.6s, the thermometer in the basin, which was stationary, suddenly moves without any force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10086", "filename": "bffbbf81acc40cb09fbee1f7bc7b4fc585e3d620fbc9dbd2c041b7c9ef99359a_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 2.3s, a small iron ball appears out of thin air in the left hand when it is picked up, and at 3.4s, a small iron ball suddenly disappears from the upper left corner of the table).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10087", "filename": "c0e64cc7edbf45aed7ed579560b9f666129d405ecb76a9b4320b66c7e97851d9_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is not continuous (in the video, the distant waves are calm and there are no natural factors such as tides, but at 3.4 seconds, a wave suddenly appears in the middle of the sea, and the continuous wave is layered).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10088", "filename": "c1ec660f7e675df7bbe358e36297c83ee532f0a3d5988367ddc6c6b5a5c11a26_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The scene is abnormal: the time is continuous (at 0.5 seconds, the charger cable in the upper left corner of the wall suddenly appears out of thin air and does not leave a shadow on the wall).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10089", "filename": "c2d30dce3be2dcdf0cc752213057fc06b94e78ca2e34ef83faf0dc876abe126f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Time continuity (starting at 5.7 seconds, the smoke from the burning paper gradually transforms into perfectly aligned and continuous smoke rings, which is inconsistent with the initially chaotic smoke).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10090", "filename": "c2fa7c6e9f8b263c72f5932560fbe31df6a445226970d8582605771f76b88c64_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (as the crystal ball rotates from 1.1 seconds to 6.7 seconds, a small piece of glass on the left side of the crystal ball suddenly detaches from the crystal ball and floats in the air, which does not conform to the laws of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10092", "filename": "c3d780c8c7205bdd7843f85e6498848e194c97f3b3228faf96bd953498862429_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10093", "filename": "c4fe1930efdc8b2c5fe0883d3efd6c5aa5aa040ceb0c7da1b4981ed1dc5a622f_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10094", "filename": "c5dd4a1a5168876a5b105f14215bafe188c0a56c9cf25bf037221318c26b1f13_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10095", "filename": "c5e91179588547edae1485b72336383b0d8789c58a577257becf7c82358faedf_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Continuous time (the leaves in the video are constantly flickering throughout).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10096", "filename": "c6c8f4aad6018160f0e4ad53f8d92b9ac7511271b36a323a34a42ac7f91eb410_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The image is abnormal: the time is continuous (from 0s to 2.6s, the reflections on the diamond are messy and do not move randomly, but rather move up and down as if rotating on the diamond).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10098", "filename": "c7bfd4458e5eea2d60c08dc932fbf9ea33078555c688ab9850365bef3345b78e_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Causality (A blue aura appeared on the wall throughout the video, and the blue aura moved with the camera's movement)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10099", "filename": "c7dc883128f612ad025f632661d804c821a91ab4c2f5096bc39d678165846df2_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video shows an anomaly: physical behavior (the straw is inserted into the cup and refraction occurs within the cup, but the second refraction occurs in the middle of the refraction part and the direction of refraction is inconsistent, which does not conform to the laws of light refraction).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10100", "filename": "c08e3f471656434930fd301fad4ae02beed1825425bb54b1ee73591e0f77292c_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal visual behavior: Physical behavior (0.9s-8s, the basketball bounced to the left after being hit to the right without being slapped back by hand, which does not conform to the laws of inertia)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10101", "filename": "c8cafce4b50f59ed06d41da0197333493ab4118510b5c783c80dab46e9665f6d_processed_s", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_10102", "filename": "c8f2b995ec6f91114b970a6c8f1a025a227eff53516bfd20fb167212210e3712_processed_s", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: cause and effect (the smoke from the dust collector should be continuously and irregularly emitted throughout the video, but the video shows smoke rings being produced in a regular pattern and the smoke rings are too regular).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Sora 2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10103", "filename": "0b9f1c59dca3a073d3a0bca303cc173a89c7a13eee98061a9d11978594d389f7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Time Continuity (There are no water droplets on the screen at 1.3s, but water droplets appear out of nowhere on the glass on the right side of the screen at 1.5s). Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (The key to liquefaction is that water vapor releases heat and condenses when it encounters cold glass. In the video, there is already water on the glass surface, and the temperature of the glass surface is approaching equilibrium with the ambient temperature. The appearance of water droplets between 1.3s and 1.5s violates the principle of liquefaction).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10104", "filename": "0b9f1c59dca3a073d3a0bca303cc173a89c7a13eee98061a9d11978594d389f7_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video behavior: physical behavior (from 1.8 seconds to the last second of the video, the water flow and water droplets in the video show a phenomenon of flowing from bottom to top, and there is no phenomenon of flowing downward under the influence of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 5, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10105", "filename": "0b9f1c59dca3a073d3a0bca303cc173a89c7a13eee98061a9d11978594d389f7_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_10110", "filename": "0b65a12b4da9e7d7ebf7b8103c9e6c2655768b780b6a1b369602ea5a731abd89_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual Anomaly: Physical Behavior (From 0.7 seconds to the last second of the video, after being repeatedly run over by the tire, the bread undergoes significant plastic deformation, and its internal structure is damaged. This deformation and damage to the internal structure are irreversible. The bread returning to its original shape in the video does not match reality.)", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10111", "filename": "0b65a12b4da9e7d7ebf7b8103c9e6c2655768b780b6a1b369602ea5a731abd89_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (after 3.6 seconds in the video, what was originally a package containing two separate small breads becomes a single, whole bread without any boundaries after being run over by a tire, which is inconsistent with reality).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10112", "filename": "0b65a12b4da9e7d7ebf7b8103c9e6c2655768b780b6a1b369602ea5a731abd89_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10113", "filename": "0b65a12b4da9e7d7ebf7b8103c9e6c2655768b780b6a1b369602ea5a731abd89_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (at 6.6s in the video, the bread is deflated and shriveled in one frame, but in the next frame it looks like it hasn't been crushed).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10114", "filename": "0b70f0ee8ed98158dfda53ba26f31c7cfe1314e8455acc227845ed90980a62f3_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is abnormal: the timing is continuous (in the first second of the video, the duck does not swim to the left side, but ripples appear out of nowhere on the water surface on the left).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10115", "filename": "0b70f0ee8ed98158dfda53ba26f31c7cfe1314e8455acc227845ed90980a62f3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (the water flows from right to left in the video, and the duck floats from bottom to top, which does not conform to the principle of inertia).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_10116", "filename": "0b70f0ee8ed98158dfda53ba26f31c7cfe1314e8455acc227845ed90980a62f3_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10117", "filename": "0b70f0ee8ed98158dfda53ba26f31c7cfe1314e8455acc227845ed90980a62f3_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_10118", "filename": "0ba50e8a7dbba5a2ea95d9a75d997eb157968d4c87663b70bfb3b38af8305802_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video exhibits the following anomalies: Time continuity (during the video's 1.4s-1.6s interval, the two balls did not collide, yet the ball on the right already produced debris); Physical behavior (from 4.2s to the last second of the video, the balls did not fall to the ground due to inertia but remained suspended in the air, which contradicts the principles of gravity).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10119", "filename": "0ba50e8a7dbba5a2ea95d9a75d997eb157968d4c87663b70bfb3b38af8305802_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal behavior: Physical behavior (at 1.6s in the video, the white ball suddenly explodes without touching any object, violating the law of conservation of energy).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "T1_10120", "filename": "0ba50e8a7dbba5a2ea95d9a75d997eb157968d4c87663b70bfb3b38af8305802_processed_v", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The footage is abnormal: the time is continuous (in the footage from 5.4s to 8s, the ball collides with a plane and explodes, but the sparks from the explosion in the footage spread out in a very uniform radial pattern. In reality, there should be irregular fragments flying everywhere).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10124", "filename": "0bbd07c00bf7de0efcd7a38edf3ad1b53dcc7afdb4ab2a7ff3d4daec8111f13d_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "The video is malfunctioning: the timing is inconsistent (the packaging bag is white one second and yellow the next, showing a discrepancy).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "T1_10125", "filename": "0bbd07c00bf7de0efcd7a38edf3ad1b53dcc7afdb4ab2a7ff3d4daec8111f13d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Visual anomaly: Physical behavior (After the contents of the bag are run over by a car at 1.1 seconds, the contents of the bag unfold on their own without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "T1_10126", "filename": "0bbd07c00bf7de0efcd7a38edf3ad1b53dcc7afdb4ab2a7ff3d4daec8111f13d_processed_k", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "[system_log][No explanation provided]", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Kling 2.5", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10127", "filename": "0bbd07c00bf7de0efcd7a38edf3ad1b53dcc7afdb4ab2a7ff3d4daec8111f13d_processed_v", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Veo 3.1 Fast", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "T1_10128", "filename": "0bd7ff8c025b992eff2f9d4781c7d30552a0956e83307a19b61ea3a2fd75992b_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Anomaly in the video: Physical behavior (a square pile of bricks stacked between 1.9s and 2.3s in the video explodes on its own without any external force).", "glitch_severity": 4, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10129", "filename": "0bd7ff8c025b992eff2f9d4781c7d30552a0956e83307a19b61ea3a2fd75992b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": "Abnormal video footage: Physical behavior (between 0.7s and 1.3s in the video, the brick on the right falls without any external force, violating the principle of inertia).", "glitch_severity": 3, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "T1_10132", "filename": "0bf75496e65721b8b42f0a13873d4d414aa21493feb8cc2ca8ee176572da760c_i2v_a14b_processed_w", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "73d02cd8-4425-56e9-a897-495c0c1bc876", "filename": "P30_111_624_ebcab3aab38c3f33_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: In the 3.2s video, the person turned off the tap, but the water flow did not change at all." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "f5afcf35-daad-5c84-bf37-72ec02092107", "filename": "P30_113_141_414e10217a988652_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 0-5 seconds, the person in the video takes the sponge out of the pool, but the sponge is not wet and soft; instead, it appears dry and fluffy." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "f10c4b18-a5b5-5737-accb-825c452d7fc5", "filename": "P35_101_22_2e54cbdbae5d56fd_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: At 1.2 seconds, the scissors can be seen cutting the object, but at 3 seconds, the object appears intact." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "a87dccb8-bea4-57f6-b393-70e5c0b680f9", "filename": "P35_103_20_fc675112a2fde06b_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: In the 0-5s video, water continuously enters the cup, but the amount of water in the cup decreases instead of increasing." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "77d6de7d-7130-50e9-83fd-46ee30752ceb", "filename": "P35_103_49_e67667d5e4b41aa6_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: The food in the frying pan disappears into thin air at 2.1 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "ee2b26a1-2b25-5b14-8a46-50c4875843d2", "filename": "P35_103_54_be3b409977aa7274_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "b6f377e8-24cf-570f-a377-bd226395b746", "filename": "P35_103_55_31f9a4cc0b54918e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 4.1 seconds, an item identical to the one in your hand appears out of thin air on the ground." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "1d3256d4-0356-540c-bf24-9ef12b417933", "filename": "P35_103_166_5d347946d32147cc_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "0ad57ae8-30fb-52c3-b16c-e5faf4fa74c7", "filename": "P35_103_236_4260abb27a75bf01_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "7c60a04e-a3f8-5e5b-b741-d1bb5065e162", "filename": "P35_104_102_65d74300562d0ed0_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality: At 3 seconds, the person in the video turned the switch by hand, but the button did not change, while the firepower controlled by the button changed." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "c1b91333-aab3-58b7-8da3-5e331fbee095", "filename": "P35_104_210_a2557b689381c587_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous anomalies: At 3 seconds, the plate being washed by the person in the video suddenly splits in two." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "b328feaa-6dd9-538f-ace7-816ab136ac15", "filename": "P35_104_240_eca5746da9df4c37_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: 0-5 seconds, the water in the pot is boiling even though there is no fire in the video." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "7beb873a-3759-532f-af39-bb99b4a6d7dc", "filename": "P35_104_266_cd0c5c2341b0c4da_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time sequence: 5 seconds ago, the person's left hand in the video had a normal five fingers, but 5 seconds later it only had three." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "4f2e29ab-b449-5c9e-bc71-17f5460fcfdd", "filename": "P35_104_269_03941604ca082189_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: In the 0-5s video, a person uses a towel to smooth out the lid, but the towel does not soften or become floppy." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "f43be3d3-57d2-5337-bf2e-fd3d46186a14", "filename": "P35_104_291_2e1f637b1cbb42ed_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "3f25763b-7b0d-5518-9767-1ee81abce117", "filename": "P35_104_450_abc7c1770ce456a7_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: There was no fire in the 0-5s video, but the food in the pot was steaming hot." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "1cdaef97-5147-5267-ad49-9968aff16a3d", "filename": "P35_104_614_ea1898564b04ed98_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "9ecee242-58f6-5c9e-bab5-7778908275fb", "filename": "P35_104_632_37874415988d2ecd_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "42ae1058-160c-5d6a-886f-cfb929f57d9b", "filename": "P35_104_675_db59b729555fe4c5_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 4.1 seconds, the roll of paper undergoes a sudden change, abruptly transforming into a single sheet of paper." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "98692707-60e4-565e-8915-a8df9efe0941", "filename": "P35_104_676_e914583be3d2c137_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: In the 0-5s video, the person crumpled the paper into a ball with their hand, but when the paper was unfolded, it was completely intact." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "0b3e70fb-da87-5728-b8d1-3011ec9f32d2", "filename": "P27_103_226_b7257fa7a5361777_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 0s-5s, in the video, the main body of the blender moves during the blending process, while in reality, when a blender is blending, only the mixing head moves, and the other parts remain stationary." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "17a43ecd-8a69-5ad8-bcb2-fdb3557a2c79", "filename": "P27_103_267_77c7ee7cfd405336_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: The powder packet in my hand disappears after 5 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "48ebaefc-8748-5de9-b964-c2652f252bde", "filename": "P27_103_274_c906550dd90ad640_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: Deformation of the glass basin occurred at 3.1 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "027ba571-9e59-5974-8236-03578c2700a1", "filename": "P27_103_302_ed68936ca5181def_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: After 1.2 seconds, most of the pale yellow liquid in the basin on the table disappeared into thin air.", "Physical behavior: 0.1s-0.2s, clipping occurs between the hand and the brush." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "5192147d-4de1-5679-95df-ae6955f56623", "filename": "P27_103_325_8ae110a8160c8d46_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "1e62b3bc-ebf4-591f-90eb-1cace727cc2f", "filename": "P27_103_377_c5f148db506231de_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall impression: From 0s to 5s, there were continuous stutters in the video." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "d491b680-524b-5a6e-9be1-ca3a2e8907b4", "filename": "P27_103_411_726af87904b4e0c4_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The duration is continuous: 0.1s-0.3s. The wire in my hand keeps disappearing in part and then suddenly reappearing.", "Time continuity: At 1 second, the white wire connected to the red machine turns into a line where white and brown intersect.", "The duration is continuous: 3s-3.1s, during which the front end of the plug disappears into thin air.", "Continuous time: The shape of the plug changes at 4 seconds.", "The duration is continuous: 4.1s-4.2s, during which the fingers of the right hand become transparent." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "646f9c2c-0f34-50e4-8bce-2e164772252d", "filename": "P27_103_482_3cceff37c0d6a628_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 0s-0.1s, the whisk in the character's hand deforms into a fork.", "Time continuity: At 0.2s, a blue cloth appears out of thin air on the left side of the screen.", "Physical behavior: The cloth that appears on the left side of the screen between 0.2s and 5s is suspended in the air without being subjected to any force.", "Time continuity: The fork in the character's hand disappears into thin air at 1.2 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "cca0064d-d91c-5a70-92df-0c0269b65169", "filename": "P27_103_547_0d0eb2e59b8b01d1_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "8b3774af-e684-5151-861d-530bd6fdaa1e", "filename": "P27_104_21_d82f1eabb0a8159a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 0s-2.1s, there is no plastic frame on the shelf where cola is placed on the refrigerator door, whereas in reality, there is always a plastic frame on the refrigerator door where items are placed.", "Overall intuition: 0s-2.1s, the top layer of the refrigerator door is completely sealed. In reality, the place where items are placed on the refrigerator door is only a plastic frame, not completely sealed." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "7748b26c-e1e8-5484-be53-7c33a1389fb7", "filename": "P27_104_25_1bb84dd239f33d4c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: 2.2s-2.3s, the items on the table disappear into thin air.", "Time continuity: 3.2s is when two red objects appear next to the white plastic bag." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "05c6068c-9e32-5a8d-9e83-9f180d586b0c", "filename": "P27_104_26_7a5c834a84d04c30_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 5s. There is no plastic frame on the bottom shelf of the refrigerator door where items are placed, whereas in reality, there is always a plastic frame on the refrigerator door where items are placed." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "e71ce0bc-224f-5bc8-9886-a8139ba3af52", "filename": "P27_104_145_7325cbbfe99440c3_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 1.2s, a bone-shaped decoration appears out of thin air on the towel.", "The duration is 3.2 seconds, during which the small bone decoration on Towel Mountain disappears into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "e65bb011-bdbc-5598-89e1-eebbb9802d2c", "filename": "P27_104_264_17d5179dd11864df_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: 2.1s-3.1s, in the video, the blue rag flies precisely back to the hook from the hand without any force." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "0dc37a11-fd91-58b1-8b71-2bdbf0ac22dc", "filename": "P27_104_327_7e9e2c24d04d6f71_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time duration: 0.2s. After peeling off the thin film on the cookie, another thin film appears on the cookie." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "3a254172-7a24-5f41-a4b6-52d86f954598", "filename": "P27_104_341_e1b2ac08f492cc31_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 4.2 seconds, the black object inside the light purple roll in the upper right corner of the bag disappears into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "ddf7abbe-faca-5cdf-8f20-932fea34d290", "filename": "P27_105_166_30520b4daf415752_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "2d11fa98-350e-5fb6-a709-46297d084a40", "filename": "P27_105_252_46bd01be7aea9884_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: At 3.2 seconds, the folded surfaces on the paper merge to form a new sheet of paper." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "15cd5fe1-9626-58cb-9f71-c6e105e67815", "filename": "P27_105_265_18f5f81aea543589_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "f59e4a9b-573c-5ee3-a62c-0e886fc09412", "filename": "P28_101_40_9c6cc02b62d8070d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: During the period of 4s-4.1s, the paper in the left hand disappears into thin air and then reappears in the right hand, becoming larger." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "3263cf36-9e5f-5c1b-bade-a898f61623b3", "filename": "P28_101_42_f4752545319fa43c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 2s-3.2s. In the video, there was only a small piece of garlic in his hand, but a lot of garlic bits were chopped off.", "Time continuity: At 4.2 seconds, most of the minced garlic disappeared into thin air, leaving only three pieces.", "Overall intuition: 3.3s-4s. The character's action of holding the knife is dangerous. In reality, to remove food stuck to a knife, you can wipe the side of the knife with your palm, not hold the knife with your hand." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "61e95124-a70b-55a4-b820-0d842d77c7bc", "filename": "P28_101_68_bc18ec4cb24fbd62_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 1.1s, a piece of paper is torn out of thin air from the corner of the plastic bag by the left hand.", "Time interval: 1.2s-2s, the character's right hand becomes twisted, and the soft paper in the left hand becomes harder plastic.", "Time continuity: After 4.2 seconds, the white plastic changes into a white packaging bag with a green pattern." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "25f3be6d-3389-5a67-b3b9-a3039b9fb018", "filename": "P28_101_71_2ca39f2ce03a381c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: The white zipper on the transparent plastic bag disappears out of thin air at 0.1s.", "Continuous time: An orange line appears above the plastic bag between 2.1s and 5s." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "1043e854-261e-5424-9c5d-a32352877e71", "filename": "P28_103_110_63826acbd81990eb_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 0s-5s, in the video, when cutting the potato, only one cut is made, but multiple potato chunks fall off.", "Time continuity: The potato in my hand suddenly grows larger at 0.1 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "408e2e0e-bb21-5797-ab5c-2e501a15daa2", "filename": "P28_104_122_cf46d20729cfd17e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The time is continuous: the upper part of the fork in the hand disappears and then reappears out of thin air between 0.1s and 0.3s.", "Time continuity: At 1.1 seconds, the lower half of the fork disappears into thin air.", "Time continuity: Between 2s and 2.1s, the fork in her hand disappears into thin air and then reappears out of thin air.", "Time duration: 5 seconds, the fork in hand disappears into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "fbca3a56-8caa-5455-84e3-ddaf394d0030", "filename": "P28_104_157_2b4e91772ff24ffd_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "bf8bf6cd-23e9-5ac3-adc4-e0850ad5ee1d", "filename": "P28_105_8_d9b7a90f4e168ced_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 0.2s, a piece of yellow food appears out of thin air under the black spoon.", "Overall intuition: 2s-2.2s, the left arm twisted too much when pouring food. In reality, you only need to flip your wrist slightly, without twisting your arm so much.", "The time interval is 4s-4.1s, during which the food in the spoon disappears into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "85866ba8-92dc-58b1-9812-8daef71831be", "filename": "P28_108_12_251b33eb3df1c4ed_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "6c3ccfe3-2622-5766-ad52-daed268996e1", "filename": "P28_111_141_a35a50549f9f19ce_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: 2s-2.1s, when holding a towel, a clipping phenomenon occurs when the towel passes through the cabinet door handle.", "The duration is continuous: 2.2s-2.3s, during which the character's hands appear to twist and stick together.", "Overall intuition: 0.1s-5s, the character's right foot never appears, only the part above the knee appears." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "25d1071b-480d-57a2-bb46-c47f2ca80054", "filename": "P28_111_149_9b1c75e5c4373002_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: After 5 seconds, the handle of the spoon in the character's hand disappears into thin air.", "Continuous time: The spoon in the character's hand grows larger at 0.1s.", "Physical behavior: The spoon passes through the pot at 0.2s, and a piercing phenomenon occurs.", "Time continuity: The rubber band on the character's right hand breaks at 0.2 seconds.", "The duration is continuous: 0.3s-5s, during which the pattern on the bracelet on the left hand changes continuously." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "ce9937d1-e273-5b6d-8782-ed718911ba37", "filename": "P28_111_153_18a42a9a3fe5e1d0_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: The steel wool in the left hand disappears into thin air at 0.1s.", "Time interval: 0.1s-5s, a large number of soybeans appear out of thin air in the pot.", "The duration is continuous: 0.3s-5s. The pattern on the left bracelet keeps changing, while the right bracelet keeps breaking and then starts to close again." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "2b1156c0-c3f2-53d7-93d6-f934d231518a", "filename": "P28_111_155_8e4fde39c5269b67_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 0.3 seconds, the pot handle suddenly changes from the right hand to the left hand.", "Overall intuition: 0.1s-1.3s, left hand shape is distorted.", "Time continuity: At 0.1s, a steel wool ball appears out of thin air in the left hand." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "fd81cbda-6b3d-5cf2-92be-f1529586b0f0", "filename": "P28_111_156_c7b321445f9c0ba7_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: The item in the left hand disappears into thin air at 0.1s." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "98cefc58-e93c-5733-ab5b-e5ae1506a532", "filename": "P28_111_199_92c7d0ce81912b1e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: The opening of the packaged bag that has been opened at 1.3s and 5s will be sealed again." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "7a6d50c4-8866-5ff2-a90e-adb7a2d6090b", "filename": "P28_112_77_7019cea5689c7299_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: 0s-1.1s, the object in the hand disappears into thin air, and the hand undergoes fusion and distortion." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "bce1712e-ff99-5dd6-bdcc-d1df72fb8ca6", "filename": "P28_113_117_185938b727fc4271_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "dd22fd80-b9f3-5937-bd43-3ecb5acf95ae", "filename": "P28_113_139_540cee08a34eb97f_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 0s-5s, in the video, when chopping scallions, only one cut is made, but a lot of scallion bits fall off." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "dce4ca9f-26b7-588c-bbff-00e61adf16c3", "filename": "P30_101_80_776e34df3a648981_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The duration is continuous: 0s-5s, during which the handle of the plastic fork in the hand continuously disappears and reappears." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "3bf8c311-0189-5470-aa25-8e8ffffd19d9", "filename": "P30_101_96_7712bac6d6b3ef10_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "d501ac6e-798a-5db6-b1a3-bb446ad0be8f", "filename": "P01_102_113_babb379c10836c19_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous Time: Throughout the video, as the person washes their hands, their left and right hands repeatedly appear distorted, deformed, and blurred, which does not conform to the texture of a real hand." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "09437803-14a0-5119-93f1-e85aeb1a13bf", "filename": "P01_102_118_d49aea32331bb1fb_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 0.02s, the person's hand and arm appear to merge with the towel in their hand in the video, and the person's fingers appear twisted and deformed.", "Time Continuity: At 4 seconds, the person's right hand in the video twists and deforms during movement, and the fingers become blurred and blended.", "Time continuity: Between 4.1s and 5s, the towel and hand appear blurred and merged in the video, and the fingers of the right hand appear twisted and deformed." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "409d2601-6548-5ef9-8c01-29842e84a086", "filename": "P01_104_91_94ef0a01f09ef94b_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The timing is inconsistent: In the entire video, only the first time the cucumber is cut, the knife is cut from above. However, in subsequent cuts, the knife is not raised above the cucumber, yet complete cucumber slices are produced, which is inconsistent with reality. Furthermore, the number of cucumber slices appears to increase out of thin air during the movement of the video after they are cut." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "32135489-d981-5b17-8b7f-378f7893821f", "filename": "P01_105_76_30c1fcc614565a35_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: During the 0s-3s segment of the video, as the hand sprinkles seasoning, the fingers appear distorted, deformed, and blurred.", "Time Continuity: After 2.1 seconds, the right hand did not squeeze the condiment bottle, but the black cap of the condiment bottle deformed.", "Cause and effect: During the period from 0s to 2.1s, the seasoning was evenly sprinkled around the food in the pot. All the food in the pot should have traces of the seasoning, but in the video, only the food in the lower right corner of the pot shows traces of seasoning." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "b5fed6d1-d5c1-5899-8980-df04fd59683e", "filename": "P01_105_144_d1a8f6feb96d9e8d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: During the period from 0s to 0.1s, the box in the hand suddenly deforms, and a clipping phenomenon occurs between the fingers and the box in the hand.", "Time continuity: During the 0s-1s movement of the hand, the fingers appear distorted, blurred, and merged, lacking the texture of a realistic hand.", "Time continuity: At 0.2 seconds, a piece of paper appears out of thin air in the box in the video.", "Time continuity: A notch appears in the upper right corner of the banknote in hand between 0.2s and 1s, and then suddenly returns to normal.", "Time continuity: Between 3.2s and 4s, clipping and merging occurs between the right side of the banknote in the hand and the right index finger.", "Time continuity: During the folding of the banknote at 4.1s-4.2s, the fingers of both hands twist, deform, and blur, and the banknote in their hands also twists and deforms." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "aef820fe-0d9f-56eb-8c9b-713c3c1a31a8", "filename": "P01_105_220_3307b9418c09282c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: In the video from 3.1s to 5s, when the white object in the hand is stabbed with a knife, the white object continuously twists and deforms, and part of the tip of the knife disappears." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "d97bb579-584c-5b4e-9a29-19f44087168e", "filename": "P01_105_230_94a512d90806569b_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: Throughout the video, when wiping hands with a cloth, the fingers and the cloth appear to stick together and merge, and the hand twists and deforms as it moves.", "Continuous timing: At 1.2 seconds, when the right hand touches an object on the right side of the video, the fingers of the right hand and the object appear blurred and merged." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "3d69d7ed-2d81-5709-ae62-a032bd236c98", "filename": "P01_105_264_3edd594b6c52126c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous timing: During the vegetable cutting process from 0.2s to 5s, extra vegetable pieces appear out of thin air with each cut.", "Time continuity: At 4.2 seconds, the piece of vegetable under the blade in the video suddenly disappears into thin air as the knife moves." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "54a5bbbe-8cea-50e3-8cb9-1e25409a51f2", "filename": "P01_105_347_03fddc60c4be8497_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: The right thumb showed twisting and deformation at 0.2 seconds.", "Continuous timing: At approximately 3.2 seconds, the thumbs of both hands appear blurred and merged in the video.", "Time continuity: In the video between 3s and 3.1s, the right thumb appears to be twisted and deformed, and the left and right thumbs appear to merge." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "0b4d852d-04b6-5479-a24f-7f956156f922", "filename": "P01_105_443_23d45e749b5187f7_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: In the video between 0s and 0.2s, the left hand and the cloth in the hand appear to be twisted and deformed, and the hand and the cloth appear to be clipped together.", "Time continuity: After 0.2 seconds, a cabinet door appears out of thin air on the cabinet in the middle of the video.", "Physical behavior: In the video, the cabinet door opens on its own without any external force during the 0.2s-1.2s interval, which does not conform to the laws of physics." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "5ca95b21-3e8a-5f53-8e41-04fb2353a287", "filename": "P01_105_593_ae7d4836fcbf0a6a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous timing: The black spatula in the lower left corner of the video partially disappears, and the knife in the hand becomes blurry and its outline is unclear during the spinning process." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "36c87b89-1ddc-5033-a325-895e0e4ad43a", "filename": "P01_105_642_72c6b778bc37cf3a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: During the 4-5 second period of rubbing the towel, the fingers and the towel show a phenomenon of clipping and merging, and the fingers appear to be twisted and deformed." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "31eeff48-7206-5a14-9783-54b84d127af9", "filename": "P01_105_738_fb6bbabdd0e60c5d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: In the 0.1s-5s video, the black spoon in the bowl in the upper left corner appears to have a partially missing spoon tip.", "Continuous time: Throughout the video, as the hand rubs the towel, the area where the hand and towel come into contact appears to stick together." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "6747cd05-612d-5573-bcbc-ee851a2d4f45", "filename": "P01_106_146_74770cc9d40625be_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: In the video, between 2 and 5 seconds, a hand takes a blue and white object into and out of the refrigerator, and the fingers appear twisted and deformed.", "Time continuity: During the 2.1s-2.2s interval, a blue-white object appears out of thin air above the hand inside the refrigerator in the video." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "9e1246d5-cba3-50c2-b0b6-4c54df760139", "filename": "P01_106_233_cdc637b47067452a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous timing: During the 1.1s-1.2s period of rubbing the towel, the fingers of the left hand suddenly pierce through the towel.", "Continuous time: During the hand movement from 3s to 3.1s, the fingers of the left hand twist and deform, and the towel and fingers become blurred and merged." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "82843457-1202-5dce-b667-bd396a1dd80d", "filename": "P01_107_45_5906d61cc58fa757_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous timing: During the 0.1s-0.2s interval, when the right hand moves above the bottle in the video, the fingers of the right hand penetrate the edge of the bottle.", "Time continuity: The footage of the right hand touching the bottle throughout the entire video is distorted." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "5781ebbf-888e-58e8-be03-7bc8a00c0231", "filename": "P01_108_51_56b0b0ce0690a49e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: The faucet switch rotates on its own without any external force between 0s and 1.1s, which does not conform to the laws of physics.", "Time continuity: In the video between 2s and 2.1s, when the left hand takes the cup out of the sink, there is a momentary teleportation in the movement of the left and right hands, and the outline of the cup suddenly becomes larger after it is put down.", "Time continuity: During the 3s-3.1s interval, a fusion phenomenon appears between the left hand and the spoon head in the video.", "Time Continuity: When the left hand touches the faucet switch at 4-5 seconds, the left hand and the faucet switch merge, and the spoon in the right hand deforms, producing two spoon heads." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "3ded79a5-7457-59b3-80ce-68a4bba106b1", "filename": "P01_109_34_3da78901a9412c5b_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: During the 0s-0.1s interval in the video, artifacts appear between the hand and the towel as they move, and the hand and towel seem to merge when the hand picks up the towel.", "Time Continuity: At approximately 2.1 seconds, a towel suddenly appears out of thin air on the character's left hand." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "f5e20746-d7a7-5359-bc48-728dca58524b", "filename": "P01_109_211_4929ec23228871a3_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: During the 1-5 second interval in the video, the hand is constantly tossing the pan, and the potato slices in the pan should be flipping and moving, but the potatoes in the pan remain in a stable state in the video." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "9884c093-cb97-5bfb-a8c7-dd6fe430cc5d", "filename": "P01_109_271_ea9c0304c5b0c186_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous timing: During the 0s-0.2s interval, the object in the right hand appears to merge with the object in the left hand in the video.", "Time Continuity: At 1 second, a brown object suddenly appears out of thin air between the left and right hands.", "In a continuous video clip (1-5 seconds), as a person's hand rubs an object, the fingers appear distorted, deformed, and blurred." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "77e664ac-6e44-5261-95d3-9593b2142a29", "filename": "P35_104_697_9e6303fae0f53a1e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality: 2.2 seconds ago, the person in the video had already wrapped the flesh on the left side with plastic film, but 2.2 seconds later, the plastic film on the left side appeared out of thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "cb2d6a49-66d3-59e0-9f6f-8a1ac2117d2c", "filename": "P35_104_700_e98b78f09f403c44_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: At 3.2 seconds, the person in the video moves the item on the right to the left, but the item on the right is returned to its original position." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "5f2a59ba-e809-56b1-80e9-e05d4e5296d3", "filename": "P35_104_715_479de4c388af0470_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: at 2 seconds, the plastic film appears to be oriented left-right, but at 3.1 seconds, it changes to an up-down orientation." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "14f88635-fa0f-50b4-b6e7-58ad7e44be6d", "filename": "P35_104_762_cb4de7718b0c684f_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: The flat cover automatically flew up at 2.1 seconds without any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "7a784397-6476-5183-87af-241bdb927544", "filename": "P35_105_9_7505a98b60a18a74_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "95e43b10-2686-53db-a0f2-6da4dd54d2c4", "filename": "P35_105_61_2dcd2af969f11e93_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality: At 3.1 seconds, the person in the video can be seen tearing the plastic film with their hands, but at 4.2 seconds, the plastic film appears out of thin air on the flesh." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "a939ffdc-7213-5ac3-8493-aae701621d88", "filename": "P35_105_104_b05b530342a5c755_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "5f33c916-18cb-51be-a174-83d0e3506a8a", "filename": "P35_105_136_cc292dc248dd73d7_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: At 3 seconds, the trash can lid in the video moves downward automatically without any force acting on it." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "bf2d9cef-9d55-56c8-ba25-9a02ee4e30ef", "filename": "P35_105_137_315039f7200947d0_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: At 1.1 seconds, the fingers of the person in the video exhibit clipping." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "f857bdf7-e150-5d0c-8d73-5d64dcf9a789", "filename": "P35_105_139_e3079e4c16be3b16_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: At 2.1 seconds, the first button in the video moves on its own without any force being applied." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "e0409bea-cea5-5a73-bdfe-8383a6910e73", "filename": "P35_105_158_da2dd4912131bf46_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "cbffba26-8fdc-5ea6-b3a8-db27b3cd264e", "filename": "P35_105_259_502ee52f9e4604ca_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality: 0-5 seconds, the person in the video is using the lower gas stove, but the food is steaming hot on the other gas stove." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "151707ac-cea6-5b80-a26e-a8af204ecadc", "filename": "P35_105_268_a9977f2cac5aa00d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: 2.1 seconds. The towel in the video undergoes a sudden change, from a long towel to a short towel." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "26e3d2bd-9188-571f-a3c7-397baee7541a", "filename": "P35_105_395_d96ee1f1e6d9a3cd_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall impression: The image is not too blurry or unclear despite the shaky footage." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "56a79d4f-1107-589b-b0e5-3a04eaf46ced", "filename": "P35_105_408_9f9b2fc3a05effdc_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time sequence: 2 seconds ago there was no round object in the plate, but 2.1 seconds later a round object suddenly appeared out of nowhere." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "ab19dd2f-c5ef-5bf7-a1a7-4e55f238ec11", "filename": "P35_107_24_b71d1b96e0d418b9_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "aab58a23-7769-599e-b563-5299e0451bc9", "filename": "P35_107_136_b2000258034e87a1_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "18f3f426-137f-57c8-8fc4-d4eb2a885100", "filename": "P35_107_149_9f1a9d4dbddb07c9_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 0.2 seconds, the fork in the video did not fall down before turning into a knife." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "b559eb6a-3b02-5fff-821e-05f06a78330f", "filename": "P35_107_241_aca224349a2909d3_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "a2ea32ab-d8d2-5c54-a4c3-cb2ff21ff220", "filename": "P35_108_76_2f20bc98fa8c4f15_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: At 4 seconds, the knife and hand in the video showed clipping." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "847c65de-8bf7-552c-ba8c-982719e3050d", "filename": "P03_123_16_5e7211dcd3a4efdf_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: In the video, between 0.2s and 3s, the right thumb appears to merge with the edge of the basin in the hand.", "Time continuity: When picking up the basin with both hands between 0s and 1s, twisting and artifacts appear on the fingers of both hands.", "Time continuity: From 0s to 5s, the numbers on the object in the upper left corner continuously jump and distort." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "7df0f72e-54b7-5109-88ad-bbaf868dd611", "filename": "P04_101_14_db57d5aaeed76c79_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: In the video, the left hand appears to twist and deform during movement between 0s and 0.1s.", "Time continuity: At 0.2 seconds, a white unidentified object appeared out of thin air below the cabinet.", "Time Continuity: At 4 seconds, when the cat passes the pot handle, the cat's backward movement shows blurring, distortion, and artifacts.", "Time continuity: During the period from 0.1s to 1s, the left hand was not holding the transparent object in the cabinet, but the transparent object in the cabinet moved without any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "1b5a1f44-aeea-5a2a-9391-291e6e7e14d6", "filename": "P04_102_10_fb9d7b18bb4505d3_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: A white object taken from the refrigerator suddenly deforms within 0.2s-1s.", "Time continuity: At 3.1 seconds, the right hand fingers pierced through the white object beneath the hand.", "Continuous time: During the period of 0.2s-1s, the object in the hand becomes stuck to the hand, and the outline of the fingers becomes blurred." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "e9f96c1e-4c63-504c-995b-235ff6e3d49c", "filename": "P04_106_109_d65292f24b2e8104_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: In the video between 0s and 0.2s, the fingers of the left hand appear twisted and deformed, and artifacts appear on the right hand.", "Continuous time: When the left hand moves at 1 second, the fingers of the left hand appear blurred and merged.", "Continuous timing: Between 2s and 2.1s, the fingers of the left and right hands appear to merge in the video.", "Continuous time: During the 3s-3.1s interval, the fingers of the right hand appear deformed and blurred, with indistinct finger outlines.", "In the continuous time frame (3.2s-5s), the fingers of both hands appear blurred and distorted in the video, and the fingers of the right hand and left hand appear to merge into a blurred image." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "43cc981c-ffb1-5f2f-9125-b49b26d18bbd", "filename": "P04_107_23_576dcbfb3e1b9c35_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: During the period from 0s to 2s, a cut mark appears out of thin air on the right side of the object on the cutting board, even though no cut was made.", "Continuous timing: At 1.2 seconds in the video, after the knife cuts an object on the cutting board, the blade and the object stick together, and the blade deforms.", "Time continuity: At 4.1 seconds, after the knife on the right side of the cutting board touches the object, the cut on the object becomes distorted and deformed." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "e25a451b-7b1e-5bdb-9bdc-e5868f0cae3f", "filename": "P04_107_70_1a288fce546cb48a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous timing: During the 2s-2.2s interval of the video, the right hand appears distorted and blurred as it moves, and the metal part of the scissors disappears out of thin air.", "Time continuity: During the period from 3.1s to 3.2s, the yellow object on the platform appears and then disappears out of thin air.", "Time Continuity: At 4 seconds, a portion suddenly appears out of thin air below the yellow object in the left hand.", "Time continuity: Between 4s and 4.1s, the metal part at the tip of the scissors in the right hand blurred and disappeared.", "Time continuity: Between 4.1s and 4.2s, the yellow object in the upper right corner of the table moves without external force and gradually disappears during the movement, while an artifact appears at the tip of the scissors in the hand." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "964ca54d-6afa-5449-b725-34fb68390edf", "filename": "P04_107_328_0ef61777df5c80f1_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: Between 0s and 0.1s, the fingers of the left hand appear blurred and merged, with indistinct finger outlines.", "Time continuity: Between 0.1s and 0.2s, the left hand and the rolling pin appear to merge through a mold, and the fingers of the left hand show blurring and deformation.", "Continuous time: During the rolling process, the fingers of the hand deform within 1-5 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "b1f11810-841a-523a-85db-ab36deba2d79", "filename": "P04_107_330_d35f7c7e22ee678c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: From 0s to 5s, the image distorts when the left hand touches the green object on the left side of the video." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "c341c34d-c861-5baf-9c2c-1678308bbf57", "filename": "P04_107_354_4e7748a34ef819ac_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: During the rolling process (0s-5s), the image around the left hand distorts as the left hand moves.", "Continuous timing: Between 1.2s and 2s, the left hand and the handle of the rolling pin go through a mold, and the left hand twists and deforms during the movement.", "Time continuity: Between 2.2s and 3.1s, the left hand and the handle of the rolling pin appear to pass through the mold, and the left hand shows blurry deformation during the movement." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "87a4e26d-c661-501c-902d-3ebde3ec3ffc", "filename": "P04_107_475_099c8cf14be753a6_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: Noticeable abnormal flickering appeared on the screen between 0s and 5s.", "Continuous timing: During the 0s-0.2s interval in the video, the fingers of the left hand appear to twist and deform during the movement of the left hand." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "85173b9e-4ba6-5362-9ad5-ef175ed03aa5", "filename": "P04_107_491_7dc5a85c8d06ec8f_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "In the continuous time frame (0s-5s), the fingers of the hand are blurry, the finger outlines are unclear, and the texture of a real hand is lacking.", "Continuous time: During the movement of the left hand from 0.2s to 5s, a pulling sensation is felt between the left hand and the image on the table." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "e5e1a250-7fe2-5377-8bfc-3a1afd105ddc", "filename": "P04_107_562_0f891959174435b8_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: 0s-5s During the movement of the left hand, there is a noticeable pulling sensation between the left hand and the table, and the dough bounces abnormally under the rolling pin." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "797cccd5-ee98-513a-bb99-dadaca6a665c", "filename": "P04_107_692_8baf366a7ccd9b92_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: 0s-5s. During the hand's movement, there is a noticeable pulling sensation between the hand and the table surface, and the white object above the video shakes abnormally without any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "a6be66c8-8040-546d-84bc-9b1dfd7519d0", "filename": "P04_107_693_e820b3deeaecf9f7_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: During the period from 0.2s to 2s, without the hand shaping the dough, the dough continuously transforms into a regular five-pointed star shape, and the hand exhibits blurred deformation during the movement." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "9f628e41-6156-537b-bf63-ae3b4e6106e7", "filename": "P04_107_697_827fd9b20c90a35a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: 0s-5s During the movement of the left hand, there is a noticeable pulling sensation between the left hand and the image on the table.", "Time continuity: Between 3.2s and 4s, the right hand and the rolling pin handle appear to be clipped together, and the right hand shows blurry deformation during the movement." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "296017a6-24e8-593b-8324-d980389df24f", "filename": "P04_107_841_e78e4efac2b162fc_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous timing: When the left hand touches the dough at 0.1s-0.2s, the dough suddenly slides downwards from the cutting board.", "Time continuity: Between 0.2s and 1s, the left hand and the rolling pin appear to pass through each other, the left hand becomes blurred and deformed, and a ball of flour suddenly appears below the rolling pin.", "Continuous timing: During the 1-5 second time frame, as the left hand moves in the video, noticeable fluctuations appear at the point where the left hand contacts the table surface." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "5abf07df-c1c1-5660-899b-1efb73e3bd7f", "filename": "P04_107_844_a14adda509924415_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 0.1 seconds, a ring appears out of thin air on the left hand.", "Continuous time: 0s-5s. During the movement of the left hand, abnormal fluctuations appear at the point where the left hand contacts the table surface." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "7af0eeae-2b85-5560-a24e-5cf2042dd27a", "filename": "P04_108_42_71c7eb21b98d01dd_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "5c84fc22-22cd-5fc0-be1a-f873c663dac6", "filename": "P04_108_44_a5949b9fbee49681_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 0.1 seconds, a pot handle suddenly appears out of thin air on the side of the pot in the left hand in the video, and the position of the hand on the pot suddenly changes.", "Time sequence: Between 1.2s and 2s, an unidentified yellow object appears out of thin air on the towel in the right hand, and after being sprinkled into the pot, it disappears out of thin air inside the pot.", "Continuous time: Within approximately 5 seconds, the towel on the edge of the pot begins to twist and deform." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "ac7f96e5-62cd-5a99-8f95-f8c666f8ea90", "filename": "P04_109_133_7b71b040189ed07e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: Between 0s and 1s, the cucumber slice cut by the knife merges with the cucumber piece on the right side of the knife, and the cucumber piece on the right side of the knife breaks apart without being cut by the knife.", "Time Continuity: At 1.1 seconds, the small cucumber piece in the left hand suddenly disappeared into thin air.", "Continuous time: Between 0.2s and 1s, the blade and the cucumber slices on it begin to merge, and the blade becomes blurred and deformed.", "Time continuity: The cucumber cut at 2-3 seconds undergoes deformation during movement." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "e87184a1-6967-5526-89f4-7a99e1e7e9a9", "filename": "P06_108_67_af1dd90706354a80_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: 0.1s-1s, the shape of the object in the person's hand distorts.", "Abnormal physical behavior: 2.1s-2.2s, the figure's left hand clips through the cabinet." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "8312613c-e52d-589e-ac22-5c46df35a0f6", "filename": "P06_108_69_9aea7b74224b9dff_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent time anomaly: 0.1s-1.1s, some objects in the drawer disappear without a trace." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "311bee09-725f-508b-a32a-96656450c6cd", "filename": "P06_108_113_3b78e10b9b10525b_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: From 2.1s to 4.2s, a black line with a metallic sphere shape in the lower right corner of the screen continuously swings up and down without any force acting on it." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "6322ca29-a4a3-54d4-8604-ce02fb7f784a", "filename": "P06_113_107_de929860172c9323_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Anomaly in causality: 0.1s-0.2s, a clear liquid in a glass bottle suddenly turns black when poured into a cup.", "Continuous time anomaly: The black liquid in the cup disappeared into thin air in 1.1 seconds.", "Continuous time anomaly: The glass bottle cap disappeared out of thin air between 3.2 and 4 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "3215e1e6-a519-5841-9d83-6da83c58b6bc", "filename": "P07_101_3_b707221c6fd817b4_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: 0.1s A silver solid object appears out of thin air in the character's hand.", "Intermittent time anomaly: 2.1s-2.2s, the silver solid in the character's hand turns blue." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "dde4ce26-5a13-559f-b8d6-d1119cbe9632", "filename": "P07_101_65_f4d671a4c7536f0a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous anomaly in time: The red stripe on the cutting board suddenly disappeared in 1.2 seconds.", "Continuous time anomaly: A cutting board appears out of nowhere next to the sink within 3-5 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "e961eed0-bb48-52bb-a335-ab78f643fec0", "filename": "P07_110_29_8c99a271f9d4cd2e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal anomaly: 2.2s-3s, the paper box in the lower right corner of the screen automatically seals itself without the character performing any sealing action." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "c3e522c3-dd99-546e-9b72-e0b898d15cfa", "filename": "P07_110_39_00b9f80d347cca55_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent time anomaly: 2.2s-2.3s The ring on the character's right ring finger suddenly disappears and then reappears out of thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "18fa3c7c-b31b-58eb-a053-6955c7f00c0e", "filename": "P07_113_46_1a4e0a62d11a6cfd_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: Water from a faucet hits a person's hands for 0.1-5 seconds, and the person's hands are constantly rubbing together, but the water does not splash freely due to friction or impact." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "a67e6a65-30a8-500d-bcbe-7f9dae37f966", "filename": "P07_113_79_2d512fe1c8ba1152_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: After the drawer in the lower left corner of the screen is pulled open, it automatically closes inward without being pushed. (0.2s-1s)" ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "49442518-c197-5d36-a11d-d693b53d311d", "filename": "P09_103_5_d9beda35ce08488b_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal anomaly: 3s-3.1s After the character flips the food packaging bag in their hand, the back of the packaging returns to its original state after being flipped over." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "6e95a9b0-8190-5041-b20c-f66b06ddd6e3", "filename": "P09_103_23_e81a3c04e70e0086_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: 1.1s-2s A closed, non-perforated spatula becomes a shape with linear perforations, and the spatula's shape is inconsistent." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "03c6826a-0aab-51d4-96ea-92fb9e5c888c", "filename": "P09_104_58_53dd714022f0ea16_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent time anomalies: 0.1s-0.2s The juicer automatically teleports to the character's hand, fruit appears out of thin air and the quantity increases, the banana on the character's left hand teleports to the character's hand and automatically peels.", "Anomaly in causality: At 1 second, the juicer produces banana pieces, but the banana in the character's hand remains intact.", "Time-related anomalies: The blade on the table suddenly shifts automatically within 1-1.1 seconds.", "Anomaly in causality: Within 1-1.2 seconds, a large amount of white liquid was poured from the cup into the juicer, but the amount of liquid in the cup did not decrease." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "cd8ed224-df35-57f2-b891-04bf7b3d8fdc", "filename": "P09_104_75_a8ddbf4007c029a8_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: 1.1s-2.1s There is no reasonable interaction force between the person's hands and the towel, but the shape of the back of the towel continues to change." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "19026fb1-c236-59d6-bcbc-22085deb6fe9", "filename": "P11_101_35_5384c79702c2f189_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: 0.2s, objects on the character's left hand and the table disappeared into thin air.", "Intermittent anomaly: A bag of food suddenly appears next to the pot between 1.2s and 2.2s.", "Time-series anomaly: The blue packaging bag turned transparent in 3.2 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "d34cc41a-0cf3-5e81-96d0-0bd1b615b269", "filename": "P11_103_17_ac7324a695c491c3_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time-series anomaly: 0.1s later, the knife suddenly bent into the shape of a spatula." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "a59ae3c5-2258-5930-a722-798bea5cbbe5", "filename": "P11_103_73_04354addd6b7641c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Anomaly in causality: From 0s to 3.1s, no water flows from the faucet, but water appears to be flowing inside the sink." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "78980092-8a10-5e0a-9be1-2b06e352c49e", "filename": "P11_104_90_379f6b5a060c01df_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: 1.2s The piece of food on the character's right hand changes from one piece to two pieces.", "Time continuity anomaly: 2.2s A piece of food appears out of thin air on the character's right hand." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "3b109631-ff3f-53cc-a4a8-23ec6716a00e", "filename": "P11_104_174_f9278dd3e303cd24_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: The shape of the jarred food in the character's hand changes at 4.2 seconds, and the shape of the item is inconsistent." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "b43db657-8f3c-5b1b-9da7-57f068ff3301", "filename": "P11_105_19_35d387f0e4c76b3f_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "18c3c822-754d-5e8d-986a-8926c4e6f32b", "filename": "P11_107_16_6914796fba36523f_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: After the pizza was cut with scissors between 2.1s and 5.1s, the cut should be closed or slightly open without any external pulling force. However, the pizza in the video shows a large, obvious V-shaped tear." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "02be1c59-6793-5aef-b098-4b76dafc0b44", "filename": "P11_107_19_fa0f4f499e08ae0c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "06c59ad4-f831-56d8-8d31-c7d3f6d717f4", "filename": "P11_107_20_a488b600ebf8e0fa_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly: The amount of food on the plate suddenly decreased between 2.1s and 3.2s." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "d306ff06-fe22-5ff8-a8f5-672741bd813b", "filename": "P12_101_54_494f3a5f9edbf9b4_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "6b0a6398-1a88-5ae6-b292-0a602abdd057", "filename": "P12_101_251_1aaaade933c2d90a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: The food in the pot is continuously heated for 3-5 seconds, but the steam suddenly disappears and no more steam is emitted." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "f43091eb-a8af-516e-b37d-b492e4e52b61", "filename": "P12_101_310_b863a6b478524d26_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: In the 0.1s-5s frame, the food in the pot on the right side of the screen appears to be slightly boiling and bubbling, but no steam is emitted." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "df961eac-68df-518a-a002-a2bec03344bd", "filename": "P12_101_487_9b91496e4b9fdfed_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal anomaly: 0.1s later, the character in the scene did not perform the action of turning on the faucet, but water automatically flowed from the faucet.", "Anomaly in causality: Water continuously flows from the faucet into the pot for 0.1s-5s, but there is no trace of water in the pot." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "36579efa-4494-54f2-aeca-37b965fb136f", "filename": "P12_103_49_ff8d8f7695fcb82f_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly: The amount of minced meat in the plate suddenly increases from 1.1s to 1.2s." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "88c42862-6be3-5ca3-9617-90694efb5bcb", "filename": "P12_103_100_4198f5d926ee9096_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: 2.2s-3s, the person's right foot slightly twisted and deformed." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "5eb0b03e-499d-5d3b-9670-a42365f1a862", "filename": "P12_103_102_af48d5c95db28c1d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Anomaly in causality: From 1.1s to 1.2s, the flame on the gas stove is orange-yellow, but an orange-red flame appears above the pot." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "1e07b1b6-bc9a-5c21-bcdf-fe84bb80c243", "filename": "P12_103_113_a6e1b478b9c734b9_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time-related anomalies: 3s-3.1s, some of the minced meat in the pot disappeared out of thin air.", "Intermittent anomaly: Increased amount of minced meat within 4s-4.2s." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "706427c1-893a-5508-9b64-d7b599c131a2", "filename": "P12_104_60_a237e756c03f1dca_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Anomaly in causality: 1.1s-2s No water was poured into the sink, but a small puddle of water suddenly appeared in the lower right corner." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "be8e59bc-12c6-5e19-b901-762e5d58e0a2", "filename": "P12_104_98_dd5c467a08dfb56f_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: 3s-4.1s A rapid flow of water from a faucet impacts a spoon, but no water droplets splash." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "e38f08d6-9c00-5b03-a15a-4eedcd80379e", "filename": "P12_104_104_2a9af31fd33f1c18_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal anomaly: 0s-0.1s The person's hands did not move to open the paper, yet the paper was opened.", "Intermittent anomaly: 2.1s-2.2s, the shape of the paper in the person's hand suddenly increases in size." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "a299a72e-681f-59a7-b87c-b91e3ec2d00c", "filename": "P12_104_176_7e9a5a039e578ea5_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: From 0s to 5s, the water flow from the faucet is a rigid rectangular shape with stiff edges, and the water flow is extremely unnatural." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "29b92378-d549-553d-9523-d6c6c9de1b6e", "filename": "P22_101_122_d884d0ffe919cc1b_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: 3s-3.1s after the spoon leaves the person's hand, it shifts and shakes within the bowl without being subjected to any force.", "Time-series anomaly: 0s-1.2s, the number of cookies in the packaging bag suddenly decreases and then suddenly increases.", "Temporal anomaly: 4.1s-5s, the food in the character's hand gradually shrinks in size." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "694cf0c6-7a7e-586d-a156-ccdf48c57333", "filename": "P22_103_181_80344a1f4df9a36b_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal causal relationship: 1s-2.1s The person's hands did not make a coordinated movement to rotate the chopping board, but the chopping board was rotating." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "8c5e1daa-afb8-59c0-bedd-2bc33be96b2b", "filename": "P22_104_76_4ad85ac03498c2c2_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous temporal anomaly: The number of black granular food particles on the cutting board increases out of nowhere from 0s to 0.2s.", "Intermittent anomaly: The number of red foods on the character's left hand increases from 3s to 3.1s." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "25d0126f-8edd-5912-ab61-354709ca5b02", "filename": "P22_104_82_863a7ff5e8d531e5_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous temporal anomaly: The number of black granular objects on the cutting board increases out of nowhere within 1-1.2 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "12a4683b-c3fa-58a8-9faa-eb37bca5767f", "filename": "P22_106_85_32ace7ee674e2b1b_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality anomaly: The blue liquid in the bottle, squeezed out, turns into a transparent, watery liquid after 2s-3.2s." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "e18888f7-ebf5-5823-aafc-bba713144c33", "filename": "P04_109_138_02a21fca291edcdb_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: At 0.2 seconds, the knife only made one downward cut, yet the cucumber was divided into three pieces.", "Causality: At 0.2 seconds, without any cutting action, the cucumber was automatically divided into four pieces.", "Intermittent anomaly: 1.1s, the cucumber suddenly returned to its uncut state.", "Time continuity anomaly: 1.1s The cucumber piece on the character's left hand disappears into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "0e9ae261-6d44-509d-b31e-054f7bcf42a1", "filename": "P04_109_174_115912896c53c07e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time-related anomaly: 0.1s-0.3s, the number of cucumber strips the character is holding with their right hand suddenly decreases.", "Time-related anomalies: The number of carrot sticks suddenly increased from 2s to 2.1s." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "ce104645-c1c3-56ab-8874-fd20e87df860", "filename": "P04_109_312_b96e0912ddf0ea37_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time anomaly: 4.2s later, the broccoli plastic bag suddenly returned to its unopened state." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "23db10d7-2ebc-56ee-accf-24bcd10959c7", "filename": "P04_109_395_79e7cb2657a9191d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: The refrigerator door continuously opens and closes in a loop without any external force for 0-5 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "d6c23083-37fd-5a66-ac85-c5bb4a92d5e8", "filename": "P04_110_17_93a3f33512b01d99_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal anomaly: The broccoli on the right side of the pot shifted without being touched by the spatula.", "Time anomaly: The number of broccoli in the pot suddenly increased by 2.1 seconds.", "Abnormal physical behavior: 4.2s The broccoli around the spatula moved with the spatula without touching it." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "4aba4b73-cbba-595b-9e33-0cc031da4147", "filename": "P04_110_109_273fcf24cf795b96_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "f9003f63-afac-590d-bc63-96b04d946c48", "filename": "P04_110_200_7636b51b1aaa41e3_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: The character's right hand twists and fuses between 2.3s and 3.1s." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "febe3fd9-34af-56d3-bba1-4d39ed3c4d89", "filename": "P04_113_47_3f60158ce48b90ee_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "50fd9135-809f-51ab-b1ab-c9963a1dddfc", "filename": "P04_113_169_a288a06243c7df55_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Anomaly in causality: After 1.2 seconds, the person's right thumb did not touch the yellow liquid in the pot, but liquid remained on their finger." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "79f1054d-2f4d-5c9f-973a-9ad1a5da610d", "filename": "P04_113_224_a38fafa2d2d339a9_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent time anomaly: From 3.3s to 4.2s, a green object appears out of thin air in the character's right hand, and its shape gradually increases in size." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "ae65ced1-8bb6-5e40-ab20-0873f3b12507", "filename": "P04_113_407_99e898d45f6c866d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time-series anomaly: The number of water droplets on the blade suddenly decreased within 0.1 seconds.", "The timing of the anomaly was 1.3s-4.1s. Even after the knife was repeatedly wiped clean with a towel, water droplets continued to appear out of thin air on the knife." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "7dbdf1a9-fb8c-5cfd-9aba-006722ab9e87", "filename": "P04_113_434_d969a22e9e9c4020_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: Within 0.3 seconds, white particulate impurities on the left side of the black tabletop shifted without being subjected to any force.", "Time-related anomaly: The number of white impurities on the table surface increased out of nowhere within 0.3 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "3da5a577-f390-5517-b22f-2333fa388861", "filename": "P04_113_435_6b88c9662b559b97_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time-related anomaly: 2.1 seconds later, the dish soap on the spatula suddenly turned into powder and then disappeared.", "The timing was abnormal: dishwashing foam appeared out of nowhere between 3 and 4.9 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "bf274c86-0211-5b8c-a036-41ae544cc72f", "filename": "P04_113_507_901fff4dfa130ce1_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly in timing: Between 1.2s and 4.1s, scratches appear out of nowhere on the dough near the handle of the pan, and the length of the scratches continuously increases and decreases.", "Time anomaly: A scratch on the dough disappeared out of thin air in 4.1 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "4a851f2c-d062-500e-8fd1-602bbf657651", "filename": "P04_115_16_ef88130859b6edad_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: 0.1s A cleaning tool appears out of thin air in the character's hand.", "Time continuity anomaly: 0.1s The cleaning tool in the character's hand suddenly enlarges." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "44b051bd-cefa-562a-ba82-760af5515216", "filename": "P04_116_111_2121f5ef49de255a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent time anomaly: The handle did not rotate with the pot between 0s and 2s. Normally, the pot and handle are firmly fixed and should rotate together." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "c8160036-b7f6-539e-84e0-030291b0b5b6", "filename": "P04_116_142_bde378ff50125e6f_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: 3.1s-3.3s, the hot gas escaping from the container did not rise and diffuse freely, but instead moved to the right as a whole." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "bd1b6746-6e0c-5208-bd61-0d7a31eebce2", "filename": "P04_116_169_7730b25837e07dcb_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Anomaly in causality: A large amount of the object in the container was poured into the pot in 3.3 seconds, but the volume did not change." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "21d92a4d-6d18-58bd-bd7b-27b07c80c64f", "filename": "P04_117_48_daedd11cbff5cbe2_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: After 0.3 seconds, the knife began to wobble and tilt to the left, yet remained upright on the cutting board without any support." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "090745ef-4211-5995-a401-176d4a86132c", "filename": "P04_118_53_288c1f0339d229ca_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: After 2 seconds, the object in the character's hand disappears into thin air.", "Time continuity anomaly: A yellow sponge block appears out of thin air in the character's hand after 2.1 seconds.", "Abnormal physical behavior: 3.1s-5s, the sponge block floats in mid-air next to the character's arm without any gripping force." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "adc8d1bd-c3ce-5939-8757-9b49939b09e7", "filename": "P22_106_166_f7ecfdf62a6b2492_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality Anomaly: After 1-5 seconds, the water from the faucet continuously poured into the green cube and then vanished into thin air, without any water flowing into the sink at the edge of the object." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "befc8391-11a7-5a3f-b66c-bcd66a77c44f", "filename": "P22_107_8_e390bd8bf8575808_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Anomaly in causality: After the green cup was filled with water for 3 seconds, no water was observed overflowing from the top of the cup, but water was seen gradually spreading outwards around the cup." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "d8e1ae5b-8f9f-5ba3-aeb8-f0dc65a3bc7d", "filename": "P22_107_94_bb9c655f9b2bdf65_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: 2.2s-3.1s, the silver curtain-like film around the cabinet automatically curls inward and deforms without any force." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "7f611541-f78b-5857-8268-d115c5f32db6", "filename": "P22_109_160_12636db4d59215ee_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "6ca359cc-05d4-5c1b-af8d-6b980e799b44", "filename": "P22_109_246_357348604d1be43f_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: From 0s to 5s, the figure's hands are rubbing back and forth. The hands come into contact with the water and collide, generating an interaction force that should cause the water to splash or drop freely, but no trace of water splashing is found in the image." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "87a301aa-1199-5b98-ab7d-93ae162a3de7", "filename": "P22_109_485_767c8b9ecdf5bd33_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Anomaly in causality: No water droplets or other forces were found in the water tank during the 0s-5s interval, but a puddle of water in the tank was continuously sloshing back and forth." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "03947fdc-efaa-5bf2-989c-312272cf7955", "filename": "P22_109_621_e32bd585130cce20_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: In the 1-5 second frame, a light source casts a shadow of the person's body from behind, obscuring the light source. However, a clearer shadow of the person's arm appears in the frame, indicating that the two shadows do not originate from the same light source." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "31533737-21d1-5f57-93aa-e6fe6be0c3fd", "filename": "P22_109_674_936515c97d80787c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: After 2 seconds, the black object on the character's left hand disappears into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "1f66aa82-04aa-58a1-a3a4-581547aaf3d5", "filename": "P22_109_688_4220efa2e1144e5a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "f1a5ca6e-1233-5d0e-a327-bfe7a6a14e0f", "filename": "P22_111_137_1280401792f267d1_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time-series anomaly: The cup-shaped object on the edge of the sink changes shape continuously from 1 to 4 seconds until it turns into a plastic film.", "Time continuity anomaly: 4.1s-5s, the plastic film on the person's right hand gradually disappears." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "eca828fc-eeb3-5438-bdbe-917eb947e622", "filename": "P22_111_198_018e3da92f55a882_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time-related anomaly: From 0s to 1.1s, the number of tomato pieces cut increased out of nowhere.", "Abnormal causal relationship: The tomato on the upper right side of the cutting board wobbled from side to side without being subjected to any force for 2-3 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "0fa66f96-7173-5128-b9e7-a20d98aa3248", "filename": "P22_111_199_7c9405134902379b_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal anomaly: Within 0.2s-4s, the character only performed a few cutting actions, and the cut tomatoes automatically turned into fine cubes.", "Temporal anomaly: The number of tomatoes on the cutting board suddenly increased from 1.1s to 2.1s." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "d6db0cab-789b-5219-b52d-484b78cf9b71", "filename": "P22_111_302_c37fb49e1adf54b2_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly: 2.1s-4.1s. Black food on the cutting board is cut into cubes automatically, and their number continuously increases." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "dc7dda7d-5bad-51b9-9324-9db6cc907934", "filename": "P22_111_659_f772b7e878f03bef_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality anomaly: 0s-0.1s, the spatula did not touch the dough, yet the edges of the dough in the pan showed signs of being pushed up." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "a42e8a1f-936b-5c68-adf5-8581fd74b9ad", "filename": "P22_112_66_84635d2a3381122c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity Anomaly: 1s-1.1s A yellow brush appears out of thin air in the character's left hand.", "Time-related anomalies: 1-1.2 seconds later, the iron spoon and rag in the character's right hand disappear into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "69c75f6a-c0ce-55a3-a94f-e5434f21bbba", "filename": "P22_112_170_90ec8c1b9670e54f_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "623d8202-818e-5079-ae17-383970b682c0", "filename": "P22_113_201_5dc7138eeaf921cf_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal causal relationship: After the food in the pot was poured into the bowl 4-5 seconds later, there was no obvious increase in the amount of food in the bowl." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "078e8bd5-b873-5419-9d29-004f791768bb", "filename": "P22_115_109_e37d6fb701bf7c01_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "a6ebb8b5-c3b5-5250-9df9-3805c924fc83", "filename": "P22_116_87_da68427d2658c3d4_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time-series anomaly: The blue cup suddenly enlarges between 0s and 0.1s.", "Temporal anomaly: The blue cup suddenly turns into a white cup in 0.1 seconds.", "Abnormal causal relationship: The faucet suddenly started dispensing water automatically within 1.2 seconds without being turned on." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "b5f72741-ce6f-5eb1-af35-a37ee832eaf4", "filename": "P02_123_251_d2fcffd728703f9d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly in timing: After 4-4.2 seconds, the character is washing dishes, but the stain on the upper left side of the bowl appears and disappears intermittently, appearing and disappearing intermittently.", "Overall, the visual impression is unusual: in the 0s-5s interval of the video, the wooden spatula and spoon placed on the right are connected, while they should be independent." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "c94a7149-e528-55f2-85ad-278583efc6b3", "filename": "P02_129_150_595e20947c511dff_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall, the video shows an unusual feature: 1.1s-5s. The person's left foot only has one big toe, whereas normally there should be five toes." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "3dcf6c1e-b13d-5288-8145-80082c5ca8b5", "filename": "P02_129_174_87c72cf1a33b1a74_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent timing anomaly: Between 0.1s and 0.2s, when the person in the video picks up the knife and spoon from the cutting board, the fork disappears into thin air, followed by the spoon.", "Timing anomaly: In the 3.1s-4s interval of the video, when the person opens the cabinet door, the cabinet door suddenly changes from one door to two doors." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "e0e10593-5af4-599b-a218-dabd20511dd5", "filename": "P02_129_177_5f0f6a859867e84c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent timing anomaly: At 4.1 seconds, the box moves into the cabinet on its own without any external force in the video." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "029a135b-17fc-5e65-b012-16c8bfe7feed", "filename": "P02_130_93_8ca598927b7a8e87_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: Between 0s and 0.1s, the character picks up the blender lid and disappears into thin air.", "Time continuity anomaly: Between 3s and 3.1s, the mixer contains only cookies, but when the character reaches in, the white lid on the mixer pops out of thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "189c3518-3769-541a-a1e9-209c004291ab", "filename": "P02_130_127_ecc4bf8c5d21e844_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Interval anomaly: Between 1 and 1.1 seconds, the person in the video did not press the button on the blender, but the blender started spinning on its own.", "Time continuity anomaly: During the 0s-5s interval, the little finger and ring finger of the person's left hand show significant indentation." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "dd564078-bdfe-54a8-8472-ed83b54e8d39", "filename": "P02_131_8_85056be09c5edc9c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: During the 0s-0.1s interval, the character simply places their hand on the towel rack, yet the disheveled towel automatically folds up.", "Overall, the visual impression is off: during the 0s-5s interval, the person's motion of spinning the towel in the video is too smooth and lacks a sense of resistance." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "5b13de4d-cf41-5375-9459-24d09c89ab73", "filename": "P02_131_14_6004236093653ee0_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: In the video, between 2s and 2.2s, the person's hands are seen kneading something resembling dough, and the hands are seen to be pierced through the surface, violating the principle that solids are impermeable." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "b7bb654c-cf9b-5dbb-8b87-b76573752071", "filename": "P02_131_18_3dc04972743308ee_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "10dd8781-b404-5009-8508-ea2136a7147d", "filename": "P02_132_41_747bf80a4bea6e46_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: Between 2.1s and 4.1s, in the video, a person is cutting a bread-like object, and the knife clips through the person's left hand, violating the principle that solids are impermeable." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "f96de868-093b-5f0d-97dc-00dec46096b3", "filename": "P02_132_47_5e1684ba8ba72e19_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: Between 0s and 0.2s, the character did not cut the bread, and part of the bread had already split into two slices.", "Intermittent time anomaly: Between 1 and 1.1 seconds, the knife in the character's hand suddenly disappears and reappears, while at the same time, part of the bread magically splits into two pieces.", "Temporal continuity anomaly: Bread that was just cut within 4s-4.1s suddenly reverts to its original uncut shape." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "aa9b2400-205c-5eb2-ae59-7840bbe0c334", "filename": "P02_132_50_c00ad0131a3d748f_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "dbd9ee5b-b50b-5097-a9ca-ad7ef896f1c5", "filename": "P02_132_72_90ebc8379731a1ab_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Timing anomaly: In the video between 0s and 1s, the fragments above the aluminum foil are obscured by a hand and suddenly change shape, showing inconsistency.", "Intermittent anomaly: Between 1 and 1.1 seconds, there are no fragments in the character's hand, but a small piece of fragment suddenly falls out of thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "23a88771-35ea-5ee6-83ae-165393269b01", "filename": "P02_135_39_397941aa39c7e281_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Temporal continuity anomaly: In the 0s-0.2s interval, without any camera transition, a food resembling a potato suddenly transforms into a banana.", "Timing anomaly: In the period of 2s-2.1s, what was originally a large piece of banana was cut into a small piece, while the size of the banana pieces did not decrease.", "Interval anomaly: Between 3 and 3.2 seconds in the video, three slices of banana, which were originally cut on the cutting board, suddenly disappeared without any obstruction from the camera. Subsequently, the cut banana returned to its uncut shape." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "6a5b79cc-9aa9-5027-a3fa-e22e736d6ed2", "filename": "P02_135_92_b591e54d8957af6a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly: During the 0s-0.1s interval, only a small amount of sauce is applied to the character's knife, but when it is placed on the bread slice, the amount of sauce suddenly increases." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "2e86dfd0-f580-5875-8199-7f4419e2952c", "filename": "P02_135_103_1ca975adebe26b43_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Timing anomaly: Between 1s and 1.1s, the character dips in sauce twice, but the amount of sauce spread on the bread slice gradually decreases, which is inconsistent with the amount of sauce dipped.", "Timing anomaly: Between 2s and 2.1s, the character only spreads the sauce on the bread slice and does not touch the cup on the right, but the liquid in the cup is shaking for no apparent reason." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "e7037a85-623f-563d-8381-4b15d5d6274c", "filename": "P03_101_255_137b432bdb4caea6_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Timing anomaly: Between 0s and 0.1s, there is only a small amount of sauce on the bread slice and no sauce on the knife, but when the blade is applied, the amount of sauce suddenly increases." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "c845d57d-13ef-51cb-8ae8-14f4f5a0d2aa", "filename": "P03_101_271_f03ab98004d6118b_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Timing anomaly: In the 3s-3.1s interval, the person in the video only cuts a slice of cheese, but many more slices of cheese appear out of nowhere." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "844c3a20-8056-5cad-a945-9c33c36bf069", "filename": "P03_101_323_076fb2eafbf3f536_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The overall impression is abnormal: in the 0s-0.1s interval, the character simply pulls out a clothes rack, and then the light inexplicably changes from dark to bright." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "acb0a311-618e-5cbc-bb99-780dd3309673", "filename": "P04_119_24_f52d6da77154d972_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: 0.1s-0.2s The shape of the character's right hand distorts and merges.", "Time Continuity Anomaly: 1.2s A ring suddenly appears on the character's right ring finger." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "cf8891c4-0cdd-5ed1-9cb5-939f9f255834", "filename": "P04_119_101_5435628e9627b2ce_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal anomaly: 2.2 seconds later, the person's hands did not make a reasonable action of tearing open the packaging bag, yet the yellow packaging bag was torn open." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "45fbdabe-fe0b-50ce-8d65-c8c435232d3b", "filename": "P04_119_148_798120eb046ef868_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: 0.1s, the convex surface of the pot bottom suddenly becomes the concave surface of the pot.", "Abnormal physical behavior: The pot handle detached from the hand in 2.1 seconds, and the pot floated in the air without any supporting force.", "Abnormal physical behavior: The character's hand movements change at 3.2 seconds, but during the change, there is no reasonable grip between the hand and the pot handle." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "cccbbc77-ad06-530d-a176-9ca042504a08", "filename": "P04_119_230_f017c70d93dd0beb_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "36182799-4194-5c22-8260-abaa20cc9e01", "filename": "P04_119_253_97f03b97163b7b39_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: 3s-3.3s The character's left hand fingers are open, but the silver object in the hand is still floating beside the hand and moving with the hand.", "Cause and effect: From 0s to 5s, the character presses the induction cooker with their right hand. The function that lights up is inconsistent with the function pressed by the character, causing the induction cooker to malfunction." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "ca0b2677-1515-514b-bdf3-5976fb4a2cbd", "filename": "P04_119_265_eadce31310d52518_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time-related anomalies: At 3.2 seconds, liquid suddenly appeared out of thin air in the glass (the person had already poured all the liquid from the glass into the pot 3.2 seconds earlier)." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "22f0785c-b3da-56cb-96e8-a516529c4160", "filename": "P04_120_156_747894580b0bcae5_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: 0.1s The person's right hand fingers are in an open position, there is no reasonable grip force relationship between them and the towel, the towel is in a suspended state and moves with the hand." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "383003d6-09f5-5158-b81c-8c7510a2c655", "filename": "P04_120_222_1922ee417f3ab578_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Anomaly in causality: From 0.2s to 2.1s, the steel wool only came into contact with a small area of the cutting board, but most of the cutting board gradually changed from dry to wet.", "Time continuity anomaly: The left toes of the character have modeling defects and are incomplete between 1.9s and 4.1s." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "a8fbc757-fd78-54be-9031-14c25bf19729", "filename": "P04_120_239_cdc8caf466c82bdc_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: 0.3s-4.1s, the person's left index finger clips through the glass container, and the finger appears folded and twisted." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "146369d2-a1fa-5926-ad9d-c8e546602583", "filename": "P04_120_340_b39d486c8d577a3e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time anomaly: 1.3s later, the black tube on the thermometer on the character's left hand suddenly turns white." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "a2c8b8b8-e6a6-5b08-903d-8e6cea004338", "filename": "P04_120_355_fa50a2ce3e7467c7_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Anomaly in causality: From 1.1s to 4.3s, the character's stirring motion is intermittent and slow, but the white liquid in the pot is rotating at a relatively fast speed." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "4daae02b-10eb-57da-aacd-d7ba57543a2f", "filename": "P04_120_369_ae26d5efffb4516c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "99c55996-5a06-5d29-9a24-adbc58d356b0", "filename": "P04_121_13_5828d614e1f4c9bb_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality anomaly: From 0.2s to 1.1s, the character only performed one cutting action, but multiple small pieces appeared at the point where the pale yellow blocky food in the pot was cut." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "a8d7e67f-22b4-57cd-bd73-d8a5b8f5f280", "filename": "P04_121_27_172946becd329d55_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time anomaly: 0.1s, the hilt of the sword in the character's hand suddenly disappears, leaving only the blade." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "d5f84e77-539e-5db4-badf-c56350622b2d", "filename": "P04_121_104_7ac78d4a80d6c373_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall, the feeling was unusual: from 0 to 5 seconds, the cutting board felt like it was one with my left hand or strongly glued to it. The wiping motion on the cutting board was large and fast, but the cutting board didn't wobble at all." ], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "7221fdda-65da-5009-9b65-c18be82f553f", "filename": "P04_121_188_d8516de605d0766f_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Image anomaly: 0.1s-4.2s of continuous, intense screen flickering and shaking." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "5c85531e-c801-55d0-b656-4772037c67d3", "filename": "P04_121_272_ad6f7cb0a063c58a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Anomaly in causality: A large amount of water continuously flowed into the glass container during the period of 0.1s-5s, but the amount of water in the container did not increase." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "8bff5dbc-174e-557d-b4ad-acd949c33e5b", "filename": "P04_121_407_392d5ae6ebdd4f4c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: 0.1 seconds ago, the character's left hand became distorted and the screen jumped.", "Abnormal physical behavior: One side of the glove suddenly curls up without any external force within 1.5s-2.3s." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "488abd91-4719-544e-a0d3-106ef6bbc49c", "filename": "P04_121_415_ecdc655cd3eda16c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly: 0.1s-0.2s, the towel in the person's hand suddenly changes from grayish-white to green." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "f3d8ff03-5df4-5f90-bc35-08de6095e67e", "filename": "P04_121_440_8ef651412f6651ba_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: 3.1 seconds later, a person holds a glass bowl almost vertically and pours the liquid from the bowl into a pot, but the object in the bowl does not tilt or fall off." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "f96958ba-289c-516e-a9b6-175d1961939e", "filename": "P04_121_470_aa020cf1caa760d9_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent Time Anomaly: 2.1s-3s The volume of the dough in the character's hand increases, and the shape of the dough changes even without being grasped or subjected to force." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "1dcefa3b-e9a1-5f52-a44b-3bc14054f910", "filename": "P04_121_505_015fcf7a4374bf29_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "f999ffe7-8c53-5259-905c-ac211aaa070d", "filename": "P04_121_530_d8e3f67d7025fba3_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: Within 0.1s-0.2s, the black scissors automatically teleport to the character's left hand without any force applied.", "Abnormal physical behavior: From 0.3s to 1.2s, the black knife and blue scissors on the character's right hand clip through and merge.", "Intermittent anomaly: 4.3 seconds later, the red spoon, knife, and scissors in the drawer suddenly twisted." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "0136fe28-768c-537c-8afa-a26663b8e8b8", "filename": "P04_121_566_652097912f4e954f_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: Within 0.1s-4s, the yellow liquid in the pot reaches a boiling state upon heating, but only the edge of the pot near the spatula shows boiling and bubbling, while the liquid near the handle sways up and down as a whole, without natural boiling." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "c8794d74-5345-58e4-b2c6-bb7cf3e1c161", "filename": "P04_121_571_ca9df2f6ffdbed71_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: If the dough is not squeezed or kneaded for 0.1s-0.2s, the wrinkles will automatically become smooth.", "Time continuity anomaly: 3.2s - the dough suddenly becomes smooth after the initial wrinkles have appeared." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "65b6494d-34f1-5c88-9e02-36721e3956f4", "filename": "P06_101_39_57e9b429eb0a763b_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent time anomaly: The phenomenon of objects on the cutting board repeatedly shifting automatically within 2.2s-3s.", "Intermittent anomaly: 4.3 seconds later, the shape of the food on the left half of the cutting board suddenly changed from small to large." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "5e8e6a8c-6f52-5685-8bb7-d88650725dc7", "filename": "P06_101_101_5c8057486ecf0a0c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous temporal anomaly: The number of garlic cloves on the cutting board suddenly increases within 1-1.2 seconds.", "Time-related anomaly: The garlic cloves next to the cutting board suddenly became smaller in shape after 3.1 seconds.", "Time anomaly: 3.2s-4s garlic cloves on the cutting board suddenly merged into one clove." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "6fcf0280-fef3-5898-aca8-c078817721ac", "filename": "P06_101_107_3cac1f3beca0ff34_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "24ddfde5-5237-548f-9e3a-d0836f65b9d6", "filename": "P06_101_134_a8687dba41c55a29_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time-related anomalies: At 3 seconds, the chopping board in the character's left hand suddenly disappears into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "dfd990c4-861a-526a-aa00-f8053c00fde2", "filename": "P06_101_177_cc8321f225e6848e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "776c33fe-93f8-5870-a3ae-89c0eaf00083", "filename": "P06_101_389_048468e6c66a6d79_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time anomaly: From 2.2s to 3.2s, food residue on the countertop shifts automatically and its quantity increases out of nowhere." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "f7e60891-f64c-5922-9c9f-aff469451cc8", "filename": "P06_101_417_14f706526aa67c74_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: Within 3-3.1 seconds, the cutting board detaches from the person's left hand, automatically suspends itself under the faucet without support, and automatically rotates to change direction." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "9ccdb3dc-6b5f-551a-a74a-de4d988309a3", "filename": "P06_102_39_7739e47eee44a4fe_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: 0.2s, the color of the object in the character's hand suddenly changes from yellow to bluish-white.", "Time-related anomalies: At 2 seconds, the color of the packaging bag in the person's hand suddenly changes from half yellow to half blue-white.", "Time-series anomaly: A blue pattern suddenly appears on the yellow packaging bag after 4.1 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "f7a9d594-cdc9-538c-b086-8f858a710a4a", "filename": "P06_102_97_f250ba16844f2aba_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent time anomaly: 1.1s-1.2s The knife on the character's right hand disappears into thin air and then suddenly reappears." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "25dfcefc-6e6a-526d-9522-8108abf1518e", "filename": "P06_102_118_0a09355f5f7fedc7_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: Within 0.2s-1s, the white bowl on the table moved automatically to the right without being subjected to any force.", "Time-related anomalies: At 2 seconds, a ring of white plastic appeared out of nowhere on the transparent plastic wrap roll." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "1dd690ab-bc5a-5a34-aa64-7b5c3c70e2b9", "filename": "P06_102_119_b633ab4ada7683e0_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "efe1046f-1d10-51c8-a3c9-72deedfd6bfe", "filename": "P06_103_171_17ed61e60dd55888_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time-related anomalies: The transparent plastic packaging bag, which was torn open 4.1s-5s, disappeared into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "01a09f7c-02b6-56ad-8b32-af470fa1f3c9", "filename": "P06_106_45_3a50c019b97eec5c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Anomaly in causality: From 0.2s to 5s, a yellow, blocky solid was continuously shaved into the bowl, but the shape of the yellow solid in the hand remained unchanged." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "499645f7-8148-5802-8c5a-d67e5b00f93e", "filename": "P06_108_0_5a1eaacd9e5b318b_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal anomaly: 0s-0.1s The person's hand did not touch the refrigerator, yet the refrigerator appeared to be open." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "13edd51f-1e8b-5e3b-9b5a-82488a765cd4", "filename": "P06_108_5_161ff4ec96c0d9f0_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal anomaly: 2.2s-3s before the character's hand touches the middle button, the button has already begun to rotate slightly." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "a873f5e0-1612-5dad-91ae-92e17145cead", "filename": "P03_109_244_7d988ea8da9cab00_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 1s-1.2s. The water in the tank suddenly disappears, and the tank and its surroundings become distorted. The black scissors in the person's hand turn dark blue. A white object appears on the floor beneath the right foot.", "The duration is continuous: 2.1s-2.2s, during which the character's shoe changes from one shoe splitting in half to having two toes.", "Continuous duration: 1.2 seconds; the person's right foot in the video is transparent.", "Time continuity: After 2 seconds, the transparent right foot transforms into a foot wearing off-white shoes and merges with the left foot.", "Overall intuition: 0s-3.1s, the character's hand holding scissors, the handshake posture is strange and distorted." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "0390dc34-f858-5ebb-ad29-2fdf8ab80fa4", "filename": "P03_109_291_6b76ce53b04d2263_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: 0s-1.3s, the water basin in the tank deforms.", "Time continuity: At 5 seconds, the messy pile of bowls and basins next to the sink in the video disappears out of thin air, and a black object appears.", "Overall intuition: 1.1s-4.2s, the heating coils on the induction cooker in the video are not neatly arranged. In reality, the heating coils are neatly arranged." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "169df6e1-860b-5854-a7c9-5075fd46304f", "filename": "P03_109_292_dc435ca3dce51838_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 0.2s-3s, the size and shape of the heating coils on the induction cooker in the video are inconsistent. In reality, the size and shape of the heating coils should be consistent." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "92d36f07-2048-5d90-b186-f4aa57a60cb3", "filename": "P03_109_318_24bf90fdcacc85f9_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "4886d7d3-5f34-55f1-b994-af2a0198088a", "filename": "P03_109_321_bd3f45ea44ea64fe_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: 0s-4.1s, in the video, there is only a small piece of butter on the knife, but when spreading butter on the bread, the amount of butter spread on the bread is much more than that on the knife." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "3961ed41-2c65-5a60-a217-1b8dae60585b", "filename": "P03_109_342_fc9925db0f44f975_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous timing: 3.2s-4.1s. In the video, when cutting butter, knife marks appear on areas of the butter that were not cut by the knife.", "Overall intuition: 0s-5s, the force used when cutting the butter in the video was too great. Butter is a relatively soft substance, and you don't need to use that much force when cutting butter in reality." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "5361717c-c551-5515-a502-1ff9106430c1", "filename": "P03_109_357_22e8f4e5bcc70a75_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The time interval is 0s-0.1s. Suddenly, a white seal appears on the plastic bag in the hand.", "In the continuous time frame of 2.2s-3s, when the hand is tearing the plastic bag in the video, a transparent plastic bag appears out of thin air on the left side.", "The duration is continuous: 3s-4.1s. The white seal above the plastic bag in the right hand shrinks and then disappears." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "d216ce23-602e-57d8-97a9-88e8caa87787", "filename": "P03_109_372_f9a0547118282ba2_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 0s-3.1s, the video shows too much force being used when cutting soft bread, but in reality, soft bread only needs to be cut gently." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "8b91777c-269e-5bbd-82b0-4da392726ed1", "filename": "P03_112_112_78e5231e10c0e671_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 0s-2.2s, the plastic bag in the character's hand is constantly deforming, and the opening of the plastic bag switches back and forth between open and closed." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "d348b905-745a-50cc-8971-a995c92d135f", "filename": "P03_112_150_f35dc439e8ff6b81_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: 0s-5s, in the video, no shadow appears on the ground when the person is mopping, only a bright spot of light. In reality, under strong light, there will be a shadow of a person on the ground." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "202f92f4-330f-59a4-8337-9bf633763bfa", "filename": "P03_113_48_ecc89f1395c7b22d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "2239fb18-0a31-562c-89c3-cb548d76bf27", "filename": "P03_117_218_16502d99e2351f4f_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: 1s-1.2s, more butter on the knife, less when spread on the bread, and the butter on the bread becomes lighter in color." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "ea674e7b-eb9d-5742-b92e-882abe32ddff", "filename": "P03_117_236_20c0ee7a59e22c6c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 0s-5s. In the video, the knife is placed close to the hand holding the butter when cutting it. In reality, people keep the knife away from their hands when cutting things to avoid cutting themselves." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "e3b34d94-f71c-553f-8719-537027c79632", "filename": "P03_117_247_9b2e82665519fd65_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 0s-2.2s, the item in the character's hand suddenly shrinks.", "Time interval: 2.2s-3s, the torn plastic bag disappears into thin air.", "Time duration: 3.2s-4s, the item in hand is wrapped in a transparent plastic bag out of thin air.", "The duration is continuous: 4.1s-5s. The packaging bag of the item in hand changes from transparent packaging to white plastic packaging." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "bde82650-61ff-56a0-ac39-8f222adda8cb", "filename": "P03_119_10_2f37a565f30b0627_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 5 seconds, the character's right hand takes an odd shape, with the two fingers sticking together and merging." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "fcd3be63-a1e4-55c5-99d5-1d1c58ee9a09", "filename": "P03_119_148_b56cbcb28e4d89b6_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "5b3e5131-213f-5552-af2a-074f0d90379f", "filename": "P03_120_3_7c85cff5a25ef5bf_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The duration is continuous: 4.1s-5s. The brownish-red towel on the towel rack disappears, and a black spoon is placed on the clip." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "cc7e5612-a2f0-52c4-b82f-572591ab033f", "filename": "P03_120_93_c77a764d013797e9_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "08246394-33a7-5d12-9bb0-9de7234dbe2f", "filename": "P03_120_232_4689168e3f215e1b_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time interval: 0.2s-1s. A yellow object that fell into the basin suddenly shattered into several pieces." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "c2db5816-589a-5e64-b544-75f2566b95ee", "filename": "P03_122_4_c46b1028cb79c033_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 0s-0.2s and 4s-5s, the toes in the video are flat, but in reality, when people wear socks, they have a curve, not a flat one." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "95825df1-eafc-5f27-8872-f579eab185e0", "filename": "P22_117_137_200474f5df4ea63a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The black spoon in the character's hand grows larger between 0.2s and 1.1s.", "The time interval is 2.1s-2.2s. The two objects in the left hand merge and then disappear into thin air.", "Time duration: 4.1s, the stick-shaped object next to the left hand disappears into thin air.", "The duration is continuous: 4.1s-4.2s, and part of the barbed wire above the left hand disappears out of thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "0ba4c3bd-8a99-5499-bfb7-74e7b7a8d42b", "filename": "P22_117_220_cd0d742ed1773ac4_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: From 0s to 4.2s, the knife was placed close to the hand holding the food when cutting it. The video shows the food being cut in one stroke, as if sawing, but the food appears to be in multiple pieces. In reality, people hold the knife further away from their hand when cutting vegetables to avoid injury. Furthermore, the cutting method is an up-and-down cut, not a pulling motion.", "Continuous time: 0s-4.2s. The smooth black object that was initially cut in the video becomes a jagged object after being cut." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "a3f4b3d9-1472-53fa-b1b9-4f4bcc0f666a", "filename": "P22_117_390_2778ae454f7fad4a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The time is continuous: 0s-0.2s, and the pattern of the towel in my hand keeps changing.", "Physical behavior: 0.1s, the finger and the towel show a clipping phenomenon.", "Time continuity: At 2.2s, the fingers of the character's left hand become stuck together and fused, and there is no hand shape." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "d9425292-71bd-5cac-a48c-dc10c9a5d00b", "filename": "P23_101_151_31ed65929ff2bce6_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The duration is continuous: 0s-0.2s, during which the color of the character's left hand becomes lighter." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "b40017b0-e084-5b14-999e-326a0eb241a9", "filename": "P23_102_9_a2d324e5afafff26_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: at 0.1s, the foam floating in the pot turns into rice grains.", "Continuous time: After 4 seconds, the iron handle on the pot changes from silver to black and becomes larger.", "Overall intuition: 3.2s-4s, in the video, the two handles on the pot are different shapes and sizes, and they are not in symmetrical positions on the pot. In reality, the two handles on the pot are symmetrically positioned and are the same shape and size." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "af89942d-b39f-5dcd-87b6-cda6450eb9a8", "filename": "P23_102_13_29e622adb88f1bb3_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous duration: 2.2s-5s, smoke appears out of thin air above the pot.", "Overall intuition: 4.2s-5s. In the video, the pot is tilted sharply downwards while water is being poured in, yet there are still many beans inside. In reality, when water is poured in at such a steep tilt, only a small portion of the contents of the pot would remain." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "badd9894-d557-538b-93d5-af5c42cb3538", "filename": "P23_102_108_189bf359ac960c98_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: 2s-4.1s. In the video, when the knife is used to cut the onion, onion slices are cut off under the cutting board, but the onion is still intact and the onion skin turns yellow." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "3c0dbd1d-bafa-5bbf-b595-de04d66a3734", "filename": "P23_102_253_e8f8fd0bff18d300_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 0s-5s, continuous flickering occurs in the video footage.", "Time continuity: At 4.1 seconds, the yellow towel by the sink and the yellow towel in the person's hand merge into one piece.", "Continuous time: At 3.2 seconds, the towel in the character's hand and fingers twist together." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "bc217b29-acbd-5fdf-b081-d9581f8c230a", "filename": "P23_102_274_f694e62c34037339_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: The knife in the character's hand grows larger at 0.1s.", "Time continuity: The shape of the garlic in the character's hand changes at 0.2 seconds.", "Time continuity: At 1.2 seconds, the garlic that the character cut off disappears into thin air.", "Time continuity: At 2.1 seconds, a piece of garlic appears out of thin air at the tip of the knife.", "Time continuity: After 3 seconds, a piece of garlic appears out of thin air at the tip of the knife, and the garlic under the knife disappears out of thin air.", "Time continuity: At 3.1 seconds, the garlic cloves on the edge of the cutting board disappeared into thin air.", "The duration is continuous: 4s-4.1s. During this time, the shape of the character's fingers changes, and garlic appears out of thin air on the tip of the knife.", "Continuous time: 4.3 seconds. Two pieces of garlic cut off merge into one." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "599a5af0-4690-5128-9cad-979f23450d65", "filename": "P23_102_364_ff143eed27b1114e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 0s-5s. In the video, the knife is placed close to the hand holding the garlic when cutting it. In reality, people keep the knife away from their hands when cutting things to avoid cutting themselves." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "db8b458c-bb84-5e1f-9423-85cd95f5c34f", "filename": "P23_102_378_db33e4ad74844e8d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: 0.1s-1s, the stove in the video moves horizontally to the wall and merges with the table next to the wall without being subjected to any force, resulting in a clipping phenomenon." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "55832ece-06a3-584a-9849-a9eee7f7cbed", "filename": "P25_101_57_f9b7a9f4a0e93071_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "63ef3046-5965-58ca-8ad1-0715aa3c28f5", "filename": "P25_101_95_3cb1c063da24b3ba_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The time interval is 4s-4.1s. The wrinkles on the paper in your hand merge and become a piece of paper without wrinkles." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "0e56e100-97bc-54ae-8ee3-1e438ca9cdb4", "filename": "P25_102_1_826a5b5a5d5742f4_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: The white object on the edge of the pot disappeared at 0.2s.", "Overall intuition: A flickering phenomenon appeared on the lower pot handle at 0.3 seconds.", "Time continuity: At 3.2 seconds, the silver ring on the handle of the pot in my hand widens.", "Time duration: 4s-4.2s, the pot handle in the character's right hand disappears." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "855fbd3c-aa1b-55f3-8b9b-00c387529d61", "filename": "P25_103_52_4b763c7d975a6f43_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: The shape of the food being flipped changes at 2.1 seconds.", "Time Continuity: The fork in your hand disappears after 5 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "54efa557-9c70-5577-a7fe-b3323bd1f14a", "filename": "P25_104_104_84e28be07a226329_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: 4.1s-4.3s. As the character picks up the spoon, the spoon twists and deforms, eventually shrinking.", "Physical behavior: In 4.1s-4.2s, the spoon floats up and lands in the person's hand without being subjected to any force." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "9f626ec5-fc94-52dc-a530-adf06fe64695", "filename": "P25_104_127_c9d4950bd9c06187_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "464404fa-f3e8-5799-8224-730f33eedb6e", "filename": "P25_104_241_618a2443c391da74_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The time is continuous; the spoon on the square paper gets bigger after 1 second.", "Physical behavior: 3s-4.1s, the drawer in the video passes under the cabinet on the left and under the cabinet on the right. This is a clipping phenomenon." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "604c315d-3fda-59df-83be-ef1a86e5b26b", "filename": "P25_106_70_0546033caf381f67_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: The spoon in the character's hand bends after 5 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "ebc0576f-6f1e-576b-a034-829d06196856", "filename": "P35_108_221_9903ef1446045098_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: At 3 seconds, a clipping phenomenon occurred between the steel fork in the hand and the hand in the video." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "29d051b2-284c-5302-9753-b94d767e84e2", "filename": "P35_108_267_4a97ba77d70a7170_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: At 2.2 seconds, a clipping phenomenon occurred between the cup being washed and the hand in the video." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "e017375c-4842-5985-8d3c-f8aa1c6ff57f", "filename": "P35_108_402_8e67d318695c52e0_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: After 2 seconds, water stains can be seen appearing on the left side of the pool, but they disappear quickly without any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "e7a73668-370e-5c55-a994-80d1ca84f30c", "filename": "P35_108_408_5b13ed13cd7231a5_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: The image flickers and changes continuously from 0.2 seconds until the end of the video, and the video shakes." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "282d4688-480a-513e-b3b6-ab8469f6cd22", "filename": "P35_108_516_88b84e77f20fe794_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: 0.1-0.2s, in the video, the bowl being washed is not being emptied of its water, but the amount of water in the bowl is decreasing significantly." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "05bfd1f4-4bd3-56e3-84d2-ece55ded08fd", "filename": "P35_108_582_4f78440b10a95d19_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "42049b4f-f387-54d8-9dce-06e23c24d246", "filename": "P35_108_588_9e46eca0cb81830d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: In the 0-5s video, the faucet is in the exact center of the pool, but the water only splashes onto the left and right sides of the pool." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "79dc3e69-0c21-532a-8c52-4cc09f148e4d", "filename": "P35_108_632_5470acc36afb477e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: At 0.2s, an object that was originally a single entity suddenly splits into two." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "d7210aa7-f564-5cfd-911f-dfa12b11a659", "filename": "P35_109_148_e074d90f3322b1cd_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "5e3faebc-bf4b-5c1c-94b6-781f78addf89", "filename": "P37_101_1_349d01ecc266866f_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 2.1 seconds, the person's fingers in the video undergo a sudden change; the three middle fingers of the hand suddenly shrink and stick together." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "17a753f9-ed51-5cdc-8102-5b732c266990", "filename": "P37_101_87_a0a5f1e554cde13f_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 0-5 seconds, the person in the video behaves strangely, operating on the stove in the video, but the stove does not change in any way." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "75f7f45b-46d5-5516-a51d-1e159c664a4c", "filename": "P37_101_200_e3b8426b372835b8_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous anomaly: At 1.2 seconds, the red food being processed suddenly turned into yellowish-white garlic paste." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "9f27c2ab-f785-5d82-80fa-f3dc73c6dc43", "filename": "P37_101_216_6efbe5e55f430595_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous anomaly: At 2 seconds, the person in the video is chopping small, round garlic cloves when suddenly a long, thin object appears." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "860c36de-821e-5f7f-bd50-e5c2d5346875", "filename": "P37_101_228_f2325d5d478202f1_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: At 4.2 seconds in the video, the garlic was chopped into uniform small pieces with just one cut." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "bdb81f8f-5fe2-5b88-ad01-e9212895b188", "filename": "P37_101_257_61f23b78389a5a06_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "33b52623-7bcb-5a39-bae5-401f5ff78a4b", "filename": "P37_101_269_b4f6e76f42c0fc85_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: At 1.1 seconds, the skin of the chicken leg in the video automatically tore open without any external force, even though the person's hand did not touch it." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "796175bd-f393-536f-809b-05489185b57c", "filename": "P37_101_273_be6086e5555bb29d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 2.3 seconds, the chicken leg that was originally in my hand turned into two when it was put into the pot." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "fe17098f-e6ec-58d1-9724-8193d79a829f", "filename": "P37_101_278_77bd38db4d98d112_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality: At 4.2 seconds, you can see the person in the video tearing a piece of chicken skin off the chicken leg, but the chicken leg itself remains intact." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "84adb664-32ce-5c75-b26a-77345a233ac4", "filename": "P37_101_288_4f320640fbc25fd8_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 2.2 seconds ago, a person in the video tore a piece of chicken off a chicken leg, but in the next shot, the meat on the chicken leg returned to its original shape." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "d4d794c2-417b-5e45-b0c5-e2d2ccade87f", "filename": "P37_101_304_35ac2c74987a7123_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "4cff559a-90a6-5023-9350-4c2eebae7ab9", "filename": "P30_101_107_ac583877b61829d1_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: At 2.25s, the yellow object clipped through the lens." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "b6bbd6a3-d2b5-5fc6-8703-59398eadcae3", "filename": "P30_104_73_b7b375be4b1c1bc5_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "867ea08d-4fad-5382-ac08-790c8296ebd0", "filename": "P30_104_88_3059c3a3f6579090_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time sequence: Before 2.08 seconds, there was nothing in the middle of the white object being cleaned, but then a circular white object appeared out of thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "1ec0c35e-000d-52c9-85bb-cc29d4b5a2fe", "filename": "P30_104_117_448392e2c5e8cc8d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "c563faa9-bb6a-5014-a33e-47528ea477e4", "filename": "P30_104_123_2558b753a121f4b6_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: 2.1 seconds ago, the upper part of the cup was sealed, but then the seal on the cup disappeared out of thin air.", "Physical behavior: At 2.1 seconds, the cup deformed without any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "70d89d39-53c6-5e2b-a550-2a35c7461afc", "filename": "P30_104_136_bb9070f93f1559c4_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 2.1 seconds, the object on the left suddenly transforms into a door.", "The timing is continuous: at 3.1 seconds, the person in the video places the towel used to wipe the apple on the left side and the towel disappears from the video, but at 4.1 seconds, the towel reappears in the video." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "6e410098-26ee-57d9-bfb8-3473600f390d", "filename": "P30_107_96_e4fb6c0295cad84e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 0s-5s, the shape of the towel used to wipe the plate in the video did not change no matter how it was wiped, but in reality, towels are soft and their shape is easily changed." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "1b7b3093-25df-5edf-92de-3f5c937f4325", "filename": "P30_107_214_221a127e894ab1ce_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: In 1.1 seconds, without any external force, the knife in the video moved to the right side.", "Causal relationship: At 2.26s, the video shows that there are very few carrots left on the cutting board, but after 4s, there are more carrots left on the cutting board." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "f39e7a9d-48f8-531b-bef0-0d060f393610", "filename": "P30_107_320_c2211d4ace034367_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 1.1s, the vegetables on the cutting board suddenly split into two." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "85952823-d57e-5e61-8263-a9f2fcd485ec", "filename": "P30_107_341_ffb2544226e4f69e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality: 2.2s, the video shows only a small piece of food being cut, but a lot of food appears on the cutting board." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "e9bc1229-8d7a-582e-9271-d2726db53161", "filename": "P30_107_362_fb7ac62b0bef3de7_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality: 2 seconds, the person in the video cuts food with a knife but the food does not change at all." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "3e2fad7e-da77-5f48-b277-7c772c9b13fc", "filename": "P30_107_500_a33b20b358461f0a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "64c7ebcd-cffc-56bb-bfee-51d8c3c0dcfd", "filename": "P30_107_533_06cd32cfe20f540c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality: 0.1s, in the video, the person wipes the knife with a towel; their hand does not rotate, but the knife does." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "be595cc4-06e9-5e9d-b4a7-83cc3df7c390", "filename": "P30_107_563_1dc3d605296508f5_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: At 2.1 seconds, the person in the video wipes the bubbles in the water with a towel, but the bubbles in the water do not change." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "d7b002b9-ace2-523d-a580-ea06fc232100", "filename": "P30_107_623_8cded94b40c0238d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "2dcce678-b31d-5a92-9e32-588fbf5934f0", "filename": "P30_107_663_16eaee91c8d8e8d6_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "3084fabb-606d-5cf7-8cee-0fe9072f8f96", "filename": "P30_107_691_8884d85c528480a3_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: Before 2.2 seconds, only one person can be seen from the reflective mirror, but at 2.2 seconds, a third hand appears in the video." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "c72d8732-8d19-58c6-9d7c-133a0842a426", "filename": "P30_107_715_7dbe8d0d68775444_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time sequence: At the beginning of the video, a rectangular object can be seen in the bowl, but it disappears after 0.1 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "5bd9d9db-a783-5865-bc53-e714b972732d", "filename": "P25_106_112_f17182772fcb9436_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "abeca1cc-cb00-580a-8749-d7d77ff7bba5", "filename": "P25_106_118_30be49c9432717e6_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: 0s-1.1 means that an extra table and two plates appear next to the left arm in the video." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "253259a0-c418-5809-b202-29023562c960", "filename": "P25_106_129_542975dabdc19076_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: 0.2s-1s, the pot flies into the character's hands without being subjected to any force.", "The timing is continuous: 1 second to 1.1 seconds. The spoon poured into the egg mixture disappears, and a spoon handle appears leaning against the side of the pot. In reality, the spoon should be poured into the pot along with the egg mixture, and it should be poured into the bottom of the pot, not leaning against the side.", "Physical behavior: The egg mixture in the pot suddenly cooked after 2 seconds, which was too fast." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "75084e2d-e79d-5842-98b2-47a54cd84a98", "filename": "P25_107_52_673e028382201e6d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "34886b95-91ee-52e8-9257-cf0e6e406ebc", "filename": "P25_107_189_23cc153118e85013_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: At 0.2s, the paper used to wipe the pot suddenly changed from an unfolded state to a folded state without being folded." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "d97f54f7-7572-5ad2-848d-96b68d232777", "filename": "P25_107_360_8ca2b90b23db7e8d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "42740f90-5046-53b0-9f6a-378b344e7ee5", "filename": "P25_107_367_a23cf541cb41672c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: The shape of the food picked up by the fork changes at 1.1 seconds.", "Physical behavior: At 2.2s, the fork did not hit the food, but one side of the food was upright. The food in the video is soft and would not stand upright without force.", "Time continuity: After 4 seconds, the food that the fork is picking up becomes two pieces." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "5cb4a749-79fe-587e-b58d-6e08c8993f67", "filename": "P25_107_373_c7e58caf0b7a9506_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: 2.1s-3s. In the video, the food was flipped with a fork but the action of flipping it was not completed. However, the original front of the food became larger and mushy." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "b0deb3f8-bfe9-54ae-a890-cc7a50bca02e", "filename": "P25_107_445_3d6e5082eeab0922_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: The flame on the stove next to the pot went out at 4.1 seconds.", "Causal relationship: From 0.3s to 5s, the tap was on the whole time, but the water level in the pot below the tap did not rise.", "Time interval: 4-5 seconds, a small melon suddenly appears out of nowhere in the plate." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "3a5ce531-a80c-513f-bec7-c2f0dc72923d", "filename": "P25_107_509_bff83b3812cbd19e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The duration is continuous: 0s-0.1s, during which the character's left hand twists and deforms.", "Time continuity: 0.5s-1s A plate of food appears out of thin air in the character's hand.", "Overall intuition: 2.1s-5s, in the video, the water from the faucet flows out from the middle of the pipe, while in reality, the water from the faucet flows out from the top outlet." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "c1b7bef8-09ce-57d8-be99-8427c64f48a5", "filename": "P26_103_23_c3e7e067d3798760_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: 0s-0.1s, the transparent brown plate in hand turns into a reddish-brown cuboid object.", "Time Continuity: 0.2s-1.1s. The brownish-red cuboid merges with the fork, the hand becomes distorted, and the brownish-red cuboid disappears, leaving a blurry white object in the character's hand. The blurry white object moves from the hand to the bottom of the sink, where it transforms into a teacup.", "Continuous time: The white teacup turns into a transparent glass cup at 2.2 seconds.", "The duration is continuous: 3.2s-4.1s, during which the glass in my hand turns into a brownish-red object." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "9b6bfa15-d500-5b1d-807c-f1facae61a35", "filename": "P26_103_33_dc2f5d4393ba16a2_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time interval: 0.1s-1s, several white flower patterns appear out of thin air on the brown transparent plate.", "Time continuity: 0s-5s. The character's right hand only has four fingers." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "393ce2a9-eb8f-510d-b7c5-aa4dabc2e547", "filename": "P26_103_109_c7572f6508668a0a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "7726770a-401b-5adc-870b-0df322b69743", "filename": "P26_104_61_dc344a6fdc53c62e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: 0.1s, many sausages suddenly appear out of thin air in the left plate.", "The time interval is 1.2s-3.17s. The person's hand does not pick up a new sausage but puts sausage on the pizza, but there are more sausages on the pizza." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "40f3eb99-fb67-5263-a29d-0bd1dda9231d", "filename": "P26_104_104_7c9dd17c6b2b645e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: The iron net in the character's hand suddenly disappears at 1.2 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "4d72dc36-710b-5a2f-85aa-8f063a40fc73", "filename": "P26_105_20_af75ad464e718551_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: The lid on the table thins when the hand is placed on it at 0.1s." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "7d291e40-3683-56de-8c11-b359e6738f18", "filename": "P26_105_46_077e7cf69ce1ccad_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "b16e2727-79bd-5ccb-90ad-233d33aacf6d", "filename": "P26_105_87_d75f9a0f4f43a510_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: In 0.1 seconds, one end of the cuboid box becomes a pointed point. In reality, both ends of a cuboid box are flat, not pointed.", "Continuous duration: 3.1s-4.2s, the tip becomes square when the cardboard box is torn open." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "7aad71f9-060c-5214-a545-39d3f6b970f0", "filename": "P26_108_10_ffce54d8eb2acea3_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "b611100a-ccd5-53b0-95fa-89963564e4ca", "filename": "P26_108_35_5f291453d270bd03_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 0.2s, a white object appears out of thin air in the right hand.", "Continuous duration: 1.2s-5s. The lower half of the white object adheres to the left hand, and the lower half of the white object continues to deform." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "8136af46-fe52-5d47-b98d-2d0bc256cc2d", "filename": "P01_109_363_c32adc66c2243dee_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: In the video, between 1 second and 1.1 seconds, when the egg is held in the right hand, the right side of the egg appears to be twisted and deformed.", "Time continuity: At 3.2 seconds, the eggshell on the left hand and some fingers on the left hand suddenly disappear into thin air in the video.", "Continuous time: During the period from 3.2s to 4.1s, the eggshell on the right hand gradually transforms into a complete egg.", "Time sequence: At 4.2 seconds, after the right hand picks up the egg from the egg carton, an extra egg appears out of thin air below the carton, and the picked-up egg and the egg in the carton seem to stick together and merge." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "5a713c49-11f5-54d5-ae07-381f7fa0c18b", "filename": "P01_109_367_801471c732e57b9c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 1.1 seconds, as the eggs are cracked open with both hands, the eggshell between the thumbs of both hands suddenly disappears into thin air.", "Time continuity: At 0.1 seconds, the egg white in the bowl suddenly disappears into thin air in the video.", "Time continuity: When the egg in the hand falls into the bowl at 1.2 seconds, the yolk in the bowl and the yolk falling into the bowl begin to merge.", "Continuous timing: When the index fingers of the left and right hands touched at 1.1s-2s, a blurred fusion occurred.", "Time continuity: At 2 seconds in the video, the eggshell in the left hand suddenly disappears out of thin air.", "Time Continuity: Between 2.2s and 3s, after the eggshell in the right hand is placed into the egg carton, a complete egg appears out of thin air in the right hand.", "Causal relationship: At 3.1 seconds in the video, before the hand had even made the action of breaking the egg, a crack suddenly appeared in the egg.", "Continuous time: During the period from 4.1s to 5s, as the eggshell in the right hand moves, the edges of the eggshell twist and deform, and the eggshell in the upper right corner of the packaging box shakes without any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "f5d80ab5-1df2-59bb-8b62-cc9f222030f9", "filename": "P01_109_425_e2ddc881aa635e8c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: Between 1.1s and 1.2s, the green object in the hand appears distorted and deformed, and an extra segment appears out of nowhere on the upper right side of the object.", "Time continuity: After a layer was torn off the upper right side of the green object at 1.2 seconds, it remained intact.", "Continuous time: When the right hand fingers touched the green object at 2.1s-2.2s, the right hand fingers adhered and fused with the green object, and the fingers showed twisting, deformation, and partial loss.", "Time continuity: During the period from 4.2s to 5s, the green object in the hand appears to twist, deform, stick together, and fuse." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "6888f0bd-66bc-57f6-9d71-b1093e8750e4", "filename": "P01_109_505_21e38433c8d15586_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: Throughout the video, the person's hand twists and deforms as it moves, and the fingers and towel appear to merge together.", "Causality: Between 3 and 4 seconds in the video, the hand is not holding the pot handle; it's just a towel wrapped around it. Yet, the pot is still able to toss food normally, and the pot is constantly shaking, but the spoon inside only shakes slightly. The images don't correspond to each other." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "dfad757a-aab2-5f76-9b86-dc900f86d538", "filename": "P02_101_63_98318a85aa8038f2_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous timing: Between 1.2s and 2s, the length of the left index finger in the video changes continuously, and the left index finger is blurry with an unclear outline, which does not conform to the texture of a real hand.", "Time continuity: At 2 seconds, the left index finger appears to merge with the tip of the knife in the video." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "f34137d1-36a7-55ee-bd70-b78ac86867e1", "filename": "P02_102_77_c73b0d8a649c1bc4_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: The shape of the black cap on the bottle in the hand changes between 0s and 1s.", "The timing is continuous: between 2s and 2.1s, the bottle in the hand merges with the bottle in the upper left corner of the video.", "Time continuity: During the 3.1s-4.2s interval, when the right hand makes contact with the white bottle above the video, clipping occurs, and the white bottle appears to be twisted and deformed." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "721299fc-1e14-52d2-aa25-de496d22704a", "filename": "P02_104_83_5b95e253501eec35_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: Between 0s and 0.2s, the yellow glove next to the water tank splits and suddenly merges into the right hand.", "Time continuity: At 1.2 seconds, the yellow glove penetrates the edge of the transparent object in the hand in the video.", "Cause and effect: Throughout the video, water continuously flows into the transparent object, but the amount of water inside the transparent object does not increase." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "659cd2e2-e508-5bdc-868f-bd67d3d855c3", "filename": "P02_104_111_ff2113d2018334c8_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The cooking process continued for 1.1s-3.2s, but the steam in the pot disappeared without a trace.", "Time continuity: At 3.1 seconds, the spoon head under the meat in the pot suddenly penetrated the edge of the meat.", "Continuous movement: The image on the right side of the table appears to shake throughout the entire video." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "61470cba-b6c8-55b0-986c-772d13166257", "filename": "P02_104_124_34d3bb60f5ef7fcd_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: During the movement of the right hand, twisting and deformation occurs between 0s and 0.1s.", "Time continuity: Between 0.2s and 1s, the edge of the plate below the right hand at the top of the video appears distorted, and the left hand also appears distorted during its movement.", "Time continuity: At 1.1 seconds, the left index finger clips through the plate below in the video." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "0ea1e697-05d9-5657-b9cf-50d9deaaec3d", "filename": "P02_104_149_8b768193f6d97ae2_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: Throughout the video, the oil in the pan is shown boiling while frying the meat, but only a small amount of steam is visible in the pan, which does not match reality." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "46d523cd-ca41-5443-8a6f-35eedb5be795", "filename": "P02_105_68_6dd450c698ad8b36_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: The edge of the pot in my hand twists and deforms between 0s and 0.1s.", "During the continuous time frame (0.2s-5s), when the right hand is washing the pot, the yellow glove on the right hand appears to twist and deform, and the glove seems to merge with the object in the right hand.", "Causality: During the period from 0.1s to 3.1s, water was continuously poured into the pot, but the amount of water in the pot did not increase." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "30e6a9a7-5d2b-5c1f-aac5-fdde0c06dd47", "filename": "P02_105_85_a184128bbf06f580_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: During the period from 0s to 1.1s, when washing a black object in one's hand, the black object continuously deforms." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "b365f370-097f-548e-b5e1-f01cac4fe62b", "filename": "P02_105_178_a199dc8af81930a6_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: During the 2s-4s interval, the number of objects below the hand increases out of thin air.", "Continuous timing: In the video between 2s and 2.1s, the fingers of the right hand appear to merge with the object in the hand, and the fingers partially disappear.", "Time continuity: The image of the table below the hand is distorted throughout the video." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "be38262d-d0dc-5030-a83e-05df8a3aed24", "filename": "P02_107_31_c6e03c2415bf383d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall, the video appears abnormal: the entire video feed exhibits unusual flickering and shaking." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "6936c66a-d5f5-56f0-a5de-47f8528149fa", "filename": "P02_108_116_5286ed55d078040a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 1 second, the white object below the object in the hand suddenly disappears into thin air.", "Continuous time: During the 0s-1s interval, the internal structure of the hand-held mixer continuously twists and deforms.", "Time Continuity: At 2 seconds in the video, a lid and a bottle appear out of nowhere on the blender.", "Continuous timing: At approximately 4.2 seconds, when the mixer is moved to the bottom right corner of the video, the mixer deforms." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "d0190dca-389b-5248-a944-a04b33760c83", "filename": "P02_108_180_1edef8bcc465376f_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall, the visual impression is unusual: throughout the video, there is noticeable shaking on the surface of the table below the white object in the left hand." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "a2f058fc-f5e5-550d-8450-7751b9c9deb4", "filename": "P02_108_223_e37f22b02735c782_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality: In the 0s-0.1s interval, the yellow gloves were suddenly put on the hands without being worn normally at the edge of the water tank.", "Time continuity: In the video, between 1.1ss and 1.2s, the black object in the water is lifted up when it penetrates the white object in the water.", "Time Continuity: Within 3s-3.1s, the water in the object in the hand disappears into thin air without being poured out." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "9593eb28-0377-5377-8024-2e9133fb6bda", "filename": "P02_108_351_4611aba364e6bb0e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: The transparent object in the right hand undergoes continuous deformation between 0s and 0.2s.", "Time continuity: During the period from 2.2s to 3.1s, when the right hand picks up the fruit on the table, the fruit and the hand twist and deform, and a ring appears out of thin air on the right hand's fingers." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "e873f9b9-acb8-50b2-ad45-4d8c9c2cf843", "filename": "P02_108_447_6b7ebbc070e4e336_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 1.1 seconds, the right hand fingers merge with the silver handle in the video.", "Continuous timing: The towel between the left and right hands splits within 0.2s-1s." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "2d2b6928-8bdf-5b56-b1c9-410edd06b331", "filename": "P02_109_149_21af70ea6cb45625_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: In the video, between 2 and 3 seconds, the wooden spatula in the person's right hand becomes blurred and the spatula body disappears while stirring the meat.", "Overall intuition: In the 0s-5s interval, the green bottle on the right side of the hand has blurry and unreadable text, appearing as gibberish." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "5c51d2b6-c282-5473-af0f-9a25abbbd353", "filename": "P02_109_151_0ed950841e20cbb7_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: In the 0s-5s interval, the green bottle on the right side of the hand has blurry and unreadable text, appearing as gibberish.", "Continuous timing: At 2.1 seconds, the wooden spatula in the person's right hand blurs and disappears as it blends with the meat and the spoon body." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "74b47f30-81e7-5f90-b7eb-3c1be042ffb1", "filename": "P02_112_259_ac9d40cb6699550d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "In the continuous time frame (0s-0.1s), the hand at the bottom of the video appears distorted and exhibits noticeable white artifacts.", "Time Continuity: From 1s to 4s, the right index finger of the person in the middle of the video merges with the black button, and the black button gradually disappears.", "Overall intuition: From 0s to 5s, the bottle body in the upper right corner is blurry, and the text is unrecognizable and appears as garbled characters." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "ca1aef43-59aa-5d12-8da4-9baac0ec0596", "filename": "P02_118_33_8466fd97f10fc4d7_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 1 second, the number of objects in the mixer in the video increases without external force, and then suddenly decreases and disappears at 3.2 seconds.", "Overall impression: The text on the 0s-5s packaging is blurry and unreadable, appearing as garbled characters.", "Overall intuition: The power strips to the left of the blender in the 0s-5s sequence are arranged haphazardly, and their structure does not match reality." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "fa04e464-0f5c-5f13-bd8b-8bcf4cb41934", "filename": "P02_118_34_71c7977b55db4418_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 1 second, the number of objects in the mixer in the video increases without external force, and then suddenly decreases and disappears at 4 seconds.", "Overall impression: The text on the 0s-5s packaging is blurry and unreadable, appearing as garbled characters.", "Overall intuition: The power strips to the left of the blender in the 0s-5s sequence are arranged haphazardly, and their structure does not match reality." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "f9b6f92d-9392-5d80-831e-2517b55999b5", "filename": "P02_118_58_654c17ff8e212d88_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: From 0.2s to 5s, the tip of the right index finger of the figure deforms multiple times.", "Overall impression: The text on the 0s-5s packaging is blurry and unreadable, appearing as garbled characters.", "Causal relationship: During the period from 0s to 5s, the character repeatedly pressed different buttons on the blender with his right hand, but the state of the blender did not change." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "e2f89331-ed22-5cc2-8407-f36585584748", "filename": "P02_118_59_87761b1f2e19020d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: During the period from 2.2s to 3.2s, when the character picks up the scissors with their right hand, clipping occurs between the scissors and the character's hand.", "During the continuous timeframe from 2.2s to 3.2s, the character's right hand holding the scissors suddenly loses four fingers." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "5f89397b-77e5-5ffd-a4b4-1bf968d7a1e6", "filename": "P02_118_128_a84ea3834b0c8733_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: During the 1-5 second time period, when the person is wearing a glove on their right hand, the glove deforms.", "Overall intuition: The white drain basin flickers and changes color between 0s and 5s." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "9866bd0b-8e1d-5fe1-bdeb-a0629ca6249c", "filename": "P02_119_15_dbd29910f8e82088_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time sequence: At 1.2s, the yellow object in the white bowl being stirred by the person suddenly splits into two pieces; at 2.2s, the volume of the yellow object suddenly increases; at 4.1s, it splits into smaller pieces, which then disappear again while being stirred." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "2e3cdecd-370c-5d28-997e-cdbeb23da5bf", "filename": "P02_120_156_5d420d02cad13d30_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous timing: At 0.2 seconds, the crossed fingers of the hands merge and deform; after separating, the fingertips of the left hand deform, and the left edge of the mixing bowl merges with the white line in the video.", "The white line on the left side of the mixing bowl in the video splits during the 0.2s-5s time interval." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "27d87924-cbac-5b14-b1ec-7f8c602d6dc5", "filename": "P02_120_187_9043e21d84129864_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: From 2.2s to 4.1s, the fingertips of the person's right hand are deformed and blurred, and the fingers are constantly deformed and stuck together.", "Overall intuition: The power strips to the left of the blender in the 0s-5s sequence are arranged haphazardly, and their structure does not match reality." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "f3e2070a-047b-576f-9477-ae35f8ec28dd", "filename": "P02_121_41_ce72f033c32fe2dc_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: The fingertips of the character's left hand are deformed and blurred during the period from 4.2s to 5.1s.", "Physical behavior: At 0.2 seconds, the first roll of paper on the lower right side of the screen moves on its own without any external force.", "In the continuous time frame (0.2s-1.2s), the edge of the paper on the right side of the box merges with the first roll of paper on the lower right side of the screen." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "92d455c7-fb0a-51a8-8aa4-fd336add849c", "filename": "P02_121_46_9094d99d7b991bce_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: From 0s to 5s, the hand and the cardboard box continuously deform and stick together.", "Overall impression: The text and patterns on the 0s-5s cardboard boxes are blurry and unreadable, displaying garbled characters.", "Overall intuition: From 0s to 5s, the figure's left foot loses the normal shape and outline of a human foot, and toes are missing." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "58476215-8cd0-571e-bc64-42ad15b022fa", "filename": "P02_121_47_ef3a0792a59ca8d9_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: From 0s to 1.2s, the clip on the person's hand is clamped onto the cardboard box, causing distortion and blurring.", "Cause and effect: At 1.2 seconds, the clip on the box held by the character's left hand does not actually move, yet the clip remains stuck to the box.", "Time sequence: At 2.1s, a blue artifact appears out of thin air on the character's right hand; at 2.2s, a clip appears out of thin air.", "Continuous time: During the 0s-5s interval, the human hand continuously deforms and sticks together, resulting in blurring." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "a3ec73a6-f481-5b02-a733-e9fb2f34f3ec", "filename": "P02_121_49_4b8a76ab4b42193d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The clip on the character's right hand disappears out of thin air at 0.02 seconds.", "Time Continuity: At 0.2 seconds, a clip appears out of thin air on the lower left side of the box.", "Continuous timing: During the 1.2s-2.2s interval, clipping occurs between the paper on the top side of the box and the box itself.", "Continuous time: During the 0s-5s interval, the human hand continuously deforms and sticks together, resulting in blurring." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "99d1e919-386f-5bb5-baeb-09a19b6c06bf", "filename": "P02_122_162_22ab21fd3c87b1e5_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 2 seconds, a red object suddenly appears out of thin air on the left-hand plate, with no consistency in the image.", "Time Continuity: From 0s to 5s, the fork in the character's right hand continuously deforms and blurs." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "47c39257-3d85-524f-8ee7-0c8390fd7d64", "filename": "P02_122_199_a52d17d357caa51c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: From 0s to 5s, the figure's left foot loses the normal shape and outline of a human foot, and toes are missing.", "Time Continuity: 0s-5s. There is no obvious change in the objects on the plate, and the contents of the pot do not fall onto the plate. They disappear into thin air when stirred with the spatula in the right hand." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "d37bc203-8ddf-5cd4-b13f-2ceeae04d9db", "filename": "P02_123_19_fe6c9949542039dc_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 4.2 seconds, the fingers of the person's right hand become deformed and blurred." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "40d4234d-a305-5684-b29a-888a32507447", "filename": "P02_123_89_5fe576cc8ebc0c2b_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: In the absence of external force within 2-4 seconds, a large amount of white powder suddenly appeared from the packaging bag.", "Overall impression: The text and images on the 0s-5s packaging are blurry and unreadable, and some even appear as gibberish." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "e708379b-c002-59f8-8fed-f7c6ddeecadc", "filename": "P02_123_210_1fb8a7d871b343d1_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: From 0.2s to 1s, the unused yellow glove on the left side of the video changes to a hand wearing it.", "Time Continuity: At 1 second, the character's left hand and the left-side yellow glove merge.", "Physical behavior: At 4 seconds, the pot picked up by the right hand and the spatula inside the pot merge and clip through the mold.", "Time Continuity: During the 4-5 second interval, the spatula disappears as the right hand picks up the pot, and the lid appears out of thin air.", "Time Continuity: 0s-5s The character's hands and yellow gloves are repeatedly deformed and blurred." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "a8cf92fa-ecc3-52ab-811c-c5eb13565620", "filename": "P26_115_31_a1b42c0b2275a5b7_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The duration is continuous: 0.2s-1.1s, during which the towel in the hand transforms into a plastic-wrapped object.", "Time duration: 5 seconds. A silver-white object appears out of thin air below the refrigerator." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "fe522112-c898-50a5-b612-20e41d03f795", "filename": "P26_115_35_412c7051789d86a6_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 2.1 seconds. In the video, the fabric is simply lifted up, and neatly folded when it falls onto the table. In reality, folding fabric neatly wouldn't be that fast, and there would be a folding motion involved.", "Continuous time: The folds on the fabric merge at 2.3 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "ba0ff94e-0e8b-5206-a0f1-2eb831c93970", "filename": "P26_117_76_addd6463c21bb230_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "4b02688c-3c10-551f-b54d-0462c88c76ac", "filename": "P26_118_26_7248997c5fc4c69b_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The duration is continuous: 2.2s-5s, during which the dishcloth in one's hand disappears into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "a5e4c18a-41c7-5ba8-997e-397f5c25d611", "filename": "P26_119_45_36803179ef20d5ca_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 0.2 seconds, the cloth in my hand suddenly bursts into flames.", "Physical behavior: Within 0.2s-5s, the fabric ignites, but it is not burned. In reality, fabric is flammable and easily burned." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "2fee2a3e-f102-5d79-8eb3-1a8329d1a447", "filename": "P26_119_137_4c1a32897fbbf2ae_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The time sequence is 0s-0.1s. In the video, the white opaque plastic bag changes into a transparent plastic bag with a red pattern, and then the transparent plastic bag changes back into a white opaque plastic bag.", "Continuous time: 0.1s-2.2s, the white plastic bag transforms into a label.", "Time interval: 2.2s-3s. The unsealed transparent box of tomatoes in the left hand merges with the label in the right hand, transforming it into a sealed transparent box of tomatoes, and the content of the label changes.", "The duration is continuous: 3.1s-5s. The transparent box in the right hand keeps deforming, and the way the right hand holds the box is strange." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "62aaefd9-9111-5bc8-a2eb-21c0451aad6d", "filename": "P26_124_18_6f3da8e1e9b04009_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "1483f9d1-e183-5330-bf73-531015a892f2", "filename": "P26_124_50_f24bba4d74c15a69_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The time interval is 0s-0.3s. The green rag in the left hand turns into a green stain on the plate and then disappears." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "71b4ca39-efba-501d-b01f-a7745216153b", "filename": "P26_124_125_16187705b9b44950_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 0s-5s, the cupboard on the wall in the video is too close to the sink. In reality, the distance between the cupboard and the sink is large enough for a person to stand upright without touching their head. In the video, the cupboard is constantly close to the head." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "24e19e0c-723d-52f1-9c5e-cbbdc552681b", "filename": "P26_124_145_632be6e8c4c72089_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The duration was continuous: 2.1s-2.2s, and adhesion occurred in the left hand.", "Continuous duration: 3s-5s, the upper part of the faucet turns into a green glass bottle and merges with the faucet." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "f668f038-0075-5a41-acb3-a6aa0e38f8f7", "filename": "P26_124_153_58096bdc8e2a287e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: The blue fabric at the feet disappears into thin air at 2.1 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "02be99bb-af11-5856-bbcc-258d3b2ab454", "filename": "P27_101_78_345db36e71f5e99d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "25ee5d1b-eb4f-506f-bb05-d1e749cc3848", "filename": "P27_101_142_7ff8a6cd9823c190_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 2.2s, a gap appears in the bracelet on the right hand, and a closed loop is not formed.", "The time is continuous: the right bracelet disappears and reappears between 3s and 3.1s." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "1d3c32c5-4d9f-5f6f-89f0-facbe792244d", "filename": "P27_101_328_75124dd5ea9de035_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 0.3s and 1.1s, a gap appears in the bracelet on the right hand, and a closed loop is not formed.", "Continuous timing: Red spots appeared on the right wrist at 1.1s and 1.2s.", "Time continuity: The chain bracelet transforms into a gemstone bracelet at 2.1 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "c0813c04-d0c7-5b8a-af34-eaedf6a87b76", "filename": "P27_101_363_cf1042e57cc57cd7_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: At 0.1s, the left side of the fabric was not being held by hand, but in the video, the left side of the fabric showed an arc as if it had been picked up by hand." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "cda6109e-bd00-5ceb-b335-f5364b2aeae5", "filename": "P27_101_371_6aaaeb5d96d11adf_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "2c47e8df-b360-5f17-bdd5-8b0f611672c6", "filename": "P27_103_85_8b8bc94044e79a61_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: The middle finger on the character's hand disappears after 3 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "92f0eac2-9898-5577-88fa-aab29db5f2d3", "filename": "P27_103_123_02b39c32267d2934_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "4020b681-4d45-5e0e-91b4-a141a8949e2e", "filename": "P27_103_163_656193dc8209b850_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous timing: At 1.1 seconds, the button on top of the stirrer changes from a rotary button to a push-button button." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "1563b6c8-253c-5a8f-8b80-0fa186e7b44b", "filename": "P27_103_170_757d61026a0d2926_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 4.1s-5s, a large amount of milk appears out of thin air in a pot that originally contained no milk." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "e3b811c3-f88e-556f-bda7-9c3b2cb907ad", "filename": "P30_107_745_4135eb23726394d0_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: The food on the plate disappears into thin air at 3.1 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "c431f6d7-8ebd-5bb6-a34c-7ed54f0a668a", "filename": "P30_107_813_538d8e8cce74b642_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: The foam on the cutting board was wiped clean at 4.2 seconds, but when the person in the video wiped it with their hand, a large amount of foam appeared." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "9fd486b4-4e19-55d8-b889-6eab85163a56", "filename": "P30_107_863_5d808505b1a0f304_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 1.1 seconds, a small bottle appears out of thin air on the left hand." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "0d3453ea-f0db-5240-a905-13ef5f62cc77", "filename": "P30_107_880_e2e1437729af5577_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "6867d893-4370-527d-82d5-8443ffe4cc44", "filename": "P30_108_43_9930d05ead378dab_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 3.1 seconds, the frying pan in the right hand appears out of thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "00a578a6-a2df-552b-ad7a-78e80c2cd7ad", "filename": "P30_108_46_ff0737b715b37ac8_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "280adf86-8ab4-5e97-9394-6546abda96a3", "filename": "P30_108_110_28d16962eb3583b2_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: 0-5s, the water in the pool rotates on its own without any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "6a03c3fe-c0aa-546d-a8ed-73a73599c371", "filename": "P30_108_118_a70ea358fdea15c1_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 4.2 seconds, the originally yellow item turned silver-white." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "93dfbeb8-d499-5d55-9691-0507d0531bda", "filename": "P30_109_94_b4cbb57feef6db6e_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "cca9a0a4-8f61-584b-bd6f-c0e050cb622f", "filename": "P30_109_186_73659980585fb905_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 0.2 seconds, an object appears out of thin air on the upper left hand of the person in the video." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "0320e1c6-5376-52aa-a090-b9e71475401c", "filename": "P30_110_89_4040d8fcb1eaa968_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: At 2 seconds, water can be seen entering the cup in the video, but at 2.2 seconds, there is no water in the cup." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "d0b6a17c-5d99-543c-be79-9bb1eb3a59dc", "filename": "P30_111_127_191656c899fcacf4_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: At 1.1 seconds, some of the food in the person's hand in the video fell off, but the amount of food in their hand did not decrease but increased." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "7765d54d-4300-5b33-8a7c-49c8eb704369", "filename": "P30_111_283_b290c5e3f6f83143_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: 0-5s, the food being shaken in the video does not move at all inside the transparent box." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "92d1b839-3bf4-5b50-a25a-b280eb86c2e2", "filename": "P30_111_314_54f9c076ae66f4d0_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 1 second, the item in the person's left hand in the video disappears out of thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "d61edd8d-98c1-57db-aae8-3c0f297c3e18", "filename": "P30_111_343_7de5c8132d98879a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: At 3.2 seconds, the towel in the right hand underwent a clipping phenomenon." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "4974b025-63ea-5f4a-806c-ddc3f18134c4", "filename": "P30_111_460_55d6cbff38012c7d_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 2.2 seconds, the food in the person's hand in the video disappears into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "934aa19e-4c25-540e-ac52-110b87c5be3c", "filename": "P30_111_461_e8a59446c08f9002_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "d4e2713b-7dd5-5d08-88d3-b607afd330dd", "filename": "P30_111_499_0efa292a70f6c67c_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "4ab0b78e-1836-53f1-a114-1834cdfd9ef9", "filename": "P30_111_608_001bcd37e12fccbc_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: 0-5 seconds, no trash was visible in the video, yet a lot of trash appeared out of thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "5a5066f3-b98c-5113-9469-0180168b4496", "filename": "P37_101_306_73f0d9ec074ac782_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality: Between 4.1 and 5 seconds, a large amount of sauce can be seen being poured into the food by the person in the video, but when the camera cuts to the person's hand, the amount of sauce has not decreased." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "5f407759-a465-5375-972e-a0d6f95f0a9a", "filename": "P37_102_61_05929ea498cb3950_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: 1. Between 1 and 3 seconds, the person in the video cut a piece of food with a knife, but many pieces of food appeared on the cutting board." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "6829979c-9bdb-543e-bf70-1e3d8cd7f0c3", "filename": "P37_102_77_4ad2e573398bc280_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality: At 1 second, the person in the video cuts a small piece of food with a knife, but when the camera pans to 1.2 seconds, the cut food disappears and returns to its original shape." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "0cd53735-799a-565c-b4de-3d5d33e2dc87", "filename": "P37_102_89_52322bc1d032c9df_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality: At 0.2 seconds, a person in the video can be seen cutting off a piece of food with a knife, but when the camera pans to 1.1 seconds, the cut food is intact again." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "1602a21d-8707-513e-9f9c-3365451ed03e", "filename": "P37_102_101_08455f59502f13da_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: The food in the video was cut into several small pieces 3 seconds ago, but it returned to its original intact state 3 seconds later." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "daacc637-54f6-5c79-b2c5-8a6725b1f22b", "filename": "P37_102_130_5671271f4027c582_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: In the 0-5s-4s video, water from the faucet continuously enters the pot, and the person washing the pot does not pour out the water, but the water level in the pot does not rise." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "cbca8ecc-9275-5a88-8a00-233675b06635", "filename": "P37_102_142_e1e5c5dda1d07fbd_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality: 0-5 seconds, the person in the video cuts food with a knife, but the food remains intact without any marks." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "b1dd6461-09c1-562a-b730-dc28c07d8c5e", "filename": "P37_103_28_2e2f23de7a52c55a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: In the 4.1s-5s video, the person only tore off a small piece of the chicken leg, yet the entire chicken leg disappeared." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "937ef77e-6cfa-57ec-8aa9-148104b86559", "filename": "P37_103_34_11f9f31a233661ec_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: In the video from 3.2s to 4.8s, a person throws a piece of chicken into a bowl on the right, but when the camera pans, the chicken has disappeared from the bowl." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "b6245dd0-b1dd-5f87-b56f-6628e6877c3d", "filename": "P37_103_35_4cfa29d0feec755a_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality: Between 3.4 and 5 seconds, it can be seen in the video that the person in the video puts most of the chicken in their hand into the bowl, but the amount of chicken in their hand does not decrease." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "e6a21574-acb8-5abc-8fd8-27fdb16321b0", "filename": "P37_103_42_5f6effc318fb1e63_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "c127153d-02e3-5366-99ca-e5ccd9b9f450", "filename": "P37_103_46_99b4f4ad41805f07_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "1558dc52-7fc8-584a-a1b6-5202627f0610", "filename": "P37_103_52_f9abd6779dfbb113_i2v_a14b", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: A piece of chicken torn apart at 4.1 seconds becomes a chicken leg in the bowl on the right." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Wan 2.2", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "c6bd19cc-ea76-5d81-91ac-6091d426ad85", "filename": "P30_107_497_25b746c75244880a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: The drawer under the stove moved without any external force during the period from 0s to 2.3s.", "Physical behavior: The left hand penetrates the towel at 2.1 seconds, violating the principle that solids are impermeable.", "Time Continuity: At 4.1 seconds, the towel appears out of thin air, passing through the handle of the cup." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "1206d16f-3965-5371-aab9-d98cdbb4f3d9", "filename": "P30_107_533_06cd32cfe20f540c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly: At 0.1 seconds, the sponge on the right hand suddenly enlarged and changed from a regular shape to an irregular shape.", "Continuous time: The position of the faucet shifts out of thin air at 0.2s.", "Continuous time: Throughout the video, there is no drain hole in the sink, but the faucet is constantly running water, yet the water level in the sink does not show any upward trend." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "dea50c9a-3bbc-5329-9427-888e9cf0e075", "filename": "P30_107_563_1dc3d605296508f5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuous: At 5 seconds, the right thumb twists and bends significantly to the right." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "64747768-7dc1-5240-87d8-afd065442c25", "filename": "P30_107_642_3e6884258e38269b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 0.1s, the phantom image of an iron spoon appears out of thin air on the wooden spatula in the right hand." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "c9144d93-0a70-5c37-a61b-d6605e21e248", "filename": "P30_107_731_9f5c3b8089220f4e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 3.2 seconds, an oval wooden block appears out of thin air on the left hand.", "Time continuity: The water in the plate disappears into thin air at 1.3 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "c8f87b09-bafd-5e22-b07c-45bdef830df9", "filename": "P30_107_745_4135eb23726394d0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: At 2.1 seconds, the pot on the right side shifted without any external force.", "Time Continuity: At 4 seconds, the handle of the right pot disappears out of thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "0edde6ad-6f69-58ea-830e-fdd984e3e10f", "filename": "P30_107_813_538d8e8cce74b642_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: During the 2.1s-5s interval, water is poured onto the slanted cutting board, but instead of dripping down the board, the water disappears into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "cb8e8857-9b30-53fd-bd18-2860ac8e419e", "filename": "P30_107_846_d1963f701df1167b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: Between 1.2s and 3.2s, the egg in the dish slowly cracked open out of thin air without any external force.", "Continuous timing: Egg liquid flowed out of the plate out of thin air at 4.1 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "98b55228-1b2a-5c26-a38c-64bf89d48d91", "filename": "P30_107_865_c066572da495a252_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: Throughout the video, the water in the pot on the stove fluctuates dramatically without any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "4a284f42-19fd-5b3c-b422-164e1a21759d", "filename": "P30_107_880_e2e1437729af5577_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "ee1db2f2-e794-5a0f-bbee-5b5a532e5659", "filename": "P30_108_28_daedb9a67e92b52d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuous: At 1.1, the pot in my hand automatically flips over, and after flipping, a bowl appears out of thin air inside the pot.", "Time continuity: At 4.2 seconds, the two handles on the side of the pot disappear into thin air.", "Physical behavior: When the pot was dropped on the ground at 4.1 seconds, there was no bouncing reaction." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "484bab30-16a5-5b29-be7f-47090356eb0c", "filename": "P30_108_46_ff0737b715b37ac8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 1.2 seconds, the stainless steel frame in the sink suddenly transforms into a pot, while the wooden stick held in the left hand vanishes into thin air.", "Time Continuity: At 2.3 seconds, a wooden stick appears out of thin air in the left hand.", "Time Continuity: At 3.3 seconds, the pot in the sink disappears into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "c0b29c69-2f11-522d-8dfc-95a8c868f885", "filename": "P30_108_84_93c1012d7aaba020_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: Water appears out of thin air in the small pot in my hand at 1.1 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "face16ca-cc24-5aeb-a90d-4ecd66297544", "filename": "P30_108_110_28d16962eb3583b2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: Throughout the video, the water in the tank surged without any external force acting upon it." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "fbf9d656-d6f7-5372-b7ef-8f425876f2ac", "filename": "P30_108_118_a70ea358fdea15c1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 0.2 seconds, the blue sponge in the right hand disappears into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "31bdbe84-41fc-5075-a9fe-6b676ab56906", "filename": "P30_108_156_7dbd4855fdb07ca7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 4.1 seconds, the plate in my hand flips over and changes from a zebra-striped color to pure white." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "38b4f7d4-c4cf-52df-841d-4a0dd2140011", "filename": "P30_108_215_65f205f34b2d811c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: At 2.2 seconds, the left thumb penetrates the towel, violating the principle that solids are impermeable." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "5923661e-07ab-541c-be2b-3cc755b5e4a5", "filename": "P30_109_94_b4cbb57feef6db6e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 0.1s, the small yellow rag disappears from the bottom of the cup out of thin air.", "Time Continuity: At 4.1 seconds, the color at the bottom of the cup suddenly changes from blue to white." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "b4aaee91-83b7-5f7b-9036-f8f6c095f6b3", "filename": "P30_109_162_54d23070d0af47db_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 1 second, the stainless steel pan beneath the pizza disappears into thin air.", "Physical behavior: The pizza and the refrigerator penetrate each other at 1.3s, which violates the principle that solids are impermeable.", "Time continuity: At 4.1 seconds, a plastic box appears out of thin air in the left hand." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "d45f3866-5a77-5d94-980e-b2b75e03220c", "filename": "P30_111_75_fbd1d18b86556659_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: Between 0s and 1s, the pot on the stove flew into a person's hand out of thin air without any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "1ea156b4-e6fe-522b-9060-a20eb6156c7b", "filename": "P35_108_632_5470acc36afb477e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: At 1.1 seconds, the person's right hand grasps the faucet and lifts it, causing water to flow out of thin air.", "Time Continuity: From 2s to 5s, the character's left hand and the white mesh deform, the fingertips merge with the white mesh object, and the tip of the right index finger clips through the purple plate." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "bb6cc140-2509-5a2c-928f-2ffc40bd54ee", "filename": "P35_109_137_2789bb16369d3312_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "e55405ea-27f9-5dae-9f9f-2bc2467e4bd7", "filename": "P35_109_148_e074d90f3322b1cd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: From 0s to 3.1s, the black handle on the left side of the video screen shakes on its own without any external force.", "Time continuity: From 0s to 1s, the character's left hand is deformed and blurred, while the right thumb is deformed and elongated. At 0.2s, the index and middle fingers behind the ear of the cup stick together and merge.", "Time Continuity: During the 2s-5s interval, when the character's right hand is touching the white cup, the thumb is elongated and deformed." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "34b660ab-fd7c-539b-b1b1-66668c3c24a2", "filename": "P37_101_1_349d01ecc266866f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: A green artifact appears on the yellow bottle in the lower right corner of the refrigerator when it is opened at 0.1s-1s.", "In the continuous timeframe from 1.1s to 4.1s, the fingers of the character's right hand, which is holding an object, become deformed and are missing a finger.", "Time Continuity: Between 4s and 4.2s, the blue box in the character's right hand undergoes a sudden change, turning from blue-white to red." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "2c2e969f-956a-5d5c-aa83-671f752c538e", "filename": "P37_101_87_a0a5f1e554cde13f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: From 1.1s to 5.1s, the human hand in the video appears deformed, with the left ring and little fingers sticking together, and the right index and middle fingers sticking together and fusing.", "Overall intuition: Between 1 and 6 seconds, the chicken leg-like object in the pot in the video looks strange and doesn't match reality. Also, at 3 seconds, the person's hand and the object in the pot merge and distort.", "Causal relationship: In the video, between 4.1s and 5.2s, the person's left hand is holding the pot, and their raised right hand is pressing on the range hood. The sudden change to the left hand is a logical error." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "96ecf112-4a5d-550d-8749-4c8e2a1f64eb", "filename": "P37_101_94_6c47161cf517be53_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: From 2.1s to 3.1s in the video, after the person closes the cabinet door with their right hand, a black object inside the cabinet clips through the cabinet.", "Time Continuity: At 4 seconds, the character's right hand becomes deformed and blurred.", "Overall intuition: The structural logic of the cabinet above in the video from 0s to 5s is flawed and does not match reality." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "3b8a278b-3a66-5b7f-83d5-abd214e741f7", "filename": "P37_101_226_34d3a426ae1baf0a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 0.03s video - Garlic appears out of thin air in the bowl on the left.", "Time Continuity: 0.2s. Garlic skin appears out of thin air on the character's right hand, and the index finger merges with the garlic skin.", "Time Continuous: After 5 seconds, the garlic disappears, and the garlic skin sticks to the hand.", "Time Continuous: At 3 seconds, garlic cloves appear out of thin air in the hand, the fingers and the garlic cloves stick together, and the fingers deform.", "Time Continuous: After 4 seconds, the garlic disappears out of thin air, and then the finger and the garlic reappear stuck together.", "Time Continuous: After 1 second, the garlic skin disappears, and a clove of garlic appears out of thin air in the bowl on the left.", "The duration is continuous: from 1.1s to 2.2s, garlic cloves appear out of thin air in the hand and then disappear, with the garlic skin sticking to the fingers." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "82d20131-488f-5c3c-b4cc-1fe5e04302c7", "filename": "P37_101_260_c0045cc880cf0801_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: During the period from 0s to 2.2s, the outline of the person's right hand is blurred and indistinct.", "Overall intuition: At 3.2 seconds, the screen is exposed, and the character's left-hand knife disappears and then reappears.", "In continuous time: from 4s to 5.2s, the number of yellow objects on the white cutting board increases out of thin air, and artifacts appear." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "21844431-551d-5c35-bdcf-0cd1a9d6ddca", "filename": "P37_101_278_77bd38db4d98d112_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: During the 0s-1s interval, the object in the bowl in the video undergoes a sudden change, transforming into a chicken leg, after which the object below the bowl disappears into thin air.", "Time Continuity: From 2s to 5.2s, the character picks up two objects from the bowl, causing them to merge and deform. The character's hand deforms, and the left hand's fingers clip through the objects.", "Continuous time: 0s-5s, the hand in the image continuously deforms and blurs." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "0df41994-5024-5960-8990-bfd6abf83b76", "filename": "P37_101_304_35ac2c74987a7123_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 0s-5s, the figure's hands are blurry and the outline is unclear.", "Overall impression: The red lettering on the induction cooker (0s-5s) is blurry and unreadable, displaying garbled characters." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "cad257aa-f2b7-5447-959d-506fcbfd663b", "filename": "P37_101_306_73f0d9ec074ac782_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: During the 0s-3s interval, the bottle in the character's left hand, the red bottle cap deforms, and the fingers stick together.", "Time Continuous: At 3.1 seconds, liquid suddenly flowed from the sealed red bottle cap in the left hand.", "Causal relationship: The amount of liquid poured out between 3.1s and 5.2s is not directly proportional to the amount of liquid rising in the pot." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "493dd109-ffc2-52fd-82ff-4c1bec650075", "filename": "P37_101_319_df38435dbc815479_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 0.1s, some red objects appear out of thin air on the white cutting board.", "Time Continuity: At 3 seconds, unidentified debris appears out of thin air in the character's hand, and their fingers deform.", "Physical behavior: From 5s to 5.2s, the physical force of the character's left hand flows to the right hand without any external force affecting it." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "c902394b-76bb-5d12-8492-258a018fa0d2", "filename": "P37_101_357_05336d13031a78f8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: A sudden change in the video frame between 2.1s and 3.2s reveals obvious artifacts.", "Time Continuity: The onion was cut twice with a knife at 5.2 seconds, and the onion did not change at all." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "242f80d3-8316-51f5-bf69-2fcede7489c1", "filename": "P37_102_77_4ad2e573398bc280_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: From 0.2s to 3.2s, the sliced carrots abruptly transform into strips, and their quantity increases out of nowhere; the outline of the human hand becomes blurred and indistinct.", "The timing is continuous: from 3.2s to 4.1s, when the character moves the carrot with their left hand, the carrot and the fragments merge.", "Time sequence: At 4.2 seconds, when the left hand puts the carrot into the bowl, the whole carrot suddenly breaks into pieces." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "edc396b7-3b55-5798-b3fb-52f454660e31", "filename": "P37_102_101_08455f59502f13da_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: From 1s to 5.2s, while the character is cutting carrots, they keep cutting from the same spot, but many carrot slices appear out of nowhere." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "33faa5b4-8a18-5206-b6a7-bd8f751d60a0", "filename": "P37_102_114_293e812131e7a810_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 0.2, the carrot chunk that appeared out of thin air in the left hand merged with the two carrot pieces on the cutting board.", "The sequence of time is continuous: from 1.1s to 4.2s, the character is cutting carrots in the same spot, but many carrot strips appear out of nowhere.", "Time Continuity: At 4.1 seconds, the carrot held in the character's left hand disappears into thin air.", "Time continuity: At 5.2 seconds, the carrots the character picks up from the bowl start to stick together." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "ca71618e-fee6-5b30-9229-0287f5d6a236", "filename": "P37_103_3_f21d5ed2d345d569_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 0s-5s. In the scene, the chicken leg in the character's hand continuously deforms, and the deformed hands merge with the chicken leg." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "d1d3bd00-73fc-5e43-a449-d274ed0ba074", "filename": "P37_103_28_2e2f23de7a52c55a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 1 second, the chicken leg in the character's right hand, which was on the plate, fused and deformed, and the chicken leg that had fallen from below the plate disappeared into thin air.", "Time Continuity: 0s-5s In the scene, the chicken leg in the character's hand continuously deforms, and the deformed hands merge with the chicken leg." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "92b378d3-e597-5481-924e-922ea9468374", "filename": "P37_103_34_11f9f31a233661ec_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 1 second, the chicken leg on the plate on the right side of the screen undergoes a sudden change, merging and deforming, with the chicken leg held in the character's right hand and the shredded chicken in the left hand merging together.", "Time Continuity: From 1s to 5.2s, the shredded chicken in the character's hands continuously deforms, and the deformed hands merge with the shredded chicken.", "Time Continuity: At 5.2 seconds, the shredded chicken that the right hand took out of the bowl suddenly turned into chicken bones." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "6dabfa33-3479-51e1-9123-dfee91e62bf9", "filename": "P37_103_35_4cfa29d0feec755a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 4 seconds, the character picks up the chicken leg from the plate on the right with their right hand, and the chicken leg merges and disappears.", "Time Continuity: From 0s to 5s, the shredded chicken in the character's hands continuously deforms and merges, with the hands deforming and merging with the shredded chicken." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "d3d21492-0783-5381-97c7-95f07348d545", "filename": "P37_103_42_5f6effc318fb1e63_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: From 3s to 4.2s, the character's right hand picks up the chicken leg from the plate on the right, and the chicken meat in their left hand merges and disappears.", "Time Continuity: From 0s to 5s, the chicken in the character's hands continuously deforms and merges, with the hands deforming and merging with the chicken." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "82f07680-f908-50d9-9f43-e8bf2869b4c8", "filename": "P37_103_46_99b4f4ad41805f07_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: From 0s to 5s, the chicken in the character's hands continuously deforms and merges, with the hands deforming and merging with the chicken." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "93b2ea93-5e04-51fd-9446-44f1af5889f4", "filename": "P37_103_52_f9abd6779dfbb113_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: From 1s to 5.2s, the character's right hand picks up the chicken leg from the plate on the right, and the chicken meat in the left hand merges and disappears. At the same time, the chicken leg in the plate on the right disappears out of thin air.", "Time Continuity: 0s-5s In the scene, the chicken in the character's hands continuously deforms, merges, and disappears; the hands deform and merge with the chicken." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "e0bfdcf2-bf93-55fd-8d78-e6ecee74efda", "filename": "P02_101_63_98318a85aa8038f2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous timing: At 1 second, the foil fuses with the area near the right-hand blade.", "Cause and effect: When the knife was used to cut the butter vertically at 2 seconds, the butter was cut into a horizontal slice instead.", "Physical behavior: The aluminum foil wrapping the butter closed up on its own without any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "0d21c0ad-2713-54a7-8f64-de050dc43bae", "filename": "P02_101_65_fae214c805c75800_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 0.1s, the left index finger, thumb, and bread slice merge.", "Time continuity: At 0.2 seconds, the two slices of bread in the bowl merge into one.", "Continuous timing: At 1.2 seconds, the knife is no longer in contact with the butter, and the volume of the butter decreases out of thin air.", "Continuous time: 0s-5s. The fingertip appears blurred and distorted, with indistinct outlines." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "58a5024b-7301-52ef-b77a-1f56d71bc9dc", "filename": "P02_101_82_8edf24284732e4f3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: Between 2 and 5 seconds, the bread slices suddenly increase in area, and the jam suddenly increases in volume, showing no consistency.", "Continuous time: 0s-5s. The fingertip appears blurred and distorted, with indistinct outlines." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "cafcdb14-ab1b-5c72-a4f2-38cefa304459", "filename": "P02_102_100_a26e6525a6171ba3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuous: From 1s to 3s, a large amount of liquid appears out of thin air from the bottle cap in the person's left hand.", "The time sequence is continuous: from 3.1s to 5.2s, the bottle cap in the person's left hand undergoes a sudden change, becoming a transparent cap that adheres to and fuses with the bottom of the bottle in the right hand.", "Causal relationship: The liquid flowing from the bottle in the character's right hand during the 0s-5s interval is not proportional to the liquid in the transparent box." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "7b36b8fb-d541-5df4-8446-9df60101b252", "filename": "P02_104_111_ff2113d2018334c8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: Between 3.2s and 4.1s, the spatula did not flip the meat patty; it merely moved the patty to the right, yet the patty flipped itself." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "e16fcced-e6d9-53d7-9f1e-c9c9fd46c8c7", "filename": "P02_104_124_34d3bb60f5ef7fcd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "b42e92e3-0700-547a-821e-6f1e6f388c33", "filename": "P02_105_68_6dd450c698ad8b36_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: From 0s to 1s, the character is holding the water pool below the pot handle when a knife and the pot handle merge and disappear.", "Continuous time: At 1 second, when the person rotates the pot in the video, distortion and blurring occur.", "Continuous timing: From 1s to 5.1s, when the right-hand sponge is rubbing inside the pot held in the left hand, foam appears out of thin air, and at 5.1s, the pot flips over without any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "5772bbd4-1e55-5a7d-8f44-a22276f60729", "filename": "P02_105_89_88acb57f7e56cbfb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 0.1 seconds, the fork in the cup in the pool in the video disappears out of thin air.", "Time continuity: During the 0.1s-0.2s interval, the knife in the left hand suddenly transforms into a fork.", "Between 0.2 and 4 seconds, the foam from the right-hand sponge rubbed against the left-hand fork caused the foam to stick together, resulting in deformation of both hands." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "1cf23402-20fc-5949-a30a-12c562eb2d39", "filename": "P02_107_31_c6e03c2415bf383d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall impression: The image is blurry from 0s to 5s, and the text on the packaging appears garbled." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "d18e6432-0bbd-57a6-97d2-e4258876db20", "filename": "P02_108_116_5286ed55d078040a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: During the 1-2 second interval, a stone table appears out of thin air below the person's hand as the viewpoint rotates.", "Time continuity: During the period from 0.1s to 2.1s, the object in the left hand of the person undergoes a sudden change, and the fingers become blurred and distorted." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "f1160e7d-2d6b-52f0-bf88-9a21366bc780", "filename": "P02_108_180_1edef8bcc465376f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 0s-5s In the scene, the dough in the character's hands continuously deforms, and the hands deform and stick to the dough." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "a9fbdc00-b2fd-5a91-b18c-5719042dcc78", "filename": "P02_108_351_4611aba364e6bb0e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "In the continuous time frame from 2.2s to 4.2s, the white object in the character's right hand deforms, abruptly changing from a rectangular object into a round lid, and the right hand's fingers become deformed and blurred." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "be4e645d-5a54-580b-a1ae-d4109feade01", "filename": "P02_108_447_6b7ebbc070e4e336_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: From 0s to 5s, the character's hands and the towel in their hands are blurred and constantly distorted, making meaningless movements. The overall feeling is strange." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "2ecf8cb8-fe52-5096-af1f-019a776d31b8", "filename": "P02_109_149_21af70ea6cb45625_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: In the 0s-5s frame, the red object in the pot keeps blurring, the objects at the bottom of the pot separate and do not blend together during stirring, and the text on the bottle on the right is blurry and unrecognizable, appearing as garbled characters." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "aae14cef-0465-55b0-a3e2-8abbedbd7b19", "filename": "P02_112_82_3b31bfed099ad502_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 1.2 seconds, the character's right hand smears liquid on the plate on the table, causing a large amount of liquid to appear out of thin air, and the hand to deform.", "Overall intuition: From 0s to 5s, the text on the bag on the right side of the screen is blurry and unrecognizable, appearing as garbled characters.", "Overall intuition: The power strips to the left of the blender in the 0s-5s sequence are arranged haphazardly, and their structure does not match reality." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "21f26fa6-8b11-5bd0-8171-c3b9952b27b4", "filename": "P02_112_229_bac682be874c5e16_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 0.2 seconds, the meat sauce spread on the second piece of dough on the plate by the character's right hand disappears into thin air.", "Time Continuity: During the 3.1s-5.2s interval, when the character's right hand is spreading meat sauce on the fourth piece of dough in the plate, the meat sauce appears out of thin air.", "Time Continuity: 0s-5s The meat sauce in the bowl on the left side of the screen blends and becomes blurred, the character's fingers are deformed and stick to the meat sauce 1." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "d38a08a7-ad55-551d-a60c-51dce6fe85ee", "filename": "P02_112_281_249946ecd6b8acb2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 0.2 seconds, the meat sauce in the character's right hand disappears into thin air.", "Time Continuity: At 2.2 seconds, the dough in the character's right hand suddenly flattens and enlarges." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "9c839de1-905a-596b-96f2-f50aac71933b", "filename": "P02_112_318_d91aa6528fd6178b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: The view from the right window flickers between 0s and 3s.", "Overall impression: The image is blurry from 0s to 5s, and the text on the packaging is unreadable." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "4fd83227-dd8e-5077-92aa-a815aada292f", "filename": "P02_113_38_aee945ca72eabcec_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: Between 0.1s and 1.2s, the packaging on the character's left thumb and right hand merges and clips through.", "Time continuity: 2s-. At 2s, the objects poured from the packaging bag begin to stick together.", "Time continuity: From 3.2s to 5s, the contents of the right-hand packaging bag and the packaging bag merge.", "Overall impression: The image is blurry from 0s to 5s, and the text on the packaging is unreadable." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "f3535cf2-7286-5ef5-b750-73b7b22c6e06", "filename": "P02_113_125_2c1e1d9a2ede0a02_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: The glove automatically puts on the hand within 1-4 seconds; the right glove flips irrationally.", "Time continuity: Between 5s and 5.1s, the end of the right glove suddenly separated into two parts." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "9d7100cd-98c3-593f-a8ba-f223b05fee10", "filename": "P02_118_33_8466fd97f10fc4d7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: Between 0s and 0.1s, the juicer rotated itself to the inside of the person's left hand.", "Causal relationship: The juicer started automatically immediately after the character turned on the start switch at 1.1 seconds.", "Causal relationship: Between 2.1 and 2.2 seconds, the object in the person's right hand opened its packaging on its own." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "fa83a2ca-9ea6-5cdd-9cb8-5fdcd2586b5d", "filename": "P02_118_59_87761b1f2e19020d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: Between 0s and 0.1s, the juicer started automatically before the character's right hand had pressed the start button.", "Time Continuity: At 4.2 seconds, when the person's right hand is holding the scissors, the right handle of the scissors suddenly deforms." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "c803a2aa-c69a-5245-8ff9-609964b8e13c", "filename": "P02_118_127_b7bc0fa0f18ee46b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "fb7d9366-f4df-5352-a41f-ff818cabf841", "filename": "P02_118_128_a84ea3834b0c8733_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: From 1.1s to 3.2s, the two gloves suddenly deform and continuously stick together until the left and right gloves are put inside the gloves.", "Time continuity: When the glove undergoes a sudden change and merges around 3.3s-3.4s, there is a noticeable deformation protrusion in the upper left corner, which then retracts.", "Time continuity: At approximately 5.2 seconds, the glove suddenly deformed and stuck together." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "f271c801-00d0-58ae-935a-a81389cb56a5", "filename": "P02_119_15_dbd29910f8e82088_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: At 1.2 seconds, several pieces of yellow, butter-like substance inside the plastic bowl suddenly loosened and scattered relatively evenly throughout the bowl.", "Causality: Between 0s and 0.1s, when the spoon drags the yellow substance to the edge of the bowl, the white particles below should leave drag marks, but this is not shown in the original video.", "Time continuity: The number of objects in the container increases out of thin air from 0s to 2s." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "32aea247-1ee1-5f15-baee-da9396981363", "filename": "P02_121_40_934595e1d8681715_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: At 0.2s, the white film in the video suddenly unfolds smoothly on its own.", "Time continuity: The film at the lower edge of the box suddenly disappears at 4.2s.", "The duration is continuous: at 5.1s-5.2s, the thin film on the upper edge of the box suddenly breaks off and then gradually disappears as the box is pulled apart by both hands.", "Causal relationship: 0.2s-2s, the hand repeatedly lifted and shook without touching the bottom and edge of the box." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "7672b5d4-cd24-53dd-a6a3-69f2ac10952f", "filename": "P02_121_41_ce72f033c32fe2dc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: Between 0.2s and 0.3s, the film above the edge of the box folds up and sticks tightly to the outer wall of the box without being subjected to any external force.", "Cause and effect: Between 5 and 5.3 seconds, the film above the edge of the box spontaneously popped off the outer wall of the box without being subjected to any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "6e684d2b-ac3b-5ee8-9b0c-3fca60448bda", "filename": "P02_121_46_9094d99d7b991bce_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: From 2s to 3.2s, the packaged object gradually changes from incomplete to complete and gradually increases in size.", "Causal relationship: The packaging strip tore off by itself without the hand removing it between 5.1 and 5.2 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "06e8caad-9aa7-5365-b904-bc2c9819f7d9", "filename": "P02_121_47_ef3a0792a59ca8d9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 0.2s, the gray clip on the right hand suddenly turned blue.", "Time Continuity: At 1 second, the blue clip in the lower left corner of the box suddenly clamped the film on the left side.", "Time continuity: From 1.3s to 2s, the clip at the bottom left corner of the box disappears and reappears in the character's right hand.", "Time sequence: A clip appeared in the lower right corner of the box between 3.2s and 4s.", "Time continuity: At 4 seconds, the positions of the clips in the lower left and lower right corners suddenly changed on their own." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "54f7f2ca-0a9f-5fca-b4e6-360031a0809e", "filename": "P02_123_89_5fe576cc8ebc0c2b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality: A torn packaging bag between 4s and 5.2s should have fragments behind it, but the video only shows fragments from the front, which does not conform to the integrity of the object." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "8380696e-52c0-529e-b999-dd4eb648f537", "filename": "P02_123_170_62151ae4407b843f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: Food suddenly appears out of thin air on the wooden spoon at 1 second.", "Time continuity: At 4.2 seconds, the wooden spoon suddenly transformed into a brush." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "d38cf786-5d1c-575b-895f-ecb36984c163", "filename": "P02_123_177_d40610b38558bc5b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: When the cutting board was moved between 1.1s and 2.1s, the cutting board pressed down on the knife, but the cutting board did not bulge or the knife showed no signs of movement; it was as if the knife had disappeared into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "31f71b0e-6998-5477-a80f-485ba46bec2d", "filename": "P02_123_210_1fb8a7d871b343d1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: During the period from 0.2s to 1.2s, the wooden shovel suddenly bends and merges with the glove before disappearing.", "Time continuity: During the process of the character putting on gloves from 1.1s to 2.3s, the two gloves suddenly deformed and continued to deform, gradually incorporating the hand into the state of being put on gloves.", "Causal relationship: Between 3.1s and 3.2s, the pan and spoon moved on their own without touching the pan and spoon in the upper left corner." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "cb6f6875-56e8-59b1-b7a2-f56daa54ec02", "filename": "P02_129_150_595e20947c511dff_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: During the 1-5.2 second interval, when controlling the flame size, a person should be holding the flame button and twisting it left and right, rather than constantly touching the button left and right." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "321eadef-d00d-537f-8126-c6c11185ec32", "filename": "P02_129_174_87c72cf1a33b1a74_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: The knife on the right side of the spoon suddenly disappears at 0.2s.", "Time continuity: At 2.2 seconds, the spoon suddenly transforms into a knife.", "Causal relationship: Between 5.1 and 5.3 seconds, the cabinet opened by itself without the hand touching it." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "9484d722-ea6b-56ec-99fb-88678f04587b", "filename": "P02_129_177_5f0f6a859867e84c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: From 0s to 3.2s, a towel-like object suddenly appeared, sandwiched between the storage box and the inside of the cabinet door." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "aa7af737-8537-5cd3-8f8d-55147b538d8a", "filename": "P02_129_431_460d10ba56f5463e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: From 0s to 1s, the objects held in the character's left and right hands merge.", "Physical behavior: The structure of objects undergoes unscientific changes within 3s-5s." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "837de853-3c05-5ad7-bcc9-58a20a1260be", "filename": "P02_130_244_6e451e0f7f5f0662_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: The lid suddenly shrinks in 1.5s-2s.", "Physical behavior: From 3s to 4s, the lid held in the character's right hand changes from square to round." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "5acec232-be82-5c20-8ac7-28f5bdd68ea4", "filename": "P02_130_93_8ca598927b7a8e87_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: The amount of butter in the pan increases out of thin air in 4-5 seconds.", "Physical behavior: The knife penetrates the can twice during the 2.5s-5s process.", "Physical behavior: The butter in the jar disappears out of thin air from 0s to 2s." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "d9167972-6e76-5288-b48c-c157878713be", "filename": "P30_111_219_d288aee4bb34c84b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous timing: 0.2s-1.1s As the camera zooms in, the symbols around the induction cooker button appear out of thin air; these symbols were not present around the button before this.", "Physical behavior: From 1.1s to 5.1s, the mirror image of the iron pot handle on the induction cooker surface is abnormal. The mirror image is located slightly to the right below the handle, while the mirror image shows the shape characteristics observed from the lower left of the handle.", "The time sequence is as follows: A yellow-green light spot appears out of nowhere on the surface of the induction cooker at 1.2 seconds, and then suddenly disappears at 5 seconds.", "Time Continuity: After 5 seconds, the wounds on the character's arm disappear into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "599fbc5c-87fc-57a8-89a2-a2fc1b3e26d0", "filename": "P30_111_251_5de5056b0021782f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: From 1.1s to 5.1s, the video shows the tip of the person's thumb parallel to the handle of the spatula; the image shown in the induction cooker mirror does not match the actual object.", "Overall intuition: In the 0s-5.2s video, the induction cooker can be seen placed on the stovetop in the lower left corner, with a clear outline and a certain distance from the wall. However, the tail of the induction cooker appears to blend into the wall and tabletop, lacking a clear outline.", "Physical behavior: From 0.1s to 5.2s, the water bottle shows strong natural light on the left, but the water bottle does not cast a corresponding shadow." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "30df3664-3e68-594a-9c6e-b0b7edc83f40", "filename": "P30_111_283_b290c5e3f6f83143_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 0.12s The label on the transparent box is not subjected to force and twists/deforms.", "Continuous time: 0.13s The label suddenly moves from the left side of the box lid to the right side, and the label's shape continuously changes from 0.13s to 0.22s.", "Continuous time: 0.13s-5.2s. As the box is shaken, the quantity of solid food inside continuously increases or decreases, and its size also continuously changes.", "Time continuity: 0s-1s The two round objects in the box become four, and their surfaces become smooth, making them completely different objects.", "An anomaly in the footage: From 0s to 1.1s, the half-open refrigerator door twists unnaturally as the camera position changes." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "c8aca833-ddd4-5412-b7c3-9c01e31968de", "filename": "P30_111_319_5c06974cfa9a4b97_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: 3.2s-42s, the towel and faucet show clipping.", "Overall intuition: From 1.1s to 5.2s, the way the character holds the cup looks strange and unnatural. In the real world, people hold objects with two or more fingers.", "Time Continuity: 1s-1.1s A towel appears out of thin air in the character's left hand." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "e788b1ad-a809-508a-87a6-f22e2d30cd30", "filename": "P30_111_460_55d6cbff38012c7d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: Within 1.1s-5.1s, the food moves on its own before the finger even touches it, and the direction of movement is inconsistent with the direction of the force applied by the finger, which does not conform to physical mechanics." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "1bbd0570-d3c5-506d-b11f-e22221a8531a", "filename": "P30_111_461_e8a59446c08f9002_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 1.1s-1.2s The debris falling from the character's hand continues to coalesce and split in mid-air.", "Continuous timing: 2.2s-3.1s. Small pieces of food poured from the palm onto the grill disappear into thin air during their fall. In the real world, small pieces of food falling onto a grill would fall through the grill mesh, but this effect is not shown in the video.", "Overall impression: The logic of the character's hand scattering small pieces of food from 1.1s to 5.2s is not reasonable. It presents a state of random scattering without a clear purpose and lacks the natural and smooth feeling that should be present in reality." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "4b16b637-41f5-5314-ab98-ecd391fb5097", "filename": "P30_111_463_c424256b706c1b68_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: 0.2s-5.2s. During the process of manipulating the food, the food continuously increases out of thin air, and the shape of the food contracts when no external force is applied." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "898da04a-9c14-5fbd-8960-e762da998121", "filename": "P30_111_499_0efa292a70f6c67c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 0.1s The pot handle disappears out of thin air", "Physical behavior: During the 0s-0.2s process of lifting the tray by hand, the hand only slightly touches the tray, yet the tray is steadily placed into the oven without being affected by gravity, which does not conform to physical mechanics." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "27144b64-6cb6-5357-a956-495ab770b57f", "filename": "P30_111_534_0e43096a4c6126f8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: From 0s to 2.2s, water was continuously poured into the pot, but the water level did not rise, and there was only a small amount of water at the bottom of the pot.", "Causal relationship: When the kitten jumped into the pot at 2.2 seconds, a large amount of water splashed out, but the video shows that there was only a small amount of water in the pot, which is inconsistent.", "Causal relationship: 2.1s When the kitten appeared, it was larger than the pot; 3.1s After the kitten entered the pot, it was noticeably smaller than the pot." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "e2e435aa-b1f5-521f-b1f9-f0626132cea5", "filename": "P30_111_608_001bcd37e12fccbc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: Dust appears out of thin air on the ground in 0.2 seconds and continues to increase." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "c4ea6bd2-b5df-5947-9ce7-7b63a8a56290", "filename": "P30_111_624_ebcab3aab38c3f33_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time sequence: 3.2s-4 The phantom image of another cutting board appears below the cutting board; 4.1s The cutting board in hand disappears into thin air, and the phantom image transforms into a new cutting board.", "Time duration: 4.2 seconds. Water suddenly flows from a tap without any operation." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "75bf322e-d58a-5bc8-976d-e088436a65fa", "filename": "P30_112_3_b9aff79f908219bf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 2.1 seconds, the hand suddenly changes from the shape of the left hand to the shape of the right hand." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "1b26148b-0090-5cd6-aac1-5d7c2ed54c3f", "filename": "P30_113_99_92ffd4488bf3203a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "An overall feeling of unease: the water in the sink seemed to be pulsating and about to boil." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "16da387d-a43b-589c-99db-5ffc669f98ee", "filename": "P35_101_22_2e54cbdbae5d56fd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: 5s-5.2 In the real world, when scissors cut a plastic bag, the plastic bag gradually separates along the point where the scissors bite. However, the sharp corner cut in the video shows the shrinkage and deformation that occurs when burned.", "Time-related anomaly: The color of the upper half of the bag changes from dark to light within 0s-0.8s." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "5cce97e5-6591-5a2f-94d7-7320534e5196", "filename": "P35_103_49_e67667d5e4b41aa6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: At 0.1s and 3.2s, the spoon stopped applying force to the meat strip, but the meat strip defied gravity and flipped over the edge of the pot and fell out.", "Continuous timing: 0.1s Two pieces of meat in the pot are blocked by the spoon; 0.2s When the spoon is removed, the meat pieces have not yet appeared." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "c399827f-b195-587f-96db-48cf43c73458", "filename": "P35_103_166_5d347946d32147cc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: 0.2s. Cloth appears out of thin air in one's hand." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "f05031fa-d623-5bd8-9f35-cd2a19fe1852", "filename": "P35_103_233_6f6ceeb2ca1083f0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 4.2s. When the hand picks up the rag, the lower half of the rag disappears into thin air, and the shape and texture of the rag after being picked up are inconsistent with those before." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "281fa5ea-26c7-51de-bf4c-d06b941e9c99", "filename": "P35_103_235_4183a2599a052d53_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 0.1s. During the process of the character picking up the plastic tray, the outline of the area where the plastic tray is close to the faucet suddenly changes.", "Continuous time: 0.1s-4.2s, the grid in the disc continuously twists and deforms." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "22ded054-438c-5a23-873c-e777e7363ed3", "filename": "P35_104_64_4c52c9241014390e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 0s-1s shows the character holding the handle of a knife, with the shape and color of the object in their hand changing. When the hand is raised, it transforms into another object." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "79652150-b3f5-5988-8ab4-d06fc922b00d", "filename": "P35_104_97_23916bbd635f3922_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: In 0.1 seconds, one finger is vertically positioned, which is inconsistent with the posture of the rest of the hands. This phenomenon violates the posture that human fingers can actually assume.", "Physical behavior: During the 0.1s-5.2s process of rubbing a face towel with fingers, the shape and size of the face towel do not match the force and direction of the hand." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "b0ec3eaa-e4f2-5254-ae06-d3d4a96aa1ec", "filename": "P02_131_8_85056be09c5edc9c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: When the yellow towel is taken out between 1 and 2.2 seconds later, it remains straight and does not droop naturally, which does not conform to the laws of gravity.", "Continuous time: During the process of wrapping the towel, it gradually deformed and suddenly became regular in shape between 3.2s and 4s." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "a2fe5e68-c291-5b6c-b726-d03d884e6e5e", "filename": "P02_131_263_c1ea19c1b314a945_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuous: 0s-2.1s The yellow substance held in the left hand undergoes continuous abrupt changes until it suddenly turns into a yellow rag." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "845f924e-3de6-5aca-9171-1fc73239374e", "filename": "P02_132_41_747bf80a4bea6e46_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: From 0s to 2.2s, while the knife was cutting the same spot on the bread, two knife marks appeared even though the knife's position did not change." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "6136d81e-d262-5fb8-8208-ded34d1c2d3b", "filename": "P02_132_48_535fdc1538602fb6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: At 1.2 seconds, during the process of slicing bread, an extra slice of bread suddenly appeared on the left side of the knife." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "d0e6527f-9403-5edc-bf76-6f4e8d54170c", "filename": "P02_132_50_c00ad0131a3d748f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: If the knife doesn't cut the bread within 2 seconds to 2.1 seconds, the left end of the bread is separated." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "ce58d230-f90a-5a39-be69-14825bbef855", "filename": "P02_132_72_90ebc8379731a1ab_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: Between 0s and 5.2s, there was nothing in the character's hands or the container, but the character seemed to be constantly applying something, which seemed abrupt." ], "glitch_severity": 1.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "90b3fafc-c979-529e-8c0f-7c8bbbba9c15", "filename": "P02_132_74_90326c3fd0540065_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: During the 2s-2.1s interval, the foil below flipped upwards on its own without being touched.", "Time Continuity: From 3s to 5.2s, the foil was initially empty, but after the wrapping action was completed, it appeared that there was something inside the foil." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "cc25dadd-527c-54df-8743-68b2f8361436", "filename": "P02_135_92_b591e54d8957af6a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: During the process of spreading jam on the bread slice from the knife between 1.1s and 5.2s, the amount of jam on the bread slice increased, which was inconsistent with the amount of jam on the knife." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "a0178c6b-00f8-5fb8-80ae-2d11e1986926", "filename": "P02_135_103_1ca975adebe26b43_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: During the process of spreading jam on the bread slice with the knife from 1s to 5.2s, the jam on the bread slice was not spread evenly, and when the process of adding jam began, the amount of jam on the bread slice did not decrease." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "e9487134-4ec5-5f85-bd1e-ec5842ddab98", "filename": "P03_101_269_14f2f73073acf662_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous timing: During the butter-cutting process from 1s to 3.3s, more and more butter is cut." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "0f516468-dde4-512c-bcf3-54e165b7b7fb", "filename": "P03_101_271_f03ab98004d6118b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: At 1.1s, during the process of cutting butter in the video, the butter and the knife suddenly become larger.", "Continuous timing: The butter cut by the knife gradually disappears between 2.2s and 3.2s." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "8877dd3f-8477-528e-8272-3d729aa3e061", "filename": "P03_101_283_d91dd050eb827ec7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "b55c1a93-a262-535f-8270-3ffd1e7bca20", "filename": "P03_101_312_c9e42a2d94d0e7ed_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall, the movement was not smooth: when the right hand released the clothing at 5.1-5.2 seconds, the clothes did not droop noticeably, and the movement appeared unnatural." ], "glitch_severity": 1.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "ea199437-c7ac-573e-beee-e3c84529bf43", "filename": "P03_101_323_076fb2eafbf3f536_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: After the character releases the clothes in their hand between 0s and 1.1s, the clothes automatically hang up." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "a812b7a4-3c7a-5b90-bb39-54707d1c60d6", "filename": "P03_107_46_64b3fb4f929cdf32_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: From 0s to 5.2s, the time on the microwave oven dashboard in the upper left corner did not flow normally, but instead kept changing between 22:07 and 22:00." ], "glitch_severity": 1.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "c0cef036-9b41-52b4-922b-5864e492f107", "filename": "P03_107_90_7086ece14cb81007_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: During the period from 0s to 5.2s, when water continuously flowed into the pot, the water level in the pot did not change." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "df81a1b3-5536-5975-8e77-097c7f17ea71", "filename": "P03_109_21_9b257f00ba149c1a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: During the period from 3s to 5.2s, when water continued to flow into the pot, the water level in the pot did not change.", "Physical behavior: The character suddenly lets go after 5 seconds, but the pot shows no signs of falling even though there is no support, which violates the laws of physics." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "c82075c9-b605-5d1f-8e25-e8ca960294b0", "filename": "P03_109_46_d6eb7e3feef07559_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "During the continuous time frame (1s-4.2s), the spoon was only used to stir the contents of the bowl slightly for a short while, and the large amount of foam in the bowl gradually and noticeably disappeared." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "58815805-5d76-556e-bd58-6a29172a784f", "filename": "P03_109_244_7d988ea8da9cab00_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: Between 3.2s and 4.1s, when the character holds the scissors in their left hand, a clipping phenomenon occurs rapidly between the left hand and the scissors, violating the fundamental physical rule that matter cannot pass through each other." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "69cc9fbc-89d1-5fd1-93dc-e9d29d8654df", "filename": "P03_109_291_6b76ce53b04d2263_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "698206f9-2f3b-5887-95c4-b78c0834a3ff", "filename": "P06_101_39_57e9b429eb0a763b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Temporal anomaly: Within 2s-2.1s, a small piece of the onion's outer skin spontaneously peeled off without external cutting force.", "Time continuity anomaly: Between 4s and 4.1s, the character is cutting a yellow onion, but the onion that falls in the scene is a whole yellow onion." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "272a2c80-ea0f-51d5-862b-45d90bc9d799", "filename": "P06_101_134_a8687dba41c55a29_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent Time Anomaly: In the 0s-2s scene, while a character is processing food on a cutting board with a knife, the food suddenly disappears into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "7c95d524-a250-541f-871c-07a8e2bf7dd5", "filename": "P06_101_389_048468e6c66a6d79_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Temporal continuity anomaly: In the 4.1s-5s frame, the character's hand suddenly changes shape and becomes distorted.", "Intermittent anomaly: Between 1.2 and 4.2 seconds, a pile of orange skin appears in the frame. As the character holds it in their hands, the skin gradually increases in number, and some larger fragments disappear." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "5e23d3d3-e85d-5e17-b994-c314f7d34636", "filename": "P06_102_118_0a09355f5f7fedc7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: Between 3 and 3.1 seconds, the left hand of the person in the scene passes directly through the plastic wrap stick, causing a clipping phenomenon, which violates the principle that solids are impermeable." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "a5cc0e71-1973-52ca-ba1a-3ea7c01e806c", "filename": "P06_103_15_73d2d7f5a9629785_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly: The knife in the drawer disappeared without a trace between 1.2s and 2.1s.", "Interval anomaly: The soup pot in the frame has a lid between 0s and 0.1s, but the lid suddenly disappears at 4.1s." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "7a133941-8198-53a3-bc30-03dbde9ee523", "filename": "P06_103_171_17ed61e60dd55888_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "dbf8b0c8-578c-55f3-9d3d-4d357d0ac580", "filename": "P06_106_45_3a50c019b97eec5c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly: Between 0s and 2.1s, a character is holding a white, blocky food ingredient and grating it on a grater, but no grated food particles fall off.", "Intermittent time anomaly: From 2.2s to 5.2s, a person is seen grating white, blocky food ingredients on a grater. As the grated ingredients fall, some of the fragments that land on the ground disappear into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "4e7d00ce-4f49-5c19-8bc5-c585579e0c50", "filename": "P06_107_29_ca8b1207dec45171_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "3ae40dcd-e918-5e65-8085-699abd54b416", "filename": "P06_108_67_af1dd90706354a80_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly: Between 1 and 1.1 seconds, the character's left hand in the frame suddenly deforms and distorts.", "Interval anomaly: Between 2.1s and 4s, the person takes out two spoons, then suddenly it becomes one spoon; the video is blurry and uncertain." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "11effd91-2083-5f68-a377-a958945e10e7", "filename": "P06_108_113_3b78e10b9b10525b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent timing anomaly: Between 3 and 5.2 seconds, the character moves the gas stove knob to the upper right, after which the knob disappears. The gas stove knob should be fixed in place and cannot be manually moved." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "8bb1f063-7ab8-5639-b975-7b4d54067562", "filename": "P07_101_3_b707221c6fd817b4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time anomaly: Between 0s and 0.1s, two metallic items suddenly appear out of thin air in the character's left and right hands.", "Abnormal physical behavior: A spark is generated when a metal object comes into contact with the gas stove knob between 0s and 0.1s. The simple contact between the metal and the knob directly produces a spark, which does not conform to the core physical principle of spark generation.", "Intermittent anomaly: Between 4.2s and 5.2s, the metal object in the character's hand suddenly disappears into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "6d12b4b1-df2e-5e51-b5f0-aed38838bbc8", "filename": "P07_101_29_b70a45de04eebba8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "6581d24f-0f1e-526c-9ea4-92b3d08b3c32", "filename": "P07_107_57_61112229c2201302_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Timing anomaly: The glass cover displays a red icon of 13 before 0s-0.1s, but the icon after 0.1s is significantly different from the previous one.", "Abnormal physical behavior: Between 5 and 5.1 seconds, a clipping phenomenon occurred between the glass lid, the person's hand, and the bottle opener, violating the principle that solids are impermeable." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "09defd2f-1ccd-56b8-b452-b6c18cec193f", "filename": "P07_110_11_d0d35a5d17011ae3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: In the 0s-0.1s frame, the character initially holds a banana, but the item instantly changes to an orange the moment they raise their hand to pick it up.", "Time continuity anomaly: Between 4s and 4.1s, the character is holding an orange, but when peeled, the pulp inside resembles a lemon, not an orange." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "18208591-00a0-5824-a7d1-ef289bf3eec1", "filename": "P07_110_29_8c99a271f9d4cd2e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "time-series anomaly: cereal that fell from the box onto the table between 1.1s and 5.2s vanished into thin air.", "Time-series anomaly: The upper half of the box, which was white between 1.2s and 5.2s, suddenly turned entirely brownish-red. Simultaneously, without external force, the box automatically folded from a rectangle into a square." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "eefab783-798e-57af-90c9-77249129bc55", "filename": "P07_110_39_00b9f80d347cca55_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "dceec841-21b0-5ec3-880a-bb20b56b2f99", "filename": "P07_113_46_1a4e0a62d11a6cfd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Timing anomaly: Between 3s and 3.1s, the hands of a person in the frame overlap." ], "glitch_severity": 1.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "d4554314-e51e-5ebf-b6b1-6a4caa0f4e7b", "filename": "P07_113_109_4a89712eb436edc6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: In the 0s-0.1s frame, the character only has a small knife in their hand, but suddenly another small knife appears out of nowhere.", "Abnormal physical behavior: Sparks are generated when the knife comes into contact with the cutting board between 2.1s and 5.2s. The simple contact between the knife and the cutting board directly generates sparks, which does not conform to the core physical principle of spark generation." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "8e1a96c4-4130-56ea-843c-91ed2ed7f5ca", "filename": "P09_103_5_d9beda35ce08488b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly: The fingers of the character's right hand appear twisted and deformed between 1s and 1.1s.", "Intermittent anomaly: The peeler on the cutting board suddenly disappears into thin air between 1 and 1.2 seconds." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "65dfc688-80c0-561e-82d7-f51c2a0d0008", "filename": "P09_103_11_3d5dcf160404add7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time anomaly: 0s-0.2s A small piece of chicken breast suddenly turns into three large pieces of chicken breast out of thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "9cda983c-1e1e-5c29-8615-62000e9beb90", "filename": "P04_121_440_8ef651412f6651ba_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: From 4s to 5.2s, half of the edge of the bowl shows a blue effect, and the blue circular reflective arc on the pot does not conform to the laws of physical reflection, presenting an exaggerated effect." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "0d10c3a5-cd3a-56a9-8efb-bdf47b2e016d", "filename": "P04_121_470_aa020cf1caa760d9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "a8674c9f-6e3f-5013-aa3b-536b01374d90", "filename": "P04_121_505_015fcf7a4374bf29_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly: From 1.2s to 5.2s, the spatula in the right-hand pot moved spontaneously without any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "6759b64a-b560-58ba-97bd-dacc1d7812ef", "filename": "P04_121_530_d8e3f67d7025fba3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly in timing: In the 1-1.2 second video, the knife disappears into thin air, and at the same time, the scissors suddenly turn into black clips." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "586222d2-55a7-5f84-a371-7276c0be68d1", "filename": "P09_104_58_53dd714022f0ea16_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly: Between 0s and 0.1s, a small piece of food in the video suddenly splits into two or three pieces of an apple.", "Intermittent anomaly: Between 1 and 1.1 seconds, the character's left hand deforms and twists, then the knife disappears and a juicer appears out of thin air below the right hand, while a banana and a green apple appear out of thin air in the left hand.", "Time Continuity Anomaly: 2s-2.1 When the character picks up the blender with their right hand, a milk carton-like object appears out of thin air where the blender was originally placed, and the top of the blender disappears out of thin air. At the same time, the banana and apple in their right hand fall onto the table and turn into dried bananas, and their right hand becomes deformed and twisted.", "Intermittent anomalies: Between 3 and 3.1 seconds, the juicer contained only apples, but suddenly liquid appeared out of thin air inside, and the blender started rotating automatically. My right hand became deformed and twisted.", "Time-related anomalies: 2-2.3 seconds later, the white flour in the mixing cup suddenly increases out of nowhere.", "Intermittent time anomaly: At 3.2 seconds, a spoon appears out of thin air in the character's left hand, and then disappears out of thin air at 4 seconds.", "Intermittent anomaly: Between 4.2s and 5.2s, a blender lid appears out of thin air on the character's right hand, and the right hand appears deformed and twisted." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "80ef217d-200f-5da7-89d4-c669824884a6", "filename": "P09_104_72_0188fde785ec4046_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition abnormality: 0s-0.1s The second toe and middle toe of the character are connected.", "The timing is abnormal: between 0.2s and 3s, a piece of sausage in the pot gradually disappears, and then the egg that the character takes out of the pot with both hands is broken, with only half of the eggshell remaining in one hand, containing a small amount of yolk.", "The timing was abnormal: between 3 and 3.1 seconds, only half of the eggshell remained in both hands, containing a small amount of yolk liquid. However, when the eggs were suddenly placed into the pot, they turned out to be two intact eggs." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "473e7f96-421b-5b1f-b956-3567b8dfd0b6", "filename": "P11_102_48_66cdb76a029d82ec_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: Before 0.1s-0.2s, the grinding tool was below the blade, but after 0.1s, a die-piercing phenomenon occurred, and the grinding tool suddenly appeared above the blade out of thin air, violating the principle that solids are impermeable.", "Overall, the visual impression is abnormal: In the 0s-5.2s video, the person's feet show many toes, whereas normally there should be five toes." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "6154beee-b4ab-5e50-b4bd-c841368f1f09", "filename": "P11_104_90_379f6b5a060c01df_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: From 0s to 1.1s, the figure's hand and the fish slice undergo a clipping phenomenon, violating the principle that solids are impermeable.", "Abnormal physical behavior: Between 2.1s and 3.1s, the character is holding the fish slice with only one hand, but the other end of the slice is suspended in mid-air, violating the principles of gravity.", "Time-related anomaly: Between 4.1s and 5.2s, when the character places a fish fillet into the pan to fry, two more fish fillets appear out of thin air.", "Overall, the intuition is abnormal: between 4.1 and 5.2 seconds, the person places their hand into hot oil. Hot oil has an extremely high temperature, and direct contact with human skin would cause instantaneous burns." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "96fa7977-d974-5898-bba4-a00e6ae3642e", "filename": "P11_104_174_f9278dd3e303cd24_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly: Between 3 and 3.2 seconds, the person's hand and the Lao Gan Ma chili sauce deformed and twisted.", "Abnormal physical behavior: Within 4.2s-5.2s, the person easily deformed the Lao Gan Ma glass bottle with their bare hands, violating the physical properties of solid materials and common sense about human force." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "120eb5c3-2238-5fba-8c18-84a8727e8226", "filename": "P11_105_18_0731d5dc6fd25fc6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "880191fe-8091-54b6-aeb4-4f280b76d972", "filename": "P11_105_27_15f59ef0444be9bb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent time anomaly: 2-3 seconds after the character throws a paper plate into the trash can, the plate then automatically floats back into the character's hand." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "1887d228-87cd-5a6e-9984-d044ffed6c52", "filename": "P11_107_19_fa0f4f499e08ae0c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: Between 0s and 0.1s, the scissors held in the character's left hand and the fingers of the right hand undergo a clipping phenomenon, which violates the principle that solids are impermeable.", "Timing anomaly: Between 1.1s and 5.2s, the character only cuts one side of the pizza, but the other side also splits, and the entire pizza shrinks, showing inconsistency.", "A continuous time anomaly occurred: between 0s and 5.2s, the pizza's color gradually changed from black to brighter, while the plate also deformed and twisted." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "7355e6e3-6f35-536d-bfee-22303b3bd1e0", "filename": "P11_107_20_a488b600ebf8e0fa_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity Anomaly: 0s-0.1s, the scissors in the character's left hand jump to the right hand without any external force, while the left hand twists and deforms.", "Anomaly in physical behavior: From 0s to 0.1s, the scissors in the character's hand exhibit a clipping phenomenon, violating the principle that solids are impermeable.", "Abnormal physical behavior: From 4s to 5.2s, the character has cut the pizza in half, but the other half does not fall and remains suspended in mid-air, violating the laws of gravity." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "6016cd5f-f2aa-5d6e-be38-ac82cd30413f", "filename": "P12_101_11_eae70477f92b9ea0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "c27945b7-7ed9-5110-ae3b-8a5f65ebe06e", "filename": "P12_101_54_494f3a5f9edbf9b4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The overall impression is unusual: the iron pot in the video from 1.1s to 5.2s is not transparent, but the ignition point of the gas stove can be seen burning from the right side of the pot.", "Overall, the visuals are unusual: from 1.2s to 5.2s, the character keeps turning the gas stove button to the left, maintaining a consistent action, yet the gas stove flame fluctuates in size." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "3957a761-56b2-5e29-a872-27f1f713168b", "filename": "P12_101_251_1aaaade933c2d90a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: From 0s to 5.2s, the food in the iron pot is boiling. The liquid reaches its boiling point and vaporizes violently, which will inevitably produce a large amount of water vapor. When the water vapor cools, it will form visible steam, which violates the laws of physics." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "7e1fe7c8-fac6-52b3-9143-24889461957a", "filename": "P12_101_310_b863a6b478524d26_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent timing anomaly: 2s-5.2s. The foil wrapping around the box is separated from the foil inside the box, but when the foil at the opening is pulled out, the foil inside the box is simultaneously pulled out as well." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "07aae09e-9a21-5f6d-9e3a-e347999ca620", "filename": "P12_101_353_874e3e6960c41f8b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The timing is abnormal: In the 4.2s-5.2s video, the person simply takes a plastic bag out of the drawer, and then, without any external force, a glass bottle inside the bag jumps up and falls down." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "5cae8100-3048-5e8e-83df-0784712339b6", "filename": "P12_101_360_81790ff2c0b9c200_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: 0s-0.2s When the character releases the pot they are holding, the pot rotates to the left on its own without any external force.", "Time-related anomalies: 4s-5.2s, the person's hand released the packaging bag, and the bag floated to the trash can on its own without any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "c6567661-1a30-5106-8651-0f826f70dd75", "filename": "P12_101_484_e1fdafaa37eedcaa_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time anomaly: 0.1s-1.1s A gas stove knob appears out of thin air on the character's hand; when it touches the corresponding position on the stove body, the knob automatically adapts and installs." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "a8372b07-912a-5356-94b5-f31dd9c7b270", "filename": "P03_109_318_24bf90fdcacc85f9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: The wobbling motion of the spread-on bread slice between 3 and 5.2 seconds appears unnatural, leaning more towards up-and-down movement, which doesn't align with the overall direction of force applied to the bread." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "40735a19-031f-5562-a0f5-b4fc77437608", "filename": "P03_109_357_22e8f4e5bcc70a75_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: During the 0s-1s interval, the solid block of butter suddenly transformed into multiple flakes, and the bag containing the butter changed to a transparent box." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "84d15a02-a19f-5426-aab6-423ad2814641", "filename": "P03_109_372_f9a0547118282ba2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: When the bread was completely cut at 5s-5.2s, the right side of the bread moved on its own without being pushed away by the knife, and naturally bounced open." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "3ec9711a-29b2-5a9e-8b15-85b45209adbf", "filename": "P03_111_16_49c3417aaaf75e67_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: Water flowed out on its own during the period of 0s-1.1s without the tap being turned on.", "Overall intuition: The volume of water rising in the container from 0s to 5s is significantly greater than the flow rate of water being injected." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "b2d5bdf9-faf3-545f-bcb9-705155c03259", "filename": "P03_112_96_e070a22994164ebb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: During the boiling process from 0s to 5.2s, the steam did not escape from the kettle spout and around the lid, but instead continuously emerged from the switch, violating the basic physical rules of heat convection." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Other Failures" }, { "id": "ef289501-8cfc-5368-bb60-a71618409a63", "filename": "P03_112_150_f35dc439e8ff6b81_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "During the continuous time frame of 0s-1.2s, the broom suddenly turned into a mop, and the trash on the ground inexplicably disappeared.", "Overall intuition: In the 0s-5s video, it looks more like the mop is controlling the person's movement, rather than the person controlling the mop." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "d343b088-a8aa-5ccc-84d7-5c57cb13397e", "filename": "P03_113_48_ecc89f1395c7b22d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causality: Water flowed into the pot between 0s and 1.2s, but there were no signs of ripples or disturbances on the water surface." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "1fe2871f-bdf1-5f2d-b8db-e211326eb53b", "filename": "P03_117_218_16502d99e2351f4f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical anomaly: During the process of spreading butter on the bread slice with the knife between 2.1s and 5.2s, the amount of butter on the bread slice increased significantly, exceeding the amount on the knife." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "c4141102-68c0-57bf-9af4-69797c641dad", "filename": "P03_117_220_11e08d81d136fb0e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical anomaly: Between 0s and 2.5s, the butter on the bread slice increased out of nowhere, while the amount of butter on the knife was significantly less.", "Continuous timing: From 3s to 5.2s in the video, the amount of butter on the underside of the knife remained unchanged when it was taken out of the butter box, and this also did not change during the buttering process." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "30f04267-4249-53d9-99db-3b9b3157ee1d", "filename": "P03_119_19_03b3c12383cd3826_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: Water was flowing continuously from the faucet from 0s to 3.1s, but water began to appear in the dish after 3.2s." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "5085a3ab-a04b-52ca-950e-e7c8c2456c55", "filename": "P03_120_3_7c85cff5a25ef5bf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: At 1.1 seconds, clipping occurred between the character's fingers and the book, violating the fundamental physical rule that matter cannot pass through each other.", "Physical behavior: Between 1.1s and 3.2s, there is no corresponding virtual image of the kettle in the microwave oven in the upper right corner, which violates the basic physical rules of specular reflection." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "49190880-1ded-5c5c-846d-bc2d72c03355", "filename": "P03_120_93_c77a764d013797e9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: There was noticeable screen flickering at 0.1 seconds.", "Overall intuition: noticeable screen flickering occurred at 5.2 seconds.", "Time continuity: From 0.2s to 2s, a yellow substance suddenly appeared in the bowl, and the amount of the yellow substance that fell out suddenly increased." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "ded246cf-54a0-5c89-8d25-7eeca8c0747e", "filename": "P03_120_107_ff99d342fdb155c7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "5f38ffd7-b21e-5493-a85c-26cf0b74af58", "filename": "P03_121_17_7438308a8df02b20_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: Yellow powder appeared out of thin air between 0s and 4.2s and increased in quantity." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "e8f69199-0694-5317-ba70-c733e73b461d", "filename": "P03_121_62_099215c8c89ef5f6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: At 1.2 seconds, the numbers on the microwave oven's dashboard suddenly flashed even though the microwave oven was not started.", "Physical behavior: The amount of yellow substance in the basin increases out of thin air from 0s to 5s." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "977a5657-e753-5468-8849-eae8af632c34", "filename": "P03_123_4_a9334390e20faf08_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: When the spoon was removed from the yellow liquid between 3.2s and 5.2s, there was no trace of yellow liquid adhering to the spoon, which does not conform to a causal relationship.", "Physical behavior: The amount of yellow substance in the basin increases out of thin air from 0s to 5s." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "e37f37ca-21c8-5b01-9bd0-73b373d11e43", "filename": "P03_123_16_5e7211dcd3a4efdf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: Between 0 and 0.1 seconds, the video suddenly flickers, transitioning from blurry to clear.", "Physical behavior: From 0s to 0.8s, the character's right hand clips through the container." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "5bbe817b-389e-5ef3-914a-2f5d2ed6b0a8", "filename": "P04_102_10_fb9d7b18bb4505d3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 3s-3.2s The pattern of the character holding the box suddenly changes." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "c373d7c9-55b8-58de-9202-229468d5d521", "filename": "P04_106_109_d65292f24b2e8104_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 4s-5s, the ring on the character's left ring finger disappears into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "5a253f7d-8e94-5409-a22c-259445907d2f", "filename": "P04_107_168_b1684dcdf4aa725f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: During the period from 0s to 0.2s, the left hand did not have much contact with the object, yet a large number of objects moved with the left hand.", "Time continuity: At 1.1s, a wad of cotton suddenly appeared in the left hand, and the two pieces of paper in the right hand suddenly turned into two regular cylindrical objects.", "Time continuity: At 4.1 seconds, a wad of cotton suddenly appeared inside the cylindrical object above.", "Time continuity: At 5.2 seconds, a new cylinder suddenly appears to the right of the two cylinders." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "78e0bed6-24f7-5df5-bb13-de8f55f714cb", "filename": "P04_107_328_0ef61777df5c80f1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: Between 0s and 1.1s, the rolling pin and the right hand experience a piercing phenomenon, which should be independent of each other, violating the principle that solids are impermeable.", "Temporal continuity anomaly: Between 0s and 1.1s, the character's right hand deforms and twists, resulting in a sudden change.", "Timing anomaly: During the 0s-5.2s interval, the screen initially shows only a small amount of dough, which gradually increases in quantity as it is rolled out with a rolling pin." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "c87f0bf8-debd-5006-9b9f-473411c37e02", "filename": "P04_107_354_4e7748a34ef819ac_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The timing is inconsistent: between 2s and 3.2s, the figure only lightly rotates the rolling pin once, and then the dough increases dramatically without any transition. The physical operation of rolling dough should be a gradual and progressive process.", "Abnormal physical behavior: Between 4.2s and 5.2s, the figure's left hand and the rolling pin undergo a clipping phenomenon, which should be independent of each other. This violates the principle that solids are impermeable." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "4ecc2186-7078-548c-8370-cedd631ad98b", "filename": "P04_107_405_bc093441d06e111d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: 0s-0.2s Initially, there is only a small amount of dough with a small area, but suddenly the area of the dough increases and the amount of dough increases out of nowhere.", "The timing is abnormal: from 2.1s to 5.2s, the figure only holds the top edge of the dough. The dough is not cut by any external force, but rather torn, yet it breaks cleanly in the middle, with a neat break as if caused by a knife, which violates the principle of mechanical action on the dough." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "93ab4a13-d96a-5b97-a307-357ada767e0f", "filename": "P04_107_615_80e7b0e2cbd56d84_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "9f468344-7827-5bff-ad63-f1f9594d6bef", "filename": "P04_107_689_d8b57a30d8421e93_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: From 0s to 5.2s, the left thumb of the person in the video appears bent and deformed." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "fc8dc418-d468-5a84-856d-b6567c1d989b", "filename": "P04_107_844_a14adda509924415_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: 0s-5.2s The character is rolling out a small dough ball with a rolling pin. After only one roll, the dough ball increases in size significantly. Rolling out dough should be a gradual and progressive process." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "0d705ce9-7cba-50f0-a386-c48de7e2279b", "filename": "P04_108_42_71c7eb21b98d01dd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "a98bcfda-8ef4-587f-9498-32255b4ac883", "filename": "P04_109_138_02a21fca291edcdb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The timing is abnormal: from 0s to 5.2s, when the cucumber ring was being cut, the blade had not yet applied any force, and the cucumber broke in the middle without any external force; subsequently, the blade only completed one cutting motion, but a large number of cucumber shreds appeared out of nowhere in the footage." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "5daff9b0-bdda-55a4-85a9-e83da196333a", "filename": "P04_109_234_954f8bec3f013410_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time-related anomalies: During the period from 0s to 3s, while the character was grabbing pumpkin and carrot shreds, the pumpkin shreds that had fallen from the bottle onto the table disappeared into thin air.", "Intermittent anomaly: During the period from 0s to 5.2s when the character is grabbing pumpkin and carrot shreds, the pumpkin shreds in the bottle gradually decrease out of thin air, while the carrot shreds gradually increase out of thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "dba3af3b-82d0-508f-9831-5991bc3770dc", "filename": "P04_109_312_b96e0912ddf0ea37_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall, the visuals are off: from 2s to 5.2s, the character doesn't actually tear the membrane; they merely touch the broccoli membrane, and then it tears, lacking any sense of force." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "351d4a4f-b11e-5232-9552-1ad0267c0a72", "filename": "P04_109_395_79e7cb2657a9191d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly: From 3.1s to 5.2s, the lower half of the refrigerator's handle disappeared, followed by twisting and deformation.", "Intermittent time anomaly: The refrigerator light was yellow between 0s and 4s, and suddenly turned blue just before the refrigerator door closed." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "77cf9452-9999-5626-84a5-233924e1ae76", "filename": "P04_109_438_cfa2648f37faee78_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: From 3.2s to 4s, the character's left hand becomes distorted and abruptly changes shape, becoming very blurry." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "a97c8e91-198e-54fd-9750-30d4d8506249", "filename": "P04_110_109_273fcf24cf795b96_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: Before opening the lid in the stainless steel pot between 0 and 0.2 seconds, the food inside is clearly visible with no signs of steam escaping. However, at the instant the lid is opened (0.2 seconds), a large amount of steam suddenly bursts out, violating the physical laws governing steam release." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "ea92c889-a948-501b-85b7-3d391a1a9e83", "filename": "P04_110_200_7636b51b1aaa41e3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous anomaly in time: 0s-5.2s. Both the bottom of the pan and the gas stove surface are flat. According to physical laws, the cooking oil should be evenly distributed on the bottom of the pan, but instead, the oil flows abnormally down the sides of the pan." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "7cd3cb5d-fffb-5f5f-a80e-a0c556733cdb", "filename": "P04_113_2_938d875a4eca20b1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "80389556-ff18-5f30-babf-c3e853eb56f6", "filename": "P04_113_169_a288a06243c7df55_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "f239780d-1b63-5766-b42a-167a03e5db15", "filename": "P04_113_179_99eee426a7e49cdd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time-related anomaly: From 0s to 5.2s, the character was simply plugging in the power cord, and the water in the pot was shaking on its own without any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 2.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "e0126bb5-7433-586d-ae76-9c06ad9c2bda", "filename": "P04_113_224_a38fafa2d2d339a9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall, the visual effect is off: the action of the character spreading sauce on the pancake between 4s and 5.2s does not match the area of sauce on the pancake; the area of sauce on the pancake is larger than the area spread by hand." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "613d7a49-0a79-5a22-86bb-da6407f864cf", "filename": "P04_113_407_99e898d45f6c866d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall, the visual impression is abnormal: from 0s to 1.1s, the entire surface of the stove appears noticeably distorted.", "Time continuity anomaly: The knife the character is wiping is small before 0s-1.1s, but suddenly becomes large between 1.1s-5.2s." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "38a72abf-597f-5d30-bf43-a7cc3922dcbf", "filename": "P04_113_433_edb06f70cfad8838_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "A time-series anomaly: In the video, between 3 and 3.2 seconds, when the brush touches the soap on the stove, the soap suddenly disappears into thin air.", "Time-related anomalies: From 0s to 5.2s, a shovel-like object floats in mid-air when the character releases their grip." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "649b9d49-5667-5b6d-86e0-e0517ae1f2eb", "filename": "P04_113_434_d969a22e9e9c4020_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous duration: 1.3s-5.3s, a pink object appears out of thin air at the head of the brush.", "Continuous duration: 1.2s-1.3s, powdery objects appear out of thin air next to the brush.", "Overall intuition: 1.2s-5.3, the character's feet are oddly shaped and have no foot shape." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "e1aa1c30-f075-5dbc-ad9c-3a89180f58e6", "filename": "P04_113_507_901fff4dfa130ce1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 0.2s-1s, the character lightly touches the object, but a deep cut appears on the object.", "Overall intuition: 1.2s-5.3s, when the character is slicing the object, there is a prying motion, but there are only cut marks on the object, and no part of it is pried up." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "392e4edc-f610-5608-ad11-ffdda33a152d", "filename": "P04_115_49_529e31318c065d42_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "d24b7c65-290f-5895-915c-15a1466a2650", "filename": "P04_116_111_2121f5ef49de255a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: 0s-1.1s, the black spoon next to the hand suddenly moves without being subjected to any force.", "Overall intuition: 0s-5.3s, when stirring a viscous substance in the pot, the substance in the pot does not move with the stirring of the spoon." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "4f4dc3b7-e953-52be-bd9a-a41aae6fe3a8", "filename": "P04_116_142_bde378ff50125e6f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time interval: 0s-0.3s, many yellow viscous substances suddenly appear in the pot." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "cead7134-9b9f-51f8-86dd-8973c7fe7034", "filename": "P04_116_169_7730b25837e07dcb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The duration is continuous: 1.1s-5.3s. In the video, the bottom of the spice bottle is facing the pot, not the part of the spice bottle that is being sprinkled with spice. However, a large amount of brown spice appears out of nowhere in the pot." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "2c75a5a4-108d-580c-9892-12024da016ed", "filename": "P04_117_48_daedd11cbff5cbe2_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "c7adb746-0fd8-5731-9c3b-2b1e9b8d58b0", "filename": "P04_119_24_f52d6da77154d972_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The duration is continuous: 1.2s-2s. The steel ring on the notebook in the right hand disappears, and a steel ring appears where there was no steel ring." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "fa989af6-0435-59d0-921f-6040c67761fe", "filename": "P04_119_148_798120eb046ef868_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: 0s-1.1s, the cabinet door closes without any force applied." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "22338270-ceb8-5500-a5a6-dcee87f83675", "filename": "P04_119_230_f017c70d93dd0beb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "912f8d46-647d-5eb8-b720-7f319d2124a6", "filename": "P04_119_253_97f03b97163b7b39_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: 0s-5.3s. In the video, the hand clicks on a button on an appliance without actually clicking the button itself. In reality, to select a function on an appliance, you must click the corresponding button to make the machine work." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "2295128c-841a-5afc-82f4-72c4f84d9a19", "filename": "P04_119_265_eadce31310d52518_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: 0.2s-1.1s, the water in the cup increases and becomes cloudy.", "Continuous time: 4.1s-5.3s, hot steam suddenly comes out of the pot, but the thermometer needle does not move." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "aa7dd78c-469a-5c34-8fa8-9753ceeb52d4", "filename": "P04_120_11_16d03b340d13217d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: 3s-3.2s, the spoon in the right hand merges with the spoon on the table to become one spoon." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "4ba548fc-cae5-5c4e-8500-43d70b55e501", "filename": "P04_120_145_5995cbbfee8ec66d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuous: 0s-5.3s, the white box in the cardboard box next to the pot containing white liquid continuously deforms." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "86658a6c-e65e-552c-8a38-0a66c9328425", "filename": "P04_120_222_1922ee417f3ab578_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: 0.1s-5.3s. The video shows a steel wool scrubbing a cutting board, but the entire board gets wet. In reality, a steel wool scrubber doesn't contain enough water to wet an entire cutting board; only an absorbent item like a cloth could do that.", "Overall intuition: 0.2s-5.3s, the light reflected from the cutting board is too bright, reflecting light even before it is fully wet. The cutting board is made of wood and will not produce a very bright light when wet." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "fa03b352-1043-5459-8671-b24d153211a6", "filename": "P04_120_239_cdc8caf466c82bdc_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: 4.1s-5.3s, the character's left hand passes through the transparent basin, resulting in a clipping phenomenon." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "f9ffb392-3507-5953-a79a-00687b032d97", "filename": "P04_121_27_172946becd329d55_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: 0s-0.1s, a white knife appears out of thin air in the right hand.", "Overall intuition: 2.3s-5.3s, the location of the knife mark on the white substance in the pot is inconsistent with the location where the knife was cut." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "ef7d9234-ed3d-5e43-bf94-e0ad3cf8195b", "filename": "P04_121_104_7ac78d4a80d6c373_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "654abbad-5cdb-5b1b-aae2-69803247215b", "filename": "P04_121_272_ad6f7cb0a063c58a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: 0.2s-5.3s. In the video, the water flow is completely falling into the basin and does not flow out of the basin. However, water flows through the basin on the left and into the sink, causing a dangling phenomenon." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "68250432-4bb0-51a6-a7e1-9cf36cf0fac0", "filename": "P04_121_438_5174c2a7006657f5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: 0.1s-1.2s, the white substance in the basin increases and the water decreases.", "Overall intuition: 4.1s-5.1s, the white object remains stationary at the edge of the basin when it is tilted significantly." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "6ce18561-9a11-5b6b-a09c-96037d9a4962", "filename": "P35_104_206_5af2275caf0a2ed1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: 0s-0.1s Before the hand touches the plate in the pool, the plate defies gravity and moves upward with the hand.", "Time Continuity: 0.1s The outline of the larger, dark blue plate at the bottom of the pool shrinks out of thin air.", "Causal relationship: 2.1 seconds later, no water flowed from the faucet, but the plate below showed a large amount of water flowing onto it." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "d8819001-2928-54c6-bfe4-784d0156efbc", "filename": "P35_104_234_04d0749af19e5abe_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 0.2s-1.1s The outline of the black cat's front paws is distorted and deformed.", "Overall intuition: The action of the white cat jumping up and the character reaching out to catch it in 5 seconds presents an inverted effect, and the movement logic does not match reality." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "bc2c4730-16f4-5e5a-b979-4cc028da5566", "filename": "P35_104_240_eca5746da9df4c37_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: After the white powder in the spoon was poured into the pot in 3.2 seconds, the spoon changed from an oval shape to a round shape.", "Continuous time: 4.1 seconds. When the spoon enters the pot to stir, the size of the food has increased significantly compared to before.", "Causal relationship: From 0s to 5s, the water in the pot boiled violently, but no steam was produced. In the real world, boiling water would produce steam, and the amount of steam would increase with the intensity of boiling." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "910a0f4f-cba2-598e-bd5c-8ba95bca5675", "filename": "P35_104_266_cd0c5c2341b0c4da_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 0.1s. The upper right corner of the towel appears out of thin air and then disappears out of thin air again." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "2b2f98f1-e6cd-55dd-97b5-ae3c748cfd3d", "filename": "P35_104_280_2f352341a1d4a63b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: From 0s to 0.1s, the label on the red cap appears out of thin air and moves to the center of the cap. During this process, the label is not subjected to any force and its shape continues to twist and deform, violating the laws of physics.", "Cause and effect: At 0s, the towel completely covers the right hand and appears larger; at 0.1s, the towel, without being folded, suddenly shrinks, indicating an inconsistency in size between the front and back.", "Physical behavior: During the 4.2s-5.1s flipping process, the red lid had already detached from the hand, yet it fell downwards without being affected by gravity, which does not conform to the physical law of gravity.", "Time Continuous: After the red lid is flipped over, the label on the lid appears out of thin air in your hand." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "05213351-643f-5c3c-a0d1-1b9aefa52fef", "filename": "P35_104_291_2e1f637b1cbb42ed_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: The spoon being inserted into the pot and stirred within 0.1 seconds causes the liquid inside to rotate, but in the video, the liquid inside the pot begins to rotate on its own immediately after the spoon enters the pot and before any stirring is performed." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "213cbde0-ea50-5f71-ac16-02e84f51dbc2", "filename": "P35_104_367_a903c6d0aa7a2cd8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: At 0.2 seconds, when the right hand passes over the left hand, the two hands do not touch, and there is no action of passing an object. However, the ball in the left hand appears in the right hand, which does not conform to the laws of physics." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "f7616a72-e9d5-5272-a1d6-b8bda162f096", "filename": "P35_104_438_06f464b144636a9d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 0.2s, the character's right hand is oddly shaped, inconsistent with the characteristics of a normal human hand in the real world; at 3.10s, it changes to a left hand.", "Physical behavior: From 1.2s to 5.2s, the hands are holding the items inside the iron basket, without touching the basket, yet the basket is lifted, which violates the laws of physics.", "The duration is continuous: 3.1s-5.2s. During the process of the plastic basket falling, part of the plastic basket disappears.", "Physical behavior: The red and blue pieces flipped on their own without any external force from 4.2s to 5.2s, which does not conform to the laws of physics." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "b802f67e-d58d-58ec-9f9a-9d25a277c23d", "filename": "P35_104_450_abc7c1770ce456a7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: The liquid in the pot boiled violently from 0s to 5.2s, but there was no flame on the gas stove under the pot, which is inconsistent.", "Physical behavior: In the 0s-5.2s video, the shadows of objects indicate that the only light source is from the upper left, while the reflections from the sink and the wall indicate that there is a light source from the upper right, which contradicts each other." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "e7af60ec-d5d3-54e9-9ef2-6da76f473857", "filename": "P35_104_675_db59b729555fe4c5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: 0.2s The top edge of the roll of paper suddenly becomes serrated; 4.2s-5.2s A layer of paper suddenly appears on top of the roll of paper and its shape continues to change." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "f966ee77-e04e-5ffe-8633-dab526eec264", "filename": "P35_104_676_e914583be3d2c137_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: The deformation of the paper as it is crumpled in the hand from 0s to 5.2s is unnatural and inconsistent with the deformation of paper in reality as a force is applied by the hand." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "8a052c73-bbc4-5f30-bd09-1c9ac7ca98b8", "filename": "P35_104_691_ebf7a4e28908410f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: 0.2s-1s, the deformation at the lower end of the paper shell disappears; 1.1s-2.2s, the paper shell continues to twist and deform." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "794d442d-4f7e-5b86-a6a9-ad027af6db57", "filename": "P35_104_697_9e6303fae0f53a1e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: The desktop wallpaper continuously twists and deforms from 0.2s to 4.1s.", "Continuous duration: 1.2 seconds. Untorn plastic wrap appears out of thin air below both hands.", "Time Continuity: 4.2s When the left hand picks up the piece of meat from the plate, plastic wrap appears out of thin air above the meat." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "50358479-fffd-525d-8374-24c204a278fb", "filename": "P35_104_700_e98b78f09f403c44_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 1.1s. When the character picks up the red lid, a blue lid appears out of thin air beneath it.", "Time Continuity: 2s-2.1s During the process of picking up the sponge-like object with the right hand, the object transforms into a cardboard box containing a white object." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "9e3d2a77-003a-57d7-b53d-701883c36cc5", "filename": "P35_104_704_f83a3adfddf4c7ec_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall intuition: Within 0.2s-1s, the cardboard in my hand twists and deforms, its shape changing from clear to blurry.", "Continuous duration: 1.2s-5.2s As the plastic wrap is used as a rag to wipe the table, it continuously disappears and reappears." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "2c4d9b1a-7585-5971-8bec-34019e5c6d28", "filename": "P35_104_709_bb397278955e0f3a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: From 1.2s to 2.1s, the meat block is not subjected to any external force, and its local shape changes spontaneously, which does not conform to the laws of physics.", "Physical behavior: Within 2.1-2.2 seconds, the cling film bounces up on its own, wrapping the meat, violating the laws of physics.", "Physical behavior: After 3.2 seconds, the hand had already left the meat block, and without any external force, the meat block flipped and deformed on its own, violating the laws of physics." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "89c23e32-d951-543d-b291-5cf7c18539ab", "filename": "P35_104_712_70a13e8d527e0636_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: The plate flies upwards to the hand on its own in 1-1.2 seconds without any external force, which does not conform to the laws of physics and mechanics." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "9dd64c1d-7e30-5245-9da6-29f8c5ecffb7", "filename": "P35_104_715_479de4c388af0470_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: The opening on the cardboard suddenly closes after 0.1 seconds.", "Time continuity: 2.1s-4.1s, the paper shell twists and deforms and disappears into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "a47c56af-cc2a-5bbc-a313-a693ae393a87", "filename": "P35_104_726_213c5d9e8fdf48a0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: The opening on the cardboard suddenly closes after 0.1 seconds.", "Overall intuition: The side of the cardboard continues to twist from 0.1s to 1.2s.", "Physical behavior: When tearing cardboard by hand, the cardboard first twists unnaturally and then quickly breaks apart, taking 3.1s-5.2s. In the real world, tearing cardboard by hand manifests as the cardboard gradually tearing according to the point where force is applied by the hand." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "b9db3fbe-4c1a-5629-8724-2d7a31999c19", "filename": "P35_104_730_74b4144975033aa8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 0.2s When the hand picks up the meat piece, the plastic wrap underneath suddenly appears on top of the meat piece.", "Time Continuous: 1.2s Plastic wrap appears out of thin air in the left hand" ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "70ef0a7a-faf0-5bf6-b896-7333eee4e703", "filename": "P27_105_252_46bd01be7aea9884_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly: Between 5.2 and 5.5 seconds, after folding the paper with both hands, the creases and the folded shape disappear out of thin air when the fingers are removed from the paper." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "e147f2c3-7a01-520e-a99f-3bafc53d291f", "filename": "P27_105_261_c00c8e4c3eb2e9ff_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly: Between 0.0s and 3.3s, the wrinkles on the tin foil packaging in the video disappear without a trace and become smooth.", "Time continuity anomaly: At 0.1 seconds, an object wrapped in a tissue on the table suddenly transforms into a white object.", "Abnormal physical behavior: The foil on both sides folds up on its own without any external force between 3.2s and 5.2s." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "dfbf43c6-ceac-5a7e-8394-591c7fa92d63", "filename": "P27_105_265_18f5f81aea543589_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: Between 0.1s and 0.3s, the white item in the character's hand disappears into thin air and is replaced by an item wrapped in tin foil.", "Abnormal physical behavior: 1.1s-3.1s, the tin foil folds back into the person's hand without any grasping force." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "62b24413-6211-5718-8424-f32e962e8333", "filename": "P28_101_40_9c6cc02b62d8070d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time-related anomalies: 3.2s-5s, the banana peel that the character threw into the trash can disappears into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "fd08da0a-305e-588f-ad1c-25b620abf45a", "filename": "P28_101_68_bc18ec4cb24fbd62_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent time anomaly: Between 2.2s and 5.2s, the wrapping paper in the character's hand vanishes into thin air and transforms into a white spherical object." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "389e47ae-674a-5587-a0dc-a1a81b7d1dc1", "filename": "P28_101_71_2ca39f2ce03a381c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall, the intuition is abnormal: the way the character tears the plastic bag between 1.2 and 5 seconds does not match the opening of the plastic bag." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "dc9a26ea-1bf8-59db-b197-11056cb5e247", "filename": "P28_103_121_eb31a2ca76fc3847_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Anomaly in causality: 1.1s-5s A large amount of onion from the cutting board was grabbed and put into the bowl, but the quantity increased.", "Abnormal physical behavior: The onion is suddenly attracted to the character's hand after 4-5 seconds, which is inconsistent with physical behavior." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "89e47156-12f4-51db-8abd-705fb100922a", "filename": "P28_103_161_0ca77dfd242a2237_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "b6a9625f-2354-5b2e-96d6-537b10f82ac2", "filename": "P28_103_167_3e0155f58922a695_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "c7e6d965-c858-5774-b5fb-31bc82f722dd", "filename": "P28_103_194_eacabf8d7a4e4df8_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: 1.2s-5s The knife in the character's hand is cutting vertically, and the object is cut into long strips horizontally without any external force.", "Intermittent anomaly: Between 2 and 5 seconds, the number of cut strips in the character's hands inexplicably increases." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "5c5df8d9-0dfb-5124-aa00-66db923d676d", "filename": "P28_103_289_0b4ca78f8f9a2c2e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: At 3.1 seconds, a pot lid appears out of thin air in the character's hand.", "Cause and effect: From 2.2s to 2.3s, the upper right handle of the pot moves to the right without any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "e34358dd-da63-55dd-a523-aea72aa23399", "filename": "P28_104_122_cf46d20729cfd17e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "5aec7bd6-96d2-5545-abe3-f2ba16bf00e7", "filename": "P28_104_157_2b4e91772ff24ffd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: From 4.2s to 5.2s, some hot steam did not come out of the pot, but instead came out of the pot lid that the character had opened.", "The overall feeling is abnormal: after opening the lid after 3-5 seconds, the boiling of the pot becomes even more pronounced, which defies common sense." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "e1b76348-f2ac-561b-9850-c06f43d334aa", "filename": "P28_105_8_d9b7a90f4e168ced_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time-series anomalies: 4.1s-5s, one potato in the spoon disappears out of thin air, then the number of potatoes decreases from three to two, and finally another potato reappears out of thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "6297047b-1567-5f68-a2c9-58d3010b9aae", "filename": "P28_105_40_3937ab210964d78f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: The refrigerator door opened to the right on its own without any external force during the 0.0s-1.2s period.", "Continuous time anomaly: 3.1-4.0s, boxed items in the lower compartment of the refrigerator disappear without a trace." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "a7afc756-72d3-528a-9278-4082cf9e2013", "filename": "P28_105_75_eb2d25939f8e7faf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: At 1.0s, the object in the character's hand changes from a black spoon to a black bowl out of thin air.", "Abnormal physical behavior: 1.0s-5.0s, the black bowl floats in the character's hand without any gripping force." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "5f2b0842-501b-5e6d-a15b-9a041816cf82", "filename": "P28_108_46_1c21ae1f03839e87_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal anomaly: Cheese crumbs appeared without contact between the left-hand cheese and the right-hand scraper within 0.0s-5.2s." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "23901acc-9112-5c2c-b7a8-e9ea740784fb", "filename": "P28_110_7_ff771de3fd9dd785_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: Between 4.2s and 5.2s, after a character takes some clothes out of their pocket and puts them into the washing machine, the number of clothes in the pocket does not change." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "26b556b5-d7cb-53ce-808c-ae98694dd566", "filename": "P28_111_149_9b1c75e5c4373002_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: From 0.0s to 4.0s, the pink object on the left sways left and right without any external force.", "Time continuity anomaly: Water from the tap continuously flows into the container from 0s to 5.2s, but the amount of water in the container remains unchanged." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "7a7df0a5-7bc3-51ad-bc96-2832ed1035b9", "filename": "P28_111_156_c7b321445f9c0ba7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent anomaly: Between 0.2s and 1.0s, the left index finger of the person in the video appears to merge with the pot." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "9c2a7fdc-16ce-54b3-80aa-bf4e9309c57e", "filename": "P01_102_113_babb379c10836c19_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: During the handwashing process from 0s to 2s, the fingers of both hands show signs of fusion and twisting deformation." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "ae279a79-aaea-56ca-b362-17a4ab25422c", "filename": "P01_102_117_3799ecce1897a87e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: During the wiping process from 0s to 5s, the fingers appear distorted, deformed, and blurred." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "d88f9e01-c5b0-516c-b9eb-0dac6d1ff7ea", "filename": "P01_104_3_592b19e3e375f65d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: Distortion and artifacts appear during the movement of the left hand in the video from 0s to 0.2s.", "Continuous timing: At 1.1s-1.2s, the right thumb and the edge of the towel begin to fuse together, and the thumb becomes twisted and deformed.", "Time duration: 3.2s-4s. The messy towel in my hand suddenly becomes neat." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "0b7acfcb-487c-55e8-ac8c-9700038e462d", "filename": "P01_105_76_30c1fcc614565a35_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: From 0s to 5s, only the first time the cucumber was cut, the knife was cut from above. However, in subsequent cuts, the knife was not lifted above the cucumber, yet complete cucumber slices were still produced, which is inconsistent with reality.", "Time interval: 4.1s-6s. The knife did not cut the cucumber, but cucumber slices kept appearing on the cutting board." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "4958aefe-5885-55e3-9532-a1830caaebda", "filename": "P01_105_235_7d01e9dbf9c15b20_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 0s-5s When cutting an object on a cutting board with a knife, the object's volume suddenly increases, and the number of cuts does not match the number of cuts on the object." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "7d60554e-065e-5503-afc3-3542bbeb904f", "filename": "P01_105_239_9bf1aeace7c084ef_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: From 0s to 5s, the scene shows a knife rubbing against a cutting board, during which the potato seemingly multiplies and splits into many small pieces.", "Time Continuity: The potato in the left hand suddenly deforms without being cut during the 1-2 second interval.", "Time continuity: After 5.2 seconds, as the hand lowers the knife, the fingers of the right hand merge with the knife." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "dd94bc4d-cae6-5168-8daf-719f06e343dd", "filename": "P01_105_264_3edd594b6c52126c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 1.2 seconds, the hand and towel in the video clip through each other, and the fingers become deformed.", "Time continuity: At 2.1 seconds, the hand and towel in the video clip through each other, and the fingers become deformed.", "Time continuity: At 4 seconds, the hand and towel in the video clip through each other, and the outline of the fingers becomes blurred." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "ddc07e4a-9eb0-5ccc-aee4-223f0a7af2db", "filename": "P01_105_738_fb6bbabdd0e60c5d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: During the 0s-1s interval, artifacts appear across the entire video frame.", "Time Continuity: At 1 second, a large amount of food and a pot suddenly appear out of thin air on the table on the right side of the screen, and the pot handle and spatula handle merge together. The green object on the table disappears out of thin air.", "Time continuity: At 2 seconds, the right hand is deformed and the outline of the fingers is blurred.", "Continuous time: At 4 seconds, the right hand deforms and the outline of the fingers becomes blurred, and the towel twists and deforms." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "5f183d2a-ae00-53e3-9e0e-966401d4a297", "filename": "P01_106_146_74770cc9d40625be_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall impression: The text on the 0s-5s packaging is blurry and contains garbled characters.", "Time continuity: At 2-3 seconds, the right hand becomes stuck together, and the fingers and the blue box clip through.", "Time Continuity: At 2 seconds, the blue box placed in the refrigerator by the right hand merges with the blue box inside the refrigerator.", "Physical behavior: At 5.2 seconds, the right thumb clipped through the box." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "4cadee0e-f5c1-526b-a7de-96db11906e7b", "filename": "P01_106_233_cdc637b47067452a_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: At 0s, the left hand fingers and the towel clipped through each other.", "Overall intuition: Between 2.1 and 5 seconds, artifacts appear in the towel in the hand, the right hand and the towel clip through each other, and both hands become distorted and blurred." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "a2175e9e-f41a-532f-8059-24e389c08e42", "filename": "P01_106_243_e562bbeddbcc56f9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous duration: 0.1s. The right index finger and the towel in the hand merge.", "Overall intuition: The shadow on the floor at 2 seconds does not match the shape of the towel.", "Time continuity: At 3.1 seconds, the shadow of the towel changes to the shadow of the left hand.", "Continuous duration: 4.1s-5.1s. The towel in the hands continuously deforms and blurs, and the outlines of the hands also become distorted and blurred." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "8e4b994d-9e16-5ade-8cbc-add9c8aad47f", "filename": "P01_108_5_fedbace56eb4b0f0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: Right fingertips sticky and blurry during 0s-0.2s", "Time continuity: During the period from 1.1s to 4.2s, artifacts appeared due to the towel splitting and deformation, and clipping occurred multiple times between the fingers and the towel.", "Continuous time: From 4s to 6s, the towel, which was not folded by the hand, suddenly transforms into a neat square folded towel." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "69014b5d-6cdd-5cbc-bed8-e892f9a79630", "filename": "P01_109_165_0326944abcac026c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The time interval is continuous: the hand and the towel merge during the period from 0s to 0.2s.", "Time Continuous: At 3 seconds, the left side of the towel deforms, and its color changes from light to dark blue.", "Continuous time: Between 3 and 5 seconds, the human hand and the towel merge multiple times, causing the hands to become deformed and blurred." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "f19bc5b8-6ec9-5963-bf6e-1916bac7d45a", "filename": "P01_109_211_4929ec23228871a3_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "f6dabb83-c6c1-5012-86a0-987b669e8321", "filename": "P01_109_271_ea9c0304c5b0c186_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 0s, the fingers of the left hand became stuck together.", "Continuous time: During the period from 0s to 0.2s, the black trash can lid floats up and down without any external force.", "Time continuity: 1.1s. An unidentified object appears out of thin air on the right hand." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "e1421ca8-62c0-561a-a5de-66c6f824a718", "filename": "P01_109_309_cbe8544a1ab04cbd_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: Deformation of the left thumb occurs between 0s and 0.1s.", "Time sequence: From 0.1s to 0.2s, the chopped onion pieces in the left hand suddenly transform into onion chunks.", "Time sequence: At 1 second, an onion chunk appears out of thin air at the tip of the knife in the right hand, and then disappears out of thin air when the knife falls.", "Time Continuity: At 1.2 seconds, the knife in the right hand slices towards the onion piece on the right, disappears into thin air, and then reappears.", "Time Continuity: At 2 seconds, the onion piece pinched by the left thumb fused together.", "Time continuity: At 2.1 seconds, the tip of the knife in the right hand fused with the onion.", "Time continuity: The onion pieces on the cutting board blurred and merged during the 4.1s-5s interval." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "fcd627a9-c9bb-53b9-bfbe-790463ac369b", "filename": "P01_109_367_801471c732e57b9c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Cause and effect: When the egg was broken in half by hand at 2-3 seconds, the shell did not crack, and the yolk was evenly distributed in both halves of the shell." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "16bbea05-48b2-58af-8cea-475cbafc70fd", "filename": "P01_109_425_e2ddc881aa635e8c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: The outline of the character's left foot is blurred during the 0s-0.1s interval.", "Continuous timing: The left foot deforms between 1.1s and 1.2s.", "Overall intuition: My feet felt strange between 1.2 and 3 seconds; my socks seemed to be glued directly to the soles of my shoes.", "Continuous time: When a person squeezes a green object in their hand for 3-5 seconds, a clipping occurs between the hand and the green object, causing the green object to break into fragments and deform." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "9d666dfc-96df-5257-b28b-23376cdbe930", "filename": "P01_109_468_43ed60f74f8ef5d9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: The towel picked up by the hand deforms during the 0s-0.2s interval.", "Time Continuity: During the period from 0s to 5s, the person holding the towel deformed their hand multiple times, and the towel also deformed multiple times." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "e3711098-6422-5800-9afb-9fbae9acb56d", "filename": "P01_109_783_c9d7a897f1828a56_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: At 0s, the right hand and the towel in its hand are deformed and blurred.", "Overall intuition: The shadow of the person's head on the table between 0s and 2.2s is strange and does not match reality.", "Physical behavior: During the 2s-5s interval, when the character turns left, their body clips through the table." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "b49dc5ef-e094-53f0-b697-9ee6d58afc62", "filename": "P28_111_199_92c7d0ce81912b1e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent timing error: There is no transition between the 3.1s and 5.2s video frames, and the outer packaging image is abnormal." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "0539ab3a-6495-58af-ac98-9c7ffaee4cb0", "filename": "P28_111_203_d618853c86d2dd86_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: In the 0.0s-1.0s video, the bag containing the item in the person's hand closes automatically without any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Causal Sequence Violation" }, { "id": "fa91040b-e8f1-5b77-aaf1-588c2de03f65", "filename": "P28_112_72_62383abf9f0ad657_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent time anomaly: 0.1s-1.3s A green rag appears out of thin air on the character's right hand." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "4402da5e-f40b-5e1c-b74b-4c8ee1dbe940", "filename": "P28_112_77_7019cea5689c7299_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: 0.1s-2s The object in the person's hand disappears into thin air, leaving only the hands washing.", "Cause and effect: From 0.0s to 4.0s, the pink object on the left sways left and right without any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "20fc0a73-ebc2-5f33-a2ef-db26ffa25a10", "filename": "P28_113_134_32859922741ab9bb_processed_h", "has_glitches": 0, "reasoning": [], "glitch_severity": 0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "No Issue" }, { "id": "0ac01738-7a6a-50e3-855c-e0322b519786", "filename": "P28_113_139_540cee08a34eb97f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent time anomaly: 0.1s-1.0s A kitchen knife appears out of thin air on the character's right hand.", "Time-related anomalies: 2s-5s: When the character is chopping scallions, the scallions don't break but instead appear as small pieces." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "9b1810b6-fee5-58a3-b285-8e19235a3101", "filename": "P30_101_107_ac583877b61829d1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: Water from the tap continuously flows into the container from 0s to 5.2s, and the container is full but does not overflow." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "499b9ac7-b3b6-51f0-9114-a10071341716", "filename": "P30_104_73_b7b375be4b1c1bc5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Abnormal physical behavior: In the 0.0s-5.2s video, water does not flow from the tap but instead flows from the plate into the sink." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "ae37e211-a2c6-5754-88b9-a1df68b8534f", "filename": "P30_104_84_3b254db2c08e998b_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Interruption of time: There is no transition between 0.1s and 0.2s in the video, and the scene changes without any continuity." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "9b83c459-185b-5718-a1af-543a991ca98c", "filename": "P30_104_88_3059c3a3f6579090_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: 1s-5s, the surface texture of the object in the character's hand changes out of thin air, from three-dimensional to smooth and finally to horizontal stripes." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "af414fb4-2b22-5455-ab6f-a8c6e41dc4c9", "filename": "P30_104_117_448392e2c5e8cc8d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: In the 0.5s-1.2s video, the pink sponge appears in the person's left hand without any external force." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "4e004ae8-3ce9-5871-9fde-14529920f1c9", "filename": "P30_104_123_2558b753a121f4b6_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: A scene change occurs in the video at 0.1s without any transition.", "Time anomaly: From 0.1s to 1.4s, the green rag in the character's right hand and the text on the cup disappeared into thin air.", "Abnormal physical behavior: The cup remains suspended in the pool without any external force between 2.1s and 5.0s." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "54d84d32-de31-5fd9-afa0-dff6738e01fb", "filename": "P30_104_136_bb9070f93f1559c4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent time anomaly: 1.0s-4.0s The rag in the character's hand disappears into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "bc057a43-a4e0-5cde-a26f-27f4730c4925", "filename": "P30_107_54_3026d02bd42bd4bf_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent time anomaly: 0.1s-0.2s, the cup in the character's hand disappears into thin air.", "Intermittent timing anomaly: Between 2.2s and 5.0s, there is no transition between shots in the video." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "985f63f6-41b8-5468-b030-c22b853944ea", "filename": "P30_107_86_4efe6c9bedeb2444_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent timing anomaly: Between 0s and 0.2s, there is no transition between shots in the video, and the rag in the person's hand changes." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "1525123f-3c3a-54da-bbb1-b1ca59361039", "filename": "P30_107_96_e4fb6c0295cad84e_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: Between 0s and 2.0s, there is no transition between shots in the video, and the shape of the object in the person's hand changes." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "ac79cb26-949b-5e10-aa0e-cea3e103f8f7", "filename": "P30_107_147_02ae01157d5a6933_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Timing anomaly: At 1.1 seconds, there is no transition between shots in the video, and the texture of the plastic box in the person's hand changes." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "f7544d16-281c-53b3-b7cf-3db636c88979", "filename": "P30_107_214_221a127e894ab1ce_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Intermittent time anomaly: 2.1s-3.0s, the vegetables in the character's hand disappear into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "7987725e-4007-51b6-a9f1-793a409e5a2b", "filename": "P30_107_265_6b9874c6dac9ac2d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "The timing was abnormal: from 0.0s to 5.2s, the left hand continuously removed carrot shreds from the cutting board, but the number of carrot shreds on the cutting board did not decrease." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "697ff025-c1ec-54c8-a08e-3315d3420d7c", "filename": "P30_107_362_fb7ac62b0bef3de7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity anomaly: 1.2s-5.0s The mushrooms in the left hand have been completely cut off, but the knife is still cutting mushroom slices out of thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "bb0a42bb-29e6-558d-ba40-7d774e6e315d", "filename": "P35_104_762_cb4de7718b0c684f_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: Within 4s-5.2s, the plastic disc, without any external force, is thrown into the air and suspends there, continuously tumbling, which does not conform to the law of gravity.", "The time sequence is continuous: 0.2s-0.27s. The textured surface of the lunchbox lid, the label, and the buttons around the edges disappear into thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "ba16eb1c-7fac-5849-8ad1-6dd1a169a525", "filename": "P35_105_2_5b968481a4d5087c_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous duration: 5s-5.26s. The originally normal right hand continuously twisted and deformed, eventually exhibiting the shape characteristics of a left hand.", "Physical behavior: During the 2.1s-2.25s interval, the rag is thrown down with the right hand. The rag does not collide with the chair back below during its fall; instead, it passes directly through the chair back and disappears, which does not conform to the laws of physics." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "49c32ba5-ebb8-56e5-be44-30f4806abc72", "filename": "P35_105_9_7505a98b60a18a74_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 2.2s-5.1s. A plastic fruit plate with a larger top opening and a smaller bottom opening is being turned and wiped. The bottom opening gradually increases in size until it eventually becomes the same size as the top opening. In the real world, solids do not deform without reason under normal circumstances.", "Continuous time: 0s-5.26s. During the wiping of the fruit plate, the cloth gradually shrinks without being folded." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "b4c60787-63cd-5cee-b1e9-2c2a48d04631", "filename": "P35_105_61_2dcd2af969f11e93_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Overall Intuition: 0.2s-5s In the real world, the process of peeling plastic wrap off food involves pinching the plastic wrap from one end, and then the plastic wrap gradually separates from the food as the hand moves. However, in the video, the plastic wrap appears to move on its own, inconsistent with the force applied by the hand." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "3a2ebd05-ae6c-5c93-8d12-bb316612388f", "filename": "P35_105_136_cc292dc248dd73d7_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous duration: 1.1s-4.2s. During the process of rubbing hands together, twisting and deformation, finger breakage, and clipping occur, with debris appearing and disappearing out of thin air.", "Physical behavior: During the rubbing of hands together from 1.1s to 4.2s, the debris that appears around the hands does not fall down due to gravity, but instead adheres to the area around the hands and moves irregularly, which violates the laws of physics." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "4cba981f-8325-59d5-9af9-3c9fc4c1afe7", "filename": "P35_105_137_315039f7200947d0_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous duration: 2.1s-2.2s. During the upward movement of the left hand, the hand appears to twist and deform, with some fingers fading and then reappearing out of thin air.", "Physical behavior: During the 4.1s-4.2s interval, the fingers did not pinch the snack bag, but the snack bag that was being pressed showed a trajectory as if it were being dragged forcefully by the fingers, which does not conform to the laws of physics." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "91ae3ea1-0fae-541d-8549-26d9edfa575f", "filename": "P35_105_139_e3079e4c16be3b16_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous duration: 0s-0.1s The ignition button on the gas stove below the finger appears and disappears out of thin air.", "Continuous duration: 0.2-1.1s. Visual effects include finger distortion, blurring, and an increase or decrease in the number of fingers." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "a923b859-2d5f-504e-b890-33cba9a05a86", "filename": "P35_107_24_b71d1b96e0d418b9_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: 3s-4.1s. A vertical wooden board in the lower left corner exhibits visual effects such as distortion, blurring, and tearing." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "32cf35b8-709a-5465-a058-30c30f030c1b", "filename": "P35_107_136_b2000258034e87a1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 4.2s-5.26s The cloth in the hand partially appears and disappears out of thin air." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "74bb40be-afa6-5343-a025-7f1701ea7762", "filename": "P35_107_145_594a8658fca5d317_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuous: 0.1s-1.1s The wire-like object in the palm of the hand twists and deforms, its number changes abnormally, and finally it passes through the fingers and appears below the fingers.", "Overall intuition: When picking up the spoon with both hands in 2.1s-3.1s, it presents the visual effect of the spoon appearing to materialize out of thin air in the hands, which is inconsistent with the effect of reaching out and picking up a spoon in the real world." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "3896185c-f3f2-5037-87c6-dea9e214b08b", "filename": "P35_107_239_d920028633c54326_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Causal relationship: In the 0s-1.1s video, water suddenly flows out of a gate valve faucet even though the switch is not touched.", "Overall intuition: During the water rinsing process from 2.2s to 5.26s, the entire surface of the grid disk was severely bent and deformed, and its shape and texture were completely changed, which does not conform to the characteristics of displaying solids in the world being rinsed by water." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "aa710fa3-7bb6-5075-a51f-a0de960c743f", "filename": "P35_107_331_86d13ae6ac1d0141_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "In the video from 0s to 5.26s, during the kneading of dough by both hands, the shape of the dough changes arbitrarily and does not follow the movement of the fingers. Some areas suddenly increase or decrease in size. In the real world, the shape of dough is affected by the force of the hands, and it will stretch or compress with the fingers, while its overall volume remains constant." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Material / State Inconsistency" }, { "id": "07ad9559-bbba-54a2-8f4b-e1f9db1c7ca4", "filename": "P35_108_174_d392889b239be248_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous timing: 1s-1.2s A clipping phenomenon occurs between the upper right corner of the cutting board and the sink.", "Cause and effect: After the 2-4 second cutting board was placed in the sink, it appeared to float slowly and randomly on the surface of the water, but the sink showed no water. This is contradictory." ], "glitch_severity": 3.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Geometric / Collision Violation" }, { "id": "e4b14273-7392-5bcf-b4f1-6e7e2fe11ec0", "filename": "P35_108_211_d5f90343573ce0d4_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time continuity: 0s-0.1s, a fork appears out of thin air in the left hand.", "Continuous duration: 1.1s-5.26s. During the process of rubbing the fork with fingers, a large amount of foam appears out of thin air near the contact surface between the fingers and fork." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Object Permanence Violation" }, { "id": "6fc886e0-f1da-5c3b-bcdb-86fb46537dfa", "filename": "P35_108_267_4a97ba77d70a7170_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Time Continuity: 0s-0.1s As the left hand picks up the glass, the shape of the glass distorts and changes, then it passes through the fingers from the back of the hand and appears in the hand.", "Time Continuous: 1.1s-5.26s A clipping occurs between the right hand's fingers and the glass, and a large amount of clear water spontaneously forms inside the glass." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "1bb7dbd3-23a8-5b4e-aa06-e168c19a1497", "filename": "P35_108_277_2c50f65d7115f9a1_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: From 0s to 5.26s, when the water flowed onto the hand and the bottom of the sink, there was no corresponding splashing effect. In the real world, when water comes into contact with a solid surface, it will splash in all directions due to inertia.", "Continuous duration: 4.1s-5.26s A large amount of water appears out of thin air in the palm of the right hand, rinsing the cup.", "Continuous duration: 5.1s-5.2s. During the cup's inversion process, after the rim is turned down and then flipped back up, the rim is suddenly sealed off like the bottom of the cup." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "268f22cd-b33c-5093-9dd4-bf1631678b22", "filename": "P35_108_408_5b13ed13cd7231a5_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "From 0s to 2.2s, the shape of the white cloth in the hands changes randomly. This change is not related to the movement of the hands. In the real world, when a flexible material is kneaded by a hand, the change in shape is determined by the direction and magnitude of the force applied by the hand." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Temporal Coherence Breakdown" }, { "id": "718ef80d-dbf7-5bb6-968d-b371cd7e5000", "filename": "P35_108_516_88b84e77f20fe794_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: When the water flow impacts the bowl from 0.2s to 1.1s, there is no splashing effect; instead, it appears to disappear into thin air. In the real world, when water hits a solid surface, it splashes out in all directions due to inertia.", "Physical behavior: From 1.1s to 2.2s, the transparent fruit plate and pot suddenly move violently, but no force corresponding to their movement is shown in the video. This movement violates the laws of physics." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Force & Motion Inconsistency" }, { "id": "23afbe99-10c0-5ff2-9e92-5e17d3755650", "filename": "P35_108_582_4f78440b10a95d19_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Continuous time: 0s-0.05s, the very tip of the faucet disappears into thin air.", "Physical behavior: From 0.1s to 5.26s, water flow impacts the hand and sponge, but there is no splashing effect; instead, the water disappears directly. In the real world, when water flows into a solid surface, it will splash in all directions due to inertia." ], "glitch_severity": 5.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" }, { "id": "af8f6910-4383-5bf3-96f4-cc06367d9ff9", "filename": "P35_108_588_9e46eca0cb81830d_processed_h", "has_glitches": 1, "reasoning": [ "Physical behavior: From 0s to 5.26s, when the water flow came into contact with the hand and the sponge, there was no splashing effect. Instead, the water passed through the object and continued to appear below it. In the real world, when water comes into contact with a solid surface, it will splash in all directions due to inertia." ], "glitch_severity": 4.0, "model": "Hailuo 2.3", "Glitch_Category": "Contact / Interaction Failure" } ]