{ "model_name": "style-discriminator-v1", "model_version": "1.0.0", "created_at": "2026-08-09T00:18:28Z", "seconds": 172.5, "compute": { "device": "cuda", "framework": "scikit-learn + policy rollouts", "hist_gradient_boosting_max_iter": 400, "extra_trees": 120, "rollout": { "warmup_events": 12, "max_new_events": 40, "temperature": 0.8 } }, "data": { "battles_total": 30306, "min_card_plays": 12, "train_battles_used": 2000, "eval_battles_used": 512, "feature_dim": 67, "train_policy_id": "policy_bc_v2", "train_policy_path": "models/policy_bc", "eval_policies": [ { "policy_id": "policy_bc_v2", "path": "models/policy_bc" }, { "policy_id": "policy_bc_v3", "path": "models/policy_bc_v3" }, { "policy_id": "policy_bc_v4", "path": "models/policy_bc_v4" }, { "policy_id": "policy_bc_v4_1", "path": "models/policy_bc_v4.1" } ], "splits": [ { "split": "train", "battles": 21216, "team_win_rate": 0.5046662895927602, "mean_events": 64.98670814479638 }, { "split": "val", "battles": 4545, "team_win_rate": 0.5152915291529153, "mean_events": 64.86314631463146 }, { "split": "test", "battles": 4545, "team_win_rate": 0.5036303630363036, "mean_events": 64.97623762376237 } ] }, "transfer": { "trained_on": "policy_bc_v2", "fit": { "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "n": 3980, "mean_score_real": 0.9996667004489418, "mean_score_fake": 1.2997944183712571e-05, "log_loss": 0.00023050082506624803, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "mean_P_human_ai": 1.2997944183712571e-05, "mean_P_human_real": 0.9996667004489418, "n_train_rows": 3383, "n_val_rows": 597, "hgb_iterations": 400, "boost_curve": [ { "iteration": 0, "train_loss": 0.693109372900105, "val_loss": 0.6931165177447659 }, { "iteration": 5, "train_loss": 0.4918102958292081, "val_loss": 0.4920230890776124 }, { "iteration": 10, "train_loss": 0.36040997518329, "val_loss": 0.360900348698101 }, { "iteration": 15, "train_loss": 0.2691602556062363, "val_loss": 0.27021266359246726 }, { "iteration": 20, "train_loss": 0.20354958079587715, "val_loss": 0.20510106744017306 }, { "iteration": 25, "train_loss": 0.15547465066625638, "val_loss": 0.15760619269826356 }, { "iteration": 30, "train_loss": 0.11940975024307342, "val_loss": 0.12220674008656313 }, { "iteration": 35, "train_loss": 0.09217570925295884, "val_loss": 0.09549091780736593 }, { "iteration": 40, "train_loss": 0.07150678319968151, "val_loss": 0.07522928938354072 }, { "iteration": 45, "train_loss": 0.05553596413331744, "val_loss": 0.05975811274431469 }, { "iteration": 50, "train_loss": 0.04322740852237203, "val_loss": 0.04780994749597585 }, { "iteration": 55, "train_loss": 0.03370958231235492, "val_loss": 0.038622116326156745 }, { "iteration": 60, "train_loss": 0.026372960422448494, "val_loss": 0.0313471056227048 }, { "iteration": 65, "train_loss": 0.020637451048205364, "val_loss": 0.025840688052363385 }, { "iteration": 70, "train_loss": 0.01609902766245408, "val_loss": 0.021231909952337015 }, { "iteration": 75, "train_loss": 0.012604612310352013, "val_loss": 0.017929053466669113 }, { "iteration": 80, "train_loss": 0.009877353709190883, "val_loss": 0.01538110347625261 }, { "iteration": 85, "train_loss": 0.00775854943077564, "val_loss": 0.013372742216746624 }, { "iteration": 90, "train_loss": 0.006102237940709022, "val_loss": 0.011756151500677268 }, { "iteration": 95, "train_loss": 0.00480540181675105, "val_loss": 0.010586658923556778 }, { "iteration": 100, "train_loss": 0.003792675277589494, "val_loss": 0.009451968251049226 }, { "iteration": 105, "train_loss": 0.0029970837878097057, "val_loss": 0.008557652930869571 }, { "iteration": 110, "train_loss": 0.0023774752838063096, "val_loss": 0.007989106192608437 }, { "iteration": 115, "train_loss": 0.001889013816766433, "val_loss": 0.007402354202028638 }, { "iteration": 120, "train_loss": 0.0015070937124677833, "val_loss": 0.007010222563300616 }, { "iteration": 125, "train_loss": 0.001205775669100487, "val_loss": 0.006665366949784567 }, { "iteration": 130, "train_loss": 0.0009706258246974283, "val_loss": 0.006394451689316959 }, { "iteration": 135, "train_loss": 0.0007841243277665089, "val_loss": 0.00619573761262395 }, { "iteration": 140, "train_loss": 0.0006371692318249895, "val_loss": 0.00603355470778546 }, { "iteration": 145, "train_loss": 0.0005208946591135901, "val_loss": 0.005657861010906525 }, { "iteration": 150, "train_loss": 0.0004288472747792278, "val_loss": 0.005544871793012365 }, { "iteration": 155, "train_loss": 0.0003554803101273231, "val_loss": 0.00530224963152945 }, { "iteration": 160, "train_loss": 0.0002972380877082798, "val_loss": 0.005044170113845216 }, { "iteration": 165, "train_loss": 0.0002503533943022274, "val_loss": 0.00495277820754729 }, { "iteration": 170, "train_loss": 0.00021253174175928975, "val_loss": 0.004785648012540685 }, { "iteration": 175, "train_loss": 0.00018219448118021598, "val_loss": 0.004685767608960454 }, { "iteration": 180, "train_loss": 0.0001573328544749512, "val_loss": 0.004473479291487709 }, { "iteration": 185, "train_loss": 0.00013701418265431135, "val_loss": 0.0044364390414202105 }, { "iteration": 190, "train_loss": 0.000120273730349729, "val_loss": 0.004270866562471038 }, { "iteration": 195, "train_loss": 0.00010638595512791868, "val_loss": 0.004134763794334566 }, { "iteration": 200, "train_loss": 9.479510594724199e-05, "val_loss": 0.004109419968821381 }, { "iteration": 205, "train_loss": 8.505149009657734e-05, "val_loss": 0.0039548251196041655 }, { "iteration": 210, "train_loss": 7.682320362410447e-05, "val_loss": 0.0038466112108490056 }, { "iteration": 215, "train_loss": 6.983400512889947e-05, "val_loss": 0.003749949508657339 }, { "iteration": 220, "train_loss": 6.373978701109458e-05, "val_loss": 0.0035954612594839078 }, { "iteration": 225, "train_loss": 5.847677142402047e-05, "val_loss": 0.0035032422924403143 }, { "iteration": 230, "train_loss": 5.387576936471329e-05, "val_loss": 0.0033864642871212994 }, { "iteration": 235, "train_loss": 4.986426216117523e-05, "val_loss": 0.0032606005656775597 }, { "iteration": 240, "train_loss": 4.633685746196849e-05, "val_loss": 0.0031881440522057575 }, { "iteration": 245, "train_loss": 4.322943657751398e-05, "val_loss": 0.0030784015643866795 }, { "iteration": 250, "train_loss": 4.046522107945488e-05, "val_loss": 0.0030078099181556103 }, { "iteration": 255, "train_loss": 3.798801603906332e-05, "val_loss": 0.0029086489023929943 }, { "iteration": 260, "train_loss": 3.578065188787323e-05, "val_loss": 0.002814366629759113 }, { "iteration": 265, "train_loss": 3.381434109500507e-05, "val_loss": 0.002758940103960996 }, { "iteration": 270, "train_loss": 3.20012759305877e-05, "val_loss": 0.002682514571502908 }, { "iteration": 275, "train_loss": 3.0345956481586908e-05, "val_loss": 0.0026324525631308657 }, { "iteration": 280, "train_loss": 2.8854276966399822e-05, "val_loss": 0.002559395163349587 }, { "iteration": 285, "train_loss": 2.7489457280316457e-05, "val_loss": 0.002485402786617479 }, { "iteration": 290, "train_loss": 2.6213760477508085e-05, "val_loss": 0.0024305127595293675 }, { "iteration": 295, "train_loss": 2.5071386562567076e-05, "val_loss": 0.0023811747381379807 }, { "iteration": 300, "train_loss": 2.4011844525449984e-05, "val_loss": 0.002343137501996454 }, { "iteration": 305, "train_loss": 2.304562307180654e-05, "val_loss": 0.0022968969203075586 }, { "iteration": 310, "train_loss": 2.212835416040209e-05, "val_loss": 0.0022596057130301124 }, { "iteration": 315, "train_loss": 2.129887772194083e-05, "val_loss": 0.0022075240835058513 }, { "iteration": 320, "train_loss": 2.0509104025879856e-05, "val_loss": 0.002187824347401671 }, { "iteration": 325, "train_loss": 1.9778960317196043e-05, "val_loss": 0.00213823417395602 }, { "iteration": 330, "train_loss": 1.9103513637160395e-05, "val_loss": 0.0021092148689514727 }, { "iteration": 335, "train_loss": 1.8462622631635608e-05, "val_loss": 0.0020649988877649793 }, { "iteration": 340, "train_loss": 1.785745400367523e-05, "val_loss": 0.002041089879312135 }, { "iteration": 345, "train_loss": 1.7295000722892493e-05, "val_loss": 0.002006405258815194 }, { "iteration": 350, "train_loss": 1.6768346653452823e-05, "val_loss": 0.0019826789507435653 }, { "iteration": 355, "train_loss": 1.6270793279307614e-05, "val_loss": 0.0019572009982950496 }, { "iteration": 360, "train_loss": 1.579568726506638e-05, "val_loss": 0.0019207899263754512 }, { "iteration": 365, "train_loss": 1.53476864027097e-05, "val_loss": 0.0018909332342581654 }, { "iteration": 370, "train_loss": 1.492574415847879e-05, "val_loss": 0.001861275446023599 }, { "iteration": 375, "train_loss": 1.4529219094353577e-05, "val_loss": 0.0018429117166414118 }, { "iteration": 380, "train_loss": 1.4137680356542614e-05, "val_loss": 0.0018073603455124674 }, { "iteration": 385, "train_loss": 1.3779097241029502e-05, "val_loss": 0.0017908012099039305 }, { "iteration": 390, "train_loss": 1.3436912107424757e-05, "val_loss": 0.0017706693140136652 }, { "iteration": 395, "train_loss": 1.3109579074945578e-05, "val_loss": 0.0017400793835980026 }, { "iteration": 400, "train_loss": 1.279147559282277e-05, "val_loss": 0.0017159798393116881 } ] }, "eval": [ { "policy_id": "policy_bc_v4", "policy_path": "models/policy_bc_v4", "panel": "transfer", "trained_on": "policy_bc_v2", "acc": 0.9980372914622179, "auc": 1.0, "n": 1019, "mean_score_real": 0.9960417781296925, "mean_score_fake": 7.310015739154003e-05, "mean_P_human_ai": 7.310015739154003e-05, "mean_P_human_real": 0.9960417781296925, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "detect_rate_at_0.5": 1.0, "human_likeness": 7.310015739154003e-05, "score_histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05, 0.1, 0.15000000000000002, 0.2, 0.25, 0.30000000000000004, 0.35000000000000003, 0.4, 0.45, 0.5, 0.55, 0.6000000000000001, 0.65, 0.7000000000000001, 0.75, 0.8, 0.8500000000000001, 0.9, 0.9500000000000001, 1.0 ], "real": [ 1, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 509 ], "synthetic": [ 507, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "policy_id": "policy_bc_v4_1", "policy_path": "models/policy_bc_v4.1", "panel": "transfer", "trained_on": "policy_bc_v2", "acc": 0.9980372914622179, "auc": 1.0, "n": 1019, "mean_score_real": 0.9960417781296925, "mean_score_fake": 7.074711287262004e-05, "mean_P_human_ai": 7.074711287262004e-05, "mean_P_human_real": 0.9960417781296925, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "detect_rate_at_0.5": 1.0, "human_likeness": 7.074711287262004e-05, "score_histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05, 0.1, 0.15000000000000002, 0.2, 0.25, 0.30000000000000004, 0.35000000000000003, 0.4, 0.45, 0.5, 0.55, 0.6000000000000001, 0.65, 0.7000000000000001, 0.75, 0.8, 0.8500000000000001, 0.9, 0.9500000000000001, 1.0 ], "real": [ 1, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 509 ], "synthetic": [ 507, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "policy_id": "policy_bc_v2", "policy_path": "models/policy_bc", "panel": "transfer", "trained_on": "policy_bc_v2", "acc": 0.9980372914622179, "auc": 1.0, "n": 1019, "mean_score_real": 0.9960417781296925, "mean_score_fake": 1.5289149273327188e-05, "mean_P_human_ai": 1.5289149273327188e-05, "mean_P_human_real": 0.9960417781296925, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "detect_rate_at_0.5": 1.0, "human_likeness": 1.5289149273327188e-05, "score_histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05, 0.1, 0.15000000000000002, 0.2, 0.25, 0.30000000000000004, 0.35000000000000003, 0.4, 0.45, 0.5, 0.55, 0.6000000000000001, 0.65, 0.7000000000000001, 0.75, 0.8, 0.8500000000000001, 0.9, 0.9500000000000001, 1.0 ], "real": [ 1, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 509 ], "synthetic": [ 507, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "policy_id": "policy_bc_v3", "policy_path": "models/policy_bc_v3", "panel": "transfer", "trained_on": "policy_bc_v2", "acc": 0.9980372914622179, "auc": 1.0, "n": 1019, "mean_score_real": 0.9960417781296925, "mean_score_fake": 1.3331757304089826e-05, "mean_P_human_ai": 1.3331757304089826e-05, "mean_P_human_real": 0.9960417781296925, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "detect_rate_at_0.5": 1.0, "human_likeness": 1.3331757304089826e-05, "score_histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05, 0.1, 0.15000000000000002, 0.2, 0.25, 0.30000000000000004, 0.35000000000000003, 0.4, 0.45, 0.5, 0.55, 0.6000000000000001, 0.65, 0.7000000000000001, 0.75, 0.8, 0.8500000000000001, 0.9, 0.9500000000000001, 1.0 ], "real": [ 1, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 509 ], "synthetic": [ 507, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } } ], "training_stages": [ { "trees": 1, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 0.9846733668341708, "tree_auc": 0.9969146464646464, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 2, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 0.9962311557788944, "tree_auc": 0.9999709595959596, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 3, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 0.9992462311557789, "tree_auc": 0.9999992424242424, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 5, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 0.999748743718593, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 8, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 10, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 15, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 20, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 25, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 30, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 35, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 40, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 45, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 50, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 55, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 60, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 65, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 70, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 75, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 80, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 85, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 90, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 95, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 100, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 105, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 110, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 115, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 }, { "trees": 120, "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "tree_acc": 1.0, "tree_auc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "hgb_acc": 0.999748743718593, "hgb_auc": 1.0 } ] }, "matched": { "eval": [ { "policy_id": "policy_bc_v4", "policy_path": "models/policy_bc_v4", "panel": "matched", "trained_on": "policy_bc_v4", "fit": { "acc": 1.0, "auc": 1.0, "n": 3980, "mean_score_real": 0.9997654010358369, "mean_score_fake": 0.00012760162757330585, "log_loss": 0.00022315587931933062, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.00012760162757330585, "mean_P_human_real": 0.9997654010358369, "n_train_rows": 3383, "n_val_rows": 597, "hgb_iterations": 400, "boost_curve": [ { "iteration": 0, "train_loss": 0.6931335699121838, "val_loss": 0.6931402502341754 }, { "iteration": 5, "train_loss": 0.49266093957347135, "val_loss": 0.49306009764527764 }, { "iteration": 10, "train_loss": 0.36187453068036296, "val_loss": 0.36253619869503784 }, { "iteration": 15, "train_loss": 0.2713016023148361, "val_loss": 0.272374467481908 }, { "iteration": 20, "train_loss": 0.20627508401822808, "val_loss": 0.20775354324462544 }, { "iteration": 25, "train_loss": 0.15734247125055978, "val_loss": 0.1588512242101801 }, { "iteration": 30, "train_loss": 0.12068362109166106, "val_loss": 0.12242983944221902 }, { "iteration": 35, "train_loss": 0.09301469797666094, "val_loss": 0.09527074009232282 }, { "iteration": 40, "train_loss": 0.07199076734421468, "val_loss": 0.07462042443006213 }, { "iteration": 45, "train_loss": 0.05591927511794955, "val_loss": 0.058873927630763614 }, { "iteration": 50, "train_loss": 0.043564224804962616, "val_loss": 0.04683624188642347 }, { "iteration": 55, "train_loss": 0.0340260923214224, "val_loss": 0.03750947251952921 }, { "iteration": 60, "train_loss": 0.02657271777938182, "val_loss": 0.029905063635195187 }, { "iteration": 65, "train_loss": 0.020781317785134028, "val_loss": 0.023913479796756613 }, { "iteration": 70, "train_loss": 0.016282044234165016, "val_loss": 0.019320795674972475 }, { "iteration": 75, "train_loss": 0.012762132767951885, "val_loss": 0.015585574884408539 }, { "iteration": 80, "train_loss": 0.01002674220015342, "val_loss": 0.01277744233307947 }, { "iteration": 85, "train_loss": 0.007883004650606564, "val_loss": 0.010603018131503833 }, { "iteration": 90, "train_loss": 0.006214955718999371, "val_loss": 0.00901805224566284 }, { "iteration": 95, "train_loss": 0.0049116770217952875, "val_loss": 0.00769759096147975 }, { "iteration": 100, "train_loss": 0.003892670510272113, "val_loss": 0.00671810567642976 }, { "iteration": 105, "train_loss": 0.0030955028502739003, "val_loss": 0.00591952034583333 }, { "iteration": 110, "train_loss": 0.00246674230528853, "val_loss": 0.005252969379880804 }, { "iteration": 115, "train_loss": 0.001974589315223308, "val_loss": 0.00477955841047309 }, { "iteration": 120, "train_loss": 0.001583145997078499, "val_loss": 0.004296349029302558 }, { "iteration": 125, "train_loss": 0.0012740137758884475, "val_loss": 0.0038696509501574697 }, { "iteration": 130, "train_loss": 0.0010297097928378797, "val_loss": 0.003550714951413097 }, { "iteration": 135, "train_loss": 0.0008376760275417359, "val_loss": 0.0033251126933534236 }, { "iteration": 140, "train_loss": 0.0006832644193607217, "val_loss": 0.003059248859053756 }, { "iteration": 145, "train_loss": 0.0005624784410662222, "val_loss": 0.002886078260020514 }, { "iteration": 150, "train_loss": 0.0004655772160820993, "val_loss": 0.002727308759868066 }, { "iteration": 155, "train_loss": 0.0003882644883189713, "val_loss": 0.0025598506900262356 }, { "iteration": 160, "train_loss": 0.00032624380574135107, "val_loss": 0.0024413882147767355 }, { "iteration": 165, "train_loss": 0.00027565262169576283, "val_loss": 0.0023498271986852823 }, { "iteration": 170, "train_loss": 0.0002345930565856814, "val_loss": 0.0022752590714479157 }, { "iteration": 175, "train_loss": 0.00020141240921311783, "val_loss": 0.0021873670209085643 }, { "iteration": 180, "train_loss": 0.00017411815309640457, "val_loss": 0.0021335743942560137 }, { "iteration": 185, "train_loss": 0.00015179124746386483, "val_loss": 0.00208193110486513 }, { "iteration": 190, "train_loss": 0.00013338696278008798, "val_loss": 0.002100683824613195 }, { "iteration": 195, "train_loss": 0.00011783634704329879, "val_loss": 0.002073141942519769 }, { "iteration": 200, "train_loss": 0.0001050128557910438, "val_loss": 0.002039571172419124 }, { "iteration": 205, "train_loss": 9.421610372508011e-05, "val_loss": 0.0020110621724435318 }, { "iteration": 210, "train_loss": 8.503867035298148e-05, "val_loss": 0.0020198794840617486 }, { "iteration": 215, "train_loss": 7.712958690768737e-05, "val_loss": 0.001989825059053928 }, { "iteration": 220, "train_loss": 7.026257936374972e-05, "val_loss": 0.001973075514168545 }, { "iteration": 225, "train_loss": 6.445001385822289e-05, "val_loss": 0.001984582215293175 }, { "iteration": 230, "train_loss": 5.9377846430208764e-05, "val_loss": 0.001940332789727096 }, { "iteration": 235, "train_loss": 5.4838755927336995e-05, "val_loss": 0.0019364262577243805 }, { "iteration": 240, "train_loss": 5.08650770091377e-05, "val_loss": 0.0019075257516137252 }, { "iteration": 245, "train_loss": 4.741635312625258e-05, "val_loss": 0.0018825418916472178 }, { "iteration": 250, "train_loss": 4.430670109157755e-05, "val_loss": 0.0018838489826268428 }, { "iteration": 255, "train_loss": 4.153428283997436e-05, "val_loss": 0.0018680319680818788 }, { "iteration": 260, "train_loss": 3.907919343084054e-05, "val_loss": 0.0018626947520155685 }, { "iteration": 265, "train_loss": 3.681755903927758e-05, "val_loss": 0.0018692768045901046 }, { "iteration": 270, "train_loss": 3.4830737647289676e-05, "val_loss": 0.001850984298818085 }, { "iteration": 275, "train_loss": 3.302747110520676e-05, "val_loss": 0.001856333721856205 }, { "iteration": 280, "train_loss": 3.138421305075458e-05, "val_loss": 0.001834304966410851 }, { "iteration": 285, "train_loss": 2.9866417451448106e-05, "val_loss": 0.0018221101589393854 }, { "iteration": 290, "train_loss": 2.8476879549415884e-05, "val_loss": 0.0018299589972761074 }, { "iteration": 295, "train_loss": 2.7205545723923927e-05, "val_loss": 0.0018136838863866726 }, { "iteration": 300, "train_loss": 2.6041238601003078e-05, "val_loss": 0.001814293939898166 }, { "iteration": 305, "train_loss": 2.4973153437542802e-05, "val_loss": 0.0018004718928305728 }, { "iteration": 310, "train_loss": 2.3978860864618255e-05, "val_loss": 0.001793415205943863 }, { "iteration": 315, "train_loss": 2.3045379326951252e-05, "val_loss": 0.0017959483604818222 }, { "iteration": 320, "train_loss": 2.216640389717109e-05, "val_loss": 0.0017808526948873036 }, { "iteration": 325, "train_loss": 2.1373424177045204e-05, "val_loss": 0.001767160501265382 }, { "iteration": 330, "train_loss": 2.0612728348868758e-05, "val_loss": 0.0017598606520785652 }, { "iteration": 335, "train_loss": 1.992285910087597e-05, "val_loss": 0.0017482726234758863 }, { "iteration": 340, "train_loss": 1.9268519472305147e-05, "val_loss": 0.0017348541346357555 }, { "iteration": 345, "train_loss": 1.8647036053919154e-05, "val_loss": 0.0017215842954316106 }, { "iteration": 350, "train_loss": 1.8066027539869927e-05, "val_loss": 0.0017220754142618464 }, { "iteration": 355, "train_loss": 1.7518559618838148e-05, "val_loss": 0.0017006988694262877 }, { "iteration": 360, "train_loss": 1.6999230477491212e-05, "val_loss": 0.0016887287996906323 }, { "iteration": 365, "train_loss": 1.6515108463599532e-05, "val_loss": 0.001678710002772153 }, { "iteration": 370, "train_loss": 1.605627657748076e-05, "val_loss": 0.0016544107588590587 }, { "iteration": 375, "train_loss": 1.5618021106481382e-05, "val_loss": 0.001656145193467746 }, { "iteration": 380, "train_loss": 1.5195382478868213e-05, "val_loss": 0.0016509957622958694 }, { "iteration": 385, "train_loss": 1.480135440432003e-05, "val_loss": 0.0016433884811196389 }, { "iteration": 390, "train_loss": 1.4424124075164613e-05, "val_loss": 0.0016335846902048592 }, { "iteration": 395, "train_loss": 1.4071553536055305e-05, "val_loss": 0.0016226375763192145 }, { "iteration": 400, "train_loss": 1.3734657857157613e-05, "val_loss": 0.0016211965225390603 } ] }, "roc": [ { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.001953125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.03515625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.068359375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.1015625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.13671875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.169921875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.203125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.236328125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.271484375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.3046875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.337890625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.37109375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.40625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.439453125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.47265625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.505859375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.541015625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.57421875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.607421875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.640625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.67578125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.708984375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.7421875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.775390625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.810546875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.84375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.876953125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.91015625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.9453125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.978515625 }, { "fpr": 0.011834319526627219, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.045364891518737675, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.08086785009861933, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.11439842209072978, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.14792899408284024, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.1814595660749507, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.21696252465483234, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.2504930966469428, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.28402366863905326, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.3175542406311637, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.3530571992110454, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.3865877712031558, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.42011834319526625, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.4536489151873767, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.4891518737672584, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.5226824457593688, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.5562130177514792, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.5897435897435898, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.6252465483234714, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.6587771203155819, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.6923076923076923, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.7258382642998028, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.7613412228796844, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.7948717948717948, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.8284023668639053, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.8619329388560157, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.8974358974358975, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.9309664694280079, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.9644970414201184, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 1.0, "tpr": 1.0 } ], "acc": 0.9980372914622179, "auc": 1.0, "n": 1019, "mean_score_real": 0.996416894380842, "mean_score_fake": 3.809274771888009e-05, "mean_P_human_ai": 3.809274771888009e-05, "mean_P_human_real": 0.996416894380842, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "detect_rate_at_0.5": 1.0, "human_likeness": 3.809274771888009e-05, "score_histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05, 0.1, 0.15000000000000002, 0.2, 0.25, 0.30000000000000004, 0.35000000000000003, 0.4, 0.45, 0.5, 0.55, 0.6000000000000001, 0.65, 0.7000000000000001, 0.75, 0.8, 0.8500000000000001, 0.9, 0.9500000000000001, 1.0 ], "real": [ 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 1, 508 ], "synthetic": [ 507, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "policy_id": "policy_bc_v2", "policy_path": "models/policy_bc", "panel": "matched", "trained_on": "policy_bc_v2", "fit": { "acc": 0.999748743718593, "auc": 1.0, "n": 3980, "mean_score_real": 0.9996287891760162, "mean_score_fake": 1.6402727077858644e-05, "log_loss": 0.00028254212463065355, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "mean_P_human_ai": 1.6402727077858644e-05, "mean_P_human_real": 0.9996287891760162, "n_train_rows": 3383, "n_val_rows": 597, "hgb_iterations": 400, "boost_curve": [ { "iteration": 0, "train_loss": 0.6931456682718483, "val_loss": 0.6931418458724481 }, { "iteration": 5, "train_loss": 0.49225768291842764, "val_loss": 0.49250998590589323 }, { "iteration": 10, "train_loss": 0.3610654332165955, "val_loss": 0.3614594652560808 }, { "iteration": 15, "train_loss": 0.2702148743674761, "val_loss": 0.2705781061532713 }, { "iteration": 20, "train_loss": 0.20506715933277242, "val_loss": 0.2055123607601608 }, { "iteration": 25, "train_loss": 0.15691899960800956, "val_loss": 0.1573371630107471 }, { "iteration": 30, "train_loss": 0.12079147560539229, "val_loss": 0.12113880768141375 }, { "iteration": 35, "train_loss": 0.09345604579891702, "val_loss": 0.09399420159671808 }, { "iteration": 40, "train_loss": 0.07264523198727914, "val_loss": 0.07341215359098115 }, { "iteration": 45, "train_loss": 0.05659274477524757, "val_loss": 0.05753249857239633 }, { "iteration": 50, "train_loss": 0.04413629377929203, "val_loss": 0.04512570954312746 }, { "iteration": 55, "train_loss": 0.034435758348892696, "val_loss": 0.03535045437333108 }, { "iteration": 60, "train_loss": 0.026960889110540828, "val_loss": 0.027937455892957923 }, { "iteration": 65, "train_loss": 0.02110607420609059, "val_loss": 0.022081516469666742 }, { "iteration": 70, "train_loss": 0.016529426272109824, "val_loss": 0.017436483672458595 }, { "iteration": 75, "train_loss": 0.012958239919593738, "val_loss": 0.013820919021684648 }, { "iteration": 80, "train_loss": 0.010164641110950865, "val_loss": 0.011024996527906172 }, { "iteration": 85, "train_loss": 0.007989418892544254, "val_loss": 0.008736265135005186 }, { "iteration": 90, "train_loss": 0.006295179395070961, "val_loss": 0.006975071836213071 }, { "iteration": 95, "train_loss": 0.00496834955377759, "val_loss": 0.005608450266104452 }, { "iteration": 100, "train_loss": 0.003924507671474894, "val_loss": 0.0044829084345222765 }, { "iteration": 105, "train_loss": 0.0031061842732323847, "val_loss": 0.003599166903377382 }, { "iteration": 110, "train_loss": 0.0024686168879499504, "val_loss": 0.00290033840536239 }, { "iteration": 115, "train_loss": 0.0019629301593147965, "val_loss": 0.002315849794541317 }, { "iteration": 120, "train_loss": 0.0015678903778289523, "val_loss": 0.0018740647456062666 }, { "iteration": 125, "train_loss": 0.001258937731616025, "val_loss": 0.0015236119436888662 }, { "iteration": 130, "train_loss": 0.0010138391076924332, "val_loss": 0.0012356013963713518 }, { "iteration": 135, "train_loss": 0.0008200290506670812, "val_loss": 0.0010001200563699928 }, { "iteration": 140, "train_loss": 0.0006670666863562921, "val_loss": 0.0008300390041107362 }, { "iteration": 145, "train_loss": 0.0005460216268814743, "val_loss": 0.000690056876326923 }, { "iteration": 150, "train_loss": 0.0004499188787751408, "val_loss": 0.000577836858473664 }, { "iteration": 155, "train_loss": 0.0003729338685614241, "val_loss": 0.0004872076116262439 }, { "iteration": 160, "train_loss": 0.0003120880643355504, "val_loss": 0.0004182607602835243 }, { "iteration": 165, "train_loss": 0.0002631319287292625, "val_loss": 0.0003586822744842318 }, { "iteration": 170, "train_loss": 0.00022394931658380917, "val_loss": 0.00031478840811702095 }, { "iteration": 175, "train_loss": 0.00019173468670117622, "val_loss": 0.00027199410510005074 }, { "iteration": 180, "train_loss": 0.00016588327680491303, "val_loss": 0.00023668079397758492 }, { "iteration": 185, "train_loss": 0.00014428653009031353, "val_loss": 0.00020736985065747285 }, { "iteration": 190, "train_loss": 0.00012666142891594223, "val_loss": 0.00018512531465870262 }, { "iteration": 195, "train_loss": 0.00011198666072313141, "val_loss": 0.00016498027689748794 }, { "iteration": 200, "train_loss": 9.960549918336652e-05, "val_loss": 0.00014670547935295342 }, { "iteration": 205, "train_loss": 8.923341254833493e-05, "val_loss": 0.0001343132577300712 }, { "iteration": 210, "train_loss": 8.047400238936338e-05, "val_loss": 0.0001230840708188669 }, { "iteration": 215, "train_loss": 7.292736111404898e-05, "val_loss": 0.00011334895400649822 }, { "iteration": 220, "train_loss": 6.648675824765817e-05, "val_loss": 0.00010304953125168924 }, { "iteration": 225, "train_loss": 6.0957885533430735e-05, "val_loss": 9.647750434746176e-05 }, { "iteration": 230, "train_loss": 5.6128472548924546e-05, "val_loss": 9.047018164519112e-05 }, { "iteration": 235, "train_loss": 5.184509660117741e-05, "val_loss": 8.369655568674099e-05 }, { "iteration": 240, "train_loss": 4.8141383436476464e-05, "val_loss": 7.914733958100864e-05 }, { "iteration": 245, "train_loss": 4.486177651354261e-05, "val_loss": 7.437704089235741e-05 }, { "iteration": 250, "train_loss": 4.191751298256423e-05, "val_loss": 6.971247912340203e-05 }, { "iteration": 255, "train_loss": 3.9311467225859324e-05, "val_loss": 6.581870419875672e-05 }, { "iteration": 260, "train_loss": 3.6966845544879744e-05, "val_loss": 6.263795316040517e-05 }, { "iteration": 265, "train_loss": 3.489510123280618e-05, "val_loss": 5.946125517622561e-05 }, { "iteration": 270, "train_loss": 3.3030202315729064e-05, "val_loss": 5.7205822823670166e-05 }, { "iteration": 275, "train_loss": 3.1314761669197005e-05, "val_loss": 5.47481818116446e-05 }, { "iteration": 280, "train_loss": 2.9749299116786972e-05, "val_loss": 5.1999951088174276e-05 }, { "iteration": 285, "train_loss": 2.8335336587594282e-05, "val_loss": 5.00000079238e-05 }, { "iteration": 290, "train_loss": 2.7036563718264766e-05, "val_loss": 4.7685513730161135e-05 }, { "iteration": 295, "train_loss": 2.58353637812959e-05, "val_loss": 4.598018959546356e-05 }, { "iteration": 300, "train_loss": 2.4738885395449648e-05, "val_loss": 4.424436898302314e-05 }, { "iteration": 305, "train_loss": 2.3719901540039953e-05, "val_loss": 4.271213500535463e-05 }, { "iteration": 310, "train_loss": 2.2770130055446156e-05, "val_loss": 4.0952961482449834e-05 }, { "iteration": 315, "train_loss": 2.190585578930181e-05, "val_loss": 3.967690857992743e-05 }, { "iteration": 320, "train_loss": 2.108277416390668e-05, "val_loss": 3.824900440805975e-05 }, { "iteration": 325, "train_loss": 2.032196126843546e-05, "val_loss": 3.7130250362488606e-05 }, { "iteration": 330, "train_loss": 1.961061458072659e-05, "val_loss": 3.586528978157098e-05 }, { "iteration": 335, "train_loss": 1.8946101858208755e-05, "val_loss": 3.4941721327741003e-05 }, { "iteration": 340, "train_loss": 1.832294099956891e-05, "val_loss": 3.3696439586748055e-05 }, { "iteration": 345, "train_loss": 1.773267115880283e-05, "val_loss": 3.277597099428192e-05 }, { "iteration": 350, "train_loss": 1.718213760535843e-05, "val_loss": 3.18263090733603e-05 }, { "iteration": 355, "train_loss": 1.6668886335649678e-05, "val_loss": 3.099706443889629e-05 }, { "iteration": 360, "train_loss": 1.6179437717770587e-05, "val_loss": 3.0065811180044405e-05 }, { "iteration": 365, "train_loss": 1.571347388502388e-05, "val_loss": 2.931118859742753e-05 }, { "iteration": 370, "train_loss": 1.527486351326596e-05, "val_loss": 2.848061597938145e-05 }, { "iteration": 375, "train_loss": 1.4867753245672765e-05, "val_loss": 2.7941041616360957e-05 }, { "iteration": 380, "train_loss": 1.4472219453728708e-05, "val_loss": 2.7208129959976263e-05 }, { "iteration": 385, "train_loss": 1.4102104496023488e-05, "val_loss": 2.6642315270852753e-05 }, { "iteration": 390, "train_loss": 1.3738639242260308e-05, "val_loss": 2.607187981839131e-05 }, { "iteration": 395, "train_loss": 1.3406070075494349e-05, "val_loss": 2.546778309451884e-05 }, { "iteration": 400, "train_loss": 1.308109319107441e-05, "val_loss": 2.4905908198173868e-05 } ] }, "roc": [ { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.001953125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.03515625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.068359375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.1015625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.13671875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.169921875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.203125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.236328125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.271484375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.3046875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.337890625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.37109375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.40625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.439453125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.47265625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.505859375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.541015625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.57421875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.607421875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.640625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.67578125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.708984375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.7421875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.775390625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.810546875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.84375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.876953125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.91015625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.9453125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.978515625 }, { "fpr": 0.011834319526627219, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.045364891518737675, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.08086785009861933, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.11439842209072978, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.14792899408284024, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.1814595660749507, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.21696252465483234, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.2504930966469428, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.28402366863905326, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.3175542406311637, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.3530571992110454, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.3865877712031558, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.42011834319526625, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.4536489151873767, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.4891518737672584, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.5226824457593688, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.5562130177514792, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.5897435897435898, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.6252465483234714, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.6587771203155819, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.6923076923076923, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.7258382642998028, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.7613412228796844, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.7948717948717948, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.8284023668639053, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.8619329388560157, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.8974358974358975, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.9309664694280079, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.9644970414201184, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 1.0, "tpr": 1.0 } ], "acc": 0.9990186457311089, "auc": 1.0, "n": 1019, "mean_score_real": 0.9970176663735841, "mean_score_fake": 2.2638500048010705e-05, "mean_P_human_ai": 2.2638500048010705e-05, "mean_P_human_real": 0.9970176663735841, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "detect_rate_at_0.5": 1.0, "human_likeness": 2.2638500048010705e-05, "score_histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05, 0.1, 0.15000000000000002, 0.2, 0.25, 0.30000000000000004, 0.35000000000000003, 0.4, 0.45, 0.5, 0.55, 0.6000000000000001, 0.65, 0.7000000000000001, 0.75, 0.8, 0.8500000000000001, 0.9, 0.9500000000000001, 1.0 ], "real": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 1, 0, 508 ], "synthetic": [ 507, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "policy_id": "policy_bc_v4_1", "policy_path": "models/policy_bc_v4.1", "panel": "matched", "trained_on": "policy_bc_v4_1", "fit": { "acc": 1.0, "auc": 1.0, "n": 3980, "mean_score_real": 0.9996991653739355, "mean_score_fake": 1.723552286634327e-05, "log_loss": 0.0001876709057286847, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "mean_P_human_ai": 1.723552286634327e-05, "mean_P_human_real": 0.9996991653739355, "n_train_rows": 3383, "n_val_rows": 597, "hgb_iterations": 400, "boost_curve": [ { "iteration": 0, "train_loss": 0.6931296984164822, "val_loss": 0.6931181029670488 }, { "iteration": 5, "train_loss": 0.4928965835514818, "val_loss": 0.4920582282956828 }, { "iteration": 10, "train_loss": 0.36214952721888005, "val_loss": 0.3610291825240827 }, { "iteration": 15, "train_loss": 0.2715752755148066, "val_loss": 0.27041188612052747 }, { "iteration": 20, "train_loss": 0.20645455633783105, "val_loss": 0.20541737336823093 }, { "iteration": 25, "train_loss": 0.15788099674930828, "val_loss": 0.15729890957046966 }, { "iteration": 30, "train_loss": 0.12140210465516398, "val_loss": 0.12133537528217131 }, { "iteration": 35, "train_loss": 0.09377527912528973, "val_loss": 0.0939855940434974 }, { "iteration": 40, "train_loss": 0.07265187390354055, "val_loss": 0.07291123187580474 }, { "iteration": 45, "train_loss": 0.056459732075112935, "val_loss": 0.056753164847608006 }, { "iteration": 50, "train_loss": 0.04393426019267701, "val_loss": 0.04475797143844446 }, { "iteration": 55, "train_loss": 0.03423594853986967, "val_loss": 0.035298333967362504 }, { "iteration": 60, "train_loss": 0.02674778033293212, "val_loss": 0.028143586739625463 }, { "iteration": 65, "train_loss": 0.020941042852017953, "val_loss": 0.0222143147128355 }, { "iteration": 70, "train_loss": 0.016397877607731984, "val_loss": 0.01763612184769384 }, { "iteration": 75, "train_loss": 0.012872080195097568, "val_loss": 0.014100543183672496 }, { "iteration": 80, "train_loss": 0.01012406549993674, "val_loss": 0.011231180896244156 }, { "iteration": 85, "train_loss": 0.00796986986450925, "val_loss": 0.009036060939332095 }, { "iteration": 90, "train_loss": 0.006287359106142194, "val_loss": 0.0073192035310931155 }, { "iteration": 95, "train_loss": 0.0049650122521395995, "val_loss": 0.005920179635545357 }, { "iteration": 100, "train_loss": 0.003931092860739315, "val_loss": 0.0047837749766489555 }, { "iteration": 105, "train_loss": 0.0031194888906641884, "val_loss": 0.003940073197051286 }, { "iteration": 110, "train_loss": 0.0024848990619709722, "val_loss": 0.0032272569993968166 }, { "iteration": 115, "train_loss": 0.001980449093432995, "val_loss": 0.0026848613232999534 }, { "iteration": 120, "train_loss": 0.0015872032973987234, "val_loss": 0.0022755886118783677 }, { "iteration": 125, "train_loss": 0.0012752971673944103, "val_loss": 0.0019337280934115873 }, { "iteration": 130, "train_loss": 0.0010290248734618243, "val_loss": 0.0016620349805654298 }, { "iteration": 135, "train_loss": 0.0008348758313257234, "val_loss": 0.001429571735180861 }, { "iteration": 140, "train_loss": 0.0006810377700359176, "val_loss": 0.00125420092043825 }, { "iteration": 145, "train_loss": 0.0005589595383065894, "val_loss": 0.0011379703271929425 }, { "iteration": 150, "train_loss": 0.00046093639031810944, "val_loss": 0.0010612495038748227 }, { "iteration": 155, "train_loss": 0.00038409869395680194, "val_loss": 0.0009741217669915835 }, { "iteration": 160, "train_loss": 0.00032138894417882695, "val_loss": 0.0009466706114584767 }, { "iteration": 165, "train_loss": 0.000270987965448257, "val_loss": 0.0008783301384173341 }, { "iteration": 170, "train_loss": 0.0002307728884560404, "val_loss": 0.0008271199463456033 }, { "iteration": 175, "train_loss": 0.00019776563011439897, "val_loss": 0.0007771467514131616 }, { "iteration": 180, "train_loss": 0.00017110484281350873, "val_loss": 0.0007315850041957218 }, { "iteration": 185, "train_loss": 0.00014912332284185622, "val_loss": 0.0007208725640546242 }, { "iteration": 190, "train_loss": 0.00013088323886957471, "val_loss": 0.0006940375520414581 }, { "iteration": 195, "train_loss": 0.00011583709654680764, "val_loss": 0.0006694522157477802 }, { "iteration": 200, "train_loss": 0.00010323868520583268, "val_loss": 0.0006492299510922377 }, { "iteration": 205, "train_loss": 9.258637192846556e-05, "val_loss": 0.0006419564065536406 }, { "iteration": 210, "train_loss": 8.342018136746836e-05, "val_loss": 0.0006318686369024013 }, { "iteration": 215, "train_loss": 7.57087955709456e-05, "val_loss": 0.0006285722243779149 }, { "iteration": 220, "train_loss": 6.90443759504983e-05, "val_loss": 0.0006296423164459448 }, { "iteration": 225, "train_loss": 6.325095237329361e-05, "val_loss": 0.0006282650999063903 }, { "iteration": 230, "train_loss": 5.821790009488809e-05, "val_loss": 0.0006088535855811128 }, { "iteration": 235, "train_loss": 5.383236620931921e-05, "val_loss": 0.0006033909527876401 }, { "iteration": 240, "train_loss": 5.001335527208851e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005907803729321328 }, { "iteration": 245, "train_loss": 4.658872672760094e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005950653351482324 }, { "iteration": 250, "train_loss": 4.3562664326421585e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005867103854655816 }, { "iteration": 255, "train_loss": 4.0825999301176336e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005760661477091585 }, { "iteration": 260, "train_loss": 3.842370854441594e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005755243560016521 }, { "iteration": 265, "train_loss": 3.6251619212785826e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005630662527019521 }, { "iteration": 270, "train_loss": 3.4265334594088e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005567399653132885 }, { "iteration": 275, "train_loss": 3.248620256171694e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005511457230292044 }, { "iteration": 280, "train_loss": 3.086541947264653e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005483609567645481 }, { "iteration": 285, "train_loss": 2.9374125663474198e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005399878428316008 }, { "iteration": 290, "train_loss": 2.8012908085156714e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005417798625107377 }, { "iteration": 295, "train_loss": 2.6761121715826688e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005438138431658095 }, { "iteration": 300, "train_loss": 2.562555573553377e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005452007612668118 }, { "iteration": 305, "train_loss": 2.4556849808766078e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005425730597596594 }, { "iteration": 310, "train_loss": 2.3576205424254307e-05, "val_loss": 0.000544620404764405 }, { "iteration": 315, "train_loss": 2.2658251043531075e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005468654742342579 }, { "iteration": 320, "train_loss": 2.1802460378110382e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005422602526254558 }, { "iteration": 325, "train_loss": 2.0999742729936998e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005416602949645223 }, { "iteration": 330, "train_loss": 2.0267764254246484e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005381773697676101 }, { "iteration": 335, "train_loss": 1.958548381603846e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005388143064483292 }, { "iteration": 340, "train_loss": 1.8928711776021443e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005390408926581747 }, { "iteration": 345, "train_loss": 1.831726907141815e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005331683464845101 }, { "iteration": 350, "train_loss": 1.774461705619665e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005303032454458625 }, { "iteration": 355, "train_loss": 1.720485855192122e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005302325318728199 }, { "iteration": 360, "train_loss": 1.6692088594635638e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005305839862691366 }, { "iteration": 365, "train_loss": 1.621218038582278e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005271422008515626 }, { "iteration": 370, "train_loss": 1.5753544493463314e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005220634965411446 }, { "iteration": 375, "train_loss": 1.5325675627039903e-05, "val_loss": 0.000520865381548412 }, { "iteration": 380, "train_loss": 1.491254024837025e-05, "val_loss": 0.000518506396972481 }, { "iteration": 385, "train_loss": 1.4527504508506411e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005162580389991544 }, { "iteration": 390, "train_loss": 1.4159762428958053e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005150092210932917 }, { "iteration": 395, "train_loss": 1.3803923626239286e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005139910320699274 }, { "iteration": 400, "train_loss": 1.3470069640667207e-05, "val_loss": 0.0005095277531029822 } ] }, "roc": [ { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.001953125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.03515625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.068359375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.1015625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.13671875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.169921875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.203125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.236328125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.271484375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.3046875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.337890625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.37109375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.40625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.439453125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.47265625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.505859375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.541015625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.57421875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.607421875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.640625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.67578125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.708984375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.7421875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.775390625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.810546875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.84375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.876953125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.91015625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.9453125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.978515625 }, { "fpr": 0.011834319526627219, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.045364891518737675, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.08086785009861933, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.11439842209072978, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.14792899408284024, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.1814595660749507, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.21696252465483234, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.2504930966469428, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.28402366863905326, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.3175542406311637, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.3530571992110454, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.3865877712031558, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.42011834319526625, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.4536489151873767, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.4891518737672584, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.5226824457593688, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.5562130177514792, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.5897435897435898, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.6252465483234714, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.6587771203155819, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.6923076923076923, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.7258382642998028, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.7613412228796844, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.7948717948717948, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.8284023668639053, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.8619329388560157, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.8974358974358975, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.9309664694280079, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.9644970414201184, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 1.0, "tpr": 1.0 } ], "acc": 0.9980372914622179, "auc": 1.0, "n": 1019, "mean_score_real": 0.9962705930461748, "mean_score_fake": 1.838149538810249e-05, "mean_P_human_ai": 1.838149538810249e-05, "mean_P_human_real": 0.9962705930461748, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "detect_rate_at_0.5": 1.0, "human_likeness": 1.838149538810249e-05, "score_histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05, 0.1, 0.15000000000000002, 0.2, 0.25, 0.30000000000000004, 0.35000000000000003, 0.4, 0.45, 0.5, 0.55, 0.6000000000000001, 0.65, 0.7000000000000001, 0.75, 0.8, 0.8500000000000001, 0.9, 0.9500000000000001, 1.0 ], "real": [ 0, 1, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 1, 508 ], "synthetic": [ 507, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "policy_id": "policy_bc_v3", "policy_path": "models/policy_bc_v3", "panel": "matched", "trained_on": "policy_bc_v3", "fit": { "acc": 1.0, "auc": 1.0, "n": 3980, "mean_score_real": 0.9999726000495934, "mean_score_fake": 1.3589570843374862e-05, "log_loss": 2.0616377087551865e-05, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "mean_P_human_ai": 1.3589570843374862e-05, "mean_P_human_real": 0.9999726000495934, "n_train_rows": 3383, "n_val_rows": 597, "hgb_iterations": 400, "boost_curve": [ { "iteration": 0, "train_loss": 0.6931471200684508, "val_loss": 0.6931472410514425 }, { "iteration": 5, "train_loss": 0.49287698850730444, "val_loss": 0.49317885113177595 }, { "iteration": 10, "train_loss": 0.3622520482746597, "val_loss": 0.3625408830269045 }, { "iteration": 15, "train_loss": 0.2709559606104275, "val_loss": 0.2713158045091668 }, { "iteration": 20, "train_loss": 0.20491175290524766, "val_loss": 0.20582409785982464 }, { "iteration": 25, "train_loss": 0.1565142019441352, "val_loss": 0.1573836999838214 }, { "iteration": 30, "train_loss": 0.12011159933733337, "val_loss": 0.12090430235415507 }, { "iteration": 35, "train_loss": 0.09269462408490978, "val_loss": 0.09323193512088764 }, { "iteration": 40, "train_loss": 0.07166208380746923, "val_loss": 0.07243169947327498 }, { "iteration": 45, "train_loss": 0.05556356800393338, "val_loss": 0.05655186594493267 }, { "iteration": 50, "train_loss": 0.043202999195442814, "val_loss": 0.04429481366367792 }, { "iteration": 55, "train_loss": 0.033720578946880006, "val_loss": 0.034694372600498485 }, { "iteration": 60, "train_loss": 0.026326495218930067, "val_loss": 0.02737188176424467 }, { "iteration": 65, "train_loss": 0.02061833133437087, "val_loss": 0.02159644886279903 }, { "iteration": 70, "train_loss": 0.01616578711524902, "val_loss": 0.017140141213835555 }, { "iteration": 75, "train_loss": 0.012706109745704736, "val_loss": 0.01365229243144846 }, { "iteration": 80, "train_loss": 0.009966027319185623, "val_loss": 0.010823625116014934 }, { "iteration": 85, "train_loss": 0.00782479515871744, "val_loss": 0.008662765388375349 }, { "iteration": 90, "train_loss": 0.006155183376097244, "val_loss": 0.006906576577132339 }, { "iteration": 95, "train_loss": 0.004848086248507215, "val_loss": 0.005579697400733989 }, { "iteration": 100, "train_loss": 0.0038269073011189788, "val_loss": 0.004489893168504503 }, { "iteration": 105, "train_loss": 0.0030287460656082, "val_loss": 0.0036606765442743212 }, { "iteration": 110, "train_loss": 0.002403287728742314, "val_loss": 0.0029894444827951562 }, { "iteration": 115, "train_loss": 0.0019124170664594716, "val_loss": 0.0024535036391572043 }, { "iteration": 120, "train_loss": 0.0015277203068478986, "val_loss": 0.0020361457642476006 }, { "iteration": 125, "train_loss": 0.00122451846514575, "val_loss": 0.0016926032644106824 }, { "iteration": 130, "train_loss": 0.0009857336065489646, "val_loss": 0.001436456059506317 }, { "iteration": 135, "train_loss": 0.0007979451434891126, "val_loss": 0.0012260440489920677 }, { "iteration": 140, "train_loss": 0.0006495545793720296, "val_loss": 0.0010505571192247086 }, { "iteration": 145, "train_loss": 0.0005313755467924886, "val_loss": 0.0008980511146452305 }, { "iteration": 150, "train_loss": 0.00043812150414167554, "val_loss": 0.0007812729556491992 }, { "iteration": 155, "train_loss": 0.00036370417421149355, "val_loss": 0.0006892494082906297 }, { "iteration": 160, "train_loss": 0.00030408198089667583, "val_loss": 0.0006054595387289099 }, { "iteration": 165, "train_loss": 0.0002565575849702228, "val_loss": 0.0005456864119285428 }, { "iteration": 170, "train_loss": 0.00021816695004540023, "val_loss": 0.0004982597741421576 }, { "iteration": 175, "train_loss": 0.00018753882642373338, "val_loss": 0.00045575063947152076 }, { "iteration": 180, "train_loss": 0.0001624340323821391, "val_loss": 0.00039607113645625917 }, { "iteration": 185, "train_loss": 0.00014184648800755223, "val_loss": 0.000358631259658874 }, { "iteration": 190, "train_loss": 0.00012453955697077764, "val_loss": 0.00032328674129972256 }, { "iteration": 195, "train_loss": 0.00011032976914422335, "val_loss": 0.00030183737401530945 }, { "iteration": 200, "train_loss": 9.815558369880135e-05, "val_loss": 0.0002702396181790363 }, { "iteration": 205, "train_loss": 8.814747179430627e-05, "val_loss": 0.0002485815708047944 }, { "iteration": 210, "train_loss": 7.967038968488252e-05, "val_loss": 0.00023534207707273953 }, { "iteration": 215, "train_loss": 7.228514607274685e-05, "val_loss": 0.00021314795688225237 }, { "iteration": 220, "train_loss": 6.602532621139983e-05, "val_loss": 0.00019846695566226263 }, { "iteration": 225, "train_loss": 6.063070833459744e-05, "val_loss": 0.00019003322051285243 }, { "iteration": 230, "train_loss": 5.585446080854874e-05, "val_loss": 0.0001769355494208998 }, { "iteration": 235, "train_loss": 5.1676096117152436e-05, "val_loss": 0.00016486397198462406 }, { "iteration": 240, "train_loss": 4.801830361530993e-05, "val_loss": 0.0001557261789434473 }, { "iteration": 245, "train_loss": 4.473487953112752e-05, "val_loss": 0.0001479110137350817 }, { "iteration": 250, "train_loss": 4.185543634491904e-05, "val_loss": 0.00014093224450875778 }, { "iteration": 255, "train_loss": 3.930668287943217e-05, "val_loss": 0.00013419427900284643 }, { "iteration": 260, "train_loss": 3.701314359545186e-05, "val_loss": 0.0001295095422934449 }, { "iteration": 265, "train_loss": 3.4935069457691114e-05, "val_loss": 0.00012372194747855634 }, { "iteration": 270, "train_loss": 3.305469739603207e-05, "val_loss": 0.00011883823275150076 }, { "iteration": 275, "train_loss": 3.134739469038408e-05, "val_loss": 0.00011605424102492591 }, { "iteration": 280, "train_loss": 2.981257089221413e-05, "val_loss": 0.00011168022905133178 }, { "iteration": 285, "train_loss": 2.8377582580000293e-05, "val_loss": 0.00010934807548996692 }, { "iteration": 290, "train_loss": 2.70847021320573e-05, "val_loss": 0.00010652137433513295 }, { "iteration": 295, "train_loss": 2.5888825657797212e-05, "val_loss": 0.00010367562915004898 }, { "iteration": 300, "train_loss": 2.479067093955282e-05, "val_loss": 0.0001003683092765584 }, { "iteration": 305, "train_loss": 2.3772729655469856e-05, "val_loss": 9.81279001821542e-05 }, { "iteration": 310, "train_loss": 2.283552321359614e-05, "val_loss": 9.518419973724224e-05 }, { "iteration": 315, "train_loss": 2.1948621211519505e-05, "val_loss": 9.387277221981976e-05 }, { "iteration": 320, "train_loss": 2.1141218133630485e-05, "val_loss": 9.119636501344507e-05 }, { "iteration": 325, "train_loss": 2.0375342213279894e-05, "val_loss": 8.95772385817223e-05 }, { "iteration": 330, "train_loss": 1.967589812922222e-05, "val_loss": 8.830028836635498e-05 }, { "iteration": 335, "train_loss": 1.9009125550074294e-05, "val_loss": 8.62044689603817e-05 }, { "iteration": 340, "train_loss": 1.8387398559676604e-05, "val_loss": 8.506865920806795e-05 }, { "iteration": 345, "train_loss": 1.7802612635896403e-05, "val_loss": 8.244370540435985e-05 }, { "iteration": 350, "train_loss": 1.7247096873315718e-05, "val_loss": 8.119157581086679e-05 }, { "iteration": 355, "train_loss": 1.6737121475168502e-05, "val_loss": 8.028555549346426e-05 }, { "iteration": 360, "train_loss": 1.6244634829223564e-05, "val_loss": 7.814842168719041e-05 }, { "iteration": 365, "train_loss": 1.5785405488632846e-05, "val_loss": 7.7284219813266e-05 }, { "iteration": 370, "train_loss": 1.5344756411298998e-05, "val_loss": 7.573162598565929e-05 }, { "iteration": 375, "train_loss": 1.4931690416674135e-05, "val_loss": 7.492721036710614e-05 }, { "iteration": 380, "train_loss": 1.4541975634347252e-05, "val_loss": 7.348180224350029e-05 }, { "iteration": 385, "train_loss": 1.4164957434897613e-05, "val_loss": 7.214985851947729e-05 }, { "iteration": 390, "train_loss": 1.380607746302985e-05, "val_loss": 7.151637738805692e-05 }, { "iteration": 395, "train_loss": 1.3468688211451617e-05, "val_loss": 7.054308957605589e-05 }, { "iteration": 400, "train_loss": 1.3147166148111345e-05, "val_loss": 6.931697930920868e-05 } ] }, "roc": [ { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.001953125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.03515625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.068359375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.1015625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.13671875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.169921875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.203125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.236328125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.271484375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.3046875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.337890625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.37109375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.40625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.439453125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.47265625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.505859375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.541015625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.57421875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.607421875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.640625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.67578125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.708984375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.7421875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.775390625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.810546875 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.84375 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.876953125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.91015625 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.9453125 }, { "fpr": 0.0, "tpr": 0.978515625 }, { "fpr": 0.011834319526627219, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.045364891518737675, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.08086785009861933, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.11439842209072978, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.14792899408284024, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.1814595660749507, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.21696252465483234, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.2504930966469428, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.28402366863905326, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.3175542406311637, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.3530571992110454, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.3865877712031558, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.42011834319526625, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.4536489151873767, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.4891518737672584, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.5226824457593688, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.5562130177514792, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.5897435897435898, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.6252465483234714, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.6587771203155819, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.6923076923076923, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.7258382642998028, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.7613412228796844, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.7948717948717948, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.8284023668639053, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.8619329388560157, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.8974358974358975, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.9309664694280079, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 0.9644970414201184, "tpr": 1.0 }, { "fpr": 1.0, "tpr": 1.0 } ], "acc": 0.9990186457311089, "auc": 1.0, "n": 1019, "mean_score_real": 0.9973188054317502, "mean_score_fake": 1.3073038784412534e-05, "mean_P_human_ai": 1.3073038784412534e-05, "mean_P_human_real": 0.9973188054317502, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "detect_rate_at_0.5": 1.0, "human_likeness": 1.3073038784412534e-05, "score_histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05, 0.1, 0.15000000000000002, 0.2, 0.25, 0.30000000000000004, 0.35000000000000003, 0.4, 0.45, 0.5, 0.55, 0.6000000000000001, 0.65, 0.7000000000000001, 0.75, 0.8, 0.8500000000000001, 0.9, 0.9500000000000001, 1.0 ], "real": [ 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 1, 0, 509 ], "synthetic": [ 507, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } } ], "best_policy_id": "policy_bc_v4" }, "sanity_controls": { "easy": { "acc": 0.5, "auc": 0.91326904296875, "n": 256, "mean_score_real": 0.9999924240152036, "mean_score_fake": 0.9999828025742894, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.9999828025742894, "mean_P_human_real": 0.9999924240152036, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 1.0, "detect_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "human_likeness": 0.9999828025742894, "score_histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05, 0.1, 0.15000000000000002, 0.2, 0.25, 0.30000000000000004, 0.35000000000000003, 0.4, 0.45, 0.5, 0.55, 0.6000000000000001, 0.65, 0.7000000000000001, 0.75, 0.8, 0.8500000000000001, 0.9, 0.9500000000000001, 1.0 ], "real": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 128 ], "synthetic": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 128 ] } }, "medium": { "acc": 0.5078125, "auc": 0.94647216796875, "n": 256, "mean_score_real": 0.9999924240152036, "mean_score_fake": 0.9834914992874211, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.9834914992874211, "mean_P_human_real": 0.9999924240152036, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.984375, "detect_rate_at_0.5": 0.015625, "human_likeness": 0.9834914992874211, "score_histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05, 0.1, 0.15000000000000002, 0.2, 0.25, 0.30000000000000004, 0.35000000000000003, 0.4, 0.45, 0.5, 0.55, 0.6000000000000001, 0.65, 0.7000000000000001, 0.75, 0.8, 0.8500000000000001, 0.9, 0.9500000000000001, 1.0 ], "real": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 128 ], "synthetic": [ 0, 1, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 125 ] } } }, "forensics": { "features": [ { "feature": "alt_rate", "index": 13, "separation_auc": 0.9993619893483343, "human_mean": 0.6768886436293056, "ai_mean": 0.9304250299725414, "human_std": 0.08622937031786226, "ai_std": 0.029499502695643318, "cohens_d": -3.934291376663296, "permutation_drop": 0.26722401824814207, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.26666666666666666, 0.3074074074074074, 0.34814814814814815, 0.3888888888888889, 0.42962962962962964, 0.4703703703703704, 0.5111111111111111, 0.5518518518518518, 0.5925925925925926, 0.6333333333333333, 0.674074074074074, 0.7148148148148148, 0.7555555555555555, 0.7962962962962963, 0.837037037037037, 0.8777777777777778, 0.9185185185185185, 0.9592592592592593, 1.0 ], "human": [ 2, 1, 2, 2, 3, 9, 18, 42, 65, 90, 106, 80, 57, 24, 3, 3, 0, 0 ], "ai": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 12, 120, 247, 128 ] } }, { "feature": "in_single", "index": 66, "separation_auc": 0.9951410042443269, "human_mean": 0.03944773175542406, "ai_mean": 0.0, "human_std": 0.19465766929349632, "ai_std": 0.0, "cohens_d": 0.2865929580676452, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05555555555555555, 0.1111111111111111, 0.16666666666666666, 0.2222222222222222, 0.2777777777777778, 0.3333333333333333, 0.38888888888888884, 0.4444444444444444, 0.5, 0.5555555555555556, 0.611111111111111, 0.6666666666666666, 0.7222222222222222, 0.7777777777777777, 0.8333333333333333, 0.8888888888888888, 0.9444444444444444, 1.0 ], "human": [ 487, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 20 ], "ai": [ 507, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "frac_triple", "index": 17, "separation_auc": 0.98839909900447, "human_mean": 0.0, "ai_mean": 0.0008024906214951464, "human_std": 0.0, "ai_std": 0.01062110756601638, "cohens_d": -0.1068526152796803, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.008714596949891067, 0.017429193899782133, 0.0261437908496732, 0.03485838779956427, 0.04357298474945533, 0.0522875816993464, 0.061002178649237467, 0.06971677559912853, 0.0784313725490196, 0.08714596949891067, 0.09586056644880173, 0.1045751633986928, 0.11328976034858387, 0.12200435729847493, 0.130718954248366, 0.13943355119825707, 0.14814814814814814, 0.1568627450980392 ], "human": [ 507, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "ai": [ 504, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 2 ] } }, { "feature": "in_overtime", "index": 65, "separation_auc": 0.98839909900447, "human_mean": 0.0, "ai_mean": 0.005917159763313609, "human_std": 0.0, "ai_std": 0.07669515619417586, "cohens_d": -0.1091089451179962, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05555555555555555, 0.1111111111111111, 0.16666666666666666, 0.2222222222222222, 0.2777777777777778, 0.3333333333333333, 0.38888888888888884, 0.4444444444444444, 0.5, 0.5555555555555556, 0.611111111111111, 0.6666666666666666, 0.7222222222222222, 0.7777777777777777, 0.8333333333333333, 0.8888888888888888, 0.9444444444444444, 1.0 ], "human": [ 507, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "ai": [ 504, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 3 ] } }, { "feature": "frac_gap_lt_1", "index": 10, "separation_auc": 0.9775879307058187, "human_mean": 0.1718022818895277, "ai_mean": 0.037243299686738604, "human_std": 0.05688012218233456, "ai_std": 0.032394662801818117, "cohens_d": 2.9071290790011397, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.020697167755991286, 0.04139433551198257, 0.06209150326797386, 0.08278867102396514, 0.10348583877995643, 0.12418300653594772, 0.144880174291939, 0.1655773420479303, 0.18627450980392157, 0.20697167755991286, 0.22766884531590414, 0.24836601307189543, 0.2690631808278867, 0.289760348583878, 0.3104575163398693, 0.3311546840958606, 0.35185185185185186, 0.37254901960784315 ], "human": [ 1, 4, 4, 16, 40, 46, 64, 54, 78, 64, 51, 37, 22, 12, 10, 1, 1, 2 ], "ai": [ 244, 120, 76, 35, 12, 7, 8, 3, 0, 2, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "gap_p10", "index": 7, "separation_auc": 0.9769927134515209, "human_mean": 0.6833333333333331, "ai_mean": 1.55133872550219, "human_std": 0.2695143805345539, "ai_std": 0.32332191442946734, "cohens_d": -2.91632636849116, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.19999999999998863, 0.3238506420086793, 0.44770128401736997, 0.5715519260260606, 0.6954025680347513, 0.819253210043442, 0.9431038520521327, 1.0669544940608233, 1.190805136069514, 1.3146557780782047, 1.4385064200868953, 1.562357062095586, 1.6862077041042767, 1.8100583461129673, 1.933908988121658, 2.0577596301303487, 2.1816102721390394, 2.30546091414773, 2.4293115561564207 ], "human": [ 32, 45, 112, 92, 103, 45, 42, 16, 9, 2, 5, 1, 0, 0, 2, 1, 0, 0 ], "ai": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 2, 10, 23, 37, 60, 65, 62, 62, 73, 50, 28, 24, 8, 3 ] } }, { "feature": "team_x_std", "index": 32, "separation_auc": 0.9642480616536147, "human_mean": 0.22438892131512136, "ai_mean": 0.11253006698686532, "human_std": 0.046569604547822926, "ai_std": 0.03647008409688, "cohens_d": 2.67439843734021, "permutation_drop": 5.187078468823121e-06, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.04097885715007226, 0.05967554406726931, 0.07837223098446636, 0.09706891790166342, 0.11576560481886045, 0.1344622917360575, 0.15315897865325456, 0.1718556655704516, 0.19055235248764865, 0.2092490394048457, 0.22794572632204274, 0.2466424132392398, 0.26533910015643686, 0.28403578707363386, 0.3027324739908309, 0.321429160908028, 0.34012584782522504, 0.3588225347424221, 0.37751922165961915 ], "human": [ 0, 0, 0, 4, 9, 21, 41, 55, 62, 62, 81, 72, 56, 27, 11, 5, 0, 1 ], "ai": [ 10, 69, 141, 85, 65, 58, 40, 19, 14, 5, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "n_events", "index": 1, "separation_auc": 0.9602371532275947, "human_mean": 47.84220907297831, "ai_mean": 52.0, "human_std": 7.7423216051740775, "ai_std": 0.0, "cohens_d": -0.759462680364035, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 12.0, 14.222222222222221, 16.444444444444443, 18.666666666666668, 20.88888888888889, 23.11111111111111, 25.333333333333336, 27.555555555555557, 29.77777777777778, 32.0, 34.22222222222222, 36.44444444444444, 38.66666666666667, 40.888888888888886, 43.111111111111114, 45.333333333333336, 47.55555555555556, 49.77777777777778, 52.0 ], "human": [ 3, 4, 2, 2, 5, 3, 2, 2, 7, 6, 3, 5, 13, 37, 29, 25, 21, 338 ], "ai": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 507 ] } }, { "feature": "opp_x_std", "index": 36, "separation_auc": 0.9594629817661224, "human_mean": 0.22185115081848295, "ai_mean": 0.11211718531541556, "human_std": 0.04852449056794523, "ai_std": 0.0362945098377592, "cohens_d": 2.5610001650866927, "permutation_drop": 2.5935392344115607e-06, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.03717820654597674, 0.05463523560517283, 0.07209226466436892, 0.08954929372356502, 0.1070063227827611, 0.1244633518419572, 0.14192038090115328, 0.15937740996034938, 0.1768344390195455, 0.1942914680787416, 0.21174849713793764, 0.22920552619713375, 0.24666255525632985, 0.26411958431552596, 0.281576613374722, 0.2990336424339181, 0.3164906714931142, 0.3339477005523103, 0.3514047296115064 ], "human": [ 0, 0, 0, 3, 6, 15, 35, 52, 52, 48, 58, 60, 73, 51, 32, 14, 6, 2 ], "ai": [ 4, 39, 130, 109, 52, 61, 50, 35, 14, 8, 4, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "gap_std", "index": 6, "separation_auc": 0.9567903395850597, "human_mean": 3.2854997082974453, "ai_mean": 2.0514412409424376, "human_std": 0.6614128387175212, "ai_std": 0.44468498872213913, "cohens_d": 2.189734675494674, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.8203780477431759, 1.2216192238353494, 1.622860399927523, 2.0241015760196968, 2.4253427521118702, 2.8265839282040437, 3.2278251042962176, 3.629066280388391, 4.030307456480564, 4.4315486325727385, 4.832789808664911, 5.234030984757085, 5.63527216084926, 6.036513336941432, 6.437754513033607, 6.838995689125779, 7.240236865217954, 7.641478041310126, 8.0427192174023 ], "human": [ 0, 0, 2, 16, 101, 141, 131, 68, 30, 4, 5, 4, 1, 1, 2, 0, 0, 1 ], "ai": [ 8, 57, 205, 150, 54, 22, 10, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "frac_gap_gt_8", "index": 12, "separation_auc": 0.910985843166089, "human_mean": 0.09119874210778797, "ai_mean": 0.03407201144757706, "human_std": 0.04330488923357134, "ai_std": 0.02330321547875564, "cohens_d": 1.6428370766700275, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.025925925925925925, 0.05185185185185185, 0.07777777777777778, 0.1037037037037037, 0.12962962962962962, 0.15555555555555556, 0.18148148148148147, 0.2074074074074074, 0.23333333333333334, 0.25925925925925924, 0.28518518518518515, 0.3111111111111111, 0.337037037037037, 0.36296296296296293, 0.3888888888888889, 0.4148148148148148, 0.4407407407407407, 0.4666666666666667 ], "human": [ 10, 47, 116, 195, 72, 29, 23, 4, 6, 1, 2, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1 ], "ai": [ 227, 155, 92, 31, 2, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "n_plays", "index": 2, "separation_auc": 0.9083521040735424, "human_mean": 45.19921104536489, "ai_mean": 51.32741617357002, "human_std": 7.577720859265211, "ai_std": 1.4139687143018445, "cohens_d": -1.1242883887429072, "permutation_drop": 8.299325550120695e-05, "histogram": { "edges": [ 12.0, 14.222222222222221, 16.444444444444443, 18.666666666666668, 20.88888888888889, 23.11111111111111, 25.333333333333336, 27.555555555555557, 29.77777777777778, 32.0, 34.22222222222222, 36.44444444444444, 38.66666666666667, 40.888888888888886, 43.111111111111114, 45.333333333333336, 47.55555555555556, 49.77777777777778, 52.0 ], "human": [ 5, 2, 2, 2, 8, 2, 2, 6, 3, 8, 9, 17, 27, 42, 32, 59, 128, 153 ], "ai": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 8, 0, 0, 1, 497 ] } }, { "feature": "opp_y_std", "index": 38, "separation_auc": 0.9062746791467775, "human_mean": 0.18274008900837094, "ai_mean": 0.11556225137918996, "human_std": 0.04019991904405759, "ai_std": 0.03174514770591364, "cohens_d": 1.8547127445289848, "permutation_drop": 1.2967696172057803e-06, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.047177173605198096, 0.0626865233542638, 0.07819587310332951, 0.09370522285239521, 0.10921457260146092, 0.12472392235052662, 0.14023327209959235, 0.15574262184865806, 0.17125197159772376, 0.18676132134678947, 0.20227067109585517, 0.21778002084492087, 0.2332893705939866, 0.2487987203430523, 0.264308070092118, 0.2798174198411837, 0.2953267695902494, 0.3108361193393151, 0.3263454690883808 ], "human": [ 0, 1, 7, 6, 17, 35, 67, 67, 77, 74, 64, 40, 25, 10, 11, 4, 1, 1 ], "ai": [ 26, 37, 65, 89, 105, 80, 48, 33, 16, 7, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "team_y_std", "index": 34, "separation_auc": 0.896867912343561, "human_mean": 0.18075031692848254, "ai_mean": 0.11732451167209045, "human_std": 0.038964129152156184, "ai_std": 0.030194779089407583, "cohens_d": 1.8196349963559866, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.039674223372811825, 0.053167478294694856, 0.0666607332165779, 0.08015398813846092, 0.09364724306034397, 0.107140497982227, 0.12063375290411002, 0.13412700782599307, 0.1476202627478761, 0.16111351766975915, 0.17460677259164217, 0.1881000275135252, 0.20159328243540822, 0.21508653735729127, 0.2285797922791743, 0.24207304720105735, 0.2555663021229404, 0.2690595570448234, 0.28255281196670645 ], "human": [ 0, 0, 0, 3, 10, 18, 33, 48, 55, 59, 49, 73, 57, 49, 26, 14, 7, 6 ], "ai": [ 9, 23, 25, 45, 88, 84, 80, 70, 47, 23, 12, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "gap_p90", "index": 9, "separation_auc": 0.873020319083132, "human_mean": 7.352169625246549, "ai_mean": 5.768765572736348, "human_std": 1.2639595384414093, "ai_std": 0.7470650061477818, "cohens_d": 1.525150162656681, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 3.5381977833183953, 4.144686795356263, 4.751175807394131, 5.3576648194319985, 5.964153831469867, 6.570642843507734, 7.177131855545602, 7.78362086758347, 8.390109879621338, 8.996598891659204, 9.603087903697073, 10.20957691573494, 10.816065927772808, 11.422554939810677, 12.029043951848545, 12.635532963886412, 13.24202197592428, 13.848510987962147, 14.455000000000014 ], "human": [ 1, 1, 13, 46, 78, 107, 101, 65, 52, 19, 8, 9, 4, 2, 0, 0, 0, 1 ], "ai": [ 7, 30, 116, 168, 119, 45, 18, 3, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "pending_deep", "index": 57, "separation_auc": 0.8475660282669841, "human_mean": 0.9861932938856016, "ai_mean": 0.9270216962524654, "human_std": 0.11668796416370052, "ai_std": 0.26010088606090354, "cohens_d": 0.2935398260675941, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05555555555555555, 0.1111111111111111, 0.16666666666666666, 0.2222222222222222, 0.2777777777777778, 0.3333333333333333, 0.38888888888888884, 0.4444444444444444, 0.5, 0.5555555555555556, 0.611111111111111, 0.6666666666666666, 0.7222222222222222, 0.7777777777777777, 0.8333333333333333, 0.8888888888888888, 0.9444444444444444, 1.0 ], "human": [ 7, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 500 ], "ai": [ 37, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 470 ] } }, { "feature": "n_abilities", "index": 3, "separation_auc": 0.8356305607102148, "human_mean": 2.6429980276134124, "ai_mean": 0.6725838264299803, "human_std": 2.2313803950585682, "ai_std": 1.413968714301845, "cohens_d": 1.0548620181619934, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 1.0555555555555556, 2.111111111111111, 3.166666666666667, 4.222222222222222, 5.277777777777778, 6.333333333333334, 7.388888888888889, 8.444444444444445, 9.5, 10.555555555555555, 11.61111111111111, 12.666666666666668, 13.722222222222223, 14.777777777777779, 15.833333333333334, 16.88888888888889, 17.944444444444446, 19.0 ], "human": [ 166, 106, 94, 73, 40, 11, 6, 4, 0, 0, 0, 0, 2, 2, 1, 1, 0, 1 ], "ai": [ 467, 30, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 2, 5, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "side_count_imbalance", "index": 64, "separation_auc": 0.8266595084983797, "human_mean": 0.10822643404257506, "ai_mean": 0.02564102564102564, "human_std": 0.08969985970450793, "ai_std": 0.024196931255197823, "cohens_d": 1.2571113992303087, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.037037037037037035, 0.07407407407407407, 0.1111111111111111, 0.14814814814814814, 0.18518518518518517, 0.2222222222222222, 0.25925925925925924, 0.2962962962962963, 0.3333333333333333, 0.37037037037037035, 0.4074074074074074, 0.4444444444444444, 0.48148148148148145, 0.5185185185185185, 0.5555555555555556, 0.5925925925925926, 0.6296296296296295, 0.6666666666666666 ], "human": [ 76, 133, 78, 67, 47, 38, 26, 23, 8, 6, 3, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1 ], "ai": [ 211, 256, 38, 2, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "frac_gap_lt_2", "index": 11, "separation_auc": 0.8115417683009855, "human_mean": 0.3648432568299111, "ai_mean": 0.2493328692423715, "human_std": 0.08492147246868662, "ai_std": 0.09839476307676576, "cohens_d": 1.2568407652589775, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0196078431372549, 0.053376906318082784, 0.08714596949891067, 0.12091503267973855, 0.15468409586056642, 0.1884531590413943, 0.2222222222222222, 0.25599128540305005, 0.28976034858387795, 0.32352941176470584, 0.35729847494553374, 0.3910675381263616, 0.4248366013071895, 0.4586056644880174, 0.4923747276688452, 0.5261437908496732, 0.5599128540305011, 0.5936819172113289, 0.6274509803921569 ], "human": [ 0, 1, 2, 1, 6, 12, 32, 35, 65, 95, 53, 85, 59, 35, 6, 10, 8, 2 ], "ai": [ 5, 27, 30, 28, 49, 57, 80, 37, 71, 59, 25, 23, 10, 3, 2, 1, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "tile_diversity", "index": 47, "separation_auc": 0.7871806542721427, "human_mean": 0.7538384917081241, "ai_mean": 0.6672735548475193, "human_std": 0.07622646695762214, "ai_std": 0.07647050717716798, "cohens_d": 1.1338119409036551, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.4423076923076923, 0.4732905982905983, 0.5042735042735043, 0.5352564102564102, 0.5662393162393162, 0.5972222222222222, 0.6282051282051282, 0.6591880341880342, 0.6901709401709402, 0.7211538461538461, 0.7521367521367521, 0.7831196581196581, 0.8141025641025641, 0.8450854700854701, 0.8760683760683761, 0.907051282051282, 0.938034188034188, 0.969017094017094, 1.0 ], "human": [ 0, 0, 0, 3, 10, 6, 40, 32, 79, 101, 54, 85, 40, 31, 16, 4, 2, 4 ], "ai": [ 2, 9, 11, 25, 63, 38, 91, 55, 90, 69, 14, 29, 5, 5, 0, 1, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "pre_elixir_mean", "index": 21, "separation_auc": 0.7637726659119467, "human_mean": 6.918139563156301, "ai_mean": 6.246328386030658, "human_std": 0.7194066856916392, "ai_std": 0.6198000015194158, "cohens_d": 1.0005335696583073, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 4.431568475921534, 4.6684860697500685, 4.905403663578603, 5.142321257407139, 5.379238851235674, 5.616156445064209, 5.853074038892744, 6.089991632721279, 6.326909226549814, 6.563826820378349, 6.800744414206884, 7.037662008035419, 7.2745796018639535, 7.511497195692489, 7.748414789521024, 7.98533238334956, 8.222249977178095, 8.45916757100663, 8.696085164835164 ], "human": [ 0, 0, 5, 9, 7, 16, 24, 32, 68, 56, 71, 59, 51, 48, 27, 12, 15, 7 ], "ai": [ 1, 6, 10, 23, 37, 55, 71, 87, 67, 55, 45, 26, 12, 7, 3, 0, 1, 1 ] } }, { "feature": "max_streak", "index": 14, "separation_auc": 0.7575209395873939, "human_mean": 3.5976331360946747, "ai_mean": 2.5483234714003946, "human_std": 1.3601232394006142, "ai_std": 0.7557355638755481, "cohens_d": 0.9537067707911102, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 1.0, 1.7777777777777777, 2.5555555555555554, 3.3333333333333335, 4.111111111111111, 4.888888888888889, 5.666666666666667, 6.444444444444445, 7.222222222222222, 8.0, 8.777777777777779, 9.555555555555555, 10.333333333333334, 11.11111111111111, 11.88888888888889, 12.666666666666666, 13.444444444444445, 14.222222222222223, 15.0 ], "human": [ 0, 48, 252, 137, 0, 41, 14, 7, 0, 1, 2, 3, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 2 ], "ai": [ 9, 270, 180, 40, 0, 5, 3, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "dump_rate", "index": 23, "separation_auc": 0.7449396807612556, "human_mean": 0.22089203639072455, "ai_mean": 0.3322333485055379, "human_std": 0.1214190082667482, "ai_std": 0.12219251665880065, "cohens_d": -0.9140844292766387, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.0373931623931624, 0.0747863247863248, 0.1121794871794872, 0.1495726495726496, 0.186965811965812, 0.2243589743589744, 0.2617521367521368, 0.2991452991452992, 0.33653846153846156, 0.373931623931624, 0.4113247863247864, 0.4487179487179488, 0.48611111111111116, 0.5235042735042736, 0.560897435897436, 0.5982905982905984, 0.6356837606837608, 0.6730769230769231 ], "human": [ 16, 25, 55, 64, 54, 71, 50, 50, 39, 22, 18, 14, 15, 6, 6, 2, 0, 0 ], "ai": [ 1, 8, 7, 14, 27, 40, 47, 46, 67, 72, 56, 40, 33, 20, 11, 7, 10, 1 ] } }, { "feature": "plays_per_min", "index": 4, "separation_auc": 0.7253364144579438, "human_mean": 15.714884819495717, "ai_mean": 17.350074527783768, "human_std": 2.1214521818452625, "ai_std": 1.6373449554772421, "cohens_d": -0.8629325174258413, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 8.627182471756246, 9.381932968729735, 10.136683465703227, 10.891433962676716, 11.646184459650206, 12.400934956623697, 13.155685453597187, 13.910435950570676, 14.665186447544166, 15.419936944517657, 16.174687441491145, 16.929437938464638, 17.684188435438127, 18.438938932411617, 19.193689429385106, 19.948439926358596, 20.70319042333209, 21.457940920305575, 22.212691417279068 ], "human": [ 5, 4, 4, 3, 11, 25, 38, 64, 70, 63, 69, 58, 40, 32, 16, 4, 1, 0 ], "ai": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 3, 2, 7, 5, 31, 78, 80, 95, 78, 58, 34, 26, 7, 3 ] } }, { "feature": "resp_latency_std", "index": 55, "separation_auc": 0.7082346167462235, "human_mean": 5.431637211348812, "ai_mean": 2.248464578450304, "human_std": 7.43433643994027, "ai_std": 4.984312189789767, "cohens_d": 0.5029495622180122, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 3.5208333333333335, 7.041666666666667, 10.5625, 14.083333333333334, 17.604166666666668, 21.125, 24.645833333333336, 28.166666666666668, 31.6875, 35.208333333333336, 38.72916666666667, 42.25, 45.770833333333336, 49.29166666666667, 52.8125, 56.333333333333336, 59.85416666666667, 63.375 ], "human": [ 198, 212, 37, 20, 13, 6, 5, 4, 4, 2, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 0, 1, 1 ], "ai": [ 435, 50, 6, 5, 1, 2, 1, 3, 0, 1, 0, 1, 0, 0, 1, 1, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "opp_bridge_rate", "index": 42, "separation_auc": 0.705651451668748, "human_mean": 0.3717680597769321, "ai_mean": 0.2650397793555653, "human_std": 0.13560167054681574, "ai_std": 0.14803774942156994, "cohens_d": 0.7518407930673124, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.04700854700854701, 0.09401709401709402, 0.14102564102564102, 0.18803418803418803, 0.23504273504273504, 0.28205128205128205, 0.32905982905982906, 0.37606837606837606, 0.4230769230769231, 0.4700854700854701, 0.517094017094017, 0.5641025641025641, 0.6111111111111112, 0.6581196581196581, 0.7051282051282051, 0.7521367521367521, 0.7991452991452992, 0.8461538461538461 ], "human": [ 2, 2, 11, 26, 39, 57, 61, 63, 76, 53, 37, 35, 22, 13, 5, 4, 0, 1 ], "ai": [ 32, 37, 37, 65, 75, 48, 45, 55, 31, 29, 16, 24, 4, 6, 3, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "team_bridge_rate", "index": 41, "separation_auc": 0.7046399713673268, "human_mean": 0.3597140172253174, "ai_mean": 0.26002545174828856, "human_std": 0.12394879179340401, "ai_std": 0.14594368903517052, "cohens_d": 0.7362870367729377, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.043209876543209874, 0.08641975308641975, 0.12962962962962962, 0.1728395061728395, 0.21604938271604937, 0.25925925925925924, 0.30246913580246915, 0.345679012345679, 0.38888888888888884, 0.43209876543209874, 0.47530864197530864, 0.5185185185185185, 0.5617283950617283, 0.6049382716049383, 0.6481481481481481, 0.691358024691358, 0.7345679012345678, 0.7777777777777778 ], "human": [ 1, 1, 6, 26, 30, 41, 63, 64, 80, 60, 47, 26, 27, 20, 10, 3, 2, 0 ], "ai": [ 34, 33, 40, 52, 43, 59, 60, 37, 60, 21, 27, 15, 12, 6, 3, 1, 2, 2 ] } }, { "feature": "resp_latency_mean", "index": 54, "separation_auc": 0.7045582748814428, "human_mean": 12.628192620684198, "ai_mean": 10.798724590969725, "human_std": 17.64655386380832, "ai_std": 24.937896420071333, "cohens_d": 0.08468944683426634, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 8.156024354618276, 16.312048709236553, 24.46807306385483, 32.624097418473106, 40.78012177309138, 48.93614612770966, 57.09217048232794, 65.24819483694621, 73.4042191915645, 81.56024354618276, 89.71626790080104, 97.87229225541932, 106.02831661003759, 114.18434096465587, 122.34036531927414, 130.49638967389242, 138.6524140285107, 146.808438383129 ], "human": [ 304, 89, 42, 27, 21, 5, 6, 3, 1, 2, 0, 0, 1, 2, 1, 2, 1, 0 ], "ai": [ 422, 11, 21, 8, 7, 5, 4, 4, 3, 2, 2, 0, 3, 4, 1, 7, 2, 1 ] } }, { "feature": "spend_team", "index": 24, "separation_auc": 0.6972795070200624, "human_mean": 79.02169625246549, "ai_mean": 89.40039447731755, "human_std": 15.424100697603999, "ai_std": 13.29573495116855, "cohens_d": -0.7207781706465556, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 17.0, 22.666666666666668, 28.333333333333336, 34.0, 39.66666666666667, 45.333333333333336, 51.0, 56.66666666666667, 62.333333333333336, 68.0, 73.66666666666667, 79.33333333333334, 85.0, 90.66666666666667, 96.33333333333334, 102.0, 107.66666666666667, 113.33333333333334, 119.0 ], "human": [ 6, 3, 4, 3, 11, 3, 2, 13, 22, 68, 93, 99, 89, 42, 27, 17, 4, 1 ], "ai": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 2, 11, 23, 37, 44, 55, 80, 90, 70, 60, 25, 10 ] } }, { "feature": "spend_opp", "index": 25, "separation_auc": 0.689047613490035, "human_mean": 79.40236686390533, "ai_mean": 88.74753451676528, "human_std": 15.00058625808732, "ai_std": 12.742765625068829, "cohens_d": -0.6714670673805653, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 14.0, 20.22222222222222, 26.444444444444443, 32.66666666666667, 38.888888888888886, 45.111111111111114, 51.333333333333336, 57.55555555555556, 63.77777777777778, 70.0, 76.22222222222223, 82.44444444444444, 88.66666666666667, 94.88888888888889, 101.11111111111111, 107.33333333333333, 113.55555555555556, 119.77777777777779, 126.0 ], "human": [ 3, 4, 2, 6, 8, 3, 2, 16, 36, 102, 114, 98, 52, 38, 14, 7, 2, 0 ], "ai": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 3, 7, 38, 47, 51, 79, 109, 90, 51, 26, 3, 2 ] } }, { "feature": "leak_team", "index": 18, "separation_auc": 0.6440289594590914, "human_mean": 1.2879684418145956, "ai_mean": 0.4486329096205783, "human_std": 3.446088836378819, "ai_std": 1.0977359115695902, "cohens_d": 0.3281992348221601, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 1.8740079365079358, 3.7480158730158717, 5.6220238095238075, 7.496031746031743, 9.37003968253968, 11.244047619047615, 13.11805555555555, 14.992063492063487, 16.866071428571423, 18.74007936507936, 20.614087301587293, 22.48809523809523, 24.362103174603167, 26.2361111111111, 28.110119047619037, 29.984126984126974, 31.85813492063491, 33.73214285714285 ], "human": [ 427, 37, 15, 9, 6, 3, 2, 2, 1, 0, 1, 0, 0, 1, 1, 0, 0, 2 ], "ai": [ 468, 27, 10, 0, 1, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "gap_mean", "index": 5, "separation_auc": 0.6407260872440663, "human_mean": 3.5320994629873135, "ai_mean": 3.298910051680868, "human_std": 0.48705423739008624, "ai_std": 0.2846876410406492, "cohens_d": 0.5845568227583279, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 2.527565679795567, 2.7497379568439615, 2.971910233892356, 3.1940825109407505, 3.416254787989145, 3.638427065037539, 3.8605993420859335, 4.082771619134328, 4.304943896182722, 4.527116173231117, 4.749288450279511, 4.971460727327906, 5.1936330043763, 5.415805281424695, 5.637977558473089, 5.860149835521484, 6.082322112569878, 6.304494389618273, 6.526666666666667 ], "human": [ 2, 35, 92, 113, 83, 83, 51, 22, 14, 2, 2, 2, 0, 2, 1, 1, 1, 1 ], "ai": [ 13, 61, 97, 148, 127, 55, 5, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "frac_single", "index": 15, "separation_auc": 0.6292068827344203, "human_mean": 0.5857528578958227, "ai_mean": 0.5280814060401805, "human_std": 0.13694611976488916, "ai_std": 0.09065903790507243, "cohens_d": 0.4966024229890693, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.06613756613756613, 0.13227513227513227, 0.1984126984126984, 0.26455026455026454, 0.3306878306878307, 0.3968253968253968, 0.4629629629629629, 0.5291005291005291, 0.5952380952380952, 0.6613756613756614, 0.7275132275132274, 0.7936507936507936, 0.8597883597883598, 0.9259259259259258, 0.992063492063492, 1.0582010582010581, 1.1243386243386242, 1.1904761904761905 ], "human": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 2, 9, 49, 115, 146, 100, 39, 10, 8, 7, 1, 12, 7, 2 ], "ai": [ 3, 0, 0, 1, 1, 9, 98, 156, 134, 66, 30, 8, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "leak_opp", "index": 19, "separation_auc": 0.6259584748433178, "human_mean": 1.1762820512820515, "ai_mean": 0.5290817905754697, "human_std": 2.830340245154219, "ai_std": 1.1611440487770128, "cohens_d": 0.2991831076857032, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 1.779761904761905, 3.55952380952381, 5.339285714285715, 7.11904761904762, 8.898809523809526, 10.67857142857143, 12.458333333333336, 14.23809523809524, 16.017857142857146, 17.79761904761905, 19.577380952380956, 21.35714285714286, 23.136904761904766, 24.91666666666667, 26.696428571428577, 28.47619047619048, 30.255952380952387, 32.03571428571429 ], "human": [ 405, 59, 25, 3, 1, 3, 7, 0, 1, 0, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 1 ], "ai": [ 453, 37, 12, 1, 4, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "cost_delta_mean", "index": 29, "separation_auc": 0.62536325758902, "human_mean": 1.627611236644356, "ai_mean": 1.494295548594191, "human_std": 0.3158691765120263, "ai_std": 0.3105573469326702, "cohens_d": 0.42562340644766294, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.6274509803921569, 0.7494553376906318, 0.8714596949891068, 0.9934640522875817, 1.1154684095860568, 1.2374727668845318, 1.3594771241830066, 1.4814814814814816, 1.6034858387799567, 1.7254901960784315, 1.8474945533769065, 1.9694989106753815, 2.0915032679738563, 2.2135076252723316, 2.3355119825708064, 2.457516339869281, 2.579520697167756, 2.7015250544662313, 2.823529411764706 ], "human": [ 1, 1, 8, 20, 23, 46, 68, 60, 87, 81, 49, 27, 19, 7, 5, 3, 1, 1 ], "ai": [ 2, 9, 14, 23, 62, 59, 89, 71, 63, 55, 24, 15, 11, 9, 0, 1, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "gap_p50", "index": 8, "separation_auc": 0.6206520935697085, "human_mean": 2.6085305719921106, "ai_mean": 2.7309754478959745, "human_std": 0.47567035698378846, "ai_std": 0.26825864035857777, "cohens_d": -0.3170907690768281, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 1.4000000000000004, 1.655555555555556, 1.9111111111111114, 2.166666666666667, 2.4222222222222225, 2.677777777777778, 2.9333333333333336, 3.188888888888889, 3.4444444444444446, 3.7, 3.9555555555555557, 4.211111111111111, 4.466666666666667, 4.722222222222222, 4.977777777777778, 5.233333333333333, 5.488888888888889, 5.7444444444444445, 6.0 ], "human": [ 4, 17, 56, 101, 124, 102, 59, 23, 11, 4, 3, 0, 1, 0, 0, 0, 1, 1 ], "ai": [ 0, 1, 11, 42, 163, 170, 99, 20, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "opp_unique_frac", "index": 49, "separation_auc": 0.6199051542701975, "human_mean": 1.038214990138067, "ai_mean": 0.996301775147929, "human_std": 0.09799729865933311, "ai_std": 0.07822539663878099, "cohens_d": 0.472718545446659, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.5, 0.5347222222222222, 0.5694444444444444, 0.6041666666666666, 0.6388888888888888, 0.6736111111111112, 0.7083333333333334, 0.7430555555555556, 0.7777777777777778, 0.8125, 0.8472222222222222, 0.8819444444444444, 0.9166666666666667, 0.9513888888888888, 0.9861111111111112, 1.0208333333333335, 1.0555555555555556, 1.0902777777777777, 1.125 ], "human": [ 1, 0, 0, 2, 0, 0, 0, 9, 0, 0, 53, 0, 0, 0, 206, 0, 0, 236 ], "ai": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 5, 0, 0, 92, 0, 0, 0, 323, 0, 0, 87 ] } }, { "feature": "team_unique_frac", "index": 48, "separation_auc": 0.6189520286015506, "human_mean": 1.0414201183431953, "ai_mean": 0.997534516765286, "human_std": 0.09161252675678755, "ai_std": 0.07925215227954416, "cohens_d": 0.5123495596280288, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.625, 0.6527777777777778, 0.6805555555555556, 0.7083333333333334, 0.7361111111111112, 0.7638888888888888, 0.7916666666666666, 0.8194444444444444, 0.8472222222222222, 0.875, 0.9027777777777778, 0.9305555555555556, 0.9583333333333333, 0.9861111111111112, 1.0138888888888888, 1.0416666666666665, 1.0694444444444444, 1.0972222222222223, 1.125 ], "human": [ 2, 0, 0, 0, 4, 0, 0, 0, 0, 56, 0, 0, 0, 207, 0, 0, 0, 238 ], "ai": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 4, 0, 0, 0, 0, 95, 0, 0, 0, 315, 0, 0, 0, 93 ] } }, { "feature": "team_deck_spells", "index": 60, "separation_auc": 0.6177382522398454, "human_mean": 1.8875739644970415, "ai_mean": 1.856015779092702, "human_std": 0.6290027108127011, "ai_std": 0.6944257512588191, "cohens_d": 0.04763339515465677, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.2222222222222222, 0.4444444444444444, 0.6666666666666666, 0.8888888888888888, 1.1111111111111112, 1.3333333333333333, 1.5555555555555554, 1.7777777777777777, 2.0, 2.2222222222222223, 2.444444444444444, 2.6666666666666665, 2.888888888888889, 3.1111111111111107, 3.333333333333333, 3.5555555555555554, 3.7777777777777777, 4.0 ], "human": [ 9, 0, 0, 0, 105, 0, 0, 0, 0, 327, 0, 0, 0, 66, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "ai": [ 14, 0, 0, 0, 119, 0, 0, 0, 0, 303, 0, 0, 0, 68, 0, 0, 0, 3 ] } }, { "feature": "opp_deck_wincons", "index": 63, "separation_auc": 0.6153729444580605, "human_mean": 1.2090729783037475, "ai_mean": 1.2110453648915187, "human_std": 0.6086786288142154, "ai_std": 0.5865321915707037, "cohens_d": -0.0032999167111533194, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.2222222222222222, 0.4444444444444444, 0.6666666666666666, 0.8888888888888888, 1.1111111111111112, 1.3333333333333333, 1.5555555555555554, 1.7777777777777777, 2.0, 2.2222222222222223, 2.444444444444444, 2.6666666666666665, 2.888888888888889, 3.1111111111111107, 3.333333333333333, 3.5555555555555554, 3.7777777777777777, 4.0 ], "human": [ 39, 0, 0, 0, 335, 0, 0, 0, 0, 122, 0, 0, 0, 10, 0, 0, 0, 1 ], "ai": [ 36, 0, 0, 0, 337, 0, 0, 0, 0, 125, 0, 0, 0, 9, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "pre_elixir_std", "index": 22, "separation_auc": 0.6114048294294084, "human_mean": 2.222560593255056, "ai_mean": 2.1235981303889204, "human_std": 0.27097887436281265, "ai_std": 0.3515567461609228, "cohens_d": 0.31530326363955924, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 1.181489995671505, 1.297146835325068, 1.4128036749786308, 1.5284605146321937, 1.6441173542857563, 1.7597741939393194, 1.875431033592882, 1.991087873246445, 2.106744712900008, 2.2224015525535705, 2.3380583922071336, 2.4537152318606967, 2.569372071514259, 2.685028911167822, 2.800685750821385, 2.916342590474948, 3.0319994301285105, 3.1476562697820736, 3.2633131094356367 ], "human": [ 1, 0, 1, 5, 13, 27, 48, 72, 88, 73, 80, 54, 25, 8, 8, 1, 1, 2 ], "ai": [ 2, 2, 10, 13, 37, 57, 84, 76, 52, 53, 31, 28, 18, 22, 10, 7, 4, 1 ] } }, { "feature": "cost_std", "index": 28, "separation_auc": 0.6050091616773455, "human_mean": 1.47178530925544, "ai_mean": 1.3846947205988898, "human_std": 0.25203834558550564, "ai_std": 0.2600604042997993, "cohens_d": 0.3400902848559764, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.6114658882917171, 0.7076270994429048, 0.8037883105940924, 0.89994952174528, 0.9961107328964677, 1.0922719440476554, 1.188433155198843, 1.2845943663500305, 1.3807555775012181, 1.4769167886524057, 1.5730779998035935, 1.6692392109547813, 1.765400422105969, 1.8615616332571565, 1.957722844408344, 2.0538840555595317, 2.1500452667107193, 2.246206477861907, 2.3423676890130944 ], "human": [ 0, 0, 6, 9, 20, 29, 51, 61, 85, 84, 57, 44, 26, 20, 5, 7, 2, 1 ], "ai": [ 1, 2, 13, 14, 34, 39, 66, 96, 80, 69, 33, 21, 14, 11, 4, 7, 2, 1 ] } }, { "feature": "team_spell_rate", "index": 50, "separation_auc": 0.5969484417367894, "human_mean": 0.15876936575956682, "ai_mean": 0.19492581029327447, "human_std": 0.0868580301042222, "ai_std": 0.10725070510742273, "cohens_d": -0.3704990248108036, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.031111111111111114, 0.06222222222222223, 0.09333333333333334, 0.12444444444444445, 0.15555555555555556, 0.18666666666666668, 0.2177777777777778, 0.2488888888888889, 0.28, 0.3111111111111111, 0.34222222222222226, 0.37333333333333335, 0.4044444444444445, 0.4355555555555556, 0.46666666666666673, 0.4977777777777778, 0.528888888888889, 0.56 ], "human": [ 29, 46, 54, 51, 77, 53, 62, 47, 47, 21, 12, 4, 2, 1, 0, 0, 1, 0 ], "ai": [ 32, 17, 38, 62, 54, 45, 53, 48, 47, 39, 19, 29, 10, 4, 6, 1, 2, 1 ] } }, { "feature": "opp_spell_rate", "index": 51, "separation_auc": 0.5956218464183871, "human_mean": 0.1598556351784849, "ai_mean": 0.19552792088397067, "human_std": 0.09218874145022089, "ai_std": 0.10414334392975681, "cohens_d": -0.36271545176285674, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.02888888888888889, 0.05777777777777778, 0.08666666666666667, 0.11555555555555556, 0.14444444444444446, 0.17333333333333334, 0.20222222222222225, 0.23111111111111113, 0.26, 0.2888888888888889, 0.3177777777777778, 0.3466666666666667, 0.3755555555555556, 0.4044444444444445, 0.43333333333333335, 0.46222222222222226, 0.49111111111111116, 0.52 ], "human": [ 40, 41, 37, 46, 59, 63, 65, 46, 39, 27, 15, 15, 7, 5, 1, 1, 0, 0 ], "ai": [ 28, 21, 39, 42, 19, 69, 63, 56, 28, 43, 29, 36, 14, 9, 5, 3, 1, 2 ] } }, { "feature": "cost_delta_std", "index": 30, "separation_auc": 0.5956101754918323, "human_mean": 1.275905295249223, "ai_mean": 1.1975629303753375, "human_std": 0.2461497864297551, "ai_std": 0.24138567929023866, "cohens_d": 0.321365850308142, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.5224671605676169, 0.6079084416241601, 0.6933497226807033, 0.7787910037372465, 0.8642322847937898, 0.949673565850333, 1.0351148469068763, 1.1205561279634195, 1.2059974090199628, 1.291438690076506, 1.3768799711330493, 1.4623212521895923, 1.5477625332461353, 1.6332038143026786, 1.7186450953592218, 1.804086376415765, 1.8895276574723083, 1.9749689385288516, 2.060410219585395 ], "human": [ 0, 0, 7, 13, 24, 44, 48, 68, 63, 72, 68, 30, 32, 12, 13, 6, 5, 2 ], "ai": [ 1, 2, 10, 22, 39, 60, 62, 72, 83, 55, 41, 22, 13, 8, 7, 6, 0, 4 ] } }, { "feature": "team_deck_wincons", "index": 62, "separation_auc": 0.5882574917622709, "human_mean": 1.2011834319526626, "ai_mean": 1.1617357001972386, "human_std": 0.5356691145453208, "ai_std": 0.6003576721295937, "cohens_d": 0.06933627448639632, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.2222222222222222, 0.4444444444444444, 0.6666666666666666, 0.8888888888888888, 1.1111111111111112, 1.3333333333333333, 1.5555555555555554, 1.7777777777777777, 2.0, 2.2222222222222223, 2.444444444444444, 2.6666666666666665, 2.888888888888889, 3.1111111111111107, 3.333333333333333, 3.5555555555555554, 3.7777777777777777, 4.0 ], "human": [ 26, 0, 0, 0, 359, 0, 0, 0, 0, 116, 0, 0, 0, 6, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "ai": [ 46, 0, 0, 0, 343, 0, 0, 0, 0, 109, 0, 0, 0, 8, 0, 0, 0, 1 ] } }, { "feature": "opp_deck_spells", "index": 61, "separation_auc": 0.582457041264506, "human_mean": 1.8500986193293885, "ai_mean": 1.8678500986193294, "human_std": 0.6860220280835342, "ai_std": 0.7272465114235354, "cohens_d": -0.02511048897880193, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.2777777777777778, 0.5555555555555556, 0.8333333333333334, 1.1111111111111112, 1.3888888888888888, 1.6666666666666667, 1.9444444444444446, 2.2222222222222223, 2.5, 2.7777777777777777, 3.055555555555556, 3.3333333333333335, 3.611111111111111, 3.8888888888888893, 4.166666666666667, 4.444444444444445, 4.722222222222222, 5.0 ], "human": [ 15, 0, 0, 113, 0, 0, 0, 316, 0, 0, 60, 0, 0, 0, 2, 0, 0, 1 ], "ai": [ 19, 0, 0, 112, 0, 0, 0, 296, 0, 0, 77, 0, 0, 0, 3, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "duration_norm", "index": 0, "separation_auc": 0.5741434512485946, "human_mean": 0.5755032873109797, "ai_mean": 0.5964718422505733, "human_std": 0.07556170250552667, "ai_std": 0.05372393727682591, "cohens_d": -0.3198449750452723, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.1595, 0.19786703728426983, 0.23623407456853962, 0.27460111185280944, 0.31296814913707927, 0.3513351864213491, 0.3897022237056189, 0.42806926098988873, 0.46643629827415856, 0.5048033355584284, 0.5431703728426982, 0.581537410126968, 0.6199044474112377, 0.6582714846955076, 0.6966385219797774, 0.7350055592640472, 0.773372596548317, 0.8117396338325868, 0.8501066711168567 ], "human": [ 2, 2, 2, 4, 5, 5, 3, 3, 15, 65, 129, 173, 52, 32, 14, 1, 0, 0 ], "ai": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 18, 70, 113, 136, 114, 47, 4, 2, 0, 3 ] } }, { "feature": "cost_mean", "index": 27, "separation_auc": 0.5636318367315181, "human_mean": 3.330476443154394, "ai_mean": 3.42592171142467, "human_std": 0.4484469888026179, "ai_std": 0.43677389750438605, "cohens_d": -0.21562295345090973, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 2.1923076923076925, 2.3301282051282053, 2.467948717948718, 2.605769230769231, 2.7435897435897436, 2.8814102564102564, 3.0192307692307696, 3.1570512820512824, 3.294871794871795, 3.432692307692308, 3.5705128205128207, 3.708333333333334, 3.8461538461538467, 3.9839743589743595, 4.121794871794872, 4.259615384615385, 4.397435897435898, 4.535256410256411, 4.673076923076923 ], "human": [ 1, 4, 18, 26, 43, 50, 54, 50, 50, 49, 43, 44, 32, 24, 15, 3, 1, 0 ], "ai": [ 3, 5, 10, 10, 25, 42, 43, 71, 42, 49, 63, 55, 31, 38, 11, 7, 1, 1 ] } }, { "feature": "team_wincon_rate", "index": 52, "separation_auc": 0.5569910795218033, "human_mean": 0.14151489121097238, "ai_mean": 0.12592938652882055, "human_std": 0.08201617690494188, "ai_std": 0.0829643791178959, "cohens_d": 0.18893435266719785, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.025252525252525252, 0.050505050505050504, 0.07575757575757576, 0.10101010101010101, 0.12626262626262627, 0.15151515151515152, 0.17676767676767677, 0.20202020202020202, 0.22727272727272727, 0.25252525252525254, 0.2777777777777778, 0.30303030303030304, 0.3282828282828283, 0.35353535353535354, 0.3787878787878788, 0.40404040404040403, 0.4292929292929293, 0.45454545454545453 ], "human": [ 38, 23, 28, 69, 72, 82, 57, 49, 17, 15, 16, 16, 11, 8, 3, 1, 1, 1 ], "ai": [ 62, 43, 23, 52, 113, 27, 63, 51, 10, 21, 15, 13, 5, 3, 2, 3, 1, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "team_x_mean", "index": 31, "separation_auc": 0.5351742274819198, "human_mean": 0.4988165441917979, "ai_mean": 0.5160322222887216, "human_std": 0.13241186160634055, "ai_std": 0.19415885503113023, "cohens_d": -0.10359752972572488, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.19408119658119657, 0.228991339444238, 0.2639014823072794, 0.29881162517032084, 0.3337217680333623, 0.3686319108964037, 0.4035420537594451, 0.4384521966224865, 0.47336233948552797, 0.5082724823485694, 0.5431826252116108, 0.5780927680746523, 0.6130029109376937, 0.647913053800735, 0.6828231966637764, 0.717733339526818, 0.7526434823898593, 0.7875536252529007, 0.8224637681159421 ], "human": [ 2, 14, 21, 29, 28, 33, 45, 47, 58, 38, 37, 40, 33, 28, 33, 17, 2, 2 ], "ai": [ 5, 33, 58, 59, 46, 21, 10, 3, 1, 1, 7, 9, 34, 58, 68, 77, 17, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "team_deep_rate", "index": 39, "separation_auc": 0.5325210368451152, "human_mean": 0.32342682773874815, "ai_mean": 0.38908463423556466, "human_std": 0.25641594349290153, "ai_std": 0.3519570087974998, "cohens_d": -0.2132337807960358, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05555555555555555, 0.1111111111111111, 0.16666666666666666, 0.2222222222222222, 0.2777777777777778, 0.3333333333333333, 0.38888888888888884, 0.4444444444444444, 0.5, 0.5555555555555556, 0.611111111111111, 0.6666666666666666, 0.7222222222222222, 0.7777777777777777, 0.8333333333333333, 0.8888888888888888, 0.9444444444444444, 1.0 ], "human": [ 103, 50, 53, 33, 17, 15, 12, 22, 23, 45, 47, 30, 31, 15, 4, 7, 0, 0 ], "ai": [ 163, 32, 28, 11, 6, 11, 14, 15, 7, 14, 24, 27, 21, 27, 23, 39, 31, 14 ] } }, { "feature": "opp_x_mean", "index": 35, "separation_auc": 0.5312411252329323, "human_mean": 0.4967375752668424, "ai_mean": 0.5138369779858999, "human_std": 0.13192673898098733, "ai_std": 0.19394365609101982, "cohens_d": -0.10309565382076591, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.20057905982905982, 0.233863816414255, 0.26714857299945016, 0.30043332958464536, 0.33371808616984056, 0.3670028427550357, 0.4002875993402309, 0.4335723559254261, 0.46685711251062123, 0.5001418690958164, 0.5334266256810116, 0.5667113822662068, 0.5999961388514019, 0.6332808954365972, 0.6665656520217923, 0.6998504086069874, 0.7331351651921827, 0.7664199217773777, 0.7997046783625731 ], "human": [ 3, 9, 19, 37, 28, 36, 42, 43, 42, 47, 42, 32, 33, 34, 28, 14, 13, 5 ], "ai": [ 11, 40, 54, 50, 39, 28, 8, 6, 0, 2, 5, 10, 22, 40, 70, 69, 47, 6 ] } }, { "feature": "opp_wincon_rate", "index": 53, "separation_auc": 0.5299534330030461, "human_mean": 0.14106233500647825, "ai_mean": 0.1296688309964512, "human_std": 0.08590783947333429, "ai_std": 0.07984848716966343, "cohens_d": 0.13738116846910836, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.025641025641025644, 0.05128205128205129, 0.07692307692307693, 0.10256410256410257, 0.12820512820512822, 0.15384615384615385, 0.17948717948717952, 0.20512820512820515, 0.23076923076923078, 0.25641025641025644, 0.2820512820512821, 0.3076923076923077, 0.33333333333333337, 0.35897435897435903, 0.38461538461538464, 0.4102564102564103, 0.43589743589743596, 0.46153846153846156 ], "human": [ 45, 29, 28, 68, 68, 71, 70, 23, 21, 33, 13, 15, 11, 4, 4, 2, 1, 1 ], "ai": [ 52, 50, 16, 46, 109, 33, 68, 54, 13, 28, 24, 2, 9, 0, 1, 1, 0, 1 ] } }, { "feature": "team_deck_cost_mean", "index": 58, "separation_auc": 0.5278837886939844, "human_mean": 3.592209072978304, "ai_mean": 3.646696252465483, "human_std": 0.5477144115358583, "ai_std": 0.5612926951167979, "cohens_d": -0.09825562996373638, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 2.125, 2.2847222222222223, 2.4444444444444446, 2.6041666666666665, 2.763888888888889, 2.923611111111111, 3.083333333333333, 3.2430555555555554, 3.4027777777777777, 3.5625, 3.7222222222222223, 3.881944444444444, 4.041666666666666, 4.201388888888889, 4.361111111111111, 4.520833333333333, 4.680555555555555, 4.840277777777778, 5.0 ], "human": [ 0, 4, 2, 52, 25, 23, 20, 62, 37, 37, 97, 44, 34, 27, 35, 5, 1, 2 ], "ai": [ 1, 8, 6, 35, 15, 24, 22, 59, 41, 37, 83, 45, 46, 30, 43, 6, 3, 3 ] } }, { "feature": "spend_diff", "index": 26, "separation_auc": 0.5262459686674525, "human_mean": -0.3806706114398422, "ai_mean": 0.6528599605522682, "human_std": 8.526271105152846, "ai_std": 12.746110003565498, "cohens_d": -0.0953138534388862, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ -41.0, -36.166666666666664, -31.333333333333336, -26.5, -21.666666666666668, -16.833333333333336, -12.0, -7.166666666666671, -2.3333333333333357, 2.5, 7.333333333333329, 12.166666666666664, 17.0, 21.83333333333333, 26.666666666666657, 31.5, 36.33333333333333, 41.16666666666666, 46.0 ], "human": [ 1, 1, 0, 6, 15, 15, 37, 108, 150, 106, 42, 15, 6, 2, 1, 2, 0, 0 ], "ai": [ 1, 0, 7, 17, 20, 32, 39, 77, 101, 80, 51, 33, 20, 17, 6, 3, 1, 2 ] } }, { "feature": "opp_deep_rate", "index": 40, "separation_auc": 0.5219160549155997, "human_mean": 0.31846228288065, "ai_mean": 0.37906583773447683, "human_std": 0.24506152638800008, "ai_std": 0.3460631578729056, "cohens_d": -0.20211581939383594, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05555555555555555, 0.1111111111111111, 0.16666666666666666, 0.2222222222222222, 0.2777777777777778, 0.3333333333333333, 0.38888888888888884, 0.4444444444444444, 0.5, 0.5555555555555556, 0.611111111111111, 0.6666666666666666, 0.7222222222222222, 0.7777777777777777, 0.8333333333333333, 0.8888888888888888, 0.9444444444444444, 1.0 ], "human": [ 90, 62, 53, 30, 21, 17, 11, 21, 30, 46, 48, 35, 28, 9, 6, 0, 0, 0 ], "ai": [ 165, 32, 27, 9, 11, 12, 8, 16, 15, 20, 18, 24, 26, 24, 33, 28, 25, 14 ] } }, { "feature": "frac_double", "index": 16, "separation_auc": 0.5211730059249404, "human_mean": 0.47501514595923705, "ai_mean": 0.48513043209774914, "human_std": 0.13345024772857067, "ai_std": 0.08277332519461099, "cohens_d": -0.09109471523383689, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.04807692307692308, 0.09615384615384616, 0.14423076923076925, 0.19230769230769232, 0.2403846153846154, 0.2884615384615385, 0.33653846153846156, 0.38461538461538464, 0.4326923076923077, 0.4807692307692308, 0.5288461538461539, 0.576923076923077, 0.625, 0.6730769230769231, 0.7211538461538461, 0.7692307692307693, 0.8173076923076924, 0.8653846153846154 ], "human": [ 20, 1, 0, 5, 4, 5, 9, 26, 55, 92, 113, 91, 49, 31, 6, 0, 0, 0 ], "ai": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 3, 5, 18, 23, 76, 89, 128, 129, 23, 6, 3, 0, 2, 2 ] } }, { "feature": "leak_diff", "index": 20, "separation_auc": 0.5205583371263844, "human_mean": 0.11168639053254402, "ai_mean": -0.08044888095489137, "human_std": 4.133523806711124, "ai_std": 1.4179338003379898, "cohens_d": 0.06217912103006882, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ -32.03571428571429, -28.38194444444445, -24.728174603174608, -21.07440476190477, -17.420634920634928, -13.766865079365086, -10.113095238095248, -6.459325396825406, -2.8055555555555642, 0.8482142857142776, 4.501984126984119, 8.155753968253961, 11.809523809523796, 15.463293650793638, 19.11706349206348, 22.77083333333332, 26.424603174603163, 30.078373015873005, 33.73214285714285 ], "human": [ 2, 0, 0, 0, 0, 5, 4, 27, 354, 87, 11, 9, 3, 2, 1, 1, 0, 1 ], "ai": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 2, 20, 402, 78, 5, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "opp_left_rate", "index": 46, "separation_auc": 0.5193056576761629, "human_mean": 0.47708422969392306, "ai_mean": 0.4620308076027997, "human_std": 0.2634426579717388, "ai_std": 0.43755692367076354, "cohens_d": 0.041681954718119314, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05555555555555555, 0.1111111111111111, 0.16666666666666666, 0.2222222222222222, 0.2777777777777778, 0.3333333333333333, 0.38888888888888884, 0.4444444444444444, 0.5, 0.5555555555555556, 0.611111111111111, 0.6666666666666666, 0.7222222222222222, 0.7777777777777777, 0.8333333333333333, 0.8888888888888888, 0.9444444444444444, 1.0 ], "human": [ 36, 17, 28, 24, 21, 32, 34, 29, 34, 40, 42, 31, 41, 18, 31, 18, 16, 15 ], "ai": [ 153, 54, 49, 10, 3, 1, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 2, 7, 11, 53, 44, 119 ] } }, { "feature": "team_left_rate", "index": 45, "separation_auc": 0.5181774681091932, "human_mean": 0.4733956897964447, "ai_mean": 0.46069645723963537, "human_std": 0.26175209838518954, "ai_std": 0.43935201864976886, "cohens_d": 0.03511719319149489, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05555555555555555, 0.1111111111111111, 0.16666666666666666, 0.2222222222222222, 0.2777777777777778, 0.3333333333333333, 0.38888888888888884, 0.4444444444444444, 0.5, 0.5555555555555556, 0.611111111111111, 0.6666666666666666, 0.7222222222222222, 0.7777777777777777, 0.8333333333333333, 0.8888888888888888, 0.9444444444444444, 1.0 ], "human": [ 33, 27, 20, 29, 23, 18, 41, 35, 28, 54, 40, 24, 28, 28, 28, 25, 15, 11 ], "ai": [ 158, 54, 46, 6, 6, 1, 0, 0, 0, 0, 1, 0, 1, 4, 15, 40, 57, 118 ] } }, { "feature": "opp_back_rate", "index": 44, "separation_auc": 0.5136258067527981, "human_mean": 0.30976965734241785, "ai_mean": 0.355894382909958, "human_std": 0.22792869576721528, "ai_std": 0.33255091944309634, "cohens_d": -0.16179553110813502, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05555555555555555, 0.1111111111111111, 0.16666666666666666, 0.2222222222222222, 0.2777777777777778, 0.3333333333333333, 0.38888888888888884, 0.4444444444444444, 0.5, 0.5555555555555556, 0.611111111111111, 0.6666666666666666, 0.7222222222222222, 0.7777777777777777, 0.8333333333333333, 0.8888888888888888, 0.9444444444444444, 1.0 ], "human": [ 96, 52, 40, 32, 20, 13, 33, 41, 42, 53, 36, 19, 19, 7, 3, 0, 1, 0 ], "ai": [ 168, 29, 29, 10, 18, 13, 15, 15, 13, 23, 19, 26, 27, 18, 28, 27, 18, 11 ] } }, { "feature": "resp_rate", "index": 56, "separation_auc": 0.5098677684021334, "human_mean": 0.37879158506464944, "ai_mean": 0.3498617061030523, "human_std": 0.21920632555707972, "ai_std": 0.3048178702159785, "cohens_d": 0.1089696188479866, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05072463768115942, 0.10144927536231883, 0.15217391304347824, 0.20289855072463767, 0.25362318840579706, 0.3043478260869565, 0.3550724637681159, 0.40579710144927533, 0.45652173913043476, 0.5072463768115941, 0.5579710144927535, 0.608695652173913, 0.6594202898550724, 0.7101449275362318, 0.7608695652173912, 0.8115942028985507, 0.8623188405797101, 0.9130434782608695 ], "human": [ 94, 0, 7, 10, 16, 14, 47, 49, 47, 84, 34, 48, 21, 23, 6, 4, 2, 1 ], "ai": [ 178, 6, 11, 11, 11, 6, 25, 15, 19, 27, 35, 38, 24, 28, 24, 20, 19, 10 ] } }, { "feature": "opp_deck_cost_mean", "index": 59, "separation_auc": 0.5076191698858973, "human_mean": 3.6235207100591715, "ai_mean": 3.621301775147929, "human_std": 0.5883465457152928, "ai_std": 0.5491879262691124, "cohens_d": 0.003898996280614945, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 2.0, 2.1944444444444446, 2.388888888888889, 2.5833333333333335, 2.7777777777777777, 2.9722222222222223, 3.166666666666667, 3.361111111111111, 3.5555555555555554, 3.75, 3.9444444444444446, 4.138888888888889, 4.333333333333334, 4.527777777777778, 4.722222222222222, 4.916666666666666, 5.111111111111111, 5.305555555555555, 5.5 ], "human": [ 1, 3, 6, 41, 33, 50, 30, 53, 29, 89, 80, 34, 43, 9, 3, 0, 1, 2 ], "ai": [ 1, 3, 2, 41, 24, 36, 41, 85, 30, 84, 80, 25, 41, 5, 7, 1, 1, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "opp_y_mean", "index": 37, "separation_auc": 0.5058451890495587, "human_mean": 0.5053937349794487, "ai_mean": 0.5061558239284861, "human_std": 0.14360182443998246, "ai_std": 0.12724416377462539, "cohens_d": -0.005617235667450518, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.190625, 0.22488290895061727, 0.25914081790123455, 0.2933987268518518, 0.32765663580246907, 0.3619145447530864, 0.39617245370370363, 0.4304303626543209, 0.4646882716049382, 0.49894618055555545, 0.5332040895061727, 0.56746199845679, 0.6017199074074073, 0.6359778163580245, 0.6702357253086418, 0.7044936342592591, 0.7387515432098763, 0.7730094521604938, 0.807267361111111 ], "human": [ 1, 0, 14, 30, 79, 60, 40, 15, 4, 6, 12, 46, 67, 76, 37, 15, 2, 3 ], "ai": [ 0, 0, 0, 22, 63, 64, 56, 26, 17, 19, 22, 46, 64, 64, 36, 5, 3, 0 ] } }, { "feature": "team_back_rate", "index": 43, "separation_auc": 0.5020171251395649, "human_mean": 0.3168591550359344, "ai_mean": 0.3508899140161468, "human_std": 0.23790131677057486, "ai_std": 0.3267035534547272, "cohens_d": -0.11908324560438875, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.0, 0.05555555555555555, 0.1111111111111111, 0.16666666666666666, 0.2222222222222222, 0.2777777777777778, 0.3333333333333333, 0.38888888888888884, 0.4444444444444444, 0.5, 0.5555555555555556, 0.611111111111111, 0.6666666666666666, 0.7222222222222222, 0.7777777777777777, 0.8333333333333333, 0.8888888888888888, 0.9444444444444444, 1.0 ], "human": [ 103, 40, 52, 29, 14, 14, 26, 32, 39, 54, 40, 30, 24, 6, 3, 0, 0, 1 ], "ai": [ 170, 28, 24, 19, 16, 15, 11, 15, 12, 22, 16, 26, 37, 31, 19, 26, 11, 9 ] } }, { "feature": "team_y_mean", "index": 33, "separation_auc": 0.5014685915914865, "human_mean": 0.49404238106869625, "ai_mean": 0.4957855626028964, "human_std": 0.1498893451153663, "ai_std": 0.12919521781996765, "cohens_d": -0.012457937365514751, "permutation_drop": 0.0, "histogram": { "edges": [ 0.165625, 0.2000252403846154, 0.23442548076923078, 0.2688257211538462, 0.3032259615384616, 0.33762620192307696, 0.37202644230769233, 0.40642668269230775, 0.44082692307692317, 0.4752271634615386, 0.5096274038461539, 0.5440276442307693, 0.5784278846153847, 0.6128281250000002, 0.6472283653846155, 0.6816286057692309, 0.7160288461538463, 0.7504290865384617, 0.784829326923077 ], "human": [ 1, 2, 12, 20, 56, 54, 73, 33, 9, 7, 6, 15, 40, 67, 66, 32, 11, 3 ], "ai": [ 0, 0, 1, 9, 42, 75, 63, 31, 27, 16, 17, 29, 47, 80, 52, 13, 5, 0 ] } } ], "top_tells": [ "alt_rate", "in_single", "frac_triple", "in_overtime", "frac_gap_lt_1", "gap_p10", "team_x_std", "n_events", "opp_x_std", "gap_std", "frac_gap_gt_8", "n_plays" ], "tell_profile": [ { "feature": "alt_rate", "human_mean": 0.676888643629305, "separation_auc": 0.9993619893483343, "policies": { "policy_bc_v2": { "mean": 0.9304250299725383, "z_vs_human": 2.940255569635226 }, "policy_bc_v3": { "mean": 0.9304250299725383, "z_vs_human": 2.940255569635226 }, "policy_bc_v4": { "mean": 0.9304250299725383, "z_vs_human": 2.940255569635226 }, "policy_bc_v4_1": { "mean": 0.9304250299725383, "z_vs_human": 2.940255569635226 } } }, { "feature": "in_single", "human_mean": 0.03944773175542406, "separation_auc": 0.9951410042443269, "policies": { "policy_bc_v2": { "mean": 0.0, "z_vs_human": -0.20265182408994234 }, "policy_bc_v3": { "mean": 0.0, "z_vs_human": -0.20265182408994234 }, "policy_bc_v4": { "mean": 0.0, "z_vs_human": -0.20265182408994234 }, "policy_bc_v4_1": { "mean": 0.0039447731755424065, "z_vs_human": -0.18238664168094812 } } }, { "feature": "frac_triple", "human_mean": 0.0, "separation_auc": 0.98839909900447, "policies": { "policy_bc_v2": { "mean": 0.0008024906214951464, "z_vs_human": 802490.6214951463 }, "policy_bc_v3": { "mean": 0.0008419086038299404, "z_vs_human": 841908.6038299403 }, "policy_bc_v4": { "mean": 0.0007258858633728109, "z_vs_human": 725885.8633728108 }, "policy_bc_v4_1": { "mean": 0.0003465807503398871, "z_vs_human": 346580.7503398871 } } }, { "feature": "in_overtime", "human_mean": 0.0, "separation_auc": 0.98839909900447, "policies": { "policy_bc_v2": { "mean": 0.005917159763313609, "z_vs_human": 5917159.763313609 }, "policy_bc_v3": { "mean": 0.005917159763313609, "z_vs_human": 5917159.763313609 }, "policy_bc_v4": { "mean": 0.005917159763313609, "z_vs_human": 5917159.763313609 }, "policy_bc_v4_1": { "mean": 0.005917159763313609, "z_vs_human": 5917159.763313609 } } }, { "feature": "frac_gap_lt_1", "human_mean": 0.1718022818895281, "separation_auc": 0.9775879307058187, "policies": { "policy_bc_v2": { "mean": 0.0372432996867385, "z_vs_human": -2.365659162465371 }, "policy_bc_v3": { "mean": 0.05453068801485075, "z_vs_human": -2.061732453716471 }, "policy_bc_v4": { "mean": 0.061685423676373724, "z_vs_human": -1.9359462319747562 }, "policy_bc_v4_1": { "mean": 0.06543682561782094, "z_vs_human": -1.8699934562507212 } } }, { "feature": "gap_p10", "human_mean": 0.6833333333333335, "separation_auc": 0.9769927134515209, "policies": { "policy_bc_v2": { "mean": 1.5513387255021913, "z_vs_human": 3.220627375976226 }, "policy_bc_v3": { "mean": 1.3855020838730423, "z_vs_human": 2.605310889708483 }, "policy_bc_v4": { "mean": 1.2922215910168768, "z_vs_human": 2.2592050801737438 }, "policy_bc_v4_1": { "mean": 1.2403412836959067, "z_vs_human": 2.0667095731879166 } } }, { "feature": "team_x_std", "human_mean": 0.22438892131512148, "separation_auc": 0.9642480616536147, "policies": { "policy_bc_v2": { "mean": 0.11253006698686538, "z_vs_human": -2.4019713161486442 }, "policy_bc_v3": { "mean": 0.11164787023357138, "z_vs_human": -2.42091493316794 }, "policy_bc_v4": { "mean": 0.11224946555666138, "z_vs_human": -2.407996736225292 }, "policy_bc_v4_1": { "mean": 0.11317504583474816, "z_vs_human": -2.388121534641042 } } }, { "feature": "n_events", "human_mean": 47.84220907297831, "separation_auc": 0.9602371532275947, "policies": { "policy_bc_v2": { "mean": 52.0, "z_vs_human": 0.5370212113435185 }, "policy_bc_v3": { "mean": 52.0, "z_vs_human": 0.5370212113435185 }, "policy_bc_v4": { "mean": 52.0, "z_vs_human": 0.5370212113435185 }, "policy_bc_v4_1": { "mean": 52.0, "z_vs_human": 0.5370212113435185 } } }, { "feature": "opp_x_std", "human_mean": 0.22185115081848322, "separation_auc": 0.9594629817661224, "policies": { "policy_bc_v2": { "mean": 0.11211718531541562, "z_vs_human": -2.261414065736875 }, "policy_bc_v3": { "mean": 0.11118506276776051, "z_vs_human": -2.2806233873957993 }, "policy_bc_v4": { "mean": 0.11221551335371585, "z_vs_human": -2.259387706734454 }, "policy_bc_v4_1": { "mean": 0.11261661511150428, "z_vs_human": -2.2511217413818287 } } }, { "feature": "gap_std", "human_mean": 3.2854997082974435, "separation_auc": 0.9567903395850597, "policies": { "policy_bc_v2": { "mean": 2.0514412409424385, "z_vs_human": -1.865791522504828 }, "policy_bc_v3": { "mean": 2.0366321126108673, "z_vs_human": -1.888181665944266 }, "policy_bc_v4": { "mean": 2.075464696965343, "z_vs_human": -1.8294700987031887 }, "policy_bc_v4_1": { "mean": 2.1036740912787044, "z_vs_human": -1.7868198919608167 } } }, { "feature": "frac_gap_gt_8", "human_mean": 0.0911987421077882, "separation_auc": 0.910985843166089, "policies": { "policy_bc_v2": { "mean": 0.03407201144757696, "z_vs_human": -1.3191750786404206 }, "policy_bc_v3": { "mean": 0.02796148045016815, "z_vs_human": -1.4602799539918099 }, "policy_bc_v4": { "mean": 0.02873496538654901, "z_vs_human": -1.4424185773650517 }, "policy_bc_v4_1": { "mean": 0.030668677727501162, "z_vs_human": -1.3977651357981566 } } }, { "feature": "n_plays", "human_mean": 45.19921104536489, "separation_auc": 0.9083521040735424, "policies": { "policy_bc_v2": { "mean": 51.32741617357002, "z_vs_human": 0.8087134960523407 }, "policy_bc_v3": { "mean": 51.32741617357002, "z_vs_human": 0.8087134960523407 }, "policy_bc_v4": { "mean": 51.32741617357002, "z_vs_human": 0.8087134960523407 }, "policy_bc_v4_1": { "mean": 51.32741617357002, "z_vs_human": 0.8087134960523407 } } } ], "ablation": [ { "dropped": 0, "features_left": 67, "auc": 1.0, "acc": 0.9970414201183432, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "mean_P_human_ai": 6.168240937609121e-05 }, { "dropped": 1, "features_left": 66, "auc": 1.0, "acc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.00044660318128924876 }, { "dropped": 2, "features_left": 65, "auc": 1.0, "acc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.00044660318128924876 }, { "dropped": 3, "features_left": 64, "auc": 1.0, "acc": 1.0, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.00044660318128924876 }, { "dropped": 5, "features_left": 62, "auc": 1.0, "acc": 0.9990138067061144, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.0005615655880557744 }, { "dropped": 8, "features_left": 59, "auc": 0.9999649872203354, "acc": 0.9980276134122288, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0039447731755424065, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.004702882901289178 }, { "dropped": 12, "features_left": 55, "auc": 0.9998132651751223, "acc": 0.9930966469428008, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0039447731755424065, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.007026868325757979 }, { "dropped": 20, "features_left": 47, "auc": 0.9996732140564639, "acc": 0.9930966469428008, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.009861932938856016, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.014526301659351483 }, { "dropped": 30, "features_left": 37, "auc": 0.9997160074538317, "acc": 0.9940828402366864, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.009861932938856016, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.0182798544120909 }, { "dropped": 45, "features_left": 22, "auc": 0.9997121171449801, "acc": 0.9901380670611439, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.013806706114398421, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.022582491973956034 }, { "dropped": 60, "features_left": 7, "auc": 0.9926589871969935, "acc": 0.9585798816568047, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.023668639053254437, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.0582093931185991 } ], "harness_free": { "dropped": 13, "features_left": 54, "auc": 0.9999805484557419, "acc": 0.9990138067061144, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.001857638940766647, "excluded": [ "alt_rate", "duration_norm", "frac_double", "frac_single", "frac_triple", "in_overtime", "in_single", "max_streak", "n_abilities", "n_events", "n_plays", "plays_per_min", "side_count_imbalance" ] }, "harness_features": [ "alt_rate", "duration_norm", "frac_double", "frac_single", "frac_triple", "in_overtime", "in_single", "max_streak", "n_abilities", "n_events", "n_plays", "plays_per_min", "side_count_imbalance" ], "truncation": [ { "ai_events": 1, "total_events": 13, "n_pairs": 506, "auc": 0.5650728803761971, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.9769967778757899, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.9802371541501976 }, { "ai_events": 2, "total_events": 14, "n_pairs": 504, "auc": 0.6285942617787856, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.9500058558996968, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.9503968253968254 }, { "ai_events": 3, "total_events": 15, "n_pairs": 504, "auc": 0.6812523620559335, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.9493082456315957, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.9523809523809523 }, { "ai_events": 5, "total_events": 17, "n_pairs": 500, "auc": 0.763324, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.8950490176390088, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.892 }, { "ai_events": 8, "total_events": 20, "n_pairs": 497, "auc": 0.8675635300738029, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.868057016268647, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.8672032193158954 }, { "ai_events": 12, "total_events": 24, "n_pairs": 491, "auc": 0.9413848457572351, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.7250808272926187, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.7107942973523421 }, { "ai_events": 16, "total_events": 28, "n_pairs": 486, "auc": 0.9777091906721537, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.5358716525364661, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.5 }, { "ai_events": 20, "total_events": 32, "n_pairs": 477, "auc": 0.9903968285361426, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.4439977300883062, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.40670859538784065 }, { "ai_events": 28, "total_events": 40, "n_pairs": 456, "auc": 0.9994036626654356, "mean_P_human_ai": 0.12754656617990662, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.08333333333333333 }, { "ai_events": 40, "total_events": 52, "n_pairs": 314, "auc": 1.0, "mean_P_human_ai": 1.671288737418617e-05, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0 } ] }, "trajectories": [ { "battle_id": "00JYP82V0LJ9", "warmup_events": 12, "human": { "score": 0.99999, "events": [ { "t": 8.7, "side": "team", "card": "barbarian-barrel", "x": 0.1389, "y": 0.5469, "ability": false }, { "t": 12.75, "side": "opponent", "card": "electro-spirit", "x": 0.1944, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false }, { "t": 15.25, "side": "team", "card": "skeletons", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.9843, "ability": false }, { "t": 17.7, "side": "opponent", "card": "dark-prince", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.0156, "ability": false }, { "t": 19.15, "side": "team", "card": "ice-golem", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.9843, "ability": false }, { "t": 28.65, "side": "team", "card": "musketeer", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.8281, "ability": false }, { "t": 31.75, "side": "opponent", "card": "lightning", "x": 0.3056, "y": 0.7344, "ability": false }, { "t": 35.45, "side": "team", "card": "balloon", "x": 0.0278, "y": 0.5781, "ability": false }, { "t": 36.55, "side": "team", "card": "miner", "x": 0.0278, "y": 0.2344, "ability": false }, { "t": 37.55, "side": "opponent", "card": "musketeer", "x": 0.4166, "y": 0.2656, "ability": false }, { "t": 41.25, "side": "team", "card": "_ability", "x": 0.5, "y": 0.5, "ability": true }, { "t": 42.65, "side": "opponent", "card": "berserker", "x": 0.2499, "y": 0.3281, "ability": false }, { "t": 44.45, "side": "opponent", "card": "giant-snowball", "x": 0.1944, "y": 0.2344, "ability": false }, { "t": 55.15, "side": "team", "card": "barbarian-barrel", "x": 0.1944, "y": 0.6719, "ability": false }, { "t": 68.4, "side": "opponent", "card": "dark-prince", "x": 0.0277, "y": 0.0469, "ability": false }, { "t": 77.1, "side": "opponent", "card": "ram-rider", "x": 0.0833, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false }, { "t": 78.05, "side": "team", "card": "ice-golem", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.6406, "ability": false }, { "t": 80.1, "side": "team", "card": "bomb-tower", "x": 0.0833, "y": 0.7031, "ability": false }, { "t": 85.8, "side": "team", "card": "giant-snowball", "x": 0.1389, "y": 0.7031, "ability": false }, { "t": 94.6, "side": "opponent", "card": "mega-knight", "x": 0.0277, "y": 0.0469, "ability": false }, { "t": 100.85, "side": "team", "card": "musketeer", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.9843, "ability": false }, { "t": 110.15, "side": "team", "card": "skeletons", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.6093, "ability": false }, { "t": 112.55, "side": "team", "card": "ice-golem", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.7031, "ability": false }, { "t": 112.6, "side": "opponent", "card": "lightning", "x": 0.3056, "y": 0.7031, "ability": false }, { "t": 116.9, "side": "opponent", "card": "giant-snowball", "x": 0.25, "y": 0.7656, "ability": false }, { "t": 117.95, "side": "team", "card": "balloon", "x": 0.0278, "y": 0.5781, "ability": false }, { "t": 119.6, "side": "team", "card": "miner", "x": 0.3611, "y": 0.2656, "ability": false }, { "t": 121.55, "side": "opponent", "card": "musketeer", "x": 0.4166, "y": 0.2969, "ability": false }, { "t": 123.45, "side": "opponent", "card": "electro-spirit", "x": 0.3055, "y": 0.2969, "ability": false }, { "t": 123.6, "side": "team", "card": "giant-snowball", "x": 0.4167, "y": 0.2969, "ability": false }, { "t": 124.55, "side": "team", "card": "_ability", "x": 0.5, "y": 0.5, "ability": true }, { "t": 133.45, "side": "team", "card": "skeletons", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.8281, "ability": false }, { "t": 135.1, "side": "opponent", "card": "mega-knight", "x": 0.9722, "y": 0.0469, "ability": false }, { "t": 135.35, "side": "team", "card": "ice-golem", "x": 0.8611, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 137.05, "side": "team", "card": "balloon", "x": 0.9722, "y": 0.5781, "ability": false }, { "t": 139.55, "side": "opponent", "card": "dark-prince", "x": 0.9722, "y": 0.0469, "ability": false }, { "t": 139.55, "side": "team", "card": "miner", "x": 0.6944, "y": 0.1719, "ability": false }, { "t": 145.05, "side": "opponent", "card": "giant-snowball", "x": 0.8056, "y": 0.2656, "ability": false }, { "t": 146.05, "side": "team", "card": "giant-snowball", "x": 0.8056, "y": 0.2656, "ability": false }, { "t": 148.1, "side": "opponent", "card": "musketeer", "x": 0.75, "y": 0.1406, "ability": false }, { "t": 149.9, "side": "opponent", "card": "electro-spirit", "x": 0.9722, "y": 0.2969, "ability": false }, { "t": 150.3, "side": "team", "card": "musketeer", "x": 0.6389, "y": 0.9843, "ability": false }, { "t": 157.9, "side": "opponent", "card": "mega-knight", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.6406, "ability": false }, { "t": 159.85, "side": "team", "card": "ice-golem", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 162.2, "side": "team", "card": "barbarian-barrel", "x": 0.4167, "y": 0.7656, "ability": false }, { "t": 163.55, "side": "opponent", "card": "dark-prince", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.6406, "ability": false }, { "t": 165.05, "side": "team", "card": "miner", "x": 0.8611, "y": 0.5469, "ability": false }, { "t": 166.35, "side": "opponent", "card": "berserker", "x": 0.9167, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false }, { "t": 166.65, "side": "team", "card": "skeletons", "x": 0.3055, "y": 0.7031, "ability": false }, { "t": 169.1, "side": "team", "card": "musketeer", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.8281, "ability": false }, { "t": 177.55, "side": "team", "card": "ice-golem", "x": 0.75, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 177.95, "side": "team", "card": "balloon", "x": 0.9722, "y": 0.5781, "ability": false } ] }, "ai": { "score": 1e-05, "events": [ { "t": 8.7, "side": "team", "card": "barbarian-barrel", "x": 0.1389, "y": 0.5469, "ability": false }, { "t": 12.75, "side": "opponent", "card": "electro-spirit", "x": 0.1944, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false }, { "t": 15.25, "side": "team", "card": "skeletons", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.9843, "ability": false }, { "t": 17.7, "side": "opponent", "card": "dark-prince", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.0156, "ability": false }, { "t": 19.15, "side": "team", "card": "ice-golem", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.9843, "ability": false }, { "t": 28.65, "side": "team", "card": "musketeer", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.8281, "ability": false }, { "t": 31.75, "side": "opponent", "card": "lightning", "x": 0.3056, "y": 0.7344, "ability": false }, { "t": 35.45, "side": "team", "card": "balloon", "x": 0.0278, "y": 0.5781, "ability": false }, { "t": 36.55, "side": "team", "card": "miner", "x": 0.0278, "y": 0.2344, "ability": false }, { "t": 37.55, "side": "opponent", "card": "musketeer", "x": 0.4166, "y": 0.2656, "ability": false }, { "t": 41.25, "side": "team", "card": "_ability", "x": 0.5, "y": 0.5, "ability": true }, { "t": 42.65, "side": "opponent", "card": "berserker", "x": 0.2499, "y": 0.3281, "ability": false }, { "t": 48.07, "side": "opponent", "card": "giant-snowball", "x": 0.3002, "y": 0.342, "ability": false }, { "t": 54.87, "side": "team", "card": "giant-snowball", "x": 0.3188, "y": 0.7048, "ability": false }, { "t": 61.41, "side": "opponent", "card": "electro-spirit", "x": 0.3874, "y": 0.3242, "ability": false }, { "t": 66.58, "side": "team", "card": "skeletons", "x": 0.3733, "y": 0.7596, "ability": false }, { "t": 71.96, "side": "opponent", "card": "dark-prince", "x": 0.4534, "y": 0.2542, "ability": false }, { "t": 75.03, "side": "team", "card": "ice-golem", "x": 0.4052, "y": 0.7615, "ability": false }, { "t": 79.52, "side": "opponent", "card": "mega-knight", "x": 0.4139, "y": 0.3043, "ability": false }, { "t": 82.08, "side": "team", "card": "bomb-tower", "x": 0.394, "y": 0.7185, "ability": false }, { "t": 86.7, "side": "opponent", "card": "musketeer", "x": 0.3091, "y": 0.4923, "ability": false }, { "t": 88.36, "side": "team", "card": "musketeer", "x": 0.2971, "y": 0.6245, "ability": false }, { "t": 91.64, "side": "opponent", "card": "berserker", "x": 0.2524, "y": 0.6171, "ability": false }, { "t": 93.33, "side": "team", "card": "barbarian-barrel", "x": 0.2644, "y": 0.6015, "ability": false }, { "t": 97.51, "side": "opponent", "card": "giant-snowball", "x": 0.2516, "y": 0.6246, "ability": false }, { "t": 99.24, "side": "team", "card": "skeletons", "x": 0.2756, "y": 0.6322, "ability": false }, { "t": 104.22, "side": "opponent", "card": "dark-prince", "x": 0.2666, "y": 0.5672, "ability": false }, { "t": 105.89, "side": "team", "card": "ice-golem", "x": 0.2818, "y": 0.647, "ability": false }, { "t": 109.92, "side": "opponent", "card": "electro-spirit", "x": 0.2732, "y": 0.5371, "ability": false }, { "t": 111.73, "side": "team", "card": "balloon", "x": 0.2769, "y": 0.6646, "ability": false }, { "t": 116.53, "side": "opponent", "card": "musketeer", "x": 0.2525, "y": 0.3537, "ability": false }, { "t": 120.94, "side": "team", "card": "giant-snowball", "x": 0.2388, "y": 0.4502, "ability": false }, { "t": 124.91, "side": "opponent", "card": "berserker", "x": 0.2223, "y": 0.3649, "ability": false }, { "t": 127.35, "side": "team", "card": "musketeer", "x": 0.3154, "y": 0.6313, "ability": false }, { "t": 130.55, "side": "opponent", "card": "ram-rider", "x": 0.2521, "y": 0.4214, "ability": false }, { "t": 131.96, "side": "team", "card": "bomb-tower", "x": 0.2342, "y": 0.6221, "ability": false }, { "t": 133.41, "side": "opponent", "card": "giant-snowball", "x": 0.2108, "y": 0.6063, "ability": false }, { "t": 134.82, "side": "team", "card": "ice-golem", "x": 0.2092, "y": 0.6083, "ability": false }, { "t": 136.87, "side": "opponent", "card": "electro-spirit", "x": 0.2186, "y": 0.5134, "ability": false }, { "t": 138.5, "side": "team", "card": "skeletons", "x": 0.234, "y": 0.5899, "ability": false }, { "t": 140.73, "side": "opponent", "card": "lightning", "x": 0.2234, "y": 0.3907, "ability": false }, { "t": 142.43, "side": "team", "card": "balloon", "x": 0.2818, "y": 0.5048, "ability": false }, { "t": 145.36, "side": "opponent", "card": "berserker", "x": 0.2185, "y": 0.3097, "ability": false }, { "t": 146.75, "side": "team", "card": "miner", "x": 0.2439, "y": 0.3925, "ability": false }, { "t": 148.84, "side": "opponent", "card": "musketeer", "x": 0.2203, "y": 0.3037, "ability": false }, { "t": 150.84, "side": "team", "card": "giant-snowball", "x": 0.2046, "y": 0.4889, "ability": false }, { "t": 153.09, "side": "opponent", "card": "giant-snowball", "x": 0.1858, "y": 0.3106, "ability": false }, { "t": 155.58, "side": "team", "card": "barbarian-barrel", "x": 0.2497, "y": 0.6667, "ability": false }, { "t": 157.72, "side": "opponent", "card": "electro-spirit", "x": 0.2104, "y": 0.3329, "ability": false }, { "t": 160.06, "side": "team", "card": "musketeer", "x": 0.3007, "y": 0.7339, "ability": false }, { "t": 161.93, "side": "opponent", "card": "ram-rider", "x": 0.2301, "y": 0.3273, "ability": false }, { "t": 163.61, "side": "team", "card": "ice-golem", "x": 0.2047, "y": 0.6729, "ability": false } ] } }, { "battle_id": "082Y82RUPLUY", "warmup_events": 12, "human": { "score": 0.99999, "events": [ { "t": 6.8, "side": "team", "card": "princess", "x": 0.1388, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false }, { "t": 8.9, "side": "opponent", "card": "golden-knight", "x": 0.1388, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 11.85, "side": "opponent", "card": "_ability", "x": 0.5, "y": 0.5, "ability": true }, { "t": 13.05, "side": "team", "card": "goblins", "x": 0.4166, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false }, { "t": 15.8, "side": "team", "card": "skeleton-army", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.3281, "ability": false }, { "t": 21.2, "side": "opponent", "card": "flying-machine", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.7031, "ability": false }, { "t": 27.6, "side": "team", "card": "firecracker", "x": 0.3611, "y": 0.1406, "ability": false }, { "t": 36.8, "side": "opponent", "card": "berserker", "x": 0.8611, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 40.05, "side": "team", "card": "elite-barbarians", "x": 0.5833, "y": 0.2969, "ability": false }, { "t": 44.1, "side": "opponent", "card": "hunter", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.8281, "ability": false }, { "t": 47.1, "side": "opponent", "card": "ice-golem", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.5781, "ability": false }, { "t": 49.05, "side": "opponent", "card": "archers", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.7656, "ability": false }, { "t": 53.05, "side": "team", "card": "princess", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.1719, "ability": false }, { "t": 55.3, "side": "team", "card": "arrows", "x": 0.4167, "y": 0.7031, "ability": false }, { "t": 56.05, "side": "opponent", "card": "arrows", "x": 0.3056, "y": 0.2656, "ability": false }, { "t": 60.75, "side": "team", "card": "barbarian-barrel", "x": 0.1944, "y": 0.3906, "ability": false }, { "t": 67.55, "side": "opponent", "card": "berserker", "x": 0.1388, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 71.4, "side": "team", "card": "skeleton-army", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.3594, "ability": false }, { "t": 74.3, "side": "team", "card": "firecracker", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.1719, "ability": false }, { "t": 75.15, "side": "opponent", "card": "flying-machine", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.7031, "ability": false }, { "t": 80.35, "side": "team", "card": "goblins", "x": 0.1944, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false }, { "t": 81.55, "side": "opponent", "card": "golden-knight", "x": 0.1388, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 83.05, "side": "opponent", "card": "_ability", "x": 0.5, "y": 0.5, "ability": true }, { "t": 87.2, "side": "team", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.2499, "y": 0.3281, "ability": false }, { "t": 104.6, "side": "team", "card": "princess", "x": 0.1944, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false }, { "t": 107.15, "side": "opponent", "card": "hunter", "x": 0.1944, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 112.05, "side": "team", "card": "skeleton-army", "x": 0.1944, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false }, { "t": 115.55, "side": "opponent", "card": "archers", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.6718, "ability": false }, { "t": 125.15, "side": "opponent", "card": "ice-golem", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.9843, "ability": false }, { "t": 125.55, "side": "team", "card": "barbarian-barrel", "x": 0.25, "y": 0.3281, "ability": false }, { "t": 128.55, "side": "team", "card": "firecracker", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.0156, "ability": false }, { "t": 129.7, "side": "opponent", "card": "berserker", "x": 0.8611, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 132.3, "side": "opponent", "card": "arrows", "x": 0.3056, "y": 0.2656, "ability": false }, { "t": 132.8, "side": "team", "card": "goblins", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.3594, "ability": false }, { "t": 139.25, "side": "opponent", "card": "golden-knight", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.9843, "ability": false }, { "t": 139.6, "side": "team", "card": "elite-barbarians", "x": 0.8056, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false }, { "t": 140.3, "side": "team", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.8056, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false }, { "t": 142.55, "side": "opponent", "card": "skeletons", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.6093, "ability": false }, { "t": 143.05, "side": "opponent", "card": "archers", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.7656, "ability": false }, { "t": 144.7, "side": "opponent", "card": "ice-golem", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.5781, "ability": false }, { "t": 145.05, "side": "team", "card": "_ability", "x": 0.5, "y": 0.5, "ability": true }, { "t": 147.4, "side": "opponent", "card": "berserker", "x": 0.5833, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 151.75, "side": "team", "card": "arrows", "x": 0.6389, "y": 0.7656, "ability": false }, { "t": 153.7, "side": "opponent", "card": "_ability", "x": 0.5, "y": 0.5, "ability": true }, { "t": 154.65, "side": "opponent", "card": "golden-knight", "x": 0.1388, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 156.05, "side": "opponent", "card": "_ability", "x": 0.5, "y": 0.5, "ability": true }, { "t": 156.55, "side": "team", "card": "skeleton-army", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.4219, "ability": false }, { "t": 158.75, "side": "team", "card": "goblins", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.2969, "ability": false }, { "t": 160.9, "side": "team", "card": "barbarian-barrel", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.2656, "ability": false }, { "t": 161.2, "side": "opponent", "card": "flying-machine", "x": 0.4167, "y": 0.5469, "ability": false }, { "t": 165.65, "side": "team", "card": "firecracker", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.2344, "ability": false }, { "t": 168.05, "side": "opponent", "card": "arrows", "x": 0.3611, "y": 0.2969, "ability": false } ] }, "ai": { "score": 1e-05, "events": [ { "t": 6.8, "side": "team", "card": "princess", "x": 0.1388, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false }, { "t": 8.9, "side": "opponent", "card": "golden-knight", "x": 0.1388, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 11.85, "side": "opponent", "card": "_ability", "x": 0.5, "y": 0.5, "ability": true }, { "t": 13.05, "side": "team", "card": "goblins", "x": 0.4166, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false }, { "t": 15.8, "side": "team", "card": "skeleton-army", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.3281, "ability": false }, { "t": 21.2, "side": "opponent", "card": "flying-machine", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.7031, "ability": false }, { "t": 27.6, "side": "team", "card": "firecracker", "x": 0.3611, "y": 0.1406, "ability": false }, { "t": 36.8, "side": "opponent", "card": "berserker", "x": 0.8611, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 40.05, "side": "team", "card": "elite-barbarians", "x": 0.5833, "y": 0.2969, "ability": false }, { "t": 44.1, "side": "opponent", "card": "hunter", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.8281, "ability": false }, { "t": 47.1, "side": "opponent", "card": "ice-golem", "x": 0.4722, "y": 0.5781, "ability": false }, { "t": 49.05, "side": "opponent", "card": "archers", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.7656, "ability": false }, { "t": 51.53, "side": "team", "card": "princess", "x": 0.431, "y": 0.3803, "ability": false }, { "t": 56.14, "side": "opponent", "card": "arrows", "x": 0.4152, "y": 0.5041, "ability": false }, { "t": 60.37, "side": "team", "card": "barbarian-barrel", "x": 0.4782, "y": 0.357, "ability": false }, { "t": 67.29, "side": "opponent", "card": "golden-knight", "x": 0.4571, "y": 0.6493, "ability": false }, { "t": 70.96, "side": "team", "card": "goblins", "x": 0.4398, "y": 0.2822, "ability": false }, { "t": 76.17, "side": "opponent", "card": "hunter", "x": 0.4056, "y": 0.6448, "ability": false }, { "t": 78.27, "side": "team", "card": "firecracker", "x": 0.4234, "y": 0.2844, "ability": false }, { "t": 81.84, "side": "opponent", "card": "berserker", "x": 0.3298, "y": 0.5091, "ability": false }, { "t": 83.62, "side": "team", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.3482, "y": 0.3621, "ability": false }, { "t": 88.39, "side": "opponent", "card": "archers", "x": 0.3074, "y": 0.6202, "ability": false }, { "t": 91.22, "side": "team", "card": "princess", "x": 0.2992, "y": 0.4254, "ability": false }, { "t": 94.49, "side": "opponent", "card": "ice-golem", "x": 0.2106, "y": 0.576, "ability": false }, { "t": 97.8, "side": "team", "card": "elite-barbarians", "x": 0.2755, "y": 0.4125, "ability": false }, { "t": 101.71, "side": "opponent", "card": "flying-machine", "x": 0.2594, "y": 0.6531, "ability": false }, { "t": 105.98, "side": "team", "card": "arrows", "x": 0.2638, "y": 0.545, "ability": false }, { "t": 110.5, "side": "opponent", "card": "golden-knight", "x": 0.2751, "y": 0.6459, "ability": false }, { "t": 117.63, "side": "team", "card": "firecracker", "x": 0.2968, "y": 0.348, "ability": false }, { "t": 121.83, "side": "opponent", "card": "arrows", "x": 0.2486, "y": 0.5148, "ability": false }, { "t": 126.15, "side": "team", "card": "skeleton-army", "x": 0.3097, "y": 0.3394, "ability": false }, { "t": 129.59, "side": "opponent", "card": "archers", "x": 0.3172, "y": 0.7187, "ability": false }, { "t": 132.52, "side": "team", "card": "princess", "x": 0.2924, "y": 0.3358, "ability": false }, { "t": 134.59, "side": "opponent", "card": "berserker", "x": 0.2727, "y": 0.6683, "ability": false }, { "t": 136.63, "side": "team", "card": "goblins", "x": 0.2703, "y": 0.336, "ability": false }, { "t": 138.27, "side": "opponent", "card": "flying-machine", "x": 0.2897, "y": 0.6494, "ability": false }, { "t": 139.92, "side": "team", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.2912, "y": 0.3459, "ability": false }, { "t": 141.94, "side": "opponent", "card": "golden-knight", "x": 0.3225, "y": 0.6534, "ability": false }, { "t": 143.67, "side": "team", "card": "firecracker", "x": 0.2949, "y": 0.3589, "ability": false }, { "t": 145.65, "side": "opponent", "card": "ice-golem", "x": 0.2913, "y": 0.5806, "ability": false }, { "t": 147.28, "side": "team", "card": "elite-barbarians", "x": 0.2746, "y": 0.3941, "ability": false }, { "t": 148.98, "side": "opponent", "card": "hunter", "x": 0.3014, "y": 0.6058, "ability": false }, { "t": 151.1, "side": "team", "card": "arrows", "x": 0.2242, "y": 0.4926, "ability": false }, { "t": 153.15, "side": "opponent", "card": "berserker", "x": 0.2627, "y": 0.6492, "ability": false }, { "t": 155.28, "side": "team", "card": "princess", "x": 0.2406, "y": 0.4306, "ability": false }, { "t": 156.95, "side": "opponent", "card": "flying-machine", "x": 0.2265, "y": 0.6305, "ability": false }, { "t": 159.04, "side": "team", "card": "goblins", "x": 0.2298, "y": 0.4387, "ability": false }, { "t": 161.22, "side": "opponent", "card": "archers", "x": 0.2139, "y": 0.5999, "ability": false }, { "t": 163.2, "side": "team", "card": "firecracker", "x": 0.2402, "y": 0.451, "ability": false }, { "t": 165.55, "side": "opponent", "card": "golden-knight", "x": 0.2113, "y": 0.5736, "ability": false }, { "t": 167.58, "side": "team", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.2211, "y": 0.4391, "ability": false }, { "t": 169.96, "side": "opponent", "card": "hunter", "x": 0.237, "y": 0.5867, "ability": false } ] } }, { "battle_id": "00JYP2VURU9R", "warmup_events": 12, "human": { "score": 0.99999, "events": [ { "t": 6.05, "side": "team", "card": "baby-dragon", "x": 0.9167, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false }, { "t": 8.65, "side": "opponent", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.6944, "y": 0.7031, "ability": false }, { "t": 18.55, "side": "team", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.8056, "y": 0.2656, "ability": false }, { "t": 21.05, "side": "opponent", "card": "dark-prince", "x": 0.5833, "y": 0.9843, "ability": false }, { "t": 27.25, "side": "team", "card": "witch", "x": 0.5833, "y": 0.0156, "ability": false }, { "t": 28.05, "side": "opponent", "card": "giant", "x": 0.9167, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 32.7, "side": "opponent", "card": "dart-goblin", "x": 0.5833, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 33.75, "side": "team", "card": "wizard", "x": 0.9167, "y": 0.2031, "ability": false }, { "t": 36.6, "side": "team", "card": "_ability", "x": 0.5, "y": 0.5, "ability": true }, { "t": 39.55, "side": "opponent", "card": "fireball", "x": 0.8056, "y": 0.2344, "ability": false }, { "t": 65.9, "side": "opponent", "card": "baby-dragon", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.9844, "ability": false }, { "t": 69.4, "side": "team", "card": "ram-rider", "x": 0.1944, "y": 0.2656, "ability": false }, { "t": 72.2, "side": "team", "card": "baby-dragon", "x": 0.1944, "y": 0.4219, "ability": false }, { "t": 73.55, "side": "opponent", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.1944, "y": 0.6718, "ability": false }, { "t": 88.1, "side": "opponent", "card": "giant", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.9843, "ability": false }, { "t": 94.4, "side": "team", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.5833, "y": 0.0156, "ability": false }, { "t": 96.85, "side": "team", "card": "witch", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.0156, "ability": false }, { "t": 96.9, "side": "opponent", "card": "dark-prince", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.9843, "ability": false }, { "t": 103.75, "side": "opponent", "card": "dart-goblin", "x": 0.9722, "y": 0.5781, "ability": false }, { "t": 107.05, "side": "team", "card": "freeze", "x": 0.8056, "y": 0.5469, "ability": false }, { "t": 109.6, "side": "opponent", "card": "baby-dragon", "x": 0.5833, "y": 0.5469, "ability": false }, { "t": 117.55, "side": "team", "card": "fireball", "x": 0.9722, "y": 0.5469, "ability": false }, { "t": 126.15, "side": "opponent", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.6944, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 130.15, "side": "team", "card": "baby-dragon", "x": 0.9167, "y": 0.3594, "ability": false }, { "t": 130.2, "side": "opponent", "card": "balloon", "x": 0.9167, "y": 0.5469, "ability": false }, { "t": 132.55, "side": "team", "card": "ram-rider", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false }, { "t": 135.55, "side": "opponent", "card": "dark-prince", "x": 0.8056, "y": 0.7031, "ability": false }, { "t": 137.4, "side": "team", "card": "wizard", "x": 0.9722, "y": 0.2344, "ability": false }, { "t": 144.55, "side": "opponent", "card": "dart-goblin", "x": 0.5833, "y": 0.6718, "ability": false }, { "t": 146.05, "side": "team", "card": "witch", "x": 0.6944, "y": 0.3594, "ability": false }, { "t": 147.05, "side": "team", "card": "_ability", "x": 0.5, "y": 0.5, "ability": true }, { "t": 151.2, "side": "opponent", "card": "giant", "x": 0.9167, "y": 0.6093, "ability": false }, { "t": 153.35, "side": "opponent", "card": "baby-dragon", "x": 0.5833, "y": 0.5469, "ability": false }, { "t": 155.9, "side": "team", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.9167, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false }, { "t": 157.55, "side": "team", "card": "freeze", "x": 0.6944, "y": 0.5781, "ability": false }, { "t": 163.1, "side": "opponent", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.9167, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 164.55, "side": "team", "card": "ram-rider", "x": 0.5833, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false }, { "t": 168.2, "side": "opponent", "card": "dark-prince", "x": 0.6389, "y": 0.7343, "ability": false }, { "t": 168.75, "side": "opponent", "card": "arrows", "x": 0.8056, "y": 0.6094, "ability": false }, { "t": 174.75, "side": "team", "card": "baby-dragon", "x": 0.9722, "y": 0.2031, "ability": false }, { "t": 178.15, "side": "opponent", "card": "giant", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.9843, "ability": false }, { "t": 179.85, "side": "team", "card": "witch", "x": 0.5833, "y": 0.2656, "ability": false }, { "t": 185.55, "side": "opponent", "card": "baby-dragon", "x": 0.6389, "y": 0.7344, "ability": false }, { "t": 186.75, "side": "team", "card": "wizard", "x": 0.9722, "y": 0.0781, "ability": false }, { "t": 189.3, "side": "opponent", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.9167, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 190.05, "side": "team", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.9167, "y": 0.3906, "ability": false }, { "t": 193.05, "side": "opponent", "card": "dart-goblin", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.6406, "ability": false }, { "t": 194.9, "side": "team", "card": "freeze", "x": 0.6944, "y": 0.5781, "ability": false }, { "t": 195.2, "side": "opponent", "card": "fireball", "x": 0.8056, "y": 0.3906, "ability": false }, { "t": 199.05, "side": "opponent", "card": "arrows", "x": 0.8056, "y": 0.4219, "ability": false }, { "t": 199.2, "side": "team", "card": "_ability", "x": 0.5, "y": 0.5, "ability": true }, { "t": 202.55, "side": "team", "card": "fireball", "x": 0.75, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false } ] }, "ai": { "score": 4e-05, "events": [ { "t": 6.05, "side": "team", "card": "baby-dragon", "x": 0.9167, "y": 0.4531, "ability": false }, { "t": 8.65, "side": "opponent", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.6944, "y": 0.7031, "ability": false }, { "t": 18.55, "side": "team", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.8056, "y": 0.2656, "ability": false }, { "t": 21.05, "side": "opponent", "card": "dark-prince", "x": 0.5833, "y": 0.9843, "ability": false }, { "t": 27.25, "side": "team", "card": "witch", "x": 0.5833, "y": 0.0156, "ability": false }, { "t": 28.05, "side": "opponent", "card": "giant", "x": 0.9167, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 32.7, "side": "opponent", "card": "dart-goblin", "x": 0.5833, "y": 0.5468, "ability": false }, { "t": 33.75, "side": "team", "card": "wizard", "x": 0.9167, "y": 0.2031, "ability": false }, { "t": 36.6, "side": "team", "card": "_ability", "x": 0.5, "y": 0.5, "ability": true }, { "t": 39.55, "side": "opponent", "card": "fireball", "x": 0.8056, "y": 0.2344, "ability": false }, { "t": 65.9, "side": "opponent", "card": "baby-dragon", "x": 0.5278, "y": 0.9844, "ability": false }, { "t": 69.4, "side": "team", "card": "ram-rider", "x": 0.1944, "y": 0.2656, "ability": false }, { "t": 72.24, "side": "team", "card": "baby-dragon", "x": 0.2703, "y": 0.4495, "ability": false }, { "t": 73.77, "side": "opponent", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.2523, "y": 0.7119, "ability": false }, { "t": 78.05, "side": "team", "card": "freeze", "x": 0.2828, "y": 0.5399, "ability": false }, { "t": 80.48, "side": "opponent", "card": "giant", "x": 0.3022, "y": 0.7121, "ability": false }, { "t": 87.33, "side": "team", "card": "skeleton-army", "x": 0.3444, "y": 0.2656, "ability": false }, { "t": 91.03, "side": "opponent", "card": "dark-prince", "x": 0.3523, "y": 0.6189, "ability": false }, { "t": 96.22, "side": "team", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.2784, "y": 0.2673, "ability": false }, { "t": 101.15, "side": "opponent", "card": "balloon", "x": 0.3507, "y": 0.6156, "ability": false }, { "t": 105.69, "side": "team", "card": "wizard", "x": 0.2984, "y": 0.2797, "ability": false }, { "t": 111.09, "side": "opponent", "card": "dart-goblin", "x": 0.3032, "y": 0.5037, "ability": false }, { "t": 115.27, "side": "team", "card": "baby-dragon", "x": 0.2292, "y": 0.4522, "ability": false }, { "t": 120.17, "side": "opponent", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.2418, "y": 0.6116, "ability": false }, { "t": 126.73, "side": "team", "card": "witch", "x": 0.3139, "y": 0.3688, "ability": false }, { "t": 129.89, "side": "opponent", "card": "baby-dragon", "x": 0.3594, "y": 0.6274, "ability": false }, { "t": 133.34, "side": "team", "card": "skeleton-army", "x": 0.2627, "y": 0.3789, "ability": false }, { "t": 135.48, "side": "opponent", "card": "dark-prince", "x": 0.2537, "y": 0.5476, "ability": false }, { "t": 137.47, "side": "team", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.2067, "y": 0.3904, "ability": false }, { "t": 139.26, "side": "opponent", "card": "arrows", "x": 0.2498, "y": 0.4972, "ability": false }, { "t": 141.65, "side": "team", "card": "fireball", "x": 0.2101, "y": 0.372, "ability": false }, { "t": 144.36, "side": "opponent", "card": "dart-goblin", "x": 0.2961, "y": 0.6899, "ability": false }, { "t": 147.55, "side": "team", "card": "baby-dragon", "x": 0.2229, "y": 0.408, "ability": false }, { "t": 150.14, "side": "opponent", "card": "giant", "x": 0.2898, "y": 0.6852, "ability": false }, { "t": 153.47, "side": "team", "card": "witch", "x": 0.2466, "y": 0.3258, "ability": false }, { "t": 155.66, "side": "opponent", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.2458, "y": 0.6397, "ability": false }, { "t": 158.42, "side": "team", "card": "ram-rider", "x": 0.2058, "y": 0.3611, "ability": false }, { "t": 160.33, "side": "opponent", "card": "baby-dragon", "x": 0.2213, "y": 0.6044, "ability": false }, { "t": 162.66, "side": "team", "card": "skeleton-army", "x": 0.1889, "y": 0.5235, "ability": false }, { "t": 164.35, "side": "opponent", "card": "fireball", "x": 0.1938, "y": 0.6205, "ability": false }, { "t": 166.64, "side": "team", "card": "freeze", "x": 0.1996, "y": 0.5694, "ability": false }, { "t": 168.68, "side": "opponent", "card": "dark-prince", "x": 0.2152, "y": 0.6754, "ability": false }, { "t": 171.83, "side": "team", "card": "baby-dragon", "x": 0.2153, "y": 0.493, "ability": false }, { "t": 174.29, "side": "opponent", "card": "dart-goblin", "x": 0.2369, "y": 0.6783, "ability": false }, { "t": 177.17, "side": "team", "card": "fireball", "x": 0.1891, "y": 0.5575, "ability": false }, { "t": 179.74, "side": "opponent", "card": "giant", "x": 0.2295, "y": 0.6375, "ability": false }, { "t": 183.78, "side": "team", "card": "ram-rider", "x": 0.2494, "y": 0.3587, "ability": false }, { "t": 185.81, "side": "opponent", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.2065, "y": 0.6812, "ability": false }, { "t": 188.81, "side": "team", "card": "wizard", "x": 0.2188, "y": 0.4098, "ability": false }, { "t": 190.81, "side": "opponent", "card": "fireball", "x": 0.2619, "y": 0.5523, "ability": false }, { "t": 193.67, "side": "team", "card": "valkyrie", "x": 0.1893, "y": 0.4427, "ability": false }, { "t": 195.58, "side": "opponent", "card": "arrows", "x": 0.2203, "y": 0.5793, "ability": false } ] } } ], "ranking": [ { "policy_id": "policy_bc_v4", "human_likeness": 3.809274771888009e-05, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "detection_auc": 1.0, "transfer_human_likeness": 7.310015739154003e-05 }, { "policy_id": "policy_bc_v2", "human_likeness": 2.2638500048010705e-05, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "detection_auc": 1.0, "transfer_human_likeness": 1.5289149273327188e-05 }, { "policy_id": "policy_bc_v4_1", "human_likeness": 1.838149538810249e-05, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "detection_auc": 1.0, "transfer_human_likeness": 7.074711287262004e-05 }, { "policy_id": "policy_bc_v3", "human_likeness": 1.3073038784412534e-05, "fool_rate_at_0.5": 0.0, "detection_auc": 1.0, "transfer_human_likeness": 1.3331757304089826e-05 } ], "checkpoint": "models/style_discriminator/style_ensemble.pkl", "lessons": [ "The realism scorer said policy rollouts look real (0.85 vs 0.87); against actual policy negatives the same feature set separates them perfectly. A discriminator is only as strong as its negatives.", "Top tells: alt_rate, in_single, frac_triple, in_overtime, frac_gap_lt_1. These are what a policy must fix to become statistically human.", "Several top tells come from the rollout harness (strict side alternation, fixed 40-event continuation), not the policy. Removing all 13 harness features still leaves AUC 1.000, so the style gap is real either way.", "Detection is not a close call, so mean P(human) \u2014 not accuracy \u2014 is the ranking signal while every policy sits at AUC 1.0.", "The judge needs roughly 8 generated actions before it is confident, so short bursts of policy play are much harder to spot than full continuations.", "Dropping the 60 strongest tells still leaves near-perfect detection: the AI signature is distributed across the whole feature set, not one fixable bug." ], "notes": "Binary style discriminator: P(sequence is human) from action-sequence statistics. Negatives are offline policy rollouts starting from real battle prefixes." }